analyzing breadland shareholder value. shareholder value breadland 2 contents breadland performance...
TRANSCRIPT
Analyzing Breadland Shareholder Value
Shareholder Value
Breadland
2
Contents
• Breadland Performance versus Food Companies
• Breadland Performance versus RTE Companies
• Opportunities for Creating Additional Shareholder Value
• Appendix
Shareholder Value
Breadland
3
Companies with High ROE-Ke Spreads Tend to be Rewarded
Will High Market to Book Ratios
Value Creation Matrix
MVBV
ROE - Ke
High
High
Low
Low
High Value Adders
Low Value Adders
High Value Adders tend to be companies with either high earnings or high potential for earnings growth.
High Value Adders tend to be companies with either high earnings or high potential for earnings growth.
Shareholder Value
Breadland
4
Breadland's Market to Book was Above the Industry
Average in 1990 . . .
Name of Stock MV/BV P/E
Ralston 7.44 15
General Mills 7.09 22
Kellogg 4.22 21
Breadland 4.15 19
Heinz 3.79 15
Borden 2.62 13
Sara Lee 2.58 20
Hershey 2.53 19
Campbell 1.59 24
CPC International 0.98 18
Average 3.7018.6
Depending on which proxy is used (MV/BV or P/E), attaining parity with Kellogg could add between $71 MM and $410 MM in Shareholder Value.
Depending on which proxy is used (MV/BV or P/E), attaining parity with Kellogg could add between $71 MM and $410 MM in Shareholder Value.
1990
Source: Value Line, Wall Street Journal 9/12/91, Gemini Analysis (see appendix)1. P/E is from 1991.
1
Shareholder Value
Breadland
5
. . . and the Market to Book Has Been High in the Past Market to Book versus ROE-Ke Spread
Food Companies1988 - 1990
Source: Value Line, Gemini Analysis
MVBV
ROE - Ke
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
-20.00% -10.00% 0.00% 10.00% 20.00% 30.00% 40.00%
CP'90
S'90HY'90
HZ'90
CA'90
B'90
Q'90
R'90
K'90
G'90
CP'89
S'89HY'89
HZ'89
CA'89
B'89
Q'89
R'89
K'89
G'89
CP'88
S'88HY'88
HZ'88
CA'88
B'88
Q'88
R'88K'88
G'88
B = BordenCA = CampbellCP = CPC InternationalG = General MillsHZ = HeinzHY = HersheyK = KelloggsQ = BreadlandR = RalstonS = Sara Lee
Shareholder Value
Breadland
6
Contents
• Breadland Performance versus Food Companies
• Breadland Performance versus RTE Companies
• Opportunities for Creating Additional Shareholder Value
• Appendix
Shareholder Value
Breadland
7
Breadland Has Lagged Behind RTE Competitors in Achieving
High ROE - Ke SpreadsMarket to Book versus ROE-Ke Spread
RTE Companies1988 - 1990
ROE - Ke Spread (%)
Source: Value Line, Gemini Analysis
MVBV
G = General MillsK = KelloggsQ = BreadlandR = Ralston
KeyBreadland Strategy
• Be the Best
Breakfast
Company
Kellogg Apparent Strategy
• Strong International Sales
General Mills Apparent Strategy
• Leverage brands with line extensions
• Attack core industry segments
• Long run “year 2000” growth plan
Ralston Apparent Strategy
• Licensing products
• Private label
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
0.00% 5.00% 10.00% 15.00% 20.00% 25.00% 30.00% 35.00% 40.00%
Q'90
R'90
K'90
G'90
Q'89
R'89
K'89
G'89
Q'88
R'88K'88
G'88
Shareholder Value
Breadland
8
And Equity Analysts Have Questioned the Sustainability ofBreadland Earnings Growth
Breadland:"As the [sports beverage] category grows in the U.S., will it attract more competitors?"
— Dean Witter"Lower-than-expected results in its U.S. Grocery Division out to 1992." — Merrill Lynch
General Mills:“Leveraging brands is one of General Mill's strong points - just look at the success of Cheerios and Total line extensions.”
— Prudential
Kelloggs:"Driven by strong overseas operations. Sales were up 20% in 1990"
- Duff and Phelps“Clearly [overseas] is where the growth is, and Kellogg is wonderfully positioned to capitalize on it.”
— Prudential
Ralston:“Its calendar 1991 private-label gains only offset branded weakness… Ralston is doing what it can to survive and grow in a category in which it only has a modest share.”
— Prudential
Shareholder Value
Breadland
9
Contents
• Breadland Performance versus Food Companies
• Breadland Performance versus RTE Companies
• Opportunities for Creating Additional Shareholder Value
• Appendix
Shareholder Value
Breadland
10
Based on Breadland P/E, A $1 Million Profit Improvement CouldIncrease Shareholder Value by $11.4 Million
Company
Kellogg
General Mills
Breadland
RTE Sales
$4,200
$1,600
$441
Total Sales
$5,181
$6,448
$5,031
RTE % of Sales
80%
25%
9%
PE
21
22
19
1. 1990 Annual Report.2. 76,012,000 shares as of 3/31. Share price = $61.625 on 8/1/9Source: Benchmarking Analysis
$1,000,000 X (1-.40) X 19 = $11,400,000
IdentifiedCost Savings
Breadland Tax Rate
Breadland PE
AdditionalShareholder
Value
For every $1 million that is added to Breadland ' RTE profit, value for Breadland stockholder increases by .24%
$11,400,000
$4,684,239,5002
= 0.24%
1
Shareholder Value
Breadland
11
A $47 Million Profit Improvement Program in BBC Should
Increase Shareholder Value by at Least $532 Million
Business CaseProfit Improvement
Estimate
$616 MM
$84 MM
$532 MM$19 MMTax
$47 MM
Gen. MillsPE = 22
BreadlandPE = 19
$28 MM² ATOI
$63 MM² ATOI
$41 MM
$104 MM
Gen. MillsPE = 22
BreadlandPE = 19
$1,197 MM
$189 MM
$1,386 MM
Increase inShareholder Value
1. No Interest expense deducted yet.2. 1991 Breakfast Division P&L, 1991 Breadland P&L.
19.4% Profit Improvement
Migrationto ALL of Breadland
11
BBC DivisionIncrease in
Shareholder Value
BBC “As Is”
BBC if at “Best-in-Class”
19.4% ProfitImprovement
Total Breadland
Breadland “As Is”
Breadland if at “Best-in-Class”
Shareholder Value
Breadland
12
Improving BBC Profit by $47 MM Will Raise Breadland's
ROE by 2.6%
21.2%
23.8%
1990ROE
ProjectedROE
Source: Value Line, Business Case
Effect on ROE by BBC Profit Improvement:
ROE = Net Income + Profit Improvement • (1 - tax rate)
Average Stockholder Equity
228.9 + $47 MM (1 - .40)
$1,078 MM
ROE Improvement
23.8% =
27.1%
Effect on ROE by Total Breadland Profit Improvement:
ROE = Net Income + Profit Improvement • (1 - tax rate)
Average Stockholder Equity
228.9 + $104 MM (1 - .40)
$1,078 MM27.1% =
BBCProfit
Improvement = $47 MM
Breadland Profit Improvement = $104 MM
Shareholder Value
Breadland
13
Breadland Could Break Out of the Middle of the Pack by Increasing its ROE - Ke SpreadMarket Value vs. ROE - Ke
1990
ROE - Ke
MarketValue($MM)
Low ValueLow Returns
Medium ValueMedium Returns
High Value Medium Returns
Medium ValueHigh Returns
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40%
Hershey
Breadland
Borden
Sara LeeCampbellSoup
CPC International
Kellogg
Heinz
General Mills
Ralston
Shareholder Value
Breadland
14
Hot Cereals Contributed the Most to Breadland MarketValue
Breadland Market ValueShare Price 9/25/91 $58
Common Shares Outstanding x 76,537,000shares
Total Market Value $4,439 MM
Breadland Market ValueShare Price 9/25/91 $58
Common Shares Outstanding x 76,537,000shares
Total Market Value $4,439 MM
Hots$912 MM
RTE$609 MM
Wholesome$580 MM
Canada - $146 MM
Other BBC- ($143 MM)
Frozen - $139 MM
Food Service - $308 MM
Pet Foods - $337 MM
Golden Grain - $248 MM
Gatorade$762 MM
Van Camp - $112 MM
Pritiken & Other - $131 MM
Other
USGP$4,141 MM
North American BBC
$2,104 MM
GroceryServiceDivision
$1,767 MM
Shareholder Value
Breadland
15
Contents
• Breadland Performance versus Food Companies
• Breadland Performance versus RTE Companies
• Opportunities for Creating Additional Shareholder Value
• Appendix
Shareholder Value
Breadland
16
Appendix: Calculations
p.5 If Breadland attains Kellogg's MV/BV of 4.22, $71 million will be added to market value.
Increase in shareholder value = ( MV/BV) • (Breadland Book Value)
MV/BV = (Kellogg - Breadland)
= .07
Market Value = (.07) • Breadland Book Value
= (.07) • $1019 million
= $71 million
If Breadland attains Kellogg's P/E of 21, $410 million will be added to market value.
Increase in shareholder value = ( P/E) • (Breadland Book Value)
MV/BV = (Kellogg - Breadland)
= 2
Market Value = 2 • Breadland Earnings
= 2 • $205 million
= $410 million
Shareholder Value
Breadland
17
Appendix: Calculations (cont'd)
p.12
BBC Division Increase in Shareholder Value
BBC contribution to increase in shareholder value
= (BBC ATOI Improvement) • (1-tax rate) • Breadland PE
= ($47 MM) • (1-0.40) • 19
= $532 MM
Total Breadland Increase in Shareholder Value (Assumes 19.4% improvement in ATOI across all of Breadland
Total = (Breadland ATOI Improvement) • (1-tax rate) • Breadland PE
= ($104 MM) • (1-0.40) • 19
= $1,197 MM
1
1. From Business Case
Note: $47 MM improvement in profit for BBC => 19.4 %
For total Breadland this implies 19.4% • 533 MM = $104 MM.
$47 MM
$242 MM