d. w. shin, s. cocke, y.-k. lim, t. e. larow, g. a. baigorria, and j. j. obrien center for...

34
D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. O’Brien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL, USA Agricultural&Biological Engineering Department, Univ. of Florida March 6, 2008 at CPASW Interannual Crop Yield Simulations over the Southeast US using Global and Regional Climate Model Products

Upload: john-egan

Post on 26-Mar-2015

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. O’Brien

Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction StudiesFlorida State University, Tallahassee, FL, USA

Agricultural&Biological Engineering Department, Univ. of FloridaMarch 6, 2008 at CPASW

Interannual Crop Yield Simulations over the Southeast US using Global and Regional

Climate Model Products

Page 2: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Outline

1. Background

2. The FSU/COAPS Climate Modeling System and The DSSAT Crop Model

3. Ensemble Runs

4. The FSU/COAPS GCM results

5. The FSU/COAPS RCM results

6. Station Level results

7. Crop Model results

8. Future Directions

Page 3: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Background

RISA http://www.climate.noaa.gov/cpo_pa/risa/Regional Integrated Sciences and Assessments

http://secc.coaps.fsu.edu

http://AgClimate.org

Page 4: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

FSUNRSM(20km)

OASIS Coupler

FSU/COAPS Climate Modeling System

Regional Biosphere

FSUGSMT63 (200km)

Global Biosphere

OCEANHOPE-OM1, HOPE-G,

HYCOM, MICOM

Crop Model

Crop Model

Page 5: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

DSSAT (Crop Model)

• DSSAT: Decision Support System for Agrotechnology Transfer

• DSSAT: a microcomputer software program combining crop soil and weather data bases and programs to manage them, with crop models and application programs, to simulate multi-year outcomes of crop management strategies.

• DSSAT allows users to ask "what if" questions and simulate results by conducting, in minutes on a desktop computer, experiments which would consume a significant part of an agronomist's career.

Page 6: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Linking Climate Models to Crop Models

• Grand idea is to be able to make forecast before season regarding crop situations and perhaps suggest “best management” practices for that year

• At present, we are looking into peanut or corn yields in some selected stations in southeast USA

Page 7: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

The regional model was centered over the southeast U.S. and run at 20 km resolution, roughly resolving the county scale. Outputs from the model such as max/min surface temperature, precipitation and shortwave radiation at the surface is used as inputs into the crop model to determine crop yields.

Using the FSU/COAPS GSM & RSM system, warm season (March-September, 7 month simulation) and cold season (October-march, 6 month simulation) ensemble simulations are performed for the period of 19 yrs (1987-2005) to characterized uncertainty in the forecast. Twenty member ensembles of the regional model are generated using different initial conditions and model configurations (i.e., the ensemble methods based on different convective schemes).

Ensemble runs

Page 8: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

GSM Results

Page 9: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

PRECIPITATION: Temporal correlation (1987-2005)

Page 10: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

PrecipitationPrecipitation

DEMETER MMEPAPCC MMEP

JJA

DJF

MME Hindcast Skill: Temporal Correlation/ 1981-2001MME Hindcast Skill: Temporal Correlation/ 1981-2001(Lee et al. 2007)(Lee et al. 2007)

Page 11: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

2m Temperature: Temporal correlation (1987-2005)

Page 12: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

2m Air Temperature2m Air TemperatureDEMETER MMEPAPCC MMEP

JJA

DJF

MME Hindcast Skill: Temporal Correlation/ 1981-2001MME Hindcast Skill: Temporal Correlation/ 1981-2001(Lee et al. 2007)(Lee et al. 2007)

Page 13: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Saha et al (2006)

PRECIPITATION: Temporal correlation (1987-2005)FSU/COAPS (1987-2005) CFS (1981-2003)

Page 14: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

FSU/COAPS (1987-2005) CFS (1981-2003)Saha et al (2006)

2m Temperature: Temporal correlation (1987-2005)

Page 15: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

RSM Results

Page 16: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Downscaling (Regional model)

FSU Regional Model

20 km

Page 17: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

MAXIMUM TEMPERATURE19 year (1987-2005) ave (oC) (model – obs)

Ensemble Mean

Page 18: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

MINIMUM TEMPERATURE19 year (1987-2005) ave (oC) (model – obs)

Ensemble Mean

Page 19: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

PRECIPITATION19 year (1987-2005) ave (mm/day) (model – obs)

Ensemble Mean

Page 20: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Tmax: Temporal correlation (1987-2005)

Page 21: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Tmin: Temporal correlation (1987-2005)

Page 22: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

PRECIPITATION: Temporal correlation (1987-2005)

Page 23: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Station Level Results

Page 24: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Station Level (Tifton, GA, 1987)

Tmax

Page 25: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Station Level (Tifton, GA, 1987)

Tmin

Page 26: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Station Level (Tifton, GA, 1987)

Prcp

Page 27: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Crop Model Results

Page 28: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Observed weather

Raw ensemble member 1….

Raw ensemble member 20

Raw daily seasonal-climateHindcast

Bias-corrected ensemble member 1….

Bias-corrected ensemble member 20

Bias-corrected daily seasonal-climate Hindcast

Bias-correction

Raw crop-yield ensem. member 1….

Raw crop-yield ensem. member 20

Crop yield Hindcast

CERES-Maize

Bias-corrected crop-yield ens. member 1….

Bias-corrected crop-yield ens. member 20

Crop yield Hindcast

CERES-Maize

CERES-Maize

Crop yield using observed weather

Experimental Design

Page 29: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

PEANUT YIELDS

(1994-2003)

Site specific soil profiles (U.S. Soil Conservation Service data)

Rainfed conditions

Identical planting date for each year: April 25

Page 30: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Maize Yield

No bias-correction!

Page 31: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Peanut Yield

No bias-correction!

Page 32: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Baigorria et al. (2007) see member 2&6

Page 33: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Tifton, GA

Maize Yield global (green) vs. regional (red) model

Page 34: D. W. Shin, S. Cocke, Y.-K. Lim, T. E. LaRow, G. A. Baigorria, and J. J. OBrien Center for Ocean-Atmospheric Prediction Studies Florida State University,

Future Directions

1. More sites and other crops

2. A posteriori bias correction: precipitation

3. How can we use a climate ensemble forecast to issue an ACCEPTABLE probabilistic crop yield forecasts?

4. Dynamical vs. Statistical approaches

• Schoof et al. (2007); Lim et al. (2007)

5. CFS Statistical downscaling

6. A coupled version of atmospheric and crop models

- nonlinear seasonal weather-yield interactions