current regulation of hct-ps and tissue banks in us and ... · current regulation of hct/ps and...

57
www.ac-gt.com Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD Advanced Cell & Gene Therapy 2010 Taipei International Symposium on Human Cell and Tissue- Based Products and Tissue Banks October 13, 2010

Upload: others

Post on 07-Jan-2020

9 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and

Tissue Banks in the US and Europe

Scott R. Burger, MD

Advanced Cell & Gene Therapy

2010 Taipei International Symposium on Human

Cell and Tissue- Based Products and Tissue

Banks

October 13, 2010

Page 2: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Cell/Gene/Tissue Therapies - Potential,

Promise, and Plenty of Challenges

• Numerous potential applications, often for unmet needs

– Potentially definitive therapies

• Novel uses of

cells/genes/tissues

– Difficult to evaluate efficacy, predict

clinical risks

• Complex cell/gene/tissue

engineering

– Risk of manufacturing problems,

product/process characterization

challenges

Science 2000;287:1423

Potential Patients (USA)

Cardiovascular Diseases

Autoimmune Diseases

Diabetes

Cancer

Osteoporosis

Neurologic Diseases

Burn Injuries

Birth Defects

58M58M58M58M

30M30M30M30M

16M16M16M16M

8M8M8M8M

101010106666

Page 3: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Regulations and Standards - US, Europe

� FDA-CBER Office of Cell, Tissue and Gene Therapy

(OCTGT)

� Good Tissue Practices (GTPs)

� Good Manufacturing Practices

(GMPs)

� Quality System Regulations (QSRs)

� Good Clinical Practices (GCPs)

� European Medicines Agency (EMEA)

� CAT

� International Conference on

Harmonisation (ICH)

� International Organization for Standardization (ISO)

� United States Pharmacopeia (USP)

� European Pharmacopeia (EP)

� American Association of Tissue

Banking (AATB)

� American Association of Blood Banks (AABB)

� Foundation for the Accreditation of Cellular Therapy (FACT)

� Clinical Laboratory Improvement

Amendments (CLIA)

� Joint Commission (formerly JCAHO)

� Institutional Review Board, Biosafety Committee

Page 4: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com4

US FDA Office of Cell, Tissue and Gene

Therapy (OCTGT)-Regulated Products

• Human Cells, Tissues, and Cellular and Tissue-Based Products (HCT/Ps)

• Cell therapy products

• Tissue and tissue-based products

• Cell- or tissue-based combination products

– Cell/device, tissue/device, other

• Devices used for cells/tissues

– Processing devices, other

• Tumor vaccines and immunotherapy

• Gene therapy products

• Xenotransplantation products

• Donor screening tests (cadaveric blood samples)

Page 5: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com5

Examples of Indications/Sources

• Pancreatic islets for diabetes

• Stem and skeletal muscle progenitor cells for

ischemic cardiac

• Hematopoietic reconstitution in treatment of

malignancies

• Stem cells for metabolic storage diseases

• Stem cells for CNS indications (Parkinson’s

disease)

• Expanded autologous cartilage for joint repair

Page 6: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Regulation Reflects the Evolving Nature

of Cell and Tissue Therapy

• Cell therapy products are complex living biologics, and are being developed in novel, evolving ways. FDA’s

regulatory approach reflects the novel, diverse nature of these products.

• Regulations set a framework of criteria that must be

met.

– Safety, identity, purity, potency, and clinical efficacy

• FDA takes a flexible but science-driven, risk-based approach in evaluating whether and how these criteria

have been met.

Page 7: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

US FDA Requirements

Good Manufacturing Practices (GMPs)

Ensure consistent manufacture of safe, pure, potent products

Good Tissue

Practices (GTPs)

Prevent infectious disease transmission

Donor screening and testing

Prevent cross-contamination, mixups

Product recovery, processing, storage,

labeling, distribution

Good Clinical

Practices (GCPs)

Ethical, scientific quality standards

Protect trial subjects rights, safety,

confidentiality

Assure credibility of clinical trial data

Page 8: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Risk-Based Approach to Cell Therapy

Regulation

• Products that present greater risk of adverse

clinical outcome require more and better control,

and hence more stringent regulation and

oversight.

• Risks, and potential risks

– Complex manufacturing, complex product

– Unrelated allogeneic clinical strategy

– Cells/tissues used in a manner unlike natural function

– Or, cannot assess risk due to extreme novelty

• Higher-risk products regulated under Public

Health Service Act, Section 351

Page 9: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Application of FDA Regulatory Requirements

IF a cell therapy product meets criteria 1 and 2 and 3, and (4a or 4b or 4c).

1 Minimally manipulated (not activated, encapsulated, expanded ex vivo ,or genetically modified) AND

2 Intended for homologous use AND

3 Not combined with a drug or device AND

4a. Does not have a systemic effect, AND

Primary function does not depend on metabolic activity of viable cells OR

4b. Has a systemic effect and is intended for autologous, related- allogeneic, or reproductive use OR

4c. Primary function depends on metabolic activity of viable cells) and is intended for autologous, related-allogeneic, or reproductive use

THEN…

– IND or IDE NOT

required– GTPs ARE required

IF a cell therapy product does not meet

one or more of the four major criteria

defining minimally manipulated

products

THEN…

– Regulated using IND/IDE

framework, clinical trial

pathway

– GMPs AND GTPs

required

“361” Products

Nearly any interesting cell

therapy meets criteria for the

“351” category

“351” Products

Page 10: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

FDA Premarket Review Pathways

• Biologics (FDA CBER)

– Investigational New Drug (IND)

– Biologics License Application (BLA)

• Device (FDA CDRH)

– Investigational Device Exemption (IDE)

– Premarketing Application (PMA)

• Combination products

– Regulatory pathway determined based on primary

mode of action, previous intercenter agreements and precedents

Page 11: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Product Development Pathway

• Product development stage determines key aspects of regulatory review. Safety is a consistent, critical focus

throughout product development.

Raj K. Puri, MD, PhD

Director, Division of Cellular and Gene Therapies

US FDA OCTGT

Page 12: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Development Throughout Clinical Trials

• FDA expects greater control and

characterization as clinical development progresses

– Manufacturing, characterization,

specifications are refined based on experience

• Early-stage trials and manufacturing must be sufficiently controlled to enable

clinical development to licensure

– The nightmare scenario: the therapy works,

but inadequate understanding of the product

impedes further clinical progress

Prod

uct/P

roce

ss

Char

acte

rizat

ion,

Con

trol

Phase III

Phase I

PreClin

Phase II

Page 13: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Current Good Manufacturing Practices

(cGMPs)• General provisions

• Organization and personnel

• Buildings and facilities

• Equipment

• Control of components

• Production and process controls

• Packaging and label controls

• Holding and distribution

• Laboratory controls

• Records and reports

• Returned and salvaged product

A set of current, scientifically

sound methods, practices or principles that are

implemented and documentedduring product development

and production to ensure consistent manufacture of safe, pure and potent products.

21 CFR 210, 211

Page 14: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Current Good Tissue Practices (cGTPs)

• Methods, facilities for manufacture of human cellular and tissue-based products

– Prevent introduction, transmission and spread of infectious disease

– Donor screening and testing

– Prevent mix-ups, cross-contamination

– Product recovery, processing, storage, labeling, distribution

• Resemble GMPs, but narrower focus

21 CFR Part 1271

• Quality Program

• Organization, Personnel

• Procedures

• Facilities

• Environmental Control,

Monitoring

• Equipment

• Supplies and Reagents

• Process Controls, Changes

• Process Validation

• Labeling Controls

• Storage Requirements

• Receipt and Distribution

• Records

• Tracking

• Complaint File

Page 15: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

GTP-Specific Requirements

• Requirements for GTPs and GMPs overlap in

many respects - GMP-compliant operation will

meet many of the GTP requirements.

• However, certain requirements are GTP-specific.

Either not covered by GMPs at all, or

requirement is more HCT/P-specific than in

GMPs, so GMP compliance alone is not

sufficient. – Donor eligibility

– Tracking systems

– Quality program

– Predistribution shipment

– Recovery of HCT/Ps

– Exemptions and alternatives

– Records

– Availability for Distribution

– Receipt procedures

– Processing, process controls

– Reporting requirements

Page 16: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Core GTP Requirements - 1271.150(b)

• Directly related to preventing introduction, transmission, or spread of communicable disease. Other GTP requirements support core cGTPs– Facilities - 1271.190(a) and (b)

– Environmental control - 1271.195(a)

– Equipment - 1271.200(a)

– Supplies and reagents - 1271.210(a) and (b)

– Recovery - 1271.215

– Processing and process controls - 1271.220

– Labeling controls - 1271.250(a) and (b)

– Storage - 1271.260(a-d)

– Receipt, pre-distribution shipment, distribution - 1271.265(a-d)

– Donor eligibility determination - 1271.50, 1271.75, 1271.80, 1271.85

Page 17: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Recovery Procedures and Records

• Recovery is a core CGTP, therefore procedures

and records must be established and maintained

for:

– Facilities

– Environmental control

– Equipment

– Supplies and reagents

– Labeling controls

– Storage and

– Receipt, predistribution shipment and distribution

1271.215

Page 18: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Recovery-Related Environmental

Controls

• Procedures must be established and maintained to prevent contamination or cross-contamination

• Environmental controls should be in place at each recovery site

• Establish recovery site suitability parameters and verify that they have been met

• Operating room setting is recommended but not required

• If other types of facilities are used for recovery then they

must provide adequate temperature and humidity controls and ventilation

1271.195(a)

Page 19: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Recovery-Related Facility Requirements

• Area used for recovery should be evaluated for:

– Suitable size, location and construction for aseptic procedure

– Limited access

– Good state of repair

– Adequate lighting, ventilation and airflow

– Access to running water and sink

– Working surfaces – verified cleaning agents used and use documented

– Recommend development of a checklist to document that the location meets established parameters each

time a recovery is performed

1271.190(a)

Page 20: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Recovery: Reducing Potential

Contamination, Cross-Contamination

• Evaluate technical procedures used– Aseptic technique– Use of published industry practices

– Specific body cooling parameters established

• Evaluate personnel involved– Experience, education and training

• Evaluate equipment, supplies, and reagents– Appropriate design

– Records and procedures for maintenance, cleaning, sanitizing, calibration and other activities

• Establish and document suitability of facilities where recovery takes place - audits, gap analyses

Page 21: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Regulatory Considerations for Initiating

Clinical Trials

• Risk-benefit balance

– Clinical trial subject safety balanced against potential

public health benefits of novel therapies

• Risk assessment based on:

– Product characterization and safety testing data

– Preclinical data supporting safety

– Eligibility criteria

– Product administration procedure

– Clinical safety monitoring plans

Page 22: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Cell- and Tissue-Based Products: Potential

Safety Concerns

22

• Contaminated cells/tissue raw material, infectious

disease transmission

• Ex vivo manipulation

• Risks of the delivery procedure

• Potential inflammatory/immune response

• Inappropriate cell proliferation

• Inappropriate cell differentiation

• Cell migration to non-target sites/tissues

• Interactions with concomitant therapies

Page 23: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Translation from Preclinical to

Initial Clinical Trials

23

• Proof-of-concept – in vitro, in vivo– Potential mechanism of action

– Establish pharmacologically effective dose(s)

– Optimize dosing regimen– Rationale for species/model selection for further testing

• Safety of conducting clinical trial – risk/benefit

– Dose levels and dosing scheme

– Potential target tissue(s) of toxicity/activity– Parameters to monitor clinically

– Patient eligibility criteria

Page 24: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Questions - I

• What type(s) of cells will be used, and what is the

source?

• What is the projected dose? How many cells are

needed to achieve a minimum/optimal biological

effect?

• Have the cells been sufficiently characterized for

the stage of clinical development?

Page 25: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Questions - II

• What is the proposed mechanism of action?

• Is cell survival/engraftment necessary?

• Is repair or replacement of damaged tissue the

goal?

• What is thought to happen to the cells in vivo,

following administration?

• Will the cells be administered as a suspension?

Seeded onto a scaffold? Encapsulated?

• Will immunosuppression be needed?

Page 26: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Questions - III

• What is/are the biologically relevant animal

species for preclinical studies?

• Are there potentially relevant animal models of

disease/injury that can be used?

• What is the optimal method/route/anatomical

site/timing for product administration?

• What is the risk/benefit balance?

Page 27: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

• Administering cells with certain devices, or seeded onto

scaffolds, can make the cell therapy product a Combination Product

– Cells regulated under Biologics/Drug regulations, device regulated under Device regulations

• Discuss regulatory pathway with FDA, and with Device

manufacturer

• Establish cell-device compatibility

• Include cells and device in preclinical studies

• Establish and qualify administration procedure, and

clinician-investigator training

Combination Products

Page 28: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Key Points to Enable Progress to Clinical

Trial

• Dosing!

• Minimum effective dose

– Single or multiple administrations?

• Route/mode of administration

– Effect of any surgery on interpretation

• Sustained efficacy, if applicable

• Blinding

• Long-term follow-up

Page 29: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Common Causes of Hold Actions: Phase 1

• General

– Product to be used in the trial differs from that used in

preclinical studies

– Insufficient preclinical data to support safety of product

administration to humans

– No information about compatibility of product and delivery

device

– Inadequate clinical monitoring plan

Page 30: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

• Manufacturing– Absent or inadequate manufacturing description

– Research-grade ancillary reagents inadequately qualified

– Bovine-derived components inadequately qualified

– No description of tracking and segregation procedures to assure patient receives correct cells

– Segregation and cleaning procedures inadequately described

– Inadequate QA/QC program

• Testing– Inadequate lot release testing

– Cells do not meet minimum viability criteria of 70%

– No action plan for positive sterility test after administration

– Donor virus testing - inadequate or inappropriate tests

– Incomplete human pathogen testing (human cell lines)

– No tumorigenicity testing

Common Causes of Hold Actions: Phase 1

Page 31: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

• Critical assays (potency, identity, other) are not…

– … validated, reproducible, quantitative, sensitive, specific,

biologically relevant

• Stability program inadequate, unsuitable, or absent

• Characterization data insufficient to establish lot release specifications

• Comparability not adequately demonstrated

• Safety issues

– High levels of bioburden resulting from contamination

Common Causes of Hold Actions: Post-Phase 1

Page 32: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

BLA Issues

• Significant change(s) made late in development,

without adequate product comparability data

– Viral clearance evaluation studies may be needed

• Process validation data incomplete, inadequate, or absent

• Inadequate stability studies

• Characterization data inadequate to support

establishing specifications

• Consistent manufacturing inadequately demonstrated

• Compliance issues - contract manufacturers, finish and

fill facilities

Page 33: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

US Regulatory Guidance Documents - I• Draft Guidance for Industry and FDA Staff: INDs for Minimally

Manipulated, Unrelated Allogeneic Placental/Umbilical Cord BloodIntended for Hematopoietic Reconstitution for Specified Indications 10/2009

• Guidance for Industry: Minimally Manipulated, Unrelated Allogeneic Placental/Umbilical Cord Blood Intended for Hematopoietic Reconstitution for Specified Indications 10/2009

• Draft Guidance for Industry: Clinical Considerations for Therapeutic Cancer Vaccines 9/2009

• Guidance for Industry: Considerations for Allogeneic Pancreatic Islet Cell Products 9/2009

• Draft Guidance for Industry: Somatic Cell Therapy for Cardiac Disease 4/2009

• Guidance for Industry: Current Good Tissue Practice (CGTP) and Additional Requirements for Manufacturers of Human Cells, Tissues, and Cellular and Tissue-Based Products (HCT/Ps) 1/2009

Page 34: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

US Regulatory Guidance Documents - II• Draft Guidance for Industry: Use of Serological Tests to Reduce the

Risk of Transmission of Trypanosoma cruzi Infection in Whole Blood and Blood Components for Transfusion and HCT/Ps 3/2009

• Draft Guidance for Industry: Potency Tests for Cellular and GeneTherapy Products 10/2008

• Guidance for Industry: CGMP for Phase 1 Investigational Drugs 7/2008

• Guidance for FDA Reviewers and Sponsors: Content and Review of Chemistry, Manufacturing, and Control (CMC) Information for Human Somatic Cell Therapy Investigational New Drug Applications (INDs) 4/2008 (www.fda.gov/cber/gdlns/gtindcmc.htm)

• Guidance for Industry: Content and Review of Chemistry, Manufacturing, and Control (CMC) Information for Human Gene Therapy Investigational New Drug Applications (INDs) 4/2008

• Draft Guidance for Industry: Validation of Growth-Based Rapid Microbiological Methods for Sterility Testing of Cellular and Gene Therapy Products 2/2008

• Guidance for Industry: Eligibility Determination for Donors of HCT/Ps 8/2007 (www.fda.gov/cber/gdlns/tissdonor.htm)

Page 35: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

US Regulatory Guidances in Development• Characterization and Qualification of Cell Banks Used in the

Production of Cellular and Gene Therapy Products

• Clinical Study Design for Early Phase Studies of Cellular and Gene Therapies

• Devices Involved in Manufacture, Storage and Administration of Cellular Products and Tissues

• Preparation of Investigational Device Exemptions and Investigational New Drugs for Tissue Engineered and Regenerative Medicine Products

• Submission of Information for the National Xenotransplantation Database

Page 36: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Regulations and Standards for Cell and

Tissue Therapy Products: Europe

• Centralized European regulatory authority and national regulatory agencies

• European Commission, European Medicines Agency (EMEA)

– Centralized approval pathway

• Federal regulatory agencies for each nation

– Mutual Recognition approval pathway

– Regulations and policy vary between nations

Page 37: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Page 38: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Human Cell-based Medicinal Products,

Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (ATMPs)

• Guideline on Human Cell-based Medicinal Products

(EMEA/CHMP/410869/2006)

– General aspects of all cell-based products, including ATMPs

• Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (ATMPs)

– Medicinal products prepared industrially or manufactured by a method involving an industrial process.

– Somatic Cell Therapy Products, Tissue-Engineered Products, ATMP Combination Products, Gene Therapy Products

• Non-ATMPs

– Autologous tissues and cells obtained and grafted within the same surgical procedure

– Blood and blood components

– Organs or parts of organs, if homologous use

Page 39: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Somatic Cell Therapy Products

• Autologous, allogeneic, xenogeneic

• Somatic living cells, the biological characteristics

of which have been substantially altered as a

result of their manipulation to obtain a

therapeutic, diagnostic or preventive effect

through metabolic, pharmacological and

immunological means. This manipulation includes

the expansion or activation of autologous cell

populations ex vivo, the use of allogeneic and

xenogeneic cells associated with medical devices

used ex vivo or in vivo.

Page 40: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Tissue Engineered Products

• Contain or consist of engineered cells or tissues,

and is presented as having properties for, or is

used in or administered to human beings with a

view to regenerating, repairing or replacing a

human tissue. A tissue engineered product may

contain cells or tissues of human or animal origin,

or both. The cells or tissues may be viable or non-

viable. It may also contain additional substances,

such as cellular products, bio-molecules,

biomaterials, chemical substances, scaffolds or

matrices.

Page 41: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Gene Therapy Products

• Products obtained through a set of manufacturing

processes aimed at the transfer, to be performed

either in vivo or ex vivo, of a prophylactic,

diagnostic or therapeutic gene (i.e. a piece of

nucleic acid), to human/animal cells and its

subsequent expression in vivo. The gene transfer

involves an expression system contained in a

delivery system known as a vector, which can be

of viral, as well as non-viral origin. The vector can

also be included in a human or animal cell.

Page 42: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Page 43: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Page 44: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Advanced Therapies and Scientific

Expertise at EMEA

CHMPCHMP

Working Parties(i.e Gene Therapy, Cell-based

Product, Biological…)

Committee Committee

for Advanced Therapiesfor Advanced Therapies

(CAT)(CAT)

Pediatric Committee,Committee for Orphan

Medicinal Products

5 double members5 double members

Scientific Advisory Groups (i.e Oncology, Diagnostics…)

CHMP: Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use

Page 45: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Composition of the CAT

Chair

Christian Schneider (GER)

Vice-Chair

Paula Salminkangas (FIN)

Including

Members representing clinicians from

European Society of Gene and Cell Therapy

European Group for Blood and Marrow

Transplantations

Members representing Patients’

organisations from

European Genetic Alliances' Network

European Organisation for Rare Diseases

Page 46: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

ATMP Certification (CAT)

Certification

•Certification of Quality and/or non-clinical data by CAT

•At any stage of development (although minimum set of data)

Data required and standards

� Data and methodology in compliance with scientific/technical

requirements

� Minimum set of data:

� Quality: General information and specific on starting materials,

characterization and control of drug substance, description and

composition of product

� Non-clinical: primary pharmacology data, biodistribution data, 1

toxicology study

Page 47: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Clinical Trials of ATMPs

Clinical Trial Directive (2001/20/EC)Not under the responsibility of EMEA

Opportunities for communication among regulators

� National level in competent authorities

� European level

- European Clinical Trial Facilitation Group - voluntary harmonization

procedure for assessment of multinational clinical trials

- National experts in CAT, EMEA cell-based product/gene therapy

working parties

� International level: ICH gene therapy discussion group

� EMEA-FDA confidential arrangement on ATMPs

Harmonization of scientific requirements for cell or gene therapy at EU and international level

Page 48: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Marketing Authorization

Scientific and technical requirements� Quality, non-clinical and clinical data in Marketing Authorization

Application intended to fit living biologic nature of ATMPs

Revision of Annex I (Directive 2001/83/EC) pending

� General requirements underpinned by EMEA or ICH guidances

EMEA centralized procedure mandatory� Harmonised requirements, uniform and direct access to market

� Synergy between EMEA scientific committees - CAT, CHMP

� Pooling of expertise at all levels (CAT, CHMP, Scientific Advisory Groups, Working Parties)

Additional information on packaging and labelling

Page 49: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Post-Authorization

• EMA guideline on follow-up on Efficacy and Safety, Risk Management for ATMPs (11/2008)

• Traceability requirements for manufacturer and clinical site(s) where ATMP is used

• Follow-up of efficacy and of adverse reactions

• Risk management system and pharmacovigilance

Page 50: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

European Regulatory Framework: Current

Status, Developments• Definitions and technical requirements

– Directive 2001/83/EC - Ongoing revision of Annex I, part 4

• Cells/tissue donation, procurement and testing

– Directive 2004/23/EC - Unchanged

• GMPs

– Directive 2003/94/EC - Ongoing revision of Annex 2 to GMP Guidance

• Clinical trials

– Directive 2001/20/EC - Unchanged

• GCPs

– Directive 2005/28/EC - Guideline specific to ATMPs in preparation

• Marketing Approval Application

– EC Regulation 726/2004 - Centralized procedure for ATMPs

Page 51: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Human Cell-based Medicinal Products:

Manufacturing

• Controlled quality of starting materials

– Cells - primary origin, cell lines (appropriate banking

system)

– Other material, reagents, excipients (enzymes,

cytokines, antibiotics…)

– Matrix, device, scaffold components

• Validated manufacturing process

– In-process controls

– Batch definition (from sourcing to labeling of final container)

Guideline on Human Cell-based Medicinal Products (EMEA/CHMP/410869/2006)

Page 52: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Human Cell-based Medicinal Products:

Characterization

• Characterization elements

– Cell purity

– Impurities (product or process related)

– Adventitious agents

• Quality control

– Release criteria

– Stability

• Potency assay

– …based on the intended biological effect which should

be ideally related to the clinical response

Guideline on Human Cell-based Medicinal Products (EMEA/CHMP/410869/2006)

Page 53: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Human Cell-based Medicinal Products:

Challenges

• Balance between risks, quality requirements and

specific limitations of the cell-based products

(limited sample size, short shelf-life, unique

manufacturing process)

• Requirement of alternative test methods

(alternative microbiological tests for products with

short shelf-life)

• Living cells are intrinsically variable and

heterogeneous

Guideline on Human Cell-based Medicinal Products (EMEA/CHMP/410869/2006)

Page 54: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Human Cell-based Medicinal Products:

Non-Clinical Development

• Conventional requirements not always appropriate, deviation should be justified

• To demonstrate proof-of-principle, define pharmacological and toxicological effects predictive of human response

• Support intended clinical use

– Dose

– Route of administration and application

– Identification of parameters for monitoring in patients

• Relevant animal model

– Combined studies - pharm/tox, safety, local tolerance

Guideline on Human Cell-based Medicinal Products (EMEA/CHMP/410869/2006)

Page 55: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

EMEA Guidance Documents• Guideline on human cell-based medicinal products

(EMEA/CHMP/410896/2006)

• Concept paper on the development of a guideline on the risk-based approach according to annex I, part IV of directive 2001/83/EC applied to advanced therapy medicinal products (CHMP/CPWP)708420/09)

• Reflection paper on stem cell-based medicinal products(CAT/571134/09)

• Human cell-based medicinal products CHMP/410869/06

• Points to Consider on Xenogeneic Cell Therapy CHMP/1199/02

• Potency Testing of Cell-based Immunotherapy medicinal Products for Treatment of Cancer CHMP/BWP/271475/06

• Points to Consider on Xenogeneic Cell Therapy Medicinal ProductsCHMP/165085/07

• Xenogeneic Cell-based Medicinal Products CHMP/CPWP/83508/09

• Reflection paper on in vitro-cultured chondrocyte containing products for cartilage repair of the knee CAT/CPWP/288934/09

Page 56: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Page 57: Current Regulation of HCT-Ps and Tissue Banks in US and ... · Current Regulation of HCT/Ps and Tissue Banks in the US and Europe Scott R. Burger, MD ... • Stem cells for CNS indications

www.ac-gt.com

Summary

• Living biological products present unique

challenges in development, manufacturing,

characterization, and delivery.

• Compliance with GMPs and GTPs fosters both

good science and good clinical medicine, and

(mostly) makes good business sense.

• Rigorous, evolving characterization and process

control are vital to address biological

heterogeneity and variability. Processes,

analytical methods, and product definition must

evolve over multiple clinical trials.