bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

13
MINIREVIEW Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials Rute Andre, Muhammad N. Tahir, Filipe Natalio and Wolfgang Tremel Institut fu ¨ r Anorganische Chemie und Analytische Chemie, Johannes Gutenberg-Universita ¨t Mainz, Germany Keywords biomimetic systems; biosilica; functional protein mimics; metal oxides; multifunctional materials; silicatein Correspondence W. Tremel, Institut fu ¨ r Anorganische Chemie und Analytische Chemie, Johannes Gutenberg-Universita ¨t Mainz, Duesbergweg 6, D-55128 Mainz, Germany Fax: +49 6131 39 25605 Tel: +49 6131 39 25135 E-mail: [email protected] Website: http://www.ak-tremel.chemie. uni-mainz.de/ (Received 2 September 2011, revised 19 March 2012, accepted 20 March 2012) doi:10.1111/j.1742-4658.2012.08584.x Owing to their physical and chemical properties, inorganic functional mate- rials have tremendous impacts on key technologies such as energy genera- tion and storage, information, medicine, and automotive engineering. Nature, on the other hand, provides evolution-optimized processes, which lead to multifunctional inorganic–bio-organic materials with complex struc- tures. Their formation occurs under physiological conditions, and is gover- ened by a combination of highly regulated biological processes and intrinsic chemical properties. Nevertheless, insights into the molecular mechanisms of biomineralization open up promising perspectives for bioin- spired and biomimetic design and the development of inorganic–bio- organic multifunctional hybrids. Therefore, biomimetic approaches may disclose new synthetic routes under ambient conditions by integrating the concept of gene-regulated biomineralization principles. The skeletal struc- tures of marine sponges provide an interesting example of biosilicification via enzymatically controlled and gene-regulated silica metabolism. Spicule formation is initiated intracellularly by a fine-tuned genetic mechanism, which involves silica deposition in vesicles (silicassomes) under the control of the enzyme silicatein, which has both catalytic and templating functions. In this review, we place an emphasis on the fabrication of biologically inspired materials with silicatein as a biocatalyst. Introduction In biological mineralizing systems, the formation of inorganic structures occurs in aqueous media at neu- tral pH by a set of biomolecules, such as proteins and polysaccharides. A prototypical case is provided by marine sponges and diatoms [1,2]. The control over mineralization achieved in biological systems has been an inspiration for the development of new synthetic routes to materials of technological interest [3,4]. Organisms are able to synthesize a variety of inorganic materials (calcium carbonate, calcium phosphate, silica, iron oxide, etc.) from simple precursors under mild reaction conditions, resulting in highly complex structures with several levels of hierarchy, ranging from the nano-level to the macro-level [5,6]. These mineralized inorganic–bio-organic composite materials are formed either by controlled condensation in spe- cific compartments or by regulation of the concentra- tion of the inorganic precursors with the help of enzymes. Diatoms [7] sponges [8] and grasses [9] pro- vide classical examples of biosilicification processes Abbreviations SAM, self-assembled monolayer; SEM, scanning electron microscopy; TEM, transmission electron microscopy; TEOS, tetraethoxysilane. FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS 1737

Upload: rute-andre

Post on 28-Sep-2016

218 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

MINIREVIEW

Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic andbio-organic hybrid materialsRute Andre, Muhammad N. Tahir, Filipe Natalio and Wolfgang Tremel

Institut fur Anorganische Chemie und Analytische Chemie, Johannes Gutenberg-Universitat Mainz, Germany

Keywords

biomimetic systems; biosilica; functional

protein mimics; metal oxides;

multifunctional materials; silicatein

Correspondence

W. Tremel, Institut fur Anorganische

Chemie und Analytische Chemie, Johannes

Gutenberg-Universitat Mainz, Duesbergweg

6, D-55128 Mainz, Germany

Fax: +49 6131 39 25605

Tel: +49 6131 39 25135

E-mail: [email protected]

Website: http://www.ak-tremel.chemie.

uni-mainz.de/

(Received 2 September 2011, revised 19

March 2012, accepted 20 March 2012)

doi:10.1111/j.1742-4658.2012.08584.x

Owing to their physical and chemical properties, inorganic functional mate-

rials have tremendous impacts on key technologies such as energy genera-

tion and storage, information, medicine, and automotive engineering.

Nature, on the other hand, provides evolution-optimized processes, which

lead to multifunctional inorganic–bio-organic materials with complex struc-

tures. Their formation occurs under physiological conditions, and is gover-

ened by a combination of highly regulated biological processes and

intrinsic chemical properties. Nevertheless, insights into the molecular

mechanisms of biomineralization open up promising perspectives for bioin-

spired and biomimetic design and the development of inorganic–bio-

organic multifunctional hybrids. Therefore, biomimetic approaches may

disclose new synthetic routes under ambient conditions by integrating the

concept of gene-regulated biomineralization principles. The skeletal struc-

tures of marine sponges provide an interesting example of biosilicification

via enzymatically controlled and gene-regulated silica metabolism. Spicule

formation is initiated intracellularly by a fine-tuned genetic mechanism,

which involves silica deposition in vesicles (silicassomes) under the control

of the enzyme silicatein, which has both catalytic and templating functions.

In this review, we place an emphasis on the fabrication of biologically

inspired materials with silicatein as a biocatalyst.

Introduction

In biological mineralizing systems, the formation of

inorganic structures occurs in aqueous media at neu-

tral pH by a set of biomolecules, such as proteins and

polysaccharides. A prototypical case is provided by

marine sponges and diatoms [1,2]. The control over

mineralization achieved in biological systems has been

an inspiration for the development of new synthetic

routes to materials of technological interest [3,4].

Organisms are able to synthesize a variety of inorganic

materials (calcium carbonate, calcium phosphate,

silica, iron oxide, etc.) from simple precursors under

mild reaction conditions, resulting in highly complex

structures with several levels of hierarchy, ranging

from the nano-level to the macro-level [5,6]. These

mineralized inorganic–bio-organic composite materials

are formed either by controlled condensation in spe-

cific compartments or by regulation of the concentra-

tion of the inorganic precursors with the help of

enzymes. Diatoms [7] sponges [8] and grasses [9] pro-

vide classical examples of biosilicification processes

Abbreviations

SAM, self-assembled monolayer; SEM, scanning electron microscopy; TEM, transmission electron microscopy; TEOS, tetraethoxysilane.

FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS 1737

Page 2: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

whereby complex and unique 3D structures are synthe-

sized even with very low concentrations of silicon pres-

ent in the surrounding environment.

The interest in biosilicification has led to great

efforts to isolate, purify and characterize proteins and

other biomolecules, especially from diatoms and mar-

ine sponges, driving the mild synthetic route of silica

polymerization in vivo. Prominent examples include

long-chain polyamines and sillafins from diatom shells

[10–13], and silicateins from marine sponges [5,14–16].

The formation of silica in these organisms proceeds

through different reaction mechanisms: in diatoms, sil-

ica is deposited passively via electrostatic interactions,

whereas in sponges silica deposition is governed by an

enzymatic process. The formation of silica spicules in

marine sponges is of particular interest, because of

their hierarchical structures and the resulting proper-

ties; that is, the spicules have high mechanical strength

and are excellent optical waveguides. Other examples

are the hexactinellid sponge Euplectella marshalli,

whose skeletal structure is composed of elaborate

cylindrical structures with six hierarchical levels [14],

and the giant basal spicules of Monoraphis chunii (also

a hexactinellid), which can reach a length of up to 3 m

and a thickness of up to 8.5 mm [17].

Nature can easily fabricate hybrid materials under

ambient conditions; these have intricate structures and

more sophisticated combined properties than materials

synthesized in the laboratory, where conventional syn-

thetic methods involve usually high temperatures for

procedures such as thermolysis [18] or sol–gel pro-

cesses combined with subsequent calcination [19].

By emulation of the chemistry behind natural miner-

alization pathways, the known biomineralization agents

might be employed to fabricate materials with non-nat-

ural compositions and a wide spectrum of properties

[20]. Molecules such as silicateins that are involved in

biomineralization have proven to be very versatile:

besides the formation of silica and polysilsesquioxanes

[21–23], these proteins can also catalyze the formation

of diferent metal oxides such as TiO2 [24], ZrO2 [25],

CaTiO3 [26], and GaOH ⁄Ga2O3 [27]. Furthermore, the

materials formed under physiological conditions by

catalysis with silicatein often exhibit crystalline poly-

morphs that normally require high temperatures

[24,27,28] or extreme pH conditions for preparation by

classical synthetic methods [29–31]. Consequently, there

is an ever-growing need to search for new bioinspired

synthetic pathways that allow the formation of materi-

als at low processing temperatures, with a wide range

of properties and compositions and a high level of

structural complexity. In this contribution, we summa-

rize the most important advances regarding the synthe-

sis of new materials by the use of silicatein, taking

advantage of its catalytic versatility. We also emphasize

the formation of oxide thin films with a wide range of

applications by surface-bound silicatein.

Reaction mechanism of silicatein andversatility of the precursors

The isolated biomolecules involved in silica formation,

e.g. silaffins, siladicins, and silicateins, not only show an

accelerated silica polymerization from silica precursors

in vitro, but are also a source of inspiration for the use

of other biomolecules, such as synthetic polyamines,

polypeptides, and a variety of polymers that mimic the

active site of either silaffin or silicatein (e.g diblock co-

polymers) to perform similar tasks [5,11,32–36]. In fact,

these molecules in combination with site-directed muta-

genesis allow the elucidation of a plausible reaction

mechanism. The structures, compositions and molecular

masses of the bioinspired polymers, as well as the experi-

mental conditions used in the laboratory (e.g. buffer

composition and pH), have been shown to significantly

affect the kinetics of the condensation and precipitation

processes, and also the shape of the formed silica col-

loids, which can range from typical spherical shapes to

hexagons or other more complex forms [5,11,32–36].

For bioinspired silaffin-related silicification, the mecha-

nism of silica formation from solutions containing such

additives involves an electrostatic interaction between

positively charged amines and negatively charged silica

precursors, facilitating the passive condensation of silica

around the amine group. Additionally, the molecular

backbone acts as a template for the structure of the

deposited material [12,21,37–39] (for detailed informa-

tion on the chemistry of silica in biomineralized systems,

see [40]).

In contrast, to other organisms that deposit silica in

a passive, template-controlled manner [10–13,32–

36,38,39,41], marine sponges (phylum Porifera) show

the singular ability to actively synthesize their siliceous

skeleton enzymatically [5,7,14–16,21,37,42–46]; silica-

tein-a, silicatein-b, silicatein-c (subunits), silicase and

silintaphin-1 are known representatives of the proteins

responsible for sponge biosilification. These proteins

have been isolated and cloned from different siliceous

sponges (e.g. Tethya aurantium and Suberites domuncu-

la) [7,15,16,37,42–45]. Silicatein-a not only catalyzes

the formation of silica from orthosilicic acid under

in vitro conditions, but can even utilize different

related substrates to produce other metal oxides. This

indicates that silicateins have a relatively flexible active

center, and a very general mechanism can therefore be

assumed to underlie their catalytic activity.

Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials R. Andre et al.

1738 FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS

Page 3: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

The charge density associated with the polarity of the

Si–O–C bonds makes metal alkoxide precursors (e.g. Si,

Ge, Sn, Ti, Zr, and Hf) susceptible to hydrolysis. How-

ever, simple alkoxides such as tetraethoxysilane (TEOS)

do not occur in nature; therefore, other molecules, such

as esters, alcohols, sugars, and catechols, may play an

active role in the transport, storage and sequestration of

silicic acid. It is known that, in both diatoms (silica

deposition vesicles) and marine sponges (silicassomes),

silica is accumulated in intracellular vesicles in higher

concentrations than in those where spontaneous poly-

merization occurs (> 100 p.p.m.) [47]. This suggests

that, parallel with the sequestration ⁄ storage mechanism,

a stabilization process preventing the spontaneous poly-

merization of silica must be active [32,48–50]. Because

of this complex silicon sequestration mechanism, the

natural substrate for silicatein has not been identified

unambiguously, although the most likely candidate

seems to be orthosilicic acid, because of its natural

abundance in seawater. Nevertheless, it has also been

speculated that the in vivo enzymatic function of silica-

tein is the activation of silanol groups (Si–OH bonds) of

silicic acid esters [5,21,46], because there is currently no

evidence to support the in vivo presence of Si–O–C con-

jugates in demosponges or their availability in nature.

Several other silicon alkoxides have been used in vitro

(as synthetic substrates) to assess the intrinsic catalytic

activity of silicatein [51,52]. Interestingly, the enzymatic

hydrolysis and polycondensation could be extended to

various nonbiogenic oxides, starting from the respective

alkoxide precursors.

Typically, the sol–gel synthesis of metal oxides from

the corresponding alkoxides proceeds in two steps: (a)

hydrolysis of a metal alkoxide to yield a metal hydrox-

ide (olation); and (b) polycondensation (oxolation)

through the condensation of two metal hydroxide spe-

cies, with concomitant release of water (oxolation), or

of a metal hydroxide with a metal alkoxide, with

release of alcohol (alkoxolation) [53], leading, ulti-

mately, to an oxide network [54,55]. Depending on the

charge density of the metal and the coordinating

strength of the ligand, the hydrolysis and the polycon-

densation reactions rates vary to a considerable extent;

they can be very fast for sterically less hindered metal

alkoxides. As a result, early transition metals of

groups 4 and 5, such as titanium, zirconium, hafnium,

and niobium, are more prone to nucleophilic attack by

water molecules, whereas silicon alkoxides are more

resistant to nucleophilic substitution by water mole-

cules. Therefore, hydrolysis and polycondensation of

silicon alkoxides must be initiated either by a catalyst

(acid, base, fluoride, or biomolecule) or elevated tem-

peratures [54]. Recombinant and native silicatein-a

were found to be active catalysts for the hydrolysis of

silicon alkoxides to yield biosilica at neutral pH and

ambient temperature [5,21,46].

Synthesis of nonbiological metaloxides with silicatein

As described above, silicatein-a possesses the ability to

catalyze the hydrolysis and condensation of various

metal oxides that do not occur in nature. This nonbio-

logical activity of silicatein can be attributed to the

similarity in size and charge of the electrophilic centers

of the substrate molecules and the steric tolerance of

the silicatein-a active center. One of the most difficult

tasks in demonstrating the catalytic activity of silica-

tein-a towards nonbiological metal oxides is the choice

of suitable precursor compounds, because most metal

alkoxides are very unstable and will spontaneously

react with water at room temperature to form an

amorphous metal oxide precipitate [53–55], precluding

their use as silicatein-a precursors. For titania, this

problem could be circumvented by using titanium

bis(ammonium lactato) dihydroxide as a water-stable,

alkoxide-like precursor [23], whereas for zirconia and

tin dioxide, the hexafluoro complexes (ZrF2�6 and

SnF2�6 ) proved to be suitable choices [56,57]. The ener-

getics imposed by the surface and bulk lattice energies

lead to the formation of metastable polymorphs whose

synthesis under standard conditions would require high

temperatures or extreme pH conditions. The mobility

of the reactant atoms at ambient temperatures prevents

the formation of well-crystallized products, yielding

nanocrystalline or partially amorphous compounds

(e.g. rutile-TiO2 and c-Ga2O3) [26,58] with reduced free

surface area, owing to particle aggregation. The forma-

tion of stabilized amorphous or nanocrystalline phases

for structural purposes is favored from a biological

perspective [10,58].

Native silicatein filaments can catalyze and template

the in vitro formation of nanocrystalline gallium oxohy-

droxide (GaOOH) and the spinel polymorph of gallium

oxide (c-Ga2O3), using stable gallium nitrate as precur-

sor [26]. Gallium (Ga3+), like its Al3+ congener, is an

example of aquo acid formation; that is, at neutral pH,

the [Ga(H2O)6]3+ hexaaquo complex predominates,

whereas in acidic or basic solution, protonation ⁄depro-tonation reactions lead to the formation of unstable

aquo ⁄hydroxo complexes such as [Ga(H2O)6 )

n(OH)n](3 ) n)+ [48–50,59,60]. Consequently, in acidic

media, the condensation of hydrolyzed Ga3+ will pro-

ceed via either olation or oxolation [53].

In contrast, under neutral pH conditions or in the

presence of thermally denatured protein filaments, no

R. Andre et al. Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials

FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS 1739

Page 4: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

hydrolysis of [Ga(H2O)6]3+ occurred. However, upon

incubation of gallium nitrate with protein filaments,

nanocrystalline GaOOH was formed [60]. Moreover,

when lower Ga3+ concentrations were present, silica-

tein-mediated hydrolysis of gallium nitrate yielded

nanocrystalline spinel-type gallium oxide (c-Ga2O3) as

the kinetically preferred product. Electron diffraction

analysis showed that, in both cases, the nanocrystals

formed via the silicatein-mediated route exhibit a pre-

ferred orientation relative to the axis of the main pro-

tein filament. This suggests that, in the case of

c-Ga2O3, the protein filaments are responsible not only

for catalyzing the hydrolysis of the water-stable gal-

lium nitrate precursor ([Ga(H2O)6]3+) and inducing

the crystallization of the spinel oxide, but also for

influencing the preferred pseudo-oriented crystal

growth relative to the protein.

From a materials science perspective, perovskites

with a generic structure ABO3 drawn from a range of

metals, subject to certain size constraints, represent a

very flexible system. The range of possible cationic

substitutions is limited only by constraints on thermo-

dynamic stability, as represented in terms of the

Goldschmidt factor. The perovskite structure can toler-

ate significant nonstoichiometry and partial substitu-

tion. Its compositional variability is linked directly to

its physical properties, including ferroelectric, dielec-

tric, pyroelectric, piezoelectric, ferromagnetic ⁄ ferrimag-

netic, electrically (super)conducting or catalytic

behavior [50,61]. The different physical properties of

perovskite-phase materials are related to their phase

transitions, which in turn are sensitive to variables

such as chemical composition, purity, numbers of sur-

face and bulk defects, grain size, and sintering condi-

tions. Hence, the control of these parameters is critical

for effective property control. The methods for synthe-

sizing perovskites with an ABO3 generic structure are

far from the physiological conditions. However,

sponge filaments isolated from T. aurantium are able

to template barium titanium oxyfluoride (BaTiOF4) as

dispersed florets of nanocrystals [62]. Unlike previous

silicatein-catalyzed reactions involving the formation

of silica, titania, or gallium oxide, the synthesis of

BaTiOF4 required a cofactor, H3BO3, which was pro-

posed to scavenge excess fluoride ions generated by the

hydrolysis of the BaTiF6 precursor [58].

Deposition of thin films withsurface-bound recombinant silicatein

For many applications, it is necessary to synthesize

thin films of metal oxides on solid surfaces rather than

in solution, with simultaneous control of the pattern

and shape of the deposited inorganic materials over

more than the micrometer scale. However, the chemi-

cally driven deposition of uniform silica coatings on

solid surfaces has not been achieved under ambient

conditions, despite many potential applications for

such materials in sensors [63], membranes, and struc-

tural materials [64]. With, again, nature as inspiration,

metal oxide thin films on solid supports could be pre-

pared by immobilizing silicatein-a and making use of

its catalytic properties. Moreover, the creation of silica

patterned thin films by the use of immobilized poly-

peptides and polyamines that act as templates has been

reported with several methods, such as electrostatic

deposition [65,66], direct write assembly [67], holo-

graphic patterning [68], photolithography [67], and sur-

face-initiated polymerization [69]. However, this

approach is beyond the scope of this review.

Silicatein-a was immobilized on various inorganic

substrates with His-tags, Glu-tags, and Cys-tags.

Initially, the immobilization and activity of surface-

bound recombinant silicatein-a containing a His-tag

(His6 additional sequence) was demonstrated on solid

supports by the formation of heterogeneous silica, tita-

nia and zirconia films [60,70,71]. In the initial experi-

ments, silicatein-a was immobilized on self-assembled

monolayers (SAMs) on Au(111) surfaces by use of a ni-

trilotriacetic acid-terminated organic thiol (Fig. 1A).

The thiol binds to the gold surface, and the nitrilotri-

acetic acid terminus remains free for Ni2+ and His-tag

protein complexation [72]. The kinetics of the SAM

deposition of the nitrilotriacetic acid organic thiol, the

subsequent chelation of Ni2+ and the anchoring of sili-

catein were monitored by surface plasmon resonance

spectroscopy and atomic force microscopy. The hydro-

lytic activity of surface-bound silicatein-a was con-

firmed by the formation of a thin layer of silica (SiO2,

surface coverage � 70% with TEOS as a metal alkox-

ide precursor; Fig. 1B–D). The nitrilotriacetic acid–

Ni2+ linker group selectively binds to the His-tag of

the recombinant protein, thereby providing a controlled

spatial orientation. These factors (linker and well-

defined spatial orientation) are of major importance for

the catalytic activity of a surface-bound enzyme, which

is constrained by: (a) the accessibility of the active site

of the enzyme to the substrate; and (b) protein folding

(e.g. denaturation). In an alternative biomimetic silicifi-

cation approach – based on kinetically controlled cata-

lytic hydrolysis and polycondensation – synthetic

analogs of the active site of the enzyme were immobi-

lized on surfaces. Therefore, attempts were made to

anchor recombinant silicatein-a (His-tagged) on gold

surfaces with a reactive ester polymer [59] (Fig. 1E).

After protein complexation, the film thickness increased

Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials R. Andre et al.

1740 FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS

Page 5: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

by 3.4 nm, which is close to the theoretical diameter of

the 24-kDa silicatein-a. This was confirmed by a posi-

tive cross-reaction between polyclonal antibodies raised

against silicatein-a and the surface, which was observed

by confocal laser microscopy (Fig. 1F). The catalytic

activity was verified by the formation of 50–60-nm lay-

ered particles of TiO2 and a thin film of cubic ZrO2 (an

unusual ZrO2 polymorph, in particular at ambient

reaction conditions) on surface-bound silicatein-a, withtitanium bis(ammonium lactato) dihydroxide and hexa-

fluoro-zirconate (ZrF2�6 ) as stable nonbiological precur-

sors (Fig. 1G,H).

Tin dioxide (SnO2) is a well-studied semiconductor.

Of particular interest are SnO2-coated glass surfaces,

A

E

Nitrilotriacetic acidNitrilotriacetic acid Nitrilotriacetic acid

Nitrilotriacetic acidNitrilotriacetic acid

F G H

B C D

Fig. 1. Biocatalytic activity of surface-bound silicatein-a immobilized with nitrilotriacetic acid-based ligands. (A) Chemical structure of nitrilotri-

acetic acid-terminated alkanethiol used as a SAM to immobilize His-tagged silicatein-a to gold (111) surfaces. (B–D) SEM images of silicatiza-

tion onto surfaces functionalized with nitrilotriacetic acid alkanethiol without Ni2+ (A) and nitrilotriacetic acid alkanethiol with Ni2+ chelating

silicatein (B, C). No observable formation of SiO2 occurred on nitrilotriacetic acid alkanethiol-modified surfaces (A). In contast, Ni2+-chelated

silicatein immobilization onto nitrilotriacetic acid alkanethiol surfaces induced the formation of SiO2. (E) Schematic representation of the

immobilization of His-tagged silicatein-a via a SAM. Silicatein-a was immobilized by tailoring the Au(111) surface by using: (a) cysteamine

SAMs; (b) reactive ester polymer that was covalently bound to the amine head group of cysteamine; (c) and nitrilotriacetic acid molecules

that were further immobilized by using the remaining reactive ester group present in the backbone of the polymer. (F) Confocal laser scan-

ning microscopy images of immunodetection of immobilized silicatein-a with polyclonal antibodies raised against silicatein-a (PoAb-SILA).

(G, H) High-resolution SEM images of TiO2 and ZrO2 formed by catalysis with surface-bound silicatein.

R. Andre et al. Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials

FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS 1741

Page 6: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

because they form the basis for transparent semicon-

ductors. These SnO2-coated surfaces were obtained by

immobilizing silicatein-a (His-tagged) on glass, as con-

firmed by a positive cross-reaction with antibodies

(Fig. 2A). The catalytic activity was demonstrated by

the formation of a dense film of SnO2, by use of a

water-stable tin precursor (Na2SnF6), with surface-

bound silicatein-a at neutral pH and room temperature

[57] (Fig. 2B). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM)

analysis of the surface showed that the film was com-

posed of spherical SnO2 agglomerates with an average

size of 50 nm that, in turn, were composed of smaller

particles (between 2 and 5 nm) (Fig. 2C). This mor-

phology of the product can be rationalized as arising

from a templating effect of the protein agglomerates

[43,57]. Crystallographic analysis of the nanodomains

showed the presence of cassiterite-type SnO2, the poly-

morph selection being independent of the reaction

parameters. At the macroscopic level, the transparency

of the glass slides was maintained after catalytic depo-

sition of SnO2 (both for visible and for UV light),

making both functionalization and surface coating a

facile approach for the production of new materials

with better performance (Fig. 2D,E).

In a similar manner, silica-coated magnetic nanopar-

ticles c-Fe2O3@SiO2 could be fabricated [73]. For this

purpose, His-tagged silicatein-a was immobilized on

c-Fe2O3 nanoparticles functionalized with a nitrilotri-

acetic acid-containing polymeric ligand and by making

use of the efficient chelating properties of Ni2+. The

particle-bound silicatein-a was shown to be active for

catalyzing and structurally directing the deposition of

a protective biosilica shell around the magnetic oxide

nanoparticles.

This convenient surface modification strategy based

on a multifunctional nitrilotriacetic acid-containing

polymeric ligand could be generalized. His-tagged silica-

tein-a was immobilized on the highly hydrophobic sur-

face of WS2 nanotubes, which – in turn – made WS2highly water-soluble (Fig. 3A) [74]. The protein binding

was confirmed by scanning force microscopy. The activ-

ity of WS2 surface-bound silicatein-a was demonstrated

by the formation of a dense and hydrophilic TiO2 coat-

ing on hydrophobic WS2 surfaces (Fig. 3B). High-reso-

lution transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images

showed nanocrystalline domains with a fringe spacing

of 0.32 nm, which is close to the (110) lattice spacing of

rutile-type TiO2 (Fig. 3C).

A B C

D E

Fig. 2. Enzymatic formation of SnO2 by silicatein-a immobilized on glass surfaces. (A) Structural and schematic representation of functional-

ization of glass slides with His-tagged silicatein-a. The surfaces were first treated with a epoxide-terminated silicane, which reacted further

with amine-terminated nitrilotriacetic acid, allowing binding of silicatein-a through Ni2+ complexation. (B) SEM overview image of the homo-

geneous deposition of SnO2. (C) Higher-resolution SEM image, showing the sphere-like SnO2 particles with average size of 50 nm. (D) UV–

visible transmittance of glass slides before (dashed line) and after (bold line) SnO2 functionalization. (E) Optical images of glass slides before

and after silicatein ⁄ SnO2 functionalization. Almost no color change was detected after functionalization with protein and SnO2 deposition,

and the glass slides remained transparent in the visible range.

Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials R. Andre et al.

1742 FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS

Page 7: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

Whereas most of the above examples rely on the

hydrolytic abilities of silicatein-a, its (nonphysiological)reductive properties can be utilized for the fabrication

of unusual structured composites. This was demon-

strated by biofunctionalizing TiO2 nanowires [75], first

with a bifunctional polymeric ligand containing pen-

dant catechol moieties (specific anchor groups for

metal oxides) and nitrilotriacetic acid functionalities

(complexation with Ni2+), and then with recombinant

His-tagged silicatein-a, which allowed the subsequent

silicatein-mediated growth of gold nanocrystallites on

the TiO2 surface with AuCl4– as precursor [71,76]

(Fig. 3D). The reductive properties of TiO2-supported

recombinant silicatein-a were attributed to free thiols

present in the protein [17]. Moreover, the nanocrystals

possess an unusual S3 symmetry axis, which suggests

chiral induction from the protein to the triangular-

shaped nanocrystals (Fig. 3E,F).

In order to expand the affinity of silicatein-a to

other solid supports and to simultaneously reduce the

number of reaction steps, new tags were introduced

during protein expression. For example, silicatein-acontaining a Glu-tag (Glu8) in its C-terminus was

developed, allowing specific immobilization on

hydroxyapatite [77]. Comparative studies of the

strengths of adhesion of silicatein-a and Glu-tagged

silicatein-a to hydroxyapatite showed that the addi-

tional Glu-rich sequence is, indeed, required for a

strong binding affinity ⁄ interaction. Its potential appli-

cation in dentistry was explored; that is, the treatment

of dentin tubules with Glu-tagged silicatein-a and

exposure to a silica source (sodium metasilicate was

used, owing to its negligible toxicity) led to tubule

occlusion, suggesting that this integration of protein

into toothpastes can reduce significantly hypersensitiv-

ity. The modes of binding of Glu functional groups

to calcium surfaces can be extrapolated to metal oxi-

des in general (Fig. 4A). Here Glu-tagged silicatein-awas used to functionalize TiO2 nanowires, thereby

avoiding the other additional functionalization steps

required for protein immobilization. The protein

could be detected with antibodies raised against silica-

tein-a, and its activity in the formation of SiO2 and

ZrO2 was confirmed, allowing the formation of core-

shell structures [78] (Fig. 4E,F). It may be expected

that this method can be generalized for other metal

oxide surfaces, and the possible development of other

material-specific tags would allow the synthesis of a

wide range of nanocomposite materials under physio-

logical conditions.

A B C

D E F

Fig. 3. Immobilization of silicatein on different nanostructured surfaces. (A) Digital photographs of WS2 nanotube dispersions before (left)

and after (right) functionalization with silicatein-a, showing the change in hydrophilicity of the functionalized material. (B) SEM image showing

the deposition of TiO2 in the WS2 nanotubes, catalyzed by silicatein-a. (C) High-resolution TEM image showing the interface between the

WS2 nanotube surface and the newly formed TiO2 layer, where crystalline domains are visible, corresponding to the rutile phase of titania.

(D) Schematic representation of polymer ⁄ silicatein-a-functionalized TiO2 nanowires with deposited gold nanoparticles. (E) TEM overview of

TiO2 nanowires covered with gold nanocrystallites, catalyzed by silicatein-a. (F) High-resolution TEM image of the gold nanocrystals.

R. Andre et al. Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials

FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS 1743

Page 8: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

Complex mineralization matrixes –silicatein interactors

The axial filament of spicules is composed of several

different biomolecules with different properties and

functions (see acompaning minireviews for more

detailed information). Silicateins are the main proteins

responsible for silica polymerization, but, recently,

another group of proteins – silintaphins – were discov-

ered that interact strongly with silicatein. It was shown

that both proteins could be colocalized in the spicule

filaments and – when incubated together – they tended

to assemble in a stoichiometric manner and to form fil-

amentous aggregates [77,79]. The role of silintaphin-1

in the activity of silicatein was also explored. For pro-

teins present in a 4 : 1 ratio (silicatein ⁄ silintaphin),maximum polymerization of SiO2 from TEOS was

observed. The use of silintaphin-1 was shown to affect

assembly of the synthetic materials. For example, when

c-Fe2O3 nanoparticles functionalized with polymeric

ligand carrying silicatein-a on its surface were coincu-

bated with silintaphin-1, needle-like spicules with

lengths of up to hundreds of nanometers, with clear-

cut edges, were formed by the assembly of the nano-

particles [77]. The interaction between the proteins was

also confirmed by exposing silintaphin-1 to TiO2 nano-

wires functionalized with silicatein-a. Both proteins

could be colocalized by immunostaining, and the

organic matrix proved to remain active for the forma-

tion of SiO2 and ZrO2 (Fig. 4B–D). It was observed

that, in the presence of both proteins, higher amounts

of SiO2 and ZrO2 were deposited, resulting in a thicker

layer than obtained with nanowire surfaces carrying

only silicatein [78] (Fig. 4E–H). This phenomenon

points to the importance of complex matrices in bio-

mineralization mimetics, where increasing the complex-

ity of the organic matrix can lead to fine-tuning of the

produced materials.

Silicatein synthesis ofpolysesquioxanes

Polysilsesquioxanes (RSiO1.5)n are organic silica ana-

logs in which each silicon center in the network pos-

sesses at least one Si–C bond [80]. Silicones have

found a wide range of commercial and technological

applications. Polysilsesquioxanes are formed by hydro-

lytic condensation of organosilane precursors (RSiX3,

where R = an organic functionality and X = alkox-

ide, amide, halide, etc.) under acidic or basic condi-

tions, and often at elevated temperatures [81].

Silicatein-a can catalyze the in vitro condensation of

A

B C D

E G

F H

Fig. 4. Glu-tagged silicatein-a immobilization on metal oxide surfaces and its interaction with silintaphin-1. (A) Schematic representation of

the possible modes of binding of the Glu domains to TiO2 surfaces, or other metal oxides in general. The Glu-tag in the recombinant silica-

tein-a consists of a Glu8 domain in the C-terminal region of the protein. (B–D) Atomic force microscopy phase-contrast images of (B) bare

TiO2 nanowires, (C) Glu-tagged silicatein-a and (D) Glu-tagged silicatein-a ⁄ silintaphin-1-functionalized TiO2 nanowires. It is possible to observe

that: (a) the Glu-tagged silicatein-a binds directly to the metal oxide surface; and (b) the increase of organic matrix is evident when both pro-

teins are incubated together, indicating their strong affinity. (E–H) Formation of SiO2 (E, G) or ZrO2 (F, H) by Glu-tagged silicatein-a (E, F) and

by Glu-tagged silicatein-a ⁄ silintaphin-1 (G, H). An evident increase in the formation of SiO2 or ZrO2 is observed when both proteins are on

the surface of TiO2 nanowires.

Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials R. Andre et al.

1744 FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS

Page 9: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

alkoxysilanes during a phase transfer reaction at neu-

tral pH and ambient temperature to yield silicones

[5,21,46], as confirmed by 29Si-NMR analysis. In the

absence of silicatein-a, the alkoxysilane monomer pre-

cursor was hydrolyzed only to a negligible extent.

Highly substituted precursor compounds (e.g. pheny-

lated alkoxides) blocked the polymerization reaction

completely.

Although these substrates (e.g. polysilsesquioxanes)

possessing Si–C bonds are nonbiological substrates for

silicatein-a that do not occur in nature, the Si–C bonds

do not influence the silicatein-catalyzed formation of

polysilsesquioxanes. As shown by 29Si magic angle

spinning NMR spectroscopy, only silicon centers car-

rying organic groups with varying degrees of steric

crowding and electron withdrawing and donating

properties (e.g. phenyltriethoxysilane and methyltrieth-

oxysilane) seem to affect the catalysis. More recently,

other functional polysilsesquioxanes have been pro-

duced, with silicatein-a as catalyst, further demonstrat-

ing the tolerance of the enzyme for nonbiogenic

precursors.

Organic substrates for silicatein-a

Interestingly, the catalytic activity of silicatein-a with

respect to hydrolytic ⁄polymerization reactions is not

restricted to inorganic oxides. It was extended for

organic polymers as well, by the generation of

poly(lactic acid) from a cyclic precursor (l-lactide)

through a biocatalytically controlled ring opening

polymerization mechanism. The enzyme acts a catalyst

rather than a ring opening polymerization initiator,

and was found to be adsorbed to the surfaces of the

axial filaments rather than covalently bound [82].

Synthetic analogs of silicatein-a

One of the limitations of the protein-catalyzed syn-

thetic systems is that – in general – only low concen-

trations of the proteins are available from natural

sources (e.g. spicules) or as products of laboratory

genetic manipulation [21,46]. However, in recent years,

numerous strategies have been introduced to mimic

bioinspired catalysts, such as silicatein from sponges

and silaffins from diatoms. Organic templates such as

polymers [83,84], polymer–peptide hybrids [85,86],

diblock copolypeptides [27], self-assembling peptides

[87–91] and cationic peptide amphiphiles [92] were

used to promote sol–gel condensation of silica and

other inorganic precursors. Template sol–gel processes

yield hybrid materials with a wide range of different

morphologies that are strongly influenced by factors

such as temperature, concentration, and the pH of the

reaction medium [93].

The successful application of polymeric and surface-

functionalized silicatein-a mimics had indicated that

even simple bifunctional compounds might act as func-

tional analogs of the silicatein-a active site for hydro-

lytic catalysis, as confirmed by use of a series of small

molecules with a nucleophilic terminus (e.g. –OH,

–SH, and –SC2H5) and a hydrogen bond acceptor (e.g.

a primary or tertiary amine) at the other end [94]. In

the absence of catalyst, TEOS mixed with the buffered

aqueous solution remained stable for several days.

Cysteamine (followed by ethanolamine) promoted the

highest yield of silica condensation. This result is con-

sistent with previous results obtained with synthetic

block copolypeptides and with the observation that

proteases possessing Cys residues in the catalytic triad

are enzymatically more active than proteases that con-

tain Ser residues instead [14,88].

These nucleophilic and basic functionalities (which

influence the catalytic formation of silica) are not

required to be part of a single molecule or a polymer;

they may be different molecules functionalized ⁄ chemi-

sorbed separately onto different active surfaces. This

was demonstrated for a synthetic system where an

appropriate nucleophilic function (e.g. hydroxyl) and

nitrogen bases (e.g. imidazole) were immobilized onto

two populations of gold nanoparticles (as carriers) via

self-assembled monolayers of x-functionalized organic

thiols [95]. The mechanistic assumption of the nano-

particle-bound system is that, when two nanoparticles

with different functionalities come close enough to

allow hydrogen bonding (e.g. 2–3 A), an active catalyst

is formed. This would correspond to the interaction of

a hydroxyl group from Ser and the imidazole group

from His (separation � 2 A), which is essential for

promoting silica alkoxide hydrolysis, i.e. for cleaving

the silicic ester bonds. Little or no hydrolysis occurred

when: (a) only one type of functional nanoparticle

were present; (b) either class of functional nanoparticle

was replaced with a noninteracting molecule; or (c) un-

functionalized gold nanoparticles were used.

The awareness that silica can be catalyzed efficiently

by cysteamine led to useful, convenient and low-cost

encapsulation of biological materials, such as enzymes,

antibodies, and cells, that otherwise might be damaged

by exposure to the acid, base, or heat [96]. This was

shown elegantly by encapsulating blue fluorescent pro-

tein and live Escherichia coli cells expressing green

fluorescent protein with cysteamine in 2D micropat-

terned matrices. The 2D micropatterned matrices

(obtained by microcontact printing of live cells

expressing green fluorescent protein or a solution of

R. Andre et al. Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials

FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS 1745

Page 10: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

blue fluorescent protein mixed with the silica precursor

and cysteamine) displayed stable and active fluores-

cence, confirming that the encapsulation with cyste-

amine was successful in maintaining the activity of the

biological materials, and that this method could there-

fore potentially be extended to the encapsulation and

micropatterning of a whole host of live cells, enzymes,

antibodies, receptors, and fluorescent and other func-

tional proteins [97].

Conclusion

The discovery that silicatein-a from demosponges can

act as a hydrolytic enzyme and – in the form of natu-

ral filaments – as a template for biosilicification has

inspired the development of new synthetic methods for

bioinspired material synthesis. The key aspects are:

(a) the kinetically controlled, catalytic hydrolysis of

molecular precursors; and (b) the templated polycon-

densation and growth of metal oxides on the surface

of the silicatein filament. The steric tolerance of the

active site of silicatein allows translation of the basic

chemical principles of silicatein-mediated catalysis and

growth to a range of nonbiological chemical substrates

that are not found in the biosphere. This review has

highlighted some examples of silicatein-inspired, low-

temperature fabrication of materials and some bioin-

spired methods that do not even require biocatalysts

or organic templates for making a wide range of

advanced nanostructured and microstructured

materials.

The next generation of methods for the fabrication

of bioinspired materials must begin to draw inspiration

from complex biological systems in which the con-

certed action of several components produces sol-

ids ⁄biomaterials, which, of course, must increase the

complexity of the synthetic analog. If this can be

accomplished, a higher degree of structural complexity

and precision may be possible. This may involve the

use of genetically manipulated proteins that are capa-

ble of building complex 2D or 3D structures via bot-

tom-up processes. Cloned biomolecules acting as

mineralization templates, e.g. spider silk proteins and

their mutants, could be employed for 3D assembly of

nanofibers, or film and foam formation. Existing

cloned peptides and proteins could be genetically opti-

mized for building up such 3D structures.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by grants from the Bundes-

ministerium fur Bildung und Forschung Germany

(project ‘Center of Excellence BIOTECmarin’), the

Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, and the European

Commission (Biomintec).

References

1 Bauerlein E, Behrens P & Epple M (2007) Handbook of

Biomineralization, 1st edn. Wiley-VCH, Weinheim.

2 Mann S, Archibald DD, Didymus JM, Douglas T,

Heywood BR, Meldrum FC & Reeves NJ (1993) Crys-

tallization at inorganic–organic interfaces: biominerals

and biomimetic synthesis. Science 261, 1286–1292.

3 Lakes RS (1993) Materials with structural hierarchy.

Nature 361, 511–515.

4 Douglas T (2003) A bright bio-inspired future. Science

299, 1192–1193.

5 Shimizu K, Cha J, Stucky GD & Morse DE (1998) Sili-

catein-a: cathepsin L-like protein in sponge biosilica.

Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95, 6234–6238.

6 Brutchey RL & Morse DE (2008) Silicatein and the

translation of its molecular mechanism of biosilicifica-

tion into low temperature nanomaterial synthesis. Chem

Rev 108, 4915–4934.

7 Wetherbee R (2002) The diatom glasshouse. Science

298, 547.

8 Schroder HC, Wang X, Tremel W, Ushijima H &

Muller WEG (2008) Biofabrication of biosilica-glass by

living organisms. Nat Prod Rep 25, 455–474.

9 Lux A, Luxova M, Morita S, Abe J & Inanaga S

(1999) Endodermal silicification in developing seminal

roots of lowland and upland cultivars of rice (Oryza

sativa L). Can J Bot 77, 955–960.

10 Kroger N & Poulsen N (2008) Diatoms – from cell wall

biogenesis to nanotechnology. Annu Rev Genet 42, 83–

107.

11 Kroger N, Deutzmann R & Sumper M (1999) Polycat-

ionic peptides from diatom biosilica that direct silica

nanosphere formation. Science 286, 1129–1132.

12 Kroger N, Deutzmann R, Bergsdorf C & Sumper M

(2000) Species-specific polyamines from diatoms control

silica morphology. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97, 14133–

14138.

13 Kroger N, Lorenz S, Brunner E & Sumper M (2002)

Self-assembly of highly phosphorylated silaffins and

their function in biosilica morphogenesis. Science 298,

584–586.

14 Aizenberg J, Weaver JC, Thanawala MS, Sundar VC,

Morse DE & Fratzl P (2005) Skeleton of Euplectella

sp.: structural hierarchy from the nanoscale to the mac-

roscale. Science 309, 275–278.

15 Foo CWP, Huang J & Kaplan DL (2004) Lessons from

seashells: silica mineralization via protein templating.

Trends Biotechnol 22, 577–585.

16 Cha JN, Shimizu K, Zhou Y, Christiansen SC, Chm-

elka BF, Stucky GD & Morse DE (1999) Silicatein fila-

ments and subunits from a marine sponge direct the

Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials R. Andre et al.

1746 FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS

Page 11: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

polymerization of silica and silicones in vitro. Proc Natl

Acad Sci USA 96, 361–365.

17 Wang X, Schloßmacher U, Wiens M, Batel R, Schroder

HC & Muller WEG (2012) Silicateins, silicatein interac-

tors, and cellular interplay in sponge skeletogenesis:

formation of glass fiber-like spicules. FEBS J 279,

1721–1736.

18 Bill J & Aldinger F (1995) Precursor-derived covalent

ceramics. Adv Mater 7, 775–787.

19 Segal D (1989) Chemical Synthesis of Advanced Ceramic

Materials. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

20 Dickerson MB, Sandhage KH & Naik RR (2008) Pro-

tein- and peptide-directed syntheses of inorganic materi-

als. Chem Rev 108, 4935–4978.

21 Zhou Y, Shimizu K, Cha JN, Stucky GD & Morse DE

(1999) Efficient catalysis of polysiloxane synthesis by

silicatein-a requires specific hydroxyl and imidazole

functionalities. Angew Chem Int Ed 38, 779–782.

22 Wolf SE, Schloßmacher U, Pietuch A, Mathiasch B,

Schroder HC, Muller WEG & Tremel W (2010) Forma-

tion of silicones mediated by sponge enzyme silicatein-

a. Dalton Trans 39, 9245–9249.

23 Sumerel JL, Yang W, Kisailus D, Weaver J, Choi JH &

Morse DE (2003) Biocatalytic structure-directing

synthesis of titanium dioxide. Chem Mater 15, 4804–

4809.

24 Tahir MN, Theato P, Muller WEG, Schroder HC,

Boreijko A, Faiß S, Janshoff A, Huth J & Tremel W

(2005) Formation of layered titania and zirconia cata-

lyzed by surface-bound silicatein. Chem Commun 28,

5533–5535.

25 Ould-Ely T, Luger M, Kaplan-Reinig L, Niesz K,

Doherty M & Morse DE (2011) Large-scale engineered

synthesis of BaTiO3 nanoparticles using low-tempera-

ture bioinspired principles. Nat Protoc 6, 97–104.

26 Kisailus D, Choi JH, Weaver JC, Yang W & Morse

DE (2005) Enzymatic synthesis and nanostructural con-

trol of gallium oxide at low temperature. Adv Mater 17,

314–318.

27 Cha JN, Stucky GA, Morse DE & Deming TE (2000)

Biomimetic synthesis of ordered silica structures by

block copolypeptides. Nature 403, 289–292.

28 Mueller WEG, Wang XH, Kropf K, Ushijima H,

Geurtsen W, Eckert C, Tahir MN, Tremel W, Bore-

iko A, Schlossmacher U et al. (2008) Bioorganic ⁄ inor-ganic hybrid composition of sponge spicules: matrix

of the giant spicules and of the comitalia of the deep

sea hexactinellid Monorhaphis. J Struct Biol 161,

188–203.

29 Jovilet JP (2000) Metal Oxide Chemistry and Synthesis:

From Solution to Solid State. Wiley, New York.

30 Ovenstone J & Yanagisawa K (1999) Effect of hydro-

thermal treatment of amorphous titania on the phase

change from anatase to rutile during calcination. Chem

Mater 11, 2770–2774.

31 Roy R, Hill VG & Osborn EF (1952) Polymorphism of

Ga2O3 and the system Ga2O3–H2O. J Am Chem Soc 74,

719–722.

32 Menzel H, Horstmann S, Behrens P, Barnreuther P,

Krueger I & Jahns M (2003) Chemical properties of

polyamines with relevance to the biomineralization of

silica. Chem Commun 24, 2994–2995.

33 Annenkov VV, Patwardhan SV, Belton D, Danilovtseva

EN & Perry CC (2006) A new stepwise synthesis of a

family of propylamines derived from diatom silaffins

and their activity in silicification. Chem Commun 14,

1521–1523.

34 Bellomo EG & Deming TJ (2006) Monoliths of aligned

silica-polypeptide hexagonal platelets. J Am Chem Soc

128, 2276–2279.

35 Belton DJ, Patwardhan SV, Annenkov VV, Danilovts-

eva EN & Perry CC (2008) From biosilicification to tai-

lored materials: optimizing hydrophobic domains and

resistance to protonation of polyamines. Proc Natl Acad

Sci USA 105, 5963–5968.

36 Spinde K, Kammer M, Freyer K, Ehrlich H, Vournakis

JN & Brunner E (2011) Biomimetic silicification of

fibrous chitin from diatoms. Chem Mater 23, 2973–2978.

37 Muller WEG, Schroder HC, Lorenz B & Krasko A

(2001) Silicatein-mediated synthesis of amorphous sili-

cates and siloxanes and use thereof. US Patent 7169589.

38 Sumper M & Kroger NJ (2004) Silica formation in dia-

toms: the function of long-chain polyamines and silaf-

fins. J Mater Chem 14, 2059–2065.

39 Kent MS, Murton JK, Zendejas FJ, Tran H, Simmons

BA, Sajita S & Kuzmenko I (2009) Nanosilica forma-

tion at lipid membranes induced by the parent sequence

of a silaffin peptide. Langmuir 25, 305–310.

40 Belton DJ, Deschaume O & Perry CC (2012) An over-

view of the fundamentals of the chemistry of silica with

relevance to biosilicification and technological advances

using silica. FEBS J 279, 1710–1720.

41 Muller WEG, Belikov SI, Tremel W, Schloßmacher U,

Natoli A, Brandt D, Boreiko A, Tahir MN, Muller IM

& Schroder HC (2007) Formation of siliceous spicules

in demosponges: example Suberites domuncula. In

Handbook of Biomineralization, Vol. 1 (Bauerlein E ed.),

pp. 59–82. Wiley-VCH, Weinheim.

42 Martin-Jezequel V, Hildebrand M & Brzezinski MA

(2000) Silicon metabolism in diatoms: implications for

growth. J Phycol 36, 821–840.

43 Muller WEG, Belikov SI, Tremel W, Gamulin V, Perry

CC, Boreiko A & Schroder HC (2006) Siliceous spicules

in marine demosponges (example Suberites domuncula).

Micron 37, 107–120.

44 Krasko A, Lorenz B, Batel R, Schroder HC, Muller IM

& Muller WEG (2000) Expression of silicatein and col-

lagen genes in the marine sponge Suberites domuncula

is controlled by silicate and myotrophin. Eur J Biochem

267, 4878–4887.

R. Andre et al. Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials

FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS 1747

Page 12: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

45 Schroder HC, Boreiko A, Korzhev M, Krasko A, Tahir

MN, Tremel W, Eckert C, Muller IM & Muller WEG

(2006) Co-expression and functional interaction of

silicatein with galectin: approach to understand shape

formation of siliceous spicules in the marine demo-

sponge Suberites domuncula. J Biol Chem 281, 12001–

12009.

46 Muller WEG, Eckert C, Kropf K, Wang X, Schloßm-

acher U, Seckert C, Wolf SE, Tremel W & Schroder

HC (2007) Formation of giant spicules in the deep-sea

hexactinellid Monorhaphis chuni (Schulze 1904): elec-

tron-microscopic and biochemical studies. Cell Tissue

Res 329, 363–378.

47 Iler RK (1979) The Chemistry of Silica. Wiley, New

York.

48 Son JH & Kwon YU (2003) New ionic crystals of

oppositely charged cluster ions and their characteriza-

tion. Inorg Chem 42, 4153–4159.

49 Swaddle TW, Rosenqvist J, Yu P, Bylaska E, Phillips

BL & Casey WH (2005) Kinetic evidence for five-coor-

dination in AlOH(aq)2+ ion. Science 308, 1450–1453.

50 Rao CNR & Raveau B (1998) Transition Metal Oxides,

2nd edn. Wiley-VCH, Weinheim.

51 Shimizu K & Morse DE (2000) The biological and

biomimetic synthesis of silica and other polysiloxanes.

In Biomineralization (Baeuerlein E ed.), pp. 207–220.

Wiley-VCH, Weinheim.

52 Weaver JC & Morse DE (2003) Molecular biology of

demosponge axial filaments and their roles in biosilicifi-

cation. Microsc Res Tech 62, 356–367.

53 Bradley DC, Mehrotra RC & Gaur DP (1978) Metal

Alkoxides. Academic Press, London.

54 Henry M, Jolivet JP & Livage J (1992) Aqueous chem-

istry of metal cations: hydrolysis, condensation and

complexation. In: Chemistry, Spectroscopy and Applica-

tions of Sol-Gel Glasses (Reisfeld R, ed.), pp. 153–206.

Structure and Bonding 77. Springer Verlag, Heidelberg,

Berlin.

55 Brinker CJ & Scherer GW (1990) Sol-gel Science: The

Physics and Chemistry of Sol-gel Processing. Academic

Press, New York.

56 Tahir MN, Theato P, Muller WEG, Schroder HC, Bore-

iko A, Faiß S, Janshoff A, Huth J & Tremel W (2005)

Formation of layered arrangements of zirconia by sur-

face bound silicatein. Chem Commun 44, 5533–5535.

57 Andre R, Tahir MN, Schroder HC, Muller WEG &

Tremel W (2011) Enzymatic synthesis and surface depo-

sition of tin dioxide using silicatein-a. Chem Mater 23,

5358–5365.

58 Mann S (2001) Biomineralization Principles and Con-

cepts in Bioinorganic Materials Chemistry. Oxford Uni-

versity Press, Oxford.

59 Wiberg N, Wiberg E & Holleman AF (2007) Lehrbuch

der Anorganischen Chemie, 102nd edn. de Gruyter,

Berlin.

60 Bradley SM, Kydd RA & Yamdagni R (1990) Detec-

tion of a new polymeric species formed through the

hydrolysis of gallium(III) salt solutions. J Chem Soc,

Dalton Trans 41, 3–417.

61 West AR (1992) Solid State Chemistry, 2nd edn. Wiley,

New York.

62 Brutchey RL & Morse DE (2006) Template-free, low-

temperature synthesis of crystalline barium titanate

nanoparticles under bio-inspired conditions. Angew

Chem Int Ed 45, 6564–6566.

63 Schmidt H (2006) Considerations about the sol-gel pro-

cess: from the classical sol-gel route to advanced chemi-

cal nanotechnologies. J Sol-Gel Sci Technol 40, 115–130.

64 Caruso RA & Antonietti M (2001) Sol–Gel nanocoat-

ing: an approach to the preparation of structured mate-

rials. Chem Mater 13, 3272–3282.

65 Glawe DD, Rodriguez F, Stone MO & Naik RR (2005)

Polypeptide-mediated silica growth on indium tin oxide

surfaces. Langmuir 21, 717–720.

66 Pogula SD, Patwardhan SV, Perry CC, Gillespie JW,

Yarlagadda S & Kick KL (2007) Continuous silica

coatings on glass fibers via bioinspired approaches.

Langmuir 23, 6677–6683.

67 Xu M, Gratson GM, Duoss EB, Shepherd RF & Lewis

JA (2006) Biomimetic silicification of 3D polyamine-rich

scaffolds assembled by direct ink writing. Soft Matter 2,

205–209.

68 Brott LL, Naik RR, Pikas DJ, Kirkpatrick SM, Tomlin

DW, Whitlock PW, Clarson SJ & Stone MO (2001)

Ultrafast holographic nanopatterning of biocatalytically

formed silica. Nature 413, 291–293.

69 Kim DJ, Lee KB, Lee TG, Shon HK, Kim WJ, Paik

HJ & Choi IS (2005) Biomimetic micropatterning of sil-

ica by surface-initiated polymerization and microcontact

printing. Small 1, 992–996.

70 Tahir MN, Theato P, Muller WEG, Schroder HC,

Janshoff A, Jiang J, Huth J & Tremel W (2004) Moni-

toring the formation of biosilica catalysed by histidin-

tagged silicatein. Chem Commun 24, 2848–2849.

71 Muller WEG, Schlossmacher U, Wang X, Boreiko A,

Brandt D, Wolf SE, Tremel W & Schroder HC (2008)

Poly(silicate)-metabolizing silicatein in siliceous spicules

and silicasomes of demosponges comprises dual enzy-

matic activities (silica-polymerase and silica-esterase).

FEBS J 275, 362–370.

72 Sigal GB, Bamdad C, Barberis A, Strominger J &

Whitesides GM (1996) A self-assembled monolayer for

the binding and study of histidine-tagged proteins

by surface plasmon resonance. Anal Chem 68, 490–

497.

73 Shukoor MI, Natalio F, Tahir MN, Metz N, Ksenofon-

tov V, Theato P, Schroder HC, Muller WEG & Tremel

W (2008) Growing fluorescent magnetic c-Fe2O3@SiO2

core-shell nanoparticles by an immobilized enzyme.

Chem Mater 20, 3567–3573.

Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials R. Andre et al.

1748 FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS

Page 13: Bioinspired synthesis of multifunctional inorganic and bio-organic hybrid materials

74 Tahir MN, Natalio F, Therese HA, Yella A, Shah MR,

Berger R, Butt HJ, Metz N, Theato P, Schroder HC

et al. (2009) Enzyme-mediated deposition of a TiO2

coating onto biofunctionalized WS2 chalcogenide

nanotubes. Adv Funct Mater 19, 285–291.

75 Tahir MN, Eberhardt M, Theato P, Faiß S, Janshoff

A, Gorelik T, Kolb U & Tremel W (2006) TiO2 nano-

particles with dye-labeled polymer ligands with multiple

anchor groups. Angew Chem Int Ed 45, 908–912.

76 Muller WEG, Rothenberger M, Boreiko A, Tremel W,

Reiber A & Schroder HC (2005) Formation of siliceous

spicules in the marine demosponge Suberites domuncula.

Cell Tissue Res 321, 285–297.

77 Wiens M, Bausen M, Natalio F, Link T, Schlossmacher

U & Muller WEG (2009) The role of the silicatein-

alpha interactor silintaphin-1 in biomimetic biomineral-

ization. Biomaterials 30, 1648–1656.

78 Andre R, Tahir MN, Link T, Jochum FD, Kolb U,

Theato P, Berger R, Wiens M, Schroder HC, Muller

WEG et al. (2011) Chemical mimicry: hierarchical 1D

TiO2@ZrO2 core-shell structures reminiscent of sponge

spicules by the synergistic effect of silicatein-a and silin-

taphin-1. Langmuir 27, 5464–5471.

79 Schlossmacher U, Wiens M, Schroder HC, Wang X,

Jochum KP & Muller WE (2011) Silintaphin-1 interac-

tion with silicatein during structure-guiding bio-silica

formation. FEBS J 278, 1145–1155.

80 Loy DA & Shea KJ (1995) Bridged polysilsesquioxanes.

Highly porous hybrid organic–inorganic materials.

Chem Rev 95, 1431–1442.

81 Greenwood NN & Earnshaw A (1997) Chemistry of the

Elements, 2nd edn. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford.

82 Curnow P, Kisailus D & Morse DE (2006) Biocatalytic

synthesis of poly(l-lactide) by native and recombinant

forms of the silicatein enzymes. Angew Chem Int Ed 45,

613–616.

83 Patwardhan SV, Mukherjee N & Clarson SJ (2001) The

use of poly-L-lysine to form novel silica morphologies

and the role of polypeptides in biosilicification. J Inorg

Organomet Polym 11, 193–198.

84 Patwardhan SV (2011) Biomimetic and bioinspired

silica: recent developments and applications. Chem

Commun 47, 7567–7582.

85 Kessel S, Thomas A & Borner HG (2007) Mimicking

biosilicification: programmed coassembly of peptide–

polymer nanotapes and silica. Angew Chem. Int. Ed. 46,

9023–9026.

86 Kessel S & Borner HG (2008) High rate silicification of

peptide–polymer assemblies toward composite nano-

tapes. Macromol Rapid Commun 29, 419–424.

87 Meegan JE, Aggeli A, Boden N, Brydson R, Brown

AP, Carrick L, Brough AR, Hussain A & Ansell RJ

(2004) Designed self-assembled b-sheet peptide fibrils as

templates for silica nanotubes. Adv Funct Mater 14,

31–37.

88 Tomczak MM, Glawe DD, Drummy LF, Lawrence GG,

Stone MO, Perry CC, Pochan DJ, Deming TJ & Naik JJ

(2005) Polypeptide-templated synthesis of hexagonal sil-

ica platelets. J Am Chem Soc 127, 12577–12582.

89 Holmstrom SC, King PJS, Ryadnov MG, Butler MF,

Mann S & Woolfson N (2008) Templating silica nano-

structures on rationally designed self-assembled peptide

fibers. Langmuir 24, 11778–11783.

90 Liang Q, Guan B & Jiang M (2010) A one-pot

approach to coaxial hybrid nanotubes of calixarene

⁄ silica via self-assembly and sol–gel transition. J Mater

Chem 20, 8236–8239.

91 Wang S, Ge X, Xue J, Fan H, Mu L, Li Y, Xu J &

Lu JR (2011) Mechanistic processes underlying biomi-

metic synthesis of silica nanotubes from self-assembled

ultrashort peptide templates. Chem Mater 23, 2466–

2474.

92 Yuwono VM & Hartgerink JD (2007) Peptide amphi-

phile nanofibers template and catalyze silica nanotube

formation. Langmuir 23, 5033–5038.

93 Yang H, Ozin GA & Kresge CT (1998) The role of

defects in the formation of mesoporous silica fibers,

films, and curved shapes. Adv Mater 10, 883–887.

94 Roth KM, Zhou Y, Yang W & Morse DE (2005)

Bifunctional small molecules are biomimetic catalysts

for silica synthesis at neutral pH. J Am Chem Soc 127,

325–330.

95 Kisailus D, Najarian M, Weaver JC & Morse DE

(2005) Functionalized gold nanoparticles mimic cata-

lytic activity of a polysiloxane-synthesizing enzyme. Adv

Mater 17, 1234–1239.

96 Beck JS, Vartuli JC, Roth WJ, Leonowicz ME, Kresge

CT, Schmitt KD, Chu CTW, Olson DH, Sheppard

EW, McCullen SB et al. (1992) A new family of meso-

porous molecular sieves prepared with liquid crystal

templates. J Am Chem Soc 114, 10834–10843.

97 Luckarift HR, Spain JC, Naik RR & Stone MO (2004)

Enzyme immobilization in a biomimetic silica support.

Nat Biotechnol 22, 211–213.

R. Andre et al. Bioinspired synthesis of inorganic materials

FEBS Journal 279 (2012) 1737–1749 ª 2012 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2012 FEBS 1749