machinery softfoot causes characteristics and solutions
Post on 02-Jun-2018
217 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
1/27
Copyright 2
I. DefiniII. EffectIII. CausIV. MeasV. BehaVI. AnalyVII. ComVIII. Concl
I. Defini
Soft Fmachine ffoot. Asbehaviorsprobable
II. Effect
The efa soft foo
bearing halignmentmachinebetween trotating cvibration fof seals, punplanne
The inmachine fshaft and
result froinverselydoublingoperatingas a form
014 by LUDEC
tion of Softs .....................s ....................ring Soft Fioral Charazing and Colex Soft Feeusion ............
ion of So
oot is a game or casiuch, a softof the macause, which
s of Soft
ects of a socondition i
usings defwith each
haft that ihe two coumponents
rom the miacking, anddowntime
ternal misalame also imust act di
this actiroportionalhe radial lconditions)la:
E x
, INC. www.lu
Cause
Foot .............................................................ot ..................teristics ofrrecting a St and Multi........................
ft Foot
neric termng to distorfoot condiine casingin turn ma
Foot
ft foot conds anchored
lects the shother. Thiscoupled t
pled shaftsof the macalignmentother non-
and higher
ignment ofcreases therectly upon
n drasticallto the ratiad on a bby eight tim
e c t e d B e a
eca.com
SO, Charac
By Al
.......................
.......................
.......................
.......................oft Foot (Fft Foot Cole-Footed.......................
hat represet upon tightion can has it distortsuggest th
ition are nutightly to it
aft internallshaft dist it. The r
produces eines, suchf the cente
rotating eleepair costs
the bearinradial loadit to deflec
reduce bof the desill bearing res. Tripling
r i n g L i f e =
FT FOOTeristics, a
n Luedeki
........................
........................
........................
........................ur Footeddition ...........achines ......
........................
nts machinening (or love many
s. A given blikeliest so
erous, anfoundatio
as the bertion chansulting miscessive vibs the coupllines of rotments of thare the con
bores reson the beaor distort
aring life.gn load toeduces its lthe load re
ormula 1
D e s ig n LA c t u a l L o
nd Soluti
g
........................
........................
........................
........................achines).....
........................
........................
........................
frame disosening) aifferent caehavior calution to th
all are har, the resulti
aring boreses its posi
alignmentration thating, bearintion resultse machine.equences.
ulting fromings, since ithe shaft. T
The life exactual radiaife expectauces it by 2
a da d
( B 1 0
3
ons
........................
........................
........................
........................
........................
........................
........................
........................
ortion. Anytold-downses, whichbe analyzeproblem.
ful. Whenng distortio
of the maction in relaf the cent
causes pres, and rotoin prematuCatastrophi
a soft foot is the beare increase
ectancy ofl load, cubecy (under
7 times! Thi
o u rs L i f e )
Pag
.......................
.......................
.......................
.......................
.......................
.......................
.......................
.......................
hing that colt is calleproduce did to deter
machine tn of its casi
hine movetion to theerlines of rature wear
rs. In additire wear and
machine f
distortionings that caradial forc
a ball bead. This meatherwise idcan be ex
e 1 of 27
........... 1
........... 1
........... 2
........... 3
........... 7
........... 9
........ 23
........ 26
uses aa soft
fferentine its
at hasg and
out ofothertationin then, thefailure
ailures,
of therry thees that
ring isns thatenticalressed
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
2/27Copyright 2
B10 Hof identicnormal co
In addhousings
This douter racethe first pl
As theelastic defmagnitudback andthat the uof the sha
This bhalf a revdeflectedhours). Evafter numaction ind
014 by LUDEC
urs Life is tl bearings
nditions ma
ition to incrlso distorts
istortion isof a ball-
ace, free fro
shaft turns,lection in tof the deforth cyclicarestrainedt.
nding actiolution. Thuyclically 5,1ntually, str
erous priorces.
Fig.
, INC. www.lu
he bearingat maximutypically b
asing radiathe bearing
often evider roller bea
m unintend
it must alwe structure
lection thatlly, every 1haft would
n occurs in, a machine84,000 timectural fatigbearing an
ig. 1
2
eca.com
anufacture design loexpected
l load on ths themselve
ced by diaring. This pd preloads.
ays conforof the shafexists whe0 of rotatitake if the
ll directionthat spinss a day! (2 tue may res seal failur
rs given mad and spo be betwe
bearing, as. See Figur
metrically oesupposes
to the patinduced bat rest. Asn. Figure 2eflection in
at twice tht 1800 RP
imes everylt in an unes have oc
nimum lifeed conditi
en three to
soft foot-c1.
pposed wethat the be
hway of thethe soft fit turns, thbelow shoit were a p
e speed of rand runsevolution xpected brurred due
xpectancyns. Actualive times th
used distor
ar zones oring was p
bearing boot is amplishaft is bes this, by ilrmanent be
otation, sinontinuousl1800 RPMeak of the sto the vibr
Pag
or a groupbearing lifee B10 Hour
ion of the
the insideoperly inst
res. Thereffied to douing fully delustrating tnd in the st
e it reversewill have i 60 minuthaft, perhation this b
e 2 of 27
of 90%underLife.
earing
of thelled in
re, thele the
flectede pathucture
s everys shafts 24s only
ending
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
3/27Copyright 2014 by LUDECA, INC. www.ludeca.com Page 3 of 27
III. Causes of Soft Foot
A soft foot can be caused by many different things. Missing shims under one or more feet maycause the machine frame to distort as the hold-down bolts are tightened. Too many shims under afoot may create a high spot on the base that also produces distortion. Bent feet or angled supportpads under the feet will distort the machine frame as its feet are tightened down. Similarly, on avertical flange-mounted machine, a non-planar contact between the machine flange and itssupport surface will produce distortion.
An externally induced machine frame distortion may occur if pipe stress is present; this is alsoproperly considered a soft foot situation. Why? Improper pipefitting can exert enormous stresseson the machine frame, trying to pull, push, or twist the frame away from its intended position. If thehold down bolts were entirely absent, these pipe stresses might be great enough to lift themachine right off the base, or angle it with respect to its base. Therefore, as the hold down boltsare tightened to anchor the machine down, its frame is distorted, just the same as if there wereshims missing under a foot or the soleplate were angled with respect to the foot. Thus, pipe strainfalls under the family of causes that produce a soft foot situation, or machine frame distortion.
Incidentally, similar distortion may be created through thermal growth or dynamic positionalshifts of a running machine that is placed under operating loads. These are no longer consideredsoft foot since they are a product of the machines own dynamic behavior when in operation. As
such, they would instead be handled by means of special design accommodations to thefoundation, base or structure of the machine itself, and by alignment target specifications duringthe cold alignment procedure, and thus fall outside the scope of this discussion.
IV. Measuring Soft Foot
Proper measurement of the effects of soft foot involves discerning and quantifying the impacton shaft movement that results from loosening or tightening a hold down bolt. The carefulmeasurement and comparison of these movements from foot to foot can help us ascertain whythemachine is behaving the way it does, which in turn puts one well along the way to finding the rightsolution to the problem. The overall picture of how the machine frame behaves is important tounderstanding why it reacts as it does, each time an individual foot is loosened or tightened. To
obtain this picture, several careful steps must be taken, with a thorough understanding of themeasurement techniques and principles involved.
Usually, a soft foot condition can be corrected simply by shimming the correct machine foot orfeet by the correct amounts. Sometimes this even involves step shimming a foot*if the problem isan angled soleplate or bent foot, or may require actual remachining of the foot or support surface.On the other hand, eliminating an induced soft foot (i.e., pipe stress) (see Section V) simplyrequires removing the undue external forces that are acting on the machine frame.
The Measurement Procedure Considerations
In order to correctly diagnose (i.e., analyze and reach a conclusion as to correction) a soft foot
problem, it is necessary to understand why the machine behaves in the ways that it does, inreaction to soft foot stresses. It must be emphasized here that a soft foot condition means that amachine frame is strained (i.e., distorted) and therefore under constant stress when all of its feet arebolted down at the correct torque. Since most machines have four feet, and three points alwaysdefine a plane, fitting a fourth point into that plane will always require careful machining orshimming, as well as clean conditions. Fulfilling these requirements will usually take care of most
*For more information on step shimming see the article Best Practices: Machinery Alignment Shimmingby AlanLuedeking, under the Resources tab on the Ludeca website at: http://www.ludeca.com/res_articles_alignment.php
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
4/27Copyright 2014 by LUDECA, INC. www.ludeca.com Page 4 of 27
soft foot problems. To discover if a soft foot exists on a four-footed machine, one should onlyloosen one foot at a time, with the other three feet tight!*
The frame will always seek to relieve the stress within it, to the greatest extent possible,wherever it can. Thus, as you loosen each foot individually (always with the other three tight) thatfoot will move, relieving as much of the distortion within the machine frame as possible for itslocation. As the frame and bearing housings undistort, the internal alignment of the bearings willchange; therefore, the shaft contained within these bearings will also undeflect and move. Thismovement will result in a change in the alignment of this shaft with respect to the other shaft that
it is coupled to, and it is this change that we seek to accurately measure. When considered jointlywith the nature of the movement of the feet, this information is highly significant in helping todiagnose the cause, and by extension, the solution for the problem. Since a machine frame is astructure of complex shape and varying flexibility, it is more important to know how much the shafthas moved when a particular foot is loosened or tightened, than it is to know just how much thefoot itself moved. On a rigid frame with flimsy feet, you could see significant foot movement withvery little effect on overall frame and shaft distortion. In the opposite scenario, a weak machineframe with very sturdy feet might mean that even just a little foot movement represents significantmachine frame and shaft distortion. Therefore, relying on foot movement only to diagnose theproblem may not be entirely reliablein fact, it can be highly misleading. Thus, shaft movement isall important in diagnosing the situation. Let us delve a little deeper into why this is so: Keeping inmind that three points constitute a perfect plane, imagine now a rigid machine frame with four
feet, whose undersides are all perfectly machined into a plane. This frame with perfect feet restsupon a perfectly clean, glass-smooth base that is also perfectly flat. Now imagine that all four feetare torqued tight to this base. Now loosen just one of these feet. Obviously, under these perfectconditions, nothing should move when you loosen just that one foot, because any one of the fourfeet is in the plane of the other three. If, on the other hand, you loosen one foot and shaftmovement occurs, what can one conclude, beyond the shadow of a doubt? That machine framedistortion was present when all four feet were tight, for whatever reason(s) might be causing it.
Now let us examine a bit more closely the nature of the shaft movement that results fromrelieving stress within a frame by loosening a foot. Shaft movement from distortion relief can becharacterized as primarily angular in nature, since only one foot is being allowed to move, with theothers tight. Since the amount of offset at the coupling generated by this movement is dependent
on the distances involved (rise over run), it can be highly variable, depending on the geometry ofthe machine. Therefore, it is better to directly measure the angularity of this observed movementinstead. Laser systems which employ only the reverse indicator approach to measurement, or onlymeasure offset, are necessarily limited in their usefulness for measuring the effects of soft foot.Much better is a system that directly measures the angularity of the movement and then calculatesthe foot movement from that value.
The Soft Foot Function of the best laser alignment systems will detect the change in relativevertical angularity that occurs when a foot is loosened, and calculates the corresponding value offoot movement that would have been required to produce it. The values displayed by a RotalignUltra for instance, are calculated according to the following formula:
Soft Foot Reading = |2VA (FB)|
Formula 2
where VA is the change in the Vertical Angularity, and FB is the distance Front Foot to Back Footof the machine being checked. The result is always displayed as an absolute value.
Why is vertical angularity measured, and not horizontal? Given that the anchor bolts aretightened in the vertical direction, a machines movement resulting from the distortion its framemust always have a vertical component to it. A change in horizontal angularity may also occur, but
*If a machine has more than four supports, loosen all except the four nearest the rotor supports, and treat themachine as if it were an ordinary four-footed one, providing you are dealing with a compact, rigid frame.
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
5/27Copyright 2
its magnitto the acc
Sincepure macunder a mthat the cdirectly oand the i
quite natfoot may
Notethe Frontfoot on bon the shcomputerdoes notstart withcalculatedwas positi
This givestorque wrrepeatabl
Lastly,doubled ione footthe left paloosen onnothing, tbelow. Thmovemenboth frontalone mo
To finmay requiobtainedthe othereven or uuneven (nany), as thhint at a pgap of at l
014 by LUDEC
de and dirrate and c
he laser aliine foot machine footlculated valserved moherent flexi
ral to obtactually hav
lso that it isto Back Footh machineafts, so lonis the corratter whe
the foot loabsolute ve or negati
the laser sench and) tightenin
if you lookorder to c
t a time.Siir of feet aly the left fen it follo
us, the veras you loofeet or boted.
the correcre measure
ith feelerfeet tight. Teven, so as
ot parallel)is will greatrobable caeast two th
, INC. www.lu
ction are unsistent de
nment systvement pe
when you lue for softement at tbility of the
n a calculatmoved.
irrelevant tt dimensios without hg as youct one forher you takse and tiglue of the uve. In the s
ystems Sofroper lubriof the hold
at the formalculate thence in nord the rightoot and its that the stical angulen or tightback feet
shimmingent of theauge readie objective
to determiirgap is me
ly help youse. A signifiusandths o
eca.com
predictablection and
em measurr se, it is nosen it. Insoot at theat foot. Sinmachine fr
d value th
the systeis involvedving to swiake sure t
the machine your reaten it, sincndistorted fme vein, it
Foot Funccation of t-down bolt
ula again, ysoft foot real machinepair of feet
ere to riseaft in therity at then the foot ieen raised
olution foractual gapgs taken u
is to accure the shap
asured, it isto diagnosecant taperf an inch (0.
and possibeasureme
s the chant a pure gead, it is aachine foo
e the machme and be
t is slightly
which foo. This has tch the laserat the Frowhose fo
ings by stathe displaoot movemis immateri
tion greathe fastener.)
u will notiading. Thisframes the(as you loo ten mils,iddle betwshaft cent
s only half together by
Fig. 3
the soft fooalues thatnder the sotely measuor taper p
importantthe typeseans that
002") occur
ly inconsistt of a soft f
e in relativp meter fooft foot eft is just thaines movearing play a
different (
is loosenee advantagemitter annt to Backt you are
rting with ted value f
ent, regardll whether
ersatility fthreads ar
e that theis necessarshaft is localong thehile the rien them wirlines that
he value ththe same a
t problem rppear undft feet while this air gattern of tho know thef forces actconsistents from one
nt, and theoot proble
e shaft angthe air ga
ects meter.t: a calculat
ent is by dbsorb som
sually small
on eithere that you
receiver cFoot distanchecking. Fe foot tighr the soft f
ess of whetright or lef
r ease of ue a must f
easured vsince youted exactly
axis of theht foot is lll only riseis produc
t would haount that
quires addir the soft f these arep and detee air gap. Idirection oing on the fdifference icorner (or e
Pag
refore less s.
larity andthat mayhat this m
d value anefinition disof the stra
er) than wh
achine, sinay check f
mponentsce enteredrthermore,
t and looseoot readinger this mot foot is lo
se. (Incidenor a correc
rtical angulre only loohalf way bhafts), then,eft tight anmils. See Fid by a soe been obthe single s
tional analyet. These aloose, alwamine whetthe eventf taper or slrame, and tthe measge) of the
e 5 of 27
uitable
ot theappeareans is
not atorted,in, it is
at that
e onlyor softroundin theit also
n it, oris the
ementsened.
tally, at (and
arity isseningtweenif you
d risesgure 3ft footin hadft foot
sis andre bests wither it ishat anope (ifherebyred airfoot to
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
6/27Copyright 2014 by LUDECA, INC. www.ludeca.com Page 6 of 27
the opposite corner or edge. Always make a note of which way the air gap points, from highest tolowest. To do this, mike the air gap at the four corners of the soft foot itself, by measuring theseparation between the underside of the foot and the top of the shim pack which is already inplace. Again, it is imperative that this area be clean and the shims in excellent condition in order tobe able to do this accurately. You may omit miking the corner of the foot that is farthest inside themachine frame, if it is too difficult to reach, provided that the three outside corners of the foot canbe accurately miked. These three should be sufficient to establish the direction of taper, if any.
The procedure to measure soft foot follows, and applies only to four-footed machines, or those
rigid machines with more than four feet whose non-rotor-bearing feet have been preloosened soas to treat such a machine as if it were just a four-footed one. Machines whose frames are not rigidor more complex situations are treated in Section VII.
The Measurement Procedure Sequence of Steps
1) Thoroughly clean the area under and around the machine feet.
2) Rough-align the machines to remove any coupling strain. Even if uncoupled, you should stillrough align prior to beginning soft foot measurement procedures, since soft foot conditionsmay change if large moves are later made later in aligning the machines. Also eliminate anyobvious air gaps or gross soft foot conditions, using four or fewer (if possible) precut stainlesssteel shims.
3) Use your laser systems Soft Foot Function to obtain a soft foot reading at each foot of themachine. Remember to loosen only one foot at a time, always keeping the other three tight.Any reading greater than 0.002" is considered a soft foot. If your laser system does not recordthese values for you then record these values manually for later use.
4) After each measurement tighten that foot completely to the correct torque value and thenrepeat Step 3 for all four feet (if practical) to establish repeatability.
5) Once each foot has been loosened in turn and all soft foot readings recorded, see if any ofthem is greater than two mils (0.002"). If so, use feeler gauges or an inside micrometer tocarefully measure the air gap under the foot with the largest soft foot reading first. If necessary,mike the others also. (The determination of whether or not it is necessary to measure the airgap under the foot or feet with the second and/or third largest readings will be addressed laterin this paper, as we analyze different soft foot situations.)
6) Analyze the data obtained and diagnose the soft foot condition, and decide on a correctiveaction.
7) Correct the problem.
8) Recheck soft foot starting at Step 3 to make sure that the problem has indeed been eliminated.
9) Proceed with the final alignment of the machines, preserving any relative differentials inshimming under the feet while performing alignment corrections.
This general procedure applies to both (or all) machines in your machine train. Always find andcorrect soft foot on the stationary machine first, and then on any machines to be moved.
Remember, it is not necessary to switch your laser system components around on the shafts toobtain soft foot readings for the feet of the Stationary Machine, if you have a competent laseralignment system that allows you to set any pair of feet in the train to be stationary. (Just makesure all of your dimensions are entered correctly for the orientation of your actual setup.)
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
7/27Copyright 2
The Softlaser soft f
V. Beha
A soft
the shaftoverall piother canproblem.particular
Soft ffoot beha
Type 1TypeTypeType
Within(more spproblems.represent
Type 1:
Type 1a:
In thismachine ithis shortof the mawill rock.are both fdeform tsituationthis chairuntil all fsituationinternal mbearing pr
014 by LUDEC
Foot Diagraoot reading
ioral Cha
foot conditi
nd foot mocture whicbe used tll these m
soft foot co
ot behaviorioral patter
) Rocking) Angled s) Induced) Squishy
each of thcific behavFollowing,tive of thes
he Rockin
The Sho
situation, almissing sfoot and thine formhen all fo
orced to co accommos would occnd it no lour feet cor it will defisalignmenteloads, as p
, INC. www.lu
m shown bs and air ga
racteristi
on in a mac
ement thatemergesdiagnose
vements, tadition.
can be class can be re
oft footft footoft footoft foot
se types oior patternwe will pretypes.
g Soft Foo
t Foot Roc
so called a ims, or ise one locathigh ridger feet are titact the suate itself tur with a cnger rocks,tact the grrm to the eof the bea
reviously di
eca.com
elow in Figs that you
s of Soft
hine frame
it generaterom studyihe most likken togeth
sified accoradily identif
families of) that aresent variou
t
king Soft F
short foot rachined tod diagonal
, across whihtened doport surfac
o the newair that hasit is becausound. Thetent that iting bores,cussed.
re 4 is a haobtain.
Fig. 4
Foot (Fo
can be accu
s upon tighg these sh
ely causesr, represen
ding to its cied. These a
behaviorrepresentatis individual
ot
cker or pshort. Thi
ly across froch the shorn, the sho
e. Since theconfiguratione leg tothe struct
machine mcan, when tpoor seal c
ndy form f
r-footed
rately meas
ening or loaft and foo(and hencethe beha
auses. Fourre:
atterns, theve of partibehavior
rallel soft fwill causem it on thet foot and it foot and imachine frn of the fshort andre of the cst be pro
he anchorntact and
r recording
Machines
ured and a
sening a ht movementhe likeliesior pattern
basic types
re may exiscular soft fattern com
ot, one fothe machinother side.
ts diagonallts diagonallame is flexieet. This isocks. If a hair has deferly shimmolts are tigseal deform
Pag
and analyzi
)
alyzed in t
ld-down bts relative tsolutions)characteris
or families
t several suoot conditibinations t
t of a four-e to rock bhe other topposedopposed
le, it will bexactly thavy personlected anded to corrtened, resuations, and
e 7 of 27
ng the
rms of
lt. Theo eachto theic of a
of soft
btypesons orat are
footedtweeno feetartnerartnerw andsame
sits onwistedct thislting inundue
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
8/27Copyright 2014 by LUDECA, INC. www.ludeca.com Page 8 of 27
Type 1b: The Even Rocking Soft Foot
Here we have two short feet or shims missing evenly from two diagonally opposedfeet on afour-footed machine. In this situation, the machine will behave similarly to the case of the shortfoot rocker (Type 1a), in that it rocks between the two feet missing shims. Again, both short feetmust be shimmed up, or both high feet must have shims removed from them to correct theproblem. The first alternative is usually to be preferred over the other since it corrects the problemwithout affecting the existing shaft alignment of the machines. It is also very likely that shims maybe missing in unequal amounts from these diagonally opposed corners. This we might call an
uneven rocking soft foot. The diagnostic techniques and solutions remain the same, however. SeeSection VI for more detail on analyzing and correcting the problem.
Type 1c: The High Foot Rocking Soft Foot
Also called a high foot rocker, in this case, a machine with four feet has too many shims underone foot, or that foot is machined too long, or a bump or protrusion on the base upon which thatfoot rests is affecting it. Again the machine will rock, but this time between the two feet adjacent tothe high foot, which are diagonally opposed to each other. Here, either the high foot must havesome shims removed from it, or the other three feet can be shimmed up to make them parallelwith the high foot. However, an even better third alternative exists which will be discussed in thesection devoted to detailed analysis and corrections (Section VI). This excellent third alternative isrevealed by means of the Short Cut Method for rocking soft feet and will be discussed in detail at
the end of Section VI.
Type 2: The Angled Soft Foot
Type 2a: The Outside Angled Soft Foot
Sometimes called an outside bent foot soft foot, this situation presents one or more feet on amachine which are bent up to the outside, or mismachined on an angle with respect to the supportsurface, in such a way that only the inner edge or corner contacts the support surface when thefoot is unloaded and undistorted. Alternatively, the foot may be perfect, and instead it is the base,sole plate, or other support surface which is angled relative to the foot. In these cases, the angledcontact between the foot and its support surface will cause the both the foot and the machineframe to distort as this foots hold-down bolt is tightened and the foot is forced to deflect until it
fully contacts the support surface. Moreover, tightening the outside angled foot will cause liftingforces to be induced in the machine frame. This is further evidenced by the shaft and footmovement that occurs when the other, (not angled), feet are loosened and rise.
Type 2b: The Inside Angled Soft Foot
In this case, also called an inside bent foot soft foot, the contact between foot and base againis angled, but this time with a decreasing slope from inside to outside. In other words, with theproblem foot loosened, an uneven air gap will be seen, highest on the inside. This results inprimarily negative (downward) forces being induced in the machine frame when the foot istightened. This time, loosening the two adjacent feet will not relieve the stress within the framemuch, and little or no movement occurs, as these feet are trying to move downwards into the baseinstead. The diagonally opposite foot may experience some positive rise due to the conversion of
the negative forces washing over the hump formed by the nearer two feet. More on this inSection VI.
Type 3: The Induced Soft Foot
Type3: The Induced Soft Foot
This is a broad classification which embodies most types of distortion produced by outsideforces acting on the machine frame. By far the most common of these is pipe strain, or conduitstrain. It is obvious that improper pipefitting may exert substantial forces on the machine casing,resulting in machine frame distortion when the improperly fitted pipe is forced to mate to itscounterpart flange on the machine. The existence of pipe stress and its exact effects of on shaftalignment can be measured and quantified by way of a special procedure described in Ludecas
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
9/27Copyright 2014 by LUDECA, INC. www.ludeca.com Page 9 of 27
TechNotes for various different laser alignment systems such as Rotalign Ultra and OptalignSmart RS. (TechNotes are a series of documents with procedures to deal with special applications,available from Ludeca, Inc.) In this paper we are concerned more with the effects pipe stress has onmachine frame distortion (soft foot) than with its impact on shaft alignment; however, theelimination of undue pipe stress solves both problems at once and a competent pipefitter can bethe millwrights best friend in these situations.
The effects of pipe stress on machine distortion and movement are very difficult to predict orquantify accurately. However, in general, when a machine evidences a soft foot problem but its
behavior pattern does not fall into one of the clearly defined patterns that characterize the othertypes of soft foot problems, then an induced soft foot should be suspected and an independentpipe strain verification procedure should be undertaken to prove that a pipe strain problem exists.Let us add here a small clarification of terms: Pipe Stress is the force exerted on a machine framefrom improperly fitted and supported piping; Pipe Strain is the resulting distortion from thatstress.
Coupling strain from misalignment of the coupled shafts may also cause the shaft and feet tomove when a foot is loosened; however, it is not included in this family of problems since, bydefinition, it is an alignment problem. Moreover, as this condition would change or influence anunrelated soft foot behavior, it must be eliminated prior to embarking on the formal soft footmeasurement procedure. Therefore a rough alignment is essential before beginning soft footreadings, and should precede all other activity in the alignment job except for safety procedures
(lockout and tag-out) and basic policing of the work area. This also makes sense from thestandpoint of the alignment job in general, since it would be pointless to expend time and effort inrectifying a soft foot situation only to then discover that the machine is bolt-bound or base-boundand must come off the base for further corrective action.
Type 4: Squishy Foot Soft Foot
Type 4: The Squishy Foot Soft Foot
In this case, when a foot is loosened, a movement of the shafts or feet is again observed.However, this time it is due to an external force acting on the foot itself, and pushing it up. Thissituation can be caused by too many shims under the foot, bowed or bent shims, and shims withburrs, dirt or oil. The foot will be caused to move by the powerful spring effect of the shims under
that foot (much like a leaf spring.) Having this condition is harmful because it means that thetorque on the hold-down bolt or nut is being exerted in overcoming the spring effect, rather thanbeing applied to properly anchoring the machine to its foundation. Thus, a bolt torqued to theproper specs might not necessarily guarantee that that foot is adequately secured againstoperational load stresses.
A squishy soft foot is a condition that should be eliminated in the initial clean-up and roughalignment of the machine, prior to the formal soft foot checking procedure. Good alignmentpractice suggests that one never use more than three, or at the most four, clean, precut stainlesssteel shims under a foot. Good base preparation will ensure that it is never necessary to violate thisrule of thumb, since standard commercially available precut shims allow you to achieve any desiredthickness of up to 0.150" with three or fewer shims, given the 13 different standard thicknessesnormally available. It is important to note that precut stainless steel shims that are clean and flat
will exhibit a compression factor of at most 0.5% to 1% of the total thickness involved. (In contrastto this, brass hand-cut shims may yield as much as 5% to 6% compression!) Additionally, oneshould allow approximately 0.00025" to 0.0005" movement for each air gap between shims.Therefore, the acceptable tolerance for a soft foot movement or laser reading is 0.002" or less.
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
10/27Copyright 2
VI. Anal
As megap pattecalculatednow explsuggest sindividualreflect thi
specific ex
Type 1: Ro
Type 1a: T
Behavior:
Your llikely be sFoot 1. Thnot consi
Feelerbase.) Thiopposedto lowest)
Diagnosis
The soft fis Foot 1 i
Solution:
Shim Foot
Analysis:
014 by LUDEC
zing a S
ntioned befns under tby the lasere the specolutions tofeet are lo. Note tha
amples sho
cking Soft F
he Short Fo
ser systemomewhat le remainingered soft.
gauges fin will usualloft foot (Fotowards th
ot with thethe illustra
1 by the a
Fig. 5
Fig. 5a
, INC. www.lu
ft Foot C
ore, the bee feet as wr system asific behaviothese prosened onethe expla
n.
ot
ot Rocking
will show trger than ttwo diago
that onebe the o
t 3), presesoft foot w
even air gated exampl
ount of the
eca.com
ndition
avior patterll as the aa theoreticpatterns olems. Remat a time, aations for
oft Foot
o high value other (ually oppos
f the soft fe that prets a tapereith the even
(and highin Figure 5
even air ga
n of a softgular movel moveme
f the soft fmber, eac
lways withehavior an
s diagonallually by 10d feet (Fee
eet has anents the hiair gap thaair gap.
r laser read.)
that was
foot conditiment of tht of the foot situatio of these
the othersd suggeste
y opposed.% or more.2 and 4) w
even air gagher laser rt points di
ing) is too
easured (0.
on is a comshaft. Thet that wass describedbehaviorsight! The ill solutions
See FigureIn the exa
ill show 0.0
(not tapereading. Thagonally (fr
hort, or is
015").
All 4 feet
Page
bination ofshaft movemeasured.in Sectionccurs only
ustrated exrelate only
. One of thmple given,2" or less
ed, parallelother, diam highest
issing shim
tight
10 of 27
the airent ise will
V, andwhenmplesto the
se willthis isnd are
to theonally
air gap
s. (This
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
11/27Copyright 2
Whensurface wi
If thefoot will short will2 and 4)ridge acforces beirelief occu
With athe foot trise, andtapered ai
It shofoot), madiagonallyonly loosseparate sat more tconfusionor she enobtainedwithin it aevidencewhole poispare youcorrection
at one ofinadverteproblem t
014 by LUDEC
a foot that ih the other
hort foot iop up intppear as aill not movoss which
ng exertedrs when the
ll feet tight,at is locates it does, i
r gap that
ld be notedifests itsel
opposed lning one foft foot proan locationfor the ineds up shimt each soft
s much asf a given p
nt of thesethe frustra
s. When bo
he feet, thetly createdice, and t
Fig. 5c
Fig. 5b
, INC. www.lu
s short or ifeet alread
self is releathe planeeven air g
if loosenehe frame ison these hse feet are l
the stress td diagonallt leaves thoints towa
and emphf by genercations onot at a tim
blems on thon the macperiencedming bothfoot. Let usossible whroblem inexercises ision of chah feet are s
problem wia Type 1c at is overkil
eca.com
missing shbolted tigh
ed with thof the othep under thindividuallbeing bowigh feet (Fosened.
at the shoropposite f plane of trds the shor
sized hereating unacthe machi
e. As we he machine; iine frame.illwright, l
soft feet bnot forgetrever possiore than oto familiariing your taimmed by
ll simply beigh foot r
lnever a
ims (in thist, the frame
other threr three parafoot. The r(with thed. When b
eet 2 and
t foot inducrom the shhe other tht foot. See
hat this typeptably hie frame, wve just seenstead, youhis circumsading himthe full a
that the male, and the
ne locatione you withil (so to spthe full amo
transferredcking softood thing.
case Foot 1will be dist
e feet tight,llel feet. Thmaining tthers tight),oth soft fee) are negat
es in the frrt foot is loree feet, prigure 5c.
of probleh soft fo
hen the cor, this doesare seeingtance is oftr her to oount of t
chine framrefore it isas we loosthese distieak), in perunt to corr
to the othefoot. In oth
is forced drted. See Fi
the stress ie amount bo feet that, since theyt (Feet 1 aive (downw
me will alsosened. Thiesenting a
(the short readingsrect procednotmean
evidence ofn the singl
vercorrecte soft footwill seek tntirely likeln the feetct behaviorforming unct a proble
r two feet sir words, y
Foot 3 lo1, 2 and
Foot 1 lo
2, 3 and
Page
own to its sgure 5a.
s relieved awhich itere not so
represent td 3) are tigards), so n
be relieves foot (Footoutside-to
foot rockiat two se
ure is follohat you hathe same pbiggest so
the proble reading threlieve ththat we
one at a tipatterns, secessary sthat only
nce you hau killed th
ose;tight
ose;
4 tight
11 of 27
upport
nd theas toot (Feete highht, thestrain
when3) will
-inside
g softparate,
ed ofe twooblemurce of
as heat wasstress
ay seee.Theas to
ft footxisted
e nowsame
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
12/27Copyright 2
Type 1b:
Behavior:
Laser rvery simil
Feelerlowest) fr
towards t
Conclusio
Both s
Solution:
Shimmay instehowever,
Analysis:
Whenfeet will b
Loosenot soft.looseningdistortionmust splitamount t
Foot 1 loos2, 3 and 4 ti
014 by LUDEC
he Even Ro
eadings indr to each ot
gauges finm the out
e other dia
:
ft feet (in t
oth soft fed remove the first sug
both feet diw the mac
ing each shus, botheach of trelief, shim the differeey came up
;ight
Fig. 6
Fig. 6a
, INC. www.lu
cking Soft F
icate soft foher.) The ot
tapered aiide corner
onally opp
is case Fee
t by 50% ofhe same amested solut
agonally opine frame a
ft foot indivof them tae soft feet
ming the fnce and le.
eca.com
oot
ot at two dier two feet
r gaps undoward the
sed soft fo
1 and 3) ar
the averagount of shiion is better
posed to eacross the h
idually causer inwards
individuallll air gap uel the mac
Figs.
agonally opare not sof
r both sofinside corn
t.
e short or
air gap ths from un
, for several
ch other arump or rid
es it to com towards e affords t
nder bothhine by shi
b and 6c
posed feet..
feet. Thesr of the so
missing shi
t was measer the tworeasons. (S
short or me formed
e up beyonch other.e machinef them wo
mming bot
The values
gaps tapeft feet, eac
s.
ured underhigh feete analysis b
issing shimsy the two hi
the planeee Figuresframe the
uld be oveh feet up
All four fe
Page
ill be ident
r (from higpointing i
each of thethat were nelow.)
, tighteninggh feet.
of the two t6b and 6cfull value
kill. Therefy just half
Foot 3 l1, 2 and
et tight
12 of 27
ical (or
est towards
m. Yout soft;
all the
hat are. Sinceof there, weof the
ose;4 tight
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
13/27Copyright 2
This wthe machientire macbetweenmachinesthe least. Iunder thefrom eachwith a Tyinwards,situation sremain ex
Foot at t
Type 1c:
Behavior:
Your lother doe
Feelerof the adjopposite
Conclusio
One fFoot 4.) Tto the sof
Solution:
(1) Adfoot, or (3will be prthat appeamount tappeared
014 by LUDEC
ill eliminatene, relativehine will nohe two coalready rout is importatwo shortother by me 1a Shorthereas in thould be aactly as de
e end of Se
igh Foot R
ser again fi(by 10% or
gauges findcent feet tdjacent cor
:
ot is highe foot withfoot that is
shims to) add shimssented in tared under
be removunder the s
Fig. 6d
, INC. www.lu
the probleto the othew be lowerepled machih aligned, i
nt to note tfeet may diore than 10Foot Rockie Type 1auneven r
cribed abo
ction VI for
cking Soft
nds two sofmore.)
that both sat was noter that also
it is macthe higherlocated clo
he soft footo the reme Analysisthe soft fod from theft foot that
eca.com
without ar machine.d to the planes. Sincet behoovesat in many,fer from on%. However,g Soft Foohort Foot ocking softe. See A
more in-d
oot
t feet diago
oft feet havoft. Put anwas not so
ined too lolaser soft foest to the h
nearest thining threeparagraphot that is chigh foot iis closest t
ig. 7
fecting thef you remne of the tsoft foot cus to choosif not most,e another. Tdo not bethe keynly one of toot. Howehort Cut t
pth view of
nally oppos
e tapered aither way, bt.
ng, or hasot reading (igh foot.
high footfeet. The firelow; simpllosest to thapproximathe high f
undistorteve shims fro short ferrections a
e the soluti, cases, theherefore, thmisled intoifference hem did! Peer, the dia Analyzing
how the m
ed. One pr
r gaps whicoth of thes
oo many shere Foot 1
or (2) remot solution i
y add shime high footely the saot. This is
leveled aliom the higet. This chare being pn which aff
amount of se soft foot rbelieving tre is that brhaps the bnostic appand Corre
achine beha
duces a hig
h point outair gaps p
ims under i) will almos
ve shims frthe best, fequal to t. In the see as the avlso the am
Feet 1 and 3
Page
nment posi feet insteges the alirformed w
ects the alihims missineadings maat you areoth air gapetter nameoach and sting Rocki
ves in this c
her value t
ardstowarint awayfr
t. (In this einvariable
m under tr the reasoe averageond solutierage air gunt that w
loose
13 of 27
tion ofd, thenmentith thenmentg from
differealingtaper
or thislutiong Soft
ase.
an the
ds onem the
ampleelong
e highns thatir gapn, thep thatuld be
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
14/27Copyright 2
added toonly one
Analysis:
Whenprotrusionin Figureto form a
This inacross theadjacent taway froand 7c aband therefup to elim
it to bringfeet maywork, but
Solutieffect onbut haveSolutionadvantagerocking sthat we hrocking so
014 by LUDEC
the remainif the three
one foot ison the basa above. Tigh ridge
turn will chigh ridgeo the highthe high f
ove.) The sore also teinate the ro
it into plalso be shiay be nec
n 1 is prefehe existinga marked
(which isof the fac
ft foot. Thiave alludedft feet. This
Fig. 7a
, INC. www.lu
g three feeossible cor
oo high (loe, it is out ois causes thacross whic
use the twformed byfoot are liftot and towft foot closds to presecking condi
e with themed up tossary if ther
rred becausalignmenteffect on talso the e
t that the s characteri to earlier,method is p
eca.com
t besides tections!
g), or has tf the planeis foot andh the machi
feet adjache high fod off theirrds the cor
est to thet the higheion (Solutio
emaining tmake a leve are not e
this will dif the mache existing
asiest to ehigh foot rstic is partiwhich hasresented ne
Figs. 7
e high foot
oo many shf the other
the one diane will bow
ent to thet and the osupport suner diagonigh foot ofr of the twon 1), or, the
ree feet (Sel plane witough shim
rectly elimiines, wherealignment,fect) is thcking softularly usefproven toxt.
and 7c
, if the thir
ims under ithree. This
gonally oppwhen you ti
igh foot tone diagonalrface andlly oppositers the grelaser readihigh foot
lution 2).h the highto remove
ate the softas Solutionwhich ma best alterfoot behal when eme an excel
option we
(here Footwould be tosite to it (ighten all th
be soft. Thly opposedill presentthe high f
atest influegs. This foust have sh
f course, tfoot (Solutifrom the hi
foot proble2 and 3 c be inconnative. Soles much li
ploying thelent diagno
Al
Page
re chosen.
4), or restse case withn this case
feet.
e machineto it. The sir gaps thaot (see Figce on strest can be shims remove
e remaininn 3.) This ih foot.
m while harrect the penient. Thtion 1 alsoke the shoshort cutstic techni
l feet tight
14 of 27
hoose
pon aFoot 4oot 2)
rocksft feet
t taperres 7bs reliefimmedd from
threemore
ing nooblemrefore,takes
rt footethodue for
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
15/27Copyright 2014 by LUDECA, INC. www.ludeca.com Page 15 of 27
A Short Cut to Analyzing and Correcting Rocking Soft Foot
The Short Cut Method, pioneered by Mr. Pedro Casanova of LUDECA, is a very effective techniquefor diagnosing anyrocking soft foot problem. However, this procedure should only be applied torocking soft feet (the Type 1 soft feet), and not to any other types of soft foot conditions.
Outline of the Procedure
1) Your laser system discovers a rocking soft foot.
2) Loosen both diagonally opposed soft feet. (In other words, both soft feet should be loosenedtogether, leaving the other two (not soft) feet tight.)
3) Manually feel the shim packs under the soft feet. Try to wiggle them.
4) Diagnose the problem and correct it as follows:
a) Prepare your laser system to measure soft foot on the foot whose shim pack still felt snug,and take a measurement by tightening that anchor bolt (with the diagonally opposite onstill loose!)
b) Now loosen the foot you just measured again, and prepare your laser system to take areading on the diagonally opposite soft foot.
c) Take a reading at this foot by tightening its anchor bolt, again with the diagonally oppositefoot loose.
d) Shim both of the soft feet you just measured by the amounts just indicated by your lasersystem.
e) Take another set of laser soft foot readings to make sure all problems have been eliminated.
Explanation:
If you have a short foot rocking soft foot (Type 1a), then, upon loosening both soft feet, you willfind that the machine tends to rest upon the three feet that are not short. These form a plane, sothe short foot lifts off its shim pack, which will feel loose. With both of these diagonally opposedfeet loose, your laser system will accurately measure the foot that is short and reveal the amountthat it is to be to be shimmed since this short foot can now move freely without the restriction ofthe diagonally opposite foot acting hindering it. The foot that was not short (the soft foot
diagonally across from the short foot), only comes up when the short foot is forced down;therefore, with the short foot loose it will now rest upon its shim pack, which will feel snug.Tightening this foot will reveal no movement, and hence no correction to be performed at thatfoot.
You may, of course, use feeler gauges to determine the right amount to insert under the shortfoot. This too will correct the problem. As explained earlier, your laser system only sees theabsolute value of the movement of the shafts, and calculates the undistorted foot movement thatwould have produced the observed change in vertical angularity.
If you have an even rocking soft foot (Type 1b), the machine will tend to rest upon the two highfeet as it levels itself, raising both short feet off their shim packs. Both of these will feel loose, andwhen you tighten each of these feet individually, with their diagonally opposite number loose, your
laser system will reveal the exact amount that you must shim them both by to eliminate theproblem. Youll note that the amount of shimming needed will be about half of what each footoriginally came up individually, when its diagonally opposite partner was tight.
A high foot rocking soft foot (Type 1c) will manifest itself in similar manner to the short footrocking soft foot. If you follow the procedure outlined above exactly, your laser system will tell youwhat to do to fix the problem accurately.
Always follow up any corrections with a new round of laser soft foot readings to confirm thatthe problem has indeed been eliminated (step 4e in the procedure.)
Note that sometimes different amounts of shimming may be needed under each of thediagonally opposed soft feet if they are not equally short. Your laser system will accurately feelthe correct amount that needs to be inserted under each, as each is tightened with its opposite
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
16/27Copyright 2
partner lowhen looswould ofrocking sand the tto be a shsame as taligned towhich you
after all so
Notesaves yougap undethe machirocking seach othe
Type 2:
Type 2a:
Behavior:
Your loccurring
Feelergap is mathe foot w
014 by LUDEC
ose. The se, until youourse be tft foot (Typo feet furthort foot. Sihat for thethe otherwill correct
ft foot has
hat the Shmuch timethe soft fe
ne to levelft problem,, then you
he Angle
utside Ang
Fig. 8.1
ser systemadjacent to
gauges finrkedly taperith the seco
, INC. www.lu
orter onehave the cae short fo
e 1c), theest from it,ply shim tshort footachine, soanyway as
een elimina
rt Cut Metand effortet with feelitself and sand insteaust procee
Soft Foot
ed Soft Foo
finds that teach other,
that the foed (from land highest l
eca.com
foot is, relae where ont rockingachine willhereas the
is foot androcking sobe it! Thisyou procee
ted.
od only wy eliminatir gauges. Yim accordifind that td to analyze
t
hree or eveither on th
ot with thegest to smser soft fo
ive to thely one footoft foot (Ttend to resfoot closesthe problet foot. If till now justin your ta
rks adequg the needou simply tngly. Nothie two largthe situatio
Fig. 8.2
Fig. 9
n all four fesame side
largest laserllest gap) ft reading.
ther, theis short, witpe 1a) situ
t on the plt to it will lifis solved!
he machinebe a straig
sks to the fi
tely for roto actuallyake advantg could bst laser sofn formally,
et are soft,or the sam
reading slrom outsid
ore even ita perfectl
ation. If yone formedt off its shiThis approais now no
htforward anal alignme
king soft fmeasure tge of the neasier! Iffoot readis outlined
F
with the twend of the
pes up to tto inside a
Page
air gap beven air ghave a hiby the higpack, and
ch is of cou perfectly llignment prnt of the m
ot situatioe shape ofatural tendou do notgs are adjaelow.
ig. 8.3
o largest remachine.
he outside.nd points t
16 of 27
comesp. Thish foot foot
appearrse thevel or
oblem,chine,
s, andthe airncy ofhave acent to
adings
The airwards
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
17/27Copyright 2
Fig
Conclusio
The fowhich it rtouching.
Suggeste
Step-sremachine
Analysis:
Since
seeks to rthe foot tthereby gadjacent tthe next lFigure 9 aframe andbend, thefoot, sincethe diago
Step sthe machiintention.This may,there forthis is a shas beenedge of ttemptatiothinking tbe said abinterested,
Alignmenhttp://ww
Just remetouching
014 by LUDEC
. 10
:
ot with thests is angl
Solution:
him the anthe feet, or
this situatiomethod, a
occ
b
forclieve the st
hat is bentnerating th
o the bentrgest effecbove. (If thFoot No. 4third bestforcing theally opposi
imming isne frame fThe objectihowever, rlignment pecial excepompleted,he foot (sefor a well-at perhapsout step-sh we refer
Shimming.ludeca.co
ber to usedont pus
, INC. www.lu
ighest lased (or both.
led foot ifthe base, if
n is clearlyd must insr under th
identsolut
feet tigse, it acts a
es into theess within ihas the gr
e highest laoot and ison stress rbend is dimight displource of stbent foot de corner.
an excellentom distortie is to fill tsult in haviurposes whtion to the ou may wis
e Figure 1meaning cohe has discimming teche reader
y Alan Lue/casestudy
common sthem in wi
eca.com
reading an The foot r
ou are preit is the cau
not a rockead proceee soft feetifying theion for it.
foot readiair gap)that you
t! When ths a lever, pi
frame, tryinas much aatest ander readingxially alignlief when l
agonal, they the seco
ress relief oown causes
short-termng when yhe uneven (g to use
ile the steno more thh to trim of.) This willlleague whvered shimnique; thatto the arti
eking, whic/shimming_
ense when ih excessive
d tapered aiests on the
sed for timse of the pr
ing soft coto learn
when you lature of thhen you long, feeleroft foot, slre only loois outsideoting on it
to pick upossible bost immehen it is lo
d with theosened. Tthe forcesd highest laccurs at thit to act si
stop-gapou tightenangled) airore than fped shimsan three orthe excessavoid safethappens bs that are slhowever, gle on shi
h can be fouptime0413
nserting thforce.
r gap is besupport su
e or resourblems.
ndition, yoore about toosen thee problemosen the fauges clearping fromening this fent foot (Finside edg
the otherraising eaciate effectosened. Wdirection ofis would bwill be traser reading. foot diagilarly to a s
solution forthe feet. Tgap underur shims, stake carefour shimsshimmingy hazards
later, to pipping out fes beyondming entitl
nd here:.pdf
step shim
t, or the surface with
es to corre
cannot ahe shapes. This willnd conseqot with thely identifyoutside to
oot alone,igure 8.1) ie or corner.
side (Figureh of the oton stress ren it is tighthe angleFoot No.
smitted dia) If not axialnally oppo
hort foot, al
this probleat is, afterhe foot asince somef the soft frule. Afteraterial thatnd also elish the shi
rom underthe scope oed Best Pr
s; insert the
Page
port surfacnly its inne
ct the probl
ply the shf the air gagreatly aidently the l
highest lasn angled (tinside. Remith the othe forced doThis inject
8.2.) The mer feet. Oblief of the
t, the footor bend) wiin the diaggonally acrly aligneded from tho tending
m, which wi all, yourvenly as pay be alre
oot. Not tohe final alisticks out pminate a ps in all thehe foot! Mf this paper,ctices: Ma
m gently u
17 of 27
uponr edge
em, or
rt cutps thatyou inikeliester softaperedemberr threen thelifting
achineiously,frame,hich isll haveram inss theith thee bento raise
ll keeprimaryssible.
ady beworry,nmentast theossible
ay in,ch canand ifhinery
til just
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
18/27Copyright 2
Type 2b: I
Behavior:
Your l Feeler
smallest oConclusio
The fooutside e
Suggeste
Step-s
Analysis:
Unlike
soft foot tthe anchoframe. Threlief, as tdown, notemporaril
It shobent footinside angshe mightHowever,
014 by LUDEC
side Angle
ser systemgauges fin
n the outsid:
ot that is sge of the f
Solution:
him the ben
the outside
ends to pullr bolt and fs, no liftinghe machine come up.y until you
ld be noteare negativled one; thibe fooled ihe second
, INC. www.lu
d Soft Foot
Fig
finds only o that the s
e part of th
ft is bent inot.
t foot or re-
bent foot,
it down. Sirce it flat tforces areframe rem
Again, stepave the tim
that even, some mo
s can be exnto believinighest valu
eca.com
. 11.1
e soft footft foot has
foot.
wards, or is
machine th
hich tries t
ce the pivthe baseransmitted
ains distort shimminge and resou
though thvement maremely cong at first glfor soft re
Fig. 1
on the maca significa
sitting on
foot or the
o lift the m
t point forou inject nto the othed. All the fthe insiderces to corr
forces indbe observusing for tance that tistered by
Fig. 11.2
ine.t tapered
n angled s
support su
chine as y
he foot is igative rotar feet. Looseet (exceptiangled softct the prob
uced in theed at the fe less expeey have enhe laser sys
ir gap, larg
rface whic
rface.
u tighten it,
s outside etional forcening them
ng the benfoot may
lem more p
machine frot diagonalrienced millcountered atem will not
Page
est from in
only conta
, the inside
ge, as youinto the mregisters nt one) wanolve the p
ermanently.
ame by thely oppositeright, sinc
rocking sofall within
18 of 27
ide to
cts the
angled
torqueachinestressto go
oblem
insideto thehe or
ft foot.0% or
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
19/27Copyright 2
20% so ofless, probsignalingsometimesoft footfeet andmethod isreadingsbent one,
still restinis immediwield thereading,dead giveType3: I
014 by LUDEC
the higherbly not mohat this sitoccurs is teing tightehen tend ttried, then,gain as perand the ang
on the shitely obtainfeeler gaugith the othway as to
duced So
ig. 14
, INC. www.lu
one (as itre than 50ation is notat the neged down t rise a littlupon loosthe procedled foot itse
pack, eved from thees and mer feet tight.hat the pro
ft Foot
eca.com
oes with aof the val
a true rocktive forcesnd to wasat the dianing bothre, no corr
lf will displa
if only aloshort cutsure the shThe tapere
blem is.
Fig. 13
true rockine of the la
ing soft fooinduced in
over thegonally opiagonally oction will b
y a snug shi
g its outerethod, thatape of the
air gap fr
ig. 14
soft foot)ger readint condition.he machineump formosite foot.pposed sofe indicatedm pack sinc
edge. Theris a definitiairgap of tm inside to
but will be. This shoulThe reasonframe frod by the twNeverthelet feet togetat the oppe the weigh
fore, if no cve indicatioe foot wit
outside wil
Page
found to bd ring alarthat this bthe insideo nearest as, if the sher and takisite foot frt of the mac
lear-cut corn that it isthe bigge
l immediate
19 of 27
muchbells,
haviorangledjacentort cutng them thehine is
rectionime tot laserly be a
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
20/27Copyright 2014 by LUDECA, INC. www.ludeca.com Page 20 of 27
Behavior:
Your laser system finds two, three or even all four feet soft. The two highest values tend to bealong the same side or the same end of the machine frame. One pair of feet may even show zerosoft foot. Feeler gauges find that the largest soft feet have fairly even air gaps; that is to say, nosignificant tapers can be determined.
Conclusion:
An external force is acting on the machine frame, which is trying to pull or push it up, down,sideways, or axially. This force will, in all likelihood, originate from the pipe stress of improperlyfitted piping, poor pipe hanging, or excessively rigid electrical conduit. Caution! Never loosen morethan one foot at a time under these circumstances! The external forces acting on the machineframe may be so great that loosening more than one foot may result in more force acting on theremaining feet than these can withstand, resulting in bending or sudden cracking or breaking ofthe machine feet. Therefore, as much to preserve the health of the machine as looking out for yourown safety, never loosen more than one anchor bolt on a machine frame unless you are convincedthat you can do so safely (as in the short cut method, which applies only to situations where youfind the two largest soft feet to be diagonally apart.) It is always better to proceed with great careand err on the side of caution and safety.
In the example illustrated in Figure 15, the piping forces would be construed as pulling upwardsmore than sideways, since all four feet are soft. In cases where the pipe stress pulls the machinesideways, the tendency may be for this force to roll the machine, which would be evidenced by onepair of feet showing zero soft foot and the opposite pair lifting up.
Suggested Solution:
Eliminate the source of undue strain on the machine frame.
Analysis:
If the soft feet do not present significant taper patterns of the air gaps when loosened, and theoverall stress-relief pattern doesnt tend to act like a rocking condition, then the machine frame is
simply trying to move with whatever outside force is acting on it, to the extent possible. Since anoutside angled soft foot clearly shows up tapered when loosened, as do the other feet which reactto it, this situation obviously is different. Furthermore, we assume as a precondition, that a goodrough alignment of the coupled machines exists by the time you are checking soft foot, eliminatingcoupling strain as a source of the observed soft foot behavior. Therefore, the only explanation forthe observed soft foot condition must be that it is externally induced. The advantage of notloosening more than one foot at a time in a properly executed soft foot check is that you mayprevent immediate damage to the machine frame from occurring if a great external force such aspipestrain exists, as well as preserving your own personal safety and that of others around you.
It is possible that poorly trained personnel forced a pipe to mate to a pump casing by using acome-along for instance, after all four feet were already bolted tight. Loosening two feet
simultaneously might mean that the remaining feet are no longer quite strong enough to hold themachine frame in place against this force, with disastrous consequences as the frame or feet crack,or even break off. Incidentally, as mentioned earlier, with the Short Cut Method, which does involveloosening two feet at one time, you know up front, going into the procedure, that you have arocking soft foot situation which safely allows you to safely loosen two feet at a time. It is highlyunlikely that an induced soft foot from external forces acting on the frame will present as a rockingsoft foot. Still, if in doubt, do not loosen more than one foot and proceed instead to perform apipestrain check with your laser system, to verify whether or not pipestrain exists and to quantify itsimpact (if any) the shaft alignment of the machines.
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
21/27Copyright 2
Type4: S
Behavior:
Your lsoft feet.
Conclusio
A squ
Suggeste
Elimin
Analysis:
This bburrs, or
a soft fooshaft movdisplay agrown witwent. Thisfoot alwainstead thdistortionloosen thproblem.
If thorquality prproblem ssoft foot canchor bFollowing,
014 by LUDEC
quishy So
Fig. 16
ser system
:
ishy or spri
Solution:
te the spri
havior is pil, grease, o
conditionement occignificant a
h the footcan only bs means me machine fexists whenfoot, or n
ough cleancut stainle
hould haveheck is perflt bottomswe present
, INC. www.lu
t Foot
finds one o
ng type soft
gy conditio
obably caur otherwise
xists, it is erred, uponir gap, it cas it movedthe resultchine framrame will bethe foot is
soft foot
up was dos steel shibeen automormed. Oneout in thea few exam
eca.com
r more soft
foot exists.
under the
ed by havidirty conditi
vidence thalooseningn only mea, filling theof a leaf-spdistortion.distorted a
tight, theneading wo
e beforehas were useatically elimother possifoundationles of unus
feet. Feeler
feet.
g too manons under
t the situati foot. Yet,
n that whagap betweing type ofIf no distors you tighthe spring ild have oc
nd, and nod in the iniinated befobility for a: full torquual or unort
gauges fin
shims, bohe feet. If y
on is bad eif the footever causen the footshim packion exists wn the footso strong
curred. The
more thanial rough a
re even reaceemingly se is achievhodox situa
Fig. 17
little or no
ed or bentour laser sy
nough thatthat was l it to movand the suunder the fhen the foond the sprihat it bendefore, eithe
three or alignment ofhing the stuishy soft fd yet thetions:
Page
air gap un
shims, shitem indicat
significant rosened dohas expanport surfacot. A squis
t is looseneg gives wathe framer way, you
t most fouthe machige where aoot happenfoot is still
21 of 27
er the
s withes that
elativees notded ore as ithy soft
, then. If no
as youhave a
goode, thisformals if theloose!
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
22/27Copyright 2
The Floa
Behavior:
Your lgauges fiSee FigureConclusio
Therethe machi
Suggeste
Remo
014 by LUDEC
ing Soft F
ser systemd tapered a19.:
is a high spe frame hi
Solution:
e the protr
, INC. www.lu
oot
finds thatir gaps und
ot on the bher than an
sion or fore
eca.com
ll four feetr all four fe
ase, locatedy of the fee
ign object
Fig. 1
are soft. Eaet, all of whi
inside the.
hich is stuc
ch foot is lich point in
area bound
k under the
osened onards (from
ed by the f
belly of the
Fig. 18
Fig. 20
Page
e at a time.highest to l
et, which i
machine.
22 of 27
Feelerwest.)
lifting
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
23/27Copyright 2
Analysis:
If all fFigure 18.underneatthe machinegativesurprise scausing ethe locatijackscrewcorrection
Gaps Wit
Behavior:
Uponlooseningfoot whereads a s
Conclusio
Chancframe. It isimply mlooseningthe machiand go asalignment
014 by LUDEC
ur feet co) Sometimeh the bellynes at thelignment cft foot coch foot ton of the hior positionis to the alig
out Soft F
hecking fothe feet), y that foot iall soft foo
:
s are you halso possians that tan anchore frame. S
it pleases wof shimmin
Fig. 21
, INC. www.lu
e up, soms a foreignf the mach
beginningrrection cadition. As top up indi
gh spot. Sng device isnment.
et
soft foot, yet feeler gas loose, anbut the fee
ave a foot tle that thee foot (orolt, causinimming toithout affecg this foot
eca.com
thing is boobject suc
ine. This shf the job.ses the mo
he feet areidually wite Figures 2not sufficie
our laser syges (or evno gap wler gauges f
at is crackbase is flimsupport suthe gap till this gap iing the fraill be unpre
ing the fra as a loosuld be cau
It can haptor to botttightened,an outside
0 and 21. Sintly backed
Fig. 2
tem findsn the nakeen the foond a much
d or brokey, or the soface) can fappear an
s enticing be, it follow
dictable.
me out ofe nut or aght when clen, howevom out onthe frameangled air
milar behaoff prior to
2
one (i.e., nd eye) disct is tight. Alarger gap.
, or one thle plate haslex and md disappeaut rarely effthat the ef
he plane ofpiece of deaning upr, that remsuch an obeflects acrogap pointiniors can ocmaking ne
shaft movever a signi
lternatively,
t is very wecome loosve freely u, without afctive; since
fects on sof
Page
the four febris finds ind rough aoving shimject, introdss this protg inwards tur when a
gative (dow
ment occuricant gap uyour laser
k on this min the gro
pon tightefecting thethe gap cafoot correc
23 of 27
et (seets wayligning
for acing arusion,wardsertical
nward)
s uponnder asystem
achinet. Thising orrest ofcome
tion or
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
24/27Copyright 2
Suggeste
The ohand, if ynot damamachine fto the ma
VII. Co The fosituationsthese behthe field. Iin a macdiagnosis.foot maydiagonallyfoot is mtechniqueunnecessayour analthe foot tmeasurebehaviorthe machiyou far alrealize it ba differenfoot situaalso actinthe readilproceed t
eliminate
Three-F
Somesince thresurface arsoft feet. Ithe otherthree feetraise the fyour laser
014 by LUDEC
Solution:
ly real soluu find thated or broame, bearihine.)
plex Softregoing diswhere a sinvior types
t may happine frame,In these calso be sho
opposite wre bent thand princiry error tsis procedat had the
nd analyzef the mach
ne to act oong the paecause youtack. If a cion, then,on the ma recognize
o correct t
your soft f
oted Mac
smaller geapoints alwas need to
f the third ftwo feet hto rise wherame evenlsystem ma
Fig. 23
, INC. www.lu
ion to thishe machineen, perhapgs or shaft
Feet andcussion angle type ofill adequatn however,
causing stres, only cart. If the beill have hign short, orples presenat might ore by meashighest lasthe foot wiine in light
behave inh to a solproblem dirrection yohen you rechine framed behaviorat problem
ot problem
ines
boxes haveys define amate withot which iss an outsidloosened ion that sidnot recog
eca.com
roblem is tdoes respo the problis taking pl
Multipleexamplesproblem waly describethat two ornge behavieful analysid is alignesoft foot rvice-versa.ed thus fartherwise pluring and ar soft footh the secof this infor
this mannetion. If youd not get battempt eheck soft fwill suddenpatterns t, without u
s and can n
three-footeplane. Howheir supporpositionede angled sodividually;
e. This meaize the soft
o repair thend to alignm can be ice when th
Footedof soft foots acting onthe majoritmore distior patternswill lead twith the fadings. Whither way,will greatlygue a soft
nalyzing threading. Ifd highest s
mation. Askwhen I lo
make a mtter, or yods up solviot on all t
ly emerge tat you arendoing wh
w proceed
d frames wever, as thet surfaces,by itself onft foot in thowever, ths that no a
foot on th
machine, tent shimm
gnored, sine bolts are
achinesconditions
the machinof the softct types ofto occura solution.ot next to
ich is highethe correctreduce thefoot correcshape of
the mysteryoft foot reayourself, wsen or tighistake, thatmade anot
ng one of te feet agaiat much m
already fat you did
to the final
ich, in prinfeet are nothis gives rione side ofe side-to-s
is foot, whicngular movt side. Che
e base, oring correctice no actuaightened (i.
all illustrate frame. Mfoot probleproblems ehich defyFor exampl
it, both thar depends oapplicationamount oftion procedhe airgap t is not immding, thenhat are theten anchoris okay: yoher soft fooe problem
n, the otherore clearlymiliar with.before, an
alignment o
iple, shoulpoints bute to the pothe machinide directioh is by itselfement of thk this midd
All fe
Page
oth. On thns, and thel distortione., no harm
d straightfre often th
ms encountist simultahort cutse, an outsione and tn whether tof the diagfruitless triure. Alwayshat appearsediate clearnalyze thelikeliest caubolts? This
will immet worse. So
in a complproblem tnd fall intoYou thenvoil!yo
f the machi
have no spads, whosssibility for
midway b, it may ca
in the mide shafts occle foot any
t tight
24 of 27
otherfoot isof thecomes
rwardn not,
ered ineouslyr easye bente foot
he softnosticsl andbeginundered up,overallses for
ill setdiatelyou try
ex softat wasone ofsimply
have
es.
ft footlarger
angledtweenuse allle, willurs, soay, by
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
25/27Copyright 2
entering ta significamachine fangular cand corredescribed.
On thend of thhigh soft f
system w
You mreasons efoot or sindirectlyfoot becafor soft fogearboxesMultiple
*See Formul
014 by LUDEC
e Front tont soft fooame. Any smponent t
ct any obs
other hanmachine,oot reading
ich assume
ay notice iplained onpport actss on a fourse this val
ot on machi.)
Footed M
a 2 on page 4.
, INC. www.lu
ack Foot di reading isoft foot thaits movemrved soft f
, a three-fn the axis os, because
readings t
the formulpage 5 anddirectly on
-footed mae should nnes whose
achines (
eca.com
stance as tobtained i
t occurs onent that willot conditi
oted machf the shaft,f the calcul
ken on a fo
a that theillustrated i the shafthine, thist be doubleet lie direc
achines w
e axial dist means ththe side ofbe readilyn accordin
ine whosesuch as shotion formul
ur-footed m
alue for thFigure 3. Ibecause itill produced. Therefortly under t
ith more t
Fig. 25
Fig. 24
nce from tt the softthe machinmeasuredg to the di
ingle foot iwn in Figura*for soft f
achine.
e observeda three-fo
is locatedan erroneoe, keep thise shaft cen
han four f
at foot to afoot conditie with twoy your laseragnostic pr
s located at24, may p
oot being a
angularity ited machin
directly uns value foreffect in mi
terline (as i
eet)
Page
ny of the oton is twistfeet alwayssystem. Di
inciples pre
the back ooduce abnpplied by t
s doubled,e where ther it, raththe calculatnd when csome pum
25 of 27
hers. Ifng thehas angnose
viously
r frontrmallye laser
for thesingle
r thaned softeckingps and
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
26/27Copyright 2
Unlessfooted mshould befeet.) Sincshaft aligonly suppthan threein a partarea of inf
the four accordingseen in athe overalappreciablcan be mlaser systefeet and sappears. Tthis is dintermediair gaps b
into consi
Vertical
If thebetter to lto take mionly oneair gap wi
014 by LUDEC
the machichine, withtightenedthese four
ment. Theyrt the mac
feet remaif the machluence of t
main suppto the air g0,000+ H.P.l mass of te strain reliasured wit
ms soft fomply feelerhis will reliene, proceete supportetween the
eration.
lange-Mo
support flaoosen all ofsalignmentt a time. If
th feeler ga
, INC. www.lu
e frame isthe followind all otherfeet are nesupport th
hine housintight while
ine framee four or m
ort points,p that wasDC motor f
he machineef or shaft
your laset readingsgauge eace localized
with thefeet as needrotor and
unted Ma
ge for a vethem excereadings. Cany bolt pouges and a
eca.com
very large,g caveats:support p
rest the bebearings a. Since thr
checking ahich cannoore feet tha
he rest ofmiked. If thor instance). In these
ovementsystem. T
ltogether afoot nearedistortionsalignment
ed. This aligtator of th
hines
rtically mot four, locateck each o
sition yieldsply the tra
these applienerally, t
ints loosenrings, theynd shaft me points d
ny other fobe relievet are still ti
the feet camachine i, the machiases, looset more diserefore, innd proceedt the bearihat mightof the manment procmachine, t
Fig. 26
nted motored at the cf these foura flange mitional dia
cations shoe four feed (whetherill have th
re directlyfine a plant. Otherwisby looseniht. Once s
simply bevery largee casing wi
ning any oant locatiothese applias follows:gs individue present achine by sedure shoulaking norm
has morerdinal clockpositions
ovement ofnostic prin
uld be treanearest thinboard ormost imm
han the res, it is impo
e, a distorting a foot lft foot has
feeler gauand heavy, (ll be very flne foot wills on theations, we
Loosen allally, and shit or near thimming th
d also accoal sag of th
than four bpositions aith a dial igreater thaiples for th
Page
ted like anbearing houtboard odiate influe
t of the feetant that nn may becated outsieen elimin
ed and shsuch as coxible in rela not produachine fradispense wf the interm any air gse locationese feet ant for any
e frame an
olts, it is prt which youdicator, loon 0.002", mbehavior
26 of 27
four-usingsf thesence onwhichmore
resentde theted at
immedmonlytion toce anye that
ith theediatep that. Onced theesiredrotor
obablyintendseningike theattern
-
8/10/2019 Machinery SoftFoot Causes Characteristics and Solutions
27/27
observed. The idea is to eliminate frame distortion by shimming these four points until no furthermovement occurs. Once this has been done, simply feeler gauge the remaining bolt positions withtheir respective bolts loose and shim accordingly. A different approach is to rotate your laseralignment system to a position 90 degrees from the bolt position you intend to test, and use theSoft Foot measurement function. Use the outside diameter of the motors support flange as theFront-to-Back Foot (FB) distance.
VIII. Conclusion
To sum up, measuring, diagnosing and correcting soft foot is as much an art as it is a science. Ifyou have read this far, you know by now that there is still plenty of room for trial and error in theprocess. However, a bit of common sense and a good visualization of why the machine is doingwhat its doing will take you a very long way down the road to eliminating the unnecessary trialsand errors in the soft foot correction process. This paper aimed to have provided you not only withan insight into the causes, characteristics, and possible solutions to various soft foot problems, butalso, and most importantly, with the mental tools to hone these visualization skills. The authorhopes he has succeeded.
top related