boson stars in axisymmetry -...

17
Boson Stars in Axisymmetry Kevin Lai Department of Physics and Astronomy University of British Columbia Vancouver BC [email protected] APS April Meeting 2004 Denver, Colorado March 3, 2004 C OLLABORATOR : M. Choptuik, D. Choi

Upload: others

Post on 20-Jan-2021

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

Boson Stars in Axisymmetry

Kevin Lai

Department of Physics and AstronomyUniversity of British Columbia

Vancouver [email protected]

APS April Meeting 2004Denver, Colorado

March 3, 2004

COLLABORATOR: M. Choptuik, D. Choi

Page 2: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 1

Outline

• A Brief Introduction to Boson Stars

• The (2+1)+1 Formalism

• The GRAXI code

• Code Test

• Binary Collisions of Boson Stars

• Perturbation of Boson Stars by Real Scalar Field

• Summary

Page 3: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 2

A Brief Introduction to Boson Stars

• Wheeler 1955:

? (EM) Geons: gravitating systems which are held together by gravitationalforces and are composed of fundamental, classical fields

Page 4: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 2

A Brief Introduction to Boson Stars

• Wheeler 1955:

? (EM) Geons: gravitating systems which are held together by gravitationalforces and are composed of fundamental, classical fields

• Kaup 1968 & Ruffini 1969:

? Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalarparticles which satisfy the Klein-Gordon equation

? Classical, massive complex scalar field

? Balance between attractive force of gravity and dispersive nature of wave

? Field solutions have different number of nodes, where the ground statehas no nodes

Page 5: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 3

A Brief Introduction to Boson Stars

• Boson stars = Stationary solutions to Einstein Klein-Gordon system

• The action: ∫d4x√−g

[R

16π− 1

2(∇µφ∇µφ∗ + m2φ∗φ

)]• EOM:

Gµν = 8πTµν

∇µ∇µφ−m2φ = 0

where

Tµν =12

(∇µφ∗∇νφ +∇µφ∇νφ∗)−12

gµν(∇αφ∗∇αφ + m2φ∗φ

)

Page 6: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 4

A Brief Introduction to Boson Stars

• Boson Stars Ansatz:

? 1D case

φ = φ0(r)e−iωt

? 2D case

φ = φ0(ρ, z)e−i(ωt−kϕ)

Page 7: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 5

A Brief Introduction to Boson Stars

• A typical solution in spherical symmetry:

Page 8: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 6

The (2+1)+1 Formalism

Z

• Project and describe the object as (2+1)+1

• Use the Killing vector ξ to define a project operator Hαβ ≡ δαβ −

ξαξβξγξγ

.

Page 9: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 7

The GRAXI Code

• GRAXI (GR AXIsymmetric): developed by M. Choptuik, E. Hirschmann, S.Liebling, F. Pretorius

• Designed to solve the Einstein field equations for axisymmetric spacetimes

• Goal: study gravitational collapse, critical phenomena, head-on black holecollisions, head-on stars collisions

• 2+1+1 formalism

• Adaptive mesh refinement (AMR), multigrid, black hole excision

Page 10: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 8

Code Tests

• Initial data: Interpolate spherically symmetric boson stars from 1D to 2D

Evolving (theoretically) static spacetime,

animation shows the modulus of the scalar field

|φ| for φ(0) = 0.02

Evolving (theoretically) static spacetime,

animation shows the conformal factor ψ for

φ(0) = 0.02

Page 11: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 9

Code Tests

• Assume a harmonic time dependence of field perturbation ∼ eiσt:

Simulation: σ2 ≈ 0.00032 Perturbation Theory: σ2 ≈ 0.00035

maximum value of |φ| as a function of time. The

period of oscillation T ≈ 380

ADM mass as a function of time

Page 12: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 10

Convergence Tests

maximum value of |φ| as a function of time

for 4 different resolutions. The value

converge to a constant

Convergence factor uhl+2−uhl+1

uhl+1−uhl

versus time. The average is close to 4 and

shows a second order convergence

ADM mass as a function of time for the 4

different resolutions. The value converge to

a constant

Page 13: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 11

Binary Collisions of Boson Stars

• Initial data: Two identical boson stars boosted towards each other (nearcritical solution)

Supercritical evolution of two identical

boson stars with φ(0) = 0.02: the stars

merge on the first encounter

Subcritical evolution of two identical boson

stars with φ(0) = 0.02: the stars do not

merge on the first encounter, but merge on

the second

Page 14: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 12

Critical Phenomena: Binary Collisions

Time of black hole formation tBH v.s.log(p∗z − pz)

Page 15: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 13

Perturbation by Real Scalar Field: In Progress

Real massless perturbingscalar field φ

Complex massive scalarfield Φ (boson star)

max(Φ, φ)

Page 16: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 14

Perturbation by Real Scalar Field: In Progress

Real massless perturbingscalar field φ

Complex massive scalarfield Φ (boson star)

max(Φ, φ)

Page 17: Boson Stars in Axisymmetry - laplace.physics.ubc.calaplace.physics.ubc.ca/People/cwlai/talks/aps04/aps04.pdf · Klein-Gordon geon: self-gravitating compact objects consists of scalar

BOSON STARS IN AXISYMMETRY 15

Summary

• Boosted boson stars show solitonic behavior in relativistic regime

• Critical phenomena (scaling law) is observed in:

? axisymmetric binary boson stars collisions? perturbation by non-spherical real scalar field

• Momentum transfer?