active management of distribtion networks.pdf
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
1/95
Project Title
Integration of operation of embedded
generation and distribution networks
K/EL/00262/REP
URN 02/1145
Final Report
Prof. Goran Strbac (UMIST)
Prof. Nick Jenkins (UMIST)
Martin Hird (UMIST/Econnect)
Predrag Djapic (UMIST)
Guy Nicholson (Econnect)
MANCHESTERCENTRE FORELECTRICAL ENERGY
Department of Electrical Engineering &Electronics
PO Box 88, Manchester, M60 1QD
May 2002
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
2/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 2 of 95 UMIST, 2002
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
3/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 3 of 95 UMIST, 2002
CONTENT
Page number
Executive summary........................................................................................................4
1. Control Strategies for Close Integration of Embedded Generation and
Distribution Networks..................................................................................................10
1.1. Background .............................................................................................................10
1.2. From Passive to Active Distribution Networks..........................................................12
1.3. Active Management of Voltage Rise Effect in Rural Areas.........................................17
1.4. Qualitative Analysis of Options for Control of Voltage Rise Effect..............................19
1.4.1 Worst Case Scenario (Minimum Load Maximum Generation) Approach...........20
1.4.2 Managing the voltage rise effect by generation curtailment..................................21
1.4.3 Managing the voltage rise effect by reactive compensation.................................22
1.4.4 Managing the voltage rise effect using coordinated voltage control.....................22
1.5. Application to a characteristic situation................................................................ ......23
2. Distribution Management System for Close Integration of Embedded
Generation and Distribution Networks.......................................................................28
2.1. Introduction..............................................................................................................28
2.2. Design of a Distribution Management System Controller............................................29
2.2.1 Outline of Operation.........................................................................................29
2.2.2 Network..........................................................................................................30
2.2.3 Hardware Configurations..................................................................................32
2.2.4 Communications...............................................................................................36
2.2.5 Software..........................................................................................................37
2.3. State Estimation........................................................................................................39
2.3.1 Background - Transmission State Estimation.....................................................39
2.3.2 Distribution State Estimation.............................................................................40
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
4/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 4 of 95 UMIST, 2002
2.3.3 A Distribution State Estimator...........................................................................41
2.4. Control Scheduling...................................................................................................45
2.4.1 Priority List......................................................................................................46
2.4.2 Optimal Power Flow........................................................................................47
2.5. Implementation.........................................................................................................50
3. Quantifying the Benefits of Active Management of Distribution Networks .............54
3.1. Introduction..............................................................................................................54
3.2. Case Studies ............................................................................................................56
3.2.1 Description of the System.................................................................................56
3.2.2 Base Case Scenarios........................................................................................58
3.2.3 Tool for Modelling the Operation of an Active Distribution System....................58
3.2.4 Generation Curtailment.....................................................................................60
3.2.5 Reactive Compensation and Voltage Control....................................................65
3.2.6 Area Based Voltage Control by OLTC ............................................................66
3.2.7 Area Based Voltage Control by OLTC and Voltage Regulator..........................68
3.2.8 Impact of Voltage Controls on Losses................................ ..............................70
4. Commercial Arrangements to Support Active Management.....................................73
4.1. Background.............................................................................................................73
4.2. Voltage Rise Effect and Connection Costs ................................................................74
4.3. Problems with Present Arrangements........................................................................75
4.4. Cost Benefit Analysis of Implementing Active Management of Distribution
Networks.................................................................................................................78
4.5. Commercial Arrangements for Active Distribution Networks .....................................82
4.6. Unbundling of Distribution Network Services ............................................................83
5. Conclusions ...................................................................................................................89
6. References....................................................................................................................93
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
5/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 5 of 95 UMIST, 2002
Executive summary
Rural distribution systems in which embedded generation is connected are susceptible to voltage
rise. In order to minimise the overall effect of embedded generation, network operators prefer
to connect embedded generation to higher voltages where their impact onto voltage profile is
minimal. However, the commercial viability of embedded generation projects is sensitive to
connection costs. These costs increase considerably with the voltage level at which the
embedded generation is connected; generally the higher the voltage or sparser the network, the
higher the connection cost. The developers of embedded generation therefore generally prefer
to connect at lower voltages. The amount of generation that can be connected is usually
established through deterministic load flow studies, usually with the critical case representing
conditions of minimum/maximum load and maximum embedded generation output. This
operating policy limits considerably the capacity of generation that can be connected to the
existing distribution network.
In this context, this project assesses the potential benefits of changing the operation philosophy
of distribution network and embedded generation from passive to active management. This
report deals with voltage control aspect of active management while issues associated with fault
levels are not considered.
The following four main control strategies are quantified:
(i) Active power generation curtailment: The developer of embedded generation schemes
may find it profitable to curtail some of the output for a limited period if allowed to
connect greater generator capacity. This may be particularly attractive if the probability of
the coincidence of high generation output with low network load condition is low.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
6/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 6 of 95 UMIST, 2002
(ii) Reactive power management: Absorbing reactive power can be very beneficial in
controlling the voltage rise effect, especially in weak overhead networks with embedded
generation. By absorbing reactive power, an increase of the output of active power can
be realised.
(iii) Area based coordinated voltage control of On Load Tap Changing Transformers
(OLTCs): The present voltage control in distribution networks is primarily carried out by
OLTCs. Clearly, the voltage rise effect in distribution networks with embedded
generation can therefore be controlled by OLTCs (by reducing the voltage at times of
high generation output). However, the present voltage control policy is designed for
passive networks with strictly unidirectional power flows. Alternative voltage control
practices that go beyond the present local voltage control, such as an area-based control
of OLTC are considered in this study and the benefits of such policies quantified. The
studies performed in this study show that this form of control is likely to bring the largest
benefits in terms of the increase of embedded generation that can be connected to weak
distribution networks.
(iv) Application of voltage regulators: In the context of the voltage rise effect, minimum
load - maximum generation conditions are usually critical for the amount of generation that
can be connected. However, it may also be necessary to consider maximum load
maximum generation conditions. This is because, the use of OLTC transformers to reduce
the voltage on the feeder where the generator is connected, may produce an
unacceptably low voltage on adjacent feeders that supply load. In this case it may be
beneficial to separate the control of voltage on feeders which supply load, from the
control of voltage on feeder to which the generator is connected. This can be achieved by
the application of voltage regulators on appropriate feeders.
The benefits of an active management of distribution network, exercised through the above
alternative control strategies, are quantified by the volume of the annual energy and
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
7/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 7 of 95 UMIST, 2002
corresponding revenue that can be generated for various capacities of embedded (wind)
generation installed. This analysis is carried out on a characteristic 33 kV network that exhibits
all the phenomena of interest.
The studies performed clearly show significant benefits of active control of distribution network.
The most beneficial are schemes with area based voltage control by OLTCs and voltage
regulators achieving a 3 fold increase in the capacity of embedded generation that can be
connected.
The report also discusses how this control might be achieved and also maps out a possible
implementation path so that the concepts proposed can begin to be implemented quickly. The
outline design of a Distribution Management System (DMS) controller suitable for embedded
generation is discussed. Five hardware configurations are proposed of increasing complexity.
The simplest relies merely on local measurements at the 33/11kV substation while the most
complex proposes a hierarchical arrangement of DMS controllers. Although the first,
straightforward approach is conceptually simple, it is likely to give considerable improvements in
the capacity of embedded generation that may be connected.
The overall concept for the controller software is then discussed with the two major elements:
state estimation and control scheduling. Although state estimation techniques are well developed
for transmission networks these approaches are not directly transferable to distribution systems
with embedded generation. The basis of state estimation is explained and then the further work
that is required to adapt existing techniques to dealing with the limited number of measurements
available on distribution networks and the use of load data to provide pseudo-measurements is
outlined.
Two approaches have been identified for control scheduling. A priority-list, rule-based
approach may be applied whereby engineering judgement and knowledge of various contracts
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
8/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 8 of 95 UMIST, 2002
is used to determine the order in which various controls should be adjusted. This approach is
attractive for an early implementation of a simple system, as it is conceptually straightforward
and transparent to practicing engineers. For more complex implementations it may be preferable
to consider using an optimal power flow to optimise the control rigorously.
Furthermore, a possible implementation route is discussed given the present constraints on
distribution network operates and generators. Initially, simple implementations are proposed
with the embedded generator under local control and the controller operating on the Automatic
Voltage controller (AVC) at the 33/11 kV transformer.
The presence of embedded generation in distribution systems alters radically the way these
networks should be viewed not only from technical but also from a commercial vantage point.
With the introduction of embedded generation, distribution networks are expected to offer an
non-discriminatory open access to the networks and facilitate competition in the generation and
supply sectors. This requirement introduces a new role for distribution networks. Distribution
network operators now are required to provide network services to generators and to enable
them to take part in provision of such services.
Under the present regulatory framework Distribution Network Operators (DNOs) do not have
any incentive to connect generation and offer active management services to reduce the
connection costs and increase the amount of embedded generation that can be connected. In
this report, costs and benefits of active management of distribution networks are identified and
discussed. This is necessary for the development of appropriate commercial incentives for
DNOs. Furthermore, the report discusses a number of issues associated with present
commercial arrangements, particularly in relation to pricing that may impact an reactive power
based voltage control.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
9/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 9 of 95 UMIST, 2002
A market based exchange of services between distribution network operators and embedded
generators (and other network users in general) is proposed and discussed.
This would require unbundling of distribution network services and enabling users to contribute
to the major responsibilities of DNOs (i) voltage and (ii) service quality management. As a
consequence of the historical development of distribution systems, these objectives have been
traditionally met by employing the operational and development practices that involved the use of
assets, facilities and resources owned and managed by DNOs. In this traditional approach
embedded generation is effectively excluded from the opportunity to support DNOs in carrying
out their main duties and also from receiving enhanced services from DNOs which would
provide more choice in connection (active management).
The new role of distribution networks requires unbundling of distribution network services and
the development of commercial arrangements within which DNOs would carry out their
responsibilities at least cost and efficiently, by using services from a number of potential
providers. Under this scenario DNOs would maintain the responsibility of managing all
components of service quality, but the means of achieving this objective would involve not only
distribution network facilities. It would also make use of the inputs provided by embedded
generation, and more generally, by demand-side management, storage facilities, reactive
compensation facilities including an active interchange of services between the DNOs and the
TNO on the distribution-transmission boundary. In the context of embedded generation, this
concept could open the possibility for generators to provide DNOs with network support
(substitute for network capacity), with voltage regulation and contribute to service quality. On
the other hand, DNOs could offer enhanced network services to generators, such as active
distribution management and enable them to control their connection costs. The value of various
services provided by and to DNOs could be determined on a market basis.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
10/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 10 of 95 UMIST, 2002
1. Control Strategies for Close Integration of Embedded
Generation and Distribution Networks
1.1. Background
The UK Government is working towards a target of renewable energy providing 10% of UK
electricity supplies by 2010 with 10GW of CHP by the same date. Depending on the load
factor assumed, this will require the installation of up to 14 GW of generation capacity on to
distribution networks (i.e. at voltages of 132 kV and below). Renewable generation will benefit
considerably from the Renewables Obligation that rewards green energy through a mechanism
of Renewables Obligation Certificates [1]. However, under the present conditions the owners
and operators of the distribution networks, the Distribution Network Operators (DNOs)
anticipate that they can integrate only a much more limited capacity of generation [2] without a
major reinforcement.
The environment in which distribution companies function creates a number of interrelated
regulatory, commercial and technical questions that need addressing in order to facilitate thisgrowth in small-scale generation. This reflects
(i) the historic function of the distribution network, that has been primarily viewed as a
transport provider, rather than in the role of a facilitator of competition in the generation
and supply sectors, and
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
11/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 11 of 95 UMIST, 2002
(ii) the historic passive configuration of the distribution system, in which the expectation is
that virtually all the electricity is supplied from the transmission networks at several
points in each DNOs area and is then distributed to consumers at lower voltages.
An open access based framework for distribution networks clearly needs to be developed. The
Utilities Act 2000 requires DNOs to facilitate competition, which is effectively a vehicle for
opening up distribution networks and for providing equitable access to the energy market. In
order to take full advantage of this opportunity an adequate regulatory and commercial
environment needs to be developed and a number of technical issues related to network
operation and development resolved, as documented in the Report of the OFGEM/DTI
Embedded Generation Working Group [4]. The report recognises that at present there are
neither commercial nor technical frameworks to encourage the DNOs to integrate this
embedded generation (EG) into their systems in an optimal manner.
The overall problem can be viewed as a conflict between two regulatory systems: the aggressive
economic regulation of the UK power industry, which is dominated by relatively short-term
issues of economic efficiency, and the environmental which aims to establish incentives for small-
scale, less carbon intensive technologies in pursuit of climate change objectives. It may be seen
that a high penetration of embedded generation, which is essential if renewable energy sources
and CHP are to be introduced to meet government targets, represents a paradigm shift in the
UK electricity system.
Specifically, this work is centred around an analysis of the benefits that can be derived from
changing the operation philosophy of distribution networks from passive to active. The emphasis
is on the design of control strategies of active distribution systems that would enhance the ability
of the existing networks to accommodate additional embedded generation.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
12/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 12 of 95 UMIST, 2002
In this section the fundamental features of passive distribution networks are examined and their
inability to accommodate increased amounts embedded generation discussed. It is
demonstrated how the voltage rise effect, the main limiting factor in rural areas, can be
effectively controlled within an active network environment, and as a result, enable considerably
higher levels of penetration of embedded generation into existing systems. The following three
main control strategies are then elaborated in some detail:
(i) Active power generation curtailment
(ii) Reactive power management
(iii) Area based coordinated voltage control
(iv) Application of voltage regulators
Qualitative analysis of these alternatives is then carried out on a simplistic distribution network
model where the effect of these controls can be easily understood.
The ability of active networks to accommodate embedded generation is illustrated on a
characteristic case study of connecting a wind farm to a weak distribution network. It is shown
that through reactive power management or coordinated voltage control the amount of
embedded generation that can be connected to the existing system can be increased for a factor
of 3, in comparison with passive networks.
1.2. From Passive to Active Distribution Networks
Modern distribution systems were designed to accept bulk power from the transmission
network and to distribute it to customers. Thus the flow of both real power (P) and reactive
power (Q) was always from the higher to the lower voltage levels. This is shown schematically
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
13/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 13 of 95 UMIST, 2002
in Figure 1.1 and, even with interconnected distribution systems, the behaviour of the network is
well understood and the procedures for both design and operation long established.
Load
P,Q P,Q
Figure 1.1 - Conventional distribution network deign and operation
However, with significant penetration of embedded generation the power flows may become
reversed and the distribution network is no longer a passive circuit supplying loads but an active
system with power flows and voltages determined by the generation as well as the loads. This is
shown schematically in Figure 1.2. For example, the CHP generation scheme with the
synchronous generator (S) will export real power when the electrical load of the premises falls
below the output of the generator but may absorb or export reactive power depending on the
setting of the excitation system of the generator. The wind turbine will export real power but is
likely to absorb reactive power as its induction (sometimes known as asynchronous) generator
(A) requires a source of reactive power to operate. The voltage source converter of the
photovoltaic (pv) system will allow export of real power at a set power factor but may
introduce harmonic currents, indicated as in Figure 1.2. Thus the power flows through the
circuits may be in either direction depending on the relative magnitudes of the real and reactive
network loads compared to the generator outputs and any losses in the network.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
14/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 14 of 95 UMIST, 2002
P,Q? P,Q?
A
P,-Q
CHP S
pv
P+/-QP,+/-QIn
Figure 1.2 - Ad-hoc approach with existing operation practice
The change in real and reactive power flows caused by embedded generation has important
technical and economic implications for the power system. To date, most attention has been
paid to the immediate technical issues of connecting and operating generation on a distribution
system and most countries have developed standards and practices to deal with these. In
general, the approach adopted has been to ensure that any embedded generation does not
reduce the quality of supply offered to other customers and to consider the generators as
negative load. No real attempt has been made to consider how the overall performance of a
distribution system with a significant penetration of embedded generation may be optimised.
Clearly, a number of difficulties, following from the different objectives of the generator and
network operator, can be identified immediately. At present in the UK networks, the objective
of the generator is to supply the maximum energy (kWh) to the network and so receive the
largest payment. The objective of the DNO is to maintain supply to all customers, the majority
of whom will be load customers. As the network operator has no control over the embedded
generator all decisions concerning the network must be made considering the worst possible
conditions of the generation for any set of network conditions. Hence at minimum (or even zero)
load the maximum generation is assumed and at maximum load, minimum generation is assumed.
In summary, there is no mechanism where the overall distribution network and embedded
generation system can be optimised.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
15/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 15 of 95 UMIST, 2002
Every DNO has an obligation to supply its customers at a voltage within specified limits. This
requirement often determines the design and expense of the distribution circuits and so, over the
years, techniques have been developed to make the maximum use of distribution circuits to
supply customers within the required voltages. For example, it is well known that the ratio of the
MV/LV transformer is usually adjusted so that at times of maximum load the most remote
customer receives acceptable voltage. During minimum load the voltage received by all
customers is just below the maximum allowed. If an embedded generator is now connected to
the end of such a circuit then the flows in the circuit will change and hence the voltage profiles.
The most onerous case is likely to be when the customer load on the network is at a minimum
and the output of the embedded generator must flow back to the source.
In some cases, the voltage rise can be limited by reversing the flow of reactive power (Q) either
by using an induction generator or by under-exciting a synchronous machine and operating at
leading power factor. This can be effective on higher voltage overhead circuits, which tend to
have a higher X/R ratio. However, on LV cable distribution circuits the dominant effect is that of
the real power (P) and the network resistance (R) and so only very small embedded generators
may generally be connected to LV networks.
Some DNOs use more sophisticated control of on-load tap changers of the HV/MV
distribution transformers including the use of a current signal compounding the voltage
measurement. One technique is that of line drop compensation and as this relies on an assumed
power factor of the load, the introduction of embedded generation and the subsequent change in
power factor may lead to greater uncertainty in operation if the embedded generator is large
compared to the customer load.
As the present network operation philosophy is known to considerably limit the amount of
embedded generation that can be connected, the focus of this particular piece of work is on
quantifying the benefits of the integration of embedded generation into distribution network
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
16/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 16 of 95 UMIST, 2002
operation in terms of the increased ability of the networks to accommodate embedded
generation. This integration effectively changes the conventional doctrine of the operation of
distribution networks from passive to active and this work carries out a conceptual analysis of
the operation of such active networks. Various degrees of integration are possible, ranging from
a simple local based control of generation to a coordinated control between distribution and
generation facilities over interconnected distribution circuits. This co-ordinated, system level
voltage and flow control could be based on a controller that allows this integrated operation to
be implemented.
The controls may be implemented either using central Distribution Management System
controllers, such as one depicted in Figure 1.3 (say one for each 33/11 kV substation), or by
distributing the control functions among the various controllers associated with each item of plant
(i.e. generators, tap-changers). However this choice is largely an issue of implementation only as
the control philosophy proposed accepts the requirement for communication between the
various items of plant. The control actions required are slow (e.g. change of tap-changer set-
point or generator despatch) and so low cost, slow, communications systems will be
appropriate. The overall control system will be arranged in a hierarchy with the controllers of the
33/11 kV substations communicating upwards to similar equipment in 132/33 kV substations
etc. Particular attention must be paid to the consequences of failure of the communications
systems and how the system then reverts to a safe state.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
17/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 17 of 95 UMIST, 2002
A
P,-Q
CHP S
pv
P+/-Q
P,+/-Q
DMSController
P,Q,V, P,Q,V,
P,Q,V,
DMS Controller inputs-Network flows and voltages (P, Q, V)-Contracts for constraining on and off
generation;
DMS controller outputs:Tap positions and generator dispatch
(P , Q)
Figure 1.3 - Active distribution network operation
As indicated earlier, the degree of integration can vary from a simple local based control of
generation to a coordinated control between distribution and generation facilities over
interconnected distribution circuits.
1.3. Active Management of Voltage Rise Effect in Rural Areas
Connections of embedded generation in ruraldistribution systems are susceptible to voltage
rise. Current operating policy based on passive operation of distribution network limits the
capacity of generation connected based on the extreme condition of minimum load, maximum
generation. In order to minimise the overall effect of embedded generation network operatorsprefer to connect embedded generation at higher voltages where their impact onto voltage levels
is minimal. However, the commercial viability of embedded generation projects is sensitive to
connection costs. These costs increase considerably with the voltage level at which the
embedded generation is connected; generally the higher the voltage or sparser the network, the
higher the cost. The developers of embedded generation therefore prefer to connect at lower
voltages. This conflict of objectives between embedded generation developers and network
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
18/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 18 of 95 UMIST, 2002
operators is usually settled through simple deterministic load flow studies, usually based on one
critical case representing conditions of minimum load and maximum embedded generation
output.
As this will demonstrate, an active distribution network will allow considerably greater
penetration of embedded generation. Three alternative control strategies are evaluated1:
(a) Active power generation curtailment (shedding) can be used as a means of reducing the
voltage rise effect. The generator may find it profitable to curtail some of its output for a
limited period if allowed to connect a larger capacity. This may be particularly suitable for
embedded generation, as the generation curtailment is likely to be required during times of
relatively low value of energy (such as summer nights). This mode of control is local and,
generally, there is no need for communication system.
(b) Secondly, absorbing reactive power can be beneficial to controlling voltage rise effect,
especially in weak overhead networks with embedded generation. This mode of control is
also local and, generally, there is no need for communication system. In this respect, the use
of a reactive compensation facility, such as a STATCOM, at the connection point is
discussed in [3]. However, reactive power management as a means of increasing the
penetration of embedded generation has not been widely applied in the UK. Within this
work an advanced optimal power flow method will be applied to illustrate the potential of
reactive power management in the context of managing voltage rise-effect.
(c) Thirdly, the introduction of a co-ordinated voltage control policy may be beneficial from the
embedded generation penetration levels point of view. Present voltage control in
1Application of voltage regulators is elaborated in Section 3 of the report
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
19/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 19 of 95 UMIST, 2002
distribution networks is primarily carried out by On Load Tap Changing-transformers
(OLTC). Voltage control is usually based on a simple constant voltage policy or a scheme
that takes into account circuit loading while determining the voltage that should be
maintained. It is important to bear in mind that this voltage control policy was designed for
passive networks with strictly unidirectional power flows. In active distribution networks
with multi-directional power flows, the validity of this local control voltage practice becomes
inherently inadequate. In fact, this practice limits the degree of openness and accessibility of
distribution networks and therefore has a considerable adverse impact on the amount of
generation that can be accommodated. On the other hand, alternative voltage control
practices that go beyond the present local voltage control, such as an area-based control of
OLTC will be considered and the benefits of such policies quantified. This coordinated
control would be accompanied with an adequate communication system and measurements
from a number of points along the feeder.
(d) Finally, application of voltage regulators may be very beneficial for decoupling voltage
control on feeders supplying loads from feeders to which generation is connected.This is
useful when it is necessary to consider maximum load maximum generation conditions.
This is because, the use of OLTC transformers to reduce the voltage on the feeder where
the generator is connected, may produce an unacceptably low voltage on adjacent feeders
that supply load. In this case it may be beneficial to separate the control of voltage on
feeders which supply load, from the control of voltage on feeder to which the generator is
connected. This can be achieved by the application of voltage regulators on appropriate
feeders.
1.4. Qualitative Analysis of Options for Control of Voltage Rise Effect
The voltage rise effect is illustrated using a simple circuit shown in Figure 1.4. This figure
represents the basic features of a distribution system into which an embedded generator, G, is
connected (assumed at 11kV). This generator (PG, QG) together with a local load (PL, QL) and
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
20/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 20 of 95 UMIST, 2002
a reactive compensator (QC) is connected to the distribution system (DS) via a weak rural
distribution overhead line with impedance Z and, say a 33/11 kV transformer with an On Load
Tap Changer (OLTC).
QC
PGG
Q Comp
PL, QL
QG
Z=R + jX
1
2
OLTC
DS
Figure 1.4 - Simple system for modelling voltage rise
The voltage at busbar 2 (V2) can be approximately calculated as follows:
X)QQQ()PP(RVV CLGLG12++
(1)
This simple equation can be used to qualitatively analyse the relationship between voltage at
busbar 2 and the amount of generation that can be connected to distribution network, as well as
the impact of alternative control actions.
1.4.1 Worst Case Scenario (Minimum Load Maximum Generation) Approach
As discussed above, the capacity of generation that can be connected to a distribution circuit
determined by analysing the extreme conditions of the coincidence of minimum load (PL= 0, QL
= 0) and maximum generation (PG = PGMAX). This policy enables DNOs to continue to operate
their systems as if generators were not connected at all. The effect of such connection policy on
the amount of generation that can be connected to existing system can be analysed by the
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
21/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 21 of 95 UMIST, 2002
following expression (for the simplicity sake unity power factor operation is assumed, i.e.
QGQC=0):
max
G12 PRVV + (2)
The capacity of the generator that can be accommodated in the existing system is clearly limited
by the maximum voltage at busbar 2:
R
VVP 1
max
2max
G
(3)
It is important to observe that the real part of the network impedance, R, is critical for the
amount of generation that can be connected (as the value of reactance, X, is not relevant as the
generator is assumed to operate with a unity power factor). This resistance is determined by
conductor size and is assumed constant for a given system.
1.4.2 Managing the voltage rise effect by generation curtailment
It is important to observe that the probability of such extreme situation (coincidence of minimum
load with maximum generation) actually occurring is generally low, and hence it may be
beneficial to accommodate a larger generator at busbar 2 and curtail it when voltage at busbar 2
rises to that of the limit. The effect of generation curtailment on the capacity that can be
connected is given by the equation below.
R
VVPP 1
max
2cur
G
max
g
+ (4)
The likelihood of the coincidence of minimum load with maximum generation will determine the
total annual energy curtailed. As the price of electricity is primarily driven by load demand, and
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
22/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 22 of 95 UMIST, 2002
generation curtailment occurs typically during periods of low load, the value of this energy
curtailed is likely to be relatively low.
1.4.3 Managing the voltage rise effect by reactive compensation
Managing of reactive power injections can make a considerable impact on the capacity of
generation that can be connected to weak overhead distribution networks. If reactive power,
Qimport (i.e. ( )CLG QQQ ), is absorbed from the network, the amount of generation that
can be connected under no load conditions can be increased:
R
XQ
R
)VV(P
import1
max
2max
G+
(5)
Observe that the effectiveness of reactive power import is greatly influenced by the value of line
reactance X. In this context, reactive compensation is considerably more effective on overhead
networks (with typical reactance of]km/[4.0XOH
), than on cable networks (with typical
reactance of ]km/[1.0XC ). It is also important to bear in mind that absorbing reactive
power would lead to an increase in losses, and the evaluation of this control option should
therefore include loss assessment.
1.4.4 Managing the voltage rise effect using coordinated voltage control
Control of voltage at busbar 2 by regulating voltage V1, at busbar 1, using the OLTC, can
considerably increase the capacity of embedded generation. In this control option, the OLTC is
used to lower voltage to the minimum value min1V , enabling larger injection of active power at
busbar 2:
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
23/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 23 of 95 UMIST, 2002
R
VV
P
min
1
max
2max
G
(6)
However, in a more complex network, the value of this voltage, and the corresponding tap
position of the OLTC, would have to be optimised.
All these three methods of regulating voltage can be applied in combination. It should also be
noted that reinforcing the system could also enhance the amount of generation that can be
accommodated. This is however out of scope of this study that is focused on voltage regulation
in the existing system.
1.5. Application to a characteristic situation
In order to illustrate the limitation of passive distribution network operating philosophy and the
benefits of active control of distribution systems arising from the management of the rise effect
(and hence connection cost), a weak 20 kV distribution network to which a wind farm is to be
connected is considered (Figure 1.5). Network and load parameters are given in Table 1.1 and
Table 1.2. Induction generators with power factor correction capacitors are considered for the
operation of the wind farm. The combined active-reactive characteristic of the group of
generators (without power factor correction) to be used is given in Figure 1.6. The size of the
fixed power factor correction used is 3 MVAr. Voltage at busbar 2 is held at 1.03 p.u. by the
transformer tap changer.
High and low loading conditions as two characteristic snap shot situations are analysed.
Minimum demand is set to be at 10% of the peak.
Table 1.1. Circuit data
Line Records
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
24/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 24 of 95 UMIST, 2002
From
Number
To Number R(p.u.) X(p.u.)
2 1 0.01869 0.17726
2 3 0.03100 0.40174
2 5 0.33290 0.58310
3 4 0.09000 0.15770
3 5 0.64460 0.86000
5 6 0.23900 0.21040
6 7 0.24762 0.25132
1
1.00 pu
21.03 pu
3
1.01 pu
4
0.99 pu
51.00 pu
6
1.00 pu
7
1.00 pu
12.8 MW
12.8 MW12.1 MW12.0 MW
0.6 MW
0.6 MW
0.0 MW
0.0 MW0.0 MW0.0 MW
8.8 MW
8.6 MW
31.50 MW6.31 MVR
12.00 MW2.40 MVR
54 MW18 MVR
9.20 MW1.85 MVR
0.00 MW
53.7 MW
53.2 MW
2.97 MVR0.00 MVR
3.00 MVR
2.6 MVR-2.4 MVR
0.0 MVR-0.0 MVR
0.0 MVR
-0.0 MVR
1.2 MVR
-1.1 MVR
4.5 MVR
-3.8 MVR
-12.0 MVR
17.7 MVR
1.2 MVR
-0.7 MVR
Figure 1.5 - Seven-bus network
Table 1.2. Load data
Load Records
Busbar MW MVAr MVA
2 31.5 6.31 32.13
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
25/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 25 of 95 UMIST, 2002
4 12.0 2.40 12.24
5 9.2 1.85 9.387 0 3.00 3.00
Induction generator circle diagram (without pfc)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Power export (MW)
ReactivePowerimport(MVAr)
Figure 1.6 - Induction generator circle diagram
Assuming that allowable voltage variation in the network are +/- 5%, three exercises are
performed:
(i) Passive network operation is simulated and the maximum amount of embedded
generation that can be connected to the network is determined. Both heavy and light
loading conditions are considered. By performing a number of load flow calculations it
can be concluded that 13.5 MW and 4.6 MW can be absorbed under heavy and light
loading conditions respectively.
(ii) Active distribution network operation is simulated with local control via a reactive
power compensation plant, installed at the point of connection. The case study
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
26/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 26 of 95 UMIST, 2002
demonstrates that absorbing reactive power can be very beneficial to controlling voltage
rise effect, and hence enable increased amount of embedded generation to be connected
to the existing system. Furthermore, the minimum size of the plant to allow various
amounts of generation to be connected is determined. It is important to observe changes
in active losses as shown in Table 1.3 (voltage at busbar 2 is held at 1.03 p.u.). The
compensation plant is modelled simplisticly as a synchronous condenser, which is
certainly adequate for this type of analysis.
Table 1.3
High loading conditions Low loading conditions
PG QG Q absorbed by
the compensator
Plosses Q absorbed by the
compensator
Plosses
(MW) (MVAr) (MVAr) (MW) (MVAr) (MW)
1.0 3.2 0 0.99 0 0.01
3.0 3.6 0 0.92 0 0.05
5.0 4.0 0 0.91 0.16 0.15
10.0 5.0 0 1.13 3.18 0.78
15.0 7.3 0.66 1.85 3.81 1.83
20.0 9.5 1.18 3.02 4.12 3.27
This table shows that, at the extreme, this network could accommodate 20.0MW, from the
voltage rise point of view, if a compensation of 4.12 MVArs (of reactive absorption) is installed.
Note that in this particular case losses would be more than 3MW under all load conditions.
When considering the economics of reactive compensation plant, the installation cost of thisreactive support will have to balance against the value of the increase in generation output taking
into account negative effects on system losses. This topic is discussed in Section 3.
(iii) In passive distribution networks voltage regulation is carried out by On Load Tap
Changing-transformers (OLTC). Voltage control is usually based on a simple constant
voltage policy. In active distribution networks with embedded generation and multi-
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
27/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 27 of 95 UMIST, 2002
directional power flows, the validity of this local control voltage practice may become
inadequate. This case study illustrates the benefit that a co-ordinated voltage control
including OLTC with respect to amount of embedded generation that can be connected
and the amount of reactive support required (Table 1.4 and 1.5). Thus, with busbar 2
maintained at 1.015 pu a 7 MW generator may be connected with no additional reactive
compensation. Reducing busbar 2 voltage to 1.pu increases this to almost 15 MW.
Table 1.4 - Set voltage at bus 2 V = 1.015 p.u.
High loading conditions Low loading conditions
PG QG Q absorbed by
the compensator
Plosses Q absorbed by the
compensator
Plosses
(MW) (MVAr) (MVAr) (MW) (MVAr) (MW)
1.0 3.2 0 1.00 0 0.01
3.0 3.6 0 0.94 0 0.06
5.0 4.0 0 0.93 0 0.15
10.0 5.0 0 1.17 1.47 0.68
15.0 7.3 0 1.84 2.18 1.67
20.0 9.5 0 2.91 2.56 3.07
Table 1.5 - Set voltage at bus 2 V = 1.00p.u.
High loading conditions Low loading conditions
PG QG Q absorbed by
the compensator
Plosses Q absorbed by the
compensator
Plosses
(MW) (MVAr) (MVAr) (MW) (MVAr) (MW)
1.0 3.2 0 1.02 0 0.01
3.0 3.6 0 0.95 0 0.06
5.0 4.0 0 0.95 0 0.1610.0 5.0 0 1.19 0 0.64
15.0 7.3 0 1.89 0.53 1.55
20.0 9.5 0 2.99 0.98 2.89
The exercises performed clearly show that a coordinated voltage control has a significant
potential for increasing the level of penetration of embedded generation to weak overhead
distribution networks.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
28/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 28 of 95 UMIST, 2002
2. Distribution Management System for Close Integration of
Embedded Generation and Distribution Networks
2.1. Introduction
It has been shown in Section 1 that there is very considerable benefit in integrating the control of
embedded generation and the local distribution networks. This section discusses how this
control might be achieved and also maps out a possible implementation path so that the
concepts proposed can begin to be implemented quickly.
Firstly the outline design of a Distribution Management System (DMS) controller suitable for
embedded generation is discussed. Five hardware configurations are proposed of increasing
complexity. The simplest relies merely on local measurements at the 33/11kV substation while
the most complex proposes a hierarchical arrangement of DMS controllers. Although the first,
straightforward approach is conceptually simple, it is likely to give considerable improvements in
the capacity of embedded generation that may be connected.
The overall concept for the controller software is then discussed with the two major elements:
(1) state estimation and (2) control scheduling. Although state estimation techniques are well
developed for transmission networks these approaches are not directly transferable to
distribution systems with embedded generation. The basis of state estimation is explained and
then the further work that is required to adapt existing techniques to dealing with the limited
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
29/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 29 of 95 UMIST, 2002
number of measurements available on distribution networks and the use of load data to provide
pseudo-measurements is outlined.
Two approaches have been identified for control scheduling. A priority-list, rule-based
approach may be applied whereby engineering judgement and knowledge of ancillary services
contracts is used to determine the order in which various controls should be adjusted. This
approach is attractive for an early implementation of a simple system, as it is conceptually
straightforward and transparent to practicing engineers. For more complex implementations it
may be preferable to consider using an optimal power flow to optimise the control.
Finally, a possible implementation route is discussed given the present constraints on distribution
network operates and generators. Initially, simple implementations are proposed with the
embedded generator under local control and the controller operating on the AVC controller at
the 33/11 kV transformer.
2.2. Design of a Distribution Management System Controller
2.2.1 Outline of Operation
Conceptually, the DMS controller is located at the primary substation which is the lowest
voltage point on the network with an on load tap changer for voltage control although in practice
there is no reason why its capabilities cannot be distributed amongst other controllers. It has the
necessary data to provide a model of the local HV distribution network. At a set interval,
perhaps every half-hour, the DMS controller estimates the state of the part of the network that
is under its control. The estimate comprises the voltage at each bus of the network. To
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
30/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 30 of 95 UMIST, 2002
calculate the estimate, the DMS controller uses models of the loads connected to the network
and a minimum number of real-time measurements.
Using the state estimate, the DMS controller calculates control values and outputs these to
devices connected to network elements, such as on-load tap-changers and embedded
generators. The control values are calculated to optimise the power flow in that part of the
network.
If any real-time measurement changes significantly, the DMS controller calculates and outputs
new control values within a few seconds, to prevent infringement of, or reduce the probability
of, network constraints.
The DMS controller comprises software that runs on a hardware platform that is connected to
the electrical network. The main features of the electrical network and hardware platform are
described in the following sections. The software inputs and outputs are then briefly described.
A detailed description of the software is given in Sections 2.3 and 2.4.
2.2.2 Network
Figure 2.1 is a simplified schematic diagram of part of a distribution network. The primary
substation transformers are fitted with on-load tap-changers (OLTC) that are controlled by
automatic voltage control (AVC) relays. For the DMS controller to control the voltage at a
multi-transformer substation, as illustrated, the AVC relays are assumed to be operated in
master-follower configuration and the DMS controller controls the set point of the master. For a
single transformer substation, the DMS controller controls the set point of the single AVC relay.
The voltage at more than one substation can be controlled by different DMS controllers or by
communication from one controller.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
31/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 31 of 95 UMIST, 2002
Several circuits are shown connected to the substation, each comprising several busbars
connected together by lines or cables. The DMS controller can re-configure the network, which
can be radial or meshed, by opening or closing circuit breakers.
Customer loads are connected to the buses. The DMS controller can control some loads by
disconnecting and reconnecting them.
Embedded generators are connected to several of the busbars. These have different types of
controller, depending upon the type of generator. The DMS controller controls the active and
reactive power export of embedded generators by sending control signals to their controllers.
Examples of control signals are: a set point for the automatic voltage regulator of a synchronous
generator, a set point for the governor of an engine, a signal to a wind farm supervisory control
and data acquisition (SCADA) system to stop a number of wind turbines in a wind farm or to
change the set point of the pitch angles in all wind turbines in a wind farm to a new maximum
output.
Measurements of voltage, current or power are taken at the substation bus bar and several
other busbars. These would typically be busbars to which generators are connected or at which
large voltage variations are expected. The DMS controller uses the minimum number of
measurements necessary to calculate a state estimate sufficiently accurate for satisfactory control
of the network.
Reactive power compensation devices, such as capacitor banks or static compensators may
also be connected to the network. The DMS controller controls these by, for instance,
connecting and disconnecting a capacitor bank.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
32/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 32 of 95 UMIST, 2002
33 / 11 kV
Transformer
with On-line
Tap-changer
Measurement
Generator
KEY
11 kV / 230 V
Transformerwith low
voltage loads
Network bus
Network line
or cable
VAR
LOAD
Reactive
power
com ensator
VAR
Controllable
LoadLOAD
Circuit
breaker
3
2
1
Figure 2.1 - Schematic diagram of part of a distribution network
2.2.3 Hardware Configurations
Schematic diagrams of possible DMS controller hardware configurations are shown in Figures
2.2 and 2.3. Five different possibilities are shown, increasing in scale and complexity.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
33/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 33 of 95 UMIST, 2002
Remote Terminal
Unit
Remote Terminal
Unit
Real-time
Microcomputer
Automatic Voltage
Control Relay
Local
measurements
Real-time
Microcomputer
Automatic Voltage
Control Relay
Local
measurements
Remote Terminal
Unit
Real-time
Microcomputer
Automatic Voltage
Control Relay
Local
measurements
Remote Terminal
Unit
1
2
3
Figure 2.2 - Schematic diagrams of simple DMS controller hardware configurations
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
34/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 34 of 95 UMIST, 2002
Remote Terminal
Unit
Remote Terminal
Unit
Real-time
Microcomputer
Automatic Voltage
Control Relays
Local
measurements
Remote Terminal
Unit
4
Embedded Generators
Loads, Compensators,
Circuit Breakers
5
DMS
Controller
DMS
Controller
DMS
Controller
DMS
Controller
DMS
Controller
DMS
Controller
DMS
Controller
Figure 2.3 - Schematic diagrams of more complex DMS controller hardware configurations
The three configurations shown in Figure 2.2 illustrate simple applications of the DMS
controller, which control only a single AVC relay. The DMS control software runs on the real-
time microcomputer and the output is a single set point value to an AVC relay. The computer
and relay are sited at a primary substation (e.g. 33/11kV). These two units are in each of the
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
35/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 35 of 95 UMIST, 2002
three configurations; the difference between the configurations is the number and type of real-
time measurements that are provided as inputs to the software.
Configuration 1 is the simplest and uses only local substation measurements. Examples of these
are substation busbar voltage, total substation power, feeder power, total substation current and
feeder current. This configuration may provide workable control for a radial network with a
single embedded generator.
In configuration 2, local substation measurements are supplemented with network measurements
from a single remote terminal unit (RTU). The RTU is a partially intelligent device that has
monitoring, communications and some control functions. The RTU is sited at a key point on the
network, such as the busbar at which an embedded generator is connected or the bus at which
the largest voltage variations are expected. The RTU takes measurements at this point and
communicates them to the real-time microcomputer (DMS controller). Examples of network
measurements are bus voltage, load (or generator) power, feeder power, load (or generator)
current and feeder current. This configuration may be suitable for a radial network with a single
embedded generator for which configuration 1 provides insufficient data to allow workable
control.
Configuration 3 is the same as configuration 2, except that it has several RTUs. This
configuration may be suitable for a radial or meshed network with one or more embedded
generators.
Figure 2.3 shows two more complex configurations. These configurations control AVC relays,
embedded generators, loads, reactive power compensators and circuit breakers.
Configuration 4 uses local measurements and measurements from several RTUs, in the same
way as configuration 3. Configuration 4 controls many network devices, therefore it is likely that
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
36/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 36 of 95 UMIST, 2002
it will require a larger number of RTUs than configuration 3. Configuration 4 is suitable for
control of a re-configurable radial or meshed network with one or more substations, several
embedded generators, controllable loads and reactive power compensators.
Configuration 5 shows how the DMS controllers could be used in a hierarchical manner. Each
controller is as illustrated in configuration 4. At the lowest level, the four controllers would
typically be sited at primary substations or perhaps at a lower level at in-line voltage
regulators. The intermediate level controllers could be sited at medium voltage substations (bulk
supply points 132/33kV). The highest-level controller could be sited at a grid supply point
(e.g.400 or 275/132kV). Configuration 5 is suitable for control of part of a distribution network
that contains a large number of embedded generators and is supplied from a single grid supply
point.
2.2.4 Communications
For configuration 1 the real-time microcomputer, the local measurement device and the AVCrelay are directly connected to each other. In configurations 2 to 5, remote communications are
needed between the RTUs and the real-time computer. In configurations 4 and 5 remote
communications are additionally needed between the real-time computer and the devices
connected to the network.
Measurement data is communicated from an RTU to the real-time microcomputer once per
interval, say every half hour, or if there is a significant change in a measurement. The number of
data values communicated each time is typically less than five e.g. voltage magnitude, real power
and reactive power.
A control value is communicated from the real-time microcomputer to a controlled device when
a change in the device output is required. The number of data values communicated each time is
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
37/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 37 of 95 UMIST, 2002
typically one or two e.g. a set point for generator real power output and a set point for
generator power factor, or a binary value to open or close a breaker.
The choice of remote communications medium depends largely on the required speed of data
transfer. It is common for AVC devices to have an initial delay of 10 120 s between measuring
an over or under voltage and outputting a change tap signal to the OLTC. Once a change tap
signal has been output, some AVCs have a 5 60 s delay before outputting a second change
tap signal. These durations reflect present distribution network voltage control practice.
If the time between a significant real-time measurement change and a controlled device receiving
a new control value is no more than 5 s, then the DMS controller is operating in line with
present voltage control practice.
Two types of communication that permit this speed of data transfer are:
A public data network e.g. Vodafone Paknet, which gives call set-up times of less than
0.5 s.
Power line carrier.
2.2.5 Software
Figure 2.4 is a block diagram of the DMS controller software, showing its inputs and outputs.
The measurement input comprises the local and network measurements. The outputs are the
control values for the various devices under control. These are all real-time signals. The
remaining inputs are off-line data.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
38/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 38 of 95 UMIST, 2002
The network data input comprises the network topology and electrical parameters. The pseudo
measurement input provides values for all un-measured quantities that are required for the state
estimator. This input is described in more detail in Section 2.3.
The constraints input comprises three types of constraint:
Primary plant constraints e.g. embedded generator capacity
Control limits e.g. OLTC maximum number of tap steps
Network constraints e.g. voltage limits
The contracts input comprises the details of ancillary service contracts between the distribution
network operator and owners of:
Embedded generators
Controllable loads
Reactive power compensators
The DMS controller software has two functional blocks: state estimation and control scheduling.
The state estimation block uses the network electrical parameters, network topology, load
models and real-time measurements to calculate a network state estimate. This is passed to the
control-scheduling block, which uses it to calculate a new set of control values for the devices
connected to the network. The set of control values optimises the power flow in the network,
while observing all the constraints and taking account of all the contracts.
State estimation and control scheduling are discussed in detail in Sections 2.3 and 2.4.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
39/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 39 of 95 UMIST, 2002
StateEstimationMeasurements
NetworkData
Pseudomeasurements
Automatic voltagecontrol relays
EmbeddedGenerators
Contracts
EstimatesControl
Scheduling
Loads,Compensators,Circuit breakers
Constraints
Figure 2.4: Block diagram of DMS controller software
2.3. State Estimation
2.3.1 Background - Transmission State Estimation
A state vector is a set of variables that defines all the possible states of a system. Knowledge of
the state vector provides a basis for real-time control of the system. In the case of a power
system, the state variables are usually taken to be the voltage magnitude and relative phase angle
at each bus. These can be calculated using a load flow, given the system load and generation.
On a transmission network, the number of measurements is usually larger than the number of
state variables. The measurements contain errors and are therefore not necessarily the variables
required for load flow calculations. State estimation (SE) provides a means of utilising all
available measurements, taking account of the expected errors, to calculate the best estimate of
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
40/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 40 of 95 UMIST, 2002
the state vector. SE is used widely in Energy Management Systems (EMS) as the basis for real-
time control of transmission networks.
2.3.2 Distribution State Estimation
State estimation has not been widely applied to distribution networks. The main reason for this
is that distribution networks have traditionally been operated as passive radial networks and so
there was little need to estimate their state accurately.
The level of automation in distribution networks has increased in recent years, drive n mainly by
a perceived need to improve the quality of supply. Distribution management systems (DMSs)
have been installed that can rapidly re-configure the network to restore customers supplies
following a fault. The recent growth in embedded generation presents new challenges to these
systems. Embedded generators are far from being integrated into distribution networks, meaning
that their full potential is not realised. For this to happen, DMSs need to incorporate the
generation scheduling features of EMSs. As SE is the basis for these EMS functions, work isrequired to transfer SE from transmission to distribution systems.
Some work on distribution state estimation (DSE) has been reported in the academic literature
in the 1990s [1]-[7]. The following features of distribution networks are identified as being
different from those of transmission networks when applying SE.
Lack of real-time measurements although the number of measurements available to a
DMS is increasing, it is still much less than the number of state variables. This necessitates the
use of pseudo measurements, which are derived from historical data.
Network size distribution networks are topologically much larger than transmission networks.
Researchers have therefore developed computationally efficient algorithms for Distribution State
Estimators (DSE) that can be applied to a large part of a distribution network [1]-[4]. Network
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
41/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 41 of 95 UMIST, 2002
reduction methods have also been applied to provide a network model that is sufficiently simple
to analyse.
Low X/R ratio 11 kV distribution line impedance typically has a ratio of inductance to
resistance of about 0.5. The same ratio for a transmission line is typically about 10. This means
that transmission SE algorithms that decouple active and reactive power terms may not be
appropriate for distribution networks.
Radial topology distribution systems are generally operated as radial networks, unlike
transmission systems, which are operated as mesh networks. As the amount of embedded
generation increases, distribution networks may be operated meshed. A DSE algorithm
therefore needs to perform satisfactorily on both radial and meshed networks.
Bi-directional power flow distribution networks were generally designed for uni-directional
power flows from a few grid supply points radially outwards to customers. An embedded
generator may reverse the direction of power flow. A DSE algorithm therefore needs to take
account of bi-directional power flow on a radial network.
Unbalanced loads - distribution networks are operated with unbalanced loads in the USA and
consequently DSE algorithms that estimate state variables for all three phases have been
developed [2]-[4]. These may be unnecessary for UK distribution systems, which are operated
with more or less balanced loads compared to the USA.
2.3.3 A Distribution State Estimator
The following is a description of a distribution state estimator that is suitable for use with
embedded generation. The approach to selecting the SE method has been to use the simplest
applicable established techniques.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
42/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 42 of 95 UMIST, 2002
Weighted Least Squares Algorithm
The most common SE algorithm is the weighted least squares formulation, defined by Equation
1 below:
i2
{x1, x2, , xNs}
J (x1, x2, , xNs) = [Zi
eas fi(x1, x2, , xNs)]2
Nm
i = 1
min
(2.1)
Where:
x is a state variable
Ns is the number of state variables
fi is the function relating the ith measurement to the state variables
Zimeas is the ith measurement
Nm is the number of measurements
i2 is the variance of the ith measurement
J(x) is the measurement residual
The algorithm finds the best fit between the state variables and the available measurements,
taking account of the accuracy of the measurements. The difference between a measurement
and the measurement value calculated from the state variables is first taken. This is then squared
and divided by the variance of the measurement. The sum of these terms is then minimised by
adjusting the values of the state variables. This method has been proven in transmission systems
and is applicable to both radial and meshed networks.
Newton-Raphson Solution
The functions fi are non-linear and so Equation 2.1 cannot be solved directly. The Newton-
Raphson method finds the set of state variables for which the derivative of Equation 2.1 is zero,
by approximating the derivatives of the functions fi with Taylor series. This method is used in
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
43/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 43 of 95 UMIST, 2002
load flow and transmission state estimation (TSE) and so is well documented and is suitable for
use with the low line X/R ratio on distribution networks. Other methods, such as forward-
backwards sweep can be applied only to radial network.
State Variables
The state variables are taken as the bus voltage magnitudes and relative phase angles. These are
the most commonly used state variables in load flow and TSE and so their use is well
documented. In addition to these, the statuses of circuit breakers are taken as state variables.
Their use at transmission level is documented in [9] and their application to DSE is reported in
[8].
Some researchers have used branch currents as state variables for DSE, claiming improved
computational efficiency [3]. This is worth further investigation for application to the DMS
controller.
Measurement Functions
The functions fi relate measurements to state variables. The constants in these functions are the
network line impedances. Functions fi for DSE measurements are:
Bus active power injection
Bus reactive power injection
Line active power flow
Line reactive power flow
Line current magnitude
Bus voltage magnitude
Measurement equipment for some or all of these quantities may already be installed on a
particular part of a network.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
44/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 44 of 95 UMIST, 2002
Pseudo measurements
On distribution networks, the number of measurements is much less than the number of state
variables. A SE algorithm requires the number of measurements to be the same as or larger than
the number of state variables. The unmeasured quantities are provided by pseudo
measurements. These are measurement values that are derived from off-line data. Some
researchers have investigated the availability and use of such data [6], while others have
assumed it to be available [4]. It is proposed to calculate pseudo measurements using standard
load profiles for three load classes: domestic, commercial and industrial. The profiles specify a
normalised load expected value and variance for each half hour of the day. These will be
matched to the particular network using available historical data. The variance associated with
each pseudo measurement will be much larger than that associated with each measurement.
Statistical SE
In TSE, each measurement is modelled as an independent normally distributed random variable
with expected value Zimeas and variance i
2. The estimated state variables are therefore also
random variables. In TSE, generally only the expected values are considered. This is because in
TSE there are more measurements than state variables and so the state estimate is the most
accurate representation of the system state available.
In DSE, as the variances of the pseudo measurements are much larger than the variances of the
real measurements, the accuracy of the state estimate can be improved by increasing the number
of measurements. Clearly, the balance must be struck between cost of measurements and the
value that they bring.
A particular accuracy of state estimate will be necessary for control scheduling and this will
require a particular number of measurements. This accuracy and number of measurements can
be determined by calculating the statistical properties of the state variables and using these to set
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
45/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 45 of 95 UMIST, 2002
confidence limits. For example, consider an estimated bus voltage magnitude, modelled as a
normally distributed random variable and a fixed system voltage magnitude limit. If the expected
value of the estimated voltage is three standard deviations from the voltage limit, then there is a
99.73 % certainty that the actual bus voltage is within the limit. An acceptable level of certainty
is chosen and this determines how many standard deviations from a limit the expected value of a
state variable can be. The number of measurements is then chosen to provide a sufficiently small
state variable standard deviation to allow the state variable expected value to vary over an
acceptable range for control scheduling.
Three approaches to statistical DSE have been made. These use probabilistic load flow [5],
stochastic load flow [7] and fuzzy state estimation [8]. The stochastic load flow approach is the
simplest. It assumes that the measurements and pseudo measurements are normally distributed
random variables and approximates the state variables as normally distributed random variables.
It also allows correlation of measurements and pseudo measurements.
The accuracy of the stochastic state estimate will also depend upon the goodness of fit of a
normally distributed random variable to the actual variations of the measurements and pseudo
measurements.
2.4. Control Scheduling
Two methods have been considered for scheduling controls. These are priority list and optimal
power flow.
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
46/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 46 of 95 UMIST, 2002
2.4.1 Priority List
A priority list is specific to the part of network under the control of the DMS controller. The
network is studied off-line and a priority list of controls and sets of rules are drawn up. A set of
controls is then selected in real-time by testing the state estimate against the rules.
The priority list might comprise, for example, 30 sets of controls, with set 1 being the most
preferred and set 30 the least preferred. One set of controls comprises a setting for each device
under the control of the DMS controller. Each set of controls has an associated set of rules. Aset of rules comprises a permissible range for each state variable. The control-scheduling
algorithm tests the state estimate against each set of rules, starting with the most preferred set of
controls and continuing down the priority list. If the state estimate obeys all the rules for a
particular set of controls, then that set is output.
In drawing up the priority list, decisions are made as to the most desirable controls. The
following is a possible list of control aims that could be used to draw up a priority list. They refer
to the network shown in Figure 2.1 and are listed in descending order of preference. Generators
1 and 2 are taken to be synchronous and generator 3 to be asynchronous.
1. Maximise generator 1 active power export
2. Maximise generator 2 active power export
3. Maximise generator 3 active power export
4. Minimise generator 1 reactive power import
5. Minimise generator 2 reactive power import
6. Minimise compensator reactive power import
7. Minimise time controllable load is disconnected
8. Maximise voltage setting for OLTCs
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
47/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 47 of 95 UMIST, 2002
The order of preference would be established from the ancillary service contracts between the
network operator and the owners of the devices.
In selecting a set of controls, the control-scheduling algorithm also needs to take account of the
number of changes in control setting that it makes. In doing this, the type of device under control
needs to be considered. For instance, too many changes to the set point of an AVC relay will
cause mechanical wear in the OLTC, shortening its life. This is a less important issue for an
automatic voltage regulator of a synchronous machine, but would still need to be taken into
account.
The control settings also need to take account of generators such as wind turbines that have
fluctuating output power.
2.4.2 Optimal Power Flow
In general, the following sources of control may be available for managing the voltage and flowprofiles of active distribution networks:
Control limits e.g. OLTC maximum number of tap steps
Reactive power compensators
Embedded generators
Controllable loads
The choice of controls will depend on
Objective of the optimisation and cost associated with each of the controls
Operating conditions defined by the network topology and loading
Location and magnitudes of violated voltage and/or flow limits and
Effectiveness of each control source in eliminating specific violations and its cost
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
48/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 48 of 95 UMIST, 2002
This problem belongs to the class of general Optimal Power Flow problems. The main idea of
an OPF applied in the context of active distribution networks would to minimise the total cost of
available control actions while satisfying voltage and thermal constraints and determining the
value of the corresponding controls applied (GiP DiP , cQ and kT ).
This problem, for each individual settlement period t, may be stated mathematically as follows:
Objective function
),,,(,,,
ijiDiGiTQPP
TQPPMinimiseCDiGi
(2.2)
Subject to:
),,( TVPPPPP injiDiGiLiGi =+ (2.3)
),,( TVQQQQQQ in jiDiGiLiCGi =++ (2.4)
max
ijij SS (2.5)
max
ii
min
iVVV (2.6)
maxmin
Gi
cur
GiGi PPP (2.7)
max
cc
min
c QQQ
max
kk
min
k TTT (2.9)
)(GiGi
PfQ = (2.10)
)( DiDi PgQ = (2.11)
Where,
LiLi Q,P Active and reactive load at node i, at time t
-
7/28/2019 Active Management of Distribtion Networks.pdf
49/95
Integrated operation of embedded generation and distribution networks
Page 49 of 95 UMIST, 2002
GiGi Q,P Active and reactive generation at node i, at time t
GiGi QP , Active and reactive generation curtailment/increase at node i, at time t
(if possible)
DiDiQP , Active and reactive demand curtailment/increase at node i, at time t (if
possible)
cQ Reactive power absorbed by a reactive compensator, at time t
inji
inji Q,P Active and reactive power injection at node i, at time t
kTTap setting of the tap-changer k, at time t
ijS Load flows of the branch ij, at time t
max
ijS Maximum control load flow in branch ij, at time t
i Voltage angle at node i, at time t
iV Voltage at node i, at time t
The objective function (Equation 2.2) minimises the total cost of control actions. It is envisaged
that exercising each of the available control actions may be associated with some cost. For
example, there is likely to be some cost associated with constraining generators in order to
manage the voltage and flows in the network. The costing should be based on some form of the
opportunity cost which would form a base for the cost of contracts curtailment. This may be in
the form of fees associated with the exercise of the options. Nodal power balance equations are
represented by Equation 2.3 and 2.4.
The optimisation is also subject to the branch thermal constraint (Equation 2.5) and network
voltage limits (Equation 2.6). The maximum