cleveland clinic journal of medicine 2009 mireles cabodevila 417 30
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
1/14
EDUARDO MIRELES-CABODEVILA, MDDepartment o Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine,University o Arkansas or Medical Sciences,Little Rock, AR
Alternative modes o mechanicalventilation: A review or the hospitalist
ABSTRACT
Newer ventilators can be set to modes other than the
pressure-control and volume-control modes o older ma-chines. In this paper, the authors review several o thesealternative modes (adaptive pressure control, adap-tive support ventilation, proportional assist ventilation,airway pressure-release ventilation, biphasic positiveairway pressure, and high-requency oscillatory ventila-tion), explaining how they work and contrasting theirtheoretical benets and the actual evidence o benet.
KEY POINTS
The alternative modes o ventilation were developedto prevent lung injury and asynchrony, promote betteroxygenation and aster weaning, and be easier to use.However, evidence o their benet is scant.
Until now, we have lacked a standard nomenclature ormechanical ventilation, leading to conusion.
Regardless o the mode used, the goals are to avoidlung injury, keep the patient comortable, and wean thepatient rom mechanical ventilation as soon as possible.
CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009 417
Technologic advances mputr-z tr m ttr
m t pb t r ttry
t w m. Dr t -t t r t prt ttr-u u jury, mpr ptt mrt, brt t ptt rm m -tt pb.
W t t trtm t rtt tm rm t pum-tr prur-tr m.Sm rry u t w m,but m m tr ty bmt mt mm u, r r b uukwy (t prtr murt
t m m). T rmt w pr t m tt by m rmt tr u, but rtr tt p t urt tr py-, trt, t.
W u tw :Exp wt t m Bry rw t trt bft t tu upprt t tr-t m tt.
STANDARD NOMENCLATURE NEEDED
S t t, m tt b pu by mutp m b ut rb t m t. Fr xmp, -um-tr tt um-y tt, t-tr tt,um-mt tt, trm tt. Smry, mutpbbrt r u, p tbr ttr, w rym b rt yr w m
b p. T t umbr m
REVIEW
*Mr. Chatburn has disclosed that he has received ees rom Cardinal Health or serving onadvisory committees or review panels and rom Strategic Dynamics Inc or consulting.
doi:10.3949/ccjm.76a.08043
ENRIQUE DIAZ-GUZMAN, MDRespiratory Institute,Cleveland Clinic
GUSTAVO A. HERESI, MDRespiratory Institute,Cleveland Clinic
ROBERT L. CHATBURN, BS, RRT-NPS*
Respiratory Institute, Respiratory Therapy Section,Cleveland Clinic
Abbreviations used in this articleAPCadaptive pressure controlAPRVairway pressure-release ventilationASVadaptive support ventilationCPAPcontinuous positive airway pressureFio2raction o inspired oxygenHFOVhigh-requency oscillatory ventilationPAVproportional assist ventilationPEEPpositive end-expiratory pressurePSVpressure support ventilation
EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVE: Readers will be able to explain what some o the new ventilator modes doand their theoretical and actual benetsCREDIT
CME
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
2/14
418 CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009
MECHANICAL VENTILATION
m u t mt - rt r py.
Ert t tb mm m-tur r ur wy.1
WHAT IS A MODE?
A m m tt trt mpt:
T tr rbT brt quT trt m.Smr m my rqur mr t
rpt t tu tm, but t but b xp by t tr m-pt.
The control variableI r, prt t pr,r by t ptt rt, t ttr, rbt, w xprt p. Fr mp-ty, t rt m brt mt prtry p t brt.
T m y tr t um( w) r t prur . T brt b urtr rb t b wttrr t brt, wt mt t (t mx-
mum u tr rb), wt
(y) t.Trr, um-tr brt
trr by t ptt r by t m,mt by w, y by um (FIGURE1). A prur-tr brt trr byt ptt r t m, mt by pr-ur, y by tm r w (FIGURE 1).
The breath sequenceTr r tr pb brt qu:
Ctuu mtry tt, w brt r tr by tm (but b trr by t p-tt)Itrmttt mtry tt, w t ptt tk ptubrt btw mtry brtCtuu ptu tt, w brt r ptu (TABLE 1).
The targeting schemeT trt r bk m rr tt ttr tt prrmm tttt t rp t t ptt u m-p, u rt, rprtry rt.T rut b mp trt prur prur-tr m, r t
b b mpt rtm.
The mode
name can be
misleading
Tidal volumeset by operator
Inspiratory pressureset by operator
Airwaypressure
Patienteffort
Larger respiratoryeffort
Small respiratoryeffort
No respiratoryeffort
Volume
Flow
FIGURE 1. Volume control (top) and pressure control (bottom) are modes o continuous mandatoryventilation. Each mode is depicted as patient eort increases. Notice that the modes control variable(volume or pressure) remains constant as patient eort increases. Contrast these ndings with thosein FIGURE 2.
Volume control
Pressure control
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
3/14
CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009 419
MIRELES-CABODEVILA AND COLLEAGUES
I t t tt w, w rb m t b trt m m- tt. W w xp y t tr-t m t m rw (TABLE 1,TABLE 2), but mr rmt tr trt- m b u wr.1,2 W wu rt ut pttr m tt.
ADAPTIVE PRESSURE CONTROL
O t r wt prur-tr -tt tt t t urt mmum
mut tt (t um r tt
ut 1 mut; t t um brt pr mut) t u m r ptt rt, r bt. T t prbm, 1991 t Sm Sr300 ttr (Sm, Mqut Crt CrAB, S, Sw) tru Prur R-ut Vum Ctr, m tt rprur-tr brt wt trt tum tt trw kw p-t prur tr (APC) (FIGURE 2).
Other names or adaptive pressure controlPrur Rut Vum Ctr (M-
qut Sr-, Rttt, Grmy)
A mode
o ventilation
is only as good
as the operator
who applies it
TABLE 1
Mechanical breath terminology
Mechanical breath descriptionControl variablethe mechanical breath goal, ie, a set pressure or a set volume
Trigger variablethat which starts inspiration, ie, the patient (generating changes in pressure or fow)or a set rate (time between breaths)
Limit variablethe maximum value during inspiration
Cycle variablethat which ends inspiration
Breath sequenceContinuous mandatory ventilationall breaths are controlled by the ventilator, so usually they have thesame characteristics regardless o the trigger (patient or set rate); no spontaneous breaths are allowed
Intermittent mandatory ventilationa set number o mechanical breaths is delivered regardless o the
trigger (patient initiation or set rate); spontaneous breaths are allowed between or during mandatorybreaths
Continuous spontaneous ventilationall breaths are spontaneous with or without assistance
Tpe o control or targeting scheme a
Set pointthe ventilator delivers and maintains a set goal, and this goal is constant (eg, in pressurecontrol, the set point is pressure, which will remain constant throughout the breath); to a degree, all modeshave some set-point control scheme
Servothe ventilator adjusts its output to a given patient variable (ie, in proportional assist ventilation,the inspiratory fow ollows and amplies the patients own fow pattern)
Adaptivethe ventilator adjusts a set point to maintain a dierent operator-selected set point (ie, in
pressure-regulated volume control, the inspiratory pressure is adjusted breath to breath to achieve a targettidal volume)
Optimalthe ventilator uses a mathematical model to calculate the set points to achieve a goal (ie, inadaptive support ventilation, the pressure, respiratory rate, and tidal volume are adjusted to achieve a goalminute ventilation)
a Mentioned in this review; or more inormation, reer to Chatburn1
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
4/14
420 CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009
MECHANICAL VENTILATION
AutFw (Drr M AG, Lbk,Grmy)Apt Prur Vtt (HmtG, Hmt M AG, Buz,Swtzr)Vum Ctr+ (Purt Btt, TyHtr; Mf, MA)Vum Trt Prur Ctr, Pr-ur Ctr Vum Gurt (E-
trm, Gr Etr, M, WI).
What does adaptive pressure control do?T APC m r prur-trbrt wt pt trt m(TABLE 2).
I prur-tr tt, t -um p t u py m- (mp rt) pttrt (FIGURE 1). Trr, t t umr wt u pyy (,
rr r mr t um t trt).
Mechanical
breaths can be
delivered only
via pressure
control or
volume control
TABLE 2
Classifcation o modes o ventilation
CONTROL VARIABLE BREATH SEQUENCE TARGETING SCHEME EXAMPLES O COMMERCIALLy AVAILABLE MODES
Volume Continuousmandatoryventilation
Set point Volume control, VC-A/C, CMV, (S)CMV,Assist/Control
Dual CMV + pressure limited
Adaptive Adaptive fow
Intermittentmandatoryventilation
Set point SIMV, VC-SIMV
Dual SIMV + pressure limited
Adaptive AutoMode (VC-VS), mandatory minute volume
Pressure Continuousmandatory
ventilation
Set point Pressure control, PC-A/C, AC PCV,high-pressure oscillatory ventilation a
Adaptive Pressure-regulated volume control, a VC+AC a,AMV+AutoFlow a
Intermittentmandatoryventilation
Set point Airway pressure-release ventilation, aSIMV PCV, BiLevel, a PCV+ a
Adaptive VC+SIMV, V V+SIMV APVSIMV,SIMV+AutoFlow, Automode (PRVC-VS)
Optimal Adaptive support ventilation a
Continuousspontaneousventilation
Set point Continuous positive airway pressure,pressure support
Dual Volume assured pressure support,
volume augmentServo Proportional assist ventilation, a automatic
tube compensation
Adaptive Volume support
Intelligent SmartCare
Three levels o classication o the modes o mechanical ventilation. As noted in the text, or a given combination o control vari-
able, breath sequence, and targeting scheme, several commercial mode names are described. Each commercial mode name can
have subtle dierences rom others in the same class; however, the main characteristics o the mode can be determined by this
classication.a Discussed in this paper
CMV = continuous mandatory ventilation, CSV = continuous spontaneous ventilation, IMV = intermittent mandatory ventilation,
SIMV = synchronized intermittent mandatory ventilation
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
5/14
CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009 421
MIRELES-CABODEVILA AND COLLEAGUES
T rm t t, m APCm jut t prtry prur t rt t mm trt t um. I t -um r, t m r t -prtry prur, t um r,t m r t prtry prur.Hwr, t ptt rt r u,t t um w r pt r- t prtry prur (FIGURE 2). T jut-mt t t prtry prur ur tr tt um -trt umbr brt.
Common sources o conusionwith adaptive pressure controlFrt, APC t um-tr m. Ium tr, t t um t; APC t t um rr r, t ttr w jut tt prur t t trt um.Tu, APC urt r mmumt um but t mxmum t um.
S, rtrt prur -tr ( , APC) tt t w r t mt tt rwy prur(, mt t t prtry prur).T rtrt w ptt w -rt prtry rt t r w
m, w ky mr mrtb.
T ty rt rm um -tr, w w t by t prtr fx. Tu, t ptt rt tr u (FIGURE 1), t t wt w yry, w t ptt t t t w k r brt.
Ventilator settingsin adaptive pressure controlVttr tt APC r:
T umTm pt prt (prtry tm)FrquyFrt pr xy (F o2)Pt -xprtry prur (PEEP).Sm ttr rqur tt t
p t r t pk prur ( kw p prt r prtry r tm).
Clinical applicationso adaptive pressure controlT m t mt -tt t um ur prur-trtt t prmt prtry wyry. It m utmty r-u ttry upprt (, w) t ptt prtry rt bm tr-
r, wk rm t.
The response o
the ventilator
to the patient is
regulated in a
number o ways
Target tidal volumeset by operator
Target tidal volumeset by operator
Inspiratory pressure isadjusted to maintaina target tidal volume
Larger respiratory
effort
Small respiratory
effort
No respiratory
effort
Airway
pressure
Patienteffort
Volume
Flow
Pressure
FIGURE 2. A machine in adaptive pressure control mode (top) adjusts the inspiratory pressure to main-tain a set tidal volume. Adaptive support ventilation (bottom) automatically selects the appropriatetidal volume and requency or mandatory breaths and the appropriate tidal volume or spontaneousbreaths on the basis o the respiratory system mechanics and the target minute ventilation.
Adaptive support ventilation
Adaptive pressure control
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
6/14
422 CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009
MECHANICAL VENTILATION
APC adjusts
the inspira-
tory pressure
to deliver the
set target tidal
volume
APC my t b r ptt w pprprty r rpr-try r (, r mtb ), t prtry prur w r t
mt t trt r t um,pprprty t t wrk brtt t ptt.
Theoretical beneftso adaptive pressure controlAPC urt mmum r t -um (u t prur rm tr tt w, tt t trt t um tr). Otr trt bft r wyry, ttr mput by tprtr, utmt w ttr
upprt.
Evidence o benefto adaptive pressure control Physiologic benefts. T m wrpk prtry prur t um-tr tt,3,4 w t rprt pt f. Hwr, um-tr m (t uu mprtr), tpk prtry prur mtt bt rt mp. H, pkprtry prur xpt t b rbut t rt tu u-tprur. It t ptu prur, m-tt u mp, tt rt tu jury. Patient comort. APC my r twrk brt w u w t -um tt w tr rrprtry rt (r).5 Itrty, APCw mrtb t prur upprttt m tr.6
Outcomes t b tu.7
Adaptive pressure control: Bottom lineAPC wy b wy u,mtm ukwy (, t prtrtk t um tr). It rtyy t u t t; wr, tbft t.
ADAPTIVE SUPPORT VENTILATION
Apt upprt tt (ASV) rm mtry mut tt
mpmt wt pt prur tr.
Mtry mut tt m ttw t prtr t prt trt muttt, t ttr t uppmtry brt, tr um- r pr-
ur-tr, t ptt ptubrt rt wr mut tt.
ASV utmty t t pprpr-t t um rquy r mtrybrt t pprprt t um rptu brt t b t rp-rtry ytm m trt mutr tt.
Drb 1994 by Lubr t ,8,9ASV bm mmry b 1998 Eurp 2007 t Ut Stt(Hmt G ttr, Hmt M-
AG). T t frt mmry -b ttr tt u ptm trt- m ( bw).
What does adaptive support ventilation do?ASV r prur-tr brt u- pt (ptm) m (TABLE 2).Optm, t txt, m mmzt m wrk brt: t m- t t um rquy ttt ptt br wu prumby t t ptt wr t t t t-tr. T pttr um t ur tptt t rt ptu brt.
T ttr ut t rm r-qur mut tt b t p-tt wt tmt pum (, 2.2 mL/k). T utrprt 100% mut tt. T t t b t trt prt mut tt tt t ttr wupprtr t 100% t ptt r rqurmt u, , t p r -r p, r t 100% urw.
T ttr ty r ttbrt, w t mur t xprtrytm tt r t rprtry ytm t u t wt t tmt p rm mut tt t u-t ptm brt rquy trm m wrk.
T ptm r trt t um u-t t rm mut tt - by t ptm rquy. T trt t
um by t u APC (
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
7/14
CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009 423
MIRELES-CABODEVILA AND COLLEAGUES
b) (FIGURE 2). T m tt t prurmt utmty jut t r r t um qu t ttrt. T ttr tuuy mtr
t rprtry ytm m jutt tt ry.
T ttr jut t brt t r trpp by w u tm t x-, t yptt by rt um rtr t t p, t utrum by r tum.
Ventilator settingsin adaptive support ventilationVttr tt ASV r:
Ptt t (t ut t bywt)SxPrt rm prt mut -tt F o2PEEP.
Clinical applicationso adaptive support ventilationASV t m t-t, rm t upprt t w.
Theoretical beneftso adaptive support ventilationI try, ASV r utmt t ttr tt, utmt ptt t ptt u m, r um mput t m, m-pr yry, utmt w.
Evidence o benefto adaptive support ventilation
Physiologic benefts.Vttr tt
r jut utmty. ASV t -rt t um-rprtry rt mb-t b rprtry m p pryz ptt.1012 I ty brt- ptt, tr w r tttr tt by ASV r r-t r ( u pyy).10Cmpr wt prur-tr trmt-tt mtry tt, wt ASV, tprtry ptt-ttrtrt bttr.13
Patient-ventilator synchrony and com-
ort t b tu. Outcomes. Tw tr ut ttASV my r tm mtt.14,15 Hwr, tr tr,16
mpr wt tr prt, ASV t wr ttr jutmt but mr ptur w utm. Tt t m t t rt tb xm.17,18
Adaptive support ventilation: Bottom lineASV t frt mmry b mtt utmty t t ttrtt xpt PEEP Fio2. T mpprprt r rt r ptt wt pr rprtry rt r
pryz ptt. E t t ty brt ptt utmu t ty r t t k-.
PROPORTIONAL ASSIST VENTILATION
Ptt w rm rprtry rbut w futy ut qutptu tt r t ubjtt prur upprt tt (PSV), w t ttr rt ttprur truut prt rr t tty t ptt rt.
I 1992, Yu u19,20 -p prprt t tt (PAV) trt w t ttr -rt prur prprt t t pttrt. PAV bm mmry b Eurp 1999 w ppr tUt Stt 2006, b t Pur-t Btt 840 ttr (Purt BttC, Bur, CO). PAV b u r tt, but t t -b t Ut Stt.
Other names or proportionalassist ventilationPrprt Prur Supprt (Drr M-; t yt b t Ut Stt).
What does proportionalassist ventilation do?T m r prur-trbrt wt r tr m (TABLE 2).
T bttr urt PAV, w mpr
APC
is not a
volume-
controlled
mode
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
8/14
424 CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009
MECHANICAL VENTILATION
ASV selects
a tidal volume
and requency
that the
patients
brain would
presumably
select
t wt PSV. Wt PSV, t prur pp byt ttr r t prt tt tt ( t-pt m) ut yrtr ( prt t mxmum prt-ry w u) r. T prtry w t um r t rut t pttprtry rt, t prur pp, t rprtry ytm m.
I trt, ur PAV, t prur pp ut ptt rt: t rtr tprtry rt, t rtr t r p-p prur (r trt m) (FIGURE3). T prtr t t prt upprtt b r by t ttr. T t-tr trmttty mur t mp rt t ptt rprtry ytm t ttu ptt-rt w um, t b t t r prprt mut prtry prur.
I PAV, PSV, brt r pt-u (TABLE 1). T ptt tr t tm z t brt. Tr r prt pr-ur, w, r um , but ty mt t um prur r b t.
Ventilator settingsin proportional assist ventilationVttr tt PAV r:
Arwy typ (tr tub, tr-tmy)Arwy z (r mtr)Prt wrk upprt (t r5%95%)T um mtPrur mt
Exprtry tty (rmy, p-
rt , w u tp; t prm-tr t t ttr t wt w t prt).
Caution when assessing the literature.Err ttr r, , Drr M-tb (Urty Mtb, Wp, MB,C), w r t b t UtStt, rqur t rpt ut trprtry ytm m t mutt w um t (mpfttr) pty. T rm t m-tt, w twr utmty jut tw um mpft t upprt t mp by t utmty muru rt t (r mp) t rprtry ytm.21 Ttwr u t m (Purt B-tt) b t Ut Stt.
Clinical applicationso proportional assist ventilationT PAV m t r mxmzttr ptt yry r t p-tu tt.
PAV trt ptt wtrprtry pr (bryp) r r rk (, brpur ftu). It ub u wt ut ptt wt ryprt, w t ptt my tb x but t ttr t r-z t. Atr rup w PAV ub u wt ut t wt -ttry r, w t ttr r-tmt rprtry ytm m. Ttut t rt u t t
ruwy pm, w t t-
Ventilator measuringrespiratory system
characteristics
Flow, pressure, and volume deliveredby the ventilator are adjusted
proportionally to patient effort
Patienteffort
Volume
Flow
Pressure
FIGURE 3. In proportional assist ventilation, the fow, pressure, and volume delivered are adjustedproportionally to the patients eort.
Proportional assist ventilation
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
9/14
CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009 425
MIRELES-CABODEVILA AND COLLEAGUES
In PAV, the
greater the
inspiratory
eort, the
greater the
increase in
applied
pressure
tr tu t pr upprt tptt tpp prt.22
Theoretical benefts
o proportional assist ventilationI try, PAV u ru t wrk brt, mpr yry, utmtypt t ptt u m rt, r t r ttr tr-t mput, r t r t, mpr p.
Evidence o benefto proportional assist ventilation Physiologic benefts. PAV ru t wrk brt bttr t PSV,21 t
rprtry m r -r rprtry m (yprp).2325T mym prf mr t tt PSV. T um r rb; wr, rt rprt t t um wr wtt u-prtt r (68 mL/k, ptuprur < 30 m H20).
26,27
Comort. PAV t ptt rt mrt tt PSV .23,25 PAV -fty ru yry,27 w turmy rby t p rty p-tt.28
Outcomes. T prbbty ptubrt wtut t w ftybttr rty ptt tt wtPAV t wt PSV. N tr rprt tt PAV t.27,29
Proportional assist ventilation: Bottom lineExt b rr b wtPAV rt rm rprtry ur,u btrut u , ut rpr-try tr yrm (ARDS), r r-prtry ur. It uf t m , w t mpr ptt-ttr yry. C- xpr wt PAV t Ut Stt mt, t w y rty ppr.
AIRWAy PRESSURE-RELEASEVENTILATION ANDBIPHASIC POSITIVE AIRWAy PRESSURE
Arwy prur-r tt (APRV)w rb 1987 by Stk t 30 m r r tt ut u
jury w rwy prur.
APRV mb tt pt rwyprur (mpr xyt prmt- r rrutmt) wt trmtttr (u xt).
I 1989, Bum t 31 rb bp- pt rwy prur tt m w ptu tt ub t y pt t mtt yprt r xt(FIGURE 4). T w t w urtrtptu brt t ru t prmt w. T m r ptu-y t m, t m r b ttt tm pt w prur (T w; b-w) t 1.5 r APRV. Otr-w, ty t rtrt, tu
w y ttr wt t pbty r APRV t r bp p-t rwy prur, r. Mwt t m bm mmry -b t m 1990.
Other names or biphasic positive airwapressureOtr m r bp pt rwy pr-ur r:
BL (Purt Btt)BIPAP (Drr Eurp)B Vt (Sm)BP (A, Cr Ht, I,Dub, OH)PCV+ (Drr M)DuPAP (Hmt).
Cautionname conusion. I NrtAmr, BPAP (Rpr, Murry,PA) BL r u t rr t - m tt.
APRV tr m.
What do these modes do?T m r prur-tr,tm-trr, tm-y brt u- t-pt trt m (TABLE 2). Tm tt t ttr mt -tt prur (t pt) t ptu brt. Cautionsource o conusion. T trmtuu pt rwy prur (CPAP) t u t rb t m. Hwr,CPAP prur tt pp tuuyt t m ; t ptt rt
t wrk t mt tt (prur-
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
10/14
426 CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009
MECHANICAL VENTILATION
tr tuu ptu t-t t urrt mtur). I APRV,t rwy prur trmttty r rpp, rt t um ttupprt tt. I tr wr, t prur-tr brt wt ry pr- prtry tm rt xprtrytm w ptu tt p-b t y pt (prur-tr tr-mttt mtry tt t urrtmtur).
Hw t m r t t ttrmy b ur u. T rbt tm pt w rwy pr-ur, w u t trm T
T
w, rp-
ty. By t, t r btwAPRV bp m t urt Tw (< 1.5 r APRV).
Smry, P Pw r u t rbt w rwy prur. T bttr u-rt t pt, yu rt t mm t prur-tr t-t by tk t T t prtrytm, t Tw t xprtry tm, t P prtry prur, t Pw PEEP.
H, APRV xtrm rm -
r rt tt, wt prt-t-
xprt rt 4:1. T m pttp mt t tm P T, xt r rt (Tw Pw). I -trt, t bp m u tprt-xprt rt (FIGURE 4).
A wt y rm prur tr, tt um rt by rwy prurr b b (, t -xprtryu). H, t ur r muttt, t mtry brt rt mutb r (, r T, Tw, r bt)r t t um mut b r (, -r t r btw P Pw).T m tt APRV t Tw t p-p mr t (by r t umbr brt) r b mr pr (w mrr t x). Bu urtrt pt-u brt r prmtt t y pt ty, t ptt trbut t t tt m-ut tt (uuy 10%40%).
I APRV bp m, t pr-tr t tm prur prt xprt w b r rr tptt brt rtt ptt p-tu brt t trr mbrt. Sm ttr utmt -
jutmt t mpr t trr yry.
Spontaneous breaths occurat any point without altering
the ventilator-deliveredbreaths
Thigh
:Tlow
= 4:1Phigh
and Thigh
Plow
and Tlow
Thigh
:Tlow
= 1:14Phigh
and Thigh
Plow
and Tlow
Volume
Pressure
FIGURE 4. Airway pressure-release ventilation (top) and biphasic positive airway pressure (bottom)are orms o pressure-controlled intermittent mandatory ventilation in which spontaneous breathscan occur at any point without altering the ventilator-delivered breaths. The dierence is that thetime spent in high pressure is greater in airway pressure-release ventilation.
Biphasic positive airway pressure
Airway pressure-release ventilation
APRV allows
spontaneous
breaths at any
point in the
cycle
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
11/14
CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009 427
MIRELES-CABODEVILA AND COLLEAGUES
Ventilator settingsin APRV and biphasic modeT m rqur t tt tw prur (P Pw) tw tm urt
(T Tw). O prur upprtr utmt tub mpt t t p-tu brt. T r Tw r-t r t T:Tw rt: APRV rt Tw ( prt-xprt r-t 4:1). Bp m tprt-xprt rt 1:1 t 1:4.
Clinical applications APRV u ut u jury ARDS. T m u b u wt u-t r t t ptt wt btrut
u r pprprty r r-prtry r.3235
Biphasic mode t r bt t-t w. I ptt w prrprtry rt r w pryz, bp- t t prur-tr/tuumtry tt.
Theoretical beneftso APRV and biphasic modeMutp bft b rb t tm. I try, APRV w mxmz mt r rrutmt, mpr xy-t, wr t prur, rrt. Bt APRV bp, by pr-r ptu brt, w mprtt-pru mt u,mpr t mym prf ( rprr, r r utput, ru -trur wrk, mpr r pru), mpr yry (r t wrk brt t r t).
Evidence o beneft o APRVand biphasic modeAPRV bp r rt m.Hwr tu ut tr t rmb. T prt t rut t -mtur u rt prt rt utr.36
Physiologic benefts. I tu, pt-u brt trbut t 10% t 40% mut tt,37,38 mpr tt pt r t u, mpr -tt-pru mt rrutmt,39
mpr mym prf.40
Patient comort. T m rtut t r t r t,38 but rt tr w r wt prur-tr trmt-
tt mtry tt.41 Ptt t-tr yry mrt t btu.32,42
Outcomes. I m tr, t mm r trm t, butty my r t t mtt.38,41,43,44
APRV and biphasic mode: Bottom lineMt ptu brt w m tt mym ttry bft.
APRV bp m r t t mt. APRV m t mxmz mrwy prur , , u rrutmt,wr t m t bp m yry.
Tr ptr ttr tt qut rt t py t.33,34,36
Atu t m r wy u m tr, tr yt ttty r uprr t t um- rprur-tr tt wt w t -um r ARDS ut u jury. Tr u tt t m m-pr yry, tm t w, r pttmrt.
HIGH-REQUENCyOSCILLATORy VENTILATION
H-rquy try tt(HFOV) w frt rb ptt 1952 by Emr w y p t ry 1970 by Lukmr.45
T HFOV t mmz ujury; t rtrt (u bw)mk t uu ptt wt r ARDS.T US F Dru Amtrt p-pr t r t 1991 r r 1995. T ut m b b 1993, but t w t ppr ut 2001(SrM 3100B, Cr Ht, I).
Other names or high-requencoscillator ventilationW HFOV trt m, t
w rym rb mr m:
Maintaining
spontaneous
breathing while
on mechanical
ventilation has
benefts
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
12/14
428 CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009
MECHANICAL VENTILATION
HFPPV (-rquy pt prurtt)HFJV (-rquy jt tt)HFFI (-rquy w trrupt)HFPV (-rquy pru t-t)HFCWO (-rquy t w -t).A t m rqur rt p-
z ttr.
What does high-requencoscillator ventilation do?Cptuy, HFOV rm prur-tr trmttt mtry t-t wt t-pt tr m. Itrt t t prur-trtrmttt mtry tt, wrty m ptu brt my buprmp rty r mtrybrt, HFOV uprmp ry m m-try brt (t) tp pt-u brt.
HFOV b r y wt p- ttr. T ttr r tt w (b w), w r-t rt t mt rwy prur, tp w pt pump t trqu 3 t 15 Hz (160900 brt/mut). T rt tt rwy pr-ur wt m t (FIGURE 5); t, t t b k r t tw t t pprprt mptutt, tu t t b ytm-ty tu.
Aut ptt r uuy pryz r
py t, p ptubrt w trr rm t t-tr prrm.
T m tt (CO2 r), r r t w mur b : r t t rquy,r t mptu t t, -r t prtry tm, r r bw (w w tr tub uk). Oxyt jutmt r trby mput t m rwy prur t Fio2.
Ventilator settingsin high-requenc oscillator ventilationVttr tt HFOV r46:
Arwy prur mptu (t P rpwr)M rwy prurPrt prtIprtry b wF io2.
Clinical applicationso high-requenc oscillator ventilationT m uuy rr r ARDS p-tt r wm t tt . A rty pub prt46 u-t r HFOV w tr xy-t ur (Fio2 0.7 PEEP 14 mH2O) r tt ur (pH < 7.25 wtt um 6 mL/k prt by wt ptu rwy prur 30 m H2O).
T m trt wtr kw r rw btrut r
trr yprt.
Frequency
Mean airwaypressure
Tidal volume
Airway pressureamplitude (power)
FIGURE 5. High-requency oscillatory ventilation delivers very small mandatory breaths (oscillations)at requencies o up to 900 breaths per minute.
The goal
o HFOV
is to minimize
lung injury,
especially
in ARDS
High-requency oscillatory ventilation
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
13/14
CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009 429
MIRELES-CABODEVILA AND COLLEAGUES
Theoretical beneftso high-requenc oscillator ventilationCptuy, HFOV pr t -t m rwy prur pr wt t w-
t t um y m. T bftmt mk HFOV t u-prtttt trty.
Evidence o benefto high-requenc oscillator ventilation Physiologic benefts. Am m w t m u m-mt wt HFOV t wt -t-um t tt47,48 w-t-um t tt.49
Patient comort t b tu.
Hwr, urrt ty mpuu wrk brt ptuybrt ptt.50
Outcomes. Sr rtrpt -r rb bttr xyt wt
HFOV ru trpy r r ARDSt wt t m t-t. Tw rmz tr tr tu HFOV -t-um -
t m tt r ry rARDS; HFOV w but m r- trm t.42,5154
High-requenc oscillator ventilation:Bottom lineI try, HFOV pr t bft u-prtt trty, t t r pr-yz r py t ptt. Am tu- upprt t pt. I um ut,HFOV b w t b t pr- bttr xyt but mprmt
t rt mpr wt tm tt. Currty, HFOV bttr rr r ptt wt r ARDSr wm t m t-t .
REERENCES
1. Chatburn RL. Classication o ventilator modes: update and pro-
posal or implementation. Respir Care 2007; 52:301323.
2. Chatburn RL. Computer control o mechanical ventilation. Respir
Care 2004; 49:507517.
3. Alvarez A, Subirana M, Benito S. Decelerating fow ventilation e-
ects in acute respiratory ailure. J Crit Care 1998; 13:2125.
4. Guldager H, Nielsen SL, Carl P, Soerensen MB. A comparison ovolume control and pressure regulated volume control ventilation
in acute respiratory ailure. Crit Care 1997; 1:7577.
5. Kallet RH, Campbell AR, Dicker RA, Katz JA, Mackersie RC. Work o
breathing during lung protective ventilation in patients with acute
lung injury and acute respiratory distress syndrome: a comparison
between volume and pressure regulated breathing modes. Respir
Care 2005; 50:16231631.
6. Betensley AD, Khalid I, Crawford J, Pensler RA, DiGiovine B. Patient
comort during pressure support and volume controlled continuous
mandatory ventilation. Respir Care 2008; 53:897902.
7. Branson RD, Chatburn RL. Controversies in the critical care setting.
Should adaptive pressure control modes be utilized or virtually
all patients receiving mechanical ventilation? Respir Care 2007;
52:478485.
8. Laubscher TP, Frutiger A, Fanconi S, Jutzi H, Brunner JX. Automatic
selection o tidal volume, respiratory requency and minute ventila-
tion in intubated ICU patients as start up procedure or closed-loop
controlled ventilation. Int J Clin Monit Comput 1994; 11:1930.
9. Laubscher TP, Heinrichs W, Weiler N, Hartmann G, Brunner JX . An
adaptive lung ventilation controller. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 1994;
41:5159.
10. Arnal JM, Wysocki M, Nafati C, et al. Automatic selection o breath-
ing pattern using adaptive support ventilation. Intensive Care Med
2008; 34:7581.
11. Campbell RS, Sinamban RP, Johannigman JA, et al . Clinical evalu-
ation o a new closed loop ventilation mode: adaptive supportive
ventilation (ASV). Crit Care 1999; 3(suppl 1):083.
12. Belliato M, Palo A, Pasero D, Iotti GA, Mojoli F, Braschi A. Evaluation
o adaptive support ventilation in paralysed patients and in a physi-
cal lung model. Int J Arti Organs 2004; 27:709716.
13. Tassaux D, Dalmas E, Gratadour P, Jolliet P. Patient ventilator
interactions during partial ventilatory support: a preliminary study
comparing the eects o adaptive support ventilation with synchro-
nized intermittent mandatory ventilation plus inspiratory pressure
support. Crit Care Med 2002; 30:801807.
14. Gruber PC, Gomersall CD, Leung P, et al. Randomized controlled trial
comparing adaptive-support ventilation with pressure-regulated
volume-controlled ventilation with automode in weaning patients
ater cardiac surgery. Anesthesiology 2008; 109:8187.
15. Sulzer CF, Chiolero R, Chassot PG, et al . Adaptive support ventila-tion or ast tracheal extubation ater cardiac surgery: a randomized
controlled study. Anesthesiology 2001; 95:13391345.
16. Petter AH, Chiolro RL, Cassina T, Chassot PG, Mller XM, Revelly
JP. Automatic respirator/weaning with adaptive support ventila-
tion: the eect on duration o endotracheal intubation and patient
management. Anesth Analg 2003; 97:17431750.
17. Brunner JX, Iotti GA. Adaptive support ventilation (ASV). Minerva
Anestesiol 2002; 68:365368.
18. Campbell RS, Branson RD, Johannigman JA. Adaptive support venti-
lation. Respir Care Clin North Am 2001; 7:425440.
19. Younes M. Proportional assist ventilation, a new approach to venti-
latory support. Theory. Am Rev Respir Dis 1992; 145:114120.
20. Younes M, Puddy A, Roberts D, et al. Proportional assist ventilation.
Results o an initial clinical trial. Am Rev Respir Dis 1992; 145:121
129.
21. Kondili E, Prinianakis G, Alexopoulou C, Vakouti E, Klimathianaki M,
Georgopoulos D. Respiratory load compensation during mechanical
ventilatioproportional assist ventilation with load-adjustable gain
actors versus pressure support. Intensive Care Med 2006; 32:692
699.
22. Kondili E, Prinianakis G, Alexopoulou C, Vakouti E, Klimathianaki
M, Georgopoulos D. Eect o dierent levels o pressure support
and proportional assist ventilation on breathing pattern, work o
breathing and gas exchange in mechanically ventilated hypercap-
nic COPD patients with acute respiratory ailure. Respiration 2003;
70:355361.
23. Grasso S, Puntillo F, Mascia L, et al. Compensation or increase in re-
spiratory workload during mechanical ventilation. Pressure support
versus proportional assist ventilation. Am J Respir Crit Care Med
2000; 161:819826.
24. Wrigge H, Golisch W, Zinserling J, Sydow M, Almeling G, Burchardi
-
8/2/2019 Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 2009 MIRELES CABODEVILA 417 30
14/14
430 CLEVELAND CLINIC JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOLUME 76 NUMBER 7 JULY 2009
MECHANICAL VENTILATION
H. Proportional assist versus pressure support ventilation: eects on
breathing pattern and respiratory work o patients with chronic ob-
structive pulmonary disease. Intensive Care Med 1999; 25:790798.
25. Ranieri VM, Giuliani R, Mascia L, et al. Patient ventilator interaction
during acute hypercapnia: pressure support vs. proportional assist
ventilation. J Appl Physiol 1996; 81:426436.
26. Kondili E, Xirouchaki N, Vaporidi K, Klimathianaki M, GeorgopoulosD. Short-term cardiorespiratory eects o proportional assist and
pressure support ventilation in patients with acute lung injury/acute
respiratory distress syndrome. Anesthesiology 2006; 105:703708.
27. Xirouchaki N, Kondili E, Vaporidi K, et al. Proportional assist ven-
tilation with load-adjustable gain actors in critically ill patients:
comparison with pressure support. Intensive Care Med 2008;
34:20262034.
28. Bosma K, Ferreyra G, Ambrogio C, et al . Patient ventilator inter-
action and sleep in mechanically ventilated patients: pressure
support versus proportional assist ventilation. Crit Care Med 2007;
35:10481054.
29. Sinderby C, Beck J. Proportional assist ventilation and neurally
adjusted ventilatory assistbetter approaches to patient ventilator
synchrony? Clin Chest Med 2008; 29:329342.
30. Stock MC, Downs JB, Frolicher DA. Airway pressure release ventila-
tion. Crit Care Med 1987; 15:462466.31. Baum M, Benzer H, Putensen C, Koller W, Putz G. [Biphasic positive
airway pressure (BIPAP)a new orm o augmented ventilation].
Anaesthesist 1989; 38:452458.
32. Seymour CW, Frazer M, Reilly PM, Fuchs BD. Airway pressure release
and biphasic intermittent positive airway pressure ventilation: are
they ready or prime time? J Trauma 2007; 62:12981308.
33. Myers TR, MacIntyre NR. Respiratory controversies in the critical
care setting. Does airway pressure release ventilation oer impor-
tant new advantages in mechanical ventilator support? Respir Care
2007; 52:452458.
34. Neumann P, Golisch W, Strohmeyer A, Buscher H, Burchardi H, Sy-
dow M. Infuence o dierent release times on spontaneous breath-
ing pattern during airway pressure release ventilation. Intensive
Care Med 2002; 28:17421749.
35. Calzia E, Lindner KH, Witt S, et al. Pressure-time product and work
o breathing during biphasic continuous positive airway pressure
and assisted spontaneous breathing. Am J Respir Crit Care Med
1994; 150:904910.
36. Rose L, Hawkins M. Airway pressure release ventilation and biphasic
positive airway pressure: a systematic review o denitional criteria.
Intensive Care Med 2008; 34:17661773.
37. Sydow M, Burchardi H, Ephraim E, Zielmann S, Crozier TA. Long-
term eects o two dierent ventilatory modes on oxygenation in
acute lung injury. Comparison o airway pressure release ventilation
and volume-controlled inverse ratio ventilation. Am J Respir Crit
Care Med 1994; 149:15501556.
38. Putensen C, Zech S, Wrigge H, et al . Long-term eects o spontane-
ous breathing during ventilatory support in patients with acute
lung injury. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2001; 164:4349.
39. Davis K Jr, Johnson DJ, Branson RD, Campbell RS, Johannigman JA,
Porembka D. Airway pressure release ventilation. Arch Surg 1993;128:13481352.
40. Kaplan LJ, Bailey H, Formosa V. Airway pressure release ventilation
increases cardiac perormance in patients with acute lung injury/
adult respiratory distress syndrome. Crit Care 2001; 5:221226.
41. Varpula T, Valta P, Niemi R, Takkunen O, Hynynen M, Pettil VV .
Airway pressure release ventilation as a primary ventilatory mode in
acute respiratory distress syndrome. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2004;
48:722731.
42. Siau C, Stewart TE. Current role o high requency oscillatory
ventilation and airway pressure release ventilation in acute lunginjury and acute respiratory distress syndrome. Clin Chest Med 2008;
29:265275.
43. Rathgeber J, Schorn B, Falk V, Kazmaier S, Spiegel T, Burchardi H.
The infuence o controlled mandatory ventilation (CMV), intermit-
tent mandatory ventilation (IMV) and biphasic intermittent positive
airway pressure (BIPAP) on duration o intubation and consumption
o analgesics and sedatives. A prospective analysis in 596 patients
ollowing adult cardiac surgery. Eur J Anaesthesiol 1997; 14:576
582.
44. Habashi NM. Other approaches to open lung ventilation: airway
pressure release ventilation. Crit Care Med 2005; 33(suppl 3):S228
S240.
45. Hess D, Mason S, Branson R. High-requency ventilation design and
equipment issues. Respir Care Clin North Am 2001; 7:577598.
46. Fessler HE, Derdak S, Ferguson ND, et al. A protocol or high re-
quency oscillatory ventilation in adults: results rom a roundtablediscussion. Crit Care Med 2007; 35:16491654.
47. Hamilton PP, Onayemi A, Smyth JA, et al. Comparison o con-
ventional and high-requency ventilation: oxygenation and lung
pathology. J Appl Physiol 1983; 55:131138.
48. Sedeek KA, Takeuchi M, Suchodolski K, et al. Open-lung protec-
tive ventilation with pressure control ventilation, high-requency
oscillation, and intratracheal pulmonary ventilation results in similar
gas exchange, hemodynamics, and lung mechanics. Anesthesiology
2003; 99:11021111.
49. Imai Y, Nakagawa S, Ito Y, Kawano T, Slutsky AS, Miyasaka K . Com-
parison o lung protection strategies using conventional and high-
requency oscillatory ventilation. J Appl Physiol 2001; 91:18361844.
50. van Heerde M, Roubik K, Kopelent V, Pltz FB, Markhorst DG.
Unloading work o breathing during high-requency oscillatory
ventilation: a bench study. Crit Care 2006; 10:R103.
51. Derdak S, Mehta S, Stewart TE, et al; Multicenter Oscillatory
Ventilation For Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Trial (MOAT)
Study Investigators. High-requency oscillatory ventilation or acute
respiratory distress syndrome in adults: a randomized, controlled
trial. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2002; 166:801808.
52. Bollen CW, van Well GT, Sherry T, et al . High-requency oscillatory
ventilation compared with conventional mechanical ventilation in
adult respiratory distress syndrome: a randomized controlled trial
[ISRCTN24242669]. Crit Care 2005; 9:R430R439.
53. Mehta S, Granton J, MacDonald RJ, et al. High requency oscillatory
ventilation in adults: the Toronto experience. Chest 2004; 126:518
527.
54. Chan KP, Stewart TE, Mehta S. High-requency oscillatory ventila-
tion or adult patients with ARDS. Chest 2007; 131:19071916.
ADDRESS: Eduardo Mireles-Cabodevila, MD, Department of Pulmonaryand Critical Care Medicine, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences,4301 West Markham Street, Slot 555, Little Rock, AR 77205; e mail [email protected].
WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO WRITE, tr
t rp t rt pub tJournal
r t r u mprt t
yu. Yu my ubmt
ttr by m, x, r -m.
MAILING ADDRESSLttr t t EtrCleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine9500 Eu A., NA32C, OH 44195
FAX 216.444.9385E-MAIL [email protected]
P b ur t u yur u r,p umbr, x umbr, -mr. P wrt y, p mt. Lttr my b t r ty t. W t rtur mtr t.Subm ttr ttut prmr t Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine tpub t ru t rm.
We Welcome Your LettersWe Welcome Your Letters