american foreign policy - ms. lagleder's online...
TRANSCRIPT
APUSH Super Saturday
American Foreign
Policy
What is Foreign Policy?
American Foreign Policy
1789-1941
A Brief Overview
Factors that influence Foreign Policy
• Geography
• Military needs/power
• Economic needs/power
• Ethnic/cultural ties
• History
US Foreign Policy (FP) A Brief History
5
1798-1941 The Isolationist Era
1942-1945 World War II (start of “Globalism”)
1990-present Post-Cold War
1946-1989 The Cold War
New category after 9/11/2001
An Endless Argument:
• Should American policy be based on our
own national interests (protecting our
independence, borders, security, power
and interests in peace) or should we take
the “high road” and base our policies on
moral principles (human rights,
democracy, freedom) that could serve as a
model for others?
Brief History of U.S. Foreign Policy • Isolationism
A foreign policy built on the principle of avoiding formal military and political alliances with other countries.
• The Isolationist Era
– 1st 150 yrs of US History
• Adherence to guidance of Washington’s Farwell address
• Stressed avoiding political connections overseas
• Pursue commercial trade ties only
– US militarily weak & focused on expansion westward
– Not interested in global role (2 oceans of separation)
7
John Quincy Adams: Secretary of State to
James Monroe 1817-1825
• Very successful
• Clear vision of U.S.
policy
• Philosophy: National
interests should
determine foreign
policy
John Quincy Adams: Accomplishments
• Adams-Onis Treaty
gives Florida
(strategic
importance) to US,
eliminated Spain
from contention for
Oregon Territory
• Architect of Monroe
Doctrine
• Adams’ Vision:
expansion of US to the
Pacific, pursuit of good
relations with newly
independent nations in
Latin America.
The Monroe Doctrine (1823)
Stressed America’s special
interests in the Western
Hemisphere and remains, with
some modifications, viable today.
In response to fears that
European powers including Britain
might expand its influence into the
Western Hemisphere.
Monroe Doctrine (1823) • Invoked 1895: early foreign policy involvement outside US (T.
Roosevelt)
– Aim: Protect US interest in Western Hemisphere
– US military intervention escalated beginning in 1898:
12
Late 19th Century Imperialism: The USA
Enters the World Stage
• Economic motivations: new markets, new resources
• Ideas about racial supremacy driven by Social
Darwinism
• Manifest Destiny-extended (Frontier through 1890)
• Military considerations (strategic, defensive)
• Alfred Mahan & “The New Navy” Great White
Fleet.
• US Exceptionalism
Early Non-Contiguous Expansion
• Offer to purchase Cuba from Spain in 1848 and 1854
• Alaska 1867
• Pago-Pago, Samoa 1878
• Pearl Harbor 1884
• Hawaii 1898
Spanish American War 1898-1900
• Cuba (for “freedom”?)
• “USS Maine” incident, yellow journalism, jingoism & war fever
• Rough Riders & Theodore Roosevelt
• US acquires Philippines, Puerto Rico, Guam
McKinley, T. Roosevelt & Taft
• McKinley: Open Door Policy, Spanish
American War
• Roosevelt: Panama Canal, Roosevelt
Corollary to Monroe Doctrine,
“Walk Softly and Carry a Big Stick”
• Taft: Dollar Diplomacy (private funds to
pursue diplomatic goals)
WWI: From Neutrality to
Versailles
• Traditional neutrality
• Challenges to neutrality:
u-boats, US business loans,
munitions trade, propaganda,
some pro-war advocates (ex: TR)
• Wilson’s 1916 Pledge: To keep us out of
war ( helped him get re-elected)
• Wilson’s 1917 statement to “make the world safe for democracy”.
RMS Lusitania
Wilson’s 14 Points & Versailles Treaty & the “Lessons of War”
• 14 Points largely disregarded
• Fight for Ratification of the Treaty
• Henry Cabot Lodge and American Isolationists prevail-reject League of Nations
• US returns to its “isolationist” position vs. Europe
• “Lessons” of WWI, Red Scare & Peace Movement
20
World War I
• US deviated from Isolationism briefly during WWI
WW1 (W. Wilson)=> make world “safe for democracy”
After WW1=> isolationism returns w/vengeance
Senate rejects League of Nations & Versailles treaty
Sets the stage for next global war => ?
American Isolationism
5 Isolationists like Senator Lodge, refused to allow the US to sign the Versailles Treaty.
5 Security treaty with France also rejected by the Senate.
5 July, 1921 Congress passed a resolution declaring WW I officially over!
Sen. Henry Cabot
Lodge, Sr. [R-MA]
Five-Power Treaty (1922)
5 A battleship ratio was achieved through this ratio: US Britain Japan France Italy 5 5 3 1.67 1.67
5 Japan got a guarantee that the US and Britain would stop fortifying their Far East territories [including the Philippines].
5 Loophole no restrictions on small warships
Dawes Plan (1924)
European Debts to the US
Hyper-Inflation in Germany: 1923
Locarno Pact (1925)
5 Guaranteed the common boundaries of Belgium, France, and Germany as specified in the Treaty of Versailles of 1919.
5 Germany signed treaties with Poland and Czechoslovakia, agreeing to change the eastern borders of Germany by arbitration only.
Clark Memorandum (1928)
5 Clark pledged that the US would not intervene in Latin American affairs in order to protect US property rights.
5 This was a complete rebuke of the Roosevelt Corollary to the Monroe Doctrine!
Secretary of State
J. Reuben Clark
Kellogg-Briand Pact (1928)
5 15 nations dedicated to outlawing aggression and war as tools of foreign policy.
5 62 nations signed.
5 Problems no means of actual enforcement and gave Americans a false sense of security.
Japanese Attack Manchuria (1931)
5 League of Nations condemned the action.
5 Japan leaves the League.
5 Hoover wanted no part in an American military action in the Far East.
Ludlow Amendment (1938)
A proposed amendment to the Constitution that called for a national referendum on any declaration of war by Congress.
Introduced several times by Congressman Ludlow.
Never actually passed.
Congressman Louis Ludlow
[D-IN]
Neutrality Acts: 1935, 1936, 1937 When the President proclaimed the existence of a foreign
war, certain restrictions would automatically go into effect:
Prohibited sales of arms to belligerent nations.
Prohibited loans and credits to belligerent nations.
Forbade Americans to travel on vessels of nations at war [in contrast to WW I].
Non-military goods must be purchased on a “cash-and-carry” basis pay when goods are picked up.
Banned involvement in the Spanish Civil War.
This limited the options of the President in a crisis.
America in the 1930s declined to build up its forces!
US Neutrality
Panay Incident (1937)
December 12, 1937.
Japan bombed USS Panay gunboat & three Standard Oil tankers on the Yangtze River.
The river was an international waterway.
Japan was testing US resolve!
Japan apologized, paid US an indemnity, and promised no further attacks.
Most Americans were satisfied with the apology.
Results Japanese interpreted US tone as a license for further aggression against US interests.
1939 Neutrality Act In response to Germany’s invasion of Poland.
FDR persuades Congress in special session to allow the US to aid European democracies in a limited way:
The US could sell weapons to the European democracies on a “cash-and-carry” basis.
FDR was authorized to proclaim danger zones which US ships and citizens could not enter.
Results of the 1939 Neutrality Act:
Aggressors could not send ships to buy US munitions.
The US economy improved as European demands for war goods helped bring the country out of the 1937-38 recession.
America becomes the “Arsenal of Democracy.”
“Lend-Lease” Act (1941) Great Britain.........................$31 billion Soviet Union...........................$11 billion France......................................$ 3 billion China.......................................$1.5 billion Other European.................$500 million South America...................$400 million The amount totaled: $48,601,365,000
A date which will live in infamy!
Pearl Harbor – Dec. 7, 1941
37
Globalism Era => The Cold War 1945-1990s
• Globalism:
– US should be prepared to use military force around the globe to protect its political & economic interests
• Following WWII => who emerges as primary thereat to US political & military interest?
• Presidential doctrine formulated as a result?
• Truman Doctrine:
– US would actively oppose communists’ attempts to overthrow or conquer non-communist nations
38
Containment A bedrock principle of U.S. foreign policy from mid 1940s to early 1990s that emphasized the
need to contain any further Soviet territorial & communist ideological expansion.
Marshall Plan: US commitment to rebuild Europe
$100 Billion+ appropriated for task in today’s $$$
Soviets initially invited to participate (reaction?)
YOUR VIEW: Which goal should be most important today? Why?
• 1. Preserve independence
• 2. Maintain security for the nation
• 3. Seek prosperity for the nation
• 4. Seek revenge or prestige
• 5. Spread ideals or ideas
Legacy of World War II on American Foreign Policy
• New World Order – U.S. virtually unscathed from war
destruction
– Imperialist powers and Axis belligerents weakened • Decolonization
– Non-Alignment Movement
– Superpowers • United States and Soviet Union
• State of Israel – Involvement in Middle East affairs
• National and International Defense – Reorganization of diplomatic and
military bureaucracy
– United Nations and Security Council
Understanding the Cold War
Superpower nations after WWII
– Soviet Union = communism, police state
– United States = capitalism, democracy
Cold War meant a “war of words” rather than outright conflict
– However, the Cold War includes episodes of “hot” conflicts in various regions around the world.
United Nations General Assembly
– Member nations convened to develop a postwar world to combat global issues while respecting sovereignty and peace.
Security Council – 15-member body to authorize
peacekeeping and promote international security
– Permanent Members
United States, Soviet Union, Great Britain, France, China
Resolutions must be unanimous
Occupation of Japan
• Reform
– Emperor as ceremonial role
– Democratization
– Breakup of conglomerates
– Demilitarization
• Economic Recovery
– Avoid communist incursion
• Peace and Alliance
General Douglas MacArthur and
Emperor Hirohito
Iron Curtain
German Occupation Zones – Democratic Republic of Germany
(East Germany)
– Federal Republic of Germany (West Germany)
Eastern Europe – Soviet Union did not withdraw
its troops from occupied Eastern Europe
– Virtually forced communist regimes on Eastern European
Harry S. Truman (D) (1945-1953) Containment Truman Doctrine (Containment)
– Provide economic and military support for nations threatened by communism
– Greece and Turkey
National Security Act (1947)
– Department of Defense
– National Security Council (NSC)
– Central Intelligence Agency (CIA)
NSC-68 (1950)
– Justify defense spending and arms buildup as necessary
– Establish alliances with non-communist nations
Truman & Containment (1945-1953) Cold War Alliances
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO)
– Permanent alliance between U.S., Canada, and Western Europe
– If one member is attacked, all treaty nations will defend
Warsaw Pact
– Soviet Union’s version of NATO
– Eastern European satellite nations
47
NATO
Cold War Military Alliances
Warsaw
Pact
Truman & Containment (1945-1953) Berlin Airlift
Soviet Union establishes blockade of West Berlin
U.S. and allies launch aerial campaign from 1948-1949
– Drop food and fuel to citizens
Extremely successful
– Over 200,000 flights
– 47,000 tons daily
Truman & Containment (1945-1953) Marshall Plan
European Recovery Program – $13 billion in grants
– Rebuild and develop European infrastructure
Designed to prevent communist uprisings or infiltration in vulnerable nations
Truman & Containment (1945-1953) Korean Conflict (1950-1953)
North Korean Invasion (1950) – Advised by Soviet Union and China
Truman and United Nations Intervention – General Douglas MacArthur launched
successful counterattack
– Repulsed to 38th parallel by Chinese support troops
Armistice (1953) – 38th parallel: Communist North and
Democratic South
– Truman win/lose Containment worked
“soft on Communism”
Nuclear Arms Race Nuclear weapon
development – United States develops
weapons with higher yields
Soviet Union – Detonated first nuclear
weapon (August 1949)
United Kingdom – Detonated first nuclear
weapon (October 1952)
France – Detonated first nuclear
weapon (February 1960)
China – Detonated first nuclear
weapon (October 1964)
Second Red Scare (1947-1957)
Government Policies
– Loyalty Review Board
– McCarran Internal Security Act (1950)
House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC)
– Investigate Americans for pro-communist beliefs and blacklisting
Senator Joseph McCarthy (R)
– McCarthyism
Espionage
– Alger Hiss
– Klaus Fuchs
– Julia and Ethel Rosenberg
Dwight D. Eisenhower (R) (1953-1961) Brinkmanship
Secretary of State John F. Dulles – Massive Retaliation
Domino Theory
Eisenhower Doctrine
– Extension of Truman Doctrine to Middle East
Covert Operations – Operation Ajax (1953) - Iran covert operation by the United States CIA in
collaborating with the Pahlavi dynasty, to overthrow the elected government
– Operation PBSUCCESS (1954) – Guatemala covert operation carried out by the United States Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) that deposed the democratically elected Guatemalan President Jacobo Árbenz and ended the Guatemalan Revolution
Temporary Thaw with Soviet Union
– “Atoms for Peace” (1953)
Hungarian Revolt (1956)
Sputnik (1957)
U-2 Incident (1960)
Eisenhower & Brinkmanship (1953-1961) Soviet Union
Eisenhower & Brinkmanship (1953-1961) Vietnam and Cuba
• Vietnam
– Geneva Conference (1954)
– Ho Chi Minh and North Vietnam
– Southeast Asia Treaty Organization (SEATO) (1954)
• Cuba
– Fidel Castro and Revolution • Deposes Fulgencio Batista (1959)
– American Embargo
– Cuban Alliance with Soviet Union
Eisenhower & Brinkmanship (1953-1961) Farewell Address (1961)
• “Military-Industrial Complex”
– Cold War and Arms Race implications
– Warning of a military-corporate state
John F. Kennedy (D) (1961-1963) Flexible Response
Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara
– Develop conventional military strategies and policies
– Nuclear weapon escalation as last phase
Alliance for Progress (1961)
– Economic cooperation with Latin America
Peace Corps (1961)
American University Speech (1963)
– Nuclear Test Ban Treaty (1963)
Vietnam (1963)
– Military advisors for South Vietnam and Ngo Dinh Diem
Kennedy & Flexible Response (1961-1963) Berlin Wall
Berlin Crisis (1961)
Berlin Wall (1961)
– Checkpoint Charlie
“Ich Bin Ein Berliner” (1963)
Premier Nikita Khrushchev and JFK (1961)
Kennedy & Flexible Response (1961-1963) Cuba
Bay of Pigs Invasion (1961)
Soviet missiles in Cuba
Cuban Missile Crisis (1962)
Lyndon B. Johnson (D) (1963-1969) Vietnam
Gulf of Tonkin (August 1964)
– Incident - North Vietnamese fired upon U.S. warships
– Resolution - Congress authorized combat troops through Johnson’s urging
Escalation
– Operation Rolling Thunder
– Troops increases from 1964 to 1969
540,000 at most during Vietnam Conflict
Tet Offensive (January 1968)
– Vietcong launch surprise attack
– U.S. military victory but political and popular victory for Minh and North Vietnamese
Johnson & Vietnam (1963-1969) War and Tragedy
Space Race National Aeronautic and Space
Administration (NASA) (1958) – Response to Sputnik and Yuri
Gagarin
– Mercury Program
Alan Shepard
– First American in space (1961)
John Glenn
– First American to orbit Earth (1962)
Kennedy’s Race to the Moon – Apollo Program
– Apollo 11 (1969)
“One small step for man, one giant leap for mankind” - Neil Armstrong
Richard M. Nixon (R) (1969-1974) Detente
Secretary of State Henry Kissinger
Nixon Doctrine
Vietnamization
Visit to China (1972) – Met with Chairman Mao
– Virtual recognition of Communist China
Soviet Union and Leonid Brezhnev – Visit to Moscow (1972)
– Strategic Arms Limitation Treaty (SALT I) (1972)
OPEC’s Oil Embargo (1973)
Nixon & Detente (1969-1974) Vietnamization • Purpose
– Expand, equip, and train South Vietnamese – Reduce American troop involvement – “Peace with honor”
• Cambodia bombings • My Lai Massacre (1968)
– U.S. troops slaughtered women and children • Pentagon Papers (1971)
– Avoid defeat and ensure containment – NOT to help a friend – New York Times v. United States (1971)
• War Powers Act (1973) – 48 hours advance notice – 60 day military authorization, 30 day withdrawal
• Paris Peace Accords (1973)
Gerald R. Ford (R) (1974-1977) Detente
Helsinki Accords-signed the declaration in an attempt to improve relations between the Communist bloc and the West. The Helsinki Accords, however, were not binding as they did not have treaty status.
Strategic Arms Limitation Treaty (SALT I) -froze the number of strategic ballistic missile launchers at existing levels
Vietnam-Fall of Saigon (1975)
Jimmy Carter (D) (1977-1981) Human Rights
• Panama Canal Treaty (1977)
• Camp David Accords (1978) – Peace between Egypt and Israel
• SALT II (1979)
• Soviet Union and Afghanistan (1979) – Boycott of Moscow Olympics (1980)
• Iranian Revolution (1979) – Ayatollah Khomeini
– 55 American hostages for 444 days
– Operation Eagle Claw (1980)
Ronald Reagan (R) (1981-1989) Rollback
Reagan Doctrine – Provide support for
resistance movements against communist governments
– “peace through strength” Operation Cyclone (1979-1989)
– Support of Mujahideen in Afghanistan
Lebanon (1983) – Marines barracks bombing
Grenada (1983) – Operation Urgent Fury
Libya Bombings (1986)
Reagan & Rollback (1981-1989) Iran-Contra Affair
• Iran-Iraq War
– U.S. sold weapons to both sides; mostly to Saddam Hussein and Iraq
• Nicaragua
– Sandinistas
– Contras
– Boland Amendment (1985)
• Iran-Contra Affair
– Colonel Oliver North
– Weapons sales to Iran funded Contras against Sandinistas
Reagan & Rollback (1981-1989) Soviet Union and Gorbachev
“Evil Empire”
– Strategic Defense System (SDI) - “Star Wars”
– Brandenburg Gate "Mr. Gorbachev, Tear Down This
Wall."
Mikhail Gorbachev’s Reforms
– Glasnost Openness and freedom of
expression
– Perestroika Gradual capitalist reforms
George H.W. Bush (R) (1989-1993) End of Cold War
Iron Curtain Falls – Germany
Berlin Wall falls (1989) and Reunification (1990) – Eastern Europe
Poland and Solidarity – Soviet Union
Dissolution (1991) START I (1991) and START II (1993)
China and Tiananmen Square (1989)
H.W. Bush & End of Cold War (1989-1993) Panama and Persian Gulf War and Somalia
• Operation Just Cause (1989-1990) – Invasion of Panama
• Operation Desert Storm (1991) – Iraq invaded Kuwait
– Coalition victory over Iraq
• Operation Restore Hope (1992-1993) – Somalia
– Continued through Clinton administration
Bill Clinton (D) (1993-2001) Foreign Policy
• North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) (1993)
• Bosnia (1995-1999)
• Globalization – World Trade Organization
(WTO)
– World Bank
– International Monetary Fund (IMF)
– Group of 8 (G-8) Foreign Policy Shifter, 1994 Seattle Post-Intelligencer
George W. Bush (R) (2001-2009) War on Terror
• 9/11
• Bush Doctrine
– Afghanistan
– Iraq
• Homeland Security
• USA PATRIOT Act
Obama and Today’s World (2009-Present) • Death of Osama bin Laden
• Iraq – Ended occupation
• Afghanistan – Taliban resurgence
• Arab Spring – Egypt
– Libya
– Syria
• Ukraine – Crimea
76
Unilateralism:
The tendency of the US to act alone in foreign affairs without consulting other
countries.
Multilateralism:
Three or more Nations cooperate together to solve some common foreign policy problem
Unilateralism vs. Multilateralism
Particular approach selected will depend on the major
FP problems the US will face during the 21st Century
77
The United States will face complex problems in:
• Nuclear proliferation (North Korea & Iran)
• Military interventions (The Middle East & exiting Iraq)
• Economic policy (Trade imbalance w/China & ME Oil prices)
• Globalization (Global interdependence & domestic impact)
• “Inter-mestic” issues (Foreign Policy impact at home)
• Human rights (American ideals vs. US National interests)
• Homeland Security (Balancing security with liberties)
• The unknown threat (Future “9/11s”?)
Potential Problems in US Foreign Policy for 21st Century