a turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based …fpinho/pdfs/ci103_rhodes2007_turb.pdfa...

39
A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED ON THE FENE-P MODEL FLUIDS BASED ON THE FENE-P MODEL F. T. Pinho Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, FEUP & Universidade do Minho, Portugal P. R. Resende Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, FEUP, Portugal C. F. Li Dep. Energy, Environmental and Chemical Engineering, Washington University of St. Louis, St Louis, MO, USA Currently at School of Energy and Power Engineering, Zhenjiang, Jiangsu, P. R. China R. Sureshkumar Dep. Energy, Environmental and Chemical Engineering, Washington University of St. Louis, St Louis, MO, USA B. A. Younis Dep. Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of California, Davis, USA XV th International Workshop on Numerical Methods for Non-Newtonian Flows 6 th -10 th June 2007 Rhodes, Greece

Upload: others

Post on 06-Jul-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTICA TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC

FLUIDS BASED ON THE FENE-P MODELFLUIDS BASED ON THE FENE-P MODEL

F. T. PinhoCentro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, FEUP & Universidade do Minho, Portugal

P. R. ResendeCentro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, FEUP, Portugal

C. F. LiDep. Energy, Environmental and Chemical Engineering, Washington University of St.

Louis, St Louis, MO, USA

Currently at School of Energy and Power Engineering, Zhenjiang, Jiangsu, P. R. China

R. SureshkumarDep. Energy, Environmental and Chemical Engineering, Washington University of St.

Louis, St Louis, MO, USA

B. A. YounisDep. Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of California, Davis, USA

XVth International Workshop on Numerical Methods for Non-Newtonian Flows

6th-10th June 2007

Rhodes, Greece

Page 2: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

We! = 25,Re! = 395

" = 0.9,L2= 900

2hu

1,x

2,y

We!="u

!

2

#0

Re!=hu

!

"0

DNS case: LDR- DR= 18%

Fully-developed channel flow

2

B = B+ b ' where b ' = 0

Previous eddy viscosity model- Li et al (2006a) JNNFM v139, 177-189Li et al (2006b) JNNFM v140, 23-40

Remembering Reynolds decomposition

^- instantaneousOverbar or capital letter- time-average‘ or small letter- fluctuations

Page 3: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Time-average governing equations: turbulent flow & FENE-P

!Ui

!xi

= 0Continuity:

Momentum balance:

!"Ui

"t+!Uk

"Ui

"xk=#

"p

"xi+$s

"2Ui

"xk"xk#

"

"xk!uiuk( )+

"% ik,p"xk

! ij = 2"sSij + ! ij ,pRheological constitutive equation: FENE-P

! ij ,p ="p

#f Ckk( )Cij $ f L( )%ij

&'

()

f Ckk( )Cij

+ !"C

ij

"t+U

k

"Cij

"xk

# Cjk

"Ui

"xk

# Cik

"Uj

"xk

$

%&

'

() = f (L)*

ij

!Cij

!t+Uk

!Cij

!xk" C jk

!Ui

!xk" Cik

!U j

!xk

#

$%%

&

'((= Cij

)

= "* ij ,p+p

3

Page 4: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

-0.035

-0.030

-0.025

-0.020

-0.015

-0.010

-0.0050

0.0

0.1 1 101

102

c'12

/[L2-(C

kk+c'

kk)]

C12

/[L2-(C

kk)]

Cx

yD

TR

(J)

ave

(+ s

ide)

y+

20 times smaller

f Ckk( )C12 >> f 'c12

Time- average polymer stress

! ij ,p ="p

#f Ckk( )Cij $ f L( )%ij&' ()+

"p

#f Ckk + ckk( )cij

f 'cij ! 0

4

! ij ,p ="p

#f Ckk( )Cij $ f L( )%ij&' ()+

"p

#f Ckk + ckk( )cij

? Cij ?

What about

Page 5: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece 5

!Cij

"

+ ! uk#cij#xk

$ ckj#ui#xk

+ cik#u j

#xk

%

&'

(

)*

+

,--

.

/00= $ f Ckk( )Cij $ f L( )1 ij+, ./

Cij

!

+ uk"cij"xk

# ckj"ui"xk

+ cik"u j

"xk

$

%&

'

() = #

* ij ,p+p

Mij CTij NLT

ij

: turbulent distortion originates in distortion of Oldroyd derivative- not negligible Must be modeled

: originates in advective term, negligible no need for modeling

Exactand large

DNS: Housiadas et al (2005) Phys Fluids 17, 35106, Li et al (2006 a) JNNFM

Time-average equilibrium equation for the conformation

Page 6: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Modeling the Reynolds stress

1) Reynolds stresses: Prandtl-Kolmogorov model (k-! closure)

2) Dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy:

6

!uiu j = 2"T Sij !2

3k#ij

!T =Cµ fµk2

!"N+"

Vwith

!N

2!s

"ui

"xm

""x

m

# Dui

Dt

$

%&

'

()+ 2!

s

"ui

"xm

""x

m

#uk

"Ui

"xk

$

%&

'

()+ 2!

s

"ui

"xm

""x

m

# "ui

uk

"xk

$

%&

'

()

+2!s

"ui

"xm

""x

m

"p '

"xi

#

$%

&

'() 2*!

s

2"u

i

"xm

""x

m

"2ui

"xk

2

#

$%

&

'() 2!

s

"ui

"xm

""x

m

"+ 'ik , p

"xk

#

$%

&

'(= 0

As for Newtonian fluids, most terms will be approximated

New term(will be considered in the future)

Next slide

Page 7: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.1 1 10 100

Pk

QN

QV

DN

!N

!V

Pk

y+

3) Turbulent kinetic energy: its transport equation

7

!Dk

Dt= "!uiuk

#Ui

#xk" !ui

#k '

dxi"#p 'ui#xi

+$s

#2k

#xi#xi"$s

#ui#xk

#ui#xk

+#% ik , p

'ui

#xk" % ik , p

' #ui#xk

QV

!V!"D

N

-Need to model viscoelasticstress work

- Viscoelastic turbulent transport is small

QNP

k0

Page 8: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

-500

0

500

1000

1500

0.1 1 10 100

Cik f' !u'

i/!x

k

c'ik f' !u'

i/!x

k

SUM

y+

Assumptions for viscoelastic stress work: !V

!V "1

#$ ik ,p' %ui

%xk=&p

#'Cik f Cmm + cmm( )

%ui%xk

+ cik f Cmm + cmm( )%ui%xk

(

)*

+

,-

8

Cik f Cmm + cmm( )!ui

!xk<< cik f Cmm + cmm( )

!ui

!xk

Except in viscous sublayer and buffer, but here is not important

!V

f 'c 'ik!ui

!xk" f Cmm( )cik

!ui

!xk

Also

Page 9: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece 9

!V "#p

$%f Cmm( )cik

&ui&xk

= C!V

#p

$%f Cmm( )

NLTnn

2

Needs model

C!V = 1.076

Viscoelastic stress work model

!V+Re

"0

( )2

versus

f Ckk( )NLTij*

-500

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

0.1 1 101 102

!V

+ Re

"0

2

1.076*f(Cmm)*NLT

nn

+/2

EpsilonVkk/2

y+

Page 10: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Key ideas for both models:1) Exact equation2) Assumptions, physical insight and a priori testing of each term3) Test in code and modify values of coefficients

f Cmm( )NLTij

!= function Sij ,Wij ,Cij ," ij

N,#uiu j

#xk,#Cij

#xk,#NLTij#xn

,Mij ,uiu j

$

%&

'

()

f Cmm( )NLTij

!= fµ

1

CE3

u"2

#0

2Ckkuiu j +

C$14

#0

uiukWknCnj + u jukWknCni + ukuiWjnCnk( )%

&'

(

)*

Modeling NLTij-- first model

10

CE3= 0.00035;C

!14= 0.00015 fµ1 = 1! exp ! y

+ 26.5( )( )2

First model

2 coefficients 1 damping function

Page 11: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Modeling NLTij-- second model

f Cmm( )NLTij

!=f Cmm( )

!CN1

u"2

#$ s

Ckk f Cmm( )%CN2Ckj

&Ui

&xk+Cik

&Uj

&xk

'

()

*

+,

-./

012

+CN3

Ckn

$02SpqSpq

uium&Uj

&xk

&Um

&xn+ u jum

&Ui

&xk

&Um

&xn

'

()

*

+,

% fN1CN4Cjn

&Uk

&xn

&Ui

&xk+Cin

&Uk

&xn

&Uj

&xk+Ckn

&Uj

&xn

&Ui

&xk+&Ui

&xn

&Uj

&xk

345

678

'

()

*

+,

+CN5fN2

4

15

9 N

#$ s

Cmm: ij

CN1= 0.0164;C

N2= 0.32;C

N3= 0.024;C

N4= 1.11;C

N5= 0.045

fN1 = 1! 0.8exp !y+

30

"#$

%&'

(

)*

+

,-

2

fN2 = 1! 0.8exp !y+

25

"#$

%&'

(

)*

+

,-

4

11

uium!ckj

!xm+ uium

!Ckj

!xm" Coef # uium

!Ckj

!xm

4 coefficients:

2 damping functions:

Page 12: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Model for NLTij- First versus second model

12

-1000

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

0.1 1 10 100

f(Ckk)*NLTxyf(Ckk)*NLTyyf(Ckk)*NLTiif(Ckk)*NLTxyf(Ckk)*NLTyyf(Ckk)*NLTiif(Ckk)*NLTxyf(Ckk)*NLTyyf(Ckk)*NLTii

y+

DNS

First

Second

Page 13: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Viscoelastic turbulent transport: QV

QV !

"# ik ,p'ui

"xk=$p

%"

"xkCik f Cmm + cmm( )ui + cik f Cmm + cmm( )ui&'

()

13

Same simplifications as for !V

Cik f Cmm + cmm( )ui << cik f Cmm + cmm( )ui

cik f Cmm + cmm( )ui ! f Cmm( )cikui

1)

2)

QV=!p

"#

#xkf Cmm( )cikui$% &' Needs modelCUijk ! cjkui

Page 14: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

f Cmm( )CUijk

!= fµ

2

"C#1

uium$Ckj

$xm+ u jum

$Cik

$xm

%

&'

(

)*"

C#7

!f Cmm( ) ± u j

2Cik ± ui

2Cjk

+,-

./0

+

,-

.

/0

C!1= 1.3;C!7

= 0.37

fµ2 =1! exp !y+

26.5

"

#$

%

&'

Model for CUijk

14

- Same modelling approach as for second model of NLTij

-20

-10

0

10

20

30

40

0 1 10 100

DNSModel f(Ckk) CU

ii2

QFii2

y+

2 coefficients

1 damping function

Page 15: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

0 =d

dy!s +

" fT#T$ k

%&'

()*dk

dy

+

,-

.

/0 + Pk 1 " !2 N 1 "D +!p

d

dy

f Cmm( )3

CUnny

2

+

,-

.

/0 1!p

f Cmm( )3

NLTnn

2

!N= !!

N+D

N DN= 2!s

d k

dy

"

#$

%

&'2

0 =d

dy!s +

" fT#T$%

&

'()

*+d !% N

dy

,

-.

/

01 + " f

1C%

1

!% N

k

Pk

"2 " f

2C%

2

% N2

k+ "E + E3 p

E =!s

"#T 1$ fµ( )

d2U

dy2

%

&'

(

)*2

f1=1

f2 =1! 0.3exp !RT2( )

fµ = 1! exp!y+

26.5

"

#$

%

&'

(

)*

+

,-2

k and ! transport equations: modified Nagano & Hishida

15

Based on Newtonian model of Nagano & Hishida (1984)Variable Prandtl numbers: Nagano & Shimada (1993), Park and Sung (1995)

fT =1+ 3.5exp ! RT 150( )2"

#$%&'

!k= 1.1

C!1=1.45;C

!2=1.90;"

!=1.3

!k=1.0

or

Page 16: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

1 10 100

DNS

Newtonian- ft=1

Newtonian ft=function

First ft=1

First ft=function

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft=function

u+

y+

Predictions 1: Re!0= 395; We!0= 25; "=0.9, L2=900

Newtonian log law

Virk’s asymptote

16

NLTij

CUijk

Models for

&

changed

Page 17: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

-20

0

20

40

60

80

0.1 1 10 100

CUii2

+

y+

Predictions 2: Re!0= 395; We!0= 25; "=0.9, L2=900

Model fitted to DNS

Modified with simulations Model 1 with ft=1

17

C!1=1.3;C!7

= 0.37

C!1=1.3

2;C!7

=0.37

2

CUijk

Page 18: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

-500

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

0.1 1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft=function

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft= function

NLTii

*

y+

Predictions 3: Re!0= 395; We!0= 25; "=0.9, L2=900

18

NLTii

*

Models fitted to DNS

Code diverges

Models modified with simulations

Coefficients & reduced by 4

CN1

CN2

Coefficient increased 60%

CN3

CN5

Coefficient reduced 30%

Model 2

Page 19: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

NLTyy

*

Predictions 4: Re!0= 395; We!0= 25; "=0.9, L2=900

19

NLTxy

*

0

100

200

300

400

500

0.1 1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft=function

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft=function

NLTyy*

y+

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft=function

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft=function

NLTxy*

y+

Page 20: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

!N

+

20

Predictions 5: Re!0= 395; We!0= 25; "=0.9, L2=900

k+

0

1

2

3

4

5

1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft=function

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft=function

k+

y+

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.1 1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft

!N+

y+

Page 21: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Predictions 6: Re!0= 395; We!0= 25; "=0.9, L2=900

21

CyyCxy

-50

-40

-30

-20

-10

0

0.1 1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft

Cxy

y+

0

5

10

15

20

25

0.1 1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft

Cyy

y+

Page 22: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Predictions 7: Re!0= 395; We!0= 25; "=0.9, L2=900

22

CUii2

+Cxx

0

100

200

300

400

500

0.1 1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft

Cxx

y+

-20

-10

0

10

20

30

1 10 100

DNS

First ft=1

First ft

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft

CUiiy

+

y+

Page 23: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece 23

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

DNSFirst f

t=1

First ft

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft

u'v

'+

y*

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

DNSFirst f

t=1

First ft

First ft=1 No !

V

Second ft=1

Second ft

"p,xy

+

y*

u 'v '+

!p,xy

+(zoomed)

Reynolds and polymer stresses

Page 24: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Conclusions

24

- Developed simplified k-! model: code and closures are working well

- Viscoelastic turbulent transport not very important at DR= 18%

- Viscoelastic turbulent transport is reasonably well modeled

- Viscoelastic stress power well modeled by NLTij (model 2)

- NLTij required for Cij and !ijV

- NLTij is now fairly good (Model 2)

- Model 2 has viscoelastic turbulence production close to wall

- Isotropic turbulence does not allow a good model

- Deficiencies are related to Newtonian base model: Use better model

- Need to consider anisotropic turbulence: anisotr. k-! and RSM

- Need to consider DNS for HDR & MDR & # & L2

Page 25: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

A turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model

CEFT-FEUP Centro de Estudos de Fenómenos de Transporte, Universidade do Porto XVth IWNMNNF 2007, Rhodes, Greece

Acknowledgments

Funding

Fundação Calouste GulbenkianProject 72259

Fundação para a Ciência e TecnologiaProject BSAB/507/2005Project Turbopol, nº POCI/EQU/56342/2004

Page 26: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

!

!"#$##%&'(()&*+,-.-/0+&12342.5

6.7&89&"+:,+;:.7&<=-+2,33,>&?@,+&A>&'(()

"#$%%&"#$'% !"#$%&'(&$)*

"#$'%&"#$(% )*+,-.*/0*.1023/4/5-678167-9/4/:0;197<167-91+/=*617+3>819/5763-?+73@/A167-91+/B*,C97,1+/D978*0376E/-F/G6C*93@/H0**,*

1B+,.27&C+D-@2++,($'-./0.1$&%)23$%

"#$(%&"I$J% BC*/,C19;79;/F1,*/-F/,-.K?6167-91+/0C*-+-;EL-;*0/B199*0@/D978*0376E/-F/ME=9*E@/ME=9*E@/AM)@/G?3601+71

E+;;/3,&89&F/;D3+B.;-/D&E@;G+,;/3,;+,($'-.4050.1(6'(*&7(%

"I$J!&"I$(! NGJ(O/L7;7=/0-=3/79/9-9&C-.-;*9*-?3/3C*10/F+-P5QRQ/H0**9@/LQSQ/G0.360-9;@/5TB@/S1.U07=;*@/5G@/DMGLQGQ/V0-P9@/V-36-9/D978*0376E@/V-36-9@/5G@/DMG

"I$!%&J%$"% NG'%O/A?.*07,1+/37.?+167-93/-F/,-9,*96016*=/873,-*+1367,/3?3K*937-9379/19/*+-9;167-91+/F+-PHQ/W G879-@/XQYQ/51FF*6-9*@/D978*0376E/-F/A1K-+7@/T61+E5QGQ/Z?+3*9@/HQ)Q5Q/X*6*03@/>79=C-8*9/D978*0376E/-F/B*,C9-+-;E@BC*/A*6C*0+19=3

J%$"!&J%$'! NGJ'O/A?.*07,1+/37.?+167-9/-F/K-+E.*0/.*+63/,-9617979;/3C-06/19=+-9;/F7U*03XQ/)1KK*0-.@/WQHQ/V170=@/HQ/[*+*<@/GQXQLQ/>U*0+*@/[70;7971/B*,C@V+1,23U?0;@/[G@/DMG

J%$(%&J"$%% NG\%O/ A?.*07,1+/ 37.?+167-9/ -F/ 3?3K*937-93/ -F/ 07;7=/ 19=/ =*F-0.1U+*K1067,+*3/79/K-+E.*0/.*+63GC1.1=7/51+7=7@/:QHQ/Z10+*9@/D978*0376E/-F/Y**=3@/D]

J"$%!&JJ$'% 8"39):".;2<<"&.=.!"#$%&'(&$)*.>9)*&0?

Page 27: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

^

6.7&'9&*H@2;:.7&$32,/,4>&?@,+&)>&'(()

E+;;/3,&'9&$@B-/;D.B+&$3:+B/,4&.,:&[email protected]&E/[email protected]/3,;+,($'-.4050.1(6'(*&7(%

#$%%&#$J% NG(!O/ L*1+7<79;/ 0C*-+-;7,1+/ =0*1.3$/ *FF7,7*96/ 3-+?67-9/ -F/ C7;C+E=7.*937-91+/_-22*0&X+19,2/*`?167-93GQ/G..10@/Y1U-016-70*/=*/LC*-+-;7*@/H0*9-U+*@/_019,*_Q/SC79*361@/>AMG5@/X1073@/_019,*LQ/ ]*?979;3@/ D978*0376a/ S16C-+7`?*/ =*/ Y-?8179@/ Y-?8179&+1&A*?8*@V*+;7?.

#$J!&#$(! NGJ%O/:K67.1+/,C-7,*3/-F/,-00*+167-9/-K*016-03/79/V0-P9719/37.?+167-9.*6C-=3L1</]?KF*0.19/19=/b-337/MC1.17@/BC*/Z*U0*P/D978*0376E@/R*0?31+*.@T301*+

#$!%&I$"% NGIO/ G/ +-;/ 60193F-0.167-9/ 1KK+7*=/ 6-/ 6C*/ .*6C-=/ -F/ V0-P9719,-9F7;?0167-9/F7*+=3S+1?=*/ 519;-?U7@/ 19=/ L1</ ]?KF*0.19@/ BC*/ Z*U0*P/ D978*0376E@R*0?31+*.@/T301*+51067*9/ GQ/ Z?+3*9@/ >79=C-8*9/ D978*0376E/ -F/ B*,C9-+-;E@/ BC*A*6C*0+19=3

I$"!&I$'! NG""O/G/ X'5/.*6C-=/ F-0/ ,-.K?6167-9/ -F/.19E&U-=E/ CE=0-=E91.7,796*01,67-93/ 79/ 1/ ,-9F79*=/ ;*-.*60E$/ 1KK+7,167-9/ 6-/ .7;0167-9/ 19=1KK10*96/3+7K/79/9-9=7+?6*/K-+E.*0/3-+?67-93RQXQ/ Z*0919=*<&:067<@/ MQ/ G9*21+@/ 5QWQ/ H01C1.@/ D978*0376E/ -F)73,-9379&51=73-9@/DMG

I$(%&"%$%% NG\#O/ _07,67-91+/ =01;/ K0-K*067*3/ -F/ K-+E.*07,/ 3-+?67-9/ 79/ ,-.K+*c279*.167,3/F+-P3$/1/.?+67&3,1+*/37.?+167-9/1KK0-1,CGQXQ/]-KK-+@/LQ/M?0*3C2?.10@/)13C79;6-9/D978*0376E@/M6Q/Y-?73@/5:@DMGVQ/]C-.1.7@/D978*0376E/-F/B*99*33**@/]9-c87++*@/BA@/DMG

"%$%!&"%$J% +)<<"".;'"(@

"%$J%&"%$(% NG'(O/WXW/13/1/6--+/F-0/0C*-+-;7,1+/,C101,6*07<167-9BQ_Q/S+102*/19=/LQSQ/G0.360-9;@/5TB@/S1.U07=;*@/5G@/DMG

"%$(!&""$%! NG\'O/ G6-.7367,/5-96*&S10+-/ 37.?+167-9/ -F/ 1/ K-+E.*0/ .*+6/ ?9=*0/ 1F+-P/F7*+=/UE/*.K+-E79;/;*9*01+7<*=/*93*.U+*3SC?9;;?/ V17;/ 19=/ [QHQ/ 5180196<13@/ D978*0376E/ -F/ X16013@/ H0**,*d_:LBZ&TS>eZB@/X16013@/H0**,*

""$"%&""$'% NG^O/ LC*-+-;7,1+/ 19=/ >9619;+*.*96/ SC101,6*07367,3/ -F/ Y79*10/ SC179X-+E*6CE+*9*/Y7`?7=3/79/X+1910/S-?*66*/19=/X+1910/>+-9;167-91+/_+-P3RQ5Q/]7.@/WQRQ/]*FF*0@/VQRQ/>=P10=3@/D978*0376E/-F/B*99*33**@/DMG5Q/]0-*;*0@/>BZ@/f?07,C@/MP76<*0+19=

Page 28: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

\

""$'!&"J$%% NG(JO/B01937*96/'W/_+-P/-F/X-+E.*0/M-+?67-93AQ_Q/5-0073-9@/RQ5Q/L1++73-9@/D978*0376E/-F/S1.U07=;*@/D]

"J$%!&"($%% A2*9,

Page 29: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

#

6.7&'9&*H@2;:.7&<=-+2,33,>&?@,+&)>&'(()

E+;;/3,&I9&F/;D3GB.;-/D&=B@/:;&J&$3:+B/,4&.,:&E/[email protected]/3,;+,($'-.B0C0.D"'$%

"($%%&"($J% NG(IO/ M6*1=E/ U?UU+*/ 073*/ 19=/ =*F-0.167-9/ 79/ V79;C1./ F+?7=3/ 19=,-9=767-93/F-0/6C*70/*9601K.*96RQ/ B31.-K-?+-3@/ bQ/ W7.12-K-?+-3@/ AQ/ SC16<7=17@/ HQ/ ]101K*6313@/ 5QX18+7=73@/D978*0376E/-F/X16013@/H0**,*

"($J!&"($(! NG\^O/)*12+E/,-.K0*337U+*/X-73*?7++*/F+-P3/-F/1/V79;C1./F+?7=>Q/ B1+71=-0-?@/ HQ/ H*-0;7-?@/ GQ/ G+*c19=0-?@/ D978*0376E/ -F/ SEK0?3@A7,-371@/SEK0?3

"($!%&"!$"% NG\IO/A?.*07,1+/37.?+167-9/-F/,1+*9=*079;/-F/873,-K+1367,/.16*071+3>Q/ 5763-?+73@/ MQ/ M-F-?@/ A167-91+/ B*,C97,1+/ D978*0376E/ -F/ G6C*93@H0**,*

"!$"!&"!$'! NG!IO/)18*/*8-+?67-9/79/6P-&+1E*0/K0*33?0*/=078*9/F+-P/4/A*P6-9719?KK*0/+1E*0/-8*0/1/9-9&A*P6-9719/U-66-./+1E*0XQ/[1++?07@/XQWQ5Q/MK*+6@/:Q]Q/51610@/SQRQ/Y1P0*9,*@/T.K*071+/S-++*;*Y-9=-9@/D]

"!$(%&"!$!! +)<<"".;'"(@

"!$!!&"^$"! NG'JO/A?.*07,1+/,-.K1073-9/U*6P**9/V79;C1./19=/3-.*/0*;?+107<*=.-=*+3SQ:Q/ _1071@/ RQ/ ]101./ _Q@/ A167-91+/ Y1U-016-0E/ -F/ M,7*967F7,S-.K?6167-93@/V01<7+

"^$J%&"^$(% NG^'O/ V+--=/ C*.-=E91.7,3/ 79/ ,10-67=/ U7F?0,167-9$/ 79F+?*9,*/ -F0C*-+-;7,1+/.-=*+3XQ/B*0972@/fQ/f?97,@/RQ/5109@/D978*0376E/-F/5107U-0@/M+-8*971

"^$(!&"\$%% W73,?337-9

E'""./6"*$*#

Page 30: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

I

6.7&I9&%2/:.7&$32,/,4>&?@,+&K>&'(()

E+;;/3,&L9&F/;D3+B.;-/D&%B3M&!,;-.N/B/-/+;+,($'-.4050.1(6'(*&7(%

#$%%&#$J% NG#O/D379;/A*P6-9&H5L>M/F-0/873,-*+1367,/F+-P/67.*&36*KK*03fQ/G9P10/19=/LQSQ/G0.360-9;@/5TB@/S1.U07=;*@/5G@/DMG

#$J!&#$(! NG^%O/WAM/-F/K-+E*36*0/ ,-*c60?37-9/4/ 79F+?*9,*/-F/873,-*+1367,76E/-9796*0F1,71+/79361U7+767*3XQ/Y1?0*@/:Q/51=C1-?7@/LQ/[1+*66*@/YQ/M7+81@/RQ&_Q/G;133196@/BQ/S-?K*<@S>5>_@/>,-+*/=*3/579*3/=*/X1073@/_019,*

#$!%&I$"% NG(^O/:9/1/9*P/*+1367,/79361U7+76E$/U7F?0,167-9/79/1/,0-33&3+-6LQRQ/X--+*@/D978*0376E/-F/Y78*0K--+@/D]5QGQ/G+8*3@/D978*0376E/-F/X-06-@/X-06?;1+XQRQ/:+78*701@/D978*0376E/-F/V*701/T96*07-0@/S-87+C1@/X-06?;1+

I$"!&I$'! NG\JO/V7F?0,167-9/191+E373/-F/F+-P/79361U7+767*3/79/K-+E.*0/.*+63/=?079;*c60?37-95Q>Q/]18-?3191273@/SQTQ/M7*66-3@/GQHQ/V-?=-?873@/A167-91+/B*,C97,1+D978*0376E/-F/G6C*93@/H0**,*YQ/L?33-@/D978*0376E/-F/A1K+*3@/T61+EHQ/H*-0;7-?@/D978*0376E/-F/SEK0?3@/A7,-371@/SEK0?3

I$(%&"%$%% NG'"O/ 5-=*+79;/ -F/ 1c73E..*607,/ 79361U7+767*3/ -U3*08*=/ =?079;/ 6C**+*,60-3K79979;/-F/C7;C+E/,-9=?,679;@/9-9&A*P6-9719/g*63SQXQ/S100-++@/bQYQ/R--@/S-09*++/D978*0376E@/T6C1,1@/Ab@/DMG

"%$%!&"%$J% +)<<"".;'"(@

"%$J%&"%$(% NG!'O/S1876E/ F7++79;/K0-,*33/.-=*+79;/UE/ 0C*-+-;7,1+/,C101,6*07<167-919=/+10;*/3,1+*/,-.K?6167-9]Q/SC0736-=-?+-?@/LQ/5*C01U7@/GQ/5*C01U7@/>Q/L-<*9U1?.@/G8*0EL*3*10,C/S*96*0@/X131=*91@/SG@/DMG

"%$(!&""$%! NG!JO/G/K101++*+/1=1K678*/?9360?,6?0*=/F7976*/8-+?.*/.*6C-=/F-0/+79*10361U7+76E/N9-0.1+/.-=*O/191+E373/-F/873,-*+1367,/F+?7=/F+-P35Q/M1C79@/ZQRQ/)7+3-9@/D978*0376E/S-++*;*/Y-9=-9@/D]

""$"%&""$'% NGIO/G/9*P/361U7+76E/.*,C1973./133-,716*=/P76C/6C*/:+=0-E=&V/.-=*+79/,0**K79;/F+-P/0*;7.*L1</]?KF*0.19@/BC*/Z*U0*P/D978*0376E@/R*0?31+*.@/T301*+

""$'!&""$!! NG!(O/S-7+&360*6,C/60193767-9/19=/6C*/U0*12/=-P9/-F/,-9679??./.-=*+35Q/V1g1g@/RQ/L187/X01213C@/5-913C/D978*0376E@/5*+U-?09*@/G?3601+715Q/X13`?1+7@/L7,*/D978*0376E@/Z-?36-9@/Bh@/DMG

"J$%%&"($%% A2*9,

Page 31: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

"%

6.7&I9&%2/:.7&<=-+2,33,>&?@,+&K>&'(()

E+;;/3,&O9&13;-+2&E+;;/3,+,($'-.4050.1(6'(*&7(%

"($%%&"!$(% 18Q/NG\(O/G/;*9*01+7<*=/379;+*&,-9F-0.167-9/6*93-0/873,-*+1367,/.-=*+U13*=/-9/K079,7K+*3/-F/9-9&*`?7+7U07?./6C*0.-=E91.7,3XQ/ M6*F19-?@/ SC?9;;7/ V17;@/ [QHQ/ 5180196<13@/ D978*0376E/ -F/ X16013@H0**,*

1'Q/ NG!#O/ A?.*07,1+/ 37.?+167-9/ -F/ ,-.K+*c/ F+?7=/ F+-P3/ P76C/ 9-9&A*P6-9719/=7FF*0*9671+/.-=*+3:Q/)?*93,C/19=/5Q/]0*U3@/D978*0376E/-F/]133*+@/H*0.19E

1IP& NG!\O/ A?.*07,1+/ 37.?+167-93/ -F/ F+-P/ 79/ 1/ 81071U+*/ 3K**=/ ,-&0-61679;/6P79/3,0*P/*c60?=*0SQ/B<-;191273/19=/MQ/fC?@/D978*0376E/-F/)16*0+--@/S191=1BQ/MC7;*73C7/19=/]Q/B72101@/R1K19/M6**+/)-023@/Z70-3C7.1@/R1K19

1LP/ NG(#O/ S-00*+1679;/ 6C*/ 0C*-+-;E/ -F/ X[S/ K136*3/ P76C/ K1067,+*,C101,6*07367,35QHQ/L136*70-@/YQ5Q/_*00*701@/GQ/B-.i3@/MQ/_7;?*70*=-@/D978*0376E/-FS-7.U01@/X-06?;1+

1OQ/ NG#%O/ LC*-+-;7,1+/ ,C101,6*07<167-9/ -F/ F--=36?FF/ ?3*=/ 79/ 0-++79;*cK*07.*963/19=/.-=*+79;/871/796*;01+/,-93676?678*/*`?167-93>Q/ 5?+71P19@/ MQHQ/ Z16<7270712-3@/ D978*0376E/ -F/ V07673C/ S-+?.U71@[19,-?8*0@/S191=1MQ/ M-F-?/ 19=/ >Q/5763-?+73@/A167-91+/ B*,C97,1+/D978*0376E/ -F/G6C*93@H0**,*

1AQ/NG#"O/X0*=7,679;/6C*/U*C187-?0/-F/9E+-9&^/6C0-?;C/79=?36071+/3K79K1,23GQ/H?3679/19=/GQ/f?K19,7,@/D978*0376E/-F/Yg?U+g191@/M+-8*971>Q/5763-?+73@/A167-91+/B*,C97,1+/D978*0376E/-F/G6C*93@/H0**,*

1)Q/ NG\"O/ A?.*07,1+/ 37.?+167-9/ -F/ 6C*/ *c60?37-9/ -F/ 360-9;+E,-.K0*337U+*/+7`?7=/F-1.3>Q/B1+71=-0-?/19=/HQ/H*-0;7-?@/D978*0376E/-F/SEK0?3@/A7,-371@/SEK0?3>Q/5763-?+73@/A167-91+/B*,C97,1+/D978*0376E/-F/G6C*93@/H0**,*

1KQ/ NG\\O/ G99?+10/ X-73*?7++*/ F+-P/ -F/ 1/ A*P6-9719/ +7`?7=/ P76C/ 9-9&.-9-6-97,/3+7K/1+-9;/6C*/P1++35Q/SC16<7.791@/HQ/H*-0;7-?@/D978*0376E/-F/SEK0?3@/A7,-371@/SEK0?3]Q/Z-?371=13@/D978*0376E/-F/6C*/G*;*19@/M1.-3@/H0**,*MQHQ/ Z16<7270712-3@/ D978*0376E/ -F/ V07673C/ S-+?.U71@/ [19,-?8*0@S191=1

1QQ/ NG("1O/ S-.K101678*/ 36?=E/ -F/ .?+67&.-=*/ ,-93676?678*/ *`?167-93F-0/F7+./U+-P79;/K0-,*33

Page 32: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

""

MQ/ M101F01<7@/ _Q/ MC107F@/G.7021U70/D978*0376E/ -F/ B*,C9-+-;E@/ B*C019@T019

18(Q/NG#JO/BC*/6*.K*016?0*/=*K*9=*9,*/-F/6C*/L-?3*/.-=*/0*+1c167-93K*,60?./19=/<*0-/3C*10/016*/873,-376E/79/,73&"@(&K-+EU?61=7*9*$/0*3?+63F0-./+-9;/16-.7367,/.-+*,?+10/=E91.7,3/37.?+167-93/=-P9/6-/6C*/;+13360193767-9/6*.K*016?0*/B;HQ/B3-+-?@/[QHQ/5180196<13@/D978*0376E/-F/X16013@/H0**,*

188Q/NG"!O/:9/279*67,/.-=*+3/F-0/=7+?6*/3?3K*937-93/-F/07;7=/0-=3_Q/:66-@/D978*0376E/-F/V-99@/H*0.19EGQ/B<181013@/D978*0376E/-F/510E+19=@/5W@/DMG

"!$(%&"!$!! +)<<"".;'"(@

"^$%%&J%$'% /F92'%$)*.&).A$*G)%

Page 33: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

"J

6.7&L9&E.-@2:.7&$32,/,4>&?@,+&Q>&'(()

E+;;/3,&A9&F/;D3+B.;-/D&%B@/:;&R&$3:+B/,4&.,:&E/[email protected]/3,;+,($'-.4050.1(6'(*&7(%

#$%%&#$J% NG(\O/:9/6C*/;13/K*9*60167-9/79/K*07-=7,1++E/,-93607,6*=/,70,?+10/6?U*3F7++*=/P76C/873,-*+1367,/+7`?7=3bQ/W7.12-K-?+-3@/RQ/B31.-K-?+-3@/D978*0376E/-F/X16013@/H0**,*

#$J!&#$(! NGJ\O/BC*/+-;&,-9F-0.167-9/6*93-0/1KK0-1,C/79/ 6C*/_[5/F01.*P-02$U*9,C.102/3-+?67-93/19=/361U7+76E/191+E373GQ/GF-93-@/5QGQ/G+8*3@/D978*0376E/-F/X-06-@/X-06?;1+_QBQ/X79C-@/D978*0376E/-F/579C-@/V01;1@/X-06?;1+XQRQ/:+78*701@/D978*0376E/-F/V*701/T96*07-0@/S-87+C1@/X-06?;1+

#$!%&I$"% NG"'O/ :3,7++1679;/ ,C199*+/ F+-P3/ -F/ DS5/ 19=/ :+=0-E=&V/ F+?7=3$9?.*07,1+/19=/191+E67,1+/3-+?67-93GQMQLQ/ W?106*@/ GQTQXQ/ 57019=1@/ XQRQ/ :+78*701@/ D978*0376E/ -F/ V*701T96*07-0@/S-87+C1@/X-06?;1+

I$"!&I$'! NG'IO/A?.*07,1+/37.?+167-9/-F/1/XBB/F+?7=/K136/1/,E+79=*0ZQ/]1.1+@/YQ/BC173@/HQ/5-.K*19@/ZQ/A1g7@/X-+E6*,C Y7++*@/_019,*

I$(%&"%$%% NG^!O/M6*1=E/F+-P/-F/1/.?+67&.-=*/hXX/F+?7=/K136/1/,E+79=*0AQRQ/T923-9@/BQAQ/XC7++7K3@/S10=7FF/D978*0376E@/D]

"%$%!&"%$J% +)<<"".;'"(@

E+;;/3,&)9&F/;D3+B.;-/D&%B@/:;&R&$3:+B/,4&.,:&E/[email protected]/3,;&SD3,-T:U+,($'-.B0C0.D"'$%

"%$J%&"%$(% NG!"O/ [73,-*+1367,/ 191+E373/ -F/ ,-.K+*c/ F+-P3$/ F0-./ 6C*/ ,-93676?678*.-=*+/ 6C0-?;C/ 6C*/ 9?.*07,1+/ 37.?+167-93/ 19=/ 6C*70/ *cK*07.*961+81+7=167-9TQ/M7012-8@/D978*0376E/-F/M6&>67*99*@/_019,*>Q/5763-?+73@/A167-91+/B*,C97,1+/D978*0376E/-F/G6C*93@/H0**,*

"%$(!&""$%! NG!%O/ A?.*07,1+/ 37.?+167-9/ -F/ 873,-*+1367,/ F+-P3/ 79/ ,0-33&3+-6/ F+-P=*87,*35Q_Q/ )*U36*0@/ _Q/ V*+U+7=71@/ VQ/ X?19;270=@/ D978*0376E/ -F/ )1+*3@MP193*1@/D]

""$"%&""$'% NG"IO/ X0*=7,67-9/ -F/ =7*/ 3P*++/ 79/ K-+E.*0/ .*+6/ *c60?37-9/ ?379;/ 19G0U76010E/Y1;019;719/>?+*0719/NGY>O/U13*=/F7976*/*+*.*96/.*6C-=[Q/H19870@/GQ/Y*+*@/X?9*@/T9=71LQ/BC1-210@/TTB@/V-.U1E@/T9=71VQXQ/H1?6C1.@/ASY@/X?9*@/T9=71

""$'!&""$!! NG("UO/A-9&73-6C*0.1+/ 37.?+167-9/ -F/ 6C*/ F7+.&U+-P79;/ K0-,*33/ ?379;6C*/.?+67&.-=*/*c6*9=*=/K-.&K-./.-=*+

Page 34: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

"'

MQ/ M101F01<7@/ _Q/ MC107F@/G.7021U70/D978*0376E/ -F/ B*,C9-+-;E@/ B*C019@T019

"J$%%&"($%% A2*9,

Page 35: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

"(

8'P((R8LP(! 6.7&L9&E.-@2:.7&<=-+2,33,>&?@,+&Q>&'(()

E+;;/3,&K9&V35GB+W&$.-+2/.B;9&XWG+2/5+,-;&.,:&$3:+B/,4+,($'-.4050.1(6'(*&7(%

"($%%&"($J% NGJJ1O/S-.K?679;/P76C/K-P*0&+1P/873,-*+1367,/.16*071+3L-;*0/B199*0@/_Q/j7@/MQ&SQ/W17@/D978*0376E/-F/ME=9*E@/AM)@/G?3601+71

"($J!&"($(! NG^"O/G0*/*9619;+*=/K-+E.*07,/3-+?67-93/=7FF*0*96/F0-./.*+63k5Q[Q/G,C10E1@/WQGQ/A;?E*9@/BQ/M07=C10@/5-913C/D978*0376E@5*+U-?09*@/G?3601+71XQ]Q/VC1661,C10g**@/5TB@/S1.U07=;*@/5G@/DMG

"($!%&"!$"% NG^#O/ SC101,6*07<167-9/ -F/ 6C*/ ,-.K0*3378*/ U*C187-?0/ -F/ U0179/ 6733?*19=/,-93676?678*/.-=*+79;HQ)Q5Q/ X*6*03@/ 5Q/ Z01K2-@/ RQGQ)Q/ 819/ W-..*+*9@/ RQMQZQ5Q)73.193@/>79=C-8*9/D978*0376E/-F/B*,C9-+-;E@/BC*/A*6C*0+19=3

"!$"!&"!$'! NG('O/>cK*07.*961+/19=/9?.*07,1+/*81+?167-9/-F/=0-K/=*F-0.167-9/19=U0*12&?K/79/,-.K+*c/F+-P/F7*+=3LQWQ/ >;C-+.@/ XQ/ M<1U-@/ B*,C97,1+/ D978*0376E/ -F/ W*9.102@/ YE9;UE@W*9.102XQ/_73,C*0@/>BZ@/f?07,C@/MP76<*0+19=]Q/_*7;+@/57,C7;19/B*,C9-+-;7,1+/D978*0376E@/Z-?;C6-9@/5T@/DMG

"!$(%&"!$!! +)<<"".;'"(@

"!$!!&"^$"! NG^\O/ >cK*07.*961+/ 19=/ 9?.*07,1+/ 36?=E/ -F/ ,1876167-9/ 79/ g-?091+U*1079;3XQSQ/V-++1=1@/BQAQ/XC7++7K3@/S10=7FF/D978*0376E@/D]XQLQ/)7++71.3@/LQYQ/)7++71.3@/D978*0376E/-F/)1+*3@/MP193*1@/D]

"^$J%&"^$(% NGJ^O/5-=*+79;/ -F/ 9-9&73-6C*0.1+/ *+*,60-3K79979;/ -F/ K-+E.*0/ .*+63P76C/19=/P76C-?6/,0E361++7<167-9>Q/fC.1E*8@/bQYQ/R--@/S-09*++/D978*0376E@/T6C1,1@/Ab@/DMG

"^$(!&"\$%! NG'\O/M60?,6?0*&K0-K*06E/0*+167-93C7K3/F-0/6C*/A*P6-9719/19=/6C*/9-9&A*P6-9719/F+-P/-F/K-+E.*0/3-+?67-93_Q/5*E*0@/ZQ/M6-0<@/RQ/M6-0<@/GQ/V79;-*+@/)Q&5Q/]?+7,2*@/D978*0376E/-FZ1.U?0;@/H*0.19E

"\$"%&J%$'% E'"".&$:"

J%$'%&JJ$'% +)*<"'"*9".G$**"'

Page 36: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

"!

6.7&O9&E@,:.7&$32,/,4>&?@,+&8(>&'(()

E+;;/3,&Q9&*@2N@B+,D+&/,&D35GB+W&=B@/:;+,($'-.4050.1(6'(*&7(%

I$%%&I$J% NG!^O/WE91.7,/]&Y/191+E373/-F/,-C*0*96/360?,6?0*3/U13*=/-9/WAM/-F6?0U?+*96/A*P6-9719/19=/873,-*+1367,/F+-P3HQ/M1.1961@/GQAQ/V*073@/D978*0376E/-F/W*+1P10*@/A*P102@/W>@/DMGHQ/:cU*00E@/5TB@/5G@/DMGLQ/Z19=+*0@/A181+/L*3*10,C/Y1U-016-0E@/)13C79;6-9@/WS@/DMG]Q/Z-?371=13@/D978*0376E/-F/6C*/G*;*19@/M1.-3@/H0**,*

I$J!&I$(! NG!!O/ G/ +-;&*cK-9*9671+/ .1KK79;/ F-0/ 6C*/ K0*3*08167-9/ -F/ K-37678*=*F7976*9*33/ 79/ 6C*/ 9?.*07,1+/ 796*;0167-9/ -F/ 873,-*+1367,/ ,-93676?678**`?167-93]Q/Z-?371=13@/D978*0376E/-F/6C*/G*;*19@/M1.-3@/H0**,*YQ/)19;@/GQAQ/V*073@/D978*0376E/-F/W*+1P10*@/A*P102@/W>@/DMG

I$!%&"%$"% NG'#O/W70*,6/19=/+10;*/*==E/9?.*07,1+/37.?+167-93/-F/_>A>&X/=01;0*=?,67-9/F+-P3YQ/BC173@/HQ/5-.K*19@/X-+E6*,C Y7++*@/_019,*GQ>Q/B*g1=1&510679*<@/D978*0376E/-F/M-?6C/_+-07=1@/_Y@/DMGBQVQ/H16327@/D978*0376E/-F/X-767*03@/>AM5G@/_019,*

"%$"!&"%$'! NGJIO/G/6?0U?+*9,*/,+-3?0*/F-0/873,-*+1367,/F+?7=3/U13*=/-9/6C*/_>A>&X/.-=*+_QBQ/X79C-@/D978*0376E/-F/579C-@/V01;1@/X-06?;1+XQLQ/L*3*9=*@/D978*0376E/-F/X-06-@/X-06?;1+SQ_Q/Y7@/LQ/M?0*3C2?.10@/)13C79;6-9/D978*0376E@/M6Q/Y-?73@/5:@/DMGVQGQ/b-?973@/D978*0376E/-F/S1+7F-0971@/W1873@/SG@/DMG

"%$'!&""$%% +)<<"".;'"(@

""$%%&""$'% W73,?337-9/4/S+-379;/0*.1023

"J$%%&"($%% A2*9,

X#6&Y%&"YZ[E\Y1

Page 37: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

J%

YZ<C&VY#*Z!]^*!Y#E

Page 38: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

!J

*H+&B34RV3,=325.-/3,&*+,;32&<GG23.DH&/,&-H+&%F$%2.5+M32_9&]+,DH5.2_&E3B@-/3,;&.,:&E-.N/B/-7&<,.B7;/;

GQ/GF-93-/l"m@/5QGQ/G+8*3/l"m@/_QBQ/X79C-/l"@Jm/19=/XQRQ/:+78*701/l'm

l"m/_1,?+=1=*/=*/>9;*9C1071/=1/D978*037=1=*/=-/X-06-@/S>_B@/L?1/W0Q/L-U*06-/_0713@/(J%%&(^!/X-06-@/X-06?;1+

lJm/D978*037=1=*/=-/579C-@/Y10;-/=-/X1n-@/(\%(&!!'@/V01;1@/X-06?;1+l'm/W*K1061.*96-/=*/>9;*9C1071/>+*,60-.*,i97,1@/D97=1=*/5BX@/D978*037=1=*/=1/V*701

T96*07-0@/^J%"&%%"/S-87+C1@/X-06?;1+

BC*/ +-;&,-9F-0.167-9/ F-0.?+167-9/ K0-K-3*=/ UE/ _1661+/ 19=/ ]?KF*0.19/ lRAA_58-+Q"J'@/ KQJ#"/ NJ%%(Om/ C13/ C*+K*=/ 79/ K0-87=79;/ F?06C*0/ 7937;C63/ 796-/ 6C*/ Z7;C&)*733*9U*0;/ A?.U*0/ X0-U+*.Q/ T9/ 6C73/ P-02/ P*/ 798*367;16*/ 6C*/ U*C187-?0/ -F/ 6C16F-0.?+167-9/ P76C79/ 6C*/ _7976*/ [-+?.*/ 5*6C-=/ N_[5O/ F01.*P-02@/ UE/ 37.?+1679;3*8*01+/ U*9,C.102/ ,0**K79;/ F+-P3/ -F/ 873,-*+1367,/ F+?7=3$/ 36*1=E/ 19=/ ?936*1=E/ F+-P6C0-?;C/1/($"/1U0?K6/,-9601,67-9@/ F+-P/10-?9=/1/,-9F79*=/,E+79=*0/19=/ F+-P/ 6C0-?;C($"/3`?10*&3`?10*/'W/1U0?K6/,-9601,67-9Q/BC0**/.-=*+3/NDS5@/:+=0-E=&V/19=/XBB/OP*0*/?3*=/6-/133*33/6C*/*FF*,6/-F/=7FF*0*96/0C*-+-;7,1+/U*C187-?0/-9/6C*/F+-P/K166*09319=/3-+?67-9/361U7+76EQ/BC*/K-+E.*0/360*33/P13/,1+,?+16*=/?379;/U-6C/6C*/3619=10=/19=6C*/ +-;&,-9F-0.167-9/ .*6C-=-+-;7*3Q/ _-0/ 1++/ 6*36/ ,13*3@/ 6C*/ +-;&,-9F-0.167-96*,C97`?*/ K0-87=*3/ 3-+?67-93/ P76C/ 37.7+10/ 1,,?01,E/ 13/ 6C*/ 3619=10=/ 1KK0-1,C/ PC*9U-6C/.*6C-=3/,-98*0;*/6-/1/36*1=E/3-+?67-9Q/T9/6*0.3/-F/361U7+76E/6C*/+-;&,-9F-0.167-9F-0.?+167-9/ 73/ F-?9=/ 6-/ U*/.?,C/.-0*/ 0-U?36/P76C/ 3-+?67-93/ 1,C7*8*=/ 16/ 8*0E/ C7;CW*U-01C/9?.U*03@/1+6C-?;C/79/3-.*/,13*3/*+1367,/79361U7+767*3/=-/*.*0;*Q

>.17+$/..1+8*3oF*Q?KQK6

Page 39: A TURBULENCE CLOSURE FOR VISCOELASTIC FLUIDS BASED …fpinho/pdfs/CI103_Rhodes2007_Turb.pdfA turbulence closure for viscoelastic fluids based on the FENE-P model CEFT-FEUP Centro de

\%

<&*@2N@B+,D+&VB3;@2+&=32&F/;D3+B.;-/D&%B@/:;].;+:&3,&-H+&%X#XR1&$3:+B

_Q/BQ/X79C-/l"m@/SQ/_Q/Y7/lJm@/VQ/GQ/b-?973/l'm@/LQ/M?0*3C2?.10/lJm/19=/XQ/LQL*3*9=*/l"m

l"m/D978*037=1=*/=-/579C-@/(\%(&!!'/V01;1@/X-06?;1+/19=/S>_B@/_>DX@/(J%%&(^!X-06-@/X-06?;1+

lJm/W*K106.*96/-F/>9*0;E@/>9870-9.*961+/19=/SC*.7,1+/>9;79**079;/19=/6C*/S*96*0F-0/516*071+3/T99-8167-9@/)13C79;6-9/D978*0376E@/M6Q/Y-?73@/5:/^'"'%@/DMG

l'm/W*K106.*96/-F/S787+/19=/>9870-9.*961+/>9;79**079;@/D978*0376E/-F/S1+7F-0971@W1873@/SG/I!^"^@/DMG

WAM/0*3*10,C/-9/6?0U?+*96/,C199*+/F+-P/-F/_>A>&X/F+?7=3/C13/K0-87=*=/=161/16/C7;C*9-?;C/ L*E9-+=3/ 9?.U*03/ 6-/ 1++-P/ 6C*/ =*8*+-K.*96/ -F/ ,+-3?0*3/ F-0/ LGAM/ 6EK**`?167-93@/ 3?,C/ 13/ <*0-6C&-0=*0/ .-=*+/ -F/ Y7/ *6/ 1+/ NRAA_5/ "(%/ NJ%%\O/ "\\OQ/ _-079=?36071+/ 1KK+7,167-93/ C7;C*0/ -0=*0/ 6?0U?+*9,*/ ,+-3?0*3/ 10*/ 0*`?70*=/ 19=/ F?06C*0=*8*+-K.*963/9**=*=QG/+-P/L*E9-+=3/9?.U*0/@H /6?0U?+*9,*/,+-3?0*/F-0/_>A>&X/F+?7=3/73/=*8*+-K*=/U13*=-9/WAM/=161/F-0/+-P/=01;/0*=?,67-9/79/,C199*+/F+-P/N!" p/'I!@/8" p/J!@/ p/%QI@/AJpI%%OQ/ S+-3?0*3/ 10*/ K0-87=*=/ F-0/ 6C*/ 9*P/ 873,-*+1367,/ 360*33/ K-P*0/ NP-02/ =-9*/ UE873,-*+1367,/ 360*33*3O/ 19=/ 6?0U?+*96/ 60193K-06/ 6*0.3/ 13/ P*++/ 13/ 6-/ 6C*/ 9-9&+79*106?0U?+*96/6*0./NAYBO/107379;/79/6C*/0C*-+-;7,1+/,-93676?678*/*`?167-9/19=/,-.K1073-9310*/ .1=*/ P76C/ 6C*/ ,-00*3K-9=79;/ WAM/ =161Q/ BC*/ .-=*+/ F-0/ 6C*/ 873,-*+1367,/ 360*33K-P*0/ 0*+7*3/ -9/ 19/ 1,,?016*/ .-=*+79;/ F-0/ AYB@/ PC*0*13/ 6C*/ 873,-*+1367,/ 6?0U?+*9660193K-06/6*0./73/-F/+*33/0*+*819,*/79/6C*/60193K-06/*`?167-9/-F/@QX0*=7,67-93/ -F/ F?++E&=*8*+-K*=/ ,C199*+/ F+-P/ 10*/ ,1007*=/ -?6/ 1F6*0/ 1=1K6167-9/ -F/ 1U-?9=10E&+1E*0/ ,-=*Q/ BC*/ 0*3?+63/ 3C-P/ 6C*/ K-6*9671+/ -F/ 6C73/ 1KK0-1,C/ 19=/ 79=7,16*0-?6*3/F-0/F?06C*0/.-=*+/=*8*+-K.*96Q

>.17+$/FK79C-oF*Q?KQK6