department of computer science and engineering computing handles and tunnels in 3d models tamal k....

Department of Computer Science and Engineering

Computing handles and tunnels in 3D models

Tamal K. Dey

Joint work: Kuiyu Li, Jian Sun, D. Cohen-Steiner

2/52Department of Computer Science and Engineering

Projects in Jyamiti group

• Surface reconstrucion (Cocone)• Delaunay meshing (DelPSC)• Shape feature processing (Segmatch,

Cskel)


Handle loops/Tunnel loops


Topological Simplification


Use of Handles and Tunnels

• Topological simplification / feature recognition / parameterization• El-Sana and Varshney[1997] use α-hulls to search for

tunnels.• Guskov and Wood[2001] propose a surface growing

strategy to remove small handles.• Nooruddin and Turk[2003] use morphological operations to

remove small handles.• Wood, Hoppe, Desbrun, and Schroder[2004] use Reeb

graph to remove handles.• Shattuck and Leahy[2001] use Reeb graph to compute

handles.• From WUSTL Model/surface editing (Zhou, Ju, and Hu[2007]

use medial axis to detect loops) and work by Grimm et al.


• Nontrivial loops can neither be handle nor tunnel.

• Handle and tunnel loops have to be non-separating.

Nontrivial loops as first attempt?


• Loops on a surface• Compute polygon schemas [Vegter-Yap90][Dey-Schipper95]

• Linear time algorithm• Compute optimal systems of loops [VL05][EW06]

• Verdiere and Lazarus gave an algorithm for computing a system of loops which is shortest among the homotopy class of a given one.

• Erickson and Whittlesey gave a greedy algorithm to compute the shortest system of loops among all systems of loops.

• Compute optimal cut graph [EH04]

• Computing a shortest cut graph is NP-hard.

Related work for loops on surface


A better idea

• Intuitively, a loop on a connected, closed, surface M in R3 is:• handle if it spans a disk

(surface) in the bounded space bordered by M.

• tunnel if it spans a disk (surface) in the unbounded space bordered by M.


Cycle, Boundary and Homology

• p-chain: c=aii, i is p-simplex.

(e2+e3+e4) is a 1-chain.

• If c'=ai'i, then c+c'=(ai+ai')i.

• c + c = 0 for Z2 coefficients.

• Boundary operator p = [v0,v1,…,vp] = i=0

p[v0,…,~vi,…,vp]

• e.g.: t = (e2+e3+e4)

• e.g.: e0+ e1+ e4 = (v0+v2)+(v0+v1)+(v1+v2) = 0


Cycle, Boundary and Homology

• p-cycle: if pc = 0.

• p-boundary: if there’s (p+1)-chain d, s.t. c=pd .• p-cycle group Zp = kernel (p).• p-boundary group Bp = image (p+1).• Hp= Zp / Bp

• Each element of Hp represents an equivalent class.

• c1 and c2 are in the same class if c1 + c2 is in Bp.• Trivial elements in Hp bounds (p+1)-chain


Handle and tunnel loops – definitions [Dey-Li-Sun 07]

• Let M be a connected, closed, surface in R3. M separates R3 into inside I and outside O. Both I and O have M as boundary.

• Handle: A loop on M whose homology class is trivial in H1(I) and non-trivial in H1(O).

• Tunnel: A loop on M whose homology class is trivial in H1(O) and non-trivial in H1(I).


• Consider a thickened trefoil• handle loop (green)• tunnel loop (red)

Nasty knots


Handle and tunnel loops – existence

• Theorem (Dey, Li, Sun[2007])• For any connected closed surface M of

genus g in R3, there exist g handle loops {hi}i=1…g forming a basis for H1(O) and g tunnel loops {ti}i=1...g forming a basis for H1(I).

• Furthermore, {hi}i=1...g and {ti}i=1...g form a basis for H1(M).


First algorithm for GR models

[Dey-Li-Sun 07]

• Graph retractability assumption : A surface is graph retractable if both I and O deformation retract to a graph, denoted I and O, respectively.


• I and O are disjoint core graphs, each with g loops : {Kj

I}j=1g and {Kj

O}j=1g and {Kj}j=1

2g all together.

• How to compute I and O ?

Inner and outer cores


Linking number

• J and K are two disjoint loops in R3. • In a regular projection, there are two ways

in which J crosses under K. • The linking number, lk(K, J), is the sum of

these signed crossings.


Linking number Theorem

• A loop on M is a handle iff lk(, KiI) 0 for at

least one inner core and lk(, KiO)=0 for all outer

cores.

• A loop on M is a tunnel iff lk(, KiO) 0 for at

least one outer core and lk(, KiI)=0 for all inner

cores.


Minimally linked basis

• A loop is minimally linked if it links once only with one core loop.

• Theorem : There exist 2g minimally linked loops, denoted {Jj}j=1

2g, such that lk(Ki, Jj)=ij.

• Half of them linked with KiI’s, denoted {JjI}j=1

g, are handle loops.

• Other half linked with KiO’s, denoted {JjO}j=1

g, are tunnel loops.

• {[JjI]} j=1g form a basis for H1(I) and {[JjO]}j=1

g form a basis for H1(O). Hence {[Jj]}j=1

2g form a basis for H1(M).


Topological algorithm• Assume I and O are given.

• Step1: Compute {Ki}i=12g using the spanning tree of I and

O.• Step2: Compute a system of 2g loops on M, denoted

{j}j=12g. (say by Dey-Schipper or Vegter-Yap linear time

algorithms)

• Step3: Compute lk(Ki, j) for all i and j. Let A be the 2gx2g matrix {lk(Ki, j)}.• A is the transform matrix from a minimally linked basis

{[Jj]}j=12g to basis {[j]} j=1

2g.

• A-1 = {aji} exists and has integer entries.

• [Jj] = i=12g aji[i].

• Step4: Obtain Jj by concatenating i’s according to the above expression.


An implementation to compute system of handle and tunnel loops

with small size

• Compute I and O• Basic idea: Collapse the inside

(outside) Voronoi diagram to obtain I (O).

• The curve-skeleton [Dey-Sun06] captures the geometry better.

• Each skeleton edge (e) gets associated with an additional value called geodesic size (g(e)) indicating the local size of M.

• Establish graph structure on the curve skeleton.

• The geodesic size for a graph edge, g(E) = min{g(e): e is a skeleton edge in E}.

• Issue: not always work for any graph retractable surface, e.g., a thickening of a house with two room.


Core graphs by curve-skeletons[DS05]


An implementation to compute system of handle and tunnel loops

with small size

• Compute core loops {Kj}j=12g

• Compute the maximal spanning tree for I and O using geodesic sizes as weight.

• Add the remaining edges, Ei’s, to form Ki’s.

• Compute minimally linked {Jj}j=1

2g

• Basic idea: compute Ji’s at different location indicated by Ei’s.

• Let e be the skeleton edge with the smallest geodesic size in Ei. Let p be one of the vertices of the dual Delaunay triangle of e.

• Compute an optimal system of loops by geodesic exploration and apply topological algorithm.

• In our experiments, one of the loop in the system of loops itself satisfies the condition to be Ji’s.


Results


A Persistence based algorithm [Dey-Li-Sun-Cohen-Steiner 08]

• A fast algorithm based on persistent homology introduced by Edelsbrunner, Letscher, Zomorodian[2002].

• The algorithm does not require any extra structure such as medial axis, curve skeleton, or Reeb graphs.

• It works on a larger class of models. Both surface mesh and isosurface with volume grids can be input.


Filtration in persistent homology

• Filtration of a simplicial complex K is a nested sequence of complexes:

• 0 = K-1 < K0 < K1 < …< Kn = K

• Assume Ki - Ki-1 = i

• Persistence homology studies how the homology groups change over the filtration.

• In our algorithm, we use the pairing concept in the persistent homology.


Positive and Negative simplices

• Once a p-simplex is added to Ki-1, it is• Positive if it creates a non-boundary p-

cycle.• Negative if it kills an existing (p-1)-cycle.

• A negative p-simplex is always paired with a unique positive (p-1)-simplex ' where kills a (p-1)-cycle created by '.


Positive and negative simplices


Pairing algorithm – pair ()

1) c=p2) d is youngest positive (p-1)-simplex in c3) while (d is paired and c Φ) do

• Let c' be the cycle killed by the simplex paired with d

• c=c'+c• d is the youngest positive (p-1)-simplex in c

end while4) if c is not empty, then

is negative p-simplex and paired with d else

is positive p-simplex.


Computing handle and tunnel loops

• Topological algorithm• Two refinements for improving loop quality.• Assume M, I, and O denote the simplicial

complexes of surface, inside, and outside respectively; g is the genus of M.


Topological algorithm

• 3 Steps: • 1) Simplices of M are added to the filtration,

generating 2g unpaired positive edges;• 2) Simplices of I are added, g previously

unpaired edges get paired, each pair corresponds to a handle loop;

• 3) Simplices of O are added, the rest of g unpaired edges get paired, each pair corresponds to a tunnel loop.


Topological algorithm cont.


Refinement 1

• For a negative triangle , a series of homologous loops are obtained.

• Let L1, L2,…,Lk be those that lie on M, sorted by the time when they are found. Set the handle (or tunnel) loop L() for as L1.


Refinement 2

• A handle (or tunnel) loop is found when a cross section of M get filled.

• Cross sections of small size will get filled first if we add triangles in I and O to the filtration in increasing order of their geodesic sizes.


Computing geodesics – for refinement 2

• Geodesic size of an edge E =(A1, A2): geodesic distance between points A1' and A2' on M, where Ai'=Ai if Ai is on M; otherwise, Ai' is the closet point on M for Ai

• Geodesic size size of a triangle t: max {g(e)|e is in t}


Entire algorithm

• 1) Compute geodesic size for edges and triangles in I and O;

• 2) For each simplex on M, pair();• 3) E = unpaired positive edges on M;• 4) In the order of increasing geodesic size,

pair() for each triangle in I;• 5) if ( is negative and its paired positive

edge is in E), then output a handle: hi = L();

• 6) Do similarly as 4) and 5) to get tunnels.


Entire algorithm


Gearbox (genus 78)


Isosurface Fuel (genus 8)


Isosurface (Engine, genus 20)


Aneurysm


Knotty cup and noise


Experiments

• We implemented our algorithm in C++. All experiments were done on a Dell PC with 2.8GHz Intel Pentium D CPU and 1GB RAM.


Feature Detection

• Compute handle (tunnel) features based on handle (tunnel) loops. • Sweep the handle (tunnel)

loop until the length become too long.


Topological simplification


Simplification (Buddha)


• A simple, topologically correct algorithm for handles and tunnels.

• Mathematical proof of geometric qualities of the loops?

• What about surfaces with boundaries?• Handletunnel software available from http://www.cse.ohio-state.edu/~tamaldey/handle.html

Conclusions and future work


Pegasus (genus 5)


2-torus (genus 2)

department of computer science and engineering computing handles and tunnels in 3d models tamal k....

Documents

z p b p

h p bounds p

pboundary group b p

department of computer

engineering loops

pcycle group z p

theres p

kernel p