1

Shivaji University Kolhapur

Sub : Philosophy

C.B.C.S.

B.A. – Part – III (Syllabus)

From – 2020 – 2021 to Onward

2

Unit and No. of Lectures

Unit No.of Lectures

1 No.of Lectures - 15

2 No.of Lectures - 15

3 No.of Lectures - 15

4 No.of Lectures - 15

Equivalence in Accordance with Titles and contents of paper (for revised syllabus) Sr. Sem

No. Paper No.

Title of Old Paper Sem No.

Paper No.

Title of New Paper (C.B.C.S.)

1 V VII System of Indian Philosophy (Part I)

V VII System of Indian Philosophy (Part I)

2 V VIII Western Philosophy (Modern)

V VIII Western Philosophy (Modern)

3 V IX (a)

IX (b)

Traditional Logic or Symbolic Logic (Propositional Logic)

V IX (a)

IX (b)

Traditional Logic or Symbolic Logic

4 V X (a)

X (b)

Philosophy of Religion (Part I) or Philosophy of Saints ( Part I)

V X (a)

X (b)

Philosophy of Religion (Part I) or Philosophy of Saints ( Part I)

5 V XI (a) XI (b)

Contemporary Philosophy (Indian) or Philosophy of Education (Part I)

V XI (a)

XI (b)

Contemporary Philosophy (Indian) or Philosophy of Education (Part I)

VI XII System of Indian Philosophy (Part II)

VI XII System of Indian Philosophy (Part II)

VI XIII Western Philosophy (Recent)

VI XIII Western Philosophy (Recent)

VI XIV (a) XIV (b)

Scientific Method or Symbolic Logic (Predicate Logic)

VI XIV (a)

XIV (b)

Scientific Method or Symbolic Logic

VI XV (a) XV (b)

Philosophy of Religion (Part II) or Philosophy of Saints ( Part II)

VI XV (a) XV (b)

Philosophy of Religion (Part II) or Philosophy of Saints ( Part II)

VI XVI (a) XVI (b)

Contemporary Philosophy (Western) or Philosophy of Education (Part II)

VI XVI (a) XVI (b)

Contemporary Philosophy (Western) or Philosophy of Education (Part II)

3

Shivaji University, Kolhapur

B.A.Part III PHILOSOPHY

Nature of Question Papers for all papers (excluding Logic) Total Marks 40 Time - 2 hours

Marsk Q.1 Complete the following sentences by choosing

correct alternative 5

Q.2 Write short answers (any 3) (out of 5) 15 Q.1 Answer the questions fully (any 2) (out of 3) 20

{edmOr {dÚmnrR>

~r.E.^mJ - 3 VÎdkmZ gd© nong© - go{_ñQ>agmR>r (AndmX VH©$emñÌ)

JwU- 40 doi- 2 Vmg

Mark

iz'u 1 [kkyh fnysY;k i;kZ;kae/kwu ;ksX; i;kZ; fuoMwu fo/kkus iw.kZ djk

xq.k 5

iz'u 2 FkksMD;kr mÙkjs fygk ¼dks.krhgh 3½ ¼5 iSdh½ xq.k 15

iz'u 3 [kkyhy iz”ukaph lfoLrj mRRkjs fygk ¼3 iSdh 2½ xq.k 20

4

PHILOSOPHY (Special) Paper - VII Systems of Indian Philosophy (Part-I)

Semester – V

(Note:- The heterodox systems (Carvaka, Jainism & Buddhism) and Advaita Vedanta being included in B.A. Part-I Philosophy course, are not included in this course. 1. Philosophy in Veda and Upanisada

A) Kinds and nature of Vedas & Upanishada B) Vedic deities – C) Upanisadic conceptions of At man and Brahman

2. Philosophy in Bhagavadgita:-

A) Nature & purpose of Gita, & Today’s Life

B) Jhanayoga, Karmayoga and Bhaktiyoga

C) The concept of Idal Person

3. Samkhaya Darshan

A) The nature of Prakriti and Purusa

B) Evolution of Prakriti

C) Theory of Causation (Satkaravada)

4. Yoga Darshan

A) Nature of Yoga Darshan & Importacne in modern life

B) Astaangayoga

C) Place of God in Yoga Darshan

5

rÙoKku ¼fo'ks"k½ isij ua- 7 Hkkjrh; rRoKkukrhy n'kZus

l= & V 1½ osn & mifu’knkrhy rRoKku%&

v- osn] mifu’kns& izdkj o Lo:i c- oSfnd nsork& c- mifu"knkrhy vkRek o czg~e ladYiuk

2½ Jhen~Hkxon~xhrk n”kZu %

v- xhrsps Lo:i] iz;kstu vkf.k vktps thou c- Kku;ksx] deZ;ksx vkf.k HkfDr;ksx d- vkn”kZ iq#’kkph ladYiuk

3½ lka[; n”kZu %& v- izdrh o iq#"kkps Lo#i c- izdrhph mRdzkarh d- lRdk;Zokn 4½ ;ksx n”kZu %& v- ;ksx n”kZukps Lo#i vkf.k vk/kqfud thoukrhy egRo c- v’Vkax;ksx d- ;ksx n'kZukrhy bZ'ojkps Lo#i o LFkku Books for Readings:_ 1- Jh- g- fnf{kr %& Hkkjrh; rRoKku 2- x- uk- tks'kh %& Hkkjrh; rRoKkukpk cgn bfrgkl 3- Hkk- x- dksrdj %& Hkkjrh; rRoKkukph #ijs"kk 4- ih- Mh- pkS/kjh %& Hkkjrh; rRoKkukpk bfrgkl 5- n- ok- tksx %& Hkkjrh; loZ n”kZu laxzg 6- MkW-osnizdk”k Mks.kxkodj & Hkkjrh; rRRoKku Books for Readings:_ 1. Dr. S. Radhakrishnan :- Indian Philosophy Vol. I & II 2. Chartterji and Dutta :- Introduction to Indian Philosophy 3. Hiriyanna :- Outlines of Indian Philosophy

6

PHILOSOPHY (Special) Paper No.-VIII

Western Philosophy (Modern) Semester - V

1. Spinoza:- A) Theory of Knowledge B) Doctrine of substance, Attributes and modes C) Concept of Pantheism 2. Leibnitz:- A) Theory of monads B) Dectorine of Pre-established harmony C) Arguments for the existence of God. 3. Hume:- A) Objects of Human Knowledge B) Theory of causation C) Scepticism 4. Kant:- A) Critical Philosophy B) A priori synthetic Propositions C) Ethical theory - Gita & duty for duties sake

7

isij ua- 8 ik'pkR; rRoKku

¼vk/kqfud½ l= & V

1½ fLiuks>k%& v- Kku fl/nkar c- nzO;] xq.k vkf.k fodkj fl/nkar d- losZ'ojoknkph ladYiuk 2½ yk;fCut%& v- fpn~.kw fl/nkar c- iwoZizLrkfir lqlaoknkpk fl/nkar d- bZ'ojkP;k vfLrRokfo"k;hps ;qfDrokn 3½ g;we%& v- ekuoh Kkukps ?kVd c- dkj.krk fl/nkar d- lansgokn ¼la'k;okn½ 4½ dkaV%& v- fpfdRld rRoKku c- vuqHkoiwoZ la'ys"kd fo/kkus d- uSfrd miiRRkh&xhrk vkf.k drZO;klkBh drZO; Books for Reading:- 1- fn- ;- ns'kikaMs %& vokZphu ik'pkR; rRoKku Hkkx 1 o 3 2- x- uk- tks'kh %& ik'pkR; rRoKkukpk bfrgkl [kaM 2 o 3- 3. W.K. Wright :- A History of modern philosophy 4. D. M. Datta :- Chief currents of contemporary philosophy. 5. John Passmore:- Hundred years of Philosophy. Books for Reference:- 1- ns- n- okMsdj %& ejkBh rRoKku egkdksl [kaM 1 o 2 2. G. I. Warnock :- English Philosophy since 1900 3. D.I.O. Connoz :- A critical History of Western Philosophy

8

Paper No.-IX (a) Traditional Logic

Semester - V 1. Nature of Logic:-

A) Definition and Nature of Logic B) Deductive and Inductive Inference C) Proposition, Sentence and Terms

2. Classification of Propositions

A) Categorical Propositions B) Conditional Propositions C) Distribution of Terms in A,E,I,O Propositions

3. Immediate Inference:-

A) Opposition of Proposition B) Education :- Conversion and Obversion C) Proof of Inforene by Immediate Inforcence

4. Mediate Inference:-

A) Categorical Syllogism B) Mixed Hypothetical Syllagism C) Proof of Argument by Mediate Inference

9

isij ua- 9 ¼v½ ikjaikfjd rdZ'kkL= l= & 5

1½ rdZ'kkL=kps Lo#i%&

v- rdZ'kkL=kph O;k[;k] egRo o Lo#i c- fuxkeh vkf.k foxkeh vuqeku d- fo/kku] okD; o ins

2½ fo/kkukaps oxhZdj.k%&

v- fu#ikf/kd fo/kkus c- lksikf/kd fo/kkus d-A, E, I, O fo/kkukarhy inkaph O;kIrh

3½ vO;ofgr vuqeku%&

v- fo/kku izfr;ksxh vuqekus c- mRd"kZ.k% ifjorZu vkf.k izfrorZu d- vO;ofgr vuqekukP;k lkg~;kus vuqekukph fl/nrk

4½ O;ofgr vuqeku

v- ljy lafo/kku c- feJ vuqyac lafo/kku d- O;ofgr vuqekukP;k lkg~;kus ;qfDroknkph fl/nrk

vH;klkph iqLrds%& 1- Jhfuokl gjh fnf{kr & rdZ'kkL= 2- gqR;kGdj] dkGs] dkoGs & lqxe rdZ'kkL= vkf.k oSKkfud i/nrh 3- ukaxjs] ok?krksMs] fgjos & ikjaikfjd rdZ'kkL=] ¼f'kokth fo|kihB izdk'ku½ 4- K.T. Basantani - Introduction to Logic 5. Cohen and Nagel - Introduction to Logic and Scientific Method Books for Reading:- 1- Jhfuokl gjh fnf{kr & rdZ'kkL= 2- gqY;kGdj] dkGs] lkoGs & lqxe] rdZ'kkL= vkf.k oSKkfud i/nrh 3- ukaxjs] ok?keksMs] fgjos & ikjaifjd rdZ'kkL=] ¼f'kokth fo|kihB] izdk'ku½ 4. K. T. Basantani - Introduction to Logic 5. Cohen and Nagel - Introduction to Logic and Scientific Method. Books for Reference - 1- izk- eqdqan dne & lqyHk rdZ'kkL= 2- MkW- t- jk- nkeksGs & oSKkfud i/nrh

10

3- ukaxjs] fiVds] Qjrkjs] & oSKkfud i/nrh ok?keksMs o fgjos ¼f'kokth fo|kihB] izdk'ku½ 4- Gupta S.P. - Logic and Scientific Method 5- Hirawe, Pitake & - Scientific Method Dr. (Smt.) Patankar (Shivaji University Publication)

Paper No.-IX (b) Symbolic Logic

Semester - V (Propositional Logic)

1. Nature of Logic:- A) Definition, Logic as a formal science of inference B) Deductive and inductive inference C) Categorical Propositions

2. Symbolization of Propositions and Basic Truth-tables:-

A) Simple and Compound Propositions B) Symbolization of Propositions Propositional variables, Propositional constants

and Propositional connectives. C) Basic Truth-tables of Negation, Conjunction, Disjunction, Implication and

Equivalence. 3. Decision Procedure for Testing the Statement forms:-

A) Truth-table Method B) Shorter Truth-table Method C) Truth Tree Method

4. Formal Proof:-

A) Rules of inference and Rules of Replacement B) Method of Direct Proof, Conditional Proof and Indirect Proof. C) Proofs of Tautologies by conditional Proof and Indirect Proof.

11

isij ua- 9 ¼c½ lkadsfrd rdZ'kkL= ¼fo/kkuh; rdZ'kkL=½

l= & 5 1- rdZ'kkL=kps Lo#i%&

v- O;k[;k] rdZ'kkL=& vuqekukps ,d vkdkfjd 'kkL= c- fuxkeh o foxkeh vuqeku d- fu#ikf/kd fo/kkus

2- fo/kkukaps fpUgkadu vkf.k ewyHkwr LkR;rk dks"Vds%&

v- lk/kh vkf.k la;qDr fo/kkus c- fo/kkukaps fpUgkadu&fo/kkuh; pjs] fo/kkuh; vpjs vkf.k fo/kkuh; la;kstd d- fu"ks/ku] la/kh] oSdfYid] lksikf/kd o leeqY; fo/kkukaph ewyHkwr

lR;rk dks"Vds- 3- fo/kkuca/kkph lR;klR;rk rikl.;klkBh fu.kZ; izfdz;k%&

v- lR;rk dks’Vd i/nrh c- y?kq&lR;rk dks’Vd i/nrh d- lR;rk o{k i/nrh

4- vkdkfjd fl/nrk%&

v- vuqekukps fu;e o i;kZ;.kkps fu;e c- izR;{k fl/nrk i/nrh lksikf/kd fl/nrk i/nr o vizR;{k fl/nrk i/nr d- loZnklRo fo/kkukaph lksikf/kd o vizR;{k i/nrhus fl/nrk

Books for Study:- 1. Copi I.M. Symbolic Logic V Edn. Macmillan Publishing Co.London, New York. 2. Rich Elaine, Knight Kevin, Artificial Intelligence 2nd ed. Tata MC

Graw Hill, 1995 3. MkW- lq f'k- ckjfyaxs] MkW- eks- iz- ejkBs %& rdZjs[kk Hkkx 1 o 2 4- izk- es- iqa jsxs] vkdkfjd rdZ'kkL=] dkWafVusaVy izdk'ku] iq.ks

¼ijh{ksP;k n"Vhus ;k iqLrdkrhy nsoukxjhe/khy izfrdkaps mnk- d] [k] x ;kaps #ikarj jkseu izfrdkae/;s Eg.ktsp P, Q, R e/;s dsys tkrhy-½

5- MkW- ch- vkj- tks'kh] izk- ,l- Ogh- dqyd.khZ izk- b- vkj- eBokys & ^rdZfo|k* Hkkx& 1 o 2

Books for Reference:- 1. Huges and Londey :- Elements of Logic 2. Basson and O Conner, Introduction to symbolic Logic 3. izk- fn- ;- ns'kikaMs %& lkadsfrd rdZ'kkL= 4- izk- Ogh- Ogh- vdksydj %& rdZnhfidk 5. Korde and Sawant :- Elements of Logic 6. K. B. Nangare,

12

Dr. P. B. Chougule, :- Modern Logic R.V. Pharatare (Shivaji Univerity Publication)

Paper No.-X (a) Philosophy of Religion (Part - I)

Semester - V 1. Nature of Philosophy of Religion:-

A) Definition, Nature and Scope of Philosophy of Religion B) Relation of Philosophy of Religion of Religion C) Philosophy of Religion & God.

2. Nature of Religion:-

A) Definition and meaning of religion. B) Classification of Religion- Tribal, National and Universal religion. C) Dharma & Present situation

3. Theories of Religion:-

A) Animism, Supernaturalism B) Collectivism, Primitive monotheism

C) Ancestor – Cult, Anachronism 4. Aspects of Religion:-

A) Morality and Science B) Prayer and Worship C) Customs & Traditions

ch-,-Hkkx&3 rÙoKku ¼fo'ks"k½

isij ua-10 ¼v½ /kekZps rÙoKku ¼Hkkx & 1½

l= & V 1- /kekZP;k rÙoKkukps Lo:i %

v½ O;k[;k] Lo:i vkf.k O;kIrh c½ /kekZps rÙoKku vkf.k /keZ ;karhy laca/k d½ /kekZps rÙoKku vkf.k bZ”oj

2- /kekZps Lo:i %

v½ /kekZph O;k[;k vkf.k vFkZ c½ /kekZps oxhZdj.k & VksGh /keZ] jk"Vªh; /keZ vkf.k fo'o/keZ d½ /keZ vkf.k l|fLFkrh

13

3- /kekZfo’k;d miiRRkh % v½ thookn& vykSfdd “kDrhokn c½ leqnk; J/nkokn& izkFkfed ,ds”ojokn d½ firiwtkokn& oLrwfoi;kZlokn

4- /kekZps vaxs %

v½ uhrh vkf.k foKku c½ izkFkZuk vkf.k iwtk d½ pkfyjhrh o ijaijk@ozroSdY;@l.klekjaHk

Books for Reading and Reference:- 1- tks'kh t- ok- /kekZaps rRoKku ¼dkWafUVusVy izdk'ku] iq.ks½ 2- rdZrhFkZ y{e.k'kkL=h tks'kh] loZ/keZ leh{kk] izkK ikB'kkyk] okbZ 3- rdZrhFkZ y{e.k'kkL=h tks'kh] fganw /keZ ijh{kk] izkK ikB'kkyk] okbZZ 4- Jherh fla/kw Mkaxs] ckS/n /keZ o rRoKku 5- Lokra«;ksRRkj egkjk’Vªªrhy /keZfparu % MkW-uoukFk jkldj 6 Edwards D.M.- Philosophy of Religion

( Hodder and Stoughton) 7. Lewis H.D.- Philosophy of Religion (Tata yourself Series) 8. Hicks - Philosophy of Religion 9. John E.Smith- Philosophy of Religion (Macmillan of Co.) 1969 10. Brian Davies- Introduction to Philosophy of Religion OUP 1982 11. /kekZps rRRoKku % MkW-fuxG] izk-QkikGs

B.A.III Philosophy (Special) Paper No.-X (b)

Philosophy of Saints(Part I) Semester - V

1. Basaveshwar:-

A) Views on- Bhakti and God B) Doctrine of Kayak:- views on Pravatti and Nivatti C) Views on –Equality of cast and gender.

2. Kabir:-

A) View on nature of Ultimate Reality B) Concept of Guru, Distinction between sadguru and Dharmguru. C) Criticism of traditional religion.

3. Nanak

A) Nature and Principles of Sikhism B) Concepts of Hukum and Bhay C) Concepts of Bhakti and Sahaj

14

4. Meerabai:- A) Concept of Prembhakti-Social and Spizitual dimension B) Spiritual development of meerabai, individual and social dimension.

ch-,-Hkkx 3 & rRRoKku isij ua- 10 ¼c½

larkaps rRRoKku ¼Hkkx 1½ l= & 5

1½ clos'oj %&

v- HkfDr vkf.k bZ'oj fo"k;d ers c- dk;d fl)kar & izoÙkh vkf.k fuoÙkh fo"k;d ers d- tkrh; vkf.k ySafxd lekursfo"k;hph ers

2½ dchj %&

v- vafre lR;kP;k Lo:ikfo"k;hps er c- xq: ladYiuk & ln~xq: vkf.k /keZxq: ;krhy Qjd d- ikjaifjd /keZfo"k;hph Vhdk

3½ ukud %&

v- 'kh[koknkps Lo:i vkf.k rÙos c- gqdwe vkf.k JeladYiuk d- HkfDr vkf.k lgt ladYiuk

4½ ehjkckbZ %&

v- izse HkDrhph ladYiuk & lkekftd vkf.k vk/;kfRed vkjke c- ehjkckbZpk vk/;kfRed fodkl & O;fDrxr vkf.k lkekftd vk'k;-

Books for Reading:- 1- j- jk- xkslkoh] ikp HkfDrlaiznk;] esgrk ifCyf'kax gkowl] iq.ks&1998 2- MkW- xksfoan f=xq.kk;r& dchj dh fopkj/kkjk] lkfgR;fudsru] dkuiwj 3- MkW- 'k- xks- rqGiqGs& ikp lardoh] lqfopkj izdk'ku eaMG] iq.ks&1982 4- Xka-ck- ljnkj& lar okM%e;kph QyJqrh] Jhfo|k izdk'ku] iq.ks&1982 5- 'k- nk- isaMls& egkjk"Vªkpk Hkkxor /keZ] dkWfUVusVy izdk'ku] iq.ks 6- o- fn- dqyd.khZ& Jh- ouHkqouh] lksge izdk'ku] iq.ks&1991 7- e- ok- ?kksaM] ilk;nku& e- ik- l- izdk'ku] iq.ks 8- MkW- d".knso 'kekZ] ¼laik-½ ehjkckbZ inkoyh] jhxy cqd Msiks] uoh fnYyh 9- Hkxokunkl frokjh& ehjk dh HkDrh vkSj mldh dkO;lk/kuk dk vuq'khyu]

lkfgR;Hkou ¼izk-½ fy-vykgkckn 10- Jh- xkMxs egkjkt& xks- uh- nkaMsdj] eWtsfLVd cqdLVkWy] eqacbZ&4 11- izk- jk-rq- Hkxr &Jh- xkMxsegkjkt xkSjoxzaFk] pSrU; izdk'ku] dksYgkiwj 12 Darshan Sing- The Religion of Guru Nanak, Lyal Book Trust 13 Thipperaswami, Basaweshwar, Maker of Indian Literature service sahitya.

15

B.A.III Philosophy (Special) Paper No.-XI (a)

Contemporary Philosophy (Indian) Semester - V

1. Mahatma Jotirao Phule:-

A) Views on education of women and shudras B) Concept of Slavery C) Sarvajanic Satyadharm

2. Mahatma Gandhi:-

A) Views on Caste and Untouchability B) Concept of Truth and Non-violence C) Satyagraha and Sarvodaya

3. Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar:-

A) Criticism of Caste System B) Concepts of Liberty, Equality and Fraternity C) Dhamma and Religion

4. Vivekanand:-

A) Concept of Devine nature of man B) Universal religion C) Practical Vedanta

ch-,-Hkkx 3 rÙoKku

isij ua-11 ¼v½ ledkyhu rRoKku

¼Hkkjrh;½ l= & 5

1½ egkRek T;ksfrjko Qqys%& v- fL=;k o 'kqnzkaP;k f'k{k.kkfo"k;hph ers c- xqykefxjhph ladYiuk d- lkoZtfud lR;/keZ

2½ egkRek xka/kh

v- tkrhO;oLFkk o vLi';rk fo’k;hph ers c- lR; vkf.k vfgalk d- lR;kxzg vkf.k loksZn;

3½ MkW- ckcklkgsc vkacsMdj

v- tkrhO;oLFksojhy Vhdk c- Lokra=] lerk vkf.k ca/kwHkko d- /kEe vkf.k /keZ

16

4½ foosdkuan v- ekuokps nSoh Lo#i c- oSf'od /keZ d- O;kogkfjd osnakr

Books for Reading and Reference:- 1- egkRek Qqys%& O;kfdRo o fopkj 2- MkW- ckcklkgsc vkacsMdj%& Hkxoku cq/n vkf.k R;kapk /kEe fl/nkFkZ izdk'ku] eqacbZ- 3- Ekk/koh doh %& vk/kqfud rRoKkukrhy fopkjizokg 4- MkW- ukxksjko dqaHkkj%& folkO;k 'krdkrhy ik'pkR; rRoKku ¼laik-½ izcks/ku

izdk'ku] ykrwj 5- MkW- f'k-l- varjdj%& Hkk"kk] lR; vkf.k rdZ ¼vuq-½ dkWfUVusVy izdk'ku] iq.ks 6- ,- ts- ;kaps rRoKku%& ijke'kZ] [kaM 12] vad 1] es&1990 rRoKku foHkkx&iq.ks

fo|kihB] iq.ks izdk'ku- 7- jfoanz euksgj%& vfLrRookn] Hkkjr eqnzd izdk'kd] vkSjaxkckn] 1979 8- fojxsULVkbZu%& ijke'kZ&fo'ks"kkad] rRoKku foHkkx] iq.ks fo|kihB] iq.ks izdk'ku 9- foosdkuan lexz okMe; jked".k eB] dydRrk izdk'ku 10 N. K. Bose:- Selections from Gandhi Navjivan, 1957 11 B.R. Ambedkar:- Annihilation of Cast 12 A. J. Ayer:- Language, Truth and Logic 13 G. Pitcher:- Philosophy of Wittgenstein, Prentice, New Delhi, 1972

Paper No.-XI (b) Philosophy of Education (Part - I)

Semester - V 1. Philosophy and Education

A) Meaning of Philosophy B) Meaning of Education C) Relation between Philosophy and Education

2. Idealism and Education

A) Exponents and main Philosophical Ideas of Idealism B) Aims of Education C) The curriculum and methods of teaching.

3. Naturalism and Education

A) Exponents and main Philosophical Ideas of naturalism B) Aims of Education C) The curriculum and methods of teaching

17

4. Pragmatism and Education A) Exponents and main Philosophical Ideas of Pragmalism B) Aims of Education C) The Curriculum and methods of teaching.

ch-,-Hkkx&3 rÙoKku isij ua-11 ¼c½

f'k{k.kkps rÙoKku l= & 5

1½ rÙoKku vkf.k f'k{k.k %&

v- rÙoKku Eg.kts dk;\ c- f'k{k.k Eg.kts dk;\ d- rÙoKku vkf.k f'k{k.k ;krhy laca/k

2½ vkn”kZokn vkf.k f'k{k.k %&

v- v/;kyoknkps izeq[k izorZd vkf.k rkfÙod ladYiuk c- v/;kyoknkuqlkj /;s;s d- vH;klØe vkf.k v/;kiu i)rh

3½ fulxZokn vkf.k f'k{k.k %&

v- fulxZoknkps izeq[k izorZd vkf.k rkfÙod ladYiuk c- fulxZoknkuqlkj /;s;s d- vH;klØe vkf.k v/;kiu i)rh

4½ Qyr% izkek.;okn vkf.k f'k{k.k %&

v- Qyr% çkek.;oknkps çeq[k çorZd vkf.k rkfÙod ladYiuk c- Qyr% izkek.;oknkuqlkj f'k{k.kkph /;s;s d- vH;klØe vkf.k v/;kiui)rh

Books for Reading and Reference:- 1- MkW- e/kqdj dqaMys& 'kS{kf.kd rRoKku o 'kS{kf.kd lekt'kkL= egkjk"Vª

xzaFkfufeZrh] fo|k izdk'ku] iq.ks- 2- MkW- u- jk- ikjluhl& f'k{k.kkph rkfRod o lekt'kkL=h; Hkwfedk uwru izdk'ku]

iq.ks 3- Ikzk- fo- ika- cksdhy& f'k{k.kkps rRoKku] fp='kkGk izdk'ku] iq.ks&2 4- izk- ,y-th- ns'keq[k& f'k{k.kkps rRoKku o lekt'kkL= QMds izdk'ku] dksYgkiwj 5 Bhatia- Philosophy and Education 6 J.C. Agrawal- Theory and Principles of Education Vikas Publishing House

Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi. 7 Dr. A.S. Seetharamu- Philosophy of Education Ashish Publishing House,

New Delhi.

18

8- Xk- fo- vdksGdj& 'kS{kf.kd rRoKkukph #ijs"kk 9- ;- t- ?kk#jdj& 'kS{kf.kd rRoKku

PHILOSOPHY (Special) Paper - XII Systems of Indian Philosophy (Part-II)

Semester - VI 1. Vaisesika Darshan:-

A) Nature of Vaisesika Philosophy B) Classification of Padarthas (Seven Categories) C) Theory of Atomism

2. Nyaya Darshan:-

A) The Nature and Kinds of Pramanas B) Nature and Kinds of Pratyaksa and anuman C) Hetvabhasa

3. Visistadvaita Darshan:-

A) Views on Vedanta B) Cit, Acit and Isvara C) Concept of Moksha

4. Dvaita Darshan:-

A) Five kinds of Bheda B) Reality of world C) Nature of Moksha

rÙoKku¼fo'ks"k½isij ua-12 Hkkjrh; rRoKkukrhy n'kZus

l= & 6 1½ oS'ksf’kd n”kZu %&

v- oS'ksf’kd rRoKkukps Lo#i c- lkr inkFkZ d- ijek.kwoknkpk fl/nkar

2½ U;k; n”kZu %&

v- izek.kkaps Lo#i o izdkj c- izR;{k vkf.k vuqekukps izdkj d- gsRokHkkl

19

3½ fof'k"Vk}sRk n”kZu v- osnkarkcnn~ypk nf’Vdksu c- fpr~] vfpr~ vkf.k bZ'oj d- eks{kkph ladYiuk

4½ }Sr n”kZu

v- Hksnkps ikp izdkj c- txkps lr~ Lo#i d- eks{kkps Lo#i

Books for Readings:_ 1- Jh- g- fnf{kr %& Hkkjrh; rRoKku 2- x- uk- tks'kh %& Hkkjrh; rRoKkukpk cgn bfrgkl 3- Hkk- x- dsrdj %& Hkkjrh; rRoKkukph #ijs"kk 4- ih- Mh- pkS/kjh %& Hkkjrh; rRoKkukpk bfrgkl 5- MkW-osnizdk”k Mks.kxkodj %& Hkkjrh; rRoKku Books for Readings:_ 1. Dr. S. Radhakrishnan :- Indian Philosophy Vol. I & II 2. Chartterji and Dutta :- Introduction to Indian Philosophy 3. Hiriyanna :- Outlines of Indian Philosophy.

PHILOSOPHY (Special) Paper No.-XIII

Western Philosophy (Recent) Semester - VI

1. Idealism:-

A) Nature of Idealism B) T.H.Green’s Idealism C) F.H.Bradely’s Absolute Idealism-Appearance and Reality

2. Materialism:-

A) What is Materialism? B) Marxism:- Historical Materialism C) Marxism:- Dialectical Materialism.

3. Pragmatism:-

A) Definition & Nature of Pragmatism B) Willian James’s – Radical empiricism. C) The Pragmatic theory of truth (Willian James)

20

4. Realism:- A) Nature of Realism B) Sense data C) Existence of external world

isij ua-XIII ik'pkR; rRoKku

¼vokZfpu½ l= & VI

1½ fpn~okn%& v- fpn~oknkps Lo#i c- Vh-,p- xzhupk fpn~okn d- ,Q-,p-czWMyspk fu#ikf/kd fpn~okn&vkHkkl vkf.k lR; 2½ tMokn%& v- tMokn Eg.kts dk; \ c- ekdZl~okn&,sfrgkfld tMokn d- }a}kRed tMokn 3½ Qyr% izkek.;okn v- Qyr% izkek.;oknkph O;k[;k o Lo#i c- foY;e tsElpk eqyHkwr vuqHkookn d- lR; fo"k;d foY;e tsElph Qyr% izkek.;oknkph miiRRkh 4½ okLrookn v- okLrooknkps Lo#i v- osnunRr miiRrh c- ckg;txkps vfLrRo Books for Reading:- 1- fn- ;- ns'kikaMs %& vokZphu ik'pkR; rRoKku Hkkx 1 o 3 2- x- uk- tks'kh %& ik'pkR; rRoKkukpk bfrgkl [kaM 2 o 3- 3. W.K. Wright :- A History of modern philosophy 4. D. M. Datta :- Chief currents of contemporary philosophy. 5. John Passmore:- Hundred years of Philosophy. Books for Reference:- 1- ns- n- okMsdj %& ejkBh rRoKku egkdksl [kaM 1 o 2 2. G. I. Warnock :- English Philosophy since 1900 3. D.I.O. Connoz :- A critical History of Western Philosophy

21

Paper No.-XIV (a) Scientific Method

Semester - VI 1. Scientific Method

A) Nature of Science A) Nature of Scientific Method B) Stages of Scientific Investigation

2. Hypothesis:-

A) Definition, Nature & Importance of Hypothesis B) Conditions of Valid Hypothesis C) Kinds of Hypothesis

3. Laws of Nature and Explanation:-

A) Meaning and Types of Laws B) Kinds of Laws of Nature C) Scientific Explanation-Kinds of Scientific Explanation.

4. Fallacies:-

A) Formal Fallacies B) Verbal Fallacies C) Non-Verbal Fallacies

ch-,- rÙoKku ¼fo'ks"k½ isij ua-14¼v½ oSKkfud i/nrh

1½ oSKkfud i/nrh%&

v- foKkukps Lo#i c- oSKkfud i/nrhps Lo#i d- oSKkfud la”kks/kukP;k voLFkk

2½ vH;qixe ¼fl/nkardYiuk½%&

v- vH;qixekph O;k[;k] Lo#i vkf.k egRo c- ;qDr vH;qixekP;k vVh d- vH;qixekps izdkj

3½ fulxkZps fu;e o miiknu ¼lkfRodj.k½

v- fu;ekpk vFkZ o izdkj c- fulxkZP;k fu;ekaps izdkj d- oSKkfud miiknu%& oSKkfud miiknukps izdkj

22

4½ rdZnks"k%& v- vkdkfjd rdZnks"k c- 'kkfCnd rdZnks"k d- v&'kkfCnd rdZnks"k

vH;klkph iqLrds%& 1- Jhfuokl gjh fnf{kr & rdZ'kkL= 2- gqR;kGdj] dkGs] dkoGs & lqxe rdZ'kkL= vkf.k oSKkfud i/nrh 3- ukaxjs] ok?krksMs] fgjos & ikjaikfjd rdZ'kkL=] ¼f'kokth fo|kihB izdk'ku½ 4. K.T. Basantani - Introduction to Logic 5. Cohen and Nagel - Introduction to Logic and Scientific Method Books for Reading:- 1- Jhfuokl gjh fnf{kr %& rdZ'kkL= 2- gqY;kGdj] dkGs] lkoGs%& lqxe] rdZ'kkL= vkf.k oSKkfud i/nrh 3- ukaxjs] ok?keksMs] fgjos %& ikjaifjd rdZ'kkL=] ¼f'kokth fo|kihB] izdk'ku½ 4. K. T. Basantani :- Introduction to Logic 5. Cohen and Nagel :- Introduction to Logic and Scientific Method. Books for Reference:- 1- izk- eqdqan dne %& lqyHk rdZ'kkL= 2- MkW- t- jk- nkeksGs %& oSKkfud i/nrh 3- ukaxjs] fiVds] Qjrkjs] %& oSKkfud i/nrh ok?keksMs o fgjos ¼f'kokth fo|kihB] izdk'ku½ 4. Gupta S.P. :- Logic and Scientific Method 5. Hirawe, Pitake & :- Scientific Method Dr. (Smt.) Patankar (Shivaji University Publication)

Paper No.-XIV (b)

Symbolic Logic Semester - VI

1. Quantil Logic:-

A) Quantifier-Definition, kinds and uses B) Singular and General Propositions Universal and Existential Propositions. C) Individual variables and Individual constants.

2. Rules of Quantification (Preliminary Version):-

A) Rules of Quantification 1. U.I., 2. U.G., 3. E.I., 4. E.G.

B) Formal Proof of Argument involving Quantified Propositions.

23

3. Multiply General Propositions and Revised rules of Quantification. A) Singly General and Multiply General Propositions. B) Free and Bound variables, symbolising multiply General Propositions. C) Revised Rules of Quantifcation, Proofs of arguments involving multiply

General Propositions. 4. The Rule of Quantifier Negation and Logical Truths:

A) Rule of Quantifier Negation B) Demonstration of Logical Truths involving Quantifiers.

isij ua-14 ¼c½ lkadsfrd rdZ'kkL=

l= & 6 1- la[;kiuh; rdZ'kkL=%&

v- la[;kiu& O;k[;k] la[;kiukps izdkj] mi;ksx c- ,dokph vkf.k lkkekU;okph fo/kkus] oSf'od o vfLrRokph fo/kkus d- O;Drh pjs o O;Drh vpjs

2- lkaf[;dhdj.kkps fu;e%&

v- 1½ U.I. 2) U.G. 3) E.I. 4) E.G. c- lkaf[;dr fo/kkukauh;qDr ;qfDroknkaph vkdkfjd fl/nrk

3- cgqlkekU;okph fo/kkus vkf.k lkaf[;dhdj.kkps lq/kkfjr fu;e%&

v- ,d lkekU;okph vkf.k cgqlkekU;okph fo/kkus c- eqDr o c/n pjs] cgqlkekU;okph fo/kkukaph fpUgkadus d- lkaf[;dhdj.kkps lq/kkfjr fu;e] cgqlkekU;okph fo/kkukauh ;qDr ;qfDroknkaph fl/nrk

4- la[;kRed fu"ks/kkpk fu;e o rkfdZd lR;kaph fl/nrk%&

v- la[;kid fu"ks/kkpk fu;e c- lkaf[;dr rkfdZd fo/kkukaph fl/nrk

Books for Study:- 1. Copi I.M. Symbolic Logic V Edn. Macmillan Publishing Co.London, New York. 2. Rich Elaine, Knight Kevin, Artificial Intelligence 2nd ed. Tata MC Graw Hill, 1995 3- MkW- lq f'k- ckjfyaxs] MkW- eks- iz- ejkBs %& rdZjs[kk Hkkx 1 o 2 4- izk- es- iqa jsxs] vkdkfjd rdZ'kkL=] dkWafVusaVy izdk'ku] iq.ks

¼ijh{ksP;k n"Vhus ;k iqLrdkrhy nsoukxjhe/khy izfrdkaps mnk- d] [k] x ;kaps #ikarj jkseu izfrdkae/;s Eg.ktsp P, Q, R e/;s dsys tkrhy-½

5- MkW- ch- vkj- tks'kh] izk- ,l- Ogh- dqyd.khZ izk- b- vkj- eBokys & ^rdZfo|k* Hkkx& 1 o 2

24

Books for Reference:- 1. Huges and Londey :- Elements of Logic 2. Basson and O Conner, Introduction to symbolic Logic 3- izk- fn- ;- ns'kikaMs %& lkadsfrd rdZ'kkL= 4- izk- Ogh- Ogh- vdksydj %& rdZnhfidk 5. Korde and Sawant :- Elements of Logic 6. K. B. Nangare,

Dr. P. B. Chougule, :- Modern Logic R.V. Pharatare :- (Shivaji Univerity Publication)

Total Marks 40

Distribution of Marks 1. Complete the following sentences : one mark each for five sentences : 10 2. Short answers (any Two) out of 3 : 20 OR (a) Truth tables : any Three out of 4 : 12 (b)Truth tree : any Two out of 3 : 8 3. (a) Proving arguments by C.P. One out of two : 7 (b) Proving arguments by I.D. One out of two : 7 (c) Proving Tautologies by C.P. or I.D. any one out of two : 6

Paper No.-XV (a) Philosophy of Religion (Part - II)

Semester - VI 1. Philosophical Thoughts of :-

A) Hinduism, Buddhism, B) Jainism & Shikhism C) Islam and Christianity

2. God, Nature and Man

A) Attributes of God B) Problem of Creation C) God and Man

3. Existence of God

A) Concept of God A) For existence of God-Indian Views B) For existence of God-Western views

4. Immortality of Soul:-

A) The meaning and possibility of Immortality. B) Concepts of Immortality survival, Reincarnation, Transmigration C) Dectorine of Karma

25

ch-,-Hkkx&3 rÙoKku ¼fo'ks"k½ isij ua-15 ¼v½

/kekZps rÙoKku ¼Hkkx & 2½ l= & VI

1- rÙoKku fo"k;d fopkj %

v½ fganqer] ckS)er c½ tSuer&”kh[k er d½ bLyke vkf.k f[kz'pu

2- bZÜoj] fulxZ vkf.k ekuo %

v½bZÜojkps xq.k c½ fufeZrhph leL;k d½bZÜojkps vkf.k ekuo

3- bZÜojkps vfLrRo %

v½ bZ”oj ladYiuk v½ Hkkjrh; erkuqlkj bZ”oj vfLrRRo d½ ik”pkR; erkuqlkj bZ”oj vfLrRRo

4- vkRE;kps vejRo %

v½ vejRokpk vFkZ vkf.k 'kD;rk c½ vejRokP;k ladYiuk & thoar jkg.ks] iqutZUe] vorkj d½deZfl)kar

Books for Reading and Reference:- 1- tks'kh t- ok- /kekZaps rRoKku ¼dkWafUVusVy izdk'ku] iq.ks½ 2- rdZrhFkZ y{e.k'kkL=h tks'kh] loZ/keZ leh{kk] izkK ikB'kkyk] okbZ 3- rdZrhFkZ y{e.k'kkL=h tks'kh] fganw /keZ ijh{kk] izkK ikB'kkyk] okbZ 4- Jherh fla/kw Mkaxs] ckS/n /keZ o rRoKku 5- MkW-uoukFk jkldj] Lokra«;ksRRkj egkjk’Vzkrhy /keZfparu 6 Edwards D.M.- Philosophy of Religion

( Hodder and Stoughton) 7. Lewis H.D.- Philosophy of Religion (Tata yourself Series) 8. Hicks - Philosophy of Religion 9. John E.Smith- Philosophy of Religion (Macmillan of Co.) 1969 10. Brian Davies- Introduction to Philosophy of Religion OUP 1982

26

B.A.III Philosophy (Special) Paper No.-XV (b)

Philosophy of Saints(Part II) Semester - VI

1. Dnyaneshwar:-

A) Philosophical basis of Varkari Pantha. B) Reconcilation of Dnyanayoga, Bhaktiyoga and Karmyoga. C) Significance of Pasaayadan

2. Tukaram:-

A) Concept of true Dharma and critism pakhanda B) His growth from a commoner to sainthood. C) Tuka Zalase Kalas:- Culmination of Varakari cult.

3. Ramdas:-

A) Prapanch and Paramartha. B) Vivekavada C) Prayatnavada

4. Gadage Maharaj:-

A) Method of dialogue and keertan. B) Social view on cleanliness of villages, addiction, indebtness, social unequality,

illiteracy and dowary. C) Views on Godworship and Irradiction of blind faith.

ch-,-Hkkx&3 rÙoKku ¼fo'ks"k½

isij ua-15 ¼c½ larkaps rÙoKku ¼Hkkx 2½

l= & VI 1½ Kkus'oj

v- okjdjh laiznk;kps rkfÙod vf/k"Bku c- Kku;ksx] HkDrh;ksx vkf.k deZ;ksx ;kapk leUo; d- ilk;nkukps egÙo

2½ rqdkjke

v- [kjk /keZ vkf.k ik[kaM ladYiuk c- lkekU;RokdMwu lari.kkdMs okVpky d- rqdk >kykls dGl

3½ jkenkl

v- iziap vkf.k ijekFkZ c- foosdokn d- iz;Ruokn

27

4½ lar xkMxs egkjkt v- laokn i)rh vkf.k dhrZu c- xzkeh.k LoPNrk] O;luk/khurk] dtZcktkjhi.kk] lkekftd fo"kerk] vKku] gaqM;kph izFkk ;kfo"k;hph lkekftd ers d- bZ'ojkP;k miklusfo"k;hph ers vkf.k va/kJ)k fuewZyu Books for Reading:-

Books for Reading :- 1- j- jk- xkslkoh] ikp HkfDrlaiznk;] esgrk ifCyf'kax gkowl] iq.ks&1998 2- MkW- xksfoan f=xq.kk;r& dchj dh fopkj/kkjk] lkfgR;fudsru] dkuiwj 3- MkW- 'k- xks- rqGiqGs& ikp lardoh] lqfopkj izdk'ku eaMG] iq.ks&1982 4- Xka-ck- ljnkj& lar okM%e;kph QyJqrh] Jhfo|k izdk'ku] iq.ks&1982 5- 'k- nk- isaMls& egkjk"Vªkpk Hkkxor /keZ] dkWfUVusVy izdk'ku] iq.ks 6- o- fn- dqyd.khZ& Jh- ouHkqouh] lksge izdk'ku] iq.ks&1991 7- e- ok- ?kksaM] ilk;nku& e- ik- l- izdk'ku] iq.ks 8- MkW- d".knso 'kekZ] ¼laik-½ ehjkckbZ inkoyh] jhxy cqd Msiks] uoh fnYyh 9- Hkxokunkl frokjh& ehjk dh HkDrh vkSj mldh dkO;lk/kuk dk vuq'khyu] lkfgR;Hkou ¼izk-½ fy-vykgkckn 10- Jh- xkMxs egkjkt& xks- uh- nkaMsdj] eWtsfLVd cqdLVkWy] eqacbZ&4 11- izk- jk-rq- Hkxr] Jh xkMxsegkjkt xkSjoxzaFk]pSrU; izdk'ku] dksYgkiwj 12- Darshan Sing- The Religion of Guru Nanak, Lyal Book Trust 13- Thipperaswami, Basaweshwar, Maker of Indian Literature service sahitya.

B.A.III Philosophy (Special) Paper No.-XVI (a)

Contemporary Philosophy (Western)

Semester - VI 1. Jean Paul Sartre:-

A) Sartre as Existentialist B) Being for itself, Being on Itself, Being for others. C) Concepts of Freedom and badfaith

2. A.J. Ayer:-

A) Verifiability Principle B) A Priori and Analytic Propositions C) Approach to Metaphysics

3. Wittgenstein:-

A) His Philosophy B) Picture theory of meaning C) Language Games

28

4. B. Russell:- A) Kinds of Knowledge B) Logical Atomism C) Value of Philosophy

ch-,-Hkkx&3 rÙoKku ¼fo'ks"k½ isij ua-16 ¼v½

ledkyhu rÙoKku ¼ikf'pekR;½ l= & VI

1½ tkWu ikWy lk=Z

v- lk=Zps vfLRkRooknh rRoKku c- Logsrwd lr~] Lofufgr lr~] Losrj ¼ijgsrwd½ lr~ d- Lokra«;] nq%J/nk

2½ ,- ts- ,vj

v- izfprhps rRo c- vuqHkoiwoZ vkf.k fo'ys"kd fo/kkus d- ln~oLrw 'kkL=kfo"k;hpk n"Vhdksu

3½ foV~xsuLVkbZu

v- foV~xsuLVkbZups rRoKku c- vFkZfo"k;d fp=fl/nkar d- Hkkf"kd [ksG

4½ jlsy%&

v- Kkukps izdkj c- rkfdZd ijek.kwokn d- rRoKkukps egRRo

Books for Reading and Reference:- 1- Ekk/koh doh %& vk/kqfud rRoKkukrhy fopkjizokg 2- folkO;k 'krdkrhy ik'pkR; rRoKku laik-MkW- ukxksjko dqaHkkj] izcks/ku izdk'ku]

ykrwj 3- Hkk"kk] lR; vkf.k rdZ vuq- MkW- f'k-l- varjdj] dkWfUVusVy izdk'ku] iq.ks 4- ,- ts-,vj ;kaps rRoKku%& ijke'kZ] [kaM 12] vad 1] es&1990 rRoKku

foHkkx&iq.ks fo|kihB] iq.ks izdk'ku- 5- fojxsULVkbZu%& ijke'kZ&fo'ks"kkad] rRoKku foHkkx] iq.ks fo|kihB] iq.ks izdk'ku 6 Language, Truth and Logic - A. J. Ayer 7 Philosophy of Wittgenstein, Prentice, G. Pitcher, New Delhi, 1972

29

B.A.III Philosophy (Special) Paper No.-XVI (b)

Philosophy of Education (Part II) Semester - VI

1. Religion and Education

A) Meaning and nature of religion. B) Aspects of Religious Education. C) Importance of Religious Education.

2. Discipline and Freedom

A) Concept of Discipline B) Concept of Freedom C) Reconciliation of discipline and freedom.

3. Democratic Socialism and Education

A) Characteristics of Democratic Socialism B) Educational Policies of Democratic Socialism.

4. Education and National Integration

A) Meaning of National Integration B) Need of National Integration C) Educational Programmes for National Integration.

ch-,-Hkkx&3 rÙoKku

isij ua-16 ¼c½ f'k{k.kkps rÙoKku

l= & 6 5½ /keZ vkf.k f'k{k.k %&

v- /kekZpk vFkZ vkf.k Lo:i c- /kkfeZd f'k{k.kkph vaxs d- /kkfeZd f'k{k.kkps egÙo

6½ f'kLr o Lokra«; %&

v- f'kLrhph ladYiuk c- Lokra«;kph ladYiuk d- f'kLr o Lokra«; ;kapk leUo;

7½ yksd'kkgh lektokn vkf.k f'k{k.k %&

v- yksd'kkgh lektoknkph oSf'k"V;s c- yksd'kkgh lektoknkph “kS{kf.kd /kksj.ks

30

8½ f'k{k.k vkf.k jk"Vªh; ,dkRerk %& v- jk"Vªh; ,dkRerspk vFkZ c- jk"Vªh; ,dkRersph xjt d- jk"Vªh; ,dkRerslkBh 'kS{kf.kd miØe

Books for Reading and Reference:- 1- MkW- e/kqdj dqaMys& 'kS{kf.kd rRoKku o 'kS{kf.kd lekt'kkL= egkjk"Vª

xzaFkfufeZrh] fo|k izdk'ku] iq.ks- 2- MkW- u- jk- ikjluhl& f'k{k.kkph rkfRod o lekt'kkL=h; Hkwfedk uwru izdk'ku]

iq.ks 3- Ikzk- fo- ika- cksdhy& f'k{k.kkps rRoKku] fp='kkGk izdk'ku] iq.ks&2 4- izk- ,y-th- ns'keq[k& f'k{k.kkps rRoKku o lekt'kkL= QMds izdk'ku] dksYgkiwj 5 Bhatia- Philosophy and Education 6 J.C. Agrawal- Theory and Principles of Education Vikas Publishing House Pvt. Ltd.,

New Delhi. 7 Dr. A.S. Seetharamu- Philosophy of Education Ashish Publishing House, New Delhi. 8 Xk- fo- vdksGdj& 'kS{kf.kd rRoKkukph #ijs"kk 9- ;- t- ?kk#jdj& 'kS{kf.kd rRoKku