alcheringa an australasian journal of palaeontology volume 34 issue 3 2010 [doi...

Upload: diana-mendonca

Post on 02-Jun-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    1/13

    This article was downloaded by: [University of Chicago Library]On: 24 August 2013, At: 03:22Publisher: Taylor & FrancisInforma Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registeredoffice: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

    Alcheringa: An Australasian Journal of

    PalaeontologyPublication details, including instructions for authors and

    subscription information:

    http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/talc20

    A review of Australasian ichthyosaursMaria Zammit

    a

    aSchool of Earth and Environmental Sciences, North Terrace

    Campus, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia, 5005,Australia

    Published online: 01 Jun 2010.

    To cite this article:Maria Zammit (2010) A review of Australasian ichthyosaurs, Alcheringa: An

    Australasian Journal of Palaeontology, 34:3, 281-292, DOI: 10.1080/03115511003663939

    To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03115511003663939

    PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE

    Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (theContent) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis,our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as tothe accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinionsand views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors,and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Contentshould not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sourcesof information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims,proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever orhowsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arisingout of the use of the Content.

    This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Anysubstantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms &Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions

    http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditionshttp://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditionshttp://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditionshttp://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03115511003663939http://www.tandfonline.com/action/showCitFormats?doi=10.1080/03115511003663939http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/talc20http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditionshttp://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditionshttp://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03115511003663939http://www.tandfonline.com/action/showCitFormats?doi=10.1080/03115511003663939http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/talc20
  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    2/13

    A review of Australasian ichthyosaurs

    MARIA ZAMMIT

    Zammit, M., September, 2010. A review of Australasian ichthyosaurs. Alcheringa 34, 281292. ISSN 0311-5518.

    Ichthyosaur fossils have been recorded from four landmasses in the Australasian regionAustralia, New Zealand,

    New Caledonia and Timorand occur in all three systems of the Mesozoic. Most of the remains are non-diagnostic,

    but at least three genera have been identified:Mixosaurus, from the Middle Triassic of Timor;Shonisaurus, from the

    Upper Triassic of New Caledonia; and Platypterygius, from the Lower Cretaceous of Australia and New Zealand. Of

    these, Platypterygiuscontains the only material that can be diagnosed to species level. However, current taxonomy of

    the specimens is controversial, with two synonyms, P. australis and P. longmani, persisting in the literature. An

    examination of cranial traits in the quasi-holotype ofP. australis vs P. longmanidemonstrates that they represent

    the same taxon. Thus, P. longmanishould be regarded as the junior synonym. A neotype is also here designated for

    P. australis to replace the original, which is presumed lost.

    Maria Zammit [[email protected]], School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, North Terrace

    Campus, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia 5005, Australia. Received 14.12.2009, revised 21.1.2010,

    accepted 26.1.2010.

    Key words: Ichthyosauria, New Zealand, New Caledonia, Timor, Australia, high-latitude, Mesozoic.

    ICHTHYOSAURS were a group of extinct,

    dolphin-like marine reptiles that ranged

    from the Early Triassic (Spathian) until

    the Late Cretaceous (Cenomanian: McGo-

    wan & Motani 2003). In Australasia, their

    remains span most of this range (Fig. 1),

    with material from the Triassic of New

    Zealand, Timor and New Caledonia (Call-

    away & Massare 1989), Lower Jurassic of

    New Zealand (Sachs & Grant-Mackie

    2003), and LowerUpper Cretaceous of

    Australia (Kear 2003) and New Zealand(Fleming et al. 1971).

    The earliest published accounts of these

    ichthyosaurs come from Australia (McCoy

    1867a) and New Zealand (Haast 1871,

    Hector 1874), with later records from Timor

    (Broili 1931) and New Caledonia (Campbell

    1984). Much of the described material

    can not be confidently attributed to a family

    or genus (Fleming et al. 1971). However,

    remains from the Cretaceous of Australia

    have diagnostic features, although their

    taxonomic status is still controversial (Wade

    1990, McGowan & Motani 2003, Kear

    2005a).

    This review has two primary aims: (1) to

    summarize the record of ichthyosaur fossils

    from the Australasian region, including

    previously unpublished occurrences; and

    (2) to discuss and resolve the taxonomy of

    the Australian Cretaceous material.

    Institutional abbreviations: AM, Australian

    Museum, Sydney, Australia; GS, Geologi-

    cal Survey, Wellington, New Zealand; MV,

    Museum Victoria, Melbourne, Australia;

    WAM, Western Australian Museum, Perth,

    Australia.

    Regional setting

    Eastern Australia, New Zealand and NewCaledonia were situated in the southeast

    corner of Gondwana throughout the early

    Mesozoic (Audley-Charles 1978, Fleming

    ISSN 0311-5518 (print)/ISSN 1752-0754 (online) 2010 Association of Australasian PalaeontologistsDOI: 10.1080/03115511003663939

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    3/13

    1979) and thus experienced a convergent

    tectonic regime until the split of the

    supercontinent. New Zealand and New

    Caledonia are composite landmasses that

    assembled from disparate terranes duringthis time (Aitchisonet al. 1995, Landiset al.

    1999) but have elements of a common

    (convergent margin) geological history

    (Laird & Bradshaw 2004). The two regions

    may have retained connections until the

    opening of the New Caledonia Basin in the

    Late Cretaceous (Schellartet al. 2006), post-

    dating the initiation of separation fromAustralia (Aitchison et al. 1995). Rifting

    associated with the anticlockwise break-up

    of eastern Gondwana initiated in the

    Fig. 1. A, Map of ichthyosaur fossil localities in Australia, modified from Kear (2003). B, Map of ichthyosaur fossil

    localities in New Zealand, modified from Fordyce (1982).C, Map of ichthyosaur fossil localities in New Caledonia,modified from Campbell (1979). D (inset), Scale map of Australia, New Caledonia, New Zealand, and Timor

    showing relative size and position of the landmasses. Symbols: triangle, Triassic specimen; square, Jurassic specimen;

    circle, Cretaceous specimen.

    282 MARIA ZAMMIT ALCHERINGA

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    4/13

    Jurassic of northwestern Australia (Veevers

    et al. 1991) and resulted in separation of

    New Zealand from Australia by the earlyCenozoic (Schellart et al . 2006; but see

    Laird & Bradshaw 2004 for an alternative

    view). In contrast, little separation oc-

    curred between Timor and Australia

    throughout the Mesozoic since the forma-

    tion of Timor on the passive Tethyan

    margin of Gondwana (Audley-Charles

    1978). Large areas of western, southern,

    and eastern Australia were flooded by

    shallow epicontinental seas in the mid-Cretaceous (Frakes et al. 1987), and the

    region has occupied mid- to high-latitude

    settings throughout much of the Mesozoic

    (Embleton 1984).

    Review of Australasianichthyosaur taxa

    Triassic specimens

    New Zealand has most Triassic specimens,

    with isolated ichthyosaur bones occurring

    on both the North and South islands (Fig.

    1B). The first reported finds originated

    from the Mount Potts region near Canter-

    bury, South Island (Hector 1874, 1879),

    and have since been referred to the Middle

    Triassic (Table 1) Daonella Zone (lower

    Carnian; Campbell & Warren 1965). These

    remains comprise indeterminate vertebralcentra of extremely large dimensions

    (457 mm in diameter, Hector 1878) that

    appear to represent one of the largest

    ichthyosaurs in the world (Campbell 1965,

    Fleming et al. 1971). This is almost double

    the diameter of centra known from Shoni-

    saurus sikanniensis, an animal well known

    as a giant (Nicholls & Manabe 2004).

    Unfortunately, these particular specimens

    can not be located, and are presumed tohave been either sent to the US with other

    marine reptile bones that have now van-

    ished (Cox 1991), or alternatively lost on

    the transport ship Matoaka, which disap-

    peared en route to London (Hector 1874,

    Brazier et al. 1990). Hector (1874) diag-nosed this material, together with several

    smaller vertebral centra from Rocky

    Gully, near Mount Potts, as Ichthyosaurus

    australis (a name pre-occupied by an

    Australian species). Replacement names

    include I. hectori(Lydekker 1889, Chapman

    1914) and I. pottsi(see Fleming et al. 1971),

    though none is currently considered valid.

    This material was assigned to the Mixosaur-

    idae by Campbell (1965), but was laterregarded as simply ichthyosaurian due to a

    lack of diagnostic features (Fleming et al.

    1971). Campbell (1965) assigned a partial

    rostrum with teeth from the upper Carnian

    (Triassic) Mandeville Sandstone (Fordyce

    2003) of Otamita Stream, South Island, to

    the Shastasauridae, but this was also later

    considered to be a taxonomically unidentifi-

    able ichthyosaur (Fleming et al . 1971).

    Further Triassic ichthyosaur specimens from

    South Island, New Zealand, include unde-

    scribed partial ribs and a partial humerus

    from the Kiritehere coast (latest Carnian to

    early Norian; Sachs & Grant-Mackie 2003),

    a series of vertebral centra from Roaring

    Bay, South Otago (Carnian), and teeth and

    a series of vertebral centra from Etal Creek,

    Southland (Anisian; Fordyce 1991)the

    latter possibly constitute the oldest known

    ichthyosaur material from Australasia (For-

    dyce 1982). Putative ichthyosaurian teethare known from Nugget Point and the

    Wairoa district, but they exhibit labyrintho-

    dont characters (Hector 1878, 1879, Worley

    1894) and may derive from amphibians

    (Fordyce 1982).

    Triassic (Norian) ichthyosaur remains

    have also been reported from New

    Caledonia (Mazin 1985) and Timor (Mazin

    1983). The jaw fragments from the

    Norian Ouamoui Formation (Callaway &Massare 1989) of New Caledonia were

    originally considered plesiosaurian (Camp-

    bell 1984), but have been referred to

    ALCHERINGA AUSTRALASIAN ICHTHYOSAURS 283

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    5/13

    Formation

    Location

    Age

    Taxonomicassignment

    ToolebucFormation

    Queensland,Australia1,

    2,

    3,

    4

    late

    Albian5,

    6

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    AllaruMu

    dstone

    Queensland,Australia1,

    2,

    3,

    4

    mid

    -lateAlbian8

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    WallumbillaFormation

    Queensland1,

    2,

    3,

    4

    andNewSouth

    earlyAptianlateAlbian10

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    Wales9,Au

    stralia

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    Doncaster

    Member

    NewSouthWales,

    Apt

    ian12,

    13,

    14,

    15

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    (WallumbillaFormation)

    Australia1

    1

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    BulldogSh

    ale

    SouthAus

    tralia16

    Apt

    ian12,

    13,

    14,

    15

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    BirdrongS

    andstone

    WesternA

    ustralia17

    Hau

    terivianBarremian11,

    18

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    AlingaFormation

    WesternA

    ustralia17

    late

    AlbianCenomanian19

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    MolecapG

    reensand

    WesternA

    ustralia20

    Cen

    omanianTuronian3

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    DarwinFo

    rmation

    NorthernTerritory,

    late

    Aptian/Albian14,

    22

    P.

    australis7(currentlyvalid),

    Australia3

    ,21

    P.

    longmani3(juniorsynonym)

    Makirikiri

    Formation

    NewZeala

    nd23

    Cretaceous23

    Ichthyosauria23

    Unituncer

    tain

    MountPotts,NewZealand24

    Mid

    dleTriassic25

    Ichthyosaurusaustralis24

    (nomendubium),

    I.hectori26,Ichthyosauria23

    AratauraF

    ormation

    Kawhia,N

    ewZealand27

    HettangianSinemurian27

    Ichthyosauria27

    OuamouiFormation

    NewCaled

    onia28

    earlyNorian29

    Sh

    onisaurus30

    Lepredour

    Shellbeds

    NewCaled

    onia28

    earlyNorian29

    Ichthyosauria30

    AitutuFormation

    Timor31

    Lad

    inianNorian32

    M

    ixosaurustimorensis31

    (nomendu

    bium),

    Mixosaurussp.3

    3

    Table1.D

    istributionofichthyosaurmate

    rialintheAustralasianregion.

    Seefootnotesforsourcetexts

    included.Currentstatusoftaxonomic

    assignmentinbold

    1Molnar(1

    982),

    2Wade(1984),

    3Wade(199

    0),

    4Kear(2002b),5Mooreetal.

    (1986),

    6McMinn&Burger(1986),7McCoy(1867a),8Krieg&R

    odgers

    (1995),

    9Etheridge(1904),

    10Helbyetal.(19

    87),11Kear(2003),

    12Ludbrook(1966),

    13Johns(1968),

    14Day(1969),15Hendersonetal.(2000),

    16

    Alley&

    Pledge(2000),17Choo(1999),

    18McLoughlinetal.(1995),

    19Siverson(1999),

    20Teichert&Matheson(1944),

    21Kear(2002a),22Henderson

    (1998),

    23Flemingetal.(1971),

    24Hector(1874),25Campbell&Warren(1965),

    2

    6Lydekker(1889),

    27Sachs&Gr

    ant-Mackie(2003),

    28Campbell

    (1984),

    29Callaway

    &Massare(1989),

    30Mazin(1985),31Broili(1931),

    32Audley-Charles(1968),

    33Mazin(1983).

    284 MARIA ZAMMIT ALCHERINGA

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    6/13

    Shonisaurus spp. by Mazin (1985), based

    on the crown ornamentation and morpho-

    logy of the teeth. Long bones and vertebraehave also been recorded from the lower

    Norian Lepre dour Shellbeds (Campbell

    1984).

    Eight vertebrae and a basioccipital

    from the Middle Triassic (Callaway &

    Massare 1989), possibly from the Ladi-

    nianNorian (Table 1) shallow-marine

    Aitutu Formation (Audley-Charles 1968),

    Timor, were originally described as Mix-

    osaurus timorensis (Broili 1931), but Mazin(1983) considered the material too poor to

    identify to a species and reassigned it to

    Mixosaurus sp. Sander (1992) referred to a

    Cymbospondylus specimen from Timor

    consisting of ten anterior caudal centra.

    This was apparently based on an incon-

    gruous report by von Huene (1936), which

    identified only three centra (one a cervical)

    as being broadly similar to those of both

    Mixosaurus and Cymbospondylus. Because

    of this inconsistency, and the possibility

    that Sander (1992) might have mistakenly

    referenced the nine caudal centra attribu-

    ted to Mixosaurus by Broili (1931), Cym-

    bospondylus is here considered not

    confidently recorded from the Australasian

    region.

    Jurassic specimens

    Only one putative Jurassic ichthyosaurspecimen is currently known from the

    Australasian region. This comprises an

    isolated centrum from Kawhia, New Zeal-

    and (Sachs & Grant-Mackie 2003), from the

    HettangianSinemurian Arataura Forma-

    tion (Sachs & Grant-Mackie 2003). It is

    not yet formally described.

    Cretaceous specimensA rich record of Cretaceous ichthyosaurs is

    known from New Zealand and Australia.

    The New Zealand material comprises sev-

    eral cervical centra from the upper Albian

    (Cretaceous) Makirikiri Formation (Table

    1) that can be identified as ichthyosaurianbut not diagnosed any further (Fleming

    et al. 1971), and a partial rostrum that is

    very similar to the Australian Platypterygius

    species (Sachs & Grant-Mackie 2003). In

    contrast, Australian Cretaceous ichthyo-

    saurs are known from numerous deposits

    (Table 1), including: the Toolebuc Forma-

    tion, Allaru Mudstone and Wallumbilla

    Formation of Queensland (Molnar 1982,

    Wade 1984, 1990, Kear 2002b); WallumbillaFormation (Etheridge 1904) and, more

    specifically, the Doncaster Member (Kear

    2005b) of New South Wales; Bulldog Shale

    of South Australia (Alley & Pledge 2000,

    Kear 2006); Birdrong Sandstone (Choo

    1999), Alinga Formation (Choo 1999) and

    Molecap Greensand (Teichert & Matheson

    1944) of Western Australia; and the

    Darwin Formation of the Northern Terri-

    tory (Wade 1990, Kear 2002a). Kear (2003)

    recently summarized Australian ichthyo-

    saur remains, including diagnostic speci-

    mens. Hence, this study only reassesses the

    taxonomic status of the material. All

    Australian specimens are referred to the

    cosmopolitan genus Platypterygius based

    on 17 character states (McGowan &

    Motani 2003, pp. 118 119). Much of this

    material is referred to a single species,

    although a humerus (WAM 94.7.3) from

    the HauterivianBarremian of WesternAustralia is more similar to the Eurasian

    species, P. campylodon or P. kiprijanoffi,

    than the recognized Australian form (Choo

    1999).

    Non-ichthyosaurian remains

    Two records of Australasian ichthyosaurs

    are now considered non-ichthyosaurian. A

    presumed ichthyosaur jaw from NewZealand (Benham 1936) has since been

    referred to a squaladontid cetacean (Camp

    1942). The only proposed Triassic ichthyo-

    ALCHERINGA AUSTRALASIAN ICHTHYOSAURS 285

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    7/13

    saur from Australia (Cosgriff & Garbutt

    1972) has not been studied or figured.

    Its ichthyosaurian affinity was questioned

    by Callaway & Massare (1989), and

    was omitted from Mazins (1986) review

    of Triassic ichthyosaurs. Kear (2004)

    286 MARIA ZAMMIT ALCHERINGA

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    8/13

    considered it to be a misidentified amphi-

    bian, so this specimen requires further study.

    Systematics of the AustralianmaterialSubclass DIAPSIDA Osborn, 1903

    Superorder ICHTHYOPTERYGIA Owen,

    1840

    Order ICHTHYOSAURIA de Blainville,

    1835

    Family OPHTHALMOSAURIDAE Baur,1887

    Platypterygiusvon Huene, 1922

    Type species. Platypterygius platydactylus

    (Broili, 1907).

    Age and distribution. EarlyLate Cretaceous

    of North America, South America, Europe,

    Russia, Australia and New Zealand.

    Platypterygius australis McCoy, 1867[a]

    (Fig. 2AM)

    1867Ichthyosaurus australisMcCoy, p. 356.

    [1867a]

    1888 Ichthyosaurus marathonensis Etheridge,

    p. 408, pl. 1, figs 1 3.

    1922 Myopterygius marathonensis von

    Huene, pp. 96, 98.

    1944 Myopterygius australis Teichert &Matheson, p. 169, figs 1 3.

    1972 Platypterygius australis McGowan,

    p. 17, pls 3 4.

    1990Platypterygius longmaniWade, p. 120,

    figs 1 6.

    Neotype. MV P12989 (Fig. 2AC), desig-

    nated herein; the original holotype compris-

    ing numerous centra is lost.

    Type locality, formation and age. Flinders

    River, north central Queensland; Allaru

    Mudstone; Early Cretaceous (late Albian).

    Diagnosis [following Kear (2005a)]. Large

    ichthyosaur, around 7 m long. Maxilla with

    extensive external exposure; forms the entire

    ventral portion of both the anterior maxillary

    foramen and the bony nasal aperture. Max-illa also has a minor internal contact with the

    prefrontal via its posterodorsal surface.

    Lacrimal does not contribute to the border

    of the bony nasal aperture. Prefrontal with

    minor internal contribution to the bony nasal

    aperture. External naris subdivided with well-

    developed anterior foramen and one or more

    foramina present (in nasal) posterodorsal to

    external bony nasal opening. Parietal con-

    tributes to the facet for the paroccipital

    process of the opisthotic on the supratempor-

    al. Humerus bearing tapered crest-like dorsal

    trochanter and three distinct distal facets for

    articulation with the ulna, radius and an

    anterior zeugopodial element. Fourth distal

    facet sporadically present on humerus for

    articulation with pisiform. Three preaxial

    accessory digits and three postaxial accessory

    digits present in forelimb with digital bifurca-

    tion occurring in the primary axis (digit IV).

    Neural spines of at least neck and anteriortrunk vertebrae divided into anterior and

    posterior peaks by an asymmetric V-shaped

    apical notch. Caudal centra from tail stock

    region may bear weakly developed hemal

    arch facets.

    Fig. 2. Platypterygius australismaterial collected from the Allaru Mudstone at Flinders River, Queensland. Neotype

    material (AC), and vertebral material (DM) of P. australis. Specimens include: A, MV P12989 cranial element,

    right lateral view; B, MV P12989 basioccipital (right) and atlasaxis complex, dorsal view; C, MV P12989

    basioccipital (left) and atlasaxis complex, left lateral view; D, MV P12992, lateral view; E, MV P22657,anteroposterior view;F, MV P22655, lateral view; G, MV P22653, lateral view;H, MV P22656 anteroposterior view;

    I, MV P22658, lateral view; J, MV P22654, lateral view; K, MV P22659, anteroposterior view; L, MV P22660,

    anteroposterior view; M, MV P22661, anteroposterior view. at-axatlasaxis complex; basbasioccipital;

    bnabony nasal aperture; lac lacrimal;maxmaxilla; nanasal; snf supernarial foramen. Scale bars10 cm.

    3

    ALCHERINGA AUSTRALASIAN ICHTHYOSAURS 287

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    9/13

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    10/13

    locality, though collected one year later

    (Wade 1990). MV P12989 (Fig. 2AB) in

    particular, an incomplete skull and atlasaxis complex, has a combination of three

    characters differentiating it from other

    ichthyosaur taxa (listed here to satisfy

    ICZN Article 75.3.2): (1) reduced extracon-

    dylar area on the basioccipital (Fig. 2B); (2)

    lacrimal not contributing to the border of

    the bony nasal aperture (Fig. 2A); and (3)

    presence of at least one foramina poster-

    odorsal to the bony nasal aperture (Fig. 2A;

    B. Kear, pers. comm. 2009). The firstcharacter listed is diagnostic of Platypter-

    ygius, whereas the other two simultaneously

    differentiate the Australian Platypterygius

    species and demonstrate that P. longmani

    and P. australis are the same taxon,

    relegatingP. longmanito a junior synonym.

    MV P12989 is thus designated the

    neotype of P. australis with the expressed

    purpose of clarifying the taxonomic status

    of the Australian Platypterygius species.

    MV P12989 originates from the same

    locality as the holotype of P. australis

    (satisfying ICZN Article 75.3.6), and is held

    in a recognized scientific institution (satisfy-

    ing ICZN Article 75.3.7). Lastly, it is

    entirely possible that MV P12989 is part of

    the same individual designated as the

    original holotype of P. australis (Wade

    1984), and is thus consistent with ICZN

    Article 75.3.5.

    AcknowledgementsMany thanks to the curatorial staff and

    museums for providing information and/or

    access to specimens: Neville Hudson (Auck-

    land University); David Pickering (Museum

    Victoria); and Scott Hocknull (Queensland

    Museum). Thanks also to Ben Kear for

    photographing specimens. Ben Kear, Rachel

    Norris and two reviewers are thanked fortheir comments on the manuscript. Use of

    information contained within the New

    Zealand Fossil Record File is acknowledged.

    ReferencesAITCHISON, J.C., CLARKE, G.L., MEFFRE, S. & CLUZEL,

    D., 1995. Eocene arc-continent collision inNew Caledonia and implications for regional

    southwest Pacific tectonic evolution. Geology 23,

    161164.

    ALLEY, N . & PLEDGE, N., 2000. The plants, animals,

    and environments of the last 280 (290) million

    years. Lake Eyre Monograph Series 5, 3582.

    AUDLEY-CHARLES, M.G., 1968. The geology of Portu-

    guese Timor. Memoirs of the Geological Society of

    London, 4, 174.

    AUDLEY-CHARLES, M.G., 1978. The Indonesian and

    Philippine archipelagos. In The Phanerozoic Geol-

    ogy of the World II. The Mesozoic, A.M.

    MOULLADE & A.E.M. NAIRN, eds, Elsevier,Netherlands, 165207.

    BAUR, G., 1887. Uber den Ursprung der Extremita ten

    der Ichthyopterygia. Jahresberichte und Mitteilun-

    gen des Oberrheinischen geologischen Vereines 20,

    1720.

    BENHAM, W., 1936. A reptilian jaw from Kakanui,

    South Island, New Zealand. Transactions of the

    New Zealand Institute 65, 232238.

    BRAZIER, R., KEYES, I. & STEVENS, G., 1990. The Great

    New Zealand Fossil Book, DSIR Geology and

    Geophysics, Lower Hutt, 112 pp.

    BROILI, F., 1907. Ein neuer Ichthyosaurus aus der

    norddeutschen Kreide. Palaeontographica 54, 139152.

    BROILI, F., 1931. Mixosauridae von Timor. Wetenschap-

    pelijke Mededeelingen, Dienst van den Mijnbouw in

    Nederlandsch-Indie, Batavia 17, 310.

    CALLAWAY, J . & MASSARE, J., 1989. Geographic and

    stratigraphicdistribution of the Triassic Ichthyosauria

    (Reptilia: Diapsida).Neues Jahrbuch fur Geologie und

    Palaontologie, Abhandlungen 178, 3758.

    CAMP, C., 1942. Ichthyosaur rostra from central

    California. Journal of Paleontology 16, 362371.

    CAMPBELL, H.J., 1979. Permian-Mesozoic strati-

    graphy of the Moindou-Tere mba area, west

    coast, New Caledonia. MSc Thesis, University ofAuckland, 273 pp. (unpublished).

    CAMPBELL, H.J., 1984. New records and taxa of

    Permian and Triassic fossils from New Caledonia

    and New Zealand. Alcheringa 8, 151167.

    CAMPBELL, J., 1965. New Zealand Triassic saurians.

    New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics 8,

    505509.

    CAMPBELL, J. & WARREN, G., 1965. Fossil localities in

    the Torlesse Group in the South Island. Transac-

    tions of the Royal Society of New Zealand 3, 99

    137.

    CHAPMAN, F., 1914. Australasian Fossils: A Students

    Manual of Palaeontology, George Robertson andCompany, Melbourne, Australia, 341 pp.

    CHOO, B., 1999. Cretaceous ichthyosaurs from Western

    Australia. Records of the Western Australian

    Museum, Supplement 57, 207218.

    ALCHERINGA AUSTRALASIAN ICHTHYOSAURS 289

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    11/13

    COSGRIFF, J . & GARBUTT, N., 1972. Erythrobatrachus

    noonkanbahensis, a trematosaurid species from the

    Blina Shale. Journal of the Royal Society of

    Western Australia 55, 518.

    COX, G., 1991. Prehistoric Animals of New Zealand,

    HarperCollins, Auckland, 40 pp.

    DAY, R., 1969. The Lower Cretaceous of the Great

    Artesian Basin. In Stratigraphy and Palaeontology,

    Essays in Honour of Dorothy Hill, K. CAMPBELL,

    ed., Australian National University Press, Canber-

    ra, 140173.

    DEBLAINVILLE, H.M.D., 1835. Description de quelques

    espe` ces de reptiles de la Californie, pre cede e de

    lanalyse dun syste` me general de petologie et

    damphibologie. Nouvelles Annales du Museum

    dHistoire Naturelle, Paris 4, 233296.

    EMBLETON, B.J.J., 1984. Australias global setting: past

    global settings. In Phanerozoic Earth History of

    Australia, J.J. VEEVERS, ed., Clarendon Press,

    Oxford, United Kingdom, 1116.

    ETHERIDGE, R. Jr, 1888. On additional evidence of the

    genus Ichthyosaurus in the Mesozoic rocks (Roll-

    ing Downs Formation) of north-eastern Australia.

    Proceedings of the Linnean Society of New South

    Wales 2, 405409.

    ETHERIDGE, R. Jr, 1904. A second sauropterygian

    converted to opal, from the Upper Cretaceous of

    White Cliffs, New South Wales. Records of the

    Australian Museum 5, 306316.

    FLEMING, C.A., 1979. The Geological History of New

    Zealand and its Life, Auckland University Press,

    Auckland, 141 pp.

    FLEMING, C.A., GREGG, D. & WELLES, S., 1971. New

    Zealand ichthyosaursa summary, including new

    records from the Cretaceous.New Zealand Journal

    of Geology and Geophysics 14, 734741.

    FORDYCE, R.E., 1982. The fossil vertebrate record of

    New Zealand. In The Fossil Vertebrate Record of

    Australasia, P. RICH & E. THOMPSON, eds, Monash

    University Offset, Clayton, Victoria, 629698.

    FORDYCE, R.E., 1991. A new look at the fossil vertebrate

    record of New Zealand. InVertebrate Palaeontology

    of Australasia, P. VICKERS-RICH, J. MONAGHAN, R.

    BAIRD & T . RICH, eds, Pioneer Design Studio Pty Ltd,

    Lilydale, Victoria, 11911316.

    FORDYCE, R.E., 2003. Fossils and the history of life. In

    The Natural History of Southern New Zealand,

    J. DARBY, R.E. FORDYCE, A. MARK, K. PROBERT&

    C. TOWNSEND, eds, University of Otago Press,

    Dunedin, 3764.

    FRAKES, L.A., BURGER, D., APTHORPE, M., ALLEY, N.,

    FLINT, R., GRAVESTOCK, D., LUDBROOK, N., BACK-

    HOUSE, J., SKWARKO, S., SCHEIBNEROVA, V., MCNINN,

    A., MOORE, P.S., BOLTON, B.R., DOUGLAS, J.G.,

    CHRIST, R., WADE, M., MOLNAR, R.E.,

    MCGOWRAN, B., BALME, B.E. & DAY, R.A., 1987.

    Australian Cretaceous shorelines, stage by stage.

    Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology

    59, 3148.

    HAAST, J., 1871. On the geology of the Amuri District

    in the provinces of Nelson and Marlborough. New

    Zealand Geological Survey Reports of Geological

    Explorations during 1870-1871, 2546.

    HECTOR, J., 1874. On the fossil Reptilia of New

    Zealand.Transactions of the New Zealand Institute

    6, 333358.

    HECTOR, J., 1878. Progress Report. New Zealand

    Geological Survey Reports of the Geological Ex-

    plorations during 18778, ixv.

    HECTOR, J., 1879. Handbook of New Zealand, Sydney

    International Exhibition, 1879, Lyon and Blair

    Printer, Wellington, 105 pp.

    HELBY, R., MORGAN, R . & PARTRIDGE, A., 1987. A

    palynological zonation of the Australian Mesozoic.

    Association of Australasian Palaeontologists Mem-

    oir 4, 194.

    HELL, A., 2001. MCoy and the Australian ichthyosaur

    Ichthyosaurus australis (MCoy 1867). The Victor-

    ian Naturalist 118, 294297.

    HENDERSON, R., 1998. Eustatic and palaeoenvironmen-

    tal assessment of the mid-Cretaceous Bathurst

    Island Group of the Money Shoals Platform,

    northern Australia. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclima-

    tology, Palaeoecology 138, 115138.

    HENDERSON, R., CRAMPTON, J., DETTMANN. M., DOU-

    GLAS, J . , HAIG, D . , SHAFIK, S. , STILWELL, J . &

    THULBORN, R., 2000. Biogeographical observations

    on the Cretaceous biota of Australasia.Association

    of Australasian Palaeontologists Memoir 23, 355

    404.

    JOHNS, R., 1968. Geology and mineral resources of the

    Andamooka-Torrens area. Geological Survey of

    South Australia Bulletin 41, 1103.

    KEAR, B.P., 2002a. Darwin Formation (Early Cretac-

    eous, Northern Territory) marine reptile remains in

    the South Australian Museum. Records of the

    South Australian Museum 35, 3347.

    KEAR, B.P., 2002b. Dental caries in an Early Cretac-

    eous ichthyosaur. Alcheringa 25, 387390.

    KEAR, B.P., 2003. Cretaceous marine reptiles of

    Australia: a review of taxonomy and distribution.

    Cretaceous Research 24, 277303.

    KEAR, B.P., 2004. Biogeographic and biostratigraphic

    implications of Australian Mesozoic marine rep-

    tiles. Australian Biologist 17, 422.

    KEAR, B.P., 2005a. Cranial morphology ofPlatypterygius

    longmaniWade, 1990 (Reptilia: Ichthyosauria) from

    theLower Cretaceous of Australia. ZoologicalJournal

    of the Linnean Society 145, 583622.

    KEAR, B.P., 2005b. Marine reptiles from the Lower

    Cretaceous (Aptian) deposits of White Cliffs,

    southeastern Australia: implications of a high

    latitude, cold water assemblage. Cretaceous Re-

    search 26, 769782.

    KEAR, B.P., 2006. Marine reptiles from the Lower

    Cretaceous of South Australia: elements of a high-

    latitude cold-water assemblage. Palaeontology 49,

    837856.

    290 MARIA ZAMMIT ALCHERINGA

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    12/13

    KRIEG, G.W. & RODGERS, P.A., 1995. Stratigraphy

    marine succession. In The Geology of South

    Australia. Volume 2. The Phanerozoic, J.F. DREXEL

    & W.V. PREISS, eds, Geological Survey of South

    Australian Bulletin 54, 112123.

    LAIRD, M.G. & BRADSHAW, J.D., 2004. The break-up of

    a long-term relationship: the Cretaceous separation

    of New Zealand from Gondwana. Gondwana

    Research 7, 273286.

    LANDIS,C.A.,CAMPBELL, H.J., ASLUND,T.,CAWOOD, P.A.,

    DOUGLAS, A., KIMBROUGH, D.L., PILLAI, D.D.L.,

    RAINE, J.I. & WILLSMAN, A., 1999. PermianJurassic

    strata at Productus Creek, Southland, New Zealand:

    implications for terrane dynamics of the eastern

    Gondwanaland margin. New Zealand Journal of

    Geology and Geophysics 42, 255278.

    LUDBROOK, N., 1966. Cretaceous biostratigraphy of

    the Great Artesian Basin in South Australia.

    Geological Survey of South Australia Bulletin 40,

    1223.

    LYDEKKER, R., 1889. Catalogue of the Fossil Reptilia

    and Amphibia in the British Museum (Natural

    History). Part II. Containing the Orders Ichthyop-

    terygia and Sauropterygia, Trustees of the British

    Museum, London, 307 pp.

    MAZIN, J-M., 1983. Repartition stratigraphique et

    ge ographique des Mixosauria (Ichthyopterygia)

    provincialite marine au Trias moyen. In Actes

    du Symposium Paleontologie Georges Cuvier,

    E. BUFFETAUT, J.M. MAZIN & E . SALMON, eds,

    Montbe liard, 375387.

    MAZIN, J-M., 1985. Les Ichthyopterygia du trias superieur

    de Nouvelle Caledonia. Implications paleobiogeogra-

    phiques.Revue de Palebiologie 4, 77182.

    MAZIN, J-M., 1986. Paleobiogeography of Triassic

    ichthyopterygian reptiles; some working hypoth-

    eses. Neues Jahrbuch fur Geologie und Palaontolo-

    gie, Abhandlungen 173, 117129.

    MCCOY, F., 1867a. On the occurrence ofIchthyosaurus

    andPlesiosaurusin Australia.Annals and Magazine

    of Natural History, Third Series 19, 355356.

    MCCOY, F., 1867b. On the discovery of the Enaliosaur-

    ia and other Cretaceous fossils in Australia.

    Transactions and Proceedings of the Royal Society

    of Victoria 8, 4142.

    MCCOY, F., 1869. On the fossil eye and teeth of the

    Ichthyosaurus australis (MCoy), from the Cretac-

    eous formations of the source of the Flinders

    River; and on the palate ofDiprotodon, from the

    Tertiary limestone of Limeburners Point, near

    Geelong.Transactions and Proceedings of the Royal

    Society of Victoria 2, 7778.

    MCGOWAN, C., 1972. The systematics of Cretaceous

    ichthyosaurs with particular reference to the

    material from North America. Contributions to

    Geology, University of Wyoming 11, 929.

    MCGOWAN, C. & MOTANI, R., 2003. Ichthyopterygia.

    Handbuch der Paleoherpetologie Part 8. Mu nchen:

    Verlag Dr. Friedrich Pfeil, 175 pp.

    MCLOUGHLIN, S., HAIG, D., BACKHOUSE, J., HOLMES,

    M., ELLIS, G., LONG, J. & MCNAMARA, K.,

    1995. Oldest Cretaceous sequence, Giralia

    Anticline, Carnarvon Basin, Western Australia:

    late HauterivianBarremian. AGSO Journal

    of Australian Geology and Geophysics 15, 445

    468.

    MCMINN, A . & BURGER, D., 1986. Palynology and

    palaeoenvironments of the Toolebuc Formation

    (sensu lato) in theEromangaBasin. Geological Society

    of Australia Special Publication 12, 139154.

    MOLNAR, R.E., 1982. Australian Mesozoic reptiles. In

    The Fossil Vertebrate Record of Australasia,

    P. RICH & E. THOMPSON, eds, Monash University

    Offset, Clayton, Victoria, 169225.

    MOORE, P., PITT, G. & DETTMANN, M., 1986. The Early

    Cretaceous Coorikiana Sandstone and Toolebuc

    Formation: their recognition and stratigraphic

    relationship in the southwestern Eromanga Basin.

    Geological Society of Australia Special Publication

    12, 97114.

    NICHOLLS, E. L. & MANABE, M., 2004. Giant ichthyo-

    saurs of the Triassica new species ofShonisaurus

    from the Pardonet Formation (Norian: Late

    Triassic) of British Columbia.Journal of Vertebrate

    Paleontology 24, 838849.

    OSBORN, H., 1903. The reptilian subclass Diapsida and

    Synapsida, and the early history of the Diapto-

    sauria. Memoirs of the American Museum of

    Natural History 1, 449507.

    OWEN, R., 1840. Report on British fossil reptiles.

    Reports of the British Association for the Advance-

    ment of Science 9, 43126.

    SACHS, S. & GRANT-MACKIE, J., 2003. An ichthyosaur

    fragment from the Cretaceous of Northland, New

    Zealand. Journal of the Royal Society of New

    Zealand 33, 307314.

    SANDER, P., 1992. Cymbospondylus (Shastasauridae:

    Ichthyosauria) from the Middle Triassic of Spits-

    bergen: filling a paleobiogeographic gap. Journal of

    Paleontology 66, 332337.

    SCHELLART, W.P., LISTER, G.S. & TOY, V.G., 2006. A

    Late Cretaceous and Cenozoic reconstruction of

    the southwest Pacific region: tectonics controlled

    by subduction and slab rollback processes. Earth-

    Science Reviews 76, 191233.

    SIVERSON, M., 1999. A new large lamniform shark from

    the uppermost Gearle Siltstone (Cenomanian,

    Late Cretaceous) of Western Australia. Transactions

    of the Royal Society of Edinburgh: Earth Science 90,

    4966.

    TEICHERT, C. & MATHESON, R., 1944. Upper Cretaceous

    ichthyosaurian and plesiosaurian remains from

    Western Australia. Australian Journal of Science

    6, 167178.

    VEEVERS, J.J., POWELL, C.McA. & ROOTS, S.R., 1991.

    Review of seafloor spreading around Australia. I.

    Synthesis of the patterns of spreading. Australian

    Journal of Earth Sciences 38, 373389.

    ALCHERINGA AUSTRALASIAN ICHTHYOSAURS 291

  • 8/10/2019 Alcheringa an Australasian Journal of Palaeontology Volume 34 Issue 3 2010 [Doi 10.1080%2F0311551100366393

    13/13

    VON HUENE, F., 1922. Die Ichthyosaurier des Lias un

    ihre Zusammenhange, Mongraphien zur Geologie

    und Pala ontologie, 1. Verlag von Gebru der Born-

    traeger, Berlin, 114 pp.

    VON HUENE, F., 1936. Ichthyosaurrieste aus Timor.

    Zentralblatt fur Mineralogie, Geologie und Palaon-

    tologie Abteilung B, Geologie und Palaontologie

    1936, 327334.

    WADE, M., 1984.Platypterygius australis, an Australian

    Cretaceous ichthyosaur. Lethaia 17, 93113.

    WADE, M., 1985. Platypterygius australis (McCoy)

    1867: a Cretaceous marine reptile. In Kadimakara,

    P. RICH & G. VANTETS, eds, 137142.

    WADE, M., 1990. A review of the Australian Cretaceous

    longipinnate ichthyosaur Platypterygius (Ichthyo-

    sauria, Ichthyopterygia). Memoirs of the Queens-

    land Museum 28, 115137.

    WORLEY, W.F., 1894. Geology of Nelson. Transactions

    of the New Zealand Institute 26, 414421.

    292 MARIA ZAMMIT ALCHERINGA