assessing the campus-wide impact of strengths initiatives for first year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3...

22
Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year Students Krista Soria, Analyst, Office of Institutional Research Robin Stubblefield, Director, Student Engagement & Co-Curricular Learning Brooke Arnold, Assistant Director, Carlson School of Mgmt. Undergraduate Prog. Jerri Kjolhaug, Executive Director, Rothenberger Institute Jessica Gunzburger, Residence Director, Housing & Residential Life

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Assessing the Campus-Wide

Impact of Strengths Initiatives

for First Year Students

Krista Soria, Analyst, Office of Institutional Research

Robin Stubblefield, Director, Student Engagement & Co-Curricular Learning

Brooke Arnold, Assistant Director, Carlson School of Mgmt. Undergraduate Prog.

Jerri Kjolhaug, Executive Director, Rothenberger Institute

Jessica Gunzburger, Residence Director, Housing & Residential Life

Page 2: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Krista Soria

Achiever • Intellection • Input • Ideation • Learner

Robin Stubblefield

Relator • Communication • Connectedness • Ideation • Restorative

Brooke Arnold

Communication • Ideation • Empathy • Individualization • Includer

Jerri Kjolhaug

Developer • Empathy • Harmony • Learner • Responsibility

Jessica Gunzburger

Empathy • Achiever • Learner • Input • Intellection

Our Team’s Top Talent Themes

Page 3: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)
Page 4: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)
Page 5: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Assessment Focus

Strengths engagement:

• Did students take StrengthsFinder?

• How did students interact with it?

• What types of interventions did the U provide?

• With whom did students interact around Strengths?

Strengths impact:

• Have Strengths interactions and experiences positively

contributed to the student experience?

Page 6: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Data Collection

Triangulation, mixed-methods:

– Pre-and post-surveys of students

• quantitative

• qualitative

• random and census

– Focus groups of students

– Staff surveys

– Pairing with SERU survey

Page 7: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Participants

• Pre-survey (September; all FY): n = 2008

• Post-survey (December; all FY): n = 1493

• End of the year survey (April; random

sample ½ FY class): n = 570

• Responded to pre-and-post: n = 934

• Responded to all three: n = 299

• Focus groups: n = 28 in five groups

Page 8: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Interactions Mid Year

Survey (%)

(n=1497)

End-of-Year

Survey (%)

(n=570)

With friends 40.3 53.2

With an academic advisor 42.4 52.1

In Housing & Residential Life 52.0 50.5

In classes 32.6 34.9

With family 28.7 32.5

In student organizations or

activities 13.0 19.8

In a study group of peers 23.1 19.6

With a professor 11.3 12.1

With a career counselor 6.3 11.4

With coworkers (other than

supervisors) 1.5 3.7

With my employment supervisor

on campus 2.3 3.5

With my employment supervisor

off campus 1.2 2.5

Mid Year

Survey (%)

(n=1500)

End-of-Year

Survey (%)

(n=570)

Discussions 82.3 89.1

Workshops

23.2

20.0

Presentations

or Trainings 21.8

Types of Interactions

Where Students Discussed

Page 9: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

•End of the year survey

•Agreement scale 1-5

•n ~ 570

•Random sample

•Differences are statistically

significant (p < .05)

Discussions with Strengths Matters “I believe that knowing my Strengths and interacting with them has

positively impacted me in the following areas”

Page 10: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

•End of the year survey

•Agreement scale 1-5

•n ~ 570

•Random sample

•Differences are statistically

significant

(p < .05)

Discussions with Strengths Matters “I believe that knowing my Strengths and interacting with them has

positively impacted me in the following areas”

Page 11: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

•End of the year survey

•Agreement scale 1-5

•n ~ 570

•Random sample

•Differences are statistically

significant

(p < .05)

Impact on Students of Color “I believe that knowing my Strengths and interacting with them has

positively impacted me in the following areas”

Page 12: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Impact on Students of Color

•End of the year

survey

•Agreement scale 1-5

•n ~ 570

•Random sample

•Differences are

statistically significant

(p < .05)

Page 13: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

•End of the year survey

•Agreement scale 1-5

•n ~ 570

•Random sample

•Differences are

statistically significant

(p < .05)

Impact on International Students “I believe that knowing my Strengths and interacting with them has

positively impacted me in the following areas”

Page 14: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Impact on International Students

•End of the year

survey

•Agreement scale 1-5

•n ~ 570

•Random sample

•Differences are

statistically significant

(p < .05)

Page 15: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Insights into Retention & GPA

Disagree & Strongly

Disagree

Agree &

Strongly Agree

I can name my top five

Strengths

92.3% (336 retained

out of 364)

95.2% (819 retained

out of 860)

I believe Strengths has

value for me now

93.4% (152 retained

out of 162)

99.9% (266 retained

out of 268)

I can name my top five

Strengths

3.30 (n = 148, sd = .55) 3.42 (n = 365, sd = .49)

I know how to apply my

Strengths to achieve

academic success

3.33 (n = 120, sd = .32) 3.42 (n = 327, sd = .47)

Page 16: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Students’ Perceived Value of Strengths

• From the end of the year survey (n = 570), we

discovered:

– Approximately 75% of students reported that Strengths has

value for them now, as they continue to progress as an

undergraduate, and as they enter the workforce or continue their

education

Page 17: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Staff vs. Student Perceived Value of Strengths

Page 18: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Staff’s Perceived Value of Strengths

Did Not Take

StrengthsFinder

Took

StrengthsFinder Diff.

Increasing their self-awareness 27.2% 71.5% 44.3

Understanding others 17.1% 49.0% 31.9

Thinking about potential career paths 24.6% 53.1% 28.5

Developing as a leader 22.1% 49.9% 27.8

Increasing their overall self-confidence 19.6% 40.7% 21.1

Getting involved on campus 14.8% 29.5% 14.7

Selecting a major 13.8% 22.8% 9.0

Feeling like they would like to return to

campus next year 6.2% 7.5% 1.3

Feeling like they belong on campus 9.2% 12.4% 3.2

Page 19: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Key Take-Aways

Staff Taking Strengths

Staff Perceived Value

More Strengths Interactions with Students

Greater Student Impact & Value

Students Have Higher Retention, Etc.

Page 20: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

What’s Next for You?

• Take StrengthsFinder assessment

• Visit www.strengths.umn.edu

• View research results online:

http://strengths.umn.edu/strengths-research/results

• Sign up for the 34 in 34 listserv

• Attend workshops (& encourage others to attend with

you!)

• Engage in a conversation around strengths with other

staff members or students

• Learn how your college/department is utilizing Strengths

Page 21: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

What’s Next for You?

• What is one small actionable step you are

going to commit to in regards to Strengths

within the next month?

Page 22: Assessing the Campus-Wide Impact of Strengths Initiatives for First Year … · 2014-10-21 · 2.3 3.5 With my employment supervisor off campus 1.2 2.5 Mid Year Survey (%) (n=1500)

Questions?