antioxidant and prooxidant roles for Β-carotene, Α-tocopherol and ascorbic acid in human lung...

12
Antioxidant and prooxidant roles for b-carotene, a-tocopherol and ascorbic acid in human lung cells P. Zhang, S.T. Omaye * Environmental Sciences and Health Graduate Program and the Department of Nutrition, Mail Stop 142, University of Nevada, Reno, NV 89557, USA Accepted 1 September 2000 Abstract Experiments were conducted to determine the antioxidant and prooxidant eects of b-carotene, a-tocopherol and ascorbic acid on human lung cells at dierent oxygen (O 2 ) tensions. Free radical initiator, 2,2 0 -azobis (2-amidinopropane) dihydrochloride (AAPH), was used to induce the cellular damage associated with lipid peroxidation, protein oxidation and DNA breaks. Under hypoxic conditions (0 torr O 2 tension) all compounds produced a concentration-dependent antioxidant eect. Mixtures of the three compounds exhibited greater protective aects than any individual compound. At 143 torr O 2 tension, all compounds exhibited concentration-dependent protective eects against AAPH-induced cellular lipid, protein and DNA damage. At 722 torr O 2 tension, cells exhibited a consistent increase in lipid peroxidation (isoprostane formation), protein oxidation (carbonyl formation) and DNA damage (p53 protein accumulation). b-Carotene (1.5 mm) produced a prooxidant eect by promoting 12% isoprostane formation. Protein oxidation and DNA damage at 722 torr O 2 tension was not increased by b-carotene; however, the antioxidant eect of b- carotene was attenuated. The antioxidant eects of a-tocopherol, ascorbic acid, and mixtures of the three antioxidant compounds also were reduced by the high O 2 conditions. These results partially substantiate the hypothesis that the antioxidant and prooxidant eects of b-carotene are dependent on O 2 tension and concentration of b-carotene. Such ®ndings may partially explain why selected populations, such as smokers, respond adversely when supplemented with b-carotene. # 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: b-Carotene; a-Tocopherol; Ascorbic acid; Human lung cell line CCD-8Lu; Antioxidant; Prooxidant 1. Introduction Intervention trials and animal studies exploring the relationship between b-carotene and disease suggest that b-carotene is of little or no value in preventing cardio- vascular disease and the major cancers that occur in well-nourished populations (ATBC Study Group, 1994; Greenberg et al., 1996; Hennekens et al., 1996; Omenn et al., 1996a; Wang et al., 1999). The mechanism involved, so far understood, is the prooxidant eect of b-carotene at high oxygen concentration. The relation- ship between the prooxidant eect of b-carotene and oxygen concentration and consequences of the proox- idant eect of b-carotene have been studied in in vitro (Vile and Winterbourn, 1988; Palozza et al., 1995, 1997). In vitro, whether b-carotene is antioxidant or prooxidant is dependent on oxygen tension and the concentration of b-carotene (Zhang and Omaye, 2000). The purpose of this study was to test the anti- or prooxidant eects of b-carotene on human lung cells with respect to dierent oxygen tensions, thus allowing us to examine the eects of intact cells on the interac- tions between b-carotene, oxidation and the subsequent impact of antioxidant mixtures. Several epidemiological studies provided data showing the negative eects of b- carotene on lung cancer incidence (ATBC Study Group, 1994; Omenn et al., 1996a,b; Omenn, 1998; Albanes, 1999; Wang et al., 1999). However, the mechanism of such negative eects is unclear. Wang et al. (1999) sug- gested that diminished retinoid signalling, resulting from the suppression of RAR b gene expression and over- expression of activator protein-1, could be a mechanism 0887-2333/01/$ - see front matter # 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. PII: S0887-2333(00)00054-0 Toxicology in Vitro 15 (2001) 13±24 www.elsevier.com/locate/toxinvit Abbreviations: AAPH, 2,2 0 -azobis (2-amidinopropane) dihy- drochloride; BHT, butylated hydroxytoluene; BSA, bovine serum albumin; DNP, 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrozine; HRP, disodium horse- radish peroxidase; PBS, phosphate buered saline; pNPP, p-nitrophe- nylphosphate; THF, tetrahydro¯uran; * Corresponding author. Tel.: +1-775-784-6447; fax: +1-775-784- 6449. E-mail address: [email protected] (S.T. Omaye).

Upload: wee-ting

Post on 14-Sep-2015

9 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

research paper

TRANSCRIPT

  • ! " #$%%& '

    !!!

    " # $ $ % & '

    ( % & %)& #

    # *+ , -

    %!

    & $ .

    / $ / 01

    / $ ) *+ 2

    % & % & *+

    %31 & 4 %3 & $ 5 *+ 2

    # 6 #/ $ # $ # $ 7 # ,

    /

    # # !! "/ 8

    /

    ( )* 46 6 6 ) 44*986 6

    :/

    # / / / ;

    # %>06= >>?6 ), >>?6 >>?6 @ >>>& //

    $

    # $

    A $ / /%B @ >996 (( >>3>>2& : / #

    % !!!& #

    $ # $ # $ # A /

    / # / $ %>06 >>?6 >>96 >>>6 @ >>>& )#/

    / $ @ %>>>&

    !'!

    /

    /

    !992 111C!CD !! "/ 8 /: : E !992 111%!! &!!!30!

    B 3 % !!& 1F 0

    ###/CC/

    '++* ) ( % & 6

  • , $

    # %= >>& # ! 01 2

    /

    / # # / # / ; %4 >>9&. # # ; # !3 25 % & #E %& ! 3 ! 6 % & ! ! ! 6 %1&!0 ! 0! 6 %0& !9 0! 9! 6 %3& ? 9!

    ?! ## !3 25

    -- .

    4 %/ "& %/ 4& # 44 % 8 . -& ( % & %)& # @, 4 %G B -& '

    , # 4

    -- .

    ) %44*98& # 4 4 %.

    B-& # "K

    # !5 / %35

    "8: 44*98 # ! 01 2

    /

    4%&

    :

    %C&%&

    :

    %C&

    %&:

    %C&

    .

    %&:

    %C&

    / 0

    ! 1!3 ! 1! !? ! 03?!29 ! 139 ) 1 ? 0 ) >3?132 ) 1 110> ) 11390 ?! 1!3>1 9 3 2031> ! >01 9 9?3 1?! 2 !? ! 3 139 ! 19 1 9 103!0 3!13> ! 09> 1? 0! 3?023 1 039 32!9 393! 0! >020 9! 1 ?> 0 9319? ?29 93 9! 1?01 ?! ?1 9 3 9?> 191 0

    ! 129 ! 1?!39 ! 9>!0 ! 0 !>3) 10 31 2 ) 1 29 ) >?> 13 ) 1 ? 1?! 19> 3 1!31 ! 1 3! !391?3! ?3>1?3 ! 13 !1 ! 1! 2 0 2 3!0 3> > ! ?0> 1! 30 1 ? 113?!9 1>31 0! >2 ! 9! ?31 2 0 30 22? ! 39 9! 0 3 ?! 9 02 3 23>1 & 0

    ! 9?110 ! 9> !1 ! 20!3> ! >?? 3) 00 > ) 03 ?? ) 01 1? ) 0 9!9! 0 !3 1 3 0 22 ! 1? 1>23!2! 0 2 !> ! 12 91 9 ! 0!39199 122?2!0 03190 ! 1?3?3 0! 1130 1 1 1!903!9 003?2 0! ?1?192 9! 013!> 0 913!3? 0> 3 ? 9! ?9?? ?! 93302 3 3 0

    * * %& B 7 $ ) # % L !!3& % L !!& % L !!!&

    4 ) ( % & %/ &

    0 - 2 -3- 4 5 30 " % 6//7 18

  • -1- 3

    " # # / / M 31

    ' # # H %)'& >>>5 # !! 35 %#C/& %

  • / + # E !

    %>35 + 35 4 &6 01

    %>35 35 4 &6 2

    %>35 35 4 & % !!!& !

    7 %! & # 00 1! / )# H, ;

    #

    -9- : 0

    8 #

    %9=' 3'

    9' & %8 >>9& , %: "8: N >1&6 #/ 31 -B

    ( *+ %3!2& # >!48 $ , # # # *F %*F="& !5

  • # ) & 44*98 # !0 !9 ? % & 9 1 0?5 / 7 0! 9! 10 305 / % & / 9! ?! # 10 ?5 / % &

    . P ! 3 ! 005 / 00 0? 32 ?? 205 # % &

    1--- 1 0 01

    # !

    % & 10 13 05 !19 !22 3? / 1 12 305 9> 19 29 / 00 325 291 3?1 / . / 44*98 ) 1? 0? 3! ? 2?5

    1 0 3 /

    1--1- & 0 + )

    # # !F!9 )#/ 5 3 % & $ $ # 0 5 0! # 05

    9! % & 005 9! # 105 ?! % & $ -, 7 # ! 01

    / 7 % &

    1-- 0

    1--- 0

    ) %1! & 44*98

    3

    , % & ! ! ) 44*98 7 / 15 % & $ # / 7 # 4 9 095 !9! ?! / 7 # / # 0? 25

    ) / 0! 0! 3> ?35 ! ! 0! 9! / % & / $ #

    12 3> ?5 0! 9! ?! / % & : # , 11 32 39 235 1 0 3 / % &

    1--- 1 0 : 01

    / $ 44*98 # 7

    %015& # / %? & / $ # # 7

    # % & #

    $ ) # % & 1 0> ? 5 0! 9! ?! / % & / #, !

    ? 33 3 ??5 1 0 3 / % &

    1--1- & 0

    44*98 1! )

    # 7 $# / % &) $ $ 95 # / 9! % & $

    - 2 -3- 4 5 30 " % 6//7 18 2

  • #

    # % & 1>5 025 0 315 3

    $/ # % &

    1-1- '

    # / *+ 31 31 ) $ #

    1-1-- 0

    %&

    $ % F?& % 2F & / 31

    4 *+ >5 %?& # *+ >05 %9! & %& $ / 4

    $/ *+ , >35 31 ?! .

    ) *+ !!5 # / % & # $

    1-1-- 1 0 4 31 31 9! 91

    > >25 ! ! !0 !9 ? / % F?& : 44*9 # ) *+ ?1 93 >? >? >95 3 ! ! 0! 9! / % 2F & $ 09 ?1 21 9? 9>5 31 ! ! 0! 9! ?! / 4

    / % F?& / $/ ) *+ / >>15 % 2F & # 01

    : 31 44*98 # !

    ( % & %)& # 31 / $ # A7 / / )

    # %& 8 E 1! )6 E 1! ) ! 6 1E 1! ) ! 6 0E 1! ) !0 6 3E 1! ) !9 6 ?E 1! ) ? 6 2E 1! )6 9E 1! ) 3 6 >E 1! ) ! 6 !E 1! ) ! 6 E 1! ) 0! 6 E 1! ) 9! 6 %& E 1! ) %1! &6 E 1! ) ! 6 1E 1! ) ! 6 0E 1! ) 0! 6 3E1! ) 9! 6 ?E 1! ) ?! 6 2E 1! )6 9E 1! ) 6 >E 1! ) 6 !E 1! ) 16 E 1! ) 06 E 1! ) 3

    9 - 2 -3- 4 5 30 " % 6//7 18

  • 7 $

    1-1-1- & 0 1%&

    $ 4 $ # ! ! %1 1& 4

    31 ?25 ! ! )#/ $ # !0 # ?? 31 35 31 !0 !9 ? / % 1 0F?& 31 0> #

    ) %235 & $ $ $/ # ! #?25 !

    / 3 # >5 01

    >25 3 2

    %?25& # !

    $ $ # >?5

    9! $ # : #

    #

    # $ % 1 2F & 8, / $ #

    % 1 F?& 31 10 ? 2? 935 ! ! 0! 9! / % 1 F3& )#/ ?! / 2 5 15

    / %9! & / 1 25

    / ! 01

    / / $ #

    / $ #

    7 $ / $ % 1 2F &

    4

    #

    / / # / , / / /

    : 31 44*98 # 01

    ( % & %)& # 31 $ # A7 / / ) #

    %& 8 E 1! . )6 E 1! ) ! 6 1E 1! ) ! 6 0E1! ) !0 6 3E 1! ) !9 6 ?E 1! ) ? 6 2E 1! )6 9E 1! ) 3 6 >E 1! ) ! 6 !E 1! ) ! 6 E 1! ) 0! 6 E 1! ) 9! 6 %& E 1! ) %1! &6 E 1! ) ! 6 1E 1! ) ! 6 0E 1! ) 0! 6 3E 1! ) 9! 6 ?E 1! ) ?! 6 2E 1! )6 9E 1! ) 6 >E1! ) 6 !E 1! ) 16 E 1! ) 06 E 1! ) 3

    - 2 -3- 4 5 30 " % 6//7 18 >

  • %. >>?& G 7 / #/ / / / ;

    # %= >>?6), >>?&

    ,

    %>06 >>?&

    A 7 %& #

    # /

    # / # /

    # , )#/ #

    44*98 7, %4 >>9&9>& )#/ /

    # , / ;

    , / ,

    %, >926 9>6(( N, >>& / #

    $ : #/ # 7 / 01

    )#/ $ # # $ 2

    / / / %906 B @ >996 N 8 >> 6 (( >>3 >>2 >>9&

    # 90& # ( /

    #

    :

    (

    1 : 31 44*98 # 2

    ( % & %)& # 31 / $ # A7 / / ) #

    %& 8 E 1! )6 E 1! ) ! 6 1E 1! ) ! 6 0E 1! ) !0 6 3E 1! ) !9 6 ?E 1! ) ? 6 2E 1! )6 9E 1! ) 3 6 >E 1! ) ! 6 !E 1! ) ! 6 E1! ) 0! 6 E 1! ) 9! 6 %& E 1! ) %1! &6 E 1! ) ! 6 1E 1! ) ! 6 0E 1! ) 0! 6 3E 1! ) 9! 6 ?E 1! ) ?! 6 2E 1! )6 9E 1! ) 6 >E 1! ) 6 !E 1! ) 16 E 1! ) 06 E 1! ) 3

    ! - 2 -3- 4 5 30 " % 6//7 18

  • # A : A

    #

    ( >6N 8 >>6 8 .4>>?& >3& # 441 # / # %4 I& : # # %4414 %>>?& / / : N 8 %>> &

    M 7 # #

    # / # M $ / /

    // % >916 8, >>6

    >>16 (( >>96 !!!& # / $

    %* >>!6 Q, >>!6 >> 6 @ >>1& $ / ! 01

    # /

    / $ / / / /

    /

    # // :

    # / +/ $ E %& # , ,# % & /

    # / M /

    $ # # / / / ! 9! !

    / %4 >>9& $ /

    / # %) >>6 N 8>> & !!5 ?!4 %) >>& # / 4/

    / $ % >9!& / $ 7 $ ( %) ) >>06 ) >>?& >06 ) >>?&6 F %(( N, >> & 7 / >1& #

    # # %8*8& # 8*8 # O = %>>& #

    - 2 -3- 4 5 30 " % 6//7 18

  • 8*8 ( # 4 I./ % & 8*8 %G/ >>0& // # ,#

    %9?6 ' >9>>>!& @ # A / M / %' >99 >9>& %# A //& # #

    # %, >2>6 936 * >936 N >> 6 >16 @ >>?& 8*8 A G

    -

    / 8*8 %>1&@ / $

    # ) ) # #

    / )' / # / A 4 , # 6 $ / $ /

    )#/ // / : // 7 # # %+, >>3& 7

    '

    # @ # $ *+ )#/ $ # #

    7 % > F?& 8 @

    /

    7

    # + / A A # #

    (

    7 *+ : 7 C //

    ; # +/ " -/

    +/ G @ # , , O /#

    Q 91 8 / / 1 O + 1 ?!9F ?0

    * >>> E O 4 + ?> 103F13!

    >0 $ / "

    ,

    +# "

    O . 11! ! >F!13

    )G

    >>1 "$ 21 > F !

    93

    / 4 # / "

    # 4 O 4 ?1 1??F120

    >1

    $ / "

    # O 4

    3 ?! >F?!00

    9> O

    + > !>F

    90 E 0 3?>F321

    9? B "E

    4 G > >0F

    !

    4 . 9 . )

    , #

    7E 31 G?F !!

    ) =O / N;, 'O=. 4; N, +:

    >> 4(

    ' G >

    G / " # O

    8 G 11 193F1>2

    N 4# ': ) O8 9? 1

    G/#

    >? E 7 4

    G > 9F

    8 .

    # O* >>9 E A

    / //# O

    $

    / "

    ?

    (( N, +: >>

    ' G >

    / 2

    E $

    '

    G >! B

    4 ?F 1

    G/ * ' " +/ . # '8 >>0

    8*8 / 7E $ /

    B

    G *8 .O @

    # =" ' ' =

    N G O

    ." ) = >> K$

    O 4 + 31 ?99F?>0

    = =@ @ = >> -, /

    7 O + 1 : / 4

    / "

    E "G '

    G F?31

    , G R R .* ' =( +

    92 9> / 8 0 ?3>F??

    O R G ., ) . >9! :

    $ O

    '

    / 0 2>F>1

    = >>? E

    , O