potential use of north dakota sand and clay for natural ... and clay for natural and manufactured...

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

##

#

##

! !

!

!

! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!!

!

!

!!

!

!!!

!!

!

!!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!

!

!

!!

!!

!!!

!!

!!

!!!

!!

!

!

!!

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!!!

!

Fargo

Minot

Bismarck

Parshall

Jamestown

Dickinson

Williston

Bottineau

ValleyCity

GrandForks

Mandan

DevilsLake

Rugby

Bowman

Ward

Dunn

Cass

McLeanMcKenzie

Grant

Morton

Williams

Stark

Stutsman

Wells

McHenry

Kidder

Barnes

Slope

Walsh

Mountrail

Burleigh

Sioux

Benson

Traill

Emmons

Pierce

Dickey

Richland

Billings

Logan

Mercer

Ramsey

Nelson

AdamsBowman

Eddy

Oliver

Hettinger

LaMoure

GrandForks

SteeleSheridan

McIntosh

Sargent

Griggs

Ransom

Foster

GoldenValley

Divide BurkeCavalier

Bottineau

Towner

RolettePembina

Renville

(/85

(/85

(/2

(/2

(/52

(/52

(/83

(/83

(/2

(/52

(/83

§̈¦29

§̈¦29

§̈¦94

§̈¦94

§̈¦94

JANUARY 2011 7

Potential Use of North Dakota Sand and Clay for Natural and

Manufactured ProppantsFred J. Anderson

The overwhelming success of the Bakken/Three Forks oil playinNorthDakota can be greatly, if notwholly, attributed to theadvancesinhydraulicfracturingof“tight”reservoirrock.Aspartofthehydraulicfracturingprocess,proppants(commonlynaturalsandsandmanufacturedceramicspheres)areusedtokeepthefracturesthatarecreatedopenfortheenhancedflowofoilandgas from the fractures into the wellbore. A typical hydraulicfracturing stimulation operation in the Bakken inNorthDakotarequires anywhere from100 to 500 tonsof proppantperwell:roughly150tonsonaverage.TheNorthDakotaGeologicalSurveyhasbeeninvestigatingNorthDakota’ssandandclayresourcesinan effort to better characterize deposits that could potentiallybeusedasproppants. Specifically,weareattemptingto locateuseable deposits of sand (and potentially clays) for hydraulicfracturingandotherindustrialsandapplicationsintheWillistonBasin.

Sand (and gravel) is widespread throughout North Dakota,althoughmost is in the glaciated part of the state,where it is

found inglaciolacustrinebeachdeposits,glaciofluvial (outwash)andmodern stream deposits, and early tomid-Holocene dunefields. Most of the sand and gravel currently mined in NorthDakotaisusedinconstructionandroadbuilding.

Syntheticproppantsaremanufacturedfromavarietyofmaterialsand includealuminosilicateceramicsderived fromthesinteringofbauxite(aluminumoxide)andkaolinite.Aspartofourstudy,therefore,wearealsolookingatsomeofNorthDakota’skaoliniticclaysaspotential rawmaterials for themanufactureofceramicproppants.

ProgressofInvestigationOver 100 sand locations were sampled from across the statefor this study (fig. 1). We have identified the leading sanddepositsbasedupongrainsize,sorting,androundness.Detailedsedimentological and engineering analyses are planned for thebestcandidatesands.

Figure1.ThesandandgravelresourcesofNorthDakota(yellow)andlocationsofsandsamples(browndots)collectedforpossibleuseasproppantsforthehydraulicfracturingofoilwellsintheBakkenandThreeForksplaysintheWillistonBasin(modifiedfromAnderson,inpress).

8 GEO NEWS

MembersofNorthDakota’ssandandgravel-producingindustryarealsoparticipatinginthisevaluation,andseveral producers have submitted sand samplesfor consideration. The results of this study will becommunicatedtoindustrythroughpublicationoftheinvestigationresultsin2011.

We are also characterizing these samples for use in otherindustrial sandapplications includingwell completionmaterials(filter&gravelpacks),filtermedia, and foundrypractices. Theproduction of industrial sands as viable economic depositsgenerally requiresmaterials thatareusuallymoreconsistent incharacter, are available closer to the land surface, and requireminimal processing (screening and washing). Having a betterunderstandingofsomeofthecharacteristicsofourstate’ssandand clay resources is advantageous to both industry and thepeopleofNorthDakota.

ProppantCharacteristicsProppantsarecharacterizedbywhattheyare;thatis,theirphysicalproperties,andhowtheyperform(inbulk)withinthefracturedoil&gasreservoir; inotherwords, theirabilitytoenhanceandfacilitateflow(permeability)inaproppedfracture.Permeabilitymaybethoughtofastherate(distanceperunittime)atwhichafluid(oil,gas,water)canmovethroughaparticularsedimentorrock.Itiscommonlymeasuredincm/sec,feet/dayorthedarcy,after French engineer Henry Darcy, whose pioneering work onfluidflowledtothediscoveryofthelawthatisnamedafterhim(Darcy,1856).Texturallymaturesedimentsgenerallyhavehigherpermeabilities(fig.2)thanlesstexturallymaturesediments.Asa relevant everydayexamplehere inNorthDakota, theBakkenFormationexhibitspermeabilitiesinthemicro(10-6)darcyrange(Nordeng, oral commun., 2010). By comparison, oil and gasreservoirsworldwide typicallyhavepermeabilities ranging from5to500millidarcies(Selley,1998). Theonlywaytoliberateoilandgas froma “tight” reservoir like theBakken isbyhydraulicfracturing(fig.3).

Geologic factors such as reservoir depths, temperatures, andpressuresall relatetoaproppant’sability towithstandfractureclosurewithinthereservoir.Theclosurestrengthistheamountofstrainthatcanbetakenupbytheproppantbefore it failstokeep the induced fractures open during production from thereservoir. Whennaturalproppantsfail,particularitywhenusedin the Bakken Formation, individual sand grains may actuallyfracture under the high stresses and temperatures within theformation/reservoir (Vincent, 2010a& 2010b). These kinds ofgeologic factors are critically important to understand whendesigning fracingoperationswhere significant reservoirdepths,temperatures,andclosurestressesareanticipated.

Figure3.Schematicofanopen“propped”rockfracturewithproppantplacedwithintheapertureofthefracture.Proppantsthataremoreconsistentandwell-roundedasin(a),allowforgreaterinterconnectedporespaceandfacilitatealargeramountof flow (higher permeability) of oil and gas out of the reservoir rock and into thefracture(s) andwellbore. Proppants that are less consistent and have poor shapefactorsasin(b),(higherdegreesofangularity)tendtopackbetterbutresultinlessinterconnectedporespaceandlowerpermeabilities,whichresultsinlessflowofoilandgasintoandthroughthefracture.

Figure 2. Generalized relationships between grainsize and conductivity (permeability) of a sediment(modifiedfromShepherd,1989).

Figure 4. Outcrop of the St. Peter Sandstone near Ottawa,Illinois.Thehigherdegreesofsortingandmineralogicalmaturityof these Ordovician-age white “Ottawa” deposits allow fortheireconomicalproductionforuseasproppantsandinotherindustrialapplications.

JANUARY 2011 9

NaturalProppantsMostnaturalsandproppantsaresourcedastwotypes:“white”and“brown.”“White”orOttawasands(referringtotheirprimarysourceareaaroundOttawa,Illinois)(fig.4)areminedinpartsoftheupperMidwest fromquartz-richCambro-Ordoviciansandstonesthatarecharacterizedbytheirexceptionallyhighdegreesofpurityand textural maturity. These sands were originally depositedin a shallow marine environment where geologic factors suchas weathering, erosion, and repeated refinement in the surfzone have resulted in texturally mature sandstones that arecomposedalmostentirelyofquartz.“Brown”orBradysandsarefoundindepositslocatedinTexas.Becausetheyaresomewhatmineralogically and texturally less mature than Ottawa sands,Bradysandsarewashedduringprocessingtoremoveimpuritiessuchasclaysandfeldspars.Naturalsandproppants(figs.5aandb)areusedmainlyinshallowoperationswherefractureclosurestressesinthereservoirrockarerelativelylow.

BecauseNorthDakota’ssanddepositsaresogeologicallyyoung,theyaremuch lessmature,bothmineralogicallyand texturally,meaning that they consist of compositionallymore varied, lessrounded, less well sorted grains than most sands commonlyusedinhydraulicfracturing.Potentialproppantsandswillmostlikelybefoundinthebetter-sorteddeposits,whichtendtobeofwindblownorigin,liketheDenbighorPembinaDunes(figs.5cand6);orfluvialsedimentswheregeologicprocesseshaveselectivelyremoved someof the coarser and finer grained sediments (forexample,asandbar).

SyntheticorManufacturedProppantsSynthetic, ormanufacturedproppants aredesigned toperformunder specific reservoir conditions (high pressures andtemperatures coupled with high fracture closure stresses) andcanbeengineeredtoperformmorefavorablyinhostilereservoirconditions than natural proppants. Specialty aluminosilicateceramics, made from sintered blends of bauxite and kaoliniticclays, are one example (fig. 7). Several North Dakota clays,includingthosefromtheBearDenMemberoftheGoldenValleyFormation are being evaluated as potential candidates for themanufacture of these types of ceramic proppants. The BearDenMemberof theGoldenValleyFormation isamulti-coloredkaoliniticclaystonethatoutcropsinseverallocalitiesthroughoutDunn,Mercer,Morton,Mountrail,andStarkCountiesinwesternNorth Dakota (fig. 8). The Bear Den Member has been usedfor decades in the manufacture of bricks by the Hebron BrickCompany(Murphy,2009).

Oneofthekeydriversinproppantselectionanduseiscost.Naturalproppants,when appropriate and available, arguably provide amorecost-effectivesolutionthanacustom-designedandshippedsyntheticormanufacturedproppant.However,sincetheremay

Figure5.Photomicrographsof(a)anout-of-stateproppantsandcurrentlyinuseintheWillistonBasin,(b)aNorthDakotasandprocessedforuseasaproppant,and(c)dunesandfromPembinaCounty.Allimagesareat40xmagnification.

Figure6.SanddunefromthePembinaDunesinnortheasternNorthDakota. Small-scalewind ripples are visible on the exposeddunesurface,indicativeofrecentwindactivity.

Figure 7. Photomicrograph of sintered bauxite ceramic proppantspheresusedinthehydraulicfracturingofoilreservoirs.Theuniformityof individual particle shapes combinedwithhighermaterial strengths,specific gravities, and thermogenic resistance have resulted in theextensive use of ceramic proppants (including this one) in Bakkenreservoir-relatedhydraulicfracturingandrefracturingapplications.

(a) (b) (c)

10 GEO NEWS

beabitmorevariability inthecharacterofanaturalproppant,itmayprovedifficulttopredictexpectedwellperformancefromfractofrac,orwithinmultiplefracsinagivenwell.

DevelopmentofProppantsinNorthDakotaWhetherornotaparticulardepositofsandorclaycanbeutilizedasasourceforproppants,dependsonseveraladditionalfactors,includingtheproximityofdepositsto locationswherehydraulicfracturingistakingplace,andthedegreeofnaturalbeneficiationin the deposit; that is, howmany natural cycles of refinementthedeposithasbeenexposedtoovertime.Forexample,ifthedepositistexturallyandmineralogicallymature,therewillbelessprocessing required to produce a given amount of marketablematerial(fig.9).Thisalsoplaysintocosts,asthelesseffortoneneedstoput intotherefiningof thedeposit, the lessmoney isspentbringing thematerial“uptospec”anddowntheroadtomarket. One current market-related aspect that is interesting(andtimely)isthefactthat,acrossthenation,theavailabilityofproppantsands fromtheirprincipalsourceareasappears tobedecliningasdevelopinggasplaysintheeasternU.S.increasetheirdemand.Inaddition,ceramicproppantswillmostlikelycontinuetobe imported into theWillistonBasin fromoverseasmarkets,asmoreanddeeperoilandgasdevelopmentoccursacrossthenation(Besler,oralcommun.,2010).

Since most, if not all, of the currently available natural sandresources are being shipped east for the stimulationof oil andgas reservoirs in Appalachia (especially the Marcellus Shale inPennsylvaniaandNewYork),operatorsintheWillistonBasinmaybewillingtotakewhatismostreadilyavailableandeconomicalas a bit of a frac-design/well production trade-off. Some havesuggestedthatoverallproductionfromBakkenwellsstimulatedwithceramicproppantsmaybeasgreatas30%higherthanthosestimulatedwithnatural(sands)proppants.

Overall, North Dakota’s sand, and possibly clay resources, arelocally abundant, readily available, and contain a sufficientvarietyofmineralogicalcharactertoallowforadiversearrayofpotentialindustrialapplications.Creativityinenduse,facilitated

by producers in industry, will drive the development of NorthDakota’ssandandclayresources. Withanestimatedneedof3million ormore tons* of proppants (around a couple of billiondollars at today’s prices!) to support full development of theBakken,gainingabetterunderstandingofourpossibilitiesfortheproduction of natural and manufactured proppants is prudentandbeneficialforallofNorthDakota.

ReferencesAnderson, F.J., in press, Locations of Sand and Gravel Sites in North

Dakota, North Dakota Geological Survey, Geologic InvestigationsNo.130,1:500,000scalemap.

Babcock, E.J., 1906, The uses and value of North Dakota clays, in theFourthBiennialReportoftheNorthDakotaGeologicalSurvey,

p.191-244.Darcy,H.,1856,LesfontainespubliquesdelavilledeDijon.Paris.,reviewed

inSimmons,C.T.,2008,HenryDarcy(1803-1858):Immortalizedbyhisscientificlegacy,HydrogeologyJournal,v.16,p.1023-1038.

Hansen,M.,1959,ClaysofNorthDakotaasapotentialsourceofalumina:NorthDakotaGeologicalSurveyReportofInvestigation,no.33,

15p.Manz,O.E.,1953,InvestigationofsomeNorthDakotaclaysandshales:

NorthDakotaGeologicalSurveyReportofInvestigation,no.13, 36p.Murphy, E.C., 1995, North Dakota clays, a historical review of clay

utilization in North Dakota: North Dakota Geological SurveyMiscellaneousSeries,no.79,18p.

Murphy, E.C., 2009, The Golden Valley Formation: North DakotaDepartmentofMineralResourcesNewsletter,v.36,no.2,p.1-4.

Selley,R.C.,1998,ElementsofPetroleumGeology(2nded.):SanDiego,CA,AcademicPress,470p.

Shepherd,R.G.,1989,CorrelationsofPermeabilityandGrainSize:GroundWater,v.27,no.5,p.633-638.

Vincent,M.,2010a, ImprovedProduction fromHorizontalWells in theBakken:2010NewHorizonsinOil&GasConference,SouthDakotaSchoolofMines&Technology,RapidCity,SD,Abstract.

Vincent, M., 2010b, A Study of 75 Refracs Performed in the middleBakken:2010NewHorizonsinOil&GasConference,SouthDakotaSchoolofMines&Technology,RapidCity,SD,Abstract.

Figure8.OutcropofthecolorfulBearDenMemberoftheGoldenValleyFormation in Dunn County. The Bear DenMember is found in severalareasintheheartoftheNDportionoftheWillistonBasinandisknowntocontainintervalsrichinkaolinite(Murphy,2009).

Figure9. Asandandgravelprocessingoperation innorthernBurleighCounty. This plant produces materials for a number of industrialapplicationsinNorthDakota.

*Roughly60millioncubicyardsorthevolumetricequivalentoffillingthetoweroftheNorthDakotastatecapitoltwenty-sixtimes!