chapter 8 political parties © 2009, pearson education fiorina, peterson, johnson, and mayer new...
TRANSCRIPT
Chapter 8Political Parties
© 2009, Pearson Education
Fiorina, Peterson, Johnson, and MayerNew American Democracy, Sixth Edition
© 2009, Pearson Education
What Parties Do
Political Parties– Groups of like-minded people who band
together in an attempt to take control of government
– Central institutions of democratic governments
Parties represent the primary connection between ordinary citizens and the public officials they elect– But many people do not consider political
parties the heart of democracy– Many seem to think government would be
better without them
© 2009, Pearson Education
How Parties Contribute to Democratic Politics
What do parties offer that make them valuable to democratic government?– organizing and operating the government– focusing responsibility for government
action– developing issues and educating the public– synthesizing interests– recruiting and developing governmental
talent– simplifying the electoral systems
© 2009, Pearson Education
How Parties Detract from Democratic Politics
Capturing governments and dictating what they doConfusing responsibilitySuppressing the issuesDividing societyRecruiting candidates for the wrong reasonsOversimplifying the electoral system
© 2009, Pearson Education
The Balance Sheet
Are they good or bad for democracy?Safest Answer: they are both.But what would our system be like without parties?Reformers may want radical change, but they may not think fully of the consequences of such change.Still, we must think critically about the actions of parties and their influence in undermining representation.
© 2009, Pearson Education
Political Parties in American History
The United States pioneered the mass parties that are considered vital in modern EuropeThe first parties were composed of political notables who supported Jefferson and HamiltonQuickly these personal followings became mass parties– 1830s – Jacksonian Democrats and Whigs
• mass parties came much later in Europe– Today, parties are weaker but still very
important
© 2009, Pearson Education
The Party-Systems Interpretation of American History
Political change occurs constantly, but the system as a whole remains relatively stableOccasionally, dramatic events can make change occur quicklyRealignment scholars: four stable characteristics describe a party system:– The identity of the major parties– The relative balance of strength– The major issues– The party coalitions
Party systems can change gradually or, sometimes, suddenly.– Major changes in the system are called
realignments
© 2009, Pearson Education
© 2009, Pearson Education
Two-Party and Multi-Party Systems
Two-party system – System in which only two major parties
compete for office – In the minority among world democracies– Most democracies have multi-party systems
Electoral system– a means of translating popular votes into
control of public offices
© 2009, Pearson Education
Two-Party and Multi-Party Systems
Single-member, simple plurality system (SMSP)– Electoral system in which the country is
divided into geographic districts, and the candidates who win the most votes within their districts are elected
– The almost exclusive use of the SMSP electoral systems in the U.S. is an important part of the explanation for the American two-party system
Proportional Representation (PR)– Electoral system in which parties receive a
share of seats in parliament that is proportional to the popular vote they receive
© 2009, Pearson Education
Two-Party and Multi-Party Systems
In addition to the SMPS, other factors hurt the development of third parties in the U.S.– Ballot access laws– Campaign finance laws (presidential
elections)– Patterns of media coverage
© 2009, Pearson Education
© 2009, Pearson Education
How Strong Are American Political Parties Today?
In the 1970s, books were written about the decline and possible death of American political parties
In the 1980s, the tune changed
How did this happen?
Perhaps it lies in the conception of political party
© 2009, Pearson Education
How Strong Are American Political Parties Today?
Party in the electorate– Had declined between 1964 and 1974– Closet partisans– Today, ticket-splitting and party defection
rates are down
Party in government– Stronger than ever
Party organization– But what of party organizations?
© 2009, Pearson Education
The Decline of Party Organizations
Harder to evaluate
Party organizations were at their strongest at the point when the Progressive movement began
The decline of American party organizations was largely a consequence of deliberate public policies
– Elimination of party control of patronage
– Elimination of party control of nominations
© 2009, Pearson Education
The Decline of Party Organizations
Other factors:– Communications revolution lessened the
need for traditional parties– Technological developments have
diminished the need for party workers and party support• Elections rely instead on technology and
money– Increase in mobility: social, economic and
residential
© 2009, Pearson Education
The Revival of Party Organizations?
National committees were always the weakest level of the party organizations– Active only during presidential elections
Today, they are active and well-financedState and local parties are active and well-financed as wellYet, does this equal party organization revival?– Much less control over their candidates– Reluctance to punish officeholders who fail
to toe the party line– Contribute only fraction of resources
spent on electioneering
© 2009, Pearson Education
Parties Versus Interest Groups
Theory: power of interest groups is negatively correlated with the power of parties
Two premises:
– Parties have incentives to synthesize narrow interests in order to make the broad appeals necessary to win elections
– Strong parties can provide electoral resources and deliver the vote, freeing their candidates from dependence on interest-group resources and insulating them from reprisals
© 2009, Pearson Education
Parties Versus Interest Groups
Assumes two-party politics rather than multi-party politics.
– In the latter, parties often make narrow appeals.
Idea: when parties do not fill the political vacuum, then groups or some other influence will.
Alternative to party domination
– Not popular influence, but interest group influence