changing a culture · sun mon tue wed thu fri sat total actual hours worked 0 {e} from time sheet...
TRANSCRIPT
Changing a Culture by
DevelopingManagement Tools
and
Implementing Pay-per-Visit
Patrick ArmstrongIntermountain Homecare
(801)887-6185
Agenda
vIntermountain Homecare
vProcess of Changing a Culture
vImplementing Pay-per-Visit
vScorecards
vNext Steps
Intermountain Homecare
Ø4 Business LinesvHome Medical Equipment
vHome Health
vHospice
vIV Therapy
Ø13 Service Locations
Ø870 Employees
ØGross Revenue $115 million
ØCharity Care $2.6 million (annual report)
Home Medical Equipment
ØAnnual Revenue $36 Million
ØOxygen
ØWheelchairs
ØVentilators, and Tracheostomy Care
ØApnea Monitors
ØNebulizers
ØCPAP Machines
ØEducation and Support
Home Health
Ø1,200 Average Daily Census
ØAdult and Pediatric Skilled Nursing
ØPhysical, Speech, Occupational & Respiratory Therapies
ØAide Services
ØNutritional Counseling
ØSocial Services
Hospice
Ø300 Average Daily Census
ØPain and Symptom Management
ØFamily Education and Support
ØEmotional Support
ØSpiritual Counseling
ØVolunteer Support
ØGrief and Bereavement Assistance
IV Therapy
ØAnnual Revenue $44 Million
ØAntibiotics
ØNutritional Therapy
ØChemotherapy
ØGrowth Hormone
ØImmune Therapy to Include Synagis for RSV
ØPain Medications
ØHydration Therapy
Intermountain Homecare Mission
To be the Homecare of choice for patients, employees, and referral sources.
Intermountain Homecare Vision Statements
ØWe promote a culture that is accountable, productive, nurturing and empowered
ØWe focus on customer service excellence to distinguish us in the marketplace
ØWe maintain financial viability
ØWe strive for clinical consistency and integration within the Intermountain continuum
Common Purpose
Intermountain Board Goals
Intermountain Homecare Goals
Service Line Goals
Department Goals - Key Indicators
Changing a Culture
vVisionØGood to Great
ØCrucial Conversations
Ø If Disney Ran Your Hospital
vRight People in the Right Positions
vHiring the Right People
vSetting Clear Expectations
vAccountability/Measurements
vTraining
Right People / Right Positions
Experienced Turnover
ØSelf Selected
ØStructure Changes
ØStaff Reductions
•Management Positions
•Support Staff
Hiring the Right PeopleBehavioral/Situational by Skill
Analyzed cause of deficiency
Engaged others in understanding problem
Corrected problem in a timely manner
Monitored compliance with new process
Sought opportunities to elevate patient care
Describe a situation where your unit did not meet patient care standards. How was the deficiency identified?
What was done to make improvement?
Share an example of when you utilized research to improvepractice.
Where do you see the greatest opportunity for improving care on your current unit? Describe an action you had to take to seize this opportunity.
Enforces high patient carestandards
Standards Bearer
ScoreElements of Desired Response
Sample QuestionsSkill
Setting Clear Expectations
ØEstablished Standards
ØMonitor Results
ØBenchmark w/ other Companies
ØDemonstrated that it could be accomplished
ØEducate
ØCoach when Necessary
Accountability/Measurements
1. What’s gone right/wrong: Monthly staff meetings
2. Standardization of process: Ongoing3. Peer review (visit/chart review):
Annually4. Sharing information: Regularly and
timely5. Share financial report: At least
quarterly6. Management chart review: Monthly
• a minimum of five charts
Accountability/Measurements
7. Share visits: At least annually8. Customer service calls: Monthly
• a minimum of five calls9. Productivity: Monthly 10. Utilization management: Monthly 11. HR Report: Quarterly 12. Infection control: Monthly13. Improvement in Corrective Action Plans
(CAPs): At least quarterly14. Event reports: At least quarterly
Accountability/Measurements
15. Customer service reports: Twice a year
16. Trunk/Bag checks: At least annually
17. Site specific patient care coordination meetings: Quarterly
18. Education: Review reports 2 weeks before due date
19. Referral data: Quarterly
Training
ØNew Employee Orientation
ØManager Training Program
ØStaff Training Program
Implementing Pay-per-Visit
ØDefine Eligible Positions
ØDefine Work Standards
ØCompensation
ØEducation
ØTracking Tools
ØLessons Learned
Eligible Positions
Ø“Thinking for a Living” by Thomas H. Davenport
ØFour Types of Knowledge Workers• Transaction Workers
• Integration Workers
• Expert Workers: “have highly complex jobs that require little interdependence. They perform judgment-oriented work that relies on their individual expertise and experience. This kind of work is typified by a primary-care physician.”
• Collaboration Workers
Expert Worker: Clinician Productivity
“Expert workers are very autonomous, but some organizations have applied technology to key aspects of the process, such as hospitals managing and measuring doctors as they order medications, tests, and so on. Instead of specifying the details of work flow, the intervention should provide templates, sample outputs, and high-level guidelines.” Thinking for a Living by Thomas H. Davenport
Opportunities
ØDisciplines with Greatest Impact
vRegistered Nurse
vPhysical and Occupational Therapists
vHome Health Aides
ØFull Time Employees
Defining Work Standards
ØEvaluated other Systems
ØIdentified different visit types based on requirements and time
ØDeveloped visit weights based on historical and expert user information
Implementing New Standard
ØInvolve knowledge workers in the training of the new standards
ØUnderstand existing process
ØUnderstand the “Why’s” behind the process
ØRemember that they are the experts, clarified definitions
RN Visit CodesVisit
Visit Type Weight
RN VISIT 1.00RN SUPERVISORY VISIT 0.25RN ADMIT 2.00RN RECERT SKILL VISIT 1.50RN ROC/SCIC VISIT 1.50RN ADDON VISIT 1.50RN OASIS DSCG VISIT 1.33PHLEBOTOMY VISIT 0.50REFUSED CARE 0.25NOT TAKEN ON SERVICE 1.00PATIENT NOT HOME\EQUIP DEL 0.00Hourly
RN HOURLY 0.67Extended Travel (Over 30 miles, One Way) Write the # of Occurences 0.33
Compensation
Overall Compensation = PPV Rate + Overtime + Premiums + Mileage
Pay Per Visit Rate = Visit Credits * Visit Incentive($)
Visit Credits: Sum of weekly visit credits
Visit Incentives: Based on Discipline and Years of Experience
PPV Education Tool
PPV: Clinician Tracking ToolCOLUMN {A} (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) {B} Weekly
Visit VISIT Visit CreditVisit Type Weight Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat TOTAL {A} X {B}
RN VISIT 1.00 0 0.00RN SUV VISIT 0.25 0 0.00RN ADMIT 2.00 0 0.00RN RECERT SKILL VISIT 1.50 0 0.00RN RECERT VISIT NO SKL NC 1.00 0 0.00RN ROC VISIT 1.50 0 0.00RN SCIC VISIT 1.50 0 0.00RN ADDON VISIT 1.50 0 0.00RN OASIS DSCG VISIT 1.33 0 0.00RN ADMIT AIDE ONLY 2.00 0 0.00EQUIPMENT DELIVERY 0.33 0 0.00NOT TAKEN ON SERVICE 1.00 0 0.00PATIENT NOT HOME\REFUSED CARE 0.25 0 0.00Hourly
RN HOURLY 0.67 0 0.00Extended Travel (Over 30 miles, One Way) Write the # of Occurences 0.33 0 0.00
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00{C}
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat TotalActual Hours Worked 0 {E} From Time Sheet
Productivity Calculations
Weekly Visit Credit 0.00 {C}
Total Hours Earned {D} 0 {C} x 1.6 hours
Actual Hours Worked {E} 0 From Time Sheet (Hours)
Difference from Earned Hours and Actual Hours Worked 0 {D} - {E} Green for Favorable (Total Budgeted Hours Earned - Actual Hours Worked) Red for Unfavorable
Compenstation Your Rate: 0
PPV Impact 2004HOME HEALTH AND HOSPICE : AVERAGE MINUTES PER VISIT
Mar - Sep 2004
60.00
75.00
90.00
105.00
120.00
135.00
150.00
Min
ute
s
HH SL Avg 129.12 122.70 148.34 102.98 83.75 85.11 90.31
HH UT Avg 139.80 136.40 102.75 72.95 77.44 92.10 90.66
PT SL Avg 96.09 86.51 84.09 73.02 74.81 76.10 85.07
PT UT Avg 113.44 111.03 88.76 75.34 68.32 81.38 93.02
PT Standard 92.3 92.3 92.3 92.3 92.3 92.3 92.3
RN Standard 96 96 96 96 96 96 96
Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep
PPV Impact 2005HOME HEALTH : AVERAGE MINUTES PER VISIT
Jun - Dec 2005
60.00
75.00
90.00
105.00
120.00
135.00
150.00
Min
ute
s
HH SL Avg 91.00 100.00 96.67 98.75 108.33 102.50 98.00
HH UT Avg 87.67 87.25 94.67 88.50 94.33 92.25 98.67
PT SL Avg 72.75 82.50 78.75 81.25 79.00 76.75 75.33
PT UT Avg 72.00 71.75 78.25 78.67 71.25 75.75 69.33
PT Standard 92.30 92.30 92.30 92.30 92.30 92.30 92.30
RN Standard 96.00 96.00 96.00 96.00 96.00 96.00 96.00
Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Manager Tools
Pivot TableØClinician Detail Report
ØDepartment Summary
Web PageØDepartment Summaries
ØClinical Details
Department Summary TablePivot Table
Productivity : Average Visit Time (Minutes)/Visit CreditsEmployee Name Emp Type WK15 WK16 WK17 WK18 AVG WK
CLINICIAN 1 RN-PPV 50.29 58.43 45.00 - 51.24CLINICIAN 2 RN-PPV 80.23 80.04 91.88 - 84.05CLINICIAN 3 RN-PPV - 76.68 96.19 - 86.44CLINICIAN 4 RN-PPV 81.42 94.53 95.76 - 90.57CLINICIAN 5 RN-PPV 113.00 111.50 - - 112.25CLINICIAN 6 RN 181.07 101.20 102.33 - 128.20
Average 126.23 81.88 84.03 113.29
RN/LPNBudgeted Standard Standard StandardHrs Visits/Wk Hrs/Visit Min/Visit40 Hrs 25 1.6 9632 Hrs 20 1.6 9624 Hrs 15 1.6 96
Clinician Detail ReportPivot Table
Clinician Name 4/3-4/9 4/10-4/16 4/17-4/23 4/24-4/30
CLINICIAN 2 WK15 WK16 WK17 WK18 AVG WK
Visit Credits(VC) 20.33 19.99 11.33 - 17.22Visits (Trips, Visit Types) 17.00 17.00 11.00 - 15.00Hours Worked 27.18 26.67 17.35 - 23.73
Productivity:Avg Total Visit Time (Min)
(Prod Hrs - Ed)/VC 80.23 80.04 91.88 - 84.05In-Home Time (Min)/VC 27.15 27.71 32.57 - 29.14Patient Mgmt Time (Min)/Visit 42.47 42.35 44.09 - 42.97Travel Time (Min)/Visit 21.00 19.06 18.18 - 19.41Education Time (Minutes) - - - - 0.00
Department Summary TablePortal
Staff ProductivityPortal
Clinician Weekly SummaryPortal
Clinician Daily DetailPortal
Weekly Patient InformationPortal
Patient Detail InformationPortal
Lessons Learned
ØKeep it simple
ØReduce Selection Options
ØEducate
ØMonitor Usage
SCORECARDS
ØExpand to all Service Lines
ØReflect Homecare’s 5-Year Strategic Plan
ØDrill Down to Department Indicators
IHC Home Care ScorecardJanuary 2006
Service Line Quality
Extraordinary Caring /
Customer Service Affordability of Care
Membership /
Customer
Attractiveness
IS Development /
System Development
DME
Joint Commission Measures
Employee Retention: Decrease 1st Yr Turnover
Utilization: Pulse Oximetry
Volume Growth: 6.4% Computerized Physician Order Entry
Pinnacle: Increase Overall Satisfaction to 4.6
2211 Ded: ($142,112) Benchmarking: AA Home Care's
HHOBQI: Readmission below Utah Avg
Employee Retention Utilization: PPS Visits/Episode = 13
Volume Growth: 8.1%
OBQI: Emergency Visits below Utah Avg
Pinnacle 2211 Ded: (112,057) Benchmarking: Fazzi
OBQI: Overall Productivity: Meeting or Exceeding Visit Stds
Benchmarking: Other Systems
Home Care Referral Survey 2211 Ded: (500,000) Volume Growth: 6.6% Billing SIPIntegration into CDRPhysician Order Entry
Green Yellow RedOn Target Possible Serious
Challenges Challenges
Greater Than (5%) of Goal
Between (5%)&(15%) of Goal
Less Than (15%) of Goal
Project Status Indicators
Home Health UtilizationHOME HEALTH MEDICARE PPS BILLABLE VISITS
Jan - Aug 2005
20.1
19.0
14.1
16.5
10.4
16.6
11.8
20.3
16.6
11.8
-
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
Salt Lake Utah County McKay Central Southern Logan Cassia Heber IHC Avg Bapt Mem
Vis
its
Home Health HeberUtilization 2005
HEBER HOME HEALTH MEDICARE PPS BILLABLE VISITS
Jan - Aug 2005
19.120.1
21.020.1
19.020.1
18.0
20.0 20.3
-
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug 2005 Avg
Vis
its
Home Health Heber UtilizationAVG YTD 2005
HHRG Guideline Episodes
Avg Total
Visits
% Over
Guideline
6 5.00C0F0S0 1 1 8.00 700%C0F1S0 9 4 12.25 36%C0F2S0 10 2 6.00 C0F2S2 14 4 15.75 13%C0F2S3 14 1 13.00 C0F3S0 12 1 30.00 150%C1F0S2 10 1 7.00 C1F1S0 10 4 12.25 23%C1F1S2 12 2 21.00 75%C1F2S0 10 14 15.00 50%C1F2S1 14 1 26.00 86%C1F2S2 14 8 12.38 C1F2S3 14 3 19.67 40%C1F3S0 12 2 7.50 C1F3S2 13 4 15.25 17%C1F4S3 22 1 22.00 C2F0S0 7 1 44.00 529%C2F0S2 10 1 9.00 C2F1S0 10 5 12.80 28%C2F1S1 10 20 25.00 150%C2F1S2 12 2 30.00 150%C2F2S0 11 10 12.00 9%C2F2S2 14 11 25.00 79%C2F2S3 16 2 20.00 25%C2F3S2 14 5 18.40 31%C3F2S2 18 3 33.67 87%Grand Total 100 20.30
Home Health Heber UtilizationC2F1S1 Details
Primary Clinician Patient Name
Total
Planned
Visits Guideline
Exceeds
Guideline
Mgr
Review SN Visits
AIDE
Visits PT Visits
Clinician A Patient 1 10 14 4 No 10Clinician A Patient 2 10 14 4 No 9 1Clinician A Patient 3 15 14 -1 Yes 7 8Clinician A Patient 4 17 14 -3 Yes 6 11Clinician A Patient 5 27 14 -13 Yes 27Clinician A Patient 6 15 14 -1 Yes 15Clinician A Patient 7 33 14 -19 Yes 8 7Clinician A Patient 8 37 14 -23 Yes 5 14Clinician B Patient 9 50 14 -36 Yes 5 45Clinician B Patient 10 15 14 -1 Yes 6 9Clinician B Patient 11 9 14 5 Yes 9Clinician B Patient 12 19 14 -5 Yes 18Clinician C Patient 13 22 14 -8 Yes 21Clinician C Patient 14 20 14 -6 Yes 20Clinician C Patient 15 11 14 3 No 11Clinician C Patient 16 19 14 -5 Yes 18
RETURN to SCORECARD
IHC Home Care ScorecardJanuary 2006
Service Line Quality
Extraordinary Caring /
Customer Service Affordability of Care
Membership /
Customer
Attractiveness
IS Development /
System Development
DME
Joint Commission Measures
Employee Retention: Decrease 1st Yr Turnover
Utilization: Pulse Oximetry
Volume Growth: 6.4% Computerized Physician Order Entry
Pinnacle: Increase Overall Satisfaction to 4.6
2211 Ded: ($142,112) Benchmarking: AA Home Care's
HHOBQI: Readmission below Utah Avg
Employee Retention Utilization: PPS Visits/Episode = 13
Volume Growth: 8.1%
OBQI: Emergency Visits below Utah Avg
Pinnacle 2211 Ded: (112,057) Benchmarking: Fazzi
OBQI: Overall Productivity: Meeting or Exceeding Visit Stds
Benchmarking: Other Systems
Home Care Referral Survey 2211 Ded: (500,000) Volume Growth: 6.6% Billing SIPIntegration into CDRPhysician Order Entry
Green Yellow RedOn Target Possible Serious
Challenges Challenges
Greater Than (5%) of Goal
Between (5%)&(15%) of Goal
Less Than (15%) of Goal
Project Status Indicators
HME Admin Write Off’s2005 HME Admin Write Off
Goals vs Actual Achieved YTD
$-
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
$250,000
Team or Department
2005 Actual YTD 2005 YTD Goal
2005 Actual YTD $87,430 $14,128 $136,133 $82,128 $194,914 $227,688
2005 YTD Goal $61,756 $17,195 $116,823 $71,862 $206,806 $138,822
ABN CMN Intake PAS Auth Other Adj
HME Admin Write Off’s2005 HME Admin Write Off by Site
Goals vs Actual Achieved YTD
$-
$20,000
$40,000
$60,000
$80,000
$100,000
Site or Department
2005 Actual YTD 2005 YTD Goal
2005 Actual YTD $87,430 $51,865 $18,288 $10,000 $25,764 $75,000
2005 YTD Goal $41,647 $41,647 $13,882 $6,941 $27,764 $69,411
Provo OG Delta Heber St. George SL
SL HME Admin Write Off’s
$-
$20,000
$40,000
$60,000
$80,000
$100,000
$120,000
$140,000
$160,000
Ad
min
istr
ati
ve
Wri
te O
ff
2005 Goal 2005 Actual
2005 Goal $9,735 $19,470 $29,206 $38,941 $48,676 $58,411 $68,147 $77,882 $87,617 $97,352 $107,08 $116,82
2005 Actual $21,585 $29,184 $36,633 $49,572 $58,522 $70,638 $84,018 $136,13
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Quality Outcomes
Dan Jones Survey June 2003:
Ø234 Home Medical Equipment Patients Surveyed
Ø“Intermountain Homecare ranked highest across the board in all categories”
ØNumber 1 in Overall Customer Service
ØNumber 1 in Service Quality offered
Quality Outcomes (Cont.)
Intermountain Homecare:
Home Health Quality Indicators
ØOBQI Nationally published, outcomes
based quality indicators
ØIntermountain Homecare scores better
overall than National and State
measurements
HH OBQI Quality IndicatorsOutcome Measures Time
Period 6/1/04 - 5/31/05 Risk Adjusted
Na
t A
ve
rag
e
Uta
h A
ve
rag
e
Sa
lt L
ak
e
Og
de
n
Lo
ga
n
Sa
np
ete
Improvement in Ambulation/Locomotion (Getting better at walking/moving around using less equipment)
38.0% 40.0% 49.0% 42.0% 42.0% 41.0%
Improvement in Transferring (getting better at getting in and out of bed without help)
52.0% 57.0% 67.0% 54.0% 67.0% 63.0%
Improvement in Pain Interfering with Activity 61.0% 57.0% 55.0% 64.0% 61.0% 62.0%
Improvement in Management of Oral Meds 39.0% 39.0% 47.0% 36.0% 31.0% 44.0%
Improvement Breathing (Short of breath less often) 58.0% 63.0% 73.0% 56.0% 82.0% 64.0%
Acute Care Hospitalization (Had to be admitted to the hopital)
28.0% 23.0% 28.0% 22.0% 24.0% 15.0%
Any Emergent Care Provided (needed emergency medical care)
21.0% 21.0% 23.0% 19.0% 23.0% 16.0%
Key
Score stayed the same or change by 1%Improvementy by >1%Decline by >1%
Higher Percentages Are Better
Lower Percentages Are Better
Customer Service
Prioritized Scorecard Prioritized Scorecard Goals by Service LineGoals by Service Line
DME
Ø2211 Deductions (Administrative Adjustments related to a process breakdown)
ØVolume/Revenue Growth
ØCustomer Satisfaction (Pinnacle)
Home Health
ØUtilization
ØGrowth
ØProductivity
ØCustomer Satisfaction (Pinnacle)
ØJoint Commission
ØOBQI
Hospice
ØVolume Growth
ØCustomer Satisfaction (Perforum)
IV Therapy
Ø2211 Deductions
ØCustomer Satisfaction (Pinnacle)
Homecare
ØQuality
ØCustomer Service
ØClinical Consistency and System Integration
Next Steps
ØFinalize ScorecardsØIdentify Access LevelsØFollow Through on Action Plans for
Goals with Serious ChallengesØFormalized Monthly Review of Goals
with Executive Team by Responsible Business OwnersØLead by Example Every Day
Contact Information
Patrick Armstrong
Manager Decision Support
Intermountain Healthcare(801)887-6185