boeing aerospace co i/j,, unclassified ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing...

101
D-A131 273 RFWL BENCHMARK COMPUTER PROGRRM(U) BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, SEATTLE WA B J HENDERSON 01 MAY 82 DNR-5852F DNAOi-80-C-0056 UNCLASSIFIED F/G 912 N EhmmohEohEohiE EEEEomhEEEohhEE

Upload: others

Post on 15-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

D-A131 273 RFWL BENCHMARK COMPUTER PROGRRM(U) BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,,SEATTLE WA B J HENDERSON 01 MAY 82 DNR-5852FDNAOi-80-C-0056

UNCLASSIFIED F/G 912 N

EhmmohEohEohiEEEEEomhEEEohhEE

Page 2: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

11111 ~c~''~I1 1 2

.. :

11.6

11111 1.5M1-A B U O T R

IIIoIL

MICROCOPY RESOLUTION TEST CHART -Q

b NATIONAL BUREAU OF STANDARDS-1963-A

'-,

9.9.

°°.C

! nmmmmmm mmmmmn m mmUm W'm '-V-, i'.... n': ;" ," • :.--;,:... ... -- I

Page 3: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

DNA 5852F

AFWL BENCHMARK COMPUTERPROGRAM

-4

B. J. HendersonBoeing Aerospace Company

P.O. Box 3999

Seattle, Washington 98124

I May 1982

Final Report for Period 3 March 1980-1 May 1982

CONTRACT No. DNA 001-80-C-0056

APPROVED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE;DISTRIBUTION UNLIMITED.

THIS WORK WAS SPONSORED BY THE DEFENSE NUCLEAR AGENCYUNDER RDT&E RMSS CODE B310080464 P99DAXDB08853 H2590D.

DTICa ELECTE

Prepared forAU1.1,o8

ex. Washington,DC 20305 6€..)

Publication of this material does not imply DefenseLUI Nuclear Agency (DNA) indorsement of factual accuracy

_jI or opinions, nor does DNA accept any responsibilityLfor maintenance or support of this software.

83 07 28 036s*, '... ' .*..= '. " . " " . % .. '. .* *.'." "*-

.*

- ." .•.. . ...- " *.. ."...' . •". ° " "'

* , *j**u* 4. " " " * ' -' ,L ", "."--.. - ,' _,'","-"" L ' " ;

Page 4: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

Destroy this report when it is no longer

needed. Do not return to sender. :PLEASE NOTIFY THE DEFENSE NUCLEAR AGENCY,ATTN: STTI, WASHINGTON, D.C. 20305, IF

YOUR ADDRESS IS INCORRECT, IF YOU WISH TOBE DELETED FROM THE DISTRIBUTION LIST, ORIF THE ADDRESSEE IS NO LONGER EMPLUYED BYYOUR ORGANIZATION.

-..

Page 5: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

UNCLASSIFIEDSECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE (When DatsEntered),

REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE READ INSTRUCTIONSDA BEFORE COMPLETING FORM

1 REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT/S* . 3. RECIPIENT'S CATALOG NUMBERDNA 5852F/ G 0 0-

4. TITLE (mid Subtitle) S. TYPE OF REPORT & PERIOD COVERED

Final Report for PeriodAFWL BENCHMARK COMPUTER PROGRAM 3 March 1980 - 1 May 1982

6. PERFORMING O'tG. REPORT NUMBER

7. AUTHOR(a) 0. CONTRACT OR GRANT NUMBER(s)

B. J. Henderson DNA 001-80-C-0056

9. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME AND ADDRESS 10. PROGRAM ELEMENT. PROJECT, TASK

Boeing Aerospace Company AREA & WORK UNIT NUMBERSP.O. Box 3999 Subtask P99DAXDBD88-53

Seattle, Washington 98124II. CONTROLLING OFFICE NAME AND ADDRESS 12. REPORT DATE

Director 1 May 1982Defense Nuclear Agency 13. NUMBER OF PAGES

Washington, D. C. 20305 9614. MONITORING AGENCY NAME & ADDRESS(if different from Controlling Office) IS. SECURITY CLASS. (of this report)

UNCLASSIFIED

1Sa. DECLASSIFICATION 'DOWNGRADINGSCHEDULE

N/A since UNCLASSIFIED16. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (of this Report)

Approved for public release; distribution unlimited

17. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (of the abstract entered in Block 20, if different from Report)

IS. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

This work was sponsored by the Defense Nuclear Agency under RDT&E RMSS CodeB310080464 P99DAXDB08853 H2590D.

19. KEY WORDS (Continue on reverse side it neceesary and identify by block number)

Computer BenchmarkANSI FortranTranslator

ASSTRACT (Continue on reverse side It necessary and identify by block number)

his report includes the description of a computer program that partially

translates IBM, CDC, DEC and VAX FORTRAN into the subset lngu e of ANSIFORTRAN 77. This contract supports a DNA task to provide air benchmarkcomputer programs to vendors who bid on a DNA computer procurement project.

DI IFANm 1473 EDITION OF I NOV 65 IS OBSOLETE73,jA UNCLASSIFIED

SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE (When Date Entered)

II.

............... ....... .... .................................................

Page 6: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

PREFACE

This is the final report of an effort conducted under Defense NuclearAgency Contract DNA-80-C-0056. The contract supported a DNA task of procuring

an advanced scientific computer system by collecting representative sofware for

evaluating the performance of candidate computer systems (benchmarking, Ref. 3).

One sample benchmark program, a large hydrodynamics code named CSQ, has beenprocessed into ANSI Standard Fortran using SCOFF, a translating computer program

developed on this contract. The resulting version of CSQ has been tested and is

now available in the DNA Cyber 176 computer located at Kirtland AFB, New Mexico.

This study was sponsored by the Office of Technical Information with

LCDR Harold R. Gladwin serving as technical* monitor. Major John M. Anderson

reviewed the final report. Their comments and support are gratefully

acknowledged. Special appreciation is exteded to Michael Warshaw of RDA whose

patience, cooperation, and advice provided great support for this report. The

technical work of BAC staff members Loren Milliman and Dave Cruikshank made the

successful completion of this contract possible.

Accession ror

ITIS C-F IDTIC TAB

JusAl1. . .

Dir'4 .. ... . . .

Dizit ;' . i-4,

"-,

Dlst .p 4

Page 7: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Section Page

PREFACE ........................................... 1I

LIST OF TABLES..................................... 3

1 INTRODUCTION....................................... 5

2 THE SCOFF COMPUTERIZED CONVERSION METHOD ............. 6

2-1 RESTRUCTURING (R).............................. 6

2-2 TRANSLATION (T) ............................... 13

2-3 EXAMPLES...................................... 14

3 DEMONSTRATED USES OF SCOFF......................... 15

4 SUMMARY ........................................... 16

5 REFERENCES ........................................ 17

APPENDIX A- SAMPLE COMPUTER RUN OF SCOFF.................... 19

APPENDIX B- LISTING OF SCOFF................................ 23

2

Page 8: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

LIST OF TABLES .Table Page

1 Statement handling by SCOFF ......................... 7

2 Actions taken by SCOFF.............................. 10

3 Conventions of ANSI X3.9-1978, Fortran 77 ............. 11

4 Job control language required to execute SCOFF .... 12

3

Page 9: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-9

p

N

4

~N W% %~%*h(9m9 %' %* %~ '.'%~<-.~ .-. - - - - . - . .

Page 10: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

SECTION I

INTRODUCTION

Although the Fortran language was designed to be a universal and

machine-independent medium for development of computer programs, computer system

manufacturers have corrupted this by not fully implementing the ANSI Standard

Language (Refs. 1,2) and by providing various enhancements to ANSI Fortran.

Although a particular vendor's Fortran language may in itself be excellent, the

irregularity makes it difficult to assemble a collection of Fortran programs

which is free from non-standard coding. A computer program, SCOFF (Semi-

automated Conversion of Fortran Four) was developed to translate programs

written in the various dialects of the Fortran language to a standard, ANSI-

compatible language. SCOFF converts most of the non-standard features of major

vendor's Fortan to a standard Fortran language. For example, Control Data

Corporation (CDC) Fortran allows variable names to be up to seven characters in

length, while Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC) Fortran allows names up to 15

characters long which may contain dollar marks ($) and underscores(_). The ANSI

Standard specified that variable names be a maximum of six characters in length

and that all characters be from the set (A-Z, 0-9). SCOFF replaces each

instance of an improper variable name with a truncated, proper variable name.

The SCOFF output meets the requirements of ANSI X3.9-1978 Fortran 77

Subset with two additions: that of COMPLEX statements and BLOCK Data

structures. These additions were made because the preponderance of computer

programs used in DNA activities require one or both of these features and

because there is no convenient alternative.

SCOFF presently runs on IBM 360/370 series computers and requires

approximately 200K bytes memory. SCOFF uses an efficient input/output method,

so that the program execution time is comparable to the IBM-supplied copy

utility IEBGENER. Several input formats (corresponding to source language

maintenance program conventions) are accepted by SCOFF. Output may be in ASCII,

EBCDIC, or BCD character codes. The Job Control Language required to execute

the SCOFF program is shown in Table 4. A listing of SCOFF appears in Appendix

B.In Section 2 of this report, we describe the development of SCOFF.

Section 3 briefly describes a demonstrated use of SCOFF.

5

Page 11: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

SECTION 2

THE SCOFF COMPUTERIZED CONVERSION METHOD

SCOFF reads statements (lines or cards) one at a time from a Fortran

program which is to be standardized. It then examines the symbols of the

statements one at a time, comparing the symbols with a typical set such as a

blank, S, *, C, or a numeral. This identification of the symbols determines the

type of statement. The program then compares strings with standard statements,

and takes appropriate action in translation.

A description of all the statements (ANSI and non-ANSI) that are

recognized by SCOFF appears in Table 1, along with an indication of how SCOFF

deals with the statement type. There are five actions that SCOFF may take, as

specified in Table 2. Any statement type which does not appear in Table I will

be ignored (passed through, not translated) by SCOFF. SCOFF cannot translate

those statements which violate the ANSI Standards denoted by F in Table 1.

There are several constructs for which there is no equivalent in the ANSI

subset. The file manipulation statements OPEN and CLOSE are found in virtually

all vendor Fortrans, but the format of parameters for OPEN or CLOSE varies

considerably. Since neither OPEN nor CLOSE is defined in the ANSI Fortran

Subset Language, SCOFF does not attempt to translate these statements. Also,

SCOFF cannot resolve ambiguities which require syntactical analysis. The

notation used in Table 1 is that of ANSI X3.9-1978, Fortran 77; a reprint of the

conventions appears in Table 3.

Of the actions listed in Table 2, the first two are described below.

The last three are self-explanatory.

2-1 RESTRUCTURING (R)

SCOFF does a global reorganization of program statements. Many vendor

Fortrans allow Type Declaration statements and DATA statements to appear

anywhere in a program element (or anywhere prior to the first occurrence of one

of the defined variable names in an expression). SCOFF collects Type

Declaration statements and DATA statements and places them ahead of the

executible statements as required by the ANSI Fortran Subset. Also, some

Fortrans allow data values to be specified in the Declaration statements. Any

6

Page 12: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

Table 1. Statement handling by SCOFF

ActionInitial Form Taken Translated Form

(see Table 2)

ASSIGN s TO i T ASSIGN s TO i

BACKSPACE u T BACKSPACE uBACKSPACE (alist) F BACKSPACE (alist)

BLOCK DATA [sub] N BLOCK DATA [sub]

CALL sub [([a [,a] ...]) T CALL sub [([a [,a]...])]

CHARACTER [*len[,]] nam [,nam] ... TI CHARACTER [*len[,]] nam [,nam] ...

CLOSE (cilist) F CLOSE (cllst)

COMMON [/[cb]/]nlist[[,]/[cb]/nlist] ... T COMMON [/[cb]/]nlist[[,]/[cb]/nlist]..

COMPLEX v [,v]... T COMPLEX [,v]..COMPLEX *len[,] v [,v]... RT COMPLEX v [,v] ...

CONTI NUE N CONTINUE

DATA nlist/clistf [[,]nlist/clist] T DATA nlist/clist/ [[,]nlist/clist]

DIMENSION a(d) [,a(d)] ... T DIMENSION a(d) [,a(d)] ...

Do s [,] i=e1,e 2 [,e 3] T DO s [,] ie1 e 2[,e 3

DOUBLE PRECISION v[v..RT REAL v [,v]

ELSE NI ELSE

ELSE IF (e) THEN TI ELSE IF (e) THEN

END N END

END IF NI END IF

ENDFILE u T ENDFILE u

ENOFILE (alist) F ENDFILE (alist)

ENTRY en [([d [,d]j...]1)] TF ENTRY en [(d [,d] ...])

EQUIVALENCE (nllst) [,(nllst].. T EQUIVALENCE (nlist) [,(nlist)] ...

EXTERNAL proc [,proc] ... T EXTERNAL proc [,proc] ...

7

Page 13: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

I TABLE 1. (Continued)

ActionInitial Form Taken Translated Form

FORMAT is T FORMAT is

fun ((d]...)) = e T fun ([d]...])= e

[typ [*len]] FUNCTION fun([d [,d]...]) RT [type] FUNCTION fun ([d [,d]...])

GO TO i [[,](s [,s]...)] N GO TO i [[,](s [,s]...)]

GO TO s N GO TO s

GO TO (s [,s]...)[,] i T GO TO (s [,s]...)[,] i

IF (e) st T IF (e) st

IF (e) s1, s2, s3 T IF (e) si, 2' s 3

IF (e) s ,' s2 F IF (e) s l, s2

IF (e) THEN TI IF (e) THEN

IMPLICIT type (a [,a]...) R Specific Type Declaration StatementsGenerated As Required

INQUIRE (iflist) F INQUIRE (iflist)INQU'-" (lulist) F INQUIRE (iulist)

INTEGER v [,v]... T INTEGER v [,v]...

INTEGER *len v [,v]... RT INTEGER v [,v]...

INTRINSIC fun [,fun]... F INTRINSIC fun [,fun]...

LOGICAL v [,v]... T LOGICAL v[,v]...LOGICAL *len v[,v]... RT LOGICAL v[,v]...

NAMELIST TF NAMELIST

OPEN (olist) I OPEN (olist)

PARAMETER (p=e[,p=e]...) F PARAMETER (p=e[,p=e]...)

PAUSE (n] N PAUSE [n]

PRINT f[, iolist] T PRINT f [, iolist]

PROGRAM pgm T PROGRAM pgm

READ (cilist) [olist] T READ (cilist) [olist]

READ f , iolist] F READ f [, iolist]

8

Page 14: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

TABLE 1. (Continued)

ActionInitial Form Taken Translated Form

REAL v [,v]... T REAL v [,v]...REAL *len v [,v] RT REAL v [,v]...

RETURN [e] N RETURN [e]

REWIND u T REWIND uREWIND (alist) F REWIND (alist)

SAVE [a [,a]...] F SAVE [a [,a]...]

STOP [n] N STOP [n]

SUBROUTINE sub [([d [,d]...])] RT SUBROUTINE sub [([d [,d]...])]

WRITE (cilist) [iolist] T WRITE (cilist) [iolist]

v e T v = e Arithmetic AssignmentStatement

v =e T v = e Logical AssignmentStatement

v = e I v = e Character AssignmentStatement

v = v [-v...] e RT v = e Multiple Arithmeticv = v Assignment Statement

[v = v]

st $ st [$st...] RT st Multiple Statements perst coding line

[st]

v(e(e[(e)...])) RT v : e(e) Subscripted Subscripts[v = e (v)]

v (v)

td v/clist/[,vlclist]... RT td v [,v]... Data in Type DeclarationDATA v/clist/[,v/clist]

9

Page 15: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

. 7---7- -- i w >;- .

Table 2. Actions taken by SC OFF

Action Description

R Restructured by SC OFF to statement acceptable in A NSIsubset

T Variable names translated (truncated with ambiquityresolution) by SC OFF if longer than six characters

F Flagged as not A NSI subset. Not translated by SC OFF unlessTF appears

N Translation not needed

I Flagged as not acceptable to pre-1981 IBM compilers

10

.4.

10

Page 16: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

Table 3. Notation of ANSI X3.9-1978 FORTRAN 77

In describing the form of FORTRAN statements or constructs, the following metalanguage

conventions and symbols are used:

(1) Special characters from the FORTRAN character set, uppercase letters, and

uppercase words are to be written as shown, except where otherwise noted.

(2) Lowercase letters and lowercase words indicate general entities for which specific

entities must be substituted in actual statements. Once a given lowercase letter or

word is used in a syntactic specification to represent an entity, all subsequent

occurrences of that letter or word represent the same entity until that letter or word

is used in a subsequent syntactic specification to represent a different entity.

(3) Brackets, [], are used to indicate optional items.

(4) An elipsis, ... , indicates that the preceding optional items may appear one or more

ti m es in succession.

* (5) Blanks are used to improve readability, but unless otherwise noted have no

significance.

(6) Words or groups of words that have special significance are underlined where their

meaning is described.

An example illustrates the metalanguage. Given a description of the form of a statement

as:

CALL sub[([a[,4a]..])]

the following forms are allowed:

CALL sub

CALL sub()

CALL sub (a)

CALL sub (a, a)

CALL sub (a, a, a)

etc

When an actual statement is written, specific entities are substituted for sub and each a; for

example:

CALL ABCD (X, 1.0)

. . .11

Page 17: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-m*470 77-.77

Table 4. Job control language required to execute SCOFF

I IEXEC PGM=SCOFF1, TIME=(O,20)//STEPLIB DO DSN=ENG.BREL.PGMLIB,DISP=SHR/ /OUTPUT O SYSOUT=A,DCB=( BLKSIZE=400,RECFM=FB)//TEMP DO INIT=SYSDA,SPACE=(800, (200,20)), DCB=BLKSIZE=800//FTO6FOO1 DD SYSOUT=A,DCB=BLKSIZE=1729//INPUT DD

*The EXEC card specifies SCOFFi to be run from library ENG.BREL. The STEPLIB

statement defines where the program is in the library named ENG.BREL. The

OUTPUT card image specifies the output file from SCOFF. The TEMP statement

defines a temporary working file used for execution and storage of SCOFF. The

FT06FOOl statement defines FORTRAN unit six as the output unit. The INPUT

statement tells the machine that the input program- begins with the next

statement.

11

Page 18: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

such data values are removed from the Type Declaration statement and a separate

DATA statement is created for the data value assignment.

Another global action taken by SCOFF is the replacement of IMPLICIT

Type Statements. Any IMPLICIT statement is removed and individual Type

Declaration statements are generated, if necessary, to explicitly type each

variable name not already explicitly typed which does not correspond to the

default type convention of ANSI Fortran (all names represent floating point

variables unless the name begins with one of the letters I through N).

2-2 TRANSLATION (T)

Variable names that are more than six characters long are translated

by truncation to make a similar, legal, unique name. Variable name truncation

is done according to the following algorithm:

1. Drop all non-standard characters in the name.

2. If a vowel exists in the name, drop the last one; else drop the

last consonant.

3. If the name is longer than six characters, do Step 2.

4. Set I to 6; set N to O.

5. If the name is unique, then end.

6. Replace the Ith character with the character which succeeds it in

the alphanumeric collating sequence.

7. Increment N. If N is less than 37, then do Step 5; else set I to I-

1; set N to 0; do Step 6.

Another example of direct replacement is the Multiple Assignment

Statement (permitted in CDC Fortran) which has the form

A = B = C = expression

A Multiple Assignment Statement is expanded into two (or more) single

assignment Fortran statements:

13

, . , . o . -. - --~ -. . . . ' . .. ' . . , . .° -. ° " '% . -.. -j ..

Page 19: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

C = expressionB C

A B

2-3 EXAMPLES

,'.'

It may be helpful to examine two statements from Table 1 in more

detail. Consider the first statement:

-ASSIGN s TO i

The Action Taken is specified as T and the translated form appears to

be identical with the initial form. The translated form will be identical

except in those cases where the variable name i contains improper characters or

is more than six characters long. SCOFF does not alter the statement segments

ASSIGN, the statement number s, or TO.

Secondly, consider the statement:

COMPLEX*len[,] v [,v] ...

This statement is both Restructured and Translated (RT). The restructuring

consists of removing the *len[,] while the translation ensures that every

variable v is a legal name of six or fewer characters.

-. 1]

44

14

' ;': ;::'":"i":::" ":":i " "" ' " '" ,- -,. ' . .

Page 20: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

SECTION 3

DEMONSTRATED USES OF SCOFF

CSQ (Ref. 4) is a large two-dimensional hydrocode that was selected as

a test vehicle for demonstrating the use of SCOFF. The selection was based upon

the need for a large code representative of those used by the DNA community. CSQ

I can test the capabilities of computers proposed for purchase by DNA since it

uses large amounts of both storage and CPU time.

CSQ is composed of approximately fifteen thousand cards. Most of the

statements are pass-through statements with perhaps ten percent needing

conversion. After application of SCOFF, a few days of hand work by a programmer

were required to finish the conversion.

CSQ was first processed at Boeing via SCOFF. It was then transported

to AFWL for trial runs on the DNA computer. The first runs were made under the

NOS/BE system. Then when the operating system changed to NOS, some CSQ runs

were made under the new operating system. The conversion was successful and

made CSQ available as a benchmark code.

Appendix A presents a sample computer run of SCOFF. The input stream

contains a number of statements that are non-ANSI. The output stream shows the

translated statements. In addition, a set of SCOFF translation messages are

presented. These messages would be used by a programmer if further translation

was deemed necessary for the benchmark test.

15

Page 21: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.. !

SECTION 4

SUMMARY

SCOFF provides a positive step towards improving the development of

fair, representative benchmarks for the evaluation of competing computer systems

for DNA. The advantages of computer translation are apparent: the operation

frees the programming staff from tedious work; it is fast, without error, and,

within the limits.described previously, complete. The changes which require aprogrammer's services are often challenging but usually such that they can be

solved quickly.

Many programs already exist that are too large to translate by hand

with any great confidence in the accuracy of the output. CSQ is an example of

such a program. As larger computers and larger computer programs proliferate,the SCOFF technique will help reduce the cost of benchmarking and upgrading at a

computer facility.

16

N- o

Page 22: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

SECTION 5

REFERENCES

1. American National Standards Institute, "ANSI X3.9-1978 Fortran 77," NewYork (1978).

2. Lyon, G., Ed., "Using ANS FORTRAN," NBS Handbook 131, U.S. Department ofCommerce/National Bureau of Standards, U.S. Gov. Printing Office,Washington (1980).

3. Conti. D. M., "Findings of the Standard Benchmark Library Study Group,"Institute for Computer Science and Technology, U.S. Department ofCommerce/National Bureau of Standards, U.S. Gov. Printing Office,Washington (1979).

4. Thompson, S. L., "CSQ--A Two-Dimensional Hydrodynamic Program With EnergyFlow and Material Strength," Sandia Laboratories (SAND74-0122) Albuquerque,New Mexico (1975).

17,

Page 23: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

--. !

<11

-q°

.!

+ I

q,

.9 -, ¢ , " " + " " . " , " - ' " " - " - " ' " " '" " ' ' ' - " - w " " - " • ' - . . " '

- .. .. ..II Id ll .. u, , ,a . ~ ,,,l l, l ., +.. ,,. ++ . L . + -- . ... . ..

Page 24: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

APPENDIX A

SAMPLE COMPUTER RUN OF SCOFF

This appendix presents a sample computer run of SCOFF that

demonstrates typical inputs, outputs, and translation messages. The input

program was written for illustrative purposes and does not solve any particular

physics problem.

19

S - *. . ... ,

Page 25: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.71

INPUT TO SCOFF

PROGRAM TESTSCOFFPARAMETER (IDIMz100)IMPLICIT INTESER04 IR-S)DIMENSION ARRAYONEIIDIMJ,ARRAYTWOEIDIMJREAL04 ARRAYTHREEEIDIMI/IDIM*O./INTEGER VARIABLEI .VARIABLE2/2/..VARIABLE3CHARACTERMI ANS *YESEQUIVALENCE (ARRAYONE ARRAYTHREE IDATA YES'Y'/PRINT 5

5 FORMAT(* THIS PROGRAM DOESNT DO ANYTHING!*)DO 500 VARIABLEiUl101DMVARIA3LEWU-1 IMIARIABLE1ARRAYTWO IVAR IABLEliz ARRAYTNREE VAN EABLEIJ .VAR lAB LE2*wVAR IABLE3

A *YARIABLElIFIARRAYTWO(VARIABLEl) IOO,100,500

100 ARRAYTWOIVARIASLE11:VARIABLEI*VARIABLE2500 CONTINUE

PRINT 06 FORMATI* DO YOU WANT A PRINT74Y OR N), W

READ *,ANSIFIANS.EQ.YES)PRINT 7.IARRAYTWOIRJ,R:1,IDIMI

7 FORMAT(* ALL NUMBERS SHOULD BE POSITIVE COUNTING BY 2-- ,*-(/lXlP$El0.31JDO 000 VARIABLE2zI.IDIMARRAYONE IVAN IABLE2I:DIVIDE ITUP EARRAY TWO IVAN IADLE2) I

600 CONTINUEPRINT SREAD *MANSIFIANS.EO.YES)PRINT *,IARRAYTHREEISJ,51l,IDIMJ

$ FORMATI* ALL NUMBER SHOULD BE POSITIVE SEQUENTIAL--),*I/1X1IPSEIO.SiiCALL FLIPAROUND(ARRAYONE, IDIM,ARRAYTHREEIPRINT 6READ M,ANSIFIANS.EQ.YESIPRINT IPARRATONE

9 FORMAT(* ALL NUMBERS SHOULD BE SEQUENTIAL ALTERNATING SIGN--)-*,-I/1XIPlElO.3J IPRINT 10

10 FORMAT(* ALLLLLLDONt!MISTOPENDREAL04 FUNCTION DIVIDEITUPIRATIDIVIDE ITUP ZRAY/2RETURNENDSUBROUTINE FLIPAROUNDI 1111111,111111,11111121REAL 1111I111) 1111111DO 5000 Js'1,IIIIII

1111111 IJiI 1111112IJ)M1W5000 CONTINUE

RETURNEND

20

Page 26: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

OUTPUT FROM SCOFF

Co PROGRAM TESTSCOFF*1 ~PARAMETER IID)IMm100J 0001INTEGER ft , S 000i

Co IMPLICIT INTEGER*4 (ft-SiDIMENSION ARRAYNfIDIM1,ARRATW(IDIMIREAL ARRTHRIIDIMIINTEGER VARBI,VARBL2,VARBL3'fARACTERU1 ANS,YESEQUIVALENCE (ARRAYN.ARRTHR3DATA ARRTHR I IDIM*O. IDATA VARBL2 1 2 1DATA YES/IN1YIPRINT S

5 FORMAT(33H THIS PROGRAM DOESNT DO ANYTHING1)DO 500 VARILIllIDIMVARILS. I-iIMMYARILIARRATWIVARILI 3 ARRTHR IVARBL1I .VARBL2*VARBL3a UVARBLIIFIARRATWIVARBLI 3)100,1005300

100 ARRATWIVARILI J:VARSLhMVARBL2500 CONTINUE

PRINT 66 FORMAT(30H DO YOU WANT A PRINT71Y 0% %)- S)

READ M.ANSIF(ANS.EO.TES)PRINT 7, ARRATWIRIA,R:1 DM)

7 FORMAT(48H ALL NUMBERS SHOULD BE POSITIVE COUNTING BY 2--3,,(/1X,IP-4E10.S3DO 600 VARBL2u1,IDIMARRAYN(VARIL2)zDIVDTPIARRATW(VARBL23J

600 CONTINUEPRINT IREAD *.AN$IFIANS.EQ.YESJPRINT I,(ARATHRISJ,S:1,IDIM)

I FORMAT(44H ALL NUMBER SHOULD BE POSITIVE SEQUENTIAL--)l,I/1K,1PlEl0-.3)3CALL FLPRND(ARRAYN, IDIM,ARRTHR)PRINT &READ *,AN$IFIANS.EO.YES)PRINT 9,ARRAYN

9 FORMATISSH ALL NUMBERS SHOULD BE SEQUENTIAL ALTERNATING SIGN--)-,I-lX,lPlEl0.331PRINT 10

10 PORMAT(ISH ALLLLLLOONE'IlSTOPENDREAL04 FUNCTION DIVDTP(RAYlDIVDTPSRAY/2RETURNENDSUBROUTINE FLPRNDI 111111,111111,111112)REAL 11111111111113,111112(1111111DO 1000 J31,11II1I

111111 Jill II t12(JIWK5000 CONTINUE

RETURNEND

21

Page 27: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

..... .. . .. .... .... . -SCOFF -TRANSLATION -ME.SSAGES

PROGRAM TESTSCOFFPROGRAM TESTSCOFF --%; SYNTAX **-

.P PARAMETER IIDINzlooRPARAMETER STATEMENT NOT ALLOWED IN ALL FORTRAN LANGUAGES

.. REAL*4 ARRAYTNREEIIDIM)/IDIM*O./ --I DATA ARRAYTHREE / IDIM*O. /--

I -*-INTEGER VARIABLEI,VARIASLE2/2/1VARIASLE3IDATA VARIABLE2 / 2 /I --- CHARACTER~i ANSTYESCHARACTER STATEMENT NOT ALLOWED IN ALL FORTRAN LANGUAGES

6 FORMATI* DO YOU WANT A PRINTJY OR N)- NS)CHARACTER (S) IS NOT A VALID FORMAT TYPE.AINTEGER RI S 00000010END OF TRANSLATION

22

Page 28: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

K. f APPENDIX B

LISTING OF SCOFF

U.

UAI0

21!

4. -J

"d! 0;Us

0C 0

la 0 led

=m *6- - uC0c. a.: t aQ I,W. " " - a =-0

Is -zc z * a.0- 0 20 -p

I.--

-u - tn --

* -a- - -4-0rn

~4 0--00.-49uep~~ ~me 0 ~-.1c-

93 .9c - 11 ps o sc*-U.-in mo - -u m I- -

~~~- e4 -.- Ca -

w fi* -- oa muu -4 f -Jp 1*UI --. J-~ 4098 91 -so0i IK - U. M -I -16-

0Z 4414) 2144 t I e1- oz a ismuau -0.-~C %- t.- - U Uaa- Iso. U II so go Is "a

.4 16- W--~m %S% PC- I. -muJ -ai i - em.,-a ua (A u0 qn to III a-mc ~UH wI'2u. - 1i-o1 -mu r Z0Caa E.000000000S ~~a0 azSz MZ 0 Qb-

in~rn n~~-Z U) 0 -Ia. - - I I.- i-~-I

a -u --- = ~ rn 410, 0

mu--Z %% '% %. .% I W-U S 00, .-. J ) a .~u -23-S

Page 29: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.44.

**MR

-ow.

IL ;Wt44

W4 -f 4 a ft -0-C U" mc 4wt.;O *us0 0.

06 4

co -. A

us z0- WC

um a-

-C-I-4 US M -AH 4 , m-a so e u . 4

yg5 -a 0 0 . oasciwsc _ - b c 0 c0 1 -o-q. - U.C -l= =-

4o C4 a s 4 D - s b s U

00 a-C Cl01- C-z -a -9a 390 c S o 000 M c w0 0 e0 L

- -ea aza1

Q4.W'4 a4

Page 30: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-4' P41M4" e i- -- ------ --------- -- -------------- ----------

LL.

IL

100

usu

11Cu

L.I.- _

11 cc m3mu

116 2 0 muM 0 co I--L =1

=ow*v~ a. U

0 l if9P -b 0i. mu-s d.14c- BIi PC i;o O06-j - 0

. L:.so IL I -- .1c -do ~ ~~ C4 0O Q IsI #S U itm - X N f 4

0 _. mu me so go ~ m Ise-9 a ma mus

U. so -1 . d- - PC t- . _3 3 1 -1 _ . _ j-) 1 . jm s -

m.o -1 alU. LL .d 1 .. J- .0 L.q-c0 0 O 6 I.-

m-~'o 0- Of 00 m. mu. .*~~~-0.9~ 941f al I, mum 9 in -u) -u Jz

muC~ a mm m-3-o4 omo .i o e 02u5

Page 31: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

U. tv

* 4U

@@ 00 @@ 0000000000000000000000 0 00 00 00 00i~~0Ceai. wii-ilai-ii0.CI~~iIC~ . ~)i.C~ -4~~a -ii

-Us

100

0

z _j--MiS us

C w P us 00 =

-M # -0- w di I-04COOWASU:e~s-o 0SCUC M 00

.0 4wai12

W 0 A110m0 8u

5-- I mwwCd - 19 1 j- -

0-4 of -Ci45-co

:: a Cii- a -O 00

-4 CWIN

-0QIm, "IDu a

B.- 26

Page 32: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

=9L

I.-.

K a

3d

P:-* a *

-. 4 *~ -s- ISMS t

404M ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ CAI b.-.sa S 1.- -

wo~~~ ~ ~ ~ -3oI. D- 4-x 4

3w ~~~1 -0 1 8ILa)00 U. is -Jim 1.

0000 0u. U0 0

* - *00 3U27

1-0 0All---0 C 13 0

Page 33: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.4.D

LUU

0-0

.1 W6

uu4I-z -goI

40 Mc -9" .U

4% CPC q s bea .c

ILI

dc 0) W w

40 1. M -M~ 4 _V - M'44 - ..4..%IL" ;-.4. oU -.# V - - M m " gZ -e

I- 0- I- m69a- I _i t j"1 4 -a a _ 30 _ _ 0 -A -J3-J -

00 w 04o 0.9 00 0 00OW0 w 0 -co leww u. 0M HT MT __! M! _ -!! -T 9-- C -

ul0 0

:4 v- -a-r 4%~~j WO on ft 4 t 4 4 n I

= 4% 6 a U28

Page 34: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

*1 0 @00000@0 00000000000000@00000000000000000V0

0000 000 0000 00o 0000 000 0000 000 0000 000 0000 0M0

404

4CIL -j .

a. 0L

mmu

to 40Go IL L do m

a Ow 00- a-WL

=:Mvs 1- 9) s

w m- uC a , U - - -ad- L l- c Il

N j 0 J 11- 3- 3-A

d -C 0. 0L a 00c 0 004

ow ow 49- 0000wo

* 0 0 - 0 a...l -29

Page 35: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.44

IL 2

Udia-

0 coo

.1c.

I- 0 n Ch- a-

L a a.cIa. LM .

. I& . g U-A- u to _ M CoP- a- .

91-* -D tlz - I.ladACZ I

00 0 1- W. U1 us- !a-I0 U J 9- .

0 000 - 3" 4 ..- - '

ml---0 - 0 -

(*u - 1- P 0 cj~a -j - F- P- 0( - P -a

* U S W * a * -. *-30

* - Er~mng ~ ~ o~ ~ a. a od

Page 36: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

@@@o00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000@O0000000000O00000000000000000000000000000000000000000

,l~rq qqrr rqql I~ammt m emeeeem .1I.I m-inmminemininmm mmm mm

464

.61.

a -0 .

IL"

40 fi

w GO

C; ale.A cam

Go o M -

z a- =J

lid cl LIAOl I [ -

• • 4 z•-&me m

'0 B s *)*. I- . u 6-

,heO I 0 4 Ma --I 1 m ll - -iLi--I I

M~ 404 - t

Ia I a u,

M I. I.

SIL

:00 u s m a s 1 0 cn lmU 96- - 61- M N$- I LI - I 6I- M L- OI I - I 3I - P

0 = 0: au I-u

"-tif 00: 0 02 0 031"-- , Y- .

Page 37: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.141

000000 @000 @00000000000

4c;w dc c

a IC ; ubg um .- z -,C*1 0

wbc IC40 a U, U14-C CS

(jag 1-1 1 a Ito-am; un - 00.

W I

00 U3 a 0 oo 0 a -

bt 0 0

all 80

m- 0 4 4D 40 4

* 0- . -32

Page 38: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

MC ftm2%go"V1NC 0 --- ---- --jbe a "

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------no -- - - -. . . .. .0

-in- Ol

-0 0

ic04D

ma,-Ode "-a- --

-- U 7=a.m -- =K

a -- mL-m --U.- aa"m a

@-o - ao w

IV Noe -bog-m I.- ma14 04 04 Coe--. -- -4c4c- Uc wA w A w -4 -C A -9 4- 4- 4cM 0 -- - -a--- c -C-

a- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~4 cb amal .- a-a -a- =-------

U) -4 ~ 8-. * - N W4-l 33

Page 39: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

4'

- -- - -------- 4

=UU-

4 0

0--c-

-4 -. - - -

==0 OR 0===0 R, Z 1==== 0= R = =======X-CMM...... ... .. .. .. .. . .... .... . . . . . . . . . . . 8 "

. ~~ - - - - - --- -- --- - - - - - - --- -- ------ ---- - -- - ..

.- -. -.. .-.. m - - - - - - -- . - u - - -

. .0 .h . . . a . . . . .. ..-.

.. 4. C .............- ................... v

---------------------------------------------------------------------------- NNN

4 - 4W- 1-2azz 55840 4 Z4 a2225 2 OP- 2 SM -:=

34

r .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. ..-d 0 U -

Page 40: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.. 4

* ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ V -e0 m 8 #m-n .'0 8-* 0 4% -4n-0 Go-rr

U~'U

lip:

:3 ..

the .1.

-.

k--

1 = -WuU

on

.=.

* i - -I11c 135

s~is

ON ci-N I -.

M -= 4,-=,- I Oc 40 _""a- OD _ ao ., a RIC ag

OII -O WU ;w 4 i0i I iclO

PC - CJ- 0 1 -11p so -P Is" - o I-l

1 0. .4 ... Mm.:" .- ,so"2 0i" of ".. •. WO w., .

- ".-. .. .. ++., , , , ,.. . ,-.-----------,-. .r.-

Page 41: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

'. ' Lt% .~C~.%. -rn ;~ct . - - ---

NL

9LI

a CPO

dIC

CPC

a 3

000

ac0.090

toWP-IO

a3

e4

Page 42: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-IL

W.a.

IL 89

ima-no

-A-mc I Cdal N.

die0

.37

Page 43: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

4D4D04D 04 04 0 404 -D o 0- 01 CIO C) a) C21 40 C) C) a) a) C, 4 C3,0 C , a) C) C) C-) C) 4 4440 0 C C) a) C)0 C) C

IL

CA 0 o

o0

4cL. 1

CI-

Mm-C) 0

40-. = mu

- E z ME

0m :Ma 0 0 --- - .1cc-A)

Us&& C) Z 0 0 0 0 0 a

ftN I- -I-- I--

SO -wwwwooo-wO - OC WO

C) -. 0. o

0 49 a-o of C e4-b 4D OD P .ID4 D ,0C

- - S O0

C) S C8

Page 44: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

CCOO

0 ~-a a0- t001. a 0-t

aga

dc 0

0 U.

0 a-0 m* mu 9e- =

LL. mu0 -9 1

so =

04as- o0:4

-wdb -9 D- m 006 _ - -- 0 = a

PC 4 - - 4c onI-. ZZ04m" I..z mu a. a

9=001:9 m wwuOp..U

rowl -,- 0 9 a~ I- a

0-4 a in- mum aw4 mom owu J

94c1 &04l 49 0-. *

.4P PCI-4 ZO 0 .~ .- . . . .n . 0

- - 0- ---- - -

~ zWOW0 - 04

-m 01-0z4 4.ini-.-oo a 0 a:n,

0-440 Zin003m

Page 45: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

0 ao 000 @ 0 000 C0 0000 00 0 00@00 a0 @ 0@0a0 00a00 0 0000Q.0 00C

0000 000 0000 000@00000000000000080000 @0000000

- #4000.-CO t-tC 001..CO~-ti0000. mO - 4000 t mOO- #000?- 0 0. 40 .

---- --- - #4#4 4 # #4 4 # #4 4 # 000 0000 000 0000 000 000

Goa

I-L

00 .1

ILL

ILM 040 IMCOQD ,6 - inIL U = - C3

000 00 0 0000000COC COI.

aile 00 C

-t 11104 -q0 00400ZD#44a -40 - Z - mw-a = -S-.1

Iwo momoms-omw a000000

A- 4c00000o0 4 M

aa C4=lU..Q a00 U -IL.4cc I-. .z~

-. 4.4c

-UI.

- -0#4O-?(40

Page 46: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

oooo:!!oooaoooooooeoocaoooaooo

me

us

.4c4

mapa

"10 MC00 :11 1

va w w 0a*os a'

In 0 0C 4 -s0.- um U C I

WI40- 44 0 . o* _

I- mm 3p W-L--WS 3

o 44w U Ac-m mc -- -4W 441 0 Oww 39 kc dc

94 1

- =1- I-~41

Page 47: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

4 -aJ

InIo~~o:o @@ oooo @ooooo o@ 0000 g@@00@ @0@@ 0

000 00 00 00 00flII.IIflCcSS0fSIIfSSS~fC W ~ ISS 0.fn U

- - - -~ nn nf nn n n n n ~ 4 4

2g C4

I- 0 4c.U

- 1 0 Sbo

=g 0 A -M 44 Sc m3- 0-

-D 21M u b a -I-s iL-

1-. 49 C4usP0 V I SI9 1 N s o m v ot a- 0 0 o0a.-0- = au 31 AQa M .P

-0 sw aw n - -SI- z z c-we aclww* 0 of NOW Cj- cc

W2 22m 4c 49 %.w -00zIII.c$- ::

--. ma -,, N- 0o;c u 31 - t

0,1 .83 4- 514 C) 0w Oo . :10 do dil 0i J' 04cdC wusz I A jc

*~~~4 = 0SIUC4 go -c .1- .0 I

SM -U -SI S 42

Page 48: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

'aa

I-.

0

0

a

49 0.1.

00 OMD-c-

MA 40 0000G ftU4 U.

; C; o . -

0 0 t 0- -

o1- --. n-a OD ;I- o. -; -; -

p . . . . -I0 0 0 0 -U

0m 0 0

la 4. ._j -6 - -s

0 0400* 9LO-3,~a .o w 0 107 3.9Ia.- no N N s - - W6

000 -A$_ 0 0 0 0- - -" "C O

zo J c a to F- P-1- 1 - W aI.a P-M.-a-aI-wI-

0 00 0-0

- [email protected]

Page 49: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

4O Zo "" " " vz4:v ZZm m a m:W

- - -- - -- ----------------- ----- -- - ---------

09

MaeM

4c 0.

I-Ag I

==us

I- U;

SMM

0

go M

:40 1- . 0 OD-4 a *t u* 0 Co. -.

03

W~~~ ~ ~ ~ SMWW U 1-0 0 1 *l-& 9 I- USMUC

Mila ~ ~ ~ aaecI aA c4

0 sac 0-0a a*Pt70t 0 wor ....

m- , A .... 0-N OM 00 SM"W + 00 .0

A&. wag 00 . -- 3 S 0 OSM ama .

a 1% -M 06 0 N. -N P-- P.0-- i 1"t

w 49* -1- 1.. O Al W Se M a 0 .MSSM oUUImSmSMS 0 . gs-ecSMS *0 0 - .J-J . -0SMM0

zwo ~ ~ S--&nZW WCI--AWL "0" 4- 6M Wa'O. -a -

a No~ l0 *b 0.S --~~1 -I--I--I : Ii.,.. v -0 --- D

a ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 1....... 01-a' CA-40 0- r4 I-M-04 1 ............... .4

* 0 IS SM 0#400 LSM0.I 0 3- 05. M 5@44M

Page 50: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.2.-------------------------------------------

0 40 w

Um'

-I-.

-I

P- I a4- W-no

* 44

o t"- II

M" --- - 0 Uit 40

Ma - u -45

Page 51: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

:4

1.1

'I1

aaaaaaaaaaaa~000141410000000.: + . 000004000f4

-- sms

00

Mo '00

a~~~ ~ ~ 4D4 D4 I 4 D 4

woo SMC oI- I-o

= * U)46

Page 52: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

Ic0 @000000000000@0000 @ 0000000000

0 0.- I-

Im IL

4c4

I- us

- Go a.ll.0C M

MC-

go I=L call ' w

-A azw3. I- Izl w C .-- M

-a 0- 3- mV;, v3-v .1 w "DO

a ct 0 - C4 L M dB .

MW'C 0 0 3ico 0cc

0 0 0

gwo aci

- = 147

Page 53: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.11

.11A

N 31-

db 300

C40II vG o4

w dolArn 31 JW96 U

#04t

PC adU) C 0

aII z#4 IIodC 1

9 -1-1 - LW I- to+ *M

)4 . #4 %% W =0Qm 11 ad -9 ofU)Oag *40 we V44 0.A d 4-c

h.1'.0404U 4 0w %o 0 84O C3,0III -o- 300 3-O 0 S- z~ ~~: I-

n I& - 0

04 - U)= M 0f. 0 0m Zoo -II- e1- #4 49 0 0Ol " 101 - n D ZO - oa z o o oi

411A. 1 Iw - I - I- I

#44 z40 ) I so - 2.) bc

Ow00 3048tt 0 COb 4w eC

-U 0 -% - IN

48 2 n 2 Z

Page 54: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

99

-- A

w N I,&- CCC"21 C

49-

Page 55: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

oaoo oooo ooo ooeo ooo aooo oooo ooo oooo ooa oooao7Z

0000000000000"0 00C 00 0 00 0 00m0 0 000 a"v a P~t - " ~ f m " o 0 0000000""VW)

.00

494

0 14c

SM us0929 e33c- PC r

m"00W 00kc - L Og SM - a) go)0 Of a w -a -D- 0

m.0 we (w- W I-u= 0 - -040

92 1 -= - a M (04 -M-ofa--- 0g-w

X- 60 a -1 :Wam -ma 00c 0 0)0f = a

c"g =M .J - WO 0 - _0 L..4' 0 10 M - 02 4;W

I- IL 0O- Z -- 0

4~~~r M ) 0) aU-Sma SM -ma; _8ea L. ca- 4o

a g- a 0 . W- bc SM40 40- -* OM U. a4- 01O~0 0 i

.A V4 o 4 0-- 1.O ~ 4 to 3c S eI - 01. 0

0 -0 -A-I- a SM -z go ac In "s =' 50 I- a- W. 4n O

ama W -- aw - -IMID .a. MU4 -a - 0)0)4 a -0)0) .4- - 0 . A.

I- O W- -ome) I- -0 0 SM .- U.-

.19 SM 004ag P 29c9== 4 in 0) a- "r) .4 w) =0

4~~~3 =36 M 004 - - M-06-=4C-M d6WZWM a ~ -. 4.- U) -0 -8 LN-

=AP -- 0L 0b( -6- iLWON-.-0 110) ft -I 0) W =J 00a c

so)0' lo 4U 3.6- 0 wz z ) z 0&2 v, 0 0a 3o- -ew p- 40 3d za u a~- ) D_) cc. us -=M uU

3mm M I a M-A G- ma.034J)-0a U. 0 1 =.. w aM -of 11 OcctI- -116 - 000mZ - M= 0144CC4 WMMM ) 041 0- -C4 4L 4z 0) Z 0

-4a 0 -2110 - Mac - 000- -A 0w wL 0P

- ~ I 8-- 034 vcmam =Mo-.311-w) 0)S - - -alma0 M 49C W "(.. 0-0a -IIIS 1. 111040c ) a. -0 ) _ ~ =Cc 000)11.. 0)

6- .1 Ig _._. a So - .J.JS 4 ) ZL - -0 0011 0 MI QS ) 0

~~0 0 4 00 QO SM 0 mu 00

-050

Page 56: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

IM6

=00

ac -C4c

a 9 9.~ 0 WWI

;I --o 9LOt

a- - I.- a2~ 10-

O- a-C tC%- a- I-

0 0~c 0-6 am

6;I 0 to i 0 a 8019 W "M30WW N 0 - - 0

% MM a I- I.- * lo-M:Wo a cow Ia I- as

g -. vv "a W wanw W) -09 66m -3 c U 3 1am- c 9. a a w * 0 ma.~ w o- WM 9 IL W6 : a%9 : M._ M- MC W0I1-O sm t :"o r M 0 m Nw as* ~: a OWN I sw =a 3MO&w8 aw ;

aM z 0 no 0-Q -ww 0 ILI ma-Vu is oc-c u :4

349 .. I

0~~ 0 U__ a Z 3 -a ma

.... - - 2= ,j - -------- U.- U -L - I A I

~- 0 a. *. 0 08 A ma IL -9) AM 0~ 6 IL 0 =51

Page 57: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

'71

----------------- ----------- ------ - --- -----

- a.

.4 Z

IA.5

U!0

U'U

toa

-C

to I-.)U.

- 0 -.bc 7

ap 10aMC1- r-

as a. 0 owa IN -3

-a -0 a

us 'a C ic 00 d0 - 0 I

*M w- IUF U)- -0 4c 0 2)F z 0A Us M

al - CI -' -A vi

llww -u~ m -Q~c~ a.- va Z

.cn -c " = 0 g P-Imz 40 I. mc aI pt419 bg a

0- *0- 401 ) MCI W 2 -I-Al, .) m, III .4c F-= 901.00 - F- A -z 20 1.- of. F- - ..- WO-00 = - z-

LF-~OM 00 aI 11-U- IL00U

0~~ 0o azo C4

52

Page 58: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.c.

a a

luu

*5 a.

a 40 b

33 -to -04d

0-1 04 8 w 4

adb 019b 0 us 4.i -c cOas -a

"o 0 s 0 38 U

gq - l-- a--U

WN .66 0I - - 43 $ - -

a.~~ .. a. asa- -a09- W- W.. '4' 1 .. 6ZW- X 3 Iu IK- -Jl-

wI-Z -- - a- C, zPCmen INGi ~ .~-

o 0 40 P. -a 0 ~0 *. i W- -0 ci 0

I- - --- U53

Page 59: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

oooooo 00000000000000000000loo000000000 lo000 00000000a

U-

46

.4c

.no 0 0

-am 2 08

goWis E - z

;W :.-au.Na-M . Ifd .1 -

O- -uaa4zm o

!!P Ono-usual-c_C m oa 1-"00w 4

3.9 1116 0 PCWS .. 9 N, a4

0. - - -Q i- 0

rnt to 0 0.c3- m3-uav- 0 44

0 0

*~~P I.- - W4 -4941) 4t( WO 21 23di - I2-0U. d

III a 0t 0- a40 2#4-5fl Am 49 ';- #4JI4U- IN L =C U

-A -A I.- -h .0 z m-Sz4-.C* -NI1-fl 1113 "a w-WW3- Z:101 ac

man 0 m. -AP -. 1 .123-4U3Urn -l I.m amfi so MINW4 of Wb

W-* 4- -U 4WWI 4 orn- -:= 14 MC.p3. -4 12 . #A uSO= - #02S 4 0 , 1 + zo J" _>U 4p CO Z

1-n 4r4 -a.-1 t 31 M 3- IO V - - 30.1@,11 .C, 0 CW )Z7;* 0 bo to0 so soU lbe" N

Mal--~ 0 "90( 3-240C 1 COO 1. 1 U.0-34I 0 o 00 3- 0 -a

0 CamW IK I% = 0U -- C -S mu 9 CP beu INCa I INC 0 -9 _0

* -3-0-3-n ~ 33-W a 00 W4-- ~m w 0-too

* U~-rn -~%3-S0-W 20* ~airn ~a a 0 4 S54

Page 60: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

41C1-aI

-Amudwo PS16ILO c 40W49

IW6 6 -

55a

Page 61: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

- -a -40 kc- -a -a -C 3- -a-- .

-4i

47

2 oooocoaoocooooaoocoooaoooUlmooooo

10 30.. 1 =,

loc0

z uso I-

PCE 0 -

*D NC w m " -

w0 d SOma -S aa Ba 0i 05 Ims-sc 4 s..I z - I-A

a c a wc ac 20a -wI a;~ M

us - a lu mm IN3 - a-

-1 - -c w am - 0o a ui*O Ba 00 = tu saso &. 4- SCM W dPC@ . -z -D .9 04 00 mac al. i

a~"0 . a- -. - c m--I

0=0 ow ena - 00- Cm le owaca -w- oI. a-c c -= mcm aa:

a 0 0S aL B 1 P~ a - m a a ,1-- a p -(A w 0 fIma .I-- s-5, a - m

a- 110,281 -c- u a#- 40 co 0o 0 a* . -- = mc1 01z @o aj -inm 4c IL no

::0 -- -O, - w-ema ac ag. 0-UAW%% a me

me nc2 a -h1-.nea; - a a-2U)4mc c*%- 0 =3.cI. IaNS -a . aaM b-c aazLZ

fl@@ c - U If %%.-- 01 SO Ua Z 0mg - - m -00=sis 0-Uso -o 0-o a -. Bc

sea'~~~9 _- -- , c - c7~S - ia im --PIW aC" -- . as IB - cbzog smcc 0 0 41C 0 01-m

ma =LI WmcD af I 2 - SC cs- U Ma -m Im g "I -#i. -s w as I -o& 0 a

"!!-euca-.-m aJBII 0omcua -- p lea = = I-C

Baum~.amaa -= %0 0 -5 0la.B

cs--'-Se' -.-0.%m I D s E mU -in in--.-56-

Page 62: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

us

maimmoo 0.

21..

'4 = D

5-7

Page 63: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.16

Ifimo-

44

19a

00

00

NP

SM0

0 %9

U.

- o= - .

.*l 0 fl3

-0 -Cm

-D a0 m- I--

- ~ a --0

a Wa DU jC -:4

bm am1 Am -1 1 ~b91 -a w @ 00 - ~A IL 0 S- -

ad, w Amsm U m. amU~64 VW VW M-

au. 41Mgm- nio a- It 1-Ci-69 a1I 0,91 M -CZ -'o

Mat. 0- .9*3(m 44 4 -0 I.

P.m- 311t lo --5m ~ ~ 3 49 -1- 40. P e

n o a0 mnzpo SM WI qmf -.l 06060:: 69J Ip 08- al I~c WOCs-C W=

ain am 0-0a a ~ SM 4 0

w OW M 4 -ItL- 41 0 -Io I U

0u 40 a .0 -C 0 "a4-0 Ii

~E ** m --ama~maOa msm-s- n0404S~a4~u~n-uminum=ar a ~cic-.i--'s-

-OWO SM@O MSM a.M.401S SM0S044 .SM 58

Page 64: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

040

0 !!u

ad

AOs -L 4ma 340

-L 04 0

ma puam 44 ma- I ri 0 c

"P wefl -a0 .-

a -= .- N

oM @0 00 -maocof ma 3a c om

ag iamg -H

4 -% * - 0-fa% .4c 4-a -9 4 gN -

10 P-44 -. 4 us co zdq ma

ma mUrn - -- I--W

-- - g - L -

ma- u...a-.- - .

Page 65: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.. 4

4'.IL

* *oeoooooc~ooeo~o@@oooo~aooeooaceooooeceooooocoooee~oooeeo~ceooooeoocooccoe~eeoo

*~~~~~L be- 4 .- 4 Q-e @ # 0 1-4d-# 0 - 40t0 @w----- 44 PC 244# 4# 4# 400000 444~4

wa 1916 4; z Z-9$.- c

CIILa= 9)ft 91 z0

04 go- -0 b

-- I- LoWd e : L 3-A 4- 9L - 9L

pe =4 tv04co M 0,t. A too49 U I-

8!1 W 10 u 0

ont -3 dc.

. C; n= W -. -jc4 - Wo A.0 0 0 jb c0g

i W4 IL a c m C 40060c- i 1 1-' .- x 0

01- joufl -- A920 Ow :."* L, cC 0 _U *anC a. MO 0W Z0 o sI cM1 o 0- 0

be IN - 3p- x' -. ; w l c W -499 : 1 4 o 09 0-0-1 I. Mae

w4 =0 0 so- .

00 -- -- st -0 -I c- - -#4ICO O ... -- .- - -w

a 10, 00C4 w wUl,,U 091 40 lw wc u

80 -0 S -- 0 ~ "#4

-.. a in~wo- m60#

Page 66: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

7- 7- .7 -- - .. -

%

a-..

0

4D W

0W0

ACMd.Jola a -

30041 0 ) 0P--3 m z 0 -3

OWMI. W~i to 001 .

034 Z0 400m W

0 4 z o I- Cd 9 -% L 0 IV-M U. z .-

0-0 -10 um -a a m do

=J~ 0 -

-W -n -.4 J0 . 0 _,P .400aa 00- -aW.-c U _ - -3, a0 aw

40 li m a- aUv!m 44 r - 0 1 0D1. ul 0 -t 14 30 il 9 sW u . . CoPIC mof --.- -- a -) ofzMzoc l - N

-inn -4c .1i-M w -M! 0z!r= 0 i- 20 x~

M o 00 1- a z 0ZGW . - 00 %. ao oe . it s-W= - - U. z c 0 MoU

imWt mu * - . .-4 .j -0 -" U Uw-

= 0 l- 0- - do - --. m a mm

aI-na aa 000 WEC a toiZ wn 4 a 4C94 v -s4 4W-04 ~ 0

* ~4 ..0 1 - 4 -J - 0 4 (61

Page 67: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-. 44

0 4.-

00

Wb a

a a0 a L 0 .4 w

0 - U- 2e -

o-U - W-.09 00 4 6S900 0 = 0

N6 ma' - - 0 .0 0

o 0 00 - -- - -

W.41 00 1m21 u- 0 W U at U. .-.0 - - a 0 - -' H a - U.W-q 0 0M-0 -W

-o. oqu. O 'a. 0 I' - * -n a' 1

440 0aa - - - -(

EU-. 0.a - qmy-I *~u- 00-- ------OW~--- ) aA- ow -. Z a;:w l. -m w

w "INL I* .-- ,, C C-a * --

.0..- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c ci a aeas U..nw -n a -00-

0-i-s--u i-. i-wiy-- ~*-,.-uoe* ~ nw62,

-- ,m-m- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ wo -- e a LW I-IiWl0 -... c

Page 68: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

- - --------- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -- - --- - - - - - - -- -- - - - - - - - -- -

mL

U.

40

U..

m Mab

ua MCCW-u

40 4

4d 0 4 0 a

ci Z I- W6

I 4

re ma I-= 01 0 41 -A S

4 "a P-P

*~~U me )

0411 5- 2 0 I." 0: maz - A aisaM-I-wW -Z=o

Ise 0 - - 0 0 9 i l s- - =I- ru 0 ma -Z V 0

ma 0 -0 0 t

OW-L 000 m ------ 00-0-m

aU - * 0 U *ma -0 m U- -te 63

Page 69: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

44

Ifil

00

-, us

49 .92_Aja.

-at

maU --=4

.7co -W

1C4 04-IU. - -A

wi - 0 ,;Tc

-aIIt -M N -_ ca.C

4D -= 3" A .-- 4C0 Iw 0Ii -'C-AADO 4-

a4U -o I -aa pM- _~

do -* I. C

nj04 0 __

PC = 0 0 wo9N- i9 011 a9 0-M l 0 . oMcwa

00 to 0 m- ~ --an- I Baa * 1

-a 0 .~= 1 ~ -~ mu-a ~ N -4 069 -~640

Page 70: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

ID

00000""er -mao0

M ow

MI*

laa

cc=9

.44

WIIL

400

.1.

=|

d-

65

}i =

Page 71: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

c ID* occcoccccccccccco~~~~~Cco.- occcccccccccoeec

cccoccccoccoccooccoccooceeceaccee

74D~~ .4b .

Ulm -0

=49C

o ~ ~ e I-. .- I- I

o-a -c -mu D - #4 10

ccM aa *)

-44 -4 a 4. 4 #-

94m s4 #4-f. PC4- -

3- NC 9- #4-- -N

I-. I- 0a 0 w I.-mu -O -o a

4c u -A - c-I- - - - -- -u - C&4 -. 'L c lez b bc L 9 4

to - 00 U)0 U'o m- b-a o- be

IL -c -. .4 9.01- PC - 1:1 us 0. i 3ei u a-

IL 4.6 wo. w 19" .. . *c f0.== -@mo .- N0 U 1cc AC W j I- m a -j U ~

-310-0- - - 1 =;;0C J03 o0N (A 1-j . - a" m w 'I-~ ~ ~ 1 39; . 44 #4 -

-A - -A -1 -- - - -,-~~ A--mu # 0- U

0.4 st mu C -oc -0# -0 * #

AMM -a ow u ow -J ag 0Jz o :c tc t J% 0 -P be -OU#

0 0 N4C - 0 01-0 0 01*1

6603

Page 72: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.40

~41

1004? 00

au~ 67

Page 73: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-St

.5.

A- to

p40-00 0112 o

Z= due 42 C 00 .

.:..

1- 0 0us

Au ab 9b j b-c-0 P6- me. su -- : -

39 W = -_ 0 IZ0-#6U 'j - 30 - DPo 0 aulmc z

*N. -68 - -- #6 -044o-- z - "-. 4 - . .

2n m* -U.. U

3(rn#668

Page 74: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

rI-

zm

U.A

16.j-0

-M.A Z

ags -=:

ob.

.69

Page 75: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

.44

.4j4... 40 4C116 1,L= ].4o

-4 @aooooo~aocaaaoaooaoaeaoeeecooaaooaoaoooPCeooooaooooooooeoaaoaaooaaooaaaaoaaaooaoooIa

*~ ~ ~ 0 woa Moe. ~ a -a o a a. m [email protected] of

.4 ILw

0

a Mr s Q 7

wo I* to o w c

roi 40100*013

CS -M aaaaarn c-

4c" 1- 01"!-: ,0 1-.0

40 M -. -0 on*0.0 JKO 00 0

-ma r- I- ~ r- .t 1 a. co..1 - -c 10m

a a -- aMMMMM- I- o-ao2173 419 -; . nr"1n.nn==2404 I - W m W auaba - -3-0 OUSS -aau~ :a 04 26 6 W :-S" a.

1-.- * NIC------0 "1CA9I" -!2g a dc=z me NC0S a w CA- - 0 waI

aa4o- 0a .. p!- Ua w w z +aU a0 -ILLe 1Lf MOM bdA a0 - us- a

-0-A -1- - N 1. -- w -W a -w C4 - -I 49a- e -, -0a-. a. Ca -co-ol C- C - 0:!-

rM- I-= U - -L I -

-0 -. 9 I- L I-n dca a IgC 11 1-4 u- 0 1.. 4-~~~~:o- I, -A!-a. -ao -

a 4- ;W 1 a ar 0 J.o -- e IL C I - Ml- Iu N. -=-o M -OWES -gua -- 3 ~ - - muC a.44a - - m-

Ce rn-a grn~~-I- -UCEU- uma -o-U~a -- ~- -- a nrn~a mua -------- - m

-a-,mu -nz . 4~ *a U -64 '70

Page 76: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

j-s - -. - . . *

eeaeca a 4 W sVe v-u.uFv-u-v--u-v-v-see met em ba eansm ae 0 0 0 0

am

-40

00

o 1. a N_..I- IL 6 1-eWU j 4 -1 " -

on IL -1 Z 0 M0M -1 u 0 0 0-IRU. IL- 30 a 0 I O4l

4to - a U=qw 0 t .611 sliXa- IL 0.La "Cm l=Zk 0o4- =Wwb --

v-~~G aa -3=9 qN -O -c N - en ia

oL -I-O IL-0 -L I 4 0 0 P u-a29 - alc l = d 0

11 a; C! be do aI-6- -c. a i - 0 0 0 AMN a0801w 9 - "m In SOW~ CA 00

NW - N-Ow dc N a4 a nA -c 0 -

o6 - 1 -o - 0-1c 1C1C01__ ,

=o N NO u a-S US=. ;o -- O PC - -=. N. ----- M-aIa

tee-ISILO",-, aaW.A =Iaaaa warn-

1c -so IM a ma -s - 4sr a

as,~~~~ ~ an: a as aCAcao u i*a a (c - aa issi 44w

Sc -- - - 5 - *. -. ma~i.73

Page 77: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

P44J

000

WEW

4LM Su

ICI-

he.0 =D N~d a

4 a.-- - C a Cza II- 4N -- 4 .4

cm 0 -. M 20

goL N; 2 -W 0

o: r- I.-. oo -I P~ a. ~a .- a -2 U

tom ci .4" a , - -

I - 0r z .-m c o a -

0m W a 3w a-.-44mewa44 we -1114 601e-a

-am0 c w m -:§ -- ,-zic.

w 4 C a.W- m -4 -- 0-0 - b~. to PC

co ma." bg4 W- am - 04 &.1- -4 P- 50- 1 -0in-O cI.- -E d3. a - - -OC-- u3a - w-- a%% U . m -0 I-oNow~ * r ox% .. Rma.% 4a-. a.----- 66 - ..J *

I.-0- .. oil C ~-A

1 0am H a ac n *O -1 i@a-O. 0mr C in5in%%% %% Cn_= a w -,go...*~~~----- ------iu ma u z m w 0- -# il.# = ~ C

o @4cicio-a@CCOm~~ a- mao- cim'~rr72

Page 78: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

of DCbzN~b:-0 0z o

460 um

;bcb

MA MA

.AW.

04

IUI.001.0 Isa

P_. U S

00 M I-moou

IO o 0

W 40 WSI IC -9 A9 0 .40 0

80* U' IM If0 as o 0 _00& -Do- U 1.. )

0-- U a 0Lo aPCM z -416 .~l .b .b I-Sbi w .

am z .2 M-1 Aa-

9-- OILS C -= )0 log MAAS x 0cW I= ~Q

N 0-C IA 0e" t =f. ISb -A 0uii * 0 rd U I Muip o su sbow 4c" 0 = z - MAU - AC

- I.- - a U14s 0 -K - - b U -

4 _U..*~ S 00 . W I- .I 526 0 Z0 0cI U MAgg" ~ 0

5-S-U.~4 UP U * 4I @b 4 4 b * #b5i 0MA -I-- ~ S

MA.0A1= 44 S 0) ~ S 00 -O AI

Sb 0 - U~-bCU . 0 -73S

Page 79: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-- -- -- -- -

.4.

-4T

dc a040

0 ccU.-

3w..

49 1-zA

we It 0bU-40 1- ..0

- - C2 40)q* -1n M M*

M IL 0 029; 1 Us toW 0 oI - no -C I- d

PC 40 - * 00~~~ ~ us . - a

(@ 14 *0 to I.-00- 0 14 =0l ame U. C3, 0c =a!4 o !0 _I. I- z ce beW

00- - 'I M IL- I- CL-5-00 CO- - efii -- 4- go Us 0 4

me0- 0 m0 1: . a" 00b LC0 1- 0 0

weww .0 w- 44 U;2 9- 0w - -40 00 -u

ZOO 0 -8- .-- *. =- 0 0s ad - j4-D-m WA a= a C1 IM PC -.0

0 U 0; T.; C. O3I IC " ' w4a - IC W Us I.-cap 0- Ig a * 0 - mu Mo. 0 IC mu 0 -1Wt a4 s ;

0344 39mUCCC 0 - lf W- 0 - -JC 1. -A =

P.0. I $ -- 1.- 49 -A. -M su P 1 -s

A0- 1.0 Cu- 31, -1- @ O1 I. ow 0 -0 -A4

5-swo z-u~bum4 093 a It. Mu4 m a I- w o U w~ -e- 4 -a0 .-.aU-a-a 0 00 1-Z0-4W- 4.- (0 a .be

a3~a~on cc,-o-ace a a*.~,~~ ua-

Cu:: WOO-~-u44~ a 0U~1Ia-a0 - a74

Page 80: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

I.-R 1.

.4 Z---- a 0 a a 0 0 0 0 4----a 2 3 D D

I-pA C91C4Ct " CC

da

0diL

06

Waa

U~U

z 0&

lg 00i-

.4c 0 I

a 3-u

a -a CA So

00 %go(A . - to

a - 4D -U0 d0 a& a C N= mu am z M 1 f-I I

8 1 00 Now o - w ILn c OWo9 44 wnU 0m 1aI3If. l 1-110111- MI 1-

W 0 .1 OIL- mo. 00 - a.f 0

_3 11 Oct a.C Z- 3ma Ci -1 w 0- V 0 *

Ok I- Q- - aMa -ia a - - 11 bem zI O V -A - M a

a#m 4D- -,c- PC D- .a - 0-4a. Ifl- -L m9 1&1 1.-Z V I~ O.Wo -

0 4 0 0-s M- 1 m4. - 00 -0 111U *19041 =%me Mm0 0a 00 - -

& a *I-D 0- 0 4ma 0 ~ -.A IM a-I -.1 -

a W o -A W4 9 n o 49 a - " - 111 411 M a m a"W*0 "W0 0 1 =41 1- m. w~ I is MM*s -t be W N0 1-0 0 w 0 go 4c m0 0 m11I 1- ma z -

$ ;: -- * U0- z- -1 -a. . N w4 11 _ , ) N Ia a- M. O_- I-- mC us b- - -

a ~ ~ d 12 -0- A -Am-m -m 0- maa1o 6 U. 30 -mi-maW fi0I 200"" 0 44aC--~*~ -

0~~~~~~~~ Ua- LIP 94 UC 4B -na-m2 nam m 0 ~4~~

- in- - u- -00 -eo =004-mo a o unmam H SI n75

Page 81: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

=04

""4##"MIND .. .IN "

so

10

w~l

.4 a dg m

0 ag w

NI

no

a 04 1Q,4

eq76

Page 82: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

IW6

000

-0-

I- 16--

81.1 a91

0:0

.0 4.

bdg -IM - w N n0 z

gmu

-94

M77

Page 83: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

ICIO

'U

4

'INC

ama

ca 300

*4c

0 11 a

0a acm m 0 0 . .F _0. c 0 (

4 . -M- a LU -

m 011 c- Z III- -. M0N I-W 00 1.-

I-00L - -do . qt 4

Ia -.IO - W, - - =00 0 j- -

as-- ~--aVmaWill 0 0 .41- '0 -4O -M- on= 0Ilil Ma A~ n I- , -m -a (11 0 - z3 -_ 0 -- a 0

a(Jbc 111a - - U2

maN -a -a -- aPC- - p;;ma-t z ~ -- U_ - -C O 0 J UC - -

5- 0= -- 4= N9 -9L -- -C - 4c 5-0 90Jma 0'4r4m4 ( -- -gA--- m L WZL

ou ~~~ = a -m:

4 logo -@Q- - - -0- W 0 w oaa Na -4- 1.- *0 -4 U) do4C

4 -4uc 1% - 4Uo - - - g0--- - 01no -

o * -im--o 4c -- a -main-r Co in -Amma ~ ~ -a -m o- ma-u- 0.U- - - - r 4 -

a- wlfw= ago of C-am= 40. 0a a aI- =P.M 0 a- a -. 4o- -% Az -& A W aaa 0 uu .ua440-V "V N~a =. 040 -,m - - a 0 I-- 0 ocl0911 01

M. 40- -44-4-8 -!5*%Z .4c0 5 - 1. I000 $- 1 - $- #. . .a i-I--ma a-. 144 -0('4

- 0 C * S =m-- N%.% mamms as aN -a U. 00 0J Is 0w0o

C~~~~4 emm CIAaa-NN 440 1*s~ao ~-0050 aNmama 0 0am~a~aIOO@U~uI0IC4

&P 4-OWOUW E 4 ~ a i- s - i-, . -a

* - WWI~5 CC I- NaUau - - a a-a- -78

Page 84: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

- . .u r~US

us

CL

O4 -'

4c U. 0--l c 3C.

US SAO.

OOM 0 oc

4...

P4c 44-4A t .zz= -- al

0- IL 00 - 40 a.= l 1- a*

a 0 -3- a me 0 wc. La I39 - me s=msa 0 v a1

W) 0o -oU am to0

M;!!Y -J 0U 0 0 5 - w C4 u3--O O4 0 Ii 00 0 00u 1'

M n O 8t4C"o-D w 0 AlS -Ozr wz z 0 $ .1

llhe mu0. - 2C 00mM.I- 91g z tUM C4 -Al0-=C- 4U~ 4 -I

Can 08 4I -- 0 04

000 003 0 0 00=0 0-

0 o 0 to P-4-C,0

mu -- U a -79

Page 85: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

77t-a7. 7777 -nT.---- - - - - - - -

-. I-

0.

ILLa0

ICC0C

go a

aaget a

a-

4~t*D

0*80

Page 86: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-~~~~24 -0 ?A NO W- NO -- --- p -

* ,-- -. - ~4 -3'~. ~ ~t~ ''~~ ~- - 3-

VI.

IN

-r P

-

0-4

IU-s-C

I,-

-mm.

04c

* IA.

ID4

I-O

nw

U821 00 = aI

n sW~ODUS %c- Nl

-, "Nw 40dew I

eC.IO

08

Page 87: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

-0 -0 -0 WP z -0 a - -. a - -0- -C 3 a 4 -D a -C 2a -D

@@@ @@@ @o@@@o@C~o 0@@ Coo oooo a c ocaooocoCCocoC@@~

4c

J-.'

4 Cl

III

aaow.a.

S ~~

Asu -" M

to c

I- a -C-

go a Is

40 clbd o -

AID W 1-80 ILU

ow" -CC- a aI--044 aI IL 9 o

a 9m a a. C. z

8-I F050 - aAI.4 fl a aUU

IL w-d aAt -- V-I

o8 c4fl 0"rn =o .a44 3oaot No as0 t I 0IO WQML = V - Q

C afma m =0a -0. - -. ;. : v C ; -. ;o*C 1* 4w 01*- - 0 10 - - w -w

av. Ca-= - o 4a U -UsIOU no IL -i 3o-

>c a. - az - a aas D- w AL Z PC -- aI

-- -6 aL C -e P-a46 e-- f s -*.eian

Re - -a - I *ii-tsa-82

Page 88: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

0 bc " - I- -a

49 0z 1

@000000000000000089 @0 @0a00 8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0@ 0@00000000000000000 @00000"0 @0000000@000

O ~ce -. 7.4 c . eo~7.4.e~ee0.774mo.- eo- 7.4mm- eo- 7.7m~.-ceeceeeee.-.cccccccceFee :0ee000000008'

000

ac 4 4c s Cb-A U

m. ma.~

WMU U-C =I- I-. gu-.0 .

mo 4 Cau IL 0 .U0 0 WOW $.

.- -a. - Ucw w IWOiau C

ov. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ un !:On 0~n;No sazc w:" 0 000IL- 00 P I- V =

too i-rnZ aoc

ftmfto ~ ~ ~ vaa"4 m -ma.- 04oIa I--MCf m u4- 0 0

PC in4c l -4 4 a -A me,

z -~..k IL ma.1c aa -

tow

83a aiu.w

Page 89: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

--- -- ---- -- --- - .--- -- - -- -

.49

47 0

U. U.

000

no 00

OM *1 t -.

w 00

no m *9

0 CD I

II.. 0"- I va M b

M 00SILILM 9 -0-00tW&0

anO Ma &)w 4 A o0 M

0 0----------

IL IL 9L 0 a

~W~a 0 -0 PC0 0atI- .a o

em ~ 84

Page 90: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

W. o @ e o @ @ 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 :1

4. . -

Z U. ;c ,op 001c IS=0.co-o. mt t!

o" K 0 0o a # 0o 0 0

0001 be-u- P$ c a = = 0 - = = Cd -A

mt01 c 0 - -0 90- 0C 0wa w o6 f 0 1- 01- Wd a -

a SA= 0 CM OW OC.W 0CCO - - CdJ0 -00000 - ad~ 0d ad 00~ ad U_. a 00aaa o 0aa

S. C Cd 0 - 0 0 - *C* - Cd Cd Cd Cd P Cdc C u t

Id ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4 I. 0U lb U c -@ 0 - 0

P.. d Cd - ~- Cd- - - *85

Page 91: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

~~~U 0- n o om0~

a C;W0

- 1 U

ci a

4U L

SU

NC U .

IC ..:a m-, UO -3 = c

la3. to

us a us a.- IIU..~~~ ~ ~ ~ 0- a.aOC * I o

00~~~ ~ ~ ~ -0 42 10 a. .0 014 W0~~~ ~~ qr ;c0 04 ,-u

- a. OO 0-l 1- 1 a.so IsI

0 0 ca am

070"00 a Od .403 33wa m o -0 009b n

- - Ia. ma I WL -

- ~ ~ ~ ~ S is 0 0 I 1W ~

= 0 i i- ma ma 0Z0a8a

Page 92: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

400000O00000000000000000 0024o0dc

S 0000000U 0000000000 ~00 E

I-= = == ==mn m m m m z u~ ==z=L

b- ~ U ~ i ~ in Z ~ i . .. ... ... a

*M c - I. aa 0 d00 oa o o oo 0a I.- o am--r-A-

.40au. 0

V87

Page 93: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

M -I- P- I-- I- I-- b- I- - .

a I

.88

Page 94: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

DISTRIBUTION LIST

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY

Armed Forces Radiobiology Rsch Institute Aberdeen Proving Ground2 cy ATTN: Dir 2 cy ATTN: Tech Library

Armed Forces Staff College Atmospheric Sciences LabATTN: Library ATTN: DELAS-AS

Assistant to the Secretary of Defense BMD Advanced Technology CtrAtomic Energy ATTN: ATC-T

ATTN: Executive AssistantDeputy Chief of staff for Ops & Plans

Defense Communications Engineer Ctr ATTN: DAMO-NCNATTN: R-123

Deputy Chief Staff for Rsch Dev & AcqDefense Intelligence Agency ATTN: DAMA-CSS-N2 cy ATTN: RTS-2A

Engr Studies CtrDefense Nuclear Agency ATTN: DAEN-FES

ATTN: RAAEATTN: SPAS Harry Diamond LabsATTN: RAEV ATTN: DELHD-NW-P, 20240ATTN: NATA ATTN: DELHD-TA-L, 81100ATTN: RAEE ATTN: DELHD-NPATTN: SPSSATTN: SPTD Multi Service Communications SystemsATTN: NATD ATTN: DRCPM-MSCS-APB, M. FrancisATTN: NATA, J. AndersonATTN: COMP-1, B. Robertson US Army Ballistic Rsch LabsATTN: STTI, M. Vincent ATTN: R. Reisler

2 cy ATTN: STTI 2 cy ATTN: DRDAR-TSB-S4 cy ATTN: TITL

US Army Chemical SchoolDefense Tech Info Ctr ATTN: ATZN-CM-CC12 cy ATTN: DD

US Army Comb Arms Combat Dev ActyField Command Defense Nuclear Agency ATTN: ATZL-CAN-IDet 1Lawrence Livermore Lab US Army Comd & General Staff College

ATTN: FC-1, J. Crandley ATTN: ACQ, Library DivATTN: FC-1

US Army Communications CommandField Command ATTN: Tech Ref DivDefense Nuclear Agency

ATTN: FCTXE US Army Concepts Analysis AgencyATTN: FCPR ATTN: Classified DocumentsATTN: FCTT, S. HumphriesATTN: FCTT, W. Summa US Army Engr Waterwa-' Exper StationATTN: FCTT, G. Ganong ATTN: J. HoustunATTN: FCTT ATTN: WESGH, P. Hadala

Joint Chiefs of Staff US Army Field Artillery SchoolATTN: SAGA/SFD ATTN: M. Swett, LibraryATTN: SAGA/STAATTN: J-5, Nuclear Div/Strategy Div US Army'Forces CommandATTN: J-3 ATTN: Tech Library

Joint Strat Tgt Planning Staff US A''iy Intell & Sec CmdATTN: JLA, Threat Applications Div ATTN: Tech Library

2 cy ATTN: NRI-STINFO, LibraryUS Army Logistics Ctr

Joint Strategic Connectivity Staff ATTN: ATCL-OSS, S. CockrellATTN: JCS/DNA, F. Tedesco

US Army Material Dev & Readiness CmdUnder Secretary of Defense for Rsch & Engrg ATTN: DRCDE-D

ATTN: Strategic A Space Sys (OS)

89

•~~1 IN .t .q' .' °, .° '' ..°,' ,

.' ."". " ' •"" . ° " "- " • ,""

Page 95: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

,r ,. -,;.. . ,: . :- ,.. ........ .. ... .. ...-.-..-... :. : -. - .. --...- L-,.- .- -. :-. L-.: - .

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY (Continued) DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY (Continued)

US Army Materiel Sys Analysis Actvy Naval Weapons Evaluation Facility4 ATTN: ORXSY-CC ATTN: H. Struve

US Army Nuclear & Chemical Agency Naval Underwater Systems CtrA ATTN: Library 2 cy ATTN: Code EM, J. Kalinowski

US Amy Satellite Comm Agency Office of Naval RschATTN: Tech Library ATTN: Tech Info Svcs

US Army Signal Ctr & Ft Gordon DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCEATTN: ATZH-CD

Air Force Propulsion LabUS Army TRADOC Sys Analysis Actvy ATTN: LKDH, Stop 24, E. Haberman

ATTN: ATAA-PLAir Force Radiobiological Health Lab, AFLC

US Army War College ATTN: Dir2 cy ATTN: Library

Air Force Armament LabUS Army White Sands Missile Range ATTN: AFATL/DLY

ATTN: CommanderAir Force Rocket Propulsion Lab

USA Missile Command ATTN: LKCPATTN: Doc Section

Air Force Tech Applications CtrDEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY 2 cy ATTN: STINFO Ofc-TF

Chief of Naval Operations Air Force Test & Evaluation CtrDir Cmd Control Planning & Prgmng Div, OP-940 ATTN: J. Hoge

ATTN: OP-943

Air Force Weapons LabDavid Taylor Naval Ship R&D Ctr ATTN: AD, J. Ormand5 cy ATTN: Code L42-3 ATTN: SUL

ATTN: NTES, R. GuiceNaval Air Development Ctr ATTN: NTYC, J. Burgio

ATTN: Doc ConAir Force Wright Aeronautical Lab

Naval Air Systems Omd ATTN: Tech LibraryATTN: Tech Library

Air Force Wright Aeronautical LabNaval Civil Engrg Lab ATTN: LTE

ATTN: L-51, S. JohnsonAir University Library

Naval Electronic Systems Cmd ATTN: AUL-LSEATTN: Tech Library

HeadquartersNaval Ocean Systems Ctr Air Weather Service, MAC

ATTN: Code 4471 ATTN: AWSAE

Naval Postgraduate School Armament Dev & Test Ctr2 cy ATTN: Code 1424, Library ATTN: Doc Con

Naval Rsch Lab Ballistic Missile Office5 cy ATTN: Code 2627 ATTN: SYDT

ATTN: ENNaval Space Surveillance System ATTN: ENMP, D. Van Gari

ATTN: J. BurtonDeputy Chief of Staff

Naval Surface Weapons Ctr Rsch, Dev, & Acq

ATTN: Code R44, H. Glaz ATTN: AFRDSTATTN: Code F31 ATTN: AFRDS, Space Sys & C3 Dir

ATTN: AFRDQINaval Surface Weapons Ctr5 cy ATTN: Tech Library & Info Svcs Br Headquarters

Electronic Systems DivNaval Weapons Ctr ATTN: DCK, L. Staples5 cy ATTN: Code 343, FKA6A2, Tech Svcs ATTN: XRRT

90

. *m-

Page 96: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE (Continued) DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE CONTRACTORS (Continued)

Foreign Tech Div AVCO Systems Div

ATTN: NIIS, Library ATTN: Library, A830

Headquarters BDM CorpNORAD ATTN: J. Braddock

ATTN: J5YS, F. Smith ATTN: M. KellyATTN: L. Schlipper

Space Div 2 cy ATTN: Corporate LibraryATTN: INDATTN: SSP-6 BDM Corp.ATTN: YGJ ATTN: P. McClouskyATTN: YKM ATTN: Library

ATTN: D. PeercyOEPARTMENT OF ENERGY ATTN: F. Leech

Department of Energy Beers Associates, Inc.Tech Info Ctr ATTN: Contracts Ofc

ATTN: Doc ConBerkeley Rsch Associates, !nc

OTHER GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ATTN: J. Workman

Central Intell Agency Boeing Co.ATTN: OSWR/NED ATTN: Aerospace Library

ATTN: R. HagerDepartment of the Interior ATTN: W. CooleyUS Geological Survey ATTN: S. Sandberg

ATTN: J. Dietrich ATTN: E. Brown4 cy ATTN: M/S 42-37, B. Henderson

Department of the Interior, US Geological SurveyATTN: R. Regan Boeing Computer Svcs, Inc.

ATTN: M/S 8C-52, D. Chapman

Federal Emergency Management Agency ATTN: B. BrownATTN: Ofc of Rsch/NP, D. Bensen

Boeing Military Airplane Co.DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY CONTRACTORS ATTN: D. Pierson

ATTN: R. Syring

University of CaliforniaLawrence Livermore National Lab Booz-Allen & Hamilton, Inc

ATTN: L-21, 0. Oakley ATTN: R. HansonATTN: P. ColellaATTN: Tech Info Dept, Library California Rsch & Tech, Inc

ATTN: T. Isabelle

Los Alamos National Labratory ATTN: K. KreyenhagenATTN: Reports Library ATTN: Library

Sandia National Labs, Livermore Calspan Corp.

ATTN: Library & Security Classification Div ATTN: A. Davis

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE CONTRACTORS Calspan Corp.ATTN: M. Dunn

Aerospace Corp ATTN: LibraryATTN: M. Eskijian

66th MI GroupAgbabian Associates ATTN: RDA

ATTN: M. AgbabianControl Data Corp.

Analytic Services, Inc ATTN: R. Portillo2 cy ATTN: Library

Corrales Applied Physics Co.Applied Rsch Associates, Inc. ATTN: N. Froula

ATTN: J. PhillipsCushing Associates

Applied Theory, Inc. ATTN: V. CushingATTN: Doc Con

Decision Science Consortium, Inc.APTEK, Inc. ATTN: J. Chinnis

ATTN: A. LarrabeeDikewood

Astron Rsch & Engrg ATTN: Tech Library for K. SabischATTN: A. Levien

ATTN: C. Scott

91

, , , o,, , , % ,, ,, , , , , , , , . . . . . . . . S,

Page 97: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE CONTRACTORS (Continued) DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE CONTRACTORS (Continued)

EG&G Wash Analytical Svcs Ctr, Inc Johns Hopkins UniversityATTN: Library ATTN: F. BrelsfordATTN: J. BridgesATTN: J. Ridge Kaman AvidyneATTN: L. Daley ATTN: M. Tomayko

2 cy ATTN: Library

Electro-Magnetic Applications, IncATTN: B. Fisher Kaman Sciences Corp

ATTN: D. Conroy

Electro-Mech Systems, Inc ATTN: F. SheltonATTN. A. Stough 5 cy ATTN: LibraryATTN: R. Shunk

Kaman TempoElectrospace Systems, Inc ATTN: K. Schwartz

ATTN: H. Logston ATTN: DASIACATTN: C. Anderson

ESL, Inc ATTN: A. KleinATTN: Library 10 cy ATTN: W. Chan

Flow Sciences, Inc Kaman TempoATTN: J. Campbell ATTN: R. Miller

ATTN: Contracts OfcGarjak Rsch, Inc

ATTN: G. Erickson K Tech CorpATTN: B. Mason

General Electric Co ATTN: E. YoungATTN: N. DispensiereATTN: 0. Coceano JAYCORATTN: Tech Info Ctr 2 cy ATTN: Library

General Research Corp JAYCORATTN: J. Garbarino ATTN: C. ClarkATTN: G. PurvisATTN: 0. Sangster Lockheed Missiles & Space Co, IncATTN: J. Balter ATTN: J. HenleyATTN: L. Wogulis ATTN: T. Geers

2 cy ATTN: Doc Con 2 cy ATTN: Reports Library2 cy ATTN: Tech Info Ofc

Lockheed Missiles & Space Co, IncHarold Rosenbaum Associates, Inc ATTN: C. Rankin

ATTN: H. Rosenbaum 2 cy ATTN: TIC-Library

Horizons Technology, Inc Martin Marietta Denver AerospaceATTN: R. Kruger ATTN: Rsch Library, 6617

Information Science, Inc Mathematical Sciences Northwest, IncATTN: W. Dudziak ATTN: Doc Con

Institute for Defense Analyses Martin Marietta CorpATTN: Classified Library 2 cy ATTN: M1. Criffith

IRT Corp Maxwell Labs, IncATTN: M. Obrien ATTN: J. Smith

2 cy ATTN: Library ATTN: A. Kolb

J. D. Haltiwanger Consulting Svcs McDonnell Douglas CorpATTN: Doc Con ATTN: M. Gee

ATTN: W. Gee

JAYCOR ATTN: D. DeanATTN: W. Hobbs 2 cy ATTN: Tech Library SvcsATTN: W. Radaski

McDonnell Douglas CorpJAYCOR ATTN: R. Mapes

ATTN: E. Wenaas

ATTN: A. Woods Merritt CASES, IncATTN: J. Young ATTN: LibraryATTN: A. J. Woods ATTN: G. Wintergerst

5 cy ATTN: Library

92

Page 98: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

77 .7- -77 -71 1-7 17-~- 177- .77.77-

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE CONTRACTORS (Continued) DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE CONTRACTORS (Continued)

University of Miami Rand CorpATTN: Contract Ofc, S. Wang 2 cy ATTN: Library

Mission Research Corp Rockwell International CorpATTN: A. Gregerson ATTN: LibraryATTN: C. Longmire

5 cy ATTN: Doc Con S-CUBEDATTN: J. GlowMission Research Corp ATTN: M. Scarpa

ATTN: Library ATTN: K. PyattATTN: B. Neri 10 cy ATTN: Doc Con

Mitre Corp 10 Cy ATTN: Library

ATTN: Tech Report Ctr S-CUBEDMitre Corp ATTN: J. Murphy

ATTN: A. Schneider S-CU-.EDNorthrop Corp ATTN: J. Crepeau

ATTN: A. Scott Santa Fe Corp2 cy ATTN: RAD Effects Grp 2 cy ATTN: Sec Ofc

Pacific-Sierra Rsch Corp 2 cy ATTN: D. PaolucciATTN: S. Sanenitser Science & Engrg Associates, IncATTN: J. Levsque ATTN: J. DrenticeATTN: S. FinnATTN: Contracts Ofc Science & Engrg Associates, IncATTN: H. Brode, Chairman SAGE ATTN: J. McCulloughATTN: Doc Con

Science Applications, IncPacific-Sierra Research Corp ATTN: R. Reaugh

ATTN: 0. GormleyATTN: Doc Con Science Applications, Inc

Pacifica Technology ATTN: C. DoughertyATTN: G. Kent Science Applications, IncATTN: M. Gittings ATTN: B. Dial

2 cy ATTN: Tech LibraryScience Applications, IncPDA Engrg ATTN: C. Burgart2 cy ATTN: Doc Con 10 cy ATTN: Sec Ofc

Physical Dynamics, Inc Science Applications, IncATTN: E. Fremouw ATTN: Sec Ofc

Physical Dynamics, Inc ATTN: Contracts OfcATTN: Contracts Ofc Science Applications, Inc

Physics International Co ATTN: Contracts OfcP cATTN: J. Larson ATTN: B. Elyea, Security OfcATTN: 0. LhaoATTN: J. Shea Science Applications, IncATTN: L. Burr ATTN: Security Ofc

5 cy ATTN. Tech Library ATTN: B. Goplen

Pulse Sciences Inc Science Applications, IncATTN: W. Weseloh ATTN: P. Setty

ATTN: W. -imermanR & D Associates ATTN: W. LaysonATTN: F. Field 5 cy ATTN: Security OfcATTN: G. IvyATTN: M. Wright Science Applications, IncATTN: M. Warshaw ATTN: R. McClean

10 cy ATTN: Tech Info CtrR & D Associates Science Applications, IncR & AsocitesATTN: H. Dolatshahi2 Cy ATTN: Doc Con ATTN: R. Jaka

ATN .Jarka

R. F. Cross Associates, LtdATTN: R. Mahoney

93

%%'L %'% % "%%, , "•- . . .'a "If I - I -Ii i ' 'i i : Im

Page 99: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

AD-AI31 273 AFWL BENCHMARK COMPUTER PROGRAM(U) BOEING REROSPACE CO 2/2SEATTLE WA B JNHENDERSON Ot MAY 82 DNA-5852FDNROOi-80-C-0056

UNCLASSIFIED F/G 9/2 NL

EOlN

Page 100: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

*-8 . . . .. .j -. . . . . .

1111 1.0.F1.251 11. 1 1.

MuICRCP REOUIO 2ET 2HRNATION = BUEA O 3F STNAD- -

Page 101: BOEING AEROSPACE CO i/j,, UNCLASSIFIED ... · d-a131 273 rfwl benchmark computer progrrm(u) boeing aerospace co i/j,, seattle wa b j henderson 01 may 82 dnr-5852f dnaoi-80-c-0056

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE CONTRACTORS (Continued) DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE CONTRACTORS (Continued)

Science Applications, Inc TRW Electronics & Defense SectorATTN: C. Bates ATTN: G. Teraoka

ATTN: D. Jortner*Scientific Rsch Assoc, Inc ATTN: F. Fendell4ATTN: J. Kredozsky 2 cy ATTN: Tech Info Ctr

SRI International TRW Electronics & Defense SectorATTN: P. Wong ATTN: F. SterkATTN: B. Lew ATTN: F. StrawATTN: G. AbrahamsonATTN: P. Dolan United Technologies Rsch Ctr

9 cy ATTN: Library ATTN: H. Michels

SRI International Visidyne, Inc2 cy ATTN: Doc Con ATTN: H. Smiith

Sylvania Systems Grp Weidlinger Assoc, Consulting Engrg2 cy ATTN: Library ATTN: J. Wright

3 cy ATTN: N. BaronStrategic Systems Div

ATTN: A. Novenski Weidlinger Assoc, Consulting EngrgATTN: K. Stultz

System Planning & Analysis, IncATTN: Contracts Ofc Weidlinger AssociatesATTN: P. Vadola ATTN: J. Isenberg

ATTN: E. RichardsonTetra Tech, Inc

ATTN: Contracts Ofc Weidlinger Associates, IncATTN: E. Raney

Tetra Tech, IncATTN: J. Preston Westinghouse Corp

ATTN: J. Kasdorf -

Toyon Rsch CorpATTN: J. Garbarino

94