baseline findings jan 2011 vimosewa arogya sanshodan
TRANSCRIPT
Baseline FindingsJan 2011
VimoSEWAArogya Sanshodan
Today’s Presentation
Overview of Swasthya Sanshodan project
Summary of baseline findings
Analysis plan
Your feedback on data, analysis and use
Action Research – Why?
VimoSEWA claims 2007-9Primary illness 40% of claimsHysterectomy top claim for rural women, avg
age 37
Effectiveness of health education Longstanding SEWA activity, in different formsRecent studies show impact on neonatal
mortality Can it work for primary care and
hysterectomy?
Research QuestionsCan health education reduce unnecessary
hospitalisation for diarrhea and fever?IncidenceExpenditureHealth seeking behaviour
What are the drivers of hysterectomy? How does education impact on knowledge and
response to hysterectomy and gynecological care?
Do insured members seek health care differently?Does an education program work differently for
the uninsured?
Intervention Design
Selected 28 sevikas who work where VimoSEWA/LSM active
Randomly selected 14 sevikas to implement health education
Focus on diarrhea, malaria/fever and hysterectomyFilm, games and demonstrationsCapacity building and regular feedback
Over 2 years, 5 survey rounds amongst insured and uninsured to capture health seeking behavior
Study Coverage
70 HH sampled in each cluster 35 uninsured – from area listing35 insured – from Vimo MIS
Insured Uninsured Total
Urban 420 396 816
Rural 560 558 1,118
Total 980 954 1,934
HH Profile Rural Urban
Nuclear Family 57% 62%
HH size 5.8 5.8
Yrs in current home
17 yrs 19 yrs
Religion 93% Hindu6% Muslim
83% Hindu16% Muslim
HH income (annual)
INR 79,260 INR 83,337
HH expenditure INR 66,505 INR 66,120
Education: % ever studied
Respondent Profile
Rural Urban
Age 37 39
Marital status
92% married7% widowed
83% married13% widowed
Women working
85% 61%
% SEWA members
53% 60%
% SEWA Bank
13% 55%
Women’s Work
Housing : % HH by Type
Household Toilets
Drinking WaterRural Urban
Own Tap 74% 78%
Shared Tap 13% 12%
Use chlorine 27% 46%
Filter with cloth
94% 83%
Take with doyo
22% 40%
Mosquito precautions
Ration Cards/BPL
SEWA Health Services
VimoSEWA Services
VimoSEWA Coverage
VimoSEWA reach Rural Urban
% of SEWA members 89 74
% of Bank members 77 69
HH with anyone ill – last month
Illness Rates – last month
Leading Illnesses - Women
Place of OPD Treatment
Avg private exp: Rs. 380Primarily private care, but less so in city
Note slight differences within HH
Avg private exp: Rs. 501
% HH reported hospitalisation in last 6 months
Hospitalisation per 100; last 6 mos.
Rural and Urban
Hospitalisation amongst women
Rural Urban
Rates: Rural Vimo/Non-insured
Rates: Urban Vimo/Non-insured
Where Hospitalised - AllRural
Urban
Place of Hospitalisation
Expenditure – Vimo and NV
Are VimoSEWA members different?
DIFFERENCESSES – only urban
More salaried Higher expMore pucca houses
DemographicMore widowsLess educated
(urban)Much more likely to have a ration card
SIMILARITIESSES
Income ToiletsHousing (rural)
DemographicHH sizeFamily structure
Reproductive Health
Rural Urban
Hysterectomy
Age at hysterectomy
Hysterectomy Reasons
Place of Hysterectomy
Analysis PlanBaselineWomen’s illnesses and health seeking behaviour Insured and UninsuredSocial Determinants of Health
OverallImpact of health education – with qualitativeHysterectomy – with qualitative Community health workers – performance and roles