absolute stability and the lagrange-dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · absolute...

24
HAL Id: inria-00071792 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071792 Submitted on 23 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard Brogliato To cite this version: Bernard Brogliato. Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings. RR-4794, INRIA. 2003. inria-00071792

Upload: others

Post on 01-May-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

HAL Id: inria-00071792https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071792

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theoremwith monotone multivalued mappings

Bernard Brogliato

To cite this version:Bernard Brogliato. Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivaluedmappings. RR-4794, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071792�

Page 2: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ISR

N IN

RIA

/RR

--47

94--

FR

+E

NG

ap por t de r ech er ch e

THÈME 4

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlettheorem with monotone multivalued mappings

Bernard Brogliato

N° 4794

April 2003

Page 3: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard
Page 4: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France)

Téléphone : +33 4 76 61 52 00 — Télécopie +33 4 76 61 52 52

������������ ���������������������������� ������! "������ $#&%'�( "�)"��� *�+���� ,�� � .-

/ �����0-1�����!������ 2-3������45���� ,�6-1�!7�78������

9;:=<?>"@A<?BC9D<?EAFHGJIJ@�KLENM

OQPSR�TVUXWDY[Z]\^T`_Sacbedf\hgji8Ud,glkmdf\hTV\cnobpdo\^gliq U�nor]nsdoRtTVUtn,ugjTVkSahU�vmUtn

wyxoglz{Ud.|*\hkAglk

}.blkSkAglxod q U!xoU?u�PSU�x�u�PSU~iA��Wm�e�lW�Y��.kSxf\ha��p�l�j�XY��l�Dk&bp�jUtn

�����t���e�S�l�l� OQPS\cn8iSgpdfU�k&xoU?nsUtijd�n8bpi�U�v]doU�i�ns\^gliCgp�`dfPSUNbp�&nogla^_mdfU�nsdfbl�S\^ah\hd{r�kSxfgl�Sa^U�T�bli q gl�dfPSU`��bp�lx�bpi&�lU���5\hxf\^u�P&ahU�d$dfPSU�gjxoUtT����,PSU�i8dfPSU`i&gliSa^\hi&Utbpxf\hdo\^UtnQU�i=dfU�xf\hiS��doPSU�TVg q Uta�bpxfU�ugji&no\ q UtxoU q�,\hdoP&\hi�doP&UXu�a^bjnon*gl��TVgliSgldogjiSUXT`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_SU q T�bpkSkS\^iS�=n! ¡ugji&noUt¢=_SU�i=dfahr�\^i&ua^_ q \^iS�VglkAU�x�bedfglx�n£�,\hdoPk&\hU?uU��,\cnoU�¤ah\^iSUtblx¥�lx�bpk&P&n�dfP&bed"T�bLr5xfU�kSxfUtnoU�i=d¦k&P=rmno\^utbpajU§HUtu(d�n�ah\^¨lU*©$gj_Sa^glT`���ªxo\cu(df\hgji¥� q Utb q �J«tgliSU?n��nfbedf_Sx�bedo\^gli�n��]U�acblnsdogl�Jk&a^bjn{df\^u�\¬d{rj�]bli q _SiS\^a^bpdoU�x�bpa¥u�gli&nsdox�bp\^i=dfn�­(®¯±°=²H³f´`µ �e¶��l� �.��nsgjah_mdfU�nsdfbp�&\ha^\¬d{rj�"iSgli&noTVg]gpdoPN�¦rjbpk&_SiSge�±�ª_Si�u(do\^gli�n��"T`_&a¬df\h�ebpa^_SU q TVgliSgldogli&UT�blkSkS\^iS�jnt�S·±glxfUtbl_¥¸ n*no�*U�U�k&\hiS�DkSxfgmuUtnfnt�mk&blnfns\^�]\¬d{rj�mugli]�jUv�bli&bpa^rmns\cn�®

¹±ºª»�¼¥º¾½+¼¦¿LÀ(Á?Â{Ãc½�ÄÆÅpÂ{ÇoÈ�Épºª¼�Ê�ËÍÌXÎ(Á�ÏÑÐpÎ(ÁLÁLÎ�ÏsÈ�Ò(Ó(Ó�Ô{ÕÂ{ÁtÖLÂØ×LÂ�ÄcÙ Ú�ÖLÛ¡Î(ÅpÂÈXÜ(Ý(Ü(Ü�ÞßÊ?Ô�àÆÁÏÑÃcº¾ÇJá,àÆÂ{ÛsÈãâeÛÑÔ�ÁLä{Â(Èå ÂsÛ¡ÁeÔ�Û¡×=æ å Û¡Î(ç(ÄÆàèÔfÏJÎ�é�àÆÁLÛ¡àèÔ�ÄÆÅpÂ{Çoæ êhÛ

Page 5: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

� ���!�8�������3�!�������� � *�+� �����,�� ��.-1 2�� 2�����! "������ $#&%'�( "�)"��� *��.4� ,)2�� ,� ��7��Q "�X�� ,� �� -1�����X���`�� ,�Í-3������(4 �����,�

��� ��� � � ©$UdodoU�i&gpdoU�u�gli&u�U�xfiSU!aJ¸ U�v=dfU�i&no\^gli q _8kSxfgl�Sa^R�TVU q U�acb�nsdfbp�&\ha^\¬d ��bp�&nogla^_SU!U�d q _�doP��tgp�xfR�TVU q U8�¦bp�jxfbliS�lU��¤�5\^xo\cu�PSa^Udt�"a^glx�no¢=_SU�aѸ gli ugji&ns\ q RtxoU q UtnDgjk��txfbpdoU�_&xfn;TVgliSgldogli&Utn;T`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_��tnq bpi&nQacbD��gj_&ua^U q UXxoU�dogj_Sxt®� µ �?� ³ ��� � ��� Z=dfbl�S\ha^\hd�� bl�&nogla^_SUl�*�ªgli�u(do\^gli q U �¥r=bpkS_&iSge�ßiSgjim�Ja^\cnonoUl�Qglk���x�bedfU�_Sx�n�TVgli&gpdogjiSUtnT;_Sahdo\^�Lblah_��tnt�mkSxogmu�Utnfns_&n q U x�b���U q U�·±glxfUtbl_¥� k�blnfns\^�]\¬d �l�]bpi&blahrmnoU u�gli]�lU�v]Uj®

Page 6: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� �

& ' �;�¦ "�����)£������

OQP&U5bp��nsgjah_mdfUãnsdfbp�&\ha^\¬d{rVkSxfgl�&ahUtT� Ñbpi q \hdfn$�ebpxf\hgj_&n �ªgjxoT�n£¨=i&ge�,i�bln£doPSU5k&blnfns\^�]\¬d{r;doP&U�glxfU�T�n�­ bpi qdfPSU!�¦bl�lx�bpiS�jU���ã\^xo\cu�PSa^Ud$doPSUtglxfU�T bpxfUX��gldoP��ª_Si q blTVU�i=dfbla�dog]glacn$�ªglxQdfPSU�n{df_ q r�gl�¦dfPSU�n{d�bp�S\^a^\¬d{r�gl�i&gliSa^\hi&Utbpx q r]i&bpTV\cu�bla�nor]nsdoUtT�n)(+*�,-(Æ�.,/(Æ��*�,¤® OQPSU)0&x�nsd£gliSU ugji&uUtxoi&n doPSUXn{df_ q rVgp�HdfPSU nsdfbl�S\^ah\hd{r;gl�b�ah\^iSU?bpx w�g=ns\hdo\^�lUD},Utbla�dox�bpi&ns�ªU�x5�ª_Si&udo\^gli2143�5.6; ¡glx TVglxfU`�lUtiSU�x�bpa^a^r�gl�$bpi]r q \cnono\hk�bedo\^�lUDnsrmnsdoUtT�­�,\hdoP�b�iSgliSa^\^iSUtblxyn{d�bedo\cuQ�ªUtU q �&bju�¨;u�P&blxfbju(dfU�xf\^nsdo\cup�lnoU�U70��l_SxfU8*l®"OQPSUãnoUtu�gli q gjiSU,�l\^�lU?nyb!uxf\¬dfU�xf\hgji�ªgjx�dfPSU�nsdfbl�S\ha^\hd{r�gl�ã�¦bl�lx�bpiS�j\^bli TVUtu�P�bpiS\cu�bla$nor]nsdoUtT�n�®:9�ißdoPS\cn`i&gpdoU��$U;0&xfnsd`U�v=dfU�i q doPSUtglxfU�T< ® =&®>*@?�\^iA(+*�,. �Bt­,dfg�dfPSU�u�bjnsU;�,PSU�i�doPSU�nsdfbedf\^u;iSgjiSah\^iSU?bpxf\¬df\hU?n5blxoU;T`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_SU q TDgjiSgpdfgliSU;T�bpkm�k&\hiS�=n` ªdoP]_&n \hi�k&bpxodo\cu_Sacbpx5bpa^ahge�,\^iS��dfPSU`iSgjiSa^\hiSU?bpxf\¬d{r�dog���UtahgjiS��dfg�doP&U;noUtu(dfglxDC EGF#H8IKJ�bpi q iSgpdxfUtnsdoxf\cu(doU q dog8doP&U�nsU?u(dfglx�C ELF#H8IM6s­®�OQP&U�iN�*U�Uv]doUti q doPSU���bp�jxfbliS�lU��¤�5\hxf\cu�PSahU�d5dfPSU�gjxoUtT'dfg±doPSUutblnoU;gl�$TVUtu�P�bpiS\cu�bla"��bp�jxfbliS�l\cbpi�normn{dfU�T�n!no_S�mz{UtudXdog8_SiS\^a^bpdoUtxfblaN( W�,ã ¡glx!\^iSUt¢=_&blah\hd{rS­ã�ªxo\cu(df\hgjiSahU?nonu�gli&nsdox�bp\^i=dfnt®PO�U.T�bp¨jU,_&nsU,gl�HdoPSUãu�gli]�lU�v;bpi�bpa^r]no\cn"�ªxfblTVU��*glxf¨�bln q Ut�lUtahgjk�U q �]rV},gmu�¨ebe�ªU�a^acbpxybpi q·ØglxfUtbp_A( =.,)(è�Q,¤®;|*U�ªgjxoUDn{d�bedf\hiS��doP&U;d{�*g�T�bl\hi�xoU?ns_&a¬d�n��H�*U;�Sxf\^U �&r±xfUtutbpa^a�dfPSUVugli q \¬df\hgji&n �,PS\cu�P�j_&bpx�bpi=dfU�UXdoP�bed b��l\^�lU�iØnsdfbpdoUSRGT`\cn b�0SvmU q kAgl\^i=d5gl� doPSU q r]i&bpTV\cu�bpa�nsrmnsdoUtT u�gli&no\ q U�xfU q ®.OQP&U�rd�bp¨jU;dfPSUV�ªglxfT gl�*�jU�iSUtxfblah\^«�U q U?¢j_�bedo\^gli�n� VU?­(®�OQPSU�\hi=doUtxoU?n{dX�ªgjx!Uv]doUti q \^iS�8doPSU�bp�Age�lUVn{d�bp�S\^ah\hd{rdfg]glacn£dfge�*blx q nydfPSU�u�bjnsU �,PSU�i�doP&UX�ªU�U q �&blu�¨�iSgjiSa^\hiSU?bpxf\¬d{r�\cn,bDT`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_SU q TVgliSgldogjiSU5T�blkSkS\^iS�&�a^\^Utn5\hi�doPSU;�¡bludãdoP�bed!ns_&u�P�glkAU�x�bedogjxfnãbpxfU`�,\ q U�a^r8_&nsU q \^i�kSP]rmns\cu�bla�TVg q Utaha^\hi&�  ªUj® ��®5\^i�TVU?u�P&bpim�\cu�nN(+*t�.,W(Æ�p��,W( �pW�,W( � < ,ª­(® OQPSgl_&�lP`TVgjiSgpdfgliS\cu\hd{r�ua^Utblxoa^rX\hTVkSa^\hU?n q \cnono\hk�bedo\^�]\¬d{r!gl�&dfPSU,nobl\ q glkAU�x�bedfglx?�xfU�i q U�xf\hi&�Vno_&u�P�Uv]doUti&no\hgji&n,TVglxfUXglx,a^UtnfnQ\hi=do_&\¬df\h�jU�a^r�ua^Utblxt�SdoPSU�bli&bpa^rmns\cnQP&blnQi&gpdt�SdogVdoP&U���U?n{d.gl�gj_Sx,¨]iSge�,a^U q �jUl�]rlU�dQ�AU�Uti q gliSUj®

XZY\[^]

__�`

a�\^�l_SxfU�*�by�.��nsgjah_mdfU!n{d�bp�S\^ah\hd{r��,\hdoP8TVgliSgldogjiSUXT`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_SU q T�bpkSk&\hiS�=n�®

OQPSU�i&gpdoU�\cn!gjxo�=bpiS\^«�U q bln �ªgjaha^ge�.nQb \^iNnsU?u(df\hgjiN���*U�xoU?u�blahaynoglTVUV�&blno\cuDu�gli&u�U�kmd�n!gp�Qugji=�jUvbli&bpa^rmns\cnt®*Z]U?u(do\^gliØ�V\cn q U��lgldoU q dfg�doP&U`bp�&nogla^_mdfU�n{d�bp�S\^ah\hd{r�kSxogj�Sa^U�T8�&bpi q nsU?u(do\^gli8W�u�gli=dfbl\hi�nQdoPSU

c XZY\[^] àÆÁ4deç(Ö?ÛÑÂ�e5àÆÇ,ÔVÊÏJÛ¡àÆä�ÏJÄ f;gmÎ(ÇJà ÏÑà ÕÂX¼¥ÂsÔ�ĦÏÑÛÑÔ�ÁLÇÑêhÂ{Ûãá.ÔfÏÑÛ¡à h�Ô�ÁL×�ÏJ¿L Î(ÅlÂ{ÛÑÔfÏJÎ(Ûji�kml _onpq_�` ÇJÔfÏJàÆÇVdeÂ{Çi�k Y+r�]tsur È _@v i�k Y _ ]xw;rzy|{xw;r Ô�ÁL× y _|}�~ �P� È?àcæ Â(æ�gG�;ÐpÂ{ÄÆÎ(ÁLç(Ç¥ÏJÎQÏÑ¿L ÇÑÂsä�ÏÑÎ(ÛZ� r@� ����] æ� àcæ Â(æNä{Â{Û¡ÏJÔ�àÆÁ8Ï�ftÅlÂ{ÇXÎ�ê£Û¡Â{ÄèÔfÏJàÆÎ(ÁLÇ5ÏJ¿eÔfÏXÔ�ÛÑÂ`ÇJàÆá,àÆÄèÔ�ÛQÏÑÎ�Â��tÖLÔfÏJàÆÎ(ÁLÇ Â�htä{Â{Å?ÏXÏÑ¿eÔfÏXÎ(ÁLÂ`ÇJàÆ×?Â!Î�ê$ÏÑ¿LÂ`ÛÑÂ{ÄèÔfÏÑàÆÎ(Á8àÆÇá*ÖLÄ ÏÑà Õ(Ô�ÄÆÖLÂ{×=æ

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 7: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

W � ����x����� � �^� $���V�����T�bpdoU�xf\cbpa�ugji&uUtxoiS\^iS�;doPSU���bp�jxfbliS�lU��¤�5\hxf\cu�PSahU�d£dfPSU�gjxoUtT+bpkSk&ah\^U q dog��¦bl�lx�bpiS�j\^bli�nor]nsdoUtT�n,ns_S�Sz{Utu(ddfgV_SiS\^a^bpdoU�x�bpa¥u�gli&nsdox�bp\^i=dfn*gli�doP&U!k�g=ns\hdo\^gli¥®$©$gji&ua^_&no\hgji&n*U�i q dfPSU!iSgpdfUX\hi±noUtu(df\hgji < ®

� � �`�¦�)�e��)£��� �� )$���D4� � ��������������-1���X��� �����`�(���¦��

�ãaha�doP&U�T�bedoUtxo\cbpa�\hi8dfPS\cn5noUtudo\^gli±\cn,dfbl¨lUti8�ªxogjTq( =.,7(Æ�Q, bpi q gliSa^r�bl\hT�n5bedã\^i=doxfg q _&u\^iS��dfPSU!dog]gja^n�,P&\^u�P8bpxfUXiSU�U q U q \hi�dfPS\^n.iSgpdfUl®

���� Y���� ]��� � Y���� ]

���� Y����#] ���� Y�����]Gs��^r��� Y�����]ts ~ � ����

�� � Y��� #]ts"!��

��# �� � Y���#�]

a�\^�l_SxfU���byO�bpiS�jU�i=d,bpi q iSgjxoT�bpa�u�gliSU?n�®

�¦Ud%$'&)( *,+ q U�i&gpdoU!b�u�gli]�lU�v�nsU�dt®�9¤dfnQ\^i q \cu�bpdogjxQ�ª_Si&u(df\hgji8\^n q U�0&iSU q bjn

-/. 3VR�610 23 4 E \h��R65"$H8I \h��R875"$  �*?­

� ugji=�jUv��ª_Si&udo\^gli:9/3<; 6ãnobpdo\cn�0&U?n=9/3?>LR4H 3A@CB8>�6EDL6=FG>�9/3VR�6/H 3A@HBI>�6<9/3JD�6.�ªglx bpa^a ELKM>8KN@l�bli q �ªgjx;bpa^aNR bpi q D�\hiß\hdfn8 Ñugli]�jUv&­ q gjTVbl\hiNgl� q U�0�iS\¬df\hgji¥®�OQPSU�no_S� q \¬§HU�xfU�i=df\^bla$gl�ãbØugji=�jUv�ª_&i&u(df\hgjiL9/3A; 6ybpd1D;\cn q U�iSgldoU q bln1OP9/3JD�6ybpi q \cn dfPSU5noUd*gp�¥no_S�S�lx�b q \hUtijd�n��j\Ñ® Ul®"�jUtu(dfglx�nRQ8nfbedf\^ns�ªr]\hi&�9/3VR�6�B�9/3SDL6�TUQPV 3VRWBLDL6 �ªglx$blaha�R¦® OQPSU ns_&� q \h§HU�xfU�i=do\cbpaAgp��dfPSUã\^i q \cu�bpdoglx$gp�X$  ¡�,PS\cu�P�\^n$ugji=�jUv\h�Y$ \cn,ugji]�lUv&­$\cnQ�l\^�lU�i��]r

O - . 3 Rx6102ZZZZ3 ZZZZ4[ E]\ \¬� R�5 9�i=dj3^$26

_ . 3 R�6�\¬� R�5"O�$` \¬� Ra75"$

 Ñ�l­

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 8: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� <

�,P&U�xfU=O $2\^n*dfPSU!�Agl_Si q bpxfr�gp�R$ �Sbpi q _ . 3VR�610 [ ����� V 3��,B Rx6 FMEGF��� 5�$8\X\cn*doPSU!gj_md{�*blx q ni&glxfTVbla�u�gliSU5dog $ bpdZR¦®�ãgpdf\^u�UãdfP&bed|E 5"_ . 3 R�6$bpi q doP�bedQ�$U5P&bL�lU q xfbL�,i�doPSUXnsU�dfnZR8H:_ . 3VR�6x�bedfPSU�x�doP�bpi _ . 3 Rx6(® OQPSU,nsU�d�\^i8 Ñ�l­�\cn�doPSU,no_S� q \¬§HU�xfU�i=df\^blaj�ªxfglT ugli]�jUv�bpi&blahrmno\^nt® �ãge�$Ut�lU�x��,PSUti$'\^n$iSgpdQugji=�jUvD\¬dQ\^n$kAgjnfns\^�Sa^U,dog;Uv]doUti q  Ñ�j­ _&no\^iS�;b q \¬§HU�xfU�i=d q U�0&iS\hdo\^gli�gp��dfPSU5no_S� q \¬§HU�xfU�i=df\^blaÑ�noU�U (>* < �"kSxogjk�g=ns\hdo\^gliß�S® W�®>*L�.,¤®8OQP&\^n`�,\ha^a$�AU�_&noU�ª_&a$�,PSUtiN�$U q Utbla£�,\hdoP �¦rjbpk&_SiSge� nsdfbl�S\^ah\hd{r gl�TVU?u�P&bpiS\cu�bla�nsrmnsdoU�T�nQ�,\hdoP8iSgjim�¤u�gli]�lU�v�b q TV\cnono\^�SahU!u�gli�0&�j_Sx�bedo\^gli�ns_&�&nsk�bluU?n*\hi±noUtu(df\hgji�W�®

��° �ß�m����� OQPSU�nor=T;��gja O�\^n,_�nsU q \hi8dfPSxoUtU q \h§AUtxoUtijd5TDU?bpiS\^iS�=n,\hi8dfPS\cn.k&blk�UtxQby�Agl_&i q bpxfr�gl�"bnoUd?��no_S� q \¬§HU�xfU�i=df\^bla¦bpi q k&blxsdf\^bla q Utxo\^�ebedo\^�lUj®$Z]\^i&uU�doPSU?nsU�i&gpdfbpdo\^gli&n,blxoU�u�a^bjnono\cu�bpa��*U�u�PSg]gjnoUXiSgpddfg�u�P&bpiS�jU doPSUtT�®

OQPSU�\hi]�Qbpx q nXdfbliS�lUti=d`ugli&U���3VR�6!\cn!dfPSU�kAglacbpxDugli&UVdog _ . 3VR�6`bpi q \cn q U�0&iSU q bln���3 R�6 0[ ��� ��L5a_ . 3 Rx6�F�� V � F E]\=®j9¤d \^nXbpacnog�nsgjTVUdo\^TVUtn q U�i&gpdoU q bln�� . 3VR�65\^i±doPSUDa^\¬dfU�x�bedo_&xoUj®5|*gpdfPdfPSU!iSgjxoT�bpa¥bli q doPSU!d�bpiS�jU�i=d.ugjiSUtn,blxoU!ugji]�lUv�noUd�n�® 9¤��dfPSU�nsU�d%$2\^n q U�0&iSU q bln [ R ��� 3VR�6HT E \�ªgjx*noglTVU q \h§AUtxoUtijdf\^bl�Sa^Uã�ª_Si�u(do\^gli ��� ( *,+��'( *��`�]dfPSU�i�bpi�bpahdoU�xfi&bpdo\^�lU q U�0&iS\hdo\^gli�gp�¦doPSU5dfbliS�lUtijdu�gliSU!bpd7R±\cn8( ?., �43 Rx6 0 [ � 5"( *,+ � � V"! �$# 3 R�6 T EGF��&%15(' 3 R�6 \  ¡�j­�,\hdoP)'�3VR�6%0 [ %H5 [ @�F *+*,*+F.-:\ �/�$# 3VR�6=F E]\j®�05iSU`iSgldoU?n.dfP&bed5doPS\cn q U�0&iS\hdo\^gli�ugj\hi&u�\ q Utn.�,\hdoP�doPSU0�xfnsd,gliSU!blnQa^gli&�Vbjn7R�5�$ß�Sbpi q dfP&bed%$2iSUtU q nQiSgld.��U�u�gli]�lU�v�dog q U�0&iSU1��3VR�6Q\^i� ¡�j­®�O U�noP&blaha_�nsU nsgjTDUãTVbpdoUtxo\cbpa&�ªxogjT ( ?�,H\^i�nsU?u(df\hgji�W&®yZ]gjTDUãUvSbpTVkSa^Utn*bpxfU q UtkS\^udoU q \^i40&�l_&xoU5�S�=noU�U bpacnsg;( W�,J®

� T�bpkSkS\^iS�&2x3A; 6.�ªxogjT43�dfg�5Í\cn nobl\ q T;_Sahdo\^�Lblah_&U q \h�£\hd blnfno\h�ji&nQdog�Utbju�P±U�a^U�TVU�i=d�R�gp��3 bno_S�&noUd62�3VR�6�gl�75  ª�,PS\cu�P!T�bLrã�AU£UtTDkSd{rl�eugjijd�bp\^i*z{_&n{d�gliSU UtahUtTVU�i=dt�Lglx�ugli=d�bp\^i�nsUt�lU�x�bpaeUtahUtTVU�i=dfn�­(®OQP&U$T�bpk&kS\hi&�jn��,PSgjnoU$�jxfblkSP&n�bpxfU£\^i!0&�j_SxfU$�` Ñut­*  q ­$ ¡U?­$ ¾�f­"blxoU$T`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_SU q (>*?�.,¤®�� T`_&a¬df\h�ebpa^_SU qT�blkSkS\^iS�82x3A; 6.\cn5TDgjiSgpdfgliSU`\¬� 3VRLBKR:9 6<V 3SD B8D/9 6CT E��ªglxXbpi]r8ugj_SkSa^UtnD3 RPF�DL6ãbli q 3 R:9�F�D;9�6,\^i�\hdfn�jxfblkSP¥®8O�PSUti(<)0 @DTVgliSgldogli&U;T�bpk&kS\hi&�jnXugjxoxfUtnok�gji q dog±u�glTVkSa^UdoUtahr±i&glim� q Utu�xoU?blno\hi&��u_Sxf�lU?n�®�¦Ud�= 3>2�6"0 [ R � R 5?3 F.2x3 R�6)70 ` \Ø�AUØdoP&U q glT�bl\hi gp�@2x3A; 6(® � TVgjiSgpdfgliSU±T�bpk&kS\hi&�)2�3<; 6�\^nT�bpv]\^T�bpa¥\h� �ªglx5bpi]roR 5A33bpi q bpi]rLD"5B5+ns_&u�P8dfP&bedDCSD BaDFE.F R B RGE HHT EV�ªgjx5bli=roRGE 5B=:3I2%6bli q bpi]r�DFE 5J2�3VRGEQ6(��dfPSU�i Da5)2�3VR�6®�©$gjTVkSahU�doUViSgji q Utu�xoU?blno\hi&��u_&xo�jUtn \hia( *�KVbpxfU`dfPSUV�lx�bpkSP&ngl�.T�bevm\hT�bla*TVgjiSgpdfgliSU�T�blkSkS\^iS�jnt®N�.iSgldoPSUtxD\^i=doUtxokSxfUd�bedf\hgjiN\^n;doP�bedDdoPSU��lx�bpkSP gp�ãb TVbpvm\hT�bpaTVgjiSgpdfgliSU TVblkSkS\^iS� utbpiSi&gpd��AU�U�iSacbpxf�lU q �,\¬dfPSgl_Sd q U?n{dfxoger]\^iS�NdfPSU TVgjiSgpdfgliS\cu\hd{r~ ªPSUti&uU doPSUi&gpdo\^gli�gp��T�bevm\hT�blah\hd{rS­(® OQPSU!ns_&� q \h§HU�xfU�i=do\cbpaXOGL73A; 6*gp�"bDu�gli]�lU�v�ahge�*U�x,noU�TV\^u�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_�ny�ª_Si�u(do\^gligji ( * + \^n�b�TVgliSgldogjiSU�T�blkSkS\^iS�&®NM vSbpTVkSa^UtnVgl�5TVgliSgldogjiSU�T�blkSkS\^iS�jn± I<N0 @?­DblxoU q UtkS\^udoU q\^iM0&�l_SxfU±�S® OQPSU�r TVbLr xoUtkSxoU?nsUti=d;�ebpxf\hgj_&nDkSP]rmns\cu�bla,a^bL�.nt�ya^\h¨jU q Utb q �J«tgliSU� ¡b=­(�Qnobpdo_Sx�bedf\hgji glxUta^bjn{dfgp�¤kSacblnsdo\cu\hd{r� ª��­�=u�glxfiSU�x acbL�PO`_Si&\hacbedfU�x�bpamU§HUtudfnt�l\ q Utbla q \^g q U.u�P&bpx�bludoUtxo\cn{df\^u�O� ¡u?­(�S©$gl_Sa^glT;��ªxf\cu(do\^gli   q ­�¦·(0XZØdox�bpi&no\cn{dfglxã\ q U?bpa u�P&bpx�bedfU�xf\^nsdo\cu� ¡U?­�¥_SiS\^a^bpdoUtxfbla"bli q b q PSU?ns\^�lU;U§HUtu(d�n� ¾�f­D(Æ�p��,J®05i&UØP&bln��ªglx�\^i&nsdfbli&uUBL73VR�6 0 - ~ ��Q 3 Rx6�\^i 0&�l_&xoU��� ¡ut­�RL73 Rx660 � R � HTSVUK �ªgjx�  q ­�RL73 Rx6 0-XW>YZD[ \�] 3 Rx6 B -X^ YG\V[ _6Z@` 3 Rx6 Hba \VYcK 3VR BPd�6 K \h� � R � Ted

EX\h� � R � Kfd �ªglxV ªUL­(®89¤�gL73VRGE�F�; ;�; F R � 6C0ih6E � RE � H; ;�;@H)h � � R � � H EK R�VzR¦�mdfPSU�i�OGL73VE 6 0 3 C Bjh6E�F.h6E^J F�; ;�;WF@C Bjh � F.h � J 6AVy®

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 9: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

= � ����x����� � �^� $���V�����

� BB

� B

B

B

� B

Y\JYGc �

c \ Y\ Yc

����� ���� ����

��� � ����� �����

a�\h�j_SxoU!�Gby·±gliSgldogjiSU5T�blkSkS\^iS�jn! ¡gliSU�� q \^TVU�i&no\^gli&bla¥u�blnoU?­®

� � �� 2������������ ������!�8���(����7� ��!�8� .-

OQP&U;bp��nsgjah_mdfU;nsdfbl�S\ha^\hd{r±kSxogj�Sa^U�T ugji&ns\cnsdfn5gp�£nsdo_ q r]\^iS��doPSUVn{d�bp�S\^a^\¬d{r8gp�*b�nor]nsdoUtT'bln5\hi:0&�l_SxfU;*�,P&U�xfU�143 5.6!\cn`b±kAgjno\hdo\^�lU�xfUtbla dox�bpi&ns�ªU�x��ª_Si&u(df\hgjißbpi q dfPSU��ªUtU q ��blu�¨��&xfbli&u�PNugli=d�bp\^i&n�bØnoUtudoglxnsdfbpdo\cu�i&gliSa^\hi&Utbpxf\hd{rl® 9¤d�\cn;gl�5\^i=doU�xfUtnsdDdog�Uv]doUti q dfPS\cnVxoU?ns_SahdVdog doPSU±utblnoU��,PSUtxoU�doP&U�gjk�Utxfbpdogjx��� � DL5 ( *�����D��:5"( *���\cn.bDTDgjiSgpdfgliSU glkAU�x�bedfglx?®

OQPSU�nsdfbpdoU!nok&blu�U U?¢=_&bedf\hgji&nQgp��doPSU�normn{dfU�T+\^io0&�l_SxfU�*!bpxfU �j\h�jU�i��]r

2ZZZZ3 ZZZZ4�R ��! "�!0$#jR B&% D��D 0(' R

D�� 5"OGL73SDL6

 ªW=­

�,PSUtxoU=DxF<D � 5 ( * � �%R65 ( * + bpi q b&® Uj®"TDU?bpi&n*bpa^TVgjnsd*Ut�lUtxor]�,PSUtxoU,\^i�dfPSUX�¥U��AUtno�l_&UãTVUtbjns_SxfUl®OQP&U;0SvmU q k�gj\hi=d�n;gl�; ªW]­`utbpiß�AU8u�P&bpx�bludoU�xf\^«�U q �,\hdoP doPSU8�jU�iSUtxfblah\^«�U q Ut¢=_&bedf\hgjiAE)5 [ #jR T \ B% OGLN3�' R T 6(®y�¦Ud._&n.bjnono_STVU5doP&bpd�*) 143 5.610('�3 5 (WB+# 6 Y E %��m�,\¬dfPK3,# F-%�F.'86Qb;TV\^iS\^TVbla�xoUtkSxfUtnoU�i=dfbpdo\^gli¥�]\cn,bDZ=dfxo\cu(dfahr�w"gjno\¬df\h�jU

},UtblaA JZ]w£}ã­¦dfxfbli&n{�ªUtx¦T�bedfxo\hv�®P9�i�k�bpxodo\cu_Sacbpx¦doPS\cn�\hTVkSa^\hU?n¥dfP&bed�doP&U�xfU£Uvm\cn{d�n¦kAgjno\hdo\^�lU q U�0&iS\hdoUT�bedoxf\cuUtn/� 00�WV�bli q21 0 1 VNno_&u�P�doP&bpd3��#AH4#CV5� 0GB 1 bpi q % V�� 00' ( �.,J®

�6) L � ( *�� � ( *87 [ H8I \�\cn�u�gli]�lU�v a^ge�$Utx�noU�TV\^u�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_�n��.nogNdoP�bed OGL \cn�b TVbpvm\hT�bpaTVgliSgldogli&U T;_Sahdo\^�Lblah_&U q T�bpkSkS\^iS�± ¡noU�U!Uj® ��® (+*Q=m�mU�vSbpTVkSa^U`�m® �S® W�,ª­(®

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 10: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� �

�$° � �ß� � �¥U�d$blnfns_&TDkSdo\^gli&n � ) bpi qV�6) P&gla q ®z9¤�5' R 3VE 6�5 q glT O:L*�jdoPSUti�doP&UãnsrmnsdoUtT \^iØ ªW=­yP&blnbD_Si&\^¢=_SU�bl�&nsgjah_SdoU�a^r�ugji=do\^i=_&gl_&n! Ñ�ã©Q­Qnsgjah_mdf\hgji�gji-C ELF�H8IA6®

� � µ¥µ�� � �¦Ud%* ��UXdfPSU�no¢=_&blxoUXxfg]gpd,gp�6�V�S\J® Uj®1*M0 *,V�� E&� *,* 0(�V®$©$gli&no\ q U�xQdfPSU�ugji=�jUva^ge�*U�x5noU�TV\cugjijdf\hi]_Sgj_&nã�ª_Si&u(df\hgjia9 � ( *=+A� ( * 7 [ H8I \ q U�0&iSU q �]r 9/3 � 6%0?LN3�',* Y E � 6®��ãno\hiS�� ) nsP&ge�.nQdoP&bpd�XU�x.3 ',V 6 0 [ E]\`nogVdoP&bpdj9�T�3 ',* Y E 6 0 9�T�3 '86 0M( *��`®|aSxfglTq( =&�SdfPSU�gjxoUtT��m® �S® ��,\hd,�ªgla^a^ge�.n£dfP&bed%OP9/3 � 6Y0 * Y E ',V O:L73�',* Y E � 6(® �¦Ud._&nQkSxfge�lU5doP�bed,doP&U�nsrmnsdoU�T23 4 �� 5"* #%* Y E � BaO 9/3 � 6

� 3VE 6Y0 * Rz3 E 6  < ­

P�bln�b±_&iS\^¢=_SU��ã© nogla^_mdo\^gliNgjimC EGF#H8IM6(®ua�\^x�n{d?��dfgØnobLr�doP&bpd ' Rz3 E 6 5 q glT'O:LC\cnXdog�nfbLrØdfP&bed',* Y E � 3VE 6�5 q gjT OGL*�&bpi q dfPS\^n z{_&n{d.TVU?bpi&nQdfP&bed � 3VE 6�5 q glT OP9�®£Z]U?ugji q �S\hd,�ªgla^ahge�.n*�ªxfglT+doPSU�!blahT�blim��£bl¨]_S��ge�]\cu�Pm�¤w�gjk�ge�!a^U�TVT�bXdfP&bed *�#C* Y E HK3^*�#C* Y E 6<VØ\cnyiSUt�jbpdo\^�lU q U�0&iS\hdoU!(Æ�m� �f�&® �&®>*�,J®OQP&U�xfU�ªglxfU�dfPSUDT`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_SU q T�bpkSkS\^iS� BH* #%* Y E H O 9N\^n T�bevm\^TVbla"TDgjiSgpdfgliSUo(>*@=m�¥a^U�TVT�b��S® W�,J®©$gji&noUt¢=_SU�i=dfahrVdfPSU!Uvm\cn{dfU�i&u�U�bpi q _SiS\c¢=_SU�iSU?nonQxfUtno_SahdQ�ªgla^ahge�.n*�ªxfglT (+*Q=m�mdfPSU�gjxoUtT+�S®+*�,¤®ãge� nsU�dDR 3�� 6 0 * Y E � 3�� 6(®-9¤dD\cn;nsdox�bp\^�lP=do�ªglxf�*blx q dog�u�PSUtu�¨ doP�bed�Rz3�� 6;\cn;b nsgjah_Sdo\^glißgl�.doPSUnormn{dfU�T \^iN ªW]­(®y�,u(df_&bpa^a^r�doPSU�normn{dfU�T \^i�  < ­*\cn q U q _&uU q �ªxogjT  ªW]­*�=r�doPSU!u�P&bliS�lUXgp�"n{d�bedfU �jUtudoglx� 0 * R¦®

�5n,bpi�U�vSbpTVkSa^Ul�ma^Ud,_&nQugji&ns\ q Utx q \^nfns\^k&bpdo\^�lU5�¦\hi&Utbpxã©$gjTDk&ahUtTDUti=dfbpxf\hd{r�Zmr]nsdoUtT�nt Ñ��©QZS­ (+*Q?., b23 4 �RL00#)R�H4% >

E F D 00' R�� >�T E V=j­

�,P&U�xfUo3,#!F %;F-'865nobpdo\cn�0&U?n � ) bl��ge�jUl� DxF >a5 ( * � ��bpi q ' Rz3VE 6=T E&® OQPSUVnoUtugji q a^\hiSUD\^i  V==­,\cn5bnoUd gp�£u�glTVkSa^U�TVU�i=dfblxo\hd{r8ugli q \¬df\hgji&n5��U�d{�$UtU�i6D±bpi q >¥��nsdfbpdo\^iS��dfP&bed ��gldoPØdfPSUtnoU�dfU�xfT�nãP&bL�jU!dogxfU�T�bl\hi�iSglim�¤iSUt�jbedf\h�jU5bli q gjxsdfPSgl�jgli&bla&gjiSUãdfgVUtblu�P�gpdfPSU�x?® OQPSU!��©QZ�\hi� V==­$utbpi���UXUt¢=_S\^�ebpa^U�i=doa^rxfU��,xf\hdsdoUti�bjnQ\hiN  < ­$�,\¬dfP�LN3JDL610 -�� ~ ��� ] � 3SDL6®

��° �ß�m����� 9¤dØ\^nØ\hi=doUtxoU?n{df\hi&� dfg�iSgpdfUßb�ua^gjnoUNugli&iSUtudo\^gli ��U�d{�$UtU�iCdoPSU nsrmnsdoU�T \hiÍ  < ­8bpi q·ØglxfUtbp_¦¸ nj0&x�n{d!glx q Utx no�$UtU�kS\^iS��kSxfg]u�UtnfnD(>*?�.,)(>*e�Q,¤�¥\Ñ® Ul®DU��jgla^_mdo\^gli kSxfgl�Sa^U�T�n gp�$doPSUV�ªgjxoT �R/3�� 6 5BHO -�� W��>` 3VRz3�� 6 6;�ªglx�noglTVU8nsU�d '�3�� 6(® OQPSU±nsrmnsdoU�T�nD�*U��,\^aha q U?bpa,�,\hdoP \hi doPSU8iSU�v]d�noUtudo\^gli bpxfUnoUtu�gli q gjx q Utx�no�$UtU�kS\^iS�ßkSxfgmuU?nonoUtnt® 9�i�u\ q U�i=dfblaha^r ahUtTDT�bm* nsPSU q n�bßiSU�� a^\h�jPjd�gli dfPSUØxfUtno_Sa¬d\^i (+*Q?.,yno\hi�uU`\hd!nsPSge�.n.doP&bpd \^iS\hdo\cbpaAz{_STVk&n \^i±doPSUVnogla^_mdo\^gli:R 3�� 65bpxfU`iSgld5iSUtU q U q \h� Rz3 E 6ã��UtahgjiS�jndfg�doPSU�b q TD\cnfns\^�Sa^UVnoUd [ R � ' R 5 q glT OGL \j®VOQPSUVxoU?ns_&a¬d�nX\hi (>*@?.,£bpa^a^ge� b��ªU�U q doPSxfgl_S�jP�dfU�xfT'\^iD8bpi q kSxoge�]\ q U!iSU?uUtnfnfbpxfr�bpi q ns_���u�\hUtijd ugli q \¬df\hgji&n,�ªgjx5bl�&nsUti&uU`gp� \hi&\¬df\^blaSz{_STVk&nt®ãOQPSU;kSxoU?nsUti=dk�bpkAU�x q g]Utnoi¥¸ dXblaha^ge� b��ªU�U q doPSxfgl_S�jPØdfU�xfT'bpi q �l\^�lU?nãgjiSahrØno_���u\^U�i=d!ugji q \hdo\^gli&n5�ªglxXiSgji \^iS\hdo\cbpaz{_&TDk�n��¥P&ge�$Ut�lU�x TVglxfU;�jU�iSUtxfbla��ª_Si&u(df\hgji&n@L73A; 6XbpxfUDu�gli&no\ q U�xfU q ®Da�\hi&blaha^rØa^U�TVT�b *V\cnXxoUta^bpdoU q dogdfPSU�_&iS\^¢=_SUtiSUtnfn�xfUtno_Sahd`\^i ( ��,*�,PSUtxoU�doPSU��jxfblkSPUOGL�\cnDb±xoUta^bLr�u�P&bpx�bludoUtxo\cn{df\^uVbli q doPSU�dox�bpi&ns�ªU�xT�bpdoxf\¬v2143�5.6 \^n!b�w �¤T�bedoxf\hvA( �j�@,y�ªgjx�ns_���u�\hUtijdfahr�a^blxo�jU�5 5 ( *;®�Z]w$} dfxfbli&ns�ªU�x!T�bedfxo\cuU?n nfbedf\^ns�ªrno_&u�P�xoU?¢=_S\hxfU�TVUtijd�n��]�S_Sdã�$U!u�gli&no\ q U�xfU q TVgjxoUX�lUtiSU�x�bpa�u�P&blxfbju(dfU�xf\^nsdo\cu�nt®

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 11: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

? � ����x����� � �^� $���V�����a�\^i&bpa^ahr a^Ud¥_&n�i&gpdoU£\hiXk&bjnono\hi&�QdoP&bpd¥ahUtTDT�b�*yblkSkSa^\hU?nHdog,iSgjiSa^\hiSU?bpx¦normn{dfU�T�n¥bjn �R 0GB�� + ��� T R K � _ E BD ��� D"0 R¦�XD �)58OGL73SDL6(�PRI58( *D® 9�i q UtU q doPSU q r]i&blTD\cu�n B D��4�� D±\cnXn{dfxo\cu(dfahr q \^nfns\^k&bpdo\^�lU`�,\hdoP

nsdogjxfbl�lUã�ª_Si&u(df\hgji S UK �&nsgDdfP&bed3� 0G@�bli q � 0 R¦®

�¦Ud,_&nQiSgldo\cuU5doP&bpd DL5 q gjT OGL$® a�\^i&bpa^a^rVdoPSUtxoUXUvm\cn{d�nQb;�¦U��AUtno�l_SU \hi=dfU��lx�bp�&ahU5�ª_Si&udo\^gli��!3�� 6no_&u�P doP&bpd!Rz3�� 6 0���!3�G6 ���� �,PSU�xfU����\cnXdoP&U��¥U��AUtno�l_&UDTVU?blno_SxoUj®8�.Uti&uU�� R)0��!3�� 6 � ��bln!bliU?¢=_&bpa^\¬d{r�gp��TVU?blno_SxoU?n�®

�$° � �ß� � �¥U�dVbjnono_STVkmdo\^gli�n �*) � �6) PSgla q �"doP&U�\^iS\¬df\^bla q bed�b±��U8no_&u�P�doP&bpd ' R 3VE 6L5 q gjT O:L*�bli q bjnono_STVU!doP�bed doPSUD�lx�bpkSP±gl�1OGL u�gli=dfbl\hi�nS3 ELF E 6(® OQPSU�iWb�� ) R:0 E�\cn.dfPSUD_SiS\c¢j_&U;nogla^_mdo\^gliØgl�dfPSUD�lU�i&U�x�bpa^\h«tU q U?¢j_�bedo\^gli+#)R)54% OGL73 ' R�6���� ) OQPSUD0SvmU q kAgl\^i=d R80 E�gl�ydoPSU�normn{dfU�T \^i  ¡W=­ã\^nU�vmk�gjiSU�i=do\cbpa^a^r�n{d�bp�Sa^Ul®

� � µ¥µ�� � OQPSU�k&xog]gp�.gl�ãk&blxsd�� ) \^nDbln`�ªgla^ahge�.nt®Ka�\hx�n{dVgp�ãblahaQiSgldo\cuU�doP&bpdDR 0 E \cn`\^i q UtU q b0&v]U q k�gj\hi=d`gl�QdoPSU q r]i&bpTV\cu�n��,\hdoPNi&g�ugjijdfxogjaÑ�"no\hi&u�U;Ea5 % OGL73VE 6(®Aãge� #jR 5 % OGL73 ' Rx6����#jR65 ��% OGL73 ' R�6�� R�V ��#)R"0 R�VRO��x3VR�6�S�,PSU�xfU��x3VR�610 L73 ' Rx6�( =&�Sk¥®Æ�l� < ,¤��� 3A; 6*\cn.ugji=�jUv:( =S�k¦® � ?�,¤��bpi q �$U`_&nsU q blnfno_STVkmdo\^gli �*) ®ãOQPSU;T`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_SU q T�blkSkS\^iS� O��x3VR�6.\^nãTDgjiSgpdfgliSU;ns\^i&uU��x3<; 6\cn`u�gli]�lU�v�®ØOQP=_�n R�VRO��x3VR�6 T E±�ªglxVbpa^a R 5 ( *,+�®(.ge� doPSUtxoU�Uvm\^nsdfn 1 0 1 V � EØno_&u�PNdfP&bedR�V5��#jRL0 B EK R�V 1 R�K E��ªgjx*blahaxR870 ES®£©$a^Utbpxfa^r;dfPSU�ioR±nobpdo\cn�0&U?nydfPSUX�lUtiSU�x�bpa^\h«tU q U?¢=_&bedf\hgji�gliSa^r\h�/RL0 E&®

�¦Udã_&nãiSge� kSxfge�lUXk&bpxod���� ) ®ã©$gli�ns\ q U�x.doPSU`utbpi q \ q bpdoU`�¦rjblkS_SiSge���ª_&i&u(df\hgji�� 3 R�6 0 EK R�V ��R¦®a&xogjT a^U�TVT�b�*,\¬d£�ªgla^ahge�.n"dfP&bed dfPSU q r]i&blTV\^utn \hiØ ¡W=­�kAgjnfnsU?nonoUtn"gji:C EGF#H8IM6�b�nsgjah_Sdo\^gliDRz3�� 6y�,PS\cu�P\cn£�ã©5�=bpi q �,P&gjnoU q U�xf\h�ebpdo\^�lU �R/3�� 6"U�v]\cnsdfn£b&® Uj®h®"OQPSUãnfbpTVUãblkSkSa^\hU?n"dog�� �,P&\^u�P�\cn£�ã© (Æ�p�m�=k¥®+*Q?l��,J®�5\h§AUtxoUtijdf\^bpdo\^iS��bpa^gliS�DdfPSU!ua^gjnoU q �¤ahg]gjk�dox�bez{U?u(dfglxf\hU?n$�*UX�lU�d

�! � 3 R 3�� 6 6 ��! "�!0 R�V����0mR�V5�43 #)R B&% D �W6 0 B|R�V 1 R B-R�V5��% D��0 B|R�V 1 R B2R�V ',V D��

 J�p­

�,P&U�xfU D�� \^n!bli]r±�lUtudogjxãdfP&bed��AU�a^gliS�=n5dog�OGLN3�' R�6®VOQP&UDU?¢=_&bpa^\¬d{r�\hi doPSUD0&x�nsdXa^\^iSUVTDU?bpi&n dfP&beddfPSU q U�i�ns\hd{r�gp��doPSU!TVU?blno_SxoU���3��#"ZR�6*�,\hdoP�xoU?nskAUtud*dfgDdoPSU��¦U��AUtno�l_SU TVUtblno_SxfU�� �X ª�,PS\cu�P�U�vm\^nsdfnno\^i&uU�� 3 Rz3�� 6 6$\cn$�ã©Q­£\^n£doP&Uã�ª_Si�u(do\^gli;R V ����®$©$gli&noUt¢=_SUti=doa^r �! � H R V 1 R65 B|R V ' V OGL73 ' Rx610B|R�V O�� 3 R�6ãbS® Ul®^®,�¥Ud _&nãu�gli&no\ q U�xãbli]r � 5 O��x3VR�6® 05iSU��jUdfn �! � ��! " !0 B|R�V 1 RLB R�V � F B|R�V 1 R�ªxfglT'doPSU�kSxfglkAU�xod{rØgl�*TVgli&gpdogjiSUVT`_Sahdo\^�ebpa^_SU q T�bpk&kS\hi&�jn!bpi q no\^i&uU�3 RzF � 6W0 3VEGF E 6ã�AU�a^gli&�jn dogdfPSUØ�jxfblkSP gl�,O�� 3 Rx6(® OQPSU�noUd�gp�Xdf\hTVUØ\^i&nsdfbpi=d�n�bed��,PS\cu�P doPSU�\hiSU?¢=_&bpa^\¬d{r �! � F B|R�V 1 R�\^ni&gpd�nfbedo\cn 0&U q \^n�iSU��jah\^�l\^�Sa^U±\hi doP&UØ�¥U��AUtno�l_&U±TDU?blno_SxfUl®m9¤d��ªgla^a^ge�.nDdoP&bpd�doPSU8�ª_&i&u(df\hgji gl�5df\hTVU� 3<; 6�"�,PS\^u�P�\cn`u�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_&nt�¦\cn!iSgjiS\^i&uxfUtbjns\^iS�&®�OQP=_�n�gli&U�P&bln�� 3�� 6�B$� 3 E 6 0 � �T 3<B|R�V 1 R"BR�V � 6 �� F B � �T R�V 1 R%���®�©$gji&noUt¢=_SU�i=dfahr EK >'&)( *G3,� 6�R�VzR F�� 3VE 6�B � �T >+&)( *G3 1 6�R�VPR%����y�,P&U�xfU>'&)( *L3A; 6,\cn,dfPSU`noTVblaha^Utnsd.U�\^�lUti]�Lblah_&Ul®Q|$r�doPSU�, xogji=�Qbpa^aJ¸ nQa^U�TVT�b�gli&U��lU�dfnQdfP&bed EK >'&)( *t3,� 6�R�VPR:F� 3 E 6.-0/21�3 B�46587'9 : W<;6`5 7'9 : W<= ` � >Ø�,PS\cu�P±ugji&ua^_ q U?n*doPSU!kSxfg]gp�{®

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 12: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� �

��° �ß�m����� },U�acbedfU q �$gjxfno¨Dutbpi��AU �ªgl_Si q \^i (Æ��?.,¥bpi q \^i ( �l�m�]dfPSU�gjxoUtT *?�S® < ® �L*�,J�j�,PS\^u�P�bpkSkAUtblxfnbjnãb�k�bpxodo\cu_Sacbpx u�blnoU�gl�yahUtTDT�b��S® 0ãdoP&U�x Uv]doUti&ns\^gli�n,�ªglxãdoPSU;k&blnfno\h�]\hd{r�dfPSU�gjxoUtT �,\hdoP��ªU�U q �&blu�¨�&xfbli&u�PSUtn£doP�bedQTVbLr�u�gli=dfbl\hi��Lblxo\^gl_�n£gjk�Utxfbpdoglx�n£bli q i&gliSa^\hi&Utbpxf\hdo\^Utnt�]utbpi���U �ªgl_&i q \^i2(Æ��*�,J®yZ]gjTDUgl�.doP&U�gjk�Utxfbpdogjxfn D �� D � u�gli&no\ q U�xfU q \^i (Æ��*�,QUti&ugjTVk&blnfn�dfPSU8gliSU?n;u�gli&no\ q U�xfU q \^i doPS\cnDk&bpkAU�x ¡ah\^¨lU dfPSU!nobpdo_Sx�bedf\hgji�\^i;0&�j_SxfU �8 ª�A­s­(®��ãge�$Ut�lUtx$T;_Sa¬df\h�eblah_SU q TVblkSkS\^iS�jnQblxoU iSgpd,\^i&ua^_ q U q \^i�doPSU�ªx�bpTVUt�$gjxo¨�gl�N(Æ��*�,J�Hbpi q iSUt\¬dfPSU�x bpxfU!�lx�bpkSP�nQ\hi&u�ah_ q \hi&��_SiS\^a^bpdoUtxfbla¦ugji&n{dfxfbl\hi=d�n.bln,\^iu0&�j_SxoU��± Ñut­ ¡U?­X ª�f­(®

� � �� 2������ ������� $#&%'�( "�)"��� *� ���� ,�! " .-

�¦Ud,_&n.u�gli&no\ q U�x*doP&UX�ªgla^ahge�,\^iS��uacblnfn*gp�"_SiS\^a^bpdoU�x�bpa^a^r�ugji&n{dfxfbl\hi&U q TVU?u�P&bpiS\cu�bla¥nsrmnsdoUtTVn2ZZZZ3 ZZZZ4� 3���6���|H�43��%F ���610 ! � 3���6�>E F � 3���6 � >"T E

��L3�� _ � 6 0NB� ��%3�� Y� 6PH 3A@ZH��6�k&xogLv � W�� W ��� `>` C ��G3�� Y� 6�F���3���3�� � 6 6 J V?j­

9�i   ?j­�� 3���6�0��GV 3���6 �qEN\cn�dfPSUA<��J< \^iSUtxsdf\^bNT�bpdoxf\¬v����43��%F ���6�0 '�3��%F ���6 ��DH����� � 3���6�,P&U�xfU3'�3��%F ���6 �� q U�i&gpdoU?nyuUti=doxf\hkAUd�bpa&bli q ©$glxf\hgjah\cn"�lUtiSU�x�bpa^\^«�U q �ªglx�uU?n��j�,PSU�xfUtbjn���3���6 \^n$b!nsTVg]gpdfPkAgpdfU�i=do\cbpa$U�iSUtxo�jrØ�ªxfglT2�,PS\cu�Pßugli�nsUtxo�ebedf\h�jUD�ªglx�uUtn q U�xf\h�jUl®±OQPSU�\^TVk&blud�do\^TVUtn;bpxfU��lUtiSU�xf\^utbpa^ahrq U�iSgldoU q bln�� � ��dfPSU�a^U�¾do�Ja^\^TD\hd ���3�� Y� 6 5 BR��3���3�� � 6 6��,PSUtxoU?blnXdfPSU�xf\^�lP=ds�¤ah\^TV\¬d ���3�� _ � 6 5 ��3���3�� � 6 6(®OQP&U�doPS\^x q ah\^iSU�\^i  V?=­!\cn`b±u�gla^ah\cns\^gliNT�blkSkS\^iS�8doP&bpd;xfU�acbedfUtn!kSxfU�Xbpi q kAgjnsds�¤\^TDk�blu(d��jU�iSUtxfblah\^«�U q�jU�a^gmu\hdo\^Utnt�¥bpi q 5 C EGF�@�J \cn!b�xoU?n{df\¬df_mdo\^gli�ug]U ��u\^U�i=d4(+*t�.,¤®DOQP&UDi&gpdfbpdo\^gli kSxogLv � W��.` TVUtbli&n doPSUk&xogLvm\^TVbpdo\^gli \hi doPSU�¨]\^iSUdf\^uVTVU�doxf\^ul�¦\J® Uj®;dfPSU�TVUdfxo\cu q U�0�iSU q bln R�V�� 3���6EDØ�ªgjx8RPF�D85)( *,+xbXdoPSU�jUtudoglx �� W ��!� `I_#" �� W �%$� `E _#" \^nXdfPSU�ua^gjnoUtnsd��lU?u(dfglxXdog8dfPSU�kSxfU�¤\^TDk�blu(d��jU�a^gmu\hd{rl�¦\^i&no\ q U8��3���3�� � 6 6� ª\hd;u�blidfPSU�xfU�ªgjxoU,�AUXuglTVkS_SdoU q dfPSxfgl_S�jP�b`¢=_&b q xfbpdo\cuQkSxogj�lx�bpTVTVU?­N( ?�,¤®/9�i�k&bpxodo\cu_&a^blx doPSU5\hTVk&bju(d*a^bL� \^i  ?j­$\^TDk&ah\^UtnQdfP&bed,dfPSU!¨]\hi&Udo\cuXU�i&U�xf�lr�a^gjnfn,bedQdo\^TVU � � nfbedf\^n 0&U?n! ¡noU�U�(>*?�.,¤�W( W&�Sk¥®+*t�l�&�mk¥® W ?l��,�(>*L�@,¾­

� � 3�� � 6 0NB @4 @ B&@ZH')( ���3�� _ � 6/B ���3�� Y� 6+* V � 3���3�� � 6 6 ( ���3�� _ � 6YB ���3�� Y� 6,* FME  ¡�j­

��° �ß�m���- OQPSU �ªgjxoT;_Sa^bpdo\^gli gp�]doP&Uy_SiS\^a^bpdoUtxfblalugji&n{dfxfbl\hi=d�nH\hi�  ?j­ q g]U?n�iSgpd�U�i&u�glTVk&blnfn�bpa^aju�ahg=nsU qq glT�bp\^i&n/. 0 [ � � � 3���6 T E]\=��bln`ns\^TVkSahU�i&glim��ugji=�jUv utblnoUtnX�,\hdoPßnogp��u�blaha^U q xoUtU�i=dox�bpi=d�ugjxoi&U�x�nk&xoge�jU�(>* *�,¤® 9¤d!u�bliØ�AU;_&noU q dog q Utnfuxf\h�AUVb q TV\cnono\h�&ahU q glT�bp\^i&n0.C�,PS\cu�P bpxfU q U�0&iSU q Ut\¬dfPSU�x �]r8bno\^iS�la^U�ugji&n{dfxfbl\hi=d� ª\J® Ul® - 0 @L­(�&gjx,�,\¬dfP�- K H8I �,PSU�xfU�ugji=�jUvm\hd{r�PSgla q n.bpdãiSgji q \h§AUtxoUtijdf\^bl�Sa^UkAgl\^i=dfnQgl��dfPSU!��gj_Si q blxorLO1.  ¡no_&u�P±nsU�dfn,blxoU!u�blaha^U q � $���>��� (>* < ,ª­(® 9¤d.\cn,UtbjnsrVdfg�\hT�bl�l\^iSUXkSP]r]no\cu�bpaU�vSbpTVkSa^Utn£doP&bpd q gDiSgpdZ0SdQ�,\¬dfPS\hi�doPS\cn$�ªxfblTVU��*glxf¨A�jUl® �&® b�acb q&q U�x?®/O U5kSxoU��ªU�x*iSgpd*dogDbpi&blahr]«tU.doP&\^nutblnoUV\hi�doP&\^n!i&gpdoU�no\^i&uUViSUt\¬dfPSU�x!dfPSU�TVg q U�a^ah\^iS�±iSgjxXdoPSU�T�bpdoPSUtTVbpdo\cu�bla k&bpxodfn!blxoUVrlU�d80SvmU q �ªglxi&glim� q \h§AUtxoUtijdf\^bl�Sa^U5iSgjim��ugli]�jUv��Agl_Si q bpxf\hU?n�O2. ( � < �Sk¥®+* < =�,�(Æ�eWS� ���S® < ,¤®

�¦Udã_&nãiSgpdfU!doP�bedãdfPSU!d�bpiS�jU�i=d5ugjiSU1��3���3�� 6 6,\cnãblnfno_STVU q dog�P&bL�lUX\hdfn5glxf\h�j\hi8bed3��3�� 6 6ãnsg�dfP&bedE 5A��3���3�� 6 6�dog�bpa^a^ge�N�ªglx kAgjnsds�¤\hTVk&bju(d �lUtahgmu�\¬df\hU?n�dfbpi&�lU�i=df\^bla]dog doPSU.b q TV\^nfno\h�Sa^U,nsU�d ��gj_Si q blxor O2.5®

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 13: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

*?� � ����x����� � �^� $���V�����OQP&UDnoUtu�gli q ah\^iSUD\hi  V?=­5\^n!b�nsU�d!gp�$u�glTVkSa^U�TVU�i=dfblxo\hd{rØugji q \hdo\^gli&n �AUd{�*U�Uti � 3���6Xbpi q >¦�¦n{d�bedf\hiS�dfP&bedX�AgpdoP�doPSU?nsU`doUtxoT�n5P&bL�lU`dog�xfU�T�bl\hiØi&glim�¤iSU��=bedf\h�jU`bpi q glxodoPSgj�lgli�bpa¥gjiSU�dfg�U?blu�P±gpdfPSU�x?®�O Ubjnono_STVU.dfP&bed � 3<; 6 � ( * + ��'( * � \cn q \¬§HU�xfU�i=do\cbp�&ahUj�ldfPSU5�jxfb q \^U�i=d ! � 3���6£\^n$iSgpdQ«�Utxog;bed*doPSUXugjijd�bludu�gli�0��l_Sx�bedf\hgji&n � 3���6 0 ES�$bpi q dfPSU��lUtudogjxfn ! � # �H@:F % F - �$bpxfU�\hi q U�kAU�i q U�i=dt®KO�U��ª_&xsdfPSU�xbjnono_STVU�dfP&bedVdfPSU��ª_&i&u(df\hgji&n � 3<; 6� �43��%F ���6(�*bpi q � 3���6DbpxfU�kS\^Utu�U��,\cnsU�xoU?bpa,bpi�bpa^rjdf\^ul®NOQPSU�i doPSU�ªgjaha^ge�,\^iS�;xfUtno_SahdfnQPSgja q b\¾­8Z]gla^_mdf\hgji&nygl�   ?j­"U�vm\^nsd£gli�C ELF�H8IA6 no_&u�PDdoP�bed ��3<; 6y\^n$bp�&nogla^_mdoUtahrDugjijdf\hi]_Sgj_&n. Ñ�ã©Q­(�l�,P&U�xfUtbln���3A; 6 \cn xf\h�jPjdo�¤u�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_�n�gl��ahgmu�blam��gj_Si q U q �ebpxf\^bpdo\^gli± ¡}.©*�¦|��X­(®�9�i�k&blxsdf\^u�_Sacbpx"doP&U.ahU��¾d$bpi qxo\^�lP=do�Ja^\hTV\hdfnQgl��dfPSUtnoU �ª_Si&u(df\hgji&n,U�v]\cnsd.U��lUtxor]�,PSUtxoU (+*?�.,J®

\h\¾­�OQPSU5�ª_Si&u(df\hgji ��3<; 6*utbpiSiSgld$�AU!ns_Sk&k�g=nsU q dogD�AU5Ut�lU�xfr]�,PSU�xfU q \h§HU�xfU�i=do\cbp�Sa^Ul® 05iSU P&bjn ��3�� 6 0��3VE 6zH � �T � 3 5.6 � 5;�ªgjxãnsgjTVU!�ª_Si&udo\^gli � 3A; 6 ��! " !0 ���3A; 6(®ã·±gjxoUtge�lUtx ���3�� _ 6�0 � 3�� _ 6.bpi q ���3�� Y 6 0� 3�� Y 6 (+*t�.,¤®

\^\h\¾­8Z]gla^_mdf\hgji&n,bpxfUã_Si&\^¢=_SU�(+*?�.,y ¡PSge�$Ut�lUtx$\^i��jU�iSUtxfblaAdoPSUtr q gDiSgpd q Utk�Uti q ugli=df\hi]_Sgj_&nsa^rVgli�doPSU\hi&\¬df\^bla¦ugji q \hdo\^gli&n�­(®

\h�S­�OQPSU�blutuUtahUtxfbpdo\^gli ��`\^nãb �4 #�.��]� � � �&�,PS\^u�P8\cn*doPSU�no_ST gp�¦d{�*gVTVUtblno_SxfUtn (+*?�@, bybpi8bedfglTV\^uTVUtblno_SxfU � h \ �,bli q bN�¦U��AUtno�l_SU±\^i=doUt�lx�bp�Sa^U��ª_&i&u(df\hgji��,PS\^u�P �*U q U�iSgldoU ���3<; 6�,\Ñ® Ul® � � 0� h \ H ���3�� 6 � �(®�OQPSUVbedfglT�n uglxfxfUtnok�gji q dog�doPSUD\^TDk�blu(d do\^TVUtnD( ?�,¤®`Z]U�U;xoUtTVblxo¨ < �ªglx!nsgjTVUugjTDTVUtijd�nQgli�doP&\^n q UtugjTVk�g=ns\hdo\^gli¥®

�S­�OQPSU£noUd¥gl�=\^TVk&blud¥do\^TVUtn�\cn¦u�gl_Si=dfbl�Sa^Ul®W9�iXT�bpi]r5blkSkSa^\^utbedf\hgji&nHgliSU P�bln � h \ 0 � ��� T C ���3�� _ � 6 B���3�� Y� 6 J�� � � �m�,PSUtxoU�� � \cnydfPSU �5\^xfbju.TVUtbjns_SxfU5bli q dfPSU noUt¢=_SUti&uU [ � � \ ��� TXu�bli��AU5gjx q UtxoU q �=\Ñ® Ul®� � _ E�� � � ®��.ge�*U��lUtxXkSPSU�i&glTVU�i&b8a^\^¨lU�blutu_ST;_Sacbedo\^gli�nXgp�QahU��¾ds��blu�u�_ST`_&a^bpdo\^gli&n!gl�*\^TVk&bludfnT�bLrDU�vm\^nsd  Ñbed$a^Utbjn{d*��gj_Si q U q �ebpxf\^bpdo\^gli q g]U?n£iSgld$kSxfUtu�ah_ q U.dfPSU�T�­(®�9�i�bpi]r�u�blnoU,dfPSU5gjx q U�xo�\hi&��TVbLr�iSgpd.�AU�kAgjnfns\^�Sa^Ul®yOQPS\cn,\cn.b�nsgjxsd,gl�"u�glTVkSa^Uv�AUtiSg��AU�P&bL�]\^gl_Sx! �L­(® 9�i8doPSU�utblnoU gl�U�acblnsdo\cu \hTVk&bju(dfn` �=0N@?­$\hd,�ªgla^ahge�.n*�ªxfglT (>*L�]�Swyxfglk¥® W&®+*�*�,HdoP&bpd � � _ E�B � � T�� � E;�ªgjxãnsgjTVU� � ES®��ãU�i&u�U!nsgjah_mdf\hgji&n,bpxfUXkS\^UtuUt�,\^noU!ugjijdf\hi]_Sgj_&n*\hi�dfPS\^nãu�blnoUl®

�]\c­��.i]r�¢=_&b q xfbpdo\cu!�ª_Si�u(do\^gli � 3A; 6 gp� ���\cn5\hdfnoU�ah�*}.©*��| �;��PSU�i�uUD\¬d�n q U�xf\h�ebpdo\^�lU`\cn!b�TDU?blno_SxfU� � ( ?.,¤®£©$gli&noUt¢=_SUtijdfahr�� � F E!P&bln$b!TVUtbliS\hi&��bpi q \^TVkSah\^Utn£doP�bedydfPSU.�ª_Si�u(do\^gli � 3<; 6 q g]UtniSgpd.\^i&u�xoU?blnoUS(Æ��=m�&k¥®>*?�L*�,J®

OQP&UtnoU�xfUtno_Sahdfn;U�i&bl�SahU�gli&U�dfg a^Utb q b nsdfbl�S\^ah\hd{rßbpi&blahrmno\^nDnfbe�ªU�a^rl®ß�¦UdV_&nDiSge� \^i=doxfg q _&uU�b�iSUt��ªgjxoT;_Sacbedo\^gli gp�]dfPSU q r]i&blTD\cu�n¥\hi�  ?j­(�L�,PS\cu�P�u�bliX��Uy�,xf\hdsdoUti�blnHdfPSU �ªgjaha^ge�,\hi&�Q·ØUtblno_SxfUy�ã\h§HU�xfU�i=do\cbpa9�i�ua^_&ns\^gli� ¡·��j9s­�( ?.,

B � 3���3�� 6 6 � � B �43���3�� 6�F � 3�� _ 6 6 � ��5"O -�� W�� W �>`I` 3 �!3�� 6 6�� O -�� 3���3�� 6 6   *t�j­

�,P&U�xfU�!3�� 6=0�� W � ! `>_#" � W�� $ `E _ " 5UOG�;3���3�� 6 65�ªxfglT  V?=­(®S9¤� 0 E�doP&U�i �!3�� 6,0 � 3�� _ 6(�¥\h� 0 @`dfPSU�i�S3�� 6 0�� W � ! `I_ � W � $ `K ®�·±glxfU�ge�jU�x��,PSUti � 3A; 6�\cn;u�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_�n!doP&U�i �S3�� 6 0 � 3�� 6(®NOQPSU�doU�xfT3·Ø� 9� º¤æ Â(æ£Ô�ÄÆÄSÅL¿LÂ{ÁLÎ(á,Â{ÁeÔãàÆÁ�ÕÎ(Ä ÕtàÆÁLç5Ô�Á`àÆÁQdeÁLà Ï�f!Î�êAÂ{ÕÂ{ÁÏJÇyàÆÁ`Ô|deÁLà ÏÑÂ$ÏÑàÆá,Â$àÆÁÏJÂ{ÛªÕ(Ô�ÄcÈ]Ô�ÁL×���¿?àÆ䤿�Îtä{ä{ÖLÛ àÆÁ!Õ(Ô�Û¡àÆÎ(ÖLÇ

Ï�f?ÅpÂ{Ç�Î�ê&¿�f?Ð?ÛÑàÆ×5Ç ftÇÑÏÑÂsá,Ç¥ÄÆà��(Â"âSàÆÄÆàÆÅLÅpÎsÕj٠ǥàÆÁLä{ÄÆÖLÇÑàÆÎ(ÁLÇoÈ?Â{ÏÑä�� e{Þ��¾æ

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 14: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� * *

P�blnX�AU�U�i�ugj\hi&U q �]r�·±glxfUtbl_¥�¥bpi q   *t�j­5T�bLr�bla^nog��AU�u�blaha^U q ·±gjxoU?bp_¥¸ nXnsU?ugli q gjx q Utx!ns�*U�UtkS\hi&�k&xogmuU?nonD(+*t�.,¤®VOQPSUV\hi&u�ah_�ns\^gli�\hi doP&U�xo\^�lP=ds�¤P&bli q ��ns\ q U`gl�   *t�j­5\cnXkSxfge�lU q \hiNbpk&k�Uti q \hv ��®DO�PSU�i���3�� 6"\cn q \cnou�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_�n��A �*t�=­�\hTVkSa^\^Utn£doP&bpd$·±glxfUtbl_¥¸ n ugla^a^\^no\hgjiVxo_Sa^U.\^iØ V?=­"\^n$nobpdo\cn�0�U q ®"OQPS\cn£u�bli���Uk&xoge�jU q _&no\hi&�;�&bjns\cu,dfg]glacny�ªxfglT u�gli]�lU�vVbli&bpa^rmns\cn��]noU�UXbpkSkAU�i q \¬v�| ® OQPSU5doU�xfT -�� W�� W �>`>` 3 �!3�� 6 6*u�bli�AU�\^ijdfU�xfkSxfUdoU q bjn�b��lUtahgmu\hd{rØkAgpdfU�i=do\cbpa£bli q \¬d�n�no_S� q \¬§HU�xfU�i=do\cbpa O -�� W�� W��>`>` 3 �S3�� 6 6!\^n q U�kS\cu(dfU q \^i0��l_SxfUyWã\^i;nokAUtu\cbpa]u�bjnsU?n�®�OQPSU$·Ø� 9¥\^i� �*?�j­�e�,PSgjnoUya^U�¾ds�¤P&bli q ��ns\ q U£\cn�b.TVUtbjns_SxfU£bli q �,PSg=nsU£xo\^�lP=ds�P�bpi q ��no\ q U!\cn.b�u�gliSUj�SP&bln,doPSU!�ªgjaha^ge�,\^iS�VTDU?bpiS\^iS��(+*L�Q,N(>*?�., bydoP&U�xfU!Uvm\^nsdfnãbVk�g=ns\hdo\^�lU!TVUtbjns_&xoU � hno_&u�P�dfP&bed,�AgpdfP � �£bpi q � � kAgjnfnsU?non q Uti&ns\hdo\^Utn*�,\hdoP�xoU?nskAUtud$dfg�� h � q U�iSgldoU q xfUtnok�U?u(do\^�lUtahr�bjn � �� 3<; 6bli q � �� 3<; 6® 05iSUQbpacnog.P&bln � �� 3�� 6 0�������� T [ � � T � W>^ � [ �>_ � ] ` �� W>^ � [ �>_ � ] ` (Æ�p��,x(+*L�]�ek¥® ��,J�e�,P&\^u�PDnsPSge�.n¦doP&U$a^\hi&¨ �,\hdoPdfPSU _&ns_�bpaHiSgpdf\hgji�gl��b q U�xf\h�ebedf\h�jUl® OQPSUXu�PSgl\cuU gp� � hØ\cnQiSgld*_Si&\^¢=_SU ��U?u�bl_&nsU5doP&U xf\^�lP=ds�¤P&bpi q �¤no\ q U\cn�b8ugjiSU�( ?�,¤®8�.ge�*U��jU�xX�]rØdoP&U��¥Ut��U?ns�j_SU��}.b q glim��.\^¨lg q r]T doP&U�glxfU�T ( �l�.,J��doP&U q U�i&no\hdo\^Utn � �� 3<; 6bli q � �� 3A; 6yblxoU,_&iS\^¢=_SU.�ª_Si&u(df\hgji&n£�ªglx£b!�j\h�jU�i�� h ® O¦g`noPSU q nsgjTDU,a^\^�lP=d£gliVdfPS\cn��]a^Ud£_&n$ugji&ns\ q Utx �ªglx\^i&nsdfbli&uU � h 0 � �PH�� ��� T�� ��� �S�,PS\cu�P±ugjxoxfUtnok�gji q n$dog�blkSkSa^\^utbedf\hgji&nQ�,PSU�xfUXdoP&U�nsrmnsdoU�T \^nãns_S�Sz{Utu(ddfg!\hTVk&bju(d�n£bed£do\^TDU?n � � bpi q gpdoP&U�xf�,\^noU,U��jgla^�lUtn��ªxfU�Utahrj®�OQP&U�i � �� 3�� � 6 0 E� ªdoPSU �¥U��AUtno�l_&U,TDU?blno_SxfU� �5bli q dfPSU��ã\^x�blu;TDU?blno_SxfU � � bpxfU;T;_mdo_&blaha^rØno\hiS�j_Sacbpx(­.�,PSUtxoU?bln � �� 3�� � 6=0 � 3�� _ � 6 B � 3�� Y� 6D �� � \^nbli�bpdogjT gp��doPSU!TVU?blno_SxoU�� � ­® O�PSU�i �C70 � � doP&U�i � �� 3�� 610 @!bpi q � �� 3�� 6 0 �� 3�� 6(®

OQPSUtxoU��ªglxfUãdfPSUXTVUtbpi&\hiS�Dgp�Q �*?�j­$\^n$dfP&bedQdoP&U�xfU U�vm\^nsdfnQbDk�g=ns\hdo\^�lU TVUtbjns_SxfU�� h �,\¬dfP�xfUtnokAUtu(d*dog�,P&\^u�P���gldoP � �*bli q � � kAgjnfnoUtnfn q U�i&no\¬df\hU?n���bpi q

B � 3���3�� 6 6 � �� h 3�� 6/B&�43���3�� 6�F � 3�� _ 6 6 � �� h 3�� 6�5�O -�� W�� W �>`>` 3��!3�� 6 6�� O - � 3���3�� 6 6   *�*?­

PSgja q n�� hYB.blahTVg=n{d�U��jU�xfr]�,PSU�xfUl®m9�i�bNnoU�i&noUl� q Uti&ns\hdo\^Utn�xoUtkSa^bjuU q Utxo\^�ebedo\^�lU?n��$�ªglx�TVU?blno_SxoU?n�®O�P&U�i q Utbpa^\^iS�`�,\hdoP�TDU?blno_SxfU q \h§AUtxoUtijdf\^blaHUt¢=_&bedf\hgji&nygjx$\^i&u�ah_&no\^gli&nt�j\hdQ\^n$doP&U�i�i�bedo_&xfbla&dfg`T�bpiS\^km�_&a^bpdoU q U�i�ns\hdo\^UtnX\^i&nsdoUtb q gl� q Utxo\^�ebedo\^�lU?n�®S9�i��lU�i&U�x�bpa�gliSU�u�bli u�PSg]g=nsU�� h 0 � � � � H � �S(>*e�=�¦k¥® �l��,J��,P&U�xfU � � � � \^n`doPSU�bp�&nogla^_mdfU��ebpa^_SU�gl��� � � gjx�� hM0 �,� � 3�� 6 �+� � � H � h \ �yglx�� hG0 � � H � h \ ®-9¤dV\^n�ª_&i q bpTVUtijd�bpa�dog�xfUtutbpa^a�bpd£doP&\^n*n{d�bp�jUl�pdfP&bed*doP&U5nogla^_mdo\^gli�gl�£ �*�*L­ q g]Utn$iSgld q Utk�Uti q gli�doPS\cn$u�P&gl\cuUl®a&glx.\^i&nsdfbli&uUj�&\h� � h 0 �,� � 3�� 6 �,� � � H � h \ dfPSU�i±�ªgjxãbpa^a � 70 � � � � �� 3�� 6�0 E

��� � W �>` ��� bli q � �� 3�� 6 0 �� W �>`��� � W �>` ��� ®O�P&U�xfUtbln*\h� � h 0 � �PH � h \ dfPSU�i��ªgjx.bpa^a �%70 � � � � �� 3�� 6 0 @!bpi q � �� 3�� 610 ���3�� 6(®

��° �ß�m����� OQPSU5bl��ge�jUãT�bedfPSU�T�bpdo\cu�bpa��ªx�bpTVU��*glxf¨`\cn*TDgjxoUãdoP&bli!z{_&nsd.b�T�bedfPSU�T�bedf\^utbpa��ª_&nfn�®/9�im�q U�U q bjn!iSgldoU q \^im( ?.,J�"\^i=doxfg q _&u\^iS�8doP&U��lUtahgmu\hd{r�\^i=dog8dfPSU�xf\h�jPjdo�JP�bpi q ��no\ q UVgl�*dfPSU q r]i&blTV\^utn`blnq gliSUX\^i�  *t�j­�miSgpd,gjiSahr�blaha^ge�.n*gliSU dfgD�jUd,bVuglTVk&bju(dQ�ªglxfT`_&a^bpdo\^gli�gl�¦dfPSUXiSgli&noTVg]gpdoP q r]i&bpTV\cu�n ÑnsUtU 0&�l_SxfU�=`\^i�dfPS\cn,xoU?nskAUtud�­�m�S_md,\¬dãbla^nog`k�bL�lUtn$dfPSUX�*bLrVdfge�*blx q n£doP&UXu�gli&no\ q U�x�bedf\hgji�gp���ªxo\cu(df\hgji\^i�doP&U�TVg q U�aJ®�9�i�do_SxfiN\hd;\cn`ua^Utblx!doP�bed;\^i=doxfg q _&u\^iS�8�ªxf\^udo\^gli¥�"\cn�a^\h¨jU�a^r�dfg�ugjTVkSah\cu�bpdoU�dfPSU q r=�i�bpTV\^utn�®XM£nok�U?u\cbpa^ahr�doP&U`bp�Age�lUX�ªx�bpTVU��*glxf¨�k&bL�jUtn*dfPSU`�QbLr�doge�Qbpx q nQTVglxfU�ugjTVkSahU�v8utblnoUtn,�,P&U�xfUdfPSU TDU?blno_SxfU�� � T�bLrVu�gli=dfbl\hi�b�dfPS\^x q doU�xfT�� h + \ �,PS\cu�P�\^nQb;iSgli&bpdogjTD\cu.TVU?blno_SxoU ns\^iS�j_Sa^blx$�,\hdoPxfUtnokAUtu(d!dfg±doP&U��¥Ut��U?ns�j_SU�TVUtbjns_SxfU � �(®�9�ißno_STVT�bpxfrØdfPSU q r]i&blTD\cu�n�\hi   *�*?­!\^n`xo\cu�P�U�iSgj_S�lP�dogUti&ugjTVk&blnfnQuglTVkSa^Uv��AU�P�bL�=\^gl_&xfn*\^i=�jgla^�]\hiS�Dnsgjah_Sdo\^gli&nQ�,PS\cu�P�TVbLr��AUX�¡bpx*�ªxfglT TVUtxoUtahr�kS\^Utu�U��,\cnsUu�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_�n£blny�ªglx$doPSU TVg q U�acn$bli q nsdfbl�S\ha^\hd{rVbli&bpa^rmns\cny\^i:( ��,¤® OQPS\^n$\cn$b;ugli�nsU?¢j_&U�i&u�U.gp�¥xfU�kSacblu�\hi&��ª_&i&u(df\hgji&n,�]r�doP&U!TDgjxoU �lUtiSU�x�bpaHiSgldo\^gli�gp�"TVUtblno_SxfUl�mbed,dfPSU!kSxf\^u�UXgp��bDTVglxfUX\hi]�jgla^�lU q TVg q U�aJ®�9�i

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 15: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

*L� � ����x����� � �^� $���V������¡bju(dQ_&no\hiS�DTVUtbjns_SxfUtn*bpa^a^ge�.nygli&Uãdfg;Uti&ugjTDk�blnfn$noglTVU��,P�bed,uglTVkSa^Uv �AUtiSgD��UtP&bL�]\hgj_Sxfn£gmu�u_&xoxf\hi&�\^i8_SiS\^a^bpdoUtxfblaha^r�ugji&n{dfxfbl\hi&U q TDU?u�P&bpi&\^utbpa�nsrmnsdoUtTVnQ\^i±bDxo\^�lgjxogj_&n£T�bliSiSU�x?®

9�i�doPSU�u�bjnsUØgl�`_Si&u�gli&nsdox�bp\^iSU q �¦bp�jxfbliS�l\cbpi TVUtu�P�bpiS\cu�bla5nor]nsdoUtT�n��,dfPSU��¦bp�jxfbliS�lU��¤�5\^xo\cu�PSa^UddfPSU�gjxoUtT nsdfbedfUtnDdfP&bed�dfPSU8Ut¢=_S\^ah\^�Sxf\h_ST k�gj\hi=d 3�� T F^E 6D\cnVahgmutbpa^ahr nsdfbl�Sa^U�\h� doPSU±kAgpdfU�i=do\cbpa,UtiSU�xf�lr�43���6DP&bjn�bNn{dfxo\cu(d�TV\hi&\hT;_ST bpd � T ® a�\hx�n{d�iSgldo\cuU8dfP&bed�no\hi�uU �43��%F^E 6 0 ���� � � 0SvmU q kAgl\^i=dfn�gl�  *t�=­�nfbedo\cns�ªr dfPSU��lU�i&U�x�bpa^\h«tU q Ut¢=_&bpdo\^gli E 5 O - � 3���T�67H ���� � 3���T.6��,PS\cu�P \hiCk&bpxodo\cu_&a^blx�\^TDk&ah\^Utn��T 5 .5®`©$gji q \hdo\^gli&n5_Si q UtxX�,PS\^u�P ns_&u�P b��lUtiSU�x�bpa^\^«�U q U?¢=_&bedf\hgjiØk�g=nonoUtnfn bed5a^Utbjn{d gliSUDnsgjah_Sdo\^gli¥�bli q i=_&TDUtxo\cu�bla.bpa^�lgjxo\hdoPST�n;dogßu�glTVkS_mdfU±gliSU±nogla^_mdo\^gli¦�$U�v]\cnsd:( �=�Q,J®m9�i dfPSU8�ªgla^ahge�,\^iS���*U8noP&blahabjnono_STVU �ªglx.no\hTVkSa^\cu\hd{r�doP&bpd,doPSU�nogla^_mdf\hgji&n,bpxfU5\cnoglacbedoU q ®

�$° � �ß� � ©$gli&no\ q U�x�bßTVUtu�P&bliS\cu�bpa5nsrmnsdoU�T bjn�\^i  V?=­(® OQP&U�i \h� -�� 3���6|H �43���6�P�bln�bßn{dfxo\cu(dTV\^iS\^T`_ST�bed���T=�]doPSU!U?¢=_S\ha^\^�Sxo\^_ST k�gj\hi=d!3���T�F^E 6*\cn,�¥rjblkS_SiSge��nsdfbl�Sa^Ul®

� �

��� W��.`

� W�� `

���

.

������� W � U ` ��� T��

������� W � � `

��� ���� W ��� `� � W � `��������� W ��� `

� �

���

� U

a�\^�l_&xoUXWGby·ØglxfUtbp_¦¸ n*�lUtahgmu�\¬d{r�kAgpdfU�i=do\cbpaJ®

�¦Udy_&n"iSgldoUQdfP&bed .NiSU�U q n"iSgpdy�AU.ugji]�lUv�\^iD�lU�i&U�x�bpa¥ ¾�ªgjx \hi�n{d�bpi&u�U$dfPSU,Ut¢=_S\^a^\h�Sxf\^_ST T�bLr�Uvm\cn{d\^i-9�ijd.3 .76�¦glxX\hd�T�bLr±��UtahgjiS��dog�O2. �S_md!�AUV�ªglx�uU q �]r±doP&U�ugli=df\hi]_Sgj_&n q r]i&bpTV\cu�nt�¥nsUtUS0��l_SxfU <�ªgjx,kSacbpi&blx.UvSbpTVkSa^UtnQ�,\hdoP±�AgpdfPØugji=�jUv�bli q iSglim��ugji]�lUv .���\¬d5\^n,gj�]�=\^gl_�n*doP&bpd.\hi8dfPSU q UtkS\^udoU qi&glim��ugji=�jUv�u�bjnsU!blaha�kAgl\^i=dfn 3�� T F^E 6*�,\hdoP � T 5"O2. blxoU 0SvmU q kAgl\^i=dfnQgp��doP&U q r]i&bpTV\cu�n�­(®

� � µ¥µ�� � OQP&U�k&xog]gp�XT�bLrN��U�ahU q bjnD�ªgla^ahge�.nt®��¥Ud�_�n�ugji&ns\ q Utx;dfPSUØiSgji&noTDg]gldoP �¥rjblkS_SiSge�utbpi q \ q bpdoU �ª_Si&udo\^gli

� 3���3�� 6�F ��G3�� 6 6 0 @4 ���3�� 6 V � 3���3�� 6 6 ��G3�� 6PH -�� 3���3�� 6 6PH ��3���3�� 6 6 B �43�� T 6   *?�l­

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 16: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� *?�

������� �

� �

a�\^�l_&xoU < b£©$gji=�jUv�bli q i&gli&u�gli]�lU�v�b q TV\cnono\h�&ahU!noUdfnt®

Zm\hi&u�UydfPSU$kAgpdfU�i=do\cbpa - � 3���6�H ��3���6�P&bjn�b5n{dfxo\cu(d�TD\^iS\^T`_ST bpd ��T$U?¢=_&bpajdog0��3���T@6(�pdoPS\cn)� \^n�k�g=ns\hdo\^�lUq U�0&iS\hdoUVgjiØdoP&U;�,PSgjahUVnsdfbedfUDnok&bjuUl®�·ØglxfU�ge�lUtx5no\hi�uU8 �*t�=­ãnoUtu�_SxfUtnãdoP&bpd0��3�� 6W5.C�ªgjxXblaha �,T ES�\hd`�ªgjaha^ge�.nXdfP&bed - � 3���3�� 6 6 0 E8�ªgjx`bpa^a�� T E&�"bli q � 3���3�� 6�F ��L3�� 6 6 F�� 3 �,� ��3�� 6 �,� F �,� ��L3�� 6 �,� 6��ªglxDnsgjTVUu�a^bjnons� � �ª_&i&u(df\hgji�� 3<; 6�¥gli .  ��'��3�� 6ã�ªglx!bpa^a �=T E=­(® �.ge�*U��jU�x \¬d�n q U�xf\h�ebpdo\^�lU`gjiØdfPSUV��gj_Si q blxorO2. \cnXiSgld «tU�xfg&�¥noU�U8 Ñ�l­®;OQPSUDkAgpdoUti=do\cbpa"�ª_Si&udo\^gli -�� 3���3�� 6 6 H ��3���3�� 6 6 \cnXugjijdf\hi]_Sgj_&nXns\^i&u�U ��3<; 6\cn�u�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_&n!bli q ��3A; 6 5�.5®��¦Ud�_&n`UvSbpTV\^iSUVdoPSU��Lblxo\cbedf\hgji gl� � 3��%F ���6!blahgjiS��dox�bez{U?u(dogjxo\^UtnXgl�  *�*L­(®)9�iØ�]\^U��~gl� doPSUDbp�Age�lU q \cnou�_&nfns\^gli¥�Agli&U`u�bli�u�P&bpx�bludoUtxo\^«�U doP&U;TVUtbjns_&xoU �.�6�]r�\hdfn q Uti&ns\hd{r�,\hdoP xoU?nskAUtud`dfg � h�bpi q doP&U��ª_Si�u(do\^gli � q U?uxfUtblnoUtn`\¬�5\¬d�n q U�i&no\¬d{r �! �� 3�� 6LF E��ªglxVbpa^a �LT ES®O�UDxoU?u�bpa^a"·±glxfUtbl_¥¸ n5xf_SahU`�ªglx q \h§AUtxoUti=do\cbedo\^gli�gp�$¢=_&b q xfbpdo\cu!�ª_Si�u(do\^gli�n5gl�$}.©*� � | �ª_Si&udo\^gli&nD(+*L�=�k¦® ?p�¤��,�b"a^Ud��/3A; 6*��U�}.©*��| �;�mdoP&U�i �t3�� K 610 3�� _ H�� Y 6 ���Ø�,PSUtxoU�� _ bli q � Y bpxfU doPSU!xf\^�lP=ds�¤ah\^TV\¬dbli q ahU��¾ds�¤ah\^TV\¬d!�ª_Si�u(do\^gli�nXgp���/3A; 6(®��¦Ud!_&nXiSge� uglTVkS_SdoUDdoPSU q U�i&no\¬d{r±gl�$dfPSUVTVUtblno_SxfU��.� �,\hdoPxfUtnokAUtu(dQdfg�� h�b

�! �� 3�� 6 0 EK C ���3�� _ 6WH ���3�� Y 6�J V � 3���3�� 6 6 � �� 3�� 6PH ���3�� _ 6AV � K � �� 3�� 6zH ���� � � �� 3�� 6

H EK �� � ( ���3�� _ 6<V�� 3���3�� 6 6 ���3�� _ 6 * � �� 3�� 6   *t�j­

�,P&U�xfU�� �W0 � 3�� 6 � �Qns\^i&u�UXdoPSUX�ª_Si�u(do\^gli � 3A; 6*\^nã�¥U��AUtno�l_&U \^i=doUt�lx�bp�Sa^Ul�mbpi q � K 5�O - � 3���3�� 6 6(®�¦Ud!_&n iSge� u�PSg]gjnoU� hI0 � � H$� h \ ®;Z]\^i&u�U � �� 3�� � 6C0 E�bli q � �� 3�� � 6%0 E��,P&U�xfUtbln � �� 3�� � 6%0

�ZC � 3�� _ � 6�B � 3�� Y� 6 JP0�� C ��L3�� _ � 6�B ��%3�� Y� 6 J��ªglx*nsgjTDU���� ES�=\¬d£�ªgla^ahge�.n"�ªxfglT  �*?�j­�dfP&bed*bed£\^TVk&blud£do\^TVUtngjiSUX�lU�dfn

� �� h 3�� � 610 @4 ��� ���3�� _ � 6PH ���3�� Y� 6 � V � 3���3�� 6 6!� ���3�� _ � 6RB ���3�� Y� 6 �%0"� � ��3�� � 6�F E   *�W=­

�,PSUtxoU�� � 3�� � 6,\cn5\hi  Ñ�j­®5�¥U�d �� 3��%F ���6 0 � C � 3���3�� 6 6 J¤® �¦Ud _&nã_�nsU`doPSU;UvmkSxfUtnfns\^gli±gl� �43��%F ���6�j\h�jU�iNbe�¾dfU�x� V?j­� bpi q a^UdD_&n`bjnono_STVU�doP�bedV©$PSxf\cn{dfgp§HU�aJ¸ n;nsr]T`�Aglacn!gl�,doPSU40�xfnsd`¨]\hi q bpxfU�_&noU q dog

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 17: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

*tW � ����x����� � �^� $���V�����u�glTVkS_mdfU8doPSU±�jUtudoglx '�3��%F ���6 ��]®�OQPSU�i '�3��%F ���6 �� 0 �� 3��%F ���6%B EK�� �� � ( ���V�� 3���3�� 6 6 �� *�� V bli q doPSUT�bpdoxf\¬v �� 3��%F ���6 B 4 '�3��%F ���6�\cn;no¨lUt�Q�¤nor]TVTDU�doxf\^u:( �G*p� �Q*j® ��,J® .ge�Í\h� ��70 � � �ygjiSU��lU�dfn � �� 3�� 6 0�� 3�� 6W0����3�� 6Xbpi q � �� 3�� 6W0 @u(+*L�=��k¥®è��=�,£bli q gliSU�utbpi�u�bpacu_&a^bpdoUD�ªxogjT  �*?�j­�¥_&no\hiS�8dfPSU q r]i&bpTV\cu�nbli q doPSU�no¨lUt�Q�¤nor]TDTVU�doxfr�kSxogjk�Utxsd{rxb

�! �� 0 �! � 0GB ���V '�3��%F �� 6 ��)H EK ���V �� 3��%F ���6 ��CB ���V � E�H ���V � K0GB ���V � E H ���V � K   * < ­

�,PSUtxoU � EC5"O -�� W�� W �>`>` 3��!3�� 6 6£bli q � 3A; 6 \cn q U�0&iSU q \hi  �*?�j­(®"O¦g;ns\^TVkSah\h�ªr;doPSU5iSgpd�bedo\^gliV�*U.P&bL�jUq xogjkSk�U q bpxf�l_STVUtijd�ny\^i� �* < ­�jPSge�*U��jU�x ��X\cnydfg`�AUã_Si q U�x�n{dfg]g q bjn ��L3�� 6 0 ���3�� _ 6yno\hi�uU �C70 � � ® ãge�no\^i&uU;�ªglxXbpa^a �=T E ���3�� _ 6,5)��3���6S( ?.,y�,P&\^u�P \^n5k�gja^blx dogLO -�� 3���3�� 6 6ãgjiSUD�lUd�n � VK ���3�� _ 6,F ES��bpi q�ªxfglT doP&Uã\^i&ua^_&no\hgji�\hi�bpkSkAU�i q \¬v�� \hd£�ªgjaha^ge�.n dfP&bed � VE ���3�� _ 6�F E�bln£�$UtahaJ® OQPSU�xfU�ªgjxoUQdfPSU �4 #�.��]� �.� \cn"iSgjim�JkAgjno\hdo\^�lUl® ©$gli&noUt¢=_SUti=doa^rXdoPSU�� ��������V��� � 3A; 6�\cn"iSglim�¤\^i&uxfUtbjns\^iS�!(Æ��=S�pk¥®+*t�L*�,Sbpi q ahUtTVTVb�D\cnQkSxfge�lU q ®

��° �ß�m���� OQPSUã\hi&u�ah_�ns\^gli�gl�AdfPSU.\^i q \cu�bpdoglxy�ª_Si&u(df\hgji -�� 3���3�� 6 6£\hiVdfPSUã�¦rjbpk&_SiSge�!�ª_Si�u(do\^gliiSgpd.gjiSa^r��l_�bpx�bpi=doUtUtn$\¬d�n,k�g=ns\hdo\^�lU q U�0&iS\hdoUtiSUtnfn� ª�,P&\^u�P±bpi]r]�QbLr�\^n.bjnono_SxfU q bpa^gliS��nogla^_mdo\^gli&ngp�Q �*�*L­$�,PS\^u�P�xfU�T�bp\^i�\^i .Q­(�S�S_SdQ\hdãbpacnogDblaha^ge�.n*gliSU5dog�ugji&no\ q Utx,u�blnoUtn*�,PSUtxoU dfPSU!nsTVg]gpdfPk�gldoUtijdf\^blamP&bln"b5TV\hiS\^T`_&T~doP&bpd \^n�gl_Sdfno\ q U�.5® ZmbLr]\hiS��� -�� 3���6.H���3���6�P&bln"b n{dfxo\cu(d"TV\hi&\hT;_STbed/� T� \^n�doPSU�noblTDU�bjn�nfbLr=\^iS��� ��3���6 P&bln�b�n{dfxo\cu(d�TV\^iS\hT;_ST�bed/� T \hi�ns\ q U). ®8Z]\^i&u�U�doPSU\hi q \^utbedfglx*�ª_Si&udo\^gli�P&blnQgjxo\^�l\^i&bpa^a^rD�AU�Uti�\^i=doxfg q _&uU q �]r�·±gjxoU?bp_�bjnQb;kAgpdfU�i=do\cbpa�bjnonogmu\cbedoU qdog�_Si&\hacbedfU�x�bpa¥ugji&nsdox�bp\^ijd�n��]\hd|0&i q nQP&U�xfU \hdfn.i&bedf_Sxfbla�_&noUl®

�ãnDbpa^ah_ q U q dfg�bp�Age�lUj���,P&U�i�0 @�\^i� V?=­(�"doP&U�noUt¢=_SU�i�uU�gl�Q\^TVk&blud`df\hTVUtn [ � � \ ��� T u�bli��U�glx q U�xfU q � � h \ 0 � ��� T � ��� �"bpi q �lU�a^gmu\hdo\^Utn!blxoU�kS\^Utu�U��,\cnsU�u�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_�n�®�OQP&U�ißb8T`_�u�Pns\^TVkSa^U�xy�ªgjxoT;_Sacbedo\^gliVu�bliV��Uãb q glkSdoU q �]rDnsUtk&bpx�bedf\hiS�!u�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_&n"TVgldo\^gli�kSP&bjnsU?n"gmu�u_&xoxf\hi&�gli \hi=doUtxo�ebla^n�3�� � F � � _ E 6ã�ªxogjT \hTVk&bju(d do\^TDU?n�®;OQPSUDnsdfbl�S\^ah\hd{r8�ªxfblTVU��*glxf¨�\^iM( �.,y\cnXns_���u�\hUtijd\hi ns_�u�P�b utblnoUl® OQPSU�normn{dfU�T1\cn�dfPSU�xfU�ªgjxoU iSglim� �AUtiSgN�ªglx 0 @�bpi q �,\¬dfP�doP&U�bl��ge�jUblnfns_&TDkSdo\^gli&nt®

05iSU q g=U?nsi¦¸ d iSU�U q dog�TVbl¨lU!�ª_&xsdfPSU�x blnfns_STVkmdf\hgji&n.gji±doP&U`TVUtbjns_SxfU�� h \ dog�ugli�ua^_ q Ul�Hbpi qgliSUXnoU�Utn£doP�bed£dfPS\cn*u�gli&u�ah_�ns\^gli�\cn*gl�md�bp\^iSU q�q \hxfUtudoa^r�bpkSkSa^r]\hi&�`�lUtiSU�x�bpa q \h§AUtxoUtijdf\^bpdo\^gli�xo_Sa^Utngp�5}.©*��| � �ª_Si&udo\^gli&nt® OQPSU q r]i&blTD\cu�n;TV\h�jP=dDUt�lU�i ugjijd�bp\^i q Uti&nsU8noUdfnDgl�ã�lUtahgmu\hd{r q \cn{�ugjijdf\hi]_S\hdo\^Utnt�Q �*t�=­Xbpi q   *�W]­ �$gj_Sa q u�gli=do\^i]_SUVdogØP&gla q ®�OQPS\cn`noPSge�.n dfP&bed`_�ns\^iS�8doP&U�·Ø� 9�ªglxfT�bpa^\^noT \^i�  *t�j­yglxã  *�*L­ kSacblu�Utn dfPSU5nsdfbl�S\^ah\hd{rDbli&bpa^rmns\cny\^i�b!T;_&u�P�TVglxfU.�lUtiSU�x�bpa&k�Utxfnok�U?u(�do\^�lUXdfP&bpi¥�SnfbLrl�mxfUtnsdoxf\cu(do\^iS� ��L3A; 6$dogV�AU!kS\^UtuUt�,\^noU!ugjijdf\hi]_Sgj_&nt®

�¦Ud�_�n�iSgldoU�doP&bpd�doP&U q r]i&blTD\cu�n�\^i  �*?�j­VP&bjn�dfPSU�\^i=doUtxokSxfUd�bedf\hgji bln�\^im0&�j_SxfU =S�.�,P&U�xfU� 5)O -�� W�� W �>`>` 3��!3�� 6 6(®�Zm\hi&u�U O - � W�� W �>`>` 3��!3�� 6 6 � _ � 3���6W0 ���%3���6V ªdoPSU�u�gliSUVkAglacbpx dogB�;3���6D( =.,ª­(�dfPSUX�ªU�U q �&bju�¨�ahg]gjk�\^i 0&�l_SxfU =Vugji=dfbp\^i&n*dfPSU�ugjiSU!uglTVkSa^U�TVUtijd�bpxf\¬d{r�k&xogj�SahUtT (Æ�l�@,

_ � 3���6�� O -�� W�� W �>`>` 3��!3�� 6 6�� � � �!3�� 6 5A��3���6   *Q=j­

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 18: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� * <

O�PSUtiP- 0 @�bli q �65 O1.5��gliSU�P�bln1�;3���6 0 ( * _ bpi q _ � 3���6 0 ( * Y \^ißb8ns_S\hdfbl�Sa^UV�ªxfblTDUbpdsd�blu�PSU q dog �]�ybli q dfPSU��jxfblkSPNgp�,dfPSU�T;_Sahdo\^�Lblah_&U q T�blkSkS\^iS�Ø\cn�dfPSU�nogp��u�blaha^U q u�glxfiSU�x;a^bL�!®29�i�jU�iSUtxfbla¥dfPS\^n \cn5bli�U�vmblTVkSahU;gp�£bliB-�� q \^TVU�i&no\^gli&bla¦TVgliSgldogjiSU`T;_Sa¬df\h�eblah_SU q T�bpk&kS\hi&� �!3�� 6��� � ®OQP]_&n¦ahUtTVTVbã�,Uv]doUti q n¥doPSU*bp�&nogla^_mdoU$n{d�bp�S\^ah\hd{r kSxogj�Sa^U�TCnsdo_ q \hU q \^i!doPSU£�ªglxfU��jgl\^iS�,nsU?u(do\^gliXdfge�*blx q nbliSgpdfPSU�xDd{r]kAU±gp� q r]i&bpTV\cu�bpa,normn{dfU�T�n�®m9¤d�\cnViSgldoU��*glxodoP]r�dfP&bed�dfPSU8�ªU�U q �&blu�¨ ahg]glk \^iM0��l_SxfU =u�gli=dfbl\hi�n��AgpdoP doPSU8ugjTVkSahUtTVU�i=dfblxo\hd{rNugli q \¬df\hgji&nDbpi q dfPSU8ugla^a^\^no\hgjißT�bpkSk&\hiS� \hi  V?=­(®N� ¢=_S\hdoUno\^TD\^acbpx¦nsdoxf_&u(df_SxfU£u�bli!��U �ªgj_Si q �ªgjx�doP&U q r]i&blTD\cu�n¥\hi�  =j­H�,\hdoP�doPSU£nsdfbpdoUyxfU�¤\^iS\¬df\^blah\^«tbpdo\^gliXT�bpkSk&\hiS�k&xogjk�g=nsU q \^i-(+*Q?�,J�S�,P&\^u�P�\^nãbpi�Uv]doUti&ns\^gli�gp�, �*@=j­®

���������������� �� ����������

�������

� �!���#"%$&�(')�!���*���+-,�. � Y0/�]�132413576862413576

a�\^�l_SxfU8=Lb��.iS\^acbedoUtxfblaha^r�u�gli&nsdox�bp\^iSU q �¦bl�lx�bpiS�j\^bli�nsrmnsdoUtT�®

OQPSUD�¦bl�lx�bpiS�jU���ã\^xo\cu�PSa^UdQdoP&U�glxfU�T noU�xf�lU?n.bln5b��&bjns\cn,�ªgjxãdfPSU;nsdfbl�S\ha^\^«tbedf\hgji±gp�y_Si�ugli�n{dfxfbl\hiSU qTVU?u�P&bpiS\cu�blamnsrmnsdoU�T�nt�p�AgpdoPD\^i`dfPSU,xoUt�l_Sacbedf\hgji;bli q dfPSU*dox�blu�¨]\^iS� utblnoUtnN(Æ�@,J® 9�iDdoPSUQxfU��j_Sa^bpdo\^gliDu�blnoUl�gjiSU�T�bLr±nsP�bpkAU�doP&U`kAgpdoUti=do\cbpa�U�iSUtxo�jr�nog�doP�bed doPSU;iSU��~U?¢j_&\ha^\h�&xo\^_ST gp� dfPSUDu�ahg=nsU q �¤ahg]glk±normn{dfU�T\cn£doPSU q Utno\^xoU q gliSUj®"�¦U�TVT�b`�;u�bpi���U5_&nsU q dfg�doP�bed*bl\hTÍ�]r�noP&bpkS\^iS�!dfPSU k�gldoU�i=df\^bla - � 3���6GH ��3���6dfg±b�iSUt� u�ahg=nsU q �¤ahg]glk�k�gldoU�i=df\^bla - �Z3���6�H:9��3 9��65�=\cb8b�w£� ugji=doxfgla��,PSU�xfU 9�L0 �WB� bpi q � \^nnoglTVU�ugli�n{d�bpi=d q U?ns\^xfU q kAgjno\¬df\hgji¥®P�.ge�*U��lUtx�dfPSU�u�ahg=nsU q �¤ahg]glk 0&v]U q kAgl\^ijd�nDP&bL�lU�dfg nfbedf\^ns�ªr�doPSU�jU�iSUtxfblah\^«�U q Ut¢=_&bpdo\^gli E65UO - � 3���T�6 H �<;�� ;� 3 9��T.65�,\¬dfP 9��T 0 ��T=B'� �¥�,PS\cu�P�xfU ��Utu(d�n5doPSU;�¡blud dfP&bed��TW5 .5®"Myv=dfU�i&no\^gli�doge�Qbpx q n$dox�blu�¨]\^iS�;\cnQTVglxfU!uglTVkSa^Uv��S_mdãu�bli��AU q gjiSU4( W�, ( < ,J®

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 19: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

*@= � ����x����� � �^� $���V�������� ����� � ° � �¥U�d._&n,ugji&no\ q UtxQdoPSU�normn{dfU�T \^i 0&�l_&xoU`�`�,PSgjnoU q r]i&bpTV\cu�nQ\cnQ�l\^�lUti��]r

2ZZZZ3 ZZZZ4- �R 0 B%9 �R B���R- �D 0GBj- ��HI>PF E F)D � >�T E

�Dx3�� _ � 610GB� �Dx3�� Y� 6 �,PSU�i D 3�� � 6 0 E

  *L�p­

� ��

a�\h�j_SxoU`��b"�~no\^TDk&ahU`�e� q gl��normn{dfU�T8®

05�]�]\hgj_&noahr 3��%F ��G3�� _ 6 6 0q3VELF^E 6�\^n�doPSU�_SiS\c¢j_&U�0SvmU q kAgl\^i=d;gl�!  *L�l­!bpi q gliSU�utbpißu�PSU?u�¨�dfP&beddfPSUVnoblTDU q r]i&blTD\cu�n �,\hdoP:D:F E�i&g�a^gliS�jU�x k�g=nonoUtnfnoUtn bpi]r 0SvmU q kAgl\^i=dt®!a&glx!bpi]r"D 3VE 6 � E�bpi q 5 3 ELF @@6.doPSU�noUt¢=_SU�i�uUVgp�*\hTVk&bju(dXdo\^TVUtnXP&bjn bo0&i&\¬dfU�blu�u�_ST`_&a^bpdo\^gli � � ( W�,J®VOQPSUD�ª_Si&udo\^gli�\^i  *?�j­£\cnQUt¢=_&blaHdog

� 3��%F ���610 @4 - �R K H @4 - �D K H - ~ � � 3JD�6zHP- � D8H @4 ��R K   *Q?j­

05i&U T�bLr�u�P&Utu�¨VdoP�bed,doP&\^nQ�ª_&i&u(df\hgji�P�bln*doP&U!kSxogjk�Utxsdf\hU?nQxoU?¢=_S\hxfU q \hi�dfPSU!kSxfg=gl��gl��a^U�TVT�bV�S®� � ����)$���¦�������

OQP&\^n;iSgpdfU�UvSblTD\^iSU?n!doP&U�Uv]dfU�i&no\hgjißgp�QdfPSU�bl�&nogla^_mdoU�nsdfbl�S\^ah\hd{r k&xogj�SahUtT2bli q gl�,doPSU��¦bp�jxfbliS�lU���5\^xo\cu�PSa^Ud�dfPSU�gjxoUtT��QdfgNdoP&U u�bjnsU��,PSU�i�iSgjiSa^\hiSU?bpxf\¬df\hU?n�\^i�doP&U±�ªU�U q �&blu�¨ a^g=gjk bpxfUØT`_&a¬df\h�ebpa^_SU qTVgjiSgpdfgliSU!T�bpk&kS\hi&�jnt®,ZmglTVU�gp�"dfPSU;u�gli&no\ q U�xfU q nsrmnsdoUtTVnãT�bLr�bpacnog���U;xoU?u�blnsd.\^i8doPSU`�ªxfblTDUt�$gjxo¨gl�¦ugjTDk&ahUtTDUti=dfbpxf\hd{rDnormn{dfU�T�n��=�,PS\cu�P�\^i�do_Sxfi�T�bLrD��UXnoU�U�i�bjn$b;nskAUtu�\^blaAu�a^bjnon£gp�¥P]r]�Sxf\ q�q r]i&blTV\¬�utbpaSnormn{dfU�T�n�®��.iSgldoPSUtxt�l�ªxo_&\¬do�ª_SaSkAgl\^ijdygl���]\^U��!�p\cn"doP�bedygp� q \h§AUtxoUtijdf\^blam\hi�ua^_&ns\^gli�n��p�,\hdoPVgjx �,\¬dfPSgl_md

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 20: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� *e�

TVU?blno_SxoU?n�®�OQPS\cnyuacblnfn"gp��nsrmnsdoUtTVnyU�i&u�glTVk&blnfnoUtn�TVUtu�P&bliS\^utbpaSnormn{dfU�T�n �,\hdoPV_SiS\^a^bpdoUtxfblaSugli�n{dfxfbl\hi=dfnbli q \^TVk&bludfnt�pbln¥�*U�a^ambln q \^nfno\hk&bpdo\^�lU$ah\^iSUtblx�u�glTVkSa^U�TVU�i=dfblxo\hd{r!nsrmnsdoUtTVn¦�,\¬dfPSgl_Sd��ªUtU q dfPSxogj_S�lP�doU�xfT\^iVdoP&U,gl_mdfkS_md£U?¢j_�bedo\^gli¦®�OQPSUã�$Utahah�JkAgjnoU q iSUtnfn"\^n£u�bpxfU�ª_&aha^r`U�vmblTV\hiSU q ��U��ªglxfU.n{df_ q r]\hi&�!doPSU.nsdfbl�S\^a¬�\hd{rl®"},gj_S�lPSa^r`nok�U?bp¨]\^iS�&�ldoPSU70&x�nsd£uacblnfn"gp�HiSgli&noTVg]gpdoPVnor]nsdoUtT�nyn{df_ q \^U q \^iVdoPS\cn k&blk�Utx£ugjxoxfUtnok�gji qdfg8xoUta^bpdo\^�lU q U��jxoUtU;gjiSU�nsrmnsdoUtTVnt�¥�,PS\^a^UVdoPSU�noUtu�gli q uacblnfnXbpxfUDxfU�acbedf\h�jU q U��lxfU�UDd{�*g±nsrmnsdoU�T�nt®�9�ik�bpxodo\cu_Sacbpx�bãiSUt�NUvm\cn{dfU�i&u�U*bli q _SiS\c¢=_SU�i&Utnfn�k&xog]gp�m�ªgjx�b uacblnfn�gp�SiSgji&nsTVg]gpdfP q \cnfns\^k&bedf\h�jU£nor]nsdoUtT�n��\cn5�l\^�lU�i¦®jaS_SxodoP&U�x Uv]doUti&ns\^gli�n.gp� dfPSU`xfUtno_Sahdfn.doge�Qbpx q n,TVglxfU;u�glTVkSa^Uv8TDU?u�P&bpi&\^utbpa�normn{dfU�T�n.�,\hdoPnoUd,�ebpa^_SU q �ªgjxfu�UXa^bL�.n (Æ�eW�,m(Æ� < ,¤�&noU�U�T ¢j_&\¬dfU!\hi=doUtxoU?n{df\hi&�&®

�V�V��� µ]´ � ° ¶�� ° � ° �H�?�l� 9��*gl_Sa q ah\^¨lU.dogXdoP�bpiS¨V·Øbpi]_SUta&·±gjijdfU�\^xog!·Øblxf¢=_SU?n, J©*·Ø� a��¥\cns�Agli�­�ªgjx$P&\^n*PSUtahk�\hi�doPSU kSxfg]gp�¦\^i�blkSk�Uti q \hv����mbpi q ©$acbp_ q UX�¥UtT�bpx �tu�P&bla�  9 5}|9{�5­£�ªgjx*P&\^n*PSUtahk�\hi�doPSUk&xog]gp��gp��ahUtTDT�bu*j®

� � ���� � � ��� �! " ,����{� ���)$���¦�����

a&glx.u�gli]�lUtiS\hUti&uU a^Ud._&nQxfU��,xf\¬dfU doPSUX�ªgjaha^ge�,\hi&� q U�0&iS\hdo\^gli&n,�ªglx.bVugji=�jUv�noUd . b

_ � 3���610 [ �&� � V � F EGF�� � 5A��3���6 \   *t�j­�,PS\cu�P8\^n,bli±bpahdoU�xfi&bpdo\^�lU q U�0&i&\¬df\hgji�dfgDdoPSU!gjiSUX�l\^�lU�i�\^i8noUtudo\^gli±�m�Sbli q

O - � W��.` 3 � 6�0 [ �&��� V 3 B ���6�F ELF �� 5���3���6 \  J�p�j­Z]\^i&u�U@�;3���6*bln*\hd,\^n q U�0&iSU q \^i� Ñ�j­5 ªxfU�kSacblu�U=$ �]r .Q­$\^nQbDugjiSU bli q ns\^i&uU �� 5��;3���6�mgliSUXu�bli

u�P&g=g=nsU� 0 � H ��D�,\hdoP � 5B��3���6,blnãbVk&bpxodo\cu_Sacbpx,�eblah_SU��ªglx H®QOQP=_�n,\¬� � 56O -�� W�� ` 3 � 6QgjiSU!�lU�dfn� V�6F � V ���3�� _ 6ãbpi q \^i=doxfg q _&u\^iS�� 0 � H ��]�AgjiSU��jUdfn � V � F E�nsg�doP&bpd � 5:_ � 3���6®5OQPSUtxoU��ªglxfU·ØglxfUtbp_¦¸ n*\^i&ua^_&no\hgji�\^iN �*t�=­$\^n,k&xoge�jU q ®

�¦Ud£_&nyiSgpdfU (>*?�.,SdfP&bedydfPSUãu�gliSU?n bpxfUQdog!�AU._Si q Utxfnsdog]g q bln �AU�\^iS��bpdsdfbju�PSU q dfgXdoPSUãnfbpTVU,gjxo\^�l\^i\^i doPSU8\^i&ua^_&no\hgjiC ¾�ªgjx�\hi�n{d�bpi&u�U�\^iA0��l_SxfU�W��£gjiSU�P�bln O - � W��.` 3 � EQ6 & _ � 3���6o­(®�·±gjxoUtge�lU�xDnsgjTVUi�bedo_&xfbla¥\ q U�i=do\>0�u�bpdo\^gli&n.��U�d{�$UtU�i±nsk�bluU?n� ¾dfPSU q _&bpa ����� � ��� bpd ��Dgp��doPSU�dfbpi&�lU�i=dãnok&blu�U@� ��� bpd3�dfg�dfPSU u�gli�0��l_Sx�bedf\hgji�nsk&bjuU � �mbpi q doPSUXugldfbpi&�lU�i=d$nok&bjuUR���� � ­yP&bL�jU.�AU�U�i�T�b q Uj�ldfP&bpiS¨mn£dog;doPSUa^\^iSUtblxXnsdoxf_&udo_SxfU;gl�£dfPSUtnoU�nsk&bjuU?n5\^i��,PS\^u�P doP&UVu�gliSU?n,O -�� W�� ` 3A; 65bli q _ � 3���6XbpxfU q U�0&iSU q ®DOQP&\^nblaha^ge�.n,dfg��j\h�jU`b�TVUtbliS\hi&��dog�doPSUD\^i&ua^_&no\hgjiØ\hi  �*t�=­(® OQPS\^n5\cnyz{_&nsd!b��lUtiSU�x�bpa^\^«tbedf\hgji8gp� doP&U;�*U�a^a¬�¨]iSge�,i±\ q Utijdf\ 0Au�bedf\hgji±��U�d{�$UtU�i±dfPSU;nok&bjuU�gl�y�lU�a^gmu\hdo\^Utn5bpi q dfP&bed gp� �ªgjxfu�Utn.bju(do\^iS��gliØb�k�bpxodo\cua^U\^i b8�p� q \^TVU�i&no\^gli&bla�nok&blu�Ul�H�,PS\cu�P �AgpdfP blxoUD\ q U�i=do\>0&U q �,\hdoPa( *��l®;·±gjxoU q Ud�bp\^a^nXblxoUD\hiM(>*L�.,ybpi q( ?.,¤®

� � �� �� % ' �!�+��- 7��`)y����t-1 ,�

�¦Ud R bli q � �AUØd{�*g �jUtudoglx�n�gl�`bßa^\hiSU?bpx�My_&ua^\ q UtbliCnok&blu�U������ ��U�b u�ahg=nsU q ugli]�jUv u�gliSUgl�����Qbpi q _ �AU8doPSU±kAglacbpx�ugjiSU�dogJ��® OQP&U�i �ªxogjT ·±gjxoU?bp_¥¸ nDahUtTDT�b�gl�ãdoP&U8d{�$gNugjiSUtn ( =S�k¦® �lWj��,�( WS�Sa^U�TVT�bV�!*�,J�mgjiSUXP&bln�3 R B � 615�O - � 3VR�6���� R 0�kSxfgLvxC � F � J���� � B RL0 kSxogLvxC _:F � JJ®

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 21: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

*@? � ����x����� � �^� $���V�����OQ\^TVUtn � � blxoUØbpdoglT�nVgl�5dfPSUØTVUtbjns_SxfU � � \hi   *t�=­(® �5\^bßb�no_S\hdfbp�&ahUØ��blnoU8u�P�bpiS�jUl�$doPSUب]\^iSUdf\^uTVU�doxf\^uDbed!bpiØ\^TVk&blud5df\hTVU�u�bliØ�AUVu�gli&no\ q U�xfU q bjn5b8My_&u�ah\ q Utbli TVU�doxf\^uDns\^i&u�U/��3A; 65\^nXu�gli=do\^i]_Sgl_&nbpd � � �,bpi q \^i k�bpxodo\cu_Sacbpx�blaha,dfPSU±\ q U�i=do\>0�utbedo\^gli�n���U�d{�$UtU�i �ebpxf\hgj_&n q _&blaãnsk�bluU?n�u�bli �AU q gjiSUl®05i&U��lUd�nX�ªxfglT   *t�=­�b B � 3���3�� � 6 6�C ��G3�� _ � 6 B ���3�� Y� 6 JC5 O -�� W�� W ��� `>` 3 �S3�� _ � 6 6 ��� ���3�� _ � 6�H ���3�� Y� 6 0k&xogLv � W�� W ��� `>` C ��3���3�� � 6 6�FQ3<@ H �6 ��L3�� Y� 6�J���� ���3�� _ � 6 H ��L3�� Y� 6 0 3A@WH �6�kSxfgLv � W�� W ��� `I` C �;3���3�� � 6 6�F ���3�� Y� 6(��,P&U�xfU5dfPSU�noUtugji q Ut¢=_S\^�LblahUti&uUX\cnQkSxfge�lU q \hi ( ?�,¤®

� �e Q " ,��)* ,�(>*�,!·ß® �ã\ q rjbjnobl�jblxt��*t�j�l��� ���t����� #�����t�.��� ��S�)� �x����.���\� �&noUtugji q U q \hdo\^gli¥�&wyxoUti=do\cuU���ãblahaJ®( ��,!}�®¦�¥gj«tbpi&g&�¥| ®¥|*xogj�la^\^bpdog&� 0;®My�jU�acbpi q �¦| ®¥·Øblnfu�PS¨lUj�¦�p�j�l��� �\�#��� "L��� ��� �t�.��� ��S�8� ������.���\�

������� ���G�?� ��� ��Z]kSxf\^iS�lUtxt�&©$glTVT;_SiS\cu�bedf\hgji&n,bpi q ©$gjijdfxogjaGMyiS�l\^iSUtU�xf\hiS��Z]Utxo\^Utnt�S�¥gji q gji¥®( ��,!�;® �`®A|*bl\hi&ge�A�mw"®ÆZH®AZm\hTVU�gjiSge�H� *t� ?l� �t�.��� ��S� ����� �� ��)"x�� �� ����j ��� �����t������������ �����x�L #�����o�����

�N"�"x�� �#�����V���L� �:Mya^ah\cn �.gjxo�*g]g q noU�xf\hU?nQ\hi8·ØbedfPSU�T�bpdo\cu�n.bli q \hdfnãbpkSkSa^\cu�bedf\hgji&nt� O�\^a^U�rl®( W�,!| ®V|*xogj�la^\^bpdog&� *t�l�j��� ���G�����@��� ��� �^�G���t� ��� ��Z]kSxf\^iS�lUtx ©$glTVT;_SiS\cu�bedf\hgji&nßbli q ©$gli=doxfglaM£iS�l\^iSU�Utxo\^iS�'Z]Utxo\^Utnt� noUtu�gli q U q \hdo\^gli¥� �¥gji q gji¥®�Myxfxfbpdo_ST bli q b qSq Uti q b�bL�ebp\^a^bl�SahU bed

P=dodokWb����e�,�,�!® \^iSxf\^blahkAUtnt® �ªx �L�&\hk!�ek�UtglkSa^U��e�Sxfgl�la^\cbedog"�L�Sxfgl�jah\J® PjdfTVa( < ,!| ®l|*xfgl�jah\cbedfg&�lZH® 9(® .\cu_&ahU?nou�_¥�j·N®j·±gli=doUt\hxfgp��·Øblxf¢=_SU?n��p�p�j�l��# 05iDdox�blu�¨]\^iS�Xugli=dfxogjamgp�Ab!u�a^bjnon

gl��ugjTVkSahUtTVU�i=dfblxor=��nsacblu�¨]iSU?non"P]r]�Sxf\ q TVU?u�P&bpiS\cu�bla�normn{dfU�T�n$#p�]Zmr]nsdoUtT�n$bli q ©$gli=dfxogja��¥U�dsdfU�x�n���jglaJ® �j�S�]iSg�W��mkSk¥®Æ� <�< ����=�=&�j·Øblxfu�P¥®

( =�,!}�® OX®l}.g]u�¨ebp�ªU�a^a^blxt�L*?�=�p� � ���%�. '& � ������.���\� �jwyxf\hi&u�Udfgli��¦bli q T�bpxf¨mn�\^i�·ØbedfPSU�T�bpdo\cu�nt�pwyxf\hi&u�U�dfgli �.i&\h�jU�x�ns\hd{r�wyxfUtnfn��7ãU��)(lUtxfnoU�rj®

(Æ�.,*(�® (&®�·±gjxoU?bp_¥� *t� =�=p�^*?��==�,+ ���������V���t�� ����> ��-� ���%�. '&% �� ��Z �tTV\hi&bl\hxfU ns_SxNa^Utn �?¢j_�bedo\^gli�n�bl_mvq ��xf\h� ��UtnQk�bpxodo\^U�a^ahU?n��&©$gla^a^R��lU q U a&xfbli&uUj�mw bpxf\^nt®

( ?�,*(�® (&®y·±gjxoU?bp_¥�j*t��? ?.# �.iS\^a^bpdoUtxfblaQu�gli=dfbju(d�bpi q q xfr��ªxo\cu(df\hgji \^iM0&iS\hdoU��ªxoUtU q gjT q r]i&blTD\cu�n�#e�\^i.� ���L���4�Q�����/� �^�G���G� ���u�����u�Z" "��� �#�����V���G� �*©Z9sZm· ©$gj_SxfnoUtn`bpi q �¦Utu(df_SxfUtn�i&g��l�=�m�0(�® (&®·ØglxfUtbp_¦�yw"® �;®yw bpi&bl�l\^gpdfglkAgl_Sa^gjn� >M q n�®Æ­(�N9�i=doU�xfi&bpdo\^gli&bla.©$Uti=doxfU��ªgjxV·ØUtu�P&bliS\^utbpa.Zmu�\hUti&uU?n��ZmkSxo\^iS�jU�xo� � Utxoacbp��®h�=kSk¥®+*��?j�S®

( ��, D® (�®��¦g]gpdfnoT�bS����® (&®¥�ebli q U�x;Zmu�P�be�¾dt�"·N® �V®�©*bpTVa^\h�AU�aJ�N*t�l�j�/# �.i&\^¢=_SUtiSUtnfnXgp�,nsgjah_Sdo\^gli&n!gl�a^\^iSUtblx,xoUta^bLr�normn{dfU�T�n$#p�S�._mdfglT�bedf\^utbS�m�jglaJ® � < �]iSg��S�Sk&k¥® W ==�L�JWm��?S®

(+*t��,X·ß® �X_SiS«tUl�$·ß® �;® w"®£·Øgli=doUt\hxfg�·�bpx�¢j_&Utnt�$�p�j�l�1#�.i \^ijdfxog q _�u(do\^gli dogN·±gjxoU?bp_¥¸ nVns�*U�UtkS\hi&�k&xogmuU?non�#e�?\^i ��j"L� ��� � ���2� �^�G���G� �#���"�t�.���� ��S�43 � ������.���\�7�����5� � � �������%$ �=| ®t|*xogj�la^\^bpdog� IM q ®Æ­(�ZmkSxo\^iS�jU�x?�S�¥[email protected]\^i8wyP]rmns\cu�n,�6.w <�< *l�]kSk¥®+*��=l�&®

(+*�*�,X| ®p|*xfgl�la^\cbedog��p�p�l�G*�#V05i`dfPSU,ugli=dfxogja=gl��iSgji&noTDg]gldoP;u�glTVkSa^U�TVU�i=d�bpxf\¬d{r q r]i&blTV\^utbpamnsrmnsdoUtTVn�#e�w£PS\haJ®jO�x�bpi&nt®l},ger=bpaSZ]gmup®^�j·ØbpdoPSUtT�bedo\cu�blaÑ�jwyP]rmns\cu�blaSbpi q MyiS�j\hi&U�U�xf\^iS�`Zmu\^U�i�uUtnt�jnokAUtu\cbpam\cnfns_SUgji�.gli�nsTVg]gpdfP�·±U?u�P&bpi&\^utn��SnoU�xf\hU?nQ���S�jglaJ® � < �S�=iSg�*e��?l�&�jk&k¥® �l��=j�e�{�p��?j�S®

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 22: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

������������ ����������������������������������� ���� !���#"�"����%$�� *?�

(+*?��, w"®e|Qbpa^a^blx q �e�l�l�G*5#�aSgjxoT;_Sacbedo\^gli!bli q �*U�a^a¬�¤k�g=nsU q iSU?non¦gp�mdoP&U q r]i&blTV\^utn¥gp�Sxf\^�l\ q �J�Ag q rXnsrmnsdoU�T�n�,\hdoP k�Utxs�ªU?u(d;_&iS\hacbedfU�x�bpa£u�gli&nsdox�bp\^i=dfn�#e��wyPS\^aÑ®"O�xfbli&n�®�},gerjbla$Z]gmup®^� ·ØbedfPSU�T�bedf\^utbpaJ�"wyP]r]no\cu�bpabli q Myi&�l\^iSU�Utxo\^iS��Z]\^U�i�uUtnt��nskAUtu�\^bla¦\cnono_SU;gliBãgli&noTVg=gldoPØ·±U?u�P&bpi&\^utn��HnsUtxo\^Utn5���A�lgjaÑ® � < �S�SiSg*e��?j�S�]kSk¥®Æ�p�=�j�?�{�p�lW =&®

(+*t��,X·ß®A·Øbl�Sxfgl_S¨H�W*?�l��? #��~_SiS\>0&U q �Lblxo\cbedf\hgji&bpa¦TDg q Uta¥�ªgjx.doP&U q r]i&bpTV\cu�nãgp� k�Utxs�ªU?u(d _SiS\^a^bpdoU�x�bpau�gli&nsdox�bp\^i=dfn�#e�;My_SxfglkAUtbli (jgl_&xoi&blaHgp� ·±Utu�P&bliS\cu�n,���lZ]gla^\ q n��m�jglaJ®>*e�]�=iSg < �mk&k¥® ?G*t�p� ?lW=�m®

(+*�W�,X�`®l�ebpi q U�x$Zmu�P�be�¾dt�;��®]Zmu�P]_ST�blu�PSUtxt�=�p�l�j� � � ��t�^�^� �� �����V���o� � � �������J� � ���x���D� �^��� ���.��� ��!� �ZmkSxo\^iS�jU�x?�S� ©Z9sZ8� < *l�m�¦gli q gji¥®

(+* < ,�a*® ��®¥©$a^blxo¨jUl� *?��?l��� "������D���Q��� �V��� ����� � ���L���4�Q����� � ������.���\� �¥©*bpi�b q \cbpi8·ØbedfP¥®AZmg]ul®AZ]Utxo\^Utngl�"·ØgliSgj�lx�bpkSP&n*bpi q � q �Lbli&uU q O�Uv]d�n��LO�\^a^U�r�9�i=doUtxfnfu\^U�i�uUXwy_S�Sa^\cu�bedf\hgji&nt®

(+*Q=�,��`®A|*xfU�«t\^nt�P*?�=�e��� "����^���� �]�#��� �4& ���4���& � ���x�������x �� �.gjxsdfPm� �ãgla^a^bli q �A·ØbedfPSU�T�bedf\^utn5Z=df_ q �\^Utnt®

(+*L�.,X·ß® �;® w"®p·±gji=doU�\^xfgp��·Øbpx�¢=_SUtnt��*t�j�l�5� � �j �� ��G���V��� ������%���V���L�Z��� � ���G�#�4�@��� � �: �#�L���G� �#��� � ������+ ��S�� �L�L� �����S��� � � ��� + ��� ��� �V��� �A|$\^xf¨=P�bp_&noU�x?�=|*g=n{dfgli¥�mw 5�¦��M �S®

(+*Q?�,X·ß® �V®m©*bpTVah\^�AU�aJ��O~® w�® ·N® ��®;�.UtU�TVU�acn�� (�® ·N®=Zmu�P]_ST�blu�PSUtxt�j�l�l�=�2#V05iVah\^iSUtblx k&blnfno\h�jU.uglTVkSa^U�TVUtijd�bpxf\¬d{r�nsrmnsdoU�T�n�#e�/My_&xogjk�U?bpi�(lgj_Sxoi�bpaHgp�y©$gli=doxfglaJ�m�lgjaÑ® ?S�]iSg��S�&kSk¥®Æ�l�p�p���l�=�m®

(+*t��, w"® �`®Lw bpi�bp�l\^gpdfglkAgl_Sa^gjnt��*?��? < ��� ���G����������� �����> ��!�7���2� �#�L���G� ���j�����)�N"�"x�� �#�����V���L�43 � ���%�. '&����� � ��� �#���%�. '&2�7�� �� $�� + �� �����V���L� �S|*\^xo¨]P&bl_&nsUtx,|$g=n{dfgli¥®

(Æ�p��, Mã®y�ã\^TViSUd?�$·N® a&x��tTDgji q �£�l�l�L* #t©$gjaha^\^no\^gli&n`\hi]�lgjah�]\^iS��nogla^\ q nDbli q ��_S\ q n$#p�y\hiN.ge�jU�aQ�.km�k&xog=blu�PSU?n$\^i�©$\h�]\^aMyiS�j\hiSUtU�xf\hi&�&�&Z]kSxf\^iS�lUtx � U�xfa^bl�&�m·N®Ga&x��tTDgji q �La*®&·Øbju�u�U�xf\y >M q nt®Æ­(®

(Æ��*�,X�`®�·±Ut�lxfUd�ns¨]\J����®�}.bpi=df«�U�x?� *?�l�]� #tZ]rmn{dfU�T2bpi&blahrmno\^nX�]\cb8\hi=doUt�lx�bpay¢=_&b q xfbpdo\cu�ugji&n{dfxfbl\hi=d�n$#p�9�M M�M O¦x�bpi�nobju(do\^gli�n$gji��ã_mdogjT�bedo\cu`©$gli=dfxogjaÑ�]�lgjaÑ® W=�S�]iSg�=S�mkSk¦® ?G*t�e��?l�j�S� (l_Si&Ul®

(Æ�l��,X}�® O~®�©$gpdsdfahUj� (�® ZH®&w"bliS�&��}!® Mã®AZ=dfgliSUj�W*t�j�j� ���G ��/���� #���� ���j"��> ��� ��G������������ � �����> �� �A�,u�be�q U�TV\^uXw£xoU?nont®

(Æ�p��, O~®�},_ q \^i¥�P*?�l� ? � ������.�� ����# ����> D �� � ���j"��+ &% ���5_SiSg q �Sw bpxf\cn�®(Æ�eW�,�©$P¦® , a^gmu�¨lU�x?�p�p�j�L* �x ������t���G � + ��� �# ��z���/� �lZ]kSxf\hi&�lU�x?�L�¥Utudo_SxfUgãgpdfUtn¥\^i`�ãkSkSa^\hU q ·±U?u�P&bpiS\cu�n

�jglaJ®>*j�S|*U�xfah\^i �ãU�\ q U�a^�AU�xf�&®(Æ� < ,X·ß®GaSx ��TVgli q �&�p�j�j�2� ����� �t�4�Q����� ���G ����4���4 �^�G���t� ��� �¥Z]kSxf\hi&�lU�x?�m|*U�xfah\^i �ãU�\ q U�a^�AU�xf�&®(Æ��=�,�(�®&�5\hUt_ q gjiSi��l�P*t��=j� �N�����4 ��t�V� ��� � ����� �.�� � �����4 ! ��,Xbp_SdoPS\^U�xo� �5\ha^acbpx�n��]w bpxf\^nt®(Æ�j�.,X�;®), g=UtahUt�lUti¥� ,D® M.® Z=dfbL�]xfgl_Sacbp¨]\cn�� ,D®�ZmblahTVgji¥�"w�® �;®�w bpi�bp�l\^gpdfglkAgl_Sa^gjnt� *?�l� = #tZ]gla^�ebp�S\^a^\¬d{r

dfPSU�gjxorXbpi q k&xoglz{Utu(df\hgjiXTDU�doPSg q �ªgjx¦b.u�a^bjnon�gl�Sns\^iS�l_&a^blx¥�ebpxf\^bpdo\^gli&blae\hiSU?¢=_&bpa^\¬df\hU?n�b Mya^bjn{dfgjnsdfbpdo\cu_&iS\hacbedfU�x�bpa£u�gli=dfbju(d`blkSkSa^\^utbedo\^gli�n$#p�0(�®¦gp�R05kmdf\hTV\^«tbedf\hgjißOQPSU�gjxor bpi q �ãkSkSa^\^utbedo\^gli�n����lgjaÑ® � < �i&g��m®

¼�¼�Á��SÞ��#��Þ

Page 23: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

�l� � ����x����� � �^� $���V�����(Æ��?�,X�;® , g]U�a^U��jU�i¥���;®H·ØgpdoxfUtbli]_¥� �;® �;®�·±gpdfxoU?bpi]_¥�¥�p�j�j� � 05i±doP&UDnsdfbl�S\ha^\hd{r�gl�$nsdfbedf\hgji&bpxfr8nsgjah_m�

df\hgji&n gp�£k�bpx�bp�Agla^\^u!�eblxo\cbedf\hgji&bpa�\hi&Ut¢=_&bpa^\hdo\^Utn �Adog8bpk&k�U?bpx \hi�� q �ebpi&u�Utn5\hi .gli&ah\^iSUtblx �yblxo\cbe�df\hgji&bpaP9�iSUt¢=_&blah\hdo\^Utnt®

(Æ�p��,�(�® (&® ·±gjxoU?bp_¥�£·ß® �ybla^b q \^U�x?�)*t� ?�=��o� u�P&bp\^i xf_Sa^U�\^i]�lgla^�]\hi&���lU?u(dfglx;�ª_Si&u(df\hgji&nDgp� ��gj_Si q U q�eblxo\cbedf\hgji �"(�®GaS_&i&u(d?®&�.i&blahrmno\^nt�m�lgjaÑ®è�LW��]kSk¥® �l�l�p�¤�lW < ®

( �l��,X�`® `®A·Ø\^u�PSUtaÑ� �V®GO�bpiS���&| ®$�._¦�A�p�j�L*�� G�������������� ��x�G ^����� � � � �������D� �#��� �t�.��� ��S� �AnsU?ugji qM q \¬df\hgji¥��·�bpx�uU�a��5U�¨]¨lUtxt�7ãU��Q� yglxf¨H®( �L*�, �Hg q \^bjup�/*t�j��= �x�G ^�����:� � �j� �^���*� ���G�?� ��� ��Z]kSxf\^iS�lUtxs� � U�xfa^bl���¥gji q gli¦�¥©$gjTVT`_SiS\cu�bpdo\^gli&n bpi q

©$gji=doxfglaMyiS�j\hi&U�U�xf\^iS��Z]U�xf\hU?n��&©5®A©*bli]_ q bln q U O�\hdt�A| ®&Z]\^u�\ha^\cbpiSg��',D®&|Qblnsdo\^i� IM q nt® ­®� �`�`�� ,�`���

��� �H�t� µ ¶ ��p� �¡µ � ����D�S� � � � �S�p�?� � � � µ ��� ° � � ��¶ � µ ��� � µ¥µ �� � ����� ² � � � -���� ° �m�"� µ � ¦� ° ���?�m� � � � � ² ��� µ ��� ° � �- �� ° � � �&�e� ��� °l³�� � � � ��� � ° �D��� °]µ � ° � �

� � µ ��� � �� �ѵ ��� � �� � � µ¥µ��.µ�� � µ � ° ����h� � ����� �� �¡µ � ���� �� ° ��� �D�m� � ���"�S�p�D� � � ° � ���

ºª»�¼¥º¾½

Page 24: Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with … · 2021. 3. 17. · Absolute stability and the Lagrange-Dirichlet theorem with monotone multivalued mappings Bernard

Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes655, avenue de l’Europe - 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Futurs : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : LORIA, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique

615, rue du Jardin Botanique - BP 101 - 54602 Villers-lès-Nancy Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis : 2004, route des Lucioles - BP 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

ÉditeurINRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399