ccr standards for english language arts in adult...
TRANSCRIPT
Professional Development System
CCR Standards for English Language Arts in Adult ESL
Summer Institute 2014 Penn State University
Facilitator: Susan Finn Miller [email protected] 717-947-1015
Table Coaches: Rachel Baron, Linda Cullen & Bobbi Hurst
Professional Development System
A Warm Welcome to Everyone!
• You will need the following resources and handouts during this webinar:
– CCR Standards
– A Cloze Activity handout
– Features of Academic Language handout
– Aligning Resources to CCRS handout
– List of Resources
Activity Name 2
Professional Development System
Goals for this Session
Participants will be able to:
• Explain the central importance of teaching content and its concomitant academic language to support English learners to achieve their college and/or work-related goals
• Describe the complexity of academic language and articulate the importance of teachers being effective “language watchers”
• Demonstrate an understanding of the English Language Arts (ELA) Career & College Readiness Standards by:
– Reviewing the unpacking process
– Designing sample activities to match the standard
– Analyzing teaching materials to evaluate their alignment with the standards
• Identify instructional strategies to strengthen alignment to the standards
Professional Development System
5 Principles to Guide CCR Instruction in the Adult ESL Classroom
1. Instruction is aligned to standards, is rigorous, and provides deliberate and appropriate supporting scaffolds as learners grow in understanding and in the ability to use their emerging language skills.
2. Instruction takes into account:
– Learners’ prior schooling
– Level of home language proficiency as well as English
– Time in the U.S.
3. Instruction fosters autonomy and equips learners to construct meaning from academic talk and complex texts, and express themselves in writing across a variety of academic settings.
4. Standardized and formative assessments are used to:
– Measure content knowledge and academic language competence
– Monitor progress to adjust instruction and provide learners with useful feedback
– Encourage learners to reflect on their own thinking and learning.
5. Instruction leverages English learners’ home languages and cultures, and views them as assets that help bridge prior knowledge to new knowledge.
Professional Development System
Webb’s Depth of Knowledge
• Level 1: Recall and Reproduction – Basic tasks that require students to recall or reproduce
knowledge and/or skills.
• Level 2: Skills and Concepts – Tasks require students to use the information at Level 1 in two
or more cognitive steps such through classifying, summarizing, estimating, and inferring.
• Level 3: Short-term Strategic Thinking – Tasks require short term use of higher-order thinking such as
analysis and evaluation to solve real-world problems with predictable outcomes.
• Level 4: Extended Thinking – Tasks require extended use of higher-order thinking such as
synthesis, reflection, assessment and adjustment of plans over time.
Professional Development System
CCR Standards & 6 NRS Levels for ABE Reading & ESL
CCRS Levels
- - - - - - - - - A - - - - - - - - B C D E
ABE Levels Beg. Literacy ABE
Beg. ABE
Low Int. ABE
High Int. ABE
Low ASE High ASE
TABE Reading
367 and below (GLE -1.9)
368-460 (GLE 2-
3.9)
461-517 (GLE 4-
5.9)
518-566 (GLE 6-
8.9)
567-595 (GLE 9-10.9)
596+ (GLE
11-12)
CASAS ABE Reading
0-200 201-210 211-220 221-235 236-245 246+
ESL LEVELS Beg. Lit. ESL
Low Beg. ESL
High Beg. ESL
Low Int. ESL
High Int. ESL
Adv. ESL
CASAS ESL Reading
0-180 181-190 191-200 201-210 211-220 221-235
CASAS Listening
0-180 181-189 190-199 200-209 210-218 219-227
BEST Literacy
0-20 21-52 53-63 64-67 68-75 76-78*
BEST +
400 and below
401-417 418-438 439-472 473-506 507-540
Professional Development System
CCR Reading Anchor 2: Determine central ideas or themes of a text and analyze their development; summarize the key supporting details and ideas
CCR Level A CCR Level B CCR Level C CCR Level D
NRS Levels Beg. Lit., Low
Beg., High Beg.
NRS Level Low Intermediate
NRS Level High Intermediate
NRS Level Advanced
Identify the main topic and retell key details of a text
Determine the main ideas of a text; recount the key details and explain how they support the main idea
Determine the main idea of a text and explain how it is supported by key details; summarize the text. Determine a theme of a story, drama or poem.
Determine a theme or central idea of a text and how it is conveyed through particular details; provide a summary of the text distinct from personal opinions or judgments.
Professional Development System
Learning content
and the language used are
“mutually enriching processes”
Source: Council of Chief State School Officers. (2012). Framework for English Language Proficiency Development Standards corresponding to the Common Core State Standards and the Next Generation Science Standards. Washington, DC: CCSSO.
Professional Development System
Considering the Role of Language
Word Bank: content, language, significant, words, cognitive processes
“Students’ difficulties in ‘reasoning … may be due to their lack of familiarity with the linguistic properties of the (1) __________ through which the reasoning is … presented rather than to the inherent difficulty of the (2) _______________ involved” (Schleppegrell, 2004). “The (3) ______________ and their organization may be more (4) ______________ in learning than the actual (5) _____ or skills we are teaching” (Zwiers, 2014, p. 11).
Professional Development System
Considering the Role of Language
“Students’ difficulties in ‘reasoning … may be due to their lack of familiarity with the linguistic properties of the (1) language through which the reasoning is … presented rather than to the inherent difficulty of the (2) cognitive processes involved” (Schleppegrell, 2004). “The (3) words and their organization may be a more (4) significant issue in learning than the actual content or skills we are teaching” (Zwiers, 2014, p. 11).
Professional Development System
Implications for Our Practice
• For ABE/GED Teachers • Attention to the LANGUAGE required for critical thinking and for in depth understanding of content
• For ESL Teachers – Equal emphasis on meaningful CONTENT as well as
communication skills and language • civics, career exploration, topics of interest in the news, academic
content in science, social studies, math, etc.
• For All Teachers – Understanding the essential role of TALK – Sticking with themes over an extended period of time – Structuring many opportunities for students to
demonstrate their learning through various modes, i.e., presentations, posters, writing, projects
Professional Development System
Language … • “helps us get things done; it helps us act,
and it is action” (Walqui & van Lier, 2010)
• “is an evolving set of tools and skills used to construct and communicate ideas” … to convey ideas we “choose words, phrases, grammar and message organization strategies”
(Zwiers, 2014, p. 24)
Professional Development System
When it comes to academic language …
“We are like fish trying to describe water”(Zwiers, 2008)
Professional Development System
What is academic language?
“Academic language is
• the set of words,
• grammar, and
• organizational structures
used to describe
• complex ideas,
• higher-order thinking processes, and
• abstract concepts” (Zwiers, 2008, p. 20).
Professional Development System
What does Academic Language do?
• Serves 3 functions (as reflected in the CCR Standards )
–Describes complexity
–Describes higher-order thinking
–Describes abstraction
Professional Development System
Academic Language Describes COMPLEXITY
• Work Contexts: Numerous complex encounters
• Science: Complex calculations in chemical reactions
• History: Complex historical records
• Math: Complex applications of math to the real world
• Language Arts: Complex ideas to organize and express in writing
Professional Development System
Academic Language Describes HIGHER-ORDER THINKING
– Analyzing
– Seeking information
– Comparing
– Informing
– Explaining
– Predicting
– Classifying
– Justifying
– Hypothesizing
– Solving problems
– Synthesizing
– Persuading
– Empathizing
– Interpreting
– Evaluating
– Applying
(Do we need these skills at work, too?)
What LANGUAGE is needed for:
Professional Development System
Academic Language Describes ABSTRACTION
• John Dewey: “… abstractness depends largely on a person’s familiarity and expertise with a topic” i.e., background knowledge (Zwiers, 2014, p.
28)
– Therefore, what is concrete to teachers may not be concrete to students
• Teachers have “expert blind spots”
– Need to develop “pedagogical language knowledge” – i.e., language used in our discipline
Professional Development System
Reading Challenges
Talk with a partner or small group:
What are some of the challenges language learners have with reading?
Activity Name 20
Professional Development System
Language Challenges with Reading
• An abundance of idioms and figurative language • Density of unfamiliar vocabulary • Use of homonyms and synonyms • Grammar usage especially the "exceptions to the rules" • Word order, sentence structure and syntax • Difficult text structure with a topic sentence, supporting
details and conclusion • Unfamiliarity with the connotative and denotative
meanings of words • Literary terms for story development • Unfamiliarity with drawing conclusions, analyzing
characters and predicting outcomes • Imagery and symbolism in text
Professional Development System
Categories of Academic Vocabulary
• Content-specific: e.g., photosynthesis, balancing equations, bicameral
• General academic: e.g., feature, dimension, correspond • (Brick &) Mortar: e.g., therefore, whereas, because, etc. • Terms used in higher-order thinking: e.g., differ, boils down
to, contrast, outweigh, filter, model, evidence, consequences, aspects
Although important, teaching academic vocabulary is not enough! Academic language involves much more than vocabulary alone!
Sources: (Beck et al., 2002; Coxhead, 2000, 2010; Dutro & Moran, 2003; Zwiers, 2014)
Professional Development System 23
Word Tiers (Source: Beck et al., 2002)
Tier
1 •basic
•concrete
•in oral language
baby
drive
friendly
Tier
2
•abstract
•general academic
•in written language
approach
context
grant
Tier
3 •content/context
specific
•low frequency
molecule
pi
cartography
Professional Development System
Categorize these words into Tiers, 1, 2 & 3
• Tier 1: everyday oral language (concrete)
• Tier 2: general academic words (abstract)
• Tier 3: content/context specific (low frequency)
A: persuade brain gene
B: serious principle alliteration
C: exponent vary pick up
D: structure judicial boring
E: method holiday proton
24
Professional Development System
Categorize these words into Tiers, 1, 2 & 3
• Tier 1: everyday oral language (concrete)
• Tier 2: general academic words (abstract)
• Tier 3: content/context specific (low frequency)
A: persuade brain gene
B: serious principle alliteration
C: exponent vary pick up
D: structure judicial boring
E: method holiday proton
25
Professional Development System
First Step
Identify key thinking skills,
such as:
• Analyzing
• Comparing
• Interpreting
• Inferring cause and effect
Professional Development System
Second Step: Become language watchers!
Identify what LANGUAGE describes and clarifies each skill: • Example 1: What LANGUAGE do we use to
indicate cause & effect? – Slavery led to the Civil War. – What are the ramifications of the Emancipation
Proclamation? – As a result of the 13th amendment, slaves were
legally free. – What are the ramifications of our new work
policy?
Professional Development System
Second Step: Become language watchers!
Identify what LANGUAGE describes and clarifies each skill:
• Example 2: What LANGUAGE do we use to interpret?
– “This statement signifies …”
– “The underlying message is …”
– “… means that …”
Professional Development System
Figurative Language
• What comes to mind when you think about figurative language?
• What are some examples?
Professional Development System
Figurative Language Graphic Organizer
Figurative Expression
Why this Metaphor
Works
What it Means
The Golden Age of Society
The argument doesn’t hold water.
The research results were a red flag.
.
Source: Zwiers, J. (2008). Developing the language of thinking. Educational Leadership, 65(9).
Professional Development System
Figurative Language Graphic Organizer
Figurative Expression
Why this Metaphor Works
What it Means
The Golden Age of Society
Gold is beautiful and something people desire
The most prosperous and productive period of a society
The argument doesn’t hold water.
It’s like a weak bucket that has holes in it.
The argument is weak. It doesn’t have enough evidence.
The research results were a red flag.
A red flag signals a warning.
The findings show something unusual.
Source: Zwiers, J. (2008). Developing the language of thinking Educational Leadership, 65(9).
Professional Development System
Questions Worth Asking: Goal critical thinking
• Ask fewer questions and give more time for thoughtful answers
• Make the questions … relevant to the real world
• Ask questions you would ask of yourself
• Train students to ask their own questions
• Create learning tasks that are not so dependent on questions
“The real world does not have so many questions as in school… People are asked to produce or perform, asking their own questions along the way… Questions should be a means to learning, not the end” (Zwiers, 2014, p. 123).
Professional Development System
Speaking & Listening CCR Anchor 1 (p.29)
• Prepare for and participate effectively in a range of conversations and collaborations with diverse partners, building on others’ ideas and expressing their own clearly and persuasively.
Activity Name 34
Professional Development System
Unpacking ELA Standards
• With a partner or two, choose a standard to work with
• Identify the skill demands and write the verbs in column 2
• Identify the content or concepts related to each skill and write the nouns in column 3
• Indicate the context in which students will apply the skills and concepts in column 4
• Determine the level of thinking required as per Webb’s Depth of Knowledge
• What activity will you use to teach the standard?
Professional Development System
Let’s Confirm Our Unpacking
• When you cover up the text of the standard:
– Do the phrases listed adequately represent and describe the standard?
– Are the words used directly related to those in the standard?
– Is each skill linked to the appropriate content or concept?
– Do the words represent what you would really expect of a student?
Professional Development System
Aligning Resources to Standards
1. For this activity, you will work with ESL materials, (e.g., a textbook or teacher-created lesson or unit) used in your class or program
2. With a partner or small group, choose a standard to work with.
3. On the handout, list specific examples (sections and pages in the resource) that support the teaching of the standard.
4. Together make a professional judgment:
– Does the material include enough information to teach the standard to an appropriate level of depth and complexity?
– Record a score of 2 for tight alignment, 1 for partial alignment and 0 for no alignment
5. Discuss possible instructional strategies that could enhance the lesson to better align with the standard
Professional Development System
Aligning Resources to Standards
• Tight Alignment: The resource sufficiently supports learners’ mastery of the concepts and skills within the standard without the need for additional resources.
• Partial Alignment: The resource addresses the standard, but additional resources are needed to fill gaps and teach this standard well and in the depth necessary.
• No Alignment: The resource does not cover the standard at all or covers it too poorly for learners to gain mastery of the standard.
Professional Development System
Revisiting Our Goals
Are you able to: • Explain the central importance of teaching content and its
concomitant academic language to support English learners to achieve their college and/or work-related goals?
• Describe the complexity of academic language and articulate the importance of teachers being effective “language watchers”
• Demonstrate an understanding of the English Language Arts (ELA) Career & College Readiness Standards by – Effectively unpacking the standards? – Designing sample activities to match the standards? – Analyzing teaching materials to evaluate their alignment with
the standards? • Identify instructional strategies to strengthen alignment
to the standards?
Professional Development System
Reflections: Thinking Back & Looking Forward
• Reflect on the effectiveness of the content. What worked well and what could be improved?
• Has participating in this webinar changed your thinking about the CCRS?
• How will you use the methods and materials to improve your teaching and students’ learning?
• What questions, if any, remain for you?
• Have you identified specific needs that could be addressed through additional professional development?
Professional Development System
1. Identify one or more ELA standards that are relevant to the learners in your class
2. In your role as a “language watcher,” think carefully about the language required to complete the lesson and the learning tasks
3. Plan a standards-based ELA lesson, incorporating academic language, to address one or more of the standards – Design the lesson to ensure learners have the
opportunity to use the target language in speaking
4. After implementing the lesson, reflect on how it went and what you might want to change