courageous conversations courageous conversations: when and how for the andsooha public health...
TRANSCRIPT
Courageous Conversations
COURAGEOUS CONVERSATIONS: When and How
for the ANDSOOHA Public Health Nursing Management
Facilitated by:
Janet P. Schmidt
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY
Identify one particular challenging situation at work. Reflect on a recent unsatisfying conversation that you had
with this person. Could be with a colleague, person who reports to you
or someone who you report to.
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY Reflection #1
• Share a ‘snap shot’ of the context, highlighting the one conversation
• What did the other person do that was not helpful (be specific) i.e. raised voice, rolled eyes, said…
You will be given 2 minutes each
Courageous Conversations
• What impact did the conversation have on you at the moment, that night, during the week….
Courageous Conversations
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY Reflection #2
Imagine that the other person is sitting in your place. How would they answer the following question:
• What did you do in the conversation that was not helpful?
Take 1 minutes each
Courageous Conversations
• Who started this situation?
• Who has more organizational power?
• For those of you with less organizational power, does power effect impact?
Courageous Conversations
Courageous Conversations
Mapping the Relationship
Gather information
Disruption of Expectations
Stability/Productivity
Commitment
PinchCrunch
Courageous Conversations
Follow my instructions
Be informed about what is happening
in organization Be respected
Be listened to
Be consulted on decisions that
effect me
Enough time to complete
tasks
Opportunities for
advancement
Be allowed to do tasks in my
way
Be treated
fairly
More face time, less
Clear, timely feedback
Be spoken to with
appropriate tone
More email
Use my expertise
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY Reflection #3• Map out your relationship using the Relationship
Map• Was the conversation a ‘pinch’ or a ‘crunch’?• What are the expectations that they are not
meeting (pinches)?• What ‘paths’ have you explored on this map in your
relationship to date?• Were there initial ‘pinches’ (early warning
indicators) you experienced in the relationship?Take 3 minutes each
Courageous Conversations
When someone does not meet your expectations (pinches) you can…
1. Let it go2. Complain to someone else3. Pinch back4. Hold on to it5. Crunch back6. Talk about it
Courageous Conversations
Three Steps to Creating a Culture
When someone is not meeting your expectations and you stay silent….
• The first time you give consent• The second time you give permission• The third time you have lowered the
standard.
Courageous Conversations
Courageous Conversations
EXPECTATIONSDISAPPOINTMENT = ---------------------
REALITY
Courageous Conversations
“The only real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new landscapes but in having new eyes”
By Marcel Proust
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY Reflection #4
1. How have you made sense of why the person is not meeting expectations?
2. What have you done to address the situation? Think of as many different strategies as you can remember that you have used over time. (pinch options)
Courageous Conversations
Private
Action
Effect
Intent
Public
MeaningMaking
Words – 7% Tone –
38% Body Language – 55%
TOTAL -100%
Courageous Conversations
Utube Clips:
The Hospital Incidenthttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItG-U8OpVz4
The Surprise Dinnerhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gaP0aIsSINo
Courageous Conversations
Courageous Conversations
How we make meaning….
Edward Muzio on
The Ladder of Inference Creates Bad Judgement
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K9nFhs5W8o8
Courageous Conversations
Courageous Conversations
Meaning Making…
We are meaning making people. We are constantly creating stories about the
motivations and intentions of other people (and they are doing the same). We quickly believe our stories to be true and repeat them in our heads and to our closest colleagues, not to mention our friends and family members.
Courageous Conversations
The Problem….
All too often we analyze the situation, carefully considering why they are behaving in that way. Ultimately we come up with some theory that we believe to be true and often our own actions make it true and make it worse.
The Reality: What you believe will greatly impact what you do and how you will do it.
Courageous Conversations
• George Zimmerman – self appointed neighbourhood watch captain, focused on law and order
• Trayvon Martins – walking home with a hoody
Courageous Conversations
A question that opens the possibilities…..
Why would a reasonable, rational person do this?
Albeit it imperfect….
Courageous Conversations
SURVEY OF 64,000 WORKERS WILLING NOT WILLING
AB
LE
NO
T A
BL
EEmployees were unclear about supervisors expectations and have insufficient support to accomplish those
expectations – 89%
Employees understand supervisors expectations but are not committed to
accomplishing them – 1%
Employees have in- adequate knowledge or
skill – 9.5%Employees are incapable of learning to achieve or physically incapable of achieving expectation
- .5%
UNKNOWN – likely a small percentage of above
Courageous Conversations
Partnering with Employees: A Practical System for Building Empowered Relationships by Duke Nielsen
Jossey Bass, 1993
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY Reflection #5
1. How have you made sense of why the person is doing what they are doing?
2. What thoughts have you had about the other person recently?
3. How has your behaviour changed towards that person? What have you noticed? What may be happening that you are not noticing?
Courageous Conversations
Speculate on a reason that is more positive? A possibility that makes them reasonable and rationale with positive intent.
Courageous Conversations
The Set-Up-To-Fail Syndromeby Jean-Francois Manzoni and Jeau-Louis Barsoux, HBR, 1998
• “an employee’s poor performance can be blamed largely on his boss.”
• “The Pygmalion effect is when individual lives up to great expectations.”
• “Set-up-to-fail syndrome explains the opposite.”
Courageous Conversations
Courageous Conversations
Courageous Conversations
“a dynamic that usually creeps up on the boss and the subordinate until
suddenly both of them realize that the relationship has gone sour.”
Courageous Conversations
“…up to 90% of all managers treat some subordinates as though they
were members of an in-group, while they consign others to membership in
an out-group.”
Courageous Conversations
“We judge ourselves by our intentions.
Others judge us by the impact/effect of our actions.”
- A client at end of mediation process
Courageous Conversations
Setting Clear Expectations….
Courageous Conversations
The Perspective Check
Gather Information
Stability/Productivity
Commitment
Pinch
Courageous Conversations
Perception Check Preparation:• Observe behaviour• Identify and suspend judgment; put your
parrot in your pocket (you might be right you might be wrong, I don’t know)
• Become curious; of other’s intent• Become calm; wait until your emotions have
gone to neutral
Courageous Conversations
The Perspective Check1. Introduce the conversation
“Do you have a minute, I want to check something with you”
2. Name the action (pause momentarily)“I noticed that you interrupted Joan a number of times during the meeting.”
3. Invite the person to clarify their understanding.“What was going on for you?” OR “Are you aware of the policy?”
4. Clarify the Expectation
5. Problem solve (if necessary)
6. End Conversation
Courageous Conversations
Private
Action
Effect
Intent
Public
Make Meaning
Words – 7%Tone – 38%Body Language – 55%
Requesting a Different Action
Courageous Conversations
FEEDBACK
Traditionalist – “No news is good news”Baby Boomer – “ Feedback once a year, with lots
of documentation!”Gen Xer’s – “Sorry to interrupt, but how am I
doing”Millennials – “Feedback whenever I want it at
the push of a button.”
Courageous Conversations
“The biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has been
accomplished.”
George Bernard Shaw
Courageous Conversations
Frequent Strategies…
1) hope it goes away or 2) trust that they will figure it out.
The Problem: It often doesn’t resolve itself, and they interpret your silence as endorsement/ agreement.
Courageous Conversations
OR….
3) Wait until you are frustrated and then talk to the person.
The Problem: Your frustration will invariably impact your delivery. The end result is that you will come across stronger than you think and people will be hurt, embarrassed, defensive, etc. and will either shut down (flight) or power up (fight).
Courageous Conversations
OR
4) Give them subtle messages like look away when they are doing something displeasing or not be as friendly, so they can self correct.
The Problem: Often people don’t know what they are doing that needs to change and will interpret your distancing as disrespectful or that you don’t care about them.
Courageous Conversations
TOPunitive
WITHAccountability
Neglectful
NotPermissive
For
HIGH
LOW
Con
trol
(pr
ogre
ssiv
e di
scip
line)
Support (encouragement, nurture) HIGH
Adapted by Janet Schmidt from Ted Wachtel (1999, February). RestorativeJustice in Everyday Life: Beyond the Formal Ritual.
Social Discipline Window
Courageous Conversations
Views on Discipline1. Identify a recent time when you used each of the
strategies (neglectful, permissive, accountability, punitive)
2. Are there certain strategies that you gravitate towards?
3. What are your beliefs and values that support your preferred discipline strategies. Are they the same or different than those that raised you or taught you?
Courageous Conversations
Punishment ApproachAn offence is viewed as a violation of the institution (state, school, workplace, association) defined by rule breaking and guilt. Justice determines blame and administers pain in a contest between the offending party and the institution generally directed by systematic rules.
Typical Questions:•What rule has been broken?•Who is to blame?•What do they deserve?
Courageous Conversations
Participatory Approach
An offence is a violation of people and relationships. It creates obligations to make things right. Justice involves the person that has been hurt, the offending party, and the community in a search for solutions which promote repair, reconciliation, and reassurance that the situation will not occur.
Typical Questions:•Who has been hurt?•What are their needs?•Who is obligated to address these needs?
Courageous Conversations
TOPunitive
WITHAccountability
Neglectful
NotPermissive
For
HIGH
LOW
Con
trol
(pr
ogre
ssiv
e di
scip
line)
Support (encouragement, nurture) HIGH
Adapted by Janet Schmidt from Ted Wachtel (1999, February). RestorativeJustice in Everyday Life: Beyond the Formal Ritual.
Social Discipline Window
Courageous Conversations
Your contribution….
1. You didn’t do something you should have or you did something you shouldn’t of.
2. Process• Avoided until now• Been unapproachable/unavailable
3. Intersections (differences colliding)• Background, preferences, communication style
4. Unclear Role Expectations5. Reactions to others behaviour
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY Reflection #6What has been your contribution?
1. Have you been silent?2. Have you acted it out rather than talked it out?3. Have you been defensive in previous conversations?4. Did you miss asking them why it happened?5. Have you been punitive in the past with this person? 6. Have you used the best ‘volume’ level?7. Have you provided support for the person? Do they
feel supported?(How would they answer this question?)
Courageous Conversations
Elements of Effective Conflict Resolution/Management
1. Caring/Compassion/Support (being kind)2. Honesty/Clarity (being clear)
What are you good at? What do you sometimes miss?
(Their perception not yours)
Courageous Conversations
Lunch!
Courageous Conversations
Elements of Effective Conflict Resolution/Management
1. Caring/Compassion/Support (being kind)2. Honesty/Clarity (being clear)
What are you good at? What do you sometimes miss?
(Their perception not yours)
Courageous Conversations
Why is this not easy….
Courageous Conversations
DEFENSIVENESS
• Defensiveness is a behavioural response to a perceived threat or attack to ones face or self-esteem.
• Result of what and how something is communicated.
Courageous Conversations
Courageous Conversations
Two Pathways of the Brain
1. The first path is connected to thought; our consciousness allows us to become aware, feel the emotion, comprehend its meaning, and ultimately choose an appropriate action.
2. The second path (much faster) is designed to take immediate defensive action, focusing on bodily responses. This happens unconsciously.
Courageous Conversations
Three Core Identities1) I am competent! Am I Competent?
2) I am a good person! Am I a Good Person?
3) I am worthy of love! Am I Worthy of Love?
Which identity do you feel challenges at moments like this?
Difficult Conversations: How to Discuss What Matters Most by Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton and Sheila Heen Penguin, 1999
Courageous Conversations
Cognitive Dissonance
Self Justification
Mistakes Were Made (but not by me), Carol Travis and Elliot Aronson, Harcourt, 2007
Courageous Conversations
Frequent Trigger for Defensiveness
Evaluation – You are evaluating or judging the other person.
Description – You describe what is going on rather than evaluating it.
Courageous Conversations
Example
Evaluation: •“You don’t know what you’re talking about!”•“That would never work.”•“You are a bully, sexist, racist, mircro- manager…
Utube by Jay Sooth on Racism
Courageous Conversations
“Observing without evaluating is the highest form of human
intelligence.”By J. Krishnamurti
Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Compassion Marshall B. Rosenberg p. 29
Courageous Conversations
Feedback Often Includes
• Description
• Interpretation
• Evaluation
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY Reflection #7
Describe without evaluation the expectation gap(s). Also clearly name a number of things the person does well.
“Exaggerating things or minimizing things can lead to problems so we need to do our best to see things the way they really are.”
Courageous Conversations
Feedback Pitfalls1. Exaggeration of frequency2. Judgmental – inferring
negative intent3. Blaming4. Vague5. Rambling6. In Public7. Aggressive8. We don’t give any
Courageous Conversations
Note: Defensiveness lingers…
That energy surge from our heightened state of readiness (adrenalin) takes 20 minutes to 1 hour to dissipate. During that time, people will not be able to think clearly. The time becomes even longer if someone does something to keep it going.
You can’t talk someone out of being defensive!
Courageous Conversations
Cognitive Dissonance
Taki
ng R
espo
nsib
ility Self Justification
Mistakes Were Made (but not by me), Carol Travis and Elliot Aronson, Harcourt, 2007
Courageous ConversationsResolution Skills Centre, Winnipeg, Canada
“The truth is that many confrontations fail not because others are bad and wrong but because we handle them poorly.” p. 46
Crucial Confrontations by Kerry Patterson, Joseph Grenny, Ron McMillan, Al Switzler, McGraw Hill, 2005
Courageous Conversations
Options
• Being defensive is our primary strategy to self-protection.
• What are other options?
“To be open is to be vulnerable and to be vulnerable is to be weak.”
Courageous Conversations
PinchCrunch
Recovering from the negative impact of our actions:post pinch or crunch
Courageous Conversations
Three things to Accept about Yourself
1. You will make mistakes.2. Your intentions are complex.• Conscious• Less conscious• Unconscious3. You have contributed to the problem.
Courageous Conversations
Reasons to admit your mistakes
1. You will probably be found out anyway.2. You will learn and grow.3. You undoubtedly did something that resulted in
making the situation worse.4. You can lead by example.5. People will like you more.
Courageous Conversations
The irony
“The mind wants to protect itself from the pain of dissonance with the balm of self-justification, but
the soul wants to confess.” (p. 217)
Mistakes Were Made (but not by me), Carol Travis and Elliot Aronson, Harcourt, 2007
Courageous Conversations
Remember a good apology is rarely the end of the conversation. Most often it removes the conversation barrier and
allows for the critical conversation (renegotiation) to take place.
Courageous Conversations
Balancing the Head and the Heart
Courageous Conversations
Beliefs about Conflict
Others typically respond to me in the way I invite them to the table. The kind of
space I create for others is the way they will show up to me.
Courageous Conversations
CASE STUDY: Reflection #8
As you reflect on your case study, what is your next step?
What are one or two other ideas you want to incorporate from this workshop?
Courageous Conversations
HAPPINESS = Reality - Expectations
Courageous Conversations
And they also have expectations of you…
Two questions to discover their expectations of you.
1)What do you need me to do more off?
2)What do you need me to less off?
Courageous Conversations
Four Things Every Employee Wants to Know
1. What am I supposed to do?2. Will you let me do it?3. Will you help me when I need it?4. Will you let me know how I’m doing?
Remember: Performance is impacted the most by frequency and timeliness of feedback
www.allthingsworkplace.com
Courageous Conversations
“Life shrinks or expands in proportion of one’s
courage.”
Courageous Conversations
Anais Nin
“Life shrinks or expands in proportion of one’s
courage.”
Email: [email protected] Coming Website: www.janetschmidt.ca