business process improvement: integrated ......business process improvement: integrated thinking...

37
BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy - Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT

Upload: others

Post on 01-Jun-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING

PRESENTED BYLisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMATina Bode, CISA, COBIT

Page 2: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

2

Objectives• Identify signs of process

improvement needs within their own organization

• Gain awareness of process improvement tools, techniques and benefits

• Understand how to design improvements with internal controls in mind

2

Page 3: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Agenda• Introductions

• About Process Improvement

• Process Improvement Opportunities and Techniques

• Internal Control Considerations

3

Page 4: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Legacy Software, Systems, and Processes

44

Page 5: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

On-The-Job Training

55

Page 6: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Implementation of New Systems

66

Page 7: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Regulatory and Industry Requirements

77

Page 8: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Little Time to Examine Processes

88

Page 9: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Background on Process ImprovementLOTS OF METHODOLOGIES

• Lean• Six Sigma• Lean Six Sigma• Total Quality Management

9

Page 10: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Eliminate Waste

• Over-production• Correction (defects)• Inventory• Motion• Over-processing• Conveyance• Waiting

10

Page 11: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Reduce Variation / Error

11

Page 12: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Workflow Example: Accounts Payable

12

Page 13: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Workflow Example: Accounts Payable

13

Page 14: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Workflow Example: Accounts Payable

14

Page 15: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Principles of Process Improvement

• Eliminate paper early• Capture data once

electronically• Electronic interface• Direct lookup• Increased system

functionality• Workflow tools• Standardize

communication• Train to desired process

15

Page 16: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Potential Areas of Improvement

1616

Page 17: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Accounts Payable

• Fewer last minute vendor payments or overdue invoices

• Increase in term discounts• Lower level of grief managing

the process

17

Page 18: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Month End

• Less cumbersome monthly close

• Financial reports available faster

• Decrease “cumbersome” tasks• Fewer last minute preparations

for the board meeting

18

Page 19: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Billing and Collections

• Reduce denials• Improve collections and aging• Increase revenue• Decrease time to resolve

issues

19

Page 20: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Staff Scheduling and Payroll

• Decrease time spent managing the schedule

• Reduce overtime and/or agency staff

• Fewer scheduling conflicts• Less after payroll corrections

20

Page 21: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Purchasing, Ordering, and Inventory

• Operate with a smaller inventory

• Reduce rush ordering for inventory shortages

• Purchase in more optimal patterns

21

Page 22: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Fundraising

• More efficient outreach• Increased accuracy in donation

classification• Faster correspondence to

donors

22

Page 23: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Registration and Intake

• Fewer steps to register a patient, client, or student to receive services

• Improve alignment with eligible services

• Decrease repeated questions

23

Page 24: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

IT Support

• Decrease IT support ticket volume

• Alleviate some of the “fire fighting” the team does

• Increased end customer satisfaction

24

Page 25: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

But…. The Auditors Said

25

Page 26: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

What is the Purpose of Internal Controls?

• Safeguard assets• Reliability and integrity of

financial information• Compliance with laws and

regulations• Efficient and effective

operations

26

Page 27: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Everyday Examples of Internal Control

27

Page 28: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

COSO Framework

28

monitoring

control activities

risk assessment

control environment

information & communication

Page 29: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Control Environment

Tone at the Top

29

Page 30: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Risk Assessment

• Identification and analysis of risks to the achievement of business objectives

• Forms a basis for determining how risks should be managed

30

Page 31: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Control Activities

• Policies and procedures that help ensure that the risk responses, as well as other entity directives, are carried out

• Occur throughout the organization, at all levels and in all functions

• Include application and general information technology controls

31

Page 32: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Types of Control Activities

• Directive• Preventive• Detective• Corrective• Recovery • Automated

32

Page 33: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Monitoring

Are controls operating as intended?

33

Page 34: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Key Internal Controls

• Segregation of Duties• Authorization and approval• Reconciliation and Review• Physical Security

34

Page 35: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Designing Internal Controls IN A PAPERLESS ENVIRONMENT

• Establish prevention procedures

• Enforce segregation of duties• Automate• Perform regular internal audits

35

Page 36: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Contact Us

Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPASenior [email protected]

Tina Bode, CISA, [email protected]

36

Page 37: BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED ......BUSINESS PROCESS IMPROVEMENT: INTEGRATED THINKING PRESENTED BY Lisa Trundy-Whitten, CPA, FHFMA Tina Bode, CISA, COBIT 2 Objectives •

Questions?

37Reviewed: 09/13/17