capital adequacy in islamic banks
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
1/32
Capital Adequacy Framework for Islamic
BanksDr. Habib Ahmed
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
2/32
2
Lecture PlanBackgroundNeed for Bank Regulation
Banking Regulatory FrameworksBasel I (1988)Basel II (2006)
Regulatory Framework of Islamic BanksIFS B Approach (2005)Conclusion
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
3/32
3
BackgroundThe banking industry is one of the mostregulated sectorsReasons of regulation:
One of most leveraged industriesprotectionagainst bankruptcy Protect depositors/consumers
Monetary, financial, and economic stability (systemic risks)
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
4/32
4
Background (2)
Basic balance sheet relationship:
A=L+EOr Net-worth=A- L=EIf (Net-worth) E the firm is b ankrupt
Lia b ilities Assets
Deposits/DebtCapital/ Eq uity
Assets
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
5/32
5
Role of CapitalEx amples:Case 1: E=10State 0: A=100, L=90, E=10;State 1: A=95, L=90, E=5;State 2: A=85, L=90, E=-5; ( Bankrupt)Case 2: E=20State 0: A=100, L=80, E=20;State 1: A=95, L=80, E=15;State 2: A=85, L=80, E=5
More risks need more capital (to avoid b ankruptcy)
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
6/32
6
Regulatory Capital Ade quacy Regulatory capital was initially identified by capital-ratio defined as:
Total Capital/ Total AssetsImposing one capital ratio to all banks wasnot prudentSome banks were engaged in riskier
activities than othersLater Capital ratio evolved toTotal Capital/ Total Risk Assets
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
7/32
7
Basel I StandardsBasel Accord of 1988standardized bank capital re quirements internationally T ypes of regulatory bank capital
Tier 1 Capital (core capital): common stock,retained earnings, perpetual preferred stock,etc.
Tier 2 Capital (supplemental capital): Loan lossreserves, unpaid dividends, etc.
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
8/32
8
Risk-Weighed Assets
Classification Assets classified into 4 categories depending oncredit risk Lowest risk category (no default risk) 0 risk weight [e.g., Government bonds]
2nd
Lowest risk category (low default risk) 20% riskweight [e.g., interbank deposits, fully backed mortgage bonds, etc.]3rd risk category (low to moderate default risk) 5 0%risk weight [e.g., municipal bonds, residentialmortgages, etc.]4 th risk category (moderate to high default risk) 100%risk weight [e.g., all other loans, commercial papers,etc.]
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
9/32
9
Basel I Capital Re quirementsCapital Ratio Re quirements:
Ratio of total capital ( Tier 1 &2) to risk weighted assetsmust be at least 8 percent.
Capital Ratio= Total Capital/ Total Risk Assets=8%
N ote:
When an asset has a risk weight of 100%, the capital charge on it is 8% When an asset has a risk weight of 50%, the capital charge on it is 4%
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
10/32
10
Capital Re quirements
Ex ampleLia b ilities Assets
Deposits/Debt 95,000
Total Capital 5,000
Cash 5,000
Govt. Bonds 20,000Deposits at Banks 5,000Loans for ResidentialProperties 10,000
Loans to PrivateCorporations 60, 000
Total 100,000Total 100,000
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
11/32
11
Capital Re quirements
Ex ample (contd)5,000
20,00025,000 x 0 = 0
0% Risk WeightCashGovt. Bonds
5,0005,000 x 0.2 = 1000
20% Risk WeightBalances with Banks
10,00010,000 x 0.5 = 5000
5 0% Risk WeightLoans for Residential Properties
60,00060,000 x 1.0 = 60,000
100% Risk WeightLoans to Private Corporations
66,000To tal Risk Weighted Assets
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
12/32
12
Capital Re quirements Ex ample
(contd)Total Assets =100,000Total Risk Weighted Assets=66,000Total Capital=5,000
Capital Ratio without risk weightsTotal Capital/ Total Assets=5,000/100,000=5%
Capital Ratio with risk weightsTotal Capital/ Total Risk Weighted
Assets=5,000/66,000=7.6%
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
13/32
13
Capital Re quirements Ex ample
(contd)T wo Banks A and B (with same assets and capital value)Bank A (relatively more risky assets)
Total Assets =100,000Total Capital=5,000
Risk weighted Assets=75,000Capital Ratio with risk weights
Total Capital/ Total Risk Weighted Assets=5,000/75,000=6.7%
Bank A (relatively less risky assets)Total Assets =100,000
Total Capital=5,000Risk weighted Assets=55,000Capital Ratio with risk weights
Total Capital/ Total Risk Weighted Assets=5,000/55,000=9.1%
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
14/32
14
Capital Re quirements Ex ample
(contd)Regulatory Capital Re quirements8 %Bank A is undercapitalized (6.7%)holding lesscapital than re quired by regulation.
It can increase its capital by:Issuing new sharesReducing dividends (i.e., increasing retained earnings)Reallocating assets (opt for less riskier assets)
Bank B is overcapitalized (9.1%) holding morecapital than regulatory capital
It can reduce capital by:Buying back sharesIncreasing dividends (i.e., decreasing retained earnings).Reallocating assets (opt for more riskier assets)
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
15/32
15
Basel I Capital RequirementsConclusions and Issues
Regulatory Capital Re quirements is 8% of risk-based assetsComposition of assets determines thecapital re quirementsOnly Credit risk considereddoes notinclude market and operational risks
Banks e xposed to significant market andoperational risks (changes in interest rate,currencies, commodities, stock prices, etc.)
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
16/32
16
Basel II StandardsTo fill in the gaps and to come up with anappropriate regulatory capital re quirements, BaselCommittee on Banking Supervision initiated the
Basel II standards in 1993The standards were finally completed in June2006The Standards are complicated and comple x (251pages)
[http://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs107.htm]
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
17/32
17
Basel II StandardsMainFeatures
A framework to further strengthen the soundnessand stability of the international banking system
A more risk-sensitive capital re quirements
Three PillarsMinimum Capital Re quirementsSupervisory Review ProcessMarket Discipline
Minimum Capital Re quirementsconsiderscredit, market and operational risksNot one, but different approaches to arrive atcapital re quirements
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
18/32
18
Basel II Standards
Credit Risk Credit RiskStandardized Approach, Internal RatingsBased Approach, Securitization Framework Credit Riskdifferent risk weights are given for varioustypes of clients (Sovereign, public sector entities, MD Bs,
banks, securities firms, corporations, etc)Ex ample: Risk weights for corporations given below:
UnratedBelow BB-
BBB+ toBB-
A + to A- AAA to AA-
Credit Assessment
100%150%100%50%20%Risk Weight
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
19/32
19
Basel II StandardsMarket Risks
In conventional banking, Market risks arisemainly in the trading book (derivatives,securities, currency, commodities, etc.)Held short-term to benefit from pricemovementsDifferent risk-weights given to various typesof items (derivatives, debt securities, etc.)
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
20/32
20
Basel II StandardsOperational Risks
Operational Riskthree approachesBasic Indicator ApproachStandardized Approach
Advanced Measurement Approach
Basic Indicator Approach:K=GI xK-capital charge (for operational risk)GI-average gross income over last 3 years
15 %
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
21/32
21
Lecture PlanBackgroundNeed for Bank Regulation
Banking Regulatory FrameworksBasel I (1988)Basel II (2006)
Regulatory Framework of IslamicBanksIFSB Approach (200 5 )Conclusion
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
22/32
22
IFS B StandardsIntroductionIn December 2005 IFS B publishedCAPI T A L ADEQ UACY ST ANDARD FOR INS TITUTIONS OFF ERING ON L Y ISL AMICFINANCIA L SERVIC ES (71 pages)
http://www.ifs b .org/Uses the following BCBS documents to arrive atcapital re quirements:
International Convergence of Capital Measurement and
Capital Standards: A Revised Framework, June 2004(B ASEL II 2004) Amendment to Capital Accord to Incorporate MarketRisks, January 1996for Market Risks (Market Risks1996)
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
23/32
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
24/32
24
Issues in Capital Ade quacy for I Bs
Asset side:Islamic Instruments have both credit andmarket risks and the risks change according to
the stage of the contractIdentify the credit/market risks in theinstruments and assign the appropriate risk
weights (from Basel II standards)
Liability side: Role of PSIA
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
25/32
25
IFS B Capital Ade quacy Standards Basic E lements
Credit Risk: Standardized Approach(B ASEL II 2004)
Operational Risk: Basic Indicator Approach(B ASEL II 2004)
Market Risk: Applications from Market Risk 1996.
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
26/32
26
Capital Re quirements
Ex ample (1): S alam contractMarket Risk CapitalCharge
Credit RW Applica b le Stage of the Contract
The Simplified Approach15 % capital charge on longposition of salam exposures
Based on customers ratingor 100% RW for unratedcustomer
Payment of Purchase Price by the IIFS to a Salamcustomer
Not ApplicableReceipt of the purchasedcommodity by the IIFS
Not ApplicableNot ApplicableThe purchased commodity issold and delivered to a buyer
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
27/32
27
Capital Re quirements Ex ample(2): Operating I jarah
Market Risk Capital Charge
Credit RW Applica b le Stageof the Contract
Non-binding P L15 % capital charge untillessee takes possession
Binding Promise to I jarah (P L) Asset Ac quisition cost
less (a) market value of asset fulfillingfunction of collateral and (b) hamish
jiddiyahMultiply with the customers rating or100% RW for unrated customer
Asset available for lease(prior to signing a leasecontract
The residual value will berisk-weighted 100%
Total estimate value of the leasereceivables shall be risk-weightedaccording to the lessees rating. 100%RW for unrated customer
Upon consigning aleasing contract and thelease rental payments aredue from the lessee
15 % capital charge of thecarrying value of the asset
Not applicableMaturity of the contractterm and the leased assetis returned to IIFS
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
28/32
28
IFS B StandardsStandard formula for regulatory capital
E ligible capital/ [Total risk-weighted assets (credit andmarket risks) + Operational Risk Risk-weighted assetsfunded by PSIA (credit and market risks)]
Note:Islamic Financial Instruments are more riskierincreases capital re quirements
PSIA are profit/loss sharing contractscan share thelossessubstitutes for capital (reduces capitalre quirements)
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
29/32
29
IFS B Standards- Ex ample (1)
AssumeTotal risk weighted assets=120% of total assets= 108 Average Gross Income of last 3 years = 10Operational Risk Capital base = 10 x 0.15=1.5Percentage Total Assets financed by PSIA=40/90=44.4%Risk weighted assets financed by PSIA= .444 x 108=48
Standard formula for regulatory capitalE ligible capital/ [Total risk-weighted assets (credit and market risks)
+ Operational Risk Risk-weighted assets funded by PSIA (creditand market risks)]
= 5/ [108 + 1.5-48] = 5/61.5 = 8.1%
Lia b ilities AssetsPSIA 40Demand Deposits 55Eq uity 5
Cash 10Total Assets 90
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
30/32
30
IFS B Standards- Ex ample (2)
AssumeTotal risk weighted=120% of total assets= 108 Average Gross Income of last 3 years = 10Operational Risk Capital base = 10 x 0.15=1.5Percentage Total Assets financed by PSIA=20/90=22.2%Risk weighted assets financed by PSIA= 0.222 x 108=24
Standard formula for regulatory capitalE ligible capital/ [Total risk-weighted assets (credit and market risks)
+ Operational Risk Risk-weighted assets funded by PSIA (creditand market risks)]
=5/ [108 + 1.5-24]=5/85.5= 5.9%
Lia b ilities AssetsPSIA 20Demand Deposits 75Eq uity 5
Cash 10Total Assets 90
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
31/32
31
Conclusion
The nature of risks in IFIs comple xre quires different regulatory standards Assets of I Bs more riskier that conventional
banksComposition of both assets and liabilities(deposits) determine the capitalre quirementsB y sharing the risks, PSIA offsets thecapital re quirements of I Bs riskier assets
-
8/6/2019 Capital Adequacy in Islamic Banks
32/32
32
Thank you!