committed to mutual success...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service...

16
ANNUAL STATEMENT COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS 2015

Upload: others

Post on 09-Oct-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

ANNUAL STATEMENT

COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS

2015

Page 2: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

Provide insurance products that allow our policyholders to conduct their business with the knowledge that they areprotected by a financially strong insurer.We strive for profitable growth through our commitment to individualizedcustomer service and by providing theindependent agent with a stable market for quality insurance products.

Delivering Financial Strength

Commitment to Integrity

Superior Customer Service

Continued Learning and Improvement

Corporate and Social Responsibility

Page 3: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

HARFORD MUTUAL 2015 3

Over 450independent agencies representing

Harford Mutual across7states and the District of Columbia.

Over30,000policies in effect in 2015.

174years of partnering with our agents and policyholders,

providing them with the peace-of-mind service they deserve.

$170.7million in direct written premium,

representing 9.7% growth over 2014.

Our150employees are industry experts and

committed to serving you and your business.

435years of service represented by24employees

who received anniversary awards this year.

$26.6million in NEW business premium written.

Achieved a 92.6%premium retention ratio.

Ended the year with $193.4million in surplus.

2015 AT-A-GLANCE

Since 2010, our written premium has grown $65 million

dollars–an increase of 62%

Page 4: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

4 HARFORD MUTUAL 2015

PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE

Steven D. LinkousPresident and Chief Executive Officer

As Harford Mutual marches forward into its 174th year of safeguarding our policyholders, I am pleased to reportthat the company ended 2015 on a very prosperous note.With nearly all financial measures improved, underwritingrevenue and profitability goals surpassed, and plannedoperational achievements realized, Harford Mutual stands strong and ready to advance into a future of endless opportunities. Good fortune and the tremendouscontributions and support of our team and agency partnersposition us well to face the challenges ahead. We areprepared to serve our policyholders while remainingkeenly focused on our strategies.

Regarding underwriting profitability, it would be fair to describe 2015 as a tale of two halves. Insuredsexperienced above-average losses during the first twoquarters, most notably from the brutal winter, alate-February two-week freeze event, and a handful oflarge fires. At the halfway mark of the calendar, lossexperience turned extremely favorable, bringing the yearto a break-even underwriting position by the end ofSeptember. An outstanding fourth quarter ultimately led tothe company achieving a net combined ratio of 94.9%.

Harford Mutual continued to capitalize on strong agency partner relationships and market opportunitiesthroughout the year in maintaining existing and capturingnew premium revenue. Overall premium retention was an outstanding 92.6%, with policy retention close behindat 86.3%. Premiums retained in the large account segment(greater than $200,000) were even better at 107%. New business was robust throughout the year, even during the typically difficult fourth quarter, whichgenerated 21% of the year's $26.6 million total newpremium, $2.5 million greater than projected. Excellentperformance in both existing and new premiums led to a $15.1 million, 9.7% increase, with the company

exceeding the $170 million direct written premium mark for the first time in our history.

Our financial performance was not the only aspect of 2015 that saw significant change as the year progressed.As the company grows, so does our need for strongleadership at all levels. The additions of Chief FinancialOfficer, General Counsel/Director of Compliance, Director of Human Resources, and Director of PropertyClaims, as well as promotions and new management forour Underwriting team, have altered the face of thecompany while strengthening our core competencies. As we grow and move toward reaching our strategicoperational and profitability goals, our tremendous teamwill be at the helm looking for and introducing innovativeways to guide us.

With a full management roster by mid-year, weimmediately started to see benefit from the implementationof new efforts to support our vision. Service guidelines andinternal audit procedures were created. New employeerelations and benefits programs were introduced. Deeperanalysis of our product diversification was conducted. And, compliance and security protocols were fortified. As a growing company in an increasingly complicatedindustry and regulatory environment, these improvementsensure we are prepared for the future while maximizingoperations today.

The Underwriting team may have seen the most change in 2015. The expansion of the Large Account Unit, formedin 2014, continued throughout the year with the additionof a new team member and produced more than $7million in new business. Complementing our restaurantsegment, a Fine Dining program was introduced and finalpreparations for affording cyber liability coverage to ourpolicyholders, beginning in the spring of 2016, were

Page 5: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

completed. Twenty-five year veteran and Executive Vice President Bob Ohler retired at year’s end, and John Goodin was promoted to Senior Vice President,Commercial Business Services. We reorganized theUnderwriting Department to allow for more specializedand personalized attention at the state level, supplementedstaff to manage the increase in volume and maintain our high service standards, and placed two Directors of Underwriting to guide and oversee the teams.

At Harford Mutual, Committed to Mutual Success is morethan a tagline—it is our guiding principle. Every decisionwe make is made with our insureds, our agents, and ouremployees in mind. We strive to streamline operationalefficiencies to contain costs, ensure our profitability, andprovide for long-term, outstanding service to our insureds.We partner with agents, protecting our franchise value andhelping them grow and succeed. Lastly, but mostimportantly, we work diligently to attract and retain thebest talent possible, as they ultimately deliver the promiseof security to our policyholders and achieve the visionleadership has set forth.

Our focus on this guiding principle works. Thepolicyholders’ surplus has increased $104.5 million,117.7% over the last 10 years, to $193.4 million. We haveincreased the number of agents writing over $1 million indirect written premium with the company from 10 in 2011to 28 as of year-end 2015. The vast majority of our agencypartners have deepened their relationship with thecompany, further illustrating their commitment to, andconfidence in Harford Mutual. And you only need to turn

to pages 6-8 to read of the incredible professionalism and community involvement of our employee workforce.

Looking forward to 2016, we are excited to see criticalprojects nearing completion. After countless hours andteams of consultants on-site and overseas, we will beginimplementation of the first phase of the multi-year projectto replace our core systems, with the launch of packagelines in November. This long-term investment of time andcapital into our infrastructure is not only indicative of ourcommitment to advance our technology platform, but itis a testament of our commitment to our vision of thefuture—one that finds us a strong, stable, and dependableinsurer for our policyholders. We can also see the finishline of the major renovation to our headquarters, a64-year-old iconic landmark in Bel Air, Maryland. Morethan just new paint and furniture, the upgrades andredecorating are symbolic of our ability to adapt andchange as we continue our evolution from a hometowninsurance company to a renowned regional mutual carrierof commercial insurance.

Whether an insured, an agent, a vendor, a board director,or an employee—thank you for your part in this journey.The principles of mutuality do not thrive in a vacuum, butare dependent upon the dedication and contribution of allwho would benefit. We did this together. Thank you forbeing Committed to Mutual Success.

President and Chief Executive Office

HARFORD MUTUAL 2015 5

2015 Annual Employee Photo

Page 6: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

Harford Mutual took an aggressive approach to employeedevelopment in 2015, making changes to accommodateour growth and ensure that we attract and retain a vibrantworkforce to provide the highest caliber of service to ouragents and insureds.

A new Director of Human Resources and a new GeneralCounsel worked to elevate our departmental infrastructurewith new technology and auditing tools to manageincreasing compliance and regulatory reporting andrecord-keeping requirements. We enhanced ourEmployee Education Assistance program to includemaster’s degrees to accommodate a more sophisticatedand competitive insurance marketplace. We expandedour recruiting efforts to include Towson, Stevenson, andSt. Joseph’s Universities in addition to our continuedefforts at Temple University.

These improvements will surely bear fruit in the future, but our past efforts have seen their own success. Kelly Dougherty and Alexander Troutman joined HarfordMutual as Underwriters after interning here last summerand graduating from Temple University with degrees inRisk Management and Insurance. We continued ourinternship program with Edgewood High School Academyof Finance, hosting five students on a shadow day andhiring senior Joi Dixon as our summer accounting intern.The Edgewood program has proven very rewarding for us as we welcomed back Tia Timpson, an intern hereduring her junior and senior years, as our new Treasury &Accounting Assistant. After graduating from EdgewoodHigh School, Tia earned her bachelor's degree in BusinessAdministration from The University of North Carolina atGreensboro and was ready to “return home” to HarfordMutual at the first opportunity.

The development and professionalism of our staff can be seen in their continued advancement in education and industry affiliations. Charmian Hess, MD/DEProduction Underwriter, is the 2016 President ofInsurance Field Representatives of Delaware. SeniorClaims Examiner Caty Hartley is President-Elect of theMaryland CPCU Society. Caty, along with AccountingAssistant Missie Ruff and Underwriter Cheryl Amberman,were invited to lead a roundtable discuss at the 2015Guidewire Conference in San Francisco, where ProgramManager Gail Bianco was a featured panel speaker aswell. And our company can proudly report over a third ofour employees have completed or are in the process ofcompleting their CPCU or other advanced insurancedesignation.

6 HARFORD MUTUAL 2015

EMPLOYEES

DESIGNATIONS EARNED IN 2015• Senior Claims Examiner, Alison Barry, AINS, CPCU• Commercial Underwriter, Mike Borzatti, CPCU• Commercial Underwriter, Jack Griffin, CPCU• Commercial Underwriter, Laura Hoffses, CPCU• Senior Claims Examiner, Laura Kurrle, CPCU• Production Underwriter, Martin Kyper, CPCU• Commercial Underwriter, Kay Sheldon, AAI• Commercial Underwriter, Jennilee Sobczak, AU • Claims Examiner, Joshua Swimmer, AIC

Former Academy of Finance intern and new accounting assistant, Tia Timpson (l) mentors summer intern, Joi Dixon.

A few of the many employees who celebrated anniversary milestones in 2015. Pictured above are March milestone recipients (l to r) Missy Ruff, 10 years; Dawn Carter, 30 years; Jane Gootee, 25 years; and Richard Kipp, 5 years.

Page 7: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

HARFORD MUTUAL 2015 7

YEARS OF SERVICECatherine HartleyRichard Kipp

YEARS OF SERVICE Melissa RuffTimothy RutledgeRegina JenkinsStefanie MohrSharon LeeSusan Hannah

YEARS OF SERVICE Deborah MerkleClare EmmAngela AlaimoMichele WilliamsTara TurnerDeborah McGinley

YEARS OF SERVICE Jane GooteeRobert OhlerMartha SlemakerFrank Kellner IIICharmian HessMichael Winn

YEARS OF SERVICE Dawn CarterSteve LinkousKaren Zink

YEARS OF SERVICE Michele Crisco

LEADERSHIP RETIREMENTOn December 31, 2015, Bob Ohler retired as Executive Vice President after 25 yearsof service with the company. Ohler began his career at Harford Mutual in 1990 withthe Claims Department before transferring to Underwriting in 2003. He was promotedto Executive Vice President in 2015. Under his leadership, Harford Mutual refined itsunderwriting practices helping to achieve a direct written premium growth of $65million in the last five years and a $122 million increase in policyholders’ surplussince 2004. Ohler holds a bachelor’s in marketing from the University of Baltimore.

A respected member of the community, Ohler will continue his service as a BoardMember of the Helping Up Mission in Baltimore City. Ohler was instrumental inpioneering Harford Mutual’s Annual Bocce Tournament for their benefit. The highlyanticipated event, held in early fall, has become a fixture in the company’s numerousinternal charitable giving activities.

5

10

15

25

30

35

SERVICEAWARDS

President/CEO Steve Linkous congratulates Bob Ohler on his retirement.

Bob Ohler, (l) poses with the Bocce BallTournament final teams and Helping UpMission Donor Relations Coordinator,Barry Barnett. The tournament and donations raised $2,426 for the charity.

Page 8: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

8 HARFORD MUTUAL 2015

MEANINGFULLY INVOLVEDHarford Mutual exists to help people. As an insurance company, our veryproduct is designed to be there whenpeople need us most. We are dedicatedto extending that purpose beyond ourproducts and services to the communitieswe serve. In 2015, we elevated ourcommitment to that mission with thedevelopment of our Corporate SocialResponsibility Statement and the additionof a staff position to oversee ourcharitable contributions and volunteerefforts. Season Voelker, Corporate &Community Engagement Coordinator,will manage our corporate and employeegiving, assist in fundraising, partner withlocal agencies and organizations to ensure we are making the most impact, andencourage and lead our employee engagement in non-profit programs. As ourcompany continues to grow, it is our vision to expand our legacy of giving to otherservice areas and champion new projects where we can make a difference.

(L) Harford Mutual was a major sponsor for the Boys & Girls Clubs of HarfordCounty's 25th Anniversary, including purchasing Build-A-Bears for auction andsponsoring 10 members. (Top) Presenting $10,000 to Relay for Life.

Harford Mutual donated more

than $200,000to local charities and

community groups

$1,905was donated to

Komen Race for the Cure® by

employees through bake sales,

Ravens ticket raffle and wearing

jeans on Friday.

$31,000pledged by

employees through payroll

deduction to the United Way

of Central MD

42 patients were helped

because of our Red Cross

Employee Blood Drive

#1fundraising team for

Relay for Life in Harford County

24employee teams

participated in the Annual

Bocce Ball Tournament to

benefit Helping Up Mission

We purchased a truck for the new Habitat for Humanity, Susquehanna ReStore and sent a team ofemployees to the Bel Air home build.

CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY STATEMENT

Harford Mutual Insurance, foundedon the principles of mutuality, iscommitted to being meaningfullyinvolved in the communities weserve. The Company’s charitablegiving focuses on health & humanservices as well as organizations thatsupport a vibrant community.

Harford Mutual defines health &human services as charities that areworking on poverty alleviation,youth development and overallcommunity health & safety.

Page 9: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

HARFORD MUTUAL 2015 9

RISK MANAGEMENTHarford Mutual provides hands-on, customized Loss Control services to insuredsto identify potential risks, make recommendations for improvement, and trainemployees to prevent future occurrences. We will conduct a site and claimsanalysis to detect repeated and latent risk exposure then develop a program toaddress those specific areas.

Our services don’t stop there. Because we operate on the principles of mutuality,it’s in everyone’s best interest to learn and share. In December, in response to lastFebruary’s freeze event and in advance of harsh winter temperatures, we mailedand made available Winter Advisory Packages to agents and their insureds. These“kits” included winter safety posters with messages specific to snow and ice;maintenance tips for property managers to review before and after an event; and achecklist for tenants and unit owners on steps to take to protect their vacant units.

We tailored our safety posters for two large accounts with custom photographyusing their employees and onsite locations to accurately depict risk scenarios and drive the message. And, in an example of true mutual service, our LossControl Consultant, Jeff Okeson, brought together two insureds and facilitated atraining workshop on a piece of safety equipment that one was using and the other was considering.

DAVE ELLIOTT, ARM, CRIS Casualty SpecialistDave has been a Harford Mutualemployee since 2007, with 19 years of safety and losscontrol experience. Prior tojoining Harford Mutual, Daveserved as the Area Risk ControlManager for SuperValu foodstores where he was responsiblefor 130 supermarkets and 30convenience stores across 12states. He specializes in Property,WC, and Liability programs. He’s a member of the AmericanSociety of Safety Engineers and Insurance Loss ControlAssociation and holds theAssociate in Risk Management(ARM®) and the ConstructionRisk and Insurance Specialist(CRIS®) designations.

(L) Our Loss Control Team(R) Jeff Okeson facilitated atraining session betweentwo of our insureds–Hawkins and Sons andCeramic Tile.

“We are very pleased with the support Harford Mutual provides us to trainour staff. It is fantastic to have our insurer provide such excellent training andresources to help us meet our safety goals! With Harford Mutual behind us,we're hoping to achieve 'Safety First' in 2016.

Kelly Boyle, Safety Director for Smith Industries.

Page 10: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

When you’re looking for innovation in the insurancebusiness, looking inward can often yield effectivesolutions. In 2015, Harford Mutual formalized our product development efforts and assembled a team tosystematically review our coverages and appetites andmake recommendations for changes and improvements.We took a multi-disciplinary approach, recruiting stafffrom Claims, Compliance, Marketing, BusinessDevelopment and Underwriting, to make sure weexamined the possibilities from all angles. We mustcontinue to identify opportunities to improve and expandour product offerings to ensure we continue to meet thedemands of our agents and insureds. Our Fine DiningProgram, Large Account Unit, and Cyber Liabilitycoverage offering scheduled for release mid-year 2016,are all examples of this customer-centric focus.

FINE DININGThe development of our new Fine Dining programwas the result of a thorough evaluation process by ourteam. With the addition of four class codes to our HorizonBOP Restaurant program, we are able to recognize theunique characteristics of Fine Dining establishments andprice this business more appropriately. We also reviewedour coverage offerings to ensure we could meet the needsof this unique customer base. Fine Dining restaurants arefull-service restaurants with an upscale menu and anextensive beverage selection. With a highly-trainedwaitstaff and a more ambient and sophisticated décor, thissegment of the restaurant market presents us with anopportunity to diversify our restaurant portfolio andsupports our profitable growth strategy.

LARGE ACCOUNT UNITLaunched in late 2014, our Large Account Unit wasextremely successful in 2015 writing $7.2 million in newbusiness. Again relying on the cross-departmental

expertise of a multi-disciplinary team, the unit membersfrom Underwriting, Claims, Business Development, andLoss Control provided the high-touch service our largeaccount customers expect and deserve. The pursuit oflarge accounts, with a dedicated team responsible forhandling these customers, is not a shift from our corebusiness, but another example of refining our strategiesand committing the appropriate resources required toensure continued profitable growth.

CYBER LIABILITYOur proven capabilities and success in productdevelopment have positioned us well for the launch ofCyber Liability in April. Partnering with the experts at NAS Insurance, we are excited to introduce and offer thiscomprehensive product to our clients. Cyber-attacks affectall size businesses, and experts have found that nearly 80percent of small businesses owners don’t have a plan. Theresource and reference library we will provide along witha $100,000 limit and 1st and 3rd party coverage promisesto make our Cyber Liability a positive enhancement to ourbusinessowner and package policies.

10 HARFORD MUTUAL 2015

DEVELOPMENT FOR SUCCESS

Fine Dining BOPRestaurant Plus ClassificationCodes:

09421—No Sales of Alcohol09431—Alcohol sales up to 30%09441—Alcohol sales from 30-75%09451—BYOB

BACK: Bill Wynne, Loss Control Manager; Karl Hancock, Director of Property Claims & Account Management; Pat Stifler, Business Development Manager. FRONT: Angela Alaimo, Underwriting Supervisor; Kay Sheldon, Commercial Underwriter; Christopher D’Alessio, Field Underwriting Specialist

Page 11: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

HARFORD MUTUAL 2015 11

REGIONAL CARRIERSTATE OVERVIEW

Harford Mutual monitors and maintains state-specific goals down to the agency level. We strive to be the carrier of choice in each state byproviding products and pricing that are competitive within the state andregional marketplace. We have made adjustments to our appetite toensure the most profitable menu of offerings.

DELAWAREMoved to become our 3rd largest state with2015 direct written premium (DWP) of $17M.We remain cautious writing business in thecoastal region of the state, with our growthplans concentrated in New Castle County. Wehave limited representation in Delaware with14 appointed agencies, all with meaningfulvolume with the company. In order to maintainour current growth trajectory, we must beconsidered a core carrier for each of our partneragencies. The mix of business is spread evenlyacross all target segments, which supports ouroverall diversification strategy.

MARYLANDMaryland is our largest state representing 32.8% of our total book, with $56M in directwritten premium. Of our 94 resident agencies,11 wrote direct written premium above $1Mand 27 above $500,000. In 2016, we will focus on expanding our fine dining segment,increasing our commercial lessor’s risk writings, and driving middle market and large account opportunities.

NEW JERSEYNew Jersey experienced significant growth and moved up one position to become our 6thlargest state. Experiencing 24.4% growth in2015, the state ended the year at $14.1M with$4.1M in new business written. Middle marketproduction from domiciled agencies drives oursuccess in the state, along with our strongpartnership with the Iroquois Group.

PENNSYLVANIAServiced by two production underwriters,Pennsylvania remains our 2nd largest state withyear-end 2015 DWP of $32.8M. New businessof $4.9M and strong premium retention led to6.8% growth. With a 2015 combined ratio of

103%, we continue to focus on drivingunderwriting strategies aimed at improving ourloss ratio. We employ a conservative workers’compensation underwriting strategy, withparticular focus on our contracting book of business. The state presents considerableopportunity for growth in the middle market and large account arena.

TENNESSEETennessee remains our smallest state withyear-end 2015 DWP of $6M. $1.1M in newbusiness premium was written and renewalpremium retention finished the year at 86.2%.The direct case loss ratio was 38.13%, which is of particular importance as we have nowexperienced two consecutive profitable yearsfollowing five consecutive unprofitable yearsfrom 2009 - 2013. The state is positioned forgrowth in 2016.

VIRGINIAVirginia is our 4th largest state ending 2015 with $16.8M in DWP, $2.9M in new business,resulting in 17.8% growth. Virginia newbusiness production reached an all-time high at $2.9M for the year. The addition of a newproduction underwriter, solidifying a strongunderwriting team, along with considerablesupport from our partner agencies, all drove our success in 2015.

WASHINGTON DCThe District of Columbia holds the number fiveslot, with 2015 year-end DWP of $15M, anincrease of 15.18% over prior year. $1.8M innew business was written with a renewalpremium retention percentage over 100%. Our production continues to be driven byagents in surrounding states, with only two DC domiciled agents represented.

7th largest state in DWP

NORTH CAROLINA

79% of our North Carolina book is small business, accountswith written premium below$25,000. And while we remaincommitted to this segment of themarket, we believe there isconsiderable opportunity to writelarger accounts in the state. Withthat in mind, we added a secondProduction Underwriter to thestate in 2015 with primaryresponsibility for identifyingmiddle market and large accountopportunities.

TNNC

PA

NJ

VA

DE

MDDC

$12.9Min DWP

$1.7Min new business

Good spread of premium across all target segments of business

2015 direct case loss ratio of 40.79%

81active agencies located in the central and western regions of the state

Strong partnership with the Keystone Insurers Group

SPOTLIGHT ON

Page 12: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

12 HARFORD MUTUAL 2015

Condensed Consolidated Statutory Financial Report

200

150

100

50

0

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS

145.8 162.6 187.4 194.6 193.4

Polic

yholde

rs’ Surplus

(in m

illio

ns)

200

150

100

50

0

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

112.9 123.7 140.4 155.6 170.7

Direct W

ritten

Premiums

(in m

illio

ns) 20

15

10

5

0

-52011 2012 2013 2014 2015

-1.9 15.1 14.6 10.8 13.6

Net In

come

(in m

illio

ns)

Policyholders’ Surplus (in millions)

NET INCOMENet Income after Federal IncomeTax ended 2015 at a healthy$13.58 million, against a plan of$8.43 million. We continue toemploy a conservative investmentstrategy and focus on coreunderwriting fundamentals in order to achieve our net incomeexpectations on a consistent basisyear-over-year.

200

150

100

50

02011 2012 2013 2014 2015

POLICYHOLDERS’ SURPLUSWhile our net underwriting gainwas strong at $5.22 million andordinary investment income waspositive at $4.44 million,unrealized losses in our equityportfolio, along with sizeableexpenditures for our Core SystemReplacement Project, resulted in a $1.2 million drop inPolicyholders’ Surplus to $193.4 million. However, over the last 10 years, PHS has grown by $104.5 million, or 117.7%. In addition, our leverage ratioremains strong at 0.78:1.

DIRECT WRITTEN PREMIUMDriven by a solid premiumretention ratio of 92.6%, andcontinued momentum on the newbusiness front with $26.6 millionwritten in 2015, direct writtenpremium grew by 9.7% to anall-time high of $170.7 million.With the segmentation of ourbusiness into three distinct divisionsbased on account premium size,Small < $25k, Middle $25k -$200k, and Large >$200k, we’vebeen able to devote the properamount of resources to eachsegment, providing the appropriatelevel of service required from anUnderwriting, Loss Control, andClaims perspective.

Direct Written Premiums (in millions)

200

150

100

50

0

Net Income (in millions)

20

15

10

5

0

-5

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

145.8 162.6 187.4 194.6 193.4 112.9 123.7 140.4 155.6 170.7 -1.9 15.1 14.6 10.8 13.6

Page 13: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

HARFORD MUTUAL 2015 13

STATEMENTS OF ADMITTED ASSETS, LIABILITIES AND SURPLUS as of

Bonds

Common Stocks

Real Estate

Cash and Short-Term Investments

Premiums and Agents’ Balances

Other Assets

Total Admitted Assets

Unpaid Losses and Loss Adjustment Expenses

Unearned Premiums

Other Liabilities

Total Liabilities

Total Policyholders’ Surplus

Total Liabilities and Surplus

STATEMENTS OF INCOME for the years ended

Net Premiums Earned

Losses and Loss Adjustment Expenses

Other Underwriting Expenses

Net Underwriting Gain

Investment Income

Other Income

Income Tax (Expense)

Net Income

$ 207,818

117,096

4,551

35,075

42,537

6,214

$ 413,291

$ 114,982

78,631

26,235

219,848

193,443

$ 413,291

$ 143,853

87,631

51,007

5,215

9,496

42

(1,171)

$ 13,582

12/31/2015 12/31/2014

12/31/2015 12/31/2014

Condensed Consolidated Statutory Financial Report (in thousands)

New business outpaced plan throughout the year as a result of our effective business development efforts. As we continue to establish ourselves as a viable large account player, while remaining committed togrowing our small and middle market business, we realized a significant increase in large account productionwriting more than $7 million new in 2015 compared to $1.7 million in the prior year. Overall new businessproduction ended at $26.6 million, $2.5 million above plan.

$ 198,564

121,430

3,992

31,227

40,085

2,965

$ 398,263

$ 102,138

72,471

29,085

203,694

194,569

$ 398,263

$ 129,981

80,980

46,961

2,040

9,592

49

(912)

$ 10,769

We broke the $170 million direct written mark for the firsttime in the company’s history.

Page 14: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

14 HARFORD MUTUAL 2015

ROBERT D. MCDORMAN, JR.Retired Principal, Investment Counselors of Maryland

CLARENCE C. BOYLE, JR.President, Boyle Buick GMC Truck

SPENCER M. ROMANRetired President and COO, AAA Mid-AtlanticInsurance Group

ABIGAIL E. SMITHPresident, Abigail E. Smith, Associates, P.A.

STEVEN D. LINKOUSPresident and CEO, The Harford Mutual Insurance Companies

STEPHEN T. SCOTTChairmanRetired Principal, InvestmentCounselors of Maryland

DONALD C. FRYPresident and CEOGreater Baltimore Committee

ALBERT J. MEZZANOTTE, JR.Partner, Whiteford, Taylor &Preston, LLP

ATWOOD COLLINS, IIIExecutive Vice President, M&T

JAMES J. KENNEDYRetired President and CEO,Ohio Mutual Insurance Group

BOARD OF DIRECTORS

KENNETH G. THOMPSONAssistant Vice President andController

JOHN D. GOODINSenior Vice President,Commercial Business Services

KAREN L. MASHINSKIVice President and ChiefFinancial Officer

STEVEN D. LINKOUSPresident and Chief Executive Officer

STEPHEN M. FABIANVice President and ChiefInformation Officer

FRANK P. KELLNER, IIIVice President, Claims andCorporate Secretary

JEFFREY S. RINKVice President, Marketing andBusiness Development

JUNE A. POOLEVice President and Treasurer

Standing from left to right

Standing from left to right

MCDORMAN, JR. | BOYLE, JR. | ROMAN | SMITH | LINKOUS | SCOTT | FRY | MEZZANOTTE, JR. | COLLINS, III | KENNEDY

OFFICERSTHOMPSON | GOODIN | MASHINSKI | LINKOUS | FABIAN | KELLNER, III | RINK | POOLE

Page 15: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

HARFORD MUTUAL 2015 15

Harford Mutual lost a dear friend and respected Director withthe passing of James D. Hardesty on May 12, 2015. Jim servedas a Director on our board for 28 years, including roles asVice-Chairman, Chair of the Compensation Committee, andmember of various other committees during his tenure.

Born in Baltimore and raised in Baltimore County, Jimgraduated from Gilman School before earning his bachelor’sdegree from Georgetown University in 1968 and his master’sdegree in business from Columbia University in 1970. Hiscareer started in the mailroom at Alex. Brown & Sons followinghigh school graduation. He credited the energy from the tradingfloor there with his interest in the financial sector, taking a jobas an analyst with Mercantile–Safe Deposit and Trust Co. aftergraduating from Columbia. After a brief stint at the InvestmentCounselors of Maryland in 1972, Jim returned to Mercantilewhere he stayed until co-founding Hardesty CapitalManagement in 1995. Serving as board chairman, marketstrategist and chief economist, Jim led Hardesty CapitalManagement’s growth to nearly $1 billion in assets managedbefore he retired in April 2015.

In addition to serving on our Board, Jim was a former boardmember of Gilman School, Walters Art Museum, and Family &Children’s Services of Central Maryland. He was a member ofthe Maryland Club and Elkridge Club and a communicant forShrine of the Sacred Heart Church in Mount Washington.

The Board of Directors at Harford Mutual will long rememberthe numerous contributions, insight, wit, and wisdom that Jimblessed us and the company with over so many years.

"Jim will be remembered forhis impressive analytical skills,

a genuine interest andappreciation of history as well

as his investment wisdom. He could not resist

storytelling, a form ofentertainment he employed

often and well."STEPHEN T. SCOTT, CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD

IN MEMORIAM JAMES D. HARDESTY

Page 16: COMMITTED TO MUTUAL SUCCESS...committed to serving you and your business. 435 years of service represented by24 employees who received anniversary awards this year. $26.6 million in

THE HARFORD MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANIES200 North Main StreetBel Air, Maryland 21014-3544800-638-3669

HARFORDMUTUAL.COMThe Harford Mutual Insurance Company, Founded 1842Firstline National Insurance Company, Founded 1988