compensation to workmen for industrial...
Post on 29-Jul-2018
224 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
TABLE OF CASES
Abbu Bak.~!" Abdul Rahroan & Co. v. Narayan, ----:\. 1. F(~m Nag :272
Abdul Hussein v. secretary of State, A.I.R.1933 Rang. 244
Abida Khatun v. G.M., Diesel Locomotive, (1973) I L.L.J.387 (All.) 'F.B.}
Addl. DX. Commissioner v. Mt.Laxmibai Naidu, A.I.R.194S Nag.238
Ahmed Ab!ul v. H.K.3ehgal, A.I.R.1965 Bom.32
Ahmedabad Victoria Iron Works Ltd. v. Maganlal, .~.I.R.194l Bom.296 (D.B.)
A.I.R. Ltd., Nagpur v. 8.S.I.C., 1985 Lab.I.C. 1181 (Born.)
Ajude~~ v. E.S.I.C., A.I.R.1959 M.P.339
Alderman v. Great ~estern Rly.Co., A.C. 454 (H. L. )
Alice v. Commissioner, l'r vandrum, 1
Alimohamed v. Shankar, A.I.R.1946 Bom.169 (D.B.):
Allah Bakhsh v. M.Mohammad Allah Baksh, A.f.R.1935 Lah.670
All India Construction Co.Ltd., v. Munshi Ram, ·A.I.R.1931 Lah.319
Amri Naran v. Suken EmEIOyees' co-0tjrative Society L td.. 19&7 La. r :C . 1197 { Gu .) . .
Andre10tl v. PailsW'orth Industrial Society Ltd.,
G 90 il 2 K. B. 32 (C. A. )
A.P.State Electricity Board v. E.S.I.C., 1977 Lab.r.c.Ji6 (A.P.) (D.B.)
Armstron~ Whitworth & Co. v. Redford, ~ 926] A.C.757 (H.L.)
399
Page
165
57
120,137
85
147,148
163,164
72
122
116,132
96
163
125
146
57,61 64
123
79,80
132
400
Arxa Mun~ v. Union of India, (1965) I L.L.J.24 (All.) 125
Assam Rll. and Trading Co. v. Saraswathi Devi, 117, A.I.R.1963 Ass.127 (F.B.) 132
Associated Cement Co.Ltd., v. E.S.I.C., Bombay, 77 1981 Lab.I.C.1409 (Born.)
Asst.Executive Engr., No.3. Sub-division Bhadra- 56 River Left Bank Canal Military Camp Bhadravathi v. H.S.3unanda and another, 1994 Lab.I.C. NOC 187 (Kant.)
Ba! Chandan v. Godhra Borough MunicipalitX. (1974) 113 2 L.L.N.296 (Gtij.) (D.B.)
Ba! Diva Kaluji v. Silver Cotton Mills, A.I.R.1956 118 Born. 424 ( D • B. )
Baikulaba! v. Rajnabai, 1991 Lab.I.C.450 (Born.) 86
Bai Mane v. Exec.Engr., (1986) 2 L.L.J.426 (Guj.)
Bat Shakri v. New Manek Chowk Mills Co. Ltd., A.I.R.1961 Guj.34
Ball v. Williarn Hunt & Sons Ltd., 0. 91 ~ Ao Co 496 (H.L.)
Bansidhar v. Ramachandra, A.I.R.1960 M.P.313
Barkwax v. South Wales Transport Co. Ltd., Q.95Q} A.C o 1eS (H.L.)
Bath v. British Transport Commission, ~9S~ 2 All E.R.S42 CC.A.)
58
: 97, 98 99,100
148, 149
164
18
22
B.E.S.T.Undertaking v. Mrs.Agnes. A.I.R.1964 S.C.193 : 104,107 135
Bha~bai v. Central Railwa~, A.I.R. 1955 Born. 105 (D.B.)
Bhagwand.!!, v. Pxarelal, A.I.R.1954 M.B.59
Bhaq~anji Muruthai Sodha v. Hindustan Tiles & Cement Industries, (1977) 2 L.L.J.95(Guj.)
:: 105,119 120,130
134
: : 164,165
: : 120,132 164
.Bhanox·a Colliery Co. v. Poda Tell, ( 1 974 ) 2 L. L • J • 520 ( Ca 1.) ( D. B. )
Bharangar Service Station v. E.S.I.C. 1988 Lab.I.C.302 (Cal. (D.B.)
Bharat Gold Mines Ltd. v. Hanuman and others, (1993) 2 L.L.J.313 (Kant.}(O.B.)
Bhiwandiwala A.H. v. State of Bombay, A.I.R.1962 S.C.29
Bhurangya Coal Co. v. Sahebjan, .A..I.R. 1956 Pat.299 (8.B.)
Blovelt v. Sawyer, 0.904] 1 K.B.271 (C.A..)
S.M. & G.Engg. Factor v. Bahadur Singh, A.I.R.1955 All.182
Bombay l~unicipality v. Sulochanabai, 1977 Lab.I.C.1735 (Born.) (D.B.)
Bombay Wire Healds Mfg. Co. Ltd., v. E.S.I.C., 1986 Lab.I.C.1121 (Born.)
Borlex v. Ockenden, \}92~ 2 K.B.325 (C.A.)
Bowater v. Rowley Regis Borough Council, 1944 1 All E.R.465 (C.A.)
Brintons Ltd. v. Turrey, U.90~ A.C. 230
Broach Municipality v. Raiben Chimanlal,
1989 Lab.I.C.73 (Guj.)
Brockle Bank Ltd. v. Noor Ahmede, 42 C.W.N.179
Brooker v. Thomas Borthwick & Sons (P) Ltd.,
[1933J A. C. 669 (P .C. )
Broom v. Morgan, l!95~ 1 All E.R.849 (C.A.)
Brown v. Rolls Royce Ltd., Q.96Q! 1 All E.R.s77 (H.L.)
Bryce v. Swan HUnter Groue Plc and others, [!98@ 1 All E. R. 659 (0. B. )
Burma Oil Co. Ltd. v. Ma Hmwe Yin A.I.R.1935 Rang.428 (D.B.)
401
157
64
152
65
125 129
135
152,165 166
63
78
136
36
95
121
39
120
35
15
10,19
116
402
Butler 01:' Black v. F if. Coal Co. Ltd. ; 27 [1912J A.C.149 (H.L.)
~ v. ~lough M.etals Ltd., ~97~ 1 All E.R. 262(C.A.):: 29,31
Calcutta Electric Supply Corpn. v. H.C.Das, 1968 Lab.I.C.779 (Cal.) (D.B.)
Calcutta Licensed Measures Bengal Chamber of Commerce v. Md.Hossain. A.I.R.1969 Cal.378 (D.B.)
Canara Public Conveyance Co. v. Usman Khan, {1966) 1 L.L.J.826 (Hys.)
Cavanagh v. Ulster .... eaving Co. Ltd •• 0. 96Q1 A • C • 14 5 ( H. L. )
Cemendia Company Ltd. v. E.S.I.C., 1995 (71) ?L.R.160 (Born.)
Central Engg. COEPoration v. Dorai Raj, A.I.R.1960 Ori.39.
Central Glass Industries Ltd. v. Abdul Hossain. A.I.R.1948 Cal.12 (D.B.)
C.E.S.C. Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra Bose and others, A.I.R.1992 S.C.573
155 157
157
148
22
7S
164
::102.125 141
.. 72,74
Challapareddy Ranganayakamma v. K.Venkateswara Rao.:: 128 1975 Lab.l.C.1373 (A.P.)
Challis v. L. & s.w.Rly. Co., \}90ID 2 K.B.154(C.A.) 123
Chhat1~a Davi Gowa11n v. Rup Lal Sao,
1978 Lab.l.C.136B (Pat.)
. . 163
Ch111u K~ v. Burn & Co. Ltd., A.I.R.1953 Cal.516·· 100
Chintarnan Rao v. State of M.P., A.I.R.1958 S.C.388 .. 55.64
Chopra Pr1ntin~ Press v. Des Raj, (1964) 1 L.L.J. 658 (Punj.)
Chowgule & Co.Ltd., v. F.Rodrigues. 1970 Lab.I.C.1584 (Goa)
:: 1 S2
:: 120
403
:lover, Clanon & Co.Ltd. v. Hughes,
f.!91Q] A.C.242 (H.L.)
:. 97,118
Coimbatore Dist.Co-operative Milk Supply Union . . 77
~. v. E.S.I.C •• 1973 (26) F.L.R.19(Mad.)
Coltman and another v. Bibby Tankers Ltd., 26 [198~ 2 All S.R.65 (O.B.)
':ombat Vehicls and Research Establishment v. D.C.:: 98 of Labour, 1995 (71) P.L.R.147 (Mad.)
Cornmr. for Workmen's COmpensation v. P.V.Mohanan,·· 84 (1988) 2 L.L.J.1T7 (Ker.) (D.B.)
:ommrs. for the Port of Calcutta v. Prayag Ram, 1967 Cal.i (D.B.)
Council v. Con stance Lena, A.I.R.1950 P.C.22
Cremins v. Guest, Keen and Netllefolds, l!90@ 1 K. B. 469 (C.A.)
Daborn v. Bath Tramways Motor Co. Ltd., [194§) 2 All E.R.333 (C.A.)
Davidson v. Handler Page Ltd., ~ 94~ 1 All E.R.235 (C .A.)
Davie v. New Marton Board Hills Ltd., Q. 95@ 1 All E.R.67 (C.A.)
Davie v. New Merton Board f·UlIs Ltd., ~95~ A. C. 604 ( H • L. )
'Javies v. Swan Motor Co. (Swanesa) Ltd., [194~ 1 All E.R. 620 (C.A.)
Deep Metal Industries, Chakan v. B.D.Gaikwad, 1995 Lab.I.C.I002 (Born.)
:>ennis v. White, Q.91'[J A.C.479 (H.L.)
Jeviben Dudabhai v. Liberty Talk1e~, 1994 Lab.I.C.2S70 (Guj.)
Devidayal Ralyaram v. Secretary of State,
A.I.R.193i Sind.288 (D.B.)
157
· . 40
· . 104,107 135
· . 13 · .
135
· . 19
· . 25
37
163,165
115
.. 97,100 121
127,132
Devshi BhanJi Khona v. Smt..MarI Burno, :.
1985 Lab.I.C.1589 (Ker.) (D.B.)
Oewan Harichand v. Delhi MuniciEal1tI, A. I. R.1981 Del.71 (D. B. )
D.G., E.S.I.C. v. Scientific Instruments Co.Ltd.;
1995 (70) F.L.R.184 (All. )
Dharangadhara Chemical Works Ltd. v. State of Saurashtra, [!9511 S.C.R.152
Director (T. & M.) D.N.K.Project v. D. Buchitalli, :
1987 Lab.I.C.1795 (Ori.)
Divl.Forest Officer, Gwa1ior v. Baijnatibai, 1994 Lab.I.C.2561 (M.P.) (D.B.)
;)ivl. Railway Manager, Kota v. Shamsadi,
1988 Lab.I.C.605 (Raj.)
404
97,118
42
74,75
54
86,117 121
165
117,121 123
p.M., New India Assurance Co. Ltd. , Cut-tacK v. .. 160 Sarbeswar Patra, 1994 Lab.I.C.NOC 253(Ori.)
~ominion of India v. Kaniz Fatima, (1961) 2 L. L. J • 197 (All.)
Donoghue v. Stevenson, Q.93~ A.C.562 (H.L.)
Dudhiben Dhararnshi v. New Jehan2ir Vakil Mills
. . . .
Co. Ltd., (1977) 2 L.L.J.194 (Guj.)(D.B.)
Dukhini Rajaharin v. Corpn. of Calcutta, A.I.R.1957 Cal.653 (D.B.)
~ v. A.G.Lockwood & Co., Q..947] 1 All E.R.446 (C.A.)
E.S.I.C. v. Ashok Plastics (P) Ltd.,
1988 Lab.I.C.793 (Cal.)(D.B.)
~.S.I.C. v. Ayurvedic Industrial Co-operative Pharmacy, 1980 Lab.I.C.557 (Ker.) (D.B.)
E.S.I.C. v. Babulal, 1982 Lab.I.C.468 (M.P.)
E.S.I.C. v. Bhag 3ingh, 1988 Lab.I.C.1170
(P. & H.) (F.B.).
40
11
106,109 120,134
135 62
132,135
76
79,80
123
64
S.S.I.C. v. Bharat Pulverising MLlls (p) Ltd .. (1979) 1 L.L.J.343 (Had.)
S.S.I.S. v. Cochin Co.Pvt.Ltd., 1978 Lab.I.C. 1439 (Ker.) (D.B.)
B.S.I.C. v. Davangere Cotton Mills, (1977) 2 L. L. J. 404 ( Kart.) ( D. B. )
S.S.I.e. v. Fashion Fabrics, 1990 (2) K.L.T.713 (D.a.)
B.S.I.C. v. Francis De Costa, 1978 Lab.I.e. 925 (Ker.) (D.B.)
'::.5.1.·:. v. Gulabbaksh ~1ulla, 1987 Lab.r.C.141 (Born.)
~.5.I.C. v. Harrisons Malayalam (P) Ltd., 1993 (2) K.L.T.714 (S.C.)
:.:. J. I .C, v. Hindustan Cocoa Products Ltd., 3.995 (70) F.L.R.233 (Born.)
S.5.I.<~<. v. Jaipur 2nteryrises, 1988 (56) F' • : .. ' • 20""7 (R il j • )
E.3.I.C, v. Kerala Kaumudi, 1987 Lab.I.C. 878 (Ker.) (:J.B.)
405
73
77
79
79
108
112 136
72
72
79
73
£.3.I.C, v. Kwality Spinning Mills, 1976 81 Lab.I.C.324 (Mad.)
l:<:.S.I.C. v. Lakshmi, 1979 Lab.r.C.167(Ker.)(O.B.):: 94,135 140
E.S.I.C" v. Maharaja Bar and Restaurant, 1979 Lab.I.C.1147 (A.P,) (D.B.)
8.S.I.C" v. Malhotra & Co., 1981 Lab. I.C.
475 (P. & H.)
8.S.Le .. v. M/s.M & R. Oils Co. (P) Ltd., 1984 Lab.I.C.844 (Kant.)
S.S.I.C. v. Narhari Rao P.R •• 1986 Lab.r.C.19B1 (Ker.) (D.B.)
.. . .
54,81
73
76
79 80
E.S.I.C. v. Oswall ~oollen Mills, 1980 Lab.I.C.1064 (P. & H.) (F.B.)
E.S.I.C. v. Parameswaran, 1977 Lab.I.C. 194 (Ker.) (D. B. )
E.S.I.C. v. Prabhulal Brothers, 1974 Lab.I.C. 701 (Mad.) (0.8.)
E.S.I.C. v. Premier Timber Supplies, 1991 (1)
K.L.T.554 (D.B.)
E.S.I.C. v. Raj Kal! Devi, 1955 (70) F.L.R.405 (All.)
E.S.I.~. v. Ram chander, (1988) 2 L.L.J.
141 (S.C.)
E.S.I.C. v. Raman (Chittur Har!har Iyer), ( 1957) 1 L. L • J • 267 (Born.) ( D • B. )
E.S.I.C. v. Ramlal Textiles, (1990) 2 L.L.J. 568 ( Ke r.) ( O. B. )
E.S.I.C. v. Sriramulu Naidu, A.I.R.1960 Mad. 248 ( D • B. )
.. . .
· . · .
· . · .
· . · .
E.S.I.C. v. Suhara 8eevi, (1975)2 L.L.J.25S(Ker.)
E.S.I.C. v. Suresh Trading Co., (1990) 1 L.L.J :: 348 (Ker.) (D.B.)
E.S.I.C. v. Suvarna SaTJl Mills, 1979, Lab.I.e. .. 1335 ( Kant.) ( F • B. )
E.S.I.C. v. Ta; Textiles Industrial Co-operative Society, Calicut, 1980 Lab.I.C.1301 (Ker.) (D.B.)
E.S.I.C. v. Tata Engineering & Co. 1976
Lab.I.e. 1 (S.C.).
E.S.I.C. v. Triplex Orycleaners, 1982 Lab.I.C.944 (P. & H.)
E.S.I.C. v. Vermani T.e., 1984 Lab.I.C. 1406 (P. & H.)
· . · .
· . · .
406
79
103
75
72,79
91
63,65
77
72,75
82
108
73,79
79
80
81
64
76
IC.S.I.C. v. Victory Tile ~""orlcs, o.97~ 44 F.J.R.304 (Ker.) (D.B.)
Exec. Engr. Kadana Dam v. Phebiben, 1977 Lab.I.C.1651 (Guj.)
Bxec. Engr., P.W.D. National High Way Div. v. Girdhari, 1977 Lab.I.C.852 (Raj.)
Sxec. Engr., P.W.D. v. Narain Lal, 1977 Lab.I.C.1827 (Raj.)
Factory Manager, Associated Soap Stone Factory v. Ladkiba1, 1994 Lab.I.C.NOC 11 (M.P.)
Fakiragram Rice Mills v. Ramu Indu, A.I.R.1950
Ass.188 (n.B.)
!ederation of Labour Co-operatives Ltd. v. Baliah, A.I.R.1962 A.P.69.
Fenton v. ThorleI & Co.Ltd •• G90~ A.C.443
?ife Coal Co. Ltd. v. YounSl, I} 94Q} 2 All E.R. 85 (H.L. )
Finch v. Tele Construction and Maintenance ~~ .. ~~~~~~~~~--~~~~~~~
194~ 1 All E.R.452 (K.B.)
Fitzgeralal v. Cl ark & Son, ~90~ 2 K.B. 796 (C.A.)
Fitz Simions v. Ford Motor Co.Ltd. -1 All 2.R.429 (C.A.)
~.Powell v. Panchu Mokadan, A.I.R.1942
Pat.4S3 (D.B.)
3ane v. Norton Hill Colliery Co., Q.90~ 2 K.B.539 (C.A.)
.. . .
· . · .
· . · .
407
76
58
58
159
56
165
113
97,118
98
29
118
100
125
105 106
3anesan ~f. Bhagawathi Aroma, 1962 K. L. T. 345 (D. B. ) : : 62
Ganesh Foundry Works v. Bhasr .... anti & Others ( 1985) 1 L. L • J • 95 ( P. & H.)
54
.:;ang,d ...:2.2.lgc1r Corp':",. ~. v. R.am Darshan, 1977 Lab.I.~.1285 (All.)
Carrison ::ngr. v. Guttarruna Hanmatdas l
1978 Lab.I.C.878 (Born.)
:;ate;..ray...:·,uto Service:;; v. .:: •. 5. I. C::., 1981 Lab.I.C.49 (Born,)
General Cleaning Contractors Ltd. v. Christmas Q.95~ A,C::.1S0 (H.L.)
General Manager, G.I.P.Rly. v. Shankar,
A.I.~.1950 Nag.201
Sener;ll i,tanager, South Sastern Rly. v. Radley
Shyam, 1984 (48) F.L.R.493 (M.P.)
Ghasi Ram v. Nannibai, \.I.R.1960 M.P.267
~·nasg(~ ...... COrporation v. ~, ~94Il 2 All E.R.44.
:';0pJ..l .:iynthetics v. ,'/.C.Commr., Kota, 1995 (70) F.L.~.72 (Raj.)
:.;ould v. Minister of National Insurance, '~95D 1 K. 8.731
:;ouri Kinkar Bhakat v. Ra:lha Kissen Cotton Mills, A.I.R.1933 Cal.220 (~.3.)
:;raham v. :.::.w.s. Ltd., [}..9S?J E.R.6S4 (J.B.)
1 All
]rand I~on ~orks v. 2.3.I.C., 1971 (23) F.L.R.155 (Del.)
jrant.I"li1:I; v. roe"" .~~ld.n.jJhippinJ C? Ltd., [i 94 OJ 4 A 11 E. R. 2 58 (le B. )
::;uj arat 3tate ROad Transport Corporation v.
Bai Jivlben Arjan l 1981 Lab.I.C.86 (Guj. )
Gwalior Sugar Co. v. 3rilal, A.I.R.1958 M.P.133 ..
'-iabeebull.<lh B.M.v.Periaswami:, A.I.R.1977 Mad.330 ..
408
l·t 3
5P,
64 65
17,23 116
147
128
57
12
84
54
127 132
12
77
28
120
86
88
Harris v. Associated Portland Cement Mfrs.Ltd •..
[1931[1 4 All S.R.831 (H.L.)
Hastimal v. A.Arjunan, (1993) 2 L.L.J. 55 (Mad.)::
Haynes v. Harwood, IT 935] 1 K. B.146
Hicks v. British Transport Commission,
1}958] 2 All E.R.39 (C.A.)
Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. Bone Jan,
1971 (22) F.L.R.308 (Mys.) (!J.B.)
H1ndustan Ice & Cold Storage Co. Ltd. v. Zubeda Bibi, A.I.R.1955 N.U.C. 817 (Cal.)
Hirjibhai Lakhamsibhai v. Damodar, A.I.R.1957
M.P.49 (:>.B.)
Holt v. ";;.H.Rhodes & Son Ltd., (!94~ 1 All E.R.478 (C.A.)
Hudson v. Rid~e Manufacturing Co.Ltd.,
[i.95'?) 2 Q.8.348.
Hurley v. J.Sanders & Co.Ltd. and Another,
£! 95~ 1 All S. R. 833 ( Liverpool Assizes)
Hutchi~on v. York, Newcastle and Berwick
Rly. Co., (1850) 5 Exch.343
Hutti Gold Mines Co. v. Ratnam, (1965) 2 L.L.J.20 (Mys.)
Imperial Tobacco Co. v. sabona Bibi, A.I.4.19S6 Cal.458 (D.B.)
Indian Jute Co.Ltd. v. E.S.I.C., West Bengal
1977 Lab.I.C.816 (Cal.) (F.B.)
Indian News Chronicle Ltd. v. Mrs.Lazarus, A.I.R.1951 Punj.102
.. . .
409
128 129
56
10
23
152
115
58
55
27
23
33
149
118
77
95,118 137
Indian Rare Earths Ltd. v. A.Subaida Beevi, 1981 Lab.I.C.1359 (Ker.) (D.B.)
In re A.M. Chinniah~ A.I.R. 1957 Mad.755
In re Dependants of Kartar Singh, A.I.R.1931 Lah.752
J.D. & Co. Oil Mills v. E.S.I.C., A.I.R.1963
A.P.210
Jagadish Prasad v. Modi Lantern ',~orks,
A.I.R.1964 All.323
Janaki Aromal v. Divl. Engr., Highways,
(1956) 2 L.L.J.233 (Mad.)
Janatha Modern Rice !·1ills v. G. Satyanarayana~
1995 Lab.l.C.677 (A.P.) •
410
108
64
86
114
95
124,125 132,133
144~156
170
John Stewart and Sons v. Longhurst, l} 91 IJ A.C.249 (H.L.)
.. 103,105
Juthi Devi v. M/s.Pine Chemicals Ltd.,
1989 Lab.I.C.2310 (J. & K.)
Kali Das Ghosal v. 3.K.Mondal, A.l.R.1957 Cal. 660 (D. B. )
Kalia v. Workmen's Compensation Commr.,
1988 (57) F.L.R.314 (Raj.)
Kalpana ~resses v. E.S.I.C., 1976 Lab.I.C. 1 791 ( Born.) ( D. B. )
Kamala v. Madras Port Trust, (1966)
1 L.L.J.690 (Mad.)
Kamalabai v. Central Railway, A.I.R.1971
Bom.200
Kamala Devi. v. Bengal National Textile Mills Ltd.
( 197 5 ) 2 L. L • J • 81 ( P. & H.) . .
Kamala 3ingh v. E.3.I.2. l].962-6~ 22 F.J.R.66 (Punj.) (D.B.)
110,132
63
157
87
65
112
97
57,58
87
Kapoor 5.1:!_ v. Zmperor, .~.I.R.1937 Lah.S47
K.C • .3~O--Op. Society Ltd. v. S.S.I.~=.,
':1989) 2 L.L.J.27 (Ker.) (D.B.)
Kilgollan v. ~11liam Cooke and Co.Ltd., [19SID 2 All E:.R.294 CC.A.)
Kikubhai v. Mafatlal Fine 3p9. & Mfg.Co.Ltd., 1981 Lab.I.C.1643 (Guj.) (~.B.)
Kimpton v. The Steel Co. Of ~o\[ales Ltd.,
D960J 2 All E.R.274 CC.A.)
411
60
80
28
95,97, 98,122
22
Knight v. Howard Wall Ltd., n93~ 135
4 All S.R.667 (C.A.)
Knowles v. Liveryool City Council, 899i] 4 All E.R.321 (H.L.)
Kochappan v. Krishnan, (1987) 2 L.L.J.174 ( Ker .) ( D. B. )
Kochu Velu v. J~se2h, 1980 Lab.I.C.902 (Ker.) (D. B.)
Koduri Atchayamma v. P.Atchamma, 1969 Lab.I.C.1415 (A.P.)
Ladi Jagannadham v. Padma bati Ba~rani, A.I.R.1962 OrI.7.
Lakshmidas Premji, Ghee Merchants v. Regl.
Inspector of Factories, A.I.R.1960 A.P.147 (D.B.)
Lancashire and Yorkshire Rly.Co. v. Highley,
l!917j A.C.3S2 (H.L.)
Laszczyk v. National Coal Board, [! 95~ 3 All E.R.20S (Manchester Assizes)
Latimer v. A. ~.C. Ltd., (!9Si} 2 All E..rt.449 (H.L.)
La'.-frence v. ~orge t1atthews Ltd., l} 92~ 1 .... H • J ( •. -.. )
25
.. 56,57
.. 55,56, 57,58
120,125,
132
.. 117
.. 64
127
123
14
119
Laxmdbai v. Sqairman & Trustees, Bombay Port 'rrust, A..I.R.1954 Bom.180 (9.S.)
Lee Shi v. Consolidated Tin Mines, A.I.R.1939 Rang. 428 (!). S. )
Leela Devi v. She Ram Lal Rahu, (1990) 1 L.L.J.364 (H.P.)
412
97,121
125
120,122
Lingam Seetharamiah v. B.Bramaramba, 124 1969 Lab.I.C.118 (A.P.)
London and North Eastern RlX.Co. v. Brentnall, .. 132 [!93~ A.C. 489 (H.L.)
Lovell v. Blundells and T.Albert Crompton & Co. Ltd., IT 94i) 1 K. B. 502
24
Low or Jackson v. General Steam Fishing Co.Ltd.:: 111
[! 90 21 A. C. 523 ( H • L. )
Luizina Crril Vaz v. M/s.Caltex (India) Ltd., 152 1973 (27) F.L.R.320 (Born.)
Mackinnon Mackenzie & Co. (p) Ltd. v. Ibrahlm Mahommad Issak, A.I.R.1970 S.C.1906
Macklnnon Mackenzie & Co. (P) Ltd. v. Rita Fernandez, (1969) 2 L.L.J.812
Mackinnon Mackenzie & Co. Ltd., v. Miss Velma .. Williams, A.I.R.1964 Cal.94
Madanlal v. Mangali, A.I.R.1961 Raj. 45
Maherunisha A. Pattan v. S.S.I.C., (1995) 1 L.L.N.394 (Guj.)
Makhan Lal v. Audh Behari, A.I.R.1959 All.586
Malatibai v. ~ivl. Controller, A.I.R.1968 Mys.208 (D.B.)
Manada Aebi v. Bengal Bane Mill, A.I.R.1940 Cal.285 (D.B.)
Mana~er, Achoor Estate v. P.Nabeesa, 1994 Lab.I.C.1974 (Ker.) (D.B.
· . · . · .
· .
· .
117,
141
122
98
55.57
105 109
165
62
85
160
Manager, Khoorntaic Tea ~state v. Ramilxa Mal.
1978 Lab.I.C.139 (Gau.) (!J.B.)
Managing Dir., Orissa S.R.T.C. V. SurendraKumar, 1986 Lab.!.C.1997 (Ori.)
Mangal Chand v. Forest Dept., Kinnaur I ( 1985)
1 L.L.J.369 (H.P.)
Mankuwarbai v. Kusum Lata, 1988 (56)
F.L.R.674 (M.P.)
Manual D'3ilva v. AUgustine, 1980 K.L.T.I06 (Ker.) (D.B.)
Margarida Gomes v. Mackinnon Mackenzie & Co., 1968 Lab.I.C.1197 (Born.)
Mariambai v. Mackinnon Mackenzie & Co., 1968 Lab.I.C.629 (Born.)
Markland v. Manchester Corporation, l193~ 1 K.B.S66 (C.A.)
Marshall v. Gotham Co. Ltd., IT 95~ 1 All E.R.93? (H.L.)
Mc Dermid v. Nash Dredging and Reclamation C Co.Ltd., t!98~ 2 All :E.R.676 (C.A.)
Mc Dermid v. Nash Dredging and Reclamation Co.Ltd. r!9871 2 All E.R.878 (H.L.)
Mc Ghee v. National Coal Board, IT97~ 3 All E.R.I008 (H.L.)
Merrington v. Iron bridge Metal .'lorks Ltd.,
(!9SIJ 2 All E.R.llOl (Salop Assizes)
Mewar Textile Mills v. Kushali Bai, (1960)
2 L.L.J.369 (Raj.)
M.N.Khan v. Bombay Municipal Corpn. 1982 Lab.!. C. 780 (Born.) ( D • B. )
Modi Industries Ltd. v. E.3.I.C. 1986 (52) F.L.R.196 (AlL)
.. . .
413
157
165
166
90
62
169
95
17
15
24
20,30
29
36
125
10?
76
~ohanm~d Koya v. Balan, (1987)2 L.L.J.486 (Ker.) (D. B. )
~ohanlal Prabhuram v. Fine Knitting Mills Co.Ltd. A.I.R.1960 Bom.387.
~ohanlal 3. v. Kond1ah R., (1979) 2 S.C.C.616
~oondra & co. v. Bhanwari, 1970 Lab.I.C.695 (Raj. )
Morris v. Hurray and another, D99Q13 All E. R. 801 ( C . A. )
,"1.orris v. 'rlest Hartlepool Steam Navigation Co.Ltd. ff95~ 1 All E.R.385 (H.L.)
Moti Lal v. Thakur Das. 1984 (49) F.L.R.293 (All.): (1985) 2 L.L.N.951
~.P.S.R.T.Corporation De~as v. ~.3.I.C.,
1975 (71) F. L. R. (Sum.) 18 (M. P. )
M/S.Pochiah & Co. v. Mulle Nagabhushanam, A.I.R.1966 A.P.99
M/a.Siv. Tradini Co. v. Secy. to Govt. of India .. 1994 Lab.I.C.1593 (P. & H.) (D.B.).
Mt. Dirji v. Smt.Goalin, A.I.R.1942 Pat.33(D.B.)::
Muniswamy C v. Rajmoorthy T., 1988 (56) F.L.R.609 (Mad.)
Hunshi & Co. v. Yeshwant Tukaram. A.I.R.1948 Bom.44.
Nadirsha Hormusji Sidhwa v. Krishnabai Bala, A.I.R.1936 Bom.199.
Nagar Palika, Mandsaur v. Bhagwanti bai, 1994 Lab. I.C. NOCITI (M.P.)
Naima Bibi v. Lodhne Colliery Co.Ltd., (1977) 2 L.L.J. 69 (Ca!.) (O:"S.)
Nai Smith v. London Film Productions Ltd., l!93~ 1 All. E.R.794 (c •. ;.)
.. . .
165
120, 123
57
90,120, 128
36
13,16, 23
146, 149
74
166
79
86
54
120
55
114, 125
120, 123
21
Nanjamm~ v. City Municipal Council, 1982 Lab.I.C.120B (Kant.) (C.B.)
Narakesari Prakashan Ltd. v. E.3.I.C.~ A.I.R.1984 3.C.1916
Narayanan v. Southern Railway, (1980) 1 L.L.J.359 (Ker.) (D.B.)
National Coal Board v. Snqland, Q. 95-U 1 All E.R.546 (H.L.)
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. M.Saleen Khan, (1992) 2 L.L.J.377 (A.P.)
National Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. Manoramd, A.I.R.1953 Cal.143 (D.B.)
New Grand High Class Bakery v. E.S.I.C., 1976 Lab.I.C.1466 (Born.) (!:>.B.)
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Fatmabai, 1982 Lab.I.C.732 (M.P.)
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. G.Krishna Rao and Others, 1995 (71) F.L.R.l (Ori.)
.. . .
.. . .
New India Assurance Co.Ltd. v. Kotan Appa Rao, :: 1995 Lab.I.C.1087 (A.P.)
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Nansingh, { 1984 } 1 L. L • J • 186 (M. P • )
New India Assurance Co.Ltd. v. T.P.Sreedharan, .. 1995 Lab.I.C.602 (Ker.) (F.B.)
New Taj Mahal Cafe Ltd., Mangalore v. Inspector of Factories, Mangalore, A.I.R.1956 Mad.600
Nisbet v. Rayne and Burn, [91§) 2 K.B.689 (C.A.)
Noble v. Southern R1X' Co., \194Q} 2 All E.R.383 (H.L.)
Nolan v. Dental Manufacturing Co. Ltd. ~ [195~ 2 All E.R.449 (Manchester Assizes)
.. . .
~15
76
6)
123
145
115,132, 133
65
62
119
146
84
159
64
123
132
30,31
Non-Ferrous Rolling Mills v. E.S.I.C. 1977 Lab.I.C.1706 (Mad.)
Northern Rly. v. R.R.Nerma, 1979 Lab.I.C. 1099 (All.)
Official Liquidator v. K.S.E.B •• 1990 (1) K.L.T.256
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Guru Charan Saren, A.I.R.1991 Ori.294
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanguli 5ingh & ANR. (1995) 1 L.L.J.298 (Or1.)
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Tajuddin Abdul Rahim Karanch, 1995 (71) F.L.R. 619 (Kant.)
Orient Paper Mills_v. R.D., E.S.r.C., Bhubaneswar,
416
76
116
41,61
146
120
160
1995 Lab.r.C.212 (Or1.) 00 78
Orissa Co-operative Insurance Society Ltd. v. 0 0
Sarat Chandra Champati, 1976 L ab.!. C. 371 (0 r 1. )
()riss" State Road Transport Corpn. v. Sathya-'bhama Seth, 1994 Lab.I.C. Noe .. 204 (Or1.)
Padam Debi v. Raghunath, \.I.R.1950 Or1.207 {D.B.}
Page v. Smith, \2. 99~ 4 All E. R. 522 (C •. a.. )
Pandye R.M. v. Automobile Products of India Ltd • . ~.I.R.1956 Bom.llS (~.B.)
Pape v. £umbria county Council, Q 992] 3 All E.R.211 (Q.B.)
P aepammal v. Subbiah Thevar, Q 97 n 43 F.J.R.271 (Mad,)
ParameS'Na.rc:m v. Parameswaran Nair. 1989 (1) K.L.J.247 (~.B.)
~areira J.F. v. Eastern W~tch Co. Ltd., ( 1985) 1 L. L. J . 472 (Born.)
.. . .
62
101
62,96 97,124
10,11
113
30
87
57
41 111
Par is v. Steeney Borough Counci 1 , Q. 95 D 1 All E.R.42 (H.L.)
Parwatiba!. v. Rajkumar Mills, .?>..I.R.1959 M.P.281
Pasupati Nath Dutt v. Kelvin Jute Mills, ~.I.R.1937 Cal.495 (n.B.)
Patel En22' Co. v. Com~r. for ~.c., 1978 Lab.I.C.1279 (;.P.) (D.B.)
Patel v. InsEector of Factories, Alwaye, 1958 K.L.T. 43 (D.B.)
P.E.Davis & Co. v. Kesto Routh, A.I.R.1968 Cal.129 (n.B.)
?K.?armd~ v. G.Kenal Construction & ANR., ( 1985) 1 L. L . J • 98 (Gu j.) ( D. B. )
Plumb v. Cobden Plour Hills, Q.91~ A.C.62(H.L}::
Pollachi Transeort Ltd. v. Arumuga Kounder ~.I.R.1938 Mad.485 (n.B.)
Pondicherry State .'leavers' Co-operative Societies Ltd. v. E.S.I.C. 1983 Lab. I. C. 902 (Mad.) (D. B. )
Popatlal v. Bai Lakhu, A.I.R.1952 Sau.74(D.B.)::
Pratap Nara1n ~ingh Deo v. Shrinivas Sabata, (1976) 1 L. L. J. 235 (s. C • )
President, Iron Ore and Mining Norks Co-op. Society v. Mungai Bai and others, 1 987 (54) F. L. R. 29 (M. P • )
Priestley v. Fowler, o.835-4~ All E. R. Rep. Ex.449 (Exch.)
Proerietor, Radhakrishna Estate v. MarX' 1995 (70) F.L.R.211 (Kant.)
Public Works Dept. v. Kausa, A.I.R.1966 M.P.279:
417
12,18 20
97,118
84
107, 135
64
111,155 157
• 146,158
132
62,165
80
58
146,158 159,170
106
32
84
111,133
Qualcast (Wolver hampton) Ltd. v. Haynes, g9S~ .A..C.743 (H.L.)
Quintas v. National Smelting Co. Ltd ••
Q.96!J 1 All E.R.630 (C.A.)
R. v. Industrial Injuries Commr, exp.AEU.
R. -Q96~ 1 All E.R.97 (C.A.)
Davidson & Co. v. MC Robb L.R. n.91~ A.C.304 (H.L.)
Radhamony and others v. Secretary, Dept. of Home Affairs. (1995) 1 L.L.J.376 (Ker.) (D. B. )
Raison Tailors v. E.S.I.C •• 1982 Lab.I.C. 947 (P. & H.)
Rajan v. Union of India, 1991(2) K.L.T.604
Raj a ppa v. E. 5 • I • C .• (1 992 ) 2 L. L. J • 7 1 4 (Kant.) ( D. B. )
418
20
22
136
118,132, 134
62
64
41
109, 117
Raj ~t~ri v. Superintending &ngr •• P.S.E.B.:: 110 and another. (1989) 2 L.L.J.132 (P.& H.)
Raj Rane v. Firm Narsing Dass. A.I.R.1964 55 Punj.315
Ramabrahmam v. Traffic Mgr., Vizag Port, A.I.R.1943 Mad.353 (D.B.)
Ram Naresh Singh v. Lodhna Colliery Co.Ltd., 1973 Lab.I.C.1656 (Cal.) (D.B.)
Ram Sarup v. Gurdev Sin~h, 1969 Lab.I.C. 371 (Pung.)
Rani Bala Seth v. East Indian RIt., A.I.R.1951 Cal.501 (D.B.)
Ravuri Kottaya v. Dasari Nagavardhanamma, A.I.R.1962 A.P.42
.. . .
Rebati Gantayat v. Haguru Sethi. 1986 Lab.I.C.::
1511 (Ori.)
111, 120
157
62
106, 135
90,113 114,118
54,57
~ v. Thomas, ~899J 1 Q. B.I015 {C. A.)
Reg.Dir.,E.s.I.C. v. Batulbibi, (1988) 2 L.L.J.29 (Guj.)
Reg.~ir.,2.S.I.C. v. ~acob P.K. 1981 Lab.I.C. 237 (Ker.) (D.B.)
Reg.Dir., E.S.I.C. v. L.Ranga Rao,
1981 Lab.I.C.1S63 (Kant.)
Reg.Dir., E.S.I.C. v. Mary Cutinho and others 1994 Lab.I.C.2420 (Born.)
· . · .
Reg.Dir., E.S.I.C. v. South India Flour Mills, :: 1986 Lab.I. 1193 (S.C.)
Reg.Dir., ~.S.I.C. v. Vijayamohini Mills, 1990 (1) K.L.T.540 (D.B.)
Reg.Dir., E.S.I.C. v. Vinod K.P., 1991 (2) K.L.T.138 (D.B.)
Richards v. Morris, [!91~ 1 K.B.221 (C.A.)
Rile~ v. William Holland & Sons Ltd., (}91.!l1 K.8.1029 (C.A.)
Rosin and Turpentine Factory v. Ali Beguma, 1988 Lab. I.C. NOC 23 (J. & K.) (i). B.)
Royal Talkies v. E.~.l.C., Hyderabad, 1979 Lab.I.C.1245 (S.C.)
Sabari Mills v. M.Kulan dai, (1984) 1 L.L.J.
254 (Mad.)
Sadgunaben Amrutlal v. E.S.I.C., 1981 Lab.I.C. 1653 (Guj.) (D.B.)
Salamat v. Agent, E.l.R., A.l.R.1938 Cal. .348 (D.B.)
Salambe~ v. M.S.C.L.D.B., Beed, 1990 (1 L. L. J .) 112 (Born.)
· . · .
· .
· .
· .
· .
419
113
111, 136
73
106
111,125, 133
75,79
76,79
76
105,10?, 135
118
105
76
97
103, 106
165
97,108 130
Samir u. Par1kh v. Sika~dar Zahirudd1n, 1984 Lab.r.C.521 (Born.)
SantanFernandes v. B. P • (India) Ltd., A. 1. R. 1 957 Born. 52 (!). B. )
Saraswathi Devi v. Binapani Mahatani, A.I.R.1968 Pat.344
: :
Saraswathi K. v. Narayanaswami S, 1985 A.C.J.38 (Mad.)
..
Saraswathi Press v. Nand Ram, 1971 Lab.I.C. 1341 (All.)
Sarat Chatterjee & Co.Ltd. v. Khair Unnessa, 1969 Lab.I.C.778 (Cal.) (D.B.)
Sarat Chatterjee & Co. v. Md.Khalil, 1979 Lab.I.C.401 (Cal.)
Sarjerao Unkar Jadhav v. ~urindar Singh, (1992) 1 L.L.J.156 (Som.)
Sarup S1ngh v. Mukund Lal, A.I.R.1960 Punj.119
Sathyabhama v. E.S.I.C .• 1991 (1) K.L.T.784 (D.B.)
Satiya v. 3.J.O., P.~.D., 1974 Lab.I.C. 1516 (M.?) (D.B.)
Saundatt1 v. B1yamma, (1967) 2 L.L.J.130 ( My s.) ( D. B. )
Saurashtra Salt Mfg.co. v. Bai Valu Raja, (1958) 2 L.L.J.249 (S.C.)
Secretary of State v. Mt.Geeta, A.I.R.1938 Nag. 91
Secretary of State v. Rukhmin1 bhai, A.I.R.1937 Nag.354
Sen Raleigh Ltd. v. E.3.I.C., A.I.R.1977 Cal.165 (F.B.)
Shahabad Farmers Co-operative Market1nJ-c~ ProcessIng society Ltd. v. ChatjU Ram 1989 A. C • J • 641 ( P. & H.) { D. B.
420
154. i56
118
85
56
159, 169
117
157
158
166
106
58, 132
62
103.104 108.116
59,60
39
77
166
Shankar 9alajee v. State of Maharashtra, A.l.R.1962 S.C.S17
Shankarla~ v. G.M., Central Rly., 1990 ~.C.J.1028 (M.P.)
Shanmugham v. Union of India, 1989 Lab.I.C. NOC 60 (C. A. T.) (Cal.)
421
55
146
108
Sharp v •• Tohnson & Co.Ltd., \}90~ 2 K. B.139(C.A.) 109
Sheela v. E.S.I.C. (1991) 1 L.L.J.247(P. & H.)::
Shree Krishna Rice and Flour Mills v. Challapalli ~hittemma, (1961) 2 L.L.J.260 (A.P.)
Shyama Devi v. E • .3.I.C, A.I.R.1964 All. 427 (D. B. )
Sidappa v. G.M., K.S.R.T.C., 1988 (57) F.L.R.SOO (Kant.)
Silver Jubilee Tailoring House v. Chief Inspector of Shops and Establishments, 1 974 Lab. 1. C. 133 (s • C. ) . .
Sitharama Reddiar v. AyyaSwami Gounder, A.I.R.1956 Mad.212
Smith v. Austin Lifts Ltd., and others, [!95~ 1 All E.R.80 (H.L.)
Smith v. Baker & Sons, l}89lj A.C.325 (H.L.)
105,106 109
105, 135
95
146,156 158
55
55,56 57
23
35
Somraju v. Eastern Rly., A.I.R.1961 Cal.297 106
Spencer & Co. Ltd. v. Reg.Dir., E.S.I.C., 70 Trichur, (1991) 1 L.L.J.S41 (Ker.)(T).B.)
St. Helen's Colliery Co. v. Hawitson, o.92{)A.C.59 (H.L.)
St.Joseph's A. & M.Works v. Maria Soosai Pillai, A.I.R.1953 Mad.206 ..
Stapely v. Gypsum l-tines Ltd., ~ 95~ 2 All E.R.478 (H.L.)
102.104 107,132
134
87
123
State of Kerala v. V.M. Patel, (1961) 1 L.L.J.S49 (S.C.)
State of Madras v. Sankiah Thevar, (1959) 1 L.L.J.390 (Mad.)
State of Punjab v. Vidya Devi, 1990 Lab.I.C. 742 (P. & H.)
State of Rajasthan v. Smt.Kanta, (1989) 2 L.L.J.135 (Raj.)
· . · .
Steel v. Cammell, Laird & Co., \} 90SJ 2 K. B. 232:
Steel Authority of India Ltd. v. K.Mohantx, 1994 Lab.I.C.1528 (Ori.)
Stephen v. Cooper, Q.92~ A.C.570 (H.L.)
Sukhai v. Hukan Chand Jute lUlls,A.I.R.1957 Ca!. 501 (D. B.)
Sukhnandan Thakur v. State of Bihar, A.I.R.1957 Pat.617.
· . · .
· . · .
Suhas Chandra Base v. S.3.I.C., 1989 Lab.I.C ... 776 (Cal.) (D.B.)
Sundarbai v. G.M., Ordnance Factory, 1976 Lab.I.C.1163 (M.P. ) (D.B.)
Superintending Engr., Parambikulam Aliyar Project, Pollachi v. Andammal, ('1983) 2 L.L.J.326 (Maj.)
Suppiah Chettiar v. Chinna thurai, A.I.R.1957 Mad.215
Talcher Thermal Station v. Biju11 Na1k, 1994 Lab.I.C.1379 (Ori.)
T.D. & Co. Oil Mills v. E.S.I.C., h.I.R.1968 A.P.210
The Special Officer v. Ayyammal, 1994 Lab.I.e.NOe 326 (Mad.) (0.8.)
422
55
112
169
131
99
106
126,127
148
102
73
94.97 99,137
129
167
97,99, 104,117, 121,125,
134
117
122, 125
Thiagar~~ Chettiar K v. ~.S.I.C., A.I.R.1963 Mad.361 (~.8.)
Thom:>r 5im:pson v. Sinclair,[i.91'f] A.C.127(H.L.)
rhomas v. ~, 1995 (1) K.L.T.4
Thomas v. Bristol Aeroplane Co. Ltd., \}95ij 1 W.L.R.694 (C.A.)
.. . . _T_h_o_m~p_s_o_n __ a_n_d __ O~t_h_e_r v. Smiths Ship repairers (North Shields) Ltd., and Other actions, V,984] 1 All E.R.881 (O.B.D.)·
Tiruchy v. Kanagambal, 1995 Lab.I.C.NOC 48(Mad.)
TNCS Corpn. Ltd. v. S.Poomalai, (1995) 1 L.L.J.378 (Mad.)
Tobacco Mfrs. (India) Ltd. v. ~arian ~te~art, .. A.I.R.1950 Cal.164 (D.B.)
roronto Power Co. Ltd. v. Kate Pakistan, U 915] A. C. 734 (? ::. )
Trim v. Kelley, \} 914] A.·:. 667
Ukhra Farming Corporation Ltd. v. Satu bala 9adini, A.I.R.1955 Cal.105
Union of India v. Mohd. ','lasi, 1980 Lab. I. C.
NOC 57 (All.)
Union of India v. Noorjahan, 1979 Lab.I.C. 652 (All.)
United India Insurance Co.Ltd. v. C.S.Gopala- :: krishnan, 1989 Lab.I.C.1906(Ker.)(D.B.)
United India Insurance Co.Ltd., v. Heera Bai. ::
1987 (54) F.L.R.S07 (M.P.)
United India Insurance Co.Ltd. v. Sethu Madhavan 1992 (2) K.L.T.702 (D.B.)
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Yasodhara Amrn~1 (1990) 1 L.L.J.387 (Ker.) (D.B.)
423
76
119,120
54,57
21
16
110,123 133
106
102,131, 132,133
27
97,99
61
58
102,10S, 115,132,
135
119
115
157,158 159
95,97 121
Upton v. G.e. Rly. Co., Q.924J A.C.302
U.JayaraJ v. Thanthai Periyar Transport Corpn.Ltd., (1989) 2 L.L.J.38(Mad.)
Varadarajulu Naidu v. M.Boyan, A.I.K.1954 Mad. 1113 (D • B. )
varke~achan v. Thomrnan Thomas, 1979 Lab.I.C. 986 (Ker.) (D.B.)
Veerappan v. Muthamma Veerappan, 1995 Lab.I.C.:: 484 (Ker.) (O.B.)
Vellaichamy P.L. v. Union of India, 1991 Lab.I.C.304 (Mad.)
Venkatanarasayyamma v. Subba Laxmi, 1986 Lab.I.C.1389 (~.P.)
Vijay Ram v. Chander Prakash, 1981 Lab.I.C. 359 (J. & K.)
424
118
158
105,107 135
113,132
90
85
169,170
57
Vijay Ram v. Janak Raj, 1981 Lab.I.C.143(J.& K.): 169
Vinayaka Mudaliar T. v. Mindala Pottiamma, 58 A.I.R.1953 Mad.432
Vishram Yesu Haldankar v. Dad babhox Hormasji
& Co., A.I.R.1942 Bom.29.
'Ratt v. Hertfordshire County Council, Q.954J 2 All E.R.368 (C.A.)
Weaver v. Tredegar Iron & Coal Co. Ltd., ~ 94~ 3 All E. R. 157 (H. L. )
Webber v. Wansborough Paper Co. Ltd., [1915J
A.C.S1 (H.L.)
Western ~ly. v. Lala Nanda, 1984 Lab.I.C. 245 (Guj.)
',olhittle v. Ebbwvale, Steel, Iron & Co. Ltd.,
fl.9361 2 All E.R.1221 (C.A.). '- -
.. . .
. . . .
120
14,20
104,105 107,132
135
132
169
118
3hankar Balajee v. State of Maharashtra, A.I.R.1962 S.C.517
Shankarla~ v. G.M., Central RIl" 1990 ~.C.J.1028 (M.P.)
Shanmuqham v. Union of India, 1989 Lab.I.C. NOC 60 (C. A. T .) (Cal.)
421
55
146
1J8
Sharp v. Johnson & co. Ltd., IT 90~ 2 K. B. 139(C. A. ) 109
Sheela v. E.S.I.C. (1991) 1 L.L.J.247(P. & H.)::
Shree Krishna Rice and Flour Mills v. Challapalli ~hittemma, (1961) 2 L.L.J.260 (A.P.)
Shyama Devi v. E. s. I. C, A. r. R. 1964 All. 427 (D • B. )
Sidappa v. G.M., K.S.R.T.C., 1988 (57) F.L.R.SOO (Kant.)
Silver Jubilee Tailoring House v. Chief Inspector of Shops and Establishments, 1974 Lab.I.C.133 (S.C.) ::
Sitharama Reddiar v. Ayyaswami Gounder, A.I.R.1956 Mad.212
Smith v. Austin Lifts Ltd., anj others, [!95~ 1 All E.R.80 (H.L.)
Smith v. Baker & Sons, \].89!} A.C.325 (H.L.)
105,106 109
105, 135
95
146,156 158
55
55,56 57
23
35
Somraju v. Eastern Rly ., A.I.R.1961 Cal.297 106
Spencer & co. Ltd. v. Reg.Dir., E.S.I.C.,.. 70 Trichur, (1991) 1 L.L.J.541 (Ker.)(D.B.)
St. Helen's Colliery Co. v. Hawitson, n92~A.C.59 (H.L.)
St.Jose2h's A. & M.Works v. Maria Soosai Pillai, A.I.R.1953 Mad.206 ..
Stapely v. Gypsum 1-lines Ltd., ~ 95:D
2 All E.R.478 (H.L.)
102~ 104 107,132
134
87
123
~11liams v. B1rmin~ham Battery and Metal Co., Q.89~ 2 Q.B.338 (C.A.)
Wilson v. !yneside 4indo~ Cleaning Co.,
t!:958J 2 All S.R.265 (C.A.)
Wilsons and Clyde Coal Co. v. En]lish,
lJ.93'fl 3 All S.R.628 (H.L.)
Works Manager, C. & w. Shop v. Mahabir, A.I.R.19S4 All.132
Young v. Hoffman Mfg. Co., \} 907J 2 K. B.
646 (C.A.)
425
24
18
2e,3~
49,102 105,105
139
33
top related