biomarkers of exposure to airborne criteria and air toxic
TRANSCRIPT
Biomarkers of Exposure to Airborne Criteria and Air Toxic Pollutants
June 10, 2004
California Air Resources Board
Rogene F. Henderson, PhD
Lovelace Respiratory Research Institute Albuquerque, NM
5429W-2
To wlhat extent dlo,es exposure to· chemical!s •Co,ntrib1ute to diseas.e?
EXPOS,U1 RE
DilSEASE
Use of Biological Markers to Reduce Uncertainties in Risk Assessment
5429W-3
!Repair IExc1retion
/Excreta . . . Noneffective A / . · Physiological . . . IRepai,r
/ Macromolecular / Resp,onse / . · Adducts
l otall. Dose to Biolog1ica1llly ln_itlial . . . . . . . _. __
-i)lli.... ,Body _,.,.. ..... T~rg:et ► Effectiv·,e , • B1olog•1call • Pre~hm 1cal . ► Clm_1cal Tissue Dose• Changes Les.101ns Lesions
:Burde\. n '-.... . Nontarget
~ CeHs ,01r· ·. · Nonta rget Org1anelles
Tissue
Biological :M,arkers Biologicall Markers
of Do.siimetry of Effect
Biomarkers for Risk Assessment
5429W-4
Biological Marker of Exposure
An exogenous substance or its metabolite or the product of an interaction between a xenobiotic agent and some target molecule or cell that is measured in a compartment within an organism.
5429W-5
Ideal Biomarker of Exposure
· Quantitatively relatable to prior exposure to specific chemical
· Quantitatively relatable to, or predictive of, later developing disease
5429W-6
Sometimes, we only need a qualitative, yes/no answer.
Have you been drinking again?
5429W-7
Sometimes quantitation is required.
But I only had one beer!
5429W-8
Desirable Attributes of Biomarkers of Exposure
· Pollutant specific
· Available for analysis by noninvasive techniques
· Sensitive (detectable at trace concentrations)
· Inexpensive
· Integrates exposures from all media
5429W-9
Exposure? Marker
Strategies to Relate Markers of Exposure to Prior Exposures
What information do we need to relate a biomarker of exposure to prior exposures?
5429W-10
Exposure? Marker
If we want to be more quantitative, more information is required.
• Rate of formation of biomarker
• Rate of formation of biomarker
From this information, we can predict the steady-state concentrations of the marker following various exposure scenarios.
5429W-11
Exposure? Marker
Mathematical Models
· If we have information on rate of formation and removal of a biomarker of exposure, and the factors that influence those rates, we can develop a mathematical model that will predict the concentration of the marker following various exposure regimens.
· The concentration of a biomarker cannot be used to indicate a unique exposure scenario, but can indicate the types of exposure regimens that would produce the indicated level of biomarker
5429W-12
DETAILED I
KINETIC STUD.IES, IN ANIMALS
e PERCENT ABSORBED
I
-MATHEMATICAL
MODELOF MAR.KER
IN ANIM:ALS
e ANIIMAL TOXICOKINETIC DATA
I I
·• T112 ·ro STEADY STATE
e ANIIMAL PHYSIOLOGICAL ,D·ATA
e T1/2 IFOR CLEARAJNCE
e E.FFECTOF ... EXPOSURE CONCENTRATIO·N ... JEXPOSURE RATE - REPEATED EXPOSURES, - ROLJlE OF 1EXPOSURES
-·-MATHEMATICAL
M10 :DELFOR HUMANS
I
eHUMAN PHVSIO,LOGl'CAL D,ATA
e HUMAN METABOLIC DATA IN VITRO
-~
I
VALIDATE HUMAN MO:DEL
e LIMITED, HUMAN DATA
Exposure? Marker
Use of Animal Data on Kinetics of Biomarkers to Predict Kinetics in Humans
5429W-13
Exposure? Marker
A Second Strategy:
A battery of biomarkers of exposure with differing
half-lives in the body may provide more information
about prior exposures than a single biomarker.
5429W-14
' ------ ---------
0 1 10 100 1000 TIME AFTER 1EXPOSURE (days)
Henoor.;on, et ,~ .• Crit. Rev .. Toxicol. 20:65-82',. 1989
Exposure? Marker
Hypothetical Relationship Between “Biomarkers” and Time After Exposure
5429W-15
Marker Marker11, 2 Case I
A minutes +
e. hours +++
C days ++
D weeks +
E m:onths +
Case I - 1R.ecent e,xposure. Case H - Ongoi,ng exposure ..
Case II Case, Ill
+ -+++ -· ++
+++ ++
+++ ++
Case Ill - Exposur·es were severa,11 months ago; no recent exposure.,
Exposure? Marker
Use of a Battery of Biomarkers to Determine Past Exposure
5429W-16
Marker? Disease
Strategies to Relate Markers of Exposure to Health Outcome
Need to know which markers can be associated with the
disease outcome and the degree of the association. That
is, given a certain level of a biomarker of exposure, what
is the probability of getting the disease?
5429W-17
Marker? Disease
What information is required to relate markers of exposure to probability of health outcome?
• Mechanism of disease induction
• Quantitative relationship between marker and probability of progression to adverse health effect
5429W-18
Marker? Disease
Example:
Predicting cancer induction using DNA adducts as biomarkers
· Identify DNA adducts that are formed by exposure to chemical
· Determine t1/2 of adducts
· Determine mutagenic potential of adducts
· For adducts with long t1/2 and mutagenic potential, determine if mutations induced by adduct are present in tumors induced by chemical
· In animals, develop pharmacodynamic models that describe a quantitative relationship between adduct levels and cancer induction
5429W-19
Marker? Disease
Example: DNA adducts of vinyl chloride (VC)
VC causes liver cancer in humans and animals. In rats, preweanling rats are more susceptible than adults.
Swenberg et al., Conference of Relevance of Animal Studies to Evaluate Human Cancer Risk, Austin, TX, December 5-8, 1990.
5429W-20
CYT-P~ , ,ct /c-:c, --------...
0 2• NAO,PH
, ./Cl REAR.RANGEMENT c-c I'/ ' ·O
VINYL CHLORIDE
CHLOROETIHVLENE OXtOE
COVALENT AD1DUCTS WITH NUCLEIC .AcI:o BASES
1/ N
cvl 1,
{d)R
1/' N
N'
~ N
CICH2 -CHO
CHLOROACET ALOEIHYDE
7-(2 OXOETHYL) 3,N'4-ETH!ENQ.. 1,.N6-ETHENO- .N•\3.-ETHENO-( DE,OXY} GUANOS.I N'E ,(DEOXY)CVT l'DINE (DEOXY) AD 1ENOSINE DEOXYGUANOSI NE
OEdG EdC EdA EdG
Cirousse1, et al., Biochem. Phannaool. 39·:1109, 1990
Marker? Disease
5429W-21
Adduct
OEdG
EdC
EdA
EdG
Relative Amount T½ Formed I!!
L.iver :1n
100 62 hr
0.3 >,30 days
0.1 >30 days
1 >30 days
Swenbe1rg et al.., "Prog.ress in Predictive Toxicology" pp. 161-184,, 1:990. 1Elsevier Sci .. Pub.
Marker? Disease
Amount of Each Adduct Formed in Rats
5429W-22
Rats exp,osed to 6,00p1p,m VC for 5 ,days
Adduct
0 1EdG
EdG
EdC
EdA
1.6 X 1,Q-4
1.8 X 10.6
9 • .'0 X 11 0,-J
1.,8 X. 110 7
Mol1ar Co,ncentration
Day 7
1.2 X 10-5'
8.4 X 10-7
7 .0 X 10-7
'1.3 X 10.7
4.7 X 10-7
6.7x10-1
0.8 X 101
-
7
Swanberg et ,al. • Pro,gress :in Predictive To,xicology"., pp .. 1161 -184, 1990. El1sevier Sc - Pub
Marker? Disease
Persistence of Adducts in Liver
5429W-23
A,dduct
·OEdG
EdC
Mutation Cau.se,d
none
C-+T C--+A
A-+T Ed'A A-+C
A-+G
EdG G-+.A
Barbin, et al., Cancer Res .. 45: 244,0, 19.85 Barbin, et al., Nucleic Acids ·Res. 9: 375,, 1981 HaU, et al., Ca1rc11no -enes1s 2: 14-11., 1981 Spengler .& Sin:ger, Nucleic Acids Res. 9: 365, 11 981
Marker? Disease
Ability of Adducts to Induce Mutations
5429W-24
Exposure: 600,ppm VC. 4 hr/day for 5 days.
Concentration (M x 10·01
OEdG, EdG EdA EdC
NeiwbQ:m
Liver 162 1.8 0 .18 ,0.9 0 .. 0 1 ·1
Lung 20 0 .. 25 0 .'11 0 .. 2.5 0.010
Kidney 29 0 .31 ND ND 0 .,011
Brain ND ND o,.oG 0~22.
Spleen ND N1D
Adults
Liver 43 0 .47 0 .19 0 ,.80 0 .. 011
tung 20 0.27 0 .. 014
'Kidney ND ND
Fedtke et al ... Ca,cinogenesi's 111: 1287-1292. 1990
Marker? Disease
Relative Amount of VC Adducts in Tissues of Rats
5429W-25
AN MAL STU'DIES HUMAN S,TUD_ES SUSPECT ET OLOGl,C AG,ENTS
Identify and Measure Specd1c Biomarkers
Determine Relationship of 1
Biomarker to Exp,osu:re and Adverse Biologic Effect
-
· Model Intervention
Validated osure Ma
1Measure B iomarker 1
in Exposed People
Transitional Epidemiological Study
Cohort Intervention
Validated Risk Marker
John Groopman 1 SOT. Marth 1994
Marker? Disease
The Validation Process: Confirming the Biomarker Disease Link
5429W-26
Conclusions
· Biomarkers can be valuable for reducing uncertainties in assessing risk for disease from chemical exposures.
· More information is needed on mechanisms of disease induction by chemicals; such studies will suggest the most appropriate biomarkers of the biologically effective dose.
· Much research effort will be required to establish quantitative relationships between the level of markers present and both the degree of prior exposure and the predictability of health outcome.
5429W-27
Criteria Air Pollutants
Two oxidizing agents: Ozone and Nitrogen Dioxide
Ozone
– 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (8-oxodG)
Found in oral swabs, white blood cells and urine
Urinary 8-oxodG results from DNA repair processes
Nonspecific marker of oxidative stress
– Clara cell protein in serum
Reported to be sensitive to as low as 0.060-0.084 ppm ozone
5429W-28
Criteria Air Pollutants (Con’t)
Two oxidizing agents: Ozone and Nitrogen Dioxide
Nitrogen Dioxide
– Can form 8′-nitroguanosine in RNA and 8-nitro-2′-deoxyguanosine in DNA
The latter is unstable
The 8-nitroguaniosine has been used as a marker of endogenous reactive nitrogen species
– Urinary nitrate does not correlate with NO2 exposure
– NO-heme (cannot distinguish between endogenous and exogenous reactive nitrogen)
5429W-29
NO2 Disproportionates in Water
2 NO2 + H2O HNO2 + HNO3
2 HNO2 NO + NO2 + H2O
NO + heme protein
... 7
... 7
.... 7 NO/heme protein
NO/heme complex is detectable by its distinctive ESR signal
5429W-30
►
►
►
A Biological Marker of Exposure to SO2:
S-Sulfonates in Nasal Lavage Fluid
H+ –SO2 + H2O + HSO3
– –HSO3 + –S –S –S–SO3
– ––S–SO3 CN– HSO3
OH
5429W-3
1
V
CO
Carb
oxy h
emo
glo
bin
LeadB
loo
d lead
so
ft tissue lead
Urin
ary Pb
reflect recen
t lead exp
osu
resP
lasma P
b
Bo
ne P
b
Hair P
b
reflect lon
g term
Pb
expo
sures
Teeth
Pb
H2 SN
o b
iom
arker of exp
osu
re fou
nd
5429W-32
Particulate Matter
Carbon elemental organic (including PAH)
Metals
Markers
8-oxod G (in WBC)
1-hydroxy pyrene
Fibrinogen
Platelet counts
Total WBC
Particles in sputum macrophages
5429W-33
Air Toxics
VOCs
· Offer many opportunities for chemical-specific biomarkers of exposures:
– Parent compound or metabolites in blood, urine or exhaled breath
– DNA or protein adducts
· Studies by Albertini on 1,3-butadiene illustrate good transitional study
5429W-34
I
BIOMARKER RES,PONSES IN BUTADIENE- EXPOSED CZECH W·O'RKERS,:
EXPOSURE
EXTENSIVE EXTERNAL, EXPOSURE
ASSESSMENT
A TRANSITIONAL E.PIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY
t+ ,,
INTERNAL DOSE
I
URJN - M1 & M2 MET ABOl!.lliES
____., BIOLOGICALLY EfFECTNE DOSE
l HSIOGLOBIN HBVall & THBVal .ADDUCTS
1---tJ,
,, EA!RLY' I
BIOLOG1CAL
i---+ EFFECTS,
HP.RT MUTATIONS .. Autar.adlo,graphy • Cloning
I
MUTATIONAL SPECTRA CYTOGENETICS
- AbenatilOfla: MSCE - FISH
~LTERED STRUCTIJRE
FUNCTION
DIRECTl:ON' OF VALl1:DATIOiN
M1 :• 1,2:-DlhydrOK~N-acetylc:ysteln,t)-ButeM Ma • 1.ffydro:llCy.2---(N-A.c.tytcysite: n)4)-3-Butane HBVal = N--(2~ydrm:y-3-Butenyl)V lne THBVal • N-(2,311-'.Trlhyd'roxybulyl)Vallne FISH = FluorescenQ In· sit!:, Hybridl'ailon
CYP2E1 = A P450 Enf)TI'le GST 111 Glutatlt ~T,ran1feraae EH • Epoxlde HydroliH ADH • Af.cohol DehydrogeHH
& rt, CILINICAL DISEASE
5429W-35
@ GLUTADHONE CONJUGATES
' IIUCONALDEHYDE
H
◄ [~ --..... _ .. 0
BENZOQU NONE
...
BENZENE OXIDE
OH
... H
HYDROQIHNONE
~
' OH
© PHENOL
I
OH
@(OH
"' CATECHOL
/ GWCURONIDE AND SULFAT!
CONJUGATES
OH
OH
0
H IIUCONIC A.CID
OH
TRIHY:DROXY BENZEN1E
Metabolic Pathway for Benzene
5429W-36
· Metals
– Markers of exposure are the metals in blood, urine, hair and toe or fingernails.
· PAHs
– Urinary 1-hydroxypyrene
– Total bulks DNA adducts by 32P-postlabeling technique
· Dioxin-like compounds
– Compounds in fat
· Mixtures
– Need signature markers for specific sources of pollutants
5429W-37
· Proteomics and Genomics
– Exciting new tools that may provide excellent biomarkers in the future
– Currently we are still learning how to interpret our findings
· Sensitive Subpopulations
– Polymorphisms can be valuable biomarkers
– Examples:
· NA D(P)H: quinone oxidoreductase: enzyme responsible for reducing reactive quinones to less reactive hydroquinones
· Glutathione-S-transferase M1: enzyme required for detoxication of many electrophilic metabolites
· DNA repairs enzyme