april 1, 2009pbeerli/bsc3052/... · adaptive management: take 2 adaptive management is a process...
TRANSCRIPT
-
April 1, 2009
Discuss PVA paper and Reviews
Management
• Adaptive Management
-
Ecosystem management
Ecosystem management ismanagement of whole ecosystems rather
than individual species
-
Ecosystem management
Manage for ecosystem health: allows for
production of “ecosystem services”
Include human activities
Focus on large spatial and long time scale
Management decisions include multiple stake
holders
-
Ecosystem management
Manage for ecosystem health: allows for
production of “ecosystem services”
commodities
clean water / flood control
aesthetics
....
-
Ecosystem management
Manage for ecosystem health: allows for
production of “ecosystem services”
Include human activities
Focus on large spatial and long time scale
Management decisions include multiple stake
holders
-
Ecosystem management
Manage for ecosystem health: allows for
production of “ecosystem services”
Include human activities
Focus on large spatial and long time scale
Management decisions include multiple stake
holders
-
Endangered Species
• Butterflies:! Schaus Swallowtail!
• Rodents:! Key Largo Cotton Mouse, Key Largo Wood Rat!
• Mammals:! Florida Panther, West Indian Manatee!
• Birds:! ! Arctic Peregrine Falcon, Cape Sable Sea Side ! ! ! ! Sparrow, Snail (Everglade) Kite, Southern Bald ! ! ! Eagle, Wood Stork!
• Reptiles and Amphibians:! American Crocodile, Atlantic ! ! ! ! ! ! Ridley Turtle, Green ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Turtle, Hawksbill Turtle, ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Leatherback Turtle!
-
Ecosystem management
Manage for ecosystem health: allows for
production of “ecosystem services”
Include human activities
Focus on large spatial and long time scale
Management decisions include multiple stake
holders
-
Stakeholders
have a real or perceived interest in the resource, its use, its protection.
are dependent on the resource
have a believe that management decisions will directly or indirectly affect them
are located in or near the area
pay for the decision
are in a position of authority to review the decisions
-
Ecosystem management
Manage for ecosystem health: allows for
production of “ecosystem services”
Include human activities
Focus on large spatial and long time scale
Management decisions include multiple stake
holders
Use adaptive management
-
Adaptive management
Adaptive management treats management
decisions as experiments. Change
management if data show not getting desired
result.
-
Adaptive managementAdaptive management treats management
decisions as experiments. Change
management if data show not getting desired
result.
Baseline data
Experimental data
include comparison or/and control
replicate !
-
Adaptive management
What is the effect grazing on a plant communityin an open field?
-
We need a control!
-
We need a control!
-
Diversity
ungrazed
What is the effect of grazing on the plant
community in open fields?
-
Diversity
ungrazed grazed
What is the effect of grazing on the plant
community in open fields?
-
What is the point of reference/control?
Replication?
What is the effect of grazing on the plant
community in open fields?
-
What is the point of reference/control?
Replication. YES for THIS field, but not for treatment (all fields in general) !"Pseudoreplication
What is the effect of grazing on the plant
community in open fields?
-
Field 1
Field 2Field 3
Field 4
-
Diversity
ungrazed grazed
What is the effect of grazing on the plant community in
open fields?
-
Ecosystem and resilience
Resilience is the magnitude of disturbance that can be absorbed or accommodated by an ecosystem before its structure is fundamentally changed to a different state.Example: Shrubland turns into grassland, grassland turns into desert.
Holling 1973
-
Adaptive management: Take 2
Adaptive management is a process that combines
democratic principles, scientific analysis, education, and
institutional learning to manage resources sustainably in
an environment of uncertainty. [Lee 1993]
Commitment to improve the outcomes of management over biological time scales.
Awareness of the experimental nature of management.
Willingness to accept the risk of perceived failures.
A common understanding, with stakeholders, of the goals, strategies, and uncertainties of management.
A mandate for action from the stakeholders or other authorities
-
Use of natural processes to manage ecosystems
Fire
Preservation of an ecosystem was often synonym withkeeping the “status quo”, this resulted very often in damaging
the ecosystem.
-
Fire regime for different ecosystem types
-
Hardwood confined to understory
Hardwooddominant
Prescribed fires Fire suppressed
-
Adaptive management: Learning from errors. Burning of Long-leaved pine forests during
growing (back) and non-growing season (front)
-
Use of natural processes to manage ecosystems
Fire
Water flow
Preservation of an ecosystem was often synonym withkeeping the “status quo”, this resulted very often in damaging
the ecosystem.
-
Use of natural processes to manage ecosystems
Fire
Water flow
Herbivory
Preservation of an ecosystem was often synonym withkeeping the “status quo”, this resulted very often in damaging
the ecosystem.
-
Zonation management
Core protection area
Managed area
Exclusion area
-
Ecosystem modelling
Spatially explicit (GIS)
Incorporate as many details as possible (Geology, Climate, ...)
Incorporate human interactions/use/development
Incorporate species compositions (diversity: species, genetics)
(Complex and often not enough data)
-
Ecosystem management
Manage for ecosystem health: allows for
production of “ecosystem services”
Include human activities
Focus on large spatial and long time scale
Management decisions include multiple stake
holders
Use adaptive management