ergonomics ii error study

Compara'veErrorStudy

Guidedby:Prof.ParagSen

CompiledBy:AanchalGoel1025

ErrorStudyofSamsungCorbyS3650

1.Whilesendingamessage,theenCrephonegetsoccupiedCllthemessageissent.HencenootheracCvitycanbeperformed.

2.Thereisno‘OpCons’opConwhereonecanseetheseKngsforeachofthefeaturesavailable.

3.Wheninacall,oneneedstopresstheholdbuMontousein‐callopCons.Thistakes2‐3secondsinunlock.

4.Whilesearchingforacontact,theothercontactsgetblocked.Soit’sdifficulttoknowifthecontactisthereonthelistornot.

5.Thewidgetscomeouteverynowandthenbymistake.AnditrequiresonetoopenthewidgetsopConagaintoputtheapplicaConbackin.

6.Calllogsarenotsegregated.Sent,receivedmessages,aswellasmissed,receivedanddialedcallsarealllistedunderonecategory.

7.WhileselecCngaCmezone,astateorcountrycannotbeentered.OnehastogothroughthemaptoFINDthecountry,andthenfindthestate.

Summary

S.No ErrorsinSamsungCorby

1. Textsending,blockstheenCrescreenClltheit’ssent

2. ItsdifficulttoFINDacountryintheworldclock

3. Call/Messaginglogsarenotsegregated

4. Widgetskeeppoppingoutaccidentally.

5. UnlockingtakesCmeduringacalltousein‐callfeatures.

6. Absenceofscrollbar

7. Absenceof‘OpCons’intheMessagingFolder.

ErrorsinNokia5800XpressMusic

Nokia5800ExpressMusic

1.  ThephonerequiresyoutodoubleclickatcertainopConsinsteadofone.Likeincomputers.

2.  Thescrollbarisinconvenienttoworkwithforabeginner.3.  Thereisquickaccesstoonlyfourcontacts.Hence,quickorspeedyaccesscan

bedonetoonly4friendsatbest4.  NoinformaConregardingthecontactisdisplayedwiththeirpicturesand

names.

5.  Speeddialfeatureisabsent.

6.  QWERTYkeyboardcanbeusedonlyinahorizontalview.

7.OnlyABCkeyboardcanbeusedinverCcalview.ForsomeonewhofindsQWERTYkeypadmoreconvenientwillhaveaproblemtypingverCcally.

8.AsmallQWERTYkeyboardisavailable.ButextremelydifficulttoworkwithsincethesizeoftheleMersbecomessmaller.Althoughastyluscanbeusedtosolvesuchaproblembutitiseasiertotaponthisphonewithfingersornailsthanthestylus.

9.ThehandwriCngrecogniConiseasiesttouseoutofallthetypingopCons.Yet,ittakesCmetogetusedtoit.

S.No. ErrorsinNokia5800

1. Doubleclickingtogoinsideafolder.

2. Thescrollbarisinconvenienttouse.

3. Speeddialingcanonlybedoneto4contacts.

4. QWERTYkeypadcanbeusedonlyinhorizontalview

5. OnlyABCkeypadcanbeusedinverCcalview

6. Smallhorizontalkeypadisextremelyinconvenient.

Summary

Compara'veStudy

1.Corbyhasthephoneprofileslistedonthehomescreen.AndmodificaConscanalsobemadeinthem.Inthenokia5800,ontheotherhand,theseprofilesareavailablebutnotopContomakemodificaConfromthehomescreen.OneneedstogoinsideinthemainseKngstomakechangesintheprofile.

2.Therearetwoavailableviewstoviewpicturesinacorby.Asalistandasthumbnails.Inthenokiaonlyalistwithsmallthumbnailsisavailable.

3.Messagescanbesenttorecentcontacts,groupsandsinglenumbersaswell.Nokia5800lacksthisfeature.

4.AquicklookbuMonisavailabletoviewthelastclickedpicture.AndalltheotheropConsrelaCngtothecameraareavailableonthescreenitself.SuchafeatureisnotthereintheCorby.

5.ThereisanopConof‘snoozerepeat’whichallowsonetonumbertheCmesthephonewillringthesnoozealarm.Whichisagoodfeatureoverthenokia5800.wherenosuchopConisavailable.

6.ThereareopConstochangethefontinthecorby.Whichisunavailableinthenokia5800.

7.Inthesamsungcorby,theyhavenotprovidedforascrollbar.SomeCmesthatprovesasaproblem,whenwhiledragging/scrollingdown,abuMonisaccidentallypressed.Thisproblemissolvedinthenokia,wherenobuMonsarepressedduetothepresenceofaseparatescrollbar.

8.Noquickcontactsareavailableonthehomescreenofthecorby.Whereas4ormorequickcontactsareavailableonthenokia5800.

9.IntheCorbythetaskscanbelistedaccordingtopriority.Andhence,theonewithmaximumprioritycanbeviewedfirstintheline.

10.Inthenokia5800,thereisasocketremovethememorycardfromtheoutsideinsteadofopeningthewholephonewithbaMeryout.Suchafeatureisnotavailableinthecorby.

S.No. SamsungCorby Nokia5800

1. ModificaConsintheprofilescanbemadefromthehomescreen.

ModificaConscanonlybemadeinsidethe‘SeKngs’opConinthemenu.

2. MulCpleviewsareavailabletoseetheimagesinthegallery.

Singleviewtoseeimages.

3. MessagescanbesenttoRecentContacts,Calllog,Groupsormanually.

MessagescanonlybesentbymarkingasingleormulCplecontacts.

4. ThereisnodedicatedbuMontoseethelastclickedpicture.Youneedtogotothegallery.

ApreviewbuMonisavailabletoviewthelastclickedpicture.

5. Thereisasnooze‘duraCon’and‘repeat’buMonintheAlarmClock.

OnlyregularAlarmClockwithmulCplesnooze.

6. ThereisanopContochangethefontoftheenCrephone.

NosuchopConisavailableinthisphone.

SummaryCompara'veStudy

S.No. SamsungCorby Nokia5800

7. Ascrollbarisavailabletogoupordownthescreen.

Thescrollbarisabsent.Youneedtodragandmovethescreenupordown.

8. Fourquickcontactsareavailableonthehomescreen.

9Quickcontactsorspeeddialsareavailable.

9. Thetasksorthings‐to‐domenuisanormalnotepad.

Thetaskscanbearrangedaccordingtopriority.

Bibliographywww.youtube.com/watch?v=W_kE11yIyKISept7th20102.12amwww.youtube.com/watch?v=K9‐UYkKd_i0Sept7th20101.47am