a framework for occupational savings schemes regulation summary of recommendations for the...
TRANSCRIPT
A Framework for Occupational
Savings Schemes Regulation
Summary of Recommendations
for the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan
Jeremy Gadburyon behalf of
The International Securities Consultancy Limited
Islamabad Wednesday 27th June 2007
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
2
The SECP’s role
Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan Act, 1997 as amended by the Finance Act, 2003, as follows:
20 (4) The Commission shall be responsible for the performance of the following …
promoting and regulating development of private Pension Scheme and Funds
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
3
The SECP’s role
Legislation generally expected to include
Pension funds and pension arrangements
Provident Funds
Gratuity Funds and gratuity arrangements
in the private sector, and to some degree the public sector.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
4
The Terms of ReferenceScope of Work;• Develop a regulatory and supervisory framework for
occupational saving schemes.Detailed Tasks:• 1. Assist the SECP in developing a framework for regulation
of occupational savings schemes. • 2. Assist and guide the SECP in collating relevant data on
occupational savings schemes and, based on international best practices, provide a sequential roadmap for their regulation.
• 3. Targeted review of the operational processes of the SECP Pensions Wing and update them with regard to regulation and monitoring of pension funds.
Output/Reporting Requirements:• Make detailed recommendations for the tasks detailed above.
A Framework for Occupational
Savings Schemes Regulation
The legislation
Surveys and Statistics
Points of concern – and suggested solutions
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
6
Major features of the Consultancy to date
•The Workshop on considering the Regulatory Framework for Occupational Savings Schemes on 25th June, •Organising an internal study of pension and gratuity arrangements of leading Pakistani companies.•Developing the Survey questionnaire of occupational savings arrangements to be sent out to all listed companies in Pakistan.•Designing the style and content of a Report based on the Survey.•Providing advice on the Voluntary Pension System.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
7
The 25th June Workshop
ParticipantsInvestment Managers
Atlas, Arif Habib, JS AbamcoActuaries
Nauman Associates, Sidat Hyder MorshedCustodian, Trustees
Central Depositary CompanyCorporate Sector
Pakistan International Airlines, Engro Chemical
SECP attendees – Pension Wing
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
8
The 25th June Workshop
Approach
SECP has a planned approach of regulation
Invited workshop participants • To comment on the approach• To develop ideas related to the approach• To highlight contentious issues• To highlight matters omitted• To discuss the timing of certain measures
In a workshop environment
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
9
The recommended regulatory approach
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
10
Principles behind the Regulation• The idea of a light regulatory touch • Staggered introduction of measures• Compatibility with Voluntary Pension Scheme
Rules
The preferred route is to focus on • Registration, • Trust structure and • Audit to ensure that pension and provident funds are
financially strong and responsibly managed… …and go from there.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
11
Principles behind the Regulation
• Establishing a robust system of occupational savings that will add to the social and financial stability of the country.
• Enabling employers to develop appropriate employee benefit structures that will assist their own competitive position.
• Protecting the interests of the employer.• Protecting the current and future interests of the
employee.• Protecting the interests of a pension beneficiary .• Encouraging the development of professional
management of occupational savings schemes.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
12
Principles behind the Regulation
• To recognise that the pension and provident fund systems are, as far as we can tell, generally well managed.
• To build on those strengths.• To make it straightforward for pension and provident
funds to continue.• To discover and eliminate any bad practices and
misdemeanours.• To recognise it is not only a matter of regulating
occupational savings schemes but also the benefits and how they are paid.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
13
Points of interest and concern
General points on legislation.1. Pension regulation is not pension reform.2. But no matter how accommodating it is to well run
existing schemes and encouraging to the formation of new arrangements, new regulation will shape the structure of occupational savings in the years to come, and affect the social and economic structure of the country.
Unless the law is carefully considered, its impact may be very different to that intended. Even the prospect of compliance with legislation may result in funds closing.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
14
The recommended regulatory approach
Code of practice Legislation with
Mandatory registrationConditions to apply to registrants
Timetable October, November 2007
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
15
The recommended regulatory approach
Develop a Code of Practice as to how Occupational Savings Schemes should behave
To be introduced prior to legislation and continue afterwardsShows major target features, including• Audit• Schemes should be separate from employer’s books,
under trust• Reporting to members• Schemes should be fully funded• Data collectionHas no legislative impact but shows future intention
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
16
The recommended regulatory approach
REGISTRATION
TRUST
AUDIT
SECP CAN INTRODUCE REGULATIONS FOR REGISTRANTS
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
17
The recommended regulatory approach
1. Registration with SECP of all pension arrangements, provident funds and gratuity funds, suitably defined, with an exemption category - overseas schemes with local employees.
2. All registered arrangements to be established under Trust by a target date, with the exceptions - those established by legislation, mostly public sector.
3. All registered arrangements to be audited by a target date, again with possible exceptions.
4. SECP to introduce requirements that apply to registrants.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
18
The recommended regulatory approach
Existing pension, provident fund, gratuity legislation under Income tax Ordinance and Income tax Rules, part under control of SECP.
• Recommended: Responsibilities of Central Board of Revenue to be transferred to SECP, including process of giving approval for tax relief, whether by consolidating tax legislation or giving SECP powers.
Existing practice mainly under IAS 19, IAS 26.• Recommended: to be codified and apply to all
schemes, not just for those schemes of companies that are listed.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
19
The recommended regulatory approachLegislation: Further measures to be introduced, including• Fully funded pension, gratuity funds, again with
exceptions• Annual filing, data collection• Trustee responsibilities and liabilities• Structure for approving corporate trustees• SECP may appoint trustees in certain situations• SECP has power to investigate, prosecute, fine• Winding up provisions and process • Appointment of liquidator• Court may intervene, powers of the court, legal
processes• Appeal board on winding up
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
20
The recommended regulatory approachLegislation: Further measures to be introduced, including• Independence of solicitors and auditors.• Ability of members to make complaints.• SECP process for investigating complaints and its
various other roles.
• Restriction on investing in associated companies.• Standards on payment of benefits, and where benefits
cannot be paid or are unclaimed.• Standards on making contributions.
Code of Practice to be continuously reviewed and updated; elements to become regulations over time.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
21
The recommended regulatory approachVoluntary Pension System
Separate category of occupational savings, intention is to add this category into the broader legislation over time.
Detail to be as near identical in rules and their application,
• Standards on trustees• Standards on recordkeeping• Standards on payment of benefits• Member’s investment choice principles to apply• Broadly same investment rules
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
22
The recommended regulatory approach
On who will be liable under the legislation.Regulation will require…
1. Employers – funding requirement on defined benefit2. Trusts and trustees – payment of benefits, investment
policy3. Custodians – holding assets4. Investment Managers – breaches, contractual
agreements to manage funds
…to comply, so it will need to be legislation, with the ability of the SECP to write binding conditions on registrants.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
23
The recommended regulatory approachThe roles of the SECP will include• Registration• Annual returns, filing• Monitoring• Industry data collection and publication• Developing regulatory role• Ensuring compliance with legislation, regulations• Handling member, employer complaints and enquiries,
with legal power to access information• Investigations• Winding up schemes • Enforcement, prosecutions, fines
A Framework for Occupational
Savings Schemes Regulation
Surveys and Statistics
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
25
Surveys and StatisticsThe need for statistics…
• For the SECP to understand what it is to regulate• For monitoring, establishing trends• To know if the regulations are encouraging or
discouraging savings structures• For an assessment of penetration of savings markets,
their success• For knowing how assets are invested, helping in growth
of securities markets• For the industry to develop new products• For employers to be aware of employee benefit trends• For broad policy purposes on social security, pensions
…leading to their publication and ease of access.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
26
The July 2007 SurveyPart of building up knowledge base, a Survey of the over 600
listed companies in Pakistan.Requests to be sent out before the end of June.Replies to be received within 30 days.Outline Report and Contents already drafted.Report given to respondents, made available on SECP
website, target date October 2007.Looking at pension, provident and gratuity arrangements.Recommend that it should be repeated every two years.This would help in the development of capital markets by
establishing investment patterns of occupational savings schemes.
A forerunner of information to be required under legislation.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
27
The first internal Survey on Occupational Savings Schemes
KSE top 10098 companies, of which• 35 have funded Pension funds: Rps.123 billion, • 24 in surplus, 11 in deficit. • Largest deficit is 36% of assets.• 52 have funded gratuity funds: Rps. 11 billion• 35 in surplus, 15 in deficit.27 have unfunded gratuities: Rps. 6 billion77 have Provident Funds
A Framework for Occupational
Savings Schemes Regulation
Points of concern – and suggested solutions
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
29
Points of interest and concern
Trust structures are recommended, but…
• Is 1882 Trusts Act strong enough for a much more progressive occupational savings environment?
• Should insurance policies be allowed?• Should an occupational savings scheme be established
under an insurance policy?
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
30
Points of interest and concernOn transferring the effective regulatory responsibilities of the
Central Board of Revenue under the Income tax Act and the Income Tax rules to SECP, where their main purpose is to see if tax relief should be granted.
• Legislation would be required.• Would the CBR find this acceptable?• How might it be acceptable?• What is involved in a transfer, considering CBR have a
number of regional offices?• Would it be staggered?• Would CBR staff move to SECP?• What capacity is needed at SECP to handle this?• Would relevant Income Tax Act and Income Tax Rules
would become part of SECP pension legislation.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
31
Points of interest and concern
How do you address the problem of companies seeing regulation, however it is packaged, as a reason to close down occupational savings schemes?
A challenge, how do you encourage companies to establish defined contribution pension funds and establishing provident funds?
Voluntary Pension System covers pension funds, but you may need a new Master Trust provident fund structure for establishing provident funds for smaller companies.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
32
Points of interest and concern
Gratuities : Two types 1. Where gratuity fund is established to save for legal
obligation.West Pakistan Industrial and Commercial Employment (Standing Orders)
Ordinance, 1968 where employers fifty or more employees are obliged under to pay a gratuity to a leaving employee, at the rate of thirty days wages for every completed year of service, or part of a year in excess of six months.
2. Where provident fund (and now VPS too) replaces this legal obligation and a separate gratuity fund is then established that has different qualifying periods and benefits.
And possibly some hybrid versions with both types of members and memberships.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
33
Points of interest and concernGratuities
Recognising gratuity obligation under the West Pakistan Industrial and Commercial Employment (Standing Orders) Ordinance, 1968 –
• Do they need to be registered?
• Do they need to be funded? How would small employers cope with funding rules?
• Are the members adequately protected under the existing laws?
• Should the law be revised to include a wider range of employers?
Recommend that are not funded but that SECP/Ministry of labour determines who should regulate them.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
34
Points of interest and concern
Gratuities
For those established as an employee benefit and not subject to West Pakistan Industrial and Commercial Employment (Standing Orders) Ordinance, 1968,
Benefit is defined, should follow same path as pension funds and provident funds, and be
• Registered• Under trust• Audited
with the rest of the legislation to follow.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
35
Points of interest and concern
Gratuities – A recommendationFor small companies finding they have to establish a trust
for either of their gratuity arrangements, this will be expensive and difficult.
• Recommend one or more Gratuity Master Trusts be established, possibly under the VPS umbrella
• Easy to adhere to for creating a trust • Satisfy existing Income Tax legislation requirements• Assets pooled• Appropriate investment policy• Corporate TrusteeAs a savings vehicle for a company to cover some of it
liabilities
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
36
A Recommendation…
ALLOWING THE DEVELOPMENT OF PROVIDENT FUND MASTER TRUSTS
For employers and employees to join
ALLOWING THE DEVELOPMENT OF GRATUITY MASTER TRUSTS
for employers to join, for both voluntary and legal obligation arrangements, to allow for partial funding
These could be under same umbrella structure as VPS, using same investment pools, or merely add different classes of investor with different rules under an existing VPS structure.
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
37
A Recommendation…
GRATUITY MASTER TRUST
PROVIDENT FUND
MASTER TRUST
•To allow for new types of master trusts for existing and newly established occupational savings schemes to join.•Easier for the SECP to regulate and monitor.•Corporate trustees instead of individual trustees.•Small companies would find it very straightforward.•Takes away the burden of compliance.•Requires regional distribution capability.
VPS MASTER TRUST
Under a single umbrella, a single master trust…
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
38
Points of interest and concern
Public Sector – Government employeesSaving systems established under and derived from
OrdinancesGenerally unfunded, payable out of general revenueProvident Fund assets within Government
Some legislative requirements should apply… Ability of members to make complaints, SECP investigating complaints, Annual filing, data collection, standards on payment of benefits…
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
39
Points of interest and concern
Military pensions
Generally unfunded, payable out of general revenue
Some legislative requirements should apply… Ability of members to make complaints, SECP investigating complaints, Annual filing, data collection, standards on payment of benefits…
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
40
Points of interest and concern
Government and provincially owned organisations, universities established under charter or equivalent
Generally unfunded, payable out of specific revenue
Most legislative requirements should apply… Requirement to be funded, provident fund assets separate
from employer
Ability of members to make complaints, SECP investigating complaints, Annual filing, data collection, standards on payment of benefits, appeals process…
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
41
Points of interest and concern
On the payment of due benefits• Benefits are properly calculated and recorded.• They are not withheld without good cause.• They are paid on time at a place where the beneficiary
can access them.• That the beneficiary can readily appeal to an authoritative
body if they are not paid as expected.
• SECP should liaise with Ombudsman Offices on pension problems
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
42
Points of interest and concern
On encouraging interested groups from within the community• Employer groups, such as an Occupational Savings sub
committees of a Chamber of Commerce• WEBCOP, Workers Employers Bilateral Council of Pakistan• Employee groups• Actuaries• Accountants• Auditors • Investment Managers• Solicitors
A Framework for Occupational Savings Regulation
43
The Social Goal
That more people are promised a benefit through working and occupational savings.
That someone who is promised a benefit receives that benefit when it is due.
That benefits should be fair and affordable.