a search for white dwarfs in the solar neighbourhood filea search for white dwarfs in the solar...

2
A Search for White Dwarfs in the Solar Neighbourhood G. Rupprecht and I. Bues, Or. -Remeis-Sternwarte, Bamberg Introduetion White dwarf stars represent one of the two final stages of normal stellar evolution. Their degenerate core of a very small mass range (0.6 M0± 0.2 M 0 ) and a radius 01 < 1/100 R 0 is surrounded by a convection zone and an atmosphere with a thickness 01 several hundred metres. The ellective tempera- tures lor the observed objects range Irom 70,000 K with the colours of 0 stars down to 4,000 K with the colours 01 early M stars. This cooling sequence is due to the initial mass and the age 01 the stars, the coolest objects being several1 0 9 years old. For lurther details about white dwarfs and the evolution leading to their formation see Koester (1982, The Messenger No. 28, p 25). From white dwarf birth rates and cooling theory it is possible to compute number densities expected lor various temperature or bolometric magnitude intervals. For hot white dwarfs (T elf > 12,000 K) observations agree weil with predictions (Green 1980, Astrophysical Journal 238, 685), whereas theory pre- dicts more cool white dwarfs (Telf < 8,000 K) than are actually known (Liebert et al. 1979, Ap. J. 233,226). According to these authors there should be 11 white dwarfs with M bol between 13 m and 15 m within a distance of 10 pc and north 01 b = -20°, but only 8 are known. This is not significant; however, the delicit is more pronounced for stars with 15 m < M bOI < 17 m ; instead 0140 only 3 are observed. Several attempts to find these "missing" white dwarfs focused upon stars with large proper motions, but without much success. So we decided to investigate stars with small proper motions (generally less than 0:'5/year), mpg < 15 m , 0 > b > -35°, to look lor nearby white dwarfs with tangential velocities < 40 km/so As sources lor our candidates we took the Lowell Observatory GD and G Lists (Giclas, Burnham and Thomas 1980 and 1978, Lowell Observatory Bulletin 166 and 164) because they provide proper motions, photographic mag- nitudes, colour estimates, precise coordinates and good lind- ing charts. Photometrie Observations From 1980 to 1983 a total 01 173 stars have been observed during 6 observing periods. Ouring the lirst two seasons the Bochum 61 cm telescope on La Silla was used, in 1980 with the old OC amplilication photometer system and in 1981 with the new pulse-counting photometer, which now works completely computer-controlled as does the telescope mounting. This new computer control gave a better internal accuracy 01 the mea- surements (typically a lew hundredths 01 a magnitude lor stars with V = 12 m to 15 m ), thus signilicantly enhancing the efficiency 01 the telescope. With the Bochum telescope, observations were carried out in the UBV and Strömgren uvby systems. Ouring the lollowing lour observing seasons we used the ESO 1 m telescope for UBVRI and uvby measurements. Data Analysis Classilication 01 the stars is done by means 01 various two- colour diagrams. The classical diagram (Fig. 1) allows recogni- tion 01 main-sequence stars with spectral types later than about B 3, 01 hydrogen-rich white dwarfs (DA) and 01 white dwarfs with helium or continuous spectra (OB or OC). The two crosses high above the black-body line represent white dwarfs with 24 Fig. 1: Strömgren two-c%ur diagram (u-b)l(b-y) of stars observed in 1980-1983 with the Bochum 61 cm and ESO 1 m te/escopes on La Silla. The b/ack-body fine (bb) and the main sequence are indicated. (0) newly c/assified stars; (.) new observations of known white dwarf stars; (x) a/ready known white dwarfs. strong C 2 absorption bands, leading initially to the suggestion that the object observed with similar colours might be a white dwarf 01 spectral type C 2 . However, spectra taken with the ESO 1.52 m telescope (see below) show strong emission lines revealing GD 1339 as a aso with z = 0.114. At V E = it is one 01 the brightest asos in the sky. In the very hot region 01 the (u-b)/(b-y) diagram, however, it is not possible to separate white dwarfs with Telf> 50,000 K lrom subdwarfs and early-type main-sequence stars. The same is true in the very cool region, where white dwarfs 01 T elf < 6,000 K can be mixed up with subdwarfs 01 spectral types sdF, G and K. Both problems can be solved by introducing new two- colour diagrams where the coordinates are taken Irom different filter systems. Fig.2 shows the hot end 01 the (u-b)/(U-V) diagram where a clear separation between the main sequence and the black-body line exists. In this diagram the white dwarls cluster around the black-body line regardless 01 their spectral types. The same is true lor the (R-I)/(u-b) diagram (Fig. 3).

Upload: others

Post on 08-Sep-2019

9 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

A Search for White Dwarfs in the Solar NeighbourhoodG. Rupprecht and I. Bues, Or. -Remeis-Sternwarte, Bamberg

Introduetion

White dwarf stars represent one of the two final stages ofnormal stellar evolution. Their degenerate core of a very smallmass range (0.6 M0± 0.2 M0 ) and a radius 01 < 1/100 R0 issurrounded by a convection zone and an atmosphere with athickness 01 several hundred metres. The ellective tempera­tures lor the observed objects range Irom 70,000 K with thecolours of 0 stars down to 4,000 K with the colours 01 early Mstars. This cooling sequence is due to the initial mass and theage 01 the stars, the coolest objects being several1 09 years old.For lurther details about white dwarfs and the evolution leadingto their formation see Koester (1982, The Messenger No. 28, p25).

From white dwarf birth rates and cooling theory it is possibleto compute number densities expected lor various temperatureor bolometric magnitude intervals. For hot white dwarfs (Telf

> 12,000 K) observations agree weil with predictions (Green1980, Astrophysical Journal 238, 685), whereas theory pre­dicts more cool white dwarfs (Telf < 8,000 K) than are actuallyknown (Liebert et al. 1979, Ap. J. 233,226). According to theseauthors there should be 11 white dwarfs with Mbol between 13m

and 15m within a distance of 10 pc and north 01 b = -20°, butonly 8 are known. This is not significant; however, the delicit ismore pronounced for stars with 15m < MbOI < 17m

; instead 0140only 3 are observed.

Several attempts to find these "missing" white dwarfsfocused upon stars with large proper motions, but without muchsuccess. So we decided to investigate stars with small propermotions (generally less than 0:'5/year), mpg < 15m

, 0 > b >-35°, to look lor nearby white dwarfs with tangential velocities< 40 km/so As sources lor our candidates we took the LowellObservatory GD and G Lists (Giclas, Burnham and Thomas1980 and 1978, Lowell Observatory Bulletin 166 and 164)because they provide proper motions, photographic mag­nitudes, colour estimates, precise coordinates and good lind­ing charts.

Photometrie Observations

From 1980 to 1983 a total 01 173 stars have been observedduring 6 observing periods. Ouring the lirst two seasons theBochum 61 cm telescope on La Silla was used, in 1980 with theold OC amplilication photometer system and in 1981 with thenew pulse-counting photometer, which now works completelycomputer-controlled as does the telescope mounting. This newcomputer control gave a better internal accuracy 01 the mea­surements (typically a lew hundredths 01 a magnitude lor starswith V = 12m to 15m

), thus signilicantly enhancing the efficiency01 the telescope. With the Bochum telescope, observationswere carried out in the UBV and Strömgren uvby systems.Ouring the lollowing lour observing seasons we used the ESO1 m telescope for UBVRI and uvby measurements.

Data Analysis

Classilication 01 the stars is done by means 01 various two­colour diagrams. The classical diagram (Fig. 1) allows recogni­tion 01 main-sequence stars with spectral types later than aboutB 3, 01 hydrogen-rich white dwarfs (DA) and 01 white dwarfswith helium or continuous spectra (OB or OC). The two crosseshigh above the black-body line represent white dwarfs with

24

Fig. 1: Strömgren two-c%ur diagram (u-b)l(b-y) of stars observed in1980-1983 with the Bochum 61 cm and ESO 1 m te/escopes on LaSilla. The b/ack-body fine (bb) and the main sequence are indicated.(0) newly c/assified stars; (.) new observations of known white dwarfstars; (x) a/ready known white dwarfs.

strong C2 absorption bands, leading initially to the suggestionthat the object observed with similar colours might be a whitedwarf 01 spectral type C2. However, spectra taken with the ESO1.52 m telescope (see below) show strong emission linesrevealing GD 1339 as a aso with z = 0.114. At VE = 14~6 it isone 01 the brightest asos in the sky.

In the very hot region 01 the (u-b)/(b-y) diagram, however, it isnot possible to separate white dwarfs with Telf> 50,000 K lromsubdwarfs and early-type main-sequence stars. The same istrue in the very cool region, where white dwarfs 01 Telf <6,000 K can be mixed up with subdwarfs 01 spectral types sdF,G and K. Both problems can be solved by introducing new two­colour diagrams where the coordinates are taken Irom differentfilter systems. Fig.2 shows the hot end 01 the (u-b)/(U-V)diagram where a clear separation between the main sequenceand the black-body line exists. In this diagram the white dwarlscluster around the black-body line regardless 01 their spectraltypes. The same is true lor the (R-I)/(u-b) diagram (Fig. 3).

AO

'.~ ... '"••~ ,GO

..""5000'~bb~

50000

~.20000"'- •

"Z.12000

.1

.3

-.1

-2

,a:

-4 -.2 .0 .2 .4 .6 .81.01.21.41.61.82.0u-b

\Fig. 3: Combined two-colour diagram (R-I)/Strämgren (u-b). This dia-gram allows recognition of cool white dwarf stars. Symbols are thesame as in Fig. 1.

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank the ESO staff at La Silla, espeeially S.Vidal, for their generous and eompetent help.

Results, Prospects for Future Research

The most important result of this investigation is the removalof the alleged defieit for cool white dwarfs. This is obtained byapplieation of the just mentioned reduetion faetor (%) to ourobserved white dwarf numbers and extrapolation of our smallobserved sky area to the same total area as in Liebert et al.(1979, loe. eiL). We even find slightly more cool white dwarfsthan are predieted; this stresses the need forfuture speetrosco­pie checks of the photometrie identifieation proeedure and for abetter statistieal basis of our sueeess ratio.

A further result is a substantial inerease of the number ofobservations of southern GD stars. In the sky area undereonsideration there are about 250 stars brighter thanmpg = 15';'0. At the beginning of our projeet 50 stars had alreadybeen observed with 9 stars elassified as white dwarfs. We add78 stars with photometry and 14 with speetra, raising thenumber of white dwarfs to about 31 (after applieation of thereduetion factor). So Greenstein 's (1969, Ap. J. 158,281) initialexperienee has been eonfirmed by the present investigation:GD stars are very promising white dwarf eandidates.

In addition to a large number of normal white dwarfs severalobjeets have shown up whieh are of great interest individually­one extremely hot white dwarf (Taft ~ 70,000 K, speetral typesupposedly 00), one star with a eontinuous speetrum (OC), anova-like variable just dropping from its permanent maximum,and an exeitingly bright OSO. For these objeets extendedinvestigations are planned or already being earried out (e.g.observations with the IUE satellite, Oetober 1983).

It would be worthwile to eontinue our programme by inelud­ing objeets whieh are one magnitude fainter to improve statis­ties for at least one field of the Southern Sky.

the ESO 1.52 m telescope. A dispersion of 171 Atmm wassuffieient for these stars with only a few but broad lines.

The spectra alltogether eonfirm the photometrie elassifiea­tion of 14 objeets; among the others are a subdwarf, a subdwarfbinary and a OSO. If we apply this sueeess ratio of 2/3 to our 46photometrieally identified white dwarfs, there should remainabout 30 to be eonfirmed by means of speetroscopy.

-.2

8000

;~

-.4-.6

o

x .50000

~.20000

~o

B1 0 \b

/12000x

.4

.6

.8

·0

-.2

-.4

.0I

::l .2

-1.6 -1.4 -1.2 -1.0 -.8U-V

~ig. 2: Combined two-colour diagram Strämgren (u-b)/Johnson (U- V)or hot stars. Symbols are the same as in Fig. 1.

Oistanee in parsec cool hott--- white dwarfs

0-10 12 010 - 20 8 320- 50 1 13

- > 50 ( 0 8

Spectroscopic Observations

h~lthou9h photometry is a powerful tool forthe identifieation ofW Ite dwarfs, there still remains a chance for not reeognizingsame subdwarfs or binary stars. For a deeisive elassifieation,~~eetros.eopy is neeessary. Five of our photometrieally iden-'f~d whlte dwarfs have already been speetroseopieally clas­

~~ led, ~ainly by Greenstein (1980, Ap. J. 242,738). Ouring twoghts In Oetober 1982 we had the chance to take image-tube

Spectra of 16 others with the Boiler & Chivens speetrograph at

Fr0';1 these and similar two-eolour diagrams 46 stars wereelasslfled as white dwarfs.

For aehieving our goal- to determine the number of whitedwarfs in the solar neighbourhood - the distanees of our newobjeets should be known. Various eolour-Iuminosity relationsWere ~sed two derive photometrie parallaxes. Absolute visual~agnltudes for cool stars were derived from a Mvf(B-V) relation~Iven by Greenstein (1976, Astrophysical Journal 81, 323),

om a linear regression Mvf(b-y) based on Graham's data(1972, A. J. 77, 144) as eited by Green (1980, Ap. J. 238,685),and from linear regressions Mvf(u-b) and Mvf(R-I) wh ich weealeulated for stars with known trigonometrie parallaxes. Sineeonly very few hot white dwarfs have measured parallaxes,seeond order polynomials were fitted to hot hydrogen-rieh~odel atmospheres (Wesemael, Auer, van Horn, Savedofft 980, Ap. J. Suppl. 43, 159) or to helium-rieh (OB) white dwarfst~ deflne again eolour-Iuminosity relations. Oistanees werethen eomputed fromthe ealeulated absolute magnitudes and

(e ob~erved magnltudes. The resulting spatial distribution

exeludlng GD 1339) is given in Table 1).

"!-able 1. Distances o( photometrically identified white dwarfs

25