can ukraine and romania be a tandem in the transnistrian settlement? can ukraine and romania be a...

14
Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk, Strategic and Security Studies Group Kyiv, Ukraine International Conference “Ukraine and Romania: Partners or Competitors?” Odesa, October 14, 2013

Upload: irma-horn

Post on 08-Jan-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

Recent developments Ukraine’s OSCE Chairmanship Priority 5+2 rounds November will host the next round of negotiations on the Transnistrian settlement.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? 

Sergiy Gerasymchuk, Strategic and Security Studies Group

Kyiv, Ukraine

International Conference “Ukraine and Romania: Partners or Competitors?”Odesa, October 14, 2013

Page 2: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Transnistrian conflict

Page 3: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Recent developments

Ukraine’s OSCE Chairmanship Priority

5+2 rounds

November 25-26 will host the next round of negotiations on the Transnistrian settlement.

Page 4: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Ukraine – Romania tandem?

Key questions to answer:

Pros and cons of Romania’s involvement?What are the obstacles for cooperation?Are the obstacles artificial and the threats

exaggerated?

Page 5: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Arguments in favor of involvement

Both Romania and Ukraine are not interested in escalation of conflict

Both Romania and Ukraine agree upon the necessity to preserve territorial integrity of Moldova

Romania being on the path of the reforms can teach a lot

Page 6: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Obstacles: mutually negative stereotypes

Romania Ukraine

Page 7: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Exaggerated threats

Transnistria:

Page 8: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Exaggerated threats

Ukraine:

Page 9: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Exaggerated threats & speculations

Ukraine should react promptly: in case Romania annexes Moldova – Ukraine should annex Transnistria. Eduard Leonov “Svoboda”

Page 10: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Speculations of politicians supplemented by speculations of

“civil society” IdealistsPragmaticsFlexible HypocritesPro-Russian NGOs

Page 11: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Realistic threat and true obstacle

Page 12: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Ukraine – Romania tandem?

Added value: YESObstacles: LOTS OF THEMInvented or realistic obstacles: BOTHIs there any chance for the tandem?

Page 13: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Ukraine – Romania tandem

Already exists formallyHas good chances from both perspective of

liberal institutionalist : the politics of international organizations and Western States of consolidating democracy and good neighborliness imposed rules of cooperation

realist perspective: the patterns of cooperation are produced by the balancing behavior (fear of Russia)

Page 14: Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Can Ukraine and Romania be a tandem in the Transnistrian settlement? Sergiy Gerasymchuk,

Thank you for your attention!Q & A

Sergiy GerasymshukStrategic & Security Studies Group

Kyiv, [email protected]

www.gsbs.org.ua