autumn mist
TRANSCRIPT
The morning session began with Gareth
Chisham (British Antarctic Survey) in
the chair. Michele Dougherty (Imperial
College, London) took advantage of the
Cassini spacecraft flyby of Jupiter to carry out
simultaneous measurements of the solar wind
and Jovian magnetospheric conditions. She
reported the first observations of northward
Interplanetary Magnetic Field (IMF) condi-
tions leading to magnetopause erosion during
reconnection. Using previous spacecraft flights
through the Jovian current sheet, Jonathan
Nichols (Leicester) was able to deduce a model
of the planet’s magnetic field. He then com-
pared the resulting angular momentum and
auroral electron precipitation with those gen-
erated by a simple dipole magnetic field. It was
found that the self-consistent model was able
to account for the location and intensity of the
planet’s auroral oval.
Christina Pagel (Imperial College) examined
the heliospheric magnetic field observed
between the north and south poles during the
recent fast latitude scan of the Ulysses space-
craft. The level of magnetic fluctuations was
found to be greatest in the polar regions during
solar minimum and lower towards the solar
equator and at solar maximum. Holger
Schmitz (Warwick) made use of fully kinetic
particle-in-cell simulations of high Mach num-
ber shock waves to reveal a non-thermal
downstream electron energy distribution with
a high-energy tail in the bow shock of Mercury.
He found that electrons could become trapped
at the “foot” of the shock where they could
become accelerated by an electric field before
leaving the phase space hole.
Weak interplanetary shock waves
Several studies from Imperial College made use
of data from the Ulysses spacecraft. Jonathan
Gloag examined aspects of the detailed struc-
ture of weak interplanetary shock waves. He
observed behaviour that appeared to depart
from classical magnetohydrodynamic theory in
that there were often significant delays
between the times of the deflection of the
magnetic field and times of the change in the
magnitude of the field fluctuations. The unique
heliospheric polar orbit of Ulysses provided
Geraint Jones with data from a rapid 10-
month scan at both solar minimum and then
five years later at solar maximum (see figure 1).
During solar minimum, the dipolar solar mag-
netic field was clearly seen with a low-latitude
heliospheric current sheet. During 2001,
Ulysses sampled the Sun’s magnetic polarity at
all latitudes while it was undergoing a reversal.
Bogdan Hnat (Warwick) examined the statisti-
cal properties of the interplanetary magnetic
field. He found that a single scaling parameter
can describe its behaviour adequately on
timescales of less than 26 hours. Over longer
periods, the behaviour was more complex and
suggested a possible multifractal character.
Attention was shifted to the ionosphere by
Ranvir Dhillon (Leicester) as he described the
effect of varying the scanning angle of the
Tromsø ionospheric heater in the generation of
artificial backscatter in the CUTLASS Finland
HF radar. It was found that the power was
intensified in the direction along the Earth’s
magnetic field and that as the scan period was
reduced below a minute, there was a reduction
in the resulting backscattered power related to
the timescale of the excitation and decay
processes. Eoghan Griffin (University College
London) discussed the implications for the
thermosphere of observed small-scale structure
in the ionospheric convection flows and relat-
ed joule heating as observed by the CUTLASS
HF radar. He suggested that a high-resolution
Scanning Doppler Imager would complement
the ionospheric measurements in this region.
After lunch, Eleri Pryse (Aberystwyth) took
the chair. Richard Sims (Aberystwyth) present-
ed evidence for a “tongue of ionization” in
winter over Svalbard whereby cold plasma had
been transported from sub-auroral latitudes
into the polar cap during southward IMF con-
ditions. He made use of a range of ground-
and space-based instrumentation to show that
numerical models were not yet able to simulate
these phenomena. The first measurements of
F-region ion temperatures using a Fabry-Perot
interferometer were described by Mike Kosch
(Lancaster). Night-time singly ionized oxygen,
formed by auroral particle precipitation, pro-
vides the optical source. On three nights, there
was excellent agreement between the Euro-
pean Incoherent Scatter radar 300 km away
and the interferometer.
Chris Wilford (Sheffield) reported on
improvements to the Arecibo radar’s ability to
measure concentrations and temperatures of H+
and He+ up to altitudes of 2000 km. For the
first time it was possible to compare these val-
ues with in situ measurements from satellites.
These observations indicated significant layer-
ing of He+ around 700 km. Initial results from
the coupled thermosphere–ionosphere–plasma-
sphere (CTIP) model have been able to repro-
duce this feature. Jackie Davies (Leicester)
described joint EISCAT/CUTLASS radar obser-
vations of ionospheric signatures of dayside
transient reconnection. On the morning of 23
November 1999, the IMF was strongly south-
ward and a series of poleward-propagating
F-region electron density enhancements were
seen. These features appeared to originate from
around the open/closed field line boundary of
the magnetosphere/ionosphere system follow-
ing flux transfer events in the magnetosphere.
The magnetosphere from Cluster
The Earth’s magnetosphere, as seen by the
Cluster spacecraft, was the subject of the talk
by Jonathan Eastwood (Imperial). The behav-
iour of the magnetosheath region was com-
pared with conditions upstream in the solar
wind that were observed by the ACE space-
craft at the first Lagrangian point. Two mag-
netic field reversals took place on 13 February
2001 and statistical analysis techniques were
used to determine the evolution of the field
between the two spacecraft. Youra Taroyan
(Sheffield) was interested in the generation of
magnetohydrodynamic waves at the Earth’s
magnetopause. The existence of a finite non-
uniform layer between two semi-infinite homo-
geneous regions permitted several resonances
to occur. While Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities
tended to favour high velocities, resonant flow
instabilities were found to become significant
at much lower flow speeds.
Kathryn McWilliams (Leicester) discussed a
magnetospheric flux transfer event that was
seen by the Geotail spacecraft as it passed
through the dawn magnetopause and its
impact on the ionosphere. The SuperDARN
network of HF radars was able to monitor the
convection flow conditions in the vicinity of
the spacecraft’s ionospheric footprint.
Changes in the orientation of the IMF during
this interval influenced the location of the
merging sites in the ionosphere. Silvia Dalla
(Imperial) examined the distribution of solar
energetic particles as seen from the two Helios
spacecraft within the Earth’s orbit and also
from the Ulysses spacecraft at a much greater
Meeting report
1.23February 2002 Vol 43
Autumn MISTThe annual one-day meeting of the MIST (Magnetosphere, Ionosphere and
Solar–Terrestrial) community was held on 23 November 2001 at the
Geological Society, Burlington House. Neil Arnold reports.
“…evidence for a tongue of
ionization in winter over
Svalbard … during southward
IMF conditions”
distance from the Sun. It was found that large
events of high energy coming from the Sun
take longer to decay at greater distances from
the Sun than would be predicted from theoret-
ical “magnetic bottle” models.
Magnetic cloud properties
The final session of the meeting was chaired by
Mike Kosch (Lancaster). A force-free flux rope
model was used by Adam Rees (Imperial) to
determine the gross properties of magnetic
clouds observed by Ulysses. Over the duration
of the mission so far, cloud properties were
sampled over a wide range of heliographic lat-
itudes and solar conditions. There appeared to
be preferred cloud orientations that were inde-
pendent of the latitude. Mathew Owens (Impe-
rial) analysed three years of solar wind data
from the ACE spacecraft to investigate the
relationship between magnetic field intensities
and solar wind speeds. He showed that the cor-
relation between the two quantities increased
as the threshold value of magnetic field inten-
sity was raised, indicating that some of the
high-speed and low-field observations may be
associated with off-axis flux ropes.
Keisuke Hosokawa (Kyoto and Leicester)
carried out an inter-hemispheric comparison of
spectral width boundaries as observed by the
SuperDARN radars. At equinox, the correla-
tion between the magnetic latitudes of these
conjugate boundaries is excellent and both
hemispheres show the same response to
magnetospheric reconnection. A difference of
10 minutes in the response time to a substorm
between the two radars used in the study can
be attributed to the effects of a significant
asymmetry in the IMF. Lisa Baddeley (Leices-
ter) reported the use of high-resolution artifi-
cial targets for the CUTLASS Finland HF
radar, generated by the high-power heater at
Tromsø, to observe high wave-number ULF
waves. Simultaneous observations from the
CAMMICE instrument on the Polar spacecraft
indicated a departure from a Maxwellian ion
distribution at 10 keV, consistent with energy
transfer from the particles to these waves via
the “drift-bounce” resonance process.
Cathryn Mitchell (Bath) described the
synthesis of multi-instrument total electron
content measurements to generate three-
dimensional “images” of the ionosphere.
Results from the USA and European regions
demonstrated the potential of imaging from
the auroral regions to the equator. During a
magnetic storm on 15 July 2000, an electron
density depletion over the European sector
was seen to extend down to 44°N. Sandra
Chapman (Warwick) rounded off the presen-
tations with a provocative talk about the use
of the statistics of extremal events to charac-
terize the game of football. It was found that
the top English league over the past 30 years
produced an uninteresting negative binomial
distribution, while worldwide domestic
leagues produced a long, non-Gaussian tail.
These techniques can be applied to the likeli-
hood of extreme events in plasma transport,
including the coupled Sun–Earth system. The
meeting concluded with thanks to all the con-
tributors and chairmen. �
Neil Arnold, University of Leicester. Note: much ofthe work reported on above is collaborative. Fullprogramme details, including titles, authors,abstracts and affiliations, may be found on theMIST Web pages at www.nerc-bas.ac.uk/public/uasd/mist.html.
Meeting report
1.24 February 2002 Vol 43
1: The polarity of theinterplanetary magneticfield at Ulysses mappedback to the Sun. The datawere recorded duringUlysses’ rapid scan fromthe southern to northernsolar polar regions duringsolar minimum in 1994–95(a) and solar maximum in2000–01 (b). The spheresshow the southern andnorthern hemispherescentred on Carringtonlongitudes of 0° (left) and180° (right), respectively.The solar minimumpolarities show the northernand southern hemispheresto be dominated by a singlemagnetic polarity. The dataobtained during solarmaximum record the morecomplex magnetic structureas magnetic polarityreversal was occurring.These latter data are thefirst ever to show magneticpolarities at highheliolatitudes around solarmaximum, and mayultimately provide importantclues to the behaviour ofthe solar dynamo.
(a)
(b)