cmptbr viii fiiiahgikl l-'lma^geivekt mp accountihg...
TRANSCRIPT
346
CmPTBR VIII
FIIIAHGIkL l-'lMA GEIvEKT MP ACCOUNTIHG
V m . l Frame work;
In bus iness management, a very Ijiiportant place
amongst t h e f u n c t i o n a l a r ea s has been ass igned t o the
f inance f u n c t i o n . I t i s as much due t o the f a c t t h a t
almost a l l a c t i - v i t i e s in a Uis iness o r g a n i s a t i o n have
f i n a n c i a l i m p l i c a t i o n s in the f i n a l a n a l y s i s . Ear l ier^ . ,
the finajice funct ion \vas mainly confined t o the procurement '
of funds for bus ines s and keeping of accura te f i n a n c i a l
r e c o r d s . The modern concept of f inance func t ion h a s ,
however, expended far beyond these l i m i t e d f u n c t i o n s .
A.part from the t r a d i t i o n a l f unc t i ons of f i n a n c e , the
f i n a n c i a l manager i s now concerned v,;ith .(i) a l l o c a t i n g
funds t o s p e c i f i c a s s e t s , and ( i i ) o b t a m i n g the b e s t
mix of f inanc ing ±n r e l a t i o n to the o v e r a l l v a l u a t i o n ^
of the f i r m . For i d e n t i f y i n g the p r a c t i c e s in the a rea
of f i n a n c e , t he framework which we suggest here t a k e s
i n t o account an o v e r a l l view of the f inance f u n c t i o n .
As such, the ve r ious func t ions have been grouped under
two broacl c l r . s s i f i c a t i o n s , v i z . , ( i ) F inance , and
( i i ) Accounting and C o n t r o l .
V I I I . 1.1 Fin&nce;
The func t ions of f inance can be broken do\<m i n t o
t h r e e major d e c i s i o n s the firm must t ake^ • the inves tment
1. Van l lcrno, James C , F i n a n c i a l Management and P o l i c y , T h i i ' d L d . , P ren t ice - , HaJ.l of I n d i a , New D e l h i , 1975,P»3'
2 . I b i d . , p . 10.
347
decis ion, the financing decision, and the dividend decis ion.
F inancia l manageaient invol-ves dec i s ion-making in these
three a r ea s . Since these decis ions are i n t e r r e l a t e d ,
they Eust he ttilien j o i n t l y . ^ q)tiinum conibination of
these decisions v/ill "maximise" the objective of the firm.
VI I I . 1 .1.1 In-yeEtment Decision
Inves.Ui^cnt decision invol-ves managing the use
of funds in ousiness. Because the funds are invested dSSSJSt
e i the r in fixed/or in working c a p i t a l , these decisions
na tu ra l ly r e l a t e to the acquis i t ion and management of
00th fixed and'* current assets-, ^s regards fixed a s s e t s ,
a major as^yect of the decision relatt-;s to investment
policy, or what i s more commonly laio;^, c a p i t a l budgeting.
Capi ta l budgeting i s the a l locat ion of cap i t a l to investment
proposals whose benef i ts are to be r ea l i s ed over a long
period in tht fu.ture ^ In viev; of the uncer ta in ty and
r i s k associated \>Q.th the fu ture , c a p i t a l pro jec ts have to
be properly evaluated in r e l a t i o n to t h e i r expected
r e tu rn and r i s k , on the one hand, and the ' cos t of c a p i t a l '
for financing these pro jec t s , on the o ther .
In addit ion to se lect ing new investments, a firm
must manage ex is t ing asse ts e f f i c i e n t l y . However, here
the f inanc ia l manager i s more concerned with the management
of current a s s e t s , v i z . , inventory, receivables and cash.
Thus, inventory management, c rddi t policy and determination
of a proper l eve l of l i q u i d i t y for the firm become the
main concern of the f inanc ia l manager. 4.11 these decisions
348
involve the a l loca t ion and in-vestriient of capi ta l jno l e s s
thaji c ap i t a l budgeting. A.s such, the investment decision
perhaps becomes the most important of the three finance
functions and i t u l t ima te ly determines the t o t a l amount
and composition of asse t s held by a firm ( i . e . , i t s asse t -
s t ruc tu re ) as well as the f i rm ' s bus iness- r i sk complexion.
VIII . 1.1.2 Financing Decision
The second major area of finance is the financing
decis ion . I t involves managing the acquis i t ion of funds.
Here, the f inanc ia l manager i s d i r e c t l y concerned: with
the sources of funds - both long-term and short-terra
- available to hiin. Before taking the f ina l decisions
about the sources of financing, ho\7ever, he has to convince
hifciself about the i r d e s i r a b i l i t y . L.s such, fins.ncing
decision i s ju l t ima te ly j concerned with determining the
best financing mix, or c a p i t a l s t ructure of the firm.
An optimal mix i s one tha t minimises the overal l cost
of cap i t a l as well as the f inancia l r i s k .
The funds are required both for long-term and
short-term purposes. The long-iterm requirements of funds
would depend on cap i t a l expenditure incurred on acquiring
VcJ'ious physical resources for f a c i l i t a t i n g production
and other opera t ions . These funds are invested in fixed
assets l i ke plant and machinery, land and building (including
tea Ixishes in tea indus t ry ) , furni tures and f i x tu r e s ,
e t c . Since these a s se t s depreciate over a period of time
due to wear and tear or obsolesence, they need constant
replacements, addit ions and a l t e r a t i o n s . ^11 these aspects
349
ha^e to be studied not only for assessing the oA;erall
reouirernent of long-term funds tu t also for phasing out
the cap i t a l s t ructure in the hest i n t e r e s t of the firm.
The sh or t-term finane in g, on the other hand,
dependsupcn the v/orkjjig c a p i t a l needs Of the business .
ks mentioned e a r l i e r , the working c a p i t a l requirements
are determined by the le-vel of current a s se t s a. firm
has to keep. Because the current asse ts are convertible
in to cash within the short-run (one year ) , these funds
heep on c i r cu la t ing continuously - from cash to inventory
to rece ivables to cash - and, thus , determine the l i q u i d i t y
of a f irm. Liquidi ty, by de f in i t ion , i s the a b i l i t y to
r e a l i s e value in money, the most l i c p i d a s s e t s ; i t i s a
function of the time necessary to convert an asse t in to
money. Longer t h i s period, higher wil l be the requirement
of cash for meeting day to day expenditure, including
v;ages.
The sources of funds avai lable to a firm are
tvjo, viz .,U)internal, and ( i i ) ex t e rna l . The former cons is t s
cf o\^mership cap i t a l tha t comes e i ther from equity ( r i sk
cap i ta l ) or re ta ined earnings, or both . The external
scvirfe cf funds involves borrovjed c a p i t a l tha t may be both
long-term and short-term, depending upon the requirements
of a f irm. A.11 these sources cf funds u l t imate ly determine
the f i rm's c ap i t a l s t r uc tu r e , i t s f inanc ia l r i s k and i t s
cost cf c a p i t a l .
In dividend decision, the f inancia l manager i s
concerned with the management of income. Here, the decision
350
r e l a t e s to the dividend policy and in t e rna l financing
- tha t i s , the use of net inccnie af ter t a x e s . The dividend-
payout r a t i o determines the portion of income paid to
shareholders or the v/ithdra\^/als by the ovmers in the case
of non-incorporated firms as well as the aiiiount of earnings
re ta ined in the firm. This decision i s l inked with the
financing decision and depends, to a la.rge ex ten t , upon
the f i rm 's need for funds. The firm may need funds for
working c a p i t a l , replacement and renovation, expansion
ejid/or d ive r s i f i c a t i on , and re ta ined earnings may prove
to be a good and ready source of funds for these purposes.
VII 1.1.2 i c counting and Control :
i^ccounting may be defined as the process of
ident i fying, c lass i fy ing , recording, summarising, cuialysing,
and communicating economic information. The scope of
accounting has expanded tremendously over the years aixl
ncv; i t includes not only record keeping but also a host
of ana ly t i ca l and control tools and techniques. Cost and
management accounting have assumed a ro le of great
significance in 8.n accounting system. For the purpose
of present study, however, we ident i fy four major aspects
of accounting as our framework. These are :<i)Ilecord
keeping; ( i i ) Analyt ical viork or Tools; ( i i i ) Budgeting:
and ( iv) Report ing.
V m . 1.2.1 Record Keeping;
Record keeping, often knovm as book-keeping and
accounting, i s t r a d i t i o n a l l y the primary function of
accounting. Here we study the methods of recording
351
f inanc ia l t ransac t ions of a business e n t i t y , the i r
c l a s s i f i c a t i o n and surnnarisation in accordance with the
generally accepted p r inc ip l e s , conventions and concepts '
of accounting. The ul t imate purpose of record keeping
function of accounting i s to prepare, a t the end of an
accounting period, the f ina l accounts of the firm, v i z . ,
H ) Prof i t and Loss Ai-ccount, and ( i i ) Balance S-heet. These
are the tv/o most important f inancia l statements of a /"
firm in respect of i t s en t i r e business operations for a
given per iod. They are able to t e l l us about the f inancia l
pos i t ion of the firm, i t s c a p i t a l s t ructure ,and i t s
p r o f i t a b i l i t y as v;ell as overa l l cost s t ructure for a
given per iod.
VIII . 1.2 .2 A-nalytical VJ<ork
The ana ly t i ca l aspect of accounting comprises
the various too l s and techniques of f inancia l ana lys i s .
These may include, i n t e r - a l l a , Aj2counting Rat ios , Funds /
Flov; Statement, and Cost-Volume-Prof i t (CVP), Break-even
and a Marginal analyses, e t c . These analyses provide
useful information to management about the i r past performance
aPxd help them in planning and con t ro l ,
VI I I . 1.2.3 Budgeting
Budgeting i s a v;ell-developed system of pl,anning
and control of a f i rm's operations for a given period in
the fu tu r e . The future a c t i v i t i e s are guided by a number /
of budgets tha t a firm prepares . These budgets are divided
in to two pa r t , v i z . , ( i ) Capi ta l Budgeting which re la tes
to the long-term cap i t a l expenditure, and ( i i ) Revenue
352
Budgeting for short-term income and expendi ture . Hevenue
"Liidgets are generally prepared for a period of twelve
months and are su'o-di-vided in to ( i ) Sales Budget,
( i i ) Production Budget, ( i i i ) Direct Expenditure Budget,
(i"v) Ind i rec t Expenditure Budget, (-v) Cash Budget, and
the l i k e . Depending upon the nature and size of the business,
these re-venue budgets may be further divided into sub-
budgets. Uith the help of these budgets, the managements
are able to control the en t i r e operations by comparing
the ac tua l performance with the budget (or ' s t anda rd ' )
and taking necessary correc t ive act ions to cor rec t the
devia t ions , if any. This system of control through budgets
i s widely practised in large as well as small business
organisat ions , and i s known as Budgeting Control .
VIII .2 IRractices in Kangra Tea Industry
In general , a number of the functions of finance
are conspicuous by the i r absence in the small- industry
sector in Ind ia . More often than not , f inanc ia l management
in small u n i t s i s taken to mean merely prociarement of
funds and t r a d i t i o n a l accounting (record keeping) . Kangra
t e a indust ry i s no exception. As the study of the u n i t s
under reference shows, the management of these u n i t s are,
quite ignorant of most of the f inanc ia l management tools
and techniques. Even the i r accounting system is defec t ive .
A number of the u n i t s were not able to provide necessary
information, because often the i r accounting i s l imited
to a bare minimum, to f u l f i l ce r ta in s t a tu to ry requirements.
However, a general idea about the finance and accounting
p rac t i ce s in Kangra tea indus t ry can be had from the
353
analysis of cases . These are discussed belov;.
VIII .2 .1 Finance
I t has already been mentioned in Chapter I t h a t ,
apart from the cooperative u n i t , the present owners of
the tea u n i t s in Kangra acquired t he i r t ea gardens from
the i r o r ig ina l English owners a t quite low c o s t s . So
long the going was good,par t icular ly in the i n i t i a l stages
when- the bushes \^re young and ijroductive, they never
bothered about proper management of funds and income .
As a r e s u l t , earnings were not properly ploughed back for
replacement, renovation, rep lan ta t ion or augmenting v/orking
c a p i t a l . Other sources of funds, general ly avai lable to
tea indust ry in the country, tA ere not properly tapped.
There appears to be, since very beginning, no f inancia l
planning as regards investment, financing or dividend
dec i s ions . Hencejthe present pl ight of t h i s industry tha t
has landed almost every single tea u n i t in Kangra in to
dire f inanc ia l s t r i ngenc ie s .
In view of t h i s s t a te of a f f a i r s , our discussion
here has. been r e s t r i c t e d to ( i ) the c a p i t a l s t ructure of
the u n i t s under study, and ( i i ) the i r f inanc ia l requirements,
both long-term and shor t - term. &>. br ief reference sha l l
be made of the various sources of funds avai lable to the
indus t ry .
VIII .2 .1 .1 Capi tal Structure
S t r i c t l y speaking, c a p i t a l s t ructure r e f e r s to
the basket of financing avai lable to a firm on a par t icu la r
d a t e . Since the sources of funds in t ha t basket are generally
354
CD O
o a
H
o
0) 44
CD i>
•H +3 cd U 0) r o
o o o o n
u cd GQ
^ CD >. P
C'j ^ p -P C/Q n o •H
C3N a V-
4 J <D •H B-i
a ;::s X CD (-" r ^
-P > i
CM c O cd P^
CD S •-C) O ro o Q C ^
O CITN a v-0) EH
ro
X! c\J
=4
CO
CO
I • ^ I
ON CO CJO C\J OJ o CD o c
•% • V r*
V - ^^ if; \— o if; CM
CO
(D
ON
s CM
o vO
vO
00 O o o V " I>-V— C^ CM
«« 0\ » N
no O C7N V - vO .^ CM (>• CM
1 •> V -
vO vD CMl ro J- CO [ > . ~ CO
# s « e«
UA [ > - OJ T — CM T — V —
CVJ
no
CM CVJ
c\J lr\ m o O CM OJ t>- lr> evil J-^ f^ O- CM f^ o en c^ ro ITN O CM ^
f^ O ^ CO ITN t o , o CM vO col C3N o-• * JX • V • N #« #V r% «« » H | • • s
J - ITN O ON OJ no vO CO CO J- J -V - V - ICN 1
( > • ^ r vO 1 iS o
m •H K 0 ^ rf TJ •H p
o 0) H
P a
in
•H ?H ,-Q fH o O H o cd o •H p H -'^ •H ^ > c^ F> •H r Q «4 ^Q cJ •H •r j r j rf PH n n ntfl h ' ' ^
•H !H' a fH r j H i-q CD p o T l P^ c ^
P C/J •H o P p P O CO to > 5 CO O fH G P ^ •H o ^ ^ EH o CD fn <D ?• a ^ CD •~pjr
U O P O o c ^ ^ U r^:: P!
^ M :3 P p p ::i c;3 M ^ M c;3 O en CD
H
p •H ft
CO
cJ H CJ ft
CJ ; 3
K ca n
o
o ro .-'-1 ' O
cc5 OJ P
CM <u CO
o EH
O pn c/3
fO
CO
• H
O u u o m
o
CO
u
p o
p o
US c/3
H
p O
EH
\
C O
CON
oo
CV)
CM CM
O
-4
o EH
I
CD in
B o 13
- p 0)
w CO
<4
- p 0) 0)
CD O
H
o -p cd •Tj •H H O m
O O
f> •H -P ffi ;H 0) ft o en O ON
355
- P • H
CM O
0)
o o
4 J
o
H
o w
d>
H
Ui
<D - P cd
- p
m
rf ON O T -
PO
ft !=: O rn
EH
X c\i
w
^ '- J- ^~
O O O N ^ ^ CO
CO vO
^ - CO
CN- O
^ CM
O o o
CO o o r o J - [>- (>-u S [>- ITN
CO
CO
O
4 J T^ Q) CD O 01 i
< H -P •5 G 0) ,E; !M m iH U rf si ;3 o rq o
O -P
(D
M
^ ' ^
W - p
O
a ^ --^ o
CQ C H
(J
C M
O
-P
M -P 0
CO
<4
o PH
O •^ <D O O o q q-H ^ d O
^ -'^ T j -P
-4 o
CO c\j
\ !>- I cv ! ox I
o J-
o 4. c \0 OJ
#* v t • s
ITN rvj
H
• P O
-J3
\
tfN CO
' - CM C\J C\J O 1-CN
ON IfN ICN I r o ON 1-CN
f ^ CM
l>- o C\j ON CO C!N O C\J QJ tN. oo ^UN V - CO ON
o ON
ON ^
V
o vO UN '\— CD Y— \0 VO CvJ CO 0\ O
^ «s ^ • V
CU OJ oo ON CO [ > - o
(7s CO CO o j I C^ J- J- CK J" • -l > - C7N CN J -
O - !> - CO CM 9 J - V- CM
J "
' - ^ w 0) H O
•H
(1) P-
>^ U CD ^
-4
-p <D M CO
(D
•H
m
• H
O Ci
T^ bU d
•a s •d +:>
Ti H s •H s f§ f
o o
- p
OJ ?•
•H
in CD
. q -P O
ICN Q\
J- I
n
-p o
EH
c/1
(1); Cfl to
CD
•p o
o
CO 0) CO CO O
a ^~-> -p CO CD
CO -<
w -p CO
a P! (D O f ^ •H
-P -P CO •H 0) +3 f> O q •H
M FI4
CO
0
-p o
CM CO 00
CM OJ
CO V o o
4s CO ! o VO 1>-
»<k • s r ^ ND a\ 1 CJN J-CTs 0^ o J- (N.
CO • H CO > 5
H cd
CO ccJ
O
0) O
g 01
356 determined by the composition of a s se t s in which these
funds are invested, these have tc be analysed alon^with
the l a t t e r . The study of c a p i t a l s t ruc tu re , therefore ,
r e l a t e s both to il) the L i a b i l i t y s t ruc tu re , and ( i i ) the
Afccets s t ructure of the u n i t s under study. The balaaice
sheets ai'e the riiain s t^ teuent s&iowing the cap i t a l stixicture
of a firm on a par t icu lar d a t e . Hci/e-ver, here our
discussion sha l l be l imited to only three u n i t s (3 , X, and
"i)» The management of u n i t Z refused permission to
reproduce i t s balance sheet . Unit Vi, on the other hand,
does not prepare i t s balance sheet separa te ly , because a sKeet
combined balance/^is prepared for a l l the three u n i t s of
t h i s firm at headquar ters .
Reported in Tables VIILI-A. and 3diX?5 the res t ruc tured
balance sheets of the three u n i t s for 1972- : r.a 1973. kn
idea about the l i a b i l i t y and asse t pa t te rns may be had
therefrom. The asse t - s t ruc tu re in Kangra t ea u n i t s is
dominated by the fixed asse t s which account for 70 per cent
or more of t o t a l tangible a s s e t s . As regards the l i a b i l i t y
s t ruc tu re , the major sources of funds remain to be net
worth {owners' funds or equi ty) except in the case of
the co-operative un i t which has heavi ly depended on
borrowings from the Tea Board of India and s t a te government,
as t he i r c a p i t a l i s almost t o t a l l y wiped off due to
accumulation of losses over the years .
VIII .2 .1.2 F inaneia 1 Re qu irement s
i i . Long-term, heeds
The long term needs of tea u n i t s in Kangr a may be
H a -p o
EH
CO
1 -p 1 CO
u-ri en CD Q) g^ CU H -ra • ^ C^ S -H M P o •p Q> Q) 3 q o +^
^ PH Q) r - ^
CO .;:l o ^^ • ' - ^ r ^
W O O CH d O O S
> ^ --d Q) (D
c: o •H 0) ocj ^ - i 3 H O c i . d o ©
:2: -p ^
tu3
O 4J -H G H
W ITJ H -P H -H m ftijCH o a> a G
c
o fr; rf M
M
, 1 pi
d Q) e •H -Q CD CH ;4 a O cd
M - P + J
O 4 J •P
^ rf H O a ^
0
•P
0) ^4
1 ^ •H o
o •ci o O Si
O - P
vO
liA
J-
rO
OJ
m
H
vO
O o o o o
^ X
^ ^ ^
cd oj oj : H H H H
UN O t N O 1>- J- J- ITN
• • • • \— C\J CM CM
o o O 8 6 o o 8 o o o o •* r « »* •* o o I T N o
J- o CM o
o o O o o O 8 o • o o o O o o o 8 o o o o O o o o o o o
• N 9\ « N v« « s • V • N 0> • s
1r> o o ITN o •Lr\ p o p CM I f N o CM p CM ITN o "UA T — CM V - \ r \ CM
sn Q) F-* a C o tsO 0) to o o
•H nj -p u •H •H 4-3 -P m CD -P -P OJ CO >> >5 l=\ «j rf
+3 X^ w l=\ -P -P • s::; CD O S ^ - 4
o Q> ^ H f n u CCl Q ^ CU « B « M 0)
cd Is g s < 1 ^ . g s H fH 0 S -H cd Is O S o •H fH O
• o © •' la -P O :s 0 o fH 0) O o f i t ^ Ol f5 CO f'-t EH fi^pcj a &H Cr
O 8 o O O 8 o O
1
O
o O
o ON
CM CM
CO
0)
-P o CD
O
O
o
ON I>-
o
CO to CO 0 0) o
^ ^ • p -p -p o o o
x: CD
CO
pq X ?H N
358
for nev; p lant ing, rep lan t ing , processing machinery and
factory "Duildings. In Chapter IX on rep lan ta t ion management,
i t has been explained tha t for t he survival of industry ,
r ep lan ta t ion has to be a continuous process and 6/0 of''
the area under tea has to be replanted every five years .
The rep lan ta t ion costs work out to be Rs. 12,000 per hec ta re .
The f inanc ia l needs of various un i t s under study may be
estiiiiated for next f ive yOcirs; i t wil l comprise the cost
of replac ing some machines plus the costs cf r ep l an t a t i on .
The di f ferent u n i t s have estimated the i r long-term fine^ncial
rccjuirements rougi ly on the above b a s i s . These are shovm
±n Table V I I I . 2 .
Costs of rep lan t ing in the tsCole VIII .2 have
been calculsited by imlt iplying the area byxis.12,000 and
tha t of i n f i l l i n g by multiplying the area by iLs.2250
(cf. chapter IX). Most of the planters are thinking of
get t ing the bulk cf the i r leaf processed by the co-operative
processing un i t ' s . S-o they do not wish to go for major
rei^lacements of machinery. of
The management I u n i t s under study fee l tiiat the i r
en t i re long-term cap i t a l requirements for the next five
years are not needed immediately, ivc cor ding to the i r
rep lan ta t ion plans and other needs, these may be phased
out, on an annual ba s i s , for the next five years . This
has been shovm in Table VII I .3
CO
-p
H
a o
EH
U
<D
- P CM •H
•P
id
CD
o o a1
o
-P CO
Fq
O
CD
o o
-p
• p
en
H
O o o o o
o o o o o
CO m m U)
O O O
o
o o o
'Lr^ v O
CM
O O O
9s
O o o
;§ ^ H
J-c\i
o o o ON
o o o o CM
H
OJ
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o • s rv •% •* o
o ITN o CJN o o C\J vO j C\J
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o *v «s r* #* #« ITN IfN o ON 5 CM m J- 5
o o o
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o
•» « • N • s «« IfN p,. 5 6 CM
o NO
o o o
N ^
359
m •H
CQ
•••d
O
0 o
pi o
pq X iM i>a
360 3 . forking Capital
Short-term fiinds are reauired to meet the ^•7orking
cap i t a l of the firm, v-iorking cap i t a l r epresen t s the funds
in-vested in current asse ts which, in the case of Kangra
tea indus t ry , represent a small Einicunt as compared to fixed
asse t s (cf . Table VI I I . i rO . The'reason fol' t h i s may be
sougtit in the fact tha t the t e a s manufactured by these
u n i t s are immediately t ransferred to e i the r the co-operative
marketing on weekly basis or sent to the jajiiritsar auct ion.
Since on del ivery , 60;;5 of the cost may be reco-vered in
cash, not much funds are blocked in inventory and receivables
Tlieir main requirement of funds i s for meeting the i r v/age
b i l l s ana other cos ts which account for a major port ion
cf the i r t o t a l cos^ of production. Their main problem i s ,
the re fore , of having reasonable l i q u i d i t y for racing these
expendi tures . Had the p r o f i t a b i l i t y been good^ the v/orking
cap i t a l problem would have been negl igible . But lo\; margins
end, in many cases huge losses ( e . g . , 3 Co-operat ive) ,
have created the problem^ of l i q u i d i t y . This problem cannat
be solved by siiiiply finding out new sources of \TOrking
cap i t a l f inance . I t s u l t imate solution v;ould l i e i n
increasing product iv i ty and p r o f i t a b i l i t y .
iiiS i t may be observed from the consolidated hixtance
sheet (Table VIII .1 ^ & 3^ , the net working cap i t a l of the
u n i t s under reference i s e i the r very small or nega t ive .
I t means tha t miargin avai lable from long-teri.i sources,
pc.a?ticularly net worth, for financing the permanent portion
of working c a p i t a l i s almost non-exis tent . Hence the
perpetual l i q u i d i t y problem. The solut ion would, therefore .
361
l i e in f inding out long-term funds for rep lan ta t ion and
replacement in order to increase productivi ty and decrease
pressures on v/orking c a p i t a l and l i c p i d i t y . Moreo-ver,
the management of these u n i t s must a lso t r y t o assess
the i r short-term requirements of flinds for off-season and
busy season on a more r a t i o n a l b a s i s . Unfortunately, not
much thought has been given to t h i s aspect of working
cap i t a l Tflanageiaent in Kangra t ea i ndus t ry . £>imply
finding out short-term sources of funds i s not going to
solve the problem of working c a p i t a l .
VI I I . 2 .2 Accounting Procedures and Br act ices
The main objective of maintaining records in the
p lan ta t ions i s to meet s t a tu to ry ob l i ga t i ons . For taxat ion
purposes, various accounts have to be prepared. The
accounts normally prepared, are t rading accounts, p ro f i t
and loss account, and balance shee t , ikpart from the
personal and general ledger accounts, r e ce ip t s and
disbursments (Cash book) and cost of production records
are also maintained. For the payment of excise duty^RG
(Rav; mater ia l ) and EB (Excise books) records have to be
prepared by a l l the t ea processing u n i t s . Most of the
p lanters thought that maintenance of a l l these records
was an obl igat ion forced on them by the s ta te ,
The double ent ry system of accounting i s invar iably
used, but the accounting personnel are i l l t r a ined . They
may be able to manipu4-ate the accounts for meeting s ta tu to ry
requirements; but they could not maintain the accounts or
provide data for the benefi t of decision making in finance
3
CO
(D o
•H + i O
a:
-p
g o o
o
^
H
c o
g
\ -4
o o ©
o o 4
•H -P
O
' -O
! CO I O
is-
r n
OJ
-P ' CH •H O !
P 0) TJ CD O ^
O •P T-
-P cd
H
o " •H i+H ^1 O -P d en
^
- p K->
cd >^ •t^ ^
§ ^ Si O -P cd
o 5
CD O
0) •H
a
O
en en O
1- - P CO o O •H
12
o o ^ O - H - P
^ • 6 0 CO O O ixj IH q
en f^
a CD
s o
l>» o H -H P « - P PH 05
-P CD CD
CO
CD O
a cd
H en FQ o
O
- p
-s to O -H O O
4 W
m 1M o
o q
4J UO CO a
• -H M en PH G fi 0) •H O CD - P - H ^ 4 (1) -P CD cJ - d S M<L,
•H O Ur-\ O O .Q (D
CD CD +3 cti
•H ri CD S
o CD •H ^ 1 CD
+3 CD c:! •
H CH p O O
•» T-a ;s{ en In fH O CD oj n H CD c:j O >5 "
0) CN CD <J ^
QH - P
o :5 -H
en 13 CD & -P - p
en O CD § ^ •
en CD ^ l en U ^ CD O P H o -P CO iii m • H - P a 3 Ti P i 0) rt •H • en CD 0 CO •H ft o U o
fl CD CD - P
o «
o « en
-P M
CO o H CD t j - p ^3 ^ p; en :3 w +J
^ f H - P o ^ CD cd fH O - P + i -P
bO fH en to .a tio en 5 o d C G- l> 'H • H x j •H O H -P cv! Ctj-P •H P I cd
+ i CD 0 - P PH JH
O ,s; CD g Sa
s •H O ^1 o f n H fM o JH O r Q O CH
pq ^H r^ O r O
o o o en
•d S^
•H
H "iH (D O F>
•H cn - p i ^ o cd CD CD ft >^ CO
CD
. , ' P CD - jJ Cd o
^ ' p p - P d l r \ o d +3 - ^ -H P e n - tH
O 01 4J ft q en -H M
- i j cd :3: o
I'i a)
+3 cd
•H +3
CO
O P3 O f <i
W » r-,: -q
o b. q O SH P
ft O o
^ w o o 4 4 O PH P) - r l CO CO ^ CD O , y >s O H O cd Q) vd O
Q (x; ; / } P5
• p
J4 o -p
y 5
-p o CD
• P • CD CO
P
CD
cn
t o CO ft P P CD •H O 4 J - H
o cd
•--•J
P
CD
o P 4 + 3
o f ^ a
r o --1
p CD
• H
CD '^^ H O Ti red cn •H ^ ::z; p
CD
•H ^ O cn c\j P P ^ •
^ -P CD •H O
4-i
P H 3 S ^ O O CD " - ^ & q o X
^ 0 l CD
in +3 P
CD • •;:i cn4J 5
•H CD O O CD O N S cd
P I en CO
• CD cn !H O Q a)
4-> § IP
C/J r-l T i •H Cd p bum Cd CD
r1 • -P CO •H
CD ;4f t tiO o O
Jd O ^
O 4J
cd 4J bO
CO c
UO cn ft f:! P QJ •H o CD 4 J - H ^ CD -i-^ CD Cd 'Zi
•H O P —I O O ,Q CD
CAJ rn rvj c ^ CM ol CM
m X >H
• H ?
H O CD O O ^ P • O CD >5 cn - r l +0
P -H CD O P. .d
•H N PH W CD
'§) I'd o
^ 4J O p cd e o H
P Q) *H O i>j en o 0"LC^Cn
4 '^ o
o o +3 m -H
ft Q O
. ^ ^ O X •
• p ^ o o o O CD
P CD •H CD Td ^ c d c ^ P &4 (D
O • P
4J P P H 3 Ci 6 m o • O 4J ^ P
^ CD en o en fcn CO o *5 cd q o
o
* S - 1
P 4 J
:d cd a +3
CO
4
P o
•H cn
•H O o t d
bO
o o
P • -H
00 ft P CD O CD
p ri bO fn
•H O H O P3 CD O cd,
CM rn
36-
p o
•H 4J Cd bO
•H +J 00 (D F> P
H
Td H 0 •H
CD O P
8 C O
363
or other sre&s of ox)eration. Thus, accounting prac t ices
a t best 3Xe r e s t r i c t e d to one purpose - record keeping,
hone of the u n i t s e"ver thought to use the accounting data
.or , . . . n , ^ . t . o . . . . . . . . . state.ent o. aeccnUn,
prac t ices tha t include accounting, accounts/records
maintained, and accounting personnel in -various u n i t s under
study ai^pear in Table YIII.^-.
The record keeping aspect of accounting, as
prevalent in Eangra tea industry, does not leave much to be
discussed, as the prevalent prac t ice i s t o keep the bare
miniauLi r ecords . Hov/ever, a general idea can be had from
these records cibout ( i ) the Prof i t performance, tmd
( i i ) the cost s t ructure of t t e u n i t s under study;
y 11 ;L . 2.2 .1 Trof i t Performance
Preparat ion of f inal accounta, i . e . , the Prof i t
and Loss account and the Balance Sheet, i s an importsjit
purpose of accounting. I t provides a "test-check" for
the f i r m ' s overal l economic 'ocrformEaice for the given
period and i t s f inanc ia l Position. Much, hov;ever, depends
upon the accuracy of income determination and a.ccounting
r e c o r d s . In t h i s respect the u n i t s under study have faile;J
miserably. Not only tha t the pr inc ip les of accounting
hsvve not been uniformally followed but even the records
are not lj3pt properly. Complete p r o f i t a b i l i t y data are
avai lable only from three un i t s under study. Even these
have to be res t ruc tu red and readjusted so as to prepare
the consolidated Prof i t and Loss Statement on sc i en t i f i c
l i n e s .
364
Prof i t a b i l i t y i s probably the bes t ci"v a l i ab le
t e s t of e f f i c i en t performance of riianagement. I t prc-vid.es
not only the motii/ation for far ther in^vestrnent taut also
underscores the long-tern! f inanc ia l posi t ion and. survival
of an occnoffiic e n t i t y . The Kangra tea jjadustry has reached
i t s present abyss mainly due to continued- low prof i t s or
even l o s se s , ^s the Consolidated I^c f i t and Loss Statement
for the 3^a.r 1973 (Table VIII . 5) shows, the B co-operative
un i t -rastained a net loss of about "Rs.^0,000 on i t s net
sa les of a l i t t l e l e s s than rupees 1,^ l akhs . The performance
of th i s un i t has been equally bad in e a r l i e r years , thereby
r e s u l t i n c in accumulated, loss as uuich as Rs.^66,122 v/hich
has (^aten up almost i t s en t i r e equi ty of Rs.^79,560. The
un i t has survived, simply because i t i s in the co-operative
sector and, as such i t could, have an easy access to
borrovTod cap i t a l from Tea Board of India and the S ta te
Government (vide Table VIII . 1 A.).
The other two u n i t s under study, X and Y, from
v^ich complete p r o f i t a b i l i t y data,\'jere ava i l ab le , did earn
some iirofit in 1973 tha t amounted to 12.5 per cent on net
sales of X u n i t and a mere 1,5 per cent for Y u n i t .
Iiov;ever, t he i r r e tu rn on cap i t a l (net i i rof i ts to net
v/orth/equity) com: s to as low as 5 ?er cent in X un i t
and 2 percent in Y u n i t . Other u n i t s under study, from
which complete fincuicial data were not ava i lab le , have
been sa i l ing in the same boat so far as the i r prof i t
performance i s concerned, ^n idea abai t the i r p r o f i t a b i l i t y
may be had from Table VIII .6 v/hich consol idates the p rof i t
^
0 ^
^^
ifN
H M >
H
-P
cu
Q) • P c3
+3
en
- P • H CM O
o • P
•H r- l
o o o
m
+3 W •H CD
CD
o
365
•S -p
0) 0
Q <
X
w
?:!
H pi o •H -P
O
c/3
o 1r> I>- OS ON CO co n-) vO C5N CVJ C>- l o OJ V -
-^. o J- T— CM J- l > - T— O ITN u> l>~ ro r O -^. J" ro J- V - o t > . ro o CO T~ o OJ
r* • N • N r« *s •% rv r* •s • N •s #* « •» CvJ . -J vO ITN ON \r\ o i ro o ON CM vO ^ O J- J- C\J o c J- ro C\J V— CM CM T— J-V - — T— f ~ 1 t 1
03
ON •s
C3N CN-
O J- ro 1-XN vO CM ON O O O- r o CO' O (^
O oo CM
- 1 I T N •
• U N
vO
CM
OJ t >^ CO J -ON CM CN- I> -a\ CO CO ON V - O CM
CTN CM • X
CM
^0 J- CM OO crs • r h ON
ro O N ro ITN C^ J-ON ON vO oo. •UN »«
r* r* «« • X ** ON ro oo' ox' oo ^ o • ^ CM 0 ^ CM ^ V -
r o vO CO ON CM CO •LTN
,—1 o C N .
^ CO CO
CN.
ro ITN -iXN
VO OJ
o ro
cu
CN.
ro CM f O
H O
c/S CO •J)
w o
0) cn
cn (D cn $ : ; CD ft M Q)
o •H +3 cj •H O CD
h
2 o o e; •H
M
CO CD
ai 4 ^
TJ p. o J_ cn o to fi 4 ^ o H to 4^ O o r"t ^ J 0) -ci +3 ri •H •H
5 u3 H O o 4J <D r:| CO •H •H <4H 5 •H H GJ -IJ CO o a Ti MH 4-5 CH o CM ^ •^ w
t j (-; o j—t
. q CJ S o o ^
O 4 J T j t'JD •H CD cn M o
o 4J
Qo | S ^ •H •9 •H H
® CJO
in t o ft o 13
- p 0
• p r o <D cj o T i Xi cn •H G 1 O w CO :5 ^ r; b H S 5 vi CD C •H c 1 0) o rf '"J +3 p< o 5 4J H Pi P o 1
H Q p^ i - ^ O o cn cn 03 CD cd a rv3 m cn cn W ol CI U f\ CO
y3 w Ti m O CO CD T5 f\ to
4J o 3 ,3 hi CD 1 oj
<-> / 3 O
ft O 3 ^ 4J
* f-7-^ • H
• M M M M M
CO •H cn
!? 0 CO CTJ
lo
CD CJ
O !c/3
366
Table VIII . 6
Erof i t Performance of Units Under Study for three Years
Code of the net B?ofits or Losses un i t ( Axiiount in ru pees)
1970-71 1971-72 1972-73
B i e s se s -19,^23 -^0,233
K 13,537 12,699 3,653
M * 2^,000 -^-3,000 -52,000
X Losses 73,037 32,372
Y 6,^11 2,^n7 2,7^-1
z * 33,000 18,000 -62,000
Saarce : fiase Analys is . * Figures ri-ven for the u n i t s are approximate liiecause
the i r accounts cxe not a'vailable .
367
perfornance of a l l tlie u n i c t s under study for three
ye ar s .
VI I I .2 .2 .2 Cost Structure
Cos t ing , i s an important part of an accounting
system. The purpose i s t o ident i fy the major items of
cos ts tha t enter into the t o t a l cost of production and,
given the s e l l i ng p r i ce , u l t ima te ly determine the quantum
of p r o f i t s . I t a lso enables the management to determine
the u n i t cost of d i f ferent items or types of product.
This r equ i res proper a l loca t ion of i nd i r ec t cos t s or
overheads to d i f fe ren t products en some s c i e n t i f i c b a s i s .
This requi res proper a l loca t ion of i nd i r ec t costs of
overheads to d i f fe ren t products on some s c i e n t i f i c b a s i s .
This as t^ct of cost accounting assumes importance for the
management of Kangra t ea u n i t s in so far as i t f a c i l i t a t e s
decision-making in respect of producing (|reen teas or Black
t e a s , uihether concentratijig on the manufacture of Green
\ or_ Black t ea s i s more profi table i s an important decis ion
for small t ea u n i t s in Kangra. A.part from i t s other uses
in cost con t ro l , • cost accounting may be p a r t i c u l a r l y
helpful in t h i s r e s p e c t .
Unfortunately, the management of Kangra t ea u n i t s
under study have been quite oblivious of t h i s important fact
and do not have any cost ing data or records worth the name.
The only excercise which we can indulge in to in so far as
the cos t - s t ruc tu re i s concerned i s bas£d on the•accounting
records of the i r t o t a l c o s t s of production for a particulao*
H H H
CD
4 J
O
>> • d
4->
CD
4 J •H
O
CD fn P
-P O
O
o
I
o 0 H
^, y a E-H CD
t H M
-p •H
to
-p
Cfl
- p -
•H
P
C/l
O •H
q
o ( .
o
p> CO
o o
CO
-p
o o -p o
(D
Q
4
T— [>-
• • ON o ITN
• ^
\ " UN l>-J- o co J"
•% #« --T V.O
J - CO
CO
m
ON
o
\
o
CO
H cJ
• H f•^ O
- P d
c
CO
O
U
O
cd
CM CM
1^
CD
vO
CM •LTN
\
vO
CO
V \
ro 1 t>-OJ OXS
o C ? N ^
** • CO CO
m J -v~
\ o— • \ o J - O vD o
• • • « ICN CiN OJ t>. J- T - vO
\ \ \ \ J- C\J ro ON CO ON ro •U-N O ON vO ITN
r * r» *s « V
CO ro rvj o •s— OJ ro CN
0)
• p o
o -p
»
03
CO
-p
o o + i O CD
M
m
[> - J-• •
ro CTN
• ^
CO ro J- I>-
o CN. • V 9>
oo rn ro CM
CO
vO
P>
c:
CO
•H H
-P CO
W
' J -
o •H -P
B •H
]3 CO
•H P 'd f3
• H H H CD
m
CN-
V.O r -no IN
OJ
ITS
\ \ «. rvj : ! > - • CO CN OJ o-ON CO CO
o
o •H P> d
•H O CD
U a, <D
CO
•H ft (D
V CM
o CO
[ > -ro
l>-
CM
vO I n I
OJ OJ
V
< T -
J-•
J-•
OJ
• o •
OJ CM CTv
ro
\ CO CO CN
NO \ rN J-
CD O l > -
V. t N
CJN
UN ITN CM
C N . CO
m
-p o p>
I
03
O O
\ CJN CO ro
^ IfN
o o
V.O vO
IN
o o
vO o J-CO
OJ
+
O «
CO + 3
o o
H O
o EH
• H H M > CD
H
Cd
EH
O in
C H
T j O H •H ft
O
o
0 o
B c/5
3^9
+3
CD
'd
o •H
CD 0 X!
-P o c: CD l >
CO CD
cd +3
CD
§
<^ o + -H CO + 3 CD O < 3
CD ' d -P O ^ u •H ft
CO O
• p CO+3 O CO O O
O H d H
•H d O P> p; o vj -P
CD
O
369
period as consolidated in Table VII I .5 e a r l i e r . On the
bas is of these f igu res , a general idea about the cost
s t ruc ture of the three u n i t s under study can be had
(Table ^TIII.?).
Obviously, the compilation of the cos t - s t ruc tu re
in the table VIII .7 i s subject to the l im i t a t i on of cost
c l a s s i f i c a t i o n avai lable . If cost data for p lan ta t ion
v;ere separa te ly ava i l ab le , the cos t - s t ruc tu re would have
been more sc i en t i f i c and revealing., tbreover , the basis
of ca lcula t ing raw mater ia l cost i s not uniform in a l l
the u n i t s under re fe rence . That i s why, in X un i t raw
mater ia l s have been shown a t quite a low amount, because
perhaps here ,unl ike other u n i t s , the labour charges and
other d i rec t cos ts of farming have not been included in
the cost of raw mater ials but shovzn alongwith the factory
labour taid d i r e c t c o s t s . In any case, i t i s obvious that
the d i r e c t expenses cons t i tu te the major cost of production,
accounting for as much as 67-87 per cent of the t o t a l cos t .
Of t h i s , raw mater ia ls (tea leaf!) i s the most important
single item of c o s t . Ind i rec t expenses account for 12-33
percent of the t o t a l cost of production. Of these ,
establishment expenses and r e p a i r s and depreciat ion are most
importer.t. Hocsrever,these differences seem to a r i se more as a
r e s u l t of d i f fe ren t accounting p rac t i ces in the absence of a
well developed accounting system in t h i s . indus t ry . I or -/
example, commission on sales i s shown d i f fe ren t ly by a l l
u n i t s .
VIII . 3 . Finii:icii:,l Ilaruinciaont ikiid ..o.cGOuntinn System "^TA -FuncticruJ. Guidf l ine s/?r iriGJ-i^le s *» fU
Cii the basin of the: frcane'/orlc and iicactlccs discussed
above, ;?n attci.;pt hcs been i;ic;.:le in th i s section to arr ive at
ce r ta in p r inc ip les of f inanc ie l manageaent and accountinf-,
The*7e .,vinciples Iia-vc bran sui tably adapted and i^icdified so as to
serve as conceptual fra: .c-./orl: or functional ru iec l ines for
efff;ctiae eane{pr/'nt of tea industry , in general, and snai l
Kanffra tea u n i t s , in p a r t i c u l a r ,
VII I .3 .1 ?i:ienec: Function
do he\e e a r l i e r pointed out that there arc three
t^oe s of :' 'ecisicns hivolvoa in f inanc ia l management:
inveetejent, fincncinp and :blvidend dec is ions . And these
decis ions r-i- in te r l inaed e.nd, often, overlapaing. LQ such,
these have to bee seen in the i r t o t a l i t y , though for the
purpose of enelysis v/o discuss them separa te ly . Vfe sha l l
develop these functions h(jre, a l b e i t in a s l i gh t ly
differeni: forie, to serve as guidelines for tea indus t ry .
Using simpler tcri.iinology, as many experts of f inanc ia l
managcmeat do, ne iiay say tha t there arc three important
TJhases or elements of f inanc ia l administrat ion, njimely:
^1.^ I^etimation (of the fixed and ^Jor]:ing cap i t a l
re ru i rements) ;
2>> Cap i t a l i s a t ion , that includes (a) Fcrm.re'cion of the c a p i t a l s t ructure ( i . e . ,
determ.iiiction of the various types of ca ) i t a l funds and the i r r e l a t i v e proportion, v/hcre-^^he t o t a l c a p i t a l i s to be obtained) ,
' and
(b) Procurement of fixes and vorlcing c a p i t a l ( i . e . deterninat ion of the sources of c a p i t a l
supply); and
(3) hanagement of earnings .
VIII.3-1-I- ESTBJITIOH 3 7 | _
In order to find out the fixed and v/orl-iing capitr . l
requi rcncnts of a firm, \ 'arious components thereof are.
broken up, as far as poss ible , into unlforv.'; and homogeneous
u n i t s 3nd the cost of each un i t i s es t imated. For example,
\'ie wi l l have to assess as t o how much fixed and c i r cu l a t i ng
(current ) assets wi l l be needed and a t what cos t s they \,-ill be
ava i lab le t Obviously, t h i s wi l l depend, in ter a l i a , on
( i ) the nature of industry, ( i i ) Size of opjerations,
( i i i ) |)roccss of production, ( iv) method of handling products
(•v)terms of t r ade , c-ncl so on. For correc t es t imation,
however, f u l l hncv/ledgc of the d i f ferent recnairements of
business i s e s s e n t i a l . I .ore over, the com par i s ion method - i . e . ,
s tudies of es t imates made by other firms of simiilar nature
and size - may help in a r r iv ing a t the t o t a l re caiirements
and thiCir c o s t s . As a matter of f e e t , the ac tual est imation
as made by a firm in the dynamic s i tua t ion i s not as simple
as i t appears. For, there i s al;;ays a choice among
avai lable a l t e r n a t i v e s . Hence the importance of various
tools and tochnieues of f inanc ia l management, such as_,capital
budgeting, revenue budgeting, f inanc ia l ana lys i s , and so on.
VI I I .3 .1 .1 .1 F'miT) ASSETS
The pr inc ipa l purposes for v/hich funds are required
for fixed cap i t a l in 3. tea un i t may be l i s t e d as belows
( i ) Farm ( i . e . , Lend and Tea Dushes)
( i i ) Building
( i i i ) Plant and machinery for tea pro ce ssing u n i t
( iv) Rirni ture and f i t t i n g s
(v) Vehicles
(vi) Other fixed a s s e t s .
372 '-lliile assessing the requirements of these fixed
a s s e t s , the follovdng co:risiderations have to be taken into
account J-
1 . I f the Isjid, building and processing u n i t
recui re -very liuge investments some hi re- iurchase
system or ren t ing of factory premises can be
considered.
2 . Sometimes, the p o s s i b i l i t y of exploring purchase of second-hand machinery may also be looked into \ihen the ne\/ machinery i s beyond the means
of firm..
3 . The es ta t e may or may not process i t s o\m
green leaf . Sometimes, a p a r t i a l arrangement
of processing may also be made. Part of the
green leaf can be processed by the firm i t s e l f
aiid the r e s t handed over to the cooperative
processing u n i t s . This rec'uces the investment
in plant and machinery.
U-. its r ega rds , the reg^avenation of p lan ta t ion , a
number of a l t e rna t ive choices may be a v a i l a b l e .
Replantat ion, extension, or i n f i l l i n g of the
vacancies are the a l t e r n a t i v e * courses of
ac t ion . The firm has to take up any one of
these according to i t s needs and a v a i l a b i l i t y
of f inance .
Assessing the Financial Requirements, for fixed a s s e t s for an ejcTstinp; firm;
Funds in an ex i s t i ng tea un i t may be needed for
the following i i i rposes;-
( i ) The size of a garden may not be optimal,
but there may be fallov/ land lying v/ith the
ovmers. Extension of p lanta t ions in these
373
t r a c t s 01 land may be considered.
For every addi t ional hectare of land sought
to be planted the cost work out to be
around Rs. 13,000 (cf. Chapter IX).
( i i ) Re p l an t ing ; - If the bushes are ageing _
a fact in Kmgra tea industry - a phased
rep lan ta t ion prograranie has to be taken up .
Replantat ion requi res not only the costs
of planting but a lso the replenishment
of losses of crops . The costs of these
a c t i v i t i e s work out to be around Rs . 17,000 rer h e c t a r e .
( i i i ) I n f i l l i n g of Vacancies:- Another nethcd of
rejuvenating the garden i s f i l l i n g the
vacancies, which iii3.y exist ' in many gardens.
I n f i l l i n g can be taken up at cheaper r a t e s than
extension or r e p l a n t a t i o n . For i n f i l l i n g
the vacancies of the order of 2^% to kQ%
the costs may range frorn R s . 2,000 to
Rs . 3,000 per hec ta re .
( i v ) Costs of Processing Machinery;- The
machines weer out due to constant use fo r
ouite some time, or they become obsolete
due to the fact tha t nev/ processes of
manufacturing have been developed in tea
indus t ry . Therefore, the machines
need to be replaced or new machines have
to be added. New machinery i s na tu ra l ly
expensive and the p lan ters may l ike to
explore the pos s ib i l i t y of acquiring
second hcnd machinery. The r a t e s for
374
Table V n i . 3
Cost cf I-iachinery
Najne cf the llc.chinc P r i c e of nev/ .R?ice of Second-machine ( i n H s . ) hand machine ( in R s . )
1 . a c l l e r 3 0 , 0 0 0 ^ 5,000
2 . Dr ie r 100,000 20,000
3 . C.T.C. liachine 13,000 12,000
h, a t a l k : - x t r ac to r
( E l e c t r i c ) 11,OCX) 11,000(new)
5. C u t t e r ^+,500 2,000
6. Pucca Tea S o r t e r 8,000 3,500
7 . Tea Breaker 6,000 3,000
3 . Green Leaf So r t e r . 5,000 2,5oO
Source : Informat ion c o l l e c t e d from U n i t s Under S.tudy.
375
new ajid second hand u n i t s of processing
machinery are shov/n in Table V I I I . S .
<v) Renovation of Factory Buj.ldings;:- The
amount needed for t h i s pirpose depends upon
the type of f a c i l i t i e s to be added.
I n s t a l l a t i o n of fermentation f a c i l i t i e s
or pro-vision of e l e c t r i c supplies may
require considerable amounts of money.
Minor alteutions and r e p a i r s of the
bui ldings may also be taken up to su i t
the requirements without incurr ing heavy
c a p i t a l expenditure,
Ga~)it3-1 Budget inp;
&.S we have already seen i-^iile analysing the
c a p i t a l s t ructure of the tea u n i t s under study, the
asse t s t ruc ture i s overwhelmingly dominated by fixed
a s s e t s . In a composite tea u n i t with both farm and
factory, land, bu i ld ings , and plant and machinery involve
the major cap i t a l investment, land (including tea bushes])
being the most ii'nportant. In respect of processing
u n i t s l ike Y Tea Es ta tes and B Cooperative, buildings and
plant and machinery are obviously the major fixed a s s e t s .
Their requirements would indeed depend upo© the size of the
u n i t . ]poT the ex i s t ing u n i t s , hovrever, the major problem
i s of r ep lan ta t ion i n the farm and replacement in the
fac to ry , vie sha l l concentrate mainly on these two
aspects of cap i t a l expendi ture . Here, as a lso in a l l
376
cap i t a l expenditure dec is ions , the management of tea u n i t s
i s faced. \/ith the problem of maJiing a current im/estment in
which benef i t s are expected to be received beyond one year
in the fu tu re . The economic j u s t i f i c a t i o n for a cap i ta l
expenditure prc[Tsi:ime, thc;ref ore , recruires a long range
estimate of p ro f i t s v/liich in turn involves a project ion
of sales and costs of operations for a period of yea rs . Thus,
a c ap i t a l expenditure prograr.ime requ.ires proper matching of
cos ts snd benefi ts over a period of years and is best
evaluated as a c a p i t a l budgeting i^reject.
The very survival of Kangra tea industry depends
on reri lantation and replacement, Ov/ing to the far-reaching
implicat ions and invclvoinent of large investments, c a p i t a l
expenditures on these projects have to be undertaken in a
planned i:ianner. The management of tea u n i t s have to e s t ab l i sh
object ives and goals as p r r t of r. master plan for long-range
survival oiid/or gro^.;th. For grov.'th to become a r e a l i t y ,
management should estimate action on a time schedule i/hich wi l l d i r e c t c ap i t a l in to the projects for r a i s ing the
overa l l re tu rns on iiivestment.
Capi tal budgeting technicfues may be prof i tably used
by managcm^ent of tea u n i t s in t h i s a rea . As 7«rntioned
e a r l i e r , c ap i t a l 'oud.geting i s the planning of expenditure
whose r e tu rns s t re tch themselves beyond one-year period -
i t i s the process of deciding v/hether or not to coar^it
resources to a project whose benef i t s would be spread over
several t:uno per iods . I t considers :a?oposed cap i t a l
outlays and the i r fin.-.ncing. The m.ain exercise involved,
in cap i t a l budgeting i s to r e l a t e the benef i t s to costs
377 in soaie reasonable manner /iTich would be ccncis tent with
the. basic objocti'se s of the f i rm. The process of c a p i t a l
budf^eting, thorcforo, imjolves de^elorAn^i e-yaluatinp and
choosing--capital p ro jec t s for investment. Projects are
chosen for two reasons: ( i ) economic re tu rns and/or ous
( i i ) e s s e n t i a l i t y . The l a t t e r i s a disaster:^ approach, or
a t l e a s t a passive appror^ch, to cap i ta l budgeting v/hcre
cap i t a l expenditures are taken up when they become unavoidable
for the very survival of the u n i t , Cften, under such
circunst^aices, eccncmic j u s t i f i c a t i o n of the project is the
f i r s t casua l ty . The s i tua t ion in Kangra tea invdustry has
loerhaps reachc;d t h i s stage so far as r en lan ta t ion and
replaceaent cpe concerned and. dynamic approach to c a p i t a l
budgeting, -/here c a p i t a l expenditures are planned on a
long-term basis after ident i fying the sjTaptoms in advance
and scanning the changing envii'oninents and oppor tun i t i e s .
There are d i f f e ren t , well-developed c r i t a r i a or
techniques available tha t can be used for analysing the
economic j u s t i f i c a t i o n of reiiLantation and replacement pro jec ts
of tea. u n i t s . The two general c r i t e r i a to be used a re :
(1) Ab i l i t y to pay back the amount of c ap i t a l
investment as cuickly as possible - t h i s i s cal led
/ Pay-back method of c ap i t a l budgeting.
(2) Ab i l i t y to re turn a minimum desired rat';: on
cap i t a l investment. There are two methods by \7hich ^ rc:turn on Investment jiiay be computed, v i s . ,
(a) Ave:ragc :iato of Ileturn, and
(b) Discounted Cash Flow ( i . e . , In te rna l kate of
rieturn and ket .Hresent Value) .
378 llic ]payback metlica i s useful in respect of a u n i t
vmicli i s short of fun;ls an:' \/cints the i r in-vestment buck as
quickly as poss ib le . I t i s also a more p rac t i ca l approach
in so f:r . as the er t i t ia tes beyond a few years in the future
beconr: loss ce r ta in 5MC to uncer ta in ly ana r i s k , Vlliere the
est imates of future earnings/savings are not subject to v/ide
f luc tua t ions ana uncer ta in ly , the r a t e of r e tu rn method may be
more adviscuolc. The n,vf=rage r a t e of r e tu rn method may be
distinguishc.; from Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) . The former takes into consi:l"r.:'.ticn simole accoiinting r e tu rn , on an a-verage, for tha an t i re l i f e of the project and can be eas i ly calculated
if the or ig incl cost of tha project and estimates of future
earnings/sa'^-'-iaigs ara loaovm. In D.C.F. method, the future
e;.rnings crc reduced to the i r •rresont value, and these^matched
v;ith tha I n i t i a l invo stment/cost for f inding out the in t e rna l
(DCF) L'ata of r e t u r n . This method i s ce r t a in ly be t te r and more
s c i e n t i f i c , because tima involves cost ( i n t e r e s t ) and cash
receivad at Iciter date cannot be equated with the cash received
e a r l i e r . :-:;nca^tha faiturc r ece ip t s must be discounted a t a
r a t e of i n t e r e s t to arr ive a t the i r present values . In a
v;ay, i t i s a system of c - l cu la t ing com.pound r a t e of in te res t^
in revoi-'se order. The D.C-F-/;lntern3,l ro te of r e tu rn i s that
r a t e at whiich the present value of the future streams of
inccm.e -./111 be eeual to the present va2ue of cost or investment.
This r a t e i s usee'' as. tha cut-off ra te for the choice of a
p r o j e c t . I f the cost of c a p i t a l i s higher than t h i s r a t e , the •
nroject i s unprc f i t ab le . In tea industry, t h i s r a t e for
r en lan ta t ion or rr ^ll^!caa^nt will indicate the cost,ahdl.so the
sources; cf funds vmich may or may not be used for f:Lnancing
the sch:;:-ia, "fet j 'rosent value i s calcul;ited when the cost
of c a p i t a l or cut-off r a t e i s given anri we v/aiit to find oat
379 the p r o f i t a b i l i t y of the pro jec t . In t h i s ctsc the ertlinated
future c-riPnincs arc clisccunteJ cit thr 2i"ven ra te vnd the
present value ccinprrcd v/ith i n i t i a l invcstMent / c o s t . If the present value i s iti excess thcrrecf, the project i s clfe,sir-:ble,
1111 .3 .1 .1 .2 . \lGT]ilnr Capi ta l
The te rn './orklnp; c ap i t e l o rd ina r i ly stands for tha t
part of uhc: capita^, v/hich i s ri.jquirec' for the fini-ncin^ of ^vorking
or cur.-ent noc;e s of a f irm. These may be dor the purchase
of raw mater ia l s witli a viev/ to processing the ur.terie.ls into
f inished products end for meeting the dry-to-day expenses
iSMch as pa^TQsnt of s a l a r i e s anl \jarps, r e n t , r a t e s and taxes ,
s ta t ionery , e t c . I t i s usuel ly invested in rav; mate r ia l s ,
stock of per t ly oi' fu aiy finished goods, accounts rece ivab les , .marketable s e c u r i t i e s , and cash. Capi ta l in a l l these forms
i s ccnstont ly en:"! ruickl;/ beine converted into caslT 3Jid t h i s
cash f lovs out agein in exchoJige for other form of irorking
capitelL. Worlcing ca . - i ta l i s , t hus , constant ly ' revolv ing ' or
' c i r c u l a t i n g ' , or i t i s being' turned o v e r ' . Hence,it
generally involves t;;ii"; use of short-term funds in business ,
Adeouacy of -/orlcing c a p i t a l helps a l o t in m.aintaining the
l i q u i d i t y end the c red i t standing of a f i rm.
Quant i ta t ively speakjjig, working capite.l i s taken
to mean t o t a l current a s s e t s . This i s a good -./orking
de f in i t ion for assessing the short-term f inenc ia l recuirements,
as the current r s s e t s cons t i tu te the t o t a l funds avai lable for
operating purposes, ilany ex]>erts v.'ould, however, define
working cai . i te l as the excess of current a s se t s over current
l i a b i l i t i e s . To avoid confusion, \/e may c a l l the former as
'gross working c a p i t a l ' end the l a t t e r ' ne t working c a p i t a l ' .
380 The l a t t a r ic e. aualitati-ve cicfiniticn cf ^jorkiiig c a p i t a l , as
i t et^aiDlos the investors and c r e d i t o r s , as also the management,
of a fir.-i to judge i t s f inancia l rjcundness snd margin of
p ro tec t ion . Obviously', the, excess of current asse t s over current
l i a b i l i t i e s iiiust have been financed by some long-term sources
of funds lilcc re ta ined eoj-nings or fixed asse t s conversion
(deprec ia t ion) . The net working cap i t a l i s also iraportant from
rnaiagciicnt point of viei/, A-ltbcugh the en t i re current asse t s
sxe always revolving rvnf^. converted into cash within a short
r)eTlc:l, yet e portion cf the seiiie ali/ays remains blocked up .
This i s the permanent rjorticn of v/crking Ccipitel and may be
t rea ted l i ' ie cny other fixed a.'; set for f inancing. The net v;orking c a p i t a l , i f properly assessed, would represent the
permanent i/orking c a o i t a l . This assumes added significance for
^••rorliing cap i t a l managem.ent, as i t provides greater l i q u i d i t y
to the f i rm.
Liquidi ty Ilanagemenftt
Ilanagement of l i o u i d i t y aims a t deciding the optimum
amount c\nd compositions of assets and l i a b i l i t i e s . Every mix has
a particulaj" l eve l of r i s k and p r o f i t a b i l i t y . The greater the
r e l a t i v e "Droportions of l i au id a s s e t s , the less the r i s k of h
running out of cash, a l l other things being equa l . However,
in such a c;: sv, th? p rof i t ab i l i ty i s l e s s e r . Si i^ i lar ly , a long
maturity schedule of borrowings reduces r i s k of cash insolvency
but the prof i t l eve l i s l e s s . The l i q u i d i t y management, thus, involves a trade off between r i s k and p r o f i t a b i l i t y . Three specif ic ruor t ions , v/hich thp estat^"- management w i l l be required to ask i t s e l f , a re :
h. Van Ilorne, James C, , p-pcit, p . ^+15.
3S1
A M O U N T "3- > P^upgES
1 m
f
382 ( i ) Vlhat are the optimal le-vels of investment in variou;
current asF^ets? (ii)\:j;iiat i s the optim:a3- mix of short term in
r e l a t i on to long term financing?
( i i i ) VriTat are the appropriate means by v;hich to
finance on a short term basis?
To deciae the mix of company f inanc ia l needs to be
met by short term or long term, sources, an^ 'Hedging Approach'
may be suggested.
Hedging Ap-orocch
If the e s t a t e uses t h i s approa.ch, then every
f inanc ia l need wi l l bo met by a financing instrument of the
same matur i ty . For t h i s purpose, the working c a p i t a l needs
can be c lass i f ied as : Permanent needs and sea son aJ. n c d s .
For example, some permanent v;orkers have to be e.iiployed by
the es t a t e management and theii ' salai ' ies have to be paid and
at the peah. seasons addi t ional labour has to be contraicted and,
thus , addit ional v/ages liave to be paid. Thus, the volume of •..-..•'
working cap i t a l (current ac:sets) would vary from period to
period. I t w i l l be the highest in peaJ^ seasons and the lov/est in off-season. But i t wi l l not go below a absolute
minimum in any per iod . The amount of working c a p i t a l above
these minii.iums gc:'nerajly represents the f luc tua t ing or
seasonal workan[' c a p i t a l reouirements. This can be depicted
more striicLngly in the foriij of a diagram (figure V H I . l ) .
According to the hedging a.p'-iroach, f luc tua t ing
requirements of working cap i t a l have to 3e financed hy the
short- tcr.;, debt exc lus ive ly . The permanent working c a p i t a l ,
l ike fixed a s se t s , should be financed by long term sources of
funds. This ,jcu3_d ensure proper l i c iu id i ty . If v;e go to
finance the en t i re ./orking capita?^ nc? ds by long term funds,
383 th:.- l i r a i i^ l t ; ' vculJ, be the naxiiiium, but the cos t s wi l l be
jirohibiti-vG occuss ve ;7ij.l \:v-vo to Iveep some funds id le \jith
us e-ven •.f/.cn they :JT3 not neelod. Cn the countr;:a:*y, i f v;e
go for short- tena financing alone, the p r o f i t a b i l i t y .nay
incrcano Ijut l i r u i o i t y v/ij.l be adversely effected,
CT)eratina Cycle Concept of Uorkina Ca'Utal
Ihc cperatiny cycle (G.G.) conceat of -/orking cap i t a l
i s a new concept th:: t oay be prof i tably used by the liianagCEient
of t ea u n i t s to assess the i r ^•/orhlng cae i t a l requ;Lrencntson a
inor'- rat ional. Dasis.'^ in br ief , according to t h i s concept,
V7crking cap i t a l i s j'-iecnt to support a l l operational a c t i v i t i e s
of th-? f i r a ^iiC. cc::ts thereof. Under t h i s njethod, t o t a l -
operating exg^enses for a period are divieed by the number of
operating cycles in th'- re levant period to find out the cash
b^.sis of acrhing capitrd.. Cperatmg cycle re;n?esents the
aericd (s.) daring v/hic::- investiiient of one uni t of ijieney wil l
reaain blocked t i l l recovery cut of revenue or r e c e i p t .
The en t i r e czercise iiivclve s four ste;")s, v i z . ,
( i ) Coirgutaticn of Cperating Cycle Period;
(i i)huaber of Caerating Cycles for th:
( i l l ) Cp' r a t i a g expenses for the year; and
( iv) Ces): vForkiag G a d t n l rceuirr-iaent.
J - ^ - 5
5. A systeia-tic exposit ion of 0 .C . concept i s contained in C. Fori: ane J ,d .a iadson , 'dcrkina Ca^Utal, H;:cmii.lan Co., Pew York, 1953, Chapter 3, Also see Bhabatosh Brueerjee, 'Oi)eratJ2ir Cycle Ccnceat of hcrking Ca:" i ta l ' , Indian- Journp.1 of Accounting, Vol. I l l , Part I I , December, 1973, pp . i-i-6-53.
384 Cporrting Cycle period i s thr sura t o t a l of -lays for
w" icb cash funds reriain blocked in roA r ia ter i^ ls an" s to re s ,
procossinp, finisiiad goods in store and rece iabx^s le ss c r e d i t o r s '
turnoA/er (in cwiys). The nu.inbT'r of days for each of the abo^/e
items C^'H be ccs i ly cplculctcd frciii the accounting r rcords or'
the ^SL'-ofit and Loss statement.
The riunb'r of opcratina cycles i s deternined by di-vidlng the t o t a l period {36'^j days for a. year.) by thp operating cycle period. The conputation of cperatin/^ expenses i s not d i f f i c u l t , as these ere r ead i ly availalDle from the Prof i t and Loss
statement or frci:; the icccunting records . Total operc:.ting
expenses for tmy period wi l l include expenses l ike Mater ia l s ,
wages, pc:a;r -nd fue l , establishment and se l l ing and d i s t r i bu t i on
expenses. Depreciation or cuiiortisation of in tangibles have to
be exc;had:jd, r.s these are non-cash c o s t s . S imi lar ly , taxes and
e i-yiien.j •• ( or withdrawals) are also to be excluded in
computing Cj;^ating expenses for the period.
'.iciaiing e a a i t e l recnairevjent csxri nov; be ea s i l y computed
by dividing the operr-ttog expenses by the number of operating
cyc le s . This concept det^reeines the cash recaiirements of the working cap i t a l r e l c t i n g to opertLting as:>acts of the business , ,
v i z . , buying, manufacturing, se l l ing , e t c . Operating concept
of working c r p i t a l assumes imiDortance not only from the point I
of view of assessKient iDut also because i t f a c i l i t a t e s both
forecas t ing end control of working c a p i t a l , horeover, since
i t i s a function of the volume of a c t i v i t y , i t focuses
on demand for l irruid' i.ioney, i . e . , l i o u i e i t y .
38*5 VII I .3 .1 .2 . Gai) i tal isat ion^
;a GapitaliSc..tion, or cap i t a l s t ruc ture , of a tej
firm would l a rge ly depend on two th ings , v i z . , {i)
requirement of short terEi and long term funds, and
( i i ) the sources of these funds normally available to
the tea u n i t s in Kangra. Apart from the equity cap i t a l
and the plough-back, these u n i t s ^<^ll have to depend
upon the external sources for the i r f inanc ia l requirements.
Short Term Finances;
The Kaigra Tea P lan te r ' s Marketing Society
provides advances on the sa les proceeds to the tune
of 60;a of the value of seiles. These advances are used
by the p lan ters to meet the i r working c a p i t a l needs .
The Kangra Centr&l Cooperative Bank i s another agency
which c?.in provide short term loans to the tea p l a n t e r s .
In f ac t , the p lanters need a cash c red i t l imi t ra ther
than short term loans because the working cap i t a l
needs are not s ign i f ican t ,. vA i Operating Cycle i s
very short and there i s a very swift turnover.
Long Term Fincnces;.
For every conceivable long term requirement of
the p lan te rs Tea Boai'd of India provides f inances .
Various schemes of f inanc ia l assistance for tea industry
are outl ined in a brochure publ i shed^ea 3oard^i:ndia.
6. Pinancinr- of tea industry in K^angra i s studied jji d S ^ l s by iLgricultural Refinance Corporation in.Re£ort. O n l ^ a L Tea P l an t e r s , . ( 1965 ) . For schemes of H i S t l t r ^ i i t i H ^ s e e the ^^<^/^l%:'^^l^^,. FinanciaLAssisiance_For_Tea^Jndustn:y Calcut ta , 1973•
386
i±) Tea Plantat ion Finance Scheme;
(ii.) Re pi snta t ion Subsidy Scheme;
( i i i ) Tea Machinery Hire-Rirchase Scheme.
(1) Tea Plantat ion Finance Scheme;
The Tea Board pro-vides loan for 8 years for
the r ep lan t ing , replacements and/or extension of old
tea ai^eas through i t s replaj i ta t ion finance scheme to
the e s t a t e s , k. loan of Rs . 13j750/- per hectare
f o r ' h i l l gardens i s provided. The r a t e of i n t e r e s t
i s 7 % per annum with a rebate of 1/2^ for prompt
payment. The amount of loan i s recovered from 7th
t o l^th yevx after the loan i s advanced. The loan
i s given in four ins ta lments .
( i i ) Replantation Subsidy scheme;-
A rep lan ta t ion subsidy of R s . 5jOOO per hectare
i s provided to the p lan ters in h i l l s in s ix instalments.
Replacement planting i s allov/ed t h i s subsidy.
( i i i ) Tea Machinery Hire-Pur chase Scheme;-
Under t h i s hire-pirch&se scheme, the tea
Board provides a loan to the extent of Rs . 2 laWns
to tea e s t a t e s ' aiid f ac to r i e s engaged in manufacture
of t e a . I n t e r e s t i s charged a t the r a t e of 7 i ^ .
In the case of co-operative f a c t o r i e s , the r a t e of
i n t e r e s t i s 6-3- .
S t a t e Governments also give loans t o the
p lanters espec ia l ly to the co-operative processing
s o c i e t i e s . S ta te Government a lso cont r ibutes to
equity c a p i t a l of the co-operative processing
387 u n i t s .
VIII . 3 . 2 . Accountin£_andL_Gontrol. "
Any accounting as tern for small u n i t s s t a r t s
with record teeping. The objective should, howe-ver,
he two-fold, v i z . , ( i ) accurate determination of
incone as welj. as the f inanc ia l posi t ion of the firm
at the end of the accounting year, and ( i i ) use of
recorded fac t s for planning and decision making.
As regards the (i!), v/e suggest keeping of a complete
se t of books of accounts, of course " ccmensurate
T,ath the peculiar requirements of a tea u n i t , based
on the double ent ry system of book-keeping. The
accuracy and- consistency in record keeping requi res
proper understanding of the well-developed 'general ly
accepted p r i nc ip l e s , concepts and conventions' of
accounting. The prevai l ing system of accounting in
the u n i t s under study, as vje have observed e a r l i e r , i s
hopelessly inadequate and defective more due to the
pract ice of employing untrained and unqual if ied
accountants thani any thing e l s e . • I t hardly needs
r e i t e r a t i o n tha t improvement in the area of accounting
and control would la rge ly depend e i the r on the proper
t r a in ing of the ex i s t ing accountants or replacing
them v/ith the qual if ied ones ^ o are well-versed in the
modern account:Lng p r a c t i c e s .
Moreover, the requirements of the tea un i t s
wi l l also have to be taken in to account. The records
of a t ea u n i t w i l l obviously dif fer from those of
other manufacturing u n i t s in many respects I t i s
m
388
a d v i s a b l e , P a r t i m l a r l y from planning and c o n t r o l
po in t of view, to keep sepa ra t e account ing r e c o r d s
for the farm and the f a c t o r y , viiich could be l a t e r
s y n t h e s i s e d i n t o one composite u n i t for the purpose
of p r e p a r m g f i n a l accounts of the firm a t the c lose
of the f i n a n c i a l y e a r . Again , the r eco rd keeping
should no t be r e s t r i c t e d to f i n a n c i a l account ing
a l o n e . Both f i n a n c i a l £tnd n o n - f i n a n c i a l r e c o r d s / a c c o u n t s
have t o be mainta ined s e p a r a t e l y f o r p l a n t a t i o n
and p r o c e s s i n g . These account ing r e c o r d s , i f p roper ly
a i n t a i n e d , would n o t only r e s u l t in p rope r ly
ca s t ed P r o f i t and Loss Account and the Balance Shee t ,
bu t a l so i n t h e development of fu tu re p l ans of a c t i o n .
Use of v a r i o u s a n a l y t i c a l t o o l s of f i n a n c i a l management
and management account ing for decisL on-making,
p lanning and c o n t r o l i s then p o s s i b l e .
V I I I . 3 . 2 . 1 . Rrepara t ion of Income S ta t emen t s i n a P l a n t a t i o n System.
Stre J»r«J>ar«d The incane s t a t emen t s in an e s t a t e , in t h r e e
s t a g e s s -
( i ) Recording of v a r i o u s t r a n s a c t i o n s
in the farm, f a c t o r y and t r a n s p o r t a t i o n
system i s a cont inuous process through
out the y e a r ,
( i i ) B r e p a r a t i o n of Trading Account r e q u i r e s
the matching of the e n t i r e d i r e c t
expenses v;ith the revenues from o p e r a t i o n s
for the per iod and r e s u l t s i n e i t h e r
gross p r o f i t or g ross l o s s . The major
3S9 items of expense here are hired labour,
fuel and po\.;er charges and f e r t i l i z e r
c o s t s . The major sources of income
are the sales of t e a .
( i i i ) After preparing the Trading Account,
Prof i t and Loss Statement i s prepared
by taking into account i nd i r ec t expenses
and non-operating income. Indi rec t
expenses cannot be d i r e c t l y associated
vdth the revenue (sa les) but these are
associated with the period during ^ i c h
the revenue has been earned. Hence,
they are also known as period c o s t s .
These costs must be met o i t of the
gross margin to arr ive a t the net p ro f i t s
(or l o s s ) . I t i s advisable to arrange
ind i r ec t expenses under proper c l a s s i
f i c a t i o n s , such as establishment, s e l l i ng
and d i s t r i b u t i o n , r e p a i r s ajid depreciat ion
cos t s , e t c . , ^^^lere-ever possible so as
to ident i fy the areas where major costs
are incurred (cf. Table VIII 5)»
V I I I . 3 . 2 . 2 . Preparation of Balance Shee t ; -
, Before preparing the Balance Sheet ,a complete
jjiventory of the fw^A : a s se t s has J to be prepared.
The s ta teuent of these inventories va i l help in the
preparat ion of Balance Sheet on a more s c i e n t i f i c
b a s i s . These inventor ies provide de ta i led information
390 about the important asse ts of a firm. I t may,
hoTvever, be ncntioned tha t these statements are
based on T accounts prepared in f i rm's ledgers of
the per iod.
Once the general inventory of the es t a t e
i s taken, i t i s very simple to prepare the Balance
Sheet . . . The asset side of the Balance Sheet depicts
the value of fixed a s s e t s , investments, current
a s s e t s , locns end advances, e t c . On the l i a b i l i t i e s
s i d e , v;e have share c a p i t a l , reserve and surplus ,
secured lorj is , unsecured loans , current l i a b i l i t i e s
and provis ions , (cf. VIII.1 a & b ) . Brovisions
may also be shov/n on the as se t s s ides of the Balance
S,heet as deductions froiii the re levant a s s e t s ,
VIII ,3 .2 . 3 . Techniques of Financia l .knalysis:-
There are a number of tools and techniques
avai lable v.dth a f inanc ia l manager to analyse the
f inanc ia l posit ion of a f irm. But for a tea estgite
we sha]-l lii.iit our discussion to the following
techniques: -7
1 . Funds Flow Analysis :
Funds flow analysis i s the technique by which
we study the not funds flow between two points of
t ime. The period in between these tv/o points i s a
f inanc ia l ye tx . The flow of funds in a tea u n i t can
be studied by:
7 , Adapted fi'cm Van tlornfe , James C , Op.cit pp.677-78.
391 (i.) Classifying the chaiges occuring
in the Bal;.nce Sheet between two points
of t ime, in to those which increase
funds and those v/hich decrease funds;
( i i ) Classifying the factors In Income S t a t e
ment into those which increase the
ftinds and those which decrease these ,
and
( i i i ) Consolidating the information into
sources and uses of funds statement.
Infj.oA'7 of funds incurs \ hen there i s a net
decrease in current as:.'ets or fixed a s s e t s , a net
increase in any l i a b i l i t y and funds pro-vided by
opera t ions . Cutflow of funds v/ould r e s u l t from the
sita a t ions of a net increase in current a s s e t s , a
ne t increase in any l i a b i l i t y , any increase in fixed
a s s e t s , casljjayiiients to ovjners and investments made
by the firm, in outside s e c u r i t i e s . The t o t a l inflows
are equal to the outflows.
Information supplied by these statements gives
an i n ^ g h t into the f inanc ia l operations of the u n i t s .
I t helps in detect ing the snags in the functioning of
a u n i t . These statements t e l l how the funds v;ere
used in a pa r t i cu la r period and fran where they came,
thereby pointing out snags, i f any in f inaiicial policy
and i t s opera t ions . Balance Sheet alone cannot provide
t h i s information in such a strilcing manner .
392
I I . Ratio Analys i s .
Ratio aiialysis i s a system of deriving quant i ta t ive
measures or guides concerning the expected, of the firm
to Lieet i t s future f inanc ia l obligat ions or expocta t ions .
I t i s based on the corn imitation, analysis and in t e rp re t a t ion
of accounting r a t i o s . An accounting reitio i s an expression
of r e l a t ionsh ip hctv.'een two sets of accounting data
presented iji tli^ Bcdance Sheet and the Prof i t and Loss
account of a f irr.i. it. Isrge nutiber of accounting r a t i o s
may be calculated for analysis and in t e rp re t a t ion^ hov/sver,
here v/e v/culd lil':e to concentrate only on a fe-.-j ii.roortant
r a t i o s re levant to tea indus t ry . Ratios can be c l a s s i f i ed
in to four catogorios for our purposes:-
( i ) A-ctivit?/ Ratios v/hich r.ieasurc the efficiency of
management's use of i t s resources . The irai^ortant r a t i o s
under t h i s lie.-.d a r e : -
(.a.) Fixed .kssets Turnover Ratios
This r a t i o i s uocsured by the foriuula; Ifet Siales . Fixed Assets
Sales cjid fixed asEcts both are expressed in money va lue .
Since fixed as.aotc are reca;iired tc increase production,
the sa les ;.aist also increase and a proper balance betv/een
tiiese two I s a::iust. Higher the r a t i o , be t t e r wi l l be the
use of these a s s e t s .
(b) Tota^l Assets Turnover Rat io ;
Tills r a t i o i s given by Sa les . F^r- v/e not only Total Asse t s .
embrace fixed asr:ats but current asse t s a l so , because
393
a l l the a s se t s contribute tc prodxicticn and s a l e s .
This r a t i o v/ill indicate the fax:t tha t i f t h i s r a t i o
i s l e s s th-ia the standard or normal, fixed a sse t s
tornover oeiuic ncrna l , i t i s the i n c r e a s e ^ u r r e n t
assets wnich i s unse t t ing the balance.
( i i ) Licjuidity Hat ios :
These r a t i o s indicate the capacity of the
firiii t c meet i t s short term obligat ions in tihue . The
main r a t i o s to be disC'issed under t h i s head a r e ; -
Gurrcnt Ra t io ; This r a t i o gives ins igh t into
the present cash sol-vency of the firm and i t s
a b i l i t y to remain solvent in future , Current
r a t i o i s measured by current asse t s The
cur re nt l i ab H i t ie s .
higher the r a t i o , the greater i s the a b i l i t y of the
es ta te in Dooting i t s ob l iga t ions . But a very high
r a t i o may also indicate tha t the current asse ts are
lying id le and arc not ouiclily turnecj^ver.
liacll Tc s t Ilatio.; This is also ioicv/n as cpich
r a t i o atid i t tsJios into account only those
current as;:cts -.jhich could be cfuichly available
t c -neet the l i a b i l i t y . Inventories are the
l e a s t l i a ^ d portion- of the current a s s e t s , so
these arc subtracted fl-orn the current assets to
meaj^r, t h i s r a t i o . This r a t i o i s thus given bys n-n-wint /Vs'^ets Less-Inventor ies
Current L i a b i l i t i e s
This r a t i o concentrates on cash, marketable
s e c u r i t i e s and receivables in r e l a t i o n to current
394 l i a b i l i t i e s . This ind ica tes in a acre s t r ik ing manner
the liquid]ity of the f i rm. Though there i s no hard
and fas t r u l e , yet a quick r a t i o of 1:1 is supposed to
be quits sat isfactory/ .
Inventory Turnc-ver Hat io ; i s the r a t i o betv/een
the cost of goods sold and average Inventory
C' Opening Inventory + Closing InventoryQ i 2 - J .
This r a t i o t e l l s us hew soon (:xi.::ber of tiraes)
invsntcry i s being converted into sa les and as such
i t i s a good indicator of eff iciency in inventory or
working capital- ncnageuent. V&en the tv/elve months of
the yecJ" ±-: divided by the r a t i o Oi.e.,_12 l 0 Inventory Turnover X 5 Ratio 0
This gives the mi:-ber of ncnths ' production kept as
inventory. i«. lev/ turnover r a t i o or uore nuhiber of
months vrould indicate inventory accu-iulation.
( i i i ) O^mershin Rat ios ;
There are also "aiovrn as leverage r a t i o s and
these meas'jre the e r t en t to which the es ta te i s
financing i t s business by procurjjig d e b t s . This i s
an indicator of long-term liqu.idity and sclvcincy of
the firm. The following r a t i o s are studied under
t h i s head;
npbt Uruity i i a t i o : This i s obtained by dividjjig
the t o t a l debt of the firm (including the current
i i«b^"i i t ies) oy i t s ne t v/orth 0. Total Debt 0 . U l e t .iorth 0
Sometimes,if the intangible 'asse ts are s ign i f i can t ,
we subtract these from t o t a l 2fet Worth to com::xite
395
tangible Het Uortb.
^ low va'-ixie cf t h i s r a t i o indica tes that the e s t a t e
under study i s not t rading on equity, i . e . avai l ing of
the debt f a c i l i t i e s for financing i t s bus iness . Thus, a
s t r ingent f inancia l posi t ion has been imposed by the
managenent by discouraging deb t s . On the other hand,
a very high r a t i o would indicate too rmch dependence on borrov/ed funds v/ith a fixed charge. With low
overal l p r o f i t a b i l i t y , t h i s i s going to affect the long
term f inanc ia l posi t ion of the firm adversely. In
Kangra tea industry we find tha t apar t from the
Co-operatiV3 Unit , other u n i t s have very low debt
equity r a t i o . Cne of the reasons of t h i s i s that
re turn on c a p i t a l i n the industry does not favourably
match the cost cf deb t .
( iv) P r o f i t a b i l i t y Ratios
These r a t i o s measure the r e tu rns generated by
sales and investment and thus becom.e an indicator of
the eff ic iency of opers.tions of f irm.
P r o f i t n b i l i t y in Relat ions to Sales
Gross Prof i t margin and Ilet P ro f i t margin axe
two r a t i o s v/hich wc consider in r e l a t i o n to s a l e s . Gross ilargin, i . e . ,
Gross P ro f i t ncrgin = Scales Less Cost of Good SiOld Sales
and
Net Prof i t margin = Het Prof i t after_tax£S:L S i a l e s .
•V
396
For the mrpose of ana lys i s , the two r a t i o s
may be considered toge the r . If gross p ro f i t nargm
does not indicate r:7uch -variation, but net prof i t
margin is decl ining over a period of several years ,
we know tha t c::penses and taxes are increasing and thus^
remedial measures to r e t r i eve the p r o f i t a b i l i t y
posi t ion wil l hing around cu r t a i l i ng eijcpenses. If,
the case i s tha t gross "margin is undergoing change
tha t means, costs of production r e l a t i v e to sales
alue have increased, so v;e should t ry to cut costs
of production or increase our revenue by adjusting
cur p r i c e s ; i f poss ib le .
Us in,'-; l ia t io .Analysis:
Two typos of comparisons are made by firms v;hile
analysing the values of various r a t i o s . The r a t i o s of
the f i rm are compared over years and they are compared
vdth overal l industry averages. In f a c t , there are
no absolute values of these r a t i o s which can be
adhered to Ixit the r e l a t i v e posi t ion of the firm over
years and a lso in comparison to the u n i t s i n the same
industry ind ica tes viiether the f inanc ia l posit ion
of the company i s sound or not or >4iether i t i s
improving or d e t e r i o r a t i n g .
I l l . Break Bvon JLnalysis:
For finding the operating leverage of a
tea u n i t . Break Even M a l y s i s can be taken u p . The
analys is suggests a level of operation, the production
beyond which i d l l be p r o f i t a b l e . Hhile planning
397
production for achieving a ce r t a in r e t u r n , t h i s tool
can be used by the managers. A break up of t o t a l
costs in fixed and -variable costs has to be attempted,
at the c u t s e t . For example, the depreciat ion of
machinery and bushes m i l take place, regardless of
the leve l of production, a imi l a r l y , overheads in the
factory, , faxn and the office are a lso incurred,
regard less of the l eve l of production- a c t i v i t y .
But the d i rec t labour cos t s , pov/er, f ae l e t c . vary
with the l eve l of production. These form the
variable c o s t s . The revenue earned ^d l l again be
re la tod v/ith the l eve l of operat ion. Me have to
plan such a level of production, a t which vje meet
a l l ourfcosts and are l e f t with a margin of p r o f i t .
The margin on the f i r s t few u n i t s goes t o meet
fixed costs and then only we s t a r t earning net
p r o f i t s .
If ' F ' are the t o t a l fixed c o s t s , X the
nu..iber of u n i t s produced, V(X) the var iable costs
incurred in producing X u n i t s and P(X) the revenue
earned on the produce^ t o break even, F + V (X) =;1P(X)..1
here , V i s the var iable cost of production per un i t and
P the price per u n i t , then for cut off volume X,
C P - V) X = F,
or X = F :P - V
Or Brenk Even Point = Fixed Costs Kargin per u n i t .
398
To i l l u s t r a t e , l e t us tal^e a r ea l example from B
Cooperative U n i t . They have plans to s t a r t sa les
of t ea in consumer packs. The fixed costs of pack
aging and adaitionc:,! overheads are estimated t o be
t o R s . 9,000 per annum. They hope to s e l l the tea
a t Rs . 8.00 per kg . , and the i r production costs _;
are Rs . k jor kg. The vtiriable cost for packing i s
Re. 1.00 per kg. The average price they r e a l i s e in
the market for t he i r loose teas i s Rs . V.5o, thus,
giving them a margin of 50 paise per kg . on the i r
loose t e a s . The margin on packing \^11 increase to
Rs . 3 /kg. , so the. margin shal l improve by Rs . 2.50
per kg .
The break even point for t h i s venture shal l be
3600 kgs. , i . e . i f the factory packages tea below t h i s
cut off volume, packaging wi l l not be a prof i table
venture .
IV. Cost of Production Anal?/sis.
h. u n i t of tea industry cons is t s of two production ut»it •
sub-systems - plejitation and processings^ I t i s
advisable to compute cost of production of the, two
sub-systems scpsxately. The costmg system most
appropriate for a tea u n i t shal l be a combination of
u n i t and process cos t ing . F i r s t l y , the cost of green
leaf has to be determined. The green leaf (f inished
product) of the farm wil l then be t ransfer red to the
factory, as raw mater ia l s for processing. The
system suggested involves the preparation of the
follpwiJig cost stEitements:-
399
GCaT CF EIOHJCTIOJT
(SIIEI^ LEAF)
To labour clacxgos (f arming j p r a c l i i n g , e t c . )
To F e r t i l i s e r s €: P e s t i c i d e s
To A .nor i i s - t i on of r e p l a n t a t i o n c o s t .
To Deprec ia t ion of Farra r" qu i IJM e n t s /Yci: i c i-C s
To Tr an spor t atio:;i of Green Leaf t c tbe F a c t o r y .
To Land Rcyerv.e.
0 By sa le of ^ firewood ^ and Grass , J e t c . , I 0 3y Cost of H Green Leaf C ( t r a n s f e r r e d 0 t c the 0 F a c t o r y ) . t K
I
Tot^a.:-
400
COST OF HIOPUCTIOIT OF F3I]aHED TEAiS
0 fi Coiaponent of Cos t . jj T o t a l (Us.) 0 Cost per k g . ( r s . )
Raw m a t e r i a l s ('green l e a f ) froPi tbe farm. ;
D i r e c t l abour (.Processing) ^
PD%^T and S 'uel .
Other D i r e c t I x f c n s e s . . .
Excise Duty/GesL..
Ai.Fricie Cos t .
Fac tory Overheads;
Super-visors ' S-alary, ' Maint3nance and Deprec i a t ion
- of ELant and Machinery/ Fac to ry B u i l d i n g . : \
S t o r e s . \
Other s .
B . Viorks Cost,
Es t ab l i shmen t Overheads: Office S a l a r y . Postage and S t a t i o n e r y ,
R e n t .
i o id i t F e e .
O t h e r s .
C. Office C o s t .
c c n t d , . . 2
401 SiTatement H contd.
Gonponcnt of Cost. j Total C^^.) J Cost per kg.(RsO.
Se l l ing and Dis t r ibu t ion Overheads.
TranspOrtation-»Cost. •
Salary of 3>ales personnel .
Goinrriissions on s^ l e s .
Vigrehousinr: Gl^rges.
D. Cost of Production:-
:PrGfit or Loss:
Value of s a l e s / s e l l i n g Pr ice :
402
In order to arri-ve a t the t o t a l and u n i t cos t
of production in the manner suggested above expense
accounts have to be properly c l a s s i f i ed and maintained
separa te ly . Since the se l l ing price of teas i s beyond
the control of tlie tea u n i t s , the prof i t i s the
difference between the se l l ing price and the cost of
production, ra ther than a margin decided by the
management and added to the c o s t .
In case, the firm manufactures two types of
t e a , v i z . , Green and Black, two cos t - shee t s
(Statement I I ) wi l l have to be prepared separately
for each v a r i e t y . Here, the main problem shal l
r e l a t e to the a l loca t ion of overheads. A.s regards
the manufacturjjig overheads, these may be a l loca ted
on the basis of 'machine hour r a t e ' . Under t h i s
method, the t o t a l cost (including labour, supervision
deprecia t ion, e t c . ) of operating a machine for one
hour i s calculated and t o t a l overheads are a l loca ted
on the basis of number of hcurs^ each machine i s used
for -processing a pa r t i cu la r type of t e a , mult ipl ied
by the machine hour r a t e . Other overheads:- e s t ab l i sh
ment, s e l l i ng end d i s t r ib i tion,may be a l located on the
bas is of quantity of each type of tea manufactured.
The over a l l cost ing system suggested above
may be iixiprcved further by introducing a t ransfer
price mechaivism. This i s a modern concept of
r e spons ib i l i t y accounting viith a strong motivational
overtone for the managers of sub-units of an
403 orgaii isat ion. Under t h i s system, i^lejitation i s to be
taken.as a seni-autonomous di-vision, cal led a ^ o f i t
centre^, of the tea u n i t . The manager of a p ro f i t
centre i s responsible not only for costs but a lso
for ec-j?ning p ro f i t s for h i s cen t r e . T^is i s done
by deciding upo4 a p r i ce , cal led t ransfer price^ to
be charged on the goods or services t ransfer red from
there to the ether u n i t s of the same organisat ion.
The t ransfer price i s an in t ra - f i rm system of
pr ic ing goods or ser-vices sold (or t rans fe r red) from
one prof i t centre to another. The t ransfer price ,g^ ,
in p r a c t i c e , MCJ^IBS froin cos t -p lus througli opportunity
cost to pre-vailing market p r i c e . What vye suggest
for Kangra tea u n i t s for deciding the t ransfer price
of green leaf i s the opportunity cost of not s e l l i ng
the green leaf to the Cooperative Processing Uni t s .
Therefore, the t ransfer price i s the market price
at which green leaf could be sold to the cooperative
processing u n i t . In t h i s v/ay, the p lanta t ion manager
of a tea u n i t \;culd t ransfer h i s output of green leaf
to the factory at price d i f ferent from his co s t .
Therefore, the Statement I of cost of production wcxild
be able to shov' the p ro f i t (or los s ) on planta t ion
a c t i v i t y . The Statement I I , on the other hand, would
indicate p ro f i t (or loss) only on processing a c t i v i t y .
The overa l l p r o f i t a b i l i t y cf.the firm would remain
the same, M t the system \/ould provide an i n - t u i l t
motivation to both planta t ion and factory managers
for cu t t ing down the i r costs to show be t t e r r e s u l t s
404
for t he i r p rof i t c en t r e s .
There are a host of other technicaies used
for excsrcis ing f inancia l and cost con t ro l . But
we have l imited our discussion in t h i s chapter
to a few techniques only. For lack of r e l i a b l e
da ta , LI l u s t r a t i ons of a l l tte techniques hs.ve not
been taken up which i s a l so beyond the purview
of t h i s particulcO? study. Budgeting i s one of
the concipicutcus omnissions among the techniques .
Me have only to suggest t ha t a master plan and
cash budget must be prepared by a l l the p lanters
with which tlx; f inancia l performance could be
checked up, to detect the deviat ions and necessary
correct ive action i n i t i a t e d .