catastrophic epilepsy of infancy diagnostic considerations in progressive myoclonic epilepsy
TRANSCRIPT
Evaluation of a Paroxysmal Event
• Is the paroxysmal event a seizure?
• Classify the seizure using ILAE system• Partial• Generalized
• Identify any primary etiology• Classify the epileptic syndrome• Make an informed decision about treatment
Syncope Panic attack Breath holding spell
Benign sleep myoclonus
Behavioral Non-epileptic seizure
Neonate Infancy Childhood Adolescen
ce Adult Elderly
Epilepsies in infancy• Occur between 0-18 months of age• Incidence at this time is ~80/100,000
• Higher than childhood (up to 12y)• Higher thatn adolescence (up to 18y)
• Developmental tasks• Refinement of motor skills• Development of complex intellectual skills• Development of complex social skills
• Impact of epilepsy on these tasks can be divided• Benign• Intermediate• Catastrophic
(boundaries of this category are not clear cut)
Incidence of Catastrophic Epilepsies
Catastrophic Epilepsy in ChildhoodInfantile Spasms
Lennox-Gastaut
Progressive MyoclonicEpilepsy
Ion
Ch
an
nelo
path
ies
Incidence of Catastrophic Epilepsies
Catastrophic Epilepsy in ChildhoodInfantile Spasms
Lennox-Gastaut
Progressive MyoclonicEpilepsy
Ion
Ch
an
nelo
path
ies
Sialidosis
Unverricht-Lundborg NCL MERRFLaFBD
MERRF• Symptoms
• Canonical• Myoclonus• Generalized epilepsy• Ataxia• (Ragged red fibers on
muscle biopsy)• Common (over 50%)
• Sensorineural hearing loss • Peripheral neuropathy • Dementia • Short stature • Exercise intolerance • Optic atrophy
• Uncommon (<50%)• Cardiomyopathy • Pigmentary retinopathy • Pyramidal signs • Ophthalmoparesis • Multiple lipomas
MERRF - FeaturesSign/Symptom Present/Evaluated Percentage
Myoclonus 62/62 100
Epilepsy 62/62 100
Normal early development 17/17 100
RRF (ragged red fibers) 47/51 92
Hearing loss 41/45 91
Lactic acidosis 24/29 83
Family history 34/42 81
Exercise intolerance 8/10 80
Dementia 39/52 75
Neuropathy 17/27 63
Short stature 4/7 57
Impaired sensation 9/18 50
Optic atrophy 14/36 39
Cardiomyopathy 2/6 33
W-P-W syndrome 2/9 22
Pigmentary retinopathy 4/26 15
Pyramidal signs 8/60 13
Ophthalmoparesis 3/28 11
Lipomatosis 2/60 3
Hirano & DiMauro 1996
MERRF• Onset is usually in childhood (may be younger)• May be confused with Friedreich ataxia (abnormalities
of proprioception and pes cavus)• FH short stature• Findings
• elevated serum lactate• RRF on muscle biopsy• Pathology
• Neuronal loss/gliosis of dentate nucleus and inferior olivary complex • Dropout of Purkinje cells and neurons of the red nucleus• Pallor of the posterior columns • Degeneration of the gracile and cuneate nuclei
• Course: slowly progressive or rapidly downhill.
MERRF - PathologyMuscle biopsy typically shows ragged-red fibers (RRF) with the modified Gomori trichrome stain
Normal Muscle Ragged Red Fibers
MERRF• Muscle; biochemistry variable, with defects in
• complex III• complexes II and IV• complexes I and IV• or complex IV alone
• Maternally inherited• More than 80% of cases are caused by a heteroplasmic G to A
point mutation at nt 8344 of the tRNA(Lys) gene of mtDNA• Additional patients have been reported with a T to C mutation
at nt 8356 in the tRNA(Lys) gene
MERRF - Treatment• The seizure disorder can be treated with conventional
anticonvulsant therapy. No controlled studies have compared the efficacy of different anticonvulsants.
• No treatment for the genetic defect is currently available.• Coenzyme Q10 (100 mg three times a day)• L-carnitine (1000 mg 3 times a day)Are often used in hopes of improving mitochondrial function.
Etymology• Ceroid
• L. [cera], wax, + G. [eidos], appearance• Compare with “cerumen”
• Lipofuscinosis• G. [lipos] “fat”• L. [fuscare] “to make dark” • Compare with “obfuscation”• (~“brown”)• L. [-osis] “abnormal condition” or “a state of disease”
• Ceroid and Lipofuscins are not the same• “Ceroid is acid fast, fat insolvent, and probably a type of
lipofuscin, although differing from true lipofuscins by failing to stain with Schmorl ferric-ferricyanide reduction stain”
The product of peroxidation of unsaturated fatty acids and symptomatic, perhaps, of membrane damage rather than being deleterious in its own right
Neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis• Most common neurodegenerative disease in children
(three autosomal recessive disorders)• Characterized by
• Accumulation of autofluorescent substance within lysosomes of tissue (especially neurons)
• Epilepsy• Progressive epileptic encephalopathy• Vision loss• Pathologic findings
• Light microscopy - ceroid• EM - Granular osmophilic deposits, curvilinear profiles, fingerprint
bodies• Individual genes mutated in six forms have been
identified
NCL• Infantile type (Haltia-Santavuori)
• Begins end of the 1st year• Death by ≈10 years
• Late infantile type (Jansky-Bielschowsky)• most common type of NCL• Presentation: myoclonic seizures beginning between 2 and 4
years in a previously normal child• May live to 5th decade
• Juvenile• Adult• Northern epilepsy variant
NCL
INCL
LINCL
JNCL
ANCL
NCL - Signs and Symptoms• Myoclonic seizures• Intellectual deterioration• Vision change
• Blindness• Optic atrophy, brown discoloration of the macula are evident
on retinal exam• attenuation of vessels• black pigmentary abnormalities (peripheral, “bone spicule”)
• Cerebellar ataxia is prominent• Early onset may be associated with microcephaly
NCL - Lab findings• Electroretinogram
• abnormal early in course • deposition of storage substance within the rod and cone
area• Visual evoked potentials are characteristic
• markedly enlarged responses initially• later absent
• Autofluorescent material accumulates in • neurons• fibroblasts• secretory cells
• EM (skin or conjunctiva)• curvilinear bodies • “fingerprint profiles”
NCL - Genetics and Pathophysiology• Infantile type:
• gene: palmitoyl protein thioesterase (PPT)• a.k.a. PPT; CLN1; INCL; PPT1• chromosome 1p32• lysosomal enzyme palmitoyl-protein thioesterase-1• Failure of synaptic fusion and vesicle recycling
• Late infantile type:• gene: TPP1 (sedolisin family of serine proteases)• lysosomal cleavage of N-terminal tripeptides from substrates• weaker endopeptidase activity• Synthesized as inactive state, and activated by acidification• Failure to degrade specific neuropeptides and a subunit of ATP synthase
in the lysosome
Unverricht-Lundborg• Neurodegenerative disorder• onset from age six to 15 years• stimulus-sensitive myoclonus, and tonic-clonic epileptic
seizures. • Late symptoms
• ataxia• incoordination• intentional tremor• dysarthria
• May have normal lifespan• Mentally alert but show emotional lability, depression,
and mild decline in intellectual performance over time.
Lafora body disease• Presents between 10 and 18 years• Epilepsy
• Generalized tonic-clonic seizures• Myoclonic jerks appear later, but become more frequent and
pronounced• Mental deterioration is evident within 1 year of onset
• Other neurological signs• cerebellar signs• extrapyramidal signs
• EEG• polyspike-wave discharges• occipital predominance• progressive slowing and disorganized background
Lafora Body Disease - Brain
Lafora bodies in the brain.Dense intraneuronalinclusions. H&E Stain
Lafora bodies are present throughout the nervous system, particularly in the dentate nucleus, red nucleus, substantia nigra, and hippocampus.
Sialidosis• Type I - “Cherry red spot myoclonus syndrome”
• presents in 2nd decade• complaints of visual deterioration• fundoscopy shows a cherry red spot• unlike Tay-Sachs, visual acuity declines slowly• Extremity myoclonus
• Gradually progressive and debilitating• Eventually renders patient nonambulatory • Triggered by
• voluntary movement• touch• sound
• Not controlled with anticonvulsants• Generalized convulsions occur in most patients which are more AED-
responsive
Sialidosis• Type II
• infantile and juvenile forms• cherry red spots myoclonus plus somatic features
• coarse facial features• corneal clouding (rare)• dysostosis multiplex (seen as anterior beaking of the lumbar vertebrae)• lymphocytes show vacuoles in the cytoplasm• liver biopsy showes cytoplasmic vacuoles in Kupffer cells• membrane-bound vacuoles are found in Schwann cell cytoplasm
• No distinctive neuroimaging findings or EEG abnormalities • Patients with sialidosis have been reported to live
beyond the 5th decade.
Sialidosis Pathophysiology• Progressive lysosomal storage of sialidated
glycopeptides and oligosaccharides caused by a deficiency of the enzyme neuraminidase
• => Accumulation and excretion of sialic acid (N-acetylneuraminic acid) covalently linked ('bound') to a variety of oligosaccharides and/or glycoproteins.
• Distinct from the sialurias where there is storage and excretion of “free” sialic acid
• Neuraminidase activity in sialuria is normal or elevated.
sialic acid (N-acetylneuraminic acid, NANA)
Dravet syndrome• Severe Myoclonic Epilepsy of Infancy (SMEI)• Multiple mutations• Allelic with “generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures
plus” (GEFS+)
Heterogeneity
SMEI
SCN1a
GEFS+Familial Autism
PanayioutopolousFHM
?SCN2a
GABRD
GABRG2
SCN1b?
?
Clinical Syndrome
Gen
e
Red flags for SCN1a mutation• Febrile seizures that
• Start before age 1 year• Persist beyond 5-6 years• Are prolonged; lasting >30 minutes
• Febrile seizures that evolve into epilepsy• Seizures that are provoked by a hot bath or rapid
temperature fluctuation• Seizures following vaccination• Family history of epilepsy, especially with
heterogeneous seizure types
Diagnosis• DNA testing
• Sequencing (70-90% of mutations)• Deletion testing (10-30% of mutations)
• Sequencing cannot detect large heterozygous deletions• Sequencing requires initiation with primers• If the primers cannot bind, they produce nothing• The normal allele creates a normal transcript• It appears that everything is normal, because everything that
was synthesized was normal!• If testing shows sequence variability, parent testing is
critical
Sequencing is positive• True positive
• Pathogenic sequence alteration reported in the literature• Sequence alteration predicted to be pathogenic but not
reported in the literature• Unknown sequence alteration of unpredictable clinical
significance• False positive - polymorphism
• Sequence alteration predicted to be benign but not reported in the literature
• Benign sequence alteration reported in the literature
Sequencing is negative• True negative
• Patient does not have a mutation in the tested gene (e.g., etiology is not genetic, or is caused by a different gene)
• False positive• Patient has a sequence alteration that cannot be detected by
sequence analysis• a large deletion• splice site deletion
• Patient has a sequence alteration in a region of the gene (e.g., an intron or regulatory region) not covered by the laboratory's test
Gene “normal” Gene “abnormal”
Correct conclusion
Wrong conclusion
Uncertain
previously reportedstop codon (nonsense)
unreported missense intron?
known genetic polymorphism
true negative
not detectedsplice site?
large deletion?upstream regulatory region?
parent testing
Parent testing• If the child has a genetic change (polymorphism or
deleterious mutation; doesn’t matter) there are only two possibilities• Inherited from mom or dad• New genetic change
• Generic rate of genetic change:• 2.5 x 10-8 mutations per nucleotide site per generation• 0.0000025% per nucleotide• 8100 nucleotides in SCN1a• Any individual has 1-(1-2.5x108)8100 chance of having a new
mutation• => 0.02% (unlikely)
Parent testing• Therefore, if you can prove a mutation is new
• it is very unlikely (< 0.02%) that it is a benign polymorphism that happened by chance in the single generation
• (less than, because some of those “chance” mutations will still be deleterious, and therefore should be subtracted from the total)
• If the clinical symptoms are compatible, such a result is accepted as sufficient evidence of causality
• (compare with p values of 0.05; we rarely get this definite in clinical medicine)
• If you can prove a mutation is “old” (inherited)• It is not sufficient for disease, provided parents are unaffected
Treatment• Avoid sodium channel medications
• carbamazepine• phenytoin• lamotrigine• vigabatrin
• Preferred medications• valproate - must think about risk of hepatic failure in the very
young• non FDA-approved
• clobazam• stiripentol
• Referral to the MCBI Ion Channel Epilepsy Clinic