“progress through sharing” afiia 2017 whistle blowing...“progress through sharing”...
TRANSCRIPT
5/30/2017
1
“PROGRESS THROUGH SHARING”
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities1
THE FOURTH AFIIA CONFERENCE“Enhancing Governance Effectiveness with Insightful Internal Audit”
Andy Lazarus Chitete CIA, CRMA, FCCA, CA (M), MSc.
Treasurer - AFIIAImmediate Past President - IIA Malawi
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities2
About the Speaker:Andy Lazarus Chitete is the Treasurer of the African Federation ofInstitutes of Internal Auditors (AFIIA) since 2014. He is also theImmediate Past President (IPP) of IIA Malawi. He retired from theElectricity Supply Corporation of Malawi (ESCOM) Limited asSenior Risk Manager on 29th April 2016. On 1 September 2016 hejoined GIZ-Malawi as Technical Advisor (internal Auditing).
Andy is a Certified Internal Auditor (CIA), a Certified RiskManagement Assurer (CRMA), a Fellow of the Association ofChartered Certified Accountants (FCCA), a Chartered Accountant(Malawi) [CA(M)] and holds a Masters Degree (MSc.) in StrategicManagement - University of Derby in UK.
Andy facilitates, speaks and presents at conferences, workshopsand training, locally and internationally, on the subjects of InternalAuditing, Governance, Risk Management, Controls, FraudInvestigations, Strategic Business Management, Accounting andTaxation.Andy Lazarus Chitete
CIA, CRMA, FCCA, CA(M), MSc.
2017-05-30 4th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments and Opportunities3
Whistle Blowing - Rights toInformation, Impediments and
Opportunities
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities4
AFIIA 2017
5/30/2017
2
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities5
Introduction
Definitions of Whistleblowing and Whistleblower
Importance of Whistle blowing
World Corruption Perception Index
World Report on Occupational Fraud and Abuse
Internal and External Whistleblowing
Channels of whistleblowing
Rights to Information
Confidentiality of Information
Freedom of Speech
Whistleblowing and Leaking of Information
Agenda
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities6
Internal Auditors Responsibilities in Communicating SensitiveInformation
Whistleblowers Bills of Rights
Impediments
Whistleblowers’ unwillingness to blow the whistle
Lack of seriousness by organizations in fraud and corruption detection
Opportunities
Increased Recognition of Importance of Whistleblowing
International bodies’ conventions to fight fraud and corruption
Legislation to protect whistleblowers
Examples of whistleblowing legislation and guidelines
Access to information legislation
Agenda Cont’d
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities7
Definitions of Whistleblowing and Whistleblower There is generally no agreed definitions.
Some are as follows:
The UK’s Committee on Standards in Public Life defines whistleblowing as“raising a concern about malpractice within an organisation”,
The International Labour Organisation refers to whistleblowing as “thereporting by employees of illegal, irregular, dangerous or unethicalpractices by employers”.
A whistleblower is one who reveals wrongdoing within an organization tothe public or to those in positions of authority. (The American Heritage®Dictionary)
Introduction
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities8
Importance of Whistleblowing An important tool in the fight against fraud and corruption (Art. 33 of UN
Convention on Corruption 2003 “shall consider”... “appropriate measuresto provide protection”).
Promotes the right to life –avoidance of physical disasters.
Corporate Governance /Risk Management – Early alerts
Management neglects problems
Provides employees means for disclosing unethical or illegal conduct
Provides employees with knowledge about who to disclose to
Complement audit work
Detect more fraud and corruption
Introduction Cont’d
AFIIA 2017
5/30/2017
3
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities9
WORLD CORRUPTION PERCEPTION INDEX 2016
Introduction Cont’dWORLD CORRUPTION PERCEPTION INDEX 2016
Impact of Fraud and Corruption
Deters foreign investment
Increases the cost of public service delivery
Increases the cost of doing business,
Promotes poverty and underdevelopment
Undermines the rule of law and
Donor aid is stopped
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities10
Corruption hurts all countries, in every region of the world
No Country gets closer to a perfect Score
Over ⅔ of the 176 countries fall below the midpoint of 0 (highly corrupt) and 100 (very clean)
Global average score is 43 indicating endemic corruption
Top scoring countries (yellow) were far outnumbered by the low scoring (orange and red)countries where citizens face the tangible impact of corruption on a daily basis
Introduction Cont’d
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities11
Total fraud cases exceeded $6.3 billion with an average loss per case of $2.7million
The average loss for all cases was $150,000 with 23.2% of cases at $1 million or more
The longer a fraud case took the greater the financial damage
Organisations face economic, disaster, supply chain,regulatory and technological risks in different ways andvarying degrees while fraud risk is universally faced byall businesses and government entities.
Any organisation with assets is vulnerable as dishonestindividuals target the assets
The 2016 global fraud study established that:
A typical organisation loses 5% of its revenue to fraudevery year
Introduction Cont’d2016 World Report to the nations on Occupational Fraud and Abuse
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities12
2016 World Report to the nations on Occupational Fraud and Abuse
The most common detection method was tips (39.1% of cases)
Organisations that had reporting hotlines more likely detected fraud than thosewithout (47.3% Vs 28.2%)
2.4%
3.8%
3.8%
5.5%
5.5%
5.6%
13.4%
16.5%
39.1%
0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% 40.0% 45.0%
Notified by Law Enforcement
External Audit
Document Examination
Other
Account Reconciliation
By Accident
Management Review
Internal Audit
Tips
OCCUPATIONAL FRAUDS DETECTION METHODS
Introduction Cont’d
AFIIA 2017
5/30/2017
4
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities13
Internal and External Whistleblowing
Internal whistleblowing is contained within the organisation
External Whistleblowing involves reporting to an outside agency
However, Internal hotlines are often open to external whistlebowers
A hotline may be outsourced to a thirdparty who operates it for the organisation
Channels of Whistleblowing:
A special telephone hotline
Email based service
Web form
Regular mail
Fax
Simply speaking to trusted right persons
Introduction Cont’d Rights to Information
Confidentiality of Information
Confidential workplace information can be in three classes i.e. :
Employee,
Management and
Business information
Failure to secure confidentiality of information can lead to:
Loss of business
Misuse of the information to commit illegal activity
Loss of employee trust, confidence and loyalty
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities14
Rights to Information Cont’d
Freedom of Speech
Article 10(1) of the European Convention (ECHR) states that: “Everyone has the rightto freedom of expression. This right shall include freedom to hold opinions and toreceive and impart information and ideas without interference by public authority andregardless of frontiers...”
However, this does not provide blanket support for whistleblowers because Article10(2) states that: “The exercise of these freedoms, since it carries with it duties andresponsibilities, may be subject to such formalities, conditions, restrictions or penaltiesas are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society, in the interests ofnational security, territorial integrity or public safety. for the prevention of disorder orcrime…”.
Abraham Mansbach stated that the act of whistleblowing embodies and represents apractice of 'fearless speech' which is a crucial element in democracy. He howeverexpressed concern over the tension that exists between the socio-political facet ofwhistleblowing and the private sphere.
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities15
Rights to Information Cont’dFreedom of Speech Cont’d
People become whistleblowers as they go through the process of disclosing what they believeaffects their lives. In doing so, some organisational secrecy may be uncovered.
Whistleblowing activism claims that such secrecy should not be considered as normal or obvious,but rather that the interests of society must take priority over those of organisations. If someoneposes a Whistleblowing and Democratic Values risk to society, then society has a right to knowabout it.
The 1990s consensus supports the balancing of organisational and public interest by allowing andnurturing internal whistleblowing so that malpractice can be remedied without causing a publicscandal and protection against reprisals can be provided.
Research by Marcia Miceli, Janet Near, and Terry Dworkin in the US established that internal andexternal whistleblowing are linked. External whistleblowing is usually preceded by the raising ofconcerns internally.
Hence, how organisations manage internal whistleblowing is important, not just in the interests ofthe organisation but also in the interests of the public good and democracy.
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities16
AFIIA 2017
5/30/2017
5
Rights to Information Cont’dWhistleblowing and Leaking of Information
People need to be persuaded to raise their concerns internally rather than externally orinternationally
Many individuals have come to realise that if whistleblowers are not protected by law itmight be wiser to leak information anonymously than to use official channels.
The problem of being identified is demonstrated by the case of Bradley Manning, whowas convicted by court-martial in July2013 of violations of the Espionage Act and otheroffenses, after disclosing to WikiLeaks nearly three-quarters of a million classified, orunclassified but sensitive military and diplomatic documents. He was sentenced inAugust 2013 but President Obama commuted his sentence, hence was scheduled to bereleased on May 17, 2017.
One other trend worth highlighting is the more widespread acceptance thatwhistleblowing is an important tool in the fight against fraud and corruption
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities17
Rights to Information Cont’dInternal Auditors Responsibilities in Communicating Sensitive Information
Practice Advisory 2440-2: Communicating Sensitive Information Within and Outside theChain of Command, provides guidance:
The auditor normally communicates credible substantial information in a timely mannerto senior management and the board in accordance with Standard 2060 and PA 2060-1following the normal chain of command
In accordance with Standard 2600 the auditor should present the information anddifference of opinion to the board If senior management is exposing the organisation tounacceptable risk and is not taking appropriate action
For certain types of sensitive occurrences e.g. fraudulent financial reporting by publiclytraded securities organisations, the typical chain of command communication may needto be accelerated to the board even when the auditor and management have agreed onwhich action to take.
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities18
Rights to Information Cont’d
Internal Auditors Responsibilities in Communicating Sensitive Information Cont’d
When the auditor has to communicate information to persons outside the normal chainof command or even outside the organisation (whistle blow) she/he should first considerthe merits and demerits of such an action
Knowledge of the laws and regulations of the industry, obtaining legal advise wherevernecessary and compliance with the IIA’s code of ethic are important to the auditor
The auditor may investigate complaints, especially if related to fraud and corruption, and
may Manage an external provider, giving advice, or operating a helpline.
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities19
Rights to Information Cont’d
Whistleblowers Bills of Rights
Many countries in the world have passed whistle blower rights’ laws that give whistleblowers the right to:
Communication: Freedom to disclosures provided they respect the confidentiality ofsensitive information.
Protection from Retaliation: Institutions have a duty not to tolerate or engage in retaliationagainst good-faith whistle blowers.
Fair Procedures: Institutions have a duty to provide fair and objective procedures for examiningand resolving complaints, disputes, and allegations of misconduct.
Procedures free from Partiality: Institutions have a duty to follow procedures that are not taintedby partiality arising from personal or institutional conflict of interest or other sources of bias
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities20
AFIIA 2017
5/30/2017
6
Rights to Information Cont’d
Whistleblowers Bills of Rights Cont’d
Information: Institutions have a duty to elicit and evaluate fully and objectively information aboutconcerns raised by whistle blowers.
Timely Processes: Institutions have a duty to handle cases involving alleged misconduct asexpeditiously as is possible without compromising responsible resolutions.
Vindication: At the conclusion of proceedings, institutions have a responsibility to credit promptly--in public and/or in private as appropriate- those whose allegations are substantiated andconcluded.
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities21
ImpedimentsUnwillingness of whistleblowers to blow the whistle
The 2011 National Business Ethics Supplemental (NBES) Research Report establishedwhat goes through the mind of the whistleblower before he decides to blow the whistle.
The research suggested many possible determinants of an individual’s willingness towhistle blow, including:
Awareness: The importance or seriousness of the act impacts on his willingness to usea hotline
Agency: His perceptions of responsibility for reporting the act may impact hiswillingness to report the event
Security and Investment: The organization’s reputation for retaliation will alsoinfluence his perception to making a report.
Support and Connectedness: The whistle blower’s trust on some authorities willinfluence his perception to making a report
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities22
Impediments Cont’d
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities23
Unwillingness of whistleblowers to blow the whistle Cont’d
The 2014 Deloitte Forensic India Survey Report on making whistleblowingprograms successful in corporate India established that employees don’t whistleblow because of:
Fear of retaliation or harassment
Fear of termination or suspension
Inadequate channels to voice concern
No precedent of action taken by the management
Other – e.g. (i) Time – workload, (ii) Not mandatory, (iii) Small concerns mightbe dismissed, (iv) No knowledge of overall picture, (v) Lack of knowledge aboutwhistle blowing, (vi) Not promoted by organisation’s culture, and (vii) Lack ofsupport, advice and information.
(See results of the survey in the graph below)
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities24
Impediments Cont’d
AFIIA 2017
5/30/2017
7
Unwillingness of whistleblowers to blow the whistle Cont’d
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities25
Impediments Cont’dLack of Seriousness by organisations in corruption and fraud detection
Most organisations perceive whistleblowing as ‘yet another measure to implement’ aspart of the larger fraud risk management efforts and, hence, it gets relegated to a tick inthe box
Organisations must understand that whistleblowing is, perhaps, the only tool that comesclose to pointing out a fraud in its early stages and must therefore be supported byensuring that:
Data from the whistle blower hotline is continuously monitored and integrated into thelarger fraud risk management systems so that even small irregularities can bedetected early
More time and resources on building robust whistleblowing systems is invested
Employees are trained on the existence and use of the whistleblowing system
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities26
Impediments Cont’d
Lack of Seriousness by organisations in corruption and fraud detectionCont’d
The hotlines are functional and available through multiple access points.
The hotlines promise confidentiality to users
Dedicated teams to run the hotlines are established.
The person managing the hotline should not have a full time administrative orhuman resources responsibility.
Senior management is committed to the success of the whistle blowerhotline(Tone at the Top),
Senior Management frequently communicate about the hotline to employees.
Organisations should consider outsourcing the whistle blower hotlinemanagement to enhance its independence and whistle blowers’ trust.
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities27
Impediments Cont’d OpportunitiesIncreased recognition of Importance of Whistle blowing
More recently, organisations have realised that whistleblower mechanisms are apossible tool for the detection, and possibly prevention, of corporate wrong-doing.
For example the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (2002) requires audit committees toestablish procedures for:
The receipt, retention, and treatment of complaints received by the organisationregarding accounting, internal accounting controls, or auditing matters; and
The confidential, anonymous submission by employees of the organisation ofconcerns regarding questionable accounting or auditing matters.
Globally, organisations are publishing the number of whistle blower complaintsreceived in a bid to encourage more whistleblowing e.g. the US Department ofJustice reported over 3,000 whistle blower tips between 2012 and 2013
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities28
AFIIA 2017
5/30/2017
8
Opportunities
Increased recognition of Importance of Whistle blowing Cont’d
Organisations are establishing a whistleblowing hotlines for better governanceand reduction of fraud
Organisations understand that employees are their eyes and ears – i.e. they seeand hear everything that goes on within, including inappropriate behaviour and whois involved in perpetrating it.
The G20 Anti-Corruption Working Group prepares monitoring report for theLeaders’ Summits.
International bodies such as the United Nations, the European Union and othersmake some conventions to fight Fraud and Corruption and protect whistle blowersin the world
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities29
Opportunities Cont’dLegislation and Guidelines to protect whistle blowers
Many countries in the world are introducing whistleblowing legislation, regulation orguidance in order to protect whistle blowers from retaliation of wrongdoers and incentivisethem with financial rewards.
Different countries are at different stages of implementing their legislation and guidelines.
Examples of whistle blowing legislation and guidelines are as follows:
United States of America (USA) : The Sarbanes Oxley Act (SOX) (2002) is acomprehensive response to corporate scandals and failures which includes extensiveprovision for whistleblowing and whistle blower protection. The Sarbanes Oxley Act
United Kingdom (UK) : The Public Interest Disclosure Act (PIDA) (1998) was borne out ofthe enquiries into several major disasters (such as the sinking of the Herald of FreeEnterprise, the Clapham rail crash and the collapse of BCCI)
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities30
Opportunities Cont’dLegislation and Guidelines to protect whistle blowers Cont’d
Legislation similar to PIDA has been introduced in various other countries (e.g. Australia,New Zealand, South Africa)
Other European Countries – European countries outside the UK and Ireland haveresisted implementation of whistleblowing legislation for various reasons. In France theirbelief is that, organisations have so many controls and management have a responsibilityto prevent malpractices hence it is not necessary to place the burden of whistle blowing onstaff.
Africa: some few countries such as Uganda (Whistle blowers Protection Act 2010) andGhana (Whistle blowers Act 2006) legislated whistleblowing while so many others are inthe process of coming up with the legislation. Many organisations however have policiesthat protect whistle blowers.
Malaysia: Securities Industry Act amendments advocate protection against whistleblowers
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities31
Opportunities Cont’d
Legislation and Guidelines to protect whistle blowers Cont’d
Corporate governance codes (e.g., U.K., Australia, Singapore)
Companies’ codes of ethics/conduct encouraging or even imposing a duty onemployees to report breaches
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities32
AFIIA 2017
5/30/2017
9
Opportunities Cont’dAccess to Information (ATI) Legislation
Access to information is widely recognized as a cornerstone of good governance and animportant anti-corruption tool.
Almost 100 countries, including 10 in Africa, have national laws or decrees that recognizethe public’s right to access information or records from government. In Africa, the followingare countries in Africa which ATI legislation by 2011
South Africa: Promotion of Access to Information Act (2000)Angola: Freedom of information Law (2002)Zimbabwe: Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act (2002)Uganda: Access to Information Act (2005)Ethiopia: Freedom of Information and Mass Media Law (2008)Liberia: Freedom of Information Act (2010)Guinea: Organic law on the right of access to Public Information (2010)Nigeria: Freedom of Information Law (2011)Tunisia: Decree on Access to the Administrative Documents of Public Authorities ofTunisia (2011)Niger: Charter on Access to Public and Administrative Documents (2011)
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities33
Opportunities Cont’dATI in Africa
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities34
2017-05-304th AFIIA Conference - Whistle Blowing Rights, Impediments
and Opportunities35
AFIIA 2017