private health sector for quality health care private health sector trusted partner in the delivery...

PRIVATE HEALTH SECTOR FOR QUALITY HEALTH CARE

PRIVATE HEALTH SECTOR

Trusted Partner in the delivery of Quality Healthcare

Dr. Samwel OgilloProgram Manager

Association of Private Health Facilities in TanzaniaAPHFTA

1

APHFTA- Association of Private health Facilities in Tanzania

Established in 1994 Advocacy and Private Health

Sector Development 500+ member facilities- All

types of health service delivery

Secretariat- Headquarters and 3 zonal offices

0ver 35 full time employed full time professional staff

Projects: HIV/AIDS, NCD, FP, QI, Finance/Loans others

Partner with MoHSW and DPs

2

Why include the private sector?:

1. Provides about 50% of basic health care in Africa

- There is now convincing evidence that the private health sector provides more than 50% of basic health care in many African countries

- The role of licensed drug store as a first point of care in many African countries is usually underestimated

Role of the Private Sector

Urban and rural population receiving care from private for-profit provider of modern medicine

Percent*64

53

45 4439

2621

1712

62

45

51

67

61

48 48

21

45

34

116 7

46

Nig

eria

Ug

and

a

Ken

ya

Eth

iop

ia

Gh

ana

Cam

ero

on

Mad

agas

car

Sie

rra

Leo

ne

Gam

bia

Mo

zam

biq

ue

Bu

rkin

a F

aso Average for

11 available SSA

countries

Survey between 1995-2006

Source: WB Africa Development Indications 2006, team analysis

Why include the private sector?:

2. Many poor in the community access services from the Private facilities (WB & IFC study 2005)

3. Public health sector finances less than half of total health expenditure. Most is financed from out-of-pocket (WB & IFC study 2005)

Most recent survey year available between 1995-2006

Source: WB Africa Development Indications 2006, team analysis

Percent lowest quintile receiving care from private for-profit provider

Why include the private sector?:

4. The private sector already provides a significant amount of public health services

- Most services are provided for free, though some authorities reluctant to go into any formal arrangement/ contract

- Governments, NGOs are willing to join hands with Private Sector to serve better

4. The private health sector already plays an important role in the delivery of public health goods (The Dar Example)

# PUBLIC AND PRIVATE HEALTH FACILITIES IN DAR- Free Public Services in 2007 (Source - DMO’s office)

DISTRICT VACCINATION/ MNCH

TB & Leprosy HIV/AIDS SERVICES

Public Private Public Private Public Private

TEMEKE 29 54 3 3 29 9

ILALA 21 34 18 8 22 19

KINONDONI 33 50 27 16 25 15

83 (38%)

138 (62%)

48(64%)

27 (36%)

76 (64%)

43 (36%)

Why include the private sector?:

5. “The Private Health Sector can have a positive impact on the quality of care- and in many notable cases it is setting the benchmark for higher quality”- in a number of developing countries- IFC study- 2007

- Modern Medical Technology- CT Scans, MRI, Heart Surgery, Advanced Surgery etc

- HIV/AIDS- ARVs first delivered by private health sector

- No question about high quality of care by private facilities compared to public in many countries

9

Barriers to achieving more

1. Lack of access to credit Lack of access to affordable Financing

(Results in High Interest Rates by financial institutions)

Situation worsened by Lack of policies that encourage investment in rural and sub-urban areas (No special incentives that encourage investing in such areas, e.g. tax relief)

11

Barriers to achieving more

2. Unnecessary competition with NGOs and public sector Lack of planning means that public, private

and NGO end up competing for the same clients, while in other areas there are no providers at all

Situation worsened by DP money

12

Barriers to achieving more

3- Cumbersome registration procedures for facilities and products

- While other businesses take less than two weeks to register, medical facilities and products take up to a year to register in many cases

- Corruption cause of delay in many cases

Barriers to achieving more

4. Unnecessary barriers to accessing funds to which they are entitled – e.g. National Health Insurance Funds

- In many countries, public facilities automatically benefit from NHI funds, while private facilities have to do more than required to get registered with the fund

- Chocked again by poor terms/low prices

13

Barriers to achieving more

5. Double Standards: - Unrealistic quality standards that

are unattainable in resource-poor settings

- Not applied to public facilities - Used in some cases to “chock the

private sector out of business”

14

There is light at the end of the tunnel

Positive changes noted Policies in favor of PPPs Social Insurance schemes- are ready to

work with private sector to serve the poor Governments, NGOs, DPs- include Private

Sector in their strategies towards improving healthcare delivery

Non-Healthcare private sector playing big role- FP, Diseases control

15

16

What would make things better for the Private Health Sector?

Clear policies and guidelines that support private health sector investment in health, supported with legislative powers (Laws)

PPP in healthcare: Contracting out of services to private health sector

Provision of incentive packages to encourage investment in healthcare delivery, especially underserved areas

Use of same yardstick in the enforcement of regulations related to health care provision

Proper utilization of available resources in healthcare provision in both the private and public sector

Thank you for listening