june 2020 monthly progress reporthartdocs.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/get/document-24008/june...
Post on 29-Sep-2020
1 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
HONOLULU RAIL TRANSIT PROJECT
June 2020 MONTHLY PROGRESS REPORT
www.HonoluluTransit.org
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
2 | P a g e
DISCLAIMER NOTICE This document is disseminated under the sponsorship of the United States Department of Transportation, Federal Transit Administration (FTA), in the interest of information exchange. The United States Government assumes no liability for the contents or use thereof. The United States Government does not endorse products or manufacturers. Any trade or manufacturers' names appear herein solely because they are considered essential to the contents of the report.
NO RELIANCE BY THIRD PARTIES This report and all subsidiary reports are prepared solely for the FTA, and should not be relied upon by any party, except the FTA, its Project Management Oversight Contractors (PMOC), and the Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation (HART) Board of Directors, in accordance with the purpose as described in the next section.
REPORT FORMAT AND FOCUS This document is submitted in compliance with the terms of FTA Contract No. DTFT60-09-D-00012, Task Order No. 2. Its purpose is to provide information and data to assist the FTA as it continually monitors HART's technical capability and capacity to execute a project efficiently and effectively, and hence, whether HART continues to be ready to receive federal funds for further project development. This document covers the project and quality management activities on the Honolulu Rail Transit Project managed by HART as the project sponsor and partially financed by the FTA under the Full Funding Grant Agreement (FFGA). Concurrent non-project activities and other items not covered by the FFGA may not be included.
INFORMATION REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS This document includes forward-looking information. The words "believe”, "anticipate", "expect", "intend", "aim", "plan", "predict", "continue", "assume", "positioned", "may", "will", "should", "shall", "risk" and any other similar expressions that are predictions of or indicate future events and future trends identifies forward-looking information. Forward-looking information includes all matters that are not historical facts. Readers should not place undue reliance on forward-looking information because it involves known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that are in many cases beyond HART's control. By its nature, forward-looking information involves risks and uncertainties because it relates to events and depends on circumstances that may or may not occur in the future. Forward-looking information is not a guarantee of future performance, and HART's actual results of operations, financial condition, and the development of the industry in which it operates may differ materially from those made in or suggested by forward-looking information contained in this document. The cautionary statements set forth above should be considered in connection with any subsequent forward-looking information that HART, or persons acting on its behalf, may issue. Factors that may cause HART's actual results to differ materially from those expressed or implied by the forward-looking statements in this document include but are not limited to the risks described in HART's annual report. For projects funded through the FTA's New Starts program, the FTA and its PMOC use a risk-based assessment process to review and validate a project sponsor's budget and schedule. Any results of an FTA or PMOC risk-based assessment represent a "snapshot in time" for a particular project under the conditions known at that same point in time. The status of any assessment may be altered at any time by new information, changes in circumstances, or further developments in the project. Furthermore, any forward looking statements contained in this document are made as of the date of this report, and HART does not undertake any obligation to update publicly or to revise any of the included forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise, except as expressly required by law. ON THE COVER: Left: Guideway construction on the eastern section of the alignment. Upper Right: Construction at the Honolulu International Airport Station site. Lower Right: West Loch Station construction.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
3 | P a g e
Table of Contents LIST OF ACRONYMS .......................................................................................................................................................................... 4 PROJECT MAP ................................................................................................................................................................................... 9 1 SUMMARY .............................................................................................................................................................................. 10 2 OVERALL PROJECT PROGRESS AND FINANCIALS ................................................................................................................... 13
2.1 Project Progress .................................................................................................................................................... 13 2.2 Project Budget ...................................................................................................................................................... 15 2.3 Project Funding ..................................................................................................................................................... 16
3 SCHEDULE .............................................................................................................................................................................. 18 4 CONTRACT STATUS ................................................................................................................................................................ 22
4.1 System-wide .......................................................................................................................................................... 24 4.2 Section I – West O'ahu/Farrington Highway: East Kapolei to Pearl Highlands ..................................................... 38 4.3 Section II – Kamehameha Highway: Pearl Highlands to Aloha Stadium ............................................................... 50 4.4 Section III – Airport: Aloha Stadium to Middle Street Transit Center Station ...................................................... 59 4.5 Section IV – City Center: Middle Street Transit Center Station to Ala Moana Center .......................................... 62 4.6 Professional Services ............................................................................................................................................. 70 4.7 Contract Status by Contract Packaging Plan (CPP) Number ................................................................................. 82
5 OVERALL PROJECT-WIDE ACTIVITIES ..................................................................................................................................... 84 5.1 Overall Key Issues ................................................................................................................................................. 84 5.2 Permits .................................................................................................................................................................. 85 5.3 Hawai'i Department of Transportation (HDOT) Agreements ............................................................................... 85 5.4 Utility Agreements ................................................................................................................................................ 86 5.5 Right-of-Way ......................................................................................................................................................... 88
6 MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE UPDATES ................................................................................................................. 97 6.1 Safety and Security (S&S) ...................................................................................................................................... 97 6.2 Quality Management .......................................................................................................................................... 101 6.3 Buy America Compliance (49 CFR 661 and 49 CFR 663) ..................................................................................... 103 6.4 Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) .......................................................................................................... 103 6.5 Art-in-Transit (AIT) Program ............................................................................................................................... 104 6.6 Planning and Environment .................................................................................................................................. 105 6.7 Risk Management ............................................................................................................................................... 107 6.8 Construction Claims ............................................................................................................................................ 115 6.9 Community Outreach .......................................................................................................................................... 115 6.10 Staffing ................................................................................................................................................................ 116 6.11 HART Baseline Plans and Procedures Status List ................................................................................................ 118 6.12 Readiness and Activation .................................................................................................................................... 121
APPENDICES ................................................................................................................................................................................. 123 A. Project Costs by SCC – Level 2 ............................................................................................................................ 124 B. Core Accountability Items Including Major Issues .............................................................................................. 126 C. Construction Progress Interim Opening ............................................................................................................. 127 D. Project Organization Chart ................................................................................................................................. 128
Table of Figures Figure 1. Overall Project Progress (% Complete) ..................................................................................................................................... 13 Figure 2. Construction Progress (% Complete) ........................................................................................................................................ 13 Figure 3. Design Progress (% Complete) .................................................................................................................................................. 14 Figure 4. Planned vs. Received Project Funding ...................................................................................................................................... 16 Figure 5. New Starts Drawdown by Federal Fiscal Year ........................................................................................................................... 17 Figure 6. HRTP Master Project Schedule Summary (MPSS) ..................................................................................................................... 21 Figure 7. Right-of-Way Status for the Parcels .......................................................................................................................................... 89 Figure 8. Relocation Status for the Occupants ......................................................................................................................................... 89 Figure 9. Temporary Construction Easements and Utility ....................................................................................................................... 90 Figure 10. Inter-Governmental Agreement Status .................................................................................................................................. 90 Figure 11. Cost Probability Curve, June 2020 Risk Data ......................................................................................................................... 113 Figure 12. Schedule Probability Curve, June 2020 Risk Data ................................................................................................................. 114 Figure 13. Staffing Activities .................................................................................................................................................................. 117
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
4 | P a g e
A&E Architect/Engineer AAN Accepted as Noted
AANR Accepted as noted, resubmit AC Asphalt Concrete
ACB Articulated Concrete Block ACHP Advisory Council on Historic Preservation
ACI Application Centric Infrastructure ACS Access Control System ADA Americans with Disabilities Act AFA Air Force Association AFE Authorized for Expenditure AG Attorney General
AGS Airport Guideway and Stations AIS Archaeological Inventory Survey AIT Art-in-Transit ALS Aloha Stadium Station
AMP Archaeological Monitoring Plan ANR Accepted as Noted–Resubmit APE Area of Potential Effect API Application Program Interface APS Auxiliary Power Supply
APTA American Public Transportation Association ARRA American Recovery and Reinvestment Act
ASG Airport Station Group ASI Architect Supplemental Information
ASTM American Society for Testing and Materials ASU Airport Section Utilities ATB Asphalt Treated Base
ATFAC Active Transportation and Food Access Committee ATC Automatic Train Control ATO Automatic Train Operation ATP Automatic Train Protection ATS Automatic Train Supervision AVA Anil Verma Associates, Inc. AVS Address Verification Systems
AW0 Assigned Weight, Empty Vehicle (rail car weight with no passengers) AW3 Assigned Weight, Crush Load (empty weight plus crush load of
standees) BA Buy America
BAC Buy America Compliance BACM Buy America Compliance Matrix BAFO Best and Final Offer
BANCT Best Available Noise Control Technology BAP Buy America Plan
BART Bay Area Rapid Transit BCS Balanced Cantilever System
BFMP Bus Fleet Management Plan BFS Budget and Fiscal Services BIC Ball in Court
BLNR Board of Land and Natural Resources BLS Blue Light Station
BMP Best Management Practice BOC Backup Operations Center BOD Board of Directors BOH Bank of Hawaii BPS Baseline Project Schedule BUE Bottom-Up Estimate
BUEG Back-up Emergency Generator BUILD Better Utilizing Investments to Leverage Development
BWS Board of Water Supply C2C Cost to Cure C&C City and County CAD Computer-Aided Design
CAM Construction Access Milestone CAP Corrective Action Plan CAR Corrective Actions
Cat Ex Categorical Exclusion CC2 City Center Phase 2 CC3 City Center Phase 3 CCC Contract Change Committee ccd Consecutive Calendar Days
CCGS City Center Guideway and Stations CCH City and County of Honolulu
CCO Contract Change Order CCTV Closed Circuit Television CCUG City Center Section Utilities and Guideway CCUR City Center Utilities Relocation
CDC Compendium of Design Criteria CDL Commercial Driver License CDR Conceptual Design Review
CDRL Contract Document Requirements List CEB Civil Engineering Branch CEI Construction Engineering and Inspection CEL Certifiable Elements List
CFM Configuration Management CFMP Configuration Management Plan
CFO Chief Financial Officer CHB Car History Book CIC Communication Interface Cabinet CID Customer Installation Department CIL Certifiable Items List CIP Cast-in-place CJA Condon‐Johnson & Associates
CLOMR Conditional Letter of Map Revision CLR Cultural Landscape Report
CLSM Controlled Low-strength Material CM Construction Manager
CMP Construction Management Plan CMS Contract Management System CMU Concrete Masonry Unit
CNMMP Construction Noise Mitigation and Monitoring Plan CO Change Order
COI Conflict of Interest COMMs Communications CONRAC Consolidated Rental Car Facility
COO Chief Operating Officer COR Corporation Counsel
CORP Central Oahu Regional Park CP Contractor Proposed
CPC Cost Proposals by Consultant CPM Critical Path Method CPO Chief Procurement Officer CPP Contract Packaging Plan
CR Consolidated Resolution CRM Customer-Relationship Management
CRMS Customer Relational Management System CROE Construction Right-of-Entry CRRB Car Readiness Review Board
CSC Core Systems Contractor CSCC Construction Specification Conformance Checklist
CSD Department of Customer Services CSDBOM Core System Design-Build-Operate-Maintain
CSL Cross Hole Sonic Logging CSOC Core Systems Oversight Consultant CSSC Core System Support Consultant
CSSM Construction Safety and Security Manager CSSP Construction Safety & Security Plan
CST Customer Service Terminal CTP Central Test Procedure CTS Communications Transmission System CW Contract-Wide
CWA Clean Water Act CWR Continuous Welded Rail
CWRM Commission on Water Resource Management CZM Coastal Zone Management D&C Design & Construction
DAGS Department of Accounting & General Services DAV Disabled American Veterans
DB Design-Build DBB Design-Bid-Build DBE Disadvantaged Business Enterprise
DBEDT Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism DBF Design-Build-Finance
DBFOM Design-Build-Finance-Operate-Maintain DBOM Design-Build-Operate-Maintain DCAB Disability and Communication Access Board
LIST OF ACRONYMS
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
5 | P a g e
DCCA Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs DCCC Design Criteria Conformance Checklists DCN Design Change Notice
DD Definitive Design DDC Department of Design and Construction
DDC-MED Department of Design & Construction-Mechanical & Electrical Division
DED Deputy Executive Director DES Department of Environmental Services
DF Direct Fixation DFF Direct Fixation Fastener
DFIM Design Furnish Install Maintain DFM Department of Facility Maintenance
DHHL Department of Hawaiian Homelands DHR Department of Human Resources DIT Department of Information Technology
DKSG Dillingham and Kaka'ako Station Group DLIR Hawai'i Department of Labor and Industrial Relations
DLNR Department of Land and Natural Resources DOE Department of Education DOH Department of Health DOJ Department of Justice DOL Department of Labor DOT Department of Transportation DPM Deputy Project Managers DPP Department of Planning and Permitting DPR Department of Parks and Recreation DPS Department of Public Safety DRH D.R. Horton
DS Downstream DSDC Design Services During Construction
DTS Department of Transportation Services DTU Dillingham Temporary Utilities DUF Division of Urban Forestry
DURP Department of Urban and Regional Planning DVT Design Verification Test E&E Elevators and Escalators E&O Errors and Omissions
EA Environmental Assessment EAC Estimate at Completion
EB East Bound EC Environmental Compliance
ECP Environmental Compliance Plan ED-CEO Executive Director and Chief Executive Officer
EDD Executive Decision Document E/E Elevator/Escalator EEC Elevators & Escalators Contractor
EHE-EHMP Environmental Hazard Evaluation and Environmental Hazard Management Plan
EIS Environmental Impact Statement EJ Expansion Joint
EKP East Kapolei EMC Electromagnetic Compatibility EMF Electromagnetic Forces EMI Electromagnetic Interference
EMP Emergency Management Panel EMR Elevator Machine Room EMT Electrical Metallic Tubing ENV City and County of Honolulu Department of Environmental Services
EOM End of Month EOR Engineer of Record EOS Electrically Operated Switch EPA Environmental Protection Agency EPB Emergency Push Button ERD Environmental Review Documents ESA Environmental Site Assessment ETA Estimated Time of Arrival ETC Estimate to Complete EV Expected Value
EVC Electronic Vehicle Counter FAA Federal Aviation Administration FACI First Article Configuration Inspection
FAI First Article Inspection FAR Floor Area Ratios
FAT Factory Acceptance Tests FC Fare Collection
FCC Federal Communications Commission FCN Field Change Notice FCU Fan Coil Units
FD Final Design FDAS Fire Detection Alarm System
FDC Field Design Change FDR Final Design Review FEIS Final Environmental Impact Statement
FEMA Federal Emergency Management Agency FFC Fixed Facility Contractor
FFGA Full Funding Grant Agreement FHB First Hawaiian Bank
FHSG Farrington Highway Station Group FHWA Federal Highway Administration
FISC Fleet and Industrial Supply Center FIT Field Integration Test
FLSWG Fire/Life-Safety Working Group FM Force Main
FMB Fasi Municipal Building FMEA Failure Modes and Effects Analysis
FMECA Failure Modes, Effects, and Criticality Analysis FO Fiber Optic
FOCN Fiber Optic Communication Network FOM Finding of Merit/No Merit
FP Fix Panel FPM Fix Panel Mono FPO Federal Preservation Officer FRB Failure Review Board FSC Fare Systems Contract FTA Federal Transit Administration FTB Fluidized Thermal Backfill FTE Full-Time Equivalent FUT Functional Unit Testing FWS Fish and Wildlife Service
FY Fiscal Year GAT Great Aleutian Tsunami GBS Gap Breaker Station GDR Geotechnical Data Report GEC General Engineering Consultant GER Geotechnical Engineering Report GET General Excise and Use Tax GGP General Growth Properties GIS Geographic Information System
GOE Grant of Easement GPR Ground Penetrating Radar GRP Glass Reinforced Plastic GSA General Services Administration
GT General Terms GW Guideway HA Hazard Analysis
HABS Historic American Buildings Survey HACBED Hawai‘i Alliance for Community-Based Economic Development
HAER Historic American Engineering Record HALS Historic American Landscape Survey HAR Hawai‘i Administrative Rules
HART Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation HCC Honolulu Community College
HCDA Hawai‘i Community Development Authority HCS Historic Context Studies
HCSD Hawai'i Capital Special District HDCC Hawaiian Dredging Construction Company HDD Horizontal Directional Drilling
HDOE Hawai'i Department of Education HDOH Hawai'i Department of Health HDOT Hawai'i Department of Transportation
HDOT-A Hawai'i Department of Transportation Airports Division HDPE High-density polyethylene HECO Hawaiian Electric Company
HEI High Energy Inc. HFD Honolulu Fire Department HH Handhole
HHC Howard Hughes Corp
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
6 | P a g e
HHF Historic Hawai'i Foundation HHFDC Hawaii Housing Finance & Development Corporation
HHM Hardy Heck Moore HHPRB Hawai'i Historic Places Review Board
HIA Honolulu International Airport HIE Hawaii Independent Energy
HILT Hawaiian Islands Land Trust HIOSH Hawaii Occupational Safety and Health Division
HOP Ho'opili HP Historic Preservation
HPC Historic Preservation Committee HPCA Historic Preservation Certification Application
HPCAT Historic Preservation & Cultural Awareness Training HPD Honolulu Police Department HPF Historic Preservation Fund HPL Horizon Partners Ltd. HPU Hawai‘i Pacific University HRH Hitachi Rail Honolulu Joint Venture
HRHP Hawai'i Register of Historic Places HRI Hitachi Rail Italy
HRR Heat Release Rate HRTP Honolulu Rail Transit Project HRU Hitachi Rail USA, Inc.
HSNWG Hawaiian Station Naming Working Group HSQE Health, Safety, Quality and Environment
HSSQE Health Safety Security Quality and Environment HTI Hawaiian Telcom HTL Hazard Tracking Log HV High Voltage
HVAC Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning I&T Inspection & Testing
IAMR Interstate Access Modification Report IBEW International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers
IC Interim Certification ICCS Integrated Communications Control System ICD Interface Control Documents ICE Independent Cost Estimate
ICM Interface Control Manual ICWG Interim Certification Working Group
IDIQ Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity IDS Intrusion Detection System IFB Issued for Bid IFC Issued for Construction
IJ Isolation Joint IMP Interface Management Plan
INMS Integrated Network Management System I/O Interim Opening
IOMP Intermediate Operations and Maintenance Period IP Implementing Procedures
IRTP Individual Role Training Plans ITP Inspection and Test Plan ITS Intelligent Transportation Systems IVR Interactive Voice Response
JB Junction Box JTMC Joint Traffic Management Center JTMS Joint Traffic Management System JU&O Joint Use & Occupancy JUOA Joint Use and Occupancy Agreement
JV Joint Venture KCC Kapi‘olani Community College
KCDD Kaka'ako Community Development District KCH Kanehili Cultural Hui KHG Kamehameha Highway Guideway KHR Kamehameha Highway Resurfacing
KHSG Kamehameha Highway Station Group KIWC Kiewit Infrastructure West Company KKJV Kiewit/Kobayashi Joint Venture
KPI Key Performance Indicator KVIBE Kalihi Valley Instructional Bike Exchange KVM Keyboard Monitor Mouse
L+E Lea +Elliott LCC Leeward Community College LCP Local Control Panel LD Lagoon Drive
LDS Latter Day Saints LEED Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design
LF Linear Feet LOO Letter of Offer
LOTB Log of Test Borings LPR License Plate Reader LRV Light Rail Vehicle
LT Load Test LTC Load Tap Changer LV Low Voltage
LVPS Low Voltage Power Supply MAI Mason Architects MCY Makai Casting Yard MDS Mobile Data System MED Mechanical/Electrical Division MEP Mechanical, Electrical and Plumbing MH Manhole
MIM Manufacture-Install-Maintain MIP Manufacturing and Inspection Plans
MITT Multimodal Integration Technical Team MMIS Maintenance Management Information System MMP Mitigation Monitoring Program MOA Memorandum of Agreement MOS Minimum Operable Segment MOT Maintenance of Traffic MOU Memorandum of Understanding
MOW Maintenance of Way MPD Multiple Property Documentation MPIS Master Project Integrated Schedule MPS Master Project Schedule
MPSS Master Project Schedule Summary MPV Multiple Purpose Vehicle MPY Makai Precast Yard MS4 Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System
MSDS Material Safety Data Sheet MSE Mechanically Stabilized Earth MSF Maintenance and Storage Facility MSP Maintenance Service Plan
MSTC Middle Street Transit Center MSTCS Middle Street Transit Center Station
MTM Modern Track Machineries MV Medium Voltage
NAICS North American Industry Classification System NCE Non-Conformance Evaluation NCR Non-Conformance Report NDC Notice of Design Change
NEPA National Environmental Policy Act NFPA National Fire Protection Association NGO Non-governmental Organization NHL National Historic Landmark NOI Notice of Intent
NPDES National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System NPS National Park Service
NPW Non-Potable Waterline NR National Register
NRHP National Register of Historic Places NSM Negotiation Strategy Memo NTE Not to Exceed NTP Notice to Proceed NTS Network Time Server
NUC Next Unit of Computing O&M Operations and Maintenance
OahuMPO Oahu Metropolitan Planning Organization OCC Operations Control Center
OCCC Oahu Community Correctional Center OCCL Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands OCIP Owner-Controlled Insurance Program ODC Other Direct Costs
OEQC Office of Environmental Quality Control OH Overhead
OHA Office of Hawaiian Affairs OIBC O'ahu Island Burial Council
OIC Officer-in-Charge OIL Open Items List
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
7 | P a g e
OIP Order of Immediate Possession OMP Operation and Management Plan
OMPO Oahu Metropolitan Planning Organization OP Oversight Procedure
OR&L Oahu Railway & Land Co. ORCC Operational Readiness Conformance Checklist
OSB Operations and Servicing Building OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration
OSIT On-Site Inspection Test OSM Owner Supplied Materials
OTDR Optical Time Domain Reflectometer OTR One-Time Review OTS Oahu Transit Services
OTW Oceanic Time Warner OTWC Oceanic Time Warner Cable OWG Operation Working Group
P3 Public-Private Partnership PA Programmatic Agreement
PAIS Programmatic Agreement Implementation Schedule PARs Preventative Actions PAT Production Acceptance Test
PB Parsons Brinckerhoff, Inc. PCCP Portland Cement Concrete Pavement
PCI Payment Card Industry PCN Potential Change Notice PCY Precast Yard PD Position Description
PDR Preliminary Design Review PE Preliminary Engineering PF Power Frequency
PFP Project Financial Plan PGC Pacific Guardian Center PHA Preliminary Hazard Analysis
PHGTC Pearl Highlands Parking Garage and Transit Center PHL Pearl Highlands Station
PHNB Pearl Harbor Naval Base PHPR Pearl Highlands Park and Ride
PHPTR Pearl Highlands Parking Structure, Transit Center and Ramp H2R1 PHS Pearl Harbor Station
PI Public Involvement PICM Project Interface Control Manual
PID Parcel Identification Number PIG Permitted Interaction Group PIM Project Interface Manager PIP Public Involvement Plan PIS Passenger Information Systems
PLA Project Labor Agreement PLO Priority-Listed Offerors PLR Pearlridge Station PM Project Managers
PMC Project Management Consultant PMIM Project Management and Interface Management PMO Project Management Oversight
PMOC Project Management Oversight Contractor PMP Project Management Plan
PMSC Program Management Support Consultant PNR Park-and-Ride POC Project Oversight Committee POP Period of Performance POS Point of Sales PPE Personal Protective Equipment
PRTCC Pre-revenue Testing Conform Checklist PSC Personal Services Contract PSG Platform Screen Gate
PSGS Platform Screen Gate System PSIT Pre-shipment Inspection Test PSS Public Sector Solutions PT Post-tensioned
PTG Parsons Transportation Group PUA Possession and Use Agreements PUC Public Utilities Commission PUP Property Utilization Plan
PV Passenger Vehicle QA Quality Assurance
QAM Quality Assurance Manager QAP Quality Assurance Plan
QC Quality Control QMP Quality Management Plan QMS Quality Management System QTF Quality Task Force QTO Quantity Takeoff R&A Readiness and Activation R&R Revise & Re-submit
RA Risk Assessment RAC Rail Activation Committee
RAMP Real Estate Acquisition Management Plan RAP Rail Activation Plan RAT Routine Acceptance Test
RC Reinforced Concrete RCMP Risk and Contingency Management Plan
RCP Reinforced Concrete Pipe RE Resident Engineer
READ Real Estate Acquisition Database REC Real Estate Consultant RFB Request for Bids RFC Request for Change
RFCC Request for Change from Contractor RFCR Request for Change by HART RFHB Request for High Bids
RFI Request for Information RFID Request for Interface Data
RFMP Rail Fleet Management Plan RFP Request for Proposals RFQ Request for Qualifications RFV Request for Variance RHB Road and Highway Builders, LLC RLB Rider Levett Bucknall RLS Request for Legal Services
RMS Risk Management System RMTC R.M. Towill Corporation
RNR Revise and Resubmit ROC Rail Operations Center ROD Record of Decision ROE Right of Entry ROH Revised Ordinances of Honolulu
ROM Rough Order of Magnitude ROW Right-of-Way
RP Recovery Plan RR Risk Register
RSD Revenue Service Date RST Retail Sales Device Training RTE Request to Exceed Negotiation Strategy Memo Target
RTM Requirements Traceability Matrix RTSA Rapid Transit Stabilization Agreement
RVB+A Raul V. Bravo + Associates, Inc. S&S Safety and Security
S1 Segment 1 SA Supplemental Agreement
SAIS Supplemental Archaeological Inventory Survey SAMP System Assurance Monitoring Plan
SAT Site Acceptance Test SAV Shared Autonomous Vehicle
SC Substantial Completion SCADA Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition
SCAP Stream Channel Alteration Permit SCC Standard Cost Category SCH Satellite City Hall SDC Services During Construction
SHPD State Historic Preservation Division SHPO State Historic Preservation Officer
SIC Sandwich Isle Communications SIRP Safety Incident Review Panel
SIT System Integration Testing SITP System Integration and Test Plan SITR Site Inspection and Test Report
SL Street Light SLAN Secured Local Area Network
SLR Sea Level Rise
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
8 | P a g e
SM Service Manager SMA Special Management Area SMS Structural Monitoring Solutions SOG Slab on Grade SOI Secretary of the Interior
SON Summary of Negotiations SOP Standard Operating Procedures
SOW Scope of Work SP Special Provisions
SQP Supplemental Quality Plan SS System Site
SSA System Service Availability SSC Safety Security Certification
SSCP Safety and Security Certification Plan SSCWG Safety and Security Certification Working Group
SSI Sensitive Security Information SSMP Safety and Security Management Plan SSRC Safety and Security Review Committee SSSP Site Safety Security Plan
STATCOM Static Synchronous Compensator STCC Specification Testing Conformance Checklists STCH Sustainable Transportation Coalition of Hawai‘i
STG Shimmick/Traylor/Granite, Joint Venture STP System Test Procedure
SUBD Subdivision Branch SUE Subsurface Utility Engineering
SuMo Sustainable Mobility SuMoLab Sustainable Mobility Lab
SWPPP Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan SwRI Southwest Research Institute T&C Test & Commissioning
T&M Time and Material TAB Testing and Balancing TAC Transit Art Committee TAP Track Allocation Procedure TAT Transient Accommodation Tax
TC Train Control TCA Temporary Configuration Change
TCCR Train Control and Communications Room TCE Temporary Construction Easement TCO Temporary Certificate Occupancy TCP Traffic Control Plan TCS Train Control System
TDFM Travel Demand Forecasting Model TDM Transportation Demand Management
TES Traction Electrification System TIA Time Impact Analysis
TIGER Transportation Investment Generating Economic Recovery TIP Transportation Improvement Program
TMK Tax Map Key TMP Traffic Management Plan
TO Task Order TOC The Outdoor Circle TOD Transit-Oriented Development
TP Technical Provision TP&R Temporary Park & Ride TPBG Traction Power Backup Generator
TPBuGen Traction Power Backup Generator TPO Thermoplastic Polyolefin
TPSS Traction Power Substation TS Traffic Signal
TSA Transportation Security Administration TSI Transportation Safety Institute
TTSP Temporary Traffic Signal Plan TUT Temporary Utility Take TVA Threat and Vulnerability Assessment
TVM Ticket Vending Machine TWF Train Wash Facility UCA Utility Construction Agreement
UFRCRA Utility Facilities Relocation and Cost Reimbursement Agreement UG Underground UH University of Hawai'i
UHPRB UH West O‘ahu Park and Ride & UHWO Campus Road “B” UHWO University of Hawai'i West O'ahu
UL Underwriters Laboratories UPS Uninterruptible Power Supply URA Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition
Policies Act USACE U.S. Army Corps of Engineers USDOE U.S. Department of Energy USDOL United States Department of Labor USDOT U.S. Department of Transportation
USN United States Navy USPS U.S. Postal Service
UST Underground Storage Tank UTR Under Technical Review VAR Volt-Ampere Reactive VCR Vertical Conduit Raceway
VE Value Engineering VECP Value Engineering Change Proposal
VISTA Volunteers in Service to America VMS Variable Message Sign VRC Vertical Raceway Column
VRCS Voice Radio Communication System VRF Variable Refrigerant Flow VTP Vehicle Test Procedure WA Work Area
WCS Wireless Communication System WHS Waipahu High School
WKM Walters, Kimoda, Motoda, Inc. WL West Loch
WLO West Loch WOEDA West Oahu Economic Development Association
WOFH West O'ahu/Farrington Highway WOSG West O'ahu Station Group
WQC Water Quality Certification WSS West Side Stations
WSSG West Side Stations Groups WTB Wheel Truing Building WTC Waipahu Transit Center WTP Wayside Test Procedure
WWB Wastewater Branch WWPS Wastewater pump station
WYL West Yard Lead YCB Yard Control Bungalow YKE Yogi Kwong Engineers YOE Year of Expenditure
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
9 | P a g e
PROJECT MAP
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
10 | P a g e
1 SUMMARY
REPORTING DATE AND SUBSEQUENT EVENTS This report was published on July 31, 2020, for the PMOC meeting scheduled for Aug. 12, 2020. Data is presented with a reporting cutoff
date of June 30, 2020, unless otherwise noted.
KEY ACTIVITIES IN JUNE Project Overview All seven of the trains that will be a part of the interim opening fleet are in the testing and commissioning phase. Segment 1 of the rail line is completely energized, and trains are actively being tested between Kualaka‘i (East Kapolei) Station and Hālawa (Aloha Stadium) Station. Record Column Foundation Constructed Airport Guideway and Stations (AGS) contractor Shimmick/Traylor/Granite, Joint Venture (STG) successfully constructed what is believed to be the world’s deepest and largest column foundation. At a depth of 357 feet, 4 inches, and measuring 10 feet in diameter, the column foundation is located in Kalihi Stream on Kamehameha Highway between Middle Street and Pu‘uhale Road. It will be used as a base for a column which will support the rail’s elevated guideway and the Kahauiki (Middle Street Transit Center) Station. The column’s depth at this location was needed to ensure that the station and guideway would be built on a solid underground foundation. Art Poster Contest At the June Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation (HART) Board of Directors meeting, HART recognized 12 winners of its 2020 Art Poster Contest. Nearly 90 entries were received, and posters were judged based on artistic merit, originality, and incorporation of the theme, “Welcome Aboard Next-Gen Riders,” which allowed submitters to highlight how enjoyable riding the trains will be.
COST (as of June 30, 2020)
Project Cost Summary ($ in millions)
Description Original FFGA
Budget Recovery Plan
Budget* Current Estimate at Completion (EAC)*
Incurred To Date
Project Capital Costs
Base Cost without Contingency $4,305 $7,312 $7,761 $4,306
Allocated Contingency $542 $765 $316** $0
Unallocated Contingency $102 $222 $88 $0
Total Project Capital Costs $4,949 $8,299 $8,165 $4,306
FFGA Finance Charges $173 $609 $547 $44
Total FFGA Project Costs $5,122 $8,908 $8,712 $4,350
Post-RSD Finance Charges $42 $231 $293 $0
Total Project Costs $5,164 $9,139 $9,005 $4,350 *Total Project Costs excludes Operations and Maintenance. **Please refer to the "Current Estimate at Completion" write up for further explanation.
Original FFGA Budget The Original FFGA Budget reflects the full build-out of the project as executed by the Full Funding Grant Agreement in December 2012. The contingency is a reserve to cover known and unknown, but anticipated, project execution costs and uncertainty due to risk factors such as unresolved design issues, unknown site conditions, schedule impacts and market fluctuations. The Original FFGA Budget reflects $644 million in total contingency.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
11 | P a g e
Recovery Plan Budget Total The approved Recovery Plan Project capital cost estimate is $8,299 million (excluding finance costs). The total project cost is $9,139 million, which includes post-Revenue Service Date (RSD) financing costs of $231 million and $8,908 million in FFGA project costs (which includes $765 million in allocated contingency, $222 million in unallocated contingency, and $609 million in financing costs). While this cost is $134 million greater than HART’s cost estimate of $8,165 million, HART has revised the Project cost estimate and identified the additional funding to meet the higher estimate. The Recovery Plan Budget reflects $987 million of total contingency or 13% of the base cost estimate which reflects available funding capacity. Based on FTA requirements on contingency for the current phase of the project, the 13% is sufficient reserve to cover against the risk of cost increases during development of the project. Current Estimate at Completion (EAC) The current project capital Estimate at Completion (EAC) is $8,712 million, including $404 million in total contingency ($316 million in allocated contingency and $88 million in unallocated contingency) and $547 million in financing costs. The total project costs including post-Revenue Service Date (RSD) financing costs of $293 million is $9,005 million. The total project contingency is based on a September 2026 RSD. At the May 2020 HART Board Project Oversight Committee meeting, a new EAC of $8,210 million, due to an increase in CCUR costs, was discussed. The CCUR costs have been incorporated this reporting period. HART is currently conducting an analysis of contingency levels per contract. The revised EAC will be reflected once the contingency analysis is completed. The Project budget continues to be forecast below the Recovery Plan values. Incurred to Date The Incurred-to-date costs are cumulative through June 2020, and exclude third-party reimbursement costs. The $4,350 million to date represents 56% of the base Current EAC. The Incurred-to-date costs increased by $77 million for the period. SCHEDULE The progress reported in the table below provides percent complete based on construction and design contracts. The early and late plans are based on baseline schedules for active contracts and forecasts of future contracts.
Project Progress* Through June 26, 2020
Actual Early Plan Late Plan
Overall Project Progress 58.8% 69.8% 63%
Construction Progress 54.5% 66% 60%
Design Progress 80.6% 82.6% 79.7%
*Reported percentages complete are based on the Estimate at Completion for the MOS and
December 2025 RSD. HART will revise its progress curves further when the in-progress change orders are executed and remaining construction projects are awarded and baselined. This
revision is expected to lower the plan values.
PROGRESS REPORT SUMMARY OF CHANGES The following is a brief summary of major changes that have occurred from the previous month’s report. For more information and detail, please refer to the respective pages in the report. Contract Status Core Systems Contract (CSC)
o The projected completion of work date has changed from July 2025 to March 2026. Please see page 24. o The schedule status has changed from “On time for 2025 opening” to “On time for 2026 opening.” Please
see page 24.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
12 | P a g e
Traction Power Backup Generators o A contract page for the MI-940 Traction Power Backup Generators contract has been included. Please see
page 30-31.
Fare Collection System o The projected completion of design-build work date has changed from December 2025 to March 2026.
Please see page 34.
Farrington Highway Station Group (FHSG) o The contract substantial completion date has changed from January 2019 to June 2020 due to a change
order. Please see page 45. o The projected completion of work date has changed from July 2020 to September 2020. Please see page
45. o The schedule status has changed from “18 month behind” to “3 months behind.” Please see page 45.
Kamehameha Highway Station Group (KHSG)
o The current contract value amount has increased due to a change order. Please see page 52.
Kamehameha Highway Resurfacing (KHR) o The projected completion of work date has changed from July 2020 to August 2020. Please see page 55. o The schedule status has changed from “10 months behind” to “11 months behind.” Please see page 55.
Airport Section Guideway and Stations (AGS)
o The current contract value amount has increased due to a change order. Please see page 59.
City Center Utilities Relocation (CCUR) Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ) o The projected completion of relocation work date has changed from December 2022 to February 2023.
Please see page 65. o The schedule status has changed from “7 months behind” to “9 months behind.” Please see page 65.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
13 | P a g e
2 OVERALL PROJECT PROGRESS AND FINANCIALS
2.1 Project Progress (data as of June 26, 2020) Reported percentages complete are based on the Estimate at Completion for the MOS and December 2025 RSD. HART will revise its progress curves further when the in-progress change orders are executed and remaining construction projects are awarded and baselined. This revision is expected to lower the plan values. Note:
Actual = Actual cost of work performed, based on reported work-in-place.
Early Plan = Earliest dates activities can begin and finish, based on logic and durations used in the schedule.
Late Plan = Latest dates activities can begin and finish and not have an impact on completion date, based on logic and durations used in the schedule.
Figure 1. Overall Project Progress (% Complete)
At present "overall" project progress is based on the weighted value progress of the individual construction and design contracts (Design-Build [DB], Design-Bid-Build [DBB], Design-Build-Operate-Maintain [DBOM], Elevator/Escalator Manufacture-Install-Test-Maintain [MIM], Final Design [FD] and DB-DBOM design levels of effort), not including City or non-design consultant labor.
Figure 2. Construction Progress (% Complete)
Overall construction progress is based on the weighted average progress of the individual DBB and E/E MIM construction contracts and the DB-DBOM construction levels of effort, not including consultant Construction Engineering and Inspection (CEI) services.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
14 | P a g e
Figure 3. Design Progress (% Complete)
Overall design progress is based on the weighted average progress of the individual FD contracts and the design levels of effort of the DB and DBOM construction contracts, not including City or non-design consultant labor.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
15 | P a g e
2.2 Project Budget (data as of June 30, 2020)
Project Cost Summary ($ in millions)
Description Original FFGA
Budget Recovery Plan
Budget* Current Estimate at Completion (EAC)*
Project Capital Costs
Base Cost without Contingency $4,305 $7,312 $7,761
Allocated Contingency $542 $765 $316**
Unallocated Contingency $102 $222 $88
Total Project Capital Costs $4,949 $8,299 $8,165
FFGA Finance Charges $173 $609 $547
Total FFGA Project Costs $5,122 $8,908 $8,712
Post-RSD Finance Charges $42 $231 $293
Total Project Costs $5,164 $9,139 $9,005 *Total Project Costs excludes Operations and Maintenance. **Please refer to the write up below for further explanation.
The Original FFGA Budget reflects the full build-out of the project as executed by the Full Funding Grant Agreement in December 2012. The approved Recovery Plan Project capital cost estimate is $8,299 million (excluding finance costs). While this cost is $134 million greater than HART’s cost estimate of $8,165 million, HART has revised the Project cost estimate and identified the additional funding to meet the higher estimate. At the May 2020 HART Board Project Oversight Committee meeting, a new EAC of $8,210 million, due to an increase in CCUR costs, was discussed. The CCUR costs have been incorporated this reporting period. HART is currently conducting an analysis of contingency levels per contract. The revised EAC will be reflected once the contingency analysis is completed. The Project budget continues to be forecast below the Recovery Plan values. Total project contingency decreased to $404 million ($316 million in allocated contingency and $88 million in unallocated contingency) since last updated.
Contingency Drawdown Curve
Date Sep-2020 Mar-2021 Dec-2021 Feb-2023 Jun-2025 Sep-2026
Milestone P3 NTP Interim
Opening
DB450 Construction
Complete
DBB511 Construction
Complete
P3 Construction
Complete RSD
FTA Minimum Level ($M)
638
546
462
375
174
32
HART Minimum Level ($M)
504
412
328
241
108
8
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
16 | P a g e
2.3 Project Funding
Figure 4. Planned vs. Received Project Funding
Planned vs. Received Project Funding
Funding Source
Pre-FFGA Project1
Project Funding Total
Project
2007 - 2009 Actuals
Received
Planned2 2009 -
Present Actuals
Received
2007 - Present Actuals
Received
Actuals Received in June 2020 ($YOE M)
Beginning Project Cash Balance3 - 298 298 - -
Interest Income on Cash Balance5 7 1 9 16 0
FTA Section 5309 New Starts Revenue4 - 1,550 806 806 -
ARRA Funds - 4 4 4 -
EPA Brownfields Grant (FY2018-FY2021)6 - 1 0 0 -
Net General Excise Tax (GET) Surcharge revenues FY2010-FY2031 378 5,990 2,350 2,728
-
Transient Accommodation Tax (TAT) revenue FY2018-FY2031 - 1,182 130 130
-
City Subsidy - HART Administration FY2018-FY2031 - 214 69 69 -
Total 385 9,240 3,667 3,754 0
1 GET and Interest Income received during Pre-Preliminary Engineering (pre-PE) phase prior to entry into PE. 2 Updated to Chapter 6 - Project Finance, Figure 6-2 of HART's Approved Recovery Plan (for beginning cash balance, GET, TAT, grant revenue, city subsidy and interest income).
3 Beginning Project Cash Balance at Entry into Preliminary Engineering (PE) on October 16, 2009 (the FFGA Project start date) = Pre-PE GET, investment and miscellaneous income minus pre-PE expenditures. The $298 million is included in the Pre-FFGA actual amounts received between 2007-2009 of $378 million.
4 New Starts Funds Obligated Through Federal Fiscal Year 2014 Totals $806.3 million. 5 Interest Income received in June 2020 - $257,057.68
6 EPA $900,000 Brownfields Grant must be used by 12/31/2020 - to plan and subsidize the environmental cleanup activities.
EPA Brownfields Grant revenue received to date - $55,260.87
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
17 | P a g e
Figure 5. New Starts Drawdown by Federal Fiscal Year
New Starts Grant Information by Federal Fiscal Year (Amounts in Italics are Pending)
Federal Fiscal Year (FFY) Allocation
FTA Obligated Amounts
Actual Drawdown Amounts to Date
Available Balance FFGA Base Case Cash Flow
2008 $15,190,000 $15,190,000 $0
2009 $19,800,000 $19,800,000 $0
2010 $30,000,000 $30,000,000 $0
2011 $55,000,000 $55,000,000 $0 $20,607,242
2012 $200,000,000 $200,000,000 $0 $99,382,758
2013 $236,277,358 $236,277,358 $0 $258,280,277
2014 $250,000,000 $249,991,376 $8,624 $441,719,724
2015* $250,000,000 $0 $0 $0
2016* $250,000,000 $0 $0 $0
2017* $243,732,642 $0 $0 $0
2018 $0 $0 $0 $0
2019 $0 $0 $0 $0
2020 $0 $0 $100,000,000 $100,000,000
2021 $0 $0 $150,000,000 $150,000,000
2022 $0 $0 $150,000,000 $150,000,000
2023 $0 $0 $150,000,000 $150,000,000
2024 $0 $0 $100,000,000 $100,000,000
2025 $0 $0 $50,000,000 $50,000,000
2026 $0 $0 $43,732,642 $30,010,000
Total $1,550,000,000 $806,258,734 $743,741,266 $1,550,000,000
Note: * The funds for years 2015, 2016 and 2017 have not yet been obligated. The amounts represent the allocation for the fiscal year noted in the first column. No moneys can be drawn on awards not yet obligated.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
18 | P a g e
3 SCHEDULE (data as of June 26, 2020)
Critical Path Analysis Interim Revenue Service Date is planned for no earlier than March 31, 2021. The Projected Revenue Service date,
currently forecasted for March 4, 2021, defines operational readiness of the system. The Department of Transportation Services (DTS) makes the final determination of passenger service.
o In the June 2020 update, forecasted completion of operational readiness has been extended by 9 days due to a later forecasted canopy completion date at Aloha Stadium Station.
o The critical path for the Operational Readiness of the passenger rail system from East Kapolei Station to Aloha Stadium Station is the fabrication, delivery, and installation of canopy arms, as well as the follow-on communications cables installation at Aloha Stadium Station, and Core Systems testing activities.
o For the near critical path, activities include communications subsystem acceptance, as well as Fire Detection Alarm System (FDAS) testing and the Functional testing of the west side stations.
The Recovery Plan Revenue Service Date (RSD) is Sept. 1, 2026. The Projected Revenue Service date, currently
forecasted for March 16, 2026, defines operational readiness of the system. DTS makes the final determination of passenger service.
o Given uncertainties arising as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and the need to incorporate proper buffer in access dates provided to the P3 developers in order to de-risk the project, the operational readiness of the final segment, previously forecasted as Dec. 31, 2025, continues to be March 16, 2026. Actual schedule will be set once a contract with the P3 developer has been established.
o The critical path begins with completion of Kapalama utility bridge design, construction of the Kapalama utility bridge, and utility relocation work (AT&T, Hawaiian Electric Company [HECO] 46kV, Hawaiian Telcom, Oceanic Time Warner Cable) in City Center Utilities Relocation (CCUR) Area 1C. After the utility relocation is complete, drilled shafts, columns and segments for Area 1C continue into platform and structure construction for Kapalama Station, followed by Core Systems installation and testing.
o The near critical path includes completion of design packages and permit approvals in Area 1B, Right Of Way acquisition of a property required for utility relocation work, and procurement of the Public-Private Partnership (P3)/City Center Guideway and Stations (CCGS) contract.
Three-Month Look Ahead Station construction for the west station groups continues to include the following:
o Canopies: The Aloha Stadium canopy steel is scheduled to be received mid-July and installed by mid-August. The Aloha Stadium tension fabric is forecasted to be installed in mid-October. These activities are on the critical path for Kamehameha Highway Station Group substantial completion.
o University of Hawai‘i West O‘ahu (UHWO) Temporary Park and Ride (“Road B”): Close out outstanding submittals and quality test reports. Finalize verification of remaining punchlist items. Road B lighting testing and irrigation testing are pending HECO meter installation.
o Elevators and Escalators: Complete installation of Pearlridge Station Escalators #1 and 2. Complete installation of Pearl Highlands Station Elevators #1 and 2 and remaining escalators. Complete installation of Aloha Stadium Station Elevators #1 and 2. Continue to perform commissioning activities in preparation for State elevator inspections. Continue construction interface for Airport Guideway and Stations (AGS).
CSC
o Continue System Integration Testing in the Functional Section. o Complete Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) installation for Aloha Stadium Station and
commence SCADA testing at West O‘ahu and Farrington Highway Station Groups. o Install and test Platform Screen Gate System (PSGS) at Kamehameha Highway Station Group (KHSG). o Complete COMM (Closed Circuit Television [CCTV]/Access Control System [ACS]-Intrusion Detection System
[IDS]) installation and testing at West O‘ahu and Farrington Highway Station Groups.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
19 | P a g e
o Complete installations of the Mobile Data System (MDS) network for the west side stations. o Complete Segment 1 Wayside Automatic Train Control (ATC) testing. o Seven (7) Segment 1 trains will be ready for system integration testing.
AGS
o Reach A: Complete utility relocations. Complete traffic signal conduit work on Kamehameha Highway at Halawa, Radford and Center Drive. Complete installation of the sidewalk, curb, and gutter at Halawa Drive and Kamehameha Highway.
o Reach B: Complete wet utility relocations. Continue column and pier cap work. Continue span erection. o Reach C: Continue guideway foundations. Continue column and pier cap work. Complete Aolele Street and
Nimitz roadwork. Complete underground utility relocations for street lights, water and drainage. Continue span erection.
o Reach D: Complete infrastructure for Hawaiian Telcom (HTI) and Oceanic Time Warner Cable (OTWC) communication utilities relocations on Ualena Street with the implementation of nightly Maintenance of Traffic (MOT). Continue utility relocations for street lights, water and drainage. Continue column and pier cap work.
o Reach E: Continue guideway foundations. Continue column and pier cap work. Continue column rebar erection and formwork. Continue segment erection. Continue utility relocation work. Complete HECO Zone 9 construction.
o Pearl Harbor Station (Makalapa): Complete platform girder reinforcing steel installation. Complete underground site utilities. Continue electrical rough-in work.
o Airport Station (Lelepaua): Complete foundations for elevator and escalator pits. Continue underground conduit installation and plumbing. Begin Train Control and Communications Room (TCCR) foundations.
o Lagoon Station (Āhua): Complete TCCR building construction. Complete station structural steel erection. Complete site utility, water, sewer, and storm connections.
o Middle Street Station (Kahauiki): Begin electrical rough-in work at TCCR. Excavate station entrance and elevator pit. Complete foundations for elevator and escalator pits. Commence station structural steel erection. Complete pedestrian bridge column hammerhead construction.
CCUR
o Area 1A (Middle to Mokauea): Order HECO long lead 138kV utility poles. Start 12kV critical dry utility infrastructure work. Complete AT&T communication infrastructure work. Start 138kV underground (UG) infrastructure work.
o Area 1B (Mokauea to Waiakamilo): Finalize wet and dry design and receive permits for wet utility task order 02 and dry utility task order 22. Complete critical Area 1B drainage box culvert modifications. Commence Dillingham 1B controlled access. Finalize Kapalama Stream crossing design.
o Area 1C (Waiakamilo to Ka‘aahi): Finalize dry design and receive permits for dry utility task orders 25 and 26. Commence Dillingham 1C controlled access.
o Area 2 (Ka‘aahi): Complete all wet utility relocations. Complete all dry utility jet grouting soil stabilization work. Continue 12kV critical dry utility infrastructure work. Start communication infrastructure work.
o Area 3 (Nimitz): Complete all wet utility relocations. Finalize dry design and receive permits for dry utility task order 27. Complete all dry utility jet grouting soil stabilization work. Start dry utility infrastructure work for 12kV and 25kV.
o Area 4 (Halekauwila): Finalize dry design and receive permits for dry utility task order 32. Complete dry utility jet grouting soil stabilization work.
o Area 5 (Queen): Finalize dry design and receive permits for dry utility task order 17. Complete all wet utility relocations. Complete all dry utility jet grouting soil stabilization work. Start 12kV dry utility infrastructure work.
o Area 6 (Kona): Finalize dry design and receive permits for dry utility task order 28. Complete all dry utility jet grouting soil stabilization work. Start 12kV critical dry utility infrastructure work.
CCGS
o Technical and price submittal.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
20 | P a g e
Key Schedule Issues AGS’ Shimmick/Traylor/Granite, Joint Venture (STG) mitigation schedule has been Accepted as Noted and is
currently showing a December 2021 completion date. The contractor is required to respond to review comments and uphold commitments for schedule improvement over the next few months as outlined in the conditional acceptance letter in order to alleviate further delays, as well as work towards the current contractual completion date.
The AGS contractor submitted a Time Impact Analysis (TIA) schedule in October, requesting a schedule extension and time-related overhead costs. Construction Engineering and Inspection (CEI) and HART reviewed and responded to the TIA schedule.
Schedule Contingency Drawdown Curve
The graph has been updated from the May 2020 Monthly Progress Report to match the current contingency.
The critical path begins with completion of Kapalama utility bridge design, construction of the Kapalama utility bridge, and utility relocation work (AT&T, HECO 46kV, Hawaiian Telcom, Oceanic Time Warner Cable) in CCUR Area 1C. After the utility relocation is complete, drilled shafts, columns and segments for Area 1C continue into platform and structure construction for Kapalama Station, followed by Core Systems installation and component testing and Full System Integration Testing, Trial Run and Pre-Revenue Service Demonstration achieving operational readiness date for Segment 3. The assumed CCGS schedule has not been revised. Secondary mitigation is being explored and will be implemented.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
21 | P a g e
Figure 6. HRTP Master Project Schedule Summary (MPSS) The Master Program Summary Schedule reflects currently approved schedule end dates for contracts that have been awarded, and planned dates for future contracts.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
22 | P a g e
4 CONTRACT STATUS
Contracts in Procurement
Overview Awarded Contracts:
o HOLO Fare System Fiber contract was awarded on June 30, 2020 to Hawaiian Telcom, Inc. o Passenger WiFi System contract was awarded on June 30, 2020 to Icomera US, Inc.
Active Procurements:
o City Center Guideway and Stations / Pearl Highlands Design-Build Finance Operate and Maintain Request for Proposals (RFP) qualifications proposals in response to RFP Part 1 were received on April 12, 2019. HART released RFP Part 2 to the priority list of offerors on May 3, 2019. Due to recent COVID-19 events, the offerors requested additional time to prepare their proposals; the due date for the technical proposals has been extended to July 2020. As such, the Notice to Proceed (NTP) date has moved to September 2020.
o Art-in-Transit: HART continues its negotiations with the highest-ranked artists for each of the stations. To date, twelve (12) contracts have been awarded.
o HDOT/DTS Traffic Management Coordination Request for Qualifications was issued on Jan. 17, 2020. Statements of Qualification submissions were received on Feb. 19, 2020 and are currently being evaluated.
o Outside Claims Counsel Request for Sealed Proposals was re-issued on April 13, 2020 as a multi-award solicitation to avoid potential conflicts of interest. Sealed proposals were received on May 18, 2020 and are currently being evaluated.
o Archaeological & Cultural Monitoring “II” Request for Sealed Proposals was issued on March 9, 2020. Sealed proposals were received on April 9, 2020 and are currently being evaluated.
o Real Estate Contractor “III” Request for Sealed Proposals was issued on April 20, 2020. Sealed proposals were received on May 22, 2020 and are currently being evaluated.
o Guideway Bridge Inspection Request for Qualifications was issued on April 13, 2020. Sealed Statements of Qualification were received on May 19, 2020 and are currently being evaluated.
o Independent Financial Auditor “III” Request for Sealed Proposals was issued on May 4, 2020. Sealed proposals were received on June 3, 2020 and are currently being evaluated.
o Marketing Research Services – Data Collection Tools for Public Involvement Request for Quotes was issued on June 2, 2020. Sealed quotes were received on June 18, 2020 and are currently being evaluated.
Active Procurements
Contract Code
Contract Name Advertise
Date
Bids or Proposals
Due Issue NTP
Projected Contract
Substantial Completion
Date
AP-00 Art-in-Transit May 09 '13
12 contracts awarded;
active procurement for remaining
stations
Staggered Staggered
DB-550 City Center Guideway and Stations / Pearl Highlands Design-Build Finance Operate And Maintain (DBFOM)
Sep 28 ‘18 Apr 12 ‘19 (RFP Pt. 1)
Sep ‘20 TBD
MM-915 HDOT/DTS Traffic Management Coordination
Jan 17 ‘20 Feb 19 ‘20 July‘20 TBD
MM-980 Outside Claims Counsel Apr 13 ‘20 May 18 ‘20 July ‘20 TBD
MM-960 Archaeological & Cultural Monitoring “II”
Mar 09 ‘20 Apr 09 ‘20 TBD TBD
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
23 | P a g e
Active Procurements
Contract Code
Contract Name Advertise
Date
Bids or Proposals
Due Issue NTP
Projected Contract
Substantial Completion
Date
TBD Real Estate Contractor “III” Apr 20 ‘20 May 22 ‘20 July ‘20 TBD
TBD Guideway Bridge Inspection Apr 13 ‘20 May 19 ‘20 July ‘20 TBD
TBD Independent Financial Auditor “III” May 4 ‘20 June 3 ‘20 July‘20 TBD
HRT-201 Marketing Research Services – Data Collection Tools for Public Involvement Program
June 2 ‘20 June 18 ‘20 July ‘20 TBD
New awards/ contracts/NTP issued
Contract Code
Contract Name
Advertise Date
Due Date Contractor
Award Issue NTP
Term/Substantial Completion
Award Amount Contract Date
TBD HOLO Fare System Fiber
May 15 ‘20 June 9 ‘20
Hawaiian Telcom,
Inc. June 30 ‘20 TBD TBD $309,110.40
DBOM-920
Passenger WiFi System
Jan 17 ‘20 Mar 03 ‘20 Icomera US, Inc.
June 30 ‘20 TBD TBD $1,219,858.00
Upcoming Procurement Under Evaluation
Contract Code Contract Name Issue Date
Procurement Duration
Proposal Due Date Award
DBB-511 City Center Utility Relocation II July ‘20 2 Months Sept ‘20 Oct ‘20
HRT-201 HART Canvasser and Counselor Database Maintenance
July ‘20 1 Month Aug‘20 Sept ‘20
TBD LCC Switchgear July ‘20 1 Month Aug ‘20 Sept ‘20
TBD Keone’ae Station Park and Ride & Pouhala Station Makai Entrance (PRME)
Nov ‘20 3 – 4 Months Feb ‘21 March ‘21
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
24 | P a g e
4.1 System-wide
A. Core Systems Contract (CSC) CPP No.: DBOM-920 DBOM Contractor: Hitachi Rail Honolulu Joint Venture (HRH) Contract Start Date: January 2012 Contract Substantial Completion: January 1, 2025 Projected Completion of Work: March 2026
Project Description: A design, build, operate and maintain contract to provide rail passenger vehicles, automated train control system, traction electrification system (TES), communication systems, passenger platform screen gates (PSGs), and operation and maintenance of the Core Systems.
Design & Construction Vehicles Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 68.5% 77.5% On time for 2026
opening Early Plan* 86.4% 96.2%
Late Plan* 67.0% 57.0%
*Data as of June 26, 2020. The progress chart reflects early program expectations. Progress is being tracked against interim Construction Access Milestone dates, which show the project is "On-Time".
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $419,568
DBE % Attained: 0.054%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $209,736,373
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $209,736,373
Original Contract: $573,782,793 Incurred-to-Date: $432,745,999
Current Contract Value¹: $783,519,166 Incurred in June: $10,168,750
Outstanding Issues: 8 Contractor CP Amount: $1,787,499
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value (excluding original O&M budget) + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
25 | P a g e
KEY INDICATORS FOR 2021 INTERIM OPENING 1:
June 2020 July 2020 August 2020
Completion of Mobile Data System (MDS) network to East Kapolei (EKP): Completed
Completion of MDS network to Aloha Stadium Station (ALS): 40% Complete
Energization of 3rd Rail to ALS (Energize Pearlridge Station [PLR] Traction Power Substation [TPSS]): Completed
Completion of Secured Local Area Network (SLAN) network to PLR TPSS: Completed
Completion of PLR Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) TPSS: Completed
Start of TPSS Capability Test
Completion of PLR Platform Screen Gate System (PSGS): Installation in progress
Completion of Pearl Highlands Station (PHL) PSGS: 35% Complete
Train #9 Completion of onboard Automatic Train Control (ATC): Completed
Train #9 Completion of onboard Communications (COMM): 25% Complete
Train #8 Completion of onboard ATC: 80% Complete
Train #8 Completion of onboard COMM: Completed
Train # 13 Interim Certified for Dynamic Testing & Dynamic Test Completed: Completed
Train #13 Completion of onboard ATC
Train #13 Completion of onboard COMM
Train #14 Interim Certified for Dynamic Testing & Dynamic Test Completed: 80% Complete
Train #14 Completion of onboard ATC
Train #14 Completion of onboard COMM
Completion of Waipahu Transit Center (WTC) Fire Detection Alarm System (FDAS): Completed
Completion of University of Hawai‘i West O‘ahu (UHWO) FDAS: Target to complete on 07/02.
Completion of PHL FDAS
Completion of PLR FDAS
Completion of ALS FDAS
FDAS integration test at stations (EKP to ALS)
Completion of COMM Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) at Ho‘opili (HOP): 95% Complete
Completion of COMM Access Control System (ACS)-Intrusion Detection System (IDS) at HOP: 15% Complete
Completion of COMM Passenger Information Systems (PIS) at HOP: 30% Complete
Completion of COMM PIS at LCC: 30% Complete
Completion of COMM CCTV at UHWO: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM PIS at UHWO: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM ACS-IDS at UHWO: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM CCTV at PHL: Installation in progress
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
26 | P a g e
June 2020 July 2020 August 2020
Completion of COMM CCTV at Leeward Community College (LCC): 95% Complete
Completion of COMM ACS-IDS at LCC: 15% Complete
Completion of COMM CCTV at West Loch (WLO): Installation substantially completed
Completion of COMM PIS at WLO: Installation substantially completed
Completion of COMM ACS-IDS at WLO: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM CCTV at WTC: Installation substantially completed
Completion of COMM PIS at WTC: Installation substantially completed
Completion of COMM ACS-IDS at WTC: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM CCTV at EKP: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM PIS at EKP: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM ACS-IDS at EKP: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM PIS at PHL: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM ACS-IDS at PHL: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM CCTV at PLR: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM PIS at PLR: Installation in progress
Completion of COMM ACS-IDS at PLR: Installation in progress
Completion of Station SCADA HOP: 50% Complete
Completion of Station SCADA WLO: 30% Complete
Completion of Station SCADA WTC: 30% Complete
Completion of Station SCADA LCC: 30% Complete
Completion of Station SCADA EKP: Installation in progress
Completion of Station SCADA UHWO: 30% Complete
Completion of Station SCADA PHL
Completion of Station SCADA PLR
Completion of Station SCADA ALS
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Design: Review of design submittals is ongoing. Focus is to close out
communications, passenger vehicles and Requirements Traceability Matrix (RTM) issues.
Continued coordination between HRH and the AGS contractor for integration of Core Systems requirements.
Manufacturing: Hitachi Rail USA, Inc. (HRU) is continuing with the production of
Train #15 through #18 in Pittsburg, CA. Train #7 is being delivered to the MSF with the last car expected
to arrive on July 13. This train is for Interim Opening (I/O) #2. Testing of ventilation hole retrofit continues on Train #3.
Look Ahead: Design: Close out of open comments to finalize Final
Design of all subsystems. Continue coordination between HRH and
FHSG/KHSG/AGS. Complete Communications Final Design.
Manufacturing: Passenger Vehicle truck fabrication – continue
truck frame and bolster delivery from Italy. Complete car shell fabrication activities in Italy.
Three car shells will be fabricated in Reggio Calabria to replace the car shell used for roof and floor fire re-test and to replace Train #1 and Train #2 car shells with the extrusion defect.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
27 | P a g e
Activities this Month (continued): Fleet retrofit is substantially completed in Trains #8 and #13.
Hitachi Rail Italy (HRI) is working on the fleet retrofit for Trains #12 and #14.
Train #1 has been shipped back to the Final Assembly Facility. Installation, Testing and Commissioning: HRH completed the integration test between PLR TPSS to the
Operations Control Center (OCC). HRH continues with installation of Blue Light Stations in the
stations. HRH completed installation of PSGS at PHL Station and started
the initial testing at this station. HRH continues with PSGS electrical installation in PLR Station. HRH continues with the remediation of corrosion issues with the
PSGS components. HRH continues inter-station ATC Wayside Test Procedure (WTP)
testing between PHL and ALS. HRH completed onboard ATC testing with Train #9. HRH continues with routine acceptance test for onboard ATC
equipment in Train #8. HRH substantially completed routine acceptance test for
onboard COMM equipment in Train #9. HRH continues with routine acceptance test for onboard COMM
equipment in Train #9. HRH achieved interim certification and completed train static
and dynamic testing for Train #13. Train #13 is ready for onboard ATC and COMM testing.
HRH continues with static acceptance test on Train #14. HRH continues with the communication system installation at
EKP, UHWO, HOP, WTC, LCC, PHL and PLR stations. HRH continues to test MDS poles 6-19 in the functional section
and expanded to energize and configure poles 1-5. HRH continues COMM acceptance test at HOP Station. HRH started COMM acceptance test at LCC, WTC and WLO
stations. HRH continues with cable and fiber termination to MDS poles 20
through 29. HRH completed installation and testing of FDAS systems at WTC. HRH substantially completed FDAS cable and device installation
at UHWO station. HRH continues with SCADA cable installation at UWHO and LCC
Stations. HRH powered up and tested SCADA cabinets in UHWO, HOP,
WLO, WTC and LCC. HRH continued train testing in the entire Segment 1 alignment
(EKP to ALS). HRH continues with MSF COMM acceptance test. HRH performed platform gap measurement for Americans with
Disabilities Act (ADA) compliance in the first 8 stations (EKP to PLR) with AW0 train.
HRH performed platform gap measurement for ADA compliance in 3 stations (HOP to WTC) with AW3 train.
Look Ahead (continued): Installation, Testing and Commissioning: Complete SCADA testing with peripheral devices
in the MSF, after installation is completed. Complete MSF COMM Acceptance Test. Complete PSGS Commissioning test at PHL, PLR
and ALS. Complete Vehicle Test Procedure, Central Test
Procedure, and System Test Procedure in Segment 1.
Continue System Integration Testing with train(s) in the Yard.
Continue System Integration Testing with train(s) in the Functional Section.
Complete the remediation of corrosion issues with the PSGS components.
Complete remaining ATC Wayside testing in Segment 1.
Complete Train #8, Train #9, Train #13 and Train #14 onboard ATC and onboard COMM testing.
Achieve Train #14 Interim Certificate for dynamic testing.
Continue SCADA and Blue Light Station (BLS) installation in the stations.
Start Blue Light Station testing in the stations. Continue SCADA testing in the stations. Continue TPSS COMM installation. Start testing with multiple trains in Segment 1.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
28 | P a g e
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
VMS Signs - AGS End of Platform
Vehicle Extended Warranty
Matcon Aug 2018 Lift Repair MSF
Changing of Vehicle "Square Key" Locks (square to triangle key)
Spare Parts
Pouhala (Waipahu) Makai Entrance
Automated Response to Loss of Traction Power
Increased CSC DB MOB Costs for IO#1
A P A A P A P P
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: Interim Opening Fleet (7 trains) is on site. Interim Opening Fleet ready for System Integration Testing (3 of 7 trains are ready). Completion of System Integration Test. Trial Run.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT: Hitachi has indicated that the two remaining car shells that require replacement of the bolster assemblies due to
the aluminum extrusion defects, will be scrapped instead of repaired. Hitachi is in the process of ordering additional material for the fabrication of three (3) new car shells; one to replace the car shell used to expedite the floor and roof fire re-test and two to replace the car shells with extrusion defects.
End Car 1 of Train #12 was damaged (about 2.0 ft. long x ¾ in. wide x ¼ in. deep gouge on the left side, which did not penetrate the aluminum extrusion skin, and about ½ in. diameter penetration in the first set of the Door Panel on the right side of End Car 1) during transit from Pittsburg, CA to Honolulu, HI. Repair procedure is being developed.
CSC NCR Log (Issued by HRH)
Total Closed Open
HRH & Subs 58 57 1
Hitachi Rail 2,159 1,808 351
TOTAL 2,217 1,865 352
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
29 | P a g e
TRAIN SCHEDULE:
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
30 | P a g e
B. Traction Power Backup Generators CPP No.: MI-940 Contractor: PAC Electric Co., Inc. Contract Start Date: December 2019 Contract Substantial Completion: February 2021 Projected Completion of Work: February 2021 Project Description: Procurement of Traction Power Backup Generators, which are to be located at or near the Traction Power Substations (TPSSs) at the West Loch and Pearlridge passenger stations. The generators will provide the means for moving stranded trains into the HRTP passenger stations, in case of an island-wide or regional power outage event.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 8.5%
On time Early Plan* 8.3%
Late Plan* 6.6% *Data as of June 26, 2020.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________ COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $0
DBE % Attained: 0%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $0
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $0
___________________________________________________________________________________________________ SCHEDULE:
Generators production to be completed early July 2020. Enclosures production to be completed early August 2020. Factory Acceptance Test to be completed end of August 2020. Generators onsite delivery to be completed in October 2020.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________ WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month:
Working on project deliverables, such as Lift Plan and other documents.
Submitted 3 submittals to HART.
Look Ahead: Manufacturing of enclosures. Factory Acceptance Test
Original Contract: $8,965,000 Incurred-to-Date: $537,500
Current Contract Value¹: $8,965,000 Incurred in June: $537,500
Outstanding Issues: 1 Contractor CP Amount: $0
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
31 | P a g e
Activities this Month (continued): Continued to interface with HRH regarding Medium
Voltage (MV) Switchgear Design, Relay Coordination Study, and site conditions.
Generators’ manufacturing in progress; 1 was completed at the end of June and another one is anticipated to be completed in early July.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________ KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
Minor Field Work Allowance P
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal __________________________________________________________________________________________________ KEY MILESTONES: Factory Acceptance Test in August 2020. __________________________________________________________________________________________________ QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
Traction Power Backup Generators NCR Log (Issued by PAC Electric Co., Inc.)
Total NCRs Issued To Date Closed Open
0 0 0
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
32 | P a g e
C. Elevators and Escalators Manufacture-Install-Maintain (MIM) CPP No.: MI-930 Contractor: Schindler Elevator Corporation Contract Start Date: August 2013 Contract Substantial Completion: May 2021 Projected Completion of Work: February 2024 (see the Schedule section below) Project Description: A contract to design, fabricate, install, test, commission, and maintain all elevators and escalators at all 21 stations.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 47.7%
Just in Time** Early Plan* 58.3%
Late Plan* TBD *Data as of June 26, 2020. **The E&E schedule is dependent on other contractors' schedules. Actual release for manufacturing will be coordinated for a 'just in time' delivery.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $0
DBE % Attained: 0%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $4,879,726
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $4,879,726
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
SCHEDULE: The Elevators and Escalators (E&E) contract substantial completion date is May 2021, based on the AGS contract
substantial completion date. The final completion date for the E&E contract will be based on the CCGS contract’s scheduled installation dates after award of the CCGS contract.
Original Contract: $50,982,714 Incurred-to-Date: $28,141,001
Current Contract Value¹: $55,862,440 Incurred in June²: $0
Outstanding Issues: 2 Contractor CP Amount: $106,154 1Current Contract Value = Original contract value with Design Allowance + executed Change Orders
2Work has progressed and incurred amounts will be reflected as invoices are approved in the City’s C2HERPS system
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
33 | P a g e
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Elevator CEI inspections are occurring for the WOSG and
FHSG to ensure that the required specifications for the State Inspections for elevators and escalators are met.
HART is continuing to coordinate with the AGS contractor and the E&E contractor to firm up required equipment installation dates.
At Pearlridge Station, Escalators #1 and #2 high-speed adjustments were completed.
At Pearl Highlands Station, Elevators #1 and #2 high-speed adjustments were completed.
At Aloha Stadium, installation of Elevators #1 and #2 are continuing.
In June, the State completed preliminary inspections at East Kapolei (all units) and will provide a punchlist for each. These punchlists will be shared with the station contractor so that these items can be addressed and corrected prior to the States final inspection and acceptance.
The State has completed Pre-inspections for all the equipment installed at WOSG and FHSG, so that when the Final inspections are called in, the acceptance should go smoothly.
Look Ahead: The E&E substantial completion date for the
remaining eight east-side stations will be established once the contract is awarded for the CCGS and the schedule for this contract is accepted.
At Pearl Highlands Station, final high-speed adjustments will be completed in:
o Escalators #3-#6 August 2020. At Aloha Stadium Station, final high-speed
adjustments will be completed in: o Elevators #1 and #2 July 2020.
Preliminary State Inspections for: o Pearl Highlands Station: Elevators #1
and #2, Escalators #1 and #2 – August 2020
o Pearl Highlands Station: Escalators #3-#6 – September 2020
o Pearlridge Station: all units – August 2020
o Aloha Stadium Station: Escalators #1 and #2 – August 2020
o Aloha Stadium Station: Elevators #1 and #2 – September 2020.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
EEC pre-operations maintenance delay
FCN Allowance
A P
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: Preventive maintenance requirements along with the required final testing is continuing for the elevators that
have been installed. Installation has continued at Aloha Stadium Station for the final 2 elevators, with anticipation of completion in July 2020.
State Pre-inspections on all of the equipment installed at WOSG and FHSG began in November 2019 and was completed in June 2020. This will facilitate the State Final Inspections which are required to allow the public to use the installed equipment.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
Elevators and Escalators NCR Log (Issued by Schindler)
Total NCRs Issued To Date Closed Open
0 0 0
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
34 | P a g e
D. Fare Collection System CPP No.: MI-900 Contractor: INIT, Innovations in Transportation, Inc. Contract Start Date: April 2016 Projected Completion of Design-Build Work: March 2026
Project Description: The fare collection system is a joint HART and City and County of Honolulu [Department of Transportation Services (DTS), Department of Information Technology (DIT), Budget and Fiscal Services (BFS)] project that will consist of a multi-modal, closed loop, account based smart card system. The Fare System vendor, INIT Innovations in Transportation, Inc., is responsible for design, manufacture, testing, installation and operation of the entire system inclusive of hardware and software. The rail portion of the project will consist of Ticket Vending Machines (TVMs) and fare gates at stations that accept smart cards which can also be used for payment on board TheBus and facilitate a seamless transfer between modes. Equipment and software to be used by both HART and the City and County will include transaction processing, fare equipment monitoring, and customer service systems, as well as a Data Warehouse. TheBus equipment will consist of stand-alone smart card readers on board.
Progress Schedule Status
Percent Complete 56.3% 12 Months Behind Milestone Schedule
Payment** Early Plan* 86.8%
Late Plan* 83.9% *Data as of June 26, 2020. Planned information is being evaluated based on the current (full-alignment) scope versus the revised requirements of the Interim Revenue Service completion date. **Although the contract is 12 months behind schedule, it does not impact the Interim Opening or the RSD.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $0
DBE % Attained: 0%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $444,026
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $444,026
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
SCHEDULE: The projected completion of DB work date has changed to March 2026 to account for HART’s projected Revenue
Service Date of March 2026. Production Acceptance Test (PAT) for faregates and TVMS completed June 18, 2020. First station installation scheduled for July 7, 2020. Field Integration Test (FIT) still to be determined based on network installation and foreign staff availability on
island. Tentative schedule is Sept. 1, 2020.
Original Contract: $15,464,198 Incurred-to-Date: $7,570,108
Current Contract Value¹: $15,908,224 Incurred in June²: $0
Outstanding Issues: 4 Contractor CP Amount: $702,024 1Current Contract Value = Original contract value with Design Allowance + executed Change Orders
2Work has progressed and incurred amounts will be reflected as invoices are approved in the City’s C2HERPS system
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
35 | P a g e
WORK PROGRESS:
Activities this Month: Trained Waianae and Wahiawa Satellite City Hall (SCH) staff. Redrafted Amendment 9 for Rail Claim. Moved all language Interactive Voice Response (IVR) scripts to
test environment for review. Continued work on remaining language translations for the
website. Arranged container storage for containers 3-6 at the Pasha
yards. Provided PMOC and FTA with a fare systems briefing. Updated installation plans and coordinated the installation
schedule. Completed Finding of Merit/No Merit (FOM) and Negotiation
Strategy Memo (NSM) for Issue 18. Reviewed and commented on Failure Review Board (FRB). Reviewed Functional Unit Testing (FUT) Test Report and
approved. Created additional FIT cases for inclusion in vendor plan. Coordinated on-call request for concrete pours. Trouble shot user issues with Customer Service Terminal (CST)
and Customer-Relationship Management (CRM).
Look Ahead:
Begin installation at West Side Stations.
Arrange for Network fiber installation between Operations and Servicing Building (OSB) and Fasi Municipal Building (FMB).
Schedule installation for remaining TIMES retail locations and test 7-Eleven locations.
Implement Pilot changes. Confirm release of languages to website
and IVR. Certify FUT. Confirm FIT Test Plans.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
Rail Restart
FDAS Bank Box and DIM Rail Clamps
Pilot Changes for Customers
Vendor Installation Work
A A A P
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: Production Acceptance Testing June 2020. Equipment installation July 2020. Field Integration Testing September 2020.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
Fare Collection NCR Log (Issued by INIT)
Total NCRs Issued To Date Closed Open
0 0 0
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
36 | P a g e
E. On-Call Construction IV CPP No.: MM-949 Contractor: Royal Contracting Co., Ltd. Contract Start Date: January 2018 Contract Substantial Completion: January 2023 Projected Completion of Work: January 2023 Project Description: This is an on-call contract to perform a variety of construction services by issuance of Task Orders. The construction services to be provided will include, but are not limited to, maintenance, renovations to existing privately owned properties, demolition of buildings/structures, repairs to existing HART facilities, temporary utilities installations, utilities relocation, new construction projects or services, maintenance of roadways inclusive of, filling potholes, removing dead animals, landscape maintenance, repairing/replacing signage, and other such activities to HDOT and/or City and County of Honolulu standards, work in support of HART’s ongoing construction activities, and work in support of other HART contractors.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete* 93.0%
On Time Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* TBD *Data as of June 26, 2020.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
DBE Participation Task Orders
Actual DBE Participation: $0
Number of Task Orders Issued
Amount ($)
DBE % Attained: 0% Task Orders Previously Issued 73 $49,641,454
Task Orders Issued this Month 3 $1,155,956
Amendments to Task Orders 7 $1,611,427
Total Task Orders Issued 76 $52,408,837
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
SCHEDULE: The On-Call Contract is a Task Order based Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ) contract. The work
consists of meeting the objectivities of HART’s Joint Use and Occupancy Agreements (JUOA) requirements, maintaining HART properties, performing Cost to Cure activities, and performing permanent utility relocation work. Each Task Order has its own start and finish date, and as such, there is no overall schedule requirements for the On-Call contract proper. The contract NTP was issued on Jan. 8, 2018 and ends on Jan. 7, 2023 with two one-year options.
Original Contract: $46,000,000 Incurred-to-Date: $38,728,685
Current Contract Value¹: $53,000,000 Incurred in June: $1,509,757
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
37 | P a g e
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Continued maintenance of the HDOT roadways along
Farrington Highway and Kamehameha Highway, per the JUOA.
Work at Cutter Dodge, Stuart Plaza and UH Urban Gardens was completed at the end of June; only punchlist items remain.
Continued to complete HDOT elements of work as required by the HDOT agreements.
Continued to work on AGS HECO Zone 9. HECO Zone 9 is made up of several independent duct banks, some of which are already completed.
Continued work at LCC on the Ka‘aahi Substation and storage area for HECO vehicles. Work is at 98% complete.
Completed work on AGS HECO Zone 8A. Completed Cost to Cure work at both Dillingham Plaza
and at Aala Tofu Co. on Kaaahi Street.
Look Ahead: Continue to maintain HDOT roadways, as required
by the JUOA. Complete punchlist item work at Cutter Dodge,
Stuart Plaza and UH Urban Gardens. Continue to complete HDOT elements of work as
required by the HDOT agreements. Complete infrastructure work in support of HECO
power line relocation at Kahi Mohala. Begin work to repair erosion damage at Kaloi
Channel and prevent erosion reoccurrence. Complete contamination mitigation at HART’s two
properties on Kaaahi Street.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES (new issues are in bold font): Need to receive timely Right of Entry agreements.
Need to continue to have Maintenance of Traffic plans reviewed and accepted in a reasonable time frame. _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: The work at UH Urban Gardens – Cutter Dodge, completed in June, provides the required road widening at this
section of Kamehameha Highway. _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
On-Call Construction IV NCR Log (Issued by Royal Contracting)
Total NCRs Issued To Date Closed Open
0 0 0
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
38 | P a g e
4.2 Section I – West O'ahu/Farrington Highway: East Kapolei to Pearl Highlands
A. West O'ahu/Farrington Highway Guideway (WOFH) CPP No.: DB-120 DB Contractor: Kiewit Infrastructure West Company (KIWC) Contract Start Date: December 2009 Date of Substantial Completion Notification: December 13, 2018
Project Description: Design and construction of 6.8 miles of rail alignment, starting at the East Kapolei Station and ending at the Pearl Highlands Station.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 100% Substantial Completion Obtained**
Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* 100% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **Further explanation is provided in the Schedule section.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $17,119,976
DBE % Attained: 2.56%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $185,351,685
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $185,351,685
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
SCHEDULE: Acoustical Monitoring installation complete. Contract closeout – third quarter 2020.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Retention release routing.
Look Ahead: Route Contract Closeout Checklist for signature. Issue Final Acceptance letter, including the
Certificate and Release of Final Payment form.
Original Contract: $482,430,201 Incurred-to-Date: $667,781,886
Current Contract Value¹: $667,781,886 Incurred in June: $0
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
39 | P a g e
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
None N/A
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal _______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: One-year project warranty period ended on Jan. 14, 2020.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
SUBSTANTIAL COMPLETION: Substantial Completion was Dec. 13, 2018.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
WOFH NCR LOG (Issued by KIWC)
Total NCRs Issued to Date Closed Open
586 586 0
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
40 | P a g e
B. University of Hawai‘i West O‘ahu (UHWO) Station Temporary Park-and-Ride & UHWO Campus Road “B” CPP No.: DBB-602 Contractor: Nan, Inc. Contract Start Date: December 2017 Contract Substantial Completion: July 2019 Completion of Work: January 2020 Project Description: The project consists of the construction of a temporary park & ride, Road “B” and associated site work in the vicinity of UH West O‘ahu Station. The project includes clearing, grubbing, erosion and dust control, grading and hauling, drainage, installation of underground and overhead utilities, installation of traffic signal, street lighting, and park & ride area electrical and communication systems, concrete curbs, sidewalks and wheelchair ramps, asphalt and concrete pavement structures, signing and striping, bus shelters, landscaping including installation of an irrigation system, and other appurtenances associated with roadway and park & ride facilities.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 100% Work
Completed** Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* 100% *Data as of June 26, 2020. NTP issued Dec. 15, 2017. **Pending contract actions will extend contract completion date.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $108,454
DBE % Attained: 0.82%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $1,607,232
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $1,607,232
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
SCHEDULE: Substantial completion date is Oct. 23, 2019, per substantial completion letter dated Dec. 13, 2019. A change order is pending to compensate the contractor for time.
Original Contract: $11,589,300 Incurred-to-Date: $12,908,138
Current Contract Value¹: $13,196,532 Incurred in June²: $0
Outstanding Issues: 1 Contractor CP Amount: $710,115
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders 2Work has progressed and incurred amounts will be reflected as invoices are approved in the City’s C2HERPS system
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
41 | P a g e
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Continued to verify completion of punchlist items. Continued verifying completion of contract
documentation. Continued closing of grading permit and stockpile
transfer.
Look Ahead: Coordinate Board of Water Supply (BWS) meter
installation for Road B and Temporary Park & Ride (TP&R).
Coordinate HECO meter installation at Road B to complete lights testing and irrigation.
Complete remaining concrete issues at sidewalk cul-de-sac, per City and County (C&C) Inspector punchlist items.
Remove concrete rubble stockpile, per Field Change Notice (FCN) 22, pending PVT facility acceptance.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
Project Time Delay [establish new Contract Substantial Completion Date] A
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES:
Install BWS meter for Temporary Park and Ride. Install HECO meter for Road B. Complete punchlist work – July 2020.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
UHWO Station Temporary Park-and-Ride & UHWO Campus Road “B” NCR Log
(Issued by Nan)
Total NCRs Issued to Date Closed Open
5 1 4
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
42 | P a g e
C. West O'ahu Station Group (WOSG) CPP No.: DBB-171 Contractor: Nan, Inc. Contract Start Date: October 2015 Contract Substantial Completion: January 31, 2020 Date of Substantial Completion: January 31, 2020
Project Description: The West O'ahu Station Group construction contract includes services to build three (3) transit stations along Kualaka'i Parkway and Farrington Highway. The stations are East Kapolei (EKP), UH West O'ahu (UHWO), and Ho'opili (HOP) Stations. In addition to the transit stations, operational ancillary buildings, a traction power substation, and adjacent areas are included in this project.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 99.3%** Substantial Completion
Obtained Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* 100% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **Remaining work includes punchlist, contract change orders and closeout.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $993,708
DBE % Attained: 1.13%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $32,026,202
None N/A --- ---
Cumulative Current Report $32,026,202
Original Contract: $56,088,470 Incurred-to-Date: $82,722,876
Current Contract Value¹: $88,114,672 Incurred in June: $610,431
Outstanding Issues: 4 Contractor CP Amount: $1,048,400 1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
43 | P a g e
SCHEDULE: Substantial Completion letter issued for Jan. 31, 2020. Coordinating with CSC and the contractor to establish the date to turn over the project to HRH. Prefinal Inspection for UHWO and EKP were held in the first week of May. Base contract work impacted by pending change orders, and pending change order work to be completed.
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: East Kapolei
Completed installation of decorative floor tile at faregate. Completed installation of canopy base covers. Completed site furnishing at all rooms and common areas. Completed photocell testing for the lighting. Started station-wide signs installation. Continued station-wide painting of exposed pipes. Conducted pre-final walkthrough on all three stations. Continued station-wide correcting of punchlist and issues.
UH West O‘ahu
Continued traffic signal change (Request for Change by HART [RFCR] 41) at Road B intersection.
Landscaping work/maintenance ongoing. Continued painting of exposed pipes. Continued station-wide sign installation. Completed installing all site furnishings. Completed photocell testing for the lighting. Assisted in state inspections for the elevators and escalator. Continued station-wide completion of punchlist items/issues.
Ho‘opili
Landscaping work ongoing. Signage installation ongoing. Elevator and faregate storm drains installation ongoing. Continued painting of exposed pipes. Completed FCN 220 and 222 for permanent and temporary
irrigation. Completed photocell testing for the lighting. Completed canopy storm drain installation. Continued station-wide correcting of punchlist items/issues.
Look Ahead: East Kapolei
Complete site utility work. Complete site work and landscaping. Complete exterior signs installation. Complete exterior light posts and
testing. Pour back concrete road at Keahumoa
Parkway. Complete punchlist items. Turnover to HRH.
UH West O‘ahu
Complete contract change order (CCO) for 16” non-potable waterline (NPW).
Complete landscaping and irrigation. Complete sign installation. Complete traffic signal installation. Interior and exterior lighting – design
changes possible. Complete punchlist items. Turnover to HRH.
Ho‘opili
Complete signage installation. Complete elevator and faregate storm
drain installation. Complete painting of exposed pipes. Complete landscaping and sitework. Complete punchlist items. Turnover to HRH.
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
Keone'ae Station (UHWO) 16-in Non-Potable Waterline Reconnection
Kualaka'i (EKP) 24-inch Sewer Line Differing Site Condition - RFI 01207
FM 200 System Upgrade from Class A to C
Added Lighting at Keone'ae Station (UHWO) and Kualaka'i (EKP)
A A A A
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
44 | P a g e
KEY MILESTONES: UHWO Station:
Prefinal Inspections and HRH Turnover. EKP Station:
Site utility (24” and 8” sewer lines) installation.
Station turnover to HRH.
HOP Station:
Prefinal Inspections and HRH Turnover.
QUALITY MANAGEMENT: Conducted bi-weekly Quality Task Force Meetings.
WOSG NCR Log (Issued by Nan)
NCRs Issued to Date
Closed Open
East Kapolei 11 11 0
UH West O‘ahu 43 41 2
Ho‘opili 32 31 1
Contract Wide 12 12 0
TOTAL 98 95 3
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
45 | P a g e
D. Farrington Highway Station Group (FHSG) CPP No.: DBB-271 Contractor: Hawaiian Dredging Construction Company, Inc. (HDCC) Contract Start Date: August 2015 Contract Substantial Completion: June 2020 Projected Completion of Work: September 2020
Project Description: The Farrington Highway Station Group construction contract includes services to build three (3) transit stations along Farrington Highway. The stations are West Loch (WLO), Waipahu Transit Center (WTC), and Leeward Community College (LCC) Stations. The station work includes operational ancillary buildings, a traction power substation at WLO, and a Kiss-and-Ride lot at WLO.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 97.8% 3 months behind**
Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* 100% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **Further explanation is provided in the Schedule section.
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $4,509,709
DBE % Attained: 3.81%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $39,290,879
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $39,290,879
Original Contract: $78,999,000 Incurred-to-Date: $92,755,232
Current Contract Value¹: $118,289,879 Incurred in June: $1,816,085
Outstanding Issues: 2 Contractor CP Amount: $0
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
46 | P a g e
SCHEDULE:
Consolidated Resolution (CR) Change Order 037 extended contract completion to June 2020. HDCC deployed and tensioned fabric at both WLO platforms. HDCC also completed the fabric detailing on the
WTC platform fabric. HDCC continued to work through the COVID-19 epidemic, implementing many additional safety precautions to
minimize its team’s exposure to the virus. Final faregate canopy fabric installation to be completed in September 2020, due to contractor delay in
fabrication of faregate canopy steel. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: West Loch
● Partially erected faregate canopy steel. ● Received station signage. ● Deployed platform canopy. ● Completed punchlist items.
Leeward Community College ● Completed punchlist items. ● Post-installing sign anchors at stairs.
Waipahu Transit Center ● Platform fabric detailing. ● Grouted canopy base plates. ● Installed signage throughout the station.
All Stations ● Coordinated canopy fabric installation, train testing, NCRs,
change orders, and other closeout items. ● Faregate canopy fabrication (WLO/WTC). ● Signage fabrication. ● Signage delivery.
Look Ahead: West Loch
● Troubleshoot fit-up issues for mauka faregate steel.
● Makai faregate canopy shipment.
Leeward Community College ● Complete clamping and flashing
installation on canopy. ● Submit drain plug assembly.
Waipahu Transit Center ● Moloalo sidewalk redesign. ● Faregate canopy erection.
All Stations ● Complete punchlist activities. ● Signage delivery and installation. ● Miscellaneous FCN activities.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code ● Moloalo St. Redesign ● FM 200 Upgrade
P P
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: Station turnover. Final Platform canopy detailing – August 2020. Faregate canopies – September 2020.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
47 | P a g e
QUALITY MANAGEMENT: The CEI team is working with HDCC to ensure required submittals are approved prior to related construction
activities.
FHSG NCR Log (Issued by HDCC)
NCRs Issued to Date
Closed Open
West Loch 33 31 2
Waipahu Transit Center 22 18 4
West Loch/Waipahu Transit Center 3 2 1
Leeward Community College 20 18 2
Contract Wide 19 17 2
Void 2 2 0
TOTAL 99 88 11
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
48 | P a g e
E. Maintenance and Storage Facility (MSF) CPP No.: DB-200 Contractor: Kiewit/Kobayashi Joint Venture (KKJV) Contract Start Date: July 25, 2011 Contract Substantial Completion Date: July 2, 2016
Project Description: The MSF contract consists of the Operations and Servicing Building (OSB), Maintenance of Way (MOW), Train Wash Facility (TWF) and Wheel Truing Building (WTB). In addition to the four (4) facility buildings, MSF includes rail procurement, special trackwork, ties, third rail and other track material for the four guideway segments on the project.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 100% Substantial Completion Obtained*
Early Plan 100%
Late Plan 100% *Further explanation is provided in the Schedule section.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $710,987
DBE % Attained: 0.25%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $86,517,032
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $86,517,032
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
SCHEDULE:
HART to close remaining issues third quarter 2020. ______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS:
Activities this Month: Final Acceptance Letter routing for signature.
Look Ahead: Final retention release. Final Acceptance Letter from HART. Process final payment.
MSF Construction Status 100% Complete Overall
Element % Complete*
OSB 100%
MOW Building 100%
WTB 100%
TWF 100%
Rail 100%
Paving 100% *Not including testing and commissioning.
Original Contract: $195,258,000 Incurred-to-Date: $281,775,032
Current Contract Value¹: $281,775,032 Incurred in June: $0
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
49 | P a g e
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
None N/A
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal _______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES:
None. _______________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT: Overall quality of the contract is good.
MSF NCR Log (Issued by KKJV)
Total NCRs Issued to Date Closed Open
37 37 0
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
50 | P a g e
4.3 Section II – Kamehameha Highway: Pearl Highlands to Aloha Stadium A. Kamehameha Highway Guideway (KHG)
CPP No.: DB-320 Contractor: Kiewit Infrastructure West Company (KIWC) Contract Start Date: June 2011 Date of Substantial Completion Notification: December 13, 2018
Project Description: Kamehameha Highway Guideway DB Contract (KHG) consists of 3.9 miles and starts 400 feet east of the Pearl Highlands Station and terminates 1,400 feet beyond the Aloha Stadium Station. KHG work scope is made up of utility relocations, traffic signal improvements, highway widening, drilled shaft foundations, columns, and aerial structure.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 100% Substantial Completion Obtained**
Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* 100% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **Further explanation is provided in the Schedule section.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $860,191
DBE % Attained: 0.21%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $31,405,774
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $31,405,774
SCHEDULE: Close Contract – Pending signed Release and Certificate of Final Payment from KIWC.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Final Retention Release is routing.
Look Ahead: Receive the contractor’s signed Release and
Certificate of Final Payment. Payment of final retention release.
Original Contract: $372,150,000 Incurred-to-Date: $403,555,774
Current Contract Value¹: $403,555,774 Incurred in June: $0
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
51 | P a g e
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
None N/A
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal _______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: One-year project warranty ended on Jan. 14, 2020.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
SUBSTANTIAL COMPLETION: Substantial Completion was Dec. 13, 2018.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
KHG NCR Log (Issued by KIWC)
Total NCRs Issued to Date Closed Open
252 252 0
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
52 | P a g e
B. Kamehameha Highway Station Group (KHSG) CPP No.: DBB-371 Contractor: Nan, Inc. Contract Start Date:
Notice to Commence Administrative Work: April 2016 Notice to Commence Investigative/Pre-Construction Work at Pearl Highlands: July 2016 Full Notice to Proceed (NTP): October 3, 2016
Contract Substantial Completion: April 2020 Projected Completion of Work: October 2020
Project Description: The Kamehameha Highway Station Group construction contract includes services to build three (3) transit stations along Kamehameha Highway. The stations are Pearl Highlands Station (PHL), Pearlridge Station (PLR), and Aloha Stadium Station (ALS). Operational ancillary buildings, pedestrian crossing improvements, Train Control and Communications Rooms (TCCRs), and landscaping of the station sites are included in addition to the transit stations. The Pearl Highlands Station will include a transit center. The Pearl Highlands and Aloha Stadium Stations include both a Park-and-Ride lot and a Kiss-and-Ride lot.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 94.2% 6 months behind**
Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* 100% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **Further explanation is provided in the Schedule section.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $0
DBE % Attained: 0%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $15,219,828
00045 PLR Mauka Sewerline Changes $90,648
Cumulative Current Report $15,310,476
Original Contract: $115,805,845 Incurred-to-Date: $121,218,853
Current Contract Value¹: $131,116,321 Incurred in June: $1,405,800
Outstanding Issues: 5 Contractor CP Amount: $12,088,285
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value with Design Allowance + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
53 | P a g e
SCHEDULE:
Ongoing coordination with CSC and the contractor to meet HRH’s schedule for access turnover and interim opening.
Schedule delayed by canopy and fabric delivery. Pearlridge canopy fabric was installed in June at Pearlridge, with the exception of the center panels. Pearl Highlands’ canopy fabric is scheduled for July. Aloha Stadium arm installation to start in July with fabric installation starting in September. Working with the contractor to improve the schedule.
Working with the station and systems contractors to mitigate any impact on interim opening resulting from canopy design revisions in progress.
CCO 44 revised the contract substantial completion date to April 30, 2020 with the exception of canopies and fabric. Scheduled to be complete in October 2020.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Pearl Highlands
Continued painting of all steel. Continued ceramic tile installation. Continued articulated concrete block installation. Completed bipod modification work. Commenced parking lot work. Commenced canopy base plate installation. Commenced bipod installation. Commenced and completed wire mesh panel and
wire bench installation. Commenced architectural gate installation. Commenced canopy drain bowl installation. Continued Farrington Highway Barrier Improvements.
Pearlridge Continued painting all steel. Continued elevator Thermoplastic Polyolefin (TPO)
roofing installation. Completed elevator glazing and louver installation. Commenced and completed bipod installation. Commenced canopy fabric installation. Commenced and completed architectural fence gate
installation. Commenced wire mesh panel installation. Commenced and completed plumbing fixture
installation. Aloha Stadium
Continued driveway B rigid paving concrete pours. Completed elevator shaft roof and deck installation. Completed service stair gate installation. Continued concrete pavement striping work. Commenced escalator cladding installation. Commenced entrance area porcelain tile installation.
Look Ahead: Pearl Highlands
Complete articulated concrete block installation. Complete ceramic tile installation. Commence canopy fabric installation. Commence signage installation. Commence entrance ramp light pole installation. Commence installation of graffiti resistant coating. Commence wind screen installation.
Pearlridge Commence signage installation. Commence downspout installation. Commence architectural fence installation. Commence faregate canopy steel installation. Commence wind screen installation. Commence Fire Protection Accessories and
Cabinet installation. Commence parking lot striping. Commence wire bench installation. Commence landscape work.
Aloha Stadium Complete driveway B ridged paving concrete
pours. Commence elevator glazing installation. Commence canopy steel installation. Commence canopy fabric installation. Commence signage installation. Commence furniture installation. Commence PSG bolt grouting. Commence visual screen installation. Commence wire mesh and wire bench installation. Install fire protection cabinets.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
54 | P a g e
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
CW FM-200 Upgrade
PLR Art Program Changes
CW Elect. & Structural Canopy Changes (Construction Costs & Schedule - TIA-4)
PHL Concourse Railing Changes
PHL & PLR Canopy Bipod Strut & Cable Fix
A A C A A
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES:
Pearlridge Station TCCR and UPS Building – Pathway to guideway conduit installation is complete. TCCR and UPS rooms are now being shared with the Core Systems Contractor.
Aloha Stadium Station TCCR and UPS Rooms – Pathway to guideway conduits complete. TCCR and UPS rooms are now being shared with the Core Systems Contractor.
Canopy arms are erected at Pearl Highlands and Pearlridge. Energization of Pearl Highlands and Pearlridge – February 2020. Fabric installation to begin at Pearlridge-June, Pearl Highlands- July, and Aloha Stadium- September.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
KHSG NCR Log (Issued by Nan)
NCRs Issued to Date
Closed Open
Pearl Highlands 29 26 3
Pearlridge 26 25 1
Aloha Stadium 7 5 2
Contract Wide 0 0 0
TOTAL 62 56 6
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
55 | P a g e
C. Kamehameha Highway Resurfacing (KHR) CPP No.: DBB-701 Contractor: Road and Highway Builders, LLC (RHB) Contract Start Date: Notice to Proceed NTP #1: August 2018 Contract Substantial Completion: September 2019 Projected Completion of Work: August 2020
Project Description: The project consists of pavement resurfacing and other roadway reconstruction associated with completion of the Kamehameha Highway Guideway contract. Construction includes, but is not limited to, clearing, grubbing, erosion and dust control, grading and hauling, maintenance of traffic, pavement resurfacing, and installation of pavement markings and striping, roadway signs, curb ramps, drainage, waterlines, gas lines, traffic signal loop detectors, retaining wall, guard railing, fencing and bus shelters.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete 97.8% 11 months behind**
Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* 100% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **Pending contract actions will extend contract completion date.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $1,974,656
DBE % Attained: 6.94%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $2,455,926
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $2,455,926
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
SCHEDULE: The contract completion date will be extended due to delays in road widening at Kaahumanu Street, Construction
Right-of-Entry (CROE) for construction of retaining wall #9, and additional change work. A time extension is pending.
Developing additional change orders that could extend the completion date to October 2020. _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Prepared finding of merit for RFCR 00011 KHR
miscellaneous changes (CROE, bus shelter, electronic vehicle counter [EVC] loops and others).
Prepared finding of merit for RFCR 00013 Pearl City Stream Median Guardrail.
Look Ahead: Begin change order work.
Original Contract: $25,989,989 Incurred-to-Date: $27,703,164
Current Contract Value¹: $28,445,915 Incurred in June: $519,282
Outstanding Issues: 4 Contractor CP Amount: $14,072,952 1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
56 | P a g e
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
Kam Hwy/Ka'ahumanu St Changes
KHR Miscellaneous Changes
Left Turn at Kuala Street
Pearl City Stream Median Guardrail
P A C A
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: Secure CROE for Pearlridge bus stop – July 2020.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT: KHR continues to follow established quality processes through quality monitoring and audits.
KHR NCR Log (Issued by Road and Highway Builders)
Total NCRs Issued to Date Closed Open
0 0 0
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
57 | P a g e
D. Design Services for 138kV Utilities Relocation at KHG
CPP No.: FD-700 Contractor: R.M. Towill Corporation (RMTC) Contract Start Date: September 2018 Contract Substantial Completion: November 2021 Project Description: Architectural and Engineering Services for the final design to relocate the existing 138kV overhead electrical lines to underground lines at Kamehameha Highway Guideway and Stations.
Progress Schedule Status
Based on Expenditures* 47.9%
TBD Early Plan* 61.0%
Late Plan* 48.0% *Data as of June 26, 2020.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $0
DBE % Attained: 0%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $0
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $0
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
SCHEDULE: An updated preliminary design submittal (to HECO), incorporating additional HECO review comments on the
previously updated preliminary design submittal, was made on Feb. 21, 2020. These updated preliminary design drawings were used by HECO for sway calculations. We received final calculations for all areas except around pole 15, and between poles 18 and 20. The design consultant is updating the drawings as they receive final calculations from HECO.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: The design consultant traffic counting was temporarily
suspended due to unusual traffic patterns experienced during the COVID-19 shutdown.
The design consultant continued additional topographic survey work. This work is ongoing in reaction to comments received from affected agencies and consequential revisions being made.
The design consultant will be providing HECO with geotechnical engineering services. The geotechnical engineer continues to obtain permits for the work.
Look Ahead: Continue periodic HECO meetings. Continue refining preliminary design work. Continue to meet with third party agencies
to discuss their comments/concerns on the preliminary submittal.
Perform geotechnical investigation for the purpose of HECO’s pole foundation design, per HECO request.
Original Contract: $8,766,327 Incurred-to-Date: $4,305,543
Current Contract Value¹: $8,766,327 Incurred in June: $107,446 1Current Contract Value = Original contract value with Design Allowance + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
58 | P a g e
Activities this Month (continued): Our schedule has been revised to incorporate HECO
comments and recent developments regarding easements, acquisitions and HECO design tasks. The updated schedule was sent to HECO.
We received final sway calculations from HECO for all areas except around pole 15, and between poles 18 and 20. The design consultant is processing the results upon receipt of the final calculations. The schedule of this work is controlled by HECO.
The preliminary design has been submitted to affected third party agencies, and the design consultant continues to schedule meetings with each agency to discuss third party agency comments. Comments from the City and County of Honolulu Department of Environmental Services (ENV) and the Board of Water Supply (BWS) have been received by the design consultant, and consequential revisions to the design are being made.
A typical cross-section of the proposed Aiea Stream utility bridge was provided to HECO for review and comment. HECO confirmed that they will maintain the utility bridge following completion of construction.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES (new issues are in bold font): The design consultant needs to continue to coordinate with third party agencies to identify portions of the
alignment that need to be revised. HECO needs to complete their final sway calculations.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES:
Based on schedule information we currently have, key upcoming milestones are as follows: o Prefinal Design: Oct. 14, 2020. o Final Design: April 21, 2021.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
59 | P a g e
4.4 Section III – Airport: Aloha Stadium to Middle Street Transit Center Station A. Airport Section Guideway and Stations (AGS)
CPP No.: DB-450 Contractor: Shimmick/Traylor/Granite, JV (STG) Contract Start Date: December 2016
Contract Substantial Completion: May 2021
Projected Completion of Work: October 2021
Project Description: The Airport Guideway and Stations Design-Build contract consists of the design and construction of 5.2 miles of elevated guideway, four (4) stations, and associated facilities between Aloha Stadium and the Middle Street Transit Center. The contractor will begin by interfacing with design disciplines, third-party stakeholders, and construction contracts within the corridor of the project to coordinate and resolve utilities conflicts. Design field verification efforts (potholing and geotechnical exploration) will be followed by construction activities once design packages have been approved.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete* 71.3%
5 months behind** Early Plan* 92.4%
Late Plan 78.8% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **Further explanation is provided in the Schedule section.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $43,569,716
DBE % Attained: 4.91%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $11,684,752
00030 Zone 4 Additional Clearance Requirement $78,000
Cumulative Current Report $11,762,752
Original Contract: $874,750,000 Incurred-to-Date: $622,970,587
Current Contract Value¹: $886,512,752 Incurred in June: $38,204,598
Outstanding Issues: 14 Contractor CP Amount: $43,658,803 1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
60 | P a g e
SCHEDULE: Mitigation Schedule Accepted as Noted. The Mitigation Schedule has a December 2021 completion date; however, we
are working to mitigate it, and HART and the contractor have agreed to an Oct. 31, 2021 completion date. Additional workshops are continuing to further define station activities for access milestones for CSC.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: AGS Construction Status as of 06/26/2020
Guideway Structure Element
Total to Date
Total Qty % Complete
Shafts 188 225 83.6%
Columns 176 232 75.9%
Segment Casting 2,652 2,708 97.9%
Spans Stressed 120 210 57.1%
Spans Grouted 110 210 52.4%
Track 1 rail work 1 210 0.5%
Track 2 rail work 9 210 4.3%
Track 1 Third Rail 0 210 0.0%
Track 2 Third Rail 0 210 0.0%
Mill & Overlay 0 * 0.0% * Amounts to be determined.
Activities this Month: Guideway, Rail and Utility Work
Gantry 1 crane continued; erected/stressed 5 spans at 498 through 502. Gantry 2 crane continued; erected/stressed 1 span at 543. Gantry 3 erected 3 spans at 603 through 605.
Utilities – HECO Zones 6A, 8B and 9 infrastructure continued. Traction Power ductbanks to System Site (SS) #25 are ongoing.
Installation of rail work continued in Reach A, iron horses and plinth forms installed. Plinths poured for 8 spans for Track 2 at Span 423 through 430, and 1 span for Track 1 at Span 422.
Reach A: Traffic Signal (TS) continued on Kamehameha Highway at Radford Drive and Center Drive. Median restoration finalized from Piers 433-462. Reach B Civil/Utilities was approved by HART/HDOT/DTS and is routing for signatures.
Reach B: Pier 504 cap completed. Traffic Signal work at Center Drive and Valkenburgh Street is ongoing.
Reach C: Street Light (SL) relocation continued at airport. Reach D: HECO Zone 8A (Ualena) completed electrical cutovers
to transformer vaults and service reconnections on Ualena Street. Comm. cable installation, including service lines for Hawaiian Telcom (HTI)/ Oceanic Time Warner Cable (OTWC) commenced. Traffic Signal work commenced at Lagoon.
Makalapa (Pearl Harbor Naval Base) Station Installation of rebar for platform girders on top of the guideway.
Ewa portion of platform girders tub poured. Lelepaua (Daniel K. Inouye International Airport) Station Excavation and installation of conduits from Elevators 1-3 (Lot J)
to TCCR. Āhua (Lagoon Drive) Station Completed underground conduits for electrical, fare gates and
city fiber infrastructure installation at Mauka Entrance. Kahauiki (Middle Street Transit Center) Station Continued excavation for station entrance.
Look Ahead: Guideway, Rail and Utility Work Design Submittals Approved:
o Reach E – Civil and Composite Utilities Issued for Construction (IFC)
o Civil Common Drawings and Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) IFC
o Middle Street Transit Center (MSTC) Station IFC
Form/rebar/pour Reaches C and E columns and segment casting.
Begin drilling shafts on Ualena Street in Reach D and continue in Reaches C and E.
Continue pouring C-Bents and Straddle Bents, and columns in Reach C and Reach E.
Continue installation of rail work. Complete electrical relocation work in HECO
Zones 6A, 8B and 9. Coordination taking place with third parties.
Makalapa (Pearl Harbor Naval Base) Station Finish platform girder rebar installation,
concrete and post-tensioned (PT). Await fabrication and delivery of structural steel in August 2020.
Lelepaua (Daniel K. Inouye International Airport) Station Start foundations for TCCR and Ancillary
Building. Āhua (Lagoon Drive) Station Begin forming concrete masonry unit (CMU)
walls and slab on grade for station rooms. Kahauiki (Middle Street Transit Center) Station Finish excavation and backfill for sub grade for
station entrance.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
61 | P a g e
KEY ISSUES:
Key Issues with Contractor Proposal Title CPC Code
Hurricane Lane
Access to Premium Property
Lagoon Dr Station - Additional Infrastructure for Interim Opening Part II
FCN-KJL Properties TCE Agreement Reimbursement
HIA Site Redevelopment
ITS IP Based Design
DPP Erosion Control Notes
Fare System Walker Duct
Fare Gate FDAS Relay Cable
Pier 505 Standby Drilling Equipment
Reach A Civil and Paving
SCADA Infrastructure
Additional VMS Boards at Station Platforms
Inefficient Utility Claim
A A B P B P P P P A P P P C
LEGEND: A = less than $1 million; B = $1 million-$5 million; C = greater than $5 million; P = pending contractor submittal ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: C-Bent Capital 504 (linked to the critical path) was completed on June 15, 2020. Span 422 Track 1 plinths was completed on June 25, 2020. Segment 2,650 (98% complete) was cast on June 26, 2020. Electrical cutovers to transformer vaults and service reconnections on Ualena Street was completed on June 27,
2020. Completed erection of 9 guideway spans in June 2020.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT:
Pre-Activity Meetings continue.
AGS NCR Log (Issued by STG)
NCRs Issued to Date
Closed Open
Guideway 341 266 75 Pearl Harbor Naval Base Station 33 21 12 Honolulu International Airport Station 30 23 7 Lagoon Drive Station 16 12 4 Middle Street Transit Center Station 8 5 3 Contract Wide 17 17 0 TOTAL 445 344 101
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
62 | P a g e
4.5 Section IV – City Center: Middle Street Transit Center Station to Ala Moana Center A. City Center Section Utilities and Guideway
CPP No.: FD-530 Contractor: AECOM Technical Services, Inc., Final Design Consultant (Engineer of Record) Contract Start Date: July 2012 Contract Substantial Completion: July 2020 Projected Completion of Work: July 2020
Project Description: The original City Center Section Utilities and Guideway (CCUG) final design contract consisted of utility relocations, roadway widening, and 4.12 miles of elevated transit guideway serving eight (8) passenger stations. The scope of the CCUG contract has been reduced to include only the design of utility relocations and roadway widening to facilitate future guideway design and construction by others. The remaining work is herein referred to as the City Center Utilities Relocation (CCUR) design.
Progress Schedule Status
Based on Expenditures* 99.3% On time (based on contract substantial completion date)**
Early Plan* 100%
Late Plan* 99.9% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **Further explanation is provided in the Schedule section.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $191,227
DBE % Attained: 0.33%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $14,550,073
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $14,550,073
SCHEDULE: Due to changes to save cost and delays by third party reviews, CCUR final design is scheduled to conclude in third
quarter 2020. A change order is currently being routed to account for the additional design changes as well as a time extension for the CCUR construction period.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Coordination with City and utility third parties to address review
comments for Task Orders (TOs) within the review process: TO2A Draft Rev. 1 v2 (6/12/20), TO2B Draft Rev. 1 (6/12/20), TO22 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution v2 (6/24/20), TO23A Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution v1 (6/29/20), TO23B Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution v1 (6/29/20), Traffic Signal (TS)/Street Light (SL) 1 Draft Rev. 0 v3 (6/29/20).
Look Ahead: Complete and submit final design
drawings for TOs 22, 24, 23A, 23B, 32, 25, 28, 2 and 13; the Traffic Signal/Street Light as well as update(s) to the Roadway design plan package, as required.
Original Contract: $43,948,220 Incurred-to-Date: $57,489,264
Current Contract Value¹: $58,498,293 Incurred in June²: $0 1Current Contract Value = Original contract value with Design Allowance + executed Change Orders 2Work has progressed and incurred amounts will be reflected as invoices are approved in the City’s C2HERPS system
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
63 | P a g e
Activities this Month (continued):
Design Package submittals/resubmittals this month included: TO2A Draft Rev. 1 V1 Comment Resolution Doc. to Hawai‘i Gas on 6/2/20, HDOT on 6/11/20 and City and County of Honolulu Department of Environmental Services (ENV) on 6/12/20. TO22 Draft Rev. 0 V3 Comment Resolution Doc. to HECO and Hawaiian Telcom (HTI) on 6/24/20. TO23A Draft Rev.0 v1 to AT&T, HECO and HTI on 6/2/20, Board of Water Supply (BWS) on 6/3/20, Civil Engineering Branch (CEB) on 6/5/20, DTS on 6/23/20, and Department of Design & Construction – Mechanical & Electrical Division (DDC-MED) on 6/29/20. TO23B Draft Rev.0 v1 to BWS on 6/3/20, DTS on 6/24/20, and DDC-MED on 6/29/20. Traffic Signal/Street Light Dillingham 1 Draft Rev. 0 v2 to BWS on 6/5/20 and DDC-MED on 6/29/20. TO24 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution v2 to HECO/Customer Installation Department (CID) on 6/24/20. TO17 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution Doc. V4 to HECO on 6/12/20, and Issued for Construction (IFC) Submittal 6/26/20. TO28 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution Doc. v2 to HECO on 6/22/20.
Received official comments for: TO2A Draft Rev. 1 v2 from ENV (6/9/20), Hawai‘i Gas (6/10/20) and BWS (6/15/20); TO2B Draft Rev. 1 from BWS (6/9/20), ENV (6/9/20) and Hawai‘i Gas (6/10/20); TO22 Draft Rev. 0 V2 Comment Resolution Doc. from HECO (6/2/20); TO23A Draft Rev. 0 Comm. Reso Doc. from AT&T (6/2/20), BWS (6/9/20), HTI (6/10/20), CEB (6/12/20), DDC-MED (6/15/20), DTS (6/16/20 and 6/25/20), HDOT (6/18/20), HECO (6/26/20); TO23B Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution Doc. from BWS (6/9/20), HTI (6/10/20), DDC-MED (6/15/20), DTS (6/16/20 and 6/25/20), HECO (6/20/20); TO13 Draft Rev. 1 from Wastewater Branch (WWB) (6/17/20) and Subdivision Branch (SUBD) (6/18/20); TO25 Rev. D from WWB (6/10/20), SUBD (6/10/20) and HECO and HECO/CID (6/15/20); TO32 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution Doc. from BWS (6/9/20), HECO and HECO/CID (6/7/20), SUBD (6/15/20); TO24 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution Doc. From HECO/CID (6/30/20); TO17 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution Doc. v4 from HECO (6/12/20); TS/SL Dillingham 1 Draft Rev. 0 from CEB (6/12/20) and BWS (6/30/20); and TS/SL Nimitz Draft Rev. 0 from DTS (5/15/20).
Continued coordination with HECO and other concerned third party utility agencies (i.e. BWS, HTI, etc.) to finalize utility concerns and comments for pending design package submittal.
Continued coordination with other agencies with projects within City Center, as well as landowners and their consultants/contractors for development projects.
Continued support during construction via Request for Information (RFI) with CCUR contractors.
Continued coordination with utilities for all utility layouts for remaining dry utility task order packages, Traffic Signal and Street Light, as well as the final Roadway Packages.
Coordination with City and State agencies to process One-Time Review (OTR) and required permit approvals to allow construction to start.
Continued coordination with ROW team for ongoing negotiations for acquisitions.
Continued coordination and bi-weekly meetings with the DPP Director and staff for ongoing design task order packages review.
Look Ahead (continued): Third party reviews and comments
for Task Orders 24, 28, 2, 13, 26, 25, and Street Lights and Traffic Signal Packages.
Finalize detail submittal for 138kV steel pole foundation design.
Finalize detail submittal for micropile needed for 138kV / BWS facilities crossing(s) on Dillingham Boulevard.
Final submittal for hydraulic/hydrology analysis for Kapalama Canal, per change order.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
64 | P a g e
KEY ISSUES (new issues are in bold font): Finding of Merit/No Merit (FOM) processed this month: (1) Additional Design Services during the June 4, 2020
Contract Change Committee (CCC) meeting. Executed June 9, 2020. Executive Decision Document (EDD) for additional services and time extension to the contract was routed on
June 12, 2020 for approval and signatures; final approval by CEO June 24, 2020. A presentation for the change order was provided by the Director of Construction to the Project Oversight Committee (POC) in early June and during the main HART Board meeting on June 25, 2020; request for change order was approved during this session. The change order is currently in process for execution.
HART is working with third party utilities as well as City agencies to better streamline reviews to prevent further slippage in design schedules.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY MILESTONES: TO2A Draft Rev. 1 V1 Comment Resolution Doc., TO22 Draft Rev. 0 V3 Comment Resolution Doc., TO23A Draft
Rev.0 v1, TO23B Draft Rev.0 v1, Traffic Signal/Street Light Dillingham 1 Draft Rev. 0 v2, TO24 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution v2, TO17 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution Doc. V4, IFC Submittal, TO28 Draft Rev. 0 Comment Resolution Doc. v2.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
65 | P a g e
B. City Center Utilities Relocation (CCUR) Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ) CPP No.: DBB-511 Contractor: Nan, Inc. Contract Start Date: May 2018 Contract Term Completion: May 2022 Projected Completion of Relocation Work: February 2023
Project Description: The CCUR contract is a unit priced, task order contract that relocates utilities in advance of the City Center Guideway and Stations construction work. It provides utility relocation construction services for a variety of utilities along the civil roadway construction throughout the City Center segment of the HRTP. The construction services to be provided will include, but are not limited to, permanent and temporary wet and dry utility relocation work which will include miscellaneous, as-needed site work, installation of permanent/temporary utility poles, duct bank construction, and other utility installation support structures.
Progress Schedule Status
Physical % Complete* 11.4%**
9 months behind*** Early Plan* 55.8%
Late Plan* 44.8% *Data as of June 26, 2020. **The percentages shown are based on installed work values against the current allocated amount. The contracted amount does not incorporate the full scope of the work. In May 2020, HART presented an Estimated Cost at Completion to the HART Board for all the work required prior to the P3 contractor commencing their work. HART Project Controls and CEI are now working to incorporate a quantity-based assessment that is being imported into the oversight schedule; the resulting percentages will be presented with the July update. ***The Execution Plan reflects the most current strategies to execute the work and status of progress.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
DBE Participation Task Orders
Actual DBE Participation: $0 Number of Task
Orders Issued Amount ($)
DBE % Attained: 0% Task Orders Previously Issued 14 $378,994,598
Task Orders Issued this Month 0 $0
Amendments to Task Orders 0 $0
Total Task Orders Issued 14 $378,994,598
Original Contract: $400,000,000 Incurred-to-Date: $32,800,101
Current Contract Value¹: $400,000,000 Incurred in June: $8,483,024 1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
66 | P a g e
SCHEDULE: Multiple areas have been impacted this period. Projected Completion of CCUR by February 2023. All Traffic Signals and Street Lights pre-IFC design submitted by July 2020. Pre-IFC design complete Q2 2020. All Wet Utility task orders under construction Q3 2020. All Dry Utility task orders under construction Q4 2020. HECO completes all electrical design requirements Q1 2021. Final roadway revision encompassing all changes Q4 2020.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month:
All Area 1: Nan has initiated a Purchase Order Agreement with Rohn for the 138kV poles and will no longer pursue the Valmont poles. This reduces procurement cost and duration by approximately $800,000 and 18-weeks respectively, compared to Valmont. A letter is planned to be sent to Nan on July 2, 2020, for the approval to switch vendors.
Obtained HTI, Oceanic Time Warner Cable (OTWC) and AT&T’s concurrence for the use of HECO’s concrete mix when used in joint trenches, utilizing high slump mix and no vibration.
Area 1A: HECO approved HART’s formal request on June 8, 2020 to complete 12kv conduit installation between Laumaka and Pu‘uhale, pending certain conditions were followed, including inspection requests, meeting all HECO and manufacturer requirements and geotechnical engineer recommendations. AT&T temp connection proposal - CEI is currently working with AT&T to determine timelines and required coordination between AT&T Public Sector Solutions (PSS) and AT&T Corp.; updating the schedule accordingly. Obtained TO-22 (dry) 138kV OTR June 15, 2020.
Area 1B: Potholing for existing utilities continues, based on Rev. D submittal. Focus has been on IFC design resolution with all reviewing agencies for permitting of dry utility work from Mokauea to Kapalama Canal. HART understands DPP’s preference for trenchless crossings of the Kapalama Canal and has made a decision to go forward with it. AECOM provided a drainage report to DPP for review on June 2, 2020. Box culvert demo and temporary bypass – Nan has been directed to proceed, based upon the agreed pricing, upon receipt of the approved 2A, 2B, 23A and 23B trenching and street usage permits.
Area 1C: Potholing for existing utilities continues, based on Rev. D submittal.
Area 2: HECO and HTI duct bank installation continues. Collucio completed jet grouting activities. Hawaiian Electric Phase II Environmental remediation in the Makai yard is complete, allowing Nan access on June 27, 2020. Jensen provided a letter and revised shop drawing confirming manhole (MH) knockouts acceptable. Revised MicroStation files provided to HECO on June 22, 2020, allowing them to finalize their electrical design for the temporary connections between Area 1C and Area 2. Structural jet grout column alignment issue has been resolved by City and County (C&C) Wastewater Inspector correspondence stating they take no issue with the installation and it is accepted as installed.
Look Ahead: All Area 1: Advancing procurement with Rohn for
138kV poles is critical in order to maintain schedule. HECO is in agreement of 3” minimum, 6” maximum concrete cover tolerances for duct banks. RFI to be submitted to HECO for concurrence to cover both AGS and CCUR, and HECO will provide documentation confirming. Nan and HART continue resolution plan updates to address HDOT’s concerns on the progress of meeting HART’s commitments outlined in the Traffic Management Plan (TMP) Technical Memo comment matrix. Technical Memo approval anticipated by the end of July.
Area 1A: AT&T Temporary Connection Plan – planning for relocation through both 1A and 1B in a single phase can improve efficiency for implementation in conjunction with IFC’s and permitting for Area 1B. Obtain IFC for Traffic Signal and Street Lights Dillingham: Middle Street to Kapalama Canal - OTR received previously.
Area 1B: DTS request to assess impact to the Dillingham corridor will not hold up wet and dry IFC, due to the recent traffic analysis. AECOM anticipates providing the Turning Pocket Analysis by mid-July for DTS review. HART will pursue the necessary permitting for microtunneling of the Kapalama Canal utility crossings. Trenchless exhibit with means and method (including launch location and any Best Management Practices [BMPs]) will be prepared for the permit application. HART’s design allows for Mauka and Makai sides to occur concurrently. Finalizing details will be ongoing with HECO.
Area 1C: Initial Rev. D Traffic Signal & Street Light (TS/SL) package submittal delayed to July 10, 2020, due to edits needed during the Quality Assurance (QA)/Quality Control (QC) process and to incorporate lessons learned from the resolution of adjacent CCUR TS/SL packages, which will mitigate subsequent comments for this submittal leading to IFC. Potholing of existing utilities based on the latest design updates will be ongoing. Test trench along the proposed HECO 138kV duct line to determine potential root damage is dependent on finalizing the CROE with Honolulu Community College (HCC); discussions are ongoing.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
67 | P a g e
Activities this Month (continued):
Area 3: RFI submitted to AECOM for repair of seawall in conflict with proposed utility design; coordination is ongoing for acceptance by HDOT. An additional wall was discovered and is being investigated with HDOT to verify if it is abandoned. HDOT permit to perform work on state highways was received June 10, 2020. No trenching permit application needed within JUOA agreement limits. Nan and CEI are incorporating reduction of scope for the task order to reflect HECO variances as the design revisions are pending.
Area 4: CEI is preparing task order authorization to include the scope of all design task orders from Richards to Ward under construction TO-03. Nan is preparing work plans including potholing and jet grouting that can be performed. TO-24 potholing plan received and approved as noted. Obtained TO-32 (dry) OTR on June 12, 2020. The Hawai‘i Community Development Authority (HCDA) extended HART’s construction right-of-entry (CROE) contract through June 20, 2021.
Area 5: HECO and HTI manhole jet grouting commenced. Dry utility infrastructure focus will be ongoing for the next six months. Iwi Kupuna were found in front of Waimanu yard, all appropriate state and local officials were notified and the State Historic Preservation Division (SHPD) determined that the iwi will be relocated to the curation facility. TO-17 (dry) IFC obtained June 15, 2020.
Area 6: Nan has proceeded on additional jet grouting for dry utility lines outside of the 10-foot offset of HECO 138kV lines. CEI and Nan continue to work with HECO to investigate and remove Fluidized Thermal Backfill (FTB) overpour on the existing 138kV underground (UG) circuit to allow space for connection of a waterline. Further jet grouting work will be released once the HECO standby inspector request is approved. HECO has toned several times; further investigation will be performed with the HECO standby inspector onsite.
Look Ahead (continued): Area 2: Continue Dry infrastructure installation duct
banks and manholes. Coordination with HECO to determine pole placement as HECO completes their electrical design. Continue weekly discussions with HTI and OTWC to refine the construction schedule, production, and explore mitigations.
Area 3: Demolition/removal of existing and abandoned utilities and new dry utility infrastructure work continues. HART expects a Design Change Notice (DCN) approximately 4-6 weeks after all IFC agency signatures are completed, eta mid-July. DCN 01 will address design changes associated with previously approved HECO variances reducing dry utility scope and cost. Obtain City trenching permit required for gas line work in City ROW on TO-14 and commence work.
Area 4: Proceed with incorporating additional scoping work into the task order, this will encompass all the work along Halekauwila from Richards Street to Ward Avenue, inclusive of all related design task orders under construction TO-03. Halekauwila Staging Yard (Civic Center Station) Environmental Phase II Site Assessment is scheduled to begin the week of July 13, 2020. Remediation duration will take approximately 15-weeks; although Nan should be able to gain access back to the yard within 6-7 weeks, as remediation is not anticipated to be needed at this time.
Area 5: Finalize agreement with property owners/tenants for placement of the jet grout plant for continued jet grouting in preparation of wet and dry utility relocation.
Area 6: Continue jet grouting for dry utilities. HECO Standby Inspectors: Nan to submit a work plan addressing safety countermeasures for protection against a strike to the existing underground 138kV line during jet grouting activities. Nan to be provided decibel readings with jet grouting machinery before and after mitigations for a baseline prior to night work commencing, due to noise complaints to the Department of Health (DOH).
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES (new issues are in bold font):
Cost or schedule for the CCUR contract may be impacted if these issues aren’t resolved: o Design Finalization: The schedule for completion of the dry utility plans by AECOM, and approval by all
stakeholders has impacted CCUR Area Target Finish dates due to ongoing and additional outstanding comment resolution items from the reviewing parties. Final design approvals are critical to meeting the projected construction duration.
o Mitigation efforts: AECOM completed draft IFC submittals for final review, except TS/SL Dillingham: Kapalama Canal through Iwilei. AECOM has increased the coordination frequency with utility agencies to expedite reviews by holding informal comment resolution review sessions. DPP reviewers have been requested to bring substantial review comments up during reoccurring bi-weekly meetings with all parties present. HART is continuously strategizing with utility stakeholders on steps to shorten review and approval response time. In parallel, HART,
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
68 | P a g e
CEI and Nan, in coordination with the utility stakeholders, are analyzing and planning work scope that can start immediately upon receipt of the applicable permits. HECO, HTI and AT&T have all allowed HART the ability to move forward in Area 1A at risk as IFC is being signed off, under existing permits and with specific conditions. No new mitigations to the construction schedule were available to incorporate this month.
o HART Right-of-Way: Currently working to complete acquisition of property within CCUR. Current focus is on the following properties: Takara Printing, Bishop Estate – Club Cleopatra, Iwilei Station - HECO, General Services Administration (GSA) – Halekauwila St. by Mililani St., and Howard Hughes.
o Mitigation efforts: HART obtained FTA’s concurrence on Takara Printing’s parcel counteroffer. An official letter was provided to the owner on June 26, 2020, with anticipated access by the end of July, pending escrow and Possession and Use Agreement (PUA) completion. Cost to Cure (C2C) CROE agreement for Club Cleopatra came through from HART Corporation Counsel (COR), however the property owner was firm that no electrical work is permitted until the agreement is finalized; estimated to be December 2020, the timing of which should not affect the current CCUR schedule. GSA provided some movement to allow landscaping work to occur simultaneously as CCUR work, pending Royal obtaining a performance bond required for the landscaping. HCC acquisition pushed to Q3 2020, pending HCC providing HART feedback on the current CROE. A decision has been made to move forward with a HART CROE, rather than extending the Royal CROE, as a general HART CROE will mitigate future issues of transferring a CROE from one contractor to another (i.e., CCUR to CCUR II or the P3). Regular meetings are being held between HART and HCC to resolve the CROE details and to execute the new agreement. Hawaiian Electric Phase II Environmental remediation in the Iwilei Makai yard is complete, allowing Nan yard access on June 27, 2020. Iwilei Mauka yard is still on schedule to be completed Q3 2020.
o HECO Agreements: The Nov. 25, 2013 agreement with HECO allows HECO to complete the electrical design up to 2 years after receiving the final infrastructure design. A general agreement was in place, as of Q4 2019, to expedite electrical design times to meet schedule needs.
o Mitigation efforts: HART and HECO meet bi-weekly or more frequently as required, to review schedule assumptions based on the expedited schedule durations incorporated and requirements to maintain and improve the schedule based on the 2019 general agreement. Regular, informal communications occur between CEI and HECO on a daily basis to facilitate design and construction resolutions.
o Long lead Material Procurement: Estimates for the duration of long lead materials have been adjusted in the schedule based on information provided by HECO for electrical equipment to be purchased under the CCUR contract. These corrected durations have contributed to the critical paths associated with CCUR Area Target Finish dates. The long lead procurement cycle is driving the longest path completion of Area 1A.
o Mitigation efforts: HECO provided HART additional suppliers who met their pole requirements. Rohn provided pricing and riser pole calculations, which were submitted to HECO on June 16, 2020. Rohn’s pricing is $800,000 less and the lead time would be reduced by 18-weeks, compared to Valmont. A decision regarding Nan changing vendors was made based on HECO’s validation that Rohn’s proposal will meet the pre-requisite submittal requirements.
o Geotechnical Engineer's Recommendation: Cost impacts to the contract will occur for 2’ over excavation of trenches in areas where soft lagoonal soils or groundwater are encountered and the installation of a Mirafi wrapped rock stabilization layer is required. This will need to be monitored closely by CEI.
o Mitigation efforts: CEI confirmed HECO’s inquiry that the geotechnical engineer's recommendations are applicable to both duct lines and MH's for City Center alignment where conditions warrant. A geotechnical engineer was consulted to discuss mitigation measures for soft soil areas. AECOM has revised the trench restoration details to clarify where the crushed rock stabilization will be required based on various soil and ground water conditions. HART provided HECO with the final geotechnical engineer’s recommendations on June 10, 2020. Additional jet grouting may be considered to limit areas requiring overexcavation and stabilization to mitigate high shoring and dewatering costs associated with the extra depth.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
69 | P a g e
KEY MILESTONES:
Construction Status1
NTP Target Finish2 Installed Complete3
Area 1A: Dillingham: Middle to Mokauea 20-Sep-19 24-Nov-21 5.0%
Area 1B: Dillingham: Mokauea to Waiakamilo 20-Sep-19 25-Feb-23 1.1%
Area 1C: Dillingham: Waiakamilo to Ka‘aahi 01-Feb-20 30-Jan-23 0.8%
Area 2: Ka‘aahi Street 02-Feb-19 14-Apr-21 33.4%
Area 3: Nimitz Highway 20-Sep-19 27-Sept-21 11.9%
Area 4: Halekauwila Street 24-Jan-20 19-Jul-22 0.5%
Area 5: Queen Street 01-Oct-18 01-Jul-21 2.4%
Area 6: Kona Street 01-Mar-19 17-Sept-21 23.1%
1 Based on 6/26/2020 data date. Multiple Design Packages are incorporated into each area. 2 Based on double shifts, 6 days per week, 10 hours per shift. 3 The percentages shown are based on installed work values against the current allocated amount. The contracted amount does not incorporate the full scope of the work. In May 2020, HART presented an Estimated Cost at Completion to the HART Board for all the work required prior to the P3 contractor commencing their work. HART Project Controls and CEI are now working to incorporate a quantity-based assessment that is being imported into the oversight schedule; the resulting percentages will be presented with the July update. __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
QUALITY MANAGEMENT: No major quality issues identified this period.
CCUR NCR Log (Issued by Nan)
Total NCRs Issued to Date Closed Open
8 7 1
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
70 | P a g e
4.6 Professional Services A. Program Management Contractor Contract
CPP No.: MM-902 Contractor: HDR Engineering, Inc. Contract Start Date: January 1, 2017 Contract Completion Date: December 31, 2022 Description of Work: Oversee the successful design and construction of the full Honolulu Rail Transit Project (HRTP), which includes providing personnel with relevant transit design, construction and operations experience and leadership in the various areas, including construction management, design management, project controls, procurement and contracts, right of way, public and business outreach, safety and security, quality assurance, environmental planning, and federal programmatic compliance.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $332,229
DBE % Attained: 0.52%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $0
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $0
*Monthly actuals are based on Pay App Verification values and are reconciled with the city’s C2HERPS system instead of CMS.
Jan
-17
Mar
-17
May
-17
Jul-
17
Sep
-17
No
v-1
7
Jan
-18
Mar
-18
May
-18
Jul-
18
Sep
-18
No
v-1
8
Jan
-19
Mar
-19
May
-19
Jul-
19
Sep
-19
No
v-1
9
Jan
-20
Mar
-20
May
-20
Jul-
20
Sep
-20
No
v-2
0
Jan
-21
Mar
-21
May
-21
Jul-
21
Sep
-21
No
v-2
1
Jan
-22
Mar
-22
May
-22
Jul-
22
Sep
-22
No
v-2
2
Actual $ Per Month Forecast $ Per Month Actual % Forecast %
Actual 63.0 %
06/2020
Original Contract: $63,522,953 Incurred-to-Date: $39,755,919
Current Contract Value¹: $63,522,953 Incurred in June: $1,151,546
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
71 | P a g e
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month:
21 HDR staff contracted through HART. Hired three (3) additional senior staff members to
support HART’s Procurement Department with the CCUR RFP.
Terminated three Public Involvement (PI) subcontracts, as the PI services were transferred to HART staff.
Look Ahead: Continue to support the design and
construction of the HRTP, including assessing management needs in Project Controls.
KEY ISSUES:
Based on the average monthly expenditure rate, the current contract total will be exhausted by June 2021.
Subcontractor charges paid to date (from beginning of contract) is $5,667,627.96.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
72 | P a g e
B. Construction Engineering and Inspection (CEI) West CPP No.: MM-290 Contractor: PGH Wong Engineering, Inc. Contract Start Date: January 9, 2014 Contract Completion Date: December 31, 2020 Description of Work: Provides construction, engineering, and inspection services for construction contract compliance, construction scheduling, construction cost estimating, support, on-site field oversight, project controls and related construction support for the west section of the project.
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $12,156,277
DBE % Attained: 13.05%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $38,900,000
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $38,900,000
* Monthly actuals are based on Pay App Verification values and are reconciled with the city’s C2HERPS system instead of CMS.
Jan
-14
Feb
-14
Mar
-14
Ap
r-1
4
May
-14
Jun
-14
Jul-
14
Au
g-1
4
Sep
-14
Oct
-14
No
v-1
4
Dec
-14
Jan
-15
Feb
-15
Mar
-15
Ap
r-1
5
May
-15
Jun
-15
Jul-
15
Au
g-1
5
Sep
-15
Oct
-15
No
v-1
5
Dec
-15
Jan
-16
Feb
-16
Mar
-16
Ap
r-1
6
May
-16
Jun
-16
Jul-
16
Au
g-1
6
Sep
-16
Oct
-16
No
v-1
6
Dec
-16
Jan
-17
Feb
-17
Mar
-17
Ap
r-1
7
May
-17
Jun
-17
Jul-
17
Au
g-1
7
Sep
-17
Oct
-17
No
v-1
7
Dec
-17
Jan
-18
Feb
-18
Mar
-18
Ap
r-1
8
May
-18
Jun
-18
Jul-
18
Au
g-1
8
Sep
-18
Oct
-18
No
v-1
8
Dec
-18
Jan
-19
Feb
-19
Mar
-19
Ap
r-1
9
May
-19
Jun
-19
Jul-
19
Au
g-1
9
Sep
-19
Oct
-19
No
v-1
9
Dec
-19
Jan
-20
Feb
-20
Mar
-20
Ap
r-2
0
May
-20
Jun
-20
Jul-
20
Au
g-2
0
Sep
-20
Oct
-20
No
v-2
0
Dec
-20
Actual $ Per Month Forecast $ Per Month Actual % Forecast %
Actual 96.1%
06/2020
Original Contract: $54,232,480 Incurred-to-Date: $89,449,893
Current Contract Value¹: $93,132,480 Incurred in June: $993,335
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
73 | P a g e
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Resident Engineers (REs) provided the weekly project status and
issues briefings at the weekly HART Project Managers (PM) meetings.
RE’s managed assigned projects as the HART on-site field representatives for CEI, managing contract correspondence and contract change administrative processes, issuing Field Change Notices (FCNs) when required, and overseeing work.
Continued monitoring fabrication of Hālawa (Aloha Stadium) Station canopy supports.
Completed installation of the WTC station canopy fabric. Updated Monthly Progress Report Dashboards for all stations. Work-off of backlogged claims and changes progressed. Continued implementation of contract closeout processes for
WOSG and FHSG in anticipation of completion by the end of 3rd quarter 2020.
Look Ahead: Turning over infrastructure to allow
Core Systems to continue their installation.
Continue to monitor and track station canopy fabrication and installation activities to complete canopies at KHSG.
Oversee construction of assigned projects.
Closeout the UH West O‘ahu Park and Ride & UHWO Campus Road “B” (UHPRB) contract.
Continue closeout processes for WOSG, FHSG and KHR contracts.
Closeout MSF, KHG and WOFH contracts.
Change Orders Processed
CONTRACT FOM NSM SON CCO
UHPRB 0 0 1 0
WOSG 1 2 1 0
FHSG 0 0 0 0
KHSG 1 1 1 1
KHR 0 0 0 0
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES:
The COVID-19 pandemic has continued to impact delivery of the contracted station works; mitigation for which is not yet defined; however, construction activities are continuing to proceed within constraints at impacted pace.
Completing Core Systems access requirements and balance of structures conduit for CSC follow on work.
Continuation and completion of canopy installations.
Continue working-off of backlog of outstanding claims/change issues.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
74 | P a g e
C. Construction Engineering and Inspection (CEI) East CPP No.: MM-596 Contractor: Stantec Consulting Services Inc. Contract Start Date: September 14, 2015 Contract Completion Date: December 31, 2021 Description of Work: Provides construction, engineering, and inspection services for construction contract compliance, construction scheduling, construction cost estimating, support, on-site field oversight, project controls and related construction support for the east section of the project.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $23,655,901
DBE % Attained: 23.18%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $47,000,000
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $47,000,000
* Monthly actuals are based on Pay App Verification values and are reconciled with the city’s C2HERPS system instead of CMS.
Sep
-15
No
v-1
5
Jan
-16
Mar
-16
May
-16
Jul-
16
Sep
-16
No
v-1
6
Jan
-17
Mar
-17
May
-17
Jul-
17
Sep
-17
No
v-1
7
Jan
-18
Mar
-18
May
-18
Jul-
18
Sep
-18
No
v-1
8
Jan
-19
Mar
-19
May
-19
Jul-
19
Sep
-19
No
v-1
9
Jan
-20
Mar
-20
May
-20
Jul-
20
Sep
-20
No
v-2
0
Jan
-21
Mar
-21
May
-21
Jul-
21
Sep
-21
No
v-2
1
Actual $ Per Month Forecast $ Per Month Actual % Forecast %
Actual 69.0%
06/2020
Original Contract: $55,036,130 Incurred-to-Date: $70,438,852
Current Contract Value¹: $102,036,130 Incurred in June: $2,163,931
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
75 | P a g e
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Current Stantec East CEI support for the HRTP is at
approximately 69% of total contract value. Performed CEI services for the AGS DB, On-Call III, On-Call
IV, CCGS DB/P3, and CCUR projects throughout the east section project limits.
Implemented COVID-19 safe work practices in the field and at all project office locations.
AGS DB overall construction progress is at 71.3% - Guideway progress is at approximately 69%, and Stations are at approximately 13%.
Precast Yard activities ongoing: 2,658/2,708 segments completed (98%).
Span erection progress for 3 gantries (Reach B-502, C-544 & E-606): 122/210 spans completed (58%).
Plinth rebar installation for Track 2 continues between Span 430-432 and Span 426-428 on Track 1 for AGS DB.
Worked with HECO on CCUR to identify a second supplier for the HECO poles that could save as much as 18 weeks on the overall procurement schedule.
Provided detailed schedules relating to multiple scenarios for the CCUR construction activity required in support of the P3 access dates.
Provided CEO consultant evaluation summary of the Stantec contract for construction progress of ongoing projects along the East Section.
Identified a Public Involvement (PI) manager to replace the manager who left the project – candidate has been approved and started on the project in June 2020.
Look Ahead: Working with HART to monitor construction
progress in support of the current substantial completion dates for ongoing AGS DB and CCUR projects.
Continuing to monitor staff resources and overall East CEI II project budget with additional HART scope requests.
Continue to work with HART in support of construction completion to support the P3 planned activities.
Supporting HART with the potential addition of a second contractor for CCUR to include the review of phasing, CEI II staffing, and potential schedule improvements to support the P3 planned activities. Working with the HART PM to update the organizational structure to meet planned construction activities.
Stantec submitted a contract amendment request to HART in June 2020, in response to requests from HART for increased construction support on various contracts through December 2021. This amendment is in review by HART. The contract amendment will need to be issued by March 2021, which is the projected date for the full expenditure of the current CEI II contract funding.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES:
No issues.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
76 | P a g e
D. General Engineering Consultant CPP No.: MM-913 Contractor: CH2M Hill, Inc. Contract Start Date: December 5, 2013 Contract Completion Date: July 4, 2021 Description of Work: Task 01 – Scheduling and Estimating Support: Task Order 01 provides staff augmentation to support scheduling and cost estimating services through the design and construction phase of the Project.
Task 02 – Interface Management and Coordination: Provide oversight of technical coordination and Configuration Management.
Task 03 – Environmental and Planning: Provide environmental and planning support to ensure compliance with appropriate decision documents for the Project; integration with other applicable state or city entities for systems, station, land use, and operation planning.
Task 04 – Design Management Services: Engineering and architectural design management services for the duration of the project.
Task 05 – Program Management and Deliverables: Program Management services throughout the entire duration of the Project to include, but not limited to the Work Breakdown Structure, Budget Staffing Plan, Monthly Progress and Status Reports, and Contract Administration.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Task Description Original Value Current Value Incurred-to-Date
1 Scheduling and Estimating Support $13,187,310 $22,556,723 $20,012,698
2 Interface Management and Coordination $5,644,829 $4,097,085 $3,599,200
3 Environmental and Planning $6,537,705 $20,303,965 $12,867,198
4 Design Management Services $16,986,250 $34,866,501 $30,217,921
5 Program Management and Deliverables $2,434,232 $1,565,057 $1,366,010
OD Other Direct Expenses $1,352,951 $1,339,444 $1,038,120
Total $46,143,277 $84,728,775 $69,101,146
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $8,300,160
DBE % Attained: 9.80%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $38,585,498
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $38,585,498
Original Contract: $46,143,277 Incurred-to-Date: $69,101,146
Current Contract Value¹: $84,728,775 Incurred in June: $2,757,150
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
77 | P a g e
* Monthly actuals are based on Pay App Verification values and are reconciled with the city’s C2HERPS system instead of CMS.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month: Look Ahead: Task 01: Produced May schedule updates for PMOC meetings. Outlined schedule
updates and progress. Maintained HART’s Master Project Integrated Schedule (MPIS).
Operational Readiness – Segment 1 Turnover date is March 4, 2021. Operational Readiness – Segment 3 Turnover date is March 16, 2026.
Provided review and analysis of STG’s May 2020 progress schedule. Reviewed Elevators & Escalators schedule for coordination of installation
activities in the station contracts. Continued supporting Design and Construction with City Center Utility and
Guideway/Station coordination of activity predecessors. Began developing an interface schedule between AGS and the CSC
schedules. Provided Independent Cost Estimate (ICE) Cost to Complete for the
following: o CCUR Community Antenna Television (CATV) Installation by OTWC o CCUR Task Order 28 o CCUR Task Order 32 o CCUR Design Services During Construction (DSDC) Rough Order of
Magnitude (ROM) o UH West O‘ahu Entrance Building ICE Rev 3 o Farrington Highway and Pupukahi Street ICE
Produced Monthly Internal Schedule Progress Report. The report outlines progress on all ongoing projects.
Provided administrative support for Rapid Transit Stabilization Agreement (RTSA) activities.
Reviewed CMS payment documentation to reconcile actual invoices and payments to cost coding worksheets in Project Controls in preparation for data migration into Unifier.
Reviewed all Detail Forecast Worksheets for month-end reporting, updated variance report for the forecast sheets, and made notes as required. Completed monthly EAC requirements.
Continued reviewing request for payment for all Professional Services and Construction contracts – ensured proper coding.
Reviewed contingency for all Contract Packaging Plan’s (CPPs) project-wide.
Task 01: On-going support of ICE development or reviews of cost
estimates prepared by the CEI team for independent quality assessments. The following are projected ICE’s: o Update quantity takeoffs and Costs for CCUR
Wet/Dry Utility Task Orders o East Kapolei Park & Ride and Entrance Building o Update the CCGS & P3 ICE o ICE for Requests for Change from Contractor
(RFCC’s) and Requests for Change by HART (RFCR’s) o FOM/Negotiation Strategy Memo (NSM) Review
and Approval Continue updates of Monthly Schedule reports and
analysis. Continue providing administrative support for RTSA
activities. Incorporate updates from the Accepted and Accepted as
Noted contractor’s progress schedules. Continue developing the interface schedule between the
AGS and CSC projects. Continue to implement the Oracle Unifier system on
parts of the Business Systems, Scheduling and Cost Team Integration.
Staffing plan review for the entire project until RSD – all potential areas will be reviewed that will interface with P3 partners and will also include mitigation review should alternatives be required.
Continue updating executive summary EAC that highlights significant changes in the EAC for construction, professional services, design, management, and other contracts as required.
Dec
-13
Jan
-14
Feb
-14
Mar
-14
Ap
r-1
4M
ay-1
4Ju
n-1
4Ju
l-1
4A
ug-
14
Sep
-14
Oct
-14
No
v-1
4D
ec-1
4Ja
n-1
5Fe
b-1
5M
ar-1
5A
pr-
15
May
-15
Jun
-15
Jul-
15
Au
g-1
5Se
p-1
5O
ct-1
5N
ov-
15
Dec
-15
Jan
-16
Feb
-16
Mar
-16
Ap
r-1
6M
ay-1
6Ju
n-1
6Ju
l-1
6A
ug-
16
Sep
-16
Oct
-16
No
v-1
6D
ec-1
6Ja
n-1
7Fe
b-1
7M
ar-1
7A
pr-
17
May
-17
Jun
-17
Jul-
17
Au
g-1
7Se
p-1
7O
ct-1
7N
ov-
17
Dec
-17
Jan
-18
Feb
-18
Mar
-18
Ap
r-1
8M
ay-1
8Ju
n-1
8Ju
l-1
8A
ug-
18
Sep
-18
Oct
-18
No
v-1
8D
ec-1
8Ja
n-1
9Fe
b-1
9M
ar-1
9A
pr-
19
May
-19
Jun
-19
Jul-
19
Au
g-1
9Se
p-1
9O
ct-1
9N
ov-
19
Dec
-19
Jan
-20
Feb
-20
Mar
-20
Ap
r-2
0M
ay-2
0Ju
n-2
0Ju
l-2
0A
ug-
20
Sep
-20
Oct
-20
No
v-2
0D
ec-2
0Ja
n-2
1Fe
b-2
1M
ar-2
1A
pr-
21
May
-21
Jun
-21
Jul-
21
Actual $ Per Month Forecast $ Per Month Actual % Forecast %
Actual 81.6%
06/2020
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
78 | P a g e
Activities this Month (continued): Started quarterly review of all CPPs coding sheets versus baseline
allocations to ensure line items are being tracked and charged off properly.
EDD files were reviewed for capital reallocations between CPPs – no major shifts were found.
Look Ahead (continued):
Task 02:
Configuration Management (CFM) and Closeout activities performed: o Had over 40 meetings, informal discussions or e-mail exchanges with
various HART personnel to discuss: assessment of HRH’s compliance with their Configuration Management plans; and documentation and activities remaining for the closeout of the West Side Stations Groups (WSSG) contracts with special emphasis on Safety and Security items, Environmental submittals and permits, operation and maintenance manuals, training sessions, and status of lists of spare parts.
o Review of submittal logs for the WSSG contracts and tabulation of the status of select submittals (O&M manuals, training sessions, etc.) required for closeout.
o Prepared a comprehensive summary of the status of various aspects of the WSSG closeout activities for HART Core Systems.
Task 02:
CFM and WSSG Closeout tasks to be worked on are: o Review of HRH’s written response to the HART
letter regarding “Verification of Configuration Management Activities.”
o Continue expediting activities for closeout for the WSSG contracts and continue tracking status.
o Continue coordination with HART Environmental and Safety and Security Divisions to ascertain the status of closeout activities for WSSG contracts.
o Address review comments on draft of Revision 5 of the Configuration Management Plan.
o Schedule, organize and chair weekly WSSG Elevated Issues meetings and Configuration Control Committee meetings.
Task 03: Permits – assisted in obtaining a two-year extension of the U.S. Coast
Guard advanced approval authorization for 8 stream/waterway crossing. Submitted the application to extend the WOFH community noise permit to the Department of Health. Preparing the closeout form and supporting documentation for the Moanalua Stream Channel Alteration Permit (SCAP).
Environmental Analyses and Documentation – assisted in obtaining FTA approval for the post-Record of Decision (ROD) document for the Ho‘opili temporary park-and-ride facility and reconfigured permanent UHWO park-and-ride facility.
Programmatic Agreement (PA) Compliance – subcontractor Honua Consulting finalized the Interpretive Plan pursuant to PA Stipulation VII.A.
On-Call Support for Right of Way, Utilities, Environmental Planning – assisting with the assessment of the impending expiration of the Hawai‘i Department of Transportation Incidental Take License related to the endangered plant species Abutilon Menziesii and implications for HART’s Certificate of Inclusion.
Task 03: Permits – complete and submit SCAP for changes in pier
locations in Kalihi Stream. Environmental Analyses & Documentation – prepare
post-ROD evaluation for the East Kapolei park-and-ride facility.
PA Compliance – subcontractors Mason Architects and Minatoishi Architects will prepare for and assist with the presentation of National/Hawai‘i Register nominations of six historic properties adversely affected by the Project, per PA Stipulation VI.C. Prepare revised work plan for the Park Improvement Plan which is required by PA Stipulation VIII.D.
On-Call Support for Right of Way, Utilities, Environmental Planning – complete mapping of geospatial information for right-of-way acquired after the Record of Decision was issued. Prepare documentation of ridership projections and study methodology for the Before-and-After Study.
Task 04: Coordinated a field investigation at Leeward Community College parking
lot, which involved drilling and sampling of 8 borings to depths of 40 to 60 feet below the ground surface, and installation of groundwater monitoring and slope movement instrumentation. Recommendations for pavement repair to be developed in coordination with a subconsultant and HART construction staff.
Created a scope of work and figures to address erosion at guideway columns along Kaloi Channel. Repair work will involve extending drainage pipes from the base of the guideway columns to near the invert of the Channel.
Completed the design to add guardrail to the Pearl City Stream Bridge. Addressed HDOT comments on design drawings and calculations.
Reviewed 4 design submittals, 31 NCRs, 13 Field Design Changes, and 8 Notice of Design Changes for the Airport Guideway and Stations contract. Attended Task Force Meetings, presubmittal workshops and comment resolution meetings.
Continued to provide track engineering support to the Core Systems group to adjust track related issues identified by HRH.
Task 04: Assist in evaluating City Center P3 proposals. Continue to provide engineering support to CCUR to
evaluate possible guideway configuration changes to minimize utility relocation costs.
Continue to provide technical support to the CEI team overseeing the Airport Guideway and Stations contract.
Continue participation in third-party coordination meetings (technical meetings and management meetings) for various contracts. Third parties include HECO, HDOT, Department of Health (DOH), Airport, Navy and UH West O‘ahu.
Continue to provide construction support for the Kamehameha Highway Resurfacing project.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
79 | P a g e
Activities this Month (continued): Task 05: Monitored contract labor and sub-consultant expenditures. Updated Monthly Estimate at Completion (EAC). Participated in preparation of monthly reports. Reviewed performance of all tasks based on attachments to invoice. Received chart describing contract cost trends. Discussed flexibility and potential shifting of resources.
Look Ahead (continued): Task 05: Review five tasks versus the cost and schedule. Continue to monitor contract labor and sub-consultant
expenditures. Update Monthly EAC. Participate in preparation of monthly reports.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES: Task 01:
No current contractual issues. Task 02:
No current contractual issues. Task 03:
No current contractual issues. Task 04:
No current contractual issues. Task 05:
Contract extends through to July 4, 2021.
There is one option year remaining on the contract.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
80 | P a g e
E. Core Systems Support CPP No.: MM-962 Contractor: Lea+Elliott, Inc. Contract Start Date: February 11, 2014 Contract Completion Date: September 10, 2022
Description of Work: Provide design and construction management oversight for the Core System Design-Build-Operate-Maintain (CSDBOM) Contract, to include system commissioning, passenger services start-up, and pre-revenue operations and maintenance activities.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
COST INFORMATION:
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Participation
Actual DBE Participation: $1,738,588
DBE % Attained: 2.24%
Contract Changes in June
Change No. Description Amount ($)
Cumulative Previously Reported $33,784,957
None N/A ---
Cumulative Current Report $33,784,957
* Monthly actuals are based on Pay App Verification values and are reconciled with the city’s C2HERPS system instead of CMS.
WORK PROGRESS: Activities this Month:
Project Management: o Eight (8) letters were received from HRH and reviewed. Four (4) letters were finalized
and issued by the Core Systems Oversight Consultant (CSOC). o Six (6) RFIs were received and three (3) RFIs were responded to this period. o The CSOC received 102 submittals and completed 105 submittal reviews during this
period.
Look Ahead:
Continue to monitor, observe, witness, and report on the Core Systems Contractor’s daily activities on-site and at the factories.
Feb
-14
Ap
r-1
4
Jun
-14
Au
g-1
4
Oct
-14
Dec
-14
Feb
-15
Ap
r-1
5
Jun
-15
Au
g-1
5
Oct
-15
Dec
-15
Feb
-16
Ap
r-1
6
Jun
-16
Au
g-1
6
Oct
-16
Dec
-16
Feb
-17
Ap
r-1
7
Jun
-17
Au
g-1
7
Oct
-17
Dec
-17
Feb
-18
Ap
r-1
8
Jun
-18
Au
g-1
8
Oct
-18
Dec
-18
Feb
-19
Ap
r-1
9
Jun
-19
Au
g-1
9
Oct
-19
Dec
-19
Feb
-20
Ap
r-2
0
Jun
-20
Au
g-2
0
Oct
-20
Dec
-20
Feb
-21
Ap
r-2
1
Jun
-21
Au
g-2
1
Oct
-21
Dec
-21
Feb
-22
Ap
r-2
2
Jun
-22
Au
g-2
2
Actual $ Per Month Forecast $ Per Month Actual % Forecast %
Actual 63.7%
06/2020
Original Contract: $43,988,989 Incurred-to-Date: $49,564,600
Current Contract Value¹: $77,773,946 Incurred in June: $2,206,222
1Current Contract Value = Original contract value + executed Change Orders
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
81 | P a g e
Activities this Month (continued): o Received 1 Maintenance of Traffic (MOT) submittal and returned 1. o Developed Rough Order of Magnitude (ROM) for the proposed new entrance building at
UHWO. o Drafted Finding of Merit/No Merit (FOM) for Issue 236 Revised Date for I/O#1. o Reviewed and validated HRH’s Request for Payment #102 for work reported by HRH
during May 2020. Interface Management:
o Continued to support HART with the migration to Unifier with the Request for Interface Data (RFID) process.
o Prepared proposal for station turnover process. o Supported HART with switches guardrail flangeway dimensions issue; all switches have
been adjusted with the exception of 6 on the mainline and 1 in the yard. o Continued work on the station turnover process.
Manufacturing Oversight and Factory Inspection: o Continued oversight of Trains #15 through #18 assembly activities. o Completed shipping inspection of Train #7.
Installation Oversight: o Continued oversight for Comms installation at EKP, UHWO, HOP, WLO, WTC, LCC, PHL
and PLR. o Continued oversight of BLS installation at stations. o Continued oversight of FDAS installation at UHWO. o Continued oversight of SCADA installation at LCC, EKP and UHWO. o Completed oversight of PSGS tower installation at PLR and PHL. o Continued oversight of PSGS electrical installation at PLR. o Continued oversight of junction box (JB) and conduits remediation at ALS.
System Acceptance, Testing, and Commissioning: o Witnessing of the following testing activities:
Train #8 onboard ATC and COMM acceptance test Train #9 onboard ATC and COMM acceptance test Train #13 static and dynamic acceptance test Train #14 delivery and static acceptance test Onboard ATC Vehicle Test Procedure (VTP)/Central Test Procedure (CTP) testing
in the functional section extended to ALS Initial 3rd rail energization using PLR TPSS PLR TPSS to OCC testing MSF TEL testing (E-911 calls) MSF CCTV testing MSF Wireless Communication System (WCS) testing MSF PIS testing MSF SLAN/Communications Transmission System (CTS) testing ATC wayside phase 3 testing in different locations (LCC, PHL, PLR) HOP SLAN/CTS/CCTV/PIS Site Acceptance Test (SAT) testing LCC SLAN/CTS/CCTV SAT testing SLAN/CTS testing at WLO, WTC, WLO TPSS, HOP TPSS, WTC TPSS and LCC Gap
Breaker Station (GBS) WTC FDAS testing SCADA testing in HOP, UHWO, WLO, WTC and LCC Follow up on MDS coverage testing with Train #8 from HOP to LCC
Other Assignments: o Provided Data Room Update #12 for the P3. o Supported HART with responses to P3 RFIs and P3 Procurement activities. o Continued to manage the Traction Power Backup Generator (TPBG) Contract which
includes review of submittals, respond to RFIs, interface with necessary stakeholders, and conduct monthly progress meeting.
o Continued to manage HART’s Oversight Procedure (OP) 54 database for all stakeholders.
Look Ahead (continued): Continue to assist HART
with the resolution of change and claim issues.
Continue to assist HART with the Track Allocation Procedure.
Continue to support HART to address outstanding issues related to construction access at stations.
Continue to support HART to meet MSF Operational schedule objective and Interim Opening activities.
Continue to support HART to prepare the functional section to start integration testing on the mainline.
Support HART on P3 activities, as required.
Continue to support HART with HECO issues, including work on power quality and mitigation analysis.
Review final design, O&M, plans, and test procedures/report submittals.
Finalize passenger vehicle (PV) design solution to add car shell ventilation holes.
Finalize PV design solution to add four additional CCTV cameras.
Continue to mobilize personnel to support additional tasks added to the CSOC’s scope.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
KEY ISSUES: o No issues.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
82 | P a g e
4.7 Contract Status by Contract Packaging Plan (CPP) Number
Contract Summary by CPP
(data as of Jun 30, 2020) A B C = A + B D E = D / C
CPP # CPP Title
Original Contract
Value
Change
Orders
Current Contract
Value Incurred % Exp.
Award
Date
Original
Completion
Date
Revised
Completion
Date
DB-120 West Oahu/Farrington Hwy Guideway 482,430,201 185,351,685 667,781,886 667,781,886 100% Nov-2009 Oct-2013 Dec-2018
DB-122 Westside Bird Control 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
DB-172 DR Horton Parking / Interim PnR Ho'opili 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
DB-200 Maintenance & Storage Facility 195,258,000 86,517,032 281,775,032 281,775,032 100% Jun-2011 Dec-2014 Jul-2016
DB-275 Pearl Highlands Garage, Bus Terminal, H2 Ramp 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
DB-320 Kamehameha Hwy Guideway 372,150,000 31,405,774 403,555,774 403,555,774 100% Jun-2011 Oct-2014 Dec-2018
DB-450 Airport Section Guideway/Stations 874,750,000 11,762,752 886,512,752 622,970,587 70% Sep-2016 May-2021 May-2021
DB-550 City Center Guideway and Station (CCGS) 100,000 134,000 234,000 206,546 88% Jan-2018 Nov-2024 Nov-2024
DBB-121 WOFM Median Landscaping 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
DBB-171 West Oahu Station Group 56,088,470 32,026,202 88,114,672 82,722,876 94% Jul-2015 Mar-2018 Mar-2019
DBB-271 Farrington Highway Station Group 78,999,000 39,290,879 118,289,879 92,755,232 78% Jun-2015 Jan-2018 Jan-2019
DBB-272 Waipahu Makai Entrance 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
DBB-371 Kamehameha Hwy Station Group 115,805,845 15,310,476 131,116,321 121,218,853 93% Jan-2016 May-2019 May-2019
DBB-385 Ramp H2R2 5,203,646 332,250 5,535,896 5,535,896 100% May-2015 Oct-2016 Nov-2017
DBB-505 Airport Section Utilities Construction 27,993,290 726,200 28,719,489 28,719,489 100% Jun-2014 Feb-2016 Oct-2016
DBB-511 City Center Utilities Relocation Construction 400,000,000 0 400,000,000 32,800,101 8% May-2018 May-2020 May-2022
DBB-525 Airport Section Guideway 7-Pier 3,973,000 54,843 4,027,843 4,027,843 100% Sep-2014 Feb-2015 Apr-2015
DBB-551 Advanced Guideway Foundations in Kaka'ako 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
DBB-600 Park-and-ride Lots Construction 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
DBB-602 UHWO Temp PnR and Campus Rd B 11,589,300 1,607,232 13,196,532 12,908,138 98% Dec-2017 Jul-2019 Jul-2019
DBB-701 Kamehameha Highway Resurfacing 25,989,989 2,455,926 28,445,915 27,703,164 97% Jul-2018 Sep-2019 Sep-2019
DBB-921 WiFi Passenger Vehicles 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
DBOM-920 Core Systems Design Build O/M 573,782,793 209,736,373 783,519,166 432,745,999 55% Nov-2011 Mar-2019 Jan-2025
FD-140 West Oahu Station Group 7,789,000 6,442,995 14,231,995 13,610,465 96% Jun-2012 Nov-2016 May-2020
FD-145 Dillingham / Kaka'ako (Eastside) SG FD 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
FD-240 Farrington Highway Stations Group 9,300,696 7,697,120 16,997,816 16,450,443 97% Jan-2011 Nov-2016 Mar-2020
FD-340 Kamehameha Hwy Station Group 8,702,592 5,034,135 13,736,727 13,201,352 96% Nov-2012 Jun-2017 Nov-2019
FD-430 Airport Sect. Guideway/Util 38,840,960 4,111,440 42,952,400 42,371,374 99% Dec-2011 Aug-2013 Jun-2017
FD-440 Airport Station Group 10,177,365 (117,545) 10,059,820 10,059,820 100% Nov-2012 Jan-2014 Jul-2015
FD-530 City Center Guideway/Util 43,948,220 14,550,073 58,498,293 57,489,264 98% Jul-2012 Mar-2014 Jul-2020
FD-550 Dillingham and Kaka'ako Station Group 18,321,918 (6,020,837) 12,301,081 12,341,565 100% Aug-2013 Sep-2014 Aug-2016
FD-600 KHG 138kV Underground Design 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
FD-700 Design Services for 138kV Util. Reloc. at KHG 8,766,327 0 8,766,327 4,305,543 49% Aug-2018 Nov-2021 Nov-2021
FD-701 KH Civil Design 60,000 0 60,000 60,000 100% Jan-2018 Jan-2019 Jan-2019
MI-900 Fare Collection DFI 15,464,198 444,026 15,908,224 7,570,108 48% Mar-2016 Jan-2029 Jan-2029
MI-930 Elevators & Escalators Install/Maint 50,982,714 4,879,726 55,862,440 28,141,001 50% Jul-2013 May-2018 May-2021
MI-940 Core Systems Backup Generators 8,965,000 0 8,965,000 537,500 6% Dec-2019 Apr-2021 Jan-2021
MI-950 Volt Ampere Reactive Equipment 0 0 0 0 0% TBD TBD TBD
MM-945 On-Call Construction I 1,000,000 1,000,000 2,000,000 1,999,983 100% Aug-2014 Jul-2019 Dec-2016
MM-947 On-Call Construction II 7,500,000 0 7,500,000 7,495,772 100% May-2015 May-2020 May-2020
MM-948 On-Call Construction III 20,000,000 6,000,000 26,000,000 25,665,343 99% May-2016 May-2023 May-2023
MM-949 On-Call Construction IV 46,000,000 7,000,000 53,000,000 38,728,685 73% Jan-2018 Nov-2024 Nov-2024
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
83 | P a g e
Contract Summary by CPP
(data as of Jun 30, 2020) A B C = A + B D E = D / C
CPP # CPP Title
Original Contract
Value
Change
Orders
Current Contract
Value Incurred % Exp.
Award
Date
Original
Completion
Date
Revised
Completion
Date
MM-290 Construction Engrg & Insp CEI West 54,232,480 38,900,000 93,132,480 89,449,893 96% Jan-2014 Jan-2020 Dec-2020
MM-595 Construction Engrg & Insp CEI East I 63,083,417 (50,377,317) 12,706,100 12,711,366 100% Jan-2014 Jan-2019 Jan-2016
MM-596 Construction Engrg & Insp CEI East II 55,036,130 47,000,000 102,036,130 70,438,852 69% Sep-2015 Dec-2019 Dec-2021
MM-901 Program Mgt Support Conslt II 33,376,897 16,359,765 49,736,662 49,736,662 100% Feb-2012 Mar-2015 Mar-2017
MM-902 Program Mgt Support Conslt III 63,522,953 0 63,522,953 39,755,919 63% Jan-2017 Dec-2022 Dec-2022
MM-905 MM-905 Gen Engrg Conslt EIS/PE 0 75,995,982 75,995,982 75,995,982 100% Aug-2007 Feb-2010 Feb-2011
MM-910 MM-910 Gen Engrg Conslt FD-Construct 150,226,265 0 150,226,265 150,226,265 100% Jun-2011 Dec-2014 Dec-2014
MM-913 MM-913 Gen Engrg Recompete 46,143,277 38,585,498 84,728,775 69,101,146 82% Dec-2013 Apr-2019 Jul-2021
MM-915 HDOT Traffic Mgmt. Consult. 1,600,000 5,010,000 6,610,000 6,373,913 96% Jun-2012 Jun-2017 Jun-2019
MM-920 HDOT Coordination Conslt WOFH 3,000,000 6,500,000 9,500,000 9,483,733 100% Jun-2011 Jun-2016 Dec-2018
MM-921 HDOT Coordination Conslt KHG 16,138,390 (1,400,000) 14,738,390 8,072,380 55% Jun-2012 Feb-2025 Feb-2025
MM-922 HDOT Coordination Conslt. East 17,560,000 (7,631,360) 9,928,640 6,016,859 61% Jun-2012 Dec-2024 Dec-2024
MM-925 HDOT - WOFH/KHG Imprv Agreements 550,000 2,865,633 3,415,633 2,761,830 81% Oct-2010 Oct-2019 Oct-2019
MM-930 HDOT State SOA Manager & Consultant 1,272,400 583,142 1,855,542 990,437 53% Feb-2012 Aug-2017 Aug-2017
MM-940 Kako'o Consultant I 1,000,000 (3,106) 996,894 531,609 53% Mar-2012 Mar-2022 Mar-2022
MM-941 Kako'o Consultant II 200,000 400,000 600,000 391,667 65% Dec-2015 Jan-2018 Jan-2020
MM-946 On-Call Hazmat Assessment Consultant 12,006,227 2,075,000 14,081,227 7,724,232 55% Feb-2018 Feb-2023 Feb-2023
MM-950 OCIP Consultant I 1,250,000 0 1,250,000 1,250,000 100% May-2012 Jun-2017 May-2017
MM-951 Owner-Controlled Insurance Program 41,000,000 8,640,674 49,640,674 43,621,335 88% Apr-2014 Apr-2020 Mar-2019
MM-953 OCIP Consultant II 415,000 405,000 820,000 415,000 51% May-2017 May-2020 May-2020
MM-960 Archeological & Cultural Monitoring 2,489,748 0 2,489,748 2,935,019 118% Jan-2014 Jan-2019 Jan-2019
MM-962 Core Systems Support 43,988,989 33,784,957 77,773,946 49,564,600 64% Feb-2014 Sep-2019 Sep-2022
MM-964 Safety and Security Consultant 21,699,279 5,549,188 27,248,468 16,363,933 60% Apr-2014 Jan-2017 Jan-2019
MM-970 Fare Collection Consultant 1,178,300 640,620 1,818,920 989,464 54% Sep-2015 Dec-2019 Dec-2019
MM-975 LEED Commissioning Services for MSF 278,630 7,845 286,475 286,475 100% Oct-2010 Jan-2016 Aug-2017
PA-102 Programmatic Agreement HPC 667,275 (175,947) 491,329 274,585 56% Jul-2013 Jan-2019 Jan-2019
ART ART Contracts 2,139,500 10,000 2,149,500 807,550 38% Jan-2016 Jul-2019 Jul-2019
MM-935 Real Estate Consultant 3,000,000 5,077,665 8,077,665 7,504,910 93% Mar-2012 Mar-2017 Mar-2017
MM-936 Real Estate Consultant II 8,190,000 0 8,190,000 6,756,819 83% Sep-2016 Sep-2020 Sep-2020
MM-937 Real Estate Consultant - Maps/Surv. 2,998,000 1,130,000 4,128,000 3,086,075 75% May-2014 May-2017 May-2019
MM-981 Complex Real Property Nego. Lit. Sup 600,000 (21) 599,979 602,241 100% Sep-2016 Sep-2018 Sep-2018
MM-982 On Call Appraiser 4,000,000 0 4,000,000 654,996 16% Jun-2016 Dec-2022 Dec-2022
MM-983 Land Court Petition Services 1,200,000 0 1,200,000 102,337 9% Oct-2016 Oct-2019 Oct-2019
MM-985 On Call Appraisers II 1,261,308 0 1,261,308 354,144 28% Apr-2017 Apr-2022 Apr-2022
MM-986 Real Estate Legal Services 5,800,000 6,000,000 11,800,000 4,498,167 38% Oct-2017 Dec-2022 Dec-2022
MM-990 Design Review Consultant 4,027,781 0 4,027,781 471,099 12% Mar-2018 Dec-2024 Dec-2024
MM-991 P3 Financial Legal Services 4,282,333 6,709,384 10,991,717 8,661,498 79% Oct-2018 TBD TBD
UTIL Utility Contracts and Agreements 144,141,812 52,132,834 196,274,646 78,136,178 40% Dec-2009 Dec-2018 Jun-2018
HART-201 HART Expenses & ODCs 38,985,433 0 38,985,433 30,945,820 79% N/A N/A N/A
HART-202 Precast Yard Agreement 32,254,379 16,101,392 48,355,771 8,485,945 18% N/A N/A N/A
4,404,728,727 978,609,586 5,383,338,313 3,963,986,566
Source: HART CMS. Note: Incurred amounts for Non-Contractual Expenses (i.e. ROW transactions, debt financing costs, and City/HART contract packages) are tracked in the below table and are also included in the total incurred amount in Appendix A. 2
Non-Contractual Expenses
(data as of Jun 30, 2020)
CPP # CPP Title
Current Contract
Value Incurred
ROW Real Estate Docs/ 3P Agreements 201,003,514
CCH-100 HART/CITY CCH
14,925,228
CCH-101 HART/ City Dept of BFS 0
CCH-102 HART/ City DDC Land Division
173,182
CCH-107 HART/ City Corporation Counsel (COR) 3,088,688
CCH-108 HART / Board of Water Supply (BWS)
928,325
HART-200 HART - Labor 83,166,048
HART-201 HART Expenses & ODCs
38,893,409
OTHER Debt Financing Costs 44,189,360
TOTAL 386,367,753
Source: HART CMS.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
84 | P a g e
5 OVERALL PROJECT-WIDE ACTIVITIES
5.1 Overall Key Issues
Overview
Experienced Personnel: HRH is addressing the need for qualified personnel, including personnel in management, testing, commissioning, construction, quality and safety certification. HRH recently brought in a number of subcontractors to help support the team. This has been impacted by COVID-19 and is being addressed as we start to stabilize.
O&M Training: HRH commenced formal training classes on April 6, on schedule. HRH has developed an increased number of virtual training options. HRH has rescheduled training to align with hiring for the commencement of Trial Running in November.
HRH’s development of the Maintenance Management Information System (MMIS) (Maximo) is critical for Interim Opening. MMIS implementation has started, development of module 2 is in progress to finalize the system design, and the plan for data transfer has been completed. HRH has decided to change suppliers for the Developer Contract, but they are still targeting September for the MMIS to go live.
System Service Availability (SSA) Calculation Program: HRH must develop a computer program to automatically calculate the SSA for use in determining monthly Operations and Maintenance (O&M) invoices. The program must be accepted by the City. HRH is preparing to start a working group with City stakeholders to develop the business rules that will govern SSA calculation. The first draft of these rules is under HART review.
Trial Run Plan: HRH has begun development of plans for the trial run period. Stakeholder meetings were held to secure buy in. Detailed plans are being written to describe how system demonstration, pre-revenue O&M readiness testing, and the full-scale emergency drill will be scheduled, resourced, conducted, and evaluated.
Automated Yard Operation: Closure of open issues of the DBOM Core Systems contract are needed, particularly the communications system and the integration with the vehicles and automated train control systems. HART is working with HRH to address the Operations Control Center’s (OCC’s) outstanding issues that are necessary for the start of Functional Track testing.
Functional Track Integration Testing: Completion of all equipment installation and testing in the Functional Section is underway prior to system integration testing. Remaining critical subsystems are Communications and SCADA. Realignment of critical goals have been made to meet the revised Interim Opening #1 date. The revised goals and schedule may have to be reassessed when taking into consideration future issues related to COVID-19.
AGS integrated schedule: The latest draft of the schedule shows a delay of turnover dates to the Core Systems Contractor. This would impact Interim Opening #2. Core Systems is working with the Stantec RE and HRH construction team to try and mitigate as much as possible.
Procurement of materials by HRH has been delayed and caused schedule slippage. HRH management has added on-site procurement personnel and obtained additional support from headquarters. This issue is further amplified due to additional design changes and COVID-19, but HRH is progressing.
Canopy arms are installed at all stations with the exception of Hālawa (Aloha Stadium) Station. Completion of the final canopy arm design and shop drawing development/approval for Hālawa (Aloha Stadium) Station has continued to delay the completion and shipping of the canopy arms. They are scheduled to start installation in July 2020. Canopy fabric is installed at Kualaka‘i (East Kapolei), Keone‘ae (University of Hawai‘i West O‘ahu), Honouliuli (Ho‘opili), Pouhala (Waipahu Transit Center), Hālaulani (Leeward Community College) and Hō‘ae‘ae (West Loch). Fabric is installed at Kalauao (Pearlridge), with the exception of the center panels; installation will be completed after correction of a roofing conflict. Waiawa (Pearl Highlands) is scheduled for July 2020 and Hālawa (Aloha Stadium) fabric is scheduled to start in September 2020. Coordinating canopy arm and fabric installation with Core Systems to lessen the impact on train testing.
HART is dependent on the electrical design prepared by HECO for the electrical power line relocation work that must be performed by HART’s CCUR contractor. As HART’s civil design becomes available, HECO begins their electrical design. HART is continuing to meet at all levels within HECO to coordinate the required designs for the CCUR contract.
The ability to meet the required CCUR construction access dates as put forth in the P3/DB solicitation is critical. HART is in the process of finalizing a solicitation package to bring on board additional contractors to facilitate construction, as this would provide additional resources and means and methods to prosecute the work.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
85 | P a g e
5.2 Permits Permits Submitted and In-Progress HART submitted the University of Hawai‘i Park and Ride stockpiling permit. HART submitted a trenching permit for City Center Utility Relocation (Task Order 14). HART received the extension of the advanced approval that authorizes construction of the project over eight
streams under U.S. Coast Guard jurisdiction. HART submitted the Community Noise Permit for the West O‘ahu Farrington Highway section.
Look Ahead HART will be submitting permit applications for utility relocations across the Kapālama Canal.
5.3 Hawai'i Department of Transportation (HDOT) Agreements Activities this Month HDOT Attorney General is currently reviewing the WOFH Master Agreement and Joint Use and Occupancy
Agreement (JUOA) Amendment 1 draft amendments. The latest update from HDOT is that completion of their review and comments is expected in July 2020.
Ongoing tracking of the progress of the projects for the Highway Improvement Agreement. Coordinating documentation of the highway improvement projects with HDOT and Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) for reimbursement. Reimbursement for approximately $20 million of completed highway improvement work is being pursued for the current federal fiscal year. FHWA is reviewing files for compliance on the solicitation of items that require a waiver to disburse funding for the Highway Improvements. For the Kuala left-turn Highway Improvement project, HART is in the process of determining which contract the work is to be performed. Pupukahi right-turn and traffic signal cost estimate approvals are being coordinated with HDOT, FHWA and on-call.
DTS comments on the Draft WOFH Utility Abandonment agreement is currently being reviewed and addressed. Record drawings/as-builts need to be provided for WOFH Utilities for Exhibit A of the agreement.
Look Ahead Route externally for execution of the West O‘ahu Farrington Highway Master Agreement and Joint Use and
Occupancy Agreement Amendment 1. Route to BFS, followed by final legal review, estimated fourth quarter 2020. Presentation to the Board and City Council to follow, estimated fourth quarter 2020.
The West O‘ahu Farrington Highway Joint Use and Occupancy Agreement Amendment 2 is being prepared and includes maintenance agreements related to guideway permanent Best Management Practice’s (BMPs) and traffic signal mounts on the pedestrian bridge at the UHWO Station. WOFH Permanent BMP report acceptance by HDOT is expected in July 2020. Waiawa Stream Operations and Maintenance Manual to be drafted by HART. Expected completion of reports is July 2020. Recommendations to be added to the JUOA Amendment 2.
Comment resolution and resubmittal of the Draft Utility Abandonment agreement to DTS is expected to be completed in July 2020. Upon HART/DTS concurrence, external routing to HDOT is expected in the third quarter of 2020.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
86 | P a g e
5.4 Utility Agreements
Utility Agreements Status Matrix
Utility Owner Status WOFH KHG Airport City Center
ESA UCA ESA UCA UCA COMBINED ESA UCA
AT&T (Corporation)
Executed 05/11/11 12/20/11 5/18/12
Including with ESA
Not Required
12/26/13 05/03/17 NTP 05/12/11 12/21/11
Amd 01 07/01/11 HRS Ch. 104 11/22/16
AT&T Corp. (Public Sector)
Executed 12/26/13 08/27/18 12/26/13
NTP
Chevron
Executed 12/04/09
11/04/11
NTP 12/22/09 11/15/11
Amd 01 07/01/11
Hawaiian Telcom
Executed 05/20/10 11/17/14 05/10/12 12/31/14 05/28/15 09/27/13 04/06/17
NTP 06/14/10 11/18/14
Amd 01 07/01/11 04/13/15 05/11/17 11/19/18 09/20/19
Amd 02 05/10/12
HECO
Design
Services Construction
Services Design
Services Construction
Services Design
Services Construction
Services Design
Services Construction
Services
Executed 11/20/13 11/29/13 11/20/13 11/29/13 11/20/13
11/25/13
NTP 11/20/13 11/29/13 11/20/13 11/29/13 11/20/13 11/25/13
Executed 05/16/18
Change Order 01
06/30/17 11/13/19 02/22/18
Working on
Change Order 01
Change Order 02
02/22/18 11/13/19
Mem
ora
nd
um
s o
f
Un
der
stan
din
g
08/07/14 – Construction Drawings
05/01/15 – Access
05/15/15 – Derrick Truck
06/23/15 – Master Agreement
06/09/15 – MSF Advanced Construction
09/16/15 – Right of Entry
10/12/15 – Clearance (West) 11/10/15 – Dillingham Blvd Materials
07/13/16 – KHG Vertical Clearance
Power Quality MOU (Working on MOU)
08/16/18 - Airport Clearance Agreement
05/15/19 – Vehicle Storage MOU
08/13/19 - Airport Energization MOU
Charter Communications/Oceanic Time Warner Cable
Executed 12/08/09 12/21/11 01/09/12 06/02/14 12/19/14
04/03/13 9/22/16
NTP 12/22/09 04/04/13 9/30/16
Amd 01 07/01/11 02/27/14 HRS Ch. 104 07/06/18 Finalizing
agreement documents
Amd 02 10/07/13 HRS Ch. 104
Pacific Lightnet/ Wavecom
Executed 04/28/10 03/12/12 02/15/12
NTP 04/29/10 03/13/12 02/16/12
Amd 01 07/01/11 HRS Ch. 104
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
87 | P a g e
Utility Agreements Status Matrix
Utility Owner Status WOFH KHG Airport City Center
ESA UCA ESA UCA UCA COMBINED ESA UCA
Sandwich Isle Communications
Executed 05/20/10 04/20/12
NTP 06/08/10
Amd 01 07/01/11
Hawai'i GAS
Executed 12/18/09 06/30/11 06/01/12 04/14/14
08/19/14 09/27/13
05/08/15
NTP 12/22/09 07/12/11 08/20/14 05/11/15
Amd 01 07/01/11 10/17/14 08/28/14 08/31/17 10/24/17
Amd 02 05/09/16 10/23/15 11/03/19
Received CC final
drawings. Working on
AMD 02
Amd 03 HRS Ch. 104
Level 3/TW Telecom
Executed 12/02/09
02/14/12 Oceanic to relocate for TW Telecom
10/11/12 Oceanic to relocate for TW Telecom NTP 12/22/09 02/16/12
Amd 01 07/01/11
Tesoro
Executed
02/15/12 09/12/13
08/27/13
NTP 02/16/12 09/03/13
Amd 01 09/12/14
Amd 02 05/13/15
Amd 03 HRS Ch. 104
Legend = Action this month COR = Corporation Counsel UCA = Utility Construction Agreement
= Not applicable ESA = Engineering Services Agreement
UFRCRA = Combined Engineering and Construction Utility Agreement
Overall Key Issues No key issues to report this month.
HECO
Ka‘aahi Substation near MSF area o Supplemental Agreement (SA) –HART received a letter from HECO dated June 19, 2020, stating that based
on HART’s latest load forecast of Jan. 15, 2020, the service date remains unchanged and that it will not start construction until HART executes the SA. HECO needs 10 consecutive months to construct the substation. Also, City DTS is now agreeable to co-signing a SA with HART and HECO; HART is awaiting final comments from City DTS.
o Post-Record of Decision (ROD) Environmental Determination – HART received a letter from the Federal Transit Administration dated May 29, 2020, stating that HECO’s proposed 58-foot antenna pole (in lieu of the extension of fiber optic cable) in the substation will not cause significant environmental impacts and that the preparation of a Supplementary Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is not necessary.
Mitigation of Horizontal Working Clearance Requirements o KHG 138kV Relocation project: Refer to the Design Services for 138kV Utilities Relocation at KHG contract
page in Section 4.3 for the latest updates. o Specialized Vehicle Storage Yard at MSF: The security fencing is now targeted to be complete by the end of
July 2020. In the meantime, HECO has stored two of its older vehicles at the MSF while storing its new specialized vehicles at its own yard.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
88 | P a g e
5.5 Right-of-Way Key Issues ROW is engaging with property owners along the City Center Guideway and Stations (CCGS) Section to acquire the requisite property rights, via Right of Entry and Possession and Use Agreements (ROE/PUA) for Land Court properties pending final Grant of Easement or Deed. When acquisition by purchase is not reasonably available, ROW uses eminent domain to acquire the requisite property interests. HART’s counsel prosecutes its eminent domain actions and the respective motions for immediate possession of the property so that the construction access may be obtained. Current eminent domain actions:
o West O‘ahu/Farrington: Parcel Identification Number (PID) 102 R. Lee: HART has possession of the property, while the
Lees remediate contamination on the parcel. The judge overseeing this case has been serving as a mediator and facilitator, assisting the property owner in completing its obligations under the settlement. The judge holds biweekly status conferences with the parties and has engaged the Hawai‘i Department of Health (HDOH) in facilitating the completion of the remediation of the property. The HDOH has issued one “no further action” letter and there now remain three sections of the property to remediate.
o Airport: HART has possession of the subject property in the four cases filed with the court. For
PID 318 Masters, the parties are closing on a settlement. PID 306 SCI and PID 319 SCI were consolidated and mediation is ongoing; trial is postponed to after Aug. 31, 2020.
o City Center: Eight cases are filed with the court and are active (PID 400 Blood Bank, PID 472A Desky, PID 439
Yamauchi, PID 485 Scott Shoe, Howard Hughes various parcels, PID 433 HECO Iwilei, PID 502 Yung Soon Tajima Trust, PID 503 JY Trading Co.). HART filed its eminent domain action and motion for order putting HART in possession of PID 433 HECO Iwilei. HECO filed a challenge to HART’s Order of Possession of the property for the HECO Dillingham Avenue property. HART performed a Phase II environmental survey on this property and will also have one done on the HECO downtown property on Ala Moana Boulevard. PID 439 Yamauchi executed a settlement agreement and counsel will formally dismiss this case once the Land Court process is completed. Possession has been granted for PID 400 Blood Bank, PID 472A Desky, PID 485 Scott Shoe, Howard Hughes various parcels, and PID 503 JY Trading Co. HART began processing approvals to file eminent domain action for PID 474 Ka’a Limited Partnership.
During the month of May 2019, the FTA conducted a review of the relocation program and the FTA issued a report on Sept. 23, 2019 regarding its findings. The report details measures that must be taken to bring the closed relocation files into compliance, including interviewing the relocated parties. The FTA approved HART’s plan to bring the files into compliance, which was transmitted on Oct. 31, 2019. HART contracted with a team that met with the FTA in January 2020 to discuss the implementation of the plan. The corrective action plan team is auditing files and prepared initial contact to displaced parties in June 2020. The team provides regular reports on progress to HART and the FTA.
Regular meetings between the CCUR team, Project Controls and ROW to track progress, identify opportunities, foresee obstacles to access for critically needed parcels, and budget are ongoing. Revisions in designs made necessary by guideway and utility redesigns will require revised and new acquisitions along Dillingham and Halekauwila Street, including acquisitions currently in negotiation.
The FTA agreed to the proposed multi-agency approach to the acquisition and tenant relocations for PID 493 Watumull which is the site for the Ala Moana Station. HART has partnered with the City and County of Honolulu’s DTS, Department of Design and Construction (DDC), and BFS to facilitate. The owner recently transmitted a counter-offer for the City’s consideration. Relocation assistance work is underway.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
89 | P a g e
HART recently entered into agreements with Latter Day Saints (LDS), Otani and General Growth Properties (GGP) Ala Moana to obtain necessary property rights; the properties are currently in escrow.
Relocation assistance is being provided to the tenant and PID 404 Takara. HART and the owner are working to finalize an agreement.
ROW continues to monitor negotiations between Design and Construction and HECO regarding issues involving
clearance requirements due to maintenance equipment staging needs for 138kV poles and lines located next to the HART guideway system. These discussions will identify additional acquisitions of non-asset easements on behalf of HECO or other utility agencies and/or companies.
Negotiations are continuing with UH, including securing a construction ROE Agreement with the Honolulu
Community College.
Acquisitions Figure 7. Right-of-Way Status for the Parcels
Relocations Figure 8. Relocation Status for the Occupants
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
90 | P a g e
Non-Right of Way Figure 9. Temporary Construction Easements and Utility
Status of Inter-Governmental Agreements Figure 10. Inter-Governmental Agreement Status The status of agreements between HART and other government entities. Objectives are:
1) Obtain Construction Right of Entry, Executive Orders, Set Asides, Jurisdiction Transfers, Joint Use Agreements, licenses, easements, Memorandum of Understanding (MOUs), Memorandum of Agreement (MOAs), etc. with impacted government agencies. Government agencies HART is working with include: Federal (GSA, Navy, USPS, Office of Interior), State (HDOT-Highways & Air, DLNR, DAGS, HCDA, DOE, Aloha Stadium, UH), and County Agencies (DTS, DPP, DFM, BFS, DDC, Parks, DLM, ENV). Some government agencies may choose to issue the final documents after construction is substantially underway or near completion.
2) To help negotiate and/or obtain Rights of Entry for certain other construction-related activities as requested by Design and Construction. Such agreements may include: geotechnical borings, soil testing, environmental surveys, bus stop agreements, construction lay down surveys, and other construction-related needs. There may be other Rights of Entry and Agreements which may not involve ROW acquisition or relocation. ROW will assist other HART departments, should requests be authorized and funded.
3) Agreements to be executed are in white. Executed agreements are in grey at the end of the table, and while these parcels may be accessible at this time for construction, further documentation may also be required to complete the acquisition.
Inter-Governmental Agreements
Agency
Pending Agreements (Executed Agreements
are shaded grey)
Target
Section
Construction Right of Entry
(CROE) Obtained
Notes/Remarks
STATE AGREEMENTS
UH – University of Hawai‘i, West O‘ahu (UHWO-125)
Construction Right of Entry and Occupancy & Use Agreement for East Kapolei Park & Ride
TBD/ Estimate
2021
WOFH Yes Interim park and ride (300 spaces) completed.
3rd Amendment to CROE has been fully executed. It allows for
installation of electrical connections from Road B to station area and
subsequently into interim parking.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
91 | P a g e
Inter-Governmental Agreements
Agency
Pending Agreements (Executed Agreements
are shaded grey)
Target
Section
Construction Right of Entry
(CROE) Obtained
Notes/Remarks
UH – Urban Gardens (201A) Conveyance to HDOT (H) – Dept. of Transportation Highways
September 2020
KHG Yes
2nd Amendment to HART ROE fully executed. Based on final Phase II
results, HDOT has issued concurrence letter. Construction is
nearing completion. Quitclaim deed under review by HDOT-Highways.
Subdivision map completed.
UH – Honolulu Community College (HCC) (424A)
Construction Right of Entry for guideway & station
September 2020
City Center No Pending design finalization. Working with UH regarding ROE Agreement.
Third round of comments on Draft of CROE Agreement under review by
UH. A portion of planned demolition and preliminary construction
activities completed under letter agreement with Royal Construction.
DLNR – Dept of Land & Natural Resources (124)
Kapolei Easement Agreement for overhead guideway and for park and ride facility
September 2020
WOFH
Yes In process. DPP approved subdivision application for guideway easement footprint. Transmitted to DLNR for
land court submittal. Discussions are ongoing regarding language
permitting guideway easement. Request to expand Park and Ride
CROE (executed in 2013) from 5 to 11 acres was approved by the Board
of Land and Natural Resources (BLNR) at its May 8, 2020 Board Meeting. A Right of Entry will be
issued for 11 acres.
DLNR/C&C Wastewater Div (437B)
Easement Agreement December 2020
City Center Yes Waiting for the easement map to be finalized by DLNR.
DOE - Waipahu H.S. (118) Permanent Easement (State owned portion)
July 2020
WOFH Yes
In process. Construction is not impacted as the ROE for right to access and construct is executed.
With DOE for review. Working with DLNR for permanent rights.
DOE – Waipahu H.S. (117) Permanent Easement (City portion)
December 2020
WOFH Yes Construction is not impacted as the Master/ Construction Agreement is
executed. Still waiting for DOE to sign off on Right of Entry extension for
HECO and HART that was submitted in March 2020. It is still with the
attorney general for review. The city owned portion of Waipahu H.S. is being transferred to the State of Hawai‘i. Revised easement map
being provided by RM Towill. HART will submit to DOE and the State to finalize the easement map so the
subdivision process can commence.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
92 | P a g e
Inter-Governmental Agreements
Agency
Pending Agreements (Executed Agreements
are shaded grey)
Target
Section
Construction Right of Entry
(CROE) Obtained
Notes/Remarks
Aloha Stadium / Dept. of Accounting & General Services (DAGS) (207A to C)
Easement Agreement September 2020
KHG Yes In process. Creating maps that separate the parking area from the station and guideway easements.
2016 MOU being revised and updated to reflect the evolving
nature of the agreement between HART and Stadium Authority prior to permanent easements being put in
place. DTS will be involved. Final revised easement map submitted to DLNR, DAGS and Stadium Authority for approval. BWS easement will be
considered at 7/24 BLNR Board meeting.
Aloha Stadium/ DAGS (207B)
Ground Lease Agreement for bus interface and shared parking area
July 2020
KHG Yes In process. Agreement format may impact map approvals from Stadium
Authority, DAGS and DLNR. Construction is not impacted as the
ROE for right to access and construct is executed. Parking area rights will
be granted via long term lease. Relocation of parking spaces will be
addressed to accommodate TOD development at the Stadium.
HDOT(H) – Dept. of Transportation Highways (100,100-A, 304, 400-A, 400-B)
Master Agreement Amendment
July 2020
WOFH Yes Construction is not impacted as the Joint Use & Occupancy (JU&O)
Agreement for right to access and construct is executed.
HDOT(H) and (A) – Dept of Transportation Highways & Airports (100,100-A, 301, 304, 304, 400-A, 400-B)
Master Agreement for KHG, Airport and City Center Amendment
July 2020
KHG, Airport,
City Center
Yes for KHG & Airport
Construction is not impacted as the JU&O for right to access and
construct for City Center will be executed when the Notice to
Proceed (NTP) is issued.
HDOT(H) (100,100-A, 304, 400-A, 400-B)
JU&O Sub-agreement July 2020
WOFH Yes In process. Construction is not impacted as the JU&O for right to access and construct is executed.
HDOT(H) (100,100-A, 304, 400-A, 400-B)
JU&O Sub-agreement July 2020
City Center In process. Construction is not impacted as the JU&O will be executed when NTP is issued.
HCDA -HI Community Development Authority (444A, 450,463BE-5-B, 475)
Construction ROE, License Agreement, & Final Disposition
August 2020
City Center Coordination is ongoing. ROE for Royal Contracting pre-construction
activities extended. Final disposition pending revised design.
DAGS (441-A) Construction Right of Entry July 2020
City Center A street is being designed substantially within the footprint of
Easement U as requested by DAGS as a precondition to ROE. The street will be provided as in-kind consideration
for a staging yard for the 3rd party contractor. Survey for staging area
being conducted and street concept plan undergoing refinement. Utility
work descoped; will now be performed by the P3 contractor.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
93 | P a g e
Inter-Governmental Agreements
Agency
Pending Agreements (Executed Agreements
are shaded grey)
Target
Section
Construction Right of Entry
(CROE) Obtained
Notes/Remarks
DAGS (441-A) Guideway and Utility Easement Agreement
August 2020
City Center Design plans for the Kaaahi Street extension are still being refined and
vetted with the City.
DAGS (443-A) Utility, (Communications & Electrical) Agreement
September 2020
City Center No On-going negotiations with DAGS to secure right of entry. Letter requesting issuance of ROE
submitted to DLNR/DAGS on June 22, 2020.
DAGS (443-B) Guideway and TCE Agreement
December 2020
City Center No On-going negotiations with DAGS to secure right of entry. Agreement
being negotiated for loss of parking revenue during construction of
column in parking area.
Kalihi Kai Elementary (501) Right of Entry from DOE/DLNR
October 2020
City Center Communications with DOE is ongoing regarding “in kind”
consideration in the form of air conditioning equipment. DOE wants
this decided prior to issuance of ROE.
Kalihi Kai Elementary (501) Easement Agreement March 2021
City Center On hold pending design finalization. Once ROE is in place, subdivision
map to be completed and submitted to DPP. Notice of Intent to Acquire
containing enlarged electrical footprint for electrical easement and a new column easement was sent in
late May 2020.
State of Hawaii - DOT (504) Easement Agreement Pending City Center HECO amending easement design and under review.
FEDERAL AGREEMENTS
USPS (301) Permanent Easement 2021 Airport Via GOE Construction is not impacted. Grant of Easements were recorded in
Regular System to facilitate entry onto property for construction even though the property is registered in Land Court. Now petitions for Land Court designation of easements are
being developed for submittal to Land Court.
U.S. Gov't/General Services Administration (GSA)/Federal Courthouse (443C)
Master Agreement, Security & Landscape License Agreement, Utility License Agreement, Guideway License Agreement
September 2020
City Center Master Agreement fully executed on 8/13/19.
Design changes finalized and signed
maps, which reflect relocation of guideway supports onto GSA
property, were shared with GSA. Negotiations to amend Master
Agreement are ongoing. Appraisal underway to revalue the guideway
easement; expected by late July 2020.
GSA Federal Courthouse Quitclaim Easement Documents for Utility and Guideway Easements
2020 City Center Under development.
CITY AGREEMENTS
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
94 | P a g e
Inter-Governmental Agreements
Agency
Pending Agreements (Executed Agreements
are shaded grey)
Target
Section
Construction Right of Entry
(CROE) Obtained
Notes/Remarks
BFS – Dept. of Budget & Fiscal Svcs (204A)
Intra-Agency coordination which may take the form of a ROE, letter agreement, or license (Continental Investment)
2020 KHG Via intra-agency
coordination
In process.
DFM (423A) Work Permit (Kapalama Stream for Street, Bridge, and Guideway Improvements)
2020 City Center DFM/DLM granted entry.
DFM (423A) Easement Agreement for Utilities
2020 City Center Utility agreements on hold pending design finalization.
The property work access was granted in late March by DFM.
DTS – Dept. of Transportation Svcs (322)
Intra-Agency coordination which may take the form of a ROE, letter agreement, or license (Middle Street Station)
2020 Airport Via intra agency
coordination
In process.
OTHER AGREEMENTS
D.R. Horton (101B) MOU Construction Right of Entry Amendment – D.R. Horton & HART Easement Agreement – D.R. Horton & HECO
July 2020
WOFH Yes MOU draft circulating for comments. PH I environmental survey
completed. D.R. Horton (DRH) counsel and COR counsel speaking
directly to address remaining issues on license agreement.
Negotiations finalized regarding the License Agreement to cover
increases in park and ride construction costs, GET tax on
license and property taxes. Signature version of License Agreement being
prepared.
D.R. Horton Final Easement Agreement September 2020
WOFH Yes Construction is not impacted. D.R. Horton is completing further
subdivision of the property. Maps will be updated with new Tax Map
Key prior to submittal of application to DPP.
EXECUTED AGREEMENTS
CITY AGREEMENTS
BFS (205A) Jurisdictional transfer from DFM to HART of Kamehameha Hwy/Makalapa Manor
Airport Yes Jurisdictional Transfer from BFS Letter dated 8/26/11.
DPR - Dept. of Parks & Recreation (119)
Construction consent to construct for MSF drainage
WOFH Yes
BFS / DFM (Dept. of Facility & Maintenance) (437C)
Jurisdictional Transfer (Awa Triangle, N. Nimitz & Awa St.)
City Center Jurisdictional transfer completed July 9, 2018.
STATE AGREEMENTS
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
95 | P a g e
Inter-Governmental Agreements
Agency
Pending Agreements (Executed Agreements
are shaded grey)
Target
Section
Construction Right of Entry
(CROE) Obtained
Notes/Remarks
DLNR/C&C Wastewater Div (437B)
Construction Right of Entry
City Center Yes Construction ROE obtained from
DLNR 10/21/17. Subdivision submitted with DPP 1/1/18.
UH – University of Hawai‘i Master Agreement is not needed as the ROE for right to access and construct will be executed separately by each campus.
WOFH, KHG, City
Center
Will be executed by each campus
Construction is not impacted as the ROE for right to access and construct
will be executed by each campus.
UH Pre-Construction Right of Entry and Amendment
WOFH, KHG, City
Center
Yes
UH - West O‘ahu (UHWO) (125)
Construction Right of Entry for Station, Temporary Park & Ride, and Amendment for Construction of Road B
WOFH Yes
UH - Leeward Community College (LCC) (122)
Construction Right of Entry for Guideway
WOFH Yes
UH – LCC (122) Construction Right of Entry for Station
WOFH Yes
UH - Urban Gardens (201A)
Construction Right of Entry KHG Yes
DLNR – Dept. of Land and Natural Resources (124)
Kapolei Construction Right of Entry for overhead guideway and for park and ride facility
WOFH Yes CROE has been granted once a year by letter. Working on permanent
Easement with DLNR. Currently with DPP for subdivision.
DLNR (320) Keehi Lagoon Construction Right of Entry
Airport Yes
DOE – Dept. of Education Waipahu H.S. (117, 118)
Master/Construction Agreement
WOFH Yes
DOE/DLNR for Waipahu H.S. (118)
Construction Right of Entry WOFH Yes Executed by DLNR with DOE concurrence.
Aloha Stadium / Dept of Accounting & General Services (DAGS) (207)
MOU for guideway & station KHG Yes
Aloha Stadium/DAGS Construction Right of Entry for guideway
KHG Yes
Aloha Stadium/DAGS Construction Right of Entry for station park and ride
KHG Yes
HDOT(H) – Dept. of Transportation Highways (100)
Master Agreement for HDOT Highways for WOFH
WOFH Yes
HDOT(H) and (A) – Dept. of Transportation Highways & Airports
Master Agreement for HDOT Highways and Airports, for KHG, Airport and City Center Sections
KHG, Airport,
City Center
Yes except for City Center
whose JU&O will be
executed when the NTP
is issued
HDOT(H) JU&O Sub-agreement WOFH Yes
HDOT(H) JU&O Sub-agreement KHG Yes
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
96 | P a g e
Inter-Governmental Agreements
Agency
Pending Agreements (Executed Agreements
are shaded grey)
Target
Section
Construction Right of Entry
(CROE) Obtained
Notes/Remarks
HDOT(H) JU&O Sub-agreement Airport Yes
HDOT (A) - Dept. of Transportation Airports
Airport Special Provisions for Right of Entry
Airport Yes
HDOT(A) JU&O Sub-agreement for Airport Division parcels
Airport Yes
HDOT(A) (301A) Easement document for Airport Division parcel (Main guideway easement)
Airport Yes Ongoing intra-agency coordination. Construction is not impacted as the Special Provisions and the JU&O for
right to access and construct is executed.
DHHL - Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands (Exchange w/ Varona Village) (115A)
MOA, License/ROE from DHHL, City Council Resolution
WOFH, MSF Yes DLNR approves withdraw from GEO 571 7/14/17. DFM accepts road
widening and now City jurisdiction.
OCCC - Dept. of Public Safety, Oahu Community Correctional Center (400A)
MOU
City Center Yes
OCCC/DLNR Construction Right of Entry
City Center Yes
DLNR/OCCC Letter of Responsibility from City-DFM/Road
City Center Yes
HCDA -HI Community Development Authority (444A, 450, 463B, E-5-B, 475)
Pre-construction Right of Entry
City Center Yes, effective upon request
Verbal approval granted by the HCDA Board in 6/2016.
FEDERAL AGREEMENTS
U.S. Navy (116A) Grant of Easements for Maintenance & Storage Facility (MSF)/Rail Operations Center (ROC) offsite drainage and sewer easements
WOFH Yes Per Letter #N62478-12-RP00011 dated 6/28/12 confirming easement
from Navy.
U.S. Navy (300) Licenses/Construction Right of Entry
WOFH, KHG,
Airport
Yes 6/22/15 – 5 Yrs. License ends in 2020. All utility work needs to be
completed by then.
U.S. Navy Easement Agreements WOFH, KHG,
Airport
Yes Grant of Easement executed. Grant of Easement 8/22/16.
U.S. Navy Pearl Harbor Station Acquisition of Fee Transfer
Airport Yes Quitclaim deed executed 2/25/16.
U.S. Post Office (USPS) (301)
Honolulu Processing Center acquisition
Airport Yes Acquisition completed in regular system. Need to process through Land Court to complete process.
Funds already paid. USPS Land Court share to complete process is in
escrow.
OTHER AGREEMENTS
D.R. Horton Construction Right of Entry - D.R. Horton & HECO
WOFH Yes Executed 5/11/2018.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
97 | P a g e
6 MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE UPDATES
6.1 Safety and Security (S&S) Key Milestone Progress HART Safety works with the Core Systems Oversight Consultant (CSOC) to oversee HRH preparation for MSF
Attended Operations in the yard and the Functional Track Section. o Expected completion of HRH requirements for the Attended Operations Milestone is August 2020.
HART Safety conducts monthly certification meetings with each station group project team to close out safety and security critical Open Items in preparation for substantial completion.
HART Safety is working with Project Controls to ensure Safety and Security Certification Milestones and related activities are identified and updated on the Master Project Schedule.
The Construction Safety and Security Plan is under revision; estimated acceptance is July 2020. Key Issues Scheduled certification milestones for Segment 1 may be delayed due to the following open requirements:
MSF Attended Operations Milestone (Hold Point) o HRH to complete open items in regard to ATC, COMM, SIT and SCADA.
Specification Testing Conformance Checklists (STCC) Open Items (58)
ATC – 3 Open out of 21
Communications – 35 Open out of 38
System Integration & Testing – 9 Open out of 22
SCADA – 6 Open out of 14 o HRH to complete 8 open items in regard to Operational Readiness. o HRH to complete 13 STCC open items for PVs fleet design verification and individual certifications. o HART Safety is following up with CSOC and HRH for MSF Systems Certification (4 STCC Open Items)
Inspection and Test Procedures for MSF Yard Communication Inspection and Test Report for MSF Yard Communication On-site Inspection and Test Report for MSF Yard Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) Panel Distribution Unit Low Voltage (LV) Schematic Drawing for MSF Yard Control Bungalow
(YCB) UPS o Maintenance of Way (MOW) vehicles certification – pending approved STCC documentation for the
Multiple Purpose Vehicle (MPV) acceptance. HART Safety and CSOC are following up with HRH to close the following STCC open item (1):
HNL-23015 Accepted as Noted –Resubmit (ANR): O&M Manual
HART Safety witnessed the final acceptance test and is awaiting HRH’s submittal of the updated O&M Manual.
System Integration Testing Milestone (Hold Point) o HART Safety is working with CSOC to identify the pre-requisite requirements needed for the System
Integration Testing Hold Point for the following procedures HNL-12428 IST Procedure – Single Tracking Mode HNL-12434 IST Procedure – Operation under Headway Regulation HNL-12435 IST Procedure – Operation under Schedule Regulation
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
98 | P a g e
6.1.1 Project Overall Certification Status
Project Overall Certification Status - Progress Total Items
Total Verified 1/1/20
Total Verified 6/30/20 Total Remaining
Δ YTD
% Complete
% Remaining
Segment 1 Revenue Service 25,283 20,095 22,638 2,645 2,543 90% 10%
Segment 2 Revenue Service 9,849 4,951 5,240 4,609 289 53% 47%
Segment 3 Revenue Service 7,652 4 4 7,648 0 0% 100%
Final Overall 42,784 25,050 27,882 14,902 2,832 65% 35%
6.1.2 Segment 1 Revenue Service Date Certification Status
Segment 1 Certification Status - Progress Anticipated Completion
Total Items
Total Verified 1/1/20
Total Verified 6/30/20
Total Remaining
Δ YTD
% Complete
% Remaining
MSF (Civil & Systems) AUG 2020 740 725 734 6 9 99% 1%
Guideway (Civil & Systems) CLOSED 7,368 7,368 7,368 0 - 100% 0%
Stations & Parking (Civil & Systems) SEPT 2020 7,330 6,884 7,185 145 301 98% 2%
Passenger Vehicle (PT 8-14) and Fleet Requirements
NOV 2020 1,603 519 1,203 400 684 75% 25%
MOW Vehicles JUL 2020 458 454 457 1 3 99% 1%
Traction Electrification System (TES) AUG 2020 301 204 218 83 14 72% 28%
Automatic Train Control (ATC) AUG 2020 346 301 314 32 13 91% 9%
Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA)
AUG 2020 84 56 56 28 0 67% 33%
Communication SEPT 2020 983 676 685 298 9 70% 30%
System Integration Testing (SIT) NOV 2020 138 71 71 67 0 51% 49%
Platform Screen Gate System (PSGS) JUL 2020 96 66 71 25 5 74% 26%
Elevators / Escalators AUG 2020 508 295 295 213 0 58% 42%
Fare Collection System NOV 2020 78 28 28 50 0 36% 64%
Arts in Transit NOV 2020 168 14 14 154 0 8% 92%
Operational Readiness NOV 2020 736 123 223 513 100 30% 70%
Risk Management NOV 2020 4,346 2,311 3,716 630 1,405 86% 14%
25,283 20,095 22,638 2,645 2,543
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
99 | P a g e
6.1.3 Segment 2 Revenue Service Date Certification Status
Segment 2 Certification Status - Progress Total Items Total Verified
1/1/20 Total Verified
6/30/20 Total
Remaining Δ YTD % Complete
Guideway (Civil & Systems) 3,041 1624 1,802 1,239 178 59%
Stations & Parking (Civil & Systems) 1,998 1525 1,600 398 75 80%
Passenger Vehicles (1-7 & 15-20) 2,138 676 707 1,431 31 33%
Traction Electrification System (TES) 54 4 4 50 0 7%
Automatic Train Control (ATC) 29 12 12 17 0 41%
Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) 47 8 8 39 0 17%
Communication 32 0 0 32 0 0%
Platform Screen Gate System (PSGS) 8 0 0 8 0 0%
System Integration Testing (SIT) 44 0 0 44 0 0%
Elevators / Escalators 33 0 0 33 0 0%
Fare Collection System 50 0 0 50 0 0%
Arts in Transit 63 0 0 63 0 0%
Operational Readiness 555 0 0 555 0 0%
Risk Management 1,757 1,102 1,107 650 5 63%
9,849 4,951 5,240 4,609 289
6.1.4 Segment 3 Revenue Service Date Certification Status
Segment 3 Certification Status - Progress Total Items Total Verified
1/1/20 Total Verified
6/30/20 Total
Remaining Δ YTD % Complete
Guideway (Civil & Systems) 1,772 0 0 1,772 0 0%
Stations & Parking (Civil & Systems) 4,908 0 0 4,908 0 0%
Traction Electrification System (TES) 39 0 4 35 4 10%
Automatic Train Control (ATC) 29 0 0 29 0 0%
Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) 47 0 0 47 0 0%
Communication 47 0 0 47 0 0%
Passenger Screen Gate System (PSGS) 16 0 0 16 0 0%
System Integration Testing (SIT) 44 0 0 44 0 0%
Elevators / Escalators 33 0 0 33 0 0%
Fare Collection System 50 0 0 50 0 0%
Arts in Transit 112 0 0 112 0 0%
Operational Readiness 555 0 0 555 0 0%
Risk Management 0 0 0 0 0 0%
7,652 0 4 7,648 4
6.1.5 Construction Safety and Security: Safety and Security Incidents Incidents for June 1-30, 2020:
Recordable Safety Incidents (medical treatment and/or lost time only): o AGS: An employee was struck in the face by a winch cable that broke under stress. This cable is one of the
two cables that hold the snatch box in place. First aid was administered, and then the employee was taken to Kaiser Permanente where they received stitches to the face.
o CCUR: A belt system was started when an employee who had his right hand on the engine, had the tips and middle ring finger of his hand smashed and fractured.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
100 | P a g e
Security Incidents (arrests and/or thefts only): o None.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
101 | P a g e
6.2 Quality Management Key Issues
HART NCR Log
Total NCRs Issued To Date Closed Open
101 (Audits) 97 4
3 (Construction) 2 1 Note: HART Issued NCRs for Construction are shown on each respective contract.
Resolution of major NCRs that need to be addressed and corrected to prevent recurrence, and to mitigate impact on the overall progress of the project. The major NCRs are described below: o Cracks in Canopy Structural Steel Members. Cracks on the Canopy Structural Steel members were found in the
WOSG and FHSG station groups. HART is in the process of finding the “root cause” of the defects, the disposition, and appropriate corrective action to prevent recurrence. All lower portions of the canopy arms (grade 100 steel) will be replaced at WOSG, FHSG and KHSG. The canopies at WOSG and FHSG are corrected. Please see Section 5.1 Overall Key Issues, for the latest status on the KHSG canopies.
o Train #12. End Car 1 of Train #12 was damaged (about 2.0 ft. long x ¾ in. wide x ¼ in. deep gouge on the left side, which did not penetrate the aluminum extrusion skin, and about ½ in. diameter penetration in the first set of the Door Panel on the right side of End Car 1) during transit from Pittsburg, CA to Honolulu, HI. HRI determined that cosmetic repairs will be required. A qualified and certified surface finisher repair crew is scheduled to be in Honolulu to fix the damage using an approved repair procedure once it is available.
Audit Look Ahead Prepared and issued (Revision 5) the Project Combined Management Systems Audit Schedule for 2020 to HART and all
contractors, consultants and suppliers. Planning for the audits to be performed in July and August 2020: Audit No. 20-003 AGS (Casting Facility) Combined QA,
Buy America (BA) and Environmental Compliance (EC) Audit of STG, Audit No. 20-004 Core System Support Consultant (CSSC) QA Audit of Lea + Elliott (L+E), Audit No. 20-005 CCUR Combined QA, BA and EC Audit of Nan Inc., Audit No. 20-006 On-Call (Project Wide) of Royal Contracting, and Audit No. 20-007 GEC 3 QA Audit of Jacobs. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, all audits scheduled for April to June 2020 were postponed until July and August 2020.
Issued Closeout Letter on Audit No. 20-001 AGS (Construction) Combined QA, BA and EC Audit of STG held on Feb. 27-28, 2020. The Audit Team found eight (8) Positive Findings (5-QA/3-EC), seven (7) Observations (4-QA/3-EC), and five (5) EC Suggestions. Currently reviewing response from STG.
Issued Audit Report on Audit No. 20-016 Internal QA Audit of HART 5.CA-11 Contract Changes Procedure. The Audit Team found three (3) Positive Findings, three (3) Observations and two (2) Suggestions. Issued follow-up email to close the audit.
Issued Audit Report on Audit No. 19-019 HART Combined QA, S&S and EC Internal Audit of HART on Jan. 17, 2020. The Audit Team found: three (3) Positives, three (3) NCRs, nine (9) Observations, and three (3) Suggestions on QA; two (2) Observations, and two (2) Suggestions on S&S; and one (1) Positive on EC. Issued follow-up emails to close the audit.
Issued Audit Report on Audit No. 20-002 AGS (Surveying) QA Audit of STG held on March 5, 2020. The Audit found two (2) NCRs. One of the NCR’s was closed in April 2020.
Oversight and Monitoring Attended and participated in Pre-activity meetings, Inspections and Testing on the project
o KHSG: Best Management Practice (BMP)/Environmental Inspection. o AGS: BMP/Environmental Inspections. o CCUR: BMP/Environmental Inspection.
Prepared and issued Project NCRs Trend Analysis from July 2019 to June 2020 (Revision 53). The trend for this month: Trains: went up 22 from 29 to 51; Core System: no change (zero); Fixed Facilities: went up 10 from 12 to 22. See the next page for the Project NCRs Trend Analysis, and the following are detailed analysis of NCRs for the Trains and Fixed Facilities. o Trains: In June 2020, 51 NCRs were issued. 29 NCRs are from Honolulu: 10-Train #13, 9-Train #14, 3-Train #8, 7-
various trains during receipt inspection of new trains and dynamic testing; 22 NCRs in Pittsburg, CA: related to receipt inspection of components, cables found to be short and have to be rerouted, exterior paint scratches that happened during handling ,and other minor defects found on the two (2) trains (8 cars) being assembled in the plant with the goal of delivering one (1) train per month to Honolulu.
o AGS: In June, 22 NCRs were issued: the activities and production on the project (Superstructure, Substructures, Casting Facility and four (4) Stations) is in full blast and the number of NCRs issued is normal for that magnitude. The monthly average of NCRs for Fixed Facilities is 22.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
102 | P a g e
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
103 | P a g e
6.3 Buy America Compliance (49 CFR 661 and 49 CFR 663) Overview and Key Issues
HRH continues to execute the corrective action plan to meet the PV Buy America requirements. The implementation of all required corrective action identified in the Post-Delivery Report has not yet been completed on all previously delivered Trains #1 through #6. Train #1 has been returned to Pittsburg, CA for retrofit and Train #2 will return to Pittsburg, CA within the coming months. Trains #3 through #6 require various retrofit that are planned to be conducted off-site, but on-island. The CSC will continue to monitor the update of the monthly Buy America compliance report as the retrofit status progresses to demonstrate compliance with the Corrective Action Plan. HRH has been notified that HART plans to complete the Post-Delivery Buy America audit on the Interim Opening (I/O) #1 fleet now that all seven (7) Interim Opening #1 fleet trains have been received in Honolulu. A significant component of the remaining Post-Delivery Audit effort is a follow-up “Supplier Audit” of Hitachi’s interior lining supplier to verify domestic content based on the implemented Corrective Action Plan. However, Hitachi has indicated that the Hayward, CA based supplier was impacted by the COVID-19 shutdown and is not yet prepared to support the conclusion of the Post-Delivery Audit. Hitachi has been tasked to coordinate with this supplier and identify the earliest possible date for the Raul V. Bravo + Associates, Inc. (RVB+A) auditors to conduct the audit and complete the Hitachi component of Post-Delivery Audit and issue the complete report. There will also be a final Buy America (BA) audit once the full fleet is delivered and tested prior to full system opening.
Train # Anticipated Date for BA Compliance
Open Issues
1 TBD Carshell structural retrofit, fire resistivity retrofit, and BA retrofit.
2 TBD Carshell structural retrofit, fire resistivity retrofit, and BA retrofit.
3 TBD Interior panels in M-Cars requires replacement for BA compliance.
4 TBD Requires M-car interior panel and Auxiliary Power Supply (APS) retrofit in accordance with BA Corrective Action Plan.
5 Completed Requires fire resistivity retrofit.
6 Completed Requires fire resistivity retrofit.
7 Completed No issue and in transit to Honolulu. Delivery to MSF is planned for July.
8 (I/O Fleet) Completed No issue and delivered to MSF on March 27, 2020.
9 (I/O Fleet) Completed No issue and delivered to MSF on Feb. 14, 2020.
10 (I/O Fleet) Completed No issue and delivered to MSF on Dec. 9, 2019.
11 (I/O Fleet) Completed No issue and delivered to MSF on Jan. 9, 2020.
12 (I/O Fleet) Completed No issue and delivered to MSF on Oct. 26, 2019.
13 (I/O Fleet) Completed No issue and delivered to MSF on May 8, 2020.
14 (I/O Fleet) Completed No issue and delivered to MSF by June 1, 2020.
15 December 2020 Manufacturing activities ongoing.
16 December 2020 Manufacturing activities ongoing.
17 December 2020 Manufacturing activities ongoing.
18 December 2020 Manufacturing activities ongoing.
19 TBD Manufacturing activities ongoing.
20 TBD Manufacturing activities ongoing.
6.4 Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Activities this Month
$151,980,785 = total dollar participation for all DBEs on all HART contracts from 9/24/07 to 6/30/20 o 18.85% = DBE utilization on total disbursed FTA funds received to date ($151,980,785 divided by
$806,258,734) o 8.62% = DBE utilization to date on total Project FTA funds ($151,980,785 divided by $1,763,903,901) o 9.81% = DBE utilization to date on 5309 Project FTA funds ($151,980,785 divided by $1,550,000,000)
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
104 | P a g e
6.5 Art-in-Transit (AIT) Program The Honolulu Rail Transit Project's December 2012 FFGA grant (Sitework and Special Conditions) includes a public art program. In addition, the Revised Ordinances of Honolulu (ROH) Section 3-2.7, "Art in City Buildings," provides for the inclusion of art in city-owned buildings frequented by the public. For the rail project, the AIT staff negotiates and manages contracts for the west-side stations and AGS. AIT contracts are managed in five NTP phases:
NTP1 - Conceptual design NTP2 - Design development, final design, and construction documents NTP3 - Mobilization NTP4 - Fabrication, transportation, and installation NTP5 - Final acceptance
Conceptual and final designs are presented to the Mayor's Commission on Culture and the Arts for review and comment. The Transit Art Committee (TAC) evaluates and makes the final recommendation and approval.
Station / Facility Name Artist Name NTP Phase Comments
East Kapolei Station Robert Flint NTP4
Artist and team Safety certified. Contractor changes to art wall completed. Artist scheduled to travel to Honolulu to confirm final dimensions and finishes in mid-July to commence fabrication of ceramic mural.
University of Hawai‘i West O‘ahu Station
Satoru Abe NTP3
Artistʻs team visited station to confirm inner dimensions of architectural fence for fabrication. Assisting the artist with Design Criteria Conformance Checklists (DCCC) submittal documents. Artistʻs team is working on Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) information for Safety.
Ho‘opili Station Karen Lucas NTP3
Assisted artist in verification of dimensions and confirmed directional placement of artworks for the best visual sightline. Fabricator is exploring another technology to interpret artistʻs designs on to custom colored glass tesserae to accurately replicate the fine details of the original pastel drawings.
West Loch Station Hans Ladislaus NTP3
Conducted in-depth technical research to assist artist on fabrication questions and options. Working with the artist on required technical documentation and MSDS information for Safety & Security Design Criteria Conformance Checklist review. Artist is working on scaled depth and texture studies to prepare maquette. Installation of barrier flashing on TCCR artwall is needed for art installation.
Waipahu Transit Center Station
John Koga NTP1 The TAC reviewed conceptual design submittal #5; revisions recommended.
Rail Operations Center – Operations & Servicing Building
Shigeru Miyamoto
NTP3
Working with the artist on required technical documentation and MSDS information for Safety & Security Design Criteria Conformance Checklist review. The artist needs to submit color samples during NTP3 and NTP4.
Leeward Community College
Donald Lipski NTP4 Fabrication continues in Florida, with casting of the sculptural elements and piercing of the star patterns on each unit.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
105 | P a g e
Station / Facility Name Artist Name NTP Phase Comments
Pearlridge Station Robert Kushner NTP4
Artistʻs fabricator completed production of the (makai entrance artwork) first of two 7’x 20’ glass and stone mosaic murals. Received digital images of work, second mural started. Awaiting the station contractor’s implementation of changes to paving area to integrate artwork for the installation.
Aloha Stadium Station Jay Wilson NTP1 Revising conceptual design.
Pearl Harbor Naval Base Station
Carol Bennett NTP2
Artist is working on glass samples to test colors and techniques that will be utilized to create desired textures and areas of opacity versus transparency. First sample images received.
Honolulu International Airport Station
Mamoru Sato NTP1
Artist submitted revised conceptual designs for the Mauka and Makai artworks. Mayor's Commission on Culture and the Arts review is scheduled for mid-July via an online meeting platform. Design work is pending refinement of mullion system used for artwork installation.
Lagoon Drive Station Carol Yotsuda NTP1 Revising conceptual design.
6.6 Planning and Environment Activities this Month
Environmental Compliance o Environmental Due Diligence: HART continued remediation of the Iwilei Station location. Remediation of
the Lee Property, near Pearl Highlands Transit Center, is continuing. o Environmental Review Documentation: On June 24, HART received a formal concurrence determination
from the FTA on the post-ROD environmental re-evaluation of the addition of an interim park-and-ride facility at the Ho‘opili station and the reconfiguration of the permanent park-and-ride facility at the University of Hawai‘i West O‘ahu station.
Project Mitigation Commitments o Historic Resource Documentation: The pre-draft Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) documentation
for Chinatown and the pre-draft of the Chinatown Historic District National Register (NR) Update are still under review. Final comments of the draft of the Historic Context Studies were received by HART in May and have been reviewed by staff before transmittal to the contractor (HHM). Work was completed on the Historic Preservation Certification Application (HPCA) Part II for the Wo Fat Chop Sui House. Revisions to the draft nominations for Waimalu Stream, Kalauao Springs and Kalauao Stream Bridges were completed and transmitted for public hearing for the July 31, 2020 Hawai‘i Historic Places Review Board (HHPRB) meeting, along with the Oahu Railway & Land Co. (OR&L) Property, Wood Tenements, and True Kamani Tree Row. Draft nominations submitted for the Sept. 18, 2020 HHPRB meeting included: Aloha Tower, Dillingham Transportation Building, HDOT Harbors Division, Kapālama Canal Bridge, Aloha Chapel at Pearl Harbor, and Six Quonset Huts. Comments on the site forms for the Multiple Property Documentation (MPD) were transmitted to Fung Associates.
o Cultural Landscape Reports: Staff completed final review of the comment review matrices for the Cultural Landscape Report (CLR) reports for Mother Waldron Park and Playground, Walker Park, and Irwin Memorial Park. These comment responses will be posted on the HART website in July 2020.
o Historic Preservation Fund: Staff continued planning efforts for the public meetings for round 2 of the Historic Preservation Fund, including potential topics and speakers. This effort is on hold pending the resumption of public meetings.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
106 | P a g e
o Interpretive and Educational Materials: Staff are reviewing comments on the prototype Stipulation VII educational materials and are working to finalize the comment response matrix. Planning has started the next phase of the consultation process for Stipulation VII. Processes are being developed to engage the broader community while complying with social distancing guidelines. On June 16, HART convened a virtual consultation meeting with staff of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs. This meeting was attended by 12 participants. A broader list for community engagement has been developed that will focus on having four meetings in each section of the alignment, with the first tentatively scheduled for July 29.
o Section 106 Programmatic Agreement: The June PA report is included in the Semi-Annual report and is in draft form and being routed for edits.
o Other Mitigation: Planning staff have reviewed the required Noise and Vibration Management Plan for the Airport Guideway and Stations contractor. This is a regular 6 month update as required by the PA.
Sustainable Mobility o Youth Community Change: SuMoLab continued working with Hawai‘i Youth Climate Coalition,
HawaiiKidsCAN and the Sierra Club on developing a platform for youth-driven community change. This month, the youth focused on connecting with advocates for social justice, developing a process for interviewing them, and learning their histories.
o Malama ʻAina Rides Partnerships: SuMoLab continued conversations around a malama ʻaina partnership with Mālama Pu‘uloa by visiting Kapapapuhi Point Park in West Loch over one of the weekends. This city-owned park is on the Pu‘uloa (Pearl Harbor) shoreline and an active site for shoreline restoration and clearing Mangrove. It is also a short distance from the Hō‘ae‘ae rail station and with improved bike connectivity, could be a site for malama ‘aina work that is easily accessible through clean transportation (rail + bike). Kalihi Valley Instructional Bike Exchange (KVIBE) and Mālama Pu‘uloa are looking into a vision where KVIBE youth can someday ride to the rail, and then connect with youth and ʻaina in other communities at places like Kapapapuhi Point Park.
o Community Placemaking: SuMoLab has been developing a partnership with Hawaii Bicycling League and 808 Urban to develop a mural near Lehua Elementary in Pearl City. 808 Urbanʻs process of engaging with youth in the histories of place compliments the projectʻs work to promote sustainable mobility, while connecting people to history and place through transportation.
o Station-Community Integration: SuMoLab has also been participating in the Active Transportation and Food Access Committee (ATFAC) convened by the Department of Health on developing concepts for providing fresh produce at rail stations. The idea was inspired by Marta Market (https://www.itsmarta.com/marta-market.aspx) and is building on a grant concept developed for a Local Food Local Places program.
o ACT2 Livable Communities: Interest areas that emerged in April and May through ACT2’s focus on livable communities, continued into June. One of the most notable is the coalition building around Zero Waste O‘ahu — making connections between construction waste (with participation from Re-use Hawai‘i), eWaste, food waste, plastic waste, and more.
Planning o Oahu Metropolitan Planning Organization (OahuMPO): Staff continued to participate on the OahuMPO
Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) Board. The June 12 TAC meeting discussed the temporary Accelerated Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) Amendment Policy only for projects using stimulus funds or federal redistribution funds. The committee also reviewed congestion pricing examples from London and Stockholm.
Look Ahead
Preparation of Post-ROD and other environmental documentation: o Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS): SHPD continues to review documentation for an amendment of the
Project Area of Potential Effect (APE) to cover ITS work. o East Kapolei Park-and-Ride Lot: Staff continue to coordinate with the University of Hawai‘i regarding the
location and configuration of the 900-stall park-and-ride lot at the Kualaka‘i (East Kapolei) Station. o City Center/Pearl Highlands: Any project final design refinements or new right-of-way takes will be assessed
and submitted to the FTA, as appropriate.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
107 | P a g e
o Kamehameha 138kV Relocation: Overhead 138kV lines are to be relocated between the Waiau Power Plant and Aloha Stadium in order to provide the required working clearances around the guideway. Analysis is pending development of the preliminary design drawings.
o Right-of-Way and APE Updates: Staff will be documenting project design changes and adjustments to right-of-way acquisitions to date.
6.7 Risk Management Following is a progress report highlighting top risks and mitigation efforts from the June 2020 monthly risk update.
6.7.1 Top Risk Summary
Top Cost Risks
Core Systems: Delay to CSC due to AGS station delays
AGS Time Impact Analysis (TIA) for HECO Zone 8 Delay
Core Systems: Additional work until assigned to P3
CCUR: Insufficient performance by utility owners
Environmental for CCGS (risk sharing)
CCUR: Delay in agency permitting
CCUR Field changes resulting from HECO requirements
ROW: Mauka entrance to Kuloloia Station (at Downtown)
CCUR: Misidentified and unidentified utilities
P3 for CCGS: Affordability Cap being exceeded
P3 for CCGS: Revocation of Noise Variance
ROW: Cost and Time Impacts for Numerous Small Property Acquisitions for Straddle Bent Foundations
P3 and CCUR interface impacts
Core Systems, incomplete interface details
ROW: Makai entrance to Kuloloia Station (at Downtown)
P3 for CCGS: CCUR Access Dates if not met
Fare Collection Systems: delay if station electrical systems not ready (applies to interim RSD)
P3 for CCGS: Unanticipated Archaeological Finds
Utilities: HECO Substation at MSF
See additional low risks highlighted in green in the table below
Watch List Risks
Coronavirus Concerns. Risk impacts began to be reported in the March 2020 report including the procurement extension due to COVID-19 impacts on the PLO’s ability to price the work. The Risk Manager has continued to status this risk topic with project teams and HART management in ongoing monthly risk updates considering potential impacts to project schedules; availability of labor, equipment and materials; contingency; project funding.
Opportunities for Cost Savings
P3 competitiveness, innovation for CCGS
CCUR II competitiveness
Top Schedule Risks: Critical or Near Critical Path
CCUR: Delay in agency permitting
AGS TIA for HECO Zone 8 Delay
Core Systems: Delay to CSC due to AGS station delays
CCUR: Insufficient performance by utility owners
P3 for CCGS: Affordability Cap being exceeded (time to resolve)
Utilities: HECO Substation at MSF
CCUR: Misidentified and unidentified utilities
CCUR Field changes resulting from HECO requirements
Core Systems, incomplete interface details
Environmental for CCGS (risk sharing)
Possible Revocation of Noise Variance
P3 and CCUR interface impacts
CCUR Access Dates if not met for P3
ROW – numerous small property acquisitions for straddle bent foundations (currently not critical, but could become critical if delays occur)
P3 for CCGS: Unanticipated Archaeological Finds
Opportunities for Maintaining Schedule
Aggressive CEI oversight of CCUR with fully qualified field staff
Procurement of CCUR II contract
ROW to maintain schedule for new acquisitions based on final CCGS alignment, through appropriate staff and consultant support
Fill vacant staff positions with existing staff and consultant support
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
108 | P a g e
6.7.2 Top Risk Threats and Mitigations
Risk ID Risk Description Risk Threat Score
Risk Mitigation
DBOM920 PRO 80.03_10
Schedule and cost impacts due to AGS guideway and stations delays affecting the Core Systems Contractor (CSC). (New risk as of end of May 2020.)
15 HART Core Systems team is reviewing the merits of this issue expressed by the CSC, including concurrent delay due to time required for CSC’s design affecting the AGS schedule.
DB450 SIT 40.02_11
AGS: HECO Zone 8 Delay. 15 HART is evaluating the TIA for concurrent delays.
DBOM920 SYS 50.01_12
Core Systems: Risk of additional work by Core Systems Contractor following recent settlement, until assigned to P3.
12 1. HART is troubleshooting systems interface issues with West stations work to avoid further cost due to changed conditions. 2. Plan for 2-phase testing at platforms has allowed more time for canopy arm installation, followed by Core Systems devices and testing.
DBB511 SIT 40.02_01
Insufficient construction performance by utility owners.
12 HART is coordinating with utility companies, including HTI and AT&T, to ensure sufficient resources to meet HART’s schedule for utility relocations along the corridor. This risk was updated in May and June 2020.
P3-DB550 SIT 40.03_03 (schedule) and 40.03_02 (cost)
P3 for CCGS and PH: Environmental Cleanup, Cost and Schedule Impacts to HART (2 separate risks, but combined here for scoring). The Risk Management System (RMS) adjusted the cost portion of this risk slightly downward based on the expectation that CCUR work will uncover most, if not all, pockets of contamination. There is a risk sharing arrangement in the P3 RFP for environmental cleanup responsibilities.
12 1. Although HART would be responsible for the cost and schedule impact for cleanup of undisclosed contamination, the P3 would be responsible for the schedule risk associated with the cleanup of disclosed contamination. Some cleanup activities could be non-critical path delays depending upon where they occur in the project. 2. HART will handle the cleanup with on-call contractors familiar with this work and who can execute the work most efficiently.
DBB511 SIT 40.08_01
CCUR: Delay in obtaining City Agency Permitting had been forecast and continues to result in delays to critical utility relocation work.
12 HART continues to coordinate with City permitting agencies to provide any further design information that is needed, and to reduce the timeframes for review and permitting of utility relocation work.
DBB511 SIT 40.02_24
CCUR: Field changes resulting from HECO requirements.
12 HART is continuing to coordinate with HECO to identify all appropriate requirements are fully planned, such as epoxy coated manholes, and increased conduit diameters for cabling.
ROW 60.01_17
ROW: Parcel Scope changes for Mauka Entrance to Kuloloia Station (at Downtown)
12 HART and DTS are evaluating the preferred Mauka station entrance location for the Kuloloia Station (at Downtown). The preferred location is within the courtyard of the existing Pacific Guardian Center (PGC). Initial discussions with the Property Manager have taken place.
DBB511 SIT 40.02_07
CCUR: Scope and schedule of construction could be impacted by the discovery of misidentified and unidentified utilities
10 HART will pay for differences in quantities of utility relocations based on as-bid unit rates.
P3-DB550 PRO 80.01_07
P3 for CCGS and PH: Risk of Affordability Cap being exceeded for the capital construction and/or the future O&M. Note: This risk was part of a risk grouping that has now resulted in a delay to RSD within the risk forecast, since the Procurement Delay risk has been inactivated.
10 1. The Affordability Cap for Capital as well as O&M were provided to the P3 PLO(s) on 26JUL2019 in order to allow HART sufficient time to respond in case concerns are expressed by the PLO(s). 2. HART’s ICE estimate was reviewed and received concurrence from E&Y and from HART’s Project Execution Consultant.
P3-DB550 SIT 40.04_09
P3 for CCGS and PH: Revocation of Noise Variance which allows night and weekend work. This could have a cost and schedule impact to the CCGS project.
9 HART will pursue greater involvement with the community to inform them of construction activities and be more responsive to their concerns. HART can mitigate by compensating the contractor to utilize noise mitigation strategies and by maintaining open communication with DOH who controls the noise variance.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
109 | P a g e
Risk ID Risk Description Risk Threat Score
Risk Mitigation
ROW 60.01_19
ROW: Cost and time impacts for numerous small property acquisitions necessary for foundations to support straddle bents along Dillingham Blvd and elsewhere.
9 HART is awaiting confirmation of required properties for straddle bent foundations and Temporary Construction Easements (TCE’s). Specific property identification is dependent on final designs. Management has begun meetings with affected property owners to advise of the need for straddle bent foundations at specific locations and to attempt to minimize the impacts to the property owners and to seek their cooperation with HART's plan.
P3-DB550 SYS 50.03_01
P3 for CCGS and PH: Interface impacts between CCGS and other contracts including CCUR and Core Systems Contractor.
9 HART is working to make sure CCUR work is completed as expeditiously as possible, and that achievable access dates to the P3 (area by area in the CCGS corridor) have been included in the P3 RFP.
DBOM920 SYS 50.01_01
Core Systems: Incomplete Interface Details (Stations & Guideway).
9 Final interface details continue to be worked out as West Stations progress much closer to final completion. HART and CSC are doing additional pre-final inspections for west stations to ensure compliance.
ROW 60.01_10
ROW: HECO Kuloloia Station (at Downtown) Makai Parcel Scope Changes. Late agreement with HECO for Kuloloia Station (at Downtown) Makai parcel, currently an old power plant, could impact DB contract requirements.
9 Get agreement with HECO and perform early subsurface investigations. Include report in bid documents.
P3-DB550 SIT 40.05_02
P3 for CCGS and PH: Potential for CCUR work to extend beyond Access Dates committed to the P3 for CCGS. If committed access dates are not met, then the P3's start of work in those areas could potentially be delayed, placing HART at risk of having to compensate the P3 for owner-caused delay.
9 The P3 Procurement Documents include a list of Access Dates that HART is committing to meet. This risk pertains to HART's guarantee to the P3 that CCUR work will be completed by certain committed dates area by area through the CCGS project.
MI900 SYS 50.06_11
Fare Collection: Rail Station installation of Fare Systems equipment could be delayed if Stations’ electrical systems are not ready in time for Revenue Service.
9 Coordinate with station contractors to develop and share station as-builts with the Fare System Vendor. Coordinate schedules as well to allow sufficient time for testing and installation at each of the stations.
P3-DB550 GUI 10.04_01
P3 for CCGS and PH: Discovery of unanticipated archaeological findings could result in added cost and schedule impact to HART.
8 The HART Procurement and technical team for the P3 has been working on an appropriate level of risk for the P3 to undertake in dealing appropriately with archaeological finds. HART will be responsible for finds that cause undue cost and schedule delay.
UTIL68 SYS 50.03_01
Private Utilities: HECO Substation needed on land from UH adjacent to MSF, for reliable power for train operations.
8 HECO has stated that the electrical grid system requires a new substation adjacent to the MSF. HECO has approval from PUC to install the substation on the site. Because HART currently has all interim opening trains on-site and in testing at the MSF, there is no anticipated need for the substation to start interim service. HART will continue to work with HECO and monitor loads to install the substation before full revenue service.
DBOM920 SIT 40.05_01
Core Systems: Operating Noise Exceeds Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) Defined Limits.
6 Tangent track noise test compliant with Technical Provision (TP) requirements. Noise testing in curves still required. Evaluation against EIS noise levels outstanding. Mitigation may require installation of track lubricators along the alignment, implementation of a rail engineer grinding program, and/or noise absorption panels.
DBB271 STA 20.01_26
FHSGC: Plan B Canopy Redesign Delay Claim.
6 The risk needs to remain active within the Risk Register until the claim is negotiated and fully resolved. This risk was not part of the FHSG Consolidated Resolution that was approved by the HART Board on May 28, 2020.
DBB371 STA 20.02_05
KHSGC: HART Open Changes. 6 HART is continuing to negotiate with the contractor for a fair settlement of all remaining issues through final closeout of the project.
DBB600 SUP 30.01_01
Park-and-Ride Lots: Contingency for Park-and-Ride Lots construction.
6 HART is holding a contingency value until the final park-and-ride locations are determined, designs are complete, and construction is underway.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
110 | P a g e
Risk ID Risk Description Risk Threat Score
Risk Mitigation
MI900 SYS 50.06_20
Fare Systems Vendor could experience additional costs.
6 Negotiate change orders with the proper contractor and/or award a separate contract as needed for Fare Systems requirements. These requirements pertain to startup and rollout costs that are not included in the scopes of work for the Fare Systems Contractor or Technical Consultant.
UTIL68 SIT 40.02_08
Private Utilities: Construction sequencing for City Center creates additional work for utility companies.
6 HART is working with utility companies to understand the requirement for additional inspectors as the sequence of the CCUR work becomes more apparent through schedule coordination with the contractors involved.
UTIL68 SIT 40.02_09
HECO KHG 138 kV Relocation to provide adequate separation from guideway.
6 HART will coordinate with the design firm (RM Towill) to guide the scope to remain within reasonable limits, while meeting all necessary HECO requirements. A potholing program is underway to determine the locations of existing utilities along the route, and the reasonableness of undergrounding the 138kV along the highway. The project is in the concept design phase.
MI930 STA 20.07_03
Elevators/Escalators: Increase in Elevator and Escalator Quantity Requirements
6 The final number of additional escalators on all east stations have been determined to be two for AGS, and 11 additional for CCGS. Still need to negotiate a favorable resolution with E&E contractor for CCGS. This risk will be revisited after award of the City Center DB contract.
DBB371 STA 20.02_22
KHSGC: Potential Electrical and Structural Canopy Design Issues.
4 HART is continuing to negotiate with the contractor for a fair settlement of all remaining issues through final closeout of the project.
ROW 60.01_18
ROW: Net cost to HART for Land Trade for Rail Operations Center.
4 HART is working with the City on this land exchange. The City needs to approve this exchange once it is worked out by the Dept. of Hawaiian Homelands (DHHL).
DB450 SIT 40.02_04
AGS: Conflict Resolution – Costs for Utility Relocations.
4 HART is coordinating with the contractor and utility agencies to mitigate any utility delay risks that could result in cost or schedule impact to the project.
Risk Scoring for Risk Threats The following risk scoring table (used in the calculation of the risk threat scores shown above) is in accordance with FTA guidelines for summarizing the overall severity of project risks. HART has adjusted the cost and schedule ranges shown below in order to scale to the HART Project size.
Risk Scoring for Risk Threats
Impact Scores Legend
Low 1
Medium 2
High 3
(P) Probability <10% >10% <50% >50%
(C) Cost Impact <$10 M >$10 M <$50 M >$50 M
(S) Schedule Impact <1 month >1 month <4 months >4 months
Rating <6 7 - 12 13 - 18
Score = (Cost + Schedule) * Probability
Risks are assessed based on the probability of occurrence, potential (and most likely) cost impact, and potential (and most likely) schedule delay. The total score is arrived at by adding the cost and schedule impact scores, multiplied by the probability score. For example:
40% Probability = 2; A $60 million Cost Impact = 3; A five month Schedule Impact = 3 Resulting Score = 3 + 3 = 6 x 2 = 12; a Medium Risk.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
111 | P a g e
6.7.3 Top Risk Opportunities
Risk ID Risk Description Risk Opportunity Score
Risk Mitigation
P3-550 SIT 40.05_01
P3 for CCGS: Opportunities for P3 innovation through Alternative Technical Concepts (ATC’s).
15 1. HART plans to evaluate and approve ATC’s that are beneficial to the Project. 2. There were ATC’s that were received for previous HART projects, so there is precedence for this possible savings.
275 PRO 80.01_01
P3-PHPTR: Opportunity for P3 to present a modest cost reduction for construction of the Pearl Highlands Garage and Transit Center.
9 HART has been working to make the RFP as performance-based as possible so that it allows creativity from the P3 team(s).
DB511 SIT 40.08_16
CCUR: Opportunity for CCUR II to reduce base cost.
6 New Opportunity Risk created to capture the likelihood of benefit from the CCUR II Contract over the current CCUR Contract.
P3-DB550 PRO 80.01_02
P3 for CCGS: Opportunity for P3 to present a modest cost reduction for construction of City Center Guideway and Stations, and remaining Core Systems work.
6 HART has been working to make the RFP as performance-based as possible so that it allows creativity from the P3 team(s).
Risk Scoring for Risk Opportunities
Risk Scoring for Risk Opportunities
Impact Scores Legend
Low 1
Medium 2
High 3
(P) Probability <10% >10% <50% >50%
(C) Cost Impact <$10 M >$10 M <$50 M >$50 M
(S) Schedule Impact <1 month >1 month <4 months >4 months
Rating <6 7 - 12 13 - 18
Score = (Cost + Schedule) * Probability
Similar to the legend for scoring of Risk Threats, Risk Opportunities are assessed based on the probability of occurrence, potential (and most likely) cost impact, and potential (and most likely) schedule delay. The total score is arrived at by adding the cost and schedule impact scores, multiplied by the probability score. The scoring calculation for Risk Opportunities is the same as for Risk Threats; however, in the Opportunities scoring table above, high opportunity scores are colored green (versus red), low opportunity scores are colored blue (versus green), and medium opportunity scores are still colored yellow. 6.7.4. Recent Risk Updates
The most recent risk update occurred in June 2020, the results of which are discussed herein. These results have been summarized in the FTA Quarterly meeting including the PMOC on July 8 and July 9, 2020. The P65 results now place the projected forecast at $8.277 billion, which is $112 million above HART’s budget goal of $8.165 billion. The current P65 result at $8.277 billion is $22 million below the overall budget goal of $8.299 billion as recommended by PMOC and FTA from HART’s Revised Recovery Plan. The June 2020 Risk update was facilitated by the Risk Manager. This involved virtual meetings with project team members instead of face to face meetings because of current travel restrictions as a result of COVID-19. At the Risk update meetings, the teams reviewed each risk, discussed their validity and if any adjustments are needed to the post-responses, discussed if any new risks are necessary, and explored ongoing risk mitigation efforts.
The most significant risk adjustments in the June 2020 risk update included: 1. Based on recommendations from the CCUR team, the Risk Manager added $240 million to the base cost
for CCUR, bringing the overall base cost to $640 million from the previous $400 million. This is a conservative approach as forecasted by the Risk Manager. The $240 million adjustment is undergoing internal review by HART and has not yet been officially reflected in Project Controls’ base cost.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
112 | P a g e
2. CCUR team introduced an opportunity risk of ($33.3 million) due to presumed competitiveness from the planned CCUR II procurement.
3. CCUR team reduced risks by $77.5 million due to the risks now being included in the base cost increase. 4. Risk Manager removed extended overhead calculations occurring within the Risk Model on the CCUR
contract due to it being a task order contract. The approximate reduction from this action was $10 million.
5. Core Systems added a new risk of delay alleged by the Core Systems Contractor due to delay of several months of the AGS stations, affecting Core Systems work. Risk Expected Value is $13.8 million.
6. Other base cost adjustments included incorporation of the Consolidated Resolution for FHSG into base cost, and thus retired from the risk forecast for FHSG.
7. The base project completion date, without schedule contingency, was January 2026 in the June 2020 Risk update, which remained the same from the May 2020 Risk update. From that base date of January 2026, the Risk Model forecasts 10.9 months of schedule delay to the P65 date of December 2026.
Pending Risk Adjustments in July 2020:
1. HART overhead costs are being reviewed and may be adjusted in future months to be at the level anticipated to be needed for proper oversight of the P3’s CCGS and PHPTR work, which is the final major HART project leading to full RSD by end of year 2026. A revised HART overhead forecast could affect the cost forecast in the risk model, such as reducing the forecast if a smaller contingent of staff is needed once the west contracts are closed out, and later when the AGS contract is closed out.
Several significant adjustments in the prior May 2020 Risk Refresh included:
1. Inactivated a major ROW Risk for the Kaka‘ako area because its value is now reflected in the base budget for ROW.
2. Inactivated bid uncertainty and escalation calculations related to the Affordability Cap within the Risk Model (not the affordability cap risk itself) for the P3. The risk system normally halts the bid uncertainty and escalation calculations on projects that have bid, since those variables are reflected in the bid price. Since the P3 proposals are within 2 months of being received, and the Affordability Cap must hold, the Risk Manager determined in our monthly risk review with senior HART management that it is appropriate at this time to halt the referenced calculations which was adding a high degree of reserve on top of the base contract values for the P3 being held in the Risk Model. The Risk Manager clarified to HART management that if the Affordability Cap is exceeded by the P3 PLO’s proposals, then HART would consider the options of available contingency to cover the difference, or would consider scope reductions in order to keep the P3’s costs in line with the Affordability Cap.
3. P3 for CCGS and PH: Risk of Affordability Cap being exceeded for the capital construction and/or the future O&M, which represents a potential time delay should there be an affordability cap issue after proposals are received from the PLO’s in July 2020. This risk has not changed, but it now takes precedence because it is part of a risk grouping that has now resulted in a delay to RSD within the risk forecast, since the Procurement Delay risk has been inactivated.
4. The base project completion date, without schedule contingency, shifted to January 2026 in the May 2020 Risk Refresh, compared to June 2025 from the April 2020 risk update. This represents a shift of 7 months in the base completion schedule for CCGS. From that base date of January 2026, the Risk Model had forecast 10.5 months of schedule delay to the P65 date of December 2026.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
113 | P a g e
6.7.5. Cost and Schedule Probability Curves from June 2020 Risk Update Figure 11. Cost Probability Curve, June 2020 Risk Data
The update shown in Figure 11, at $8.277 billion, resulted in a $95.3 million increase to the P65 risk expected value when comparing the June 2020 update (shown above) to the May 2020 update (shown in the prior report). This increase is due to the following adjustments:
Base Cost: +$248.3M (due to updated CCUR base cost estimate increase of $240M, plus $8.3M of misc. CPP adjustments)
Core Systems Risks: +$13.8M (new risk re: alleged AGS delays)
CCGS Risks: +1.7M (misc. adjustments, pending July bids)
UHPRB Risks: +$0.1M
CCUR Risks: ($110.8M) (Opportunity Risk of -$33.3M, and Risk reductions of -$77.5M now in Base)
FHSGC Risks: ($19.7M) (executed Consolidated Resolution change order)
ROW Risks: ($11.9M) (misc. adjustments)
AGS Risks: ($5.3M) (misc. adjustments)
KHSG, WOSG Services During Construction (SDC) ($5.1M) (design SDC)
WOSG Risks: ($0.4M) (closing out)
Risk Model Changes: (approx. $10M) (overheads on CCUR within Risk Model not needed), and another ($5.4M) in miscellaneous Risk Model changes
Total P65 Change, May to June: +$95.3M The P65 for the overall HART project is now $8.277 billion, which is $112 million above HART’s budget goal of $8.165 billion. The current P65 result at $8.277 billion is $22 million below the overall budget goal of $8.299 billion as recommended by PMOC and FTA from HART’s Revised Recovery Plan.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
114 | P a g e
Figure 12. Schedule Probability Curve, June 2020 Risk Data
The schedule update shown in Figure 12 remained unchanged when comparing the June 2020 update (December 2026 shown above) to the May 2020 update. The P65 for the overall HART project is now December 2026, which is 9 months beyond HART’s current stated schedule goal of March 2026 for operational readiness, and 3 months beyond the PMOC recommended target date of September 2026 for meeting final revenue service.
6.7.6. Ongoing Risk Mitigation Efforts The P65 schedule extension to December 2026 from the June 2020, May 2020 and April 2020 risk updates (formerly October 2026 from the March 2020 risk update, August 2026 from the February 2020 risk update, and July 2026 from the January 2020 and December 2019 risk updates) is a significant concern to HART. The project delivery timeframe for CCGS to still accomplish the full RSD by March 2026 (formerly a goal of December 2025) had been a significant HART goal, which is now overshadowed by the expanding threat of the COVID-19 pandemic on not only the HART Project, but on the state of Hawai‘i, as well as nearly all populations and countries around the world. Nevertheless, HART will maintain particular focus on the following risk areas in order to complete the Project as expeditiously as possible given the ongoing project risks:
1. Expedite the ROW acquisition schedule for necessary acquisitions to accommodate utility relocations (CCUR) and necessary space for straddle bent foundations along the CCGS route. Ensure qualified ROW staff are in place and necessary support is received from HART’s Real Estate Consultant. All necessary ROW must be acquired in time for P3 Access Dates to be met.
2. Expedite the City Center Utilities Relocations and Road work (CCUR) in time to meet area by area Access Dates being committed to the P3 PLO’s in the procurement documents. This can be accomplished by securing all third party agreements and permits in advance, and maintaining the right level of qualified CEI staff for design oversight and field construction oversight. Ensure that the CCUR contractor is executing the work as proactively as possible with qualified construction staff, equipment selections, and effective maintenance-of-traffic planning. HART is preparing a procurement for a second CCUR contractor to expedite the work. The base estimate update for CCUR has been reviewed in March, April, May and June 2020, the results of which have now been incorporated into the June 2020 risk update. The CCUR team has incorporated numerous risk reductions due to base cost increase for CCUR as reported herein.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
115 | P a g e
3. Ensure that the approach to dealing with both identified and unidentified environmental contamination, and/or archaeological finds, are agreed with DOH and other oversight agencies in advance, in order to deal with the impacts encountered during construction appropriately and as expeditiously as possible. HART will need to set aside adequate contingency to pay for this cleanup work due to the risk transfers from the P3 to HART, which HART believes can be effectively managed by HART’s on-call environmental cleanup contractors.
4. Ensure all necessary procurement procedures are being followed correctly. Minimize the possibility of a protest over procedural issues related to this important procurement. A time extension to the P3 procurement was recently granted due to the COVID-19 concerns, which was a reasonable response by HART to the PLO(s) request for more time given the difficult current circumstance of pricing the work until the virus threat has passed.
5. Ensure final completion and closeout of the west station projects by late-2020, in order to obtain Interim Revenue Service as soon as is reasonable in the first quarter of 2021 (given the COVID-19 concerns), and to have this west section fully functional and ready for turnover to the P3 at the appropriate date to be clarified in the P3 RFP.
As reflected above, the current schedule risk forecast identifies potential concerns with risks in the categories of agency permitting, interface between contractors, construction performance by utility contractors, procurement and right-of-way. The schedule risk forecast suggests if ongoing mitigation efforts related to these risks fail, or if problems related to the COVID-19 pandemic worsen, the delay consequences could be severe.
6.8 Construction Claims Pursuant to FTA Circular 4220.1F, HART is obligated to notify the FTA and PMOC about third-party claims and litigation with which it is involved. HART considers a “claim” to arise when a third-party contractor submits a request for a final written decision by the Contracting Officer. Pursuant to Hawai‘i Revised Statutes Section 103D-711 and Hawai‘i Administrative Rules Section 3-126-28, the Contracting Officer’s decision is deemed final and the basis on which the aggrieved party can initiate an action in Circuit Court within six (6) months of receipt of the Contracting Officer’s decision.
There are currently no open claims.
6.9 Community Outreach Overview
Since the inception of HART, the outreach team has participated in: o 1,517 Public Presentations and Events
The HART Public Involvement (PI) team participated in a total of 5 events and presentations in June 2020. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many public events and meetings – which HART was supposed to present or participate as part of its public outreach activities – were cancelled or postponed.
A project-wide virtual construction update/community meeting was held on June 30, 2020 from 1:30 p.m. – 2:30 p.m., where members of the public were invited online via YouTube and Facebook to take part in a comprehensive project update from West to East. HART’s construction contractors provided updates on construction and progress – including reports from WOSG/Nan, Inc., FHSG/Hawaiian Dredging Construction Company, KHSG/Nan, Inc., AGS/Shimmick, Traylor & Granite, Core Systems/Hitachi Rail, and CCUR/Nan, Inc. An audience Q/A session was also presented. The meeting recorded a high of 95 attendees online. HART PI is looking to have these meetings presented monthly until normal in-person community meetings can resume in the future.
Community outreach events in June included virtual Project Update presentations with the West Oahu Rotary Club and the Office of Hawaiian Affairs. A HART All-Staff Meeting was also presented with a PI progress presentation to internal audiences.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
116 | P a g e
HART Public Involvement continued with its new “Rail Facts LIVE” monthly online show utilizing Facebook LIVE. This month’s edition focused on a virtual tour of UH West O‘ahu Station, a highlight of its Art-in-Transit program and cultural design elements, and a virtual audience Q/A session.
HART Public Involvement completed four more installments of its “Rail Construction Traffic Update in Sixty Seconds” weekly video updates for its website, social media and eBlast platforms.
o 895 Neighborhood Board Meetings Most of the neighborhood boards started to resume regular meetings in virtual/online formats, due
to the COVID-19 pandemic. In person meetings are still TBD. Community Input HART's public outreach team responded to 59 public inquiries and comments via the 24-hour project hotline (28
inquiries) and project email (info@HonoluluTransit.org with 31 inquiries), during the month of June 2020. Inquiries were generally related to general construction issues in the field and CCUR activities.
6.10 Staffing Overview
Organization: The latest organizational chart is dated Jan. 29, 2020. Please see Appendix D. Project Staffing:
o Target (Allocated) City Positions: 135 Full-Time Equivalent (FTE) City Staff. Does not include Project Management Support consultants below.
o Filled City Positions: 116 Employees: (103) Personal Services Contract [PSC] Employees, (1) Civil Service, (5) Appointees, (4) 89-day contract, (3) Interns
Vacancy Rate 2020
January February March April May June
11.8% 13.3% 13.3% 11.8% 10.3% 11.03%
July August September October November December
- - - - - -
o Project Management Support Consultant (HDR) Staff Total: 18 HDR employees embedded in the HART
organization directly participating in the management of the project, 2 HDR employees working for the State Historic Preservation Division (SHPD) providing support services, and 1 HDR employee assisting HART on a part-time basis with risk modeling (statistical analysis and risk report production).
Positions Filled in June:
o Electrical Engineer I (Core Systems) o Electrical Engineer I (Readiness & Activation)
Projected Position Fills: o Systems Analyst (Readiness & Activation)- July o Contract Management Assistant (Lead) - July o Right of Way Acquisition & Relocation Manager- August o Planner III (Hazmat Planner) – July o Planner IV (Transportation Planner) – July o Construction Claims Manager – August o Fixed Asset Specialist –July o Records Management Analyst II – July o Procurement & Specifications Specialist – August o Business Systems Analyst – July
June Departures: o Administrative Specialist I (Readiness & Activation) o Information Specialist II o Contract Management Assistant o Records Management Analyst II
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
117 | P a g e
Projected Departures: o N/A
Figure 13. Staffing Activities
Staffing Activities
Title Group
New/Existing HART
Position (City or PMC)
Position Status* Start Month
P3 , Core Systems, and Readiness and Activation
Electrical Engineer I Core Systems Existing (City) Filled - PSC June
Electrical Engineer I Readiness and Activation New (City) Filled - PSC June
Systems Analyst Readiness and Activation New (City) Selected – PSC July
Design & Construction
Program Manager Production East Area Construction Existing (City) Recruiting - PSC
Assistant Area Manager East Area Construction Existing (City) Recruiting - PSC
Transportation Planner Third Party and Traffic Engineering
New (City) Recruiting - PSC
Transit Property Acquisition & Relocation
Right of Way Acquisition & Relocation Manager
Transit Property Acquisition & Relocation
Existing (City) Selected - PSC August
Planning
Planner (Land Use) Planning Existing (City) Recruiting – PSC
Planner III (Hazmat Planner) Planning Existing (City) Selected - PSC July
Planner IV (Transportation Planner) Planning Existing (City) Selected - PSC July
Budget & Finance
Financial Services Manager Budget & Finance Existing (City) Recruiting - PSC
Financial Analyst/Management Analyst
Budget & Finance Existing (City) Recruiting - PSC
Financial/Management Analyst (Financing)
Budget & Finance Existing (City) Recruiting - PSC
OCIP/Risk Compliance Budget & Finance Existing (City) Recruiting - PSC
Project Controls
Financial Analyst Project Controls Existing (City) Recruiting – PSC
Scheduler I –III Project Controls Existing (City) Recruiting – PSC
Business Systems Analyst Project Controls Existing (City) Selected – PSC July
Records Management Analyst II Project Controls Existing (City) Selected – PSC July
Procurement, Contracts & Construction Claims
Director Procurement, Contracts, and Construction Claims
Procurement, Contracts and Construction Claims
Existing (City) Recruiting – PSC
Procurement & Specifications Specialist
Procurement & Consultant Contracts
Existing (City) Selected - PSC August
Procurement & Specifications Specialist
Procurement & Consultant Contracts
Existing (City) Recruiting - PSC
Construction Claims Manager Construction Claims Existing (City) Selected - PSC August
Lead Contract Management Assistant
Contract Administration Existing (City) Selected – PSC July
Administrative Services
Human Resources Specialist V Administrative Services Existing (City) Recruiting - PSC
Asset Management
Fixed Asset Specialist Executive Management New (City) Selected – PSC July
*Personal Services Contracts are limited to one year per the Revised Charter of the City and County of Honolulu, Sec. 6-1103(g).
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
118 | P a g e
6.11 HART Baseline Plans and Procedures Status List The status of the Baseline Plans and Procedures is shown below (NOTE: changes, if any, are in bold font):
Owner Plan/Procedure Revision Level Date Approved Status
Project Management (Sam Carnaggio)
Project Management Plan (PMP)
8.G April 21, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Safety and Security (Ralph McKinney)
Construction Safety and Security Plan (CSSP)
5.0 March 5, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Safety and Security Certification Plan (SSCP)
8.0 March 6, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Safety and Security Management Plan (SSMP)
9.0 March 6, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Sensitive Safety Information Plan
1.0 December 13, 2017 Approved/Baselined
Preliminary Hazard Analysis (PHA)
4.0 July 3, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Threat and Vulnerability Assessment (TVA)
2.0 January 12, 2018 Approved/Baselined
Incident Investigation Procedure
0.0 February 28, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Quality Assurance (Alberto Bonifacio)
1.PP-02, Project Procedure and Plan Revision and Control Procedure
4.0 February 22, 2019 Approved/Baselined
1.PP-03, Standard Terms, Definitions, and Acronyms Procedure
4.0 April 21, 2020 Approved/Baselined
3.PM-05, Meeting Minutes Procedure
4.0 January 28, 2019 Approved/Baselined
6.CM-01, Submittal Processing Procedure
4.0 January 28, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Quality Management Plan (QMP)
5.0 May 19, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Procurement, Contracts, and Construction
2.PA-09, Procurement Standards of Conduct Procedure
2.0 March 6, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Claims (David Ha)
2.PA-10, Procurement Methods Procedure
1.0 February 13, 2019 Approved/Baselined
2.PA-11, Procurement Full and Open Competition Procedure
1.0 February 13, 2019 Approved/Baselined
2.PA-12, Procurement Federal Compliance Procedure
1.0 March 5, 2019 Approved/Baselined
2.PA-13, Procurement Protests Procedure
2.0 February 13, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
119 | P a g e
Owner Plan/Procedure Revision Level Date Approved Status
2.PA-14, Procurement Record-keeping Procedure
1.0 April 2, 2019 Approved/Baselined
2.PA-15, Stipend Payment Procedure
1.0 February 11, 2019 Approved/Baselined
2.PA-16 Executive Decision Document (EDD) Procedure
0.0 January 24, 2019 Approved/Baselined
5.CA-06, Project Closeout Procedure
3.0 April 23, 2019 Approved/Baselined
5.CA-11, Contract Changes Procedure
6.0 May 26, 2020 Approved/Baselined
5.CA-12 Professional Services and Utility Engineering Services Agreement Contract Closeout Procedure
0.0 November 4, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Buy America Plan (BAP) 4.0 May 7, 2020 Approved/Baselined
HART Procurement Manual
1.0 April 25, 2019 Approved/Baselined
(David Uchiyama) 5.CA-13 Consultant Performance Milestone Evaluation Procedure
0.0 February 24, 2020 Approved/Baselined
5.CA-14 Consultant Performance Evaluation Procedure
0.0 February 24, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Project Controls (Nate Meddings)
2.PA-04, Project-wide Document Control and Project Library Procedure
4.0 November 25, 2019 Approved/Baselined
3.PM-01, Contract Management System Procedure
3.0 March 13, 2019 Approved/Baselined
4.PC-03, Project Progress Report Procedure
3.0 March 19, 2019 Approved/Baselined
4.PC-04, Project Scheduling Procedure
4.0 August 15, 2018 Approved/Baselined
4.PC-06, Cost Estimating Procedure
3.0 December 13, 2017 Approved/Baselined
4.PC-07, Cost Control Procedure
3.0 March 25, 2019 Approved/Baselined
4.PC-09, Contingency Management Procedure
2.0 March 5, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Contract Packaging Plan (CPP)
7.0 May 27, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Budget and Finance (Ruth Lohr)
5.CA-03, Contractor Payment Application Procedure
3.0 March 22, 2019 Approved/Baselined
5.CA-10, Consultant Invoice Payment Procedure
2.0 May 2, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
120 | P a g e
Owner Plan/Procedure Revision Level Date Approved Status
7.GA-04, Petty Cash Procedure
3.0 January 9, 2019 Approved/Baselined
7.GA-06, Travel Procedure
3.0 March 29, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Project Financial Plan (PFP): Revised Recovery Plan
1.0 November 19, 2018 Approved/Baselined
Planning and Permitting (Ryan Tam)
6.CM-08, Environmental Procedure
1.0 April 1, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Before-and-After Study Plan
1.0 March 25, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Bus Fleet Management Plan (BFMP)
5.0 April 15, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Mitigation Monitoring Plan (MMP)
4.0 June 29, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Right-of-Way (Dylan Jones)
Real Estate Acquisition Management Plan (RAMP)
7.0 January 23, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Public Information (Joyce Oliveira)
2.PA-06, Community Relations and Media Contacts Procedure
3.0 March 6, 2019 Approved/Baselined
3.PM-04, Public Involvement Communications Procedure
3.0 March 6, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Public Involvement Plan (PIP)
2.0 March 4, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Design and Construction (Frank Kosich)
6.CM-02, Request for Information (RFI) Processing Procedure
3.0 March 15, 2019 Approved/Baselined
CADD Procedures 2.0 March 19, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Configuration Management Plan (CFMP)
4.0 March 27, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Construction Management Plan (CMP)
5.0 June 16, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Operation and Maintenance (Robert Good/DTS)
Interface Management Plan (IMP)
5.0 May 5, 2020 Approved/Baselined
System Integration and Test Plan (SITP)
3.0 May 26, 2020 Approved/Baselined
Rail Fleet Management Plan (RFMP)
2.0 March 28, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Operation and Management Plan (OMP)
2.0 March 28, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Rail Activation Plan 3.0 May 18, 2020 Approved/Baselined
2. PA-17 DTS – HART Communication Procedure
0.0 July 15, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
121 | P a g e
Owner Plan/Procedure Revision Level Date Approved Status
Administrative Services (Dexter Suzuki)
1.PP-05, Identification Badge Procedure
3.0 January 24, 2019 Approved/Baselined
2.PA-03, Email Management Procedure
3.0 January 31, 2019 Approved/Baselined
2.PA-07, Training Procedure
3.0 January 31, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Staffing and Succession Plan
6.0 March 20, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Risk Management (Paul Johnson)
4.PC-08, Risk Management Procedure
3.0 March 8, 2019 Approved/Baselined
Risk and Contingency Management Plan (RCMP)
4.0 June 9, 2020 Approved/Baselined
6.12 Readiness and Activation
Overview of Key Responsibilities Oversight of the Core System Contractor’s Operations and Maintenance (O&M) development and mobilization. Review and support of HART project activities with an emphasis on O&M impact assessment. Collaborating with DTS to ensure readiness for O&M responsibilities.
Ongoing Activities
Supporting P3 procurement process. Key HRH Mobilization Activities
o Document Development Health, Safety, Quality and Environment (HSQE) documents have been formally submitted and
are under review with stakeholders. Completed internal Rule Book presentation – focus on integrated management system solution
using tablets. HRH is finalizing the Rule Book in combination with the Infrastructure Access Procedure and Railway Worker Protection Manual for formal submission.
HRH continues to develop the Trial Run Program Plan including: trial run resource loaded schedule, test cases, system demonstration, emergency drill, and transition from Test & Commissioning (T&C) to O&M. Held a Trial Run presentation for internal stakeholder comment and feedback.
o O&M Training started April 6. 8,200 hours of training for O&M staff through the end of June. Readiness and Activation (R&A) team is auditing select HRH training classes and course material. HRH continues to administer training via Instructor Led Course (in accordance with social
distancing measures) and online. o HRH continues to actively recruit key positions and experienced rail transit personnel.
HRH Head of O&M – Americas continues to support the mobilization effort. 120 of 178 O&M employees have accepted offers. Mass recruitment efforts continue, while the hiring ramp-up schedule is under review.
o Maintenance Activities Asset Management and Maintenance Management Plans officially submitted for review. Maintenance document suite drafted and under review.
All Maintenance Service Plans (MSP’s) have been formally submitted Continued oversight and auditing of the HRH maintenance program, KPIs, spares/consumables
and special tools.
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
122 | P a g e
o Ongoing COVID-19 program impact assessment. DTS and project stakeholder coordination
o Facilitate Interim Opening Task Force Meeting with DTS, BFS and City Stakeholders. o Supporting document reviews per HART Charter Amendment 4 MOU procedure.
DTS Management Capacity and Capability Plan and Operations and Maintenance plan review and comment.
o Facilitating negotiations for Amendment 1 and 2 to the HDOT West O‘ahu Farrington Highway Master Agreement, and Joint Use and Occupancy Agreement.
o Jointly developing Grand Opening and Public Awareness and Safety Outreach plans with DTS. o HDOT comments on the Transit Agency Rail Safety Plan were received and incorporated. System Security
Plan submitted to HDOT. HRH continues to revise and re-submit supporting documentation. o Supporting fixed facility contractor O&M training development and documentation. o Supporting City Stakeholder participation in station walkthroughs for handover from fixed facility
contractors to the Core Systems Contractor. Supporting HART Safety revisions of Operational Readiness Conformance Checklist (ORCC) and Trial Run
Conformance Checklist to correspond with the HRH Mobilization Program. Onboarded R&A system analyst and mechanical engineer. Fare Systems (see Fare Systems section of report).
Look Ahead
Continued development of a COVID-19 Mitigation Plan for HRH Hiring and Training.
Oversight Procedure (OP) 54 part 2 and part 3 with HDOT/Project Management Oversight (PMO).
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
123 | P a g e
APPENDICES
Ho
no
lulu
Rai
l Tra
nsi
t P
roje
ct M
on
thly
Pro
gre
ss R
ep
ort
Ju
ne
20
20
12
4 |
Pa
ge
A
pp
en
dix
A.
Pro
ject
Co
sts
by
SCC
– L
eve
l 2 (d
ata
as o
f Ju
ne
30
, 20
20
)
Co
st r
epo
rts
are
run
fro
m t
he
HA
RT
Co
ntr
act
Man
agem
ent
Syst
em
(C
MS)
SCC
De
scri
pti
on
Bas
e C
ost
Co
nti
nge
ncy
Tota
lB
ase
Co
stC
on
tin
gen
cyTo
tal
Incu
rre
d
10
GU
IDEW
AY
& T
RA
CK
ELE
MEN
TS1
,38
5,6
13
,35
0
22
2,8
68
,32
5
1
,60
8,4
81
,67
5
1,4
73
,02
1,4
40
1
35
,46
0,2
36
1,6
08
,48
1,6
76
9
40
,64
5,5
43
10
.02
Gu
idew
ay:
At-
gra
de
sem
i-ex
clu
sive
17
,37
8
-
1
7,3
78
17
,37
8
-
1
7,3
78
17
,37
8
1
0.0
4G
uid
ewa
y: A
eria
l st
ruct
ure
1,2
43
,17
0,3
39
2
14
,66
8,3
25
1,4
57
,83
8,6
64
1
,33
0,5
78
,42
9
12
7,2
60
,23
6
1
,45
7,8
38
,66
5
85
2,4
27
,72
0
1
0.0
5G
uid
ewa
y: B
uil
t-u
p f
ill
-
-
-
-
-
-
5,0
54
,74
4
1
0.0
6G
uid
ewa
y: U
nd
ergr
ou
nd
Cu
t &
Cvr
-
-
-
-
-
-
(1,2
28
,00
0)
1
0.0
8G
uid
ewa
y: R
eta
ined
cu
t o
r fi
ll1
42
,42
5,6
33
8,2
00
,00
0
1
50
,62
5,6
33
14
2,4
25
,63
3
8
,20
0,0
00
15
0,6
25
,63
3
-
1
0.0
9Tr
ack
: Dir
ect
fixa
tio
n-
-
-
-
-
-
8
0,4
48
,45
2
10
.11
Tra
ck: B
all
ast
ed-
-
-
-
-
-
2
,39
4,3
73
10
.12
Tra
ck: S
pec
ial
(sw
itch
es, t
urn
ou
ts)
-
-
-
-
-
-
1,5
30
,87
6
2
0ST
ATI
ON
S, S
TOP
S, T
ERM
INA
LS, I
NTE
RM
OD
A7
40
,27
8,8
79
91
,42
3,1
95
8
31
,70
2,0
74
81
2,1
91
,12
9
2
0,4
19
,81
8
83
2,6
10
,94
7
2
72
,68
9,1
24
20
.01
At-
gra
de
sta
tio
n, s
top
, sh
elte
r, m
all
, ter
min
al,
pla
tfo
rm4
,95
6,1
81
8,5
05
,32
5
1
3,4
61
,50
6
4,9
56
,18
1
8
,50
5,3
25
13
,46
1,5
06
1
1,4
20
,22
7
20
.02
Aer
ial
sta
tio
n, s
top
, sh
elte
r, m
all
, ter
min
al,
pla
tfo
rm5
48
,21
9,0
08
54
,49
6,4
53
6
02
,71
5,4
61
62
7,9
11
,85
7
(2
4,2
87
,52
3)
60
3,6
24
,33
4
2
43
,75
6,3
68
20
.04
Oth
er s
tati
on
s, l
an
din
gs, t
erm
ina
l-
-
-
-
-
-
-
2
0.0
6A
uto
mo
bil
e p
ark
ing
mu
lti-
sto
ry s
tru
ctu
re1
21
,60
9,4
73
26
,63
2,4
75
1
48
,24
1,9
48
12
1,6
09
,47
3
2
6,6
32
,47
5
14
8,2
41
,94
8
-
2
0.0
7El
eva
tors
, esc
ala
tors
65
,49
4,2
17
1
,78
8,9
42
67
,28
3,1
59
5
7,7
13
,61
8
9,5
69
,54
1
6
7,2
83
,15
9
17
,51
2,5
30
3
0SU
PP
OR
T FA
CIL
ITIE
S: Y
AR
DS,
SH
OP
S, A
DM
IN. B
LDG
S1
00
,80
6,8
54
-
10
0,8
06
,85
4
9
9,8
06
,85
4
1,0
00
,00
0
1
00
,80
6,8
54
12
2,2
67
,69
2
3
0.0
1A
dm
inis
tra
tio
n B
uil
din
g: O
ffic
e, S
ale
s-
-
-
-
-
-
2
31
,25
0
30
.02
Ligh
t M
ain
ten
an
ce F
aci
lity
3
,05
7,2
40
-
3,0
57
,24
0
3
,05
7,2
40
-
3,0
57
,24
0
7
,58
2,7
04
30
.03
Hea
vy M
ain
ten
an
ce F
aci
lity
64
,47
9,5
56
-
6
4,4
79
,55
6
63
,47
9,5
56
1
,00
0,0
00
64
,47
9,5
56
4
6,2
95
,36
6
30
.04
Sto
rage
or
Ma
inte
na
nce
of
Wa
y B
uil
din
g8
,61
9,2
30
-
8,6
19
,23
0
8
,61
9,2
30
-
8,6
19
,23
0
8
,89
2,7
39
30
.05
Yard
an
d Y
ard
Tra
ck2
4,6
50
,82
8
-
24
,65
0,8
28
2
4,6
50
,82
8
-
24
,65
0,8
28
5
9,2
65
,63
3
40
SITE
WO
RK
& S
PEC
IAL
CO
ND
ITIO
NS
2,3
15
,29
4,4
90
2
30
,44
2,9
32
2,5
45
,73
7,4
22
2
,43
7,0
64
,35
1
10
2,7
51
,42
9
2
,53
9,8
15
,78
0
1,0
79
,64
1,8
55
4
0.0
1D
emo
liti
on
, Cle
ari
ng,
Ea
rth
wo
rk3
3,4
46
,02
9
1,0
38
,00
0
3
4,4
84
,02
9
33
,44
6,0
29
1
,03
8,0
00
34
,48
4,0
29
5
,00
0,1
12
40
.02
Site
Uti
liti
es, U
tili
ty R
elo
cati
on
78
4,9
93
,47
4
9
7,1
26
,87
4
88
2,1
20
,34
8
1
,01
4,4
34
,88
4
(13
9,3
21
,17
8)
87
5,1
13
,70
6
2
31
,13
1,3
79
40
.03
Ha
z. M
at’
l, c
on
tam
’d s
oil
rem
ova
l/m
itig
ati
on
, gro
un
d w
ate
r tr
eatm
ents
33
,82
9,6
83
5
15
,00
0
34
,34
4,6
83
3
3,8
29
,68
3
51
5,0
00
3
4,3
44
,68
3
21
,82
3,8
78
4
0.0
4En
viro
nm
enta
l m
itig
ati
on
, e.g
. wet
lan
ds,
his
tori
c/a
rch
eolo
gic,
pa
rks
5,5
18
,86
4
-
5
,51
8,8
64
6,8
87
,36
4
(1
,36
8,5
00
)
5,5
18
,86
4
1
5,5
24
,74
3
40
.05
Site
str
uct
ure
s in
clu
din
g re
tain
ing
wa
lls,
so
un
d w
all
s2
1,7
64
,98
5
6,8
84
,51
1
2
8,6
49
,49
6
21
,76
4,9
85
6
,88
4,5
11
28
,64
9,4
96
1
3,1
25
,04
2
40
.06
Ped
estr
ian
/ b
ike
acc
ess
an
d a
cco
mm
od
ati
on
, la
nd
sca
pin
g1
4,7
44
,27
6
50
0,0
00
1
5,2
44
,27
6
14
,74
4,2
76
5
00
,00
0
15
,24
4,2
76
2
,48
2,1
94
40
.07
Au
tom
ob
ile,
bu
s, v
an
acc
essw
ays
in
clu
din
g ro
ad
s, p
ark
ing
lots
26
4,5
80
,52
4
2
9,2
37
,56
8
29
3,8
18
,09
2
2
81
,24
2,8
24
12
,57
5,2
68
2
93
,81
8,0
92
98
,42
4,6
57
4
0.0
8Te
mp
ora
ry F
aci
liti
es a
nd
oth
er i
nd
irec
t co
sts
du
rin
g co
nst
ruct
ion
1,1
56
,41
6,6
55
9
5,1
40
,97
9
1,2
51
,55
7,6
34
1
,03
0,7
14
,30
6
22
1,9
28
,32
8
1
,25
2,6
42
,63
4
69
2,1
29
,84
9
5
0SY
STEM
S3
13
,98
3,9
39
16
,03
3,6
68
3
30
,01
7,6
07
32
8,3
22
,83
3
6
,14
7,5
42
33
4,4
70
,37
5
1
66
,44
3,5
76
50
.01
Tra
in c
on
tro
l a
nd
sig
na
ls1
57
,07
7,7
32
7,7
56
,52
2
1
64
,83
4,2
54
17
0,5
38
,35
1
(1
,25
1,3
29
)
16
9,2
87
,02
2
7
2,4
59
,34
7
50
.02
Tra
ffic
sig
na
ls a
nd
cro
ssin
g p
rote
ctio
n3
,17
2,1
31
59
8,7
25
3
,77
0,8
56
3,1
72
,13
1
5
98
,72
5
3,7
70
,85
6
9
8,0
00
50
.03
Tra
ctio
n p
ow
er s
up
ply
: su
bst
ati
on
s 3
2,3
96
,80
8
-
32
,39
6,8
08
3
2,3
96
,80
8
-
32
,39
6,8
08
5
,24
0,1
30
50
.04
Tra
ctio
n p
ow
er d
istr
ibu
tio
n: c
ate
na
ry a
nd
th
ird
ra
il3
7,1
20
,97
7
-
37
,12
0,9
77
3
7,1
20
,97
7
-
37
,12
0,9
77
4
2,9
52
,90
8
50
.05
Co
mm
un
ica
tio
ns
65
,39
0,7
42
-
6
5,3
90
,74
2
65
,39
0,7
42
-
6
5,3
90
,74
2
35
,33
7,0
27
5
0.0
6Fa
re c
oll
ecti
on
sys
tem
an
d e
qu
ipm
ent
15
,01
5,2
06
7
,67
8,4
21
22
,69
3,6
27
1
5,8
93
,48
1
6,8
00
,14
6
2
2,6
93
,62
7
6,9
81
,96
7
5
0.0
7C
entr
al
Co
ntr
ol
3,8
10
,34
3
-
3
,81
0,3
43
3,8
10
,34
3
-
3
,81
0,3
43
3,3
74
,19
7
C
on
stru
ctio
n S
ub
tota
l (1
0 –
50
)4
,85
5,9
77
,51
2
56
0,7
68
,12
0
5
,41
6,7
45
,63
2
5,1
50
,40
6,6
07
2
65
,77
9,0
25
5,4
16
,18
5,6
32
2
,58
1,6
87
,79
1
Re
cove
ry P
lan
Bu
dge
tEs
tim
ate
At
Co
mp
leti
on
Ho
no
lulu
Rai
l Tra
nsi
t P
roje
ct M
on
thly
Pro
gre
ss R
ep
ort
Ju
ne
20
20
12
5 |
Pa
ge
SCC
De
scri
pti
on
Bas
e C
ost
Co
nti
nge
ncy
Tota
lB
ase
Co
stC
on
tin
gen
cyTo
tal
Incu
rre
d
60
RO
W, L
AN
D, E
XIS
TIN
G IM
PR
OV
EMEN
TS2
54
,83
5,5
74
10
6,7
89
,89
0
3
61
,62
5,4
64
38
5,0
41
,20
7
(2
3,4
15
,74
3)
36
1,6
25
,46
4
2
21
,92
2,7
07
60
.01
Pu
rch
ase
or
lea
se o
f re
al
esta
te
17
1,4
00
,00
0
1
01
,50
0,0
00
27
2,9
00
,00
0
3
01
,60
5,6
33
(28
,70
5,6
33
)
2
72
,90
0,0
00
22
1,6
44
,90
7
6
0.0
2R
elo
cati
on
of
exis
tin
g h
ou
seh
old
s a
nd
bu
sin
esse
s8
3,4
35
,57
4
5,2
89
,89
0
8
8,7
25
,46
4
83
,43
5,5
74
5
,28
9,8
90
88
,72
5,4
64
2
77
,80
0
70
VEH
ICLE
S2
11
,38
9,9
52
-
21
1,3
89
,95
2
2
11
,38
9,9
52
-
21
1,3
89
,95
2
1
37
,98
5,2
62
70
.01
Ligh
t R
ail
19
0,3
83
,69
4
-
1
90
,38
3,6
94
19
0,3
83
,69
4
-
1
90
,38
3,6
94
12
5,3
18
,57
0
7
0.0
2H
eavy
Ra
il-
-
-
-
-
-
-
7
0.0
5O
ther
12
8,7
00
-
1
28
,70
0
12
8,7
00
-
1
28
,70
0
49
3,7
00
7
0.0
6N
on
-rev
enu
e ve
hic
les
14
,37
1,3
44
-
1
4,3
71
,34
4
14
,37
1,3
44
-
1
4,3
71
,34
4
12
,17
2,9
92
7
0.0
7Sp
are
pa
rts
6,5
06
,21
4
-
6
,50
6,2
14
6,5
06
,21
4
-
6
,50
6,2
14
-
80
PR
OFE
SSIO
NA
L SE
RV
ICES
1,9
89
,87
0,7
25
9
7,6
30
,13
9
2,0
87
,50
0,8
64
2
,01
4,2
95
,72
5
73
,76
5,1
39
2
,08
8,0
60
,86
4
1,3
64
,56
9,1
99
8
0.0
1P
reli
min
ary
En
gin
eeri
ng
54
,75
3,8
40
-
5
4,7
53
,84
0
54
,75
3,8
40
-
5
4,7
53
,84
0
18
0,7
05
,91
6
8
0.0
2Fi
na
l D
esig
n5
84
,14
9,8
99
31
,51
2,6
97
6
15
,66
2,5
96
59
4,6
74
,89
9
2
0,9
87
,69
7
61
5,6
62
,59
6
3
69
,92
8,3
72
80
.03
Pro
ject
Ma
na
gem
ent
for
Des
ign
an
d C
on
stru
ctio
n6
68
,55
7,9
25
29
,85
1,8
33
6
98
,40
9,7
58
66
8,5
57
,92
5
2
9,8
51
,83
3
69
8,4
09
,75
8
5
01
,51
1,9
96
80
.04
Co
nst
ruct
ion
Ad
min
istr
ati
on
& M
an
age
men
t 2
78
,64
0,4
20
28
,22
0,0
08
3
06
,86
0,4
28
29
2,5
40
,42
0
1
4,3
20
,00
8
30
6,8
60
,42
8
2
25
,98
5,3
06
80
.05
Pro
fess
ion
al
Lia
bil
ity
an
d o
ther
No
n-C
on
stru
ctio
n I
nsu
ran
ce
99
,34
0,0
00
4
,00
0,0
00
10
3,3
40
,00
0
9
9,3
40
,00
0
4,0
00
,00
0
1
03
,34
0,0
00
45
,98
6,8
35
8
0.0
6Le
gal;
Per
mit
s; R
evie
w F
ees
by
oth
er a
gen
cies
, cit
ies,
etc
.9
9,9
28
,69
8
3,7
68
,43
9
1
03
,69
7,1
37
99
,92
8,6
98
3
,76
8,4
39
10
3,6
97
,13
7
3
4,1
70
,25
1
80
.07
Surv
eys,
Tes
tin
g, I
nve
stig
ati
on
, In
spec
tio
n1
41
,68
6,6
22
27
7,1
62
1
41
,96
3,7
84
14
1,6
86
,62
2
2
77
,16
2
14
1,9
63
,78
4
4
,16
4,1
19
80
.08
Sta
rt u
p6
2,8
13
,32
1
-
62
,81
3,3
21
6
2,8
13
,32
1
56
0,0
00
6
3,3
73
,32
1
2,1
16
,40
4
9
0Su
bto
tal (
10
– 8
0)
7,3
12
,07
3,7
63
7
65
,18
8,1
49
8,0
77
,26
1,9
12
7
,76
1,1
33
,49
1
31
6,1
28
,42
1
8
,07
7,2
61
,91
2
4,3
06
,16
4,9
59
U
NA
LLO
CA
TED
CO
NTI
NG
ENC
Y-
2
21
,73
8,0
87
22
1,7
38
,08
7
-
8
7,7
92
,27
9
87
,79
2,2
79
1
00
Sub
tota
l (1
0 –
90
)7
,31
2,0
73
,76
3
98
6,9
26
,23
6
8
,29
8,9
99
,99
9
7,7
61
,13
3,4
91
4
03
,92
0,7
00
8,1
65
,05
4,1
91
4
,30
6,1
64
,95
9
FIN
AN
CE
CH
AR
GES
60
9,0
00
,00
0
-
6
09
,00
0,0
00
54
7,0
00
,00
0
-
5
47
,00
0,0
00
44
,18
9,3
60
To
tal P
roje
ct C
ost
(1
0 –
10
0)
7,9
21
,07
3,7
63
9
86
,92
6,2
36
8,9
07
,99
9,9
99
8
,30
8,1
33
,49
1
40
3,9
20
,70
0
8
,71
2,0
54
,19
1
4,3
50
,35
4,3
19
Tota
l FFG
A P
roje
ct C
ost
(1
0 –
10
0)
7,9
21
,07
3,7
63
9
86
,92
6,2
36
8,9
07
,99
9,9
99
8
,30
8,1
33
,49
1
40
3,9
20
,70
0
8
,71
2,0
54
,19
1
4,3
50
,35
4,3
19
Esti
mat
e A
t C
om
ple
tio
nR
eco
very
Pla
n B
ud
get
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
126 | P a g e
Appendix B. Core Accountability Items Including Major Issues
Core Accountability Items Including Major Issues – June 2020 Note that HART’s Recovery Plan, with revised budget and RSD, was approved by the FTA on Sept. 5, 2019; however, HART intends to continue to manage the project to its current EAC of September 2026.
Project Status: ($ are in millions) Original Budget
at FFGA HART
Current EAC Recovery Plan
Cost Base Cost w/o Contingency
$4,305 $7,761 $7,312
Contingency
Allocated $542 $316 $765
Unallocated Contingency $102 $88 $222
FFGA Finance Charges
$173 $547 $609
Post RSD Finance Charges
$42 $293 $231
Total Project Costs
$5,164 $9,005 $9,139
Schedule Revenue Service Date (RSD) January 31, 2020 September 2026 September 2026
Project Status: ($ are in millions) Amount ($) Percent
(as % of total)
Planned Value to Date $3,121 63.0%
Earned Value to Date $2,912 58.8%
Actual cost* $4,350 56.1%
Contracts
Total Contracts Awarded to Date $5,393 69.5%
Total Construction Contracts Awarded** (Construction Contracts Only)
$2,948 67.8%
Physical Construction Work Completed*** (Amount of Construction Actually Completed)
$2,214 50.9%
Date of Next Quarterly Meeting TBD
*Percentage calculated by taking Actual Cost divided by Base Cost w/o Contingency **Percentage calculated by taking Construction Contracts Only divided by Actual Cost ***Percentage calculated by taking Physical Construction Work divided by Actual Cost
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
127 | P a g e
Appendix C. Construction Progress Interim Opening
Honolulu Rail Transit Project Monthly Progress Report June 2020
128 | P a g e
Appendix D. Project Organization Chart
top related