cebi executive briefing april 23-24, 2009 itasca, illinois douglas w. lyon, cpa

31
CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Upload: elisabeth-lewis

Post on 26-Dec-2015

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

CEBI Executive Briefing

April 23-24, 2009

Itasca, Illinois

Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Page 2: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Where Were We? (Two Years Ago)

Page 3: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Where Were We? (Two Years Ago)

First to Market

Market Leader – 28%

Virtually no competition

Prices so low, who could afford to compete?

Page 4: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

What Happened in 2006 – 2007?

Page 5: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

What Happened?

Contrary to popular thinking…the IRS is a

“good guy”!!

Page 6: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

What Happened in 2006 – 2007?

IRS announced Form 990 Schedule H

Michigan Hospital Association (MHA) indicated intention to compete “head-on” with us

- Historically, Michigan hospitals only

- Historically, survey process only (minimal hospital-level software)

Page 7: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Digression:

One of my Professional Regrets MHA and Lyon worked together in the late 90’s

- We had the software

- They had specific data aggregation needs

- We collaborated

- Their Senior VP was a supporter

Missed Obvious MHA indicators over 6 year period

- I should have “read the tea leaves”, but didn’t

Page 8: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

What Opportunities Did We See?

Page 9: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

What Opportunities?

Both a significant opportunity and a scary threat (a double-edged sword)

Opportunity was enormous… a federal agency mandating an annual report on Community Benefit

- Remaining not-for-profit hospitals should be ours for the taking (we thought)

- Lyon Software had a wonderful reputation and our

CBISA had a “Gold Standard” feeling among

hospitals

Page 10: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

What Opportunities?

Threat was significant as well… a highly-regarded, state hospital association would be a formidable competitor (tremendously more capitalized than Lyon Software)

And the bad news kept coming… another competitor was emerging

- A large healthcare consulting firm in Maine (but not a software developer)

And, RUMORS have been flying ever since about others, one of which we’ve been able to verify

Page 11: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Digression:

I Liked the “Life Style” Business Model

We had never advertised

Our prices were low (in retrospect, a good thing)

Word-of-mouth was primary source of new business

Warm relationships with two National Associations:

- Catholic Health Association (CHA)- VHA, Inc.- Each having over 1,000 hospital

members, mostly non-overlapping

Page 12: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Digression:

I Liked the “Life Style” Business Model

Figured my blue-chip, satisfied customer list of 1,200 hospitals would fund my eventual retirement

Wasn’t in for a fight … didn’t see one coming

Page 13: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

The Hospital Market

Page 14: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

The Entire Market – 4,500 NFP Hospitals

The Hospital Market

CBISA Clients:

• Full Paying 1,300 28.9%

• Free in ’08 400

CBISA Subtotal 1,700 37.7%

Prospects 2,800 62.3%

Total NFP Hospital Market

4,500

Page 15: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

How Big Was the Opportunity?

Page 16: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

How Big Was the “Opportunity”?

A hefty chunk of 2,800 remaining hospitals would have to do something by end of 2009

One 3rd (about 1,000) of the remaining hospitals would be worth over $2,000,000 a year in revenue to us

- It wouldn’t have to be Lyon Software

- It wouldn’t even have to be software

So it was worth spending some money

Page 17: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

So What Did We Do?

Page 18: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

So What Did We Do?

Market research

Identified new “buyers” in hospitals (CFOs)

Identified new messages:

- “Still the One” (for existing clients)

- “Do you have the systems in place?” (for prospects)

Page 19: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

So What Did We Do?

Evaluated our competition

- Way more capitalized than us

- No software companies (as yet)

- Minimal market penetration

- We beat MHA head-to-head in our first 3 health system battles (and one was Henry Ford Health System, in MHA’s backyard)

Did I mention their software was identical to CBISA… screens, screen prompts, reports, etc.? – what a coincidence

Page 20: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

So What Did We Do?

We did several real “marketing” things:

• Placed an ad in Healthcare CFOs periodical (called HFM)

- 8 months @ $4,200/month

• Snail-mailed (very expensive) descriptive, color

informational packets (with a specially-made

envelope stamped in red “Important Information on IRS 990H”) to 2,800 CFOs (every hospital we didn’t have)

Page 21: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Digression:

Meanwhile, Went After a New Market

Identified a new market for our software that would not require massive programming surgery – Higher Education

Hired a Higher Ed expert and one-half of a 2nd salesperson for Higher Ed

Developed the product – launched it in February ’09

- Identified 1,100 “community-engaged” colleges and universities as best prospects and mailed promotional packets to Presidents/CEOs of these institutions

Page 22: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

So What Did We Do?

Back to Hospitals

Hired a hospital community benefit expert to help sell; hired a 2nd half-time salesperson; reassigned existing staff duties to sell

Conducted educational workshops in 12 cities on new IRS requirements

- 310 attended

Page 23: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

So What Did We Do?

Changed our software to incorporate every requirement of Schedule H

- 8 to 10 new or seriously revised screens

- 15 new reports

- Expanded role/access for Finance types

Page 24: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

So What Did We Do?

MHA introduced “loss leader” pricing – sweet, one year deals for $900 (our software was $4,000 at the time)

I paid them an evening visit

For my full time staff… established a Christmas Bonus program, focusing on 2009 sales

Revised our pricing – first time in 15 years it went down - $2,000 (from $4,000)

Page 25: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Ongoing Plans

Page 26: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Ongoing Plans

CBISA and 990H educational webinars

More “face time” at conferences

Teaming up with additional states’ hospital associations (except, of course, Michigan)

- Speaking on Community Benefit and 990H at annual membership meetings (6 since November)

(Thinking about) hosting “virtual open houses”

Page 27: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Have We Been Successful?

Page 28: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Have We Been Successful?

Won’t know full effect for a year or more

Preliminary sales are up

18 state Associations are “on board” – compared to none 14 months ago

Competitors haven’t seemed to achieve “traction” (our fingers are crossed)

Page 29: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Lessons Learned

Page 30: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA

Lessons Learned

Don’t pre-announce a fabulous Christmas Bonus plan for Christmas 2009 (in late November 2008)

Stay close to your strategic partners and clients

- MHA should never have happened

Pricing strategy is so critical

“Short-term” sales help needs to be managed

Recognize some things are out of your control… and let them go

Page 31: CEBI Executive Briefing April 23-24, 2009 Itasca, Illinois Douglas W. Lyon, CPA