new euro 6 legislation on rde: overview and technical ... · new euro 6 legislation on rde:...

Post on 07-Jul-2018

217 Views

Category:

Documents

0 Downloads

Preview:

Click to see full reader

TRANSCRIPT

New Euro 6 Legislation on RDE: Overview and Technical Challenges

Theodoros G. Vlachos, Pierre Bonnel, Martin Weiss, Barouch Giechaskiel, Francesco Riccobono

European Commission - Joint Research Centre (JRC)IET - Institute for Energy and Transport

1AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Overview

2

• RDE-LDV general principles

• RDE-LDV boundary conditions

• RDE-LDV technical elements Testing protocol Testing instrumentation Ex-post evaluation

• RDE-LDV PEMS-PN

• RemarksAECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Overview

3

• RDE-LDV general principles

• RDE-LDV boundary conditions

• RDE-LDV technical elements Testing protocol Testing instrumentation Ex-post evaluation

• RDE-LDV PEMS-PN

• RemarksAECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

RDE-LDV general principles

4AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Test vehicles on the road

• Use accurate and advanced portable instruments

• Ex-ante trip selection urban, rural, motorway shares and their sequence road profile requirements for urban driving (idling)…

• Ex-post data evaluation check of dynamic conditions by composite indicators

• Moving Averaging Window (MAW) method => CO2

• Power Binning (PB) method => power at the wheels

check of vehicle dynamics (additional indicators)

Overview

5

• RDE-LDV general principles

• RDE-LDV boundary conditions

• RDE-LDV technical elements Testing protocol Testing instrumentation Ex-post evaluation

• RDE-LDV PEMS-PN

• RemarksAECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

RDE-LDV boundary conditions

6

• Ranges for all parameters (altitude, Tamb, dynamics...)

AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

RDE-LDV boundary conditions

7

• Ranges for all parameters (altitude, Tamb, dynamics...)

• A single RDE test does not cover all the possible situations

• RDE limits shall be met for any parameters combination

• Risk with ex-post data evaluation invalidation of tests (insufficient coverage...)

• Wider ranges improve the practicality increased ability to realize a valid RDE trip

AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Overview

8

• RDE-LDV general principles

• RDE-LDV boundary conditions

• RDE-LDV technical elements Testing protocol Testing instrumentation Ex-post evaluation

• RDE-LDV PEMS-PN

• RemarksAECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Testing protocol

9AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Trip selection and operational requirements

• PEMS installation

• Specifications of PEMS equipment

• Pre-tests and post-tests PEMS calibration

Overview

10

• RDE-LDV general principles

• RDE-LDV boundary conditions

• RDE-LDV technical elements Testing protocol Testing instrumentation Ex-post evaluation

• RDE-LDV PEMS-PN

• RemarksAECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Testing Equipment

11AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Measurement performance

• Safety

• Size and installation

Testing Equipment

12AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Comparison of PEMS equipment mass

Significant decrease of mass for new PEMS generation

Overview

13

• RDE-LDV general principles

• RDE-LDV boundary conditions

• RDE-LDV technical elements Testing protocol Testing instrumentation Ex-post evaluation

• RDE-LDV PEMS-PN

• RemarksAECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Ex-post evaluation

14AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• MAW method CO2 to check driving dynamics vs. reference WLTP CO2 values

• Power binning method Pwheels to check driving dynamics vs. reference Pdistribution

Ex-post evaluation

15AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• MAW method

CO2 can be used as trip severity indicator

Ex-post evaluation

16AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Complement the verification of vehicle dynamics

Additional vehicle dynamics indicators (under discussion)

Overview

17

• RDE-LDV general principles

• RDE-LDV boundary conditions

• RDE-LDV technical elements Testing protocol Testing instrumentation Ex-post evaluation

• RDE-LDV PEMS-PN

• RemarksAECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

PEMS-PN: Project Overview

18

• Phase I (2012) – Feasibility study application & performance of PEMS-PN vs PN reference (PMP)

• Intermediate step – Update of specifications Volatile Particle Remover (VPR) efficiency of diffusion chargers (DC)

• Phase II (2014) confirmation of Phase I calibration procedures more accurate estimation of uncertainty

• Finalization of PEMS-PN technical specifications next steps under discussion

AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

PEMS-PN: Phase I

19AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Results

Diffusion charger based systems: good linearity with PMP

PEMS-PN: Phase I

20AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Results

Volatile Particles Removers (VPR) recommended

21AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

PEMS-PN: Phase II, Topics

21

• Calibration in the laboratory• Comparison with PMP systems• Dependency on particle size• Regeneration• Volatile removal efficiency (moped 2-stroke)• Ambient temperature effect• Calibration at the CVS• Bias and precision• PASS or FAIL success rate• Challenge aerosol (solid sub 23 nm)

PEMS-PN: Calibration

22AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• PMP

Significant errors for particles <30nm

PEMS-PN: Calibration

23AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Diffusion Charger

Increasing response with increasing particles size

Overview

24

• RDE-LDV general principles

• RDE-LDV boundary conditions

• RDE-LDV technical elements Testing protocol Testing instrumentation Ex-post evaluation

• RDE-LDV PEMS-PN

• RemarksAECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

25AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Remarks

25

• RDE-LDV trade-offEx-ante

Boundary testing conditions ranges &

testing requirements

=>Impacts on testing representativeness

Ex-postCheck of dynamic

conditions & vehicle dynamics

=>Impacts on vehicle

performance judgement

Remarks

26AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• PEMS-PN preliminary results diffusion charging seems a promising alternative to CPCs DCs, if adopted, will require more attention during

• calibration (low levels)• instantaneous particles emissions

Acknowledgments

27AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

We thank the participants of the RDE working group and theRDE data evaluation task force for their contribution to thedevelopment of the data evaluation methods. The staff ofthe Vehicle Emissions Laboratory (VELA) of the Jointresearch Centre (JRC): Andrea Bonamin, Mauro Cadario,Massimo Carriero, Rinaldo Colombo, Fausto Forni, GastonLanappe, Philippe Le Lijour, Dominique Lesueur, FrancoisMontigny, Marcos Otura Garcia and Mirco Sculati, isacknowledged for executing the vehicle emissions testing onthe road and in the laboratory.

Contacts

28AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Light-Duty Vehicles: Martin Weiss: martin.weiss@jrc.ec.europa.eu Pierre Bonnel: pierre.bonnel@jrc.ec.europa.eu Theodoros G. Vlachos: theodoros.vlachos@jrc.ec.europa.eu

• PEMS-PN: Barouch Giechaskiel: barouch.giechaskiel@jrc.ec.europa.eu Francesco Riccobono: franscesco.riccobono@jrc.ec.europa.eu

• Heavy-Duty Vehicles & Non-Road Mobile Machinery: Adolfo Perujo: adolfo.perujo@jrc.ec.europa.eu Pablo Mendoza: pablo.mendoza-villafuerte@jrc.ec.europa.eu

New Euro 6 Legislation on RDE: Overview and Technical Challenges

Theodoros G. Vlachos, Pierre Bonnel, Martin Weiss, Barouch Giechaskiel, Francesco Riccobono

European Commission - Joint Research Centre (JRC)IET - Institute for Energy and Transport

29AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

30AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Towards RDE: RCG vs. PEMS

31AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Moving Averaging Windows

32AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Reference of dynamic conditions

33AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Urban: ̅ 45 /

• Rural: 45 / ̅ 80 /

• Motorway: ̅ 80 /

Urban/Rural/Motorway MAWs

34AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Urban: 1017 5209⁄ · 100 19.53

• Rural:2477 5209⁄ · 100 47.55

• Motorway: 1715 5209⁄ · 100 32.92

Trip Completeness

35AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Primary Tolerance: 25%

• Secondary Tolerance: 50%

Trip Normality

36AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Urban: 1017 1017⁄ · 100 100

• Rural:1759 2477⁄ · 100 71.01

• Motorway: 1222 1715⁄ · 100 71.25

Trip Normality

37AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Weighing function

38AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

PEMS-PN: Difference from PMP

• ±60% variation respect to PMP compliant system

39AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

• Good linearity with PMP compliant system

PEMS-PN: Phase II vs. Phase I

40AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Phase II: Calibration, PMP

• Counting efficiency depends on efficiencies of VPR and PNC

41AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Phase II: Calibration, DC

• Current ∝ (particles number*particle average charge)

42AECC RDE Technical SeminarBrussels, Belgium, April 2015

Phase II: Calibration, DC vs PMP

• Calibrated at 100nm monodisperse => 75nm polydisperse

Expected range of GMDs

top related