cambodian case study on par bratislava workshop 19-22 april 2004
DESCRIPTION
Cambodian Case study on PAR Bratislava Workshop 19-22 April 2004. By Han Phoumin UNDP Cambodia. Background. Twenty years of war: Fragile governance Severe Capacity constraints. Background (cont). Concept of modern state in Cambodia… predatory purposes - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Cambodian Case study
on PAR
Bratislava Workshop 19-22 April 2004
By Han Phoumin
UNDP Cambodia
Background
Twenty years of war:
Fragile governance
Severe Capacity constraints
Background (cont)
Concept of modern state in Cambodia…
predatory purposes
lack of tradition for political accountability
Post UNTAC … heavy burden of coordination vs. massive distortions
Low remuneration
PAR in Cambodia
Governance Action Plan (GAP)National Program for Administrative Reform (NPAR)UNDP approach from 1994 – 2003:
I) Strengthening the capacity of CAR Secretariat…for strategic Planning…
II) Facilitating the implementation of priority reform initiatives…
III) Support to the preparation of PMG (piloting successes)
PAR in Cambodia
PAR is also decentralisation
Seila programme
key parameters of Seila’s success
Lessons Learned
Lession #1: Strategic constituency building
PAR’s failure due to the design, lack of consensus, weak understanding of the complex system.
Vis a Vis
CARERE/SEILA’s sucess
Lessons Learned
Lession #2: PAR need to be flexible
PAR’s failure to provide linkages/ coordination from one reform to anothers. All due to lack of ownership and guidance.
SEILA’s success due to process planning and donors’ willing to take risk
Lessons Learned
Lession #3: Need piloting and experiences
PAR lack of technical competency as a convenor
SEILA’s success built from piloting and experiences
Lessons Learned
Lession #4: Need integration
PAR and decentralization need to be integrated and harmonised. D&D must seen as one process, not two tiers govt.
The next steps
Claim victory and move on
Change dual focus on PAR and decentralisation
Focus on service delivery improvement capturing both the central and decentral perspective
Pilot initiatives in civil service reforms (PMGs)Civil society