international principles of refugee protection and the roles of unhcr in indonesia

1

International Principles of International Principles of Refugee Protection Refugee Protection

andand

The Roles of UNHCR in IndonesiaThe Roles of UNHCR in Indonesia

2

Brief HistoryBrief History

In December 1950 the UN General Assembly established the Office

of theUUnited nited NNations ations

HHigh igh CCommissioner for ommissioner for RRefugeesefugees

UNHCR Office in Indonesia exist UNHCR Office in Indonesia exist since 1979since 1979

3

• Operating over 262 offices (including the Headquarters) in 116 countries

• About 6,689 employees (84% in the field)

• Assisting about 20.8 million refugees and people of concern

(1 UNHCR staff/2,800 people of concern)

• Funded by voluntary contributions: US$1.3 Billion (2007)

• No. of NGO Partners: 565

• State party to the Refugee Convention/Protocol: 147 countries

UNHCR – The Organisation

4

The 1950 statute says that the work of the UNHCR shall be

HumanitarianHumanitarian

Non Non PoliticalPolitical

Based on the Principles of International Refugee Law

5

UNHCR – The Main Functions

To provide international protection to refugees

To seek permanent solutions for the problem of refugees

To promote International Refugee Law

6

11.4 m. Refugee

13.7 m Internally Displaced

2.8 m Returnees2.8 m Returnees

0.8 m Asylum Seekers

Persons of Concern

3 m Stateless/POCs

7

Key Instruments for Refugee Protection

• International Instrument: - 1951 Convention relating to the Status

of Refugees - 1967 Protocol (Removal of time-

limitation & Geographical boundaries)

• Regional Instruments: - 1969 OAU Convention - 1984 Cartagena Declaration

8

1951 UN Convention relating to the Status of Refugees Art. 1A refugee is any person who:

owing to well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership to a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of origin of his nationality and is unable or owning to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of protection of that country.

9

Obligations of refugees

Obey national laws and measures to maintain law and order

Neutrality vis a vis country of origin

Respect of UN principles and objectives

10

Asylum seekers unlawfully in the country

of refuge - Art. 31No penalties against “unauthorized entry

or presence”,

1. If Coming directly from a territory where their life was threatened,

2. If they report to the authorities

without delay, 3. If they can show good cause for their illegal entry/presence.

11

Expulsion - Art. 32

No expulsion except on grounds of national security or public order

Decision reached in accordance to due process of law; refugee allowed to present his case

The contracting state could apply special measures during that period

If expelled can not be to the country where s/he suffers persecution (Art. 33)

12

Non refoulement - Art. 33

Cornerstone of international refugee law

International customary law

No return to the frontiers of territories where life or freedom would be threatened on account of... (art. 1)

Does not apply when reasonable grounds to be regarded as a danger to security

Does not apply if convicted by final judgement of serious crime

(Relevant with other Human Rights Standard such as: CAT Art. 3; ECHR Art. 3; ICCPR Art. 7)

13

• Political Instrument: - Decree of the People Consultative Assembly

No. XVII/1998 Concerning Human Rights, Art. 24: “every person has the right to seek asylum to

obtain political protection from another country”

• Legal Instruments: - National Constitution - Human Rights Act (No. 39/1999) - International Relations Act (No. 37/1999)

Key Instruments for Refugee Protection in Indonesia

14

National Constitution

Article 28 G: (2): “every person has the right to seek political asylum from another country”

15

Human Rights Act (No. 39/1999)

Art. 28: (1) “Everyone has the right to seek and receive political asylum from another country”

(2) “The right as referred to in clause (1) does not apply to perpetrators of non-political crimes or acts that contravene the objectives and principles of the United Nations”

16

International Relations Act (No. 37/1999)

Art. 26: “Asylum granted to aliens materialized in accordance with National Regulations and taking into account International Law, International Customs and International Practices.

Art. 25: (1) “President has the power to give asylum to aliens upon the consideration of the Minister”

(2) Implementation of the Power stipulated in the paragraph (1) has to be regulated by the Presidential Decree.

Art. 27: “President establish policy concerning refugee coming from outside this country upon recommendation of the Minister”

17

Practical Approach Directive: SE Dirjen Imigrasi No. F-IL.01.10-1297 (20 September 2002)• Immigration: tolerate the illegal presence of

asylum seekers and refugees; No Deportation • Referred/contact UNHCR • UNHCR attestations, prevent them from

having problems under immigration law with authorities

• If recognised; the person will be released upon request from UNHCR

• Asylum seeker or refugee who breaks the laws, has to be processed in accordance with the existing laws.

18

Relevant Human Rights Standard

• Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Art. 14, 25) • International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights

(Art. 2,3,6,7,13, 24,26) • UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel (Art.

3) • International Covenant on Economic, Social and

Cultural Rights (Art. 2,3,10) • UN Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of

Racial Discrimination • UN Convention on the Elimination of All Form of

Discrimination against Women • UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (Art. 3, 20,

22,23)• International Convention on the Protection of the

Rights of all Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families

19

UDHR, Art. 1:

Rights are Generally granted to “everyone”, regardless of their nationality or their legal status in the country in which they find themselves.

ICCPR, Art. 2:

States are obliged to ensure rights to all individuals within their territories and under their jurisdiction

Non-Discrimination Clause

20

The Principle of Non-Refoulementin Human Rights Law

• UDHR, Art. 5: “No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment”

• CAT, Art. 3: “No State party shall expel, return (“refouler”) or extradite a person to another State where there are substantial grounds for believing that he would be in danger of being subjected to torture”

• ICCPR, Art. 7: “No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. In particular, no one shall be subjected without his free consent to medical or scientific experimentation”

21

What does UNHCR do

in

Indonesia?

22

International protection includes a range of concrete activities that ensure that all women, men, girls, and boys of concern to UNHCR have equal access to and enjoyment of their rights in accordance with international law

23

Durable solutionsDurable solutions

Voluntary repatriation. Safety and dignity must be guaranteed in country of origin

Local integration. When voluntary repatriation not possible. Assimilation in host community.

Resettlement. When the above are not possible or appropriate.

24

Current Situation in Indonesia:

(as of 31 August 2008)

Active UNHCR caseloadActive UNHCR caseload - 599 persons (270 refugees, 329 asylum seekers)

ResettlementResettlement – 65 departed in 2008.

Voluntary RepatriationVoluntary Repatriation - Not a major solution yet as a majority of UNHCR cases are from Iraq, Afghanistan and Somalia.

25

Refugees and Asylum Seekers in ASEAN (2007)

Asylum Seekers Refugees

Singapore, 24

Philippines, 302

Malaysia, 6,851

Cambodia, 239

Viet Nam, -

Timor-Leste, 4

Indonesia, 211

Thailand, 13,484

Cambodia, 179

Viet Nam, 2,357

Timor-Leste, 1

Indonesia, 315

Malaysia, 32,243

Philippines, 106

Singapore, 10

Thailand, 125,643

26

Country of Origin Asylum Seekers &

Refugees in Indonesia

5 Main Countries for 2007/2008

Iraq

Sri Lanka

Afghanistan

Somalia

Myanmar

27

Thank you

www.unhcr.orgDerwin Anifah Djamaris

djamaris@unhcr.org