capital projects - rebooting project intelligence - workflow and collaboration
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
1/35
2012SabisuLtd Page1of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
RebootingProjectIntelligence:Workflow&Collaboration
Workflow&collaborationchallengesfacedbycapitalprojectsandhow
newtechnologycanovercomethem
WhitePaper
By
TimSharpeCEO&co-founder
[email protected]@timjsharpe
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
2/35
2012SabisuLtd Page2of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
Contents
1. INTRODUCTION..........................................................................................................4
2. EXECUTIVESUMMARY................................................................................................5
3. PROJECTPERFORMANCE:ROOMFORIMPROVEMENT?..............................................7 3.1. PERFORMANCEOFLARGECAPITALPROJECTS...................................................................................................7 3.2. MANAGEMENTOFPROJECTPERFORMANCE.......................................................................................................8
3.2.1. Decision Making During Early Stages ................................................................. 83.2.2. Skills & Project Leadership .................................................................................. 93.2.3. Enhancing Project Value ................................................................................... 10
3.3. ORGANISATIONOFMEGA-PROJECTS................................................................................................................11
4. WORKFLOW&COLLABORATIONCHALLENGES..........................................................14
4.1. AD-HOCPROJECTMANAGERCOLLABORATION...............................................................................................144.2. EMAIL&EXCELPROLIFERATION ......................................................................................................................15 4.3. COLLABORATIONTHROUGHOUTTHESUPPLYCHAIN....................................................................................17
4.4. LABOURINTENSIVEDATAHANDLING..............................................................................................................18 5. NEWTECHNOLOGY...................................................................................................19
5.1. THEPROJECTINTELLIGENCECENTRE........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... .........195.2. TOTALINTEGRATION...........................................................................................................................................205.2.1. INTEGRATION=VISIBILITY..............................................................................................................................205.2.2. KEYDESIGNCRITERIA......................................................................................................................................21 5.3. HYBRIDCLOUD.....................................................................................................................................................22 5.3.1. WHATISAHYBRID-CLOUD?........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ..225.3.2. WHYCHOOSEAHYBRID-CLOUD?..................................................................................................................23 5.3.3. KEYDESIGNCRITERIA......................................................................................................................................24 5.3.4. GOMOBILE.........................................................................................................................................................24 5.4. TRUECOLLABORATION .......................................................................................................................................25 5.4.1. TRUECOLLABORATIONNEEDSASHAREDEXPERIENCE...............................................................................25 5.5. SOCIALWORKPLACE.......... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... .........265.5.1. ENTERPRISE2.0................................................................................................................................................26 5.5.2. ASOCIALPERSPECTIVE.......... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ..27
6. MEETINGWORKFLOW&COLLABORATIONCHALLENGES..........................................28
6.1. EASY&FOCUSEDCOLLABORATION..................................................................................................................28 6.2. USER&COMMUNITYAUTONOMY.....................................................................................................................30 6.3. USERCOMMUNITYFOCUS...................................................................................................................................306.4. CONTENTDISTRIBUTION....................................................................................................................................31 6.5. FRICTIONLESSBUSINESSPROCESSES........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ..316.6. EXCEPTIONALSERVICEDELIVERY........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... ........... .......32
7. SABISU......................................................................................................................33
7.1. FUNCTIONALFIT..................................................................................................................................................33 7.2. ABOUTTHESABISUTEAM...................................................................................................................................34 7.3. TYPICALINDUSTRYSECTORS.............................................................................................................................35 7.4. CASESTUDIES.......................................................................................................................................................35 7.5. NEXTSTEPS...........................................................................................................................................................35
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
3/35
2012SabisuLtd Page3of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
FiguresFigure1.FrontEndDevelopmentInfluence...........................................................................8Figure1.Mega-projectorganisations&responsbilities.................................................11Figure2.Scalingoutamega-project........................................................................................12Figure3.DaisychainingofDelays............................................................................................15Figure4.SameIssue,DifferentTools......................................................................................17Figure5.RequiredPICIntegrationCapability.....................................................................20Figure6.TheIdealArchitecture................................................................................................22Figure7.TwoPersonalisedViewsofaSituation...............................................................25Figure8.ASocial,EventDrivenView.....................................................................................27Figure9.InPlatformChat,ShowingCommunityFocus..................................................28
Definitions/Glossary
Abbreviation Description
BI BusinessIntelligenceCIO ChiefInformationOfficer
DCS DistributedControlSystem
EPC Engineering,ProcurementandConstructioncontractorERP EnterpriseResourcePlanning
FEED FrontEndEngineeringDevelopment;theearly,pre-investmentdecisionpartofaprojectwhereopportunitiesareidentified,
plansarecreatedandprojectsdefined.FEL FrontEndLoading;processforconceptualdevelopmentofaproject,supportingordescribingprocesseswithinFEEDstage.
FID FinalInvestmentDecision;decisiontoproceedwithaproject,usuallymadepriortoappointinganEPC.
hybrid-cloud ITinfrastructurethatincorporatesbothOn-PremiseandCloudservercomponents
IPA IndependentProjectAnalysis,Inc(Projectbenchmarkinganddeliveryconsultancyorganisation.)
KPIs KeyPerformanceIndicators
MES ManufacturingExecutionSystem
MIS ManagementInformationSystemMRP ManufacturingResourcePlanning(historicallyderivedfrom
MaterialsResourcePlannning)
PIC ProjectIntelligenceCentre;Anewclassofsoftwareprovidingreal-timesituationalawarenessandcollaborationforprojects.
PMO Project/ProgrammeManagementOffice
TIC TotalInstallCost
PAR ProjectAssuranceReview
PVP ProjectValueProcess
Sabisu Sabisuplatform,incorporatingOn-PremiseandCloud
components
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
4/35
2012SabisuLtd Page4of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
1.IntroductionOil&gasorpetrochemicalssectorcapitalprojectsofferuniquemanagementchallenges.Theyaresomeofthelargestprojectsintheworld,rangingincostfrom$500mforsmalllocallymanagedprojectsupto$30bnformega-projectsinvolvingjointventuresandmultipleEPCcontractors.Thesearehighriskprojectswithcorrespondinglylargeandcomplexorganisationsthatsupportthem,includingcomplexsupply-chainsthatoftenrequiredistributedvirtualteamstorealizetheEPCdelivery.Givencapitalexpenditureandfinancinginvolvedinmega-projectsthereisarelentlessfocusonmanagementandmitigationofrisk.Theconsequencesofnotdoingsoaresignificant,includingscheduleslippage,impactonthetotalinstalledcost(TIC),capitalcostpenaltiesandrevenuepenaltiesasproductionstart-upisdelayed.Theseprojectsarecoretothegrowthandcontinuedprofitabilityof
thosethatfundthem.Theseprojectsfacemajorchallengesduetothecomplexinterfacemanagementofwidelydistributedvirtualteamsindifferingtimezones,theinherentcommunicationdifficultiesandassociatedcomplexbusinessprocesses,andgettingreliableuptodate,realtime,accuratetransparentprogressdata.Thisleavestheclientsthatfundtheseprojectsoftenlargeenterprises,jointventuresorgovernmentsatadisadvantage;thecomplexandmassivenatureoftheprojects,combinedwiththelimitationsofhistoricallyavailableprojectcontroltoolsets,meanclientsdecisioninformationinvariablylagsthetrueprojectpositionresultinginlatedecisionswhichhavescheduleimpact.Thiswhitepaperlooksatthekeychallengesrelatedtovirtualteamcollaborationandworkflowefficiency,qualitativelyassessingtheimpactsandrisksoflimitedvisibilityandprojectcontrol.Thiswhitepaperalsoshowshownewtechnologyoffersaalternativeapproachtoconventionalprojectcontroltoolsusedbyclients,EPCsandvendors,improvingmanagementtransparencyandprovidingreal-timedecisionsupportthatallowsclientsandEPCstomitigateimpactandinfluenceaproject.
Insummarythispaperwillexamine: TypicalproblemsfacedbyProjectDirectors,ProjectManagersand
Project/ProgrammeManagementOffices(PMOs).
HownewITarchitecturescanprovideunrivalledlevelsofprogresstrending,visibility,collaborationandmanagementcontrolofcapitalprojects.
Theimportanceofvisibilityandresponsivenesstomanagingrisk.OtherwhitepapersintheProjectIntelligenceseriesare:
SituationalAwareness&ProjectControls
DecisionQuality
WarRooms:TotalProjectVisibility
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
5/35
2012SabisuLtd Page5of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
2.ExecutiveSummaryMegaprojectsfacecomplexitychallengesnotaddressedbyconventionalproject
controlstools.Newwebbasedtechnologyandcommunicationsystemscanprovide
realtimevisibilitytoeffectivelymanageworld-classprojectswithdistributedvirtualteams.Independentbenchmarkingorganisationsfindthat56%ofmega-projectsfail,havelargecostoverruns,scheduleslippageandoroperationalstartupproblemsthatpersistlongafterhand-over.Thesecomplexprojectsareinvariablyfragile,withcostandschedulecontinuallyatrisk.ExperiencedProjectManagersareinstinctivelyawareoftheriskstheirprojectsfaceanddomuchinthewayofad-hoccollaborationtomitigatetheirprobabilityorimpact.RiskreviewsofcostandscheduleareamajortoolinaPMsarmory,butthelackofreal-timedatafromtheirdistributedprojectcommunitymakes
trendingalaggingindicatorandconsequentlyresultsinlatedecisions.SmartercollaborationvianewtechnologywouldprovideProjectManagerswithbetterdataandtrendstoidentifyandmitigaterisksproactively.Asclient,EPC,vendorsandsub-vendorsmaintaintheirowninternalbusinessprocessestomanageriskandcontroltheirrespectiveprojectelements,thereisinevitablyafocusondatagathering,manipulation,trendingandtransfer,leadingto:
Discussionofwhichfiguresarecorrectandrepresentthetruth,insteadofwhatthefiguresortrendsmean
Dialogandreconciliationbetweensystemstoensurerespectivepartiesagreeswiththedetailtosupportinvoicing
Significantamountsofman-hoursburnedindatamanipulationinMSExcelandsuchlike
Significantman-hoursspentsending,readingande-mailingdatafrompoint-to-point,consumesvaluableprojectmanagementtimeandleadstoduplicationofdataonalargescale
Thesechallengesreflectthelimitationsoftraditionalprojectcontrollegacytechnology.Yetnewtechnologiesandapproachesincludinghybrid-cloudarchitecture,personalization,self-serviceandvendordiagnosticsintegrationcan
deliverastep-changeinprojectcontrolsbusinessprocesses.Usingnewweb-basedtechnology,mega-projectchallengescanbemitigatedmorequicklyandeffectively,withreal-timeprocessingprovidingthefollowingadvantages:
Project control KPIs built directly, in real-time, from client, EPC, vendor and sub-vendor data systems, (i.e SAP, Primavera, Oracle, DCS, databases or Excel forexample),
A single, incontrovertible view of project progress, shared with every user throughoutthe project supply-chain according to their needs.
An end to data gathering, manipulation, trending, emailing spreadsheets, datavalidation and duplicating data.
Consistent and trustworthy KPIs delivered through a collaborative platform, allowingdecisions to be reached quickly.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
6/35
2012SabisuLtd Page6of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
Self-service portals to allow any user to analyse issues and expedite resolutions.
Accurate, real-time data to give early influence on project issues and the projectlifecycle.
Shared client, EPC and vendor KPIs to support collaborative decision making.
Improved process compliance, whether through standardized project metrics, KPIs,or through ad-hoc collaboration.
Collaborative war room communications technology for specific focus areas ofproject risk.
Thispaperdescribesindetailhowthesenewtechnologiescansolvemanyofthetraditionalchallengesfacedbyprojectcommunitiesinmanagingcapitalprojectstoday.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
7/35
2012SabisuLtd Page7of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
3.ProjectPerformance:Roomforimprovement?Howdothechallengesexaminedinthispapershowintermsofprojectimpact?Is
thereevidencetoproveprojectscouldbemoreefficientlyrun?
3.1.PerformanceofLargeCapitalProjects
Itwouldbeeasytoassumethatamegaprojectismorelikelytounder-perform;thatdistributedvirtualteamsaddcomplexityandaremorelikelytoexceedcostandscheduletolerances.Clearlytheimpactofasmallpercentageslipismoresignificantincostterms.Otherbusinesssectorsdoseevastscheduleslippageandcostincreasesonlargerprojects.Publicsectorprojectsarewellknownforit,withthe12.6bnNHSNationalProgrammeforITbeingtheobviousexampleforecastin2008tobe4yearslate,thenlargelyabandoned,writingoffcostsof2.7bn.
Exampleslikethisareclassifiedasafailure.Intheoil&gassectorawrite-offlikethiswouldcertainlyberegardedassuch,butatotalwrite-offisunlikelyprojectstendtocomplete,soafailurewouldbeanunplannedexcursionoutsidecostorscheduletolerances.Usingthisdefinition,theindustrybenchmarkingorganisationIndependentProjectAnalysis,Inc(IPA)pointsto56%ofprojectscostedat$1bn+(mega-projects)asfailing;
Schedulesslippedby25%ormore Costsgrewby25%ormoreOperationalproblemspersistedfor1year+afterhand-overAsEdwardW.Merrow,Founder&PresidentofIPAInc,putsitinhisbook,IndustrialMegaprojects:Largecostoverruns,majordelays,pooroperability,andfartoomanysafetyincidentscharacterizewelloverhalfoftheindustrialprojectsof$1billionormorearoundtheworld.Clearlythisshowsthatwhilstmega-projectsarenotinthesameleagueaslarge
publicsectorprojectsintermsoffailurethereisstatisticalevidencethatmaintainingcontrolofmega-projectsisdifficult;theyarecomplex,fragileandcangoofftrackeasily.Costandschedulearecontinuallyatrisk.Tounderstandthechallengestheseprojectsfaceweneedfirsttounderstandtheirorganisationandscale.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
8/35
2012SabisuLtd Page8of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
3.2. ManagementofProjectPerformance3.2.1. DecisionMakingDuringEarlyStagesEffectivedecision-makingandFrontEndLoading(FEL)ofaprojectduringFEED
isessentialinordertoensurehighqualityFEEDdeliverablesareavailableandoptimized,thusincreasingthelikelihoodofahighqualityexecutionoftheimplementation(EPC)phase.KeyFEEDdeliverablesincludingtheProjectSpecification,+/-10%budgetestimateandlevelII/IIIintegratedschedulesthatreflecttheprevailingmarketconditions,allofwhichgotosupporttheFinalInvestmentDecision(FID).
Figure1.FrontEndDevelopmentInfluence
Asshowninthefigureabove,itisrecognisedthatdecisionsmadeduringFEEDhavethegreatestinfluenceonoverallprojectperformance,particularlycost,schedule,quality,commissioningandstart-upefficiency.Manyproductsinformtheprojectspecificationandrisks,thoughallultimatelyresolveintoa10%estimateandschedule.OftenaProjectAssuranceReview(PAR)willprovidesafeguardswhichensuretimelydeliverablessupportconsistencyinsubsequentdeliveryphases.Giventhescaleofinvestment,clientsoftenchoosetoinvestininternalorexternalbenchmarkingwhichcomplimentstheinternalPARs,andthenfurthersupplementthemwithpeerreview
programmestoensurethatopportunitiestopositivelyimpactthecostandschedulearerealised.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
9/35
2012SabisuLtd Page9of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
3.2.2. Skills&ProjectLeadershipOwner/clientandFEED/EPCContractormanagementteamsassembledformajorprojectsintodaysmarketinvariablyhaveskillsshortageswhichresultinworkpackagesbeingdistributedonaglobalbasistowherevertherequiredskills
canbefound.Virtual,distributedteamsarecommon,addingcomplexitytotheprojectaseachteammayoccupyadifferenttimezoneandtheinterfacesbetweenteamsmustbemanaged.Itisaprovenfactthatprojectperformanceislinkedtothequalityandcapabilitiesoftheprojectleadership,supportingteamsandprojectcontrolprocesses.Ahighlymotivatedandhighperformingteamwithstrongcorevaluesandsharedobjectivesisanessentialingredientinachievingsuccessfulprojectdelivery.
Foraprojectteamtobeeffectiveeachmembermusttrusttheother,theirprocessesandtheirdata.Yettrustisfragile;unreliable,infrequentorunavailableprojectcontroldataissuretodamageit,withimmediateandlastingimpactontheprojectastheteamcanceasestofunction.Theseproblemsoftenmanifestthemselvesaslate,unexpectedsurprisesbycriticalpathcontractorsorvendorswhichtheclienthaslittleornotimetomitigateorinfluence.Whenaprojectstartstodeviatefromapredictedplanitsdependentontheawarenessandexperienceoftheprojectleadershiptorecognisethepotentialimpactand/orconsequencesoftheprojecttrendsintimetotakecorrectiveaction.However,sometimestheprojectcontrolsdatalagsreality,oris
deliberatelywithheldfromtheclientbythirdpartiesduetomisreportingorfearoflossofface.Thissituationoftenleadstoaquestioningoftheeffectivenessoftheleadershipteamatthesethirdparties,followedbyabelatedattempttointroduceaprogrammeofteambuilding,focusedKPIsandwarroomcommunitiestotackletheproblem.Anosurpriseandnoblamecultureisessentialinhighperformanceteamsiftheyaretoachievethelevelofperformancerequiredtosuccessfullyimplementcomplex,widelydistributedprojectsandmega-projectsintodayschallengingenvironment.Governance,assurance,organisationalleadershipandprojectperformancemeasurementareallkeybenchmarkingprojectperformanceandreadinesscriteria.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
10/35
2012SabisuLtd Page10of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
3.2.3. EnhancingProjectValueProjectsandmega-projectsidentifyvalueduringFEEDphase,whichistheneffectivelyrealisedthroughtheapplicationofaprogrammeofProjectValueProcesses(PVPs).Weakprojectexecution,projectmeasurementorcontrol
erodesthebestpreparationandmakesdeliveryinefficient.Infact,anythingotherthanstrongprojectexecutionandcontrolposesaproblem,asitisalmostimpossibletoaddsignificantvalueafterFrontEndDevelopmentwithoutincurringadditionalcostandscheduledelays.ThereforeownersandclientsoftenrequireindependentbenchmarkingtogiveprojectsponsorsandshareholdersconfidencethataprojectisontrackwithagoodFrontEndLoading(FEL),i.e.,acomplete,high-qualityFEEDstage.OrganisationssuchasIPAIncprovideindependentbenchmarkingbasedonmetricsofcollectedfrommanyprojectsandapplystatisticalanalysisto
determinethelikelihoodofprojectsuccess.Thebenchmarkingrequirementisusuallyspecifiedinaprojectmandateandembeddedintothegovernance,assuranceandfinancialapprovalsprocess.WhilstthebenchmarkingprocessproduceslaggingKeyPerformanceIndicators(KPIs)itneverthelessidentifiesperformancegaps,businessandprojectrisksandopportunities.Thescheduleandeffortpressuretobringtheprojecttorealizationisoftenarootcauseofweakbenchmarkingperformance.Also,fundamentalbusinesscontrolsandprojectdeliverystepsareoftenmissedintheFEEDphase,resultinginpoorFrontEndLoadingindicesandimpactingoverallprojectdelivery.Inbothcircumstanceseffectivemanagement,monitoringand
mitigationcanhelp.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
11/35
2012SabisuLtd Page11of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
3.3. OrganisationofMega-ProjectsThesemega-projectstypicallyhaveacomplexorganisationstructuredesignedtodelegateandminimiserisk.Arelativelysimple,singlefacilityconstructionprojectmayhaveasingleengineering,procurementandconstructioncontractor
(EPC),whereasacomplexrefineryandpetrochemicalcomplexwithsignificantfinancialriskmayusemultipleEPCs.Inthesecases,thefinancialriskneedstobespreadacrossanumberofimplementationcontractors.EPCsthensub-contracttheirdeliverablecontractualobligationstovariousprocurementvendorsanderectioncontractors.Vendorsanderectorcontractorswilloftenusesub-vendorstosupplycomponents,materialsorservices.Theorganisationstructureofamega-projectthereforeeffectivelyseparatesconcernssothatriskcanbedelegated:
Figure2.Mega-projectorganisations&responsbilities
Howeverthisquicklyscalesouttobeacomplexorganisationstructure:
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
12/35
2012SabisuLtd Page12of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
Figure3.Scalingoutamega-project
Amega-projectoftenaggregatesmultiplecollocatedindividualprojectsbuteveryelementapartfromthesiteitselfisgloballydistributed.UsuallytheclientandEPCwillbeheadquarteredindifferentcountrieswithengineering,constructionandcommissioningteamswhoemigratetositeastheengineeringprogresses.Procurementvendorsandsub-vendorsnormallydonothaveapresenceonsitethougherectioncontractorswillbenormallybasedonsiteoradjacenttothesite.Inadditiontothesiteteams,theprojectwilluseoff-siteprojectsupport,procurement,inspectionandtechnicalteamsfromtheclient,vendorsandsub-vendors.Theseteamscouldbebasedanywherewhichmakescommunicationandmonitoringofprogressallthemoredifficult;theprojectteammadeupofvirtual,globallydistributedteamseachwithaccountabilityforon-timeandon-budgetdeliveryofadifferentpartofproject.Intermsofmonitoringofprogressanddatagatheringandsupportsystems,theclientandEPCwilleachruntheirrespectiveprojectcontrolssystems,withtheclientssystemsfocusingspecificallyonfinancialprogress.AstheEPChasoverallresponsibilityforprogressreportingtheirsystemsarefocusedonhard
deliverablesastheymanagetheinterfaceandsupplychain.CostandschedulearestillimportanttotheEPCgiventhattheyaretheendproductofcompoundingindividualdeliverables.ThesiteisresponsibleformonitoringconstructionandcommissioningprogressandhavetheirownplanningteamwhoreportbacktotheEPChead-quarters,wheretheengineering,procurementconstructionandcommissioningprogressisaggregatedintooneoverallprojectprogresschartanS-curve.OftenthereisapointintheprojectwhereEPCplanninggroupresponsibilityispassedtosite,wheretheconsolidationofprogressinputfromthenumerousinterfacesaroundtheworldcontinuesandisreportedbacktotheclientnormallyonamonthlybasis.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
13/35
2012SabisuLtd Page13of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
Eachprojecthasitsownsupply-chain,supportteams,ITinfrastructureandcorporateorganisationeffectively,eachprojectisaseparateenterprise.Therecanbesignificantdataaggregationandscalabilitychallengesacrossamega-project.
Theglobaldistributionandvirtualnatureofthisteammakesitmuchlesslikelythatcollaborationwillhappen.Userswillmostlikelysharedataonlyifandwhenitismandatory,muchreducingthelikelihoodofreceivinginformal,earlywarningofincipientissues.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
14/35
2012SabisuLtd Page14of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
4.Workflow&CollaborationChallengesSomecommonchallengesfacingcapitalprojectsthatprojectintelligence
implementationsshouldbeabletoaddressbuttypicallydont.
4.1.Ad-hocProjectManagerCollaboration
ExperiencedProjectManagersareinstinctivelyawareofmanyoftheriskstheirprojectsface.TheyalsoknowthevalueofcollaboratingwithotherProjectManagerstoensurethattheserisksaremitigatedorlessonslearnedaremadeavailableelsewhere.ProjectManagersalsoknowthatvendorsaremotivatedbyfillingtheirorderbook.UsuallyitfallstotheProjectManagerstoworktogethertoensurethatconflictingsupplyrequirementsaremanagedasitmustbeassumedthatthevendorhaslittleinterestinthis,orhaslimitedmanagementcapabilitytodoit.
ThisiswhyinformalnetworksofProjectManagersalreadyexist,formedonthebasisofpersonalrelationshipsandexperience.Whenthesenetworksstarttoshareinformationaboutbestpracticeorareasofjointinterestsuchas,forexample,supplierloadingitcanprotectcriticalpaths.Giventhecomplexnatureofthesupply-chainandtherelianceonasmallnumberofvendorsforlonglead-timekeycomponents,suchasreactorsorcolumns,thereisclearbenefitinthesecollaborative,virtualteams.Ifanything,thesecommunitiesofsharedinterestsshouldtobeeasiertoform,includingclients,
EPCs,vendorsandsub-vendorsasrequired.Suchcollaborationisad-hocatpresent;thenetworksformbasedonloosecriteriaandarenotmanagedassuch,whichallowsthemtobeagileandresponsive.Howevertheymightseerealbenefitinbeingabletoshareandcollaboratearoundusingcurrentprojectmetricstoillustratebestpracticeoraccelerateresolutionofissues.Easierandsmartercollaborationcanresolvecomplexglobalprojectandmega-projectissuesmoreefficientlythechallengeistomakeitso.Recentadvancesincollaborationandsocialtechnologycouldmeetthischallenge.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
15/35
2012SabisuLtd Page15of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
4.2. Email&ExcelProliferationAmega-projectwithmanyusergroupscanresultinfeedbackloops,delayedresponseandoutofdateinformation.Thesystemsarchitecturethatsupportsamega-projectisunusuallycomplex;usershavetobefamiliarwithmanydifferent
systemsinordertogetthedatatheyneed.Onceauserhasaccessedtherequireddatathereisoftenasignificantamountofmanipulationneededinordertomakethedatarelevant,asisseenwiththelargequantityofMSExcelspreadsheetandMSAccessdatabaseworkthattypicallytakesplace.Oncethedatahasbeenmanipulated,theuserhasonlyemailasamethodoftransfereffectivelyanon-contemporaneoussnapshothasbeentaken.Notonlyisthedataisalreadyoutofdatebutthisprocessproducesalargeamountof
end-usercomputingandduplicationofdata.Itsverydifficulttofindtheaccurate,currentdataunlesstheuserwhocreateditcandirectothersuserstoit.Whereveraninteractionbetweenorwithintheclient,EPC,vendorandsub-vendorisdependentonemail,theprocessisartificiallyslowedbyacycleofmanipulation:
Snapshot extract the data required from the source system
Manipulate import into spreadsheet/database, transform content as required
Email attach spreadsheet/database to email
Wait
Process Response discuss, re-snapshot, re-manipulate or otherwise act.
Whentheimpactofthisisconsideredacrossmultipleactorswithintheprojectasshowninthefigurebelowitseasytoseethatmakingadecisionbasedoncurrentdataisunlikely:
Figure4.DaisychainingofDelays
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
16/35
2012SabisuLtd Page16of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
Thisinefficientworkflowproducesalargeamountofend-usercomputingandduplicationofdata.Itsverydifficulttofindtheaccurate,currentdataunlesstheuserwhocreateditcandirectothersuserstoit.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
17/35
2012SabisuLtd Page17of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
4.3. CollaborationThroughouttheSupplyChainWhilstaCIOwilloftenrightlypointtotheirERPorMRPsystemasthetoolofchoiceforallbusinessprocesses,suchsystemsusuallydonotcoveradhocprocesses,localoperationalprocessesorprojectprocesses.Itsnocoincidence
thattheseprocessesofteninvolvecollaborationwiththirdpartiessomethingthatERP/MRPsystemsarenotarchitectedtoaddress.Ofcourseusershaveachoiceofcontinuallyimprovingsimplemessagingsystems,includingtelephone,email,SMSandtodaysinstantmessagingsolutions.Theseallowadegreeofcollaborationbutnonemeettheneedsofamega-projectasdescribedintheEmail&ExcelProliferationsectionabovetheyreslowandmainlyreactive.Collaborationneedstobemorethanjustamessagewithattacheddata
changingdatahighlightsadevelopingsituationsowhenthedatachangesallcollaboratorsshouldexperiencethisinreal-time.Agingsnapshotsofdatadisconnectcollaboratorsfromthesituation,andmanipulatingthisdatainaseparateenvironmentdisconnectscollaboratorsfromthecollaborationitself.Thismakescollaborationunnecessarilydifficult.Screensharingisntasolutionasitmeanscollaboratorscedingauthoritytooneother.Forashortmeetingthisisfinebutitsnotanoperationalsolutionasitdoesntprovideeachuserwiththetoolstocontribute,e.g.,eventhoughtheyredealingwiththesameincident,aProjectManagermaywantcurrentproductiondataonhisscreenwhereastheProjectDirectorwantstoseehistorical
productiondata,pluslogisticsandenvironmentaldata.Mostexistingsolutionsaredesignedtohaveallusersexperiencethesamedatainthesameway,ignoringthefactthatusersareindividualswithdifferingneeds,toolsandexpertise.Asshowninthefigurebelow,itscrucialthateachuserhastheuserexperienceandtoolstheyrequireinordertodealwitheachsituation.
Figure5.SameIssue,DifferentTools
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
18/35
2012SabisuLtd Page18of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
4.4. LabourIntensiveDataHandlingEveryorganisationisdifferentwithdifferentlevelsofprocessmaturity,expertise,andPMOorProjectControlsteamcapability.PMOshavetheirworkcutoutwiththeircoretasks,whichmayincludefinancialreconciliations,project
controlsandensuringcompliance.Howeverinourexperienceonefeatureiscommon;labourintensivemanipulationand/orre-entryofdata.Thismanipulationisubiquitous,generallymanifestingitselfintheformofmultitudinousExcelspreadsheetsholdingcomplexmacros.Thisisoftentheonlywaythatprogress,planningandfinancialinformationcanbebroughttogetherforreconciliationorreporting.Re-entryisalsorelativelycommon,whetherre-inputtingthirdpartydatasuchasEPCorvendorplanninginformationintotheclientplan,ormanuallymapping
internalclientdatabetween,SAPandPrimaverausinguniqueidentifierssuchaspurchaseordernumbers.Lookingattheplanningdisciplineasaunifiedsystem,eachoftheclientprojects,EPCs,vendorsandsub-vendorsonamega-projectmaintaintheirownplanandthereisinevitableduplicationofdataacrossmultipleplatforms;Primavera,MicrosoftProjectServer,MicrosoftProjectProfessionalandExcelbeingtypicalexamples.Whilstsomeorganisationshavetakenstepstoreduceduplicationandre-entryofdatatherehas,inourexperience,beenpartialuptakeofthis.Forexample,some
clientsallowEPCstoupdateplanswithprogressinformation,butthishasntbeenwidelyadopted.Otherorganisationsofferwaysforavendortouploadaprojectplanbutthesearetypicallyheldasdiscretefiles,sotheresnowaytoeasilyaggregatemultipleplansfrommultiplevendors.ReducingmanualmanipulationandduplicationwouldsavetimeandallowPMOresourcestobemoreeffectivelyutilisedoncore,value-addactivities.YetitsalsoessentialifProjectDirectorsandManagerswantincreasedvisibility,earlywarningofissuesandeasyidentificationofbestpractice.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
19/35
2012SabisuLtd Page19of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.NewTechnologyAdvancesintechnologyallowanintegrated,collaborative,real-timeexperiencefor
projectteams.
5.1.TheProjectIntelligenceCentre
Currentprojectintelligenceofferingsareeithersimplereportsontheprojectscheduleandresources,orareaggregationsofprojectdataforbenchmarkingpurposes.Theydonotaddressthechallengeslaidoutinthispaper.Thechallengesexaminedabovecouldbemetbyacombinationoftechnologiesthatprovided:
Real-time visibility of data from all parties in the supply-chain, regardless of systemlocation or complexity
A single, unified view of the project or mega-project optimized to each users needs
Notification of issues Collaborative tools to allow the project to react and deal with issues
Thesefeaturesconstituteanewtypeofplatform;theProjectIntelligenceCentre(PIC).Theyalsodescribeanimprovedwayofoperatingaprojectormega-project.Thesefeaturesrelyonnewtechnologies:
Total integration; flexible, extensible, vendor agnostic
Hybrid-cloud architectures
True collaboration through shared experience
Social workplace
Thispaperwilllookbrieflyateachoftheseareas,beforelookingathowtheycontributetomeetingthechallengesdescribedpreviously.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
20/35
2012SabisuLtd Page20of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.2. TotalIntegrationUntilnowitsbeendifficulttoaccessproprietaryformatorlegacydatasources;newconnectivitycapabilitiescanpresentaconsumerstandardintegrateduser
experience.
5.2.1. Integration=Visibility
Inordertodeliverthesituationalawarenessanddatatransparencyrequired,thePICneedstobeabletodelivervisibilitythroughoutthesupply-chain.Modernintegrationtechnologiescanconnectthesystemsthatpoweryourprojectsatclient,EPC,vendorandsub-vendorlevels,bringingallthedataneededtomanageaprojecttogetherinoneplace.AsaminimumthisneedstocoverERP,planning,documentmanagementand
existingMIS/BIplatforms.However,connectivitytoMES,datahistorians,DCSandotherplantsystemswilleasethehandoverintoproduction.
Figure6.RequiredPICIntegrationCapability
ThisconnectivityallowsthePICtobeasinglepointofreferenceforallandeliminatescomplexityfortheuser.Whenalliedwiththehybrid-cloudarchitecturediscussedinsection5.3,HybridCloud,itallowstheclientand/or
EPCdirectvisibilityofallvendorandsub-vendorprogress.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
21/35
2012SabisuLtd Page21of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.2.2. KeyDesignCriteria
InsummarytheidealPICsystemshouldbeofferingasstandard:
Self-serviceplatformsrequiringnoITinvolvement
Genuineend-userdrivendataaccessbuiltaroundmodernuserexperienceprinciples
Real-time,orasnearasmakesnodifference
Simultaneousdirectaccesstosourcedataforall,soastoprovidea
platformforcollaboration
Somewaytoactiontheintelligence;tocurateitforacommunity,makeit
actionable,orstartcollaboratingwithothers
Controllableexpense-there'snowaytheenterpriseshouldbepenalised
withincreasedexpenseorcomplexityforauserwantingtoextractor
sharedata
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
22/35
2012SabisuLtd Page22of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.3. HybridCloudHowintelligentuseofcloudcomputingcandeliveravalueaddarchitecture,ratherthanjustanoutsourcedinfrastructurerisk.
5.3.1. Whatisahybrid-cloud?
Ahybrid-cloudarchitecturehastwokeyrolesinmeetingthechallengesfacedbylargecapitalprojects;externalcollaborationanduniversaldataaccess.Thetermcloudisoftenappropriatedtomeananumberofdifferentthings.Forthepurposesofthisdocumentitwillhelptodefinethecloudasserverresourcewhichis:
Off-site; centralised application deployment to clients and servers, minimisingdeployment costs ande delivering a standardised user experience.
Scalable on-demand; to permit new collaboration partners and meet data exchange
requirements. Virtualised; spread across multiple hardware platforms to minimise risk.
Private; limited to enterprise customers with appropriate provisions for data security
Thisclearlydifferentiatesthisusageofcloudfromothersolutionsthatmaybesomeornoneoftheabove.Thetermhybrid-cloudmeansthatbothcloudcomputingandOn-Premiseresourcesareused;
An On-Premise component which connects to enterprise systems, authenticatesusers, aggregates and serves data and manages communications to the cloud
servers. A cloud component which permits centralised delivery of client and server updates
and manages communications with external users and On-Premise servers.
Figure7.TheIdealArchitecture
Youcanfindamoredetailedarchitecturediagramathttp://www.sabisu.co/_artifact/sabisu-architecture.pdf.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
23/35
2012SabisuLtd Page23of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.3.2. Whychooseahybrid-cloud?
Asmentionedbrieflyabove,thehybrid-cloudarchitecturehastwokeyrolesinmeetingthechallengesfacedbylargecapitalprojects;externalcollaborationanduniversaldataaccess.
Thehybrid-cloudarchitecturefundamentallyredefinesprojectreporting,bringingthereal-timereportingandcollaborationfunctionalitysofarreservedforexpensive,hardtoimplementoperationalintelligencesystemsintoanagile,quicklydeployedprojectintelligencecentre.Thisnewapproachallowstheprojectintelligencecentretomeetchallengesthatpreviouslycouldbesolvedonlywithsignificantinvestmentandrisk:
Situational Awarenesso When combined with advanced, real-time integration capabilities can deliver
genuine situational awareness to any user anywhere.
Decision Supporto Decision support systems require hybrid-cloud architectures to provide a
single, incontrovertible version of the truth and a platform for globalcollaboration.
Workflow Efficiencyo Modern project workflows benefit from easy data transfer and instant, data-
centred collaboration.
Project Controlso Project controls teams benefit from direct access to client, EPC, vendor and
sub-vendor data, improving reporting quality and easing reconciliation.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
24/35
2012SabisuLtd Page24of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.3.3. KeyDesignCriteria
Thehybrid-cloudofferssomerealadvantages.Aswithanynewtechnologycareshouldbetakenwhenlookingatsystemcapabilitiesthefollowingcriteriawillminimizerisk:
1. No line of business data should be persisted outside the corporate network.
2. No corporate data is transmitted outside the corporate network unless external users
are specifically authorized to access it.
3. Corporate data should be provided to end-users in real-time on demand, i.e., without
caching.
4. Design for the thinnest possible client; smallest footprint, lowest cost ideally throughstandard browsers without reliance on plug-ins.
TheidealPICshouldbeprovenwithasmallpilotdeployment,whichwillshowhowit:
Adapts to your business processes and end-user requirements without requiringsignificant development work or configuration.
Delivers significant business benefit even from a deployment to a niche businessfunction or limited number of users.
5.3.4. GoMobile
Thehybrid-cloudalsoallowsthecapitalprojectchallengeslaiddowninthispapertobesolvedforanotherusertype;themobileuser.Indeed,withonlyminormodificationsrequiredtotheuserinterfacetoadapttodifferentdisplayrequirementsanddevicecapabilitiesanyuserwithamobiledevicecanbeconnectedtotheproject.Giventheglobalnatureofsuchprojectsandthefrequencywithwhichmanagementarerequiredtotravelthisisabenefitwhichbecomesmorecompellingasmobiledevicesbecomesmarterandbetter
connected.Indeed,thereisagrowingtendencyfordevicessuchasiPadsandiPhonestobeusedwithintheenterprise,particularlybyseniormanagement.Thehybrid-cloudarchitectureallowstheserequirementstobemetwithoutfurtherexpenseorcomplexity.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
25/35
2012SabisuLtd Page25of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.4. TrueCollaborationCollaborationismorethansimplemessaging;atrulycollaborativeenvironmentpromotesteamworkingandeliminateslotsofemail.
5.4.1. TrueCollaborationNeedsaSharedExperience
5.5. Asdiscussedaboveinsection4.3,CollaborationThroughouttheSupplyChain
allusersmustseethesamedevelopingsituationinreal-time.Thisisntsimplyaonesizefitsalldashboard;thisisanindividual,yetshared,experienceofthesituation.Thereiscommunalcontrolandresponsibilityforresolution.Thusallcollaboratorsneedaccesstothedatathatdescribesthesituationor
businessprocess,yetwithoutcompromisingthepersonalizedenvironmenteachuserneedstodotheirjob.Eachindividualhastoaccesstothisdataontheirownterms,i.e.,alongsideotherdata,documentsandtoolstheyneedtocontextualizethesituationormovetheprocessforward.
Figure8.TwoPersonalisedViewsofaSituation
TheroleofthePICisthereforeoneoffacilitatingthesharedexperience;creatinganenvironmentwheredataiseasilyaccessiblewhethercollaboratorsare
basedwithclients,EPCs,vendorsorsub-vendors.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
26/35
2012SabisuLtd Page26of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.6. SocialWorkplaceSocialcapabilitycanenhanceaprojectseffectivenessandabilitytorespondbutthosethatcanalignusersaroundcoredatacanseeanexponentialreturn.
5.6.1. Enterprise2.0
ThePICasdiscussedsofarhasmanyEnterprise2.0,orenterprisesocialsoftware,properties:
As discussed in all the previous sections, personalization is crucial to the success ofan PIC solution; the end-users autonomy must be respected. This is also a crucialtenet of Enterprise 2.0, or enterprise social software.
The platform as described also has significant communication features which supportits unique, genuine collaboration capability.
The platform has an appreciation of which users are linked thanks to the communitymodel, which also gives it a method for easy adoption throughout the project.
The ease with which users can share data and content makes user links andcommunities useful and therefore likely to be used, so all the ingredients for asuccessful enterprise social network are in place.
The ease with which new users can be added to communities allows for viral growth,whilst the implementation of a corporate administrator allows this growth to bemanaged.
StudiesarebeginningtoshowthebenefitsofdeployingEnterprise2.0technology;theemphasisinsocialbusinesssoftwareisnowstartingtoshifttowardsbusiness.AMcKinseystudyfoundthatexternallynetworkedorganisationswereinthetop3%oftheirsectors.Byplacingprojectdataatthecentreofanycollaborationorcommunityactivity,theplatformactuallydevelopssocialcapabilityintosomethingnew;asocialworkplacededicatedtofinding,sharingandcollaboratingonprojectdata.ThissharedpurposeisonlypossiblebecausethePICcanbringthedatatogetherinashared,yetpersonalized,environmentthevendorandplatformagnostic
integrationcapabilityisessentialtothesuccessoftheproject.OrganisationsadoptingaPICsolutionwiththesepropertiescanatlastleveragepersonalization,communityworking,enterprisedataandsocialnetworkingtoproducegenuineimprovementsinefficiency.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
27/35
2012SabisuLtd Page27of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
5.6.2. ASocialPerspective
Thetraditionaldashboardviewofaprojectassumesthattheuserwillbemonitoringitconstantly,yetthisisnotpractical;userswillbedivertedforgoodreasonatcertaintimes.Alsonotalldataisbestpresentedinadashboard,e.g.,
conversations,statusorprogressupdates.ThereforethePICneedstopresentactivityinanevent-driven,timelineview.Doingsowillkickstartcollaborationandallowofflineuserstobebroughtuptodateprovidedofcoursethatthetimelineisrelevant.Fortunatelythereisawaytoensurerelevancy;whenausernominatesdataasrelevanttotheircommunityorcommunities,theyarefilteringoutalltheirrelevantdataandthusensuringthetimelineremainsuseful.BuildingontheconceptsintheTotalIntegrationsectionabove,thevastconnectivityandself-
servicecapabilitiesofthePICallowstheusertonominatedatafromvirtuallyanywhereintheenterprise.AstheidealPICprovidesawealthofcollaborationoptionsitisalsoideallysituatedtoupdatethetimelinewiththelatestdiscussions.ThismeansthatanofflineusercangetthefullpicturefromthePICandbereadytocontribute.Thisistrulyasocialplatform.Asdiscussedthroughoutthispaper,projectsdependonbringingpeopleindifferentorganisationstogether.Sothetimelinefacilityisvaluabletoallpartiesasitpromotestransparencyandrapidresponsefurtherbreakingthedelaying
cyclesshowninFigure3.
Figure9.ASocial,EventDrivenView
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
28/35
2012SabisuLtd Page28of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
6.MeetingWorkflow&CollaborationChallengesNewtechnologybroughttobearonprojectandmega-projectchallenges,breaking
downboundariesanddeliveringvisibilityandcontrol.
6.1.Easy&FocusedCollaboration
AdhoccollaborationbetweenProjectManagersasdescribedinsection4.3isclearlybeneficialandshouldbeencouraged.Whencombinedwithnewtechnologywhichallowsuserstoshareprojectdataasdescribedin4.2,messagingfeaturescanbecomepowerfulcollaborationoptions.Agoodexampleisinstantmessaging,orchat;byputtingprojectdataatthecentreofthediscussion,itbecomesavaluablecollaborationtool.Ithastheadvantagesofbeingimmediatewhilsthavingjusttherightlevelofintrusion;likearingingtelephone,itencouragesareactionbutcanbeignored.
Giventheimportanceofcollaborativecommunities(section6.3)anymessagingmechanismshouldallowgroupsofinteresteduserstoeasilycollaborate.Ifausercanbringanentirecommunityintoareal-time,shared,collaborativeenvironmentthentherecanbenoquickerwayofexposinginsights,resolvingincipientsituations,orexpeditingbusinessprocesses.
Figure10.InPlatformChat,ShowingCommunityFocus
Perhapsmoreintrusivebutlikelytogaininacceptabilityisvideochat;facetofacediscussionviawebcam.High-resolutionwebconferencingcapabilityisnottheaimheremorearapidlyaccessedcollaborationfacility.Oftenpreferabletotextonlymessagingasinterpersonalandenvironmentalconsiderationscanbemade,itsawelcomedevelopmentprovidedthecollaborativeenvironmentisnotcompromised;iftheuserhastosacrificetheirviewofthedata,situation,orprocesstogetthevideochatsoftwareinitialized,thenitsnon-optimal.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
29/35
2012SabisuLtd Page29of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
Obviouslyaccommodationsneedtobemadeforoffline,non-real-timecollaboration.Theseshouldstillbedata-centricintheiruse,usingsomesortofnotificationprocesssothatuserscanbebroughtuptospeed.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
30/35
2012SabisuLtd Page30of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
6.2. User&CommunityAutonomyGivingeachuserapersonalperspectiveonasharedexperiencemeanssubstantialcomplexity;eachuserneedsapersonalizedenvironment.
Somedegreeofassistanceindeterminingthisenvironmentisappropriate.Ascommunitiesofusersclusteraroundcommoninterests,itseemslogicalthatthePICprovidesthefacilityforcommunitiestodetermineadefaultprojectdashboardthatcanthenbecustomisedbyindividualusersifrequired.Thesecommunitypageswillthemselvesevolveovertimeasdatasourcesevolve,mergeoraresuperseded.AsthePICisanenterpriseplatform,careshouldbetakenaroundadministrationofcommunities,theirproliferationandtheirprotection.Inparticular,thefollowingconsiderationsshouldbemade:
Administration has to be an end-user responsibility; awaiting IT involvement everytime a user needs to be added to a community will lead to delays.
End-users should be able to create communities as situations require, yet with someoversight from a corporate administrator.
Communities must have some sort of privacy structure to ensure they stay relevant,corporate intellectual property is protected and confidentiality respected.
6.3. UserCommunityFocusUsercommunitiescomeinallshapesandsizes.Eachprojecthasmany
communitiesandtheydontnecessarilymirrortheorganisationstructure.
Communitiesarereliable,robustandinclusive;theyleadtobetterdecisionsand
bytheirverynatureengageusersandensurethattherelevantdatagetsto
interestedparties.
ProjectManagersalreadyshareinformationsoastoprotecttheoverall
programme,particularlywithregardtovendorproductioncapacity.Thead-hoc
communitiesthatformasaresultgivegreatbenefitinandacrossprojects,sothe
PICneedstosupportthis;itneedstobeintuitivesothatcommunitiescan
organicallygrowasneeded.Anintuitiveandeasytodeploysolutionwillgrowat
therequiredpacewithouttrainingorITconstraintstopreventitfromreachingtherequiredconstituencies.
Communitiesarethekeyorganisationalconstructforbringingmega-project
teamstogether;bringingallprojectconversationsintooneplacebuildsa
reusablelibraryofexpertiseandbestpractice.Itsalsotheeasiestwayfora
ProjectManagerorDirectortoseewhichissuesarebeingactivelyworked.
Filteringandmakingdatadirectlyavailabletoacommunityremovesthe
traditionalrelianceonemail,oranyotherformofserialinformationdelivery.It
alsoopensthedoorforstreamliningcomplexbusinessprocessesandbreakingthebehavioursthatintroducedelay.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
31/35
2012SabisuLtd Page31of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
6.4. ContentDistributionWiththeuser/communityrelationshipestablished,thePICisuniquelypositionedtoensurethatusersareprovidedwithrelevantcontent.Thiscontentisimportanttothebusinessintermsofensuringprojectefficiencyand
consistencyandtousersforunderstandingtrendsordevelopingnewinsights.ThePIChasaroleintermsofpropagatingbestpractice;astheplatformresponsibleforbringingcommunitiesofuserstogetheraroundprojectprocessesandissuesitistheidealplacefordetermining,communicatingandensuringcompliancewithrevisionstobestpractices.Theamountandvariednatureofprojectdataavailabletousersintheenterprisemeansenterprisesearchisoflimiteduse.Thisiswherecurationbecomesvaluable;byhighlightingthemostvaluableversionofcontent,orcollaboratingto
producenewversions,usersfilterthemostrelevantcontent.Thiscontentisthenpropagatedbyallowinguserstotheneasilysharethedatawiththeircommunities.Inthisway,thePICcanaddvaluetoexistingdocumentorcontentmanagementsystems,suchasSharePointorOpenTextLivelink.ThePICmusthaveatleastrudimentarylinktopermitthesharingandhencepropagationacrossthesocialnetworkofcontentfromthesesources.
6.5. FrictionlessBusinessProcessesThoughERPsystemsensurecomplianceinkeyfinancialandoperationalbusinessprocesses,manyprocessesthatdependonthirdpartiesfalloutsidetheERPsystemscontrol.ThePICmustsupporttheevolutionoftheseprocessesasnewcommunitiesareidentifiedandnewdatasetsareshared.Thiscouldbethoughtofasavirtualenterprisenetwork;apermanentlyavailable,zeroconfiguration,on-demandfacilityforcross-enterpriseworking.Everyprojectpartnercanbeincluded-independentconsultants,SMEsandcontractors.
Thiscapabilitymeansitsnolongernecessarytotreatcontractorsasemployees;theydontneedtobeon-site,orontheclientsenterprisenetwork,orprovidedwithITsupport.Allthirdpartiescanbeprovidedwithdirectaccesstothedatathattheyrequire,savingcostsandreducingtheriskofaccidentaldataexposure.Asreferredtoinsection5.6.1,Enterprise2.0,thisistheextendedenterpriseinaction;Enterprise2.0technologyappliedtothechallengesoflargecapitalprojectsisagreatexampleofhowdata-centredenterprisesocialnetworkscandeliverrealbusinessbenefit.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
32/35
2012SabisuLtd Page32of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
6.6. ExceptionalServiceDeliveryWhilstthefocusofthePICsolutionisonprojectdeliveryfortheclient,itshouldbeacknowledgedthatexternalserviceprovidersofallkindscouldusethesameproperlyarchitectedPICsolutiontodeliversignificantbenefitforbothparties.
Thisisparticularlyrelevantduringcommissioningandhand-overtoproduction.Beyondtheimprovedinter-organisationcollaborationdescribedinsection6.5,serviceproviderscanlookforwardtoearlyinclusionindevelopingoperationalsituationsallowingearlierandlowercostresolutiontoissues.Suchaninvolvementisidealforthirdpartyconsultantsandknowledgeworkers.Serviceprovidersarealreadyusingthiscloud-basedPICcollaborationcapabilitytodifferentiatethemselvesfromcompetitors,providingon-demandaccessforcustomerstokeydataandinstant,pro-activecollaboration.
Serviceprovidersalsofindthatnewcustomerscancommissiontheirservicesmoreeasily;itssimplyacaseofmakingappropriateprovisionsforstoringthenewcustomersdataandallowingappropriateaccess.Theserviceprovideralsobenefitsfromarobust,scalablecomputingresourcethatwouldbecostprohibitivefortheserviceproviderstoimplementthemselves.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
33/35
2012SabisuLtd Page33of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
7.SabisuTherewasntasolutiononthemarketthatcouldachievegenuineimprovementsin
efficiencyorcollaboration,orextendtheenterprise.Sowebuiltit.
7.1.FunctionalFit
WithSabisu,webelievewevebuilttheultimateprojectintelligencecentre,focusingonintegration,collaborationandtheextendedenterprise.Othersolutionsmaymeetsomerequirementsbutnoothersmeetall.Sabisuwasconstructedwiththeextendedenterpriseinmind;theplatformsOn-PremisecomponentisdesignedonindustrystandardoperatingsystemsanddatabaseserverssoastopermitrapidglobaldeploymenttolocationswhereITexpertisemaybelimited.
Sabisudeliversallthefunctionalityoutlinedinthisdocument.Allofthepracticesandimpactshavebeenprovenwithinexistingcustomers,e.g.,
Visibility throughout complex supply chains and business processes
Users migrating to centralised collaborative platforms, e.g., from email to instantmessaging.
Improvements in business process execution efficiency
Identification of operational cost savings
Improved service delivery from and to third parties
Reduction in IT expenditure, particularly around meeting new informationpresentation requirements
OurcustomersarefindingusesforSabisuthroughouttheirlargecapitalprojects;KPIdashboards,documentmanagement,commissioningandassetmanagement,andofcourseexecutivereportingandday-to-daybusinessprocessexecution.Sabisuisalsoinconstantusebythosewhocreateandmaintainit;itsusedtomonitorthevariousproductionenvironmentsandserviceourcustomers.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
34/35
2012SabisuLtd Page34of35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
V1.0
7.2. AbouttheSabisuteamWereatechnologycompany;webuild,implementandhelpourcustomersexploitSabisu.
Sabisuisdesigned,builtandhostedintheUK.WehaveofficesinTeessideandManchester;ourcloudfacilityisadedicatedSabisuprivatevirtualenvironmenthostedfromourdatacentreinManchester.Sabisuwasestablishedin2003toprovideITservices,principallytothepetrochemicalsindustry.RealisingthatwehadauniquevaluepropositioninenterprisesoftwarewelaunchedSabisuintobetainJanuary2010withtheaimofbuildingaplatformtomakecomplexenterpriseseasytomanage.Ourapproachwastousethebesthybrid-cloud,socialandintegration
technologiestobuildaplatformwithunprecedentedreachandapplications.Weworkedinpartnershipwithanumberofearlycustomersintheoil&gassectortomakethishappen,withtheproductgoingliveinJanuary2011.Sincethenwehavebeenracingtokeepupwithdemandasexistingcustomersexpandandweaddnewcustomers.OurcustomersarefindingthatSabisucanbringdatatogetherfromdisparatesourcesregardlessoflocationtorefinebusinessprocesses,eliminatingtime-consumingmanipulationofdataandtheneedtomanuallymovedatabetweensystems.Asasmall,agile,responsivetechnologycompany,weregardourselvesashaving
partnersratherthancustomers;twoway,longterm,mutuallybeneficialrelationships.Foramoredetailedpresentationofourvaluesanddifferentiatingapproach,wewouldbepleasedtoprovideorpresentadditionalmaterial.
-
7/29/2019 Capital Projects - Rebooting Project Intelligence - Workflow and Collaboration
35/35
RebootingProjectIntelligence WhitePaper
7.3. TypicalIndustrySectorsDesignedinpartnershipwithleadingpetrochemicalsandrefiningcompanies,Sabisuisaperfectfitfortheoil&gasdownstreamsector.Itsbeendesignedandbuiltwiththeresilience,security,qualityandsystemintegritythatthismarket
demands.ThereforeSabisuwillbringbenefitstoanylarge-scalemanufacturingandprocessindustryoperation,withcompellingsuccessstoriesinchemicals&biofuelsinparticular.WithitsextendedenterprisecapabilitySabisuisalsothedeliveryplatformofchoiceforserviceprovidersasitenablesthecustomertodigitallycommissioneasilyandprovidesexcellentcollaborativefeaturestoensureoptimaldelivery.
7.4. CaseStudiesConstructionofSabisuwasstartedinmid-2010.Thesolutionwasdesignedandbuiltwithhelpfromleadingpetrochemicalmanufacturersandprocessindustryfigures,thoughthecompanyandallintellectualpropertyrelatedtotheplatformcontinuestobeprivatelyheldbyitsfoundersandteam. Athttp://www.sabisu.co/CaseStudies.aspxyoullfindagrowingnumberofcasestudies.
7.5. NextstepsContactus.Wedlovetohearyourcomments.Youcanreachusat:[email protected]:http://www.sabisu.co/contact-usOrourofficecontactdetailsare:
MANCHESTER
ArdenHallSaleM333SJ+441619733138GoogleMaps
TEESSIDE
A311TheWiltonCentreWiltonRedcarTS104RF+441642438124GoogleMaps