best of pharma 2014 ebook

Upload: apolotrevino

Post on 17-Feb-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    1/31

    SPONSORED BY

    WWW.PHARMAMANUFACTURING.COM

    Best ofPharmaceutical

    Manufacturing 2014

    5BestReadStoriesTop

    NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    2/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    22

    contents

    Beyond SOPs page 4

    Whats Trending in Pharma IT? page 10

    All-Star Innovators 2014 page 18

    Vials vs. Dual-Chamber Systems page 24

    Compliance Management page 27

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    3/31

    3

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    Bring on the heat.

    www.aafintl.com

    HEPA ltration for critical dry heat sterilization processes

    High temperature resistance up to a peak of 752 F (400 C)

    Robust structure for superior durability during heating and cooling

    Free of silicone to safeguard air quality during the various drying process steps

    Handles high airow rates up to 1236 CFM for speedy temperature control

    Introducing the New AstroCel

    I HTP

    i l i i

    NEXT PAGEPREVIOUS PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    4/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    4

    AS THE philosophy and techniques enshrined in

    Quality by Design (QbD) become second nature to the

    pharmaceutical industry, their application is spread-ing. Analytical method development is a current area

    o ocus. Te process o developing, validating and

    deploying analytical methods closely parallels product

    development and can similarly benefit rom the sys-

    tematic and scientific approach that QbD promotes.

    Te dependence o pharmaceutical development and

    manuacture on robust analytical data intensifies

    the need or rigor in analytical method development

    and increasingly a QbD approach Analytical QbD

    (AQbD) is seen as the way orward.

    THE GOAL IS TO DEVELOP

    In analytical method development the goal is to

    develop, validate and deploy a method or making an

    analysis that will deliver the inormation required,

    in all the instances that it is required to do so. Te

    starting point is to identiy exactly why the measure-

    ment is being made; in the same way that the starting

    point or conventional QbD is to identiy clinical

    perormance targets or the product. Once this is

    established, the process is one o understanding and

    learning to control those aspects o the measurement

    method that define critical elements o analyticalperormance. Tis closely mirrors the QbD model o

    working toward a ully scoped design space.

    INTRODUCING THE PRINCIPLES OF QBD

    A useul starting point or examining AQbD is to

    return to the generally accepted definition o QbD,which was originally presented in International Con-

    erence on Harmonization document Q8(R2). Tis

    states that QbD is:

    A systematic approach to development that begins

    with predefined objectives and emphasizes product

    and process understanding and process control, based

    on sound science and quality risk management

    Figure 1 shows the QbD workflow that represents

    this systematic approach. Te first step is to identiy

    the Quality arget Product Profile (QPP), the

    definition o what the product must deliver. Te

    subsequent steps o QbD involve identification o

    the variables that must be controlled to deliver the

    defined product perormance, and the best way o

    implementing that control.

    CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT WRAPPER

    Determination o perormance-defining Critical

    Quality Attributes (CQAs), and the Critical Process

    Parameters (CPPs) and Critical Material Properties

    (CMAs) that control them, comes first. Definition o

    the design space ollows. Te design space is the op-

    erating envelope or the process. It encompasses thedefined ranges or the CPPs and CMAs that ensure

    the CQAs will be achieved consistently. Defining the

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    5/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    5

    www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    Figure 1: QbD workflows for product development and the analogous

    workflow for analytical method development.

    Figure 2: Laser diffraction analyzers determine particle size from the pat-

    tern of scattered light produced as a collimated laser beam interacts with

    particles in the sample.

    Incident light

    Incident light

    Small angle scattering

    Large angle scattering

    control strategies needed to maintain operation within

    the design space is the final step, but the entire workflow is

    wrapped within a process o continuous improvement across

    the liecycle o the drug. Indeed, a major attraction o QbD is

    that its application permits ongoing optimization within thedesign space without requiring urther regulatory approval.

    ICHQ8 (R2) does not specifically mention analytical

    method development. However, the underlined phrases in

    the original QbD definition (above) have direct resonance

    when looking to apply a structured, rigorous approach to

    developing analytical methods. Tis resonance has prompted

    the evolution o Analytical Quality by Design (AQbD).

    TRANSFERRING QBD TO ANALYTICAL METHOD

    DEVELOPMENT

    FDA guidance on the application o AQbD [1] highlights the

    potential benefits o transerring QbD to analytical methoddevelopment. Te proposal is that AQbD will lead to the

    development o a robust method that will be applicable

    throughout the liecycle o the product. Just as with QbD,

    being able to demonstrate adherence to AQbD will be associ-

    ated with a certain degree o regulatory flexibility, providing

    the reedom to change method parameters within a methods

    design space, reerred to as the Method Operable Design

    Region (MODR).

    Te starting point or AQbD is an Analytical arget

    Profile, or AP, which is directly analogous to a QPP

    (Figure 1). Te AP defines the goal o the analytical method

    development process, linking the output o the method to

    the overall QPP. Identiying why the analytical inormation

    is required, what it will be used or and when, helps to

    ormulate the AP. Supplementary targets or perormance

    characteristics, such as precision and reproducibility, stem

    rom a more detailed analysis o these needs.

    Te next step is to identiy a suitable analytical technique.

    Tis must be done with reerence to the needs defined in

    the AP. Once the technique is identified, AQbD ocuses on

    method development and includes detailed assessment o the

    risks associated with variability associated with:

    Aayst metods Istumet couatio ad maiteace

    Measuemet ad metod paametes

    Mateia caacteistics

    Eiometa coditios

    Tis assessment identifies the CQAs, the parameters that

    impact te ATP. A Desi of Epeimets (DOE) appoac

    is then adopted to define the MODR. Tis is the operating

    range or the CQAs that produces results that consistently

    meet the goals set out in the AP. Once this is defined,

    appropriate method controls can be put in place and method

    validation carried out ollowing the guidance in ICH Q2.

    Like QbD, AQbD works on the principle o recognizingand handling variability by understanding its potential

    impact. By identiying an analytical design space, rather than

    applying a fixed set o measurement conditions, it enables a

    responsive approach to the inherent variability encountered

    in day-to-day analysis throughout the liecycle o a

    pharmaceutical product. Tis delivers an analytical method

    that is robust in daily use and which also substantially

    reduces the potential or ailure when the method is

    transerred rom, or example, a research laboratory through

    to QC. Te root causes o method transer ailure can usually

    be traced back to insufficient consideration having been given

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    6/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    6

    Figure 3: Output of an assessment of the key parameters for a dry dispersion method. Items shown

    in green are noise factors within the method; those in orange are control factors; whereas those in

    red must be investigated experimentally to determine the MODR.

    to the nature o the routine operating

    environment and a ailure to capture

    and transer the inormation needed to

    ensure robust measurement. Applying

    AQbD overcomes these issues and has the

    potential to eliminate costly mistakes.

    DEVELOPING A PARTICLE

    SIZING METHOD

    Addressing a specific analytical chal-

    lenge helps to clariy what the applica-

    tion o AQbD looks like in practice.

    Consider the scenario o measuring the

    particle size distribution o a micron-

    ized active pharmaceutical ingredient

    with the goal o assessing its suitability

    or downstream processing and bio-

    availability or a solid oral dose product.In this situation the AP is

    the measurement o particle size

    distribution at a defined point in the

    process, in a way that is precise enough

    to ensure the material will perorm to

    expectations. In practice, the required

    level o precision may exceed that

    which is laid down in the US and

    Euopea Pamacopoeias [2, 3], but

    or simplicity we will assume that the

    USP ad P. Eu. acceptace citeia

    are adequate. Many techniques are

    available or particle size distribution

    measurement, but laser diffraction

    is the method o choice or most

    pharmaceutical applications. So we

    will base this AQbD example on laser

    diffraction particle size measurement.

    INTRODUCING LASER

    DIFFRACTION

    Fast, non-destructive and amenable

    to automation, particle sizing by laserdiffraction is a technique that has been

    tailored in modern instrumentation or

    high productivity, routine use. In a laser

    diffraction particle size analyzer, the

    particles in a sample are illuminated

    by a collimated laser beam. Te light is

    scattered by the particles present over

    a range o angles, with large particles

    predominantly scattering light with

    high intensity at narrow angles, and

    smaller particles producing lower in-

    tensity signals over a much wider range

    o angles. Laser diffraction systems

    measure the intensity o light scattered

    by the particles as a unction o angle

    and wavelength. Application o an ap-

    propriate light scattering model, such

    as Mie theory, enables particle size dis-

    tribution to be calculated directly rom

    the measured scattered light pattern.

    Laser diffraction involves relatively

    little sample preparation, but it is

    essential to present the sample in a

    suitably dispersed state to generate

    data that are relevant. In our example,

    the need is to measure the primary

    particle size distribution o the active

    pharmaceutical ingredient. Tis

    means that any agglomerated material

    present must be dispersed, prior to

    measurement, to ensure consistent

    and relevant results. Here then the

    parameters applied to ensure completedispersion are CQAs, variables that

    have a direct impact on the quality o

    the results. Investigating dispersion in

    a systematic way is thereore a primary

    objective when it comes to defining the

    MODR or a laser diffraction method.

    SCOPING THE MODR

    When it comes to dispersing a sample

    or laser diffraction particle size mea-

    surement, there is a choice to be made

    between dry powder or liquid disper-

    sion. Dry dispersion is the preerred

    option because it:

    Eabes apid measuemet to be made,

    Is we-suited to moistue-sesitie

    materials,

    Accommodates eatiey ae sampe

    volumes, enabling reproducible mea-

    surement o poly disperse materials,

    and

    Is environmentally benign, as the use

    o organic liquid dispersants is avoided.

    Although dry dispersion offers

    these advantages, it is not suitable

    or all sample types. Dry dispersion

    involves entraining the sample within

    a high-velocity air stream. Te process

    o entrainment subjects the particles

    to substantial shear energy and

    promotes particle-particle/particle-wall

    collisions, dispersing any agglomerates.

    Friable materials may be damaged bythis process. It may also be hazardous

    to handle highly active ingredients in

    this way because o the risks associated

    with aerosolization. Some samples are

    thereore better suited to liquid-based

    measurement.

    Fiue 3 sows some of te CQAs

    associated with a dry method or

    a micronized API powder. In dry

    dispersion, the air pressure applied

    during entrainment o the sample is the

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    7/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    7

    Figure 4: Pressure titration data for a lactose formulation. A comparison of liquid (blue) and dry

    measurement shows close agreement at a compressed air pressure of 3 bar with the standard

    venturi (upper plot) and at 1 bar with the more aggressive venturi (lower plot).

    Figure 5: Plotting measured particle size as a function of air pressure for each venturi disperser.

    Shaded region shows where the results are in agreement with the reference method to within

    USP guidance. The standard venturi disperser delivers a wider MODR.

    VolumeDensity(%)

    VolumeDensity(%)

    Size Classes (m)

    Size Classes (m)

    Dv50/m

    Air Pressure / Bar

    lever that is used to control the input

    o energy into the dispersion process.

    Tis identifies it as a CQA. Another

    consideration is the sample eed rate, as

    this determines the amount o material

    which passes through the venturiduring the dispersion process and

    thereore the efficiency o dispersion.

    It also defines the concentration o

    a sample, which in turn can have an

    impact on the measurement process

    itsel. I particle number/density is

    too low, then the signal to noise ratio

    during measurement may be unreliable.

    Conversely, a high particle density

    increases the risk o multiple scattering,

    where the light interacts with more

    than one particle prior to detection,a phenomenon that complicates the

    calculation o particle size. Feed rate,

    thereore, tends to be the other CQA

    when using dry dispersion or laser

    diffraction particle size measurements.

    So, working on the basis that dry

    dispersion is suitable or our model

    sample, and that the above assessment

    is realistic in terms o identiying

    the CQAs or the method, one o the

    steps needed to scope the MODR is to

    determine how air pressure influences

    the results o the analysis. Te

    experiment that delivers the necessary

    data is commonly reerred to as a

    pressure titration.

    Figure 4 shows results rom two

    pressure titrations. Tese were carried

    out usi te Mastesize 3000,

    which has a number o modular dry

    dispersion units that allow the intensity

    o dry dispersion to be matched to the

    sample. Te upper o the two plotswas measured using a dry dispersion

    unit fitted with the systems standard

    venturi disperser, while the lower plot

    was generated using a venturi designed

    to provide high dispersion energies.

    Te aim with dry dispersion is to

    completely break up any agglomerates

    present, without causing damage

    to the primary particles. Te results

    show that with each venturi increasing

    pressure decreases particle size. Tis

    raises the question o how to determine

    whether a given pressure is breakingup agglomerates as required, or is

    causing damage to primary particles.

    A comparison with a reerence liquid

    dispersion measurement helps to answer

    this question since liquid dispersion

    very rarely results in particle damage.

    Results rom liquid measurements

    are shown in blue in Figure 4. Tese

    indicate that the standard venturi

    disperser delivers complete dispersion

    at a compressed air pressure o around

    3 ba, weeas usi te i eey

    venturi disperser an air pressure oaround 1 bar is required.

    Tese data suggest that it would be

    possible to use either o the venturi

    tested. However, by plotting particle

    size as a unction o air pressure or

    each venturi (Figure 5) it can be seen

    that the standard venturi is the better

    option. Tis plot shows that the MODR

    is larger with the standard venturi than

    with the high energy disperser.

    Tese results show that with the

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    8/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    8

    Figure 6: Mastersizer 3000 measurement manager, showing a dispersion trend. Figure 7: Measurement data quality advice

    provided in the Mastersizer 3000 software.

    high energy disperser any variation in air pressure will have

    a significant effect on particle size, compromising the ability

    o the method to meet the AP. Using the standard venturi,

    on the other hand, the particle size results are reasonably

    cosistet acoss te pessue ae 3 to 4 ba. is etui

    will thereore deliver an inherently more robust measurement.

    Te MODR associated with its use can be determined, in

    terms o suitable air pressure, on the basis o these data.

    METHOD VALIDATION

    Te data shown in Figure 5 enable the selection o a dispersion

    pressure which would be expected to deliver robust results. o

    ensure that a proposed method meets the AP, it is essential

    to veriy that any variability in the way the method is applied

    does not shif the precision o the results outside the intended

    limits. Tis requires the method to be validated, ollowing the

    guidance outlined in ICH Q2.

    wo concepts are central to confirming that a particle sizing

    method is fit or purpose: repeatability and reproducibility.

    Assessing repeatability involves duplicate measurements o the

    same sample. It thereore tests the precision o the instrument,

    and the consistency o the sampling and dispersion process.

    Reproducibility is a broader concept that also encompassesmultiple operators or even multiple analytical system

    installations.

    Bot te USP [2] ad EP [3] ecommed acceptace citeia

    or reproducibility testing. A Coefficient o Variability (COV)

    of ess tat 10% is suested as acceptabe fo te media

    (D50) patice size o ay simia aue wic is cose to

    the center o the particle size distribution. Tis figure rises

    to 15% o aues towads te ede of te distibutio, suc

    as D10 ad D90, te patice size beow wic 10 ad 90%

    o the population lies on the basis o volume. Tese limits

    ae doubed fo sampes cotaii patices smae ta 10

    microns because o the difficulties associated with dispersing

    such fine powders.

    In our example then, where the acceptance criteria or

    the results are based on pharmacopoeial guidance, robust

    definition o the MODR requires that any source o variability

    does not take data reproducibility outside these limits.

    For example, the precision o air pressure control during

    dispersion is a unction o the analyzer. I air pressure, a CQA,

    is cotoed to witi +/-0.1 ba, it is ecessay to coduct

    experiments to determine the level o variability that this

    introduces in terms o the repeatability and reproducibility o

    the measured data. All potential sources o variability must be

    investigated in this way.

    TOOLS TO EASE AQBD

    As with QbD, AQbD places the emphasis on ully understand-

    ing a process, rather than simply ocusing on a set o condi-

    tions that work or certain sample types. Te potential rewards

    o this approach have already been highlighted, but gaining

    the necessary understanding is inextricably linked with more

    extensive experimentation. ools that can alleviate the burden

    associated with this research are thereore to be welcomed.

    Fiue 6 sows a scee sot fom te Mastesize 3000illustrating the Measurement Manager tool. Tis is a sofware

    eature that provides real-time eedback which indicates the

    impact o changing an analytical parameter. Parameters

    can either be modified by the user in real-time as part o a

    manually controlled measurement or they can be set within

    pre-defined measurement sequences within the sofwares

    SOP-player tool. Tis tool provides the first step towards ull

    automation o the method development process.

    In addition to aiding with the process o method

    development, there is also a requirement to ensure that

    the data collected are reasonable and thereore reflect the

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    9/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    9

    capabilities o the analytical technique in terms o both

    resolving product changes and delivering reproducible results.

    Here, tools to assess the quality o the data are extremely

    valuable, helping to guide the user towards the definition o a

    good method.

    Figure 7 shows the output o the Data Quality assessmenttoo poided i te Mastesize 3000. Adice is ie eati

    the measurement process (e.g. instrument cleanliness and

    alignment) and also the analysis process (e.g. the goodness o

    fit between the light scattering data acquired by the instrument

    and the optical model selected to calculate a size distribution

    rom these data). Tis helps to address many o the method

    control issues highlighted in Figure 4. Sofware advances such

    as these can thereore make a big difference when it comes

    to the application o AQbD, and they substantially ease the

    analytical burden associated with its implementation.

    LOOKING AHEAD

    A decade or so ago the introduction o standard operating

    procedures (SOPs) was groundbreaking, but analytical method

    development is now moving beyond simply defining a fixed set

    o measurement parameters. AQbD invites analysts to estab-

    lish a robust MODR, a sae analytical working space. Work-

    ing within the MODR ensures that results consistently meet

    defined quality criteria while at the same time providing the

    flexibility to respond to routinely encountered variability.

    Te understanding that comes with scoping the MODR

    secures robust application o an analytical method across the

    product liecycle and substantially eases method transer.

    As with QbD, AQbD holds out the attraction o greater

    understanding, but brings with it the burden o a broader

    research remit. However, advances in instrumentation, mostespecially in sofware, can make a major contribution when

    it comes to efficient scoping o the MODR. Features such as

    real-time eedback on the stability o a measurement and the

    impact o changes, or example, and the ability to automatically

    step through a series o SOPs, can help to substantially lighten

    the analytical burden, enabling analysts to reap the benefits o

    AQbD more easily.

    References

    [1] QbD Considerations for Analytical Methods FDA Perspective.

    Presentation by Sharmista

    Chatterjee at IFPAC Annual Meeting, Jan 25th 2013. Available for

    download from

    http://www.fda.gov/downloads/AboutFDA/CentersOffices/OfficeofMedi-

    calProductsandTobacco/CDER/UCM359266.pdf

    [2] General Chapter , Light Diffraction Measurement Of Particle

    Size, United States Pharmacopeia, Pharmacopoeial Forum (2005), 31,

    pp1235-1241

    [3] General Chapter 2.9.31, Laser Diffraction Measurement of

    Particle Size, European Pharmacopeia.

    To learn more about automating your microbial QC lab, visit www.rapidmicrobio.com

    The Growth DirectTMSystem revolutionizes

    microbial testing.

    By providing a single technology

    to perform all key microbial quality

    control tests, the Growth Direct TM

    System automates and accelerates

    testing with positive results in

    hours and final CFU counts in

    about half the time of traditional

    methods, eliminating error-prone

    manual steps and saving labor.

    One Detection Technology.Three Applications.

    One Automated Platform.

    Automated Microbial Enumeration

    and Reporting

    Non-Destructive Test Uses No Reagents

    Positive Results in Hours

    Single or Concurrent Testing

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

    http://www.fda.gov/downloads/AboutFDA/CentersOffices/OfficeofMedicalProductsandTobacco/CDER/UCM359266.pdfhttp://www.fda.gov/downloads/AboutFDA/CentersOffices/OfficeofMedicalProductsandTobacco/CDER/UCM359266.pdfhttp://www.fda.gov/downloads/AboutFDA/CentersOffices/OfficeofMedicalProductsandTobacco/CDER/UCM359266.pdfhttp://www.fda.gov/downloads/AboutFDA/CentersOffices/OfficeofMedicalProductsandTobacco/CDER/UCM359266.pdf
  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    10/31

    10

    ChAllEngIng PhArMACEUTICAl

    manuacturers everywhere, every day are the myriad is-

    sues surrounding the acquisition, disposition and analysis

    o the huge amounts o data their operations create around

    the clock. Any Pharma producer worth its salt these days

    is likely investing a great deal o time, resources and effort

    to create or maintain a comprehensive inormation tech-

    nology (I) inrastructure to support compliant opera-

    tions, process quality and efficiency, and ultimately assure

    product saety, effectiveness and affordability.

    Accodi to eseac m Compute Ecoomics,

    which provides benchmarking metrics to aid I

    operations management, lie science organizations

    have some unique attributes. In its study, Comparative

    Analysis o I Spending in the Lie Sciences, Computer

    Ecoomics compaed i-ee spedi metics fo ife

    science companies against a broad sample o organizations

    in all industries. Te study delivered our key findings:

    1. Lie science companies have high I intensity. Tey

    spend considerably more than the composite sample,

    as measured by total I spending per user and spend-

    ing as a percentage o revenue.

    2. Lie science companies spend a higher portion o

    their I budgets on data center and network inra-

    structure than the average company, and they spend

    a correspondingly smaller portion on business ap-

    plication sofware.

    3. Te sie of te appicatio suppot staf f ad

    spending on application sotwa re per user is typi-

    cal, indicat ing that high data center and network

    inrastructure costs are the actors that drive I

    spending in this sector.

    4. Te staffing mix or lie science companies is simi-

    lar to other organizations. I staffing headcount,

    thereore, can be benchmarked against similar-size

    organizations rom all sectors.

    Within the context o a typical drug manuacturing

    environment and its incumbent data volume, it makes

    sense that Pharmas spending may be proportionately

    higher than other industries to und its high-capacity

    data adi eeds. recet, gate Becma

    Aatics eeased its IT Metics Data 2014 epot

    which revealed that Pharmaceuticals, Lie Sciencesad Medica Poducts compaies sped 3.2 pecet of

    revenues on their I inrastructure a level higher

    ta Idustia Eectoics ad Eectica Equipmet

    (2.5 percent), Industrial Manuacturing (1.7 percent),

    ad iteesti eou, Cemicas at 1.3 pecet.

    What these figures seem to reflect is the reality on the

    ground; that is, Pharma is spending more (generally)

    now than peer counterparts because those industries

    are urther along the curve when it comes to integrating

    a modern, enterprise-wide I inrastructure to support

    operations and business goals.

    OPErATIOnAl TrAnSPArEnCy AnD OPTIMIzED PrOCESSES FrOM lAB TOPlAnT FlOOr TO ExECUTIvE SUITE AnD BACk ArE DrIvIng IT InvESTMEnTS

    I N F O R M A T I O N T E C H N O L O G Y A L M A N A C I T PA N E L

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    11/31

    11

    Wheres I spending heading or Pharma and Lie

    Science companies? Analytics firm Inorma Ovum

    orecasts global lie sciences technology spending toeac $40.8 bi io b te ed of 2017. Accodi to

    Ovums research, spending will increase at a cumula-

    tie aua owt ate (CAgr) of 3.6 pecet to eac

    the predicted figure. Ovum says its study reveals that

    the increase in I spending will be ueled in large

    part by the growth in data analysis and related tech-

    nologies, the acquisition o systems to comply with

    new regulatory requirements, and increased spending

    on applications that advance operating efficiency and

    automatio. Esewee, Oums dis sow tat

    value chain ragmentation caused by new entities

    being spun out o Big Pharma and rapid growth in emerging markets will see strong I spending growth

    of 9.4 pecet CAgr i te sma pama/biotec sub

    secto, totai $10.5 biio i 2017.

    he actors driving I spending in the lie

    sciences industry continue to be complex, with

    payers o healthcare demanding greater value in

    the ace o increasing costs, technological advances

    enabling new types o research that are changing

    societal expectations, and opportunities arising rom

    the emerging markets, explains Andrew Brosnan,

    senior analyst, healthcare and lie sciences at Ovum.

    We expect much o this predicted growth to come

    rom investment in business intelligence (BI) and

    analytics, as institutions look to collect, clean,

    manage and analyze the vast amount o data rom

    sources such as social media, electronic medical

    records and genetic sequencing.

    Ovum expects total I spending as a percentage

    of tota eeues to decease to 3.4 pecet i 2017,

    even though overall I spending will be higher as

    total revenue increases, largely due to I-related cost

    efficiencies and the increased use o generics, which are

    less I-intensive to develop than novel medications.Te improvement o I-related cost efficiencies

    will be achieved through systems simplification and

    inrastructure consolidation, urther cloud adoption,

    alling component prices and increased external

    souci, epais Bosa. geate eteaiatio

    o what were once in-house resources and capabilities

    is occurring globally across all sub-sectors (biotech,

    small- to mid-sized pharma, and Big Pharma). Te

    centralization o externalized services reduces the

    total cost o ownership by stripping out duplicate

    investments and realizing greater economies o scale.

    Pharma manuacturers and prominent members o the

    pharmaceutical supply chain are certainly looking to

    make sure their I investments yield value. Te efficientflow o process/machine data and inormation rom

    production line to executive suite and back is dependent

    on a well-organized, modern data/inormatics inra-

    structure. Tis is also unflinchingly true or the reams

    o data streaming rom laboratory operations espe-

    cia tose i suppot of cgMP maufactui ad its

    incumbent quality regimes.

    In discussions with customers trying to integrate more

    unctionality and value into their existing I inrastruc-ture, inormation technology suppliers and integrators are

    witnessing first hand where customers are ocusing their

    I investments as well as the priorities they assign with

    tei sped. Pomiet Maufactui Eecutio Sstems

    (MES) suppie Weum IT Soutios seio diecto rof

    Blumenthal explains, Our customers are asking us to

    fill the gap between the business level and automation

    level. On this operational level, the first ocus in pharma

    manuacturing is the replacement o paper batch record-

    ing with an electronic system. O course, this doesnt just

    entail mere paper replacement, says Blumenthal, because

    customers are taking a broader approach to many business

    unctions including material flow, quality control and

    process automation. Using this unctionality across the

    complete liecycle o a pharmaceutical product, rom lab

    to maet, e sas, is positioi MES as a too fo pocess

    development, clinical trials production and commercial

    manuacturing. During the last three years customers

    are looking more or strategic products in manuactur-

    ing than or customized [bespoke] sofware. Using an

    out-o-the-box product with a strategic roadmap or the

    next decade, customers can achieve long-term investment

    protection and lower total cost o ownership.Te notion that Pharma customers are looking or

    a transcendental experience as they integrate new

    I unctionality and capacity is echoed by Termo

    Fisher Scientifics rish Meek, director o strategy

    Inormatics: Our customers today are looking at how

    inormatics can go beyond driving their processes to

    really transorm their business, says Meek. o push the

    boundaries o innovation, [companies] are monitoring

    their perormance and quality and actively looking or

    opportunities they can capitalize on to improve their

    operations. Tis is due, in part, says Meek, to

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    12/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    12

    At the end of the day, people are looking for solutions to eliminatepaper, to become more compliant, and to increase efciencies in

    and around [their] labs.

    Gene Tetreault,BIOVIA

    macro-trends like big data and predictive analytics that

    ae cai IT acoss a idusties. goe ae te das

    where we rely on statistics to take a sample o data that

    is believed to represent the whole because analysis o the

    entire data set is impossible. odays modern in-memorycomputing platorms offer organizations the ability to

    look at their complete operation in real time or near

    real time. Customers, explains Meek, want to achieve a

    higher level o quality and efficiency and business agility,

    but that ofen isnt possible i that data is siloed and inac-

    cessible. Our customers are working with us to achieve

    a connected inormatics inrastructure so that they can

    achieve these higher-level organizational goals.

    Citing the recent report, Product Innovation Requires

    Laboratory Inormatics Systems to ranscend Phases,

    Mee otes tat gate aast Micae Sae

    recommends manuacturers prioritize end-to-end

    inormatics investments and align metrics or innovation,

    domain expertise, operational efficiencies and quality.

    His recommendation, explains Meek, is based on an

    observation that todays laboratories are, or the most

    part, disconnected. By tightly integrating LIMS to other

    etepise opeatio sstems suc as ErP, isits fom te

    lab have the potential to be even more central to businesses

    seeking true enterprise-wide agility. Businesses arent

    simply capturing and collecting data, Meek contends, they

    are making data actionable across the enterprise, putting

    management in the position to transorm their businesses

    into agile organizations capable o responding quickly to

    market trends or new regulations and flexible enough torecognize and capitalize on cost-saving or margin-growing

    opportunities in the uture.

    gee Teteaut, BIOvIAs seio diecto of etepise

    laboratory management, also knows that besides test

    and development related data, inormatics are key to

    managing lab operations effectively and holistically.

    BIOVIAs customers, says etreault, are seeking a really

    good capability to manage inventories and managing

    all o the material flow in and out o the lab, as well as

    specialized things like environmental monitoring. Tats

    a manuacturing application typically included in the

    LIMs, but its all about managing the [potential or]

    microbial contamination in manuacturing. At the end

    o the day, people are looking or solutions to eliminate

    paper, to become more compliant, and to increase

    efficiencies in and around their labs. Once you get allo those systems [on a common electronic technology]

    platorm, people are asking: How do I connect other

    systems together? How do I get the data out o them?

    etreault explains that once a comprehensive lab

    inormatics system is in place, discoverable inormation

    becomes available and lab operations managers have

    tremendous opportunity to gather and aggregate data

    and then use it to look orward operationally creating

    models and other visualizations to support quality

    regimes in manuacturing.

    GAPS TO CLOSE

    Indeed, priorities have to be ordered and pursued to close

    the gaps created by the complexities o Pharma manuactur-

    ing environments and their supply chains. Business leader

    Bia voe, fo rocwe Automatios goba life Scieces

    business segment, finds Pharma needs to continue its e-

    orts to organize I to serve the enterprise holistically. I

    Inrastructure is a catch-all bucket that can include inorma-

    tion and manuacturing sofware as well as hardware, says

    Vogel. Most Lie Science manuacturers are moving in two

    key areas. Beyond acquisition, there is a major movement to

    shif capacity to more profitable locations. Tis is paralleled

    with an emphasis on consolidating I-related systems while

    improving and expanding access to shop-floor inormation.As this unolds, notes Vogel, Lie Science manuacturers

    ae comi to te eaiatio tat, wie ErP is

    absolutely undamental to driving the back end, there are

    cosideabe aps at te sop oo. As suc, MES ae ow

    being deployed in the context o an enterprise solution.

    Rockwell Automation has a global customer base, so we see

    a wide variety o approaches to addressing this. Developing

    a commo MES coe to efoce quait, compiace ad

    standard execution across all areas o manuacturing

    irrespective o what type or where a product is being

    manuactured is the leading trend.

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    13/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    1313

    During the last three years customers are looking more for strategic productsin manufacturing than for customized [bespoke] software. Using an out-of-the-

    box product with a strategic roadmap for the next decade, customers can

    achieve long-term investment protection and lower total cost of ownership.

    Rolf Blumenthal, Werum IT Solutions

    Tere will still be areas o the world, says Vogel, where

    the cost o energy and personnel will drive an approach

    that is more centered on adding resources and lean

    processes. However, most manuacturers are avoiding

    the band-aid approach and are working to develop amoe sstematic, oba MES coe depomet mode.

    Iauab, sas Jeife godsmit, vP, vaut r&D,

    Veeva Systems, one the most data-driven areas in lie

    sciences is manuacturing, which demands the ability to

    sae ifomatio ad coaboate quic. godsmit

    contends raw data ofen exists in multiple systems and

    file ormats, making it difficult or people to access and

    use. As a result, the data is ofen recreated in a document

    or structured report ormat to provide context and

    enable effective consumption. Content management

    systems (CMS) have become the home or many o

    these documents, and these systems typically lack the

    capability to incorporate new data as they are updated.

    Something as simple as a manuacturing specification

    may require manual update and confirmation o values

    as they change over time. Additionally, sharing this

    inormation across geographies and between organizations

    has also presented challenges. Cloud-based CMS allow

    easy, secure sharing o valuable inormation with other

    sstems ad a ae, eeat audiece, sas godsmit.

    Users effortlessly collaborate with one another, while all

    communication, content and versions are tracked and

    stored. As cloud-based CMS evolve, they will challenge

    traditional definitions o documents, enabling the storingand updating o structured data with unstructured content

    such as descriptions in one document.

    OPEX OR CAPEX?

    When it comes to expensing operational necessities like

    an I inrastructure, controlling that spend can be chal-

    lenging, especially because it is so critical to operational

    excellence and an efficient, compliant production environ-

    ment. With Pharmas business models evolving quickly to

    meet the needs o the swifly changing global marketplace,

    the industry is shifing how it invests and maintains its

    I inrastructure. Some are looking or alternative ways

    to account or I expenditures and shifing unding rom

    te capita epese (CapE) side of te baace seet to

    te opeati epese (OpE) side i a attempt to bette

    manage the rising and unavoidable cost o fielding a world-class I inrastructure. When it comes to managing I ex-

    penses, each company may take an approach biased in one

    direction or another depending on individual preerences

    and financial exigencies, but theres no clear right answer

    and Rockwells Vogel agrees. Tere is no right or wrong

    answer here; manuacturers o all sizes are managing

    expenditures as operating expenses and/or capital expenses

    at both the corporate and site levels, observes Vogel.

    Tough most customers/partners who are developing the

    core model are treating the upront design and build as a

    capital expense, and classiying the unding o the local

    extensions and roll-out as an operational expense.

    Werums Blumenthal offers this insight: Tere is a trend

    on the radar that customers are expecting realistic solutions

    beyond the cloud technology discussion in the I world. A

    ew idea is to use a suppie-osted MES ad pa pe batc

    record instead o purchasing complex I inrastructure

    ad a MES sstem. at is a iteesti popositio ad

    may offer very lean organizations an opportunity to stick to

    core competencies and leave the heavy lifing to companies

    whose core competency is in act I operations.

    Speai of ea ii, veeas godsmit poits out

    that the emergence o cloud applications has provided a new

    alternative or financing projects, moving I inrastructurespend away rom capital expenditures and toward operating

    epeses. new pojects tpica equie a siicat

    amount o upront capital, and i the investment needed is

    too high, it may deter organizations rom pursuing these

    oppotuities at a, sas godsmit. e coud owes

    the barrier to entry and supports a pay-as-you-go model,

    enabling companies to try new ideas without long-term

    commitment and easily scale as projects grow.

    BIOVIAs etreault says that customers usually dont

    include the company in the nitty-gritty o how they choose

    to und I investments, but that when making I-related

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    14/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    14

    Gone are the days where we rely on statistics to take a sample of data that isbelieved to represent the whole because analysis of the entire data set is impos-

    sible. Todays modern in-memory computing platforms offer organizations the

    ability to look at their complete operation in real time or near real time.

    Trish Meek, Thermo Fisher Scientifc

    capital purchases, cost o ownership and time to value are

    two key metrics, that help customers valuate the potential

    return o their I investment. We are trying to deliver

    sofware at the lowest cost. Were trying to make it so they

    can basically get value [even i] it is rom one mapped outgoal. Cloud solutions, certificates o valuation, etc., all sorts

    o things to deliver tangible value and to lower both o

    those numbers. Tat opens up the world tremendously to

    thousands o labs, as opposed to hundreds o labs.

    SOLUTIONS FOCUS

    Its generally accepted that contemporary I and inor-

    matics solutions must be adopted to effectively and profit-

    ably manage Pharmas operations or ace the consequenc-

    es. But just how are drug manuacturers working with

    vendors and integrators to apply and implement such nec-

    essary technologies? Rockwells Vogel offers this insight:

    A hybrid-regulated consumer goods manuacturer with

    oe 100k SkUs eeded to icease poductio tou-

    put b 20 pecet (witout iceasi pesoe), ad

    needed to meet increased market demand. Afer review-

    ing its manuacturing process, it was determined that the

    First ime Pass had to increase and the Quality Hold

    Time ad to decease b moe ta 60 pecet. Moe

    work orders per shif also needed to be executed to meet

    te compas oas. Ae impemeti a ew MES

    solution, the number o work orders per shif doubled,

    First ime Pass increased by 85 percent, and quality hold

    deceased b moe ta 90 pecet. now, adoptio of tesolution is underway in our additional plants.

    Another o Rockwells customers, a global lie sciences

    maufactue was oi out a ErP sstem to a its

    manuacturing acilities, Vogel says, explaining that

    the company needed to standardize its manuacturing

    iteiece iteface wit ErP ad epace te miad of

    eisti MES site-ee sstems wit a etepise-wide

    solution. Te first challenge was the time rame, and

    te secod was esui te MES sstem met eisti

    unctional and regulatory needs at each site regardless

    o what or how a product or ingredient was being made.

    Te system was rolled out in stages, ocusing on core

    aeas oe at a time. now, 17 pats ae ie, ad e wi

    o ie i ou 30 mots sice te poam stated.

    While each customer had different business drivers,

    says Vogel, the need to standardize their manuacturingprocess and improve time-to-results was achieved

    through Rockwells platorm.

    Termo Fisher Scientifics Meek notes that with her

    companys customer base, companies ofen take two

    distinct approaches: Te first, one-stop shopping and the

    second, integrated laboratory systems. Which approach

    makes the most sense is largely based on the existing

    systems investment and processes that are implemented

    in those systems, says Meek. One major pharmaceutical

    manuacturer has implemented a global deployment o

    ou lIMS ad it is fu iteated wit etea lES ad

    SDMS. By ocusing on strong integration between these

    applications, they eel that they have optimized their

    deployment and have a continuous flow o inormation

    enabling them to make real-time decisions. Tey are

    currently looking at predictive analytics tools to drive to a

    more proactive environment.

    Customers who have not made a significant investment

    i lES ad SDMS capabiities aead, sas Mee, see te

    value in a single solution that provides the unctionality

    of a lIMS, lES ad SDMS i oe. e custome was

    ooi at lab Eecutio ad lIMS ad we te

    realized that they could get both in a single solution,

    it made their decision or them. Teir comment wasthat, We never thought we would find a solution or lab

    execution and management that is so tightly integrated,

    why would we go with anything else?

    veeas godsmit otes ood documetatio is essetia

    or manuacturing acilities to ensure activities are executed

    correctly and are in compliance. Most companies, she

    says, rely on content management systems that were built

    when companies were less impacted by globalization and

    had ewer regulatory requirements. oday, customers

    are looking or solutions that enable greater visibility and

    flexibility, and collaboration across all parties. We have

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    15/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    15

    Most Life Science manufacturers are moving in two key areas. Beyond acqui-sition, there is a major movement to shift capacity to more protable locations.

    This is paralleled with an emphasis on consolidating IT-related systems while

    improving and expanding access to shop-oor information.

    Brian Vogel, Rockwell Automation

    customers that are in the early stages o adoption, having

    built a single source o truth or SOPs accessible by both

    documet oiiatos ad cosumes. gii moe pa-

    ties visibility into document status accelerates edit, review

    and approval cycles. Built-in read and understood tasksalso allow or real-time tracking o new SOPs as they are

    rolled out across departments and sites.

    godsmit epais tat e compas moe matue

    customers understand that such systems deliver powerul

    insights into the health o processes, departments and

    partnerships. Most metrics monitor output, only

    measuring what has happened. racking upstream

    metrics, by contrast, provides leading indicators into

    potential problems and can help identiy bottlenecks

    befoe te damae is doe, sas godsmit. Compaies

    that have developed a deeper understanding o their

    business processes are using metrics to gauge perormance

    across the organization, and drive continuous process

    improvements and proactive decision-making.

    Werums Blumenthal provides a closer look outlining

    two solutions delivered to customers using their popular

    platorm. A customer is using our [platorm] in process

    development to develop a stable, best-fitting process or solid

    dosage products, says Blumenthal. Te main business

    goal is to be aster to market with a new product. By using

    MES featues ie MBr ad EBr fo ceati ecipes ad

    eauati best tti paametes ia Desi of Epeimets,

    new processes will be continuously improved and stabilized.

    Development with such tools and the transer o the gainedknowledge to the next production phase is much aster and is

    the enabler to achieve expected business goals.

    Another Werum customer is using the companys

    technologies in the commercial production o a

    biopharmaceutical product. Te main business goal is

    to increase the yield o the actory, says Blumenthal.

    Since production runs are very long, it is critical that

    the process is stable without any contamination. Tis

    can be achieved through our [platorm] by controlling

    all process steps with additional checks o all material

    and all equipment that is used. Both business goals,

    he says, can be supported by the same system. Te

    complete unctionality supported by Werums platorm,

    says Blumenthal, is defined and controlled via recipes.

    Te creation and change o recipes (MBRs) can be both

    flexible (process development) or highly controlled withaccess rights (commercial manuacturing).

    A PATH TO IMPROVED OPERATIONS

    Many more parties are involved in the end-to-end pro-

    duction o a product adding another layer o complexity to

    te deeopmet pocess, epais godsmit. Suppoti

    technologies are ofen deployed in a siloed model, limiting

    the ability or parties to collaborate directly, thus orc-

    ing the use o uncontrolled communication mechanisms,

    such as email, she says. Mature companies are taking a

    strategic approach to technology, creating a strong ounda-

    tion or inormation sharing and collaboration to achieve

    the biggest benefit. Companies that succeed in sharing

    inormation with all parties involved and between systems

    see significant improvements in all five areas.

    Werums approach, says Blumenthal, is the

    implementation o a recipe-driven system that leads the

    operator through the business processes, enorcing the

    right first-time principle and compliance with all pharma

    regulations. Creating best practice recipes and ollowing the

    guidance o the system along such recipes (like a navigation

    system) will always result in best product quality, reduced

    costs, saety, reduced risks and compliance, Blumenthal says.

    Teteaut aees tat lES efoces it st time: Weyoure ollowing the process and doing QC testing on a

    particular batch step one, prepare the agents and global

    phase samples and so orth. Step two, do this. Step three,

    do that. On step one, i you dont adhere to the process o

    running that analytical test, i you dont adhere to all the

    equipment being calibrated, all the materials being within

    tolerance and o course not expired, all o the training

    records [te lES is] efoci a of tat at te time

    that youre doing the test. etreault notes test regimes,

    independent o the quality control provided by an integrated

    lab inormatics platorm can be problematic because any

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    16/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    16

    As cloud-based CMS evolve, they will challenge traditional denitions of

    documents, enabling the storing and updating of structured data with

    unstructured content such as descriptions in one document.

    Jennifer Goldsmith, Veeva Systems

    issues or mistakes may only be revealed afer a review.

    somebody comes along and reviews it and finds that

    tees a pobem. now tees a das wot of eot ito

    doing something that was wrong on the first step. etreault

    explains BIOVIAs platorm (as with others) electronicallyenorces process rubrics at the time they are being done.

    It reduces costs. It increases quality. It decreases saety risk.

    Termo Fisher Scientifics Meek knows that lab

    inormatics platorms truly are the pointy end o the

    spear when it comes to assuring quality when it counts.

    Esui poduct quait, is eductio ad euato

    compliance have always been among the top reasons to

    deploy a LIMS, she says. est results rom suppliers are

    checked to ensure they are fit or use beore time and

    energy is wasted, all sample results or the batch including

    environmental monitoring are collated beore product can

    be released. Business processes are implemented in the

    LIMS and the users are [systematically] stepped through

    the organizations SOPs to ensure compliance. Hazard

    warnings can be associated with any step in a workflow

    ad, witi te lES, uses ae emided as te eecute

    that step o the appropriate saety procedures including

    saety images and videos i appropriate.

    Its important, says Meek, to remember that todays

    LIMS are ar more than just lab inormation systems. It

    is also a laboratory resource planning system. Method

    execution, scientific data visualization, instrument

    calibration and maintenance, and detailed resource

    planning and allocation can al l be done through the

    LIMS. ypically, notes Meek, LIMS are on an upgradecycle o around every five years, and the first thing Termo

    Fisher Scientific does with its customers is demonstrate

    how much the unctionality o its platorms have evolved

    since initial implementation and work with them to

    leverage the new capabilities o the system. Te ocus,

    she says, is to deliver on high-level organizational goals

    by leveraging their existing investments in laboratory

    instrumentation, inormatics and enterprise systems. And

    while the concept o a truly paperless lab has been hotly

    debated or many years, it is really only now coming into

    its own. Te latest Inormatics solutions are capable o ully

    integrating the lab to the rest o the business, eliminating

    or the most part many o the paper-based processes that

    have caused bottlenecks in workflow or contributed to

    errors in transcribing results and generating reports.

    Because LIMS are tightly integrated with otheretepise opeatio sstems suc as ErP, isits fom te

    lab have the potential to be even more central to businesses

    seeking true enterprise-wide agility says Meek. Businesses

    arent simply capturing and collecting data; they are

    making data actionable across the enterprise, putting

    management in the position to transorm their businesses

    into agile organizations capable o responding quickly to

    market trends or new regulations and flexible enough to

    recognize and capitalize on cost-saving or margin-growing

    opportunities in the uture.

    Rockwells Lie Science manuacturing customers, notes

    Vogel, are moving to maximize their operating options by

    standardizing the underlying recipe and execution process

    around five imperatives: product quality, cost control,

    saety, risk reduction and compliance. Tis will maximize

    quality adherence, reduce risk and minimize cost

    variations rom plant to plant. o ensure product quality,

    fo eampe, etepise MES couped wit adaced EMI

    sofware is being used by manuacturing and I teams.

    Reports are produced throughout the day by aggregating

    data rom machine, plant, enterprise and third-party

    applications to produce real-time dashboards with unique

    situational and historical context or different users.

    o improve compliance, contends Vogel, companies

    are selecting inormation technologies that go beyondcollection and archiving o data. odays manuacturers

    are looking to inormation technology to automatically

    gather required data, drive regulatory compliance, and

    enorce execution standards while having robust security

    capabiities. Depoi a Maufactui Eecutio Sstem

    (MES) wit adaced ifomatio tecooies suc

    as these has been proving to be a plus to profitability.

    It greatly increases quality adherence coupled with the

    ability to shif the production o a single product or a group

    rom under-perorming plants to locations that are more

    advantageous to the bottom line.

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    17/31

    17

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    WellSpring is a unique pharmaceutical contract manufacturer offering complete clinical and commercial

    manufacturing, packaging and analytical services from a single FDA inspected and Health Canada

    licensed facility. Our culture flourishes with the energy of teamwork, innovation, integrity, entrepreneurial

    spirit and creative problem solving. Need fast, flexible service? We provide it. Want attention to detail at

    every stage? We deliver it. Demand expertise? We guarantee it.

    Find out why WellSpring is the supplier of choice for our clients

    and find out what we can do for you today.

    Nurturing product solutions

    844-879-7427 I [email protected] I WellSpringCMO.com I 400 Iroquois Shore Road, Oakville, ON L6H 1M5

    _ ll i _ _ i

    NEXT PAGEPREVIOUS PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    18/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    18

    Pharmas tech bench gets deeper with an All-Star lineup

    ready for the big leaguesBY STEVEN E. KUEHN, EDITOR-IN-CHIEF

    HOME RUNS are getting harder to come by in the phar-

    maceutical industry and drug makers know it. Innovation

    writ large or Pharma used to mean unneling, stadium-

    filling amounts o money into research and development

    (r&D) eots tied to di te et bocbuste teapy

    and aferwards, reaping the rewards o its patent-protected

    profitability. For most o Pharmas history, those successes

    ueled even more profligate research spending, dollars which

    not only financed the development o new winners, but also

    plenty o losers as well. But in the wake o patent expiries

    (and an ever-shrinking pool o large-class disease catego-

    ries), this Blockbuster Quest business models being traded

    fo a eae, moe cost-eectie r&D ad maufactui

    strategy designed to ocus drug discovery efforts and acceler-

    ate the time it takes to get a solid hit, take it around the bases

    and score a run.gaii suc competitie aiity is iceasiy comi

    rom the Pharma industrys technology and system

    suppliers. Tese companies are fielding some pretty

    impressive players to support big-league Pharma-style

    innovation. Fortunately, innovation is a competitive driver

    fo Pama tecooy poides as we, ad tei r&D

    efforts continue to deliver game-winning solutions ready

    to drive costs out and efficiencies in to drug manuacturing

    operations. Tese innovators deserve to be recognized. What

    ollows are this years All-Star Innovators: technologies and

    systems introduced within the last 12 months that, based

    on their relative applicational and technical merits, were

    selected by Pharmaceutical Manufacturings editors and

    reviewers to be on this years All-Star Roster. Just like in

    the big leagues, each player, er, product is highlighted by its

    own card, complete with perormance and other stats. What

    ollows are excerpts rom those cards, but to view them in

    their entirety visit PharmaManuacturing.comand click on

    the All-Star Innovators logo. For now, though, take your

    seat, grab some peanuts and find out which ones might have

    the potential to be on your team.

    ANALYTICAL AND MONITORING DEVICES

    Cobalt Light Systems RapID developed its competitive edge

    via its patented Spatially Offset Raman Spectroscopy (SORS)

    technology, which permits a high-quality Raman spectrumto be measured through the thick, unopened layers o pack-

    aging. Most players know significant time and resources

    can be spent on veriying the identity o raw materials.

    Accurate ID o these materials is essential, but time consum-

    ing, expensive and resource intensive. RapID allows ID

    through unopened plastic containers or growth media

    and brown glass bottles or sterile liquids. According to

    Cobalt, sacks o lactose can now be identified through a

    mutiaye pape sac i 20-30 secods witout eedi

    to open or sample the sack.

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

    http://localhost/var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_4/PharmaManufacturing.comhttp://localhost/var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_4/PharmaManufacturing.com
  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    19/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    19

    RapID

    COBALT LIGHTSYSTEMS

    Most understand that i you have a player who can execute

    on undamentals a little bit aster and more accurately, its

    likely it can make a winning contribution to an optimizedpocess statey. gE Powe & Wates ot oe, te Siees

    M9 Tota Oaic Cabo (TOC) Aayze. Desied to

    measure OC in a broad range o samples rom ultrapure

    wate to pocess wates, te M9 is abe

    to measure OC and conductivity

    simultaneously, and provide accurate

    results in only two minutes.

    Prozess echnologie developed an

    interesting approach that drives a bit

    o complexity and a lot o cost out o

    spectroscopic measurement with its

    rEvEAl Measuemet Appiaces.Tis in-process spectroscopic

    measurement tool confirms blend

    conormity in real time and is easily

    deployable at a price that is well below

    industry norms. Te company reers

    to its devices as appliances because

    unlike other measurement platorms,

    the unit is a single measurement

    device, eliminating the need or labs

    and scientists while delivering an

    accurate measurement or batch-based and continuously

    pocessed compouds. rEvEAl is desied to wo

    in virtually any manuacturing environment including

    hazardous materials and provides data that is accessible

    anytime via wired and wireless methods.

    need a paye wo ca deie mateia ID weee its

    needed? Rigaku Raman echnologies has one ready to run

    the base line. Its Progeny Material ID Handheld system offers

    bench top analytical perormance in a rugged, ergonomic

    and IP-68 sealed enclosure. Progenys ully customizable

    workflow sofware is 21 CFR Part 11 compliant, and its

    ast quad-core processor manages demanding search and

    quantification algorithms without requiring remote desktopwo outies. A ioatie 512-pie IgaAs detecto

    delivers improved resolution, analytics and signal to noise,

    handling the most challenging mixture analyses.

    Improving HPLC/UHPLC method development

    productivity is an optimal strategy to speed drug

    development operations. Shimadzu Scientific Instruments

    itoduced its neea Metod Scouti System at Pittco

    2014, wee it was ecoized as a stad-out pefome.

    Equipped wit two pumps eac wit a quateay ae

    Shimadzus system allows analysts to run binary gradients

    with 16 different solvent pairs. When combined with a robust,

    high-pressure resistant column selection valve, which holdsup to six conventional or UHPLC columns, the system can

    iestiate up to 96 uique sepaatio coditios pe sampe.

    A transer program allows ultra-high-speed conditions to be

    transerred to conventional conditions,

    mai te system suitabe fo bot r&D

    and QA/QC applications.

    Wates iokey/MS System iteates

    UPLC separation into the mass

    spectrometer or improved sensitivity

    and unparalleled compound separation

    and detection something that reduces

    solvent consumption and costs andsimplifies the user experience. Containing

    uidic coectios, eectoics, ESI

    interace, a column heater, eCord

    Intelligent Chip echnology and 1.7

    micron UPLC grade particles packed

    iside a 150 mico I.D. cae, te

    iokey/MS System was Mec Beta tested

    eeai a >60-fod icease i sesitiity

    fo glP-1.

    AUTOMATION CONTROL AND SENSING

    Edess+hause cotiues to iteee at citica poits

    in manuacturing and process control and data environ-

    ments, and its CM44x Liquiline Multichannel ransmit-

    ter is a strong individual contributor to processing trains

    ia Etenet/IP. Oe CM44 tasmitte i pay aows

    access to many parameters and accepts inputs down to the

    sensor level, including sensor condition and diagnostics.

    raditionally, devices measuring and controlling process

    variables rely on a process instrumentation network to

    transer data, while other devices within the plant work

    on a completely different network. By improving this

    complex, multi-tier networking strategy with one stan-dad etwo acitectue Etenet/IP uses ae

    better access to real-time inormation. Tis improves the

    ability to monitor overall perormance, troubleshoot out-

    o-margin conditions and minimize downtime.

    Diverse pH and ORP sensing applications across

    Pharma and chemical process system piping require

    a tough and smart player to get the job done. With its

    ued ryto body mateia, geo Fisce Pipi

    Systems DryLoc Sensors deploy a positive connector

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    20/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    20

    www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    DHXSINGLE-USEHEATEXCHANGER

    ASILIFESCIENCES

    system to indicate a solid, water-tight connection and

    resist moisture/dirt intrusions. Te sensors mount into

    stadad Siet 0.50-ic to 4-ic ttis as we as

    ito gF tees ad educi tees of ic o ae. e

    installation versatility makes v irtually any manuacturers

    sensor simple and easy to replace when coupled with the

    Siet 2760 Dyloc coecto, wic ca oo up to ote

    manuacturers instruments.

    BIO PROCESSING

    Ofen innovation comes rom

    understanding theres a gap andfilling it. ASI Lie Sciences engineers

    understood that without an avail-

    able high-capacity, single-use heat

    exchanger, manuacturing engineers

    were being orced to choose one o two

    sub-optimal options: Insert a stain-

    less-steel heat exchanger along with its

    incumbent CIP/SIP inrastructure or

    use a jacketed mixing tote or similar

    technology as a stop-gap solution. Cer-

    tai ot idea. ASIs Dhx Sie-Use

    heat Ecae ow oes a pupose-

    built solution by combining the heat

    transer properties o a high-capacity

    plate and rame heat exchangers with

    the advantages users can leverage rom

    its single-use configuration. ASIs sys-

    tem offers advantages or cell culture at the manuactur-

    ing scale, allowing engineers to build temperature control

    into their process without having to sacrifice the benefits

    o single-use.

    On deck last September and already bringing

    efficiencies to downstream single-stage clarificationae EMD Miipoes Caisoe Dept Fites. Wit

    higher titers coming rom todays upstream bioreactors,

    conventional approaches have posed a chal lenge to

    clarification, that is, until now. Clarisolve depth filters

    eliminate the need or centriugation, which enables

    implementation o a ully single-use process train and

    reduces pre-use flushing requirements. Tis technology

    was developed to address the shortcomings o

    traditional downstream clarification approaches when

    processing high cell density and high-product titer

    cell cultures.

    Any process operation is likely well supported by

    automating manual tasks. Parker domnick hunter

    offers its SciLog SciFlex Filter and Dispense System, a

    downstream solution that automates final bulk filtration

    and container filling, a step previously perormed in a

    manual ashion within a vertical laminar flow cabinet.

    Te system can perorm manual filtrations, constant

    pressure, constant flow rate or the companys R/P Stat

    Method, a hybrid method that maximizes filtration

    capacity. Playing or Fujifilm Diosynth Biotechnologies,

    the installation o the SciFlex Filter

    and Dispense System into thecompas cgMP maufactui

    was a critical success actor in

    achieving compliant, right-the-

    first time manuacture o biologic

    pharmaceuticals, according to the

    biotech firm.

    Single-use systems rely most on

    the disposable vessels at their heart,

    and Sartorius Stedim Biotech has

    developed its Flexsae Single-Use

    Family o scalable range bags to

    perorm better. Flexsae enables

    the implementation o single-use

    bioprocessing throughout all steps

    o drug manuacture using a single

    polyethylene film. Te innovative

    concept addresses key industry

    requirements or uture-proo single-use manuacturing

    o commercial vaccines and drugs. Te optimization

    o the resin ormulation, the complete control o raw

    materials, the extrusion process and the bag assembly

    guarantee lot-to-lot consistent cell growth perormance.

    Furthermore, batch-to-batch consistent extractablesand leachables profiles support drug manuacturers

    throughout the entire liecycle o modern biological

    treatments.

    PACKAGING AND HANDLING

    gass ampoues, ias ad ote esses ae bee o

    Pharmas team a long time and possess many superior

    qualities. However, commercial-scale handling o glass in

    Pharma filling and handling operations is prone to create

    contamination issues rom (relatively) rough handling.

    gaey Cop.s Iity rx 36 Tabe Top Accumuato is a

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    21/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    21

    544SeriesIntelliSwitchIIv

    CONCOAINFINITYRX36TABLE TOPACCUMULATOR

    GARVEYCORP.

    MANESTYTPR500TABLETPRESS

    BOSCHPACKAGINGTECHNOLOGY

    potential trade or traditional rotary table or turntable ac-

    cumulators in product-handling environments. Te Infinity

    rx 36 ca out-feed poducts faste ta a taditioa otay

    table and with less pressure and no damage, says the com-

    pany, and requires the same ootprint as a traditional rotary

    table while greatly reducing the pressure and noise associ-

    ated with rotary table accumulators.

    hamito Stoae Tecooies labEite Bectop lie

    offers users end-to-end, automated liquid sample processing,

    decapping, recapping and high-speed barcode reading. Tis

    innovator rom Hamilton provides the market with the first

    system where users have the ability to positively identiy the

    tube chosen or decapping/recapping and track it throughout

    te woow. e labEite I.D. cappe eabes abs to combie

    decapping/recapping and high-speed barcode reading within

    one device without additional user interaction. When sample

    taci is ot equied, te labEite DeCappe is eady fo

    decappi ad ecappi tubes i 48-cyoia o 96-micotube

    racks. A new eature can automatically move the racks romportrait to landscape ormats.

    PROCESS HARDWARE

    Process gas handling is ofen a critical control parameter, and

    te 544 Seies IteiSwitc II fom COnCOA is desied to

    routinely switch between two gas sources without interrup-

    tion. Tis team player offers reliable high-flow, high-pressure

    switching in the most demanding applications and environ-

    mets. Ecoomizatio sowae ituay eimiates iquid

    cylinder vent loss and substantially reduces residual return.

    Switching is actuated as inlet pressure alls below a user-defined

    point by means o a Web interace or a serial port. A server al-

    lows or remote monitoring and e-mail notification o events.

    SOLIDS HANDLING

    Conveying ragile, riable products to and rom an opera-

    tion along the line takes a player with a gentle touch. Flexicon

    Corp.s Flexi-Disc ubular Cable Conveyors have that touch

    able to move delicate pharmaceutical products gently, quietly

    and dust-ree, horizontally, vertically or any angle with

    minimal space requirements. Te conveyors are designed to

    integrate with upstream and/or downstream equipment that

    sources material rom single or multiple locations and deliver

    it selectively to storage vessels, filling machines or other pro-

    cessing equipment. Flexi-Disc conveyor moves materials

    using high-strength polymer discs in 4- and 6-inch diameters

    affixed to a stainless-steel or galvanized cable. Systems can

    have single or multiple inlets and outlets, and convey over

    short distances or hundreds o eet/meters.

    TABLETING

    Attention to detail provides Bosch Packaging echnologys

    Maesty TPr 500 Tabet Pess a ioatie ede. Buit

    or commercial, high-volume line duty, Boschs press can

    poduce moe ta 400,000 tabets pe ou ad featues we-

    integrated components and an advanced HMI to deliver high

    throughput as well as reduced maintenance requirements. For

    instance, filling parameters can be reproduced to consistently

    support high-quality yields. o ensure the smooth delivery o

    tablets, its rue Flow tablet discharge chute eatures a pneu-

    matic gate mechanism and an optimized take-off angle, which

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    22/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    22

    SmartDose

    WESThMTS

    3MACCELRYSCAPTURE

    BIOVIA

    the company says reduces product damage and increases

    output, especially with shaped/riable tablets.

    DRUG DELIVERY

    Dosing compliance is an issue both Pharma and health care

    pofessioas ae seei aswes fo, ad 3M is appyi

    its vast materials and manuacturing experience to solve

    them. Its Hollow Microstructured ransdermal System is a

    patient-riendly intradermal delivery solution designed or

    difficult-to-deliver biologics and other therapies. Human

    facto eemets to te 3M MTS icude a tetued ip

    and the capability or non-specific actuation. A cap protects

    the microneedle array, which patients simply remove, adhere

    to the skin o the thigh or abdomen, then press down to

    begin dosing. An audible click assures activation. Te FDA-

    approved device is capable o delivering liquid ormulations

    fom 0.5 ml to 2 ml.

    Achieving better perormance per dose is something

    gaoSmitkie wated fo its FDA-appoed type 2diabetes du ad noozymes vElTIS haf life Etesio

    Platorm provided via its Veltis albiglutide technology that

    helps diabetes therapies achieve an extended hal-lie; patients

    are only required to inject their medication once a week.

    Veltis hal-lie extension platorm is based on engineered

    albumins that enable manuacturers to define and optimize

    the therapeutic window o their drug candidate to help

    control dose requency, dose quantity and improve drug

    tolerability. Te platorm also offers the ability to provide

    once-weekly, once two-weekly or once-monthly peptide or

    protein dosing.

    West designed the SmartDose patch injector system

    technology to be a single-use system ready to deliver higher-

    dose volumes by injecting therapies slowly over a period o

    time. SmartDose can be pre-programmed and controlled

    to provide the optimal dosing rate because many injectable

    drugs currently on the market require repeated dosing

    and are intended or sel-administration. Wests system is

    delivered in a single package; patients insert the cartridge

    into the devices injector and adheres the system to the body.

    A push o a button inserts the needle and starts the injection,

    which is delivered over time, based on instructions entered

    by the drug company. Visible/audible indicators confirm

    operation o the system.

    INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES

    hitti te ed at Pittco, Bio-rad laboatoies kowItA

    ATr/Ir ad rama ID Epet oe ew tecooies, says

    the company, that combine years o accumulated knowledge

    in the field o spectroscopy with advanced computationalpower to provide the astest, most accurate answers possible

    to scientists identiying unknown inrared and Raman

    specta. kowItA sowae oes uses compeesie

    solutions or spectral analysis, identification, search, data

    management and reporting. It supports multiple instrument

    vendor file ormats and techniques including IR, Raman,

    nIr, nMr, MS, Uv-vis. ready fo cgMP ad QbD-

    compliant operations, the spectral intelligence built into

    kowItA ATr/Ir ID Epet, combied wit te wods

    largest spectral reerence collection, provides a high level o

    expertise to any scientist.

    PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    23/31

    23

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    TERSUSCLEANROOMLAUNDERINGSOLUTION

    CO2NEXUS

    Increasingly, mobile devices are bringing efficiencies toPharma process and procedures, especially when it comes

    to paper-based SOPs in the lab. o help run down this issue

    and support mobile-device applications, BIOVIA, a brand o

    Dassault Systmes (previously Accelrys) introduced Accelrys

    Captue at Pittco 2014. ou a sma mobie deice,

    users can enter data quickly, find procedures and make

    instant procedural annotations at the bench without having

    to document changes outside the lab.

    BIOVIAs technology helps ensure

    that laboratory data meets prerequisite

    requirements beore being recorded,

    thereby reducing review time andrework loops. Automated compliance

    solutions include validation-ready

    wireless inrastructure, validation-

    ready handheld devices or tracking/

    tracing process-linked data and

    numerous instrument-to-procedure

    integrations running on handheld

    devices in regulated laboratory

    environments.

    A hit at Spring raining,

    Biopharms BioSolve Process 5

    process analysis and economic

    modeling platorm provides

    insight that enables biopharma

    innovators to reduce manuacturing costs and make more

    inormed process and operational decisions. Armed with

    data rom a broad spectrum o sources, BioSolve Process can

    analyze a range o scenarios to support operations business

    planning, rom building a business case or a ully integrated

    continuous biomanuacturing platorm to the development

    o an integrated continuous purification process template or

    monoclonal antibodies.

    need a paye wo ca deie compete coto oemethods and SOPs rom a single source, and one that

    combies SDMS, lIMS ad lES ito oe iteated patfom,

    and obsoletes paper-based systems? Termo Fisher Scientific

    eded its a-aoude lab Eecutio System lES at Pittco

    2014 ad is eady to pay. e patfoms fuctioaity is buit

    on the Termo Fisher Scientific SampleManager platorm

    and is ully integrated with the newest SampleManager

    LIMS. It combines all the unctionality and integration

    capabilities necessary to move toward a truly paperless lab,

    and lets lab managers automate their SOPs and methods, but

    with much deeper integration.

    SUPPLY CHAIN TRANSPARENCYruag echnologies ruag microtags are inert, edible

    and can integrate into the abric o a product, independent

    o packaging and labels, much like fingerprints. Millions o

    optical patterns can be embedded into a ruag, which is

    a dust-sized particle less than the width o a human hair. It

    can be used or the authentication o ood, drugs and other

    commercial/consumer products. A security platorm that

    will help prevent countereiting, ruags technology etches

    unique spectral barcodes into a porous

    silicon waer. Te codes can be measured

    via a portable spectrometer-based optical

    reader and can reerence a label in a securedatabase, where more inormation about

    the item (including lot number, expira-

    tion date, date o manuacture, authorized

    customer, or country o authorized sale) can

    be stored as desired.

    Imagine a labeling system that could

    provide seamless, wireless, near-field

    communications and data capture along

    with temperature and time sensing.

    i Fim Eectoics did, deeopi

    te im nea Fied Commuicatio

    Smart Label. Te platorm is designed to

    handle a variety o sensing elements, both

    printed and conventional, and depending

    on the application, labels may be ully printed or eature

    a combination o printed and surace-mounted elements.

    Furthermore, Tinfilms Printed-dopant polysilicon logic

    allows Tinfilm engineers to significantly compress the

    cycle time or new designs.

    WASTE STREAM AND SUSTAINABILITY

    A solution that simplifies both resource management and a

    necessary operational chore in an innovative way is sure tofind a spot on any team, in this case near a clean control zones

    locker room. CO2neus Tesus Ceaoom laudei Sou-

    tion enables simple, modular cleanroom laundry plants to be

    deployed virtually anywhere, liberating cleanroom garment

    end-users and service providers rom the uncertainties associ-

    ated with water availability, permitting, cost, validation and

    quality. Offering the worlds first CO2-based barrier (pass thru)

    system and the companys cleanroom-specific process and

    chemistry, ersus uses liquid carbon dioxide in place o water,

    40-45 poud ceai capacity, 30-miute cyce times, ad

    90-poud touput/ou ia a adaced coto system.

    NEXT PAGEPREVIOUS PAGE

  • 7/23/2019 Best of Pharma 2014 eBook

    24/31

    BEST OFPHARMACEUTICAL M ANUFACTURING www.pharmamanufacturing.com

    24

    BY THOMAS OTTO, MANAGING DIRECTOR, VETTER

    FOR DRUG MANUFACTURERS, THE DUAL-

    CHAMBER SYSTEM OFFERS AN ALTERNATIVEFOR SENSITIVE SUBSTANCES.

    FREEZE-DRIED PRODUCTS are currently omnipres-

    ent and gaining more and more ground in the pharma-

    ceutical market. I international pharmaceutical and

    biotech industries want to keep up, they are compelled to

    reconsider their strategies. In the past ew years, no ewer

    ta 30% of a FDA appoas fo paetea dus wee

    given or lyophilized products. Market research is even

    pedicti tat 50% of a paetea dus wi be opi-lized in the uture. For the manuacturers involved, the

    major change lies in the challenges affecting the choice

    o packaging.

    Lyophilization is particularly advantageous or

    complex and highly sensitive substances. For instance,

    reeze-drying increases a drugs resistance to heat,

    light and other external influences. Development,

    manuacturing and delivery o such substances,

    however, demands different requirements than with

    iquid fomuatios. gaeic fomuatio, fo eampe,

    requires other excipients, while manuacturing demands

    efficient reeze-drying cycles. Also, the drug has to be

    reconstituted completely and saely immediately prior

    to administration.

    A STRATEGY FOR THE LONG TERM

    Lyophilized drugs require manuacturers to think care-

    ully about what kind o packaging their product will

    need; usually vials or dual-chamber systems, with the lat-

    ter being either syringes or cartridges. Tese two systems

    involve different manuacturing processes and later deliv-

    e steps. Eac oes specic oppotuities tat deped

    on the competitive situation. When determining the mostadapted packaging or the chosen system, companies

    should take into consideration three critical actors:

    e maet Wat ote dus ae aaiabe, ad i

    what drug delivery system?

    e use Wo wi be pefomi te ijectio, ad

    will the user group be expanded to the homecare seg-

    ment at a later date?

    Pacai ow-ow Does te compa itsef o a

    contract development and manuacturing organization

    (CDMO) dispose o efficient production technologies

    and innovative injection systems?

    INNOVATORS FAVOR VIALS

    Vials are a good option i the product is a genuine

    innovation with no visible competition in the medium-

    term. Tey are less complex than other options, and the

    manuacturing processes are airly standard. Choosing

    vials reduces t ime-to-market which, in turn, optimizes

    the duration o patent protection.

    At the same time, vials require experience orthe reconstitution o the drug and or producing an

    accurate dosage. I the user group includes not only

    doctors and nursing staff, but also patients and/or their

    relatives, then