BEYOND PREVENTION, ASSUME BREACH

Zach Grace

whoami /all• Lead Security Consultant at Northwestern Mutual

• @MilSec Leader

• OWASP Milwaukee Leader

• Wisconsin CCDC Red Team member

• Team member of the 2015 DerbyCon CTF champs

• Twitterz: @ztgrace

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed here represent my own and not those of my employer.

It’s not if, but when…

ASSUME COMPROMISE

• Protective technologies will fail

• Shifts blue team’s focus to the Detect phase

• Breach readiness as a mantra

PROTECTION FAILS• Protection tools are often based on signatures

• Preventative in nature

• Examples of protective technologies:

• Anti-virus

• Firewalls

• IDS & IPS

• Web App Firewalls (WAF)

• Web Proxies

• Sandbox

COMPARED TO ATTACKERSNIST CSF Identify Protect Detect Respond Recover

NIST SP800-115 Discovery Gaining Access

Escalating Privileges

System Browsing

Persistence

Cyber Kill Chain (1) Recon(3)

Delivery(4)

Exploit

(3) Delivery (4) Exploit (5) Install

(6) C2

ZoxPNG

• Used technet.microsoft.com for command and control https://blogs.rsa.com/wolves-among-us-abusing-trusted-providers-malware-operations/

DETECT ISSUES

• Logging too little/much

• Poor Security information and event management (SIEM) correlation

• Ineffective security monitoring

• Insufficient training to create use cases

REFOCUS THE RED TEAM

PEN TESTING/RED TEAMING ISSUES

• Vulnerability focused

• Reporting doesn’t help defenders

• Lack of realistic threat modeling

REPORTS

• Vulnerability Focused

• “How I PWN’d you”

• Vague recommendations

REPORTS BE LIKE

BLUE TEAM NEEDS

• Training partner

• Indicators of Compromise (IOCs)

• Attack signatures

• Use cases

Compromise

Detection

Containment

MTD - MTC = ∆

∆ FORCE

∆ FORCE OBJECTIVES

• Provide IOCs and attack signatures alongside vulns in reports

• Perform threat simulations based on threat modeling

• Breakdown attacks into stages

• Validate detection at each stage, and assist with correlation

PYRAMID OF PAIN

http://detect-respond.blogspot.com/2013/03/the-pyramid-of-pain.html

HASH VALUES• Summary/signature of bytes

• Fuzzy hashing

IP ADDRESSES

…the IP addresses used in an engagement

DOMAIN NAMES

…domain names used in an engagement

NETWORK ARTIFACTS• Protocol-level artifacts

• HTTP

• UserAgent strings

• Missing host header

• DNS

HOST ARTIFACTS

• Persistence mechanisms

• Command & Control (C2/C&C)

• Backdoors

REG ADD "HKLM\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows NT\CurrentVersion\Image File Execution Options\sethc.exe" /v Debugger /t REG_SZ /d "C:\windows\system32\cmd.exe"

Sticky Keys Hunter v2

TOOLS

• Binaries/scripts transferred to host

• Built-in administrator tools

• Built/compiled on the compromised machine

IN-MEMORY POWERSHELL

TACTICS, TECHNIQUES and PROCEDURES (TTPs)

• Detecting and responding to adversarial behaviors

• Goes beyond tool detection

LATERAL MOVEMENT• Windows

• SMB - Pass the Hash (PTH)

• WMI

• WinRM

• Linux/OS X/Unix

• SSH

WIRESHARK CreateServiceW

SNORT DETECTIONalert tcp any any -> any 445 (msg:"psexec service created"; flow:to_server,established; content:"|FF 53 4D 42|"; dce_opnum:12; reference:url,https://www.snort.org/faq/readme-dcerpc2; classtype:bad-unknown; sid:31337; rev:1;)

SERVICE CREATION - 7045

METASPLOIT SERVICE NAME

POWERSHELL PSEXEC SERVICE

Service Name: zzVSnCcgDVXwECBU Service File Name: %COMSPEC% /C echo wmic computersystem get username ^> %SYSTEMDRIVE%\WINDOWS\Temp\JvuqFpTTakgmRppQ.txt > \WINDOWS\Temp\EtVsuSpjptOYGbwK.bat & %COMSPEC% /C start %COMSPEC% /C \WINDOWS\Temp\EtVsuSpjptOYGbwK.bat

TIMELINE

TIMELINE• Log all the commands

• HISTTIMEFORMAT="%d/%m/%y %T “

• test "$(ps -ocommand= -p $PPID | awk '{print $1}')" == 'script' || (script -f $HOME/logs/$(date +”%d-%b-%y_%H-%M-%S")_shell.log)

• Metasploit: setg PromptTimeFormat "%Y-%m-%d %I:%H:%S" setg Prompt "%T - (S: %S J: %J) " spool /root/.msf4/msfconsole.log

TIPS FOR DEFENSE

• Use pen test & red team engagements as training exercises

• Ask for more than a vulnerability report (IOCs, PCAPs, logs, etc)

• Sit with and learn from the red team

• Rotate your testing firms or rotate your testers

• Perform root cause analysis on vulnerabilities

TIPS FOR OFFENSE

• Be a sparring partner

• Provide more data like IOCs, PCAPs, logs, etc.

• Incorporate use cases into reports

• Provide artifacts to reproduce attacks

THANK YOU! @ztgrace

https://github.com/ztgrace/presentations/tree/master/20160128_wctc_cyber_security_summit