constitution and reform education consortium creco · 6 baseline report on conflict-mapping and...
TRANSCRIPT
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
BASELINE REPORT ON
CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
CONSTITUTION AND REFORM EDUCATION CONSORTIUM
CRECO
ISBN: 978-9966-21-158-3
CONSTITUTION & REFORM EDUCATION CONSORTIUM (CRECO)
P.O. BOX 2231 – 00200, CITY SQUARE, NAIROBI
UPPERHILL, MATUMBATO ROAD, GATE 39
TEL: 020 3590735, 0722 209779
EMAIL: [email protected]
www.crecokenya.org
All or part of this publication may be reproduced freely, provided the CONSTITUTION & REFORM EDUCATION CONSORTIUM (CRECO) is duly
acknowledged.
Design, Layout & Printing
Myner Logistics
Tel: 020 - 22 11 890/1
APRIL 2012
© CRECO
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 3
CONTENTS PAGEACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.......................................................................................................................5
TABLE OF ABBREVIATIONS / ACRONYMS...........................................................................................6
ABOUT CRECO......................................................................................................................................7
ABOUT ELOG........................................................................................................................................8
FOREWORD..........................................................................................................................................9
THE REPORT.......................................................................................................................................10
CONFLICT MAPPING BASELINE ASSESSMENT.................................................................................11
CONFLICT RATING ON COUNTIES......................................................................................................13
CHAPTER ONE....................................................................................................................................14
STUDYBACKGROUND.......................................................................................................................14
THEBASELINESTUDY........................................................................................................................15
CONCEPTUALFRAMEWORK.............................................................................................................16
CHAPTER TWO...................................................................................................................................18
NEWCONSTITUTIONANDREFORMS..............................................................................................18
SECURITYSECTORREFORMS............................................................................................................19
POLICEREFORMSANDINSTITUTIONS.............................................................................................20
CHAPTER THREE..................................................................................................................................21
STUDYFINDINGS...............................................................................................................................21
MOMBASACOUNTY.........................................................................................................................21
KWALECOUNTY.................................................................................................................................22
KILIFICOUNTY...................................................................................................................................24
TANARIVERCOUNTY........................................................................................................................25
LAMUCOUNTY.................................................................................................................................26
TAITATAVETA...................................................................................................................................28
GARISSACOUNTY.............................................................................................................................30
WAJIRCOUNTY.................................................................................................................................32
MANDERACOUNTY..........................................................................................................................34
MARSABITCOUNTY...........................................................................................................................36
ISIOLOCOUNTY................................................................................................................................38
MERUCOUNTY.................................................................................................................................40
THARAKA-NITHICOUNTY.................................................................................................................41
EMBUCOUNTY.................................................................................................................................43
KITUICOUNTY..................................................................................................................................44
MACHAKOSCOUNTY........................................................................................................................45
MAKUENICOUNTY...........................................................................................................................46
4 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
NYANDARUACOUNTY......................................................................................................................47
NYERICOUNTY.................................................................................................................................48
KIRINYAGACOUNTY..........................................................................................................................50
MURANG’ACOUNTY........................................................................................................................51
KIAMBUCOUNTY.............................................................................................................................52
TURKANACOUNTY...........................................................................................................................54
WESTPOKOTCOUNTY......................................................................................................................56
SAMBURUCOUNTY..........................................................................................................................58
TRANSNZOIACOUNTY.....................................................................................................................60
UASINGISHUCOUNTY......................................................................................................................62
ELGEYO/MARAKWETCOUNTY.......................................................................................................65
NANDICOUNTY................................................................................................................................67
BARINGOCOUNTY............................................................................................................................68
LAIKIPIACOUNTY.............................................................................................................................70
NAKURUCOUNTY.............................................................................................................................72
NAROKCOUNTY...............................................................................................................................75
KAJIADOCOUNTY.............................................................................................................................76
KERICHOCOUNTY.............................................................................................................................78
BOMETCOUNTY...............................................................................................................................79
KAKAMEGACOUNTY........................................................................................................................81
VIHIGACOUNTY...............................................................................................................................82
BUNGOMACOUNTY.........................................................................................................................83
BUSIACOUNTY.................................................................................................................................84
SIAYACOUNTY..................................................................................................................................85
KISUMUCOUNTY..............................................................................................................................86
HOMABAYCOUNTY.........................................................................................................................87
MIGORICOUNTY...............................................................................................................................88
KISIICOUNTY....................................................................................................................................89
NYAMIRACOUNTY............................................................................................................................90
NAIROBICITYCOUNTY.....................................................................................................................91
CHAPTER FOUR..................................................................................................................................94
CONCLUSIONS.................................................................................................................................94
RECOMMENDATIONS......................................................................................................................96
REFERENCES.......................................................................................................................................99
ANNEXURE: TABLE ON RATING COUNTIES.....................................................................................100
VISITTOTHECONFLICTAREASOFISIOLO..........................................................................................101
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Constitution and Reform Education Consortium (CRECO) Secretariatwishes to acknowledgeWambuaKitukuwhoauthoredthisbaselinereport.WearealsogratefultoTomKagwe,theimmediateformer Chairperson of CRECO Management Committee, for his expert opinion and input whiledevelopingthisreport.
WethanktheManagementCommitteeofCRECOforprovidinguswithaconduciveenvironmentforcarryingoutthiswork.
TheElectionObservationGroup(ELOG)SteeringCommitteeandmemberorganisationarethankedfortheirsupportandandencouragementinthecourseofcompilingthisreport.IndeedthisreportisCRECO’scontributiontotheworkofELOG.
WedoherebyalsoacknowledgethetirelesseffortsofthestaffattheCRECOSecretariatwhoincluded:SalomeNduta,LeoMutisya,BoazMugotoandReginaOpondowhodidimmenseworkandfollow-uptoensurethefinalizationofthisbaselinereport.
Rev.Fr.NicholasMakauofConsolataMissionaries/RSCK-JusticeandPeaceisthankedforallowingustoreproducehisreportontheisiolocrisisinthisbaselinereport.
TheviewscontainedhereinreflectCRECOownviews.
MayallofusworktowardsapeacefulKenyabefore,duringandaftertheseupcomingelections.
__________________________
Kawive, Wambua
ExecutiveSecretary–CRECOSecretariat
6 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
TABLE OF ABBREVIATIONS / ACRONYMS
CDF Constituencies’DevelopmentFundCIPEV CommissionofInquiryintoPostElectionViolenceCRA CommissionforRevenueAllocationCRECO ConstitutionandReformEducationConsortiumCSOs CivilSocietyOrganizationsCSR CorporateSocialResponsibilityDPC DistrictPeaceCommitteeECK ElectoralCommissionofKenyaELOG ElectionObservationGroupFGM FemaleGenitalMutilationFORD ForumforRestorationofDemocracyFY FinancialYearGNU GrandNationalUnityPartyHIV HumanImmuno-deficiencyVirusICC InternationalCriminalCourtICT InformationCommunicationTechnologyIDPs InternallyDisplacedPersonsIEBC IndependentElectoralandBoundariesCommissionIIBRC InterimIndependentBoundariesReviewCommissionIIEC InterimIndependentElectoralCommissionIPOA IndependentPolicingOversightAuthorityJSC JudicialServiceCommissionKANU KenyaAfricanNationalUnionKCC KenyaCooperativeCreameriesKCPB KenyaCerealsandProduceBoardKDF KenyaDefenceForcesKENGEN KenyaElectricityGenerationCompanyKPF KenyaPoliceForceKVDA KerioValleyDevelopmentAuthorityLATF LocalAuthorityTransferFundMDAs Ministries,DepartmentsandAgenciesMP MemberofParliamentMRC MombasaRepublicanCouncilNARC NationalRainbowCoalitionNCIC NationalCohesionandIntegrationCommissionNDI NationalDemocraticInstituteNGOs Non-GovernmentalOrganizationsNIS NationalIntelligenceServiceNPS NationalPoliceServiceNPSC NationalPoliceServiceCommissionNSC NationalSteeringCommitteeonPeaceBuildingandConflictManagementNSIS NationalSecurityIntelligenceServiceODM OrangeDemocraticMovementPCC PoliceCodeofConductPEV Post-ElectionsViolencePNU PartyofNationalUnityPRIC PoliceReformsImplementationCommitteeSSR SecuritySectorReformsTJRC Truth,JusticeandReconciliationCommissionURP UnitedRepublicanPartyUSAID UnitedStatesAgencyforInternationalDevelopmentVPK VisionPartyofKenya
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 7
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
ABOUT CRECO
The Constitution and Reform Education Consortium (CRECO)isacoalitionofcivilsocietyorganisations(CSOs)workingondemocracy,governance, legalandhumanrights issues. Itwasfounded in1989and registered as Charitable Trust. Although, founded by legal and human rights NGOs, CRECO’smembershiphasevolvedovertheyears.CurrentlythecoalitionhasCSOsworkingindifferentsectorsbut with a common aim of promoting constitutionalism and good governance ion Kenya. As atDecember2010,CRECOhadatotalmembershipof25CSOs.
CRECObegan itsworkwith countrywide civic education targeted at citizens’ participation in theprocessofreviewingKenya’sconstitution.TheclimaxofthiswasinthedesignandimplementationoftheNationalCivicEducationProgram(NCEPI)intheperiod2000-2002.NCEP1servedasaplatformforcreatinganewcadreofleadershipinKenya.The“MoiMustGo!”campaign,aninitiativeoftheprogram,wasmajorsuccess.ItattributedtothemassivetriumphoftheNationalRainbowCoalition(NARC) in the 2002 general elections. The NARC Government come to powerwith a promise ofdeliveringanewconstitutionin100days.Thepromisewasneverfulfilledduetoanumberoffactorsincluding the feeling that thepublicwasn’tadequatelyconsultedand involved in theconstitutionreviewprocess.AdraftConstitutionpresentedbytheGovernmentwasrejectedbycitizensduringthe21stNovember2005ConstitutionalReferendum.
Intheyears2006–2007,CRECOwasinvolvedinNCEP2,afollowonprogramofNCEPI.Thepurposeoftheprogramwastochampioncomprehensivegovernancereformsaheadofthe2007elections.Throughthisprogram,CRECOchampionedadvocacyinitiativesaimedatstrengthening institutionsthatwouldguaranteefreeandfairelectionscome2007.Thereformsenvisagedwerenotsuccessfulandthisculminatedinthechaosexperiencedduringthe2007elections.Inthe2007post-electionperiod,CRECOamongotherCSOscampaignedfortheinclusionoftheAgenda4reformsinthepoliticalnegotiations.Akeyoutputofthisadvocacywasthatthecoalitionpartnersagreedoncomprehensivereformsandsetupseveralcommissionsandtimelinesforarealisationofthesame.SubsequentlytheIndependentReviewCommission(IREC),theCommissionfortheInvestigationofthePost-ElectionViolence(CIPEV)weresetup.Thesecommissionsemphasizedthatthecountryhadtohaveanewconstitutiontobethebasisforcomprehensivereforms.
InanefforttoensurethatKenyansgotanewpeople-drivenconstitution,CRECOmobilisedCSOstocreateanationalplatformforadvocacyon,andvalueadditionto,theConstitutionalReviewProcess.Thisinitiative,calledthe“KatibaSasa”campaign,wascarriedoutforoveroneyearandinterfacedwiththeworkoftheCommitteeofExperts(CoE)-acommitteethatwastaskedtoharmonisetheviewsofKenyansontheconstitution.Duringthe2010referendumperiod,CRECOwithotherHIVOs-fundedpartners,setupandrolledoutanationalICTbasedmonitoringplatform–Uchaguzi–thatmonitored the referendum. In another front, CRECOwith six other partners in a network calledElectionsObservationGroup(ELOG),carriedoutacomprehensivee-dayobservationofthevotingprocessusingthePVTmethodology.
ApprovalofthenewConstitutionintheAugust4,2010referendumwasakeymilestoneinCRECO’squest forconstitutionalismandgoodgovernance inKenya.CRECOenvisions“a justsociety”. In itscurrentstrategy(2011-2015),CRECOshiftsitsfocusandresourcestopromoteimplementationofthenewconstitutionthroughadvocacy,civicengagement,institutionalstrengtheningandpartnershipsdevelopment. The strategic drivers identified in the strategy are Public SectorManagement andHumanRights.Fromthese, theorganisationhasdevelopedthreeprogrammes:CivicEngagement,HumanrightsandInstitutionalCapacityDevelopment
8 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
ABOUT ELOG
Elections Observation Group(ELOG),aconsortiumofcivilsocietyorganisationsandotherstakeholderswasestablishedin2010,toprovideapermanentnationalplatformthroughwhichcitizenscanmonitorgeneralelectionsinKenyaandothercountriesinAfrica.TheprimarymissionofELOGistopromotedemocraticgovernanceinKenyaandotherAfricancountriesbyensuringthatcountriesholdregular,transparent,accountableandcredibleelections.ELOGmembersinclude:
• CentreforGovernanceandDevelopment(CGD);
• ConsortiumforEmpowermentandDevelopmentofMarginalizedCommunities(CEDMAC);
• ConstitutionandReformEducationConsortium(CRECO);
• InstituteforEducationinDemocracy(IED);
• SupremeCouncilofKenyaMuslims(SUPKEM);
• EcumenicalCentreforJusticeandPeace(ECJP)
• UnitedDisabledPersonsofKenya(UDPK)
• CatholicJusticeandPeaceCommission(CJPC),
• YouthAgenda(YA)
• FederationofWomenLawyersofKenya(FIDA).
ELOG Strategy on Thematic Issues Observation
Basedon theVision andMission as captured in the strategic plan, ELOGhasdetermined that itsgreatestfocuswithintheplanperiodwillbethe2012/13Generalelections.ItisaroundthisthatallofELOG’splannedobjectivesandstrategieswillbeorganizedwiththegoaltocomprehensivelymonitorandobservethenextelectioninordertostrengthenelectoralprocessinKenya.
The ELOG strategic plan identifies six key result areas. These include Enhancing stakeholders’awareness;StrengtheningELOGCoalitionandobservationinfrastructure;Comprehensivethematicmonitoring andobservation; E-day observation;Adoption and enhancement of technology basedmethodologies;andEnhancedregionaldevelopmentsandengagementonelectionobservationandreforms.
Broadly, theobjective identifiedunder the key result areaonenhanced thematicmonitoringandobservationistomonitorkeythematicissuesinfluencingtheconductoffreeandfairelections.
ELOG has particularly identified the following seven key thematic issues under which scientificthematicmonitoringandobservationshallbeanchored:
• VoterRegistration
• MonitoringimplementationofPoliticalPartiesActandPoliticalFinancing
• AdvocacyonElectoralLawReformandConstituencyDelimitation
• CampaignMonitoring
• PromotionandParticipationofMarginalizedGroups
• VoterEducation
• MediaMonitoring
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 9
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
FOREWORD
ThecomingintoforceoftheConstitutionofKenyain2010haswidelybeenseenasacornerstoneforthedevelopmentofanationalethosthatunitesusasacountryandaprecursortopeacefulco-existence.Theletterandspiritoftheconstitutionhavethustobeoperationalisedthroughaplethoraofconnectedactionssuchasreformsingovernmentarmsandorgans,legislativeeffectivenessandefficiency,respectfortheruleofjustlawandcivicengagement.
The role of the citizens in ensuring that as a countrywe realise peace and prosperity cannot begainsaid.Kenya’sdiversityisperhapsitsstrongestasset,butinthepastithasbeenusedasafulcrumfordivisivepolitics andmarginalisation.Wehaveanopportunity as a country to change that byacceptingthefactthatweareonenation,onepeopleandareboundbyonedestiny.
The Constitution and Reform Education Consortium– CRECO, undertook a study tomap out theincidences of violence as has beenwitnessed in the recent past in order to develop a basis formonitoringandcarryingoutotheractionsbydifferentactorsthatarehopedtoculminateinbuildingacultureofpeaceinKenya.Indeedthisstudyisacriticalbutfirststepintheprocess.Thereportisreferencedtomarch31st2012.
Ourkeyfindingsascapturedinthetablesbelow[Table1&Table2]indicatethatwegenerallyhavehigher incidences of violence in amajority of the counties. The attendant factors for the ratingsincludeethnicintolerance,borderconflicts,politicalpartyzoning,competitionoverlandandotherresources,proliferationofsmallarms,weaksecurityandpoverty.Thesefactorscannotbetreatedinisolation,andsomearemoresignificantincertaincountiesthaninothers.Theseareexplainedindetailinthebodyofthereport.
Althoughthisisanissueofconcern,weareawarethattherearemanycivilsocietyorganisationsandstateorgansthataremonitoringconflictandactivelyengagingcommunitiesandpersons inpeacemitigationactivities.Ourconclusionisthatalotmoreworkneedstobedonetoensurethatthethingsthatdivideusarereducedandeventuallyeliminated.
CRECOhopesthatthisreportwillbeusedbythemanyotheractorsasabenchmarkforaction.
George Collins Owuor
CRECO Chairperson
The
Report
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 11
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Table1:CONFLICT MAPPING BASELINE ASSESSMENT
County Political/Security Legal Economic/Social Environment Total
Mombasa 5 2.5 4 5 16.5
Kwale 5 2.5 4 5 16.5
Kilifi 3.5 3 3.5 5 15
Tana River 4.5 2 4.5 4.5 15.5
Lamu 3.5 2 3.5 4 13
Taita Taveta 3.5 2 3.5 4.5 13.5
Garissa 5 3 4.5 4.5 17
Wajir 4.5 2.5 4.5 4.5 16
Mandera 4 2.5 4.5 4.5 15.5
Marsabit 4.5 3 4 4.5 16
Isiolo 5 3 4 4 16
Meru 3 2 2 4 11
Tharaka-Nithi 3.5 2 2 3.5 11
Embu 3.5 1.5 1.5 3 9.5
Kitui 4 3 3.5 3.5 14
Machakos 2 2 2 4 10
Makueni 3.5 2.5 3 3.5 12.5
Nyandarua 3 2.5 3 3 11.5
Nyeri 4 2.5 4 3.5 14
Kirinyaga 4.5 3.5 4 4 16
Murang’a 3.5 3 3.5 3.5 13.5
Kiambu 4.5 3.5 4 4 16
Turkana 4.5 3.5 4 4.5 16.5
West Pokot 4 4 4 4 16
Samburu 4 3 3 3 13
Trans Nzoia 4 3.5 3.5 4.5 15.5
Uasin Gishu 3.5 4.5 3 4.5 15.5
Elgeyo Marakwet
3 2.5 3 3 11.5
Nandi 4.5 2.5 2.5 3 12.5
Baringo 3 2 3 3.5 11.5
Laikipia 4.5 3.5 4 4 16
12 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Nakuru 5 4 3.5 4.5 17
Narok 4 3.5 3.5 4.5 15.5
Kajiado 2.5 2.5 3.5 3.5 12
Kericho 3 3 3.5 3.5 13
Bomet 4.5 3.5 4.5 3 15.5
Kakamega 3.5 3.5 3 3 13
Vihiga 2 4 2 2 10
Bungoma 4.5 4 4 3.5 16
Busia 3 2.5 3.5 3 12
Siaya 3 2.5 2 2 9.5
Kisumu 4.5 2.5 4.5 4 15.5
Homa Bay 3.5 2.5 4 4 14
Migori 4.5 3.5 3 4 15
Kisii 3.5 2.5 3 3.5 12.5
Nyamira 4.5 3.5 4 4.5 16.5
Nairobi 5 2.5 5 4.5 17
Notes:
1. Risksineachcolumnareindicatedona5pointscale:
• 0=thelowestlevelofrisk
• 5=thehighestlevelofrisk.
2. LandissuesareincludedunderEnvironmentcategory.
3. InLegalrisks,thescorestakeaccountofthecontributiontraditionaldisputeresolutionmechanismsmake,setagainstthelevelofaccesstotheformaljudicialsystem.
4. Therearethreeindicativecategoriesofrisk:
0-10 Lowoverallriskscore
11-14 Moderateoverallriskscore
15-20 Highoverallriskscore
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 13
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Table 2: Conflict Rating on Counties
High Conflict Risks Moderate Conflict Risks Low Conflict Risks
Marsabit Kitui EmbuIsiolo Makueni MachakosMandera Nyeri VihigaWajir TaitaTaveta SiayaNarok HomabayGarissa TharakaNithiTanaRiver BusiaMombasa ElgeyoMarakwetKwale SamburuKilifi MeruNairobi KisiiTransNzoia KajiadoNyamira MurangaMigori LamuBomet KerichoKiambu NandiUasinGishu NyandaruaTurkana Baringo
WestPokot KakamegaLaikipia
NakuruKisumuBungomaKirinyaga
14 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
CHAPTER ONE
STUDY BACKGROUNDIntroduction
ThemayhemthatvisitedKenyaafterthe2007/8generalelectionsKenyansclaimedatotalof1,300livesandleftover350,000othersinternallydisplaced.1EventhoughelectoralviolencehadbecomepartandparcelofKenya’spoliticalculturesincetheintroductionofmultipartypoliticsinthe1990s,the nature, level and intensity of the 2007/8 Post-Elections Violence (PEV) was unprecedented.Thewantonkillingswerehaltedwhenthetwoprotagonists’andpoliticalformations(thePartyofNationalUnity(PNU)ledbyPresidentMwaiKibakiandOrangeDemocraticMovement(ODM)ledbyRailaOdinga)signedtheNationalAccordwhichcreatedapowersharingarrangementandlaidtheframeworkforbroad-basedpoliticalreformstoaddresstherootcausesoftheviolence.2
Someof thenotablereformsthatwerecarriedout includedtheestablishmentofcommissionsofinquiryintotheconductoftheelectionsandpost-electionviolence,formationofaTruth,JusticeandReconciliationCommission(TJRC)andcompletionofconstitutionalreformsthathadabortedafterthe2005referendum.Asaresultoftheseprocesses,theElectoralCommissionofKenya(ECK)wasdisbandedandanInterimIndependentElectoralCommission(IIEC)establishedtooverseeelectoralprocessespriortoadoptionofanewconstitution.AnIndependentBoundariesReviewCommissionwassetuptoaddressgrievancesarisingfromunequalrepresentation.
The commission that inquired into post-election violence recommended for the prosecution ofKenyanswhoheld thehighest responsibility for theviolence,whichwasnotdone.This instigatedthe Prosecutor at the International Criminal Court (ICC) to start investigations into the violence,culminatinginthearraignmentofsixKenyansattheICC.Bythetimethisreportwasbeingpublished,fourofthem,(UhuruKenyatta,WilliamRuto,FrancisMuthauraandJoshuaSang)hadbeenindictedtofacefulltrialattheICC,whileMajorGeneralHusseinAliandHenryKosgeyhadbeendischargedofthecharges.
Perhapsthegreatestachievementofthepost-2007reformswastheadoptionofanewconstitutionthroughapeacefulnationalreferendumheldinAugust2010.ThereferenduminitselfvindicatedthedecisiontodisbandthedefunctECKandgavehopethatKenyanscouldconductfutureprocesseswithrelativepeaceandcalm.Theconstitutionusheredinnewinstitutionsandpromisedelectionsin2012.Sadlyhowever,theIndependentBoundariesCommissionwasunabletocompleteitsmandateandhencetheunresolvedissueofunequalrepresentationwascarriedoverintothenewconstitutionaldispensation.
InKenya’shighlypatriarchalenvironment,womenhaveconstantlyfacednumerouselectoralcriseswhenseekingpoliticaloffice.Theyrangefromgenderbiasesinpartynominationstonegativesocio-cultural attitudes from the electorate even to electoral violence instiagted against women.3 TheConstitutionofKenyaprovidesopportunitiesforleadershipnotjustforwomen,buttheyouthandpersonswithdisability.Furthermoretheconstitutionstatesthatparliamentshouldnothavemore1 See Republic of Kenya, Report on Commission on Inquiry into Post Election Violence, 2009, Nairobi: Government Printers 2 See the various reforms and status of each by South Consulting. Visit Kenya National Dialogue and Reconciliation, www.kenyadialgoue.org, accessed April 13, 2012. 3 CREAW in Partnership with AMWIK - Running for political office: A handbook for women Candidates.http//www.creawkenya.org/pdf/running for political office.pdf accessed 16th April 2012
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 15
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
that2/3rdofonegender.Amechanismforthisisyettobeputinplace.
Theyouthhavebeencondemnedfortheroletheyhaveplayed inelectoralviolence intherecenthistoryofKenya.Theyhavebeenaccusedofbeingthefoot-soldiersofthepoliticalandethnicbaronswhohaveeithersponsoredorpresentedviolenceastheonlyalternativetoperceivedorrealconflict.InasmuchastheConstitutionofKenyahasaraftofpromisesfortheyouth,mechanismsofensuringthattheyouthactuallybenefitandworktowardstherealisationoftheconstitutionaldreamhavenotbeenput inplace.KazikwaVijanaandNYEFhaveremainedeither inaccessibleor inadequatetomostyouth.Itistruethatpoverty,unemploymentandunfulfilledpromisesremainfactorsthatfrustratetheyouthandthereforetheir likelihoodtoparticipate in lawlessactivitiesofmilitiasandothergroupingsarehigh.Arayofhopehoweverisdawningonthenationasmoreyouthengageinpeaceinitiativesacrossthecountry.Itshouldalsobementionedthatmoreyouththanevervotedin2007.
RecentlytheHighCourtmadeadecisionthatthenextelectionsshouldbeheldon4thMarch2013,howeveraappealhasbeenlodged.TheCourtofAppealcouldreiteratewhattheHighCourtdecidedoralterthatdatetoanyother,includinginDecember2012asmanyKenyansandsomecommentatorsand politicians have expressed. The stage therefore has been set for another intense season ofcampaignsandelectioneering.
Therefore,thequestionlingeringinthemindsofKenyansis:willKenyawitnesshigherscaleviolencethanthatof2008?ItisagainstthisbackgroundthatCRECOdecidedtoestablishageneralelectionsmonitoringprogrammewithfinancialsupportfromtheNationalDemocraticInstitute(NDI)focusingonconflicthotspots.Thisbaselinereportisthereforepartofthisinitiativeandseekstotoidentifylikely hotspots of violence in 47 Counties of Kenyawith a view of identifyingmeasures that canminimizethechancesoferuptionofviolencebefore,duringandaftertheseelections.
THE BASELINE STUDYObjectives
Theobjectivesofthestudywereto:
• IdentifylikelyhotspotsofviolenceintheCountiesinaccordancewithanalysesofvariedriskfactors;
• Review the legal reforms in the security sector since2008andhow thesewill impactonpeacebuildingandconflictpreventionstrategiesfortheupcomingelections;
• Identifytriggerfactorsthatarelikelytocauseviolenceinthecountry;and,• Identifymeasurestobeputinplacetopreventandmitigateoccurrenceandrecurrenceof
violenceintheidentifiedhotspots.
Methodology
Thestudycoveredallthe47Countiesintherepublicandthepoliticalconstituenciestherein.Thestudywasbasedonadesktopreviewofexistingliteratureincludingreportsbygovernmentsuchascensusreports,demographicsurveys,economicoutlooksurveys,CommissionforRevenueAllocation(CRA)reports,andsoon.Further,reportsbyNon-GovernmentalOrganizations(NGOs),scholarlywritingsinthefieldofconflictandtherelevantlawstodevelopageneralcontextofpeaceandsecurityinKenyawerereliedupon.WithregardtospecificpeaceandsecurityissuesattheCounties,theresearchersfurtherreviewedrelevantreportsandaugmentedthiswithtelephoneinterviewswithkeyinformants,mostlyNGOworkersandopinionleadersresidentinthesaidareas.
16 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Using information obtained from the aforementioned sources, the researchers drafted a reportcontainingthelegalcontextofpeaceandsecurityarchitectureinKenya,Countyprofilesonconflictandpeaceissuesandoverallconclusionsandrecommendations.ThedraftreportwassubjectedtoreviewbyCRECOmembersandtheviewsgeneratedthereafterwereincorporatedintothefinaldraft.
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK Conflict refers toasituationwhereat least twogroupsare inconsciousoppositiontoeachother,pursuing incompatible goals.4 Conflict will usually involve struggles over values and claims overresources,powerandstatus.Conflictscanbecharacterizedasarmed/violentornon-armed/violent(dependingondegreeofuseofweapons),inter-stateorintra-state(dependingongeopoliticalarena),localizedorwidespread(dependingonscope),short-termorprotracted(dependingontime-frame).
Thecausesof conflictsarevaried. In itsdraft report, theKenyanNationalSteeringCommitteeonPeace Building and ConflictManagement (NSC) dichotomizes conflict factors into structural (thatislongtermcauseswhichcreatepotentialclimateforviolentconflictswithoutmakingitseruptioninevitable)andacceleratingortriggerfactors(thatis,events,actionsanddecisionswhichescalatedisputes into violent conflicts).5 Structural factorsmaybe referred toas root causes,whichmeritcloseranddeeperconsiderationwhenattemptingtoresolvelongstandingandprotractedconflicts,whereastriggersandacceleratorsaretheimmediatecausesthathowevercriticalinearlydetectionandwarningsystemsforpreventionofconflicts.
TheNSCfurtheridentifiesstructuralfactors.6Theseinclude:
1. Political: exploitation of ethnic differences for political purposes (politicization ofethnicity), weak state institutions or manipulation of these institutions for politicalpurposes,disenfranchisement,marginalizationofminoritiesandperipheralgroupsanduseoforganizedviolence(gangs)toachievepoliticalends
2. Security:proliferationofarmsandlightweapons,commercializationofcattlerustling,andweaksecurityarrangements.
3. Economic:poverty,inequality,corruption,classconflictandunderdevelopment.
4. Legal:failurebylegalsystemtoresolvedisputesjustlyandcomprehensively,manipulationoflegalsystemtoperpetrateinjustices.
5. Social and cultural: exploitation of cultural differences and identities with negativeconsequences, use of cultural tools (songs, poetry, narratives etc) to propagate andperpetuateconflicts.
6. Environmental:scarcityorinequitableaccesstoanddistributionofenvironmentalgoods(land,water,forestsetc),environmentaldegradationcausingenvironmentalharm.
ThisstudyadoptstheabovefactorsastheconceptualframeworkformappingandanalysingconflictsinKenya.
4 Juma Kathina, Unveiling women as pillars of conflict building in fractured pastoralist communities in Kenya, in United Nations Development Programme interim report for Bureau for Development Programmes accessed from http://magnet.undp.org/ ac-cessed 24th January 2012 5 The National Steering Council on Peacebuilding and Conflict Management, Structural factors driving conflict in Kenya: A multi-dimensional analysis, 2011 unpublished6 Ibid pg 4-21
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 17
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
Thestudyconcentratedalotondesktopresearchandkeyinformantinterviewsaskeymethodologies.ThestudydidnotseektodisaggregateortodoanindepthstudyonparticularissusesaffectingPersonswithDisability,WomenandYouth.Thoughtheyaregenerallyreferredtofurtherstudieswouldbehandyinbringingouttherealityoftheirsituation.Thereportalsodoesnotmaptheexistingactorscarryingoutobservationandpeaceinitiativesacrossthecountry.
18 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
CHAPTER TWO
NEW CONSTITUTION AND REFORMSThe new constitution is big on the doctrine of separation of powers and at this point, especiallyindependenceof institutions suchas the judiciary. It is commonknowledge that in2007and theyears before andevenafter, until the referendum in 2010which saw to thepromulgationof thenewconstitution,thejudiciarywasatthemercyoftheexecutive.Thepresidentcouldappointandfirejudgesatwillandnobodycouldquestionhisactions.Thiscastdoubtsintheeyesofthepublicastotheintegrityofthejudiciary.Kenyanswerenolongersurewhoheldthestringsofjusticeandsopeopleresortedtoothermeansofdisputeresolution,someverybarbaricsuchasmobinjustice.Thisledtoanescalationininsecurityandsowhileseekingtoestablishsecuritysectorreforms,thejudiciaryisastrategicpoint(Brenner,2005,p.68).
Thenewconstitutionprovidesthatthepresidentcanonlyappointtwoofthe13membersoftheJudicialServiceCommission(JSC),andsotheexecutivehaslesscontrolintheappointmentofmembersoftheJSC.Article168veststhepowertoremoveajudgeontheJudicialServiceCommission.Article173establishesajudiciaryfundtocaterfortheadministrativeexpensesofthejudiciary.TheChiefRegistraroftheHighCourtpreparesestimates,whicharepresentedtotheNationalAssemblydirectly.Thesereformswillsecuretheindependenceofthejudiciaryandensurethatpublictrustisoncemorebestoweduponthejudiciarysothatpeoplearewillingtooncemorepresenttheirdisputestothejudiciaryforresolutioninsteadoftakingjusticeintotheirownhands.
Otherreformsincludethoseinvolvingtheelectoralbody.TheformationoftheIndependentElectoralandBoundariesCommission(IEBC)isagreatleapintosecureelectionsbecausethisbodyisdevoidofanypoliticalinterferencebyvirtueofitsformation(Ndungu,2011,p.5).Thenewconstitutionalsodrasticallyreducespresidentialpowersandinsodoingreducestheincentiveforviolence.The2007PostElectionsViolenceandtheconsequentpeacetalksmadeitobviousthatvestingtoomuchpowerononepositiontothedetrimentofallothercompetingcandidatessothat ifone loses,they loseitall.Thereforeaspartofthesolutiontothe2007PostElectionsViolenceKenyaendedupwithanarrangementwhichdistributedpowerbetweenthepresidentandhisprimeminister.
Finally,KenyanpoliticalpartiesarerequiredtocomplywiththePoliticalPartiesActof2011orriskderegistrationaftertheexpiryofthedeadlineinApril2012(Kisiangani,2009,p.4).Consequently,Kenya’s leaders shallbeheldaccountable for their actionsby the systemsput inplaceas variousinstitutionstowhichKenyanscanturntoforrespiteshouldconflictsarise.ThiswillsomewhatreducetheriskofarecurrenceofPEV.
It is important to realize that thePEVwas fannedbynumerous reasons including complex socio-economicandpoliticalinteractions.Violencewas,therefore,usedasatacticintheensuingpoliticalgame aswell as a weapon or a tool for settling disputes concerning the distribution of nationalresources(Namayi,2010,p.2).However,thiswasalltothedetrimentofKenyansandtheypaidthepricewiththeirownlivesandproperty.Itisthusimportantthatthesamedoesnotrecurin2012/13and this paper has discussed in brief someof themeasures takenby the government andotherplayers toenforcesecurityreformssince2008 inabidtopreventrecurringviolence.Thereformshavegonebeyondaddressingtechnicaldeficienciesandtheyhavealsotouchedonothergovernancechallengeswiththeeffectthattheentirecountryfeelsincludedinthereformactivity.AgoodexampleisthereferendumwhichusheredinaneweraforKenya.Atthispoint,itisimportanttoremember
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 19
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
thatthereasonwhypreviousattemptsatsocialsecuritysectorreformswereunsuccessfulwasthelackofaconstitutionalreferencepointgroundedindemocracy.Thenewconstitutionprovidedjustthat.
SECURITY SECTOR REFORMS
SecuritySectorReforms(SSR),alsoreferredtoassecuritysystemreform,hasemergedsincetheendoftheColdWarasastrategyforstabilizingandreconstructingsecuritysectorinstitutions,especiallyinpost-conflictortransitionalcountries.7SSRarethoseactivitiesundertakenbyacountrytoimprovethewayitprovidessafety,security,andjusticetoitscitizens.SSRareparticularly importantinthecontextoffailingorfailedstates,offeringameansofarrestingthefailureprocessinthefirstinstanceandsupportingfailedStaterecoveryinthesecond.8WhilemanymayargueKenyawasnotafailedState,manywouldagreethatKenyawasonthevergeoffailing.FailingorfailedStatesareusuallyunabletoprovideequitablesafety,security,andjusticetotheirpeoplethroughthetraditionalStatemechanismsofpoliceorcourts.Insuchsituations,Statemechanismsareineffective,predatory,orabsent.9ThedesperationthatKenyasunkintoin2008isperfectlydescribedbytheforegoingsentence,whichwasaresultofignoringmanySSRrecommendations,whichhadprecededthatviolence.10
Followingthepost-electionviolenceof2008,radicalproposalswereproposedonhowtoreformtheKenyaPoliceForce(KPF);especiallybytheCommissionofInquiryintoPostElectionViolence(CIPEV)andtheReportoftheNationalTaskforceonPoliceReforms(PhillipRansley).11Amongothers,theCIPEVfoundthatduringthepost-electionviolence,therewereactsofcommissionandothersofomissionbytheKPF.CIPEVthereforerecommendedthattheissueofrepresentationanddiversityofpoliceberelookedatafresh,decentralizationofthepolicecommandstructure,legalandstructuralreforms,createavenuesfor legalandpoliticalaccountability incaseofhumanrightsviolations,themergerof theAdministrationPolicewith theKPFunder one command, and the creationof anoversightstructurebycivilians.Ontheotherhand,Ransley’sTaskforcedidrecommendestablishmentofanexternalaccountabilitymechanism(theIndependentPolicingOversightAuthority),reformthecodeofconduct,establishaconflictofinterestpolicywithinthepolice,improvethetermsandconditionsoftheKPF,andcreateabodytosuperviseandimplementtherecommendationsoftheTaskforce,abodywhichexiststodate–thePoliceReformsImplementationCommittee(PRIC).
ThePRIChas sustaineddemand for reforms,andworkingwithvigilantCivil SocietyOrganizations(CSOs),hasgivenimpetustoSSR,inparticulartothepolice.Thegroundforreforms,afterthe2008post-electionviolence,shiftedundertheKPF.ThreemainattributesinformthisseriousnessandhasteofensuringwereformtheKPF:a)theroleoftheKPFindealingwithpost-electionviolence,whereatleast400peoplelosttheirlivesthroughgun-shotwounds;b)lackofimpartialityandobjectivityformostKPFseniorandjuniormembers,withregardtothatviolentconflict;andc)thepromulgationof
7 SSR is also called security system reform. This reframing came about with the understanding that security is an integrated activity within a system of state and non-State systems, which include not only the armed forces, police, gendarmerie, intelligence services, justice, and penal systems, but also the civil authorities responsible for oversight and democratic control (e.g., parliament, the executive). The term security system reform is used to emphasize the interconnectivity of its numerous components. See, Susan Merrill (Ed), Security Sector Reform: A Case Study Approach to Transition and Capacity Building, Visit www.StrategicStudiesInstitute.army.mil/newsletter , accessed December 06, 20118 Ibid9 Ibid10 Previous efforts had indeed foundered. These efforts included a Taskforce on Police Reforms of 2005, whose report was not adopted for implementation, but which had made radical proposals in 8 areas that could reform the police. These were benchmarks, which could measure the extent to which reforms in the force were successful or not. These included: community policing; crime reduction; effective disaster management; improved police image; enhanced accountability; efficient human resource management; building capacity of police; and lastly, establishment of an Information, Communication and Technology (ICT) strategy.11 See Reports by both the Taskforce and the CIPEV: CIPEV, http://www.dialoguekenya.org/docs/PEVReport1.pdf, accessed December 21, 2011, and for Taskforce, see Republic of Kenya, Report of the National Taskforce on Police Reforms, October 2009, Nairobi: Government Printers
20 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
theConstitutionofKenya(2010),followedbyitsimplementationthroughlegalisationthatrequiressubstantivechangestothewayKPFoperates.
Withinthisnewpoliticalandjuridicalorder,accountabilityoftheKPFtocivilianauthority,reformsthatcouldbetermedradical,andsuchSSRinitiativeswererecommendedsothatKenyacouldmovefromthatpost-conflictsocietytowherepowersexercisedbyStateagenciesaredonesowithintherealmofruleoflaw.Indeed,thelegislationthathavebeenpassedpointdirectlytowardsthechangesbeingsought.Theseinclude:theNationalPoliceServiceCommission(NPSC)Act;theNationalPoliceService(NPS)Act,whichoperationalizeshowtwopreviousoutfitswillreporttoasinglecommand;and,theIndependentPolicingOversightAuthority(IPOA)Actthroughwhichallcomplaintsagainstthepoliceorofthepoliceshallbeinvestigatedwithaviewtoprosecution.
POLICE REFORMS AND INSTITUTIONS
Thepolice‘force’isalsototransformintothepolice‘service’.Thisshouldgoalongwayinredeemingthepolice imageandcharacter fromonewhichwassecretive,corrupt,brutal,with impunity,andreactiveintoonethatistransparent,humane,responsive,andproactive.ThisalsoincludesrevampingthePoliceCodeofConduct(PCC)inanattempttostampoutdecadesofunethicalconductandtostreamlinegeneralpoliceconduct(Onguije,2009,p.5).Withregardstocapacitywithinthepoliceservice, theaforementionedvices that accompanyanymentionof thepolice includingnepotism,corruptionandlackofresourceshaveresultedininsufficientmanpowerwithinthepoliceserviceandconsequently,theirservicedeliveryisineffectiveandinefficient(Ndungu,2011,p.6).Moreover,theplightofthepoliceregardingtheirpayandthedeplorablelivingandworkingconditionshaveresultedinanunsympatheticattitudetowardsthepublicbythepolice,andthisinturnresultsinpoorservicedeliverybythepolice.
ThecostofaffectingthesereformsisapproximatelyKshs.80millionoverthecourseofthreeyears(Ndungu, 2011, p. 3). The country has already began to reap the results as portrayed by properremunerationandhousingofthepolice,refurbishingofpolicestations,newequipmentandvehiclesforthepolice,upgradedcommunicationequipment,andskillstraining.Forevenbetterresultsthegovernmentneedsensure thatbudgetingand funding for thevariousprojectsareadequate, thatthereistimelyreleaseto,andthatallthesechangesaresensitivetogenderandminorityconcerns.
In all this, the importance of the international community’s involvement and support cannot beforgotten. Kenya needs the technical expertise boasted by the developed countries in terms oftechnologytorevitalizeitssecuritysystem.Itisimportanttokeepabreastwiththeglobaldevelopmentsintermsofammunitionandinallhonesty,Kenyahasnumerousproblemsandinvestinginsecuritymaynotbegiventhedueseriousnesswhentheministeroffinanceisfacedwithdrought,andfamineamong other immediate crises while formulating the budget. Consequently, when internationalplayersliketheUnitedStates,theUnitedKingdom,Sweden,Japan,andtheUnitedNationsoffertheirsupportintermsoftechnologicalexpertiseandfunding,theireffortsshouldbeencouragedbytheKenyangovernment(Kisiangani,2009,p.7).Thiscanbeachievedthroughproperutilizationofthedonors’funds:thatis,forthepurposewhichtheywereinitiallyintendedbythedonors.
Inadditiontothepolicereforms,thereisneedforreformsinothersectorsaswell.Onesuchsectoris thecriminal justicesystem,which includesthe judiciary,criminal investigationsservice,andtheNationalSecurityIntelligenceService(NSIS,2011).Theneedforbalancecannotbeoveremphasizedin the goal of achieving effective security sector reforms. The intervention by the ICC to try theperpetratorsofthePEVinKenyahasservedasaneye-openerforthepublicintermsofaccountabilityandwhichcouldreduceinsecuritybyanotchduringtheupcomingelections(Namayi,2010,p.9).ConverselytheICCisalsoariskfactorforviolence.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 21
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
CHAPTER THREE
STUDY FINDINGSThisChapterexaminesthevariousconflictsituationsandscenariosobtainedinthe47CountiesofKenya.Theconflict triggersareanalysed in termsofpolitical, security,economic, legal, socialandculturalandenvironmentaldimensions.Theriskspertainingtotheidentifiedconflictsandtriggershavebeenweighedandinconclusion,theresearchershaverecommendedtheextenttowhichCRECOshouldcloselymonitorrespectiveCountiesorotherwise.
MOMBASA COUNTY
MombasaCountyishosttoKenya’ssecondlargestcityofMombasa.Itcoversanareaof219squarekilometersbutholdsapopulationof939,370,comprisingMvitaIslandandMombasamainland.TheCountyhas4constituencies-Mvita,Changamwe,KisauniandLikoni.Itishosttomanycommunitiesduetoitscosmopolitannature.
Political dimensions
Mombasawas significantly affectedby thePEV.At least 25people lost their lives as violent riotsspreadfromtheislandtothemainlandsuburbsinLikoniandnorthcoastareas12.Whereasviolencein the Island subsided quickly, fighting persisted in Kisauni areas due to presence of the feudingcommunities and entrenched poverty thatmade looting attractive. The scars of PEV still remainamongtheresidentsofMombasa.TheCountywasalsoaffectedbythe1997electoralviolence inLikoniarea,wherebyresidentsdeemedtohaveimmigratedfromupcountryregionswereviolentlyevictedbyindigenousMijikendapeople.
InKisauni,thechroniclandproblemoccasionedbyabsenteelandlordsandlandgrabbinghasalreadyled to recent confrontations between the residents (squatters) and security forces. The issue islikelytobepoliticizedastheelectionsapproach.Besides,asecessionistmovementhasemergedinMombasa,calledtheMombasaRepublicanCouncil(MRC).Startedassocietyofdisaffectedyouth,theMRCbeganadvocatingforsecessionoftheformerCoastProvincefromKenyaduetowhattheytermasmarginalizationofindigenouscommunityandtakingoveroftheirlandbyupcountryandforeignimmigrants.ThegovernmentinitiallyreactedtotheMRCbybanningtheorganizationandcrackingdownonitsmembers.13Later,thegovernmentretractedaftertheassociationchallengedthedecisionintheHighCourt.Thegroupisevidentlyusingthegrievancesoflocalyouthdisaffectedwithfailedpastgovernmentpromisestouplifttheirwelfare.AlreadytheyhavelodgedapetitionincourtseekingtobegrantedordersforreferendumtodecidethefateofwhatisformerlytheCoastProvince.Iftheactivitiesofthegroupassumemilitaryobjectivesandwageasecessionistuprising,thiswilldefinitelyaffecttheelectoralenvironmentinthearea.
Security dimensions
MombasahasbeenatargetofterroristattacksandisconsideredvulnerabletoAlShabaabthreat.There are heightened security operations in the County and this could also affect the electoral
12 Republic of Kenya, 2008 supra at pg 22613 See for instance see Daily Nation (24th November 2011) where it is reported that 18 suspected members of the MRC were arrested in Kisauni on suspicion of conducting illegal oathing rites.
22 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
environment.Thedrugmenace ismostpronounced inMombasathananywhereelse inthecoastregion.Druglordsareknowntousetheirmoneytoinfluenceelectoralpoliticsinthearea.Thismayinclude sponsoringviolenceagainstunfavourable candidates. This is something thatmerits closerattentionintheforthcomingelections
Economic Dimensions
Mombasa is the second largest city in the country. Its economy is based largely on tourism,transportation(port,railwayandroad),manufacturingindustryandtrade.IntheFinancialYear(FY)2008/9, the County received a combination of Kshs735million from the Local Authority TransferFund(LATF)andConstituenciesDevelopmentFund(CDF). It isthereforeexpectedthattheCountywill receive large transfers fromtheNationalGovernmentunder thedevolutionscheme.Thiswillthereforemakethe2012electoralcontestahighstakesaffair.
Legal Dimensions
Theformaljusticesystemisfairlyentrenchedintheregionandaccessthereforeisnotaproblem.Itmaybeusedtodealwithanyelectoraldisputes.
Social and cultural dimensions
Mombasa,asexplainedelsewhereisacosmopolitanarea.Intheislandareawhereallconstituenciesexcept Likoni converge, there is a sizeable Arab-Swahili majority, whereas in the mainland, theMijikendaare themajoritywithastrongpresenceofupcountrycommunitiesnotablyKikuyu,LuoandKamba.Theindigenouscommunitieshaveexpressedvocaldispleasurewiththedominationoftheupcountrycommunities intradeandemploymentsector.Thisdispleasurehasthepotentialofturningintooutrighthostilitythereforecreatingfertilegroundsforconflict.Therealsoexistanuneasyrelationship between theMijikenda and theArab-Swahili communities and therefore sometimes,electoralpoliticsintheCountyareframedintermsofonegroupversustheother.Hostilitiesthereforeare likely to emerge between these two communities where their members directly face-off inelections.
Environmental dimensions
LandprobleminMombasaismostfeltinKisauniandLikoniareaswherelargepopulationsofsquattersare tobe found. There is alsoa longstandingproblemof absentee landlordsholdingtitle to landoccupiedby indigenouscommunities.Whenever, these landlordsor their representativesattempttoasserttheirrighttotitle,this ismetwithconfrontation.Theproblemof landgrabbing isalsoapotentiallyexplosiveoneandintherecentdays,ithasledtocallsfordismissaloftheCoastProvincialCommissioneronallegationthathecontinuestogiveprotectiontolandgrabbers.
Conclusion
Mombasa,beingthesecondlargestcityisanobviousboilingpotcomethenextelection.Duetoitscosmopolitannature,activepresenceofsecessionistgroup(theMRC),longhistoryofpost-electionviolenceandpersistentlandproblem,thechancesofelectoralviolenceeruptingishighandthereforetheentireCountymeritsclosermonitoring.
KWALE COUNTYKwale issituated inthesouthernmosttipof thecountry,borderingTanzaniatothesouth, IndianOcean to the east and Taita Taveta,Mombasa and Kilifi to the north. The County occupies 8270squarekilometerswithapopulationof649,931(2009Census).TheCountyispredominatedbythe
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 23
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Mijikenda, even thoughmigrant communities (primarily the Kamba and Kikuyu) are found in thesettlementschemesthatwereestablishedduringindependenceperiod.Thereare3constituenciesintheCounty,whichareMatuga,KinangoandMsambweni.
Political Dimensions
The 2007/8post election violence affectedonlyUkunda andDiani areas inMatuga constituency.This said violencewaspurportedly ignitedby spontaneous anger following the announcementofpresidentialelectionsand lastedforonly4days14.TheviolencewasdirectedtowardsmembersoftheKikuyucommunity.Similarviolencewasreportedfollowingthe1992and1997elections,eventhoughthescaleandgeographicalspreadwaslarger.Thereasonwhythemagnitudeoftheviolencein2007/8periodwaslowcanbeattributedbytheinterventionbyreligiousleadersandelderswhodissuaded the youth from engaging in acts of violence. The scars of the violence are evident asanimositytowardstheKikuyuandotherupcountrycommunitiesstilllingerinthearea.
The County should be monitored for the exploitation of ethnic differences for divisive politicalpurposes. For instance, there are calls for the prosecution of the currentMatugaMP, Chirau AliMwakereonallegationsthathehadutteredhatespeechduringcampaignsinthe2010by-electionsthatwereheld in thatconstituency.15Thingsare likely to takeasharperdimension in thecomingelections,particularlyduetotheemergenceoftheMRCwherepro-secessionistsentimentsarehighintheCounty.
Security Dimensions
Inthe1997violence,youthmilitiawereestablishedbypoliticiansandusedtotargetnon-indigenouscommunitiesforeviction.Theseyouthcaneasilybemobilizedforviolenceifneedbe.Thispossibilityrequiresclosermonitoringsothatredflagscanberaisedifmobilizationofthemilitiatakesplace.LikeMombasa,KwaleisadverselyaffectedbytheillicitdrugtradeandthishasbeenblamedforinsecurityproblemsaffectingplacessuchasUkundaandDiani.
Economic dimensions
Kwaledependsontourism,agricultureandfishingforitslocaleconomy.Povertyintheareaisoneofthehighestinthecountryat74%.TheareareceivedKshs462MintheFY2008/9(CRA:2012).Withsuchhighpovertylevels,coupledbyignorance,itispossiblefortheelitetomanipulatevotershencetheneedtomonitorcloselytheconductofpoliticiansinthepre-electionperiod.Itisalsoanticipatedthatelections for theCounty-levelpositionswillbehotlycontested incosmopolitanareas,as theindigenouscommunitiestrytoasserttheirsuperiorityandhencecontroloverdevolutionresources.
Legal Dimensions
The County is served bymagistrates in Kwale town only and this therefore affects adversely thepeople’s access to justice in the area. The influence of religious leaders and elders is strong andthiswasattributedtothelowscaleofviolencereportedintheareain2007/8period.Anyconflictmitigationstrategyshouldtakeintoaccountthisfact
Social dimensions
Socialdistancebetweentheindigenousandmigrantcommunitiesiswide,thuscreatingfertilegroundsforethnicanimosity.Thisisreinforcedbythefactthatmigrantcommunitiesholdlargetractsofland14 Mwandawiro, Supra pg 4315 http//www.the-star.co.ke/national/national/57814-mwakwere-may-be-charged-with-hate-speech. Accessed 30th March 2012
24 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
onprimelocationsintheCountyandhavegainedemploymentinthelucrativetourismindustryattheexpenseofindigenousMijikenda.Itispossiblethereforeforpoliticianstoexploittheseethnicdifferencesforpoliticalreasonswithviolentconsequences.
Environmental dimensions
LandlessnessisanemotiveissueintheCounty.Thisiscoupledwithownershipofprimelandbymigrantcommunities.Thelandissuehascreatedfertilegroundsforpro-secessionistgroupslikeMRCtogainlargefollowinginthearea.Besideslandlessness,aridareasintheCountysuchasKinangohavebeenadverselyaffectedbyclimatechangeandthereforevulnerabilitytoperennialdroughtshasdisruptedlivelihoodsinthisconstituency.Ifafamineoccursduringelection,itwillmakeifdifficultforvoterstoparticipateeffectivelyintheelectoralprocess.InthenorthernareasoftheconstituencyborderingKilifi,therehavebeenconflictsoverpasturepittingthelocalsagainsttheSomalipastoralists,thoughthisisnotamajorissue.Human-wildlifeconflictisprevalentinareasborderingShimbaHillsParkandthismayaffectsecuritysituationduringelections.
Conclusion
Kwalepresentsaveritablechallengeforelectoralmonitoringconsideringthattheareahaspreviouslybeenrockedbypost-electionviolence.ThelikelyhotspotsareMatugaandMsambweniconstituencies.
KILIFI COUNTY
KilifiCountycomprisestheformerKilifiandMalindidistrictsanditbordersLamu,TanaRiver,TaitaTaveta,KwaleandMombasaCounties. It covers12,610squarekilometerswitha largepopulationof1,109,735persons (Census2009). TheCountyhas5Countituencies -Bahari, Kaloleni,Malindi,MagariniandGanze.Themainethnicgroupresiding in theCounty is theMijikenda,withsizeablelocalandforeign(mostlyItalian)migrantcommunitiesinthemajortouristtownsofMalindi,MtwapaandKilifi.
Political Dimensions
The area has a protracted land problemmanifested in the lack of security of tenure for locals,existenceofabsenteelandlordsandgrabbingofprimebeachplotsbyforeignersandlandspeculators.Inequalities occasioned by failure of the tourism industry to empower local communities couldeasilysnowballintoapoliticalgrievance.Itisnoteworthythatdespiteitscosmopolitannature,theCountyonlyexperiencedpostelectionviolenceinMtwapatownwhichwasattributedtoawaveoflootingandanarchythatsweptMombasatownanditsenvirons.16Otherwise,KilifiandMalinditownsremainedlargelypeaceful.
Economic Dimensions
Kilifi County is among the poorestwith a poverty rate of 71.4%despite having vast tourism andagriculturalpotential(CRA,2012).TheCountyreceivedatotalofKshs507millionintheFY2008/9asresourcetransfersfromthecentralgovernment.Povertyisattributedtoweaklandtenuresystemsthat prohibit squatters from developing their land and poor leadership in the area. Inequalitiesoccasionedbyweakresourcesharingmechanismsofthelucrativetourismindustryareasourceofconcern.
Security Dimensions
TheCountyhasrelativelyfewsecuritythreats,otherthanestablishedlongpresenceofdrugbarons.
16 Ibid pg 66-7
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 25
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Infact,thelargesthaulofcocaineeverseizedbyauthoritiesoriginatedfromMalinditownin2006.Thepotentialofdrugmoneybeingusedtoinfluenceelectionsnegativelyishigh.
Legal dimensions
Customaryandformallegalsystemsexistsidebyside.TheCountyhas4magistratecourtstationsinKaloleni,Mariakani,MalindiandKilifitowns,servedby9magistratesandoneHighCourtstationinMalindi.TheproximityofHighCourtincreasesthecapacityofcourtstoresolveelectiondisputes.
Social dimensions
This County is multi-ethnic with tension revolving around land issues and poverty. Furthermoreforeignersplayaverydominantroleinlocalindustries.TheCountyhasalsobattledforalongtimewithproblemsofchildsexabuse.Literacylevelsarelowandthismakesthepopulationvulnerabletopoliticalmanipulationhencetheneedforclosemonitoringofelections(only7.1%ofpopulationhassecondaryeducation-CRA,2012).
Environmental dimensions
Besides the land issue,Malindi town is beset by environmental degradation emanating from thelocal saltharvestingenterprise.17Thisenterpriseemploysevaporationof seawater toextract saltfromnearbyshores.Thishas ledtodestructionofmangroveforests(asourceofwoodfor locals),soilerosion, salinationof localwater sourcesandhealthproblems forworkers. It is likely tobeamajorelectionissue;withownersofthefactorylikelytousetheireconomicinfluencetomanipulatingvotingpatternsbyminimizingoppositiontotheircontinuedoperations
Conclusion
TheriskformanipulationofelectionsintheCountyishighduetolowvoterliteracy,landproblemsandpoverty.Basedonpasttrends,itisalsoimportanttocloeselyobservetheinfluenceoffactoryownersontheelectoralprocess.
TANA RIVER COUNTY
TanaRiverCounty is the largest in the formerCoastProvince,with38,437squarekilometersandoccupyingatleast49%ofthetotallandareaoftheentireprovince.However,theprovincehasthesmallestpopulationsizeat240,075persons.ItisinhabitedbythepastoralistOrmaethnicgroupofSomalidescentandtheagriculturalPokomoethnicgroupofBantuextraction.TheCountyhasthreepoliticalconstituencies:thatisBura,GarsenandGalole.
Political Dimensions
TheCountyderivesitsnamefromtheRiverTana,whichisthelargestinthecountry.TheriverprovideswaterforirrigationinthethreeschemeslocatedintheCountyi.e.Hola,BuraandTanaDeltawiththePokomobeingthebeneficiariesoftheprojects.TheriverincidentallyhascreatedconflictsoveraccesstowaterbythepastoralOrmacommunities.EffortstoresolvelandconflictsbetweentheOrmaandthePokomothroughlandadjudicationhavenotbeensuccesful. ThereisaperceptionamongtheOrmaisthatthePokomowanttodenythemtheirhistoricalrightsofaccesstopastureandwaterduringdryseasons.18Thewholematterhasbeenpoliticizedleadingtoconflictseverytimeanelectionapproaches.
17 Ibid18 See Institute of Security Studies, Guns in Borderlands, 2005 accessed from www.iss.co.za accessed 24th January 2012
26 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Security Dimensions
Theproliferationofarms inNorthernKenyahashad implications for theTanaRiverconflicts. It isclaimed that theOrmahave soughtmilitaryassistance from their Somali cousins inneighbouringGarissa in their conflicts with Pokomo resulting in an increased use of firearms with deadlyconsequences.TheaftermathoftheShiftaWaralsoledtoproliferationofbanditsintheCountywhopredatedontransportbusinessalongtheMalindi-GarissahighwayandtheGarissa-Hola-Garsenroutes.ThebanditsarealsosaidtoberesponsiblefortheriseinpoachinginTsavonationalpark.
Economic Dimensions
Inspiteofbeingendowedwithimmenseagriculturalresources,TanaRiverhashighpovertylevelsat76%(CRA,2012).Seemingly,theCountyhasbeenunabletofullyexploittheagriculturalandtourismpotentialoftheTanaDeltaduetoincessantconflicts.ResourcetransfersfromthecentralgovernmentwereatKshs542MintheformofCDFandLATFinFY2008/9(CRA2012).Withsuchhighfiguresatstake,itislikelythatthestruggleforpoliticalpowerattheCountylevelwillbeintense.
Legal Dimensions
TheCountyhastwomagistrates’courtslocatedinGarsenandHola.HighcourtmattersarehandledatMalindi.ThelocalresidentsestablishedtheTanaRiverDistrictPeaceandDevelopmentCommitteetoarbitratecommunaldisputesbetweenthePokomoandOrmacommunities,withparticipationofreligiousandpolitical leaders.This isstillaviablealternativedisputeresolutionmechanismintheCounty
Social Cultural Dimensions
HostilitiesbetweentheOrmoandPokomoduetotheculturaldifferencesarethemostsignificantfactorsexacerbatingconflictsintheCounty
Environmental Dimensions
DammingofRiverTanabytheKenyaElectricityGenerationCompany(KENGEN)hasreducedwaterflowsdownstreamleadingtosomeconflictsofwateraccess.Similarly,destructionofwatercatchmentsareasinupperpartsoftheCountyhavealsohadsimilareffects.Human-wildlifeconflictsareontheriseasresidentsencourageonwildlifehabitatswithinthevastDelta.Landandwateraccessconflictsarealsoenvironmentallyconditionedinthispartofthecountry
Conclusion
TanaRiver is highpolitical risk areaowing to ethnic differencesbetween thePokomoandOrma,whichtendtoassumepoliticaldimensionsduringelections.
LAMU COUNTYLamuCountyislocatedinthenortherntipoftheformerCoastProvince,borderingGarissa,TanaRiverandSomalia.Itoccupies6273squarekilometersareaincludingalargemainlandandseveralislandsand isletswith a populationof 101,539 (Census 2009). Resident communities include theBajuni,Pokomo,Arabs,WabonyiandalargeimmigrantKikuyucommunitythatsettledintheareaduringtheKenyattaregime.TheCountyhastwoconstituencieswhichareLamuEastandLamuWest.TheCountyisknownfortourismandricharcheologicalheritageowingtoLamuIsland,whichisoneoftheoldesturbansettlementsintheEastAfricancoastline.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 27
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Political Dimensions
Despite itsmulti-ethnic complexity, Lamu has no recent history of violent conflict.19 In the 2007generalelections,voters inLamusupportedRailaOdingaofODMforPresident,butchoseaPNUcandidatesforparliament.
However,tensionsoverlandremainintheconstituency,withlocalscomplainingoverillegalallocationofancestrallandstooutsidersandforeigners20.ThefactthattheKikuyuimmigrantsweregrantedtitledeedsbytheformerPresidentMoi’sgovernmenttotheexclusionoflocalsisanothergrievance.Sofar,thisgrievancehasnotassumedvigorouspoliticalarticulationbutthepotentialofviolentconflictstilllurks.
Security dimensions
Lamu also suffered from the aftermath of the Shifta War and the collapse of Somalia’s centralgovernment,leadingtoaninfluxofsmallarms.Asaresult,themainlandbecameinfestedwitharmedbanditswhoroutinelyterrorizedthetransportbusinessintheCounty.Cattletheftisalsocommon,intheareaandthesameisblamedontheSomalibanditsfromGarrisaorTanaRiver.LamuhasalsobeenconsideredahidinggroundoftheAlShabaabandAl-Qaedaterrorists.Infact,theslainMohammedFazulregardedasthemastermindoftheNairobiUSembassyterroristattackresidedintheislandofFazaformanyyearsunnoticed.
Recently, the islandofKiwayuwasthrusted intomedia limelight followingtheseizureofaFrenchholidaymakerbysuspectedAlShabaabandtakentoSomaliaviathesea.TheongoingwarbetweentheKDFandtheAlShabaabhasbeen launchedfromLamu’sborderareaofKiungaaswellasthecoastalwatersoffLamuIsland.Thus,alargepartofthenortherntipoftheCountyanditscoastalwatersisnowamilitaryzone.Ifthewarwillhaveanimpacton2012elections,thenLamuwillalsobeaffected(oratleastsomepartsthereof).
Economic Dimensions
LamuisamongthewealthiestCountiesinKenya,asevidencedbyrelativelylowpovertylevels(32.7%)androbustlocalrevenuebaseofKshs1.023billion(CRA,2012)duetoheavyinvestmentsinthetourismindustry.Inaddition,theCountyreceivesoneofthehighestresourcetransfersfromthecentralgovtatKshs1.23billioninFY2008/9.ThegovermenthasalsorevisedtheLamuPort&LamuSouthernSudan-EthiopiaTransportCorridor(LAPSSET)atransportandinfrastutureprojectthatwillbeKenya’s2ndtransportcoridor.TheProjectwillcostanestimated$22B.21Withsuchimpressiverevenuefigures,onewouldexpectthistotranslateintoeconomicprosperityfortheresidents.However,thisisnotnecessarilythecase.Thedistricthasonly3publicsecondaryschoolsand17primaryschoolsinLamuEastconstituency.22
Legal dimensions
Lamu County is only served by onemagistrate’s court in Hindi (mainland). High court cases arehandled inMalindi.Traditionalmethodsofdisputeresolutionarecommonamongthe indigenouscommunities.Sofar,theseseemtohavehandleddisputesfairlyinthisarea
19 Mghanga Mwandawiro, Usipoziba ufa, utajenga ukuta; Land , elections and conflicts in Kenya’s Coast Province, 2010 Heinrich Boll Stiftung: Nairobi20 Ibid 21 www.republicofkenya.org 22 Ibid pg 84
28 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Social cultural dimensions
Lamubeingacosmopolitanareaisboundtoelicitculturaldifferencesandclashes.Already,indigenouscommunities feel aggrieved by the preferential treatment given to the immigrant Kikuyu ethniccommunitiesandthismaylaterboilintoethnichatred.
Lamulikeotherpartsofthecoastalareasisaffectedbythedrugmenace.Drugcartelshavethrivedintheurbanareasforalongtimeandanti–drugabusecrusadershavebornethebruntofattacksbydruglordswhodonothesistatetodemonstratetheirpowerandinfluence.23Theextenttowhichdrugmoneyfinanceslocalpoliticsisnotclearbutthisissomethingthatmeritsmonitoring
Environmental dimensions
LandisabigissueinLamu.TenuresystemshaveensuredthatindigenouscommunitieslacktitlesorremainastenantsinpropertiesownedbyfeudalArablandlords.24Unlessthematterisresolved,itmightlateronprovetobeatickingtime-bomb.Concernshavealsobeenraisedonthepotentialeffectof the LamuPortSouthSudanEthiopiaTransportCorridor (LAPSSET)projectontheenvironmentespeciallyinreferencetotheecosystemoftheMangroveforests.
Conclusion
Even though the County has never been beset by serious conflict and strife, the land problem,togetherwiththecosmopolitannatureofthearea,widespreadilliteracy,threatsfromAlShabaabanddrugmenacemayprovidelong-termconflictriskfactorsthatcouldaffecttheelectoralenvironment.
TAITA TAVETATaitaTavetaislocatedinthesouthernpartofthecountryanditbordersTanzaniaandKwaleinthesouth,KilifiandKituitotheEast,MakueniandKajiadotothenorth.Itoccupiesatotalof17,084squarekilometersandapopulationof284,657(2009Census).TheDawidaandTavetaaretheindigenouscommunitiestothisareawhereasasizeableKikuyu,Kamba,LuoandSomalimigrantpopulationissettledinthearea.Thereare4constituenciesintheCountywhichhaveMwatate,Voi,WundanyiandTaveta.
Political Dimension
Theareawas largelyunaffectedby thePEVexcept foronecentre,Werugha,whereshopsownedbymembersoftheKikuyucommunitywerelootedfollowingtheannouncementofthepresidentialelections.ThelandquestionisanimportantpoliticalissueintheCounty,since89%ofthetotallandareaisundertheTsavoNationalPark.25Theremainder11%issharedbetweentheresidentsandfewlargescalelandholders.Duetothis,thereisasizeablesquatterpopulationandlandpressureshaveforcedsomeofthefamilymembersinatleasteachhouseholdtoemigratefromtheCountyinsearchofopportunities.26
The land issue has featured prominently in previous elections. The government hasmanaged tocompulsorily acquire land from for the settlementof some squatters. It is thereforenecessary toensurethattheresettlementofsquatters isdone inamannerthat isconsistentwiththe lawandmoreimportantly,theissueisnotabusedforpoliticalpurposes.
It isalso important tonote thatTavetaconstituency isacosmopolitanonecomprising theTaveta23 Ibid pg 8324 Ibid25 Mwandawiro, Ibid pg 3326 Ibid
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 29
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
(indigenouscommunity),theKamba,LuoandTanzanianssignificantlyrepresented.Politicsintheareahasalwaysbeenframedintermsofindigenousversusthemigrantcommunities.Thismaylaygroundfortheexploitationofnegativeethnicity.
There is a high potential for border conflicts, since Taita Taveta has historically never settled itsboundarieswithalmostallitsneighbours.WithdisputesoverIEBCboundariesreportensuing,itispossiblethatthismatterwillerupt intoopenconflictunlesspoliticalconsensus is reachedsoonerthanlater.
Security Dimensions
TaitaTavetaisaborderCountythatispronetoinsecurityduetocross-borderthuggery.Thereisalsoahighincidenceofpoachingwithinthenationalparkandanimalsanctuariesinthearea.However,thesemaynotposesignificantriskinthecomingelections
Economic dimensions
TaitaTavetahasapovertyrateof54%whichisconsiderablyhigh(CRA,2012).TheCountyhoweverisrichinmineralssuchasgemstones,ironoreandlimestone.27Tourismisalsoasignificantincomeearner, owing to the fact that TsavoNational Park and numerous animal sanctuaries are locatedwithintheCounty.However,itissadthatthesaidmineralandtourismwealthhasnotchangedthefortunesofthelocalsbutrathercontinuestobeassourceofconflict.ThelocalresidentshaveaccusedthegovernmentofdishingoutlandtomineralprospectorswithoutconsultingthepeopleandthishasreinforcedtheviewthatthewealthoftheCountyisbeingexploitedbyoutsiders.AllthetourismrevenueispaidtotheKenyaWildlifeService(KWS)andthereforeremittedtocentralgovernmentwithlittletricklingbacktothelocals.Thishascausedbitternessamongthelocals,consideringthattheybearthegreatestbruntofhuman-wildlifeconflicts.
IntheFY2008/9,theCountyreceivedatotalofKshs848millionfromcentralgovernmentasCDFandLATF.ThisissignificantforaCountywithsucharelativelylowpopulation.IntensivecompetitionforCountylevelpositionsislikelytointensifyinthecomingperiodandthereforemeritsclosermonitoring.
Legal Dimensions
The County hasmagistrates’ courts in Voi,Wundanyi and Taveta, hence locals have considerableaccess to justice.Thesecourtscouldplayan important role inaddressingconflicts thatmayariseduringtheelectoralperiod.Communityeldersarestillinfluentialinmostplacesandthereforecouldhelpstemconflictsthroughalternativedisputeresolutionmeasures
Social dimensions
TavetaandVoiarethemostethnicallydiverseconstituenciesintheCounty,duetothepresenceoflargemigrantcommunitiesthatcameaslabourersorsettlers.Sometimes,ethnictensionsarise.Thissituationwillthereforemeritexternalscrutinyasawayofdeterringanypotentialviolence.
Environmental dimensions
Tensionsoverlandownershiparemostprevalentinthedistrict.Thesetensionspitlargescalelandownersversusthesmallholders,squattersversusregisteredowners,thegovernmentversussquattersandagriculturalistsversusanimalranchers.Somedisputesoverownershipofcommunalland(groupranches) crop up. Besides land-related conflicts, the County has also experienced human-wildlifeconflictspersistently.
27 Ibid pg 28
30 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Conclusions
TaitaTavetahasaconsiderablehighconflictriskduetosuchfactorsasthelandquestion,disputesoversharingofwealth,borderdisputesandethnicdifferences.AllconstituenciesintheCountythereforemeritclosemonitoring.
GARISSA COUNTY
Garissa County is located in the lower reaches of the formerNorth Eastern province and sharescommonborderswithWajir,Somalia,Tanariver,KituiandLamuCounties.TheCountyhasacreageof44,175squarekilometerswithapopulationof623,060persons(2009Census).ItcomprisesfourconstituenciesDujis,Fafi,LadgeraandIjara.ItisinhabitedalmostexclusivelybytheOgadenclanoftheSomalibutsub-clanidentitiesaremuchstrongerandthus,thepeoplearefurtherdividedintoAbdwak,AbdallaandAuliyansubclans.Migrantpopulationfromdowncountryistobefoundinmajortradingcenters.TherealsoexistaminorityclusterofclansknownasMuhammadZubeiror‘cornertribes’whicharebelievedtohavemigratedintotheregionfromWajir.
Political Dimensions
ThepoliticalconstituenciesinGarissaaredelineatedalongclanlines.TheAuliyanoccupytheLagderaConstituencyintheNorth,whereastheAbdulla(thesmallestofthethree)occupiesIjarainthesouth.TheAdwak,whoperhapsarethewealthiestandmostpowerfuloccupyDujisandFaficonstituencies.
Like inManderaandGarissa, ascensionbya clan to the leadershipof anarea is seenas amovetowardsinstitutionalizingthegroup’sexclusiveclaimoverthepoliticalterritoryinquestion.InGarissafor instance,theAbdiwakconsiderDujisandFaficonstituenciesastheirancestral lands.However,followingthecollapseoftheSomaligovernmentin1991,therehasbeenasteadyinfluxofAuliyanSomalisfromSomalia.Overtime,thishasaffectedthedemographyinthetwoconstituenciesinfavouroftheAuliyantothechagrinoftheAbdiwak.28
Further,eventhoughthetwoclansarecloselyrelatedandhavesharedpastureaswellasaccesstoRiverTanainthepast,awaveofinhospitalitygrewintherunuptothe2002elections,whenitbecameclearthattheincreasedAuliyanpopulationwouldleadtolossoftheAbdiwak-heldconstituencies.Asaresult,tensionseruptedintofullscaleconflictbetweenthetwocommunitiesbetweentheyears1998and2000,spreadingandescalatingintoGarissatownandleavingupto30peopledead.Ittooktheinterventionofbusinesscommunityandlocalleadersfortheconflicttosubside.
Similar tensions have over time arisen following the electoral cycle, suggesting possibility ofpolitical incitementby theeliteas thekey trigger.Already, tensionsarehighover thecreationofnewconstituencywithin theCountyaswasevidenced in thefight thatbrokeoutduring the IEBChearingsheldatGarissatowninJanuary2012.It isthereforeimportanttomonitorthisCountyas2012electionsapproach
Security Dimensions
Liketherestof theNorth,GarissahasseenaproliferationofsmallarmsoccasionedbytheShiftaWarandlaterbythecollapseoftheSomaligovernment.29ThepresenceofrefugeesinDaadab,nowestimatedat400,000people,continuestobeasecurity issue.Thecamp issaidtobeasourceofilllictweapons that endbeingused in local clasheswith deadly consequences. The refugee issuealsoassumesapoliticaldimensionattimes.Itisnotuncommonduringelectionstohearclaimsby
28 See for instance, Menkhaus K, Kenya-Somali Border Conflict Analysis, 2005, USAID Nairobi at pg 2529 See Pkalya R and Halakhe H (eds, Combating the problems of small arms in Northern Kenya: Testimonies and case stud-ies of pastoral communities, 2011, Government of Kenya: Nairobi
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 31
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
politiciansthatrefugeeshavebeenillegallyregisteredasvotersinordertoinfluencelocalelections.
Garissa is thenearest largetowntothearenaof theKenyaDefenceForces (KDF)andAlShabaabconflict.IthasincreasinglybecomevulnerabletoterroristattacksfromAlShabaab.Forinstance,on24thNovember2011,agrenadeattackwaslaunchedinabarwithinthetown,leadingto2deathsandseveralcausalities.30Thisviolencewillsetarathertensestageforpoliticalandelectoralcampaigns.
Economic Dimensions
Garissahasrelativelylowerpovertylevelsat49%(CRA2012)thantherestofNorthernKenya.Themainstayofthelocaleconomyislivestockpastoralism,sedentaryagriculturealongthebanksofRiverTanaanditstributariesandthrivingtradeinGarissatownandcrossbordertownsofLiboi.
Control of cross border trade has precipitated conflicts in the area. For instance in 2000, theMuhammadZubeirclansviolentlyoverthrewtheAuliyaninthebordertownofDobleyostensiblyinabidtocontrolcrossbordertradeatthestrategictown.31ThegrudgeharbouredbytheAuliyanovertheincidentstillpersistsasnopeaceagreementorreconciliationhasevertakenplacebetweenthetwogroups.
Garissareliesheavilyonresourcetransfersfromthecentralgovernment.InFY2008/9,theCountyreceivedatotalofKshs470MintheformofCDFandLATF.
Legal Dimensions
Garissanowhasahighcourt stationaspartof theongoing judicial reforms.However, traditionaljusticeresolutionmechanismsstilloperatealongsideformalsystems.Thesetraditionalsystemsarecreditedformanaginglocalconflicts.However,whenelderstaketoolongtoresolvetheconflict,orwhereatriggerisviewedaspurelypoliticallymotivated,traditionalmechanismsseempowerlessasthesituationescalates.
Social cultural dimensions
Garissa,liketherestofNorthernKenyaispredominantlymuslim.TheconflictinSomalialedtotheemergenceofAlIttihadAlIslam,aformofSalafijihadismwithadistinctivelypan-Somalinationalistagenda.32TheCountyhasexperiencedattacksagainstChristian institutions intheCountyand it isthereforeimportanttomonitorthelevelsofreligiousintoleranceasthismayleadtodisenfranchisementoftheminorityChristiangroupsintheCounty.
Environmental Dimensions
GarissaCountyissemi-aridandthereforelandandaccesstowaterresourcesarethekeydriversofconflictintheregion.ThesetwoareconnectedwiththelivestockpastoralismlifestyleoftheresidentsoftheCounty.However,conflictsoverurbanspaceshaveemergedinrecentyears.Forinstance,localclanshaverecentlyclashedoverallocationoflandinBulaKaratasiareaofGarissatown.
Conclusion
Garissabearshigh risks thatought tobemonitoredprior to the2012elections. Thepresenceofrefugees in Daadab, deteriorating border situation in Somalia, religious intolerance and resource
30 See the Standard, 25th November 2011 Edition31 Menkhaus K, 2005 32 See more analysis of this in International Crisis Group, Kenyan Somali Radicalization, in Policy Briefing, Africa Briefing No 85, 25th January 2012
32 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
based conflicts are key factors that might affect the electoral environment in the run-up to theupcomingelections.
WAJIR COUNTY
WajirCountyislocatedinthemiddleoftheformerNorthEasternProvince,borderingManderatotheSouthandIsioloandMarsabittotheWestandSomaliatotheEast.Itoccupies56686squarekilometerswithapopulationof664,941persons(Census2009).TheCountycomprisesfourconstituencies:WajirNorth,WajirEast,WajirWestandWajirSouth.LikeMandera,theCountyisoverwhelminglySomaliwithsmallmigrantcommunitiesresidentintheCountyaseitheradministratorsorbusinesspeople.TheSomalicommunityiscomposedoftheAjuran,Degodia,OgadenandGarreclans.
Political Dimensions
During thecolonialperiod, thegovernmentdemarcated theCounty intograzingblocks thatwereassigned to each clan, ostensibly to prevent conflict over pasture and water resources for theirlivestock.33 These blocks assumed political significance when the post-independent governmenttransformed them into political constituencies. A victory by a clan in a particular constituency isviewedasamovetoinstitutionalizingtheclan’sholdoverresourcesanddisenfranchisementoftheclansthat ‘lose’ thoseelections.34Until1997,Wajirhadthreeconstituencies:WajirEast-Degodia,WajirSouth-OgadenandWajirWest-Ajuran.
TheAjuranconsiderthemselvesastheoriginalinhabitantsofWajirandhencehaveconsistentlylaidhistorical land claims to theWajirWest constituency,where theyarepredominant.However, theDegodiahaveover thetimemigrated into the constituencyandafterentering intoallianceswithneighbouringGarreclan,theywereabletocapturetheWajirWestConstituencyin1979,1984and1992elections.Thisresultedininter-clanwarspittingtheAjuranovertheDegodia.Theworstflare-upbetweenthetwocommunitieswaswitnessedintheperiodbetween1992-5whenapproximately1213peoplewerekilledand1500wereinjuredfollowingtheelectionofaDegodia.Eventually,thegovernmentcreatedaWajirNorthConstituencyexclusivelyfortheAjuran.35ThismovehasnotsettledtheAjuran’sclaimsoverWajirWestconstituency.Infact,itopenedanewconflictfrontpittingtheAjuranandtheGarrewhoconsiderpartsofWajirNorthastheircustomarygrazinggrounds.
The1992-5conflictwaseventuallyresolvedthroughabroad-basedinitiativethatwasspearheadedbycivilsocietygroupswithstatesupport,whichculminatedintheAlFatahDeclaration.36Thisledtoaperiodofrelativecalmuntil2000-1whentensionsbetweentheAjuranandGarreledtofullscaleviolencethatleft15peopledeadand3,300displaced.37TheconflicthadbeenprecededbyaquietmovebytheAjurantodisplacetheGarreinthenewWajirNorthconstituencyaspunishmentforthelatter’ssupporttotheDegodiainthe1997elections.
ItInviewofthistrendofclantensions,thesituationshouldbemonitoredintherun-upto2012/3electionsasanewconstituencyhasbeencreatedintheCounty.38
33 Ibrahim D and Jenner J, Wajir Community Based Conflict Management, 1996 accessed from http://payson.folane.edu/ conflict/cs%20st/janfin2/html 34 See Menkhaus Ken, The Rise of the Mediated State in Northern Kenya: The Wajir Story and its implications for State- building, 2008 in Afrika Focus, Vol 21 Nr2, 2008 at pg 2535 Ibid pg2836 Ibrahim D and Jenner J supra37 Menkhaus supra, pg 2838 Unfortunately, the Court has stayed the creation of the 80 new constituencies meaning that the general elections have been thrown into disarray. The IEBC has to challenge (through an appeal) whether this decision can be reversed. See Daily Nation, Saturday, April 13, 2012.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 33
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Security Dimensions
Wajirwaspartof theNorthernFrontierDistricts territory that remainedclosed to therestof thecountry during colonial period. After independence, the area residents joined the clamour forsecessionandthereforeborethefullbruntoftheShiftWarofthe1960s.In1984,clanconflictsinthearealedtotheWagallaMassacre,duringwhich400DegodiamenandyouthdiedofexposureandthirstafterbeingroundedupbytheKenyanmilitaryandleftinthesunforthreedayswithnofood,water,orshelter39.Political instability inSomaliaandEthiopia ledto influxofrefugeesandarmedweaponsintotheCountyandthishascontributedtoensuingconflictsandinstability.
Localconflictshavealsosucked in foreignmilitia thusaggravating thesituation.For instance, it isclaimedthattheDegodiaenlistedmilitarysupportfromtheirSomalicousinsinthe1992-5conflict,whereastheGarreenlistedthesupportoftheirEthiopiankinsmeninthe2000-1conflict.40Thereisnoguaranteethatsuchalliancescannotbeenlistedinfutureconflictsandhencemeritclosermonitoring
ItisalsonoteworthythatKDF’sonslaughtagainsttheAlShabaabhasbeenlaunchedfrompartsoftheWajir-Somaliaborder.TheareahasthereforebecomepronetoattacksattributedtotheAlShabaab.Forinstance,betweenDecember2011andJanuary2012,explosionshaverockedpartsoftheCountyleaving6peopledeadandscoresinjured.Iftheseattacksescalateintherun-uptotheelections,theymayadverselyinterferewiththeelectoralenvironment.
Economic Dimensions
Wajir isamongthepoorestCounties inthecountrywithpovertyrateshoveringaround84%(CRA2012).ThesituationisworsenedbytheCounty’svulnerabilitytodroughtandconflictswhichadverselyaffects its livestock base. The County nevertheless has oil potential as evidenced by numerousexplorationlicensesthathavebeengrantedtoforeigncompanies.ThestrategicimportanceoftheCounty fromamilitarypointof view ismanifested in the recent constructionof anultra-modernairportand thepresenceofa largearmyoutpostwithinWajir town.Resource transfers from thecentralgovernmentamountedtoKshs391millionintheformofCDFandLATF(CRA2012).
Social Cultural Dimensions
EthnictensionsandhatredarelongengrainedintheCounty’scultureandhistory.TheAjuranviewtheotherclansasoutsiderswhereastheotherclansseethemselvesaspoliticalascendants.Conflictsoverresourceshavealsoworsenedsocialtensionsbetweenthevariouscommunities.However,thishasnotruledoutalliances.Forinstance,inthe1992-5conflict,theAjuranandOgadenformedanallianceagainsttheDegodia,whereasinthesubsequentperiods,theDegodiahaveformedallianceswithGarretofighttheAjurans.Thecommunitieshaveusedpoetry,songsandotherculturaltoolstopropagatemessagesofethnichatredhenceworseningconflicts.Thesetoolsmeritclosermonitoringduringelectionperiods.
Legal Dimensions
Customary justice systemsplay amore central role in conflict resolutionandmanagement in theCountymorethantheformaljusticesystem.Thisisattributedtothelimitedpresenceofformalcourts(onlyonemagistrate’scourt)andtheremotenessofarenasofconflict.TheroleofeldersinadoptionoftheAlFatahDeclarationcontributedimmenselytotheresumptionofpeaceintheCounty.However,forsuchmechanismstosucceed,thetacitsupportfromthestateisnecessary.Theextenttowhichthesemechanismscanbeemployedinresolvingelectoralviolenceandconflicts issomethingthat
39 Ibrahim D, supra- this Massacre is the subject of inquiry under the ongoing Truth Justice and Reconciliation Commission’s mandate.40 Menhkaus supra
34 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
requiresfurtherexploration.
Environmental Dimensions
Like the rest of the Arid Northern Kenya, climate change has dramatically increased the region’svulnerabilitytodroughtsandfloods.Thishasimperiledtheratherfragilelivestockbasedlivelihoodsandruledoutpossibilitiesofsedentaryagriculture.Conflictsoverresources(pastureandwater)areon the riseas influxof refugees fromSomalia intensifiespopulationpressures in theCounty. It isthereforeimportantfortherootcauseofsomeoftheseconflictstoberegardedassuchandresourcesavailedtosupportclimatechangemitigationandadaptation.
Conclusion
Political risksattendingtoconflicts in theCountywill remainhighas thenextelectionsapproach.ThedeterioratingsecuritysituationinSomaliawillalsowarrantcloserattentiontotheforthcomingelections fromamonitoringpointof view. In the samevein, there isneed tomonitor theuseofenvironmentaltriggersinprecipitatingelectoralviolence.
MANDERA COUNTYManderaCountyissituatedonthenortherntipofKenya’sboundarywithSomaliaandEthiopia. Itoccupies25,999squarekilometerswithahighpopulationof1,025,756personsalmostexclusivelybelongingtotheSomaliethniccommunity.Thecommunityishoweverdividedinto5clanswhicharetheGarre,Murulle,Degodia,Marehanandso-called‘cornertribes’.TherearethreeconstituenciesintheCounty:ManderaEast,ManderaWestandManderaCentral.
Political Dimensions
PoliticsinManderaisorganizedalongclanlines.TheGarrecomprisethemajorityintheCountyandusing their numerical strength, they have dominatedManderaWest and Central Constituencies,whereas theMurullecontrolManderaEastConstituency.TheGarrebelieve thatMandera is theirterritoryafterhavingmovedintheareaandforciblyevictedtheBoranainthe19thCentury,pushingthemtotheirpresent-daysettlementinMoyale.41TheMurulleandDegodialatermovedintotheareaandwereallowedtosettlebytheGarre.
Inthepost-independenceperiod,theGarreheldthesoleManderaparliamentaryseatuntil1983,whenaMPfromMurullewaselectedwiththesupportofvoters fromvariousgroups.This ledtosuccessfulagitationbyGarre for theconstituencytobesplit intoManderaWestandEast.Duetothis history of it is therefore expected that the general electionswill be keenly contested by thecommunitiesandhenceriskswillbehigh.
It shouldalsobenoted that theGarreandMurullehaveclashedviolently in1983/4,2001/5and2007/8periodonmatterswhicharecloselyrelatedtopolitics.42WiththenextelectionsrepresentinghighstakesatCountylevel,thesituationmeritsclosermonitoring.
Security Dimensions
ManderaispartoftheNorthernFrontierDistrictsthattookpartintheShiftsecessionistcampaignin the 1960s. The County residents are scarred by the effects of the Shifta War, especially theadministrativeandeconomicisolationthatcamewithit,andhencehaveahistoricalgrievanceagainsttheKenyanstate.CollapseoftheSomaliacentralgovernmentin1991andinstabilityinEthiopialed
41 UNDP Kenya, Dynamics and Trends in Conflict in the Greater Mandera in Amani Papers Vol 1 May 2010 pg 742 Ibid pg 12
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 35
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
toproliferationofsmallarmsintheCountyandcontiguousareas,makingconflictsassumedeadlydimensions.Wheneverlocaldifferencesescaletintoviolence,itissuspectedthatfeudingclansusuallyengagemilitiasfromneighbouringSomaliatofightontheirbehalf.43
TheongoingwarbetweentheKDFandtheAlShabaabmilitantsinSouthernSomaliawillalsohaveanimpactonthenextelections,sincedeteriorationofthesecuritysituationcouldactuallyimpairfreeandfaircampaignsorleadtocancellationofelectionsalltogether.Thisheightenstheneedforclosemonitoringoftheelectoralcampaignenvironment.
Economic Dimensions
Mandera isamongthepoorestCounties in theCountrywithpoverty levelsat87.8%(CRA,2012).TheprimaryeconomicactivityislivestockpastoralismwithcrossboundarytradealsoaccountingforthevibrancyofManderabordertown. It isbelievedthattheCountyhasmineralwealthpotential(petroleum),eventhoughpreviousexplorationexerciseshavebornenofruit.Thus,theCountyreliesheavilyonresourcestransfersfromthecentralgovernmentwhichtotaledKshs213MinFY2008/9.
Legal Dimensions
TheentireCountyisservedbyoneMagistrate’scourtbasedinMandera.Duetothis,residentshavereliedontraditionaljusticemechanisms(providedbycommunityelders)toresolveconflicts.DisputeresolutionmethodscentreonpaymentofMaslaha(looselytranslatedas‘compensation’)forcrimescommittedagainstmembersoffeudingclans.44ThesemechanismshavebeenusedtoresolvedeadlyconflictsthatoccurredintheregionandwerecreditedwiththeadoptionofUmulAccordin2005,whichisperhapsthegreatestpeace-buildingeffortintheCountytodate.Theprovincialadministrationplaysaroleindisputeresolutionbutisseverelyconstrainedbyinadequateinfrastructureandlogisticalconstraints.45
Social Cultural Dimensions
Relations between Garre and the other communities have been characterized by tensions andhostilities,arisingfromtheformerssenseofentitlementtoalltheterritoryinManderaandfeelingsthatthelatterareencroachers.ItisthissentimentthatmotivatedtheGarretoattackanddisplacetheMurullefromElWaktowninthe2000conflict.46TheDegodiahaveemergedasneutralintheGarreandMurulleconflictandassuch,theireldersareusually invitedtomediatetheconflictsbetweenthesetwolargegroups.
Creationofadministrativeunits (districts,divisionsand locations) inManderahavebeenasourceof conflict as they are interpreted as giving the resident clan exclusive rights over administrativeterritories.Thishascreatedtensionsoveruseofsharedresourcessuchaswaterandpasture.Thesetensionsarenotconfinedtoaffectedareas,butalsoextendtourbancentreswhereanyslightincidentmaytriggerstreetfightsbetweenrivalclans.
Itisalsosuggestedthatlocalpoetry,songsandrhetorichasbeenusedtoincitepeopleagainstrivalcommunitiesanddemonizingsomecommunities.47Prevalenceofsuchculturaltoolsisacriticalsignthatclanhatredisindeedentrenchedinthecollectivepsychesofthesecommunities.
43 Ibid44 Due to lack of formal courts, many victims of human rights violations therefore opt for Maslaha, a kangaroo court where they receive ‘compensation’ after discussion and agreement between their families and those of the offenders, despite its shortcomings and the ‘court’ is presided over men who often discriminate against women. See Njari Gitonga, Tribal, modern law differences cause trouble, Visit http://www2.mssu.edu/international/mccaleb/kenya/tribal.htm , accessed April 10, 2012. 45 Ibid Pg 1846 Ibid pg 1047 Ibid pg 28-9
36 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Environmental Dimensions
ManderaCountyisaveryaridareawithfewwaterresources.Thereisonlyonepermanentriver(RiverDawa)flowing fromsouthernEthiopianhighlandsdown throughMandera into southernSomalia.The restof theCounty is servedbywaterpans, natural springs andboreholes,whichareownedbyresidentcommunity.Duringdryperiodswhenscarcityworsens,communityeldersusuallycomeupwithcomplexschedulesforsharingthewaterresources.Failurebyagrouptoadheretotheseschedules usually results into conflict. Access to pasture is usually a negotiatedprocess involvingeldersfromconcernedcommunities.Witharisingpopulation,deteriorationofsecuritysituationinSomalialeadingtoinfluxofrefugeesandworseningeffectsofclimatechange,pressureoverpastureandwaterresourcesismountingandthishasincreasedconflictrisksinMandera.
Conclusion
Ethnicizationofpolitics, boundarydisputes, fragile security situationand resource-based conflictselevatetheconflictrisks inManderatohighcategory.Forthisreason,monitoringoftheelectoralenvironmentinallconstituencies(particularlyManderaCentral)shouldbeamatterofpriority.
MARSABIT COUNTYThisCountyislocatedinthenortherntipoftheformerEasternprovinceanditisthelargestCountyin the republic, covering approximately 70,961 square kilometers with a population of 291,666persons.48TheCountyhas5constituencies,whichare:Laisamis,Saku,NorthHorrandMoyale. Intermsofethnography,MarsabitcomprisesoftheBorana,Gabra,Burji,RendilleTurkanaandEl-Molocommunitiesinthatdescendingorder;intermsofpopulation.
Political Dimensions
Politicizationofethnicandclan identitiesposes thegreatestchallenge in termsofconflict factorsin the County. Thismanifests itself in ethnic rivalries between the Gabra and Borana, which arethetwolargestcommunities,occupyingtheSakuandMoyaleconstituencies.Leadersinthesetwoconstituenciesareknowntomobilizeforsupportalongethniclines,henceprecipitatingconflicts.Itisnotuncommonforinstanceforleadersoftwoormorecommunitiestoformallianceswithaviewtodefeatingacandidatefromanothercommunity.Conflictattimesisalsointroducedtoantagonizecommunitiesinordertomakeitdifficultforalliancestobeformed.ThecurrentconflictbetweentheGabraandBoranainMoyaleconstituencyshouldbeseeninthislight.ItissaidthatthefightingwassparkedbyjostlingamongtheCounty’sGabraandBoranaeliteforthepoliticalpositionscreatedbythenewdevolvedstructureofgovernment.49
Ata local level, interclan tensionsoverpoliticalpoweralso triggerconflicts.Forexample,amongtheRendileinLaisamis,minorityclansareknowntobuildalliancesagainstthedominantones.50itisalsoarguedthatconflicthasbeenusedasaninstrumentforalteringdemographythroughforcefulremovalorrelocationofaparticularcommunityintheseconstituencieswithaviewtodisadvantagingacandidatebyerodinghis/hervoterbase.ThisisthelogicbehindtheensuingclashesbetweenGabraandBoranainMoyaleconstituencies.
48 Republic of Kenya, (2009), National Population and Housing Census, Nairobi: Government Printers49 Interview with Jattani Wario, a CSO representative in Moyale and corroborated by a statement by Mzalendo Kibunjia, the Chairperson of NCIC posted on http://www.irinnews.org/report.aspx?reportid=94789 accessed on 2nd February 2012 50 For instance, the Tubcha, Yuyam, Matarbah, Elegeza, Odhola and Nahgan clans have formed TUMEONA alliance against dominant clans
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 37
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Security Dimensions
MarsabitCountyborderstheOromiaregionofEthiopiatotheNorth.Therehasbeenalongstandingrebellion inOromia, ostensibly due to claimsofmarginalizationof theOromo community by theEthiopianstate,whichisdominatedbynortherncommunities.Incidentally,theOromoareethnicallyrelatedtotheKenyanBoranaandtherefore,thishasraisedtheaccusationsbyEthiopianauthoritiesthatMarsabitandIsioloCountiesharborrebelbasesoftheOromo.ItisnotinfrequentforEthiopianmilitary tomake incursions inMarsabitCountyeither inpursuitofOromorebelsor inoperationsagainsttheserebelbases.
TheOromo rebellionhas led toproliferationof small arms in theCountyhencepredisposing theareatodeadlyconflicts. InthecurrentGabra-Boranaconflict,thereareallegationsthatthelattercommunity has elicited help of the armedOromo cousins against the former.51 The reduction ofsecuritythreatinthisareathereforepartlydependsontheresolutionoftheOromiaconflict.Cattlerustling isalsoacommonfeature,sometimes leadingto largescale inter-communalfighting. Therelativelylimitedpresenceofpoliceintheareaappearstoworsenthesituation.
Economic Dimensions
Marsabitisrankedasthe4thpoorestCountyinthecountry,withanestimatedpovertyrateof83.2%(KIBHS).ThisreflectsthegeneraltrendinthenorthernfrontierregionsofKenyathathadsufferedmarginalizationfromthecolonialtimes.However,withtheintroductionofresourcetransfersystemsfromthecentralgovernmentthroughsuchinstrumentsasLATFandCDF,theCountyhaswitnessedinflowofconsiderablefunds,whichaccountfor52%oftotalrevenue(CRA2012).Forinstance,intheFY2008/9,constituenciesintheCountyreceivedatotalofKshs541MfromCDF,makingtheamountthe4thhighestinthecountry,whereaslocalauthoritiesreceived185MfromLATF(31stinthecountry).
ItshouldhoweverbenotedthattheconstructionoftheIsiolo-Moyalehighwayislikelytoimprovelocaleconomyandopenuptheregiontotradewithotherpartsofthecountry.Theinfrastructureisalsolikelytoincreasethecapacityofauthoritiestorespondtoconflictswhenandastheyhappen.
Legal Dimensions
Communities inMarsabit have over timeusedwith varying degrees of success traditional justicemechanismstodealwiththeconflicts intheregion.Thesestructureshavenegotiatedandsettledinter-ethnic disputes arising from cattle rustling through application of restorative justice. Theypresent tomost accessible and convenient formsofdispute resolution, considering that theareahastwomagistratecourtslocatedinMarsabitandMoyaletowns.TheonlyHighCourtstationistobefoundineitherMeruorNyeri.Failurebytheformaljusticesystemtorecognizethelocaljusticemechanismsmeansthatthetwonormallyrunparallelandobliviousofeachother.Attitudestowardstheformaljusticesystemsarealsopoorasthelocalsperceivejudicialofficerspostedtotheseareasaseitherincompetentorindolent(havingbeentransferredtothesehardshipareasondisciplinarygrounds)52.Thisfurtheralienateslocalstotheformaljusticesystem.
The Provincial Administration and the District Peace Committees (DPCs) supplement avenues fordispute resolutions in the County. However, these organs have been accused of bias and lack ofneutralityinsomedisputesthusreducingtheiroveralleffectiveness.53
51 See Hassan Huka, Chief Seeks Foreign Refuge as Tribal Conflict Flares in Daily Nation Thursday December 29th 2011 edition, wherein Kenyan security forces were reported to have engaged in gun battles with Ethiopian tribal militia suspected to have been hired to back the warring communities52 Interview with local CSO leader - Ali Gorar53 For instance, the Moyale MP, Mohammed Ali was reported to have called for the transfer of Provincial Administration officials for laxity and bias in the current conflict in the area- see www.capitalfm.co.ke accessed on 29th Jan 2012
38 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
HistoricalinjusticesarisingfromtheShiftaWarinthe1960sandtheattendanthumanrightsabusesdominatelocaldiscoursesonpopulargrievancesthatunderliebitternessandfrustrationsofMarsabitresidentsagainstthecentralgovernment.TheTJRCprovidedanimportantavenueforventilationofthesegrievancesandthereforeitwillbeimportanttoseethekindofrecommendationsthatwillbemadeinaddressingtheselongstandingissues.
Social and Cultural Dimensions
CommunitiesresidinginMarsabitareknownforhabouringethnicrivalriesthatcouldeasilytriggerconflicts.Sometimestheseboiloverduringelectioncampaignswithnegativeconsequences.Itisnotuncommonforfightstobreakoutduetoethnicrivalry.54Inthepastsongswouldbeusedtoinciteviolence.
Marsabitalsohasaverylowenrolmentrateofgirlchildinbasiceducationat30%comparedtothenationalrateof74%.54bGenerallywomen’sparticipationindesicionmakingandpoliticsislow.
Environmental Dimensions
Marsabit County is largely an arid and semi-arid area with the exceptions of small patches ofmountainousarableareasincentralandnorthwesternparts.Assuch,naturalresource-basedconflictsoverpastureandwaterareprevalent.LandinMarsabitiscategorizedasTrustlandwhichisheldbythelocalauthoritiesintrustforthepeople.Assuch,thereisnoindividuallandtenure.Thispredisposestheareatoconflictsbetweennomadiccommunitiesaspropertyrightsarelooselydefined.TheCountyhasnomajorwatersourceandthereforetheresidentsrelyonwatersprings,undergroundwaterandseasonalrivers.Thesearecommunalresourceswhichcouldeasilytriggerconflictintimesofscarcity.Droughtsinducedbyclimatechangeincreasevulnerabilityandexarcerbateconflict.
Conclusion
Fromtheforegoing,itisevidentthatmanyfactorsappeartopredisposeMarsabitCountytoconflicts.ItisthereforerationaltocategorizetheCountyasahighriskconflictareaduetomultiplicityoftriggersandstructuralfactorsidentifiedinthisreport.
ISIOLO COUNTYIsioloCountybordersMarsabittotheNorth,SamburutotheWest,Mandera,WajirandGarissatotheEast,TanaRiver,MeruandLaikipiatotheSouth.TheCountyoccupies25,336squarekilometreswithapopulationof143,294accordingtothe2009Census.IsioloCountycomprisesofIsiolo-NorthandIsiolo-SouthConstituencies.Intermsofethnicdemography,IsiolocomprisesBorana,Samburu,Turkana,SomaliandMeruasthekeycommunities.
Political Dimensions
Thepoliticizationofconflict intheareabeganwiththeadventofmulitpartyismasthe-thenrulingpartyKANUtacitlygavesupporttolocalethnicwarlordsinabidtokeeptheoppositionatbay.55Thisconflictworsenedinin1999-2001astheKANUrulecameunderstrongchallengesandattheonsetofthe2002elections.
Since 2002, ethnic alliances have become an important determinant in political contests in the
54 Interview with CSO leader based in Marsabit town - Ali Gorar55 See for instance UNDP Kenya, Conflicts Dynamics in Isiolo, Samburu East and Marsabit South Districts, in Amani Papers, Vol 1 No3 of June 201054b http//www.hsnp.or.kr ( Hunger Safety Net Programme accessed 16th April 2012.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 39
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
County. In theperiodpost2007elections, Isiolohas seenonandoffconfrontationsbetween thecommunitiesleadingtoadisarmamentcampaignbythemilitaryin2009.TheexercisewashoweverstoppedafterlocalleadersaccusedthegovernmentofunfairlytargetingtheSamburuhencemakingthemvulnerabletoattacksfromBorana.IttooktheinterventionofthePrimeMinisterRailaOdingafortheexercisetostop56.
Theconflictreareditsheadonceagaintowardstheendof2010andwastriggeredbyclashesoverpastureandwaterbetweentheBoranaandtheTurkana.Asaresult,displacementofpopulationstookplacewhichmayaffectthe2012elections.
Security Dimensions
Isioloisinhabitedprimarilybypastoralistcommunitiesandhencecattlerustlingiscommon.However,rustlingactivitiesusuallypittheBoranaandSamburu,withoccasional incidencesreportedagainsttheSomalisintheformerNorthEasternKenya.SmallarmsarealsoaproblemintheCounty.
Economic Dimensions
Inthefinancialyear2008/9,IsiolowasabletorealizerevenueofKshs1.013billionmakingitthe7thrichestCountyinKenya.57Outofthisrevenue,Kshs561millionandKshs270millionwereresourcetransfersfromCDFandLATFrespectively,whereasKshs193millionwasgeneratedlocallyfromlocaltaxes.EventhoughtheseresourcesportendasolutiontotherelativeunderdevelopmentwitnessedintheCounty,itcouldneverthelessbeasourceofconflict.
Isiolowasthesiteofintensivepetroleumexplorationin2009/10periodbyChineseCompanies,anditwaswidelyexpectedthattheareawouldyieldvastreservesofnaturalgas.Alreadytensionsweremountingintheareapriortothenewsthattheexplorationwasunsuccessful.ThereispotentialformineralconflictsintheCounty.
Isiolo town isearmarked tobeupgraded intoa resort city in linewith theVision2030blueprint.A railway linewill traverse the County from South Sudan to the port of Lamu. Thismakes Isiolopronetospeculationby landprospectors.However,most land in Isiolo isTrust landandthereforecommunallyowned.Another relateddevelopment is theemergenceof conservancies in theareawhich are supported by the government in order to boost tourism. This has resulted in tensionsespeciallyduringdryseasons58.
Legal Dimensions
IsioloCounty,justlikeMarsabit,sharesimilarjudicialhistoryaspartofthewiderNorthernFrontierDistrict(NFD).WithonlyoneMagistratescourtlocatedinIsiolo,residentshaveresortedtotraditionaljustice mechanisms for dispute resolutions. The Failure to prosecue those responsible for inter-communalviolencehaserodedtheconfidenceoflocalsintheformaljusticesystem.
Social and cultural Dimensions
Besidesethnicrivalries,thecultureofmoranismamongtheSamburuisofconcerntothesecuritysituationinIsiolo.AspartoftheSamburuculture,youngmenarerequiredtospend10yearsinthebush fending for themselvesafter initiationritesafterwhich theyareconsideredas juniorelders.Therefore,moransconstituteastandingarmyfortheSamburuandengageinrustlingactivitiesatthe
56 Ibid57 CRA 201158 See for instance Hassan Huka, Police seeking seven over role in Isiolo violence, in Daily Nation Tuesday November 1st 2011 edition
40 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
behestofthecommunityelders.59.Owingtothefactthatothercommunities(BoranaandSomali)lackthisculture,theyarevulnerabletoSamburuattacksastheydonothaveacommunaldefensivemechanism.
Environmental Dimensions
IsioloisbetterendowedwithpastureandwaterpointsthantheneighbouringCountiesandforthisreason,mostherdsmenconvergeattheCountyduringdryspellswiththeiranimals.Thisthereforepredisposestheareatopasture-basedconflicts.Toaddressthisproblem,apeaceaccordadoptedbythelocalDPCrequiredneighbouringcommunitiestoinformtheIsioloDPCoftheirintentiontobringintheircattleinordertoavertconflicts.60However,theSamburuhaveroutinelyignoredthisaccordthereby sparking some incidentsof clasheswith locals.Another stickingpointwas the fencingofcommunalgrazinglandsbyTurkanaresidinginIsiolo.ThiscreatedtensionswithBoranaherdsmen,whoviewedsuchfencingasactsofprovocation,consideringthattheentireCountyis landheldintrustby the localauthoritiesonbehalfof thecommunities.Thiswashowever resolvedwhenthegovernmentbannedfencingofland.61
Conclusion
PoliticalethnicizationofconflictsandconflictsduetonaturalresourcesremainthegreatestchallengesinIsioloCounty.Lookingatallfactorstogether,IsioloremainsaCountywithhighconflictriskinKenya.
MERU COUNTYSituatedintheformerEasternprovince,MeruCountyisknownforitscloseproximitytotheMountKenya. The County is relatively small covering only 6,936 square kilometerswith a population of1,356,301people.Itcomprisessevenconstituenciesi.e.NorthImenti,Igembe,Ntonyiri,SouthImenti,TiganiaEast,CentralImentiandTiganiaWestandthusmakingtheCountypoliticallysignificantduetothesheernumbersofMPsitsendstotheNationalAssembly.TheCountyisdominatedbytheMeruethnicgroup,withmotleymigrantcommunitiesconstitutinganinsignificantminority.
Political Dimensions
Traditionally, theMeru community has organized itself politicallywith the Council of Elderswithrepresentationfromvariousclans,theNjuriNcheke,attheapex.Thus,clanidentitystillremainsanimportantaspectofMeru’spolitical life.ThedominantclansaretheImentifoundinMerucentralandhavedominatedthepoliticalarenaintheCounty.62ItisthefearoftheImentidominationthatpromptedpoliticiansfromtheIgembeandTiganiatoopposethecreationoftheMeruCountyandthusmobilizedtheirsupportedtoopposetheNewConstitutionduringthe2010referendum.
Security Dimensions
SecurityremainsanissueofconcerninareasthatborderIsioloandWajironthenorthernpartofMeru.IncidencesofcattlerustlinghavebeenreportedintheseareaswithregularityaspartofthewiderpastoralistconflictsystemofthenorthernmarginalareasofKenya.Suchincidenceshowevercoulddestabilizetheregionifthescaleandintensityisnotchecked.
59 UNDP Kenya, 201060 Ibid61 Ibid62 Other clans include Igoji, Tigania, Miutuni, Igembe, Mwimbi and Muthambi, Chuka and Tharaka
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 41
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Economic Dimensions
MeruCountyisconsideredamongthemostprosperousinthecountry.Povertylevelsareat28.3%-the5th lowest inthecountry(CRA,2011).Thedistrict isendowedwithhighpotentialarable land,tourismsitesintheMeruNationalParkandsoundinfrastructure.However,dependenceonresourcetransfers fromthecentralgovernment ishighatover50%.Riskofpolitical competitionbasedoncontrolofresourcesishoweverlow.
Legal dimensions
Whereas the formal justicesystem iswellentrenched inMeruasevidencedby thepresenceofaHighCourtStationand6magistratecourts,theNjuriNchekestillplaysaroleinprovidingavenuesforalternativedisputeresolution,especiallywithregardtocustomarymattersandland.Risksassociatedwithlegalfactorsarehoweverlow.
Social and cultural dimensions
Clan rivalriesmay present a challengewith regards to ensuring harmonious relations among theMeru.Besides,Meruareapatriarchalsocietyandthereforegenderrelationsexhibitstrainsduetodominationofwomenbymen.Womenplaymarginalrolesinpoliticsandtraditionallydonotownland.TheyouthbulgeinthecountryisalsoprevalentinMeruandthismayposeachallenge.
Environmental Dimensions
PerhapslandscarcityposesthegreatestenvironmentalchallengeforMeruCounty.Withapopulationdensityof196personspersquarekilometerpressureonthelandresourceispiling.InMeruNorthforinstance,landhasbeenidentifiedasoneofthemajorcausesofconflict63.Significantportionoflandintheareaisnottitledandthereforeisgovernedundercustomarylaw.Thismeansthatinsuchapatriarchalsociety,landiseffectivelyownedandcontrolledbymen.Accesstocreditisimpossiblesinceonecannotuselandascollateral.Attemptsbygovernmenttoinitiatetheprocessoftitlinglandhavehitsnagsduetopersistentpublicrejectionofadjudicationcommitteessetupforthatpurpose64.Unlessasolutionisfoundtothisproblem,itmaycreatesocialproblemsintheCounty.
AnothermanifestationoftheproblemistheexistenceofsquattersintheTimauregion.ThesquattersettlementsdatebacktocolonialperiodswhenAfricanlabourerswereallowedtosquatonfringesofsettlerfarms.Afterindependence,thegovernmentdidnotresolvetheproblemandhencepersistenceofsquattersettlementinthisarea.Unlesstheissueisresolved,thegrowingsquatterpopulationcouldposeapoliticalrisk.
Conclusion
Perhapsthemostsignificantconflictfactorsthatrequireclosemonitoringpriorto2012electionsareinter-clanpoliticalrivalryaswellasthelandissue.Otherwise,Merupresentsrelativelyminimalrisksinsofaraselectoralviolenceandconflictisconcerned.
THARAKA-NITHI COUNTYTharaka-NithiislocatedsouthofMeruCountyandoccupiesanareaof2,639squarekilometerswithapopulationof365,330persons.ItwascarvedoutofthelargerMerudistrictintheearly1990sbytheMoiadministration,followingagitationbylocalleaderswhofeareddominationbytheirnortherly
63 See Ministry of State for the Development of Northern Kenya and Arid Land, Arid Lands Resource Management Project II Meru North District- Annual Report 2007/8at pg 6 64 Ibid
42 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
cousins. TheCountyextends from the slopesofMountKenyaall thewaydown to thearid landsborderingtheformerNorthEasternProvince,henceitshowsahighdegreeofclimaticvariability.TheCountyisprimarilyoccupiedbyTharakaandChukasub-tribesoftheMeru.TheCountycomprisesTharakaandNithiconstituencies.
Political Dimensions
Liketheirnortherlyneighbours,theresidentsofTharaka-Nithitaketheirclanidentitiesseriouslyandthisplaysanimportantroleinthepoliticallifeoftheirsociety.However,themostsignificantcauseofconflictintheCountyhasbeenthecontestationofpoliticalandadministrativeboundariesbetweenthe Tharaka and Igembe. This dispute surfaced in 1994 and erupted into violent confrontationbetweenthetwocommunitiesin1996,resultinginthegovernmentissuingaministerialstatementsayingthatthedisputehadbeenreferredtotheNjuriNchekeforarbitration.65
Thematterhoweverhaspersistedwithnosolutionthusleadingtothedeadlyclashesin1997priortotheelectionsthatwereheldthatyear.Thematteragainflaredupin2003followingpublicutterancesby local politicians that bordered on incitement. During the consultations that were recentlyconductedbytheIndependentElectoralandBoundariesCommission(IEBC),thematterresurfacedwiththeresidentsofTharakaurgingtheCommissiontoresolvethematteronceandforall.Thusfromaconflictanalysisstandpoint,thisissuecouldeasilyprovokepre-electionviolenceunlessitisresolvedinanauthoritativemanner.
Security dimensions
Thelow-lyingareasoftheCountythatbordertheIsioloandGarissaarepronetobanditryandcattlerustling.ThesecurityrisksandchallengesfacedbyresidentsinthisareaaresimilartothosethatfacethenorthernpartsofMeru.
Economic Dimensions
Unliketheirnorthernneighbours,theTharaka-Nithiarenotasprosperouswithpovertyratesat48.7%(CRA,2012).TheupperslopesoftheCountyhavebetterclimaticconditionsandthereforesupportteaandcoffeefarming,whereasthelowlyingareasarearidandthereforesupportsubsistencefarmingaswellaspastoralism.TheresourcetransfersfortheFY2008/9amountedtoKshss339M(CRA,2012)againstmodestlocalrevenueshowingahigherdependenceonsuchtransfers.
Legal Dimensions
Tharaka-NithicurrentlyhasoneSeniorMagistratesCourtinMarimati.MostcasesarerefrerredtoChukaorMeru.Thereforethetraditionaldisputeresolutionmechanismsarestrongespeciallywithregardtocustomarymattersandland.Risksassociatedwithlegalmattersarelow.
Social and Cultural Dimensions
TheTharakashareasimilarsocialculturalprofilewithMeruCounty.Thepatriachialsystemisheavilyentrenchedandmendominatethesocialscene.Youngpeoplearealsodominatedoverbytheoldandthoughtheyaremore,theirimpactonsocialissuesiscurtailedbytradition.
Environmental Dimensions
LandrelateddisputesarealsoprevalentinTharaka,primarilyduetopopulationpressureandalsoduethefactthatsignificantportionoflandstillremainsundercustomarytenure.Thishasmadelandamajorcampaignissueowingtotheslowprogressofadjudicationandtitlingofland.65 See Kenya National Assembly, Official Records (Hansard) November 1996, Government Printer, 1996 at pg 2471
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 43
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Conclusion
ConflictrisksinTharaka-NithiCountyareslightlyhigherthaninMeruowingtothepotentialforaborderdispute,securitysituationinthepastoralistareasandland-relatedconflicts.
EMBU COUNTYEmbu County is situated in themiddle of the former Eastern Province and covers 2,818 squarekilometerswithapopulationof519,212persons(2009Census).TheCountyisinhabitedbytheEmbu,MbeereandKambaandKikuyucommunitiesandhencepresentsacosmopolitancomplexion.TheCountywas createdby amalgamating the former Embu andMbeere districts that had been splitinthe1990sbytheformerpresidentMoi’sKANUadministration.TheCountycomprisesManyatta,Runyenjes,GachokaandSiakagoconstituencies.
Political Dimensions
InthecosmopolitanareasofMbeere,ifthecompetitionforpoliticalpositionsbecomesintense,risksforconflictswillincreasehencetherewillbeneedtomonitortheseareas.
Security Dimensions
UnlikeTharaka-NithiandMeruCounties,cattlerustlingisnotamajorissueinEmbu,owingtolimitedboundariesandinteractionwiththeconflict-proneareas.However,theareafacesalatentMungikithreat,consideringthatthehotbedoftheproscribedsectisintheneighbouringKirinyagadistrict.Itispossibleforyouthtobeenlistedinviolentcampaignsandhencethisriskoughttobeaddressed.
Economic Dimensions
Poverty levels inEmbuarerelativelyhighat42%,whereasdependenceonresourcetransfersalsoremainshigh(theregionreceivedKshs519millionasdevolvedfundsfromthecentralgovernmentintheFY2008/9).
Legal Dimensions
AccesstoformalsystemofjusticeiscommendableastheCountyhasaHighCourtstationthatwaspreviouslyservingboththeformerEasternandNorthEasternProvinces.MagistratecourtsarefoundinEmbuandRunyenjes.
Social and cultural dimensions
Eventhough theCounty is inhabitedby4differentcommunities, there isnothing tosuggesthighlevelsoftribalhatred.Thesecommunitieshaveco-existedpeacefullyovertheyears.
Environmental Conditions
LandisakeyissueinthelowerpartsoftheCounty.InpartsofGachokaConsituencythatarepartoftheMweaRiceScheme,landisyettobetitledandhencethishasbeenacampaignissueforyears.LikeTharaka-Nithi,thisisamatterthatmeritsattention.
Conclusion
Conflict risks in Embu are moderate, considering that the County is more cosmopolitan that itsnorthernneighbours.
44 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
KITUI COUNTYKituiCountyneighboursMachakosCountytotheeast,occupyingamassive30,496squarekilometersandapopulationof1,012,709persons. It comprises the formerKitui andMwingidistrictswithamono-ethnic(Kamba)demographiccomposition.Thereare6constituenciesintheCountywhichare:MwingiNorth,MwingiSouth,KituiEast,KituiWest,KituiCentral,MutitoandMutomo.
Political Dimension
KituiCountyishometotwopoliticalgiantsofcontemporaryKambapolitics-VicePresidentKalonzoMusyokaandHonCharityNgilu.SincebothenjoyconsiderablepoliticalfollowingwithintheCounty,and have been known to take opposing sides, their supportersmay clash during campaigns andvoting.InJune2011,clashesbetweensupportersofthetwopoliticiansoccurredwhenNgilutouredKalonzo’sMwingiNorth constituency in the companyof politicians allied toher.66 if elections arecloselycontested,theremayberiskofelectionrelatedviolenceandthereforemeritsfortiscountytobecloselymonitored.
Security Dimensions
Liketheupperpartsofeasternprovince,theareasborderingGarrisaandTharaka-NithiCountiesarepronetocattlerustling,eventhoughtheintensitymaynotbeashigh.LimitedsecuritypresenceintheareaandworseningconflictsituationinSomaliacouldworsenthesituationthough.
Economic Dimensions
EventhoughpovertylevelsinKituiarehigh(at63.5%),theregionhasahighmineralwealthpotentialfollowingdiscoveryofvastquantitiesofcoal,ironandcement.Alreadythereareconcernsthattheagreement signed by the Chinesemining company and the government over coal exploitation isshroudedinsecrecyandthattheenvironmentalimplicationsofthesamehavenotbeensufficientlydisclosed to residents.67 Issuance ofmining rights in Kitui by the County Council has to two rivalcementcompanies,BamburiCementLtdandAthiRiverMiningLtdhasledtowranglingamongthetwocompaniesaswellasamonglocalleaders.68Todate,thedisputeremainsunresolvedandeffortstoseekpresidentialandcourtinterventionhavenotbornefruit.69Thisaspectneedtobemonitoredasapotentialcauseofconflict.
Legal Dimensions
Access to justice inKitui is rather limitedowing to inadequate infrastructureasevidencedby theabsenceofahighcourtstationandfewmagistratescourt(inKituiandMwingitownsonly)servingsuchahighpopulation.However, traditionaldisputeresolutionmechanismsarerifeandstrong inruralpartsoftheCounty
Social and cultural Dimensions
Thesocial-culturaldimension,thereisprevalenceofpovertyanditsattendanteffects.Thoughalotofpremiumisplacededucationandmostofthecommunitymembershavegotstrongreligiousbeleifs,there is incidenceofabusetothegirl-child. Thisnotwithstanding,theparticipationofwomeninpoliticalaffairsisquitehighintheCounty.
66 See Mutua P, Many injured as Ngilu and Kalonzo supporters clash, in The Standard, 24th June 2011 67 See Sunday Nation 30th October 201168 See Kenya National Assembly, Official Records (Hansard) Feb 2009, Government Printers 2009 at pg 24-569 The matter is listed in court as ELC/JR No 84 of 2007
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 45
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Environmental Dimensions
ScrambleformineralresourcesinKituiislikelytoemergeascriticalfactors.Thiswillbetriggeredbydisagreementsovercompulsoryacquisitionandcompensationofresident’slandastheymakewayforminingfields.Environmentalproblemsassociatedwithcoalminingandopaqueresourcesharingagreementswill alsobring to foredisputesoverpublicwelfareandbenefit,which ifnotproperlyresolved,thismayfomentwidespreadgrievancespeculiartominingareasintheCounty.
LanddisputesowingtocustomarytenureunderwhichmostlandfallsaswellaspresenceofsquattersinMwingiNorthandKituiwestarelikelytoremainasriskfactorsespeciallyinaffectedconstituencies.Human-wildlifeconflictsneargameparksalsoposearisk,albeitamoderateone.
Conclusion
TheaboveanalysesplaceKituiCountyasamoderatepoliticalriskareaandthereforeshouldwarrantclosemonitoringintherunuptotheupcomingelections
MACHAKOS COUNTYMachakosCountyislocatedinlowerpartoftheformerEasternprovince,andcovers6,208squarekilometers with a high population of 1,098,584 people (2009 Census). With the exception ofcosmopolitan Athi River/Mavoko area, the rest of the County is occupied by Kamba community.TheCountycomprisessixconstituencies,whichare:Masinga,Kangundo,Kathiani,MachakosTown,MwalaandYatta.Owingtothishighnumberofseats,theCountyispoliticallysignificant.TheCountyisclosetoNairobi,withpartsofitslandcomprisingthelargerNairobiMetropolitan.
Political Dimensions
UnlikemostpartsofEasternprovince,politics inMachakos is largelyunaffectedbyclanorethnicconsiderations.ThiscanbeattributedtothediminishedclanidentityandauthorityofclanspartlyduetoinfluenceofChristianityandmodernity.Politicsratherisorganizedaroundpersonalitiesandpoliticalparties.Since1997,CharityNgiluandKalonzoMusyokahavedominatedthepoliticalscene,withpoliticalgroupingsandfactionsrevolvingaroundthetwo.Iftheelectionsarecloselycontested,theremaybeariskofelectionrelatedviolence.
Security Dimensions
Due to proximity to Nairobi and the relative high level of urbanization, Machakos experiencesheightenedcriminality,whichhoweverisnotpoliticallydirectedormotivated.70
Economic Dimensions
PovertylevelsinMachakosarerelativelyhighat59.6%largelyduetopooragriculturalperformanceand productivity in the vastmarginal areas. The County however is less dependent on resourcetransfers fromcentralgovernment (transfers constitute less than40%of revenue)and thushasastrong revenuebaseowing tourbanizationandpresenceof the rich industrial zoneofAthiRiver.ResourcetransfersneverthelessstandatKshs479m.
MachakoshashadconsiderableproblemswithlandespeciallyinYimitheu,Syokimauandafairshareof squatters.Secondly,Machakoswillhost theKonzaTechnopolis,an InformationCommunicationTechnology(ICT)industrialcity,whichisoneoftheVision2030flagshipprojects.Already,anintensivelandscrambleisunderwayasKenyansattempttoownlandaroundtheproposedsite.Oncethecity
70 Accordingly to CRA 2012, rate of urbanization in Machakos stands at 52%
46 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
isupandrunning,itmayupsetthelocalpoliticaldynamicsunlessadifferentpoliticalentityiscreatedtomanageit.
Legal dimensions
AccesstojusticeinMachakosisrelativelyhigh,withthepresenceofaHighCourtstationinMachakostownandmagistratecourtsinKangundo,YattaandTawa.Traditionalsystemsofjusticehaveallbuteroded.
Social and cultural dimensions
SignificantsocialandculturalfactorsthatmaytriggerconflictintheCountyarethosethatmaybeassociatedwithproblemsofurbanizationsuchasurbanpovertyandyouthunemployment.LikeinKituiCounty,theparticipationofwomeninsocialaffairsishigh.
Environmental Dimensions
LandinsomepartsofMachakosisstillasourceofpotentialconflict.InMasingaconstituency,thereare considerable populations of squatters residing in former settler ranches. So significant is thevotingpowerof these squatters that theyareable to influencewhoeverbecomesanMP in thisconstituency.Pocketsofsquattersarealsotobe found inMachakosTownandYattaconstituency.RecentdemolitionofhousesinSyokimauareabroughttothelimelight,theprecariouslandownershipsituationinMavokoarea,whereduetoyearsofcorruptionsinlanddealings,unsuspectingcitizensweresoldpublicland.Recoveryofthislandislikelytobeahotcampaignissuewhichmeritsclosemonitoring.
Conclusion
Land-related conflicts and political competition for control of resources in devolved structure ofgovernance is likely tomake theupcomingelections intense andhence attractmoderate risksofincidencesofviolence.
MAKUENI COUNTYMakueniCountyislocatedonthesoutherntipoftheformerEasternProvinceandmeasures8,009squarekilometerswithapopulationof884,527(2009Census).LikeKitui, it is largelymono-ethnic(Kamba), with few pockets of diverse migrant populations. The County comprises Kilome, Kaiti,Makueni,KibweziandMbooniConstituencies.
Political Dimensions
MakuenisharessimilarpoliticalrisksandprofileasMachakosCounty.PoliticalconflictscouldpossiblyemanatefromcompetitionbetweensupportersorsympathisersofKalonzoandNgiluiftheelectionsarecloselycontested.
Economic Dimensions
Povertyratesstandat64.1%whichisthehighestintheeasternregion.However,theCountyattractsconsiderable resource transfers (approximately Kshs 489million in FY 2008/9) owing to the highpoverty levels. The two stable economic pockets ofMbooni and Kilungu are not well tapped toprovidesupporttothelargerexpanseoftheCounty.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 47
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Legal Dimensions
Makuenihasnohighcourtstationand iscurrentlyservedbymagistratecourts inMakindu,WoteandKilungu.Traditionaldisputeresolutionmechanismsthroughsurvivingclanstructuresdoexistinremoteareasandhenceserveasimportantavenuesforredresswhereformaljusticesystemsdonotexist.
Social and cultural Dimensions
SomelevelsofsocialandculturaldifferencesexistbetweentheKambaandMaasaialongthecommonborderthatrunsfromKonzatoMtitoAndei.Sometimetensionsoccasionallyboilupbetweenthesecommunitiesbutrisksassociatedwiththesedifferencesremiallow.
Environmental Dimensions
LandproblemspersistinMakueniwithasizeablesquatterpopulationresidinginMakueniandKibweziconstituencies.Theseportendsomepoliticalrisksasthelandissueislikelytobepoliticizedbecomepotential conflict triggers.Human-wildlife conflicts inareasnearTsavoNationalParkhavebeenasourceofconcernformanyyears.
Conclusion
Makueniposesmoderateriskswithregardtopoliticalconflictandthereforecouldmeritmonitoringastheelectionsapproach.
NYANDARUA COUNTYNyandarua County is found in the north-western part of the former Central Province, borderingLaikipia,Nakuru,Kiambu,Nyeri andMurang’aCounties. Itmeasures3,245 squarekilometersandholdsapopulationof596,268(Census2009).ItcomprisesfourconstituencieswhichareKingangop,Ol-Kalou,NdaragwaandKipipiri.ItishometotheKikuyu,Maasai,KalenjinandSamburucommunities.
Political dimensions
LikeotherpartsofCentralKenya, in2007generalelections,Nyandaruavotedoverwhelmingly forPresidentKibakiinthepresidentialpollsbutexhibitedpoliticalpluralisminthemannerinwhichtheyvotedforparliamentarycandidatesinthepreviouselections.Thisindicatesthewillingnessofthevoterstoscrutinizeandjudgecandidatesonthebasisoftheirpersonalattributesandrepresentations.ItisthereforeexpectedthatparliamentarypollsintheCountywillremaincompetitivewithamoderateriskofconflictintheforthcomingelections
The IEBC has proposed to curve out a new constituency- Ol-Jorok fromOl-Kalou andNdaragwa.Disagreementshavearisenamongpoliticiansoverthedecisiontotransfersomevotingareasfromtheoldconstituenciestotheproposedconstituency.Thiscouldprovideconditionsforconflictifthematterisnotresolved.
NyandaruaishometoInternallyDisplacedPersons(IDPs)whomovedintotheareafromRiftValleyasaresultofthePEV.TheseIDPsaretobefoundintheMawingocampnearNyahururutown.Thesituationneedstobecloselymonitored.
Security Dimensions
ThenorthernareasofNyandaruaCountythatborderRiftValleyCountiesofLaikipiaandNakuruare
48 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
pronetocattlerustlingduetoproliferationofsmallarmsinthearea.TherealsohistoricalgrievancesheldbytheMaa-speakingcommunities(suchastheSamburuandMaasai)intheseareasthatthelanduponwhichtheKikuyucommunityhassettledwastraditionallytheirs.Thiscouldprovidegroundsforpolitical incitementunless thematter is resolvedwithin the contextofongoing truth, justiceandreconciliationprocess.
NyandaruaexperiencedviolentcrackdownoftheMungikisectbysecurityforcesinthe2008-9period.ItisthereforescarredbytheMungikiexperience.EventhoughtheMungikithreatappearstohavebeenneutralized,thepotentialforremobilizationofsectmembersforpoliticalcampaignsexistsandthereforeshouldbemonitored.
Legal Dimensions
TheCountyisservedbyasinglemagistratecourtstationinNyahururu.ThismayposechallengesintermsofaccesstojusticeoverelectoraldisputessincethenearesthighcourtstationisinNakuru.
Economic Dimensions
NyandaruaisthepoorestCountyincentralKenyawithpovertylevelsnowestimatedat46.3%(CRA,2012). This is attributed towidespreadpoverty conditions in the semi-arid areas in thenorthernpartoftheCountyaswellasovercrowdingconditionsinthesouthernpartswhereitisincreasinglybecomingdifficulttoexploitfullpotentialofreducingagriculturallandholdings.Theseconditionsmaycreateanenvironmentconducivetoconflicts
Social Dimensions
Thereareareaswithpocketsofethnictensionsemanatingfromhistoricallandgrievancesalludedtoabove.Unlessresolved,theseareasmaycreateconflictconditions
Environmental Dimensions
SignificantenvironmentaldegradationisevidentinmostpartsoftheCounty.Inthelowerreachesof the County, high population density has put pressure on decreasing landholdings leading tounsustainablepatternsoflanduse.Landlessnessisalsoasignificantfactorwhichhasrecentlybeenworsenedby the influxof IDPs in thecountry.Human-wildlifeconflictsarecommonon theareasborderingtheAberdaresNationalParkwhichledtofencingoffofthepark.
Conclusion
Conflict risk in Nyandarua can be termed as moderate. The key factors may include politicalcompetition,povertyoccasionedbylandlessnessandunsustainablelanduseandinsecurity.
NYERI COUNTYNyeriCountyis locatedinthenortherntipofCentralKenyaandbordersKirinyaga,Meru,Laikipia,NyandaruaandMurangaCounties.Itmeasures3,337squarekilometerswithapopulationof693,558(2009Census).ItispopulatedbytheKikuyuthoughotherethnicgroupsaretobefoundinthemajorcommercialcenters.Thereare6constituenciesintheCountythatareNyeriTown,Mukurweini,Tetu,Othaya,KieniandMathira
Political Dimensions
Nyeriisaverypolitically-significantCountyforvariousreasons.First,theCountyisthehomeofthe
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 49
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
incumbentPresident,whoisalsotheMPforOthaya.Inthesunsetyearofhispresidencyandelectivepolitics,theracetosucceedtheMwaiKibakiinhisconstituencyhasbeguninearnest.
Secondly,theCountyhasahighnumberofconstituenciescomparedtootherCountiesthatmaybemorepopulous.Thevotingpatternsthatemergedinthelastelectionsindicatethatthevotersarenotbeholdentoanypoliticalpartyperse.Hencewiththiskindofpluralismdisplayedbyvoters,politicalpartiescompetefreely.
Partyrivalrieshaveincreasedaswasevidencedinarecentby-electionwherethePresidentwasforcedtocomedowntohisconstituencyandcampaignforacouncilorafteritemergedthatthecandidatefromhispartyPNUwaslikelytolosetoanothersupportedbyGrandNationalUnityParty(GNU).71
Thirdly,theCountyishometoconstituencieswithlonghistoriesofviolentelections.InMathiraforinstance,violencehasfeaturedineveryelectionduetolocalrivalriesbetweencandidates.Politicianshaveconsistentlyusedyouthtocausemayhemandintimidatetheirrivals.Thesamehashappenedin Nyeri town andMukurweini. This culture of violence can be traced to the 1980swhen KANUattemptedtoimposecandidatesintheareainabidtocurtailtheinfluenceofMwaiKibakiwhoatthattimewastheVicePresidentandMoi’sdeputy72.Thelocalsreactedangrilytothesemovesandhenceelectionswereroutinelymarredbyviolence.
Security Dimensions
Likeotherpartsof centralKenya,Nyeriwasafflictedby theMungikiproblem,whichhadcreatedinsecurity in the area. This had raised tensions in the area following bizarre killings and revengeattacks.However,followingthemassivecrackdownonmembersofthesect,theproblemseemstohavesubsided.Howeverthethreatofre-emergenceofMungikistillremains.
Economic Dimensions
Nyeriisrelativelyprosperouswithpovertyratesat32.7%.ThemainstayoftheCountyisagriculture,livestock,quarrying,tradeandtourism.TheCountyreceivedatotalofKshs562MasdevolvedfundsintheFY2008/9.Nyerihasarelativelyhighpopulationandsignificantlyhigherpovertyascomparedtoitsimmediateneighbours.
Legal Dimensions
Thereare3magistratecourtstationsandonehighcourtstationsintheCounty.Tothisextent,accesstoelectoraljusticeissignificantandcouldbeusefulinaddressingelectoraldisputes.
Social Dimensions
TheCountyhaswomen strongly involved inpublic affairs.Ove theyears, therehasbeenalotofemphasisonthegirl-childwhiletheboychildhasreceivedlittleattention:intheeducationsectorforinstance,enrollmentofboyshasgonedown73.NyeriCountyhasoflatebeenmakingnewswithregardstodrinkingproblemsaffectingmen.Thishasledtostrainedgenderrelationsaswomenarebeingstereotypedashusbandbatterers.
Environmental dimensions
71 The PNU candidate narrowly won the seat, indicating that the influence of the retiring president on local politics is not something that people will take for granted72 Interview with a local resident 73 http://www.shrenpublishers.co.ke/education-watch/74-issue-01/269-boy-child-education-in-Central-under -threat
50 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
NyeriisgrapplingwithnegativeeffectsofclimatechangeasevidencedbyworseningofdryconditionsandpersistenceofdroughtintherelativedrierKieniconstituency.Thismaydisruptlivelihoodsduringtheelectionperiod,thusmakingtheaffectedpopulationsvulnerabletomanipulationbypoliticians.There arepockets of landless in Kieni constituency andefforts to evict the squatters could igniteviolenceinthearea.PartoftheCountyborderingMt.Kenyahasovertheyearsexperiencedhuman-wildlifeconflictaswellasconflictsbetweensedentaryfarmersandpastoralistsoverpasture.Theseconflictsoughttobemonitoredtoavoidasituationwheretheybecomedisruptivefactorsduringtheelection.
Conclusion
Nyeripresentsahighconflictriskarea,duetotheimpendingretirementofthepresident,thehistoryofviolenceinsomeoftheconstituenciesandstrainedgenderrelations.Allconstituenciesmaybepotentialhotspots
KIRINYAGA COUNTY
Kirinyaga County borders Embu, Nyeri, Meru and Murang’a Counties. It measures 1479 squarekilometerswithapopulationof528,054(2009Census).TheCountyisdominatedbytheKikuyuwhospeaktheNdia-dialectthoughwithminorityKamba,EmbuandAmberecommunitiesresidingintheMwearicesettlementscheme.Ithas4constituencieswhichareGichugu,Ndia,KirinyagaCentralandMwea.
Political Dimensions
Twopresidentialaspirants,MarthaKaruaandUhuruKenyattaarecurrentlycompetingforsupportin thisCountyand this is tending topolariseopinionswithareaMPs takingsides.Thishas led tointensification of local rivalries which evidently played out during the recently-held KirinyagaConstituencyby-electionatwhichaUhuruKenyatta-alliedcandidate(JosephGitari)wonoveraMarthaKarua-alliedcandidate(DanielKaraba).Thecampaignsduringtheby-electionwerecharacterizedbytensionswithsomeincidencesofviolence,indicatingthelevelofstakesthatweremanifestduringthecontest.
Gichuguconstituencyhasalonghistoryofelectoralviolence.Thisisassociatedwithdeeppoliticalrivalrythatcandidatesintheareahavedemonstratedovertheyears.74Youtharenormallymobilizedbythecandidatestointimidaterivalsandthisoftenleadstoviolence.Thishasthereforeledtoanentrenchedcultureofelectoralviolence.UnlesstheIEBCtakesdecisivestepstodealwiththeissue,violencemayresurfaceintheforthcomingelections.
Security Dimensions
KirinyagawasextensivelyaffectedbytheMungikimenace.Themenacewascharacterizedbyattacksandcounterattacksbythegangandmembersoflocalvigilantegroupsaswellasshootingofmembersofthegangbysecurityforces.Inoneoftheworstkillings,about28villagerslosttheirlivesafteranightattackbysuspectedmembersoftheMungiki.WhatfollowedwasanorgyofkillingsthateventuallyledtotheexpulsionofthegangfromtheupperpartsoftheCounty.PocketsoftheganghoweveraretobefoundinthelowerpartsoftheconstituencyinMweaconstituency.Thegangposesathreatinthenextelectionsinthesensethatitsmemberscouldbemobilizedbycandidatesandusedincausingviolenceforpoliticalpurposes.
74 According to a civil society leader, violence in the constituency has been a hallmark of the area since the 1980s during the NJiru v Njinu rivalry and persists to date
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 51
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Economic Dimensions
KirinyagaCountyisthethirdwealthiestCountyinthecountry,withpovertyratesestimatedat25%.Its mainstay is agriculture (tea, coffee and horticulture). It has impressive human developmentindicatorsandhasbeenreceivingconsiderabletransfersfromthecentralgovernment.TheCountyalsoisendowedwithgoodinfrastructure.
Legal dimensions
TheCountyisservedbyMagistratecourtsinKerugoya,BarichoandWangurustations.TheHighCourtatNyeriservesthearea.Thisthereforeconstraintsaccesstojusticewhichmayhavedireconsequencesforresolutionofelectoral-relateddisputes.
Social dimensions
There exist some social differences between the Kikuyu from other areas and their Kirinyagacounterparts. The declaration ofMartha Karua’s presidential candidature has been welcomed insomequarterswithintheCountyandisviewedasanattemptbytheNdiapeopletoovercomeyearsofdominationbytheirlargerKikuyucousins.Thesedifferencesarelikelytoplayoutduringthenextelections
Environmental Dimensions
WaterandlandconflictsareprevalentinthelowersectionsoftheCounty.MweaconstituencyhoststheMwea rice irrigation scheme,which is the largest and among the oldest in the country. Thescheme is plaguedby landdisputes and thesehavebeenusedas campaign fodderbypoliticiansin every electionwith sometimes violent consequences. The scheme is also riddenwith conflictsbetweenupstreamanddownstreamcommunitiesoverwateruserrights.Withreductioninflowofwatersinthelocalrivers,theseconflictsarelikelytointensifyandcouldthereforeassumeapoliticaldimensioninthecomingperiod.
Conclusion
KirinyagaCountyevincesahighlevelofconflictriskinCentralKenya.ThehistoryofviolenceinGichuguandtheconflictfactorsprevalentinMweaconstituencymakesthetwothemostsignificanthotspotsthatmeritcloserattentionintermsofmonitoring
MURANG’A COUNTYMurang’aCountyissituatedattheheartoftheformerCentralProvince.Itmeasures2,559squarekilometerswithapopulationof942,841.TheCountyisdominatedbytheKikuyucommunity,withmigrant communities found in large scale farms in the Gatanga and Makuyu area. There are 4constituenciesintheCounty:theyare,Maragua,Kiharu,Kangema,Mathioya,Gatanga,KandaraandKigumo.
Political Dimensions
Murang’aCountymayexperiencepoliticaltensionscharacterizedbydifferencesbetweenthepoliticalsupportersofPeterKenneth,MarthaKaruaandUhuruKenyattawhoarepresidentialaspirants.
InMaraguaandKandara,thelandissueisrifeowingtopresenceofsquattersingovernmentreserveland.Thismattertendstoassumepoliticaldimensionsduringelectionsandhencecouldbeasourceofconcern.
52 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Security Dimensions
Murang’awasahotbedofMungikiactivitiesuntiltheLateInternalSecurityMinister,JohnMichukidecidedtocrackdownonthegroup.Asaresult,thepoliceroundedupandshotsuspectedMungikimembers.Forthisreason,thegovernmentwasroundlycondemnedforextra-judicialkillings.Inspiteofthiscrackdown,itisnotcleariftheMungikithreathasbeeneliminatedandthereforepossibilitiesofthegroupbeingmobilizedforpoliticalreasonsinthenextelectionsremains.ThefactthatMathioyahasinpastelectionssufferedfromelectoralviolencemaypointtopossibilitiesofrecurrenceofthesame.
Economic dimensions
Poverty levels inMurang’aarerelatively lowat29.9%.TheCountydependsmainlyonagricultureand trade foreconomicoutput.Throughdevolved funds, theCounty receivedKshs448million intheFY2008/9andhencethiswill likelyincreasewiththeestablishmentoftheCountygovernmentonaccountoftherelativelyhighpopulationinthearea.ThiswilldefinitelyincreasetheintensityofpoliticalcompetitionwithintheCountyandthereforemeritsclosermonitoring
Legal Dimensions
TheCountyisservedby4magistratecourtstations-Murang’a,Kigumo,KandaraandKangemacourts.However,intheabsenceofaHighCourt,onemaysaythataccesstojusticeremainsachallengeandthismayaffecttheresolutionofelectoraldisputes.
Social dimensions
The major risks under this category include the targeting of minority communities; alcoholism;unemploymentofyouth;thejiggersmanaceandalsothecriminalityofMungikiamongothers.
Environmental dimensions
TheonlyissuerelatedtothisdimensionistheexistenceofpocketsofsquattersintheCounty,particularlyinMaraguaandKandaraarea.Conflictsrelatedtolandmayaffecttheelectoralenvironmentintheaffectedareas
Conclusion
EventhoughtheconflictriskinthisCountyisnothigh,thereisneedtomonitorMathioyaandGatangaconstituenciesduetothehistoryofelectoralviolence.
KIAMBU COUNTY
KiambuCountyneighboursNairobicityandisamongthelargestCountiessituatedintheformerCentralProvince.Itoccupies2,543squarekilometersbutwithahighpopulationof1,623,282(2009Census).TheKikuyucommunity isdominantintheCountythoughwithahighrateofurbanization(60%oftheentirepopulationlivesinurbanareas),theCountyhasattractedmembersofothercommunitiesaswell. ItbordersKajiado,Muranga,NyandaruaandMachakos.ThecurrentconstituenciesintheCountyareLari,Kiambaa,Limuru,Kabete,GatunduNorth,GatunduSouthandJuja.
Political Dimensions
Kiambuhasbeenapolitically-significantareainKenya’spoliticalhistory.Itisconsideredthebedrock
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 53
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
oftheMauMauliberationstruggleanditproducedthefirstpresidentJomoKenyatta.Thelatter’sson,UhuruKenyattahailsfromthisCounty.WhereastheresidentsoftheCountysolidlyvotedforMwaiKibakiinthelastpresidentialelections,thearearesidentshoweverdemonstratedagreatdealofpoliticalpluralismtheirchoiceofMPs-theCountyisrepresentedbyMPsbelongingtoNationalRainbowCoalition–Kenya(NARC-Kenya),PNUandKenyaAfricanNationalUnion(KANU).
There is a risk of exclusionist political campaigns in this County. Based on past history wherebycandidatesmaynotbeabletocampiagnfreely,whereadominantgroupisperceivedtosupportonlyonecandidate,theriskofviolenceisexecerbated.Already,theLariMP,DavidNjugunawasavictimofattacksbyunknownpersonsforappearingtohaveendorsedRailaOdingaforthepresidency.
TheCountywasaffectedbythePEV.TherewerereportedincidencesofretaliatoryattacksagainstmembersoftheLuoandLuyhacommunitiesbylocalresidentsinLimuru,KabeteandRuiruareas.Theseareasremainpronetorecurrenceofviolence,sincenomeasureshavebeentakenagainsttheperpetratorsofthesaidviolence.
Kiambu County was among those worst affected by the Mungiki violence in the last couple ofyears.Even though thegovernmenthas succeeded indrivingMungikiunderground, thepotentialforitsmemberstobemobilizedandusedindispensingpoliticalviolenceremainshigh.Widespreadunemployment, existence of sizeable squatter or landless population in the area and unresolvedpre-independencehistoricalinjusticesprovidegroundsforrecruitmentofyouthintomilitiasuchasMungiki.
Security Dimensions
Kiambuisoneofthemostinsecureareasinthecountry.InsecurityisfuelledbytheexistenceofmilitiasuchasMungiki,existenceofurbansprawlswithsqualorinsuchtownsasRuiruandThika,proliferationof small arms in thearea (anoverflow fromNairobi) andhigh incidencesof unemployment. It ispossiblethatinsecuritycanbeusedasapretextforpoliticalintimidationandperpetrationofpoliticalviolenceintheCounty.
Economic Dimensions
Kiambu is one of the richest Countieswith a relatively lowpoverty rate of 27.2%. The County iswellservicedwithinfrastructureandthishasmadeitanattractiveareaforrealestateinvestment.However,theCountyhaspocketsofextremepovertyinurbanslumsofRuiruandThikaaswellasmarginalareasborderingKajiadoandMachakos.Existenceofsteepinequalitiescouldfuelconflictsinthearea.
TheCountyislikelytobeabigrecipientofdevolvedfundssinceithasahighpopulationamongotherfactorsaselaboratedbytheCRAinlate2011.
Legal Dimensions
Kiambu isservedbyMagistratecourts inKiambu,Thika,Gatundu,Kikuyu,LimuruandGithunguri.However,despitehavingsuchahighpopulation, there isnoHighCourtstation intheCountyandthereforeresidentsareforcedtousetheNairobistation.There isthereforeneedtocreateaHighCourt station toenhanceaccess to justiceand thereforeprovidebetteravenues for resolutionofelection-relatedconflicts.
Social dimensions
Duetoentrenchedinequalities,classtensionsexistintheareaandthishasbeenmanifestedbythe
54 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
highinsecurityprevalenceandtakingrootoftheMungikimenace.Incosmopolitanareas,inter-ethnicsuspicionsandmistrustledtoeruptionofretaliatoryattacksagainsttheLuoandLuhyaasmentionedabove.Thesefactorsmayaffecttheelectoralenvironmentcome2012electionsandthereforerequiremonitoring.
Environmental Dimensions
Kiambucontinuestosufferfromtheintractablelandproblem.Forinstance,intheMboi-KamitiandNyakinyuafarmsinRuirudistrict,therehavebeenviolentconfrontationsbetweenmembersofthegroups that hold titles over these properties. Landlessness is also prevalent in formerMauMauhotbedssuchasLariandGatundu.Theseissuesmayprovidefertilegroundsforelectoralviolence.
Conclusion
KiambuisahighriskCountywithlikelyhotspotsbeingKiambaa,Lari,GatunduandJujaduetorisingintoleranceagainstanti-Uhurupoliticiansandtheirsupporters.TheMungikiissueisalsolikelytobeadestabilizingfactorifmembersofthesectaremobilizedfornefariouspurposes.TheCountythereforemeritscloserscrutiny.
TURKANA COUNTYTurkana County is situated in the former Rift Valley Province and shares borders with MarsabitCounty(inwhatwasEasternProvince)totheEast,SamburuCountytotheSouthEast,WestPokotandBaringoCountiestotheSouth,RepublicofUgandatotheWestandRepublicofEthiopiatotheNorth.Itoccupies68,680squarekilometers(thesecondlargestinthecountry)withapopulationofonly855,399peoplewhopredominantlybelongtotheTurkanacommunity.TherearesomePokotsandTugensintheSouthandSamburusandBoranastotheEast.
TheCountyhasbotha ruralandanurbanpopulationwithanumberof important townsnamelyLodwar,Kakuma,LokichoggioandLokitaung.Lodwaristhelargestwithapopulationof48,000people.CurrentlytheCountyhasthreeconstituencies:TurkanaNorth,TurkanaCentral,andTurkanaSouth.
Political dimensions
ItisrememberedastheplacewheretheformerfirstPresidentoftheRepublicofKenyawasdetainedwithfiveofhiscolleagueschristened‘KapenguriaSix’afterashamtrialin1952/3duringthecolonialperiod.ThetrialtookplaceinKapenguriaintheneighbouringWestPokotCounty.
ThepoliticsofthisareawaspersonalityandpoliticalpartydrivenintheMoiera.ThepeoplethusvotedforthePresidentandKANUanddidnotconsiderotherplayers inpolitics.Since2002ithashoweverbeenmoreunpredictableasshownbythepartiesofMPshavebeenelected.Today,TurkanahasanMPinODMandPNU.ThismeansthatthepeopleofTurkanahavebeenverypluralisticandthatthereisnosingledominantforceintheirpoliticssince2002.Itremainstobeseenwhetherthissituationwillchangein2012.
Security dimensions
ThegovernmentisnotabletoeffectivelysecuretheentireCounty.Asaconsequenceitisforcedtorecruithomeguardsinadditiontoregularpoliceandarmyofficers.ThesearenotenoughandthepeopleoftheCountywhoareablearmthemselvestodefendtheirlivestockfromlivestockhungryneighbours suchas theKaramojong, thePokot, theTurgen, theSamburuand theBorana.Wheredefencedoesnotarise,theTurkanamayretaliateagainstthesecommunitiesforpreviousraidsandtheftofcattlebycarryingoutsimilarattacksandtheft.Itisnotunusualthatbothhumanandlivestock
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 55
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
livesarelostintheskirmishes.
AsnotedinthecaseofWestPokotCounty,thereisaporousborderwithUganda.HeretheTurkanaareabletobuyarmsinexchangeforlivestock.Thesearmscanfindtheirwayintothehandsofmilitiasduringelectionyearsandcausedevastation.ThereisneedtocloselymonitorthesecuritysituationontheborderoftheCountywithUganda,Samburu,BaringoandMarsabit,whichintotalisanexpansivephysicalareathatmayrequirealotofresourcesthatonlythegovernmentcanmuster.
Economic dimensions
Perhapsthemostwidespreadeconomicpracticeislivestockfarming.MajorityoftheTurkanapeopleare pastoralists who rear livestock and have to find pastures through the practice of migration.Livestockisconsideredstock-in-tradeoftheTurkana,wealththatmaybeexpendedinthefutureifthedroughtdoesnotwipetheanimalsout.
TurkanahasafairshareoftourismbythosewhowishtoseethefamousLakeTurkana.This isanimportant feature as the unique lake is found in an area surrounded by dry and arid conditions.OthertouristsareattractedbytheTurkanaculturesuchasthe‘trendy’hairstylesdottedonmenandwomen’sheads;andthebeadsaroundwomen’snecks.
Thereisalsoafairlevelofbasketweaving.ThisisdoneusingreedsfromtheLakeTurkanawhicharefirstdriedbeforebeingwoven.Thebasketsarethensoldataprofittomiddlemenwhosellthemtoonwardmarkets.
ThereisalsoatremendousamountoffishtradeontheshoresofLakeTurkana.Inrecenttimes,dueinparttoachangeinclimaticconditions,therehavebeenreportsoftheLakeshrinkingandpartsofitbeingattackedbyhyacinth.Thishasnotsofarseriouslyaffectedfishingandfishtradebutitneedstobecloselymonitored.
ExperimentsarebeingcarriedouttodeterminewhetherawindpowerprojectcanbeestablishedintheCountytogeneratepowerthatcouldbeaddedtothenationalelectricitygrid.Ifitturnsoutpositive,thiscouldgenerateconsiderableincomefortheCounty.
Mostrecently,inApril2012,PresidentKibakiannouncedthediscoveryofoildepositsintheCounty(inNgamia1well)afterexplorationbyTullowOilcompanyforanumberofyears.Thisfindingcouldbringbothblessings(read,revenue)andcurses(read,conflicts)withinandoutsidetheCounty.
Legal dimensions
TheCounty is servedby theMagistrates’ Courts based in Lodwar. Appeals to theHigh Court arehandledbytheHighCourtinKitale.Duetoitssparsepopulation(whichisalmostalwaysonthemove)andexpansivegeographicareatheCountymaynotbewellservedbythejudiciary.Thereforeconflictsareusuallyresolvedthroughself-helpmeanswhichcancreateconflict.
Socio cultural dimensions
Thedominant community in theCounty is theTurkanaalthough there is anumberof Pokot andTurgenintheSouthernparts,SamburuandBoranatotheEast.Alltheaforementionedcommunitiesconsider livestockfarmingcentraltotheir livelihoodandeconomy.Asaresulttheyvaluelivestockto theextent thatafterprolongeddrought they raideachotherandsteal livestockandmeetanyresistancewith armed force. Cattle theft is also prevalent during initiation rites of passagewhenyoungmenmayraidothercommunitiesforlivestock.ThishasledtoacycleofcattlerustlingbetweenthecommunitiesinTurkanaandneighbouringCountieswhichhasinturnledtocommitteesofelders
56 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
beingsetuptoresolveconflicts.
ThefactthatTurkananeighboursUgandawhichhascommunitiessuchastheKaramojong,anarmedandfierceadversary,alsopastoralistinnaturemeanscattlerustlingispracticedacrosstheborder.Toraidordefendthemselvesagainstattacks,almostallthecommunitiesarearmed;mostlywithillegalarms.
Environmental dimensions
Theclimate inTurkana ishotanddrymostof theyear. In factrainfallherecanaverageas lowas150mm(orless)inthecentralaridparts.TheCountyispronetofamineandcattlerustlingduetoconstantmigrationbypastoralistsfromitsdifferentpartsandfromneighbouringCountiesinsearchofpasturesfortheirlivestock.Asindicatedelsewherethiscausesdegradationoftheenvironmentsleavingitworseoffthanbefore.Further,LakeTurkanaisdryingupandshrinkingduetoachangeinclimaticconditionsnot tomentioncreationofdamsupstreamby theEthiopiangovernment.Thiscouldadverselyaffectfishing.
Conclusion
ThereisneedtocloselymonitorthesecuritysituationonthebordersoftheCountywithUganda,EthiopiaandSouthSudan(ElemiTrianglewheretherehavebeentraditonaldisputesbetweentheMerrille,Toposa,KaramajongandTurkana).InregardstoneighbouringCountiesofSamburu,WestPokot,Marakwet,BaringoandMarsabit, it is importanttomonitorespeciallytheKainukarea.Thebordersbetweentheaforesaidcommunitiesarelongandmayrequirea lotofresourcesthatmaybeonlythegovernmentcanorshouldmuster.Inthisregardcivilsocietygroupsneedtoworkcloselywithgovernmentsecurityefforts.
The discovery of oil, and its further explorationwithin the County should be closelymonitored.Therefore,themanagementoftheexploration,throughlegislationandpolicy,shouldbedonewitheffectiveparticipationoftheresidentsoftheCounty.
WEST POKOT COUNTYWestPokotCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswiththeRepublicofUgandato theWest,TurkanaCounty to theNorth,TransNzoia to theSouth,ElgeyoMarakwetCountytotheSouthEastandBaringoCountytotheEast.Itoccupies9,169squarekilometerswithapopulationof512,690people.
ThePokotpeoplearethepredominantcommunityintheCountywithsomespilloverintothearidpartsoftheneighbouringBaringoCounty.Thesepeoplewereformerlyknownasthe‘Suk’,anounderivedfrom‘Msuk’whichinPokotmeansstump;thenounwasusedtohidetheirtrueidentityfromtheBritishduringthecolonialperiod.TheyclaimtohaveoccupiedthelandstretchingfromSoyinUasinGishuuptoWestPokotbeforetheyweredisplacedbytheBritishcolonialistswhopushedthemintotheKarengerandKanyarkwatranches.Consequently,thePokotharbourahistorical(andthuspolitical)grievanceoverland.
CurrentlytheCountyhasthreeconstituencies:Kapenguria,SigorandKacheliba.KapenguriaisbyfartheleadingurbancentreintheCountywithapopulationofaround35,000people.
Political dimensions
ThepoliticsoftheCountyhavebeendominatedbyKANU(intheMoiera)andbyindividualssincethen.Politiciansmainlytakeadvantageofthehighilliteracyandpovertyrates(70%arepoor)toserve
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 57
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
for longperiodsoverwhichtheysuppresstheambitionsofanypersonswhomayposeapoliticalthreat.Inthisregard,anyonewhoattainshigheracademicqualificationsisconsideredathreatandmustassureincumbentsofhis/hersupport.Themajorityfeelthatpoliticiansdonotrepresenttheirinterests.However,whenitcomestovotingthepeoplearesomewhathomogeneousandhaveinthepastvoted‘threepiece’apossiblepointertoa‘sixpiece’voteinthenextelections.75
Security dimensions
SincetheeraofthelateFrancisLotodo,aformerMemberofParliamentandMinisterunderformerPresident Moi’s government, the County is inundated with undertones of violence which aresometimesexacerbatedbythemedia,which intheiroveralleffectunfairlydepict thePokotasan“aggressivepeople”eveninsituationswheretheyarevictims,notaggressors.
Somegovernmentoperations in thearea, suchas the1984operationagainst the ‘ngoroko’werenothelpful.Localleadershavealwayssidedwiththe‘ngoroko’asituationwhichmakespeaceintheCountyelusive.Poorinfrastructurefrustratessecuritypersonnelinaccomplishingtheirtasks.ThisissoeventhoughtheCountyhasafairlyhighpercentageofgood/fairroadsstandingat58%againstthenationalaverageof43%.
AsWestPokotsharesacommonborderwiththeRepublicofUganda,whichhasahistoryofpoliticalandmilitaryturbulence,Pokotsareabletobuyarmsfromtherecheaply.Infact,someofthepurchasesofarmsareconcludedwiththemereexchangeoflivestock;someofwhichhavebeenstolenfromcommunitiesneighbouringthePokot.
ItistobenotedthatthoughontheKenyanside,thePokotshaveoftenbeenlabelledasaggressors,infact,itistheirneighboursontheUgandanside,theKaramojawhohavetakenadvantageoftheporousbordertosteal,rob,maimandkillonbothsidesoftheborder.
WithinKenyatheborderbetweenElgeyoMarakwetCountyandtheEasternpartsofPokotCounty,especiallyatChesegon,sufferhighlevelsofinsecurityandcattlerustling.
Economic dimensions
WestPokotCountyhasvasteconomicresources.ThecontroversialTurkwellpowerdamis locatedinthisCountyalthoughonly2.6%ofthelocalpopulationhasaccesstoelectricity.Thereisdiverselimestone(OstumandAlale)miningintheCountythatservestoprovidejobstoafewlocalpeople.
The area around Lelan practices very productive agriculture. In the dry regions the Kerio ValleyDevelopmentAuthority(KVDA)assiststhelocalpopulationwithirrigationalagriculture.OtherpartsoftheCountypracticepastoralism,thatistosay,rearinglivestockbymovingfromplacetoplaceinsearchofpasture.ThereareindicationsthattheareaaroundOrwoMarichandAlalemayhaveoildepositssufficientforcommercialpurposes.This, if itturnsouttobetrue,wouldbeaneconomicgamechanger.
Legal dimensions
Itseemsthatconflictistheonlywaytoaddresstheseissues.Albeit,thereareMagistrateslawcourtsinKapenguriatown.MattersthataresuitableforhearingbytheHighCourtinthefirstinstanceoronappealareheardattheKitaleHighCourt.ItwouldbedifficulttoconvinceanyoneintheCountythatthejudicialservicesareadequate.75 Unlike 2007 elections where candidates were voting for three seats (president, MP and councilor), the upcoming elections will have six seats to be filled. These are: the president/deputy president; the governor/deputy governor of the county; the senator; the member of the national assembly; the member of the county assembly; and finally, the woman representative to be directly elected from the county to be a member of the national assembly.
58 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Socio cultural dimensions
Asstartedinthepoliticalandeconomicdimensions,thePokotarethepredominantcommunityintheCounty.MembersofothercommunitiesaremainlyrepresentedintheurbanKapengurialocation.InfactitisthePokotthathavespilledoverintoBaringoCountyandsettledthere.RaidingtheMarakwetcommunityintheneighbouringElgeyoMarakwetCountyisa‘normal’activitywhichoccursfromtimetotime.
The County also hosts internally displaced persons from the neighbouring TransNzoia County atChepchoina.ThereareproblemswithsquatterstakingoverprivatelyownedlandsuchastheMwishofarm.Landiscommunallyownedleadingtowranglesoverapportionmentandinheritance.TherearealsoclaimsoflandgrabbingintheareassurroundingTurkwell.
Withregardtoeasingofethnictensions intheCounty,CSOshavebeenworkingonvariouspeacepromotingactivitiessuchassports,dialogue,connectorprojectsandprovisionofeducation.FemaleGenitalMutilation(FGM)isanongoingconcernwithhumanrightsactivistsfightingforitsabolitionwhiletraditionalistsholdingthatitisgoodforthechastityoftheyounggirlsandwomeningeneral.
Environmental dimensions
Therearesomeenvironmentalconcernssuchasthefactthatwaterprovisionreacheslessthan40%ofthepopulation.Thiscoupledwithpastoralismpracticeswhichbytheirnaturecauselanddegradationmeansconflictmayrecurandthereforeneedstobemonitoredclosely.
Conclusion
ThePokotfeeltheyaremarginalizedandthatthetendencybysomeactorstolumpthemtogetherwiththegreaterKalenjinnationhasnobenefittothematall.Theyfeelthatthehistoricallandinjusticestheyhavesufferedhaveneverbeenaddressedand if thisstateofaffairs isnotrectifiedtheymayconsiderusingforcetoreclaimtheirland.TheareashouldbemonitoredespeciallytoforestalltheriskofsmallarmscomingintotherestofthecountryfromUganda.TheborderareaaroundChesegoninparticularshouldconcernthesecurityapparatusoftheneighbouringCounties,whichshouldprovidemoresecuritypersonnelandimprovetheroadnetwork.
SAMBURU COUNTY SamburuCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswithTurkanaCountytotheWest,LaikipiaandIsioloCountiestotheSouthandEast;andMarsabitCountytotheNorth.ItsharesaverysmallborderwithBaringoCountytowardsitsSouthWesterntip.Inwhole,theCountyoccupies21,022squarekilometerswithapopulationof223,947people.TheurbanpopulationoftheCountyisfoundinitsmaintownswhichareMaralal,Baragoi,Archer’sPostandWamba.CurrentlytheCountyhastwoconstituencies:SamburuEastandSamburuWest.
Political dimensions
SamburuCountyissparselypopulatedwithjustover223,000people80%beingtheSamburuwhichisthereforethemainethnicgroup;and20%unevenlysharedbyTurkana,Kikuyu,Meru,Somaliamongothers.
TheSamburucommunityisthedominantgroupinpolitics.Thecommunitieslargelyrelatepeacefullyalthough conflicts are rife between the Samburu and the Pokot from the neighbouring Counties.Someoftheseconflictshaveresultedinlossoflivesonmanyoccasions.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 59
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
IntheCounty,Samburu,whoconstitute80%ofthevotingpopulation,voteasablock,thustheirholdontheelectiveseatsisunchallengeable.ThisisclearlyshownbythefactthatbothMPsintheregionsinceindependencehavecomefromtheSamburucommunity.Thus,electionrelatedviolencehasnotbeenexperiencedintheregion.
The County was previously divided into two constituencies, Samburu West and Samburu East.SamburuEastwasestablishedin1966asthebiggerconstituencybutwasdividedin1969toproduceSamburuWest.TheyhavebeenfurtherdividedtocreateSamburuNorthConstituencyrecentlyafterthepromulgationoftheConstitutioninAugust2010.PoliticsineachofthecurrentConstituencies,WestandEast,hasbeenlargelyapartyaffairsinceindependence.ThisisshownbythefactthatallMPsfromtheregionsinceindependencehavehailedfromKANUuntilthe2007electionswhentheODMpartytookbothseats.
Security dimensions
Muchof the insecurity isduetocattle-rustlingbetweentheSamburu,Pokot,TurkanaandBoranacommunities.DuetoitsproximitytotheNorthEasternregion,thereisahighproliferationofgunsandsmallarmswhichmakestheareaveryvolatile.Cattleraidsleavescoresofpeopledeadandthisisthemostrampantformofcrimeinthearea.
Inadditiontoafewsecurityofficerspostedorratherstationedintheregion,thegovernmenthasput in place Kenya Police Reservists. These augment the ‘normal’ police services and somewhatamelioratesthelackofpolicepatrolsintheregionwhichiswithoutdoubtvast.
Foraverylongtime,theKenyangovernmenthasbeeninvolvedinnumerousefforts,todisarmthecommunitiesinthisCountyandtheirneighbours.However,tilltodaytheseeffortsremainfruitless.Thishasledtoastockpilingofarmsbythecommunitiestoprotectthemselvesfrominsecurity,sincethegovernment’seffortsarenotadequate.
Economic dimensions
SamburuCountyissemiaridinnatureanditsmaineconomicactivitiesarelivestockkeeping/pastoralfarmingandagriculturalfarming.Oftheseactivities,themostlikelytogenerateconflictisthelivestockkeeping/pastoralismespeciallyduringthedryseasonwhenmembersofthevariouscommunitiesgoinsearchofpasturesfortheirlivestock.
AremarkablefeatureoftheCounty is thehighpercentageofgood/fairroadswhichstandat61%againstanationalaverageof43.5%.ThismeansthatSamburuissettobecomeanimportanttransitCountytoKenya’sneighbourEthiopia.
Legal dimensions
SamburuCountyisservedby,theChiefMagistrate’sCourtlocatedinMaralaltown.AllappealsfromtheCourtliewiththeHighCourtStationatNakurutownastheheadquartersoftheformerRiftValleyProvinceofwhichSamburuispart.
Socio cultural dimensions
TheSamburuethnicgrouphashadculturalconflictswiththeSomali tribeandsomeof theothertribes.TheclasheswiththeSomalisextendtodifferencesoverreligionwiththeSambururegardingIslam,thereligionoftheSomalis,withsuspicion.ThemajorcauseofconflictinthisCountyiscattle
60 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
rustling.Theraidsmostly involvetheSamburuandPokotfromtheneighbouringCountiesandarecharacterizedbygunfightsandgrislykillings.
TheissuesoframpantFGMandwomen’slowparticipationinpoliticsareabigchallenge.
Environmental dimensions
Samburu County is blessed with a rich variety of wildlife which is exemplified by the severalconservanciesandgamereservesthatserveastouristattractions.ThesearetheSamburuNationalGame Reserve, the Ewaso Ng’iro, Buffalo Springs National Reserve and Shaba National Reserve.HumanWildlifeconflictisnegligibleinthisregionandislimitedtoillegalpoachingofgamemeatandthekillingofcarnivorestoprotectlivestock.
TheEwasoNg’iroistheprimarysourceofpermanentlyflowingwaterintheCounty.ThisisexemplifiedbyimprovedwateraccessintheCountywhichhasrisenupto68%ofthepopulation.Asaresultofthis,theCounty’senvironmentislargelyconservedinitsnaturalstate.
However,duringdroughtyearstherehasbeenand likelytobe in future,competitionandconflictovernaturalresources,especiallywaterbetweenthecommunities.DuringsuchseasonstheSamburupeoplemusteitherdigwells inthesandriversandusesmalldamsandspringstoaccesswaterorrathermigrate.Otherconflictsarecausedbycompetitionbetweenhumansandwildanimals,suchaswhenherdsmenandelephantsattempttoaccesswatersimultaneously.Elephantsmayinthiscasechaseandevenkillthecattle.
Conclusion
SamburuCountyisasparselypopulatedCountywithpoorsecurityarrangements.Thereissporadicfighting between the Samburu, Borana, Turkana, Somali andMaasai communitieswho use armsseepinginfromKenya’sporousborderwithUganda(viaTurkanaandWestPokotCounties).Mostofthefightingdoesnothoweverinfluenceelectoralpolitics.Thereforeinsteadofelectoralmonitoring,concernedgroupsshouldurgethegovernmenttoprovidesecurityfortheresidentsinordertoreducesecurityself-helpmeasuresundertakenbythecommunitiesandseepageofsmallarms intootherpartsofthecountry.Inaddition,theequitablesharingofeconomicbenefitsfromnaturalresourcesdottedallovertheCountymayensurepeace.
TRANS NZOIA COUNTYTransNzoiaCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswithUgandatotheWest,ElgeyoMarakwetandUasinGishuCountiestotheEast,WestPokotCountytotheNorthandBungomaCountytotheSouth.
It occupies 2,496 square kilometers with a relatively high population of 818,757 people whopredominantlybelongtotheLuhyaandKalenjincommunities.ThatisnottosaythatothercommunitiessuchastheKikuyu,Kisii,Luo,TesoandmanyothersdonotresideintheCounty.Indeed,TransNzoiaisjustaboutthemostcosmopolitan‘rural’CountyinKenyatoday.
TheCountyhasbotha ruralandanurbanpopulationwithanumberof important townsnamelyKitaleandKiminini.Kitaleisthe20thbiggesttowninKenyawithapopulationover105,000people.
Currentlyithasthreeconstituencies:Saboti,Kwanza,andCheranganyi.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 61
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Political dimensions
Thepoliticsof theCountyhavebeendominatedeitherby the LuhyaorKalenjin communitywiththe formeroftenedging the latter.TheCountyhasa largenumberof theLuhyacommunity fromKakamega, Bungoma and even Busia; it also has a large Kalenjin community drawn from Pokot,UasinGishuandElgeyoMarakwet.ThereareothercommunitiessuchastheKikuyuandKisiiintheCountyaslandownersorbusinesspeople.IntheKANUera,MasindeMuliroandhisprotégéMichaelWamalwa(wholaterservedasPresidentMwaiKibaki’svicepresident)calledtheshotsfrompoliticalpartiesopposedtotheincumbentgovernment.
Security dimensions
TransNzoiabordersUgandaandWestPokotandElgeyo/Marakwettosomeextent.Allitsneighbourshavecommunitieswhichownanduse small arms toengage in cattle rustlingand self-defence. Itis likelythatthesearmsfindtheirwayintootherpartsofthecountrywheretheycanbeusedforpoliticalpurposessuchasarmingmilitiathatsupportcertainpoliticalinterestsorintothehandsofcriminals.Eitheroutcomeisundesirableandasecurityrisk;assuchtheCountyshouldbemonitoredthroughout.Moreover,inthisCountysittingandretiredcouncillorsandCDFofficialshavebeenkilledforpoliticalreasons.
Economic dimensions
ThetwopredominanteconomicactivitiesintheCountyarelargescalefarminganddairyfarming.TherearemanyfarmersintheCountywhoeithergrowseedmaizefromwhichmaizeseedcompaniesgettheseedtoselltofarmersintheCountyandtherestofthecountry;orwhogrowmaizecommerciallytosellittotheKenyaCerealsandProduceBoard(KCPB)foraprofit.
Thereisalsoextensivefarminginpotatoes,carrots,vegetablesandfruitsforcommercialpurposes.TheCountyisservedbytheKitaleairstripwhichisabletoaccommodatesmalltomediumaircraft.ThisisinadditiontotheEldoretInternationalAirportwhichisonlyanhourawayfromKitale.
Legal dimensions
The County is served by aHigh Court based in Kitalewhich also servesWest Pokot and TurkanaCounties. There are alsoMagistrates Courts in Kitale with jurisdiction to handle claims that arehandledbytheHighCourt.Itisnotclearwhetherthecourtsprovideasatisfactoryconflictresolutionmechanismhere.Therearehoweverhistoricalgrievancesoverlandownership.
Socio cultural dimensions
TherearemanycommunitiesinTransNzoiaasindicatedintheintroduction.TheLuhyaandKalenjinarethemajorityinthatorder.ThereareothercommunitiessuchasKikuyu,theKisii,theLuo,andtheTeso.Theinterestingthingisthatevenamongthesecommunitiesthereareintra-ethnicrivalriessuchasthosebetweentheBukusuandtheTachoni;theSabaotandthePokots;andthePokotsandtheMarakwets.
Environmental dimensions
TransNzoiaCountyliesatthefootofMt.ElgonontheborderwithUganda.Asaresultithasagoodclimatewithrainfallingwholeyearround.Thismakesitconducivetogrowmaizebothforseedandconsumptionpurposes;andtocarryondairyfarming.
TheCountyhasanationalgamereserveandhashistoriccaveswithinthefootoftheMountElgon
62 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
whichattracttourists.Apartfromthis,thereareindividualconservanciesintheareawhoalsoattracttourismandrevenue.
TheCountyhasnotsufferedadverseclimaticconditionsastheRiverNzoiawhichflowsthroughitfromCheranganyihillsisalmostalwaysfull.ThereareplanstobuildadamonthisriverinBungomaCounty(aprojectwhichrequirespeopletobemoved)withoutadverseeffectstoTransNzoia.
Conclusion
Duetothefactthatithasoneofthehighestmulti-communitypopulationinthecountryitshouldbemonitoredclosely.Nationalpoliticsinfluenceshowcommunitiestreatorreactagainstthosefromdifferentcommunities.LanddistributionbetweentheBukusuandtheSabaots,betweentheKalenjinsandtheLuhyas,andbetweentheKalenjinsandtheKikuyuamongothersprovideapowderkegatanyelectiontime.Therearenumerouscasesoflandsquatters;ontheflipsidetherearecasesoflocalpeople‘takingover’farmstheyarguewereillegally(throughpoliticalconnections)acquired.Thesedynamicsneedtobemonitored.
ItshouldnotbeforgottenthatTransNzoiasharesaborderwithUgandaandWestPokot,twoareaswhereitiseasytoacquiresmallarms.Thesecurityapparatusshouldbeonthelookouttoensureinthemonthsleadinguptotheelectionsthesedonotfindtheirwayintothehandsofmilitiaformedbypoliticianstopushtheiragenda.
UASIN GISHU COUNTY
UasinGishuCounty is situated in the formerRiftValleyProvince. It bordersNandi County to theSouth,TransNzoiaCountytotheNorth,andElgeyoMarakwetCountytotheEast. ItsharessomerathershortborderswithBungomaCountytotheWestandKerichoCountytoitsSouthEasterntip.Itoccupies3,345squarekilometerswithapopulationof894,179people.Eldoretisitscapitalcityaswellasmaincommercialcentre.Thenoun“Eldoret”isderivedfromtheMaasaiadjective“eldore”whichmeansastonyriverand isusedtorefer tothebedof theCounty’smainriver, theSosiani,whosebedisinfactstony.
The County population comprises mainly of members of the Kalenjin (Nandi, Kipsigis, Keiyos,Marakwets) community. This is complemented by other communities such as the Luhya, Kikuyu,KisiiandLuoamongothers.ThelattercommunitiesresidemainlyontheoutskirtsofEldorettown.UasinGishuhasbotharuralandanurbanpopulationwithanumberof importanttownsnamelyEldoret,Moi’sBridge,Matunda,BurntForest, JuaKali,andTurbo.Currently theCountyhas threeconstituencies:EldoretNorth,EldoretSouthandEldoretEast.
Political dimensions
The County politics are shaped mainly by the predominant Kalenjin community. Historically theCountywasalignedwiththeformerrulingpartyKANUandforsometimethemainpoliticiantherewasthe lateReubenChesire,arelativeofretiredPresidentMoi.Sincethe latter’sretirement, thehomogeneityof theKalenjinhasbeenmaintainedbehind thoseconsidered tobe thecommunityleaders.AsaconsequencethevotingpatternintheCounty’sthreeconstituencieshasbeenthesamein the 1997, 2002, and 2007 general elections. For instance in 1997 elections, all the candidateselectedasMPsbelongedtoKANU.Thesamewasreplicatedin2002.In2007,theMPswereallfromtheODMpoliticalparty.
Currently,oneoftheindividualsconsideredaKalenjincommunityleaderistheMPforEldoretNorth,Mr.WilliamRuto.IntheviewofmanyKalenjinsheisinfactbothacommunalandanationalleader.HehasbeenthemostinfluentialpoliticalactorsinceformerPresidentMoi’sretirement.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 63
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
DuetothedivisiveelectionsandevenmoreambiguousresultsthatwereannouncedbytheECK,post-electionviolencebrokeoutinmanypartsoftheCounty.ThemaincauseofthiswastheallegationthattheelectionhadbeenriggedbytheECKinfavourofthePNUanditscandidatePresidentMwaiKibaki.Therigging,intheviewoftheKalenjinpeoplehadrobbedMr.RutoandhispoliticalpartyleaderandpresidentialcandidateRailaOdingaofwhatseemedanassuredvictory.
Thetruthofthematterhowevergoesdeeperthanthat.TheCountyhasahistorical landproblemcaused by the fact that the Kalenjins, feel the County “belongs” to themand have been given arawdealinlandallocation.Theirmaingrievanceisthatunderthefirstpresident,LateMzeeJomoKenyatta’sgovernment,theregimesetapartandallocatedillegallyprimelandto“outsiders”,mostlyfromtheKikuyucommunity,withoutanycompensation.Thisgrievanceprovidesthefaultlineforallthepoliticalconflictsincludingthepost-electionviolenceinwhichtheKikuyuwereattacked,maimed,displacedorkilledforvotingagainstthewishesoftheir“hosts”.
Security dimensions
UasinGishuisarelativelystableregionintermsofsecurity.Thisiswiththeexceptionofpost-electionperiodwhere security situation isusually sensitive.Themostaffectedareaswere thoseoccupiedbythenon-Kalenjincommunities,especially theKikuyu,suchasTurbo,KiambaaandareasontheoutskirtsofEldorettown.
ProgressoftheKenyancasesattheICC,inparticularthatofWilliamRuto,willneedtobemonitoredcloselyasitmayaffectintercommunalrelationsontheground.
Economic dimensions
UasinGishuisbasicallyanagriculturalCounty.Themostimportantfarmingactivitiesarecommercialcultivationofmaizeandwheatonlargescale.Maize,beans,potatoesandpeasarealsocultivatedbothforsubsistenceandcommercialpurposes.
Livestockfarmingisalsopracticed.Farmersengageindairyfarmingonalargescale(usingmodernmethodssuchas zero-grazingandcrossbreedingofherds);producing largequantitiesofmilk fordeliverytodairyproductprocessorssuchastheKenyaCooperativeCreameries(KCC)andBrooksideDairyCompanyformoney.
Like neighbouring Elgeyo Marakwet, the County has prospered economically from professionalathletics.Itproducesathletesofthehighestcalibrewhonotonlycompetebutexcelatinternationalathletics circuits thereby winning huge sums of money (for appearance and victory) which theyreinvestintheCounty.Thissuccessofpedigreeathleteshasdrawnmanyyoungpeopletothesport.
AsadirectconsequenceoflargescalefarmingandsuccessfulathleticsEldorettownboostsalargepool of commercial banks. In fact, it is one of the few towns togetherwithNairobi, Kisumu andMombasathathostCentralBankofKenya.
TheCounty is alsooneof the fewwith an international airport: theEldoret InternationalAirportwhichprovidestheregionwithlinkagestobothlocalandinternationaldestinations.Thishasactedas a boost to the economy by promoting transportation of agricultural produce and tourists. Airtransportation isaugmentedbyahighwaythat linkstheCountywithKampala (inUganda)ontheWestandNakurutotheEast.Localroads link itwithTransNzoia,anotheragriculturallyricharea,whichtogetherwithUasinGishuandNakuruCountiesareconsideredthebreadbasketofKenya.
64 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Legal dimensions
ThemaincourtsintheCountyaretheHighCourtandtheMagistratesCourtsbasedinEldoret.Giventhecosmopolitannatureof the townthecourtsarekeptbusywith resolutionofcommercialandothercasesbroughtbeforethem.Inadditiontotheabovetwocourts,theCourtofAppealisgoingtobesetupinEldoret.ThisisaccordingtoChiefJusticeWillyMutunga’sjudiciaryreformsstatusreportreleasedinOctober2011.
ThemainconcernforthisCountyisinfact,notwhetherthejudiciaryissufficientlyequippedtodealwiththeinter-ethnicflareupsthatoccurduringandafterelectionperiods;butwhethermembersofthelocalcommunitywillregardthemasanimpartialarbiterincasesthatmayarise.
Socio cultural dimensions
Asobservedinearlierdimensions,theCounty’spopulationispredominantlyKalenjin,afactwhichhasinevitablyresultedinthecommunity’scultureheavilyinfluencingtheothercommunities.Somuchsothatmanyculturalpractices,suchasritesofpassage(initiation)intoadulthood,areinfluencedbyandbasedonKalenjintraditionalpractices.
Theinter-communityrelationsarepeacefulaslongasthereisnothingatstake.TheKalenjins,Luhyas,Kikuyusandotherslivehappilycarryingonwiththeirprivatelivesandbusinesses.ButatthebackofthemindsofmembersoftheKalenjincommunityisthenotionthatsome“foreigners”(Kikuyu)tooktheir landwithoutcompensation. Duringelectiontimethe landgrievancesarecamouflagedasapoliticalcausetobepursueduntilthe“foreigners”arepurgedfrom“their”(Kalenjin)land.
Environmental dimensions
Anestimated90percentoftheentirelandareaintheCountyisarableandcanbeclassifiedashighpotential.Therearefourmajorsoiltypesinthearea,allofwhicharesuitedforagriculturalproduction.Theseincluderedloam,redclay,brownclayandbrownloam.Atotalof29,801.92hectarestheCountyisgazettedforest.Outofthis,13,183.54hectares(44percent)isunderplantation,while,16,618.38hectares(56percent)isunderindigenousforestcover.TheforestcovercontributestosustenanceofclimaticconditionsthatprovidesufficientrainfallleavingtheCountygreenallyearround.Therefore,theCountycanberegardedasenvironmentfriendly.
89%oftheCountypopulationhasaccesstocleanwater,makingitthethirdinthecountryinthatregard.Ithasanevenbettersanitationrecordwith98%ofthepopulationhavingaccess(albeititis12thinthecountry).
Conclusion
UasinGishuisoneofthepromisingCountiesintermsofeconomicinvestmentsinthelargerNorthRiftregion.Itisconsideredasthecapital‘city’fortheNorthRiftregionpopulace.ThisisbecauseofavailabilityofproperinfrastructuresuchastheMoiTeachingandReferralHospitalwhichisoneofthefewhospitalsinKenyathatboastlatestmedicaltechnologies.Forexample,ithasanAMPATHCentreforpeoplesufferingfromHumanImmuno-deficiencyVirus(HIV).
The County’s Achilles Heel is its vulnerability to conflicts arising from historical land grievancesharbouredbytheKalenjinvis-à-vistheKikuyucommunity.Thisconflictmaycometoboilingpoint,asithasdoneinpastelectionperiods,thereforemonitoringisrequired.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 65
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
ELGEYO / MARAKWET COUNTYElgeyo/MarakwetissituatedintheformerRiftValleyprovince.ItbordersBaringoCountytotheEast,WestPokotCountytotheNorth,UasinGishuCountytotheWestandTransNzoiaCountytotheNorthWest.Itoccupies3,030squarekilometersandhasapopulationof369,998peoplewhopredominantlybelongtotheKeiyoandMarakwetsubtribesoftheKalenjincommunity.TherearealsoafewTurgensfromtheneighbouringBaringoCounty.
TheCountyhasamostlyruralpopulationwiththeTambachandItenbeingthemainurbancentresoftheKeiyopeoplewithapopulationofover42,000people.KapsowaristhemainurbancentrefortheMarakwetpeoplewitharelativelypopulationof5,000people.Kapcherop isoneof theotherrelativelyimportantcentresfortheMarakwets.
CurrentlytheCountyhasfourconstituencies:KeiyoSouth,MarakwetWest,MarakwetEastandKeiyoNorth.
Political dimensions
ForalongtimethepoliticsinthisareawasdominatedbyNicholasKipyatorBiwott.Althoughhelosthisseatinthe2007generalelectionstoanewcomer,JacksonKiptanui,Biwottremainsinfluentialduetohispoliticalorganization-heistheleaderofapoliticalpartynamedtheVisionPartyofKenya(VPK).
ThereiscontinuingpoliticalfrictionbetweentheMarakwetsandKeiyos.ThisiscausedbythefactthattheformerareaminoritygroupandhavefeltunfairlydominatedpoliticallythroughwhicheconomicresourceshavepreviouslybeendisposedbytheKeiyos.
Security dimensions
The border between Elgeyo/Marakwet and West Pokot is a source of insecurity in the Elgeyo/MarakwetCounty.ThePokothabitually raid theMarakwet (mostly theArror community) to stealcattle,rapewomenandevenkillinnocentvillagers.Theyareabletodothisbecausetheyarefairlywellarmedas theyable to sourcesmallarms fromneighbouringUganda.TheMarakwets in turnhavetoarmthemselvesfordefensiveandsometimesretaliatorypurposes;therebycreatingacycleofinsecurity.Thissituationisnotlikelytodissipatesoon.ThereforetheflowofarmsfromUgandatoWestPokotandMarakwetshouldbemonitored.
TheKamatonyforestisahabitatforthieveswhowaylaycattletraders.ThisusuallyhappenswhentheMarakwetbringtheirlivestockforauctionorsaleonthemarkets.
Economic dimensions
ThereareanumberofeconomicactivitiesincludingmaizeandpassionfarminginKeiyo.Inaddition,thereisdairyfarmingwithsomefarmersusingmoderndaymethodssuchaszero-grazing.InMarakwettheyproducepotatoes,vegetablesandmangoes.
Howeverthere isalsothetraditional livestockrearingwhichrequiresherders to look forpasturesespeciallyintheMarakwetside.ThisleadsthemtoneighbouringcommunitiessuchasWestPokotandBaringoandmaysometimescauseskirmishesbetweenherdersfromthedifferentcommunities.
Thereused tobepyrethrum farming in theCountybut thishas since faltereddue to thegeneralmismanagementofthecashcropinKenyaandthelossesincurredbyfarmers.Insteadmanyfarmerstodaygrowpotatoesmostlyforcommercialpurposes.Attemptsbyfarmerstogrowcottonhavenotbeensuccessfulforlackofmarket.
66 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
TheCountyhasafewtouristattractionpointssuchastheItenandKamarinyviewpointsoftheGreatRiftValley.Thereisalsofluorsparmining;anactivitywhichhasprovidedemploymentforyouthfromthearea.TheminingcompanieshaveincorporatedCorporateSocialResponsibility(CSR)andhencehavebuilteducationalinfrastructuresuchasschoolsandprovidingdesksandbookstostudents.
ElgeyoMarakwet is thehomeofKenya’sworld famousathleticheroesandheroines includingthecurrent Laurus Sports Personality of the Year 2011, Vivian Cheruiyot. These athletes generate alotofmoneybywinning racesallover theworld.Someof thisfinds itsway into theeconomyofElgeyo/Marakwet County; the only question beingwhether the County has sufficient investmentopportunities.
Althoughthereisahighlevelofcashinflowsfromathletics,only7%ofthepeopleinthisCountyareontheelectricitynationalgrid.Thereishoweveraverygoodroadnetworksurpassingthenationalaverageof43.5%(fairroads)by17%%.MuchofthisdevelopednetworkisattributedtotheinfluenceofBiwott,towhomreferencehasbeenmadeunderthepoliticaldimension.
Legal dimensions
ThisCountyisservedbytheMagistratescourtsatIten.ThelocationisnotidealforallmembersoftheCountyandthereisneedforredistribution.Theimportantpointtonotehereisthatsomeofthedisputescanberesolvedthroughcourtbutfulladvantageofthisisnotdemonstrated.
Socio cultural dimensions
TheCountyhastwomaincommunitiesnamelytheKeiyoandtheMarakwet;andamodestnumberofTurgen.AllthesecommunitiesbelongtotheKalenjintribeandtheyareviewedbyotherKenyansashavinggaineddisproportionatelyfromformerPresidentMoi’sregime.ButbetweentheKeiyoandMarakwet,therehasbeenanon-goingfrictioninwhichtheMarakwetfeeltheyhavebeenunfairlypoliticallyandeconomicallydominatedbytheKeiyo.Itisthisfrictionthatledtothedrawingofthecurrentconstituencyboundarieswiththeobjectiveofprotectingthecommunityofinterestofeach.SuchcompromisesmayberequiredinthefutureregardingsharingofresourceswithintheCounty,otherwisetherewillbeconflictbasedonthehistoricalfaultlineofdomination.
TheTurgens intheCountyarenot influentialastheyareamerespillover fromtheneighbouringBaringoCounty.Inaddition,thereisnotmuchculturaldifferencebetweenitandtheothertwosubtribes.
Environmental dimensions
Atageneral level, theCountyhasa fairlygoodsupplyofwater tohouseholdswithasupply.TheCountycanroughlybedividedintotwozonesnamelythehighlandsandthelowlands.Thehighlandsreceivehighamountsofrainfallandmoisture.Thesoilsarefertileanditisherethatpotatofarmingtakesplace.
Thelowlandsaredrierandasaconsequencereceive lowamountsofrainfall. It isherethattheretraditionalcattlerearingandpastureisanimportantconsideration.Conflictsregardingpasturewithneighboursoccurinthispart.
Conclusion
Inpoliticalandelectoralterms,thisconstituencymaynotneedmuchmonitoringsaveforthesecuritydimensionregardingtheflowofarmsfromWestPokotanditsneighbouringCounties(WestPokot).Thesocio-culturaltensionsdonotseemtobeunmanageablebutsharingofCountyresources,which
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 67
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
mayinfuturereflectthehighamountsofKshs778Mof2009,mayreignitethedifferencesbetweenthetwomaincommunities.ThesharingofCountyresourcesshouldbesensitivetotherivalrybetweenthem.
NANDI COUNTY
NandiCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswithKakamegaandVihigaCounties to theWest, KisumuCounty to the South, KerichoCounty to the South East andUasinGishuCountytoNorthandNortheast.Itoccupies2,884squarekilometerswithapopulationof752,965whopredominantlybelongtotheNandisubtribe(the2ndlargest)oftheKalenjincommunity.TherearecommunitiesfromtheneighbouringLuhya,KipsigisandLuobutinrelativelysmallnumbers.TheCountyhasbotharuralandanurbanpopulationwithtwoimportanttownsnamelyKapsabetandNandiHills.Kapsabetisthelargerofthetwowithapopulationofover86,000people.CurrentlytheCountyhasfourconstituencies:Emgwen,Tinderet,MosopandAldai.
Political dimensions
TheNandi hold their legendary late leader, KoitalelArap Samoei in high esteem. The communityconstructed(belatedly)amausoleuminhonourofhimforhisheroicsduringtheresistanceoftheBritishcolonialrulewhenheledobjectionstotheconstructionofarailwaylinefromMombasatoKampalapassingthroughKalenjinland.
DuringtheeraoftheformerPresidentMoi,theNandipeoplewereloyaltohimandtherulingKANUparty.Since2002howeverthepicturehasbeenverydifferentbecausetheNandihaverefusedtofollowMoi’sadvice.In2007,theyvotedforODMandlongservingMoigovernmentloyalistsjoinedthepartyinvariouscapacities.
TheothercommunitiesfromneighbouringcommunitiessuchastheLuhya,KipsigisandLuodonothaveanymajorinfluenceonthepoliticsofNandiCounty.
ItiscriticalforCSOstomonitortheprogressoftheICCcaseasitmayaffectintercommunalrelationsontheground.
Security dimensions
During the electoral violence of 1992, 1997 and also during the PEV, this County has witnessedmassivedisplacementandforcibletransferofpopulation,especiallyoftheKikuyuethnicgroup.
Economic dimensions
ThemaineconomicactivitiesintheCountyareagriculture(cashcropfarming)anddairyfarming.Themajorcashcropgrownhereistea.DairyfarmingiscarriedoutthroughmodernmethodssuchaszerograzingandtheCountyhassomeofthehighestmilkyieldsintheCountry.BothteaandmilkbringthefarmersforeigncashearningstherebyimprovingthewealthlevelswithCountyranked20inthecountry.Therearemanysmallbusinessesrunbycommerciallyactivepeople.
TheCountyisservedbyagoodroadnetworkwith51%oftheroadsfoundtobegood/fairandtheEldoretInternationalAirport,whichisaugmentedbytheKakamegaairstrip.Bothmakeairtransportpossibleandimprovetimelinesforconductingbusinessthatrequirestravel.
NandiCountyisalsotheproudhomeCountyofworldfamousathletessuchastheiconicKipchogeKeino,HenryRono,MosesTanui,andBernardLagat(nowanAmericancitizen).TheathletesfromtheCountyhaveformedNandiRunners,whichistourismpromotionventure.Inadditiontotheirown
68 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
earningsfromtheworldathleticscircuit,theyarecontributingtohigherrevenuelevelbyencouragingtourism.
Legal dimensions
TheCounty is servedby theMagistrates’Courts located inKapsabetTownand theHighCourt innearbyEldorettown(withinUasinGishuCounty).
Socio cultural dimensions
AsindicatedelsewheretheNandiarethesecondlargestsubtribeoftheKalenjincommunityaftertheKipsigis.ThoughtheneighbouringcommunitiessuchastheLuhya,KipsigisandLuohavesmallpopulationsintheCounty,therearenomajorconflictsbetweenthem.Therelativepeacemayarisefromthefactthatduetotheirsmallnumberstheymaynotbeableto influencethepoliticalandeconomicprocessesintheCounty.
Environmental dimensions
NandiCountyis locatedinthehighlandareasoftheRiftValley.Ithasagoodclimateandreceivesmoderatetohighrainfallthroughouttheyearandisthereforealmostalwaysgreen.Thereforeisanabundanceoffoodandwaterwhichinturnmeansthereisalsolackofincentiveforconflict.
Conclusions
ItisnotexpectedthattherewillbemuchpoliticaltroubleinNandi.Nevertheless,thereisneedtoobservetheborderareaswithKakamegaandKisumuwheretherecouldbeflareups.
BARINGO COUNTY
BaringoCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswithquiteanumberof neighbours namely,West Pokot, ElgeyoMarakwet,Nakuru, Laikipia andUasinGishu Counties.Itoccupies11,015squarekilometersandhasapopulationof555,561peoplewhopredominantlybelongtotheKalenjincommunity.
TheCountyhasbotha ruralandanurbanpopulationwithanumberof important townsnamelyKabarnet,EldamaRavine,Marigat,MajiMazuri,Mogotio,andTimboroa.Thereishoweverasmallnon-KalenjinpopulationespeciallytheKikuyufoundontheNakuru-EldorethighwayandaroundtheTimboroaarea.
CurrentlytheCountyhasfiveconstituencies:BaringoEast,BaringoNorth,BaringoCentral,EldamaRavineandMogotio.
Political Dimensions:
Politics inBaringoCounty isdominatedbypersonalities. PresidentMoiwas the secondPresidentoftheRepublicofKenyaandwasapatronoftheformerrulingpartyKANU(currentlyledbyhissonGideonMoi).Inthe2007generalelectionMr.GideonMoi,viedfortheBaringoCentralparliamentaryseatbutlost.
TheCountyhassomeminoritygroupssuchastheIlChamus,Ndorobo,Ogiekandotherhuntersandgathererswhichhavebeentryingtogettheirownconstituencytorepresenttheirpoliticalinterestsastheyclaimtobemarginalized.Theiragitationislikelytocontinueuntiltheirgoalisrealizedorsomeformofcompromiseisreached.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 69
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Thetwinpoliticalissuesidentifiedaboveshouldbescrutinizedandcloselymonitored.
Security Dimensions
AsindicatedintheintroductiontheCountysharesborderswithquiteanumberofneighboursnamely,WestPokot,ElgeyoMarakwet,Nakuru,LaikipiaandUasinGishuCounties.Someof itsneighbourshave serious security concerns, in particular the border between Baringo and West Pokot; andLaikipiaCountiesareporousandinthehandsofcattlerustlerswhoareinpossessionofsmallarms.CommunitiesfromthethreeCountieshabituallyraideachothertosteallivestock,andsometimestorape,commitarsonandkill.
ItispossiblethatthesmallarmsfoundintheCountycouldfindtheirwayintothehandsofmilitiasandindividualcriminalsaroundelectiontime.TheseshouldbeaconcerntothosemonitoringthesecuritysituationintheCounty.
Economic Dimensions:
TheprimaryeconomicactivityislivestockkeepingwithintheCountyandexternallywithsomeofitsaforementionedneighbours.WhenformerPresidentMoiwas inpower, thereusedtobeperiodicgoatauctionsthatraisedmillionsofshillings,butthatauctionisnomore.Thereisalsoaconsiderablelevelofbeekeepingandhoneyharvesting.
DespitebeingthehomeCountyofformerPresidentMoi(whoservedasPresidentfor24years),theCountyhasagenerallyloweconomicdevelopmentratewithlessthan10%ofthepopulationontheelectricitynationalgrid.Thereareveryfewtarmacroads.Thus,theCountyreliesheavilyonresourcestransfersfromthecentralgovernmentwhichtotalledoverKshs500millioninFY2008/9.
ItshouldbehowevernotedthatBaringoCountyhasanumberoftouristattractionswhichincludeLakesBaringoandBogoria. The LakeBaringoareahas awide rangeofbirdswhich are anaddedtouristattractionforbirdlovers.Tothisextenttheeconomicissuehasbeenhowincomemadefromthese tourist attractions shouldbe sharedwith the local community. The local communities tookthegovernmenttotheAfricanCourtofHumanandPeople’sRightsandwoninasuitrequiringthegovernmenttocompensatethemforgivinguplandforthetouristfacilities.
AsthelegislationforCountygovernmentsisdeveloped,thecommunitiesinBaringowilldefinitelykeepaneyeontheresourcesharingclausestoseewhethertheycomeoutaswinnersorlosers.
Legal Dimensions
TheCountyisservedbyMagistrate’scourtsbasedinKabarnettown.Duetothis,anumberofdisputescontinuetoberesolvedthroughtraditionaljusticemechanisms(providedbycommunityelders)toresolve conflicts. It is questionable whether thesemethods are adequate or appropriate for theresolutionofdisputesthatinvolvecattlerustling,arson,murderandothercrimes.
Social Cultural Dimensions
AsstatedearlierthepredominantcommunityinthisCountyistheKalenjin.AstheKalenjincommunitycomprisesseveralsubtribes,themajorityaretheTurgen,followedbyafewothers,thentheminorityIlChamus,Ogiek,andNdorobos.Betweenthemajorsub-groupsandtheminoritygroupstherearechargesofmarginalization.
TherearesomeKikuyuintheareaaroundTimboroaandontheNakuru-Eldorethighway.SomeofthesepeoplehadtheirhomesburnttothegroundduringthePEV.SomearestillinIDPcamps,and
70 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
citeinsecurityasareasonwhytheycannotgobacktotheirfarms.Thereisaperceptionthatthese‘foreigners’areresponsiblefortheKalenjin’s‘loss’ofland.
Thebadbloodbetweenthecommunities,generatedbywhattheKalenjinperceivetobehistoricallandinjustices,isunlikelytorelentbecauseofthepsychologicaltraumaandstressofthosewhowereaffectedorwhowitnessedwhathappenedtotheirneighboursespeciallyinBurntForest(whichwasseverelyaffected)andwhichisintheneighbouringUasinGishuCounty.
Environmental Dimensions
BaringoCountyispartlyaridandpartlysemi-aridwithfewwaterresources.Only35%ofthepopulationhasaccesstocleanwateragainstanationalaverageof66%.Theareaisthereforedrymostofthetimewithverylittlerainfallinthedryseason.TherearesomeseasonalriversintheCountybuttheseemergeonlyduringtherainyseason.
Whentherainyseasonssetsin,itpresentsnewproblems.Itcausesfloodingandmuchoftheloosetopsoil(fromtoomuchheat)iscarriedintothelakes.Inevitablythisleadstoconflictsascommunitieshavetofightforpastureandimprovetheirherdsintherainyseasons.Theseseasonsalsocoincidewithritesofpassagewhichcreatedemandforactivitiessuchascattlerustling.
Theconflictsthatariseinthesesituationsareforpastureandwater.Buttheyshouldbemonitoredincasetheymutateandtakeapoliticalform.
Conclusion
ThepoliticsofmajorandminorKalenjincommunitiesmaycausedividesthatmaymakepeaceableexistence difficult. The sharing of resources (at the National and County levels) will dominatediscussionsonthepoliticaleconomyoftheCounty.TheareatowatchespeciallyinrelationtoelectionsistheborderwithUasinGishuCounty.
LAIKIPIA COUNTYLaikipiaCounty is locatedontheEquator in theformerRiftvalleyprovinceofKenya. It lies in thenorthwestofthesnowcappedMt.Kenyaandcoversanareaofapproximately9,462squarekilometreswithapopulationof399,227.ItbordersSamburuCountytothenorth,IsioloCountytothenortheast,MeruandNyeriCountiestosouth,NyandaruaCountytothesouthwestandBaringoCountytothewest.ItcomprisesofcommunitiessuchastheKikuyu,Maasai,Kalenjin,Pokot,Samburu,Meru,Borana,Somali,Turkana,andincreasinglynonKenyanwealthylandowners.Whogiveitthecharacterof diversity. It has an urban but mostly rural population; the main urban centres are Nanyuki,Nyahururu,RumurutiandKinamba.CurrentlytheCountyhastwoconstituencies:LaikipiaWestandLaikipiaEast.
Political dimensions
TherelationshipbetweenthecommunitiesinLaikipiaisunstable,marredbypoliticaldivisionsalongethniclinesandworsenedbycompetitionfortheeconomicresourcesespeciallylandandwater.Eachcommunityhasatendencytofollowitselectedleadersandpoliticalintoleranceishigh.
Thiscausesfrictionbetweendifferentcommunitieswhichholddifferentpoliticalideas.Thisiswhatinpartledtoandisexemplifiedbythetribalclashesthatrockedtheregionfollowingthe1997elections.Thisagain isexemplifiedby the1998 tribal clashes inLaikipia thatpitted theSamburuandPokotagainsttheKikuyu.76
76 Akiwumi Akilano, Commission of Inquiry Report on Tribal Clashes, at page 2.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 71
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Duetothesetrends,electionsinLaikipiaareinfluencedbytwofactors,partyloyaltyduringthesingleparty system and tribal kingpins after the advent ofmultipartyism. Politics in LaikipiaWest havebeendominatedgenerallybyasingleCommunityatparliamentarylevelwithallthesixMPssinceindependencebeing fromtheKikuyuCommunity. InLaikipiaEastConstituency,politicshavebeendominatedbytheKikuyuCommunitysinceindependenceapartfromabreakinthe1988electionswhereFrancisOleKaparowaselectedastheMemberofParliament(MP).
Security dimensions
Security,orratherlackofit,isamajorcauseofconcerninLaikipiaCounty.Thefirstcauseofinsecurityisthecattlerustlingbetweenpastoralistcommunities,especiallythePokotandtheMaasai,whichhasbeenaperennialheadachetotheKenyanSecurityapparatussinceindependence.
Thesecondistheproliferationofgunsandothersmallarms,duetotheCounty’svastuninhabitedareasandproximitytotheunstablenorthernpartofKenya.Thissituationisnothelpedbytheadventofhighwaybanditryandarmedrobberyintherecentyears.Thereisadearthofsecuritypersonnelandpresenceinthearea.
Economic dimensions
Economic activity in the County consistsmainly of grain crops,wheat, ranching; and greenhousehorticulture.Insomeseasonshoweverbirdsdodevastatingdamagetowheatfarmersbyeatingupmostoftheirwheatcrops.Economicallyspeaking,tensioniscausedbythehistoricallandquestionandcompetitionmainlyforscarcewaterresources.
In Laikipia and someneighbouring Counties cattle rustling is considered an economic activity forreplenishing livestock after losses caused by drought. This happens rather frequently betweenpastoralcommunitiessuchasSamburuandthePokot.
Legal dimensions
LaikipiaCountyisservedbytwoLawCourts.TheseareoftheChiefMagistratescourtstatusandarelocatedinNyahururuandNanyukitowns.TheyareusuallyreferredtoastheNyahururuandNanyukilawcourtsrespectively.AppealsondecisionsrenderedbythesecourtsareheardattheNakuruHighCourtstation.
AsnotedwithafewoftheotherCounties,theservicesprovidedbythejudiciaryarehardlyadequateforeffectiveconflictresolutionbetweenthediversecommunitiesthatinhabitLaikipiaCounty.
Social and cultural dimensions
Asindicatedelsewhere,thesocio-culturaldynamicsinLaikipiaareintenseandadversarial.TheypitthedominantKikuyucommunityagainsttheMaasai,Kalenjin,Pokot,Samburu,Meru,Borana,SomaliandTurkana.Politicsisorganizedalongthedifferentculturalpoliticalunderstandingandpsychologicalposturesofsuperiority.
Environmental dimensions
LaikipiaCountyhasacool,temperateclimatewithbothrainyanddryseasonsbutwiththeclimatebeingmainlydryandarid.Therearetwoconflictcategories inthisdimension,thehuman-wildlifeconflictsandtheintercommunityconflictsoverenvironmentalresources.
LaikipiaCountyisinfamousbecauseofthehuman-wildlifeconflictswitnessedinhumansettlements
72 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
borderinganimalsanctuariesandconservancies.
LaikipiaCountyisdottedwithforestsandconservancieshometowildanimals.Anappealhasbeenmade to KenyaWildlife Services (KWS) to employ permanentmeasures to stop human/ wildlifeconflicts in Laikipia County, sometimes back, farmers in Muramati location held demonstrationsagainstdestructionof their foodcropbyelephants.TheCounty is in theneighbourhoodof threeranchesonebeingLolDaigaandelephantsstrayintofarmsontheirtransitfromMt.Kenyatotheranch.Thelocalcommunitywhosemainlivelihoodisagriculturedependsonfaminerelieffooddueoccasionaldestructionoftheirfoodcropsbythejumbos.
When farmers pursue compensation they find that it is unrealistic in value as it does not reflectcurrentfinancial values. Tomake itworse,mostof the farmerswho suffer lossesdue tohuman-wildlifeconflictsarenotawareofthelegalmechanismsavailableforthepursuitofcompensationthusdoesnotgetcompensation.Compensationsinthiscasearedeterminedbydistrictbasedtribunals.However,thetribunalsawardafixedvalueforanyloss;valueswhichwerelastreviewedin1980sandthusdonotreflectthecurrenteconomicreality.
Due to the fact that LaikipiaCounty is apredominantlyarid region;water is a scarcenatural andenvironmental resource thus a cause of conflicts between communities living in the region. ThishappensmostlywheretheMaasai,PokotandSamburucommunitiesconflictoverwateringpointsfortheiranimalsduringdrought.
Conclusion
LaikipiaCountyshouldbemonitoredcloselyduetothediversityofitspopulationwhichisdistinctlylackinginharmony.Asindicatedthe1997/8periodwitnessedelectionrelatedviolenceandwhilethecountrywasthenledbyPresidentMoi,andtheMaasai,TurkanaandPokotfearedbeingdominatedbytheKikuyuinapost-MoiState;thoseearlierconflictsmaymutateandtakeadifferentfaultlineasthesociologyofconflictissuchthatitfestersandcanrecur.
Thereisalsotheissueofsmallarmsthatposeasecuritythreatiftheyshouldfindtheirwaytomilitiagroupsandunemployedyouth.Thesecouldbeusedtoperpetrateelectionrelatedviolence.
NAKURU COUNTYNakuruCountyissituatedonthefloorofRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswithBaringoandLaikipiaandNyandaruaCountiestotheNorthandNorthEastrespectively;itbordersNarokCountytotheSouthandBometandKerichoCountiestotheSouthWest;andKiambuandKajiadoCountiestoitsSouthEasterntip.CurrentlytheCountyhassixconstituencies:Naivasha,NakuruTown,Molo,Kuresoi,Subukia,andRongai.
TheCounty,amongthelargestintheCountry,occupies7,495squarekilometerswithapopulationof 1,603,325 (which is the 5th highest in the country). Nakuru County is clearly one of themostcosmopolitanCountiesinKenyaandishosttopeoplefromitsmanycommunities.ThemajorityofitsinhabitantsarefromtheKalenjincommunity(Turgens,Kipsigis)andMaasaiandtheKikuyu.OthercommunitiessuchastheKisii,LuoandLuhyahavealsosettledhere.
TheCountyhasabigurbanpopulationwithanevenbiggerruralpopulation.ItsurbanpopulationisfoundinimportanttownssuchasNakuru,Naivasha,Molo,Gilgil,Njoro,MaaiMahiu,SubukiaandDundoriamongmanyothers.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 73
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Political dimensions
NakuruCountyisaverypoliticallysignificantCountyinKenya.SomehaveobservedthatiftheCountysneezes,othersinthecountrycatchacold.ItisthefaceofKenyainitsbeauty(andugliness).ItisinNakuruthatthefirstPresident,MzeeJomoKenyatta,gavehiskeynoteaddressafterindependence,entitledturudimashambani(letusgobacktoourfarmsandwork).
Whenever tribal animosities arise in Kenya, Nakuru County is usually the epicentre and the PEVfollowedthattrendwithdevastatingresults.
Security dimensions
Thepoliticaldimensiondovetailsintothesecuritydimension.NakuruCountysuffersserioushistorical,physical andpsychological securityproblems. Someof theseare rooted in contested land claims,whicharepartlybasedonthefearthattheothercommunitywilltakeoverallthelandoftheother(atleasteventually).
HistoricallyelectionshavebeenviewedinKenyaasacompetitionbetweencommunitiesordifferentethnic groups. This trend merits monitoring and a comprehensive early warning and mitigationsystem.
Apart from land claims, the other possible trigger for security concerns is the high number ofunemployedyouthintheCounty.Itisawellknownfactthatunemployedyouthareusefultofactionalfightingastheycanveryeasilybemobilizedasfootsoldiers.
There isalsothe issueof insecurityarisingfromthefactthatNakuruCountybordersBaringoandLaikipia(whichinturnborderWestPokot,TurkanaandSamburu)whichhaveaccesstosmallarms.ShouldthesesmallarmsfindtheirwayintoNakuruCounty,aseriousthreattosecuritymayarise.
Economic dimensions
TheCountyhasvarioustouristattractionssuchasMenengaiandLongonotmountains,LakeNakuru,LakeNakuruNationalPark,Hell’sGatereserve,LakesElementaitaandLakeNaivashatomentionbutafew.TheCountyalsohasprivateranchesandhospitalitycentres.ThesebringinalotofmoneytotheCountycontributingtomakingitoneoftherichestinKenya.
Moreover,thereisextensivedairyfarming,commercialwheatandmaizefarming.TheCountyalsohasmajor road transport carrierswhich takeadvantageof thehighway to carryout the lucrativebusiness.
OverthelastfewyearshorticulturehasbecomealeadingforeignexchangeearnerforKenya.SomeofthisbusinessisbasedintheshoresofLakeNaivasha.Thebusinesseshereemploy,notunliketheteaestatesofKerichoCounty,migrantsfromtheLuhya,LuoandKisiicommunities,afactorwhichhasledtothegrowthinpopulationofthesecommunities.ItwouldberemissnottomentionfishingasoneoftheeconomicactivitiesintheCounty.
Legal dimensions
TheCourtofAppealsitsinNakuruonitscircuitrytourofthecountrywhenhearingappellatematters.TheCountyhasaHighCourtbasedinNakuruandhasMagistrates’courtsinNakuru,Naivasha,andMoloamongothers.GiventhattheCountyhasbothaveryhighurbanandruralpopulation,andisamongthebiggest insize,thenumberofpeoplewhocanavailthemselvesofthejudicialservicescouldbelimited.
74 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
This situation is not helped by the delays in the hearing of disputes submitted to the judiciary.Consequently,therearemanymattersthatarepossiblynotsubmittedtothecourtsforfearofdelaysandthesecouldbesubjectedtoalternativedisputeresolutionwhichmayonlypartiallysettlethem.Some conflictsmay also remain unresolved. Either of these has the potential to accentuate riftsbetweendisputingparties.
Socio cultural dimensions
TherearevariouscommunitiesinthisCounty:theKalenjin(Kipsigis,TurgenandMaasai),theKikuyuandothercommunitiesrepresentedbymigrantworkers.
Inaddition,thereisfightingoverlandwhichhasbeengoingonforlong.Inthisregard,landclaimspitKipsigisandTurgenagainsttheKikuyuontheonehand;andtheMaasaiagainsttheKikuyuontheother.TobesuretheMaasaiandKalenjinfeellandintheCountybelongstothemandtheirKikuyuneighboursareimpostors:thatis,theyhaveadubiousclaimtotheland.ObviouslytheKikuyuhaveadiametricallyopposedviewtotheMaasaiandKalenjinclaims.Andthesecompetingclaimsonlandaccentuatepsychologicalinsecuritiesharbouredbythecommunitiestocreateatickingtimebomb.
Environmental dimensions
PartsofNakuruCountyaresemi-aridandassuchdonotreceivesufficientrainfall. Indryseasons.Thesepartsalsosufferdisproportionatelyintherainseasonastheyfloodduetotheflatnatureoflandandpoordrainagesoils.Thisthreathastwoeffects;oneitdestroystheinfrastructuresuchastheMaiMahiuroadtoNairobi;andtwo,itmayreducethenumberofwildanimalsavailableintheparksthroughnaturalattritionaccentuatedbyseveresemi-aridconditions.
Climatic changes have also adversely affected the lakes in the region. Lakes such as ElementaitaNakuruandNaivashahavebeenshrinking.Thishasstartedtocauseanecologicalimbalanceinthehabitatsforbirdssuchasflamingoswhicharepartofthetouristattractions.LakeNaivashahasintherecentpastalsobeenaffectedbyhyacinthattackswhichhavemadefishingasaneconomicactivitydiminished.
The climatic changeshavealsobeenaidedby the inabilityof the countryat large tomaintainorincreaseitsforestcover.IftheseclimaticchangesarenotcheckedNakuruCountyanditspeoplearelikelytosufferwatershortageinthemediumtolongterm.Suchasituationwillonlyaddfiretothefuelcreatedbyethnicanimositiesasthesamecommunitieswillnowhavetofightoverwater.
It should be noted that because of its tourist attractions there is the expected battle betweenconservationistsandlocalcommunities.Theissueofcompensationfordestroyedcrops,injuriesbywildanimalsandevendeathsmayarisefromtimetotime.
Conclusion
ThewholeCountyshouldbemonitoredcloselyforbothhistoricalandcontemporaryreasons.Theseparatebutcompetingclaimsto landbytheMaasaivis-à-vis theKikuyu;andbytheKipsigisandTurgensvis-à-vistheKikuyuwhenlacedwiththefightforpoliticalpowerarearisk.Thereisalsoagrowingmigrantworkingpopulation inareassuchasNaivashawhohavesomepolitical influence.TheramificationsoftheICCelevatingMessrs.KenyattaandMuthaurafrombeingsuspectstoaccusedpersonsneedstobemonitoredcloselyasitmayaffectinter-communalrelations.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 75
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
NAROK COUNTYNarokCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceofKenyaandsharesborderswithNakuruCountytotheNorth,RepublicofTanzaniatotheSouth,KajiadoCountytotheEast,andBometandKisiiCountiestotheWest.Itoccupies17,933squarekilometerswithapopulationof850,920peoplewhopredominantlybelong to theMaasaicommunity.Theothercommunities foundhereare theKipsigis,theKisii,andtheKikuyu.
TheCountyhasbotha ruralandanurbanpopulationwithanumberof important townsnamelyNarok,Kilgoris,NairagieEnkareandLolgorian.ThelargestoftheseisNarokwithapopulationofover38,000people.CurrentlytheCountyhasthreeconstituencies:NarokSouth,NarokNorthandKilgoris.
Political dimensions
ThepoliticsofthisCountyaredrivenbothbypersonalitiesandpoliticalparties.IntheMoiera,thepeoplesupportedtheformerPresidentMoiandKANU.Sincehisretirement,thedefactoleaderoftheMaasaicommunityhasbeenWilliamOleNtimama,whoisthecurrentMinisterforNationalHeritageandalsoaformerministerinformerPresidentMoi’sgovernment.Inthe2007generalelectionsheledthecommunitytotheODMsideinsupportofOdingaandRuto.TodayNtimamahasadvancedinyearsandthereisarealpossibilitythatnewMaasaileaderswillemergetotakeoverthemantlefromhim.
TheMaasaihavealwayshadgrievanceoverlandvis-à-vistheKikuyucommunity.Electoralpoliticsisinfluencedbythisgrievanceandislikelytocontinueinthecomingelections.
Security dimensions
TheborderbetweenKisiiandNarokCountiesisofparticularconcernsecuritywise.TheKilgorisareahasknownviolencesincethereturnofmulti-partypoliticsinKenya.TheMaasaiandtheKisiifightover scarcepastures andeven scarcerwater;with thefights intensifyingduring electionperiods.TheselandgrievancesbetweentheMaasaiandtheKikuyuandtheKisiirespectivelydefinetheethnicfaultsthatfollowthelandquestionmanifestingthemselvesasabasisforpoliticalchoicesandneedtobemonitored.
Economic dimensions
NarokisarichCountywithlargefarmingscaleofwheat,barleyandmaizeforcommercialpurposes.Theweatherisverygoodinthemiddleandnorthernpartsaffordingagriculturalpracticesonflatlandaboon.
In addition, there is livestock farming.As seenwithneighbouring KajiadoCounty,Maasai believerearingof largeherds of cattle and goats is part of their cultural practice. In the Southernparts,especiallyKilgorisconstituency,there isscarcityofpastureandwaterthusthefightsbetweentheMaasaiandKisiioverthetwo.
Moreover,theworldfamousMaasaiMaragamereserveislocatedintheCounty.Ofcourseitisthehomeoftheeighthwonderoftheworld:thewildebeestmigration.TheMaasaiMaragamereserve,theMaasaiCultureandthewildlifeintheCountybringithighrevenuesmakingtheCountyCouncilofNarokamongtherichestintheCountryandhenceNarokCountyisricherthanmostoftheCountiesinKenya.
Legal dimensions
TheCountyisservedbytheMagistratesCourtsinNarokandKilgoris.Itisclearfromobservationof
76 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
thegeographicalsizeoftheCountyandthespreadofitspopulationthatthismaynotbeenoughtoresolveconflictsthatmayarisebetweenresidentcommunities.
Socio cultural dimensions
ThesecondbiggestcommunityaftertheMaasaiinNarokistheKipsigis,followedbytheKikuyuandtheKisii.ThereislittleornofrictionbetweentheMaasaiandtheKipsigisandthereforeatmosttimethere ispeacebetweenthem.Thesamecannotbesaidof theother twocommunitieswhichareconsidered‘invaders’oflandorlandgrabbersandhasledtodisplacementofpeopleinthepastthusthereisneedtomonitorthesituation.
Environmental dimensions
Inevitablythehumanwildlifeconflict isrife intheCounty inareasaroundtheMaasaiMaragamereserve.ThisiscompoundedbythedemandsbythelocalMaasaicommunitytoshareintherevenuesthatcomefromthereserve.TheMaasaicommunityisnoworganizingitselftoblockadethearrivaloftouristsleadingtogovernmentactiontoincreaseparamilitarypolicetosecurethepark.
NarokisawaterdeficitCountywithonly33%ofitspeoplehavingaccesstocleanwater.Wheneverthereisdroughtconditionsworsenwithlivestockfarmingleadingtolanddegradationsusceptibletofloodingwhenrainscome.
Conclusion
WithoutanydoubttheborderareasbetweenKilgorisinNarokCountyandKisiiCounty;andNarokNorth(KikuyuorMaasai)shouldbemonitoredbecausethelandquestionisyettoberesolved.
KAJIADO COUNTY
KajiadoCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswithNarokCountytotheWest,KiambuandNairobiandMachakosCountiestotheNorth,andMakueniandTaitaTavetaCountiestotheEast.Itoccupies21,901squarekilometersbuthasapopulationof687,312andisthe9thbiggestCountyinKenya.MostofitsruralpopulationcomprisesoftheMaasaibutmajortribesarewellrepresentedinthepopulationfoundinthemainurbancentres.Manyoftheselattermembershaveboughtparcelsoflandandsettledinsomeparts.
TheCountyhasbotha ruralandanurbanpopulationwithanumberof important townsnamelyNgong’,Kitengela,OngataRongai,Kiserian,Kajiado,LoitokitokandNamanga,amongothers.ItshouldbenotedthattheCountysharesaborderofconsiderablelengthwiththeRepublicofTanzaniaandasaresultitmayhavesomeuniqueattributessuchashavingNamangaborderpointasagateway.CurrentlytheCountyhasthreeconstituencies:KajiadoNorth,KajiadoCentralandKajiadoSouth.
Political dimensions
TheCounty’spoliticsaredominatedbytheleading‘Maasai’politicianssuchasProf.GeorgeSaitoti(aformerVicePresidentforoveradecadeunderformerPresidentMoi)andWilliamOleNtimama(fromneighbouringNarokCounty).HistoricallytheMaasaihavetendedtobehomogeneousintheirpoliticalleaningsandforalongtimethismeanttheywereinsupportofformerPresidentMoiandhisKANUregime.However,afterMoi’sretirementin2002theMaasaihomogeneityhasbeentestedtothelimitwiththeMaasaiinNarokCounty(ledbyNtimama)takingtothe(firsttoNarcthen)ODMpartywhereasthoseinKajiado(ledbySaitoti)goingwiththePNU.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 77
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Security dimensions
TherearenomajorsecurityissuesintheruralpartsofthisCounty.ThesituationishoweverdifferentintheurbanareassuchasNgongandOngataRongaiwherethepopulationcomprisesmanydiversecommunities.Therehasbeenviolencebeforeelectionsinpreviousyearsandtheupcomingelectionsmaynotbeanydifferent.
ThegeneralsecurityoftheNgong’andOngataRongaiareasisnotgood.Therearearmedthugsthatbreakintopeople’shousesandcarjackmotoristsusingsmallarms.
Economic dimensions
TheeconomyoftheCountythrivespartlyontourismandpartlyonlivestockfarming.Asfarastourismisconcernedthemajor touristattractionsare theRiftValleyescarpment, tropicalwildlifeandtheMaasaiMaragame.KajiadosharesexpansivesavannahplainswithneighbouringNarokCountyandSerengetigamereserveinTanzania.TouristscanalsoapproachMountainsKilimanjaroandMerufromKajiadoCountythroughthebordertownofNamanga.TheAmboseliNationalGameParktomentionbutone is located intheCounty.ThetouristattractioncentresprovideemploymentandgeneraterevenuefortheCounty.
Thereiswidespreadlivestockfarming,mainlycattleandgoatrearing.ThishasmadetheCountyasuitable location forabattoirs forprocessingmeatproducts for localandexportmarkets.Further,theCountyhasamajorroadthatrunsfromNairobitoNamanga(inKenya)andtoMoshiandArusha(inTanzania)andbacktotheKenyanborderinTaveta.TheNamanga-ArusharoadalsoleadstothecapitalofTanzania,Dar-es-Salaam.ThistrunkroadbeliesthedearthofgoodroadsastheCountyonlyhas38%roadsareratedasgoodorfair.Apartfromtheroadnetwork,theCountyhasasmallairporttoservetourism.
Kajiadoisarelativelydevelopedconstituencyinitsurbanareasevidencedbytheaccessby39%ofitsinhabitantstoelectricityand71%tocleanwater.
Legal dimensions
TheCountyisservedbytheMagistratesCourtswhicharelocatedinKajiadoTown.ConsideringthehugesizeoftheCounty,thesecourtsarenotsufficientandasaresultmanyofthearisingconflictsaresettledthroughtraditionalmethodsinwhichpenaltiesarepaidthroughlivestock.
Socio cultural dimensions
TheMaasaicommunity is thepredominantoneandoneofthenotablefactsabout it is itsstrongculturalheritage.ThiscanbeeasilyobservedthroughtheMaasaiculturaldress,hairstyles,earpiercingformen,‘elevation’dances,huts,initiationceremoniesandexquisiteheadgear.TheparticipationofwomenindecisionmakingisstilllowandharmfulculturalpractisessuchasFGMandearlymarriagespersistalthoughondecline.
LivestockrearingisalsoamajoraspectofMaasaiculture.TheMaasaiarefondofrearinglargeherdsofcattleandgoats.TheothercommunitiesthatinhabittheCountysuchastheKamba,KikuyuandTaveta are more concerned with running small to medium businesses in various spheres of theeconomy.Assuchtherearefewculturalconflictswithbetweenthecommunities.
Environmental dimensions
TheclimateintheCountyismostlysemi-aridwithrainfallamountsrangingbetweenlowsof500mm
78 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
uptohighsof1,250mmofrainfallperyear.Asaconsequenceoftheseclimaticconditionswildlifethrivesinthearea.RecentdroughtsinKenyahaveaffectedtheCountyharderthanbeforebecauseit(drought)haslastedlongermeaninglittleornorainforprolongedperiods.Thegeneraleffectshavebeenlossoflivestockthroughdeath;degradationofthelandthroughmigrationinsearchofpasturesandtoevadefloodswhentherainsresume.
TheinevitableconsequenceofdifferentgroupsofMaasaiherdsmenmovingfromplacetoplaceintheCountyinsearchofpastureisconflictoverthesame(pastures)andwater.Inadditiontoconflictthereiswidespreadlanddegradationresultingfromlargeherdsofcattlemigrationsinsearchofpasture.
Conclusion
TherearefewpoliticalandsecurityproblemswiththisCounty.OnlytheurbanareassuchNgongandOngataRongaishouldtobemonitoredforbothhistoricalandcontemporaryreasons.The levelofcrimeinthetwourbancentresismediumtohighwithsmallarmsbeinginvolved.
KERICHO COUNTY
KerichoCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswithNakuruCountytotheEast,KisumuCountytotheWest,BometandNyamiraCountiestotheSouth,NandiCountyto theNorthWestandBaringoandUasinGishuCounties to theNorth. Itoccupies2,479squarekilometersandhasapopulationof758,339peoplewhoarepredominantlyoftheKipsigissub-groupoftheKalenjincommunity.Initially,beforethePEV,membersoftheKikuyucommunityhadsettledmainlyintheKipkelionandLondianiareas.MembersoftheKisiicommunitycouldalsobefoundinNyagachoinKerichotown.Butmostofthese(non-Kipsigis)leftaftertheviolence.
The important towns in theCounty includeKericho,Kipkelion,LondianiandKabuti.Thereforethemajorityof thepopulation is ruralbasedas thepopulation inurbancentres is justover200,000.CurrentlytheCountyhasfourconstituencies:Kipkelion,Belgut,Ainamoi,andBureti.
Political dimensions
Kerichohasaveryhomogenousapproachtopolitics.ThisarisesfromthefactthatavastmajorityofitsinhabitantsareoftheKipsigissubtribeoftheKalenjincommunityanddonothavetodealwithfractionsthataccompanyinter-communallypopulatedCounties.InthepastthepeopleofthisareaalignedthemselveswiththeformerrulingpartyKANUandhomogenoussupportforformerPresidentDanielMoi.
SinceMoileftofficein2002andpriortothePEV,thepoliticaldynamicshavefirsttakenthecommunitytotheODMpartyunderOdingaandRuto;andlatertotheUnitedDemocraticFront(UDF)afterthefalloutbetweenthesetwo.WhenRutofailedinhisbidtotakeovertheUDF,heformedtheURPofwhichheistheobviouspresidentialcontender.
As in other Couties in the Rift Valley, it is critical that the outcome of the ICC process is closelymonitoredasitmayaffectinter-communalrelations.
Security dimensions
KerichoCountyisafairlysecureCounty.TheexceptionistheareasofKipkelionandLondiani,whichhosted majority of the Kikuyu community. These two areas must concern anyone interested inpreventingfutureconflictastheKikuyuhereareviewedasoutsidersandmaybeisolatedpoliticallyandeconomicallyleadingtorenewedconflictsbetweenthetwocommunities.AnotherareathatmaybeofconcernistheNyagachoareainKerichotown,occupiedmainlybymembersoftheKisiiethnic
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 79
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
group.ThesewereattackedinthePEVthereforetheareashouldbemonitored.
Economic dimensions
The County is host to hugemultinational companies in the commercial business of tea farming.SomeoftheseteacompaniesincludeJamesFinlay,UnileverandWilliamson.Thecompaniesprovideemployment tomanymigrantworkers fromtheLuhya,Kisii andLuocommunities.Thesemigrantworkers tend togivepolitical support tocandidates fromtheirowncommunities, contrary to theKipsigiscommunity,thoughthishasnotbeenshowntoaffecttheteaeconomy.
KerichoCountyreceivedapproximatelyKshs505millionfordiversedevelopmentalpurposesincludingruralelectrification,roadsandconstituencydevelopment.Ithasgoodroadssurpassingthenationalaverageofgood/fairroadsby15.3%tostandat58.5%.Thismaybeattributedtothebenefitsderivedfrompreviousregimesandthepresenceofcommercialteafarmingwhichrequiresgoodmeansoftransporttofactoriesandtotheairportsforexport.
Legal dimensions
TheCountyisservedbyaHighCourtbasedinKericho.Italsohasmagistrates’courtsinadditiontotheHighCourt.Theseinstitutionsareaugmentedbythemagistrates’courts inneighbouringSotikandBomet.WhilethejudiciarymayseemcloseenoughtomembersoftheCounty,itisawellknownfactthatthejudiciaryinKenyaonlyservesabout30%oftheKenyanpopulation.Itfollowsthatthepeopleuseothermeansofdisputesettlementwhichmaynothavejusticeatitscentrebutfocusonpromotingreconciliation.
Socio cultural dimensions
The Kipsigis are clearly the dominant community despite the modest presence of migrant teaplantation workers from the Luhya, Luo, and Kisii communities; and the presence of Kikuyus inLondianiandKipkellion.Migrantworkersusuallyreturntotheir‘homelandCounties’tovote.Athreatisposedtothosenon-Kipsigis(especiallytheKikuyu)whohaveinvestedintheareasaroundKipkelionandLondiani,asthesemaybetargetedfor‘opposing’theirhostcommunity.
Environmental dimensions
KerichoissituatedinthehighlandsofKenyawithintheRiftValley.ThesehavesomeofthemostfertilelandsinKenyawithreceiptsofrainfallmostoftheyear.Asaconsequence,theCountyisoneofthemostgreeninthecountry.
Conclusion
Thefocus inKerichoCountyshouldbeonNyagacho(Kerichotown),KipkelionandLondianiurbancentresandthesurroundingareas.ThesetwoareasmustconcernanyoneinterestedinpreventingfutureconflictastheKikuyus(someofwhohavesinceleftthearea)hereareviewedasoutsidersand may be isolated politically and economically leading to renewed conflicts between the twocommunities.
BOMET COUNTY
BometCountyissituatedintheformerRiftValleyProvinceandsharesborderswithNyamira,Narok,Nakuru and Kericho Counties. It occupies 2,471 square kilometers only and has a population of724,186peoplewhopredominantlybelongtotheKipsigissubtribeoftheKalenjincommunity.TheCountyhasbotharuralandanurbanpopulationwithanumberofimportanttownsnamelyBomet,
80 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
LiteinandSotik.ThereisamajortarmacroadthatrunsthroughBomettoKisiiandNairobi.
TheCounty isdenselypopulatedandamong its inhabitantsareamodestnumberofmembersoftheMaasaiandespeciallyKisiicommunities.CurrentlytheCountyhasfourconstituenciesnamely:Bomet,Sotik,ChepalunguandKonoin.
Political dimensions
TheCounty’spoliticsareexemplifiedbythehighturnoverofmembersofparliamentinChepalunguconstituency. This constituency seems to elect a new member every election year. The currentMemberofParliament(MP)isMr.IsaacRuto,whoisastaunchsupporterandfollowerofMr.WilliamRutowhohaspresidentialambitions.
Intheyearsgoneby,thisCountywasfirmlyinformerPresidentMoi’sKANUandwasconsidereda“safe”politicalconstituencybecauseithasahomogenousapproachtopoliticalmobilizationwhichmayleadtothepoliticalisolationofthenon-KalenjinpeoplewithintheCounty.
Security dimensions
TheproblemsbetweentheneighbouringKisiiandKipsigiscommunitiesontheborderbetweenBometandNyamiraCountiesarewelldocumented.Therehavebeenfightsbetweenthetwocommunitiesoverlandandlivestockthefts;thesehaveeventuallyspilledintopolitics.InthePEV,somemembersoftheKisiitribewereattackedandtheirpropertiesdestroyedandhencebecameIDPs.Therearereportsthatsomewereevenkilled.Thisareashouldbewatchedclosely.
Economic dimensions
BometCounty is an agriculturally rich and fertile area; there aremany farmershere. Konoin andBomet constituencies grow teawhich earns thema lot ofmoneywhere someof this is donebymulti-nationals);thereisalsoextensivedairyfarming.AreaslikeChepalunguhaveaslightlydifferentclimate,withclaysoilandrequirewaterpanstocollectrainwaterforlivestockrearing(indryweather)andthesehavebeenprovidedmainlythroughuseofgovernmentfunds.TheCountyreceivedaroundKshs583Mfromgovernmentalauthoritiesfordevelopment.Regardless,only4.3%ofhouseholdsintheCountyareontheelectricitynationalgrid.
Legal dimensions
TheCountyisservedbyMagistratescourtslocatedinBometandSotik.Giventhehighpopulationdensityofthepeoplehere,thecourtsmaynotbeabletoresolveallthearisingconflictsbetweenindividuals.EldersfromtheKipsigisandtheneighbouringKisiicommunitysometimescometogetherthroughvariouscommitteestotryandresolvedisputesconcerninglandandlivestock.
Socio-cultural dimensions
Theissuesheremainlyconcerntheintegrationofthenon-KalenjincommunitiesintothepredominantKipsigiscultureandsocialorganizations.Theintegrationhasnotbeenverysuccessfuleventhoughthere is evidence of inter-marriages betweenmembers of different communities.When conflictsarisetheytendtofollowthefaultscreatedbyculturaldifferencesandareoftenaccentuatedbytheethnicitydrivenpolitics.
Environmental dimensions
MostoftheCountyisservedbymanyallseasonrivers.Afewareasaredrythoughinthehotseasons(mostlyChepalungu)andherethereispotentialforconflictovergrazingandwatersources.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 81
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Conclusion
Forelectionpurposes,monitoringoftheneighbouringconstituenciesinNyamiraandBometCounties(inthiscase,NyamiraandSotik)willbecritical.
KAKAMEGA COUNTY
KakamegaCountyhasapopulationof1,660,651andis3,051squarekilometersandisthesecondmostpopulousCounty.ThedominantcommunityistheMaragolisub-groupoftheLuhyaalongwithothersmallLuhyasub-groups.KakamegaCountyhasnineconstituencies;namely,Butere,Mumias,Matungu,Khwisero,Lurambi,Ikolomani,Malava,ShinyaluandLugari
Political Dimensions
KakamegaregardsitselfasthepoliticalcapitalofthecurrentWesternProvinceandbasicallyservesasthepoliticalbarometeroftheregion.TheCountywasdominatedbyKANUpriortothe2002electionswhichbroughtNARCtopower.NewFordKenyaandODMarethedominantparties.
KakamegaCountywasaflashpointduringthe2007/8postelectionviolencewithriotsanddisplacementofcommunitiesperceivedtobeantiODM.ThecurrentpoliticsaredominatedbytherivalryrelatedtothenextgovernoroftheCounty.Theareaislargelyhomogenousandanycommunityrivalrywilllikelybereflectedinclan-basedpolitics.
Economic Dimensions
Themain industry is sugar processing;Mumias Sugar Company, Kenya’s largest sugar producer isfoundinthecounty.Thecompanyhasbeenbesetbychallengesrelatedtolowpaymenttofarmersandlateharvesting.OtherfactoriesareButaliandWestKenyaSugarcompanies.Othercashcropsaretobacco,coffee,sugarcaneandcotton.KakamegacurrentlyservesastheprovincialheadquartersforWesternprovinceandisthehuboftheregion.Kakamegatownisthelargestandmostdevelopedtownintheprovince.Finally,Kakamegathrivesoneco-tourismbasedontheKakamegarainforest.
Security Dimensions
TheCountywashitby thePEV.Minority immigrantcommunitiesperceived tobeanti-ODMweredisplacedandtheirpropertydestroyed.Inaddition,alargenumberofpeoplewereshotandkilledbypolice.Kakamegaalsohasatraditionallyhighcrimerate.
Social Dimensions
Kakamega has a high populationwhichmeans that services are overstretched. Only 1 out every10peoplehassecondaryeducationandonly3outevery10womendeliverinahealthcarecentreattendedbyaqualifiedprofessional.BothasruralandurbanCounty,Kakamegahasahighlydiversepopulation, and indeedmore or less a cosmopolitan population, where evenminorities such asKikuyu,Kamba,KalenjimandalsoLuoenjoylivelihoodsbasedonvariousindustriesthrivinginthisCounty.
Legal Dimensions
TheCountyhas16judicialofficersand5courtstations.Itsratioof100,000citizensperHighCourt
82 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
judgeis8.3,thefourthhighestinKenyaagainstanationalaverageof8.6.77
Environmental Dimensions
Thehighpopulation growthhas resulted in severe environmental degradation, deforestation andsoilerosion(KakamegaDistrictStrategicPlan2005-2011,MinistryofPlanning).KakamegaalsohostsKenya’sonlyrainforest,whichissubjectofongoingconservationefforts.
Conclusion
There is low likelihood of any sustained conflicts. Most of the tensions revolve around politicalcompetitionandattimestheseturnviolent.TheCountyrequiresmoderatesurveillanceintherunuptothenextelections
VIHIGA COUNTY
Vihiga County is the smallest County within the formerWestern Province, with a population of554,622andanareaof531squarekilometers. Itcurrentlyhas4constituencies;that is,Emuhaya,Hamisi,SabatiaandVihiga.
Political Dimensions
Vihigapolitics isdominatedby thepoliticsof theMudavadidynasty.MusaliaMudavadi tookoverfromthepatriarch,MosesMudavadi,alifelongKANUpolitician.KANUdominatedthepoliticalsceneuntilNARCcametopowerin2002.MudavadilostthatelectiononaKANUticketbutcamebackin2007,thistimeunderODM.TheCountyislargelypopulatedbytheMaragolicommunityaswellastheBunyoreandothersmallLuhyasub-groups.
Economic Dimensions
Vihigaisextremelydenselypopulated.Themainstayoftheeconomyissubsistenceagricultureaswellassmallscalecashcropfarming.ThemainfactoryisatMudete.Otheractivitiesincludesmallscaletrading.
Legal Dimensions
Vihiga has 2 court stations and no high court station it has a ratio of 185,000 persons per courtstations,againstanationalaverageof165,000percourtstation.78Thisisanextremelylowlevelofjudicialaccess
Environmental Dimensions
The high population has put pressure on the environment with high levels of soil erosion andenvironmentaldegradation.
Conclusion
ThereislittlelikelihoodofanywidespreadandsustainedconflictintheCountyandthustheCountyisoflowpriorityinthisregard
77 Sharmit Lamba, Topographical Analysis of the Law Courts of Kenya – Mazingira Institute 201178 Ibid
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 83
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
BUNGOMA COUNTYBungomaCountyissituatedinWesternKenyaanditoccupies3,953squarekilometers.79TheCountyhas a population of 1,630,934 persons.80 There are 4main sub-ethnic communities of the Luhya‘nation’:thatis,Bukusu,Sabaot,TachoniandTura.
Political Dimensions
PoliticsinBungomahastraditionallybeendominatedbythenumerousBukusucommunities.Sincethebeginningofmulti-partydemocracy in1992,theBukusuhavebeen identifiedwithoppositionpolitics. ThepresenceofmajorBukusufigures likeMichaelWamalwa ‘Kijana’ andMukhisaKituyiintheoriginalForumforRestorationofDemocracy(FORD)anditssplinterFORD-Kenyafueledthisperception.WithWamalwatakingontheleadershipofFORD-KenyafromJaramogiOginga,thepartydominatedthearea.
WiththedeathofWamalwaandtheprecedingintra-partytroubles,thepartybegantodeclineandtheODMbecamedominant,winningmostoftheseatsonofferinthelastelections.ODMhasalong-standingrivalrywithNewFordKenya,apartystrugglingtogaindominanceinWesternKenya.81
Security Dimensions
The major security concern in Bungoma County involves Mt. Elgon constituency. Long-standingdisputesandclaimsescalated in2005whensomemembersof theSabaot community startedaninsurgencyunderthebanneroftheSabaotLandDefenceForce(SLDF).Thedisputerevolvedaroundabotched landresettlementprogramme in theChebyukarea.According toHumanRightsWatch,MwatikhoCentre for Torture Survivors andWesternKenyaHumanRightsWatch: “from2006 theSabaotmilitia ...killedmorethan600peopleandterrorizedthe localpopulationthroughphysicalassaultsandthreats,andtheseizureanddestructionofproperty.”82
In2008,theKenyaArmywasdeployedtoquelltheinsurgency.Thisoperationwaswidelycriticizedbuttheinsurgencylargelyended.Althoughnormalcyhasbeenrestored,thedisputeisstillunresolvedandtheattendantsituationneedstobemonitored.
Bungomaalsosuffersfrominsecurityrelatedtocoffeesmuggling.Casesoftheftofcoffeebeansfromfarmersunionshaveescalatedovertherecentpast.Thesecasesinvolveextremelyviolentgangs,withsuspectedcomplicityofthesecurityforcesandtheprovincialadministration.83
Economic Dimensions
Bungomaisahighlydenseareawith454peoplepersquarekilometers.Overhalfofthepopulationisconsideredtobelivinginpoverty(CRA,2012).Themainstayofthelocaleconomyisagriculture–eithersmallscalecoffeegrowingandsugarorsubsistencefarming.ThemainindustriesareNzoiaSugarandthetroubledPanpaperMills.Thecoffeeindustryisbedeviledbytheftandlackoffactoriesforvalueaddition.Thesugarsectorofferslowreturnsforfarmers.Therehavebeenattemptstore-openthePanpaperMillsbutthisprocesshasbeensloweddownbyanumberoffactorsamongthemcorruptionclaims.
79 Kenya: County Fact Sheets – Commission on Revenue Allocation, 2012, pg 280 Ibid pg 281 Interview with Robert Wanyonyi – Standard Media Group Journalist82 Visit, http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2008/04/02/kenya-army-and-rebel-militia-commit-war-crimes-mt-elgon, accessed 23rd February 201283 Release Political Prisoners (RPP), Report of Bungoma Town Hall meeting (January 15, 2012) [Unpublished]
84 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Legal Dimensions
Bungoma County has 1 High Court with a High Court/100,000 ratio of 16.3 against the nationalaverageof8.6.Thereare11judicialofficersincludingMagistratesandaKadhi.84Thisindicateslowlevelsofaccesstothejudicialsystem.
Social Cultural Dimensions
TheBukusuhavebeenseenasthedominantcommunityinBungoma–bothpoliticallyandinotherarenas.Inaddition,theclanandethnicdynamicsinMt.Elgonneedtobemonitoredclosely.
Environmental Dimensions
Bungomahasarelativelygoodclimateandagriculturalactivitiesdominatethelocaleconomy.However,thedensepopulationinsomeareasmayposeenvironmentalchallenges.Inaddition,PanpaperMillshasbeenaccusedofcausingpollutionintheWebuyearearesultinginhealthchallengesamongthelocalpopulation.
Conclusion
Thepotentialforre-emergenceoftheinsurgencyandthealienationofminoritiesfromeconomicandpoliticallifeinBungomaraisesthepotentialofconflictinBungomatoHigh.
BUSIA COUNTY
BusiaCountyhasapopulationof488,075andasizeof1,134squarekilometers.ThemainethnicgroupistheLuhyia.OthersareTeso,SamiaandWakhayo.
Political Dimensions
Between1992and2002,theareawasseenasalargelyKANUzone.ThedominantpoliticalfiguresincludedMoodyAwori,ChrisOkemoandJuliaOjiambo.Duringthisperiodtheformertwowerelargelyestablishmentfigures.WhenKANUlostin2002,theoppositionwasabletoestablishdominanceintheareawithMoodyAworicontestingundertheNationalRainbowCoalition(NARC).In2007,ODMwasabletocapturemostoftheseats,includingdefeatingAwori,thethenVice-President,throughthecurrentMinisterforSports–PaulOtuoma.
Currently, it iswidelybelieved that themainpolitical rivalrywillbebetweenODMandNewFordKenya.Inthepast,therehavebeentensionsbetweenthelargerLuhyaandtheTesocommunities.
Economic Dimensions
Slightlyover6outofevery10people in theCounty live inpovertyandonlyabout1personoutof10hascompletedsecondaryeducation.Thereispoorhealthcare,sanitationandroadnetwork.Mostoftheeconomicactivitiesaresmallscaleagricultureandfishing.ThereisalsoconflictovertheconstructionofBusiaSugarfactory.Theothermaincropsarecerealsandcoffee.Inaddition,BusiaservesasthemainborderandcrossingpointwithUganda.Thereisthusa lotsmallscaleofcrossbordertradeaswellassmuggling.InthelowerareasoftheCounty,inBudalangithereistheperennialproblemoffloodingwhichhascauseddisplacementofpeopleanddisruptedlivelihoods.ThereisaplanbythegovernmenttoconstructadamontheRiverNzoiainBungomaCountytoavertfloodsinBudalang’i.ThishascausedtensionbetweenpeopleinBusiaandBungomaCountiesasthereare
84 Sharmit Lamba, Op Cit
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 85
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
planstore-locatepeoplefromthefloodzone.85
Legal Dimensions
BusiaCountyhasatotalof5judicialofficers,includingaHighCourtJudge.Ithasanaverageof0.49on themillionsof citizensper court station ratioagainst thenational averageof 0.37.86Given itsproximitytoUgandaandtheeconomicactivities,thisishardlyadequate.
Social Cultural Dimensions
BusiaCountyisatradecentre,juxtaposedbetweenKenyaandUganda.Alotofsocialissuesprevail,justlikeinanyothertownthat‘sit’in-betweenborders.Thereismegacorruptionandillegaltrade,existingsidebysidewithformalandincorrupttradeformbusinesspersonsplyingtheroute;thereisalotofprostitution;thereisthehotelandmotelindustry;andalso,alotofethnicgroupsmeaninga lot of potential for ethnic conflict including those communities fromUganda, other than thosementionedabove.
Environmental Dimensions
FloodinginthelowerareasoftheCountynexttoLakeVictoriaremainsamajorchallenge.Communitiesinfloodproneareashaveremainedpoorandtherehasbeennolong-lastingsolutiontotheproblem.Thedykesbuilthavebeenlargelyineffective.ThebuildingofadamontheupperpartofRiverNzoiaisstillmiredincontroversyanditisuncertainwhethertheprojectwillgoaheadgiventheoppositiontoitinBungoma.
Conclusion
TheLuhyaversusTesoconflictislikelytobeexacerbatedduringthenextelectionswhileBungoma-BusiaCountyconflictduetotheRiverNzoiadam.However,thelikelyhoodofviolenceremainslow.
SIAYA COUNTYSiayaCountyhasapopulationof844,304livingon2,530squarekilometers.ThepopulationismainlyLuo.
Political Dimensions
Siaya County has diverse political dynamics. The new County systemwill bring together politicalplayerswhoserivalrysofarhasbeenconfinedtotheirconstituencies.ODMisthedominantpartyanditisunlikelythatanyotherpartywillposeasignificantchallengetoit.MajorpoliticalplayersincludeJamesOrengo,Anyang’Nyong’oandRailaOdinga.TheCountygovernmentandsenatorpositionswillbehighlycontested.TherehavebeenpocketsofviolencerelatedtotherecentODMelectionsbutnomajororsustainedviolence.
Economic
SiayaCountyeconomyreliesonfishingandsubsistencefarming.Therearefewindustries.OnemajoreconomicinvestmentistheDominionFarmsontheYalariver.Theprojectisbeingtoutedasamajorstep tousing theYalaSwamptocreate foodsecurity.However, theprojecthasbeencriticisedbyenvironmentalistsforinterferingwiththeYalaecosystemanddisplacingthelocalpopulation.Localresidentsclaimtheyhaveseennotangiblebenefits fromtheprojectandthe issuehasbecomea85 Interview with Robert Wanyonyi , Op Cit86 Sharmit Lamba, Op Cit
86 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
major flashpoint between locals on the one hand and Dominion, politicians and the provincialadministrationontheother
Security Dimensions
Themajor security issue is related to the activities ofDominion Farms. Also increase in crime Inaddition,thereislikelytobesmallpocketsofelectoralrelatedviolence.
Legal Dimensions
Thereare2courtstationsandatotalof5magistrates.ThereisnoHighCourt.
Environmental Dimensions
Generally, theenvironmentalconditionsofSiayaCountyarebasedon theneighbouringCounties,especiallyKisumu;which isdescribedbelow.Nevertheless,Siaya isbasicallyaruralCountywhoseenvironmentisnotdegradedlikeKisumu.
Conclusion
Thereisaslimpossibilityofanysustainedpoliticalviolencepartfrompocketsofcampaignviolence.
KISUMU COUNTYKisumuCountyissituatedinWesternKenya.Itoccupies2.086squarekilometersandhasapopulationof968,909(CRA,2012).ThedominantethnicgroupistheLuobuttherearesignificantpocketsofKisii,Luhya’s,NubiansandAsians.
Political Dimensions:
Kisumuhastraditionallybeenapoliticallyvolatileareaandthisissettocontinue.Theamalgamationof very politically diverse districts into one single County is likely to present challenges. Kisumu,especiallytheCity,ispronetopolitically-motivatedviolence.Thetraditionaltensionshavesometimestakenanativeclanversesimmigrantclan(jo-dak)dimension.ThecurrentdominantpartyisODMandmostpoliticalcompetitionislikelytorevolvearoundthefightforpoliticalpowerwithintheparty,andbyextension,theCountygovernment.
Security Dimensions
Kisumuhasacultureofpoliticalviolence,especiallyinthemajorurbanareas.Thelargenumberofidleandunemployedyouthingangsmakesiteasyforpoliticianstotrytoobtainleveragethroughviolentmeansbyfundinganddeployingthesegangs.Thissituationmayhavebeenamelioratedbythefactthatmostyouthwhohadpreviouslybeeninvolvedinviolencearenowengagedinactivitiesthatpromotepeace.
IntheCounty,therearebordertensionsintheconstituenciesborderingformerRiftValleyProvince,whichareMuhoroniandNyakach.
InMuhoroni,thereisamixtureofpoliticalandlandissuesthathasledtotension.Theareahashadalongstandinghistoryofinter-communalrivalrybetweentheLuoandKalenjincommunities.In2007,therewasasortofatruceasbothcommunitieswereperceivedtohaveacommonpoliticalinterestinODMwinning the elections.However,with the subsequent fall out betweenRailaOdinga andWilliamRuto,therivalryhasresumed.Duringthe2010referendumtherewastensionandlowlevelofdisplacementintheborderregion.InNyakachtherehasbeenapersistentproblemofcattlerustling,
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 87
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
whichhasoftentakenapoliticaldimensionduringelections.Thereisneedtomonitorthis.
Economic Dimensions
KisumucityistheregionalcapitalofNyanzaProvince.Thecityboastsmanybusinessandmanufacturingplant.IthasaninlandharborconnectingittoUgandaandTanzaniaaswellasaninternationalairport.It is thehubofwesternKenya. In the ruralpartsof theCounty, themaineconomicactivitiesarefishingandagriculture(rice,sugarcaneandmaizefarming)aswellassmallscalesubsistencefarming.Largescalecommercialagriculture ismainlyconcentratedintheMuhoroniandAheroarea.Thereisalsoalargehydro-electricpowerplantinNyakach.Thustheeconomyisdiverse.However,therearealargenumberofruralandurbanpoorandinequalitiesbetweenurbanandruralpopulations.Unemploymentparticularlyoftheyouthishigh,especiallyinurbanareas.
Legal Dimensions
Kisumuhas5courtstationsandajudgeto100,000bringingthecitizens’ratioto4.8againstanationalaverageof8.6.
Social Cultural Dimensions
Clanbasedpolitics is a dominant factor in Kisumu. Further,minorities havenot yet been able tofullyparticipateinsocialandpoliticallife.NubiansandSouthAsiansarelargelyinsulatedfromthemainstream.AlthoughoccasionallySouthAsianshavewonpublicoffice,thesetendtobepersonsconnectedtothepoliticalestablishment.
Environmental Dimensions
Urbanareas likeKisumuCity suffer frompollutionandotherurbanenvironmental challenges likewastedisposalandinadequatesanitation.HyacinthinLakeVictoriaisstillachallengealthoughsomeinnovativepeoplearenowusingtheweedforfurnishing.
Conclusion
ThepotentialforviolenceinKisumu,bothintheborderareasandthoserelatedtolocalpoliticsishighandrequiresmonitoring.
HOMA BAY COUNTYHomaBayCountyhasapopulationof958,791peopleon2,586squarekilometers.ThedominantcommunitiesaretheLuoandtheAba-Suba.
Political Dimensions
HomaBay isadiverseCountyandthepoliticsreflectthis.Onthe islandsandareasborderingthelake,theAbasubahavelongbeenfightingforwhattheyviewastheirdistinctpoliticalidentity.ThedistinctionbetweentheLuoandtheAbasubawasfuelledbytheKANUregimeforpoliticalpurposes.Inrealityhowever,theLuoandSubahavedifferenthistories,distincttraditionsalbeittheycanbetracedtooneancestor.Thedividehasnotbeenviolentbuthasprecipitatedpoliticalcompetition.ThusonehalfoftheCountywillmostlikelybedominatedbythisdynamic.Itisimportanttocloselymonitorpoliticalpartynominations.
Security Dimensions
Apartfrompocketsofintra-partypoliticalviolenceinvolvinggangsofhiredyouthandordinarycrime,
88 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
therearenomajorsecurityrisksintheCounty.
Economic Dimensions
HomaBayhashighlevelsofpoverty.Themaineconomicactivitiesarefishingandsubsistencefarmingaswellaslimitedmanufacturing.TheCountyhasfewfishprocessingplantsasmanyplantsaresituatedoutsidetheCounty.Inaddition,theroadsnetworkisinpoorcondition,althoughintherecentpasttherehasbeenanimprovementintheconditionofsomemajorroads.ThepoorinfrastructurehasledtounderdevelopmentinmanyruralpartsoftheCountyaswellasHomaBayitself.
Legal Dimensions
HomaBayhasaratioof0.32inrelationtomillionsofcitizenpercourtstationagainstthenationalaverageof0.42.Ithas3stationsand5judicialofficers.
Environmental Dimensions
In some lakebeaches thewater hyacinth ismajor challenge, disrupting commercial activities likefishingandinlandwatertransport.Theurbanareaslackproperwastedisposalsystemsandsewerageworks.Asresultwaterbornediseasesarecommon.
Conclusion
Thereisalikelihoodofisolatedviolentconflictsrelatedtopoliticalcompletitionbutthesewillmostlikelypeteroutinthepost-electionperiod.However,anynationalunresthasthepotentialtospreadoutacrosstheregionashappenedinthePEV.
MIGORI COUNTYMigoriCountyhasapopulationof563,033livingon1,969squarekilometers.ThemainethnicgroupistheLuo.ThesecondlargestethnicgrouparetheKuria.OtherlargeminoritiesaretheMaragoliandKisii.
Political Dimension
PoliticsinMigorihashadahistoryofextremeviolenceinalltheconstituencies.Inalmostallelectionsinthelast10yearstherehavebeenlargescaleviolenceanddeaths.Forexample,inRongoalong-standingfeudbetweenDalmasOtienoandOchilloAyakohasbeensimmering,occasionallyleadingto violence. The latest incidenthappenedduring the recentODMelections. InUriri, adeathwasreportedduringthereferendum2010. InNyatike, the lastelectionwascharacterisedbychaos. InKuria,therehasbeenviolencetoo,basedonclanrivalry.
Theworryingdimensionhere istheeasyavailabilityofsmallarmsandthewidespreadpracticeofcattlerustling.MigoriwitnessedsomeoftheworstofthePEV.ManyperceivedPNUsupportersweredisplacedandtheirpropertylooted.Inaddition,manypeoplewereshotatbytheKPFandsomediedasaresult.
Economic Dimensions
Migoriisanagriculturalarea.Theeconomyrevolvesaroundsugarcaneandtobaccofarming.Thereis a sugar factory at Awendo and a leaf curing centre in Rongo.Other crops include cereals andvegetables.ThereisalsoartisanmininginNyatikeandRongoaswellasfishing.ThemaineconomichubisMigoriandAwendotowns.Althoughfarmersearnsignificantincomesfromfarmingthereare
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 89
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
complaintsaboutlowreturnsandhighcostofinputs.ApartfromthemainhighwaythatstraddlestheCountyothersecondaryroadsareinpoorcondition.TheCountyisthegatewaytoTanzania.
Security Dimensions
Migorihasahistoryofpoliticallymotivatedandcrossborderconflicts.Thisislikelytoescalateinthecomingperiod.Inaddition,largeminoritiesliketheKuriafeelculturallyandpoliticallyalienatedfromtheLuoandthis isaperennialsourceofconflicts.TogetherwiththeongoingpoliticalfeudsintheCounty,itisimportanttokeenlymonitortheCounty.
Legal Dimensions
TheCountyhasafactorof0.34inrelationtomillionsofcitizenpercourtstationand3stations.ItdoesnothaveahighcourtandlitigantshavetogotoKisii.
Environmental Dimensions
Environmental degradation remains a challenge due to the nature of commercial agriculturespecificallytheuseofpesticidesandfirewoodinthesugarandtobaccoindustries.
Conclusion
MigoriCountyhasthepotentialforextremeandwidespreadviolenceduetopoliticalfeudsandinter-clanethnictensionandisahighpriorityareaformonitoring.
KISII COUNTYKisiiCountyhasapopulationof1,511.422livingon2,542squarekilometers.ThedominantethnicgrouparetheKisiialthoughtherearepocketsoftheLuo,LuhyaandotherethnicgroupsintheCounty,asitisanurbanCounty.
Political Dimensions
Politics inKisii isverycomplexandsignificantlydifferentfromotherCountiesintheregioninthatinanygivenelectionssince1997,therehasneverbeenanypartythathasdominatedtheCounty.Politics is largely fuelled by perceived clan interests which often supersedes political affiliation.SimeonNyachaehasbeenthemostdominantpoliticalfigureontheCountybuthassinceretired.
KANU,ODMaswellasotherminorpartieshavesignificantsupport.Itisunclearifanyofthebiggerpartieswillbeable toestablishcompletedominance in the regionandclanaswellas familyandpoliticalloyaltieswillcombinetoproducecomplexpoliticaloutcomes.
Security Dimensions
KisiiCountyhashadahistoryofborderconflictswithneighbouringCounties.TherehasbeenconflictintwofrontsontheKisii–MigoriandKisii-HomaBayborderandontheKisii-TransMaraborder.ThelattertwohavebeenlargelyresolvedbuttheonewithTrans–Maraisstillongoing.Therehavealsobeenclanrivalriesaswellasasignificantpresenceofvigilantegangswhopurporttoserveacommunitypolicingroleintheyearsbeforeelectionsbuthavebeenknowntobedeployedforpoliticalmotivesduringcampaigns.ElectioneeringinKisiiCountyispronetoviolenceandintimidation,especiallyfromillegalmilitias/gangssuchasNchinkororo,SunguSunguandAmachumaamongothers.
90 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Economic Dimensions
Kisii is a richagricultural area.Themainstayof theeconomy is small scale tea farmingand thereare numerous coffee factories. Also horticultural crops are grown widely. The County suppliesneighbouringCountieswithvegetablesandfruits.However,duetohighpopulationdensity,farmsizesaregrowingsmallerandsmaller.Competitionforlandoftenleadstoviolenceandisthoughttobelinkedtothepracticeofkillingofallegedwitches.KisiitownisathrivingalbeitcrowdedcommercialhubfortheSouthernNyanzaregionhasishosttoanumberofbusinessesandmanufacturingplants.
Legal Dimensions
TheCountyhasatotalof11judicialofficersin3stations.Itsrationof100,000citizenstoaHighCourtjudgeis5.8againstanationalaverageof8.6whileitsrationofnumberof1millioncitizenspercourtstationis0.38againstanationalaverageof0.37.
Environmental Dimensions
Thehighpopulationdensity is amajor contributing factor to soils erosionanddeforestation.Thewastedisposalandseweragesystemsareoverstretchedinurbanareas.
Conclusion
The riskofwidespreadviolence isminimal.However, there is apossibilityofpocketsofelectoralrelatedviolenceandcrossborderincidents
NYAMIRA COUNTY NyamiraCountyhasapopulationof598,252on899 squarekilometres. Thepopulation ismainlyAbagusii.NyamiraCountyislocatedinNyanzaandconstitutes3constituencies(KitutuMasaba,WestMugirangoandNorthMugirango-Borabu).
Political Dimensions
FordecadesthepoliticsinwhatisnowNyamirahadbeendominatedbyGeorgeAnyonawhohassincedied.The2007electionproducedamixedoutcome.The3constituencieswerewonbyKANU,ODMandthelittleknownNationalLabourParty.Inthoseelectionsslightlyover80candidatespresentedthemselvesforthe3positions.Theresultisthatthewinningcandidatealwayswonbyaverysmallnumberofvotes.Thisshowsaveryfragmentedelectorate.
Economic Dimensions
LikeKisiiCountyNyamiraisanagriculturalbastion.Themainstayoftheeconomyissmall-scaleteafarmingaswellashorticulturalfarming.ThereisasettlementschemeinthecountyontheborderwithBometCounty.
Security Dimensions
ThemajorsecurityissueisrelatedtoalandandborderdisputeandcattlerustlingalongtheborderwithBomet.DuringthePEV,theborderareaexperiencedinter-ethnicviolencepittingtheKisiiandtheKalenjin.Therewasalsosometensionandisolatedviolenceintherunuptothe2010referendum.Thistensionhascontinuedtosimmerandsporadicviolence-mainlyrelatedtocattlerustling-hascontinued.Althoughitisarural-basedCounty,pressurefromsurroundingCounties(suchasKisii)hasledtoalsoincreasedlevelsofcrimeguisedasSunguSunguoffering‘communitypolicing’andwith
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 91
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
tacitsupportoflocalpoliceandadministrationofficers.
Legal Dimensions
Thereare1courtstationsandatotalof2judicialofficers.ThereisnoHighCourt.
Environmental Dimensions
SimilartoKisiiCounty,Nyamiraalsosuffersfromhighpopulationdensityleadingtodeforestation,soilerosion,andalsothesub-divisionoflandintoverysmallparcelshastakentollonproductivityofland.
Conclusion
Nyamirahasexperiencedextremeelectoralviolenceinthepast.ThereispotentialforviolenceintherunuptothenextelectionsandthisrequireshighmonitoringbyCRECO.
NAIROBI CITY COUNTYNairobiCountyplayshosttothepoliticalandeconomiccapitalofKenya.ItbordersKajiado,Machakosand Kiambu Counties. It measures 695 square kilometers with a population of 3,138,369. It iscomprises the 8 constituencies i.e. Dagoretti, Kibera, Westlands, Kasarani, Makadara, Embakasi,KamukunjiandStarehe.Itisacosmopolitancitywithlargeinformalsettlements(slums)ineachoftheaboveconstituencies.
Political Dimensions
Overtheyears,Nairobihadbeenahotbedforoppositionpolitics.Thiscanbeattributedtohigherlevelsofliteracyandenlightenment.DuringtheKANUregime,therulingpartyproppedupcandidatesagainstpopularoppositioncandidatesandthereforetheensuingcompetitioneventuallyturnedintoviolentconfrontationsinalmostallconstituencies.ThusacultureofpoliticalviolenceseemstohavetakenrootinNairobiCityCounty.
NairobiwasamongtheareasthatwerebadlyaffectedbythePEV.AccordingtotheCIPEVReport,125peoplediedand348wereinjuredduringthePEV.87TheviolenceinNairobiwassensationallyreportedbylocalandforeignmediaandthisforcedthethenMinisterforInteriorSecurity(LateJohnMichuki)to order a banon live broadcasts of the violence. The gory images from the violencehavebeenimprintedonthemindsofmanyandthereforetheviolenceisapermanentscarontheconscienceofthosewhoresideinNairobi.
Theannouncementofpresidential results triggeredviolence inODMstrongholds.However, therewere tensions that had started mounting before elections within informal settlements followingrumoursandallegationsthatspreadindicatingthattheLuoandLuhyatenantsinhousesownedbyKikuyulandlordshadplannedtotakeoverthesaidpremisesshouldRailaOdingawin.88InthePEVthatensued,sometenantsrefusedtopayrentandthispromptedthelandlordstoenlistservicesofarmedthugstoeitherevictorforcetheunwillingtenantstopay-up.LongafterPEV,itisclaimedthatsomelandlordshaveunsuccessfullytriedtoreclaimtheirhouses in informalsettlementssuchasKibera.Thisgrievanceislikelytocausetensionsasthenextelectionsapproach.
Ifthenextpresidentialelectionswillbeahighstakescontest,NairobiislikelytoreflectthisasitissaidtobethebarometerofKenya’spolitics.ThePEVwaspartlyattributedtothenatureofthehighstakesthatattendedtothesaidelection.RailaOdinga,whorepresentsKiberaconstituency,waschallenging
87 Republic of Kenya, 2008 Supra at pg 317 and 33488 Ibid pg 305
92 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
PresidentKibaki,whosehasalargefollowinginNairobi.
Duetothehighnatureofthestakesatthatelection,therehavebeenfearsofrigging.ThisraisedtheprospectofviolenceintheCounty.89
SharppoliticalcompetitionisalsoexpectedinareaswhereODMandPNUhavestrongcandidates.Intensecampaigns,ifnotproperlyregulatedmayheightentensionsleadingtooutbreaksofviolenceespeciallyintheinformalsettlements.
Security Dimensions
TheCIPEVreportalludedtotherecruitmentanddeploymentofarmedcriminalgangs(particularlyMungiki and theKenyanTaliban)byprotagonistsduringPEV.90 Thegangshad thrived inNairobi’sinformalsettlements,largelyduetothefailurebytheStateandlocalauthoritiestoprovideamenitiestothelocalpopulations.Thesegangsmovedintothevoidandbecamethealternativeauthorityintheseareas.Effortstotacklethegangsbysecurityforceswereneverconcertedadsustained.AfterthePEV,aviolentcrackdownonarmedgangsgatherednewimpetusleadingtounprecedentedviolenceandspatesofextrajudicialkillingsonbothsides.Eventually,thesegangs,particularlyMungikiwereoverwhelmedandpushedunderground.Thus,eventhoughthegangshaveneverbeendecimated,thereisstillariskofthesame
TherehasbeenahighproliferationofsmallinarmsinNairobi.Thishasbeenattributedtotheinfluxofrefugees(especiallyfromSomalia)andtheincreasedcrimerate.Thedemandandsupplyfortheseweaponshas therefore increased tremendously. This shoulda cause forworry, should therebearepeatoftheviolencewitnessedintheaftermathofthepreviouselections.
The ongoing war against the Al Shabaab in Somalia has heightened terror threat in Nairobi. InDecember 2011, Nairobi experienced two terrorist-related attacks which led to 4 deaths. As theelectioneeringperiodpeaks,theterrorthreatsare likelytoescalate.Campaignmeetingsarelikelytobe targets for terrorists. If thesecurityagencieswillnotbeable topreventattacksandassureresidentsoftheirsecurity,freecampaignswillnotbepossible.
Economic Dimensions
EventhoughpovertyratesinNairobiarerelativelylowat22.5%,thereiswidespreadextremepovertyintheinformalsettlementswhereanestimatedtwo-thirdsofthecitypopulationresidesinanareathat accounts for only one-fifth of the total surface area. This alludes to deep inequality whichpotentiallycouldfansocialtensions.
NairobiCityCountystandstoreceivehighamountsoftransfersfromtheNationalgovernmentduetopopulationsize.Already,theCountyreceivedatotalofKshs1.4billionasrevenueandresourcetransfers in theFY2008/9 (CRA2012). These resourcesare likely tobehandledby theGovernorandthereforepoliticalcompetitionoverCountylevelpositionsarelikelytobeheatedandthiscouldgenerateconflicts.
Legal Dimensions
Nairobiistheseatofthejudiciaryandthereforeallcourts,includingtheSupremeCourt,aretobefoundhere.However,thecourtsystemisseverelyconstrainedbythesheerpopulationitservesandthefactthatoutlyingCounties(Kiambu,Murang’aandpartsofKajiado)relyontheNairobicourtsforservicedelivery.91Withongoingjudicialreforms,itisexpectedthatpressurewilleaseandhence89 Ibid 90 Ibid 30691 Sharmit Lamba, Op Cit, Nairobi is served by 72 judicial officers whereas every 1 judge in Nairobi serves 156,918 persons
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 93
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
accesstojusticeoverelectoralrelateddisputeswillenhance.However,shouldthesereformsstall,theriskoftheproblemescalatingconflictswillremainactive.
Social Dimensions
Inequalities,whichhavebeenalluded toabove,arecausesof social tensions inNairobibasedonclass differences.Within informal settlements, ethnic differences among communities also resultinsocialtensions. InKiberafor instance,thereisethniczoningoftheinformalsettlements,wherecertainneighbourhoodsareexclusivelyheldbyparticularcommunities.Suchzoningisillegalandmayexacerbateethnictensions.
Youthunemploymentisamajor issueinNairobi,particularly intheinformalsettlements.Absenceoflivelihoodsmeansthattheyoutharedesperateandthereforearevulnerabletoconscriptionintogangsthatcouldbeusedforpoliticalviolence.
Environmental Dimensions
Landlessnessdueto lackofsecurityof tenure in informalsettlementsand landgrabbinghave ledtoland-relatedconflictsinNairobi.RecentviolentevictionsinMukuruslumsinNairobi’sMakadaraconstituencypromptedthePrimeMinstertoannounceatemporaryfreezeinsuchevictionsuntilthegovernmentcameupwithguidelinesonthesame. Informalsettlementsarerichvotecatchmentsandthereforeresolvingthelandproblemisapoliticalminefield.Itshouldthereforebeexpectedthatpoliticianswilluse this issueaselectoral campaignpurposeswith the resultof inflamingconflictsrelatedtoland.
Conclusion
NairobiCountyisaveryhighconflictriskareaowingtoitspoliticalsignificanceinthecountry,theentrenchedcultureofpoliticalviolence,scarsofthePEVandprevalenceofsocialtensionsassociatedwithinequality,youthunemploymentandlandlessness.
94 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
CHAPTER FOUR
CONCLUSIONSThisbaselinereportexploresthelegalcontextofKenya’ssecurityandpeace-buildingarchitectureandconcludesthatalotstillneedstobedoneintermsofreformingthenationalpoliceandsubjectingitfirmlytocivilianoversight.Thisperhapswillmaketheforcemoreaccountableandresponsivetoconflictsandtheirtriggers.Inthesamevein,thereportalsocallsforincreasebudgetarysupporttopoliceauthoritiesinordertoincreasetheirpresencesespeciallyinmarginalareasthatareconflict-prone.
This County-based conflictmapping andprofilingbaseline reports reveals thatmore than80%oftheCountieshavemoderatetohighriskofconflictandhencemeritclosermonitoring.TheanalysisalsorevealsthatallpastoralistCountieshavehigherriskofconflictaswellasareasthatwererockedby2007-8post-electionviolence.Newthreatsposedby Islamicradicalizationof thenorthernandnorth-easternpartsofKenyaandtheongoingwaragainstAlShabaabinSomaliahavebroughtanewdimensiontotheconflictfactorsinthenorthandhenceclosermonitoringisnecessary.
The ongoing process of delineating constituency boundaries is emerging as an important conflicttrigger/accelerator,especially inareaswherepoliticalpower isequatedto institutionalizationofacommunity’sholdonresourcesoveritsrivalswithinthesamepoliticalterritory.
The possibility of increased resource transfers as a result of institutionalization of the devolvedgovernment structures also provides an interesting but intense arena of conflict over resourcetransfersfromthenationalgovernmentthatareexpectedtoincreasetremendously.Thiswillperhapsbeexacerbatedbyamalgamationofethnicdistricts intoCountiesandthereduction innumberofelectoralunitsatthesub-Countylevels,forcingbothdominantandminoritycommunitiestoslugitoutoverthefewelectoralunitsavailable.
Internalandexternalpoliticalparties’feudswillalsoincreasepoliticaltensionsinsomeareas,wherethereisminimalinter-partycompetitionsuchastheso-called‘strongholds’ofsomepoliticalparties:formerProvincesofNyanzaandRiftValleyprovideperfectexamples.Therecentviolenceprecipitatedbypoliticalpartynominations(inODM)inNyanzapointtothisglaringpossibility.
Theareas thatwereworst-affectedbypostelectionviolencemeritcloserscrutinyduringthepre-electionperiod, largelyduetotheunsettledorunresolveddeep-seatedgrievances.The impactoftheindictmentof4prominentKenyansshouldalsoprovidemorejustificationformonitoringofthesituation,especiallywithrespecttopossibletreatmentofcommunitiesperceivedasvictimsofthe2007-8PEV.
Conflictsbringintoforeasimilararrayofactors;politicalleadership,elders,youth(hiredas‘warriors’)and interestingly, women. Understanding the role of each social group is important in designingstrategiesofaddressingeachconflict.
Thereexistawealthoflocalpeacebuildingandconflictresolutionresourcesespeciallyinnorthernandpastoralistcommunities,wheretraditionaljusticemechanismsremainstrong.Thesemechanismshavemorphedintopeaceanddevelopmentstructuresthatincorporatecivilsocietyandgovernmentdepartments, giving rise towhatMenkhaus refers to as the “mediated state” inNorthernKenya.Thesestructuresarevitalinmonitoringandresolvingconflictsandthereforeshouldbeconsistently
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 95
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
engagedbyelectionmonitoringgroups
Due to historical circumstances and persistence of the culture of impunity, a culture of politicalviolencehaspermeatedinsomepartsofthecountry.ThiscultureisveryentrenchedinareaswhichtheformerrulingpartyKANUroutinelyimposedcandidatesagainstpopularoppositioncandidatesespeciallyinpartsofformerCentral,RiftValley,NyanzaandNairobiProvinces.Thiscultureexplainstheprevalenceofelectoralviolenceineveryelectionheldwithintheaffectedareas,irrespectiveofcandidates,partiesortypeofelectionsinvolved.Toeradicatethisculture,long-termandsustainedsolutionsmustbesought.
96 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
RECOMMENDATIONS
Inviewoftheabovefindingsandconclusions,thefollowingrecommendationsarenecessary:
(A) To State Institutions:
(i) It is important that the State, through the IEBC, National Cohesion and IntegrationCommission (NCIC), Judiciary, the KPF, the National Intelligence Service (NIS) and otherrelevant institutions,undertake their respectivemandatesandensure that therearepro-activeapproaches(includingearlywarningsystems)toensurethatconflictintheseCountiesismanaged and is not allowed to escalate as happened in the PEV. This report is but abaselineonwhichtobuildfutureinterventions,asweapproachtheupcomingelections.
(ii) With regard to NCIC, they should develop a newmethodological framework of workingso that they do not seem to respond only to hate speech. There needs to be concertedeffortstoensurethatanti-discriminationmeasuresonanyofthegroundsprovidedforintheConstitutionareenforced.Further,freshappointmentstothisCommissionshouldbemadeprior to theelectionstoavoidanyrisksassociatedwiththe impending lapseof tenureofcurrentCommissioners.ThiswillstrengthentheCommissionerstomakethenecessarybolddecisionsthatcoulddeterwould-bethehatemongers,andotherindividualsorinstitutionsthatmayviolatetheConstitutiononanyotherground,ascontemplatedinArticle33(2and3)oftheConstitution.92
(iii) Security Sector Reforms and in particular, police reforms should be acceleratedwith thenecessaryappointmentsmadeatleast6monthsbeforetheelections.ThiswillgivethenewpoliceofficialstimetoinitiatefurtherreformsandbuildpublicconfidenceintheNPS.
(iv) IEBCshouldensureitspreparednessforelectionrelatedconflictwellaheadoftheelections.The IEBC should also activate conflictmanagement structures such as the Political PartyLiaisonCommitteetoaddressanyinter-partycomplaintsanddisputes.
(v) For the long term, all State organs, including the Parliament, particularly the BudgetCommitteeandtheCRA,ensurethatNationalandCountybudgetstakescognizanceofpastandpresentmarginalizationsothatsomecommunitiesdonotfeelmarginalized;inthespiritofthenewConstitution.
(vi) Devolutionisnecessarytoaddressthestructuralcausesofviolence.Thereisthereforeneedfortheallocationofdevolvedfundstobeseenasfairtoavoidexacerbatingresourceconflicts.Devolutionmust work without unnecessary interference from the National government.In this regard, therestructuringof theProvincialAdministrationmustbedonewithin theconfines of the Constitution, especially in the participation of the people. The TransitiontoDevolutionAuthoritymustbesteadfasttoensurethatdevolutionofpowerworksfully,withinthenext4years,sothatallcommunitiesfeeltheyarepartandparcelofKenya.AllMinistries,DepartmentsandAgencies(MDAs)oftheStatethatinfringeondevolutionmustbeheldaccountablethroughcourtsoflaw.
(vii) Further,withoutaccesstotheJudiciary,justicemayremainapipedream.ThereisneedtoensurethattheChiefJusticesurveystheneedsoftheCountiestoensurethattheruleoflaw
92 The Article provides: “the right to freedom of expression does not extend to: (a) propaganda for war; (b) incitement to vio-lence; (c) hate speech; or (d) advocacy of hatred that: constitutes ethnic incitement, vilification of others or incitement to cause harm; or is based on any ground of discrimination mentioned or contemplated in Article 27 (4).” Further, in sub-Article (3), it provides that: “In the exercise of the right to freedom of expression, every person shall respect the rights and reputation of others.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 97
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
ismaintainedatalltimes,andallresidentscanaccessthecourtsincasetotheirfundamentalfreedomsareinfringed,withouthavingtotraveltoNairobi.
(viii) OnJudiciary,reformsthatentailvettingofjudges,appointmentofmorejudicialofficersandcreationofmorejudicial(especiallyHighCourt)stationsinthenewcountiesmustbecarriedoutwellbeforethenextelections.Thiswillgiveaggrievedvotersandcandidatesaccesstothejudicialsystemasandwhentheelectoraldisputesariseduringtheprocess.
(ix) Finally, with regard to political parties, a substantive holder of the Office of Registrar ofPoliticalPartiesshouldbeappointedurgentlytobringasenseofstabilityandinfuseasenseofpublicconfidenceintheoffice.Further,thePoliticalPartiesTribunalshouldalsoanticipatetheavalancheofdisputesthatmayarisefromtheelectioneeringprocessandaccordinglyputinplacemechanismsofensuringexpeditiousresolutionofsuchdisputes.
(B) To Civil Society Organizations:
(i) TheElectionObservationGroup(ELOG)thepremiercivilsocietyobservatoryprogrammeinKenya(ofwhichCRECOispart)shouldput inplacethenecessary infrastructuretocloselymonitorthe24Countiesidentifiedaselection-relatedconflicthotspots.The19countiesthatpresentmoderateconflictriskhowevermeritmonitoringthoughatafarlowerscale.
(ii) CSOsshouldoperationalizeorstrengthenanationalpeaceplatformsimilartotheonethatexistedpriortothe2010referendumunderthebannerofUwiano(cohesion).ThisplatformoughttopromotesynergiesbetweenCSOsandGovernmentagenciestoundertakeadvocacyonnationalissuesthathaveimplicationsonconflictfactorsatthelocallevel.
(iii) TheCSOsshouldparticipateeffectivelyintheexistingDistrictPeaceCommittees(DPC)andadvocateforthetransitioningofthesestructuresintoCountypeacecommitteeswithaclearandstrengthenedstatutorymandateofcoordinatingpeacematters.
(iv) TheCSOsmustactinconcertandcommoncausetoensurethatallpoliticalanddemocraticrights and governanceprocessesduring theupcomingelections are respected, protectedandpromoted.Itiscardinalthatintheseelections,CSOsworkinunison,especiallytoensurethatallStateinstitutions(particularlythosenamedabove)areheldtoaccountiftheyviolatethelaw.
(v) TheCSOsshouldensurethatintheirrespectivecompetencies,betheywomen,children,theyouth,oldpersonsormarginalizedgroupsandcommunities,thatallrightsforthesegroupsareupheld,especiallyensuringthatthereisrepresentationandparticipationofthesegroupsintheupcomingelections.
(vi) TheCSOsshouldalsoworkwith,notjustcriticizeStateinstitutions,inparticulartheyshouldworktogethertoensurethatadequatebudgetarysupporttokeyinstitutionssuchasIEBCismadeavailableontime.WithoutfinancialsupporttotheKPF,Judiciary,andotherinstitutionswithinthecriminaljusticesystemwillnotbeabletodelivertheirmandate.
(vii) CSOs,mustcontinuallymonitortheapplicationofinternationalregionalhumanrightsandgovernancemechanismsKenyaarerespectedandupheldsuchastheRomeStatuteandtheAfricanUnionCharter.
(C) To the International Community:
(i) Theinternationalcommunity,beittherespectiveStatesinEurope,UnitedStatesofAmerica,
98 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
ortheUnitedNationSystems(includingtheSpecialProcedures),shouldcontinuallysupportCSOs efforts, adequately and timely - bothwith technical and financial resources.Whilethis report fullyacknowledgesexistingefforts,muchmoreadvocacyneeds tobedone toimplementtherecommendationssetoutinthisChapter.
(ii) Secondly,theinternationalgrantmakersshouldsupportIEBCandCSOsconsortiawithlike-mindedwork,whohavenowcometogetherunderthebannerofTheElectionObservationGroup (andalsoother institutions thathavemonitoredelections singularly), rather than‘establish’ networks that seemingly do notwork. The example of KenyaDomestic Forum(KEDOF)in2007,whichtotallybackfired,shouldserveasanexampleofhownottodothings.
(D) To Communities / Kenyan People:
(i) The communities in Kenya should andmust acknowledge that Kenyadoes not belong toanyparticularethnicgrouporacombinationofgroups.AfterhavingbequeathedourselvesandfuturegenerationsanewConstitution,itisveryimportantthatallcommunitiesrespecthumanrightsforallpersons;upholdthevaluesofthatConstitution;promoteitsprinciplesofgovernance;anddefenditfrommutilationbythepoliticalclassoranyotherpersons/entities.
(ii) Second,thecommunitiesmustresistandrejectallbackward,corrupt,radar-lessandmyopicpoliticians. The Chapter on Leadership and Integrity must mean something for all theelectorate. It cannotbe ‘business asusual’.All the rottenpoliticians,whomcommunitiesknowverywell,mustberejectedattheupcomingelections;iftheKenyancommunitiesaretoharvestthepromiseofthenewConstitution.Therecannotbeanyothershort-cuttothePromisedLand.
(iii) Whileconflict ispartandparcelofcommunal living,Kenyansmust learntosolvepoliticaland social differences amicably.Whereas this report has focusedon the responsibility ofthe politicalclass, thepublic isalso responsible forpreventingviolentconflicts.AsmanyKenyanshaveexpressedsupportfortheICC, it isclearthatthevariouscommunitieshaveagreedtobanishimpunity.Thecommunitiesmustalsostartbanishingimpunityatthelocallevel, especially theCounty level.All communitiesbelong to all Counties: nooneCountywas established exclusively for any particular community. Therefore, Kenyansmust learnto accommodateminoritieswithinCountieswhere theyare themajority in linewith theConstitutionofKenya.
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 99
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
REFERENCES1. Commission of Revenue Allocation, Kenya County Fact Sheets, 2011, Nairobi: Government
Printers
2. IbrahimDand Jenner J.Wajir CommunityBasedConflictManagement, 1996.http://pason.tulane.edu/conflict/cs%20st/JANFIN2.html.
3. ConstitutionofKenya2010,Nairobi,GovermentPrinters
4. InternaitonalCrisisGroup,KenyanSomaliRadicalization,inPolicyBriefing,AfricaBriefingNo85,25thJanuary2012
5. Juma Kathina, Unveiling women as pillars of conflict building in fractured pastoralistcommunitiesinKenya,inUnitedNationsDevelopmentProgrammeinterimreportforBureauforDevelopmentProgrammes,Visithttp://magnet.undp.org/
6. Kenya National Assembly, Official Records (Hansard) November 1996, Government Printer,1996
7. MenkhausKen,Kenya-SomaliBorderConflictAnalysis,2005,USAIDNairobi
8. TheRiseoftheMediatedStateinNorthernKenya:TheWajirStoryanditsimplicationsforState-building,2008inAfrikaFocus,Vol21Nr2,2008
9. MghangaMwandawiro,Usipozibaufa,utajengaukuta:Land,electionsandconflictsinKenya’sCoastProvince,2010HeinrichBollStiftung:Nairobi
10. MinistryofStatefortheDevelopmentofNorthernKenyaandAridLand,AridLandsResourceManagementProjectIIMeruNorthDistrict-AnnualReport2007/8
11. Pkalya R & Halakhe H (eds, Combating the problems of small arms in Northern Kenya:Testimoniesandcasestudiesofpastoralcommunities,2011,GovernmentofKenya:Nairobi
12. Republic of Kenya, Report on Commission on Inquiry into Post Election Violence, 2009GovernmentPrinters:Nairobi
13. TheNationalSteeringCouncilonPeacebuildingandConflictManagement,StructuralfactorsdrivingconflictinKenya:Amulti-dimensionalanalysis,2011unpublished
14. UNDPKenya,ConflictsDynamicsinIsiolo,SamburuEastandMarsabitSouthDistricts,inAmaniPapers,Vol1No3ofJune2010
15. UNDPKenya,DynamicsandTrendsinConflictintheGreaterManderainAmaniPapersVol1May2010
Websites
1. http://www.irinnews.org
2. www.capitalfm.co.ke
3. www.iss.co.za
4. www.kenyadialogue.org
5. www.wikipedia.com
100 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
Newspapers
6. TheDailyNation
7. TheStandard
8. TheStar
ANNEXURE: TABLE ON RATING COUNTIES
(i) Counties with Moderate to High conflict risks
Marsabit Garissa Bungoma NandiIsiolo TanaRiver Kisumu TurkanaKitui Mombasa Homabay WestPokot
Makueni Kwale Nyamira LaikipiaMandera Kilifi Migori NakuruWajir TaitaTaveta Bomet Kericho
Narok TransNzoia Kiambu Kirinyaga
Nyeri Nairobi
(ii) Counties with Moderate to Low conflict risk factors
TharakaNithi Embu Machakos Lamu
Busia Kakamega Kisii Baringo
ElgeyoMarakwet Samburu Kajiado Muranga
Nyandarua Meru Vihiga Siaya
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 101
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
CONSOLATA MISSIONARIES JUSTICE AND PEACE COMMISSION
VISIT TO THE CONFLICT AREAS OF ISIOLO. (March 13-15, 2012)
Fr. Makau Nicholas
Forthepast5monthsIsiolocountyhasexperiencednastyepisodes.Despitebeinganaturaldisastercounty,ithasnowturnedtoahumandesigneddisaster.Tomany,theproblemisinventedsoastoanswertosomepersonalorparticulargroup’sinterest.TherecentconflictbetweentheBoranawhoaresearchingpasturefortheiranimalsandtheTurkanahasleftmanywondering.Theclashhasleftabout30peopledeadandmanydisplaced.Ithasreturnedthedevelopmentstridetothescratchaspropertywasreducedtoashesandpotentialincomegeneratingpeoplemaimedandincapacitated.Dishearteningisthefactthatthedisputehasnotbeengivenanysensibleattention.Recently,awardcouncilorwasarrestedaccusedofincitement.Thereisacalculatedmovetoignoretheplightofthevictims.Reasonsaregiventhatthelandindisputeistrustlandandnoonecanclaimownership.TheconstitutionisquotedtodefendthepositionofBorana’sentrytotheplacesayingthateveryonehasarightto liveanywhere inKenya.Buttheydeliberatelyavoidquotingtheclausethatdefendsthefreedomandrightagainst invasion, forcefulevictionandtheright toownership. Indefending therightoftheBoranatograzetheircamelsanywhere,itistoaccusetheTurkanasforfarmingorerectingtheirhouseswhichbarsthepresenceoftheanimals.Byallowingthepresenceofthethousandsofcamelsinsuchasmallvillageatshambani,itdis-allowsthepresenceofotherliving.OneisforcedtorepeatthequestiontheTurkanacommunityisasking;WhatisthemotiveoftheBoranaskeepingsomanyanimalsifthereisscarcityofgrazingland?WhydidtheBoranamovetoCampGarbaatthismomentoftheyear?Iftheyareonlyafterfoodfortheiranimals,whykillpeopleandburnhouses?Thechurchandtheschooldestruction,lingersveryseriousquestions;isitatribalclashorareligiousconflict, is itafightover resourcesorfightoverchiefdomdominance, is itpowerwrangleor it iseconomicstrength,istotellwhoisthehostcommunityorthenewcomer?IsitawaytopreparewhowillowntheresourcecitythatIsioloisbeingdesignedtobe?Whoisresponsibleandwhocanhelpavertit?ThelocalleadersandparticularlytheareaMPhasbeenabsentfromthearea.Verylittlehasbeendonetocall foraresolution.Nowisthetimetoseekanequitable justice.Furtherdelaywillescalatetheconflict.Ithasbeenexplained,“itisthecultureoftheBoranapeopletokeepanimals”.Butisittheirculturealsotobehostileandviolent?Theirneighborsalsohavetheirculture.Nowisthetimetodevelopanewcultureofcoexistence.LettheBoranaeldersbesummonedbythestatelawandbeforcedtoacknowledgethattheircultureisnotinisolationandthatitisnotjusttopromotetheirownhavenwithoutcareoftheothers’.Letcultureandtraditionnotbeusedtojustifyorexplainaconflictthathasclaimedlivesanddestroyedproperties.Validatingsuchcultureandtraditionisonlyalimpingpretextthatdoesnotpassthetestofcredibility.
YesterdaywevisitedtheCatholicMissionatCampGarbawhichhostsabove600peopleintheopengroundinverycompromisingcircumstances.IvisitedKiwanja,Eremetandshambanivillageswheretheyhadescapedfrom.ThevillagesofBulagadudandLMDwerealsoemptyaspeoplehadranawayfortheirsafety.Iwassaddenedbytheuglyincidentwhichwefound.Thecatholicmissionaries,Fr.TalloneandFr.Wambuahaveopeneddoorstothechildrenandmothersasotherwomenandmenarespreadacrossthecompound.Fr.Wambuaguidedusthroughthecompound;crowded,withdusty,tornmattress,blankets,wornoutsheetsandallsortsofhouseholdgoodsarescatteredallover.Thedemarcationofoccupancyspaceisthefarthemattresscanreach.Giventhatthecementedcorridorsoftheclergyhouse,thesisters’conventandthoseoftheschoolarenotenough,othersfindspacealongthefenceandunderthetrees.Sincetheschoolisstillon,theyhavetovacatetheplacebefore7.00ambeforepupilscomeandreturnat5.00pmwhentheschooldayisover.ThisisthemostpainfulmomentthatIhavewitnessed.Istoodnearthepolicepostand200mawayIcouldseesmallchildren,womenwithbabiesontheirback,andmencarryingtheiritemspackedinpolythenebagsorsackscomingtothemissionforthenight.Atarrivalitisstillpainfultoseethemrushingtogetwateror
102 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
collectinggrassforfirewoodtocooksomethingwhichyoucanguessit’sjustgrains.Themosquitoesstingleavingpimples.Childrenarecryingastheyscratchthemselvesalloverduetoirritation.Onecanhear thealternatingcryofbabiesacross thecompound.Aswevisitgroupsamoverwhelmedby fear as I see small bonfires scattered inthe entire mission compound. “hawa woteniwaturu(Turkana’s).tulichomewamahomezetu na waboraana” a teenager told us.As I look at the thickets, I could imagine ofthe invasion of snakes, scorpions or othercrawling creatures. Am taken aback and Ido not want to announce my thoughts. Isee the same place has become a toilet. It i sanightmare towalkasonewill be steppingontheexcrementorsurpriseanadultatthecallofnature.Cookingisdoneontheopen.Forthosewhohavesick,agedorsmallbabies intheirfamily,theysufferadoubletragedy.Asthecookingitemsarenotenoughorconducive,thereisalsothedangerofanaccident.Amworriedifwindchangesmindandthegrassaroundcatchfire,someofthechildrenwhoarelyingtheremaybeconsumednevertobediscoveredorrecovered.InthecornerofmyeyesIcanseechildrenandmothersfollowingbehindus,incasewehadsomethingforthem.Iwentforasleeplessnightastheimageswent roundmymind. There is an imminent threat. Escaping to spare their life, theymayjeopardizeit.
There are fleets of people going out of the churchcompound.Theywanttoprovideroomtotheschoolthatisabouttostart.Majorityareeligibletoschool,buttheirsisfaraway.“ourschoolisnothere,itwasthere (pointing the direction), we ran away whencamels came in and the ownerswere shooting us”a STD 3 girl at shambani primary school told me,as I walked her and her family out to nowhere inparticular.Itwasheartbreakingtoseefamiliesleaveonlytogooutofthefence,gatheringroupsastheyhad nothing to do. Their village is across but theycannot dare return. They spend whole day in thesameroutinewaitingforanyhope.Theyareontheir
own,noonecomestospeaktothemexceptthecatholicmissionaries.Thepolicewhoareexpectedtocometotellthemtogobackaresilent.There isanothergroupwhohavegonetocampattheIsiolo police station as a way to draw attention totheir cause.But theyarenotwanted there. “This ismyhomeandIcan’tallowstrangerstostayin.Idon’tknowwho iswho” theOCPD toldme in askinghimwhyhewanted thepeople tovacate theonlyplacethat looked securer. The police station is hostinganother450people. It isapainandnuisancetothepoliceofficers, it is amatterof their reputationandrank “but supposing something happenswhen theyarehere,whowillberesponsible”oneofthepoliceofficer tells complains. But an exchange ensures asone of the elders answers back very bitterly “it isbetterwediehereandsomeonecanreportandbeheldresponsiblethanbeingburnedinthevillage
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 103
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
byyourfriends”.IdiscoverthatthepolicehavearrangedfortwoLorriestotakethepeoplebacktothevillageswheretheyhadbeenchuckedoff.Thingsareindisarray.Itispurportedthatthepolicestationwasn’tsecure.Thepeopledonotwanttogobackinfearofapossibleattackandfearthattheywillbeforgottenandtheyhadnothingtosustainthemselves,sincealltheirbelongshadbeenburneddownorvandalizedbytheBoranainvaders.AsItriedtoengagetheOCPDtoanegotiation,wereachedadealthatmenwillgofirsttosurveythesituationaccompaniedbyacontingentofpolicemen.Ioptedtodrivedownthevillageswiththemasawayofsolidarity.
THE CAMELS OF ISIOLO THAT SHOOT AND BURN
Heaven broke loose. The village is allashes. No house is standing. No sooneras we reached the first village, t h epeoplejumpedoutofthevehicles c r y i n g“look here was my house, look t h i swas my kitchen. Oh! Here, here t h e ycaughtupmybrother,here they k i l l e dhim” the people scattered, each t r y i n gto trace their homestead that was nolonger there. The exercise was guardedby Kenya police. Visible were exercisebooks, metallic and steel items that thefirecouldnotreducetocompleteashes.Thetears,thesoliloquiesandthelamentationsweresopainful.Thejournalistswhohad kept a distance nowcamecloser. Inoticeda young police officerwipingtearsandshaking his head vigorouslyand this hurt me the more. You can onlydiscover there were homesteadswhenyouseebricks,somespared iron sheets, someother household goods that had now beenturnedblack.Beforethe houses were torchedsome were vandalized and properties werescattered outside. The Catholic Church hadnot been burnt. But it had been seriouslyprofaned. The doors hadbeenbroken,thewindows smashed and the glass spread all over. Theholy of holiness, the altar, the tabernacle the mostsacred places had been tampered with and cut intopieces.IcouldnotunderstandthemotiveofdestroyinganddisfiguringthestatueofMary.TheposterbearingtheimageofPopeBenedict16hadbeenbadlypiercedandtherewasdisorderinthechurch.Rosarieswerecutinto pieces. Amanwas able to identify a rosary thatbelongedtohismother.Iblesseditandlethimcarryittoher.Intheschool,everythingwasintotalmessspreadallover.Thefurniturewasdamaged,cutintopiecesorsimply scattered out of place. At the head teacher’soffice,therewasnoplacetostepin.Thedesksandtheshelveshadbeendestroyedandallthematerialssprinkledonthefloor.Textbooks,exercisebooks,packetsofchalkhadbeenlittered.Asimilardreadfulfaceconfrontedusattheteachers’staffroom.Wetouredthevillagecollectingvariousitems;chairs,books,spoonseitherliftedfromtheschool,the
104 BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
churchorhomesteadsandabandonedintheforest.
Ihadneverseensearchamassiveherdofcamelsatoneplaceatonegiventime.Theyfilled thewholeplace.Theyexceeded20.000camels. Thepolicemenhadpushedanequalnumberacrossthe mountains in the previous day. The menin seeing the camels were agitated, theybecame irate. The village elder explains “wesaw the camels first, as we wondered due totheir number, there was shooting and ourhousesbeganto burn”. He narrated how it allstarted.“Wehad not seen the owners, but thecamels. When wereported,wewereridiculedby the police officers; can camels shoot ortorch a house?” a heated discussion ensuredas policemen tried to explain to the elders’dissatisfaction. The situation was getting outofcontrol;IinvitedtheOCPDandhisteamforameetingwiththeeldersandprobablyinvitesomegroupsfromthecamelherderswhowerenotfar.TheofficersandTurkanaeldersacceptedbuttobringaBoranaonboardwasnotviable.Aftera fruitlesshourofconsultationtheOCPDdeclared;“youwill not goback to thebackyardof thepolice station, youeither remainhereor Iwill takeyou to the stadium” Roma l o c u a t acausafinita,Gameshort.At this timeaswesoughtthenextmove, the policeofficers jumped into their veh ic les ,and spade off at a terrific speed.Wewatched them desperately disappearandleaveusbehind.Asthedustcalmeddown,onlythe c a m e l sthat earlier we had known to “shootand torch” and 6 police o f f i c e r swere visible.We are at the m i d d l eof the camels at the battle field. Icalledthegroupforaprayer. Attheendof it, I could not only read my owntensionbutitwasinallthefacesinfrontme.Howcanwegetoutofhere?arewesafe?“Hapakunanjama,wametudanganyatuingiekwamagariyaonasasawametuletahapanakutuachiaadui.Hatunasilahakamawao,tenatukowachache.Hatakanikubaki,hatunachakula.Kwaniniwanatufanyiahivi”.Complainedoneman.
2hourslater,twoGKLorriesbroughtbackthewomenandchildren.Dumpedthemandwentback. Itwas assumed that shelters like tents, food,waterwill beprovidedbut all in vain. Peopleremainedindarkness,thenightwasunusuallychillyanddarkperhapstocelebratethemisfortune.Menorganizedthemselvestoremainawakeguardingtheirfamiliestillthefollowingday.Alllookedexhaustedandvisionless.Theyappearedapeoplewithoutafuturewithwideopeneyesofhopelessnesstosaytheleast.Somemothershadgivenupthestruggleandtheycomplained“kwaniniwasitumalizebadalayakutuangaishahivi.Hatahawaaskarisiwanabuduki, siwatuue,waendawakapumzike?” Igotdisturbedanddisappointed.Whereistheruleoflaw?Wherearetheexecutorsoflaw?WhoaretheleadersofIsiolowhoshouldintervenetorestorehopetothesedisplacedresidents?Whereistheconscienceofthegovernmentofficers?
BASELINE REPORT ON CONFLICT-MAPPING AND PROFILES OF 47 COUNTIES IN KENYA 105
BUILDING A CULTURE OF PEACE IN KENYA
By Fr. Makau Nicholas,
CoordinatorofJusticeandPeaceCommission
ConsolataMissionaries