chapter 4 development and implementation of pbl...
TRANSCRIPT
66
CHAPTER 4
DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF PBL
BASED INSTRUCTIONS __________________________________________________________
4.1 DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF PBL BASED
INSTRUCTIONS IN ANALOG ELECTRONICS 4.1.1 SYLLABUS OF THEORY AND PRACTICAL COMPONENTS
The theory component covers the following:
HIGH FREQUENCY TRANSISTOR
The high frequency T-model, common base short circuit current frequency response,
alpha cutoff frequency, common emitter short circuit current frequency response,
hybrid-π CE transistor model, hybrid-π conductance in terms of low frequency h-
parameters, CE short circuit current gain obtained with hybrid-π model, current gain
with resistive load.
LARGE SIGNAL AMPLIFIERS
Class-A direct coupled with resistive load, transformer-coupled with resistive load,
design theory, power amplifier design, harmonic distortion, power output, variation
of output power with load, thermal runaway, output transformer saturation, push-pull
amplifiers, operation of class-A push-pull amplifier, class-B push-pull amplifier,
crossover distortion, class-AB push-pull amplifier, transistor phase inverter,
conversion efficiency of class-B amplifiers, design of Class-B push-pull amplifier,
complementary-symmetry amplifier.
MULTISTAGE AMPLIFIERS
Coupling of transistor amplifiers, frequency response of coupled amplifiers,
cascading of RC-Coupled amplifiers and their analysis, tuned amplifiers - single
tuned, double tuned and stagger tuned amplifiers and their analysis.
FEEDBACK IN AMPLIFIERS
Types of feedback, effect of negative feedback on gain, bandwidth, stability,
distortion and frequency response, voltage-series, current-series, voltage-shunt,
current-shunt feedback circuits and their analysis.
67
OSCILLATORS
Conditions of oscillations, different types of oscillators - RC Phase Shift, Wein
Bridge, Hartley, Colpitts and Crystal oscillators, derivation of expressions for
frequency and amplitude of these oscillators.
REGULATED POWER SUPPLIES
Zener diode as voltage regulator, transistor series and shunt regulators, current
limiting, line and load regulation.
The list of practical in EC212, as prescribed by PTU is:
1. To study the various coupling techniques for transistor amplifiers.
2. To study the characteristics of a Class-A amplifier.
3. To study the characteristics of Class-B amplifier.
4. To study the characteristics of Class-C amplifier.
5. To study the characteristics of Class-AB amplifier.
6. To study the characteristics of Class-B push-pull amplifier.
7. To study the characteristics of complementary symmetry amplifier.
8. To study transistor series voltage regulator with current limit and observe
current fold-back characteristics.
9. To study the response of RC phase shift oscillator and determine frequency
of oscillation.
10. To study the response of Hartley oscillator and determine frequency of
oscillation.
11. To study the response of Colpitt’s oscillator and determine frequency of
oscillation.
12. To study the response of Wien Bridge oscillator and determine frequency of
oscillation.
68
4.1.2 TIME PLAN FOR CG AND TG
As shown in the table 4.1, while the students in CG were being taught by Traditional
method, the students in TG [55a] were solving open ended Technical Problems as
given in section 4.1.3.1. The time line for covering the syllabus and distribution of
ATS, MSTs and End semester Knowledge and skill tests are shown in table 4.1. The
second unit – ‘High Frequency Transistor’ was covered in traditional way only, for
both CG and TG. This table also shows how the time plans for TG and CG were
made parallel for delivery schedule.
The four assessment tools – ATSs, MSTs, End Semester Knowledge Test and End
Semester Skill Test are given in Appendices C, D, E and F respectively.
69
S. No.
Topic CG DATE TG ATS
1 Class-A direct coupled with resistive load, transformer coupled with resistive load, design theory, power amplifier design, harmonic distortion, power output, variation of output power with load, thermal runaway, output transformer saturation, push-pull amplifiers, operation of class-A push-pull amplifier, class-B push-pull amplifier, crossover distortion, class-AB push-pull amplifier, transistor phase inverter, conversion efficiency of class-B amplifiers, design of Class-B push-pull amplifier, complementary- symmetry amplifier.
08 19 Jan
to 7 Feb
TP1 TP2
ATS1
2 The high frequency T model, common base short circuit current frequency response, alpha cutoff frequency, common emitter short circuit current frequency response, hybrid-π CE transistor model, hybrid-π conductance in terms of low frequency h- parameters, CE short circuit current gain obtained with hybrid-π model, current gain with resistive load.
03 9 to 14 Feb ATS2
3 Coupling of transistor amplifiers, frequency response of coupled amplifiers, cascading of RC-Coupled amplifiers and their analysis, tuned amplifiers - single tuned, double tuned and stagger tuned amplifiers and their analysis. Types of feedback, effect of negative feedback on gain, bandwidth, stability, distortion and frequency response etc.
07 16 Feb to 04
March TP3 ATS
3
Mid Semester Test I 4 Voltage series, current series, voltage shunt, current shunt
feedback circuits and their analysis. 03 16 to
21 March
5 Conditions of oscillations. Different types of oscillators: RC Phase Shift, Wein Bridge, Hartley, Colpitts and Crystal Oscillators. 06
23 March
to 4 April
6 Derivation of expression for frequency and amplitude of these oscillators. 06 6 to 17
April
TP4
7 Zener diode as voltage Regulator, Transistor Series and Shunt Regulators, Current limiting, Line and Load Regulation 06
20 April to 01 May
TP5
ATS4
Mid Semester Test II End Semester knowledge Test and Skill Test
Table 4.1 : Lecture Plan of Analog Electronics for CG and Time line for both TG and CG
70
Lab Plan for CG of Analog Electronics for batch 2004 and 2005 (Conducted in Jan–
May 2006 and Jan–May 2007)
The students in CG conducted the experiments according to the lab plan in table 4.2.
The students in TG decided their own practical objectives and conducted the
experiments in the two hour PBL sessions. They did not have structured or separate
lab sessions.
S. no. Topic PL Date
1 To study the various coupling techniques for Transistor amplifier.
1 01/19 - 01/30
2 To study the characteristics of a Class-A Amplifier.
1 02/02 - 02/06
3 To study the characteristics of a Class-AB Amplifier.
1 02/09 - 02/13
4 To study the characteristics of a Class-B push-pull Amplifier.
1 02/16 - 02/20
5 To study the characteristics of complementary symmetry Amplifier.
1 02/23 - 02/27
6 To study Transistor series voltage regulator with current limits and observes current fold-back characteristics.
1 03/02 - 03/04
6 To study Transistor series voltage regulator with current limits and observes current fold-back characteristics.
1 03/16 - 03/20
7 Revision 1 03/23 - 03/27 8 To study the response of RC phase shift
oscillator and determine frequency of oscillation.
1 03/30 - 04/03
9 To study the response of Hartley oscillator and determine frequency of oscillation.
1 04/06 - 04/10
10 To study the response of Colpitt’s oscillator and determine frequency of oscillation.
1 04/13 - 04/17
11 To study the response of Wein Bridge oscillator and determine frequency of oscillation.
1 04/20 - 04/24
Table 4.2 : Lab Plan of Analog Electronics for CG
71
4.1.3 DETAILS OF THE TREATMENT GROUP (PBL THREAD)
The Open Ended Technical Problems (TPs) given in the section 4.1.3.1 were given
to the students in TG [55b], one after the other, as per the time line given in table
4.1. The students traversed the conceptual space while solving these TPs, touching
maximum technical nodes and achieving as many learning objectives, as in table 4.3,
in section 4.1.3.2 The journey through the conceptual space was facilitated by
triggers (examples given in section 4.1.3.3), supplied by facilitator and the students,
themselves.
4.1.3.1 Technical Problems
The tutor gave students an example of a small audio system, as per the block
diagram given in Fig 4.1
Front End (A)
Processing Circuit
(B)
Voltage Amplifier
(C)
PowerAmplifier
(D)
ControlCircuit
(E)
SinusoidalOscillator
(F)
Regulated Power Supply
(G)
Rectifier(H)
220 VACO/P3, To Other Circuit
O/P2, To Other Circuit
I/P
Fig 4.1 : Block diagram of audio system
72
TP 1: In the front end block (A) of the audio system, a voltage amplifier is to be
designed. You are given a readymade small signal amplifier for this purpose,
with a fixed bias. The bias resistors are R1 = 3 kΩ and R2 = 3 kΩ, Rc = 12kΩ and
Re = 5 kΩ, and the transistor to be used is BC107. Before proceeding further with
the design you must;
• Determine the Q-point and draw the load lines.
• Determine what happens if you change the values of various biasing
resistors.
The input signal available is 10mVp-p, 0Vdc.
• Draw the output for the given configuration. Also find out what happens if
you apply the input signal to transistors biased at cut-off and below cut-off.
• Comment on the current gain, voltage gain and power gain of such
configurations.
TP 2: The last block (D) in figure 4.1, is required to deliver 0.6W of power to a
20Ω speaker. The signal strength is 10mVp-p.
Give as many circuit designs as possible with a transistor as the active device.
Compare the designs with respect to their respective advantages, power
dissipated, useful power being delivered to the load and their efficiencies.
TP 3: Even after the first stage of voltage amplification, the processing circuit in
the second stage (B) introduces a lot of attenuation, and the signal strength
reduces to 10 -100µV p-p. To ensure that the first stage drives the subsequent
circuit properly, a voltage signal of at least 10Vp-p, is required. You are using the
circuit with a 15V supply.
Design a single stage amplifier to develop the required output.
Design a two/three stage amplifier to have the same gain.
Compare the above designs with respect to:
• Simplicity of design,
• Stability of gain,
• Methods of coupling multistage amplifiers,
• Saturation levels.
73
TP 4: In the same audio system, when there is no signal at the input, self-
sustained sinusoidal oscillations of 2Vp-p amplitude and of following frequencies
are to be generated:
(i) 200 Hz
(ii) 20 kHz
(iii) 20 MHz
Then, depending on the control circuit output, any one of these oscillations is to
be selected and given as input to some other part of this audio system.
Design circuits, which serve the above purpose. What changes should you make
in the circuits, so that the frequency can be varied in the range ±10%?
Give as many circuit variations as you can. Discuss their relative advantages and
disadvantages.
Of the designed circuits, which one has the best stability?
TP 5: The rectifier circuit which you are using for this audio system derives its
input from 220V AC and converts it into 15V DC. However, because of poor
regulation, any fluctuation in the input AC volts causes the DC output to vary by
as much as 10V to 20V. This variation causes a problem in the circuit as the
voltage variation, the circuit can tolerate is only ±0.1%. Design a voltage
regulator circuit (G) to control this fluctuation. Explain the working principle of
such a regulator and derive the expressions for line and load regulation.
4.1.3.2 Learning Objectives and Technical Nodes
Example of technical nodes and learning objectives are:
Topic: Large signal Amplifier:
Technical Nodes: (a) Recall the concept of biasing of transistors
(b) Identify and describe three regions of operations of transistor
(c) Develop, understand and apply the formulae of amplifications (current,
voltage and power);
(d) Recognize, compare and describe circuit diagrams of class-A, B and C
amplifiers etc.
Learning Objectives: (a) The students should be able to classify large signal
amplifiers in light of the biasing of the transistor.
74
(b) The students should be able to decide which amplifier to use for a particular
application and complete the design process for this large signal amplifier, with
the given specifications.
(c) The students should be able to troubleshoot a faulty design of a large signal
amplifier and rectify it for appropriate working.
Topic Number of maximum technical nodes, Learning Objectives
Number of technical nodes covered by grp1 to grp5
Average number of Learning objectives achieved by groups
Grp1 Grp2 Grp3 Grp4 Grp5 High frequency analysis of transistors
10, 4 10 14 13 9 7 4
Large signal amplifiers
25, 7 24 25 26 19 14 7
Multistage amplifiers 26, 5 23 27 24 26 16 5 Feedback in amplifiers
15, 7 14 15 17 15 12 7
Oscillators 24, 5 23 24 28 20 20 5 Regulated power supply
9, 4 8 9 8 7 8 4
Table 4.3 : Average number of technical nodes covered and learning objectives achieved by teams in PBL thread of Analog Electronics
4.1.3.3 Examples of Triggers
The words like – ‘determine’, ‘draw’, ‘comment’ in the problem statements were
used to cover various domains in the cognitive domain. While the words - Q-point,
biasing resistors, cut-off, below cut-off, current gain, voltage gain and power gain
relate to the previous knowledge base of the students.
Some, but not all, triggers used by facilitator were:
• Is it all? Perhaps you could verify it on the software, try some more
combinations of biasing resistors, try your hands on the practical board to
authenticate,
• The given combination of biasing resistors is completely invalid. It doesn’t
satisfy Kirchhoff’s Voltage Law (KVL) and Kirchhoff’s Current Law (KCL).
• But the power is too large to be delivered to the output.
• Consider redistributing your work.
75
• Add this to your learning objectives.
• Verify your calculations.
• We can discuss it in the GD at the end of the class. Collect the facts in support of
your theory.
• Why don’t you consult some specification sheets of power transistors in the data
sheets?
• But the efficiency is too less (or more).
• Some, but not all, triggers used by the students were:
• Let us try replacing the load in the amplifiers developed in problem 1.
• But we just found that the voltage amplifiers need not necessarily give power
amplification too.
• Let us refer to the literature.
• Can I find some pre calculated things on the internet?
• Let us calculate the values to find out the values of power amplification
• Since there are so many classes of amplifiers, let us design each one of them for
this value of power output.
• Will the same transistor, which we used in problem 1, work here?
• My resistor of 20Ω got burnt while doing the practical. Why? Even the transistor
is getting heated up.
• How do I actually measure power to find the power amplification?
• Why are the push–pull configuration and complementary-symmetry
configurations so called?
• I have only a particular transistor available for authenticating my result
practically, while I did my design calculations without bothering whether the
transistor is available in the lab or not. Now what should we do?
• We are getting a large variation in theoretical, software and practical results. Are
we wrong? Can we account for our errors?
• We will have to try some different combinations of resistors.
• We have heard of active, cut off and saturation regions of the transistors, but
what is –below cut off?
• When we apply the signal to this configuration, the signal clips off from the
76
bottom. I wonder, what might be the use of such an amplifier configuration?
• Although the voltage amplification is good, I see that there is no appreciable gain
the power. Why it might be so?
• This software has various components in the library, and I can place them too, in
the worksheet area joining them as I like. Let me find out if it has some
simulation tools too.
• There can be so many combinations of biasing resistors for the same transistors,
which one can be the best?
4.2 DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF PBL BASED
INSTRUCTIONS IN DIGITAL ELECTRONICS 4.2.1 SYLLABI OF THEORY AND PRACTICAL COMPONENTS
The theory component of Digital Electronics (EC 204) is set to cover following
topics:
THE NUMBER SYSTEM AND BINARY CODE: Introduction, binary, octal and
hexadecimal number system, signed and unsigned number, binary operations -
addition; subtraction, multiplication and division; subtractions using 1's and 2's
compliment; ASCII code; excess-3 code, gray code.
MINIMIZATION OF LOGIC FUNCTION: OR, AND, NOT, NOR, NAND, EX-OR
gates, basic theorem of Boolean algebra, sum-of-products and product-of-sums,
canonical form, minimization using theorems, minimization using K-map and Q-M
method. incompletely specified functions.
COMBINATIONAL LOGIC CIRCUITS: Introduction, combinational circuit
design, multiplexers, demultiplexer, encoders, decoders, adders, subtracters and code
converters, parity checker, BCD display drive, magnitude comparators.
SEQUENTIAL CIRCUITS: Introduction, flip-flop - SR, JK, D, T, edge-triggered
and decked flip-flop, registers, type of registers, circuit diagram, timing wave form
and operations counters, counter design with state equation and state diagrams.
D/A AND A/D CONVERTERS: Introduction, weighted register D/A converter,
binary ladder D/A converter, steady state accuracy test, D/A accuracy and resolution,
parallel A/D converter, counter type A/D converter, successive approximation A/D
converter, single and dual slope A/D converter A/D accuracy and resolution,
77
voltage-of-frequency conversion, voltage-of-time conversion.
SEMICONDUCTOR MEMORIES: Introduction, memory organization,
classification and characteristics of memories, sequential memories, ROMs, R/W
memories, content addressable memories, programmable logic arrays, charged-
coupled device memory.
LOGIC FAMILIES: RTL, DCTL, DTL, TTL, ECL and its various types,
comparison of logic families.
The practical Component of the subject Digital Electronics (EC212) comprises of
following experiments:
1. Verification of the truth tables of TTL gates, e.g., 7400, 7402, 7404, 7408, 7432,
7486.
2. Design, fabrication and testing of low frequency TTL clocks using NAND gates.
3. Verification of the truth table of the Multiplexer 74150.
4. Verification of the truth table of the De-Multiplexer 74154.
5. Design and verification of the truth tables of half adder and full adder circuits
using gates 7483.
6. Study and verification of the operations of ALU 74181 with regards to addition /
subtraction / comparison.
7. Design fabrication and testing of differentiator and integrator circuits using OP
AMP.
8. Design fabrication and testing of clipper and clamper circuits using OP AMP.
9. Design fabrication and testing of
a. Monostable multivibrator of t = 0.1 ms using 74121/123. Testing for both
positive and negative edge triggering, variation in pulse with and retriggering.
b. Free running multivibrator at 1KHz and 1Hz using 555 with 50% duty cycle.
Verify the timing from theoretical calculations.
10. Design of an S-R flip-flop using OR/NAND gates.
11. Verification of the truth table of a J-K flip-flop (7476).
12. Verification of the truth table of a D flip-flop (7474) and study its operation in
the toggle and asynchronous modes.
78
14. Operation of the counters 7490, 7493 and 74192. Verification of the frequency
division at each stage.
15. Verification of the truth table of decoder driver 7447 / 7448. Operation of a 7
segment LED display through a counter using a low frequency clock.
16. Repetition of above with the BCD to Decimal decoder 7442 and an array of
LEDs.
4.2.2 TIME PLAN FOR CG AND TG
As shown in the table 4.4, while the students in CG were being taught by Traditional
method, the students in TG were solving open ended Technical Problems as given in
section 4.2.3.1. The time line for covering the syllabus and distribution of ATS,
MSTs and End semester Knowledge and skill tests are shown in table 4.4. The
seventh and eighth units - ‘Semiconductor memories’ and ‘Logic Families’ were
covered in traditional way only, for both CG and TG. This table also shows how the
time plans for TG and CG were made parallel for delivery schedule.
The four assessment tools – ATSs, MSTs, End Semester Knowledge Test and End
Semester Skill Test for Digital Electronics are given in Appendices G, H, I and J
respectively.
79
S.No Topic No. of
LecturesDates TP ATS
1
Number System And Binary Code: Introduction, binary, octal and hexadecimal number system, signed and unsigned number, binary operations - addition; subtraction, multiplication and division; subtractions using 1's and 2's compliment; ASCII code; excess-3 code, gray code.
3 07-01
to 15-01
2
Minimization of logic function: OR, AND, NOT, NOR, NAND, EX-OR gates, basic theorem of Boolean algebra, sum-of-products and product-of-sums, canonical form, minimization using theorems, minimization using K-map and Q-M method. incompletely specified functions.
6 16-01
to 24-01
TP1 TP2 TP3 TP4
ATS1
3
Combinational Logic Circuits: Introduction, combinational circuit design, multiplexers, demultiplexers, encoders, decoders, adders, subtracters and code converters, parity checker, BCD display drive, magnitude comparators.
10 25-01
to 22-02
TP5 TP6 TP7
ATS2
MST I
4
Sequential Circuits: Introduction, flip-flop - SR, JK, D, T, edge-triggered and decked flip-flop, registers, type of registers, circuit diagram, timing wave form and operations counters, counter design with state equation and state diagrams.
7 25-02
to 14-03
TP8
5 Counters, counter design with state equation and state diagrams. 3
24-03 to
31-03 TP9
ATS3
6
D/A and A/D Converters: Introduction, weighted register D/A converter, binary ladder D/A converter, steady state accuracy test, D/A accuracy and resolution, parallel A/D converter, counter type A/D converter, successive approximation A/D converter, single and dual slope A/D converter A/D accuracy and resolution, voltage-of-frequency conversion, voltage-of-time conversion.
3 01-04
to 08-04
TP10
7
Semiconductor Memories: Introduction, memory organization, classification and characteristics of memories, sequential memories, ROMs, R/W memories, content addressable memories, programmable logic arrays, charged-coupled device memory. LOGIC FAMILIES: RTL, DCTL, DTL, TTL, ECL and its various types, comparison of logic families.
3 09-04
to 15-04
8 Logic Families: RTL, DCTL, DTL, TTL, ECL and its various types, comparison of logic families. 3
16-04 to
23-04
ATS4
MST II End Semester knowledge and skill test
Table 4.4 : Lecture plan of Digital Electronics for CG and Time line for both TG and CG
80
Lab Plan of Digital Electronics
The students in CG conducted the experiments according to the lab plan in table 4.5.
The students in TG decided their own practical objectives and conducted the
experiments in the two hour PBL sessions. They did not have structured or separate
lab sessions.
S.no Topic No. of Labs
Dates
1 To study the various coupling techniques for Transistor amplifier. 1 19/1 – 30/1
2 To study the characteristics of a Class-A Amplifier. 1 02/02 – 06/02
3 To study the characteristics of a Class-AB Amplifier. 1 09/02 – 13/02
4 To study the characteristics of a Class-B push-pull Amplifier. 1 16/02 – 21/02
5 To study the characteristics of complementary symmetry Amplifier. 1 23/02 – 27/02
6 To study Transistor series voltage regulator with current limits and observes current fold-back characteristics.
1 02/03 – 04/03
7 To study Transistor series voltage regulator with current limits and observes current fold-back characteristics.(continued)
1 16/03 – 20/03
8 Revision 1 23/03 – 27/03
9 To study the response of RC phase shift oscillator and determine frequency of oscillation.
1 30/03 – 03/04
10 To study the response of Hartley oscillator and determine frequency of oscillation. 1
06/04 – 10/04
11 To study the response of Colpitt’s oscillator and determine frequency of oscillation. 1
13/04 – 17/04
12 To study the response of Wein Bridge oscillator and determine frequency of oscillation. 1
20/04 – 24/04
Table 4.5 : Lab plan of Digital Electronics
81
4.2.3 DETAILS OF TREATMENT GROUP (PBL THREAD)
The Open Ended Technical Problems (TPs) given in the section 4.2.3.1 were given
to the students in TG, one after the other, as per the time line given in table 4.4. The
students traversed the conceptual space [55c] while solving these TPs, touching
maximum technical nodes and achieving as many learning objectives, as in table 4.8,
in section 4.2.3.2. The journey through the conceptual space was facilitated by
triggers supplied by facilitator and the students, themselves, as given in section
4.2.3.3.
4.2.3.1 Technical Problems
TP 1
a) Search out for literal meanings of ANALOG and DIGITAL.
b) List at least ten instances / examples / activities in real life which you can
distinctly classify under Analog or Digital heads. Take an example of an
activity analog in nature. Try doing / representing it digitally. Does the overall
ambiguity associated with that activity reduce? Explain your view point.
c) What happens if the valid digits in the present number system are reduced to 9
instead of 10? How will the counting proceed? Show by example.
d) Extrapolate (c) to further reduce the number of digits to 8,7,6,5, and so on to 2.
e) How do basic arithmetic operations take place in these modified number
systems vis-à-vis the number system using base 10.
TP 2
a) Apart from the number systems you developed in TP 1, can you develop some
alphanumeric number system too? Would it ever be advantageous to have such
a number system?
b) Compare Hexadecimal, Octal, and Binary number systems. Show how various
conversions between these number systems take place. Can you devise out
some basic thumb rules for such conversions?
c) Search the literature for alphanumeric and other codes. List them along with
their inventors. You should be able to devise out conversion mechanism from
one code to another.
82
TP 3
a) If it is raining outside and I don’t have an umbrella, I will not go out.
If it is raining outside and I have an umbrella, I will go out.
If it is not raining outside and I don’t have an umbrella, I will go out.
If it is not raining outside and I have an umbrella, I will go out.
b) My house has two overhead tanks. I have installed sensors in both the tanks,
which can sense when the water level goes down below 1/4th level. The pump
which is used to lift water to the tanks is required to be switched ON whenever
the level in both tanks goes below 1/4th. Design a control circuit, which takes
inputs from both the sensors and switches the water pump ON.
c) An electronic telephone exchange is being powered by normal power supply.
However, looking at the criticality of the exchange, a power backup generator
is also installed, which can supply the power in case of power failure. An alarm
circuit is to be designed. There will be two LEDs (one green and the other red)
on the front panel of the exchange, such that the green LED glows when power
supply is available. In case of failure of power supply, the exchange draws its
power from generator, and in this case, the green LED goes OFF and the red
LED glows. In case, the generator also goes down, both green LED and red
LED go OFF and a buzzer starts ringing indicating that there is a major failure.
Design this control circuit for both the LEDs and the buzzer.
Define independent and dependant variables in (a), (b) and (c) above.
Develop a mathematical expression for above sets of statements.
Tabulate the above sets of statements symbolically by using variables defined
above, wherever required.
Show the above sets of statements pictorially.
Verify your results practically.
TP 4
The arithmetic and Logic Unit (ALU) of a computer performs the arithmetic and
logic operations for the processor. In this ALU a circuit is to be designed, where in
two 4 bit binary numbers are to be subtracted using 2’s compliment. Design a
83
combinational circuit for the same.
TP 5
You are reporting for duty in your first ever assignment as graduate trainee in the
design department of an electronics firm. The following problem has been given to
you:
A portion of the transceiver electronics of the exchange is depicted in the form of
block diagram in Figure 4.2
Fig 4.2 : A portion of transceiver electronics of the Telephone Exchange
Both the exchanges cater for 2n users. Depending on n selection lines you have to
design and test the multiplexer and demultiplexer circuits in the exchange. You
have to find out the commercially available ICs from at least three vendors and
prepare a BOM (Bill of Material). Your boss has given you a time limit of 4 hrs to
design the same and submit the solution in written form. The data available from
users are in analog form.
TP 6
In a Computer, the Central Processing Unit (CPU) works as the brain. It not only
does the Calculations and Logical operations but also takes care of input and
User 1
User 2
User 2n
Mux
Dmux
Dmux
Mux
Channel
User 1
User 2
User 2n
n selection lines n selection lines
84
output operations. In such a generalized operation, there are 8 devices that this
processor is handling. The tabulation is given below:
Port number Device 0 Printer 1 Scanner 2 Fax machine 3 Key board 4 Mouse 5 Speaker 6 Mike 7 Monitor
Table 4.6 : Port number allocation to various devices
The processor has a 6 bit address bus. Devise a method to generate the port number
of each I/O devices one at a time, and send/receive the data.
Before transmitting analog data using bus, the same is converted into bits and
encoded too. For coding the data, many coding schemes exist. One of the error
detecting codes is an even parity code, which you have studied earlier.
At the receiver, bit streams are being received. They are first passed through an 8-
bit serial to parallel converter. Before feeding them to subsequent processing
circuit, the parity is to be checked in an error detector. Design the detector to do
the needful.
TP 7
In TP 6, you have designed a parity checker. But this parity checker can be used,
only after 8 bit parallel data is available. The incoming data from the
communication channel is always available in serial form only. So, design a 7 bit
serial to parallel converter, to be attached before parity checker, and explain the
use of storage elements in the circuit. Authenticate your design by experimental
verification.
TP 8
The upcoming event of E- Buzz, Kaun Kaun Banega Champion is going to be
hosted in a hall. At any point of time, it is required to know the exact number of
persons present in the hall. There are separate entry and exit points. A sensor, each,
is installed at both the entry and exit points. The sensor at entrance gives an output
+5V, whenever a person enters in the room from entrance door. Similarly, the
85
sensor at exit point also gives a voltage of +5V as output whenever a person exits.
At all other times the output of sensors is 0V. Taking these two outputs of the
sensors as input, design a circuit that gives the total count of the persons present in
the hall.
TP 9
A traffic signal is installed at a junction of a railroad and a road. The traffic light is
controlled by two switches in the rails placed one mile apart on either side of the
junction. A switch is turned on when the train is over it and is turned off otherwise.
The traffic light changes from green to red when the beginning of the train is one
mile from the junction. The light changes back to green when the end of the train is
one mile away from the junction. Assume that the length of the train is less than
two miles.
Design, implement and present a circuit which does the needful as described
above.
TP 10
A digital input containing stream of 0’s and 1’s are applied to all the digital circuits
– combinational and sequential. A novice engineer in a laboratory set up applied a
sinusoidal signal (5Vp-p) to a digital counter, hoping that it would count the number
of cycles in the input signal – as the name of the circuit suggests. Will this happen?
Why?
Fig. 4.3 : Control set up of an automated plant
Consider the situation in an automated plant as given in figure 4.3. The signal at
the output of the sampler is a typical analog signal in the range 2Vp-p. However the
Mechanical Process Transducer
Sampler Control Circuit
??
86
control circuit is a digital one which can accept the strings of 0’s and 1’s. Suggest
ways and means to make the three blocks ‘Sampler’, ‘Control Circuit’ and
‘Mechanical Process’ compatible to each other. 4.2.3.2 Learning Objectives and Technical Nodes
Technical nodes and Learning Objectives in each unit were identified and listed.
These were further augmented, authenticated and approved by the panel of experts.
The maximum number of technical nodes and learning objectives and the average
number achieved by the teams are given in the table 4.7. Some of the examples of
technical nodes and learning objectives are given below:
Technical Nodes:
• Prepare truth table of a Demultiplexer and Multiplexer.
• Interpret the truth table of a Multiplexer and write the algebraic equation
representing this combinational circuit
Table 4.7 : Average number of technical nodes and learning objectives achieved by Teams in TG (PBL Method) of Digital Electronics
Topic Number of maximum technical nodes, learning objectives
Number of technical nodes covered by grp1 to grp5
Average number of Learning objectives achieved by groups
Grp1 Grp2 Grp3 Grp4 Grp5 Number System And Binary Code
15, 5 9 10 11 9 12 4
Minimization of logic function
25, 10 20 18 23 16 24 7
Combinational Logic Circuits
18, 11 13 13 14 13 16 9
Sequential Circuits
19, 9 14 15 17 15 14 6
D/A and A/D Converters
9, 5 5 6 7 7 8 3
Logic Families 8, 4 6 8 5 7 8 3
87
• Learning Objectives:
• Students should be able to recognize the circuit of a Demultiplexer and prepare
its truth table.
• Should be able to use Decoder as Demultiplexer and vice versa.
• Should be able to wire the circuit of a Demultiplexer and a Multiplexer and use it
as a complete set.
4.2.3.3 Examples of Triggers
When the students traverse through conceptual space as shown in figure 3.3, the
triggeres are supplied to aid them so that they cover all the technical nodes and
achieve all the learning objectives.
The words like – ‘determine’, ‘make’, ‘comment’, ‘Devise out’, ‘Design’ in the
problem statements were used to cover various domains in the cognitive domain.
While the words- truth Table, Combinational Circuits, Sequential circuits, High /
Low sates, Analog, relate to the previous knowledge base of the students.
Some, bit not all triggers supplied by the facilitator:
• Have you taken care of the indeterminate states?
• May be – you can use Karnaugh map to minimize the expression first.
• I want you to verify the conclusions practically too.
• Authenticate by showing.
• The LED at the output is blinking. May be the voltage levels are not sufficient.
• Consider redistributing your work.
• Your list of learning objectives is still incomplete.
• Do you think the same design can be realized only using NAND gates?
• Try to find out what the terms VOH, VOL, VIL and VIH in the specification sheets
of the TTL ICs mean?
• We can discuss it in the GD at the end of the class. Collect the facts in support of
your theory.
• Can you realize the ALL – NAND circuit when and POS term is given?
Some, bit not all triggers supplied by the students were:
• Let us try realizing an OR gate using NOR and NAND gates.
• But you never seem to do the allotted piece of work.
88
• The library of components in the MULTISIM also has three input NAND gate
available. Let us simulate our circuit with the same.
• Let us calculate the values of voltages and currents in the TTL circuit and
compare them with those at the ECL output.
• Then, what is difference between a latch, register and a Flip flop?
• I will make the state diagram, but you verify this design using timing diagram.
• How will the same circuit work as Up-Down counter?
• The set of statements is what we encounter in our day-to-day lives. It would be
really interesting to depict and denote them mathematically.
• We have done some combinational circuit design in our previous class, are we
doing something new in this class?
• This is difficult, how can the present state depend on previous states!
• Can indeterminate state be verified experimentally? Will it show some voltage
level in between?
• Earlier I thought, only 5V is the high level voltage at the input – it is interesting,
though, to note that even if we have 3.5 volt at the output pin, it is a HIGH
voltage.
• It is amazing to work on MULTISIM. I can actually simulate all my circuits
• Finally, our design works!!
4.3 DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF PBL BASED
INSTRUCTIONS IN PDSC 4.3.1 Syllabi of Theory and practical Components
The theory component of PDSC is set to cover the following topics:
LINEAR WAVE SHAPING: High pass circuits, response to standard waveforms,
differentiator, double differentiation, low pass circuits, response to standard
waveforms, integrator, attenuator, RLC circuits, ringing circuits.
WIDE BAND AMPLIFIERS: Frequency response of an amplifier, short circuit
current gain, gain & band width consideration, compensation, shunt compensation,
low frequency compensation, and distributed amplifiers.
SWITCHING CHARACTERISTICS OF DEVICES: Steady state and transient
behaviors of electronic (diode & transistor) switches, dynamic analysis of switches,
89
charge storage phenomena, switching characteristics, delay time, rise time, storage
time and fall time, use of Schotkey diode for reducing storage time, behavior of
MOS transistor as switch.
NON- LINEAR WAVE SHAPING: Realization of clipping circuits (diode &
transistor), comparators, champing circuits and sweep generators.
MULTIVIBRATORS: Realization of astable, monostable, bistable, multivibrators
using transistors, unsymmetrical, symmetrical triggering, Schmitt trigger circuits.
The Practical Component of PDSC is set to have following experiments:
1. To verify the working of High Pass Circuit: Application of sawtooth and square
waveforms as input.
2. To verify the working of Low Pass Circuit: Application of sawtooth and square
waveforms as input.
3. To study various clipping circuits.
4. To study various clamping circuits.
5. To design, implement and test various multivibrator circuits.
4.3.2 TIME PLAN FOR CG AND TG
As shown in the table 4.8, while the students in CG were being taught by Traditional
method, the students in TG were solving open ended Technical Problems as given in
section 4.3.2.1. The time line for covering the syllabus and distribution of ATS,
MSTs and End semester Knowledge and Skill Tests are shown in table 4.8. The sixth
unit – ‘Steady state and transient behavior of electronic devices’ was covered in
traditional way only, for both CG and TG. This table also shows how the time plans
for TG and CG were made parallel for delivery schedule.
The four assessment tools – ATSs, MSTs, End Semester Knowledge Test and End
Semester Skill Test are given in Appendices K, L, M and N respectively.
90
S.No Topic No. of
Lectures for CG
Dates TPs for TG
ATS
1 High Pass circuits, Response to Standard waveforms, Differentiator, Double differentiation
6 6/08 to 17/08
2 Low pass circuits, response to standard waveforms, Integrator, 3 19/08 to
24/08
3 Attenuator, RLC circuits, Ringing circuits. 6 26/08 to 07/09
TP1 TP2 TP3
4 Frequency response of an amplifier, Short circuit current gain, Gain & Band width consideration
2 09/09 to 14/09
5 Compensation, Shunt compensation, Low frequency compensation, Distributed amplifiers. 3 16/09 to
21/09
TP4
ATS1
MST I
6
Steady state and transient behaviors of electronic (Diode & transistor) Switches, Dynamic analysis of switches, Charge storage phenomena, Switching characteristics, Delay time, Rise time, Storage time and fall time, Use of Schotkey diode for reducing storage time. Behavior of MOS transistor as switch.
8 01/10 to 19/10
7 Realization of clipping circuits (diode & transistor), comparators, champing circuits and sweep generators
2 21/10 to 26/10 TP5
ATS2
8
Realization of astable, monostable, bistable, multivibrators using transistors, unsymmetrical, symmetrical triggering, Schmitt trigger circuits 8 29/10 to
16/11 TP6 TP7 ATS3
MST II
End Semester Knowledge Test
Table 4.8 : Lecture plan of PDSC for CG and time plan for both CG and TG
91
Lab Plan for students in CG
The students in CG conducted the experiments according to the lab plan in table 4.9.
The students in TG decided their own practical objectives and conducted the
experiments in the two hour PBL sessions. They did not have structured or separate
lab sessions.
S.no Topic No. of Labs
Dates
1 To study the response of High Pass circuit to (i) Step (ii) Ramp and (iii) exponential inputs
1 12/08 - 31/08
2 To study the response of Low Pass Circuit to (i) Step (ii) Ramp and (iii) exponential inputs
1 03/09 - 14/09
3 To study shunt compensation of a Wide Band Common Emitter Amplifier
1 16/09 - 21/09
4 To study the Low frequency compensation of Wide Band Amplifier and to calculate the Gain Bandwidth product before and after compensation
1 01/10 - 05/10
5 To design and test a circuit for clipping a sinusoidal waveform at two voltage levels
1 8/10 - 12/10
6 To design and test an electronic circuit which clamps a givnen waveform at predetermined voltage level
1 15/10 - 19/10
7 To design and test a monostable multivibrator 1 21/10 - 26/10 8 To design and test a astable multivibrator 1 29/10 - 02/11 9 To design and test a bistable multivibrator 1 05/11 - 09/11 10 To study a sweep generator of varying frequency 1 12/11 - 16/11
Table 4.9 : Lab Plan of PDSC for CG
92
4.3.3 DETAILS FOR TREATMENT GROUP (PBL THREAD)
The Open Ended Technical Problems (TPs) given in the section 4.3.3.1 were given
to the students in TG, one after the other, as per the time line given in table 4.8. The
students traversed the conceptual space while solving these TPs, touching maximum
technical nodes and achieving as many learning objectives, as in table 4.10, in
section 4.3.3.2. The journey through the conceptual space was facilitated by triggers
supplied by facilitator and the students, themselves, as given in section 4.3.3.3.
4.3.3.1 Technical Problems
TP 1
To the two circuits in the given figure 4.4(a) and figure 4.4(b), are applied with
following waveforms:
Fig 4.4(a): Low Pass Circuit
Fig 4.4(b): High Pass Circuit
(a) Sinusoidal (b) Ramp (c) Square (d)Exponential
Sketch the output waveforms for each of the circuits.
Can you authenticate the drawings by calculations and appropriate derivations?
TP 2
Use a function generator to generate a pulse train of highest possible frequency.
Use a laboratory oscilloscope to view the output. Do you still see a perfect pulse
train on the screen? If not, note down the shape of the pulse train as visible on the
scope. Attribute reasons for the distortion – qualitatively and quantitatively.
Give widespread theoretical and practical support and evidence for your answer.
--->I(t)
--->I(t)
93
TP 3
The simple diode circuit given in the figure 4.5 is to be used with the input
waveform indicated in the diagram. When the waveform across the load resistor
1M is to be displayed on the oscilloscope the typical capacitive value of 20pf is
shunted across the load resistor. Draw the output waveform as seen on the scope.
Also determine all voltage and time values on the output waveform plot.
Fig 4.5 : A simple diode circuit
TP 4
The following circuit in the figure 4.6 is given to you fabricated on the bread
board. Plot its characteristics (gain vs frequency plot) on a graph paper. Can you
attribute some reasons to the roll off on both the sides of the characteristics?
Suggest some ways to compensate this roll off and authenticate practically.
Fig 4.6 : A two stage Common Emitter Amplifier
tp
t 0V
-10V
+10V
Q1
50 Kohm
VCC
Vi
2 Kohm
2 Kohm50 Kohm
Ce
Cb
50 Kohm
50 Kohm 2 Kohm
2 Kohm
Q2
Cz
Vo
+
-
94
TP 5
The signal shown in the following figure is applied to the given circuit. Assuming
Rf = 0 and Rr = ∞, find the steady state waveform Vo. Compute the voltage levels
in the waveform assuming different values of V= 1 to 20 V. Also sketch the
waveform if the diode terminals are reversed and if the value of R is changed from
1k to 1M. Assume any value of C between 0.01 to 0.1 µf
Fig 4.7 : A Clamper Circuit
TP 6
It is required to generate a square waveform of 12 kHz using only two identical
BC107 transistors as active devices. You can use resistors and capacitors as
passive components. Design the circuit and authenticate it practically.
TP 7
It is required to supply a pulse of 1µs to an up-down counter to change its mode of
operation. The counter uses TTL ICs. Generate this pulse using two identical
transistors (BC144). Design and authenticate practically.
4.3.3.2 Learning Objectives and Technical Nodes
Technical nodes and Learning Objectives in each unit were identified and listed.
These were further augmented, authenticated and approved by the panel of experts.
The maximum number of technical nodes and learning objectives and the average
number achieved by teams are given in the table 4.10. Some of the examples of
technical nodes and learning objectives are given below:
Technical Nodes
• The students should be able to draw the output waveform of a Low pass R-C
circuit for the four standard signals applied as inputs.
T2 T1
V
95
• Recognize and differentiate in Low pass and High pass R-C circuits.
• Attribute the reason for roll of in the gain vs frequency curve of a trasistor
amplifier.
• Derive an expression for the output waveform of the astable multivibrator.
Learning Objectives
• The students should be able to draw the equivalent circuit of a wideband
amplifier using lumped parameters.
• Should be able to design an astable multivibrator for a given frequency.
• Should be able to design and test a circuit which clamps the given sinusoidal
waveform to a given voltage level.
Table 4.10 : Average number of Technical Nodes covered and Learning Objectives achieved by Teams in PBL thread of PDSC
4.3.3.3 Example of Triggers
When the students traverse through conceptual space as shown in figure 3.3, the
triggers are supplied to aid them so that they cover all the technical nodes and
achieve all the learning objectives.
Some but not all triggers supplied by the facilitator were:
• Try redistributing your work.
• You are going too fast. Do not jump to conclusions.
• You have suggested only one possible combination of resistor and capacitor.
Try some more combinations.
Topic Number of maximum technical nodes, Learning Objectives
Number of technical nodes covered by grp1 to grp5
Average number of Learning objectives achieved by groups
Grp1 Grp2 Grp3 Grp4 Grp5 Linear Wave shaping 35, 13 25 24 31 32 20 9 Wideband Amplifiers 11, 7 9 10 8 5 6 4 Switching characteristics of Devices
10, 8 9 8 9 8 7 6
Non Linear Wave shaping
23, 11 22 21 17 17 17 7
Multivibrators 11, 7 13 12 11 10 11 6
96
• This seems to work as an integrator. Now reduce the frequency of the applied
input further, See if it is still working as an integrator.
• Wow! You have just realized an active electronic switch.
Some but not all the triggers supplied by the students were:
• Does it really roll off on the two sides. Why should the gain reduce when
everything else remains the same in the circuit?!
• If the coupling capacitor can have effect on the frequency response, so will the
bypass capacitor.
• Let us supply very high frequency to this circuit. But we don’t have more than
10 MHz generator available in the lab!!