60 kld molasses based ethanol plant with 3.0 mw...
TRANSCRIPT
FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT
AND
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
60 KLD Molasses Based Ethanol Plant with 3.0 MW Captive Power
Plant
at
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil: Shahabad,
Distt. Kurukshetra, Haryana.
Study Period: Pre Monsoon (1st October 2014 to 31st January 2015)
Applicant
M/s Shahabad Cooperative Sugar Mills Ltd.
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Distt. Kurukshetra, Haryana.
Environmental Consultant Vardan Environet
(NABET/EIA/1316/IA001)
D-142, Susant Lok –III, Sector 57
Gurgaon (Haryana)
Contact No. +91-9810355569
e-mail: [email protected]
e-mail: [email protected]
September,2015
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter Title Page No.
Table of Content
List of Tables
List of Figures
1.0 Introduction 1-18
1.0 Introduction to EIA 1
1.1 Purpose of the Report 3
1.2 Regulatory Frame Work 3
1.3 Identification of Project and Project Proponent 4
1.4 Importance of Project to the Country and Region 7
1.5 Site Selection Criteria 8
1.6 Structure of the Report 9 1.7 Scope of the Study 10
2.0 Project Description 19-46
2.0 Introduction 19
2.1 Type of the Project and Site Description 19
2.2 Project Location and Layout 20
2.3 Need for the Project 23
2.4 Size or Magnitude of Operation 23
2.5 Proposed Scheduled for Approval and Implementation 26
2.6 Manufacturing Process 27
2.7 Facilities at the Plant 34
2.8 Evaporation plant 34
2.9 Steam Generation Plant 37
2.10 Description of Mitigation Measures 42 2.11 Assessment of New and untested Technology for the Risk of
Technical Failure
46
2.12 Summary 46
3.0 Description of the Environment 47-98
3.0 Introduction 47
3.1 Study Area 47
3.2 Study Period 47
3.3 Components and Methodology 47
3.4 Land Use Pattern of the Study Area 48
3.5 Geology 53
3.6 Hydrology, Ground Water and Water Conservation 53
3.7 Air Environment and Meteorology 54
3.8 Ambient Air Quality 58
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | ii
3.9 Noise Environment 63
3.10 Land Environment 70
3.11 Water Environment 74
3.12 Biological Environment 80
3.13 Socio-Economic Environment 92
3.14 Solid Waste and Hazardous Waste 96
3.15 Risk Assessment 96
3.16 Summary 96
4.0 Anticipated Environmental Impact and Mitigation Measures 99-129
4.0 Introduction 99
4.1 Construction Phase 100
4.1.1 Impact on Land Use 100
4.1.2 Impact on Soil and Mitigation Measures 101
4.1.3 Impact on Air Environment 102
4.1.4 Impact on Water Environment 102
4.15 Impact on Noise Environment 103
4.1.6 Impact on Biological Environment 103
4.1.7 Impact on Socio economic Environment 106
4.1.8 Impact of Solid and Hazardous Waste 106
4.1.9 Risk Assessment during Construction 106
4.2 Operational Phase 106
4.2.1 Ambient Air Quality Modeling 107
4.2.2 Impact on Air Environment 116
4.2.3 Impact on Water Environment 117 4.2.4 Rain Water Harvesting /Recharge Plan 118
4.2.5 Noise Modelling 120
4.2.6 Impact on Soil Environment 125
4.2.7 Impact on Biological Environment 125
4.2.8 Impact on Socio-Economic Environment 125
4.2.9 Impact on Land Environment 126
4.2.10 Impact on Hydrogeology 126
4.2.11 Risk Assessment 126
4.2.11 Solid Waste and Hazardous Waste Management 126
4.2.13 Cultural Environment 126
4.2.14 Indirect Impacts 126 4.3 Summary 126
5.0 Analysis of Alternative Site 130
5.1 Introduction 130
6.0 Environmental Monitoring Programme 131-135
6.0 Introduction 131
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | iii
6.1 Post Project Monitoring Locations and Components 131
6.2 Monitoring Methodologies 133
6.3 Reporting and Documentation 133
6.4 Environmental Management Cell 134
6.5 Summary 135
7.0 Additional Studies 136-162
7.1 Public Consultation 136
7.2 Risk Assessment 145
7.3 Disaster Management Plan 146
7.4 Emergency Planning 149
7.5 On–Site Emergency Plan 152
7.6 Preparation of Plan 152
7.7 Kurukshetra Disaster Management Plan 156
7.8 Summary 156
8.0 Additional Studies 163-164
8.1 Introduction 163
8.2 Employment Potential 163
8.3 Corporate Social Responsibility 163 8.4 Summary 164
9.0 Environmental Cost Benefit Analysis 165-168
9.1 Project Cost and Project Appraisal 165
9.2 Financial Pattern 165
9.3 Schedule of Project Implementation 165
9.4 Physical Targets 166
9.5 Summary 168
10.0 Environmental Management Plan 169-176
10.0 Introduction 169
10.1 Pollution Control System 169
10.2 Overall Recommendation and Implementation Schedule 173
10.3 Budget and Procurement Schedule 173
10.4 Waste Minimization, recycle/reuse/recover techniques 175
10.6 Summary 175
11.0 Summary and Conclusion 177-182
11.1 Introduction 177
11.2 Project Description 177
11.3 Description of the Environment 177
11.4 Anticipated Environmental Impact and Mitigation Measures 178
11.5 Analysis of Alternative Site 180
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | iv
11.6 Environmental Monitoring Programme 180
11.7 Additional Studies 181
11.8 Project Benefits 181
11.9 Environmental Cost Benefit Analysis 181
11.10 Environment Management Plan 182
12.0 Disclosure of Consultant Engaged 183-184
12.1 Disclosure of Consultants Engaged 183
Annexure I Terms of Reference Letter
Annexure II Site Photographs
Annexure III AAQ Data
Annexure IV Demographic Data
Annexure V DMP of Kurukshetra
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | v
LIST OF TABLE
Table No. Title Page No.
1.1 Demand and Supply of Ethanol 8
1.2 ToR Compliance 10
2.1 Location Details 19
2.2 Infrastructure Details 20
2.3 Raw Materials 24
2.4 Action Plan for Transportation of Raw Material 24
2.5 Area Breakup 25
2.6 Power Consumption Details 25
2.7 Water Requirement 26
2.8 Manpower Requirement 26
2.9 List of Equipment for Standalone Evaporation plant 35
2.10 Design Basis of Steam Generator 40
2.11 Technical Data Sheet 42
2.12 Environmental Aspect, Impact and Proposed Mitigation Measures 42
3.1 Land Use Pattern of the Study Area 50
3.2 Onsite Meteorological Data -1st October, 2014 – 31st January, 2015 56
3.3 (A) Procedures for Determining Various Air Quality Parameters 59
3.3 (B) Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Sampling Stations 59
3.4 Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Results 62
3.5 Noise Monitoring Sampling Stations 64
3.6 Noise Monitoring Result 64
3.7 Traffic Study Locations 68
3.8 No. of Vehicles per Day 69
3.9 Existing Traffic Scenario and LOS 69
3.10 Modified Traffic Scenario and LOS 70
3.11 Soil Monitoring Station Details 70
3.12 Soil Analysis Result 73
3.13 Surface Water Sampling Stations 74
3.14 Surface Water Sampling Results 74
3.15 Ground Water Sampling Stations 76
3.16 Ground Water Analysis Result 76
3.17 Trees in the Study area 84
3.18 Lists of Shrubs in the Study Area 86
3.19 List of Herbaceous species observed in the study area 87
3.20 List of Climbers Observed in the Study Area 88
3.21 Schedule –I Bird(s) of Study Area 89
3.22 Systematic Lists of Birds in the Study Area with Distribution (Dist.)
Status
89
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | vi
Table No. Title Page No.
3.23 Butterflies in the Study Area 91
3.24 Reptiles and Amphibian in the Study Area 91
3.25 Mammals in Study area 91
3.26 Fishes in Study area 92
3.27 Domestic Animals in Study area 92
3.28 Distribution of Population 93
3.29 Distribution of Literate and Literacy Rates 94
3.30 Distribution of Population by Social Structure 94
3.31 Occupational Structure 95
4.1 Impact Identification Matrix (Construction Phase) 100
4.2 Ecological Impact due to proposed distillery unit 104
4.3 Identification of Impacts during Operation Phase 106
4.4 Dispersion parameters as per stability class (Urban Area) 110
4.5 Calculation of DG Set Stack Height 111
4.6 Source Parameter 111
4.7 Predicted GLC of PM10 at Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Stations 112
4.8 Characteristics of Spent Wash 117
4.9 Rain Water Harvesting/Recharge Details 119
4.10 Noise Generating Sources in Plant 121
4.11 Noise Baseline and Incremental Data 122
6.1 Parameters and Frequency for Post Project Environmental Monitoring 132
7.1 Action Plan of the issues raised during Public Hearing and reply given by Project Proponent
142
7.2 Budget detail for conservation plan 162
8.1 Breakup of CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility) 164
10.1 Action Plan to Control Fugitive Emissions 171
10.2 EMP Cost Details 174
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | vii
ABBREVIATIONS
AAQM Ambient Air Quality Monitoring
APCD Air Pollution Control Devices
cm Centimeter
CPCB Central Pollution Control Board
dB Decibel
DG Diesel Generator
E East
ECC Emergency Control Centre
EIA Environmental Impact Assessment
EMC Environmental Management Cell
EMP Environmental Management Plan
ENE East Of North- East
EPA Environmental Protection Agencies
ESE East Of South East
ETP Effluent treatment plant
FCC False Colour Composite
GC Gas Chromatography
GIS Geological Information System
GLC Ground level concentration
GPS Global Positioning System
HPLC High pressure Liquid Chromatography
IPA Iso propyl alcohol
IMD Indian Meteorological Department
IRS Indian Remote Sensing Satellite
ISCST Industrial Source Complex, Short Terms
ISO International Organization Of Standardization
ISS Indian Standard Specification
KLD Kilo Litre Per Day
Km Kilometer
KVA Kilo Volt Ampere
KW Kilo Watt
LISS Linear Imaging Self Scanning Sensor
M Meter
M bgl Meter Below Ground Level
mg Milligram
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | viii
ABBREVIATIONS
MoEF &
CC
Ministry Of Environment , Forest & Climate Change
mRL Mean Reference Level
MSMEs Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises
MT Million Tonne
MTPA Million Tonns Per Annum
N North
NE North-East
NH National Highway
NNE North Of North-East
NNW North Of North-West
NO2 Nitrogen Dioxides
NTU Naphelo Turbidity Unit
NW North-West
OHSAS Occupational Health & Safety Assessment
PPCB Punjab Pollution Control Board
PPE Personal Protective Equipment
PPM Part Per Million
Pvt. Private
R&R Rehabilitation & Resettlement
RDS Respirable Dust Sampler
RPM Respirable Particulate Matter
RSPM Respirable Suspended Particulate Matter
SE South- East
SEIAA State Level Environmental Assessment Authority
SO2 Sulphur-di-Oxide
SOI Survey Of India
SOPs Standard Operating Procedures
SPCB State Pollution Control Board
SPM Suspended Particulate Matter
SSE South Of South-East
SSW South Of South-West
STP Sewage Treatment plant
TAC Traffic Advisory Committee
TPA Tone Per Hour
TDS Total Dissolve Solid
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Page | ix
ABBREVIATIONS
TOR Terms Of Reference
TPH Tones Per Hour
TS Total Solid
US EPA United State Environmental Protection Agencies
ug/m3 Micro gram per meter cube
VOC Volatile organic matter
w.e.f. With Effective From
w.r.t. With Reference To
W/W Weight By Weight
WNW West Of North-West
WSW West Of South-West
i
ToR Reply
ToR Description Reply Citation
1 Executive summary of the
project
Executive Summary of the project is given
in Chapter 11. --
2 Detailed breakup of the land area
along with latest photograph of
the area.
Total land required for the proposed project
is 84326.4 m2.
Out of which 33% will be
used for green belt development. Detailed
breakup of the land area of the area is given
in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.4.4, page
no. 24-25
3 Present land use based on
satellite imagery
Present land use based on satellite imagery
has been prepared and is enclosed in
Chapter 3 of EIA report.
Item no.
3.4, page
no.48-51
4 Details of site and information
related to environmental setting
within 10 km radius of the
project site.
Details of site and information related to
environmental setting within 10 Km radius
of the project site have been given in
Chapter 1 of EIA report. Site photographs
are given in Annexure II.
Item no.
2.1 , page
no. 19-20
and
Annexure
II
5 Information regarding eco-
sensitive area such as national
park / wildlife sanctuary /
biosphere reserves within 10 km
radius of project area.
There is no eco-sensitive area such as
national park / wildlife sanctuary / biosphere
reserves within 10 Km radius of project
area.
Item no.
2.1 , page
no. 19-20
6 Permission from the State Forest
Department regarding the impact
of the proposed plant on the
surrounding reserve forest.
As there is no national park/wildlife
sanctuary/biosphere reserves within 10 Km
radius area and hence permission from State
Forest Department is not applicable.
---
7 List of existing distillery units in
the study area alongwith their
capacity
There is no distillery unit within the study
area.
---
8 Number of working days of the
distillery unit.
Working days - 330 days/year. --
9 Total cost of the project along
with total capital cost and
recurring cost/annum for
environmental pollution control
measures.
Total Project Cost – 6170.00 Lakhs
EMP Cost -815.00 Lakhs
Recurring Cost/Annum- 73.00 Lakhs
Item no.
10.3, page
no. 174-
175
10 Manufacturing process details of
distillery plant alongwith process
flow chart.
Manufacturing process details of distillery
plant alongwith process flow chart is given
in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.6, page
no. 27-34
ii
ToR Description Reply Citation
11 Details of raw materials and
source of raw material molasses,
bagasse etc.
S.
No
Unit Total Item no.
2.4.2, page
no. 23-24
1. Molasses Molasses from
Shahabad
sugar
mill
35,000
tonnes/y
ear
Molasses from
neighboring
mills
36,280
tonnes/y
ear
Transpo
rtation
by
tankers
2. Bagasse Requirement 24700
T/Annu
m
3. Water Requirement 950
KLD
4. Power Requirement 1780
KW
5. Steam requirement 19.0
Tons/Ho
ur
12 Sources and quantity of fuel
(coal etc.) for the boiler.
Measures to take care of SO2
emission. A copy of
Memorandum of Understanding
(MoU) signed with the coal
suppliers should be submitted, in
case coal is used.
Bagasse will be used as fuel. Details of same
is given in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.4.5.1,
page no.
25-26
13 Action plan prepared by the
SPCB to control ambient air
quality as per NAAQES
Standards for PM10, PM2.5, SO2
and NOX as per GSR 826(E)
dated 16th
November, 2009.
Action plan will be prepared under the
supervision of Haryana State Pollution
Control Board during NOC stage.
--
iii
ToR Description Reply Citation
14 One season site-specific micro-
meteorological data using
temperature, relative humidity,
hourly wind speed and direction
and rainfall and AAQ data
(except monsoon) for PM10,
PM2.5, SO2, NOX and HC
(methane and non methane)
should be collected. The
monitoring stations should take
into account the pre-dominant
wind direction, population zone
and sensitive receptors including
reserved forests. Data for water
and noise monitoring should also
be included.
One season site specific Ambient Air
Quality data for PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOX and
HC (methane and non methane) has been
collected and incorporated in Chapter 3 of
EIA report.
Data for water and noise monitoring has
been collected and incorporated in Chapter 3
of EIA report.
Item no.
3.8, page
no. 58-63
Item no.
3.9, page
no. 63-67
for Noise,
Item no.
3.11, page
no. 74-80
for Water
15
Mathematical modeling for
calculating the dispersion of air
pollutants and ground level
concentration along with
emissions from the boiler.
Mathematical modeling for calculation of
dispersion of air pollutants and ground level
concentration along with emission from the
boiler has been done and is incorporated in
Chapter 4 of EIA report.
Item no.
4.2.1, page
no. 107-
115
16 An action plan to control and
monitor secondary fugitive
emissions from all the sources.
An action plan to control and monitor
secondary fugitive emissions from all the
sources is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.1.2,
page no.
170-171
17 Details of boiler and its
capacity. Details of the use of
steam from the boiler.
Boiler (20 TPH) will be based on Bagasse as
available fuel options. This Boiler will
operate mainly to feed steam to Molasses
based operations and 3.0 MW power
generations from Turbine. Also, the detail of
same is given in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.10, page
no. 42-45
18 Ground water quality around
existing /proposed spent wash
storage lagoon and the project
area.
Ground water quality analysis has been done
and details are given in Chapter 3 of EIA
report.
Item no.
3.11, page
no. 74-80
19 Details of water requirement,
water balance chart for Molasses
based Distillery. Measures for
conservation water by recycling
and reuse to minimize the fresh
water requirement.
Details of water requirement, water balance
chart is incorporated in Chapter 2 of EIA
report.
Item no.
2.4.6, page
no.26
20 Water requirement should not
exceed 10 KL/KL of alcohol for
distillery and prior ‘permission’
Same has been noted and complied. Item no.
2.4.6, page
no.26
iv
ToR Description Reply Citation
for the drawl of total fresh water.
Details of source of water supply.
21 Hydro-geological study of the
area for availability of ground
water.
Hydro-geological study of the area is given
in Chapter 3 of EIA report.
Item no.
3.6, page
no. 53-54
22 Spent wash generation from
molasses based should not
exceed 8Kl/Kl of alcohol
production.
Same has been noted and complied Item no.
2.10, page
no. 42-45
23 Proposed effluent treatment
system for molasses based
distillery (spent wash and spent
lees) and scheme for achieving
‘zero’ discharge.
The proposed Molasses based distillery
would be based on “Zero Effluent
Discharge”
Detailed ETP scheme has been incorporated
in EIA report.
Item no.
2.10, page
no. 42-45
24 Lagoon capacity for sugar unit
and spent wash as well measures
to be taken to control ground
water contamination.
A duly lined lagoon of 30 days capacity
shall be provided.
Item no.
2.10, page
no. 42-45
25 Details of solid waste
management including
management of boiler ash.
Submit Ash management plan.
MoU with cement plant for the
use of fly ash.
Details of solid waste management is given
in Chapter 4 of EIA report.
Item no.
4.2.12,
page no.
126
26 Land available for bio-
composting. Details of lining to
be provided in the compost yard.
No land is reserved for bio composting as
waste will be incinerated in boiler.
-
27 Green belt development as per
the CPCB guidelines.
Green belt development as per the CPCB
guidelines will be done. Detail of same is
given in Chapter 10 of EIA report.
Item no.
10.1.7,
page no.
172-173
28 List of flora and fauna in the
study area.
Detailed list of flora and fauna is
incorporated in Chapter 3 of EIA report.
Item no.
3.12, page
no. 80-92
29 Noise levels monitoring at five
locations within the study area.
Noise level monitoring at five locations has
been done and is incorporated in Chapter 3
of EIA report.
Item no.
3.9, page
no. 63-67
30 Detailed Environment
management Plan (EMP) with
specific reference to details of air
pollution control system, water
and wastewater management,
monitoring frequency,
responsibility and time bound
Detailed Environment management Plan
(EMP) with specific reference to details of
air pollution control system, water and
wastewater management, monitoring
frequency, responsibility and time bound
implementation plan for mitigation measure
is given in Chapter 10 of EIA report.
Page no.
169-176
v
ToR Description Reply Citation
implementation plan for
mitigation measure should be
provided.
31 EMP should also include the
concept of waste-minimization,
recycle/reuse/ recover
techniques, Energy conservation,
and natural resource
conservation.
Details of waste-minimization,
recycle/reuse/recover techniques, energy
conservation and natural resource
conservation is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.4,Page
no. 175
32 Details of bagasse storage.
Details of press mud
requirement.
Baggase will be stored in our existing
Shahabad Sugar Co-Operative mill. Press
Mud will be procured from our own
Shahabad sugar mill. Detail of same has
been given in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.10, page
no.42-45
33 Risk assessment for storage and
handling of alcohol and
mitigation measure due to fire
and explosion and handling
areas.
Risk assessment for storage and handling of
alcohol and mitigation measure due to fire
and explosion and handling areas is given in
Chapter 7 of EIA report.
Item no.
7.2, page
no.145-
146
34 Alcohol storage and handling
area and its fire fighting facility
as per norms.
Alcohol storage and handling area and fire
fighting facility is incorporated in EIA
report.
Item no.
7.3.5, page
no. 147-
148
35 Action plan for rainwater
harvesting measures at plant site
should be included to harvest
rainwater from the roof tops and
storm water drains to recharge
the ground water.
Action plan for rainwater harvesting
measures at plant site to harvest rainwater
from the roof tops and storm water drains to
recharge the ground water is incorporated in
Chapter 4 of EIA report.
Item no.
4.2.4, page no. 118-
120
36 Details of occupational health
programme
Details of occupational health programme is
incorporated in Chapter 10 of EIA report.
Item no.
10.1.8,
page no.
173
37 To which chemicals, workers are
exposed directly or indirectly.
Details of same is given in Chapter 7 of EIA
report.
Item no.
7.5, page
no. 152
38 Whether these chemicals are
within Threshold Limit Values
(TLV)/ Permissible Exposure
Levels as per ACGIH
recommendation.
Yes --
39 What measures company has
taken to keep these chemicals
within PEL/TLV.
Not required, as all the chemicals are within
TLV
--
40 How the workers are evaluated Detail of same is given in Chapter 10 of EIA Item no.
vi
ToR Description Reply Citation
concerning their exposure to
chemicals during preplacement
and periodical medical
monitoring.
report. 10.1.8,
page no.
173
41 What are onsite and offsite
emergency plan during chemical
disaster.
Onsite and offsite emergency plan is
incorporated in Chapter 7 of EIA report.
Item no.
7.2, page
no. 145-
156
42 Liver function tests (LFT) during
pre-placement and periodical
examination.
Same will be done accordingly --
43 Details of occupational health
surveillance programme.
Occupational health surveillance programme
is incorporated in Chapter 10 of EIA report.
Item no.
10.1.8,
page no.
173
44 Details of socio-economic
welfare activities to be provided.
Details of socio-economic welfare activities
is given in Chapter 8 of EIA report.
Item no.
8.3 , page
no.163-
164
45 Traffic study of the area for the
proposed projects in respect of
existing traffic, type of vehicles,
frequency of vehicles for
transportation of materials,
additional traffic due to proposed
project, parking arrangement etc.
Detailed traffic study of the area for the
proposed project in respect of existing
traffic, type of vehicles, frequency of
vehicles for transportation of materials,
additional traffic due to proposed project has
been done and is incorporated in Chapter 3
of EIA report.
Item no.
3.9.2, page
no. 67-70
46 Action plan for post-project
environmental monitoring.
Post-project environmental monitoring will
be done after commissioning of project.
Also, proposed action plan for the same is
incorporated in Chapter 6 of EIA report.
Item no.
6.1, page
no. 131-
133
47 Corporate Environmental
Responsibility
Item no.
8.3, page
no. 163-
164
48
(a)
Does the company have a well
laid down Environment Policy
approved by its Board of
Directors? If so, it may be
detailed in the EIA report.
Yes Item no.
10.0, Page
no. 169
vii
ToR Description Reply Citation
49
(b)
Does the Environmental Policy
prescribe for standard operating
process/procedures to bring into
focus any infringement /
deviation / violation of the
environmental or forest norms /
conditions? If so, it may be
detailed in the EIA report.
Detail of same is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.0, Page
no. 169
50
(c)
What is the hierarchical system
or Administrative order of the
company to deal with the
environmental issues and for
ensuring compliance with the EC
conditions. Details of this system
may be given.
Detail of same is given in Chapter 6 of EIA
report.
Item no.
6.4, page
no. 134-
135
51
(d)
Does the company have a system
of reporting of non compliance /
violations of environmental
norms to the Board of Directors
of the company and / or
shareholders or stakeholders at
large? This reporting mechanism
should be detailed in the EIA
report.
Detail of same is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.0, Page
no. 169
52 Any litigation pending against
the project and /or any direction
/order passed by any Court of
Law against the project, if so,
details thereof
No litigation is pending against the Project
and /or any direction /order passed by any
Court of Law against the project.
--
53 Public hearing issues raised and
commitments made by the
project proponent on the same
should be included separately in
EIA/EMP Report in the form of
tabular chart with financial
budget for complying with the
commitments made.
Public consultation for the proposed project
was conducted by Haryana State Pollution
Control Board, Panchkula on dated 19th
May
2015 at 11 A.M at Village Jandheri, Tehsil
Shahabad, District Kurukshetra (Haryana).
Details of query asked by people along with
action plan is given Chapter 7 of EIA report.
Item
no.7.1,
Page no.
136-145
54 A tabular chart with index for
point-wise compliance of above
ToRs.
The details have been complied. --
A Additional TOR
1 Public hearing to be conducted
and issues raised and
Public consultation for the proposed project
was conducted by Haryana State Pollution
Item
no.7.1,
viii
ToR Description Reply Citation
commitments made by the
project proponent on the same
should be included in EIA/EMP
report in the form of tabular chart
with financial budget for
complying with commitments
made
Control Board, Panchkula on dated 19th
May
2015 at 11 A.M at Village Jandheri, Tehsil
Shahabad, District Kurukshetra (Haryana).
Details of query asked by people along with
action plan is given Chapter 7 of EIA report.
Page no.
136-145
2 Permission to be obtained for
withdrawal of water from
concerned authority
Application has been submitted for the
same.
--
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 1
Chapter -1
Introduction
1.0 Introduction to EIA
The term Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) refers to the anticipation of various
impacts a project will have on the environment and the local community. It is a decision
making tool, which guides decision makers in taking appropriate decisions prior to
sanctioning clearance.
According to the UNEP-DTIE, Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is a tool used to
identify the environmental, social and economic impacts of a project prior to decision-
making. It aims to predict environmental impacts at an early stage in project planning and
design, find ways and means to reduce adverse impacts, shape projects to suit the local
environment and present the predictions and options to decision-makers. By using EIA
both environmental and economic benefits can be achieved, such as reduced cost and
time of project implementation and design, avoided treatment/clean-up costs and impacts
of laws and regulations.
Under the Environment Protection Act 1986, a notification on EIA was passed in India,
which made it obligatory for certain development projects to prepare and submit an EIA
prior to environmental clearance. This notification says, no developmental activities shall
be allowed in unprecedented manner. This is a powerful notification, which has not only
restricted the siting of projects in restricted areas but also; restricts the commencement of
construction and production till the project gets cleared from the environmental angle.
EIA systematically examines both beneficial and adverse consequences of the proposed
project and ensures that these impacts are taken into account during the project design. It
helps to identify possible environmental impacts of the proposed project, proposes
measures to mitigate adverse effects and predicts whether there will be significant
adverse environmental effects, even after the mitigation is in place. By considering
environmental effects and mitigation early in the project planning cycle, there are many
benefits, such as protection of the environment, optimum utilisation of resources and
saving overall time and cost of the project. Properly conducted EIA also lessens conflicts
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 2
by promoting community participation, informs decision makers, and helps lay the base
for environmentally sound projects. Benefits of integrating EIA have been observed in all
stages of a project, from exploration and planning, through several phases like
construction, operations, decommissioning, and site closure.
EIA is different from other decision-making tools like environment audit, which is
conducted on existing projects, while the EIA is applied to new projects and the
expansion of existing projects. EIA uses the techniques of science, economics, sociology,
geology etc while assessing the project because it is dealing with events, which have not
yet occurred, may not occur, but whose chances of occurrence may be strong in future.
There are various other tools like energy analysis, cost-benefit analysis, environment
management systems and risk analysis. EIA is by far the most suitable tool for any
proposed project. It is also one of the most popular decision-making tools and has been
integrated in the regulatory system of many countries.
Depending on the types of project and severity of impact, generally two types of EIA are
conducted.
Rapid EIA: This is carried out for projects that are likely to cause limited adverse
impacts. In rapid EIA, data or information is collected for only one season (other than
monsoon). Therefore, the time frame for undertaking rapid EIA is much shorter (3
months).
Comprehensive EIA: As the name suggests, this is conducted over a year as it involves
collection of data/information for three seasons (other than monsoons). It is usually
conducted for projects that are likely to cause more or a series of adverse impacts.
However, in India, there are no clear guidelines on the type of projects for which
comprehensive EIA should be conducted. As per the new EIA notification, the authority
in charge of issuing environmental clearances (either the Union ministry for environment
and forests (MoEF&CC) or the state level body) decides whether the project proponent
has to conduct a rapid or a comprehensive EIA.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 3
1.1 Purpose of the Report
As per the EIA Notification dated 14th
September 2006, as amended from time to time; it
is mandatory to have the Environmental Clearance for any new industry or the expansion
of the industry from Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change (MoEF&
CC), Government of India, New Delhi for which EIA is required be conducted as per the
guidelines of MoEF&CC, New Delhi. The purpose of the EIA report is to provide a
coherent statement of the potential impacts of proposed project and the measures that
should be taken to establish the impacts and suggest mitigation measures. It contains
essential information for:
i. The proponent to implement the proposal in an environmentally and socially
responsible manner;
ii. The responsible authority to make an informed decision on the proposal, including
the terms and conditions that must be attached to an approval or authorization; and
iii. The public to understand the proposal and its likely impacts on people and the
environment.
1.2 Regulatory Frame Work
The principal environmental regulatory agency in India is the Ministry of Environment,
Forests and Climate change (MoEF&CC), New Delhi. MoEF&CC formulates
environmental policies and accords environmental clearance for the projects.
It is important to note that the Central Government framed ‘umbrella legislation’, called
the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 to broadly encompass and regulate an array of
environmental issues. The overall purpose of EPA is to establish an overall coherent
policy and provide a basis for the coordinated work of various government agencies with
operational responsibility for the environment and natural resources. This legislation also
invests authorities with regulatory powers to address specific issues affecting the
environment. The Act does not allow any person to establish an industry, operation or
process that discharge or emit any environmental pollutant in excess of standards
prescribed under specific rules and notifications.
The Acts, Rules and Notifications applicable to environmental aspects of the construction
and operational phases of proposed project is briefly described in the following sections:
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 4
Summary of Environmental Legislation for Proposed Project
i. Environment Impact Assessment Notification, dated 14th
September 2006, as
amended on 1st December, 2009.
ii. Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 Environment (Protection) Rules, 1986.
iii. Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1987 (as amended) with Rules.
iv. Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 with Rules.
v. Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2006 (as amended).
vi. The Municipal Solid Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000.
vii. The Public Liability Insurance Act, 1992 (as amended).
viii. Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemicals Rules, 2000 (as
amended).
ix. The Explosives Rules, 2008.
x. Hazardous Waste (Management, Handling and Transboundary Movement) Rules,
2008.
xi. Public Liability Insurance Rules,1992.
xii. Excise and Taxation Act 2000.
1.3 Identification of Project and Project Proponent
1.3.1 Project Details
M/s Shahabad Coop. Sugar Mills is planning to set up a 60 KLD capacity molasses based
ethanol unit having 3.0 MW captive power plant at Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana. The project is planned to be established over an area of
84326.4 m2. The plant will operate 330 days in a year and will produce Ethanol/ Absolute
Alcohol.
1.3.2 Identification of Project Proponent
M/s Shahabad Sugar Ltd. has following representatives:
1.Mr.B.S. Kaliraman, Managing Director
2. Mr. Sushil Kumar, Chief Chemist
3.Mr.Upadhayay,ChiefEngg.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 5
The Study Area and Google map is given in Figure 1.1 and Figure 1.2.
Figure 1.1: Study Area Map
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 6
Figure 1.2: Google Map of the Project Location
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 7
1.4 Importance of Project to the Country and Region
Molasses based distillation is being used in India for the production of alcohol since
ancient days. The molasses based distilleries are linked with sugar factory where sugar
producing farmers are benefited. The proposed project where alcohol will be produced
from cane molasses by continuous fermentation and multi pressure distillation technology
will give better productivity and quality of alcohol. Ethyl Alcohol, Alcohol, Spirit,
Denatures Spirit, there are myriad descriptions for this agriculture based product. A
globally traded commodity, ethanol fires combustible engines in Brazil, slakes the thirst
of many in Europe and finds its way in pharmaceutical and chemical industries across the
world. Ethanol is made by two routes either by synthetic one from petroleum substances
or by fermentation from sugar-bearing or starchy substrates using yeast. Alcohol finds its
use in diverse application ranging from potable liquor to life-saving drugs to paints &
perfumery to renewable source of energy.
Ethyl Alcohol is an important feedstock for the manufacture of various chemicals. These
chemicals are primarily the basic carbon based products like Acetic acid, Butanol,
Butadiene, Acetic Anhydride, PVC etc. Ethylene, Ethylene oxide are also produced from
a petrochemical route, however this requires plants of huge scales and thus require
substantially high investments. The drug industry also uses alcohol as a raw material for
production of Insulin, Antibiotics, tonics and several other essential bulk drugs &
formulations. Keeping in view of the above, M/s Shahabad co-operative Sugar Mills has
proposed a 60 KLD ethanol plant along with 3 MW captive power plant at Village -
Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana.
1.4.1 Demand-Supply Gap
Indian Government had set up an Expert Group headed by the Executive Director of the
Centre for High Technology for examining various options of blending ethanol with
petrol at terminals/depots. Considering the logistical and financial advantages, this Group
had recommended blending of ethanol with petrol at supply locations (terminals / depots)
of oil companies. In view of the above, Government vide the Gazette notification of 3rd
September, 2002 No. P-45018/28/2000-C.C had mandated that with effect from 1st
January 2003, 5% ethanol-doped petrol will be supplied in following nine States and four
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 8
contiguous Union Territories of Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Haryana, Karnataka,
Maharashtra, Punjab, Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh, Pondicherry, Daman and Diu, Goa,
Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Chandigarh. This was the beginning of ethanol
implementation in 1st phase. Government of India further announced to implement the
Ethanol programme in 2nd
phase. This was intended to supply ethanol blended Gasoline
across the country effective the year 2006 and in 3rd
phase switching over from the
existing 5% to 10% blending of ethanol in selected states.
With implementation of the 5% Ethanol-Blended Petrol (EBP) programme throughout
the country still a distant dream due to various complications like ethanol shortages, the
variable taxation structure of state governments and regulatory restrictions, the petroleum
ministry has decided to defer the proposed rollout of mandatory 10% blending of
ethanol, which was expected to take place from October, 2008 onwards.
Table 1.1
Demand and Supply of Ethanol
Projected demand and supply of ethanol for 5% blending in Petrol
Year
Petro
l
Dema
nd
(MT)
Ethanol
Demand
(ML)
Molasses
Prodn.
(MT)
Ethanol production
(ML)
Ethanol utilization
(ML)
Mola
sses Cane Total
Potabl
e
Indus
try
Bala
nce
2001-02 7.07 416.14 8.77 1775 0 1775 648 600 527
2006-07 10.07 592.72 11.36 2300 1485 3785 765 711 2309
2011-12 12.85 756.36 11.36 2300 1485 3785 887 844 2054
2016-17 16.4 965.30 11.36 2300 1485 3785 1028 1003 1754
Source: Planning Commission (2003)
1.5 Site Selection Criteria
Site selected for the project has some advantageous features. These are:
i. There is no human settlement in 500 m radius.
ii. Easy availability of raw material due to existing sugar mill and nearby sugar mill
iii. Location in rural area ensures adequate availability of manpower at marginally lower
rates, compared to metro cities of India.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 9
iv. There is no National Park, Biosphere Reserves, Tiger Reserves, Reserved / Protected
Forests within 10 Km radius of study area.
v. There is no water body within core zone.
vi. Nearness to NH-1 and SH -7 makes it easier to transport raw materials & final
product at market.
1.6 Structure of the Report
The entire EIA report is prepared based on the generic structure of EIA document given
at APPENDIX III of the Notification No. S.O. 1533 dated 14th
September, 2006 at MoEF
& CC, New Delhi.
The report has been divided into ten chapters as described below:
Chapter-1 gives information about the proposed project including its location and
justification/importance, brief details around the surrounding area and details about site
selection criteria considered. It also outlines the statutory requirement of obtaining prior
Environment Clearance, steps to be followed for the same and basic purpose, scope and
methodology of EIA study.
Chapter-2 is Project Description and infrastructure facilities incorporating all industrial
and environmental activities of the project proponent for setting up of the proposed
project. It also gives information about manufacturing process and raw materials, sources
of pollution and details of pollution control facilities to be provided i.e. water and waste
water details, air pollution and control system, sludge storage facility, noise control
measures etc.
Chapter-3 is Description of the Environment which includes Base Line Environment
Study giving details about status of air quality, meteorology, water, noise, land, ecology
and socio economic environment of the study area based on information collected
through actual field study or from secondary sources.
Chapter-4 is Identification of Impacts and its mitigation measures, which identifies the
impacts of various environmental parameters whether beneficial or deleterious for the
construction and operation phase of the project. It also quantifies significant impacts of
the proposed project on various environmental components for the construction and
operation phase of the project.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 10
Chapter-5 Analysis of Alternatives (Technology and Site) identifies the description of
each alternative, Summary of adverse impacts of each alternative, Mitigation measures
proposed for each alternative.
Chapter-6 is Environmental Monitoring Plan which provides details of monitoring plan
of various environmental parameters as well as its frequency of monitoring.
Chapter-7 is Additional Studies which includes Public Consultation, Risk Assessment,
Social Impact Assessment, and R and R Action Plans
Chapter-8 is Benefits due to the proposed project including improvement in Physical
infrastructure, improvement in the social infrastructure, Employment potential–skilled,
semi-skilled and others.
Chapter -9 is Environmental Cost Benefit Analysis.
Chapter-10 is Environmental Management Plan (EMP) incorporating measures to be
adopted for mitigation of anticipated adverse impacts, if any safety measures, post-
project monitoring program for environmental parameters, green belt development etc.
Chapter-11 is the Summary and Conclusion of the proposed Project, includes overall
justification of the project.
Chapter-12 is Profile of Consultant Engaged for the monitoring and preparation of EIA
report.
1.7 Scope of the Study
The Expert Appraisal Committee (Industry 2) of MoEF&CC considered the project at its
meeting held on January 20th
-21st, 2015. Based on the consideration of the documents
submitted and the presentation made by the project proponent, the Committee prescribed
the following Terms of Reference for preparing (copy enclosed as Annexure –I) the EIA
report. The reply of the ToR conditions is given below:
Table 1.2 : ToR Compliance
ToR Description Reply Citation
1 Executive summary of the
project
Executive Summary of the project is given
in Chapter 11. --
2 Detailed breakup of the land area
along with latest photograph of
the area.
Total land required for the proposed project
is 84326.4 m2.
Out of which 33% will be
used for green belt development. Detailed
breakup of the land area of the area is given
in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.4.4, page
no. 24-25
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 11
ToR Description Reply Citation
3 Present land use based on
satellite imagery
Present land use based on satellite imagery
has been prepared and is enclosed in
Chapter 3 of EIA report.
Item no.
3.4, page
no.48-51
4 Details of site and information
related to environmental setting
within 10 km radius of the
project site.
Details of site and information related to
environmental setting within 10 Km radius
of the project site have been given in
Chapter 1 of EIA report. Site photographs
are given in Annexure II.
Item no.
2.1 , page
no. 19-20
and
Annexure
II
5 Information regarding eco-
sensitive area such as national
park / wildlife sanctuary /
biosphere reserves within 10 km
radius of project area.
There is no eco-sensitive area such as
national park / wildlife sanctuary / biosphere
reserves within 10 Km radius of project
area.
Item no.
2.1 , page
no. 19-20
6 Permission from the State Forest
Department regarding the impact
of the proposed plant on the
surrounding reserve forest.
As there is no national park/wildlife
sanctuary/biosphere reserves within 10 Km
radius area and hence permission from State
Forest Department is not applicable.
---
7 List of existing distillery units in
the study area alongwith their
capacity
There is no distillery unit within the study
area.
---
8 Number of working days of the
distillery unit.
Working days - 330 days/year. --
9 Total cost of the project along
with total capital cost and
recurring cost/annum for
environmental pollution control
measures.
Total Project Cost – 6170.00 Lakhs
EMP Cost -815.00 Lakhs
Recurring Cost/Annum- 73.00 Lakhs
Item no.
10.3, page
no. 174-
175
10 Manufacturing process details of
distillery plant alongwith process
flow chart.
Manufacturing process details of distillery
plant alongwith process flow chart is given
in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.6, page
no. 27-34
11 Details of raw materials and
source of raw material molasses,
bagasse etc.
S.
No
Unit Total Item no.
2.4.2, page
no. 23-24
1. Molasses Molasses from
Shahabad
sugar
mill
35,000
tonnes/y
ear
Molasses from
neighboring
36,280
tonnes/y
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 12
ToR Description Reply Citation
mills ear
Transpo
rtation
by
tankers
2. Bagasse Requirement 24700
T/Annu
m
3. Water Requirement 950
KLD
4. Power Requirement 1780
KW
5. Steam requirement 19.0
Tons/Ho
ur
12 Sources and quantity of fuel
(coal etc.) for the boiler.
Measures to take care of SO2
emission. A copy of
Memorandum of Understanding
(MoU) signed with the coal
suppliers should be submitted, in
case coal is used.
Bagasse will be used as fuel. Details of same
is given in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.4.5.1,
page no.
25-26
13 Action plan prepared by the
SPCB to control ambient air
quality as per NAAQES
Standards for PM10, PM2.5, SO2
and NOX as per GSR 826(E)
dated 16th
November, 2009.
Action plan will be prepared under the
supervision of Haryana State Pollution
Control Board during NOC stage.
--
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 13
ToR Description Reply Citation
14 One season site-specific micro-
meteorological data using
temperature, relative humidity,
hourly wind speed and direction
and rainfall and AAQ data
(except monsoon) for PM10,
PM2.5, SO2, NOX and HC
(methane and non methane)
should be collected. The
monitoring stations should take
into account the pre-dominant
wind direction, population zone
and sensitive receptors including
reserved forests. Data for water
and noise monitoring should also
be included.
One season site specific Ambient Air
Quality data for PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOX and
HC (methane and non methane) has been
collected and incorporated in Chapter 3 of
EIA report.
Data for water and noise monitoring has
been collected and incorporated in Chapter 3
of EIA report.
Item no.
3.8, page
no. 58-63
Item no.
3.9, page
no. 63-67
for Noise,
Item no.
3.11, page
no. 74-80
for Water
15
Mathematical modeling for
calculating the dispersion of air
pollutants and ground level
concentration along with
emissions from the boiler.
Mathematical modeling for calculation of
dispersion of air pollutants and ground level
concentration along with emission from the
boiler has been done and is incorporated in
Chapter 4 of EIA report.
Item no.
4.2.1, page
no. 107-
115
16 An action plan to control and
monitor secondary fugitive
emissions from all the sources.
An action plan to control and monitor
secondary fugitive emissions from all the
sources is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.1.2,
page no.
170-171
17 Details of boiler and its
capacity. Details of the use of
steam from the boiler.
Boiler (20 TPH) will be based on Bagasse as
available fuel options. This Boiler will
operate mainly to feed steam to Molasses
based operations and 3.0 MW power
generations from Turbine. Also, the detail of
same is given in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.10, page
no. 42-45
18 Ground water quality around
existing /proposed spent wash
storage lagoon and the project
area.
Ground water quality analysis has been done
and details are given in Chapter 3 of EIA
report.
Item no.
3.11, page
no. 74-80
19 Details of water requirement,
water balance chart for Molasses
based Distillery. Measures for
conservation water by recycling
and reuse to minimize the fresh
water requirement.
Details of water requirement, water balance
chart is incorporated in Chapter 2 of EIA
report.
Item no.
2.4.6, page
no.26
20 Water requirement should not
exceed 10 KL/KL of alcohol for
distillery and prior ‘permission’
Same has been noted and complied. Item no.
2.4.6, page
no.26
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 14
ToR Description Reply Citation
for the drawl of total fresh water.
Details of source of water supply.
21 Hydro-geological study of the
area for availability of ground
water.
Hydro-geological study of the area is given
in Chapter 3 of EIA report.
Item no.
3.6, page
no. 53-54
22 Spent wash generation from
molasses based should not
exceed 8Kl/Kl of alcohol
production.
Same has been noted and complied Item no.
2.10, page
no. 42-45
23 Proposed effluent treatment
system for molasses based
distillery (spent wash and spent
lees) and scheme for achieving
‘zero’ discharge.
The proposed Molasses based distillery
would be based on “Zero Effluent
Discharge”
Detailed ETP scheme has been incorporated
in EIA report.
Item no.
2.10, page
no. 42-45
24 Lagoon capacity for sugar unit
and spent wash as well measures
to be taken to control ground
water contamination.
A duly lined lagoon of 30 days capacity
shall be provided.
Item no.
2.10, page
no. 42-45
25 Details of solid waste
management including
management of boiler ash.
Submit Ash management plan.
MoU with cement plant for the
use of fly ash.
Details of solid waste management is given
in Chapter 4 of EIA report.
Item no.
4.2.12,
page no.
126
26 Land available for bio-
composting. Details of lining to
be provided in the compost yard.
No land is reserved for bio composting as
waste will be incinerated in boiler.
-
27 Green belt development as per
the CPCB guidelines.
Green belt development as per the CPCB
guidelines will be done. Detail of same is
given in Chapter 10 of EIA report.
Item no.
10.1.7,
page no.
172-173
28 List of flora and fauna in the
study area.
Detailed list of flora and fauna is
incorporated in Chapter 3 of EIA report.
Item no.
3.12, page
no. 80-92
29 Noise levels monitoring at five
locations within the study area.
Noise level monitoring at five locations has
been done and is incorporated in Chapter 3
of EIA report.
Item no.
3.9, page
no. 63-67
30 Detailed Environment
management Plan (EMP) with
specific reference to details of air
pollution control system, water
and wastewater management,
monitoring frequency,
Detailed Environment management Plan
(EMP) with specific reference to details of
air pollution control system, water and
wastewater management, monitoring
frequency, responsibility and time bound
implementation plan for mitigation measure
Page no.
169-176
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 15
ToR Description Reply Citation
responsibility and time bound
implementation plan for
mitigation measure should be
provided.
is given in Chapter 10 of EIA report.
31 EMP should also include the
concept of waste-minimization,
recycle/reuse/ recover
techniques, Energy conservation,
and natural resource
conservation.
Details of waste-minimization,
recycle/reuse/recover techniques, energy
conservation and natural resource
conservation is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.4,Page
no. 175
32 Details of bagasse storage.
Details of press mud
requirement.
Baggase will be stored in our existing
Shahabad Sugar Co-Operative mill. Press
Mud will be procured from our own
Shahabad sugar mill. Detail of same has
been given in Chapter 2 of EIA report.
Item no.
2.10, page
no.42-45
33 Risk assessment for storage and
handling of alcohol and
mitigation measure due to fire
and explosion and handling
areas.
Risk assessment for storage and handling of
alcohol and mitigation measure due to fire
and explosion and handling areas is given in
Chapter 7 of EIA report.
Item no.
7.2, page
no.145-
146
34 Alcohol storage and handling
area and its fire fighting facility
as per norms.
Alcohol storage and handling area and fire
fighting facility is incorporated in EIA
report.
Item no.
7.3.5, page
no. 147-
148
35 Action plan for rainwater
harvesting measures at plant site
should be included to harvest
rainwater from the roof tops and
storm water drains to recharge
the ground water.
Action plan for rainwater harvesting
measures at plant site to harvest rainwater
from the roof tops and storm water drains to
recharge the ground water is incorporated in
Chapter 4 of EIA report.
Item no.
4.2.4, page no. 118-
120
36 Details of occupational health
programme
Details of occupational health programme is
incorporated in Chapter 10 of EIA report.
Item no.
10.1.8,
page no.
173
37 To which chemicals, workers are
exposed directly or indirectly.
Details of same is given in Chapter 7 of EIA
report.
Item no.
7.5, page
no. 152
38 Whether these chemicals are
within Threshold Limit Values
(TLV)/ Permissible Exposure
Levels as per ACGIH
recommendation.
Yes --
39 What measures company has
taken to keep these chemicals
within PEL/TLV.
Not required, as all the chemicals are within
TLV
--
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 16
ToR Description Reply Citation
40 How the workers are evaluated
concerning their exposure to
chemicals during preplacement
and periodical medical
monitoring.
Detail of same is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.1.8,
page no.
173
41 What are onsite and offsite
emergency plan during chemical
disaster.
Onsite and offsite emergency plan is
incorporated in Chapter 7 of EIA report.
Item no.
7.2, page
no. 145-
156
42 Liver function tests (LFT) during
pre-placement and periodical
examination.
Same will be done accordingly --
43 Details of occupational health
surveillance programme.
Occupational health surveillance programme
is incorporated in Chapter 10 of EIA report.
Item no.
10.1.8,
page no.
173
44 Details of socio-economic
welfare activities to be provided.
Details of socio-economic welfare activities
is given in Chapter 8 of EIA report.
Item no.
8.3 , page
no.163-
164
45 Traffic study of the area for the
proposed projects in respect of
existing traffic, type of vehicles,
frequency of vehicles for
transportation of materials,
additional traffic due to proposed
project, parking arrangement etc.
Detailed traffic study of the area for the
proposed project in respect of existing
traffic, type of vehicles, frequency of
vehicles for transportation of materials,
additional traffic due to proposed project has
been done and is incorporated in Chapter 3
of EIA report.
Item no.
3.9.2, page
no. 67-70
46 Action plan for post-project
environmental monitoring.
Post-project environmental monitoring will
be done after commissioning of project.
Also, proposed action plan for the same is
incorporated in Chapter 6 of EIA report.
Item no.
6.1, page
no. 131-
133
47 Corporate Environmental
Responsibility
Item no.
8.3, page
no. 163-
164
48
(a)
Does the company have a well
laid down Environment Policy
approved by its Board of
Directors? If so, it may be
detailed in the EIA report.
Yes Item no.
10.0, Page
no. 169
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 17
ToR Description Reply Citation
49
(b)
Does the Environmental Policy
prescribe for standard operating
process/procedures to bring into
focus any infringement /
deviation / violation of the
environmental or forest norms /
conditions? If so, it may be
detailed in the EIA report.
Detail of same is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.0, Page
no. 169
50
(c)
What is the hierarchical system
or Administrative order of the
company to deal with the
environmental issues and for
ensuring compliance with the EC
conditions. Details of this system
may be given.
Detail of same is given in Chapter 6 of EIA
report.
Item no.
6.4, page
no. 134-
135
51
(d)
Does the company have a system
of reporting of non compliance /
violations of environmental
norms to the Board of Directors
of the company and / or
shareholders or stakeholders at
large? This reporting mechanism
should be detailed in the EIA
report.
Detail of same is given in Chapter 10 of EIA
report.
Item no.
10.0, Page
no. 169
52 Any litigation pending against
the project and /or any direction
/order passed by any Court of
Law against the project, if so,
details thereof
No Legitimate pending against the Project
and /or any direction /order passed by any
Court of Law against the project.
--
53 Public hearing issues raised and
commitments made by the
project proponent on the same
should be included separately in
EIA/EMP Report in the form of
tabular chart with financial
budget for complying with the
commitments made.
Public consultation for the proposed project
was conducted by Haryana State Pollution
Control Board, Panchkula on dated 19th
May
2015 at 11 A.M at Village Jandheri, Tehsil
Shahabad, District Kurukshetra (Haryana).
Details of query asked by people along with
action plan is given Chapter 7 of EIA report.
Item
no.7.1,
Page no.
136-145
54 A tabular chart with index for
point-wise compliance of above
ToRs.
The details have been complied. --
A Additional TOR
1 Public hearing to be conducted Public consultation for the proposed project Item
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 18
ToR Description Reply Citation
and issues raised and
commitments made by the
project proponent on the same
should be included in EIA/EMP
report in the form of tabular chart
with financial budget for
complying with commitments
made
was conducted by Haryana State Pollution
Control Board, Panchkula on dated 19th
May
2015 at 11 A.M at Village Jandheri, Tehsil
Shahabad, District Kurukshetra (Haryana).
Details of query asked by people along with
action plan is given Chapter 7 of EIA report.
no.7.1,
Page no.
136-145
2 Permission to be obtained for
withdrawal of water from
concerned authority
Application has been submitted for the
same.
--
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 19
Chapter - 2
Project Description
2.0 Introduction
This chapter deals with the technical details of the proposed project, details of
infrastructure, various sources of pollution and mitigation measures proposed to control
pollution.
2.1 Type of the Project and Site Description
M/s Shahabad Coop. Sugar Mills is planning to set up a 60 KLD capacity molasses based
ethanol unit having 3.0 MW captive power plant at Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana. The project is planned to be established over an area of
84326.4 m2. The plant will operate 330 days in a year and will produce Ethanol/ Absolute
Alcohol.
The environmental setting of the proposed project is given in Table-2.1.
Table- 2.1 Location Details
S. No. Particulars Details
1. Nature and size of the Project 60 KLPD ethanol plant and 3.0 MW
captive power plant.
2. Location details
Village Jandheri
Tehsil Shahabad
District Kurukshetra
State Haryana
Latitude and Longitude 300 9’ 2.631’’ N
760 53’ 40.424’’ E
Toposheet No. (OSM No.) H43K16
Land Requirement 84326.4 m2
3. Cost Details
Project Cost Rs. 6170 Lakhs
Cost for Environmental Protection
Measures
Rs. 815 Lakhs
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 20
Table- 2.2 Infrastructure Details
4. Environmental Setting Details (with approximate aerial distance and
direction from the project site)
Nearest Village Village Jandheri
Nearest Town/City Shahabad Markanda, 3.1 Km NW
Nearest Post Office Barara, 15.40 Km NE
Nearest Highway SH -7, 0.2 Km SW
NH-1. 2.8 Km W
Nearest Railway Station Shahabad Railway Station.3.15 Km NW
Nearest Airport Chandigarh Airport, 58.3 Km NW
National Parks/ Wild Life
Sanctuaries/ Biosphere
Reserves/RF and PF within 10 Km
radius
There is no National Parks/ Wild Life
Sanctuaries/ Biosphere Reserves/RF and
PF within 10km radius area of project site
Nearest Water Bodies Markanda River, 2.5 Km N
Seismic Zone Zone III
2.2 Project Location and Layout
The proposed project is located at Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra,
Haryana. The Location map of the project site is given in Figure -2.1 and layout plan of
the project site is given in Figure 2.2.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 21
Figure 2.1: Location Map of the Project Site
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 22
Figure 2.2: Site Layout Plan
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 23
2.3 Need for the Project
The molasses has very high BODs and CODs. If the same is not in use properly
will cause more damage to Environment.
The molasses can be converted in valuable products like Rectified Spirit/Ethanol
and risk of more pollution can be diluted.
The latest technology is adopted with a better productivity and quality of alcohol.
The molasses based distilleries are linked with sugar factory and sugar producing
farmers will be benefit by it.
These are also involved in several developmental activities to help farmers.
Justification
Rectified Spirit/Ethyl Alcohol will be available for IMFL unit.
Revenue will be generated for the state government.
Foreign currency will be saved.
Import of foreign liquor will reduce.
Employment will be provided to nearby people, which will reduce poverty.
Development of local region
Increase in Local Business
Standard of Living of people will increase.
2.4 Size or Magnitude of Operation
2.4.1 Products
The Company proposes to setup 60 KLD capacity molasses based ethanol unit having 3.0
MW captive power plant.
2.4.2 Raw Materials
The raw materials required for proposed project is given in Table 2.3.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 24
Table 2.3 Raw Materials
S. No. Unit Total
1. Molasses Molasses from Shahabad sugar
mill
35,000 tonnes/year
Molasses from neighboring mills 36,280 tonnes/year
Transportation by tankers
2. Bagasse Requirement 24700 T/Annum
3. Water Requirement 950 KLD
4. Power Requirement 1780 KW
5. Steam requirement 19.0 Tons/Hour
2.4.3 Action Plan of Transportation of the Raw material and Product
Table 2.4 Action Plan for Transportation of Raw Material
S.no. Type of vehicle No. of vehicle/day
1. Trucks 2
2. Lorries 2
3. Van/Car 7
Total 11
i. One entry and one exit has been proposed to mitigate the traffic.
ii. Two watchman will be deployed at entry and exit gate.
iii. Pressure horn will be avoid in the factory premises.
iv. PUC will be checked for each vehicle entered in the factory premise.
v. Mettelled road will be connected to approach road to avoid traffic congestion.
2.4.4 Area breakup
The total land required for the proposed project is given in Table-2.5 and Layout of the
Plant is given in Figure -2.2.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 25
Table 2.5 Area Breakup
S.No. Particulars Area (m2) Area (%)
1. Plant Area 20575.61 24.4
2. Admin Office 3735.65 4.43
3. Storages 4528.32 5.37
4. Utilities 10152.88 12.04
5. Road Parking 15263.06 18.1
6. Store & Work Shop 2243.07 2.66
7. Green Belt 27827.67 33
Total 84326.3 100
Source: Detailed Project Report
2.4.5 Power
As the process steam requirement is quite large and suitable for cheap power generation
via cogeneration system a steam turbo- alternator is provided to meet the process demand
of power. Hence a 3.0 MW turbo alternator is suggested in conformity with steam plant
capacity. The surplus power will be exported to grid through sugar mill cogeneration
plant and power transmission during season and will be utilized in house during off-
season. Power requirement in the ethanol plant is shown in detail in Table-2.6.
Table 2.6 Power Consumption Details
Area Operating Load (KW)
Fermentation/ Distillation 300
Dehydration plant 80
Cooling water, Air compressor, Water softening plant, DM
plant, Raw water supply, waste water treatment, etc.
500
R.O and Nano station for waste water 250
CO2 plant 150
Captive power plant 400
Contingencies 100
Total 1780 Source: Detailed Project Report
2.4.5.1 Fuel for Power Plant
Shahabad Co-op. Sugar mills limited would be installing 3.0 MW cogeneration power
plant along with the distillery unit. The fuel (Bagasse / Rice husk) requirements for the 20
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 26
TPH boiler furnaces of the cogeneration power plant would be around 24700 T/Annum
(75.0 TPD). Fuel will be transported by covered trucks.
2.4.6 Water Supply
The water requirement will be 950 KLD. This water will be supplied from the existing
borewell. The water details are given in Table -2.7.
Table 2.7 Water Requirement
Sr. No. Particular Details
1. Process Water 500 KLD
2. Soft Water 195 KLD
3. Boiler Water 250 KLD
4. Domestic Use 5 KLD
Total 950 KLD Source: Detailed Project Report
2.4.7 Manpower
Total manpower required for the proposed project is 110.
Table 2.8 :Manpower Requirement
S. No. Particulars No. of personal
1. Administrative Staff 5
2. Supervisor 5
3. Skilled Worker 20
4. Semi Skilled Worker 30
5. Unskilled Worker 50
Total 110
Source: Detailed Project Report
2.4.8 Health and Sanitation
To ensure optimum hygienic conditions in the plant area, proper drainage network will be
provided to avoid water logging and outflow. Adequate health related measures and a
well equipped safety and environment department will be provided to ensure clean and
healthy environment.
2.5 Proposed Scheduled for Approval and Implementation
The proposed project will be completed with 12 months for the Zero data.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 27
2.6 Technology and Process Description
A) Ethyl Alcohol
Material balance
Molasses is the main raw material used in India for production of Alcohol. Molasses
contain about 50% total sugars, out of which, 30 to 33% are cane sugar and the rest are
reducing sugar. During the fermentation, yeast strains of the species Saccharomyces
Cerevisiae, a living micro-organism belonging to class fungi converts sugar present in the
molasses, such as sucrose or glucose to alcohol. Chemically this transformation for
sucrose to alcohol can be approximated by the equation. Process flow is given in Figure
2.2.
C12H 22O11 + H2O = C6H12O6 + C6H12O6
Sucrose Glucose Fructose
C6H12O6 = 2C2H5OH + 2CO2
180 = 2x46 +2x44
Glucose Ethyl Alcohol Carbon- Dioxide
During fermentation other by products like glycerin, succinine acid etc. are also formed
form sugars. Therefore, actually 94.5% total fermentable sugars are available for alcohol,
under ideal condition theoretically. Normally only 80 to 82% efficiencies are realized on
plant. One tone of molasses containing 45% F sugars gives alcoholic yield 255- 265 litres
per ton. For above biochemical reaction proper and careful handling of yeast, maintaining
optimum parameters like pH, temperature, and substrate concentration is required.
For manufacture of yeast, separate equipment known as pure yeast culture apparatus is
required. Initially, yeast is developed in the laboratory from the single cell yeast culture.
In the laboratory, yeast is propagated in a test tube 10 mL. Then it is transferred to a
bigger flask of 500 mL flask, and transferred to 5 litre flask containing the sterilized
molasses solution. It is necessary to adjust the pH of the molasses solution in the range at
each stage of development of yeast propagation i.e 100 liters, 500 liters and 5000 liters.
All these equipment’s are designed so as to facilitate boiling molasses solution in order to
sterilize it and also cooling to bring it to the proper temperature of 330C and letting in
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 28
culture and taking out culture. Boiling, cooling introducing culture is done in aseptic
manner, i.e. keeping the fermentation medium free from any kind of infection. Further,
stages of yeast propagation are done in open tanks i.e. pre-fermenter requires about 8
hours in order to build up necessary concentration of yeast. Finally, pre-fementer is
emptied in an empty previously cleaned fementer, Dilute molasses solution is allowed to
flow in this fementer so as to fill it to its working capacity.
The average efficiency of conversion of sugars in molasses to alcohol is 80 to 85% of
theoretical value. All the sugars are not converted to alcohol during the process of
fermentation because chemicals like glycerin; succinine acid, etc. are also produced by
yeast during metabolic process. 100% efficiency of conversion of sugars to alcohol is not
possible. The average yield of alcohol from molasses is about 250 liters from 1 MT of
molasses.
Fermentation
For fermentation granulating yeast, which settles under gravity is used. Molasses free
from suspended particles is transferred to molasses receiving tank and is weighed.
Weighed molasses is distributed to cell mass propagation, fermentation and yeast
activation section. Granulating yeast is grown in laboratory during plant start up. Yeast
propagation section comprises of molasses diluter and hygienically engineered yeast
vessels equipped with heating, cooling and air sparging facility. Dilute molasses media is
prepared in yeast vessel by recirculation of media through molasses diluter.
Laboratory propagated cell mass is scaled up in series of yeast vessels. Air is sparged in
pasteurized and cooled dilute molasses medium for optimum growth of granulating yeast.
The temperature is maintained at 32o C by re-circulating cooling water through jacket of
yeast vessels. Cell mass from Yeast vessel is transferred to yeast activation vessel to built
up cell mass required for fermentation (during start up only) by cell mass transfer pump.
At steady stage, activated cell mass from yeast activation vessel is transferred
continuously to fermentor - I. Molasses, process water and vinasse recycle stream from
distillation is added to fermentor. Fermented wash from Fermentor-I overflows
continuously to fermentor –II and then to yeast settling tank.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 29
As ethanol fermentation is exothermic process, optimum temperature required for yeast
activity is maintained by forced recirculation through fermentor wash coolers. Efficient
mixers are provided in both fermentors.
Fermented wash from Fermentor-II is sent to yeast setting tank for separation of yeast
under gravity. Vinasse stream from distillation is recycled to fermentor depending on
solids concentration in fermented wash and molasses composition.
Granulating yeast having granulation property, settles in yeast settling tank under gravity,
while fermented wash overflows to wash holding tank. Settled yeast is transferred at rated
flow to yeast activation vessel with screw pump. In yeast activation vessel, molasses,
process water, nutrients and additive are added for activation of recycled cell mass.
Filtered air is sparged as required for re-activation of cell membranes and other cell
components. Mixer is provided for better mass transfer in yeast activation vessel.
Activated cell mass is transferred to fermenter- I to maintain desired cell mass
concentration in fermenter.
Carbon dioxide generated in fermentation is entrained with alcohol vapors. Alcohol from
Carbon dioxide is scrubbed with water in gas scrubber. The scrubber water is transferred
to wash charger. Fermented wash from wash charger is fed to analyzer column.
Distillation
The next sage in the manufacture of alcohol is to separate alcohol from fermented wash
and to concentrate it to 95% alcohol called as rectified spirit. For this purpose, method of
distillation is employed. The distillation columns consists number of SIEVE plates where
wash is boiled and alcoholic vapors are separated and concentrated on each place stage
by stage.
Integrated Distillation and Evaporation Section:
Technology offered (multi-Pressure)
This technology is based on heat recovery principle. The system comprises of 3 columns
operating at different pressures and is designed to produce Rectified Spirit. The columns
in order of flow are as follows:
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 30
Analyser cum Degasifying Column (operating under vacuum)
Aldehyde Column (operating under Vacuum)
Rectifier cum Exhaust Column (Operative under Pressure)
Rectified Spirit Production
Fermented wash from the clarified wash tank is pumped to the fermented wash pre -
heater and preheated to about 68-700C by circulating hot spent wash on other side.
Incoming spent wash temperature is 80-820C and after exchanging heat with fermented
wash out let lamp of spent wash remains at 35- 400C this hot fermented wash is then feed
at the top of Degasifying column.
Analyzer column cum Degasifying Column
Analyzer column strips fermented wash before discharging the rest of the material as
spent wash. Metered flow of fermented wash is feed to the top of the analyzer column.
Vapours of rectifier column provide energy to Analyzer column through a evaporator.
Rectifier top vapours are condensed on the shell side of the evaporator and spent wash is
re -circulated on tubeside. Vapors generated from the re - boiler are used in the analyzer
column consist approximately 50% alcohol and 50% water with impurities such as higher
alcohols, aldehydes, acids, sulphur dioxide, etc. Spent wash from the analyzer column
bottom is sent for treatment to the Effluent Treatment Plant. The level in the column
bottom is controlled to ensure proper distillation and correct concentration of the spent
wash. The vapour draw from top of the Analyzer is condensed in forth stage of
evaporator system and pumped to Rectifier column for concentration. Analyzer column is
operating under vacuum. Using water ring vacuum pump creates vacuum and the vacuum
in the column is maintained by manual valve, which bleeds extra air in the system.
Aldehyde Column
Aldehyde column is principally used for removal of low boiling impurities. Vapors from
degasifying column are fed to Aldehyde column. The vapors coming out of the top of the
Aldehyde column are fed to the condenser-I where they are partially condensed
bypassing cooling water on the tube side. Balance alcohol vapors are condensed in the
condenser- II. Water is used for the Condensation. From Aldehyde column top Technical
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 31
Alcohol cut of 2% of total plant capacity is taken out. Aldehyde column works under
vacuum.
Rectifier cum Exhaust Column:
Analyzer column top vapors are condensed in forth stage of evaporator and fed to
Rectified column for further concentration. Rectifier column is designed in sieve trays
construction and operates under pressure for obtaining desired strength of alcohol.
Condensing steam provides heat to Rectifier column. Fuel Oil draws are taken from
Rectifier column and are send to fuel oil decanter. The fuel oil stream is diluted with
water for separation of fuel oils. The aqueous layer sends backs to Rectifier column and
fuel oil are sent to storage.
Technical Alcohol cut of 3% of total plant capacity is taken out from top of Rectifier
Column. Rectified Spirit of 95% v/v concentration is drawn from one of the upper trays
of Rectifier Column and sends to storage after cooling.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 32
Figure 2.3 Process Flow Diagram
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 33
B) Cogeneration of Power
Operations
The unit is proposed to set-up boiler and power turbine.
Boiler will be based on Bagasse as available fuel options. This Boiler will operate mainly
to feed steam to Molasses based operations and 3.0 MW power generations from
Turbine. Proposed 3.0 MW co-generation plant consists of a high pressure water tube
steam boiler extraction cum condensing steam turbine. Fuel in the steam boiler will be
burnt with the help of air in the boiler furnace. Water will be circulated in the boiler drum
and tubes thus getting heated by the flame burning in the boiler furnace. Water comes out
of the boiler drum located at the top of the boiler as steam. Flue gases rise in the boiler
furnace and come in contact with the steam coming out of boiler drum. Steam after
coming in contact with flue gases gets heated up further thus getting superheated. Super
heated steam leaves the boiler in a pipe. Flue gases after super heating the steam pass
through economizer where they pre-heat the boiler feed water before it enters the boiler
drum.
After economizer, flue gases pass through air pre-heaters where they heat the air which is
fed to the boiler furnace for burning the fuel. After air pre heaters flue gases pass through
an ESP where the dust particles are collected on charged electrodes. The dust is collected
from the bottom of the ESP.
High pressure superheated steam from boiler is passed through a steam turbine, which is
used for distillery process operations. While passing through the turbine, the high
pressure and temperature steam rotates the turbine rotor and an electric alternator
mounted on the same shaft. Electric power is generated by the alternator. This electric
power generated is consumed in house i.e. for running the distillery and utilities like
boilers auxiliaries etc. Process flow diagram is given in Figure 2.4.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 34
Figure-2.4 Process Flow Chart for Captive Power Plant
2.7 Facilities at the Plant
The factory building will along with other ancillary structures are proposed to be
constructed. It will be provided adequate space for the following areas of working:-
1. Storage for raw material and finished goods.
2. Plant and Machineries
3. Offices
4. Toilets
5. Under Ground Tank
Open space will be landscaped and trees will be planted in due course of time. Layout
map of the project is given in Figure 2.2.
2.8 Evaporation plant
Spent wash from distillation is used as fuel in the boiler. In this context spent wash is
concentrated from approximate 12% TDS to 60 % TDS to be able to fire the same as liquid
fuel in the boiler. This concentration is done in a quintuple effect evaporation plant either
as a stand alone or integrated cum stand alone plant. Steam will be available at 4 ata and
saturated for stand alone system. In the integrated evaporation, initial concentration is
effected by using the primary distillation column vapors in the distillation section.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 35
The steam condensate from the evaporation plant is returned to boiler as feed water. The
process condensate from the evaporators is duly treated for removing the BOD/COD to be
suitable for recirculation to process steps.
2.8.1 Evaporation Section
The spent wash generated from R.S. Plant distillation unit (for molasses distillation) is 600
m3/day and is rich in mineral content and organics. In order to make the spent wash
suitable for in the boiler as fuel, the same is to be concentrated to 60% TDS from its
original strength of 12% w/w. Thus the water to be evaporated is 480 m3/day. This is done
in a quadruple / quintuple effect evaporator system with heating medium in the first effect
as steam at ata pressure. The evaporation system shall also include the condensate flash
system to reduce steam consumption. In evaporation economy of about approximately 5.0
i.e. 50 tonnes of evaporation per tonne of steam is to be achieved.
Table 2.9 : List of Equipment for Standalone Evaporation plant
S.No. Equipment Description MOC Qty.
1. Evaporator Calendrias Designed on basis of Falling
film/rising film principle
Construction: Shell & Tube
Type.
Shell: AISI
304
Tubes : AISI
304
Tube sheet:
AISI 304
5
2. Vapor Liquid Separators Construction: Vertical, with
tangential entry for effective
vapor separation.
AISI 304 5
3. Pre Heaters Shell and Tube heat
exchanger
AISI 304 5
4. Surface Condenser Shell & Tube Type Shell : AISI 1
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 36
304
Tubes: AISI
304
Tube sheet:
AISI 304
5. Flash vessel /vapour body Vertical / cylindrical
Construction
AISI 304 4
6. Feed Tank Vertical /cylindrical
Construction
AISI 304 1
7. Process Condensate Tank Vertical Construction AISI 304 1
8. CIP tank Vertical Construction AISI 304 1
9. Steam Condensate Tank Vertical Construction MS 1
10. Product tank Vertical Construction AISI 304 1
11. Thin / lean spent wash
holding Tank
Vertical Construction MS + Epoxy 1
12. Feed pump + motor Centrifugal Type (Wetted parts
CF8)
1
13. Recirculation cum transfer
Pump + motor
Centrifugal Type (Wetted parts
CF8
4
14 CIP Pump + motor Centrifugal Type Wetted parts
CF 8
1
15. Process Condensate
Pump + motor
Centrifugal Type Wetted parts
CF 8
1
16. Condensate flash tanks Vertical, Cylindrical AISI - 304 5
17. Steam Condensate Centrifugal Type CI 1
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 37
Pump + motor
18. Product Transfer pump +
motor
Centrifugal Type Wetted parts
CF 8
1
19. Vacuum Pump + Motor Water Ring Type CI 1+1
20. Piping + Valves Standard Lot
21. Instrumentation Mimic based Instrumentation
panel will be provided.
Along with locally mounted
instruments.
Lot
22. Electrical Control panel Std. Lot
23. Cooling Tower with fans
and cooling water
circulation pumps and
complete piping.
Note: Control Loops, Temperature Indications etc. to be added in PLC/DCS System - SCADA
system. Evaporation Plant will be on common PLC/DCS System / SCADA system with
Distillation.
2.9 Steam Generation Plant
Steam generation plant comprises, the boiler, fuel handling and burning equipment, feed
water system, environmental equipment, boiler feed water deaerator alongwith all
accessory plants and chimney make the boiler fully functional and operative efficiently.
The boiler is basically a single drum, natural circulation, balanced draft, water walled
furnace type water take type boiler with distillery slops (Concentrated spent wash) and
other biomass as the fuels. Fuel burning arrangement comprised slop burner and spreader
stroker fitted with traveling grate in the furnace. The brief specification as given in the
following paras:-
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 38
2.9.1 Salient Features of the Steam Generator Proposed
Design Features
1. Travelling grate design suitable for combustion of spent wash with Bagasse and
Coal or any other Biomass as support fuel to slops to sustain combustion.
2. Liberal grate area and loading to ensure efficient combustion of fuel.
3. Single drum design.
4. Boiler configuration with three pass design having water cooled membrane wall
construction to ensure low fuel gas temperature at the inlet of super heater.
5. No heat transfer surfaces located in first and second pass of boiler. Convective
heating surface areas are located in 3rd
horizontal pass.
6. High volumetric loading of furnace.
a. Ensures adequate residence time hence efficient fuel combustion.
b. Ensures lower furnace exit gas temperature to avoid fouling due to alkali
content in the fuel.
7. Spray nozzles to be provided on the side wall of furnace (First pass) for
atomization of Spent wash. One No. additional spent wash gun to be provided on
the front wall of furnace to ensure operation of boiler at low load, while guns
provided on side walls are under maintenance.
8. Two stage integral super heater located in third pass of furnace alongwith interstage
attemperator.
9. Convective Super heater to be designed to avoid following problems.
a. Super heater placed in convective zone does not face burning fuel
particles.
b. Fouling of ash does not take place in convective design, as the temperature
is comparatively low in convective zone than radiant zone.
c. Operating metal temperature would be maintained to eliminate the
problem of super heater overheating.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 39
10. Proper split of primary and secondary air for efficient fuel combustion in the upper
furnace to ensure proper prediction of furnace exit gas temperature for downsteam
sizing of heating surface areas.
11. Flue gas temperature at superheater inlet should be less than 650˚C to avoid fouling
due to alkalis in ash (Na2O + K2O) and corrosion of Superheater tubes due to
chlorides in ash.
12. A single stoker with one number of riddling hopper with dampers in the connecting
air duct. The hoppers to be provided with proper valley angle to avoid choking of
ash.
13. Temperature elements to be provided on the skid bar, cross beam and riddling
hoppers with temperature indication facilities in the control room. Also an alarm to
be provided to alert when the temperature reaches around 3000⁰C.
14. Bush bearing to be provided for rotary air damper, considering high secondary air
temperature.
15. Design drum
a. To keep drum steam loading rate low and
b. To enable boiler operation with rapid load swings and fast response to load
changes.
16. Efficient drum internal consisting of cyclone separators and demisters to ensure high
steam purity at all loads.
17. Over fire air system with higher secondary air pressure to provide better air
penetration across furnace cross section thereby minimizing unburnt carbon loss. The
secondary air nozzles are to be staggered providing turbulence and air curtain to
minimize escape of unburnt fuel particles.
18. Optimum steam side pressure drop in superheater circuit to ensure proper steam
distribution and cooling of superheater coils.
19. Optimum flue gas velocity levels in pressure parts to minimize erosion due to ash and
also due to presence of sand in fuel.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 40
20. High circulation ratio at all loads ensuring efficient cooling of water wall tubes and
also preventing departure from nucleate boiling.
21. Air heater is provided with air through tube arrangement to prevent choking of tubes
during combustion of sticky fuels like slops.
Construction feature
i. Self lubricated graphite bearings (morganite bearings) are provided for the stoker
shaft. The morganite carbon bearing is self lubricating, chemically inert,
dimensionally stable, non-hygroscopic and highly resistant to wear characteristics
which makes it deal for hostile environment.
ii. Water-cooled membrane wall construction with optimum fin width as to give
maximum absorption of heat provide lower find tip to base differential temperature
and give structural rigidity.
iii. Wide pitching of superheater to minimize fouling/bridging due to alkali constituents
(Na2O_ K2O) in ash and also due to chlorides in ash.
iv. Economizer will be plain tape type with layout ensuring ease of cleaning and
inspection and good heat transfer.
v. Pressure parts tubes made of seamless steel construction to ensure high tub life and
hence higher boiler availability.
vi. Provide adequate access doors/observation doors for inspection and repair.
vii. Location and arrangement of heating surfaces such that good accessibility for
inspection and repairs is ensured.
Table 2.10 : Design Basis of Steam Generator
Type of Boiler Unit Single-Drum, Slop fired (TG) Boiler
Design code -- IBR 1950 with latest amendments
Boiler capacity at MSSV outlet (Kg/hr) 20000
Steam pressure at MSSV outlet (Kg/cm2(g)) 47
Steam temperature at MSSV outlet C) 410˚C 5
SH temp. control range % 70 – 100
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 41
Fuel Tons Slops+ Rice Husk
Slops+ Bagasse
Water temp at Economiser inlet C) 110˚C
Ultimate Fuel analysis (appro.) 60% Slop Rice Husk Bagasse
- Carbon % 22.93 36.70 23.25
- Hydrogen % 2.21 03.00 03.25
- Nitrogen % 1.91 00.40 00.00
- Sulphur % 0.63 00.08 00.00
- Moisture % 40 10.00 50.00
- Ash % 17.11 18.80 01.50
- Oxygen % 15.22 31.02 22.00
GCV (K.Cal/kg.) Kcal/kg 1650 -
1750 3150-3400 2270
Fuel sizing -- As
available
with 60%
Solids
As
available
Mill wet
bagasse
Flue gas temperature at Air heater
outlet
°C 160 °C
Start up fuel -- Charcoal mixed with diesel
Ambient Temperature °C 40
Electrical data for motors
- LT Volt (V) : 415 ± 10
- Frequency (Hz) : 50
- Type : AC 3 phase, 4 wire
Electrical data for instruments
- LT Volt (V) : 220 ± 10 %
- Frequency (Hz) : 50 ± 5 %
- Type : AC single phase
Compressed air pressure : 7 Kg/cm2 (Oil and Moisture free)
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 42
Table 2.11 Technical Data Sheet
S.No Description Unit Specification
1.0 General
a. Type of the boiler Single drum, water tube, slop fired boiler.
(Travelling Grate furnace)
b. Type of circulation Natural Circulation
c. Type of support Bottom support
d.
e. Design code As per IBR 1950 with its latest amendments
2.0 Boiler Predicted Performance
a. Steam output
- MCR kg/hr 20,000
- PCR % 110% of MCR (For ½ hour per 8
Hours shift)
b. Steam pressure at stop valve
Outlet
Kg/cm2(g) 47
c. Steam temp at stop valve
outlet
°C 410
d. Feed water temp at
economiser inlet
°C 160
e. Feed water temp at deaerator
outlet and W.P. heater inlet
°C 110
f. Spray water temp °C 110
g. Boiler efficiency % Slop+ Bagasse: 70 %
2.10 Description of Mitigation Measures
The environmental aspect, impact and proposed mitigation measures given in Table 2.12.
Table 2.12 Environmental Aspect, Impact and Proposed Mitigation Measures
S. No. Aspect Impact Mitigation Measures
1 Effluent Generation Water Pollution The proposed Molasses
based distillery would be
based on “Zero Liquid
Discharge” ZLD)
Spent wash will be
concentrated in MEE
(Multiple Effect
Evaporator), than the
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 43
semisolid waste from MEE
(Multiple Effect Evaporator)
will be sent in specially
designed boiler for
incineration.
Spent wash generation the
proposed unit will not
exceed beyond 8kl/kl
A duly lined lagoon of 30
days capacity will be
provided.
Online effluent quality
monitoring system will be
installed at the outlet of the
unit for measurement of the
parameters flow, pH, COD,
BOD and TSS etc. and
transmission of online data
to Haryana State Pollution
Control Board and CPCB
will be done
2 i. Emission of Gases
ii. Dust Emission
Air Pollution Sprinkler will be installed
along the haul and kuccha
road.
The wetting of Kuccha road
will be done by water tankers
regularly.
Green belt will be developed
along the project boundary,
haul road and inside the plant
roads.
The PUC (Pollution under
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 44
control) will be checked at
the entrance.
The vehicles will passed
through the water so that dust
attached with tyres will be
washed.
The material brought in
trucks will be covered
properly with plastic sheets.
The sand/cement stored at
the site will also be covered
with plastic sheet.
The temporary wall will be
created along boundary of
the project site so that effect
of wind and generation of
dust be minimized.
By adopting the above
mitigation measures the
emission level will be
brought down and PM10 will
be minimized below 100
ug/m3.
3 Generation of Solid and
Hazardous Waste
Land Pollution Boiler ash collected and
sold to brick
manufacturers.
The other solid wastes
expected from the unit are
containers, empty drums
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 45
which are returned to the
product seller or sold to
authorize buyers after
detoxification.
4 Noise generation during
operation of plant
Noise Pollution All noise generating machines
will be spread at different
places within the cover sheds.
PPEs will be provided to
Workers who will work in High
noise area
5 Use of water Impact on
Hydrogeology
Rain water recharge pits will be
constructed.
6 Removal of the soil Impact on geology Top soil will be stacked
separately and will be used for
greenbelt development.
7 Construction of building Impact on Land Use 33% area of the project site will
be developed as Greenbelt.
8 Removal of plant and
shrubs
Impact biological
environment
No tree cutting.
Adequate plantation will be
done to minimize the adverse
impact.
9 Project activity Socio Economic
Environment
Employment will be given to
local persons.
Fund allocated for CSR activity.
10 Emergency during
Operation of the Plant
Risk Risk assessment and Onsite
emergency plan will be
prepared
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 46
2.11 Assessment of New and untested Technology for the Risk of Technical Failure
The detailed risk assessment study is given in Chapter 7.
2.12 Summary:
M/s Shahabad Coop. Sugar Mills is planning to set up a 60 KLPD capacity molasses based
ethanol unit having 3.0 MW co-generation plant at Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana. Total land requirement for the project is 84326.4 m2.
Fermentation and Distillation process will be used for production of ethyl alcohol. Water
requirement will be 950 KLD. The requirement of Power for the unit is 1780 KW. 110
persons will be engaged for this project. Adequate Environmental protection measures as
well as health related measures will be taken.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 47
Chapter - 3
Description of the Environment
3.0 Introduction
The main objectives of describing the environment, which may be potentially affected,
are (i) to assess present environmental quality and the environmental impacts and (ii) to
identify environmentally significant factors. The chapter contains information on existing
environmental scenario of the proposed project study area.
3.1 Study Area
Various environmental parameters study has been done within 10 Km radius area of the
proposed project site. The study area map is given in Chapter 1, Figure 1.1.
3.2 Study Period
The ToR presentation for proposed project was held on 20th
January, 2015 and ToR was
granted by MoEF&CC on 31st March, 2014. M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd.
requested vide letter dated 30th
December, 2014 to MoEF&CC regarding permission to
start baseline monitoring from 1st October to 31
st December 2014. During ToR
Presentation Experts Committee Members accepted the period from 1st October to 31
st
December 2014 and desired that one month additional data to be collected. As per EAC
recommendation additional one month (1st January to 31
st January 2015) data collection
has been done.
3.3 Components and Methodology
3.3.1 Components
To achieve the objectives of ToR, Vardan EnviroNet team members visited the site and
study area (10 Km radius) study and monitored the environmental parameters as per of
ToR Letter and accordance with the Guidelines for EIA, issued by the Ministry of
Environment, Forests and Climate Change, Government of India. The component of the
study is given below:
1. Water Environment;
2. Air Quality and Meteorology;
3. Air Environment;
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 48
4. Noise Environment;
5. Land Environment
6. Biological Environment;
7. Socio-economic Environment;
8. Hydrogeology;
9. Geology;
10. Solid and Hazardous Waste;
11. Land Use;
12. Risk Assessment.
3.3.2 Data Collection Methodology
The baseline information on micro-meteorology, ambient air quality, water quality, noise
levels, soil quality and floristic descriptions are largely drawn from the data generated by
M/s Vardan Enviro Lab, Gurgaon (NABL Accredited Lab). Long term meteorological
data recorded at the nearest IMD station, Kurukshetra was also collected.
Micrometeorological data at site was recorded using automatic weather station. Apart
from these, secondary data have been collected from Census Handbook, Revenue
Records, Statistical Department, Soil Survey and Land use Organization, District
Industries Centre, Forest Department, Central Ground Water Authority, etc.
3.4 Land Use Pattern of the Study Area
Shri Joshua Anand FAE along with Mr. Bhagwan Sahay FAA involved in preparing the
land use report.
(A) Data Used
United States Geological Survey (USGS) Satellite Data: Landsat 8 cloud free data has
been used for Landuse / landcover analysis, Satellite Sensor – OLI_TIRS multi-spectral
digital data has been used for the preparation of land use/ land cover map of present
study. Survey of India reference map on 1:50,000 scales have been used for the
preparation of base map and geometric correction of satellite data. Ground truthing has
been carried out to validate the interpretation accuracy and reliability of remotely sensed
data, by enabling verification of the interpreted details and by supplementing with the
information, which cannot be obtained directly on satellite imagery.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 49
(B) Methodology
The methodology used for the study consists of following components.
Methodology adopted for thematic data extraction from the Satellite Imageries
ERDAS image processing 10.0 software and ARC/GIS 10.0 software were used for the
project. ERDAS 10.0 image processing software was used for digital processing of the
spatial data. Digital image processing techniques were applied for the mapping of the
land use land cover classes of the provided area from the satellite data. Methodology
Used for Land use Classification and Mapping is presented in Figure 3.1
Figure 3.1: Methodology Used for Land use Classification and Mapping
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 50
Results
In the present study, both digital image processing and using visual interpretation
technique were used to generate output of Land use cover map of study area. A standard
False Colour Composite (FCC) image has also been generated on the same scale (Figure
3.2 and Figure 3.3). The land use pattern of the study area is given in Table 3.1.
Table 3.1:Land Use Pattern of the Study Area
Landuse Area (in Hectares) % Area
Water Body 665.09 2.018
Human Settlement 6795.62 20.62
Agriculture Land 19796.35 60.07
Open Scrub 3240.13 9.83
Barren land 429.09 1.30
Follow Land 2072.72 6.28
Total Area 32954.00 100
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 51
Figure 3.2: Land Use Pattern of the Study Area (10 km Radius from the Project Site)
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 52
Figure 3.3: FCC Map of the Study Area (10 km Radius from the Project Site)
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 53
3.5 Geology
The study area represents almost flat alluvial plain without any conspicuous
topographical features. It forms a part of the vast Indo-Gangetic alluvial plains. The
average elevation of the plain varies from 274 to 241 m above mean sea level. The
general slope of the land is from north-east to south-west wards. The district falls in two
basins i.e Upper-Ghaggar Basin and the Upper Yamuna Basin. A small portion in south-
east part of the district falls in Upper Yamuna basin and the rest of the area falls in Upper
Ghaggar basin. The district is devoid of any perennial river. The only river Markhanda
flows in the north-western part of the district which originates in Nahan hills. Chautang,
Khand and Omla nalas of local existence also drain the district. The entire district of
Kurukshetra is covered by tropical arid brown soils. These soils are very pale brown in
colour. They do not have well defined horizons. In general these soils are deep and
imperfectly drained. The permeability of these soils is low to moderate. These soils are
mildly alkaline to strongly alkaline in reaction. The available moisture holding capacity
of these soils is medium to high. These soils are medium to high in organic matter. Three
soil types viz sandy loam, loam and clay loam are commonly met within this group.
3.6 Hydrology, Ground Water and Water Conservation
The area falls in the Upper Jamuna and Ghaggar Basins and the principal ground water
reservoir in the area is unconsolidated alluvial deposits of Quaternary age. Ground water
in near surface zone occurs under water table conditions and occurs under semi confined
to confined conditions in deeper aquifers. Rainfall and seepage, canal networks and
irrigation is the principal source of ground water recharge in the area. The exploratory
drilling was carried out at 5 locations for exploratory wells and 34 locations for the
installation of piezometers. The drilling has been done to a maximum depth of about
463m which indicates the presence of 3 to 9 permeable granular zones with aggregate
thickness varying from 31 to 203m.The aquifer consists of fine to coarse sand, occasional
gravel and pebble. The thickness of alluvium as deduced from geophysical survey is
likely to be a few thousand meters. In the eastern part of the district falling in the upper
Yamuna Basin, the study of exploratory boreholes drilled during the Upper Jamuna
Project of Central Ground Water Board indicated presence of three aquifer groups upto
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 54
450m depth below ground level Depth to water level in the district during pre monsoon
ranges between 15.66m bgl to 31.35 m bgl. The depth to water level is deeper in the north
and central parts and shallow in south and south-western parts. The depth to water level
during post monsoon ranges between 17.1m bgl to 34.72m bgl. (Figure 3.4). The
seasonal fluctuation varies between –4.32m to 0.21m. The water table elevation in the
district varies between 242.75m and 220.03m above mean sea level. The elevation is
higher in eastern parts of the district in Ladwa block and gradually decreases towards
west in Pehowa block. In general the ground water flow direction is from east to west.
Source : cgwb.gov.in/District_Profile/Haryana/Kurukshetra
Figure 3.4: Depth of Water Level
3.7 Air Environment and Meteorology
3.7.1 Climate
The climate of the area is characterized by a hot and dry summer from March to May, a
south-west monsoon or rainy season from June to September, a pleasant post-monsoon or
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 55
retreating monsoon from October to November and a cool winter from December to
February. Therefore, climatologically, four seasons viz. summer (pre-monsoon),
monsoon, post-monsoon and winter could be deciphered comprising the following
months:
i. Summer : March, April, May
ii. Monsoon : June, July, August, September
iii. Post-monsoon : October, November, December
iv. Winter : January, February, March
Air Pollutants upon discharge to atmosphere pass through a number of mechanisms,
which include diffusion and transportation leading to dispersion. These mechanisms are
governed by the local atmospheric conditions. All these result in the necessity to collect
the meteorological parameters like ambient temperature, wind speed, wind direction, and
other weather conditions (relative humidity, atmospheric pressure etc.), which will be
ultimately used for the prediction of the ground level concentrations of the air pollutants
through mathematical modeling. For this purpose a temporary auto weather station was
installed to record micro meteorological data on wind speed, wind direction, Ambient
Temperature, Solar Insolation and Relative Humidity on hourly basis. The primary data
from the site was matched with secondary data of IMD station, Kurukshetra for data
proofing. A sophisticated on-site meteorological observatory was established near project
site and operated continuously for four months’ period (1st October 2014 to 31
st
December 2014 and 1st January 2015 to 31
st January 2015). The observatory was located
about 10 m above the ground level and ensured to be free from any obstruction to wind.
Besides, this location was found to be most suitable one being close to the project site.
The summary of the on-site data generated in respect of the above parameters for the
period mentioned above are presented in Table-3.2. The Wind rose diagram for the entire
period is shown in Figure 3.5.
3.7.2 Temperature
The monthly maximum and minimum temperature was recorded on-site during the
aforesaid monitoring period (1st October 2014 to 31
st January 2015) varied between 28.1-
37.3 °C and 6.2-16°C respectively with overall maximum and minimum temperatures
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 56
being 6.2°C and 37.3°C respectively. It could be observed that, the pattern of data
recorded on-site generally matches with the past data of IMD.
3.7.3 Relative Humidity
The monthly minimum and maximum relative humidity recorded onsite during the said
monitoring period varied between 33-41% and 76-69% respectively, the overall
minimum and maximum being 33% and 76% respectively.
3.7.4 Atmospheric Pressure
The overall minimum and maximum atmospheric pressures recorded on-site during the
said monitoring period were 754.1 mm Hg and 760.3 mm Hg respectively. Such values
compare well with the past IMD data.
3.7.5 Rainfall
The average annual rainfall at Kurukshetra, Haryana is 800 mm/year (As per IMD), 80%
of which occurs during monsoon months (June- October). 582 mm rainfall was recorded
during the monitoring period.
3.7.6 Wind Speed and Direction
During the said monitoring period, the monthly mean wind speed measured on-site varied
between 3.57 km/hr to 4.34 Km/hr for the monitoring period of October 2014 to
December 2014 and January 2015. The overall mean wind speed during the period was
4.09 Km/hr. The most predominant wind direction was North-West (NW) followed by
NNE and NNW during the monitoring period.
Table 3.2: Onsite Meteorological Data -1st October, 2014 – 31
st January, 2015
Month (s) Temperature Relative
Humidity
Barometric
pressure
Average
Velocity
(m/sec) Max 0C
Min 0C
Max.
%
Min.
%
08:30
hr
(mm
Hg)
17:30hr
(mm
Hg)
October, 2014 32.5 20.6 70 23 759.9 755.9 3.25
November, 2014 29.8 13.6 62 30 758.9 752.0 3.89
December, 2014 27.1 12.1 70 33 760.3 754.0 3.9
January, 2015 24.3 11.2 61 34 761.0 756.0 3.9
Average 32.5 11.2 70 23 761.0 754.0 3.9
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 57
Figure 3.5: Windrose Diagram
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 58
3.8 Ambient Air Quality
The ambient air quality with respect to the study area of 10 Km radius around the
contract area forms the baseline information. The various sources of air pollution in the
region are dust rising from unpaved roads, domestic fuel burning, vehicular traffic,
agricultural activities, other industries, etc. The prime objective of baseline air quality
monitoring is to assess existing air quality of the area. This will also be useful in
assessing the conformity to standards of the ambient air quality during the operations.
The baseline status of the ambient air quality has been assessed through scientifically
designed ambient air quality network. The design of monitoring network in the air quality
surveillance program has been based on the following considerations:
Meteorological conditions.
Topography of the study area.
Likely impact area.
3.8.1 Ambient Air Quality Monitoring
Ambient air monitoring was carried out for 4 month as per CPCB guidelines in the
surrounding areas of the project site to assess the ambient air quality. To know the
ambient air quality at a larger distance i.e. in the study area of 10 Km. radius, air quality
survey has been conducted at 06 locations over a period of Post Monsoon Season. Major
air pollutants viz, PM10, PM2.5, Sulphur Dioxide (SO2), Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2), methane
and non- methane Hydrocarbon representing the basic air pollutants in the region were
identified for Ambient Air Quality Monitoring (AAQM). The ambient air quality
monitoring stations were set up as par Table 3.3 and Figure -3.6.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 59
Table 3.3 (A) Procedures for Determining Various Air Quality Parameters
Parameters Testing Procedure
PM10 & PM 2.5 Gravimetric Method by using Repairable Particulate Matter sampler “Respairable
Dust Sampler” (RDS)
NO2
Absorption in diluted NaOH and then estimated calorimetrically with
sulphanilamide and N (I-Nepthyle) Ethylene diamine Dihydrochloride and
Hydrogen Peroxide (IS: 5182 1975, Part-VI).
SO2 Absorption in Sodium Tetra Chloromercurate followed by Colorimetric estimation
using P-Rosaniline hydrochloride and Formaldehyde (IS: 5182 Part – II, 2001).
Methane and
Non-Methane
Hydrocarbon
By Gas Chromatography
Table 3.3 (B) : Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Sampling Stations
Station Sampling
Location
Aerial
distance
(km) and
direction
from
Project
Site
Co-ordinates Sampling
Criterion
Latitude Longitude
A1 Project site -- 30°09'2.631"N 76°53'40.424"E --
A2 Near Shahabad
3.5Km,NW 30°10'1.03"N 76°52'22.978"E Upwind
Direction
A3 Village Padlu
5.6Km,NE 30°11'29.511"N 76°56'12.165"E Crosswind
Direction
A4 Village
Ahemadpur
6.0 Km,SW 36°55'1.02"N 76°50'45.99"E Crosswind
Direction
A5 Village
Machrauli
6.3 Km, SE 30°05'29.643"N 76°54'35.524"E Downwind
Direction
A6 Village
Narayangarh
6.7 Km, SE 36°06'28.43"N 76°56'57.10"E Downwind
Direction
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 60
3.8.2 Air Sampling Program
As stated earlier, the sampling at the above 06 stations were carried out during Post
Monsoon Season i.e. 1st October 2014 to 31
st January, 2015. The stations were selected
and located with due consideration to the meteorological conditions of the region. The
samples were collected as per the CPCB norms during study period.
3.8.3 Baseline Data
Six major air pollutants viz. PM10 and PM2.5, Sulphur Dioxide (SO2), Nitrogen Dioxide
(NO2), Methane and Non methane hydrocarbons were monitored to establish the baseline
air quality. The results are given in Table 3.4 and Figure -3.7. Figure 3.8 is showing the
photographs of the sampling site.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 61
Figure 3.6: Key Plan of Air Monitoring Stations
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 62
Table 3.4: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Results
Name of
Village (s)
PM10
(µg/m3
)
PM 2.5
(µg/m3
)
NO2
(µg/m3
)
SO2
(µg/m3
)
Non
Methan
e
Hydroc
arbons
(µg/m3
)
Methane
Hydroca
rbons
(µg/m3
)
Max. Min. Max. Min. Max. Min. Max. Min.
A1 54.8 41.4 30.1 25.0 20.1 15.0 12.6 7.9 <0.20 <0.20
A2 69.2 55.0 40.1 30.5 28.0 17.6 14.7 9.2 <0.20 <0.20
A3 64.9 55.0 35.0 30.1 24.1 18.5 12.1 8.5 <0.20 <0.20
A4 60.1 50.2 39.8 30.1 24.8 16.4 13.9 8.2 <0.20 <0.20
A5 55.7 45.2 35.0 25.1 22.0 18.4 13.0 7.7 <0.20 <0.20
A6 60.0 50.1 32.9 27.9 23.9 20.1 12.0 8.2 <0.20 <0.20
Conclusion
Ambient Air Quality Monitoring reveals that the minimum and maximum concentrations
of PM10 for all the 06 AAQM stations were found to be 41.4 g/m3 and 69.2 g/m
3
respectively, while for PM2.5 it vary between 25.0 g/m3 to 40.1 g/m
3. As far as the
gaseous pollutants SO2 and NO2 are concerned, the prescribed CPCB limit of 80 g/m3
for residential and rural areas has never surpassed at any station. The maximum and
minimum concentrations of SO2 were found to be 14.7 g/m3 to 25.0 g/m
3 respectively.
The maximum and minimum concentrations of NO2 were found to be 15.0 g/m3 to 28.0
g/m3 respectively.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 63
Figure 3.7: Graph Showing Pollutants Concentration of the Study Area
Figure 3.8: Photographs of Air Quality Monitoring
3.9 Noise Environment
Noise often defined as unwanted sound, interferes with speech communication, causes
annoyance, distracts from work, disturb sleep, thus deteriorating quality of human
environment. Noise Pollution survey has therefore been carried out. Noise levels were
measured in residential areas and other settlements located within 10 km radius around
the site.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 64
3.9.1 Noise Analysis within the Study Area
The noise analysis within the study area was recorded using 4012 Maxtech sound level
meter. The analysis reveals that the noise’s well within the permissible range. The
location of Noise level monitoring is presented in Table 3.5 and Figure 3.9 and the
levels recorded are as stated in Table 3.6. Figure 3.10 shows the photographs of the
sampling location.
Table 3.5 : Noise Monitoring Sampling Stations
Station Sampling Location Aerial
distance
(km) and
direction
from Project
Site
Co-ordinates
Latitude Longitude
N1 Project site -- 30°09'2.631"N 76°53'40.424"E
N2 Near Shahabad 3.5Km,NW 30°10'1.03"N 76°52'22.978"E
N3 Village Padlu 5.6Km,NE 30°11'29.511"N 76°56'12.165"E
N4 Village Ahemadpur 6.0 Km,SW 36°55'1.02"N 76°50'45.99"E
N5 Village Machrauli 6.3 Km, SE 30°05'29.643"N 76°54'35.524"E
N6 Village Narayangarh 6.7 Km, SE 36°06'28.43"N 76°56'57.10"E
Table 3.6 : Noise Monitoring Result
S. No Locations
Noise Level Leq. dB (A)
Day Time
(6:00 A.M. to 10:00 P.M.)
Night Time
(10:00 P.M. to
6:00 A.M.)
1. N1 50.14 44.33
2. N2 54.17 44.70
3. N3 49.67 43.00
4. N4 54.10 42.99
5. N5 50.10 42.98
6. N6 52.10 42.00
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 65
Conclusion
Ambient noise levels were measured at 06 locations around the proposed project site. A
noise level varies from 42.00 to 54.10 Leq dB during day time and during night time.
Maximum and minimum noise levels recorded during the day time were from 54.10 Leq
dB and 49.67 Leq dB respectively and maximum and minimum level of noise during
night time were 44.70 Leq dB and 42.00 Leq dB respectively. Thus noise levels at all
locations were observed to be within the prescribed limits.
From the above study and discussions it can be concluded that noise levels in the study
area are well within the prescribed limits as prescribed by the CPCB and State Pollution
ControlBoard.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 66
Figure 3.9: Key Plan of Noise Monitoring Station
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 67
Figure 3.10: Photographs of Noise Monitoring
3.9.2 Traffic Study
Traffic study measurements were performed at two locations at National Highway-1 and
State Highway-7 to assess impact on local transport infrastructure due to this proposed
project. Traffic study measurements were performed at two locations of these stations is
marked on the map in Figure 3.11. Road and highway studies are given in Table-3.7.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 68
Figure 3.11: Roads and Highways in the Study Area
Table 3.7 : Traffic Study Locations
Traffic data collected continuously for 24 hours by visual observation and counting of
vehicles under three categories, viz., heavy motor vehicles, light motor vehicles and
two/three wheelers. As traffic densities on the roads are high, two skilled persons were
deployed simultaneously at each station during each shift- one person on each of the two
directions for counting the traffic. At the end of each hour, fresh counting and recording
was undertaken. Total numbers of vehicles per hour under the three categories were
determined and given in Table 3.8. Existing traffic scenario is given in Table 3.9.
Modified traffic scenario given in Table 3.10.
Name of National/State
Highway
Direction
Up Down
NH-1 Ambala Delhi
SH-7 Ladwa Shahabad
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 69
Table 3.8 : No. of Vehicles per Day
S.
No.
Vehicles
Distribution
Number of Vehicles
Distribution/day
Passenger
Car Unit
(PCU)
Total Number of
Vehicle (PCU)/Hour
NH-1 SH-7 NH-1 SH-7
1. Cars 24500 20050 1 24500 20050
2. Buses 1800 1680 3 5400 5040
3. Two
wheelers
2800 3400 0.5 1400 1700
4. Three
wheelers
2950 2940 1.5 4425 4410
5. Trucks 2500 1200 3 7500 3600
Total 43225/24 =
1801
34800/24
=1450
Table 3.9: Existing Traffic Scenario and LOS
Road V (Volume in
PCU/hr)
C (Capacity in
PCU/hr)
Existing V/C
Ratio
LOS
NH-1 1801 3334 0.5 C
SH-7 1450 2400 0.6 C Note: The existing level may be “Average” for both NH-1 and SH-7.
V/C LOS Performance
0.0-0.2 A Excellent
0.2-0.4 B Very Good
0.4-0.6 C Good/ Average/ Fair
0.6-0.8 D Poor
0.8-1.0 E Very Poor Note: Capacity as per IRC: 64-1990
During Plant Operation
S.No. Mode of Transportation No. of Trips PCU
1. Tankers 2 6
3. Tankers 4 12
4. Bus 6 18
5. Car 10 10
Total 46
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 70
Table 3.10 : Modified Traffic Scenario and LOS
Road Increased PCU’S-
State/National
Highway
V C Modified V/C
Ratio
LOS
NH-1 1801+46 1847 3334 0.55 C
SH-7 1450+46 1496 2400 0.62 C
3.10 Land Environment
3.10.1 Soil Quality and Characteristics
The information on soils has been collected from various secondary sources and also
through primary soil sampling analysis of which is described in this section. For studying
the soil profile of the region, 6 locations were selected to assess the existing soil
conditions around the contract area representing various land use conditions. The
concentrations of physical and chemical parameters were determined. The sampling
locations have been finalized with the following objectives:
To determine the baseline soil characteristics of the study area; and
To determine the impact of industrialization on soil characteristics.
Quality of the soil in the area is showing a marked diversity in nature depending upon the
parent rock and climatic conditions prevailing in different parts of the district. The
analysis results of the soil samples collected are given in Table-3.11. Photographs of the
sampling location and sampling location map are presented in Figure 3.12 and Figure
3.13. Soil testing results are given in Table -3.12.
Table 3.11 : Soil Monitoring Station Details
Station Sampling Location Aerial
distance (km)
and direction
from Project
Site
Co-ordinates
Latitude Longitude
S1 Project site -- 30°09'2.631"N 76°53'40.424"E
S2 Near Shahabad 3.5Km,NW 30°10'1.03"N 76°52'22.978"E
S3 Village Padlu 5.6Km,NE 30°11'29.511"N 76°56'12.165"E
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 71
S4 Village Ahemadpur 6.0 Km,SW 36°55'1.02"N 76°50'45.99"E
S5 Village Machrauli 6.3 Km, SE 30°05'29.643"N 76°54'35.524"E
S6 Village Narayangarh 6.7 Km, SE 36°06'28.43"N 76°56'57.10"E
Figure 3.12: Photographs of Soil Sampling
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 72
Figure 3.13: Key Plan of Soil Sampling Stations
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 73
Table 3.12 : Soil Analysis Result
Conclusion
Soil is the media for supplying the nutrients for plant growth. Nutrients are available to
plants at certain pH and pH of soils can reflect by addition of pollutants in it either by air,
or by water or by solid waste or by all of these. In order to establish the baseline status of
soil characteristics, soil samples were collected at 6 sampling locations. The analysis
results show that soil was basic in nature as pH value ranges from 7.23 to 8.10 with water
holding capacity of 36.78 to 42.80%. The concentration of Nitrogen, Phosphorus and
S.
No.
Parameter S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6
1. pH (at 25 0C) 7.23 7.45 7.55 7.48 7.45 8.10
2. Conductivity (mS/cm) 0.350 0.443 0.345 0.349 0.301 0.380
3. Soil Texture Sandy
loam
Sandy
loam
Silty Sandy loam Sandy
loam
Sandy loam
4. Colour Brownish
yellow
Brownish
yellow
Sandy
loam
Brownish
yellow
Brownish
yellow
Brownish
yellow
5. Water holding capacity
(%)
36.87 42.80 40.10 36.78 40.90 42.20
6. Bulk Density (gm/cc) 8.80 8.50 5.40 6.80 9.60 10.10
7. Chloride (mg/100g) 65.43 94.50 86.20 87.98 56.50 92.10
8. Calcium as Ca (mg/kg) 16.0 12.9 18.40 16.0 19.20 20.10
9. Sodium (mg/100gm) 42.2 49.2 52.10 39.8 38.50 59.90
10. Potassium (mg/100gm) 123.23 156.1 112.70 178.90 118.50 101.43
11. Organic matter 0.65 0.77 0.88 0.76 0.67 0.78
12. Magnesium as Mg
(mg/kg)
12.50 6.9 19.94 20.10 7.1 16.50
13. Available Nitrogen as
N (kg. /hec.)
205.4 239.8 232.10 248.67 198.50 218.4
14. Available Phosphorus
(kg. /hec.)
32.50 38.20 34.80 42.98 28.5 44.80
15. Zinc (mg/100gm) 4.98 4.22 5.11 3.87 4.99 6.70
6. Mangnese as
Mn(mg/100gm)
4.10 4.09 3.98 4.11 3.98 2.99
17. Chromium as
Cr(mg/100gm)
2.54 3.21 2.78 3.11 3.78 3.10
18. Lead as Pb(mg/100gm) 1.61 1.65 1.98 1.04 1.25 3.26
19. Cadmium as Cd
(mg/100gm)
3.10 1.78 3.88 1.45 2.56 1.50
20. Copper as Cu
(mg/100gm)
2.90 2.11 2.99 2.23 2.76 2.98
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 74
Potassium has been found to be in good amount in the soil samples. Soil texture is Sandy
loam.
3.11 Water Environment
Surface Water
Surface water sampling locations is given in Table 3.13 and results are given in Table
3.14. Sampling location is presented in Figure 3.14.
Table 3.13 : Surface Water Sampling Stations
Station Sampling Location Aerial
distance
(Km) and
direction
from Project
Site
Co-ordinates
Latitude Longitude
SW1 Markanada River 3.5Km,NW 30°10'37.809"N 76°53'31.184"E
SW2 Village Chapra 1.5 Km,S 30°8'8.691"N 76°53'57.346"E
SW3 Village Kharindwa 5.6 Km,SE 30°6'37.580"N 76°56'8.54"E
SW4 Village Ahemadpur 6.0 Km,SW 36°55'1.02"N 76°50'45.99"E
Table 3.14 : Surface Water Sampling Results
S.No. Parameter SW1 SW2 SW3 SW4
1. pH (at 250C) 7.80 8.40 7.60 7.90
2. Total hardness as
CaCO3 (mg/L)
252.0 220.0 276.0 276.0
3. Calcium as Ca (mg/L) 75.35 75.35 62.52 70.54
4. Alkalinity as CaCO3
(mg/L)
232.0 224.0 244.0 260.0
5. Chloride as Cl (mg/L) 73.45 63.98 67.98 69.48
6. Residual free Chlorine
(mg/L)
BDL (DL
0.20)
BDL (DL 0.20) BDL (DL 0.20) BDL (DL
0.20)
7. Cyanide as CN (mg/L) BDL (DL
0.02)
BDL (DL 0.02) BDL (DL 0.02) BDL (DL
0.02)
8. Magnesium as Mg
(mg/L)
15.55 7.78 29.16 24.30
9. Total Dissolved Solids
(mg/L)
435.0 526.0 436.5 410.90
10. Sulphate as SO4 (mg/L) 23.28 17.47 28.13 22.16
11. Fluoride as F (mg/L) 0.44 0.36 0.93 0.76
12. Nitrate as NO3(mg/L) 14.33 15.14 10.20 15.26
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 75
S.No. Parameter SW1 SW2 SW3 SW4
13. Iron as Fe (mg/L) 0.12 0.18 0.23 0.1
14. Aluminium as Al
(mg/L)
BDL (DL
0.03)
BDL (DL 0.03) BDL (DL 0.03) BDL (DL
0.03)
15. Boron as B(mg/L) BDL (DL
0.50)
BDL (DL 0.50) BDL (DL 0.50) BDL (DL
0.50)
16. COD (mg/L) 39.0 39.20 44.10 34.30
17. BOD (3 days at 270C) 12.3 9.90 13.80 11.10
18. Phenolic
Compounds(mg/L)
BDL (DL
0.01)
BDL (DL 0.01) BDL (DL 0.01) BDL (DL
0.01)
19. Anionic detergents as
MBAS (mg/L)
BDL (DL
0.02)
BDL (DL 0.02) BDL (DL 0.02) BDL (DL
0.02)
20. Hexa Chromium as Cr+6
(mg/L)
BDL (DL
0.01)
BDL (DL 0.01) BDL (DL 0.01) BDL (DL
0.01)
21. Zinc as Zn (mg/L) 1.60 0.06 0.04 1.20
22. Copper as Cu (mg/L) 0.20 1.06 1.98 0.03
23. Manganese as Mn
(mg/L)
BDL (DL
0.10)
BDL (DL 0.10) BDL (DL 0.10) BDL (DL
0.10)
24. Cadmium as Cd (mg/L) BDL (DL
0.001)
BDL (DL
0.001)
BDL (DL 0.001) BDL (DL
0.001)
25. Lead as Pb (mg/L) BDL (DL,
0.01)
BDL (DL, 0.01) BDL (DL, 0.01) BDL (DL,
0.01
26. Selenium as Se (mg/L) BDL (DL,
0.001)
BDL (DL,
0.001)
BDL (DL, 0.001) BDL (DL,
0.001)
27. Arsenic as As (mg/L) BDL (DL,
0.01)
BDL (DL, 0.01) BDL (DL, 0.01) BDL (DL,
0.01)
28. Mercury as Hg (mg/L) BDL (DL,
0.001)
BDL (DL,
0.001)
BDL (DL, 0.001) BDL (DL,
0.001)
29. Total Coliform
(MPN/100mL)
6.1 6.0 5.5 4.0
30. E.coli (MPN/100mL) Absent Absent Absent Absent
C) Ground Water
The Quality of ground water was studied by collecting six water samples from
representative hand pumps, tube wells. Sampling points were decided using google image
and field survey. Standard procedures were followed for the sampling and analysis of
physico–chemical parameters of water. Table 3.15 shows the details of location of water
sampling stations and results of different parameters are given in Table 3.16. Photographs
of the sampling location are presented in Figure 3.15.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 76
Table 3.15: Ground Water Sampling Stations
Station Sampling Location Aerial
distance (km)
and direction
from Project
Site
Co-ordinates
Latitude Longitude
W1 Project site -- 30°09'2.631"N 76°53'40.424"E
W2 Near Shahabad 3.5Km,NW 30°10'1.03"N 76°52'22.978"E
W3 Village Padlu 5.6Km,NE 30°11'29.511"N 76°56'12.165"E
W4 Village Ahemadpur 6.0 Km,SW 36°55'1.02"N 76°50'45.99"E
W5 Village Machrauli 6.3 Km, SE 30°05'29.643"N 76°54'35.524"E
W6 Village Narayangarh 6.7 Km, SE 36°06'28.43"N 76°56'57.10"E
3.11.1 Result
Table 3.16 : Ground Water Analysis Result
S.
No.
Parameter W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 Desirabl
e Limit
Permissible
Limit
1. pH (at 25 0C) 7.60 7.80 7.90 8.10 8.30 8.10 6.5 to 8.5 No Relaxation
2. Colour (Hazen) BDL(DL,5) BDL(DL,5) BDL(DL,5) BDL(DL,5) BDL(DL,5) BDL(DL,5) 5 15
3. Turbidity (NTU) BDL(DL,1) BDL(DL,1) BDL(DL,1) BDL(DL,1) BDL(DL,1) BDL(DL,1) 1 5
4. Odour Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeabl
e
Agreeable
5. Taste Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeabl
e
Agreeable
6. Total Hardness as
CaCO3 (mg/L)
268.
0
316.0 156.0 228.0 296.0 416.0 200 600
7. Calcium as Ca
(mg/L)
49.70 76.95 41.68 46.49 81.76 73.75 75 200
8. Alkalinity as
CaCO3 (mg/L)
300.0 300.0 268.0 248.0 284.0 396.0 200 600
9. Chloride as Cl
(mg/L)
25.99 31.99 19.99 29.78 23.99 39.99 250 1000
Residual
Free Chlorine
(mg/L)
BDL(DL,0.20
)
BDL(DL,0.20) BDL(DL,0.20) BDL(DL,0.20) BDL(DL,0.20) BDL(DL,0.
20)
0.2 1
10. Cyanide as CN
(mg/L)
BDL(DL,0.02
)
BDL(DL,0.02) BDL(DL,0.02) BDL(DL,0.02) BDL(DL,0.02) BDL(DL,0.
02)
0.05 No Relaxation
11. Magnesium as 34.99 5.83 12.64 27.22 22.36 56.38 30 100
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 77
Mg(mg/L)
12. Total Dissolved
Solids (mg/L)
360.0 404.9 302.00 320.5 378.8 532.50 500 2000
13. Sulphate as
SO4(mg/L)
9.52 17.05 6.39 7.95 8.38 38.92 200 400
14. Fluoride as
F (mg/L)
0.24 0.33 0.33 0.47 0.16 0.28 1.0 1.5
15. Nitrate as
NO3(mg/L)
3.24 9.06 7.94 4.94 8.85 12.34 45 No Relaxation
16. Iron as Fe(mg/L) 0.11 0.11 0.04 0.18 0.11 0.14 0.3 No Relaxation
17. Aluminium as
Al(mg/L)
BDL(DL,
0.03)
BDL(DL, 0.03) BDL(DL, 0.03) BDL(DL, 0.03) BDL(DL, 0.03) BDL(DL,
0.03)
0.03 0.2
18. Boron(mg/L) BDL(DL,
0.50)
BDL(DL,
0.50)
BDL(DL,
0.50)
BDL(DL,
0.50)
BDL(DL,
0.50)
BDL(DL,
0.50)
0.5 1.0
20. Phenolic
Compounds(mg/
L)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
0.001 0.002
22. Anionic
Detergents as
MBAS(mg/L)
BDL(DL,
0.02)
BDL(DL,
0.02)
BDL(DL,
0.02)
BDL(DL,
0.02)
BDL(DL, 0.02) BDL(DL,
0.02)
0.2 1.0
Hexa Chromium
as Cr+6 (mg/L
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL, 0.01) BDL(DL,
0.01)
0.05 No
Relaxation
23. Zinc as Zn(mg/L) 0.52 0.40 0.70 0.40 0.50 0.60 5 15
24. Copper as
Cu(mg/L)
BDL(DL,
0.02)
BDL(DL,
0.02)
BDL(DL,
0.02)
BDL(DL,
0.02)
BDL(DL, 0.02) BDL(DL,
0.02)
0.05 1.5
25. Manganese as
Mn
(mg/L)
BDL(DL, 0.10
)
BDL(DL, 0.10
)
BDL(DL, 0.10
)
BDL(DL, 0.10
)
BDL(DL, 0.10 ) BDL(DL,
0.10)
0.1 0.3
26. Cadmium as Cd
(mg/L)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
0.003 No
Relaxation
27. Lead as Pb
(mg/L)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL, 0.01) BDL(DL,
0.01)
0.01 No
Relaxation
28. Selenium as Se
(mg/L)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL, 0.01) BDL(DL,
0.01)
0.01 No
Relaxation
29. Arsenic as As
(mg/L)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL,
0.01)
BDL(DL, 0.01) BDL(DL,
0.01)
0.01 No
Relaxation
30. Mercury as Hg
(mg/L)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
BDL(DL,
0.001)
0.001 No
Relaxation
31. Total Coliform
MPN/100mL
Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent - 10.00
32. E.Coli
MPN/100mL
Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 78
Conclusion
Analysis results of ground water reveal the following;
pH varies from to 7.60 to 8.30
Total Hardness varies from 156.0 to 416.0 mg/L
Total Dissolved Solids varies from 302.00 to 532.50 mg/L
A review of the above chemical analysis reveals that water from all sources remains
suitable for drinking purposes as all the constituents are within the limits prescribed for
drinking water standards promulgated by Indian Standards (IS: 10500).
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 79
Figure 3.14: Key Plan of Water Sampling Stations
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 80
Figure 3.15: Photograph of Water sampling
3.12 Biological Environment
Terrestrial Floral and Faunal Components of the Study Area
Most of villages in the study area are engaged in crop cultivation and people are fully
depended on the agriculture of this area. Villages are scattered in between the large patches of
agriculture lands. The tree cover in the study area is scanty restricted only in the habituated
areas of the village and few along the boundary of the agricultural fields and road sides. It
was observed that most of the villages in the study area are with large village pond (Johad)
used in rain water harvesting. The name of villages in the study area has some relation like
male/female; brothers/sister; brother/brother; husband/wife etc. as Yara/Yari,
Kalsana/Kalsani, Padlu/Dadlu, Sujra/Sujri, Chapra/Chapri, Bethala/Bertholi, etc. The study
area is also characterized by many water logged regions occupied by hydrophytes. Some
people are engaged in poultry farming while many people are engaged in domestic animal for
milk production like buffalo and cows.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 81
Figure 3.16 Proposed Site for Ethanol Unit
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 82
Figure 3.17: Aquatic habitat of Study area
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 83
Northern part of the study area is occupied by Markanda River and the famers are practicing
the agriculture and some part is occupied by small patches of Prosopus juliflora while other
villages are occupied by the small patches of scrub land with sparse population of Prosopus
juliflora and Munja (Saccharum munja). The tree species, herbs and shrubs and major crops,
were documented during this base line study.
Figure 3.18 : Markanda River
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 84
Floral Diversity of the Study Area
The objective this floral inventory of the study area, is to provide necessary information on
floristic structure in the study area for formulating effective management and conservation
measures. The climatic, edaphic and biotic variations with their complex interrelationship and
composition of species, which are adapted to these variations, have resulted in different
vegetation cover, characteristic of each region (Ohasi, 1975). The tree species, herbs, shrubs,
climbers and major crops, were documented during this base line study (Jain, 1968; 1991).
The list of floral species documented in the study area is enlisted in table 1-4.
Trees: The dominant trees in the study area are Azadirachta indica (Neem), Mangifera
indica (Aam), Dalbergia sisoo (Shisham), Saraca asoca (Ashok tree), Syzygium cumini
(Jamun), Eucalyptus sp. Total 29 species of trees belong to 16 families are enumerated from
the study area.
Table3.17. Trees in the Study area
S.No. Family and Scientific name Vernacular name
1 Anacardiaceae
1/1 Mangifera indica
Aam
2 Arecaceae
2/1 Phoenix sylvestris
Kajoor
3 Bombacaceae
3/1 Bombax ceiba Semal
4 Caesalpiniaceae
4/1 Delonix regia Gaulmor
5/2 Cassia fistula Golden Shower
6/3 Cassia siamea Amaltas
5 Caricaceae
7/1 Carica papaya Papaya
6 Combretaceae
8/1 Terminalia arjuna Arjun
7 Fabaceae
9/1 Saraca asoca Asoka
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 85
10/2 Tamarindus indica Imli
11/3 Dalbergia sisoo Shisam
12/4 Acacia catachu Khair
8 Malvaceae
13/1 Thespesia populnea Paras pipal
9 Meliaceae
14/1 Azadirachta indica Neem
15/2 Melia azadirachta Bakain
10 Mimosaceae
16/1 Acacia nilotica Babool
17/2 Leucaena leucocephala Pardesi Baval
18/3 Albizia lebbeck Siris
19/4 Prosopis cineraria Khejari
11 Moraceae
20/1 Ficus benghalensis Bargad
21/2 Ficus religiosa Pipal
12 Myrtaceae
22/1 Eucalyptus sp. Nilgari
23/2 Syzygium cumini Jamun
24/3 Psidium amplexicaule Amrud
13 Papilionaceae
25/1 Pongamia pinnata Karanj
14 Rutaceae
26/1 Citrus limon Nibu
15 Salicaceae
27/1 Populus deltoides Popular
16 Rhamnaceae
28/1 Zizyphus mauritiana Ber
29/1 Zizyphus vulgaris Ber
Shrubs: Shrubs encountered during the present survey are given in the Table 2. Total 18
shrub species belong to 15 families are enumerated from the study area. The dominant shrub
community in this area was represented by Kaner (Nerium indicum), Prosopis juliflora
(Bilayati babool), Calotropis procera, (Akoda) and Ipomoea fistulosa, etc. The shrubs
observed in the study area are given in the table 3.18.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 86
Table 3.18 Lists of Shrubs in the Study Area
S.No. Family and Scientific name Vernacular name
1 Apocynaceae
1/1 Nerium indicum Kaner
2 Asclepiadaceae
2/1 Calotropis procera Akoda
3 Balanitaceae
3/1 Balanites aegyptiaca Ingorio
4 Bignoniaceae
4/1 Tecoma stans Peilafol
5 Cactaceae
5/1 Cereus peruvianus Cactus
6 Caesalpiniaceae
6/1 Cassia auriculata -
7 Capparaceae
7/1 Capparis decidua -
8 Compositae
8/1 Xanthium strumarium Gokhru
9 Convolvulaceae
9/1 Ipomoea fistulosa Besharm
10 Euphorbiaceae
10/1 Euphorbia neriifolia Thor
11/2 Jatropha curcas Ratanjot
12/3 Ricinus communis Arand
10 Lythraceae
13/1 Decodon verticillatus Water willow
11 Malvaceae
14/1 Hibiscus rosasinensis Gurhal
12 Musaceae
15/1 Musa paradisiaca Kela
13 Mimosaceae
16/1 Prosopis juliflora Bilayati babool
14 Nyctaginaceae
17/1 Bougainvillea spectabilis Bougainvelia
15 Solanaceae
18/1 Datura metel Datura
Herbs: The herbaceous cover observed in this region is given in the table 3. The most of the
undergrowth was dried up, except near water logged regions and along the periphery of the
village ponds. Total 24 species belongs to 16 family were recorded from the study area.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 87
Table 3.19 List of Herbaceous species observed in the study area
S.No. Family and Scientific name Vernacular name
1 Acanthaceae
1/1 Hygrophila auriculata Kokilaksha
2 Asteraceae
2/1 Blumea sps. -
3/2 Eclipta prostrata Bhangro
3 Boraginaceae
4/1
Trichodesma indicum -
4 Chenopodiaceae
5/1 Suaeda nudiflora Moras
6/2 S. fruticosa L. -
5 Cyperaceae
7/1 Cyperus bulbosus -
8/2 Cyperus difformis -
9/3 Cyperus rotundus
6 Lamiaceae ( Labiatae)
10/1 Ocimum basilicum L. Damaro
11/2 Ocimum sanctum L. Tuli
7 Liliaceae
12/1 Aloe barbadensis Mill. Kunvarpato
8 Nymphaeaceae
13/1 Nymphaea stellata
9 Nyctaginaceae
14/1 Boerhavia diffusa L. -
15/2 Boerhavia chinensis Druce -
10 Papilionaceae
16/1 Cortalaria medicaginea Ran methi
17/2 Indigofera oblongifolia -
11 Poaceae (Gramineae)
18/1 Cynodon dactylon Pers. -
19/2 Pennisetum typhoides (Burm.) Bajri
12 Poligonaceae
20/1 Poligonum sp. -
13 Pontederiaceae
21/1 Eichhornia crassipes Jalkumbhi
14 Potamogetonaceae
22/1 Potomogeton sp. -
15 Solanaceae
23/1 Solanum surattense Burm. Bhoringini
16 Typhaceae
24/1 Typha angustata -
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 88
Climbers and Twiners: The climbers and twiners observed along the agricultural hedges
and road side hedges of the study area are given in the table 3.20. Total 4 species of climbers/
twiners belongs to 2 families are recorded from the area.
Table 3.20. List of Climbers Observed in the Study Area
S.No. Family and Scientific name Vernacular name
1. Convolvulaceae
1/1 Ipomoea obscura Pan Bel
2. Cucurbitaceae
2/1 Citrullus colocynthis Badi indrayan
3/2 Coccinia grandis Kunduru
4/3 Luffa cylindrica Galku
Cultivated Plants in the Study Area
The crop occupying the highest percentage of the sown area of this region is taken as the
major crop and all other possible alternative crops which are sown in this region either as
substitutes of the base crop in the same season or as the crops which fit in the rotation in the
subsequent season, are considered as minor crop.
a. Major Crops: Mainly people of Sahabad (Tehsil) area was dependent on agricultural
corps. Major crops in the study area are Paddy (Oryza sativa), Sugar cane (Saccharum
officinarum), Maize (Zea mays), Wheat (Triticum aestivum) and Barley (Hordeum vulgare).
b. Minor crops: The minor crops of this region are Mustard (Brassica campestris var.),
Green gram (Vigna radiate), Sesamum (Sesamum inicum), Pigeon Pea (Punica granatum)
Jowar (Sorghum bicolar) and Black Gram (Vigna mungo) during the whole year.
Rare and Endangered Flora in the Study Area: Among the enumerated flora in the study
area, none of them were assigned any threat category by Red data book of Indian Plants (Jain
and Sastry, 1984; Nayar and Sastry, 1987; 1988; 1990; Oldfield et al., 1998; Kholia and
Bhakuni, 2009) and Red list of threatened Vascular plants (IUCN, 2010).
Endemic Plants of the Study Area: Among recorded plant species observed, none can be
assigned the status of endemic plant of this region.
Status of the Forest, Their Category in Study Area: No forest was observed in the study
area except few scrub land and grazing lands with thin vegetation cover of Prosopis juliflora
and Acacia nilotica.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 89
Faunal Biodiversity of Study Area
Avifauna: The sighting of bird species was very lass during the study period. The most
commonly spotted bird species of this area were; Cattle Egret, Intermediate Egret, Black-
winged Stilt, Red-wattled Lapwing, Rock Pigeon, Eurasian Collared-Dove, Chestnut-headed
Bee-eater, Bank Myna and Common Myna. Only one Indian Peafowl was observed which is
listed as schedule –I as per IWPA, 1972. List of schedule -1 as per Wild life Protection Act
1972, species is given in the table 3.21. Systematic account of the birds in the study area with
the status of occurrence is given in the table 3.21.
Table 3.21 Schedule –I Bird(s) of Study Area
Species As IWPA 1972 IUCN CITES
Indian Peafowl
(Pavo cristatus)
Schedule I Least Concern ver 3.1 Not listed
Table 3.22 Systematic Lists of Birds in the Study Area with Distribution (Dist.) Status
Old Common name New Common Name Scientific Name Dist.
I ORDER: APODIFORMES
Family: Apodidae (swifts)
House swift Little Swift Apus affinis R
II ORDER: FALCONIFORMES
Family: Accipitridae (vulture, Sparrow hawk, Eagle, Harrier, Kite and Vulture)
Black-winged Kite Black-winged Kite Elanus caeruleus R
III. ORDER: CICONIIFORMES
Family: Ardeidae (heron, Egret, Bittern)
Cattle Egret Cattle Egret Bubulcus ibis R
Median or Smaller Egret Intermediate Egret Egretta intermedia R
Little Egret Little Egret Egretta garzetta R
Pond Heron Indian Pond-Heron Ardeola grayii R
Family: Charadriidae (Plover, Stilt, Oystercatcher, Lapwing, Avocet )
Black-winged Stilt Black-winged Stilt Himantopus himantopus R
Red-wattled Lapwing Red-wattled Lapwing Vanellus indicus R
IV ORDER: COLUMBIFORMES
Family: Columbidae (Pigeon, Dove)
Blue Rock Pigeon Rock Pigeon Columba livia R
Ring Dove Eurasian Collared-Dove Streptopelia decaocto R
V ORDER: CORACIFORMES
Family: Dacelonidae (Kingfishers)
White breasted Kingfisher White-throated
Kingfisher
Halcyon smyrnensis R
Family: Coraciidae (Roller)
BlueJay or Roller Indian Roller Coracias benghalensis R
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 90
Family: Meropidae (Bee Eater)
Chestnut-headed Bee-eater Chestnut-headed Bee-
eater
Merops leschenaulti R
Blue-cheeked Bee-eater Blue-cheeked Bee-eater Merops persicus R
VI. ORDER: CUCULIFORMES
Family: Cuculidae (cuckoo, Koel)
Koel Asian Koel Eudynamys scolopacea R
Indian Drongo Cuckoo Drongo Cuckoo Surniculus lugubris R
VII. ORDER: GALLIFORMES
Family: Phasianidae (Peafowl, Partridge, Quail, francolin, Spur fowl, Jungle fowl,
Monal)
Common Peafowl Indian Peafowl Pavo cristatus R
Common Quail Common Quail Coturnix coturnix R
VIII. ORDER: GRUIFORMES
Family: Rallidae (Waterhen, coot, crake water cock, Moorhen, Rail)
White-breasted Water hen White-breasted Water
hen
Amaurornis phoenicurus R
Indian Moorhen Common Moorhen Gallinula chloropus R
XI. ORDER: PASSERIFORMES
Family: Corvidae
House Crow House Crow Corvus splendens R
Black drongo- King Crow Black Drongo Dicrurus macrocercus R
Family: Muscicapidae (Short wing, Chat, Robin, Shama
Indian Robin Indian Robin Saxicoloides fulicata R
Family: Nectariniidae (Sun Birds, Flower pecker, Spider hunter)
Purple Sunbird Purple Sunbird Nectarinia asiatica R
Family: Passeridae (Avadavat, Pipit, Wagtail, Munia, Snowfinch, Sparrow, Accentor)
House Sparrow House Sparrow Passer domesticus R
Family: Pycnonotidae (Bulbul)
Red-whiskered Bulbul Red-whiskered Bulbul Pycnonotus jocosus R
Family: Sturnidae (Myna, Starling)
Bank Myna Bank Myna Acridotheres ginginianus R
Indian Myna Common Myna Acridotheres tristis R
Family: Sylviidae (Warbler, Browning, Fulvetta, Babbler, Laughing thrash, Tailor birds)
Tailorbird Common Tailorbird Orthotomus sutorius R
IX. ORDER: PSITTACIFORMES
Family: Psittacidae (Parrot and Parakeet)
Rose-ringed Parakeet Rose-ringed Parakeet Psittacula krameri R
Family: Ploceidae
Baya Baya weaver Ploceus philippinus R
Note: R = Widespread Resident, r = Very Local Resident, W = Widespread Winter Visitor, w
= Sparse Winter Visitor, RW =Resident and winter visitor as per the distribution given in
WCMC, Check list of Indian Birds.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 91
Butterflies from the study area: Butterflies observed during the present study are documented in
the Table 3.23.
Table 3.23 Butterflies in the Study Area
Scientific name and family Common name
Family Papilionidae
Papilio polytes Common Mormon
Family Pieridae
Eurema hecabe Common Grass yellow
Ixias Marianne White orange tip
Family: Nymphalidae
Danaus genutia Cramer Stripped Tiger
Hypolimanas misippus Danaid egg fly
Mycalesis perseus Common bush brown
Herpetofauna: Frog and toads were sighted during the study period. The reptiles’ document in
the region is given in the table 3.24.
Table 3.24 Reptiles and Amphibian in the Study Area
S.No. Common Name Scientific name Schedule as IWPA, 1972
1. Toad Bufo bufo Not listed
2. Medhak Rana tigrina Schedule IV
3. Common Garden Lizard Calotes versicolor Not listed
4. Fan-Throated Lizard Sitana ponticeriana Not listed
5. House Gecko Hemidactylus flaviviridis Not listed
Mammals: The wild mammals observed other than the domesticated ones are given in the table
below.
Table 3.25. Mammals in Study area
S.No. Common Name Scientific name Status as per IWPA 1972
1. Bat Rousettus leschenaulti Schedule V
2. Common House rat Rattus rattus Schedule V
3. Five striped Palm Squirrel Funambulus pennanii Schedule IV
4. Indian field mouse Mus booduga Schedule IV
5. Nilgai (Blue Bull) Boselaphus tragocamelus Schedule-III
Fishes: The villages have pond (Johad) for rainwater harvesting and the water used by animals
and villages both for bathing and drinking. Some village pond in the study area is used for
aquaculture. The Markanda River is the major water body in the study area, but it has no major
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 92
water stream during the study, hence no key aquatic life observed. The fishes observed in the
study area are given in the table below.
Table 3.26 Fishes in Study area
S.No. Local Name Scientific name
1. Kali Machali Barbus chilinadea
2. Mahseer Tor barakae
3. Rohu Labeo rohita
4. Singi Clarias batrachus
Domestic Animals in the study area
The domestic animals observed in the study area are given in the table below.
Table 3.27 Domestic Animals in Study area
S.No. English/Hindi Name Family Scientific name
1. Buffalo/ Bhains Bovidae Bulbalus bulbalis
2. Cow/Gai Bovidae Bos primigenius
3. Dog/Kutta Canidae Canis lupus familiaris
4. Donkey/Gadah Equidae Equus africanus asinus
5. Goat/Bakri Bovidae Capra hircus
6. Horse/Ghoda Equidae Equus caballus
7. Ox/Bail Bovidae Bos indicus
8. Sheep/Bhed Bovidae Ovis aries
Rare and Endangered Fauna of Study Area: Some of the sighted fauna was given protection
by the Indian Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972 by including them in different schedules. Among
the birds in the study area, Pea fowl (Pavo cristatus) is included in schedule I of Wild life
protection Act (1972), while many other birds are included in schedule IV. Among the reptiles,
no one is listed except Frog (schedule IV). Among mammals; Nilgai (Boselaphus tragocamelus)
is protected as Schedule-III animal and five stripped squirrels are included in schedule IV of
Wild Life Protection act 1972.
Endemic Fauna of the Study Area: None of the sighted animal species can be assigned
endemic species category of the study area.
3.13 Socio-Economic Environment
The growth of industrial sectors and infrastructure developments in and around the
agriculture dominant areas, villages and towns are bound to create its impact on the
socio-economic aspects of the local population. The impacts may be positive or negative
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 93
depending upon the developmental activity. To assess the impacts on the socio-
economics of the local people, it is necessary to study the existing socio-economic status
of the local population, which will be helpful for making efforts to further improve the
quality of life in the area of study. To study the socio-economic aspects of people in the
study area around the proposed project site, the required data has been collected from
various secondary sources and supplemented by the primary data generated through the
process of a limited door to door socio-economic survey.
Methodology adopted for the Study
The methodology adopted for the study is based on the review of secondary data, such as
District Census Statistical Handbooks-2011 and the records of National Informatics
Center, New Delhi, for the parameters of demography, occupational structure of people
within the general study area of 10-km radius around the proposed project site.
Review of Demographic and Socio-economic Profile - 2011
The sociological aspects of this study include human settlements, demography, social
such as scheduled castes and scheduled tribes and literacy levels besides infrastructure
facilities available in the study area. The economic aspects include occupational structure
of workers. The salient features of the demographic and socio-economic details are
described in the following sections and Figure 3.16.
Demography
Distribution of Population
As per 2011 census, the study area consists of 91257 persons. The distribution of
population in the study area is given in Table 3.28. The males and females constitute
58.3% and 46.7% of the study area population respectively.
Table3.28 : Distribution of Population
Particular 10 Km around Project Site
No. of Households 18434
Male Population 48650
Female Population 42607
Total Population 91257
Average Household Size 5.0
Male % 58.3%
Female% 46.7 %
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 94
Average Household Size
The average household size of the study area is 5.0 persons. The low family size could be
attributed to a high degree of urbanization with migration of people with higher literacy
levels who generally opt for smaller family size and family welfare measures.
Gender Ratio
The configuration of male and female indicates that the males constitute to about 58.3%
and females to 58.3% of the total population as per 2011 census records. The sex ratio i.e.
the number of females per 1000 males indirectly reveals certain sociological aspects in
relation with female births, infant mortality among female children and single person
family structure, a resultant of migration of industrial workers. The study area on an
average has 876 females per 1000 males as per 2011 census.
Literacy Levels
The study area experiences an average literacy rate of 71.2 %. The distribution of literate
and literacy rate in the study area is given in Table 3.29.
Social Structure
As per 2011 census, the percentage of scheduled caste population is 21.9 % within 10-km
radius study area. The percentage of Schedule tribe population is 0 %. The distribution of
population by social structure is given in Table 3.30.
Table 3.29 Distribution of Literate and Literacy Rates
Particular 10 Km around Project Site
Total literate 65037
Average literacy (%) 71.2%
Total population 91257
Table- 3.30 Distribution of Population by Social Structure
Particular 10 Km around
Project Site
%age to
the total
population
Total SC and ST
population 20005 21.9%
Schedule Tribes 0 0%
Other caste
population
71252 78.1%
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 95
Particular 10 Km around
Project Site
%age to
the total
population
Total Population 91257
Occupational Structure
The occupational structure of residents in the study area is studied with reference to main
workers, marginal workers and non-workers. The main workers include 10 categories of
workers defined by the Census Department consisting of cultivators, agricultural
labourers, those engaged in live-stock, forestry, fishing, mining and quarrying;
manufacturing, processing and repairs in household industry; and other than household
industry, construction, trade and commerce, transport and communication and other
services. The marginal workers are those workers engaged in some work for a period of
less than six months during the reference year prior to the census survey. The non-
workers include those engaged in unpaid household duties, students, retired persons,
dependents, beggars, vagrants etc; institutional inmates or all other non-workers who do
not fall under the above categories. As per 2011 census records, altogether the main
workers works out to be 31.0% of the total population. The marginal workers and non-
workers constitute to 3.9% and 65.1% of the total population respectively. The
distribution of workers by occupation indicates that the non-workers are the predominant
population. The occupational structure of the study area is shown in Table 3.31.
Table 3.31 Occupational Structure
Particular 10 Km around
Project Site
%age to
study area
Total main workers 28349 31.0%
Marginal workers 3544 3.9%
Non-workers 59364 65.1%
Total population 91257
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 96
Conclusion
All the basic facilities like road and rail network, medical facilities, post and telegraph,
market, drinking water facilities and education facilities are available. The proposed
project will be boon for the surrounding area.
Figure 3.19: Demographic Structure of Study Area
3.14 Solid Waste and Hazardous Waste
This is a proposed project. Hence, no solid and hazardous waste observed at site. The
proposed generation details are given in Chapter 4.
3.15 Risk Assessment
As this project is a proposed project. Hence, no risk at site. The future project risk
assessment has been done and given in Chapter 7.
3.16 Summary
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 97
Various environmental parameters study has been done within 10 Km radius area of the
proposed project site. The ToR presentation for proposed project was held on 20th
January, 2015 and ToR was granted by MoEF&CC on 31st March, 2014. M/s Shahabad
Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. requested vide letter dated 30th
December, 2014 to
MoEF&CC regarding permission to start baseline monitoring from 1st October to 31
st
December 2014. During ToR Presentation Experts Committee Members accepted the
period from 1st October to 31
st December 2014 and desired that one month additional
data to be collected. As per EAC recommendation additional one month (1st January to
31st January 2015) data collection has been done. The baseline information on micro-
meteorology, ambient air quality, water quality, noise levels, soil quality and floristic
descriptions are largely drawn from the data generated by M/s Vardan Enviro Lab,
Gurgaon (NABL Accredited Lab). Land use pattern shows that most of the land is
agriculture land. The study area represents almost flat alluvial plain without any
conspicuous topographical features. The area falls in the Upper Jamuna and Ghaggar
Basins and the principal ground water reservoir in the area is unconsolidated alluvial
deposits of Quaternary age. Ambient Air Quality Monitoring reveals that the minimum
and maximum concentrations of PM10 for all the 06 AAQM stations were found to be
41.4 g/m3 and 69.2 g/m
3 respectively, while for PM2.5 it vary between 25.0 g/m
3 to
40.1 g/m3. The maximum and minimum concentrations of SO2 were found to be 14.7
g/m3 to 25.0 g/m
3 respectively. The maximum and minimum concentrations of NO2
were found to be 15.0 g/m3 to 28.0 g/m3 respectively. Maximum and minimum noise
levels recorded during the day time were from 54.10 Leq dB and 49.67 Leq dB
respectively and maximum and minimum level of noise during night time were 44.70 Leq
dB and 42.00 Leq dB respectively. Thus noise levels at all locations were observed to be
within the prescribed limits. The analysis results show that soil was basic in nature as pH
value ranges from 7.23 to 8.10 with water holding capacity of 36.78 to 42.80%. Analysis
results of ground water reveal the results: pH varies from 7.60 to 8.30, total hardness
varies from 156.0 to 416.0 mg/L, total dissolved solids varies from 302.00 to 532.50
mg/L. All the basic facilities like road and rail network, medical facilities, post and
telegraph, market, drinking water facilities and education facilities are available. The
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 98
project will also provide impetus to industrialization of the area and would be boon for
the district as it will not only result in employment opportunity but also infrastructure
development and overall growth of the area.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 99
Chapter-4
Anticipated Environmental Impact and
Mitigation Measures 4.0 Introduction
The Environmental Impact Assessment in and around the unit from proposed project is
core theme of this Chapter. Generally, the environmental impacts can be categorized as
either primary or secondary. Primary impacts are those which are attributed directly to
the project and secondary impacts are those which are indirectly induced and typically
include the associated investment and changed patterns of social and economic activities
by the proposed action. Also the Environmental impact can be categorized as short term
and long term.
Quantification of assessments in terms of measurable units would be the ideal method for
impact assessment. Mathematical models are the best tools to quantitatively describe
cause-effect relationships between sources of pollution and different components of
environment. However, due to lack of information/data, uncertainties involved and
complex interrelationships between various sectors of environment, it is not always
possible or at least not easily achievable. In such cases, only qualitative predictions have
been made based on experience and judgments.
The Environment Management Plan (EMP) is required to ensure sustainable development
in the study area (10 Km) of the proposed plant site, hence it needs to be an all en-
compassive plan for which the proposed industry, Regulating agencies like pollution
control board working in the region and more importantly the affected population of the
study area need to extend their co-operation and contribution.
The affected environmental attributes in the region are air quality, water quality, soil,
land use, ecology and public health. The management action plan aims at controlling
pollution at the source level to the extent possible with the available and affordable
technology followed by treatment measures before they are discharged. The proposed
project would create impact on the environment in two distinct phases:
i. During the construction phase which may be regarded as temporary or short term; and
ii. During the operation phase which would have long term effects.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 100
The construction and operational phase of the proposed project comprises various
activities each of which will have an impact on some or other environmental parameters.
Various impacts during the construction and operation phase on the environmental
parameters have been studied and mitigation measures for the same are discussed briefly
below and elaborated in the subsequent sections.
4.1 Construction Phase
This phase involves the activities like erection of civil structures, movement/ removal
of old construction, erection of new equipment and machinery, green belt development
etc. Air, Noise and Land are likely to be effected by these activities, although
Aesthetics and Socio-economic factors are also identified. But the impacts will be
marginal and for short term only. The green belt development will have positive impacts.
The impacts on different environmental parameters due to proposed project construction
are discussed in Table 4.1.
Table 4.1 : Impact Identification Matrix (Construction Phase)
Activities Environmental Attributes
Air Noise Water Hydro
geology
Geology Climate Land
Ecology Socio
Economic
Solid/Ha
zardous
Risk
Operation of
DGs
√ √ - - - √ - - - √ √
Operation of
Construction
Equipment
√ √ √ - √ - - √ - √ √
Traffic √ √ - - - - - - - - √
Land
Developmen
t and
Building
Construction
√ - √ √ - - √ √ √ √ √
Where √ Yes - No
4.1.1 Impact on Land Use
The construction activity would bring immediate changes in the land use pattern of the
proposed plant area as well as in the vicinity. The land required for the project will
undergo a change due to cutting, stripping, excavation, levelling, landscaping, loss of
vegetative cover and erection of structures of the proposed project:
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 101
i. The impact on land use will be long term and permanent but will be on a smaller
scale. Construction of plant will lead to permanent change in land use pattern at
the site as a direct impact.
ii. The construction activities would attract a sizeable population and influx of
population is likely to be associated with construction of temporary hutment for
construction work force. However, this will be only a temporary change and will
be restricted to construction period.
iii. As soon as the construction phase is over, the land use pattern modified to meet
the requirement of construction phase will be reversed. Development activity also
induces changes in land use pattern of the adjoining areas because of the
increased availability of infrastructural facilities, increase in commercial value of
land etc.
Mitigation Measures
Although, the impact on land use will be long term and permanent it can be considerably
reduced by taking following measures:
i. Minimize clearance of trees by appropriate attention during finalizing layout.
ii. Enforcement of restriction for timber and waste disposal etc.
iii. The excavation material should be dumped in low lying areas so as to reduce visual
impact.
4.1.2 Impact on Soil and Mitigation Measures
i. Construction activities involving levelling, excavation and removal of existing
vegetation would invariably disturb the soil of the area. The impacts on soil during
construction phase will be mainly due to loss of top soil in the construction areas and
contamination of the soils of surrounding area due to construction materials such as
cement, sand, oils, etc.
ii. The disturbances would be more pronounced during the summer and monsoon
seasons with strong rains. However, it will be temporary and will be confined to the
areas of construction only.
iii. Generally, such disturbances are confined to the area of activity i.e. the main plant.
Appropriate soil conservation measures associated with improved construction
techniques would minimize such impacts.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 102
Mitigation Measures:
i. Timely afforestation activities would also contribute positively towards soil
conservation. Apart from localized construction impacts at the plant site, no adverse
impacts on soil in the surrounding area are anticipated.
4.1.3 Impact on Air Environment
i. Impacts of construction activities on air quality are cause for concern mainly in the dry
months due to dust particles generated from leveling, grading, earthworks, and other
construction related activities. The dust generated is in the range of 2500-3000 µg/m3.
ii. The dust emitted during the above mentioned activities depend upon the type of soil
being excavated and the ambient humidity levels. The dust generated during the
construction activities will however, settle quickly.
iii. The composition of dust in this kind of operation is, however, mostly inorganic and
nontoxic in nature.
Mitigation Measures
i. Sprinkler will be installed along the haul and kuccha road.
ii. The wetting of Kuccha road will be done by water tankers regularly.
iii. Green belt will be developed along the project boundary, haul road and inside the
plant roads.
iv. The PUC (Pollution under control) will be checked at the entrance.
v. The material brought in trucks will be covered properly with plastic sheets.
vi. The sand/cement stored at the site will also be covered with plastic sheet.
vii. The temporary barrier will be created along boundary of the project site so that effect
of wind and generation of dust be minimized.
Conclusion : By adopting the above mitigation measures the emission level will be
brought down and PM10 will be minimized below 100 µg/m3.
4.1.4 Impact on Water Environment
i. Effluents from the construction area mainly contain suspended solids while the sanitary
waste from the labour colonies contains suspended matter.
ii. The loose construction material like sand, cement etc. and excavated earth/construction
debris may get washed off during heavy precipitation.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 103
Mitigation Measures
i. Adequate arrangements for proper drainage and disposal of wastewater and routing of
the effluents from construction area through sedimentation basins and provision of
proper sanitary facilities with treatment will eliminate these problems of water
pollution. Moreover, these impacts will be temporary in nature.
4.1.5 Impact on Noise Environment
i. The major sources of noise during the construction phase are vehicular traffic,
construction equipment like dozers, scrapers, concrete mixers, cranes, generators,
pumps, compressors, rock drills, pneumatic tools, vibrators etc. The operation of
these equipments will generate noise ranging between 70-90 dB (A).
ii. The noise produced during the construction will have significant impact on noise
levels in the working environment as well as on personnel operating these machines.
However, the construction noise is limited to duration of construction only.
Mitigation Measures
i. Mandatory use of personal protective equipment like ear plugs will be ensured to
mitigate any significant impact of such equipment on personnel operating the
machinary.
ii. Long exposure to high noise levels will be avoided by practicing proper shift
arrangement for workers. Similarly, shift arrangements will be made to avoid long
exposure to hand-arm vibration and full body vibration.
iii. Noise making construction activities will be carried out during day time only.
4.1.6 Ecological Impact Assessment
Table 4.2 : Ecological Impact due to proposed distillery unit
Ecological
Criteria
Identified
Impacts
Ecological significance of
Impact
Magnitude Duration
/Timing/
Frequency
Reversibility Mitigation Cumulative
Impact
Zone of
Influence
Project site
habitat
Due to Site
clearance.
The proposed distillery
unit is located in open land
(already occupied by
Shahabad Cooperative
Sugar Ltd. No site
clearance is required. Only
some scrub area will be
cleared.
Low impact - Reversible - No
Cumulative
impact
Zone of
Influence
Ecological
Impact
Surrounding
habitat due to
fugitive emission.
Not much impact on the
surrounding habitat is
envisaged due to the
transportation activity
except some fugitive
emission.
Temporary
Impact
Only during
the
transportation
activity.
Reversible The green belt
(33%) within
premises and
approach road
which will
restrict the
fugitive
emission.
No
cumulative
impact
Accessibility Ecological
Impact due to
road
construction
No Road construction is
required to assess the
project site. The existing
internal Roads are
connected to the existing
SH road and then to the
highway.
No impact - - - No Impact
Zone of Ecological During operation phase No impact During No The waste No impact
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 105
Influence
Impact on
Surrounding/
Eco sensitive
habitat due to
waste water
generated from
the project
activity.
daily water requirement of
the proposed activity will
be 950 KLD. The waste
water from the process will
treat and reuse at site only.
operation
Phase
water will be
treated in ETP
and then goes
into MEE.
Proper
treatment of
waste water to
meet CPCB
permissible
disposal limit.
Proposed
plant is ZLD.
Zone of
Influence
Ecological
Impact on
Surrounding/Eco
sensitive habitat
due to Noise
generated from
the project
activity.
The Noise level during the
operation phase is around
75 dB. The impact on
ambient noise level will be
restricted only on the
factory premises. The
ambient air quality of the
surrounding villages may
not have any significance
increase due to the project
activity.
Low impact
on Flora and
fauna
During
operation
Phase
No As given in
The EMP
section.
No impact
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 106
4.1.7 Impact on Socio economic Environment
During construction phase of the proposed project, labors will be required and this
requirement will meet from surrounding area. Hence, positive impact will be on Socio
economic environment.
4.1.8 Impact of Solid and Hazardous Waste
During construction phase of the proposed project, top soil, construction debris and oil
from the machineries will be generated.
Mitigation Measures
i. Top soil will be stacked separately and will be used for green belt;
ii. Construction debris will be used for filling of low laying area; and
iii. Used oil will be sold to CPCB authorized vendor.
4.1.9 Risk Assessment during Construction
During construction activity various risk involved. Hence, detailed study has been done
and given in Chapter 7.
4. 2 Operational Phase
This phase of the project is important because it generates long-term impacts as the
production starts. The primary impacts causing likely deterioration will be in Air, Water,
Noise and Land / Soil due to the gaseous emissions, vehicular movement, and discharge
of liquid effluent. Identification of impacts during operation phase is given in Table 4.3.
Table 4.3 Identification of Impacts during Operation Phase
Activity Environme
ntal
Attribute
Cause Impact Characteristics
Nature Duration Reversibility Significance
Emissions
from various
unit processes
and vehicular
traffic
Air Quality
(SPM, SO2,
NOx, CO,
HC)
Unit operations,
Vehicle
Operation and
fuel
Combustion
Negligible
Negative
Long
Term
Reversible Low as ambient
and stack
monitoring ,
Scrubber Vehicle
maintenance will
be performed
Noise
levels
Noise
generation from
machinery and
Vehicles
Minor
Negative
Short
Term
Reversible Low, due to noise
protection
measures,
periodical vehicle
maintenance
Solid Waste
Disposal
Land and
Soil
Generation of
Solid Waste
Minor
Negative
Short
Term
Reversible Low, proper
collection and
Disposal
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 107
Activity Environme
ntal
Attribute
Cause Impact Characteristics
Nature Duration Reversibility Significance
Wastewater
Discharge
Water
Quality
Generation of
Wastewater
Minor
Negative
Short
Term
Reversible ETP will be
provided
DG Set Air Quality Exhaust
Emissions
Minor
Negative
Short
Term
Reversible Low, DG Set is
only a standby
Noise
Levels
Noise
Generation
Minor
Negative
Short
Term
Reversible Low due to Noise
Protection
measures
Green Belt
Development
Ecology Planting of
Trees
Positive Long
Term
Reversible High Positive
Impact
Socio-
Economic
Employme
nt
Generation
Direct and
Indirect
employment
Positive Long term Irreversible High, new
opportunities of
income for many
families
Quality of
Life
In flow of funds
in the
region/nation
Positive Long
Term
Irreversible High, the project
will generate
employment
This phase includes following activities:
i. Transportation
ii. Raw material storage
iii. Industrial development
iv. Product manufacturing
v. Gaseous emission
vi. Effluent discharge
vii. Solid waste generation
viii. Occasional equipment failure / Process upset and related problems
ix. Product storage
x. Chemical Hazards
xi. Generation of employment opportunity
xii. Contribution to social welfare
4.2.1 Ambient Air Quality Modeling
ISCST3 Dispersion Model
The Industrial Source Complex (ISC) Short Term model provides options to model
emissions from a wide range of sources that might be present at a typical industrial
source complex. ISCST3 is US-EPA approved model to predict the air quality. The
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 108
model uses urban dispersion and regulatory defaults options as per guidelines on air
quality models (PROBES/70/1997-1998). Emission sources are categorized into four
basic types of sources, i.e., point sources, volume sources, area sources, and open pit
sources. The volume source option and the area source option may also be used to
simulate line sources. The model assumes receptors on flat terrain. The ISC short term
area source model is based on a numerical integration over the area in the upwind and
cross wind directions of Gaussian plume formula. This can be applied to the Point, Area,
Line or Volume sources simultaneously and their resultant incremental concentration of
the pollutant can be predicted.
Model Options Used For Computations
The options used for short-term computations are:
• The plume rise is estimated by Briggs formulae, but the final rise is always limited to
that of the mixing layer;
• Stack tip down-wash is not considered;
• Buoyancy Induced Dispersion is used to describe the increase in plume dispersion
during the ascension phase;
• Calms processing routine is used by default;
• Flat terrain is used for computations;
• It is assumed that the pollutants do not undergo any physio-chemical transformation
and that there is no pollutant removal by dry deposition;
• Washout by rain is not considered; and
• Cartesian co-ordinate system has been used for computations with 100 m grid
interval.
Gaussian Plume Model
Ground Level Concentration () from a point source at any receptor is given by (USEPA
ISCST3, 1987).
= Qg1g2
where,
g1 = exp(-y2/2y2)
g2 = exp[-(z-H)2/2z2] + exp[-(z+H)2/2z2]
(2 y zu)
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 109
Q = source strength
Z = receptor height above the ground
He = effective stack height (Plume rise + Physical stack height)
u = wind speed at stack level
y & z = dispersion parameters
Figure 4.1 – Gaussian Plume Model
Dispersion Parameters
Dispersion parameters y and z for urban diffusion are used as the project is located on a
flat terrain in an rural area. Atmospheric dispersion coefficients vary with downwind
distance (x) from emission sources for different atmospheric stability conditions.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 110
Table 4.4 : Dispersion parameters as per stability class (Urban Area)
Stability Class y
z
A 0.22x(1+0.0001x)-.5
0.20x
B 0.16x(1+0.0001x)-.5
0.12x
C 0.11x(1+0.0001x)-.5
0.08x(1+0.0002x).5
D 0.08x(1+0.0001x)-.5
0.06(1+0.0015x).5
E 0.06x(1+0.0001x)-.5
0.03x(1+0.0003x)-1
F 0.04x(1+0.0001x)-.5
0.16x(1+0.0003x)-1
Plume Rise
Plume rise h has been determined according to Brigg’s formula (CPCB guideline)
h = 21.425 F3 4
for F<55
Us
h = 38.71 F3 5
for F>55
Us
F = g VsD2(Ts-Ta)/4Ts
Where
Us = wind speed at stack level (m/s)
Vs = stack gas velocity (m/s)
Ts = stack gas temperature (0K)
Ta = ambient temperature (0K)
F = Buoyancy flux parameter (m4/s3)
h = Plume rise (m)
D = Diameter of the stack (m)
g = acceleration due to gravity, 9.807 (m/s2)
Model Setup
Calculation of Stack Height
The plant will have a 3.0 MW cogeneration power plant along with the distillery unit.
Emissions due to operation of 20TPH boiler will be the major source of pollution during
the operation phase. Slops and Agricultural waste (bagasse / rice) will be used as fuel for
boiler operation. The calculation of stack height for operating boiler is calculated as
below.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 111
Boiler Stack Height
For the small boilers, the required stack height with the boiler will be calculated by
using the formula given below. In no case the stack height will be less than 11 meters.
The percentage sulphur content in slopes, rice husk and bagasse is 0.63, 0.08 and 0.0,
respectively. The stack height is calculated based on fuel sulphur content of 0.40%.
Where,
h = height of stack, m
Q = SO2 emission rate in kg/hr
Table 4.5 : Calculation of DG Set Stack Height
Source Capacity Calculated Stack
Height (m)
Proposed Stack
Height (m)
Boiler 20 TPH 36.323 37
Emissions from DG Set and Boiler
The details of source parameters, calculated emission rates from boiler based on CPCB
guidelines are presented in the Table 3. The stack diameter and exit velocity are assumed
to be 1 m and 15m/s at the outlet.
Table 4.6 : Source Parameter
Location Capacity
Stack
Diameter
(m)
Flow
Rate
(Nm3/s)
Exit Gas
Temp.*
(oC)
Emission Rates (g/s)
SO2 NOX PM10
Boiler 20 TPH 1 8.11 160 6.67 1.92 1.22
Results
ISCST3 Model Results
The ISCST3 model was setup to predict the cumulative maximum ground level
concentration of SO2, NOx and PM10 generated due to operation of Boiler at the plant
location. Point source resembling the stack at location of proposed source was fixed.
Receptors were fixed at baseline monitoring stations. The model was run for 24-hour
operation of boiler.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 112
The predicted maximum incremental GLC (24-hour average) of SO2, NOx and PM10 in
was found as 22.539µg/m³, 6.488µg/m³ and 4.123µg/m³ respectively. The spatial
distribution of SO2, NOx and PM10 GLC in 10km study area is presented in Figure 2 to
4. The predicted 24-hourly maximum ground level concentrations at baseline air quality
monitoring locations are presented in table 4.7.
Table 4.7 – Predicted GLC of PM10 at Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Stations
Village
Max Baseline Conc.
(µg/m3)
Predicted GLC (µg/m3) Cumulative GLC (µg/m
3)
SO2 NOX PM10 SO2 NOX PM10 SO2 NOX PM10
Project Site 12.2 20.5 54.8 0.26378 0.07593 0.04825 12.464 20.576 54.848
Shahbad 15.1 28 70.1 1.63827 0.47158 0.29965 16.738 28.472 70.400
Padlu 12.1 24.1 64.9 0.46325 0.13335 0.08473 12.563 24.233 64.985
Ahmedpur 14 24.8 60.1 2.63747 0.75921 0.48242 16.637 25.559 60.582
Machrauli 12 22 55.7 0.28084 0.08084 0.05137 12.281 22.081 55.751
Narayangarh 12 23.9 60 8.26397 2.37883 1.51155 20.264 26.279 61.512
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 113
Figure 4.2 Spatial distribution of predicted GLCs of SO2
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 114
Figure 4.3 Spatial distribution of predicted GLCs of NOx
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report (60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant) Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 115
Figure 4.4 Spatial distribution of predicted GLCs of PM10
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 116
4.2.2 Impact on Air Environment
The Bagasse (of calorific value – 3500 Kcal/kg) will be used as fuel in the boiler to
produce steam for operation of plant and 3 MW power plant.
The particulate emission passing through the stack is in the range of 1500-2000mg/m3.
During transportation of raw material finished product there will be generation of dust
emission from the road.
DG set without proper stack height will cause air pollution.
Mitigation Measures
To control the emission from attached to the boiler will be designed as under:
Stack Height -37m
Stack Diameter – 1m
Flow Rate – 8.11 Nm3/sec,
it as m - C
Exit Velocity -15 m/sec
In addition to above and to control the emission level of 1500-2000 mg/m3
the ESP of
(99.8%) will be installed which will be bring down the emission level within
permissible limit of 50 mg/m3.
To control the dust emission from transfer of truck/tanker/vehicle from raw material
and products the roads will be asphalted
Water sprinkling will be done on the road
For Acoustic D. G. Sets, stack height of 8 m above the roof level will be maintained as
per CPCB guidelines.
The ambient air monitoring will be carried out regularly in the work zone and
surrounding areas, which shows that ambient air levels of the contaminants, are well
below the stipulated norms.
Around 30% area will be developed as green belt around the periphery and within
premises will be developed which will help in attenuating the pollutants emitted by the
plant.
Conclusion : By adopting these mitigation measure, the ambient air quality will come
down within limits i.e. PM10 <100 µg/m3, PM2.5 <60 µg/m
3.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 117
Besides this, odour is also a problem in the project due to typical odour compounds:
i. Better housekeeping by regular steaming of all fermentation equipment;
ii. Use of efficient bio-cides to control bacterial contamination;
iii. Control of temperature during fermentation to avoid in-activation / killing of yeast;
iv. Air Treatment Technology will manage aerial emission prior to discharge to the
atmosphere via a stack. The stack will be designed with sufficient height (30 m) to aid
dispersion to the point where emissions will not impact on any receptors.
4.2.3 Impact on Water Environment
Total except for the major and most harmful effluent (spent wash, 540m3/day) from
the analyzer column and fermenter sludge, other effluents are quite small and do not
need any specific treatment.
Table 4.8 : Characteristics of Spent Wash
S.No. Parameters Value
1. Flow, m3/day 400
2. pH 4.0-4.5
3. Temperature, deg. C 75
4. BOD (mg/L) 60,000
5. COD (mg/L) 1,20,000 to 1,40,000
6. T.S. 12-14% w/w
7. Potassium mg/L <8,500
8. Sulphate (mg/L) <6,500
9. Nitrogen (mg/L) 1000
10. Phosphorus (mg/L) 100
11. Color Dark Brown
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 118
The purge from cooling tower will probably have a maximum 2000 ppm of
dissolved solids
Floor washings will have some dissolved solids and some gritty material
Spent lees is generally pure and hence most of it will be circulated to the process
Boiler blow down will have 3000 ppm of dissolved solids and can go to normal
drainage system
Mitigation Measures:
The proposed Molasses bas d distill ry would b bas d on “Z ro Liquid
Discharg ” (ZLD)
Spent wash will be concentrated in MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator), then the
semisolid waste from MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator) will be sent in specially
designed boiler for incineration.
Condensate will be treated in condensate polishing unit and will used as make-up
water in cooling tower.
A duly lined lagoon of 30 days capacity shall be provided.
Online effluent quality monitoring system will be installed at the outlet of the unit
for measurement of the parameters flow, pH, COD, BOD & TSS etc. and
transmission done of online data to Haryana State Pollution Control Board and
CPCB will be
4.2.4 Rain Water Harvesting /Recharge Plan
The storm water disposal system for the premises will be self-sufficient to avoid any
collection/stagnation and flooding of water. Storm water drainage plan of the project is
enclosed. The amount of storm water run-off depends upon many factors such as
intensity and duration of precipitation, characteristics of the tributary area and the time
required for such flow to reach the drains. The drains will be located near the carriage
way along either side of the roads. Taking the advantage of road camber, the rainfall run
off from roads will flow towards the drains. Storm water from various plots/will be
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 119
connected to adjacent drain by a pipe through catch basins. Adequate numbers of
rainwater harvesting pits at selected locations will be constructed, which will catch the
maximum run-off from the area.
1. Since the existing topography is congenial to surface disposal, a network of storm
water pipe drains is planned adjacent to roads. All building roof water will be brought
down through rain water pipes;
2. Proposed storm water system consists of pipe drain, catch basins and seepage pits at
regular intervals for rain water harvesting and ground water recharging;
3. Design specifications of the rain water harvesting plan are as follows:
Catchments/roofs would be accessible for regular cleaning;
The roof will have smooth, hard and dense surface which is less likely to be
damaged allowing release of material into the water. Roof painting has been
avoided since most paints contain toxic substances and may peel off;
All gutter ends will be fitted with a wire mesh screen and a first flush device
would be installed. Most of the debris carried by the water from the rooftop like
leaves, plastic bags and paper pieces will get arrested by the mesh at the terrace
outlet and to prevent contamination by ensuring that the runoff from the first 10-
20 minutes of rainfall is flushed off.;
No sewage or wastewater would be admitted into the system;
No wastewater from areas likely to have oil, grease, or other pollutants has been
connected to the system.
Table 4.9 Rain Water Harvesting/Recharge Details
S.No. Particulars Catchment Area
in m2 (A)
Runoff
Coefficient
(C)
Rainfall
Intensity in
mm/Annum (I)
Discharge
(m3)
1. Rooftop area 8093 0.85 0.8 8094.65
2. Green area 6070 0.65 0.8 3946.30
3. Paved area 27822 0.20 0.8 4451.52
Total 13111.16
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 120
Annually about 13111.16 m3 water will be conserved by rain water harvesting system and
will be discharge in ground water through recharge pit.
4.2.5 Noise Modelling
The major noise sources during operation phase will be transportation and operation of
DG Sets and other machinery inside the plant. The transportation of raw materials and
finished goods to and from the plant will contribute to the noise levels both inside the
plant premises as well as outside. The contribution of noise generated from operation of
machinery will contribute mostly to the noise levels in the working environment.
Impact on Noise Levels
The main noise generating sources will be Compressors and DG set. The reference noise
levels at these sources vary in the range of 65-80 dB (A). The noise levels from the plant
units has been computed based on the mathematical model as described below.
Mathematical Model for Sound Wave Propagation during Operation
For an approximate estimation of noise levels in the ambient environment from the
source point, a standard mathematical model for sound wave propagation is used. The
sound pressure level generated by noise sources decreases with increasing distance
from the source due to wave divergence. An additional decrease in sound pressure
level with distance from the source is expected due to atmospheric effect or its
interaction with objects in the transmission path.
For hemispherical sound wave propagation through homogenous loss free medium,
one can estimate noise levels at various locations, due to different sources using
model based on first principles, as per the following equation:
1
212 log20
r
rLL pp (i)
Where Lp2 and Lp1 are Sound Pressure Levels (SPLs) at points located at distances r2 and
r1 from the source. The combined effect of all the sources then can be determined at
various locations by the following equation.
.........101010log10)10/()10/()10/(
)(321 ppp LLL
totalpL (ii)
Where, Lp1, Lp2, Lp3 are noise pressure levels at a point due to different sources.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 121
Based on the above equations a user-friendly model has been developed. The details of
the model are as follows:
i. Maximum number of sources is limited to 200;
ii. Noise levels can be predicted at any distance specified from the source;
iii. Model is designed to for flat terrain;
iv. Co-ordinates of the sources in meters;
v. Maximum and Minimum levels are calculated by the model;
vi. Output of the model in the form of isopleths;
vii. Environmental attenuation factors and machine corrections have not been
incorporated in the model but corrections are made for the measured Leq levels.
The major noise generating sources from the proposed plant are listed in Table- 4.10.
These are considered as input to the noise model.
Table-4.10 Noise Generating Sources in Plant
S.No. Sources Maximum Noise Levels dB (A)
1. Compressor 75-80
2. Operation of Equipments 70-75
3. DG set 65-70
4. CPP 80-85
Presentation of Results
The model results are discussed below and are represented through contours in
Figure-4.8.
Prediction of Impacts
The predicted incremental noise levels at the boundary of the plant are in the range 30
to 32 dB (A).
Impact on Work Environment (Inside the Plant)
The equipments with significant continuous noise levels are turbine unit, Cooling
tower, air compressor, transformers and boilers. The incremental noise levels inside
the plant will vary between 65-85 dB (A) near source to 30-32 dB (A) near plant
boundary. Based on the noise levels recorded during baseline study, the resultant
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 122
noise levels inside the plant will vary between 50.18-85.001 dB (A), as given in
Table 4.11.
Table-4.11 Noise Baseline and Incremental Data
S.No. Location Baseline
dB (A)
Maximum
Incremental
dB (A)
Minimum
Incremental
dB (A)
Max.
Resultant
dB (A)
Min.
Resultant
dB (A)
1 Near Source 50.14 85 65 85.001 65.14
2 Plant
Boundary
50.14 32 30 50.2 50.18
Inside the plant, the major increase in the noise levels will be near high noise
producing equipment which will reduce significantly as the distance to source is
increased. It is expected that the impacts on the working personnel will not be
significant on account of the high level of automation of these plant equipment, which
mean that workers will be exposed for short duration only that too intermittently. In
addition to that, ear plugs wearing will be made as compulsory personnel protective
equipment for all employees and visitors.
Impact on Community Noise Levels (Outside the Plant)
The predicted resultant noise levels found near plant boundary vary between 50.18 to
50.20 dB (A), which is dependent on the baseline noise level and the predicted
incremental noise level. It is expected that as the distance is further increased, the
impact of noise due to operation of proposed plant will deteriorate to negligible levels
based on energy loss during sound propagation. Hence, it can be safely concluded
that there will be insignificant change in community noise levels outside the plant.
Noise Mitigation Measures
i. Noise level can be reduced by stopping leakages from various steam lines,
compressed air lines and other high pressure equipment. The noise produced in
valves and piping associated with equipment handling compressible and
incompressible fluids will be attenuated to 75 dB(A) at a distance of 1.0 m from
the source by the use of low noise trims, acoustic lagging (insulation), thick-walled
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 123
pipe work as and where necessary to comply with CPCB noise standards for
industrial zones.
ii. All pipes and valves downstream of pressure control valve (including pressure
control valve) will be one schedule higher than needed by pressure considerations
to attenuate the noise.
iii. By providing padding at various locations to avoid rattling due to vibration;
iv. Providing noise proof cabins to operators where remote control for operating noise
generating equipment is feasible;
v. The air compressor, process air blower, pneumatic valves would be provided with
acoustic enclosure;
vi. In all the design/installation precautions are taken as specified by the
manufacturers with respect to noise control will be strictly adhered to;
vii. High noise generating sources will be insulated adequately by providing suitable
enclosures;
viii. Design and layout of building to minimize transmission of noise, segregation of
particular items of plant and to avoid reverberant areas;
ix. Use of lagging with attenuation properties on plant components / installation of
sound attenuation panels around the equipment;
x. The noise control system will be designed to form an integral part of the plant;
xi. Other than the regular maintenance of the various equipment, ear plugs/muffs are
recommended for the personnel working close to the noise generating units;
xii. All the openings like covers, partitions will be designed properly;
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 124
Figure 4.5 : Noise Dispersion Contour
-1000.00 -800.00 -600.00 -400.00 -200.00 0.00 200.00 400.00 600.00 800.00 1000.00
-1000.00 -800.00 -600.00 -400.00 -200.00 0.00 200.00 400.00 600.00 800.00 1000.00
-1000.00
-800.00
-600.00
-400.00
-200.00
0.00
200.00
400.00
600.00
800.00
1000.00
-1000.00
-800.00
-600.00
-400.00
-200.00
0.00
200.00
400.00
600.00
800.00
1000.00
Distance in meter
35.00
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 125
4.2.6 Impact on Soil Environment
There is no discharge of waste water onto land. The solid wastes will be
segregated according to their properties, packed, transported and stored in a separate
impervious storage area demarcated for them. They will then be disposed off
according to the requirements of statutory authorities. Hence implementation of
project will not have any major effect on the soil environment.
Mitigation
No toxic /waste water will be disposed directly on land;
Vegetation will be done on uncovered soil.
4.2.7 Impact on Biological Environment
Major Impact on Ecological Environment
1. Fugitive emission from vehicle movement will form a layer in leaves thus reducing the
gaseous exchange process. This ultimately affects the growth of plants.
2. The Indian peafowl movement is very common in the area; the noise from vehicular
transportation will hinder the same. Conservation Plan for the same has been prepared
and is given in Chapter 7.
3. The wastewater generated from distillery unit will impose the negative impact on current
ecological status.
Proposed Mitigation Measures
1. Transportation will be minimise in the morning and evening and cannot be done in night.
2. The green belt will be encouraged to mitigate the noise level in the premises. Plantation
will be carried out in the premises (33%) and on approach roads as community forestry.
The conservation plan will be implemented to conserve the peafowl in the area.
3. The proposed unit is ZLD. The waste water will be treated in ETP and then sent to MEE,
the solid waste will be sent to TSDF for incineration.
4.2.8 Impact on Socio-Economic Environment
The proposed project will generate the employment to local people. Thus, the said
project will not have any significant impact on Socio-economic pattern of the
surrounding region. The project will also generate indirect employment opportunities,
which will contribute to social upliftment of the people in surrounding area.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 126
4.2.9 Impact on Land Environment
The required plant and machinery for the full production capacity will be installed.
84326.4 m2
new land will be used for the proposed project, which is industrial
land and already purchased.
Thus, no adverse impact is likely to be generated on the land environment and
general aesthetics of the area.
4.2.10 Impact on Hydrogeology
Water will be supplied through municipal supply. Hence, no adverse impact on
hydrogeology.
4.2.11 Risk Assessment
Detailed risk assessment study is given in Chapter 7.
4.2.12 Solid Waste and Hazardous Waste Management
About 220 KLD sludge and 1.0 KL per year used oil will be generated from the
plant.
About 24700 TPA biomass will be used as a fuel. About 123 TPA ash will be
generated from boiler. Bottom ash will be 25 TPA and flyash will be 98 TPA.
Mitigation Measure:
Solid waste and Hazardous waste will be store separately. Hazardous waste will
be send to TSDF site.
Bottom ash will be used for filling of low laying area and fly ash will be send to
bricks manufacturers.
4.2.13 Cultural Environment
The workers working in the industry are of different culture and religion. The
interaction and intermingling of all these people will improve the understanding of
various cultures. This will definitely improve and strengthen friendliness, brotherhood
and unity among them.
4.2.14 Indirect Impacts
Impacts on Public Health and Safety
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 127
The discharge of waste materials (stack emission, wastewater and solid wastes), from
process operations can have potential impact on public safety and health. The impact due
to the emission from the proposed plant will be insignificant as the mitigation measures
delineated in EMP are strictly followed. The public health and safety is dependent on the
effective implementation of control measures suggested for pollution control.
4.2.14.2 Management of Public Interests
Based on the analysis of the socio-economic profile of the study area along with the
prediction and evaluation of likely impacts arising out of the proposed activity, it has
been possible to prepare a feasible environmental management plan. It is felt that this
would help in minimizing the adverse impacts on the socio-economic environment to a
considerable extent, while at the same time addressing to large extent the aspirations of
the community. For the recruitment of semi-skilled and un-skilled workers particularly
during construction, preference will be given to the local people.
The project proponent is equally conscious for socio-economic development and is
committed to raise quality of life and social well being of communities where it operates.
Its CSR initiatives have been prioritized on local needs, which focus on Health,
Education, Sustainable Livelihood, Social Mobilization, Infrastructure Development,
Water Harvesting, Agriculture, and Environment Conservation.
4.3 Summary
The construction and operational phase of the proposed project comprises various
activities each of which will have an impact on some or other environmental
parameters.
Construction Phase:
This phase involves the activities like erection of civil structures, movement/ removal
of old construction, erection of new equipment and machinery, green belt development
etc. Air, Noise and Land are likely to be effected by these activities, although
Aesthetics and Socio-economic factors are also identified. But the impacts will be
marginal and for short term only. The green belt development will have positive
impacts. The impact on land use will be long term and permanent but will be on a
smaller scale. Construction of plant will lead to permanent change in land use pattern at
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 128
the site as a direct impact. The excavation material should be dumped in low lying
areas so as to reduce visual impact. Impacts of construction activities on air quality are
cause for concern mainly in the dry months due to dust particles generated from
leveling, grading, earthworks, and other construction related activities. The dust
generated is in the range of 2500-3000 µg/m3. By adopting mitigation measures the
emission level will be brought down and PM10 will be minimized below 100 µg/m3.
Effluents from the construction area mainly contain suspended solids while the sanitary
waste from the labour colonies contains suspended matter. Adequate arrangements for
proper drainage and disposal of wastewater and routing of the effluents from
construction area through sedimentation basins and provision of proper sanitary
facilities with treatment will eliminate these problems of water pollution. Moreover,
these impacts will be temporary in nature. The major sources of noise during the
construction phase are vehicular traffic, construction equipment like dozers, scrapers,
concrete mixers, cranes, generators, pumps, compressors, rock drills, pneumatic tools,
vibrators etc. The operation of these equipments will generate noise ranging between
70-90 dB (A). Mandatory use of personal protective equipment like ear plugs will be
ensured to mitigate any significant impact of such equipment on personnel operating
the machinery. During construction phase of the proposed project, labors will be
required and this requirement will meet from surrounding area. Hence, positive impact
will be on Socio economic environment.
Operation Phase
This phase of the project is important because it generates long-term impacts as the
production starts. The primary impacts causing likely deterioration will be in Air,
Water, Noise and Land / Soil due to the gaseous emissions, vehicular movement, and
discharge of liquid effluent. During transportation of raw material finished product
there will be generation of dust emission from the road. In order to control the emission
level of 1500-2000 mg/m3 the ESP of (99.8%) will be installed which will be bring
down the emission level within permissible limit of 50 mg/m3. Total except for the
major and most harmful effluent (spent wash) from the analyzer column and fermenter
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 129
sludge, other effluents are quite small and do not need any specific treatment. Spent
wash will be concentrated in MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator), then the semisolid
waste from MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator) will be sent in specially designed boiler
for incineration. Annually about 13111.16 m3 water will be conserved by rain water
harvesting system and will be discharge in ground water through recharge pit. The
predicted resultant noise levels found near plant boundary vary between 50.18 to 50.20
dB (A), which is dependent on the baseline noise level and the predicted incremental
noise level. Noise level can be reduced by stopping leakages from various steam lines,
compressed air lines and other high pressure equipment. There is no discharge of
waste water onto land. The solid wastes will be segregated according to their
properties, packed, transported and stored in a separate impervious storage area
demarcated for them. The proposed project will generate the employment to local
people. Solid waste and Hazardous waste will be store separately. Hazardous waste will
be send to TSDF site.
It has been concluded that the proposed project has no major adverse impact on
surrounding environment.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043 130
Chapter -5
Analysis of Alternative Site 5.1 Introduction
Proposed project site has been selected on the basis of following selection criteria:
i. There is no human settlement in 500 m radius.
ii. Easy availability of raw material due to Existing Sugar Mill and nearby Sugar mill.
iii. Location in rural area ensures adequate availability of manpower at marginally lower
rates, compared to metro cities of India.
iv. There is no National Park, Biosphere Reserves, Tiger Reserves, Reserved / Protected
Forests within 10 Km radius of study area.
v. There is no water body within core zone.
vi. Nearness to NH-1 and SH -7 makes it easier to transport raw materials & final
product at market.
Thus, no alternate site has been proposed for our 60 KLD capacity molasses based ethanol
plant having 3.0 MW Captive Power Plant at Village-Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist.-
Kurukshetra, Haryana.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 131
Chapter -6
Environmental Monitoring Programme
6.0 Introduction
Environmental Monitoring is an essential tool for sustainable development and ensuring
effective most implementation and monitoring of Environmental management plan and
mitigation measures. It is also very essential to keep updating the environmental
management system for effective conservation of environment along with ongoing
project activities/operation. The environment monitoring plan enables environmental
management system with early sign of need for additional action and modification
of ongoing actions for environment management, improvement and conservation.
It provides exact idea for mitigation measures to be implemented as it is linked
with actual distraction of environmental quality due to the project activities. Hence,
monitoring of critical parameters of environmental quality is very essential in the routine
activity schedule of project operation. An Environmental Monitoring Programme will
be scheduled for the following major objectives:
a. Assessment of the changes in environmental conditions, if any, during the
project operation/activities.
b. Monitoring and tracking the effectiveness of Environment Management
Plan and implementation of mitigation measures planned.
c. Identification of any significant adverse transformation in environmental condition to
Plan additional mitigation measures
6.1 Post Project Monitoring Locations and Components
The environmental monitoring points will be decided considering the environmental
impacts likely to occur due to the operation of proposed project as the main scope of
monitoring program is to track, timely and regularly, the change in environmental
conditions and to take timely action for protection of environment. The monitoring
points/location and components of significance shall be as per Table 6.1.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 132
Table 6.1 Parameters and Frequency for Post Project Environmental Monitoring
Sr. No Particular
Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency
1. Ambient Air
quality
PM10,PM2.5, SO2, NOx,
CO, Hydrocarbon
(Methane and Non-
Methane)
Ambient Air Quality
at minimum 6
locations within the
plant premises
having 1 location in
the upwind and 2
location in
downwind direction
At Source of
emission (Stacks)
from Sampling
Port/D.G. Sets
Process emission in
workplace
area/plants (for each
area/plant minimum
2 locations and 1
location outside
plant area near vent)
Once in a Month
2. Stationary
Emission
from Stack
PM, SO2, NOX
3. Process
emission
Fugitive gaseous
pollutant expected.
4. Water and
Wastewater
pH, Temperature, EC,
Turbidity, Total
Dissolved Solids,
Calcium, magnesium,
Total hardness, Total
Alkalinity, Chlorides,
Sulphates, Nitrates, DO,
COD, BOD, oil and
Grease, Metals expected
in effluent.
Water quality of the
area was studied at
minimum 6 location
for each Ground as
well as Surface
water
Wastewater from all
sources.
Wastewater at
different stages of
Effluent treatment
Process.
Monthly
5. Treated
Sewage /
Effluent
pH, BOD, COD, TSS,
TDS, oil and Grease,
Metals expected in
effluent.
6. Noise Equivalent noise level-
dB (A) At all source and
outside the Plant
area.
At least 5 points
near/around the plant
Boundary.
Monthly
7. Soil, Solid
wastes and
Manure /
pH, Humidity, Texture,
Organic matter, N, P, K,
Sulphate, Calcium,
At least two
locations from area
near Solid/
Quarterly
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 133
Sr. No Particular
Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency
Compost Magnesium, C:N ratio. hazardous waste
storage/ Dumping
Area.
At least five
locations from
Greenbelt and area
where manure of
biological waste is
applied.
8. Greenbelt Number of plantation
(Units), Number of
Survived plants/ trees,
Number of poor plants/
Trees
Greenbelt Area at
Boundary and Garden
Ongoing- round
the year
9. Environmenta
l Audit
As per Direction of
ISO: 14001
Once in a Year
10. Risk
Assessment
PPEs, Safety committee
meeting, Audits Heath
Checkup, Training
Monthly and
quarterly
6.2 Monitoring Methodologies
Monitoring of environmental samples will be done as per the guidelines provided by
MoEF&CC/CPCB/HSPCB. The method followed shall be recommended / standard
method approved / recommended by MoEF&CC and CPCB.
6.3 Reporting and Documentation
The records of the monitoring program shall be kept on regular basis for all aspects of
the monitoring. Separate records for water, wastewater, solid wastes, air emission, soil
and manure / compost shall be prepared and preserved regularly.
Immediately upon the completion of monitoring as per the planned schedule, report shall
be prepared and necessary documents shall be forwarded to the concerned person.
Methodology of monitoring (sampling and analysis) shall be prepared as separate
documents as SOP (standard Operating Procedure) wherever required.
The records showing results / outcome of the monitoring programs shall be prepared as
per the requirement of the schedule mentioned above.
Regularly, these documents and records shall be reviewed for necessary improvement
of the monitoring plan / mitigation measures / environmental technologies as well as for
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 134
necessary actions of Environmental Management Cell.
6.4 Environmental Management Cell
Apart from having an EMP, it is also necessary to have a permanent organizational set up
charged with the task of proposed plant will create a department consisting of officers from
various disciplines to co–ordinate the activities concerned with the management and
implementation of the environmental control measures.
a. Basically this department will undertake to monitor the environmental pollution
levels by measuring stack emissions, ambient air quality, water and effluent quality,
noise level etc. either departmentally or by appointing external agencies wherever
necessary.
b. In case the monitored results of environmental pollution are found exceeding the
allowable values, the environmental management cell will suggest remedial action
and get these suggestions implemented through the concerned plant authorities. The
actual operation and maintenance of pollution control equipment of each unit will be
under the respective plant managers.
c. The Environmental Management Cell (EMC) will handle of all the related activities
such as collection of statistics of health of workers and population of the region,
afforestation and green belt development.
Responsibilities of EMC:
The responsibilities of the EMC include the following:
i. Ambient air quality monitoring in core as well as in buffer zone.
ii. Statistical interpretation of monitoring results and up-gradation in air pollution
control measures accordingly.
iii. Submission of monitoring results to the regulatory authorities on regular basis.
iv. Specification and regulation of maintenance schedules for pollution control
equipment.
v. Developing the green belt.
vi. Proper implementation of the Environmental Management Plan.
vii. Organizing meetings of the Environmental Management Committee and
reporting to the management.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 135
Figure 6.1 : Environmental Management Cell
6.5 Summary
For the proposed project post monitoring program has been prepared. Sampling stations
will be selected on the basis of CPCB guidelines. Monitoring of environmental samples
shall be done as per the guidelines provided by MoEF&CC, CPCB and HSPCB. The
method followed shall be recommended / standard method approved / recommended by
MoEF&CC and CPCB.
An environment management cell will be formed. Adequate fund will be allocated for
Environmental Protection Measures and CSR Activities.
Director
General Manager
Officer- EHS
Chemist
ETP Operator
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 136
Chapter -7
Additional Studies 7.1 Public Consultation
The public consultation was conducted by Haryana State Pollution Control Board,
Panchkula on 19th
May 2015, 11 A.M. at Village Jandheri, Tehsil Shahabad, District
Kurukshetra (Haryana). Details of public hearing are given below:
7.1.1 Public Hearing Advertisement
The Public consultation advertisement has been published in Dainik Jagran Newspaper
on dated 17th
April, 2015.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 137
7.1.2 Photographs of Public Hearing
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 138
7.1.3 Minutes of Public Hearing
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 139
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 140
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 141
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 142
Table 7.1 Action Plan of the issues raised during Public Hearing and reply given by Project
Proponent
S. No. Detail of
Villagers
Question
Raised
Reply given
by PP/
Consultant
Action Plan
1. Sh. Ram
Kumar,
Village
Khrindwa
The Local
residents are
happy and
has no doubt
from this
plant and
plant may be
installed as
soon as
possible
-- Plant will be in operation after getting EC.
2. Sh. Karnail
Singh,
Ramgarh
Plant may be
installed as
soon as
possible so
that the
employment
may be
provided and
it will be
beneficial to
villagers and
will become
a source of
income
-- Salary structure for M/s Shahabad Co-Operative
Sugar Mill will be as per Government Policy.
Also workers from nearby villages will be given
preference.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 143
3. Sh. Satpal
Rana,
Village
Phillor
What will be
the
provisions
for the
controlling
of Air
Pollution
and ash
handling
Sh. S.K.
Sharma,
consultant
replied and
informed that
ESP (Electro
Static
Precipitator)
will be
installed as Air
pollution
control devices
on the boiler
and online
monitoring
system will
also be
installed and
the data will be
transferred to
the server of
HSPCB/CPCB.
The ash which
will be
generated from
the boiler has
17 % potash
and that can be
used as a
manure. This
ash will be sold
out in packings
and given to
farmers on
subsidized rate
Mitigation Measures during construction phase
Sprinkler will be installed along the haul and
kuccha road.
The wetting of Kuccha road will be done by
water tankers regularly.
Green belt will be developed along the project
boundary, haul road and inside the plant roads.
The PUC (Pollution under control) will be
checked at the entrance.
The vehicles will passed through the water so
that dust attached with tyres will be washed.
The material brought in trucks will be covered
properly with plastic sheets.
The sand/cement stored at the site will also be
covered with plastic sheet.
The temporary wall will be created along
boundary of the project site so that effect of
wind and generation of dust be minimized.
By adopting the above mitigation measures the
emission level will be brought down and PM10
will be minimized below 100 µg/m3.
Mitigation Measures during operation phase
To control the emission from attached to the
boiler will be designed as under:
Stack Height -37m
Stack Diameter – 1m
Flow Rate – 8.11 Nm3/sec,
- C
Exit Velocity -15 m/sec
In addition to above and to control the
emission level of 1500-2000 mg/m3 the ESP
of (efficiency - 99.8%) will be installed which
will be bring down the emission level within
permissible limit of 50 mg/m3.
To control the dust emission from transfer of
truck/tanker/vehicle from raw material and
products the roads will be asphalted
Water sprinkling will be done on the road
By adopting these mitigation measure, the
ambient air quality will come down within
limits i.e. PM10 <100 µg/m3, PM2.5 <60 ug/m
3.
For Acoustic D. G. Sets, stack height of 8 m
above the roof level will be maintained as per
CPCB guidelines.
The ambient air monitoring will be carried out
regularly in the work zone and surrounding
Shri Nirmal
Kashyap,
R.O.
informed that
as per the
directions of
CPCB, the
distillery unit/
sugar mills has
to install online
monitoring
system so that
the data
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 144
regarding the
pollution level
can be viewed
easily. The
sugar mill has
already given
tender for
online
monitoring
system. The
project
proponent has
provided a cost
of Rs. 2 Crores
for installation
of air pollution
control devices
to control air
pollution
areas, which shows that ambient air levels of
the contaminants, are well below the
stipulated norms.
Around 33% area will be developed as green
belt around the periphery and within premises
will be developed which will help in
attenuating the pollutants emitted by the plant.
Online Air monitoring system for stack
emission (for Particulate Matter) will be
installed and transmission of online data to
Haryana State Pollution Control Board and
CPCB will be done.
4. Sh.
Ghanshyam,
Village
Talheri
Proposed
project may
be installed
as soon as
possible so
that farmers
from nearby
area get the
benefits
-- Salary structure for M/s Shahabad Co-Operative
Sugar Mill will be as per Government Policy.
Also workers from nearby villages will be given
preference.
The ash which will be generated from the boiler
has 17 % potash and that can be used as a manure.
This ash will be sold out in packings and given to
farmers on subsidized rate.
5. Sh. Jasbir,
Village
Hamidpur
What will be
the policy
regarding the
employment
or others and
what will be
the
provisions
for the sale
of ash
Sh. Niram
Kashyap,
R.O. requested
to M.D.
Shahabad
Sugar mill for
reply-
Sh. Devinder
Kaushik, HCS
M.D.
(Shahabad
Sugar Mill)
replied that
there is no
fixed policy
regarding the
employment of
nearby
residents. The
Regarding Recruitment : Policy made by
Government of India will be followed:
Our salary structure for our employees should not
be less than minimum wages of Haryana.
We will employee skilled workers from nearby
villages
Sale of Ash: The ash which will be generated
from the boiler has 17 % potash and that can be
used as a manure. This ash will be sold out in
packings and given to farmers on subsidized rate
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 145
policy made by
the
Government
will be
implemented
and the
management
board will
decide about
the provisions
for sale of ash.
6. Sh. Nirmal
Kashyap,
R.O.
He asked
how many
villagers
desired to
establish this
project.
Villagers
replied that
they all want
this project
i. The implementation of this project will
generate both direct and indirect
employment.
ii. The project will also provide impetus to
industrialization of the area and would be
boom for the district as it will not only result
in employment opportunity but also
infrastructure development and overall
growth of the area.
7. Conclusion The public hearing held smoothly and ended with a vote of thanks to the chairperson
as well as to all villagers.
7.2 Risk Assessment
Ethanol Plant is associated with potential hazards that effect to the employee and
environment. It would normally require the assistance of emergency services to handle it
effectively. The operation shall be taken out under the well management and control by the
qualified safety manager.
Disaster management plan has to be formulated with an aim of taking precautionary steps
to avert disasters and also to take such action after the disaster which limits the damage to
the minimum.
Activities requiring assessment of risk due to occurrence of most probable instances of
hazard and accident are both onsite and off-site.
On-site
i.Exposure to fugitive dust, noise, and other emissions
ii.Housekeeping practices requiring contact with solid and liquid wastes
iii.Emission/spillage etc. from storage and handling
Off-site
i.Exposure to pollutants released from offsite/ storage/related activities
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 146
ii.Contamination due to accidental releases or normal release in combination with
natural hazard
iii.Deposition of toxic pollutants in vegetation / other sinks and possible sudden releases
due to accidental occurrences
7.2.1 Risk Analysis Methodologies
Risk assessment often requires the synthesis of risk profiles, which represent the
probability distribution of total annual loss due to a certain set of events or activities.
These assessments usually involve estimation of losses for several sub-classifications of
the overall process and synthesis of the results into an aggregate risk profile.
Main risk assessment technologies are:
a) Hazard and operability study (HAZOP),
b) Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)
7.2.2 HAZOP Study
The HAZOP study is a systematic technique of identifying hazards of operability problems
of a process and lists all possible deviations from normal operating condition and how they
might occur. The consequences of the process are assessed and the means available to
detect and correct the deviations are examined. Thus, within the entire process all
“cr d bl ” d v on h could l d o h z rdou v n or o rability problems are
identified.
7.2.3 Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)
FTA is primarily a means of analyzing non-identifiable hazards. Hazards of top events (the
ultimate happening that is to be avoided) are first identified by other techniques such as
HAZOP. Then all combinations of individual failures that can lead to that hazardous event
show the logical format of the fault tree. Estimating the individual probabilities and then
using the appropriate arithmetical expressions can calculate the top event frequency.
7.3 Disaster Management Plan
7.3.1 Definition
A major emergency in an activity/project is one which has the potential to cause serious
injury or loss of life. It may cause extensive damage to property and serious disruption
both inside and outside the activity/project. It would normally require the assistance of
emergency services to handle it effectively.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 147
7.3.2 Scope
An important element of mitigation is emergency planning, i.e. identifying accident
possibility, assessing the consequences of such accidents and deciding on the emergency
procedures, both on site and off site that would need to be implemented in the event of an
emergency.
Emergency planning is just one aspect of safety and cannot be considered in isolation from
the proposed 60 KLD capacity molasses based ethanol unit and hence before starting to
prepare the plan, works management will ensure that the necessary standards, appropriate
to safety legislation, are in place.
7.3.3 Objective
The overall objectives of the emergency plan will be:
To localize the emergency and, eliminate it; and
To minimize the effects of the accident on people and property.
Elimination will require prompt action by operations and works emergency staff using, for
example, fire–fighting equipment, water sprays etc.
Minimizing the effects may include rescue, first aid, evacuation, rehabilitation and giving
information promptly to people living nearby.
7.3.4 Identification of Hazards
The following types of hazards may be identified at Shahabad Ethanol plant.
Fire in Electric Panels, Oil room and alcohol storage.
Waste treatment processes.
Cleaning of barrels, which have held chemical substances.
To deal the above emergencies, the Emergency Plan is prepared.
7.3.5 Safety Measures for Storage and Handling of Alcohol
The alcohol will be directly fed to the bottling unit mechanically and no manual handling
will be involved which will reduce the risk of spillage in the storage area. Following
precautionary measures would be taken for safety
Handling and Storage; Keeping away from heat, sparks and open flame, care will be
taken for avoidance of spillage, skin and eye contact, well ventilation, Use of approved
respirator if air contamination is above acceptable level will be promoted. For Storage
and handling following precautions will be taken:
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 148
Keeping away from oxidizers, heat and flames.
Avoidance of plastics, rubber and coatings in the storage area.
Cool, dry, and ventilated storage and closed containers.
Grounding of the container and transferring of equipment to eliminate static electric
sparks.
In case of any emergency following measures would be taken:
First Aid Measures: For Skin contact, Eye contact, and Inhalation.
Fire Fighting Measures:
Use of extinguishing media surrounding the fire as water, dry chemicals (BC or ABC
powder), CO, Sand, dolomite, etc
Foam System for fire fighting will be provided to control fire from the alcohol storage
tank. The foam thus produced will suppress fire by separating the fuel from the air
(oxygen), and hence avoiding the fire and explosion to occur in the tank. Foam would
blanket the fuel surface smothering the fire. The fuel will also be cooled by the water
content of the foam.
The foam blanket suppresses the release of flammable vapors that can mix with the
air.
Special Fire Fighting Procedures; Keeping the fire upwind. Shutting down of all
possible sources of ignition, keeping of run-off water out of sewers and water
sources. Avoidance of water in straight hose stream which will scatter and spread fire.
Use of spray or fog nozzles will be promoted, cool containers will be exposed to
flames with water from the side until well after the fire is out.
Hazardous Decomposition Products: gases of Carbon Monoxide (CO) and Carbon
Dioxide (CO2).
Accidental Release Measures; For Spill Cleanup well Ventilation, Shutting off or
removal of all possible sources of ignition, absorbance of small quantities with paper
towels and evaporate in safe place like fume hood and burning of these towels in a safe
manner), Use of respiratory and/or liquid-contact protection by the Clean-up personnel
will be promoted.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 149
7.4 Emergency Planning
7.4.1 General
Disaster Management Plan for an industrial unit is necessarily a combination of various
actions which are to be taken in a very short time but in a present sequence to deal
effectively and efficiently with any disaster, emergency or major accident with an aim to
keep the loss of men, material, plant/machinery etc. to the minimum.
The main functions of the Disaster Management Cell are to prepare a detailed Disaster
Management Plan, which includes:
Identification of various types of expected disaster depending upon the type of the
industrial unit.
Identification of various groups, agencies, departments etc. necessary for dealing with a
specific disaster effectively.
Preparation – by intensive training of relevant teams/groups within the organization to
deal with a specific disaster and keep them in readiness.
Establishment of an early detection system for the disaster.
Development of a reliable instant information/communication system.
Organization and mobilization of all the concerned departments/ organizations / groups
and agencies instantly when needed.
A major disaster that can be expected due to fire in this proposed distillery.
7.4.2 Emergency Planning for Disaster due to Fire
Cable rooms, transformer, unit, auxiliary transformers, oil tanks, etc. within the plant are
the likely areas for which disaster management plan is to be made to deal with any
eventuality of fire. Stores, workshop, canteen and administrative building will be included.
7.4.2.1 Classification of Fire
Class (A)
Fire involving combustible materials like wood, paper, cloth etc.
Class (B)
Fire due to liquid materials like oil, diesel, petroleum products and all inflammables.
Class (C)
Fires involving domestic and industrial gases like butane and propane etc.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 150
Class (D)
Metal fires etc.
Class (E)
Electrical fires due to short circuiting etc.
7.4.3 Need of Establishing a Fire Fighting Group
A small spark of fire may result into loss of machines and the damage by fire may high
economic losses. This type of losses can be avoided by preventing and controlling the fire
instantly for which fire–fighting group will be established.
Establish which would house and keep in readiness, the following types of equipment and
arrangements.
CO2 extinguishers
Dry powder chemical extinguishers
Foam extinguishers
80 mm. spray hoses
Fire brigade
Fire hydrant
Protocol (chemical to combat oil fires).
In order to avoid fire in cable galleries, all the power and control cables of FRLS type (Fire
Resistant Low Smoke) will be used.
7.4.4 Inspection
Fire alarm panel (electrical) will cover the entire plant. The inspection group will
periodically inspect fire extinguishers in fire stations and machines and other places.
The groups will display emergency telephone number boards at vital points.
The group will regularly carry out general inspection for fire.
7.4.5 Procedure for Extinguishing Fire
The following steps will be taken during a fire accident in the system:
As soon as the message is received about fire, one of the systems will be diverted to the
place of the fire accident along with a staff member.
Simultaneously plant fire station will be informed by phone walkie for fire brigades and
fire stations of nearby area.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 151
In the meanwhile, the pipe system will be operated to obtain maximum pressure on output.
In case cables are within the reach of fire, power supply will be tripped and the cables
shifted.
7.4.6 Fire Fighting with Water
Adequate and reliable arrangement is required for fighting the fire with water such as:
1. Provision for Fire brigade and Fire hydrant.
2. Arrangement of pipelines along and around all vulnerable areas.
3. Provision of valves at appropriate points to enable supply of water at the required
place/area or divert the same to another direction/pipe line.
4. Provision of overhead tanks which will be providing with the water during power
failure and it would work by the gravitational force.
7.4.7 Sources of Water for Fire Fighting
The following two sources of water have been considered for firefighting:
Overhead Tank
Raw Water Reservoir
7.4.8 Fire Fighting with Fire Extinguishers
To deal with fire – other than carbonaceous fires, which can be deal with by water –
suitable fire extinguishers are required to do the job effectively. It is therefore, necessary to
keep adequate number of extinguishers in readiness at easily approachable places.
Adequate number of fire stations would be:
Further, other spray groups from the system will be diverted to the spot.
In case of fire in the belt, belt will be cut near the burning portion to save the
remaining parts.
After extinguishing the fire, the area will be well prepared for reuse.
Foam System for firefighting will be provided to control fire from the alcohol storage
tank. The foam thus produced will suppress fire by separating the fuel from the air
(oxygen), and hence avoiding the fire and explosion to occur in the tank. Foam would
blanket the fuel surface smothering the fire. The fuel will also be cooled by the water
content of the foam.
The foam blanket suppresses the release of flammable vapors that can mix with the
air.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 152
7.5 On–Site Emergency Plan
7.5.1 Introduction
The views of the possible hazards that can arise out of the daily operations in the distillery
plant, various measures are adopted to prevent the occurrence of a major accident. This
comprises of:
Built in safety measures, alarms, trips and interlocks etc.
Standard safe operating and maintenance procedures permit system etc.
Training of all the involved staff in normal and emergency operating procedures.
Training of all employees in safety, fire fighting and first aid.
However, in spite of these precautions, it is required to foresee situation of major
accident and plan for taking timely action to minimize the effects of such incident on
the safety and health of persons working in the plant as well as those living around
the premises.
7.6 Preparation of Plan
7.6.1 Alarm System
A siren shall be provided under the control of Security office in the plant premises to give
warning. In case of emergencies this will be used on the instructions to shift in charge that
is positioned round the clock. The warning signal for emergency shall be as follows:
– Emergency Siren: Waxing and waning sound for 3 minutes.
– All clear signal: Continuous siren for one minute.
7.6.2 Communication
Walkies and Talkies are located at strategic locations; internal telephone system EPBX
with external P and T telephones would be provided.
7.6.3 Fire Protection System
7.6.3.1 Fire Fighting System
The fire protection system for the unit is to provide for early detection, alarm, containment
and suppression of fires. The fire detection and protection system has been planned to meet
the above objective an all–statutory and insurance requirement of Tariff Advisory
Committee (TAC) of India. The complete fire protection system will comprise of the
following.
(a)Fire brigade
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 153
Automatic / manual fire detection and alarm system
(b)Fire Hydrant
Fire hydrant will be provided at all around in the plant as per TAC Norms.
(c)Portable fire extinguishers
Various areas of the plant will have one or more of the above system depending upon the
particular nature of risk involved in that area.
(d)Portable Chemical Fire Extinguishers
These are intended as a first line of defense, and hence will be stationed at strategic
locations in different buildings and also for outdoor facilities. Portable fire extinguishers
will be foam type; carbon dioxide type and multipurpose dry chemical (MPDC) type.
(e)Fire Detection and Alarm System
Fire detection and alarm system an effective means of detection, visual indication of fire
location and audible alarm of any fire at its incipient stage. This system will comprise fire
alarm panels, automatic fire detectors, manual call points and fire siren (hooter).
The main fire alarm panel will provide both visual and audible alarm of fire in any
protected areas of the plant.
Manual break glass type fire alarms will be provided at strategic locations where high
hazards exits.
Automatic fire detectors will be provided for coal handling areas and in plant areas such as
control rooms, switchgear rooms, cable galleries etc.
7.6.4 First Aid
A first aid centre with adequate facilities shall be provided. It shall be maintained round the
clock by a compounder cum dresser and a doctor. An Ambulance shall also be provided at
site to carry affected people to hospital.
7.6.5 Security
The security requirements of the company premises shall be taken care of by CSO assisted
by a Fire In charge. The team, apart from the normal security functions will manage the
role required during a disaster management operation as a part of the crisis control team.
7.6.6 Safety
The safety wing led by a Safety Manager will meet the requirement of emergencies round
the clock. The required safety appliances shall be distributed at different locations of the
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 154
plant to meet any eventualities. Poster/placards reflecting safety awareness will be placed
at different locations in the plant area.
7.6.7 Evacuation Procedure
As the major hazard is only due to fire, which has more or less localized impact no mass
evacuation, procedures are required. Evacuation would involve only the people working
very close to the fire area.
7.6.8 Emergency Control Center
Provision is made to establish an Emergency Control Centre (ECC) from which emergency
operations are directed and coordinated. This centre is activated as soon as on–site
emergency is declared.
The ECC consists of one room, located in an area that offers minimal risk being directly
exposed to possible accidents.
During an emergency, the Emergency Management Staff, including the site controller will
gather in the ECC. Therefore, the ECC is equipped with adequate communication systems
in the form of telephones and other equipments to allow unhampered organisations and
other nearby facility personnel.
The ECC provides shelter to its occupants against the most common accidents; in addition,
the ECC’s communication systems are protected from possible shutdown. The ECC has its
own emergency lighting arrangement and electric communication systems operation.
Only a limited and prearranged number of people are admitted to the ECC, when in use.
This eliminates unnecessary interference and reduces confusion.
The ECC is always ready for operation and provided with the equipment and supplies
necessary during the emergency such as:
– Updated copies of the On–site Disaster Management Plan.
– Emergency telephone numbers.
– The names, phone number, and address of external agencies, response organizations
and neighbouring facilities.
– The adequate number of telephone (more than two).
– Emergency lights, Clocks, Personal protective equipment.
– List of fire extinguishers with their type no. and location, capacity, etc.
– Safety helmets – List of quantity and location.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 155
– Status boards/message board.
– Material safety data sheets for chemicals handled at the facility.
– Several maps of the facility including drainage system for surrounding area showing:
Areas where hazardous materials are stored.
Plot plans of storage tanks, routes of pipelines, all water permanent lines etc.
The locations where personal protective equipment are stored.
The position of pumping stations and other water sources.
Roads and plant entrances.
Assembly areas and layout of Hydrant lines.
7.6.9 Communication Equipments and Alarm Systems
This kind of equipment is absolutely vital for notifying accident; make the emergency
known both inside and outside of the facility, and coordinating, the response actions among
the various groups involved in response operations.
In particular, this equipment is used to communicate within the facility; communicate
between the facility and outside organizations; and inform the public.
Different communications systems can vary in effectiveness, depending on the task. The
most common types installed in the plant are given below.
7.6.9.1Sirens
These are audible alarm systems commonly used in facilities. In case of any emergency
siren will be operated short intermittently for 1.5 minutes.
An alarm does more than just emergency warning. It also instructs people to carry out
specific assignments, such as reach to assembly point for further instructions and actions,
or carry out protective measures; this can be achieved only if the people are familiar with
the alarm systems and are trained to respond to it.
7.6.10 Personal Protective Equipments
This equipment is used mainly for three reasons; to protect personnel from a hazard while
performing rescue/accident control operations, to do maintenance and repair work under
hazardous conditions, and for escape purposes. The list of Personal Protective Equipment
provided at the facility and their locations are available in ECC.
Effective command and control accomplish these functions necessitates personal trained in
this On–site Disaster Management Plan with adequate facilities and equipments and
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 156
equipment to carry out their duties and functions. These organizations and the facilities
required to support their response are summarized in the following subsections.
7.6.11 Procedure for Testing and Updating the Plan
Simulated emergency preparedness exercises and mock fire fighting exercises
including mutual aid scheme resources and in conservation with district emergency
authority to be carried out time to time.
7.6.12 Disclosure of Information to Worker and Public Awareness System in Existence
and Anticipated
– Safety awareness among workers by conserving various training programmes and
Seminars, competition, slogans etc.
– Practical exercise.
– Distribution and practices of safety Instructions.
– Safety Quiz contests.
– Display of Safety Posters and Safety Slogans.
– Developing Safety Instructions for every Job and ensuring these
instructions/booklets or manuals by the workers.
7.7 Kurukshetra Disaster Management Plan
District Disaster Management Plan is attached as III.
7.8 Conservation Plan Indian Peafowl (Peacock)
Zoological name–Pavo cristatus
Peacock or Indian peafowl (Pavo cristatus) is a very familiar bird and also recognized as
National Bird of India. Asiatic peafowl like the Indian Blue Peafowl and especially the
Green Peafowl occupy a similar niche as the roadrunners, secretary bird and seriema. All
of these birds hunt for small animals including arthropods on the ground and tall grass
and minnows in shallow streams. Because of human encroachment into their natural
territories, peafowl and humans have come into increasing contact. Because of their
natural beauty some are reluctant to classify the birds as pests, but their presence can be
disturbing.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 157
CLASSIFICATION
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Aves
Order: Galliformes
Family: Phasianidae
Genus: Pavo
Species: Pavo cristatus
Vernacular name: Mor or Peacock
Conservation Status
IUCN: Others (LC) ver. 3.1
IWPA: Schedule I.
CITES: Not listed.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 158
Geographical Distribution: Pakistan, India and Sri Lanka. Many feral populations exist
throughout the world.
Description of Pavo cristatus: The male, known as a peacock, is a large bird with a
length from bill to tail of 100 to 115 cm (40 to 46 inches) and to the end of a fully grown
train as much as 195 to 225 cm (78 to 90 inches) and weigh 4–6 kg. The females, or
peahens, are smaller at around 95 cm (38 inches) in length and weigh 2.75–4 kg. Indian
Peafowl are among the largest and heaviest representatives of the Phasianidae family.
Their size, colour and shape of crest make them unmistakable within their native
distribution range. The male is metallic blue on the crown, the feathers of the head being
short and curled. The fan-shaped crest on the head is made of feathers with bare black
shafts and tipped with bluish-green webbing. A white stripe above the eye and a crescent
shaped white patch below the eye are formed by bare white skin. The sides of the head
have iridescent greenish blue feathers. The back has scaly bronze-green feathers with
black and copper markings. The scapular and the wings are buff and barred in black, the
primaries are chestnut and the secondary are black. The tail is dark brown and the train is
made up of elongated upper tail coverts (more than 200 feathers, the actual tail has only
20 feathers) and nearly all of these feathers end with an elaborate eye-spot. A few of the
outer feathers lack the spot and end in a crescent shaped black tip. The underside is dark
glossy green shading into blackish under the tail. The thighs are buff colored. The male
has a spur on the leg above the hind toe. Peacocks are polygamous and the breeding
season is spread out but appears to be dependent on the rains. Several males may
congregate at a leek site and these males are often closely related. Males at leek appear to
maintain small territories next to each other and they allow females to visit them and
make no attempt to guard harems. Females do not appear to favour specific males.
Peafowl are omnivorous and eat seeds, insects, fruits and reptiles. A large percentage of
their food is made up of the fallen berries. Around cultivated areas, peafowl feed on a
wide range of crops such as groundnut, tomato, paddy, etc. Around human habitations,
they feed on a variety of food scraps. In the countryside, it is particularly partial to crops
and garden plants.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 159
Habitat: The Indian Peafowl is found mainly on the ground in open scrub forest or on
land under cultivation where they forage for berries, grains but will also prey on snakes,
lizards and small rodents. Their loud calls make them easy to detect and in forest areas
often indicate the presence of a predator such as a tiger. They forage on the ground in
small groups and will usually try to escape on foot through undergrowth and avoid flying,
though they will fly into tall trees to roost. The bird has a celebrated status in Indian
mythology and hence protected culturally in India. The Indian Peafowl is listed as Least
Concern by IUCN.
Peafowl Behavior
Peacocks are gregarious by nature. In the breeding season they are usually seen in small
parties of one male with three to five females whereas in the non breeding season they
remain in separate parties of adult males and females with juveniles. Peacocks roost in
tall trees and emerge from the dense thickets to feed in fields and openings in forests and
fields.
Life Cycle
Voice/Call: Kee-ow, Kee-ow, Kee-ow, Ka-an, Ka-an, Ka-an, Kok-kok, Kok-kok, cain-
kok
Breeding: April-September.
Nest site: On ground in undergrowth (wild), on buildings by semi-feral birds in villages.
Life Span: The life expectancy is about 10-15 years.
Food Habit: Peacocks are ground fe d r Ind n fowl’ do o of h r for g ng
early in the morning and shortly before sunset. They retreat to the shade and security of
the trees for the hottest portion of the day. They make a meal of grains, berries drupes
wild figs and some cultivat d cro h y c n l o n c ’ ll r l nd ll
mammals.
Relationship with Man
The great beauty and popularity of the Indian Peafowl has ensured its protection
throughout its native ranges. It is a National bird of India. The peafowl is prominent in
the mythology and folklore of the Indian people. The Hindus consider the bird to be
sacred because of its association with Lord Krishna who used to wear its feather as crown
(Mor Mokut). It is also associated with the God Kartikeya, son of the Lord Shiva and
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 160
Parvati and brother of Lord Ganesh. It is Vaahan (transport) of Lord Kartikeya. This long
nd clo oc on w h hu n h rov n h fowl’ d b l y o hu n
altered landscapes. In villages where it is protected it becomes quite tame, but is very shy
and secretive where hunted. In the buffer area of mine site peacock is generally protected
by the local people.
Threats in the Study Area: No perceptible threats were identified in the villages
surveyed. Village residents are against hunting or poaching of the peafowl, due to culture
and mythology reasons. Adult peafowl can usually escape ground predators by flying into
trees.
a) Foraging in groups provides some safety as there are more eyes to look out for
predators.
b) Habitat loss, specially the shortage of tall trees in and around the villages for
roosting and for providing shade during hot summer months.
c) Shortage of drinking water for the birds during the hot summer days.
d) Casualties caused by eating chemically treated agricultural crop seeds.
e) Illegal hunting by some communities.
Conservation through Habitat Improvement and Awareness: Habitat improvement
programme will be undertaken through plantation of suitable tree species in the
surrounding villages. While selecting the tree/ shrub species care shall be provided for
beery plants which attract these birds. During summer period, villagers will be
encouraged to use the old earthen pots to fill with water for drinking these birds. Summer
is the time when these. Birds are facing shortage of feeds; there by supplying the feed
like Bajri, Juwar, Maize to the identified villages will suffix the problem of food
shortage. The proponent can directly supply these feed to the villages directly or by
funding to the NGOs active in this mission.
Feeding and Watering Arrangement: Artificial water holes will be created along the
natural drained nallahs which can sufficient drinking water up to summer of the region.
An anicut and open wall will be created by the company as their community development
programme involving the local panchayats in this work. Proposition for the suitable place
to increase population of birds near plant nursery and office plantation will help.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 161
Provision for artificial nests, feeding trays and water troughs is under consideration. To
support furgivorous birds, artificial feed like wild fruits and vegetables will be provided.
Direct and indirect approach is required to provide effective conservation, which is
recommended as under:
Increasing the tree cover in the buffer area for shelter and roosting of peacocks. This will
be achieved by planting of tree groves (a group of trees that grow close together,
generally without many bushes or other plants) in buffer area. Some local species such as
Neem, Siris, Amaltash, Ardu, Shesham, Dhak, Peepal tree etc. will be plant. Planting of
tree groves in school compounds in the villages of buffers area will be plant as per the
plantation programme.
By conducting awareness programmes (community and school level) for conservation of
peacocks in the area and also through organizing competitions during Wildlife Week and
Van Mahotsav celebrations.
Some provision of rewards to informers for the control of poaching and illegal trade in
wildlife.
Carrying out census and research projects to know the potential threats and population
status of the species.
Provision of veterinary care and cages for injured or sick or deformed birds.
Suggest strategies to minimize negative impacts of changing environment in nearby area
of peacock populations and to promote conservation of peacock habitats.
Another way to help preserve the endangered species is to create society dedicated to
ecological ethics. All the conservation measures will be implemented with the help of and
in the consultation of the district forest department.
With the objective of effectively protecting the wild life and to control poaching,
smuggling and illegal trade in wildlife and its derivatives, the Government of India
enacted Wild Life (Protection) Act 1972. The Act was amended in January 2003 and
punishment and penalty for offences under the Act have been made more stringent.
The proponent has proposed a sum of Rs 47,000/- for the Peacock Conservation Plan under the
following heads:
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 162
Table 7.2 : Budget detail for conservation plan
S.No. Activity Cost (Rs.)
1. Plantation of 500 Trees (as community forestry, apart from
green belt).
10,000/- @ 20/- per
plant
2. Small water tank or Tankar–12 in number @ 2000/- per tank. 24,000/-
3. 3 cash prizes @ 1000 in a year will be awarded to the informer
of poachers.
3,000/-
4. Misc. Use (Wildlife Week, Van Mahotsav Celebration, etc.) 10,000/-
Total 47,000/-
7.8 Summary
The public consultation was conducted by Haryana State Pollution Control Board,
Panchkula on 19th
May 2015, 11 A.M. at Village Jandheri, Tehsil Shahabad, District
Kurukshetra (Haryana). The Public consultation advertisement has been published in
Dainik Jagran Newspaper on dated 17th
April, 2015. The public hearing held smoothly and
ended with a vote of thanks to the chairperson as well as to all villagers.
Ethanol Plant is associated with potential hazards that effect to the employee and
environment. It would normally require the assistance of emergency services to handle it
effectively. The operation shall be taken out under the well management and control by the
qualified safety manager. Activities requiring assessment of risk due to occurrence of most
probable instances of hazard and accident are both onsite and off-site. Emergency planning
is just one aspect of safety and cannot be considered in isolation from the proposed 60
KLD capacity molasses based ethanol unit and hence before starting to prepare the plan,
works management will ensure that the necessary standards, appropriate to safety
legislation, are in place. Personal protective equipment is used mainly for three reasons; to
protect personnel from a hazard while performing rescue/accident control operations, to do
maintenance and repair work under hazardous conditions, and for escape purposes. Safety
awareness among workers by conserving various training programmes and Seminars,
competition, slogans etc. will be done.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 163
Chapter -8
Project Benefits 8.1 Introduction
Any industrial activity will help in improving the socio-economic benefits like
employment, communication, education etc.
8.2 Employment Potential
The Shahabad Sugar Mills Limited will recruit manpower of around 110 for proposed
ethanol plant during operational phase, apart from that many people are going to be
employed indirectly.
The following benefits are expected due to the implementation of the said project:
i. The easy availability of infrastructure, man power, raw materials will reduce the
production cost as well as demand supply gap. The same will bring revenue to the
state exchequer by way of Duties and Taxes.
ii. The development of green belt in and around the plant premises will improve
on the aesthetics of the area. Moreover, it will help in reducing the noise levels
within the plant boundary.
iii. The setting up of the proposed plant will help in providing employment to local
people.
iv. There will be an increase in indirect employment and earnings of the small time
shop owners like tea vendors, transporters, etc.
v. The implementation of Rain Water Harvesting Scheme will help in increasing the
ground water level of the area.
The Project proponent has planned to contribute in socio-economic development of the
area and will organize Blood donation camps, Education Programmes, Health camps,
Health awareness programmes etc. and will continue to do so.
8.3 Corporate Social Responsibility
Corporate social responsibility is the commitment of businesses to contribute to sustainable
economic development by working with the employees, their families, local community
and society at large to improve their lives in ways that are good for business as well as
overall development. It is a voluntary activity of a company that supports social interests
and environmental issues. It is a principle through which the business houses contribute to
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 164
the welfare of the society and not only maximize their profits. CSR, in fact, is about
business giving back to the society. Some of the CSR related activities alongwith budget
allocated are summarized as Table 8.1.
Table 8.1 Breakup of CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility)
S.No. Particular Cost (Lakhs)
1. Medical Camps 2.0
2. Drinking water supply 2.0
3. Adoption of Surrounding Villages (2 ladies Toilet/Village will
be constructed)
3.0
4. Public Welfare (Swach Bharat Abhiyan) 2.0
5. Miscellaneous 1.0
Total 10.0 Lakh
8.4 Summary
The management will recruit the semi-skilled, unskilled workers from the nearby
villagers. The project activity and the management will definitely support the local
Panchayat and provide other form of assistance for the development of public amenities
in this region. The company management will contribute to the local schools,
dispensaries for the welfare of the villagers. Green belt development/plantation will be
taken around the plant premises. Rain water harvesting/recharge will also be done to
improve ground water level.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 165
Chapter -9
Environmental Cost Benefit Analysis 9.1 Project Cost and Project Appraisal
After making exhaustive study of the infrastructure available in regards to availability of
molasses, it is considered that the distillery project may be implemented. Project cost for
the proposed scheme of 60 KLD molasses based ethanol project has been estimated to the
tune of Rs. 6170.00 lakhs on the basis of the prevailing market price as under:
Major Heads Cost (Lakhs)
Land and Site development 50.00
Building and Civil works 348.00
Plant and Machinery with boundaries 5180.00
Miscellaneous fixed assets 42.00
Interest and other expenses during construction period to be capitalized --
Preoperative expenses --
Stores and Spares 32.00
Start up expenses 24.00
Provision for contingencies 279.00
Margin money for working capital --
Total 6170.00
9.2 Financial Pattern
For the proposed scheme of distillery of 60 KLD ethanol project the financing pattern of
the estimated capital cost amounting to Rs. 6170.00 lakhs has been envisaged as under:-
S. No. Particulars %age Cost (Lakhs)
Equity
Internal Generation
20 1234.00
Loan
a. Loan from Harco Bank 40 2468.00
b. Loan from SDF 40 2468.00
Total 100.00 6170.00
9.3 Schedule of Project Implementation
The estimated capital cost and financial viability of the present scheme has been worked
out on the assumption that the above scheme shall be completed by the end of November,
2015.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 166
9.4 Physical Targets
The financial feasibility and profitability projections along with cash flow for the next 10
years after completion of 60 KLD ethanol project are based on the following physical
parameters.
Physical Targets
The financial feasibility and profitability projections along with cash flow for the next 10
year after completion of the scheme for the production of ethanol are based on the
following physical parameters.
S. No. Particulars Unit Parameters
i. Installed capacity
(In terms of total spirit)
LPD 60.000
ii. Working days Days 330
iii. Capacity utilization % 80-90
iv. Capacity utilization LPD 48000-54000
v. Production of Total spirit K. litre 15800-17820
vi. Production of ENA K. litre Nil
vii. Production of Ethanol K. litre 15048- 16929
viii. Production of Fusel Oil % T.S. 79-89
ix. Production of bio-compost Ton Nil
x. Production of Grain Stillage Ton 10240-11520
Financial Parameters
S.
No.
Particulars Parameters
1. Sales Realizations
a. Ethanol Rs. 39.00 per liter
b. Impure Spirit Rs. 35.00 per litre
c. Fusel Oil Rs. 30/- per litre
d. From Bio-compost Rs. 1500/- per ton
e. Carbon Dioxide Rs. 3000 per ton
2. Molasses (Incldg. Taxes
and Trans. Charges)
a. Own production Rs. 6600/- per ton
b. Procured from outside Rs. 7200/- per ton
3. Fuel (Rice Husk) Rs. 3500/- per ton
4. Operating and
Maintenance Charges
Rs. 30.00 lakh
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 167
S.
No.
Particulars Parameters
5. Process material and
consumables including de-
hydrating agent losses etc.
Rs. 700/- per kilo litre
6. Salary and wages Rs. 80 lakh in first year and 5% increase every
year.
7. Intt. On term loan from
Financial instt./ Harco
Bank
@ 13% per annum on reducing balance method.
Repayment in assumed in 7 years.
8. SDF Loan @ 7 % per annum on reducing balance method.
Repayment in four years after moratorium of one
year.
9. Interest on working capital @ 11% per annum on 16.67% average stock with
30% margin.
10. Administrative overheads Rs. 24.00 Lakhs per year.
11. Depreciation On straight line method as per rates provides in
income Tax Act.
The project financial forecast for the annual working for the next 10 years after completion
of the project has been worked out on the basis of above physical Financial Parameters.
The total summarized results for the above mentioned period of 10 years are as under:-
S. No. Particulars Rs. (Lakhs)
1. Net Sales 75533.87
2. Raw material 48651.36
3. Cash conversion cost 10395.84
4. Total cash cost of production (without dep.
and intt.)
59047.20
5. Depreciation 3683.50
6. Interest on term loan 1962.06
7. Interest on working capital 838.07
8. Total cost of production 65530.83
9. Profit and Loss before tax 10003.04
10. Provision for income tax 2727.94
11. Profit and Loss after tax 7275.10
12. Add: back depreciation 3683.50
13. Total cash accruals 10958.60
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 168
Production Profitability and Debt service
It is apparent from the 1st year after commissioning of the project and the total amount of
term loan of Bank/SDF including interest thereon will be repaid fully by the end of 8th
year
after completion of the scheme.
During the span of 8 years after completion of ethanol scheme, the factory will generate its
own financial resources (before interest on term loan and after depreciation) to the tune of
Rs/ 8675.50 After adding back interest on term loan, the total cash available for debt
service will be Rs. 10637.56 Lakhs, whereas the total debt service including interest on
term loan and installments of term loan to be repaid to the financial institutions and others
works out to Rs. 6898.06 lakhs. Thus, the average debt service coverage for the repayment
of term loan and interest thereon comes to 1.54. Other Parameters for capital investment
are as follows:
a) Pay Back Period
The payback period of capital cost of the project will be about five years and ten
months approximately.
b) The breakeven point
The breakeven point at the installed capacity is 48.91%.
c) I.R.R.
The simple internal Rate of Return on capital investment of Rs. 6170.00 Lakhs on 10
years basis comes to 20.94.
9.5 Summary
Total Project cost is 6170.00 Lakhs. The financial feasibility and profitability projections
shows that cash back period for proposed project is 10 year. From the above financial
analysis it is clear that the ethanol plant is financial and technically viable.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 169
Chapter -10
Environment Management Plan 10.0 Introduction
The environmental management plan consists of the set of mitigation, management,
monitoring and institutional measures to be taken during implementation and operation to
eliminate adverse environmental impacts or reduce them to acceptable levels. The present
environmental management plan addresses the components of environmental affected
during construction of the plant and by the different activities forming part of the
manufacturing processes.
Objective of Environmental Policy
i. Overall conservation of environment.
ii. Minimization of waste generation and pollution.
iii. Judicious use of natural resources and water.
iv. Safety, welfare and good health of the work force and populace.
v. Ensure effective operation of all control measures.
vi. Vigilance against probable disasters and accidents.
vii. Monitoring of cumulative and long time impacts.
viii. Ensure effective operation of all control measures.
Annual review of the entire system and various environment management as well as
process control and monitoring systems shall be done. Environment monitoring shall be
done to collect the data on air, water, soil, noise etc. and duly recorded. Environmental
Management Plan which shall be implemented is detailed under the following heads.
i. Pollution control systems.
ii. Waste minimization and resource conservation.
iii. Occupational health and safety.
iv. Socio-Economic development.
v. Greenbelt development plan.
10.1 Pollution Control System
Detailed study of the pre-project commissioning environment and also the likely (and
predicted) implications after the plant commissioning suggests that the following
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 170
preventive/control measures are considered necessary to reduce the adverse impact to the
utmost practicable limit.
10.1.1 Air Environment
i. Stack height would be approx. 45 m for the boiler for gaseous emission confirming to
the CPCB norms. For D. G. Sets, stack height of 8 m above the roof level will be
maintained.
ii. Stack emission level from boiler will be kept within permissible limit by installation
of ESP/ Bag House and online stack emission monitoring will be done.
iii. Ambient air quality and stack emission would be regularly monitored and effective
control exercised, so as to keep limits on stack emission loads would be met honestly
at all the time.
iv. In order to avoid fugitive emissions from different sources, dust collectors will be
provided at material transfer points. Also the roads within the premises will be
concreted to avoid vehicular emissions.
v. The ambient air monitoring will be carried out regularly in the work zone and
surrounding areas, which shows that ambient air levels of the contaminants, are well
below the stipulated norms.
vi. Green belt around the periphery and within premises will be developed which will
help in attenuating the pollutants emitted by the plant.
vii. The storage yard for rice husk and coal will be properly covered and sheded
respectively.
10.1.2 Action Plan to Control Fugitive Emission
Main source of fugitive emissions is transportation of men and material during operational
phase of project. To control fugitive emissions following measures shall be adopted:
i. In order to avoid fugitive emissions from different sources, dust collectors will be
provided at material transfer points.
ii. The roads within the premises will be concreted / paved to avoid vehicular emissions.
iii. All transportation vehicles shall carry a valid PUC (Pollution under Control)
Certificate.
iv. Proper servicing and maintenance of vehicles will be carried out.
v. Regular sweeping of all the roads and floors will be done.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 171
vi. Adequate green belt shall be developed in the plant area. Green belt act as surface for
settling of dust particle and thus will reduce the particulate matter in air.
vii. Ambient air quality will be regularly monitored and effective control exercised, so as
to keep emission within the limits.
Table 10.1 Action Plan to Control Fugitive Emissions
S.No. Emissions Sources Management measures
1. Fuel and ash
transfer
Mechanized Handling and conveying with proper hood
Cover Definite Loading Point
Covered transfer points
2. Vehicular
emissions
Paved roads
Regular sweeping
Water sprinkling through mobile tankers
CPCB Guidelines will be followed.
10.1.3 Waste Water Environment
i. The proposed Molasses based distillery would be based on “Zero Liquid Discharge”
(ZLD)
ii. Spent wash will be concentrated in MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator), than the
semisolid waste from MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator) will be sent in specially
designed boiler for incineration.
iii. Condensate will be treated in condensate polishing unit and will used as make-up
water in cooling tower.
iv. A duly lined lagoon of 30 days capacity shall be provided.
v. Online effluent quality monitoring system will be installed at the outlet of the unit for
measurement of the parameters flow, pH, COD, BOD and TSS etc. and transmission
of online data to Haryana State Pollution Control Board and CPCB will be done
10.1.4 Solid Waste Environment
i. Boiler ash collected and sold to brick manufacturers.
ii. The other solid wastes expected from the unit are containers, empty drums which are
returned to the product seller or sold to authorize buyers after detoxification.
10.1.5 Noise Environment
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 172
Various components of industrial operations will cause some amount of noise, which will
be controlled by proper maintenance and compact technology.
i. Time to time oiling and servicing of machineries will be done
ii. Acoustic enclosure for Turbine and D.G. sets would be used
iii. Green belt development (plantation of dense trees across the boundary) will help in
reducing noise levels in the plant as a result of attenuation of noise generated due to
plant operations, and transportation.
10.1.6 Odour Management
The main causes of odour at distilleries are as under:
i.Bad management of fermentation house;
ii.Long retention of fermented wash;
iii.Unattended drains;
The remedial measures will be taken such as Better house-keeping by regular steaming of
all fermentation equipments; Temperature will be kept under control during fermentation
to avoid in-activation/killing of yeast; Staling of fermented wash would also be avoided.
10.1.7 Green Belt Development
Green belt planning will be done with ecological perspectives for distillery plant of
Shahabad Ethanol plant taking into consideration the nature of pollutants, availability of
space and dominant wind directions. Recommendations given by expert committee on
plantation requirements in the premises of the plant would be fully implemented. This will
help in reducing the concentration of pollutants and will also be effective in attenuating
noise levels.
Shahabad Coop. Sugar Mills Limited has social obligation to recreate the environmental
status by providing thick green cover to suppress fugitive emission and provide aesthetic
beauty. Trees form the important part of the biosphere in the Eco-system.
It will be exercised as follows:
i. Green belt development in and around the project site will help in to attenuate the
pollution level.
ii. Out of the total plant area 33% land will be utilized for green belt development and
plantation will be done as per Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) Norms.
iii. Native species will be given priority for Avenue plantation.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 173
iv. The periphery will be devoted to generation of green belt area.
v. Species like Azadirechta indica, Bombax ceiba, Ceiba pentandra, Pongamia pinnata,
Syzygium cumini, Cassia siamea, Populus species, Terminalia arjuna will be planted.
10.1.8 Occupational Health and Safety
Production of ethanol involves storage handling and use of several chemicals. Some of
these chemicals are toxic and hazardous in nature. Information about these chemicals is
therefore important for the safety of the employees and the plant. Besides, the health status
of the employees is also important which may be affected due to exposure to these
chemicals. The exposures may be sudden and accidental or for a long period. In both of the
cases there will be different health effects. Therefore safety measures dealing with these
chemicals are of vital importance and will be followed judiciously.
1. In order to ensure good health of workers, regular health check-up of the plant
workers will be carried out.
2. Occupational health surveillance programme will be taken as a regular exercise for all
the employees and their records maintained.
3. Proper storage and handling precautions will be taken. The storage area will be cool,
dry and well ventilated away from any source of heat, flame or oxidizers.
4. Use of Personal Protective Equipment (PPEs) will be encouraged. Proper training on
use of PPEs, characteristics of the material handled and safety precautions to be
adopted will be given to the workers.
5. Fire safety measures will be incorporated within the factory premises. All the fire
extinguishing media such as water, dry chemicals, CO2, sand, dolomite, etc. will be
kept in vital locations.
6. Mock drills will be arranged for the worker to test the effectiveness of the training
program from time to time and the way to react in case of emergency.
7. Safety precautions will be displayed in the premises on the banners, boards etc.
8. Both On-site and Off-site emergency preparedness plan will be drawn.
10.2 Overall Recommendation and Implementation Schedule
10.2.1 Introduction
The mitigation measures suggested in earlier Chapters 4 are to be implemented so as to
reduce the impact on the environment due to proposed project. The implementation of
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 174
these recommendations could be done in phases so that, the most important mitigation
measures would be implemented first and the mitigation measures, which are less
important, could be implemented later.
Along with the implementation of these mitigation measures, monitoring schedule and
infrastructural requirements for environmental protection detailed in previous chapter are
important for environmental control measures.
10.3 Budget and Procurement Schedule
On regular basis, Environment Management Cell shall inspect the necessity and
vailability of the materials, technologies, services and maintenance works. The Cell shall
make appropriate budget for the purpose. Regular record review for any change in
financial requirement of environment management shall be done and appropriate
budgetary provisions shall be made. Along with other budgets, Budget for
environmental management shall be prepared and revised regularly as per requirement.
The budget shall include provisions for:
a. Environmental Monitoring Program.
b. Operation and Maintenance of Environmental Technologies / Equipments.
c. Laboratory works for Environmental management activities.
d. Emergency Purchase of necessary material, equipments, tools, services.
e. Greenbelt development.
f. Social and Environmental Welfare and Awareness programs / training (CSR).
g. Annual Environmental Audit.
Budget for Environmental Management Plan
The total capital investment on environmental control measures is envisaged to be about
Rs 815 Lakhs out of a total project cost of Rs. 6170.00 Lakh. Details are given in
Table-10.2.
Table 10.2 EMP Cost Details
S.
No.
Particulars Initial Cost
(Lakhs)
Recurring
Cost (Lakhs)
1. Air Pollution Control (ESP) 200.00 25.00
2. Wastewater
Treatment
Mulitple Effect Evaporator 280.00 15.00
ETP and Others 160.00 12.00
3. Fire and Safety 80.00 5.00
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 175
4. Green Belt Development/Solid Waste
Disposal
5.00 5.00
5. Rain Water harvesting/Recharge 15.00 1.00
6. Mini Lab Setup 40.00 5.00
7. Occupational Health 50.00 5.00
Total 815.00 73.00
10.4 Waste Minimization, recycle/reuse/recover techniques
The proposed Molasses based distillery would be based on “Zero Liquid Discharge”
(ZLD), therefore there will be no effluent discharge out of plant premises.
Recycle/Reuse/Recover
Spent wash will be concentrated in MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator), than the
semisolid waste from MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator) will be sent in specially
designed boiler for incineration. Condensate will be treated in condensate polishing unit
and will used as make-up water in cooling tower.
Boiler ash collected and sold to brick manufacturers. The other solid wastes expected
from the unit are containers, empty drums which are returned to the product seller or
sold to authorize buyers after detoxification.
10.4.1 Energy Conservation/Natural Resource Conservation
LED will be used in whole plant premises, and hence energy will be conserved. Waster
after treatment in ETP will be reused.
10.5 Summary
The environmental management plan consists of the set of mitigation, management,
monitoring and institutional measures to be taken during implementation and
operation to eliminate adverse environmental impacts or reduce them to acceptable
levels. Effective environmental management plan will be formed. Stack height would
be approx. 45 m for the boiler for gaseous emission confirming to the CPCB norms.
For D. G. Sets, stack height of 8 m above the roof level will be maintained. In order
to avoid fugitive emissions from different sources, dust collectors will be provided at
material transfer points. Spent wash will be concentrated in MEE (Multiple Effect
Evaporator), than the semisolid waste from MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator) will be
sent in specially designed boiler for incineration. A duly lined lagoon of 30 days
capacity will be provided. Boiler ash collected and will be sold to brick
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. Final EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Captive Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 176
manufacturers. Green belt development (plantation of dense trees across the
boundary) will help in reducing noise levels in the plant as a result of attenuation of
noise generated due to plant operations, and transportation. Fire safety measures will
be incorporated within the factory premises. All the fire extinguishing media such as
water, dry chemicals, CO2, sand, dolomite, etc. will be kept in vital locations. LED
will be used in whole plant premises, and hence energy will be conserved. Waster
after treatment in ETP will be reused.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 177
Chapter -11
Summary and Conclusion 11.1 Introduction
Shahabad coop. sugar mills is planning to set up a 60 KLD capacity molasses based
ethanol unit having 3.0 MW captive power plant at Village. Jandheri, Tehsil. Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana. The project is planned to be established over an area of
84326.4 m2. The plant will operate 330 days in a year and will produce ethanol. The power
will be generated with steam during the process. As per the EIA notification, 2006 this
project falls under Category ‘A’ and Project or Activity 5(g), hence require Environmental
Clearance.
11 .2 Project Description
M/s Shahabad Coop. Sugar Mills is planning to set up a 60 KLD capacity molasses based
ethanol unit having 3.0 MW captive power plant at Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana. Total land requirement for the project is 84326.4 m2.
Fermentation and Distillation process will be used for production of ethyl alcohol. Water
requirement will be 950 KLD. The requirement of Power for the unit is 1780 KW. 110
persons will be engaged for this project. Adequate Environmental protection measures as
well as health related measures will be taken.
11.3 Description of the Environment
Various environmental parameters study has been done within 10 Km radius area of the
proposed project site. The ToR presentation for proposed project was held on 20th
January, 2015 and ToR was granted by MoEF&CC on 31st March, 2014. M/s Shahabad
Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. requested vide letter dated 30th
December, 2014 to
MoEF&CC regarding permission to start baseline monitoring from 1st October to 31
st
December 2014. During ToR Presentation Experts Committee Members accepted the
period from 1st October to 31
st December 2014 and desired that one month additional
data to be collected. As per EAC recommendation additional one month (1st January to
31st January 2015) data collection has been done. The baseline information on micro-
meteorology, ambient air quality, water quality, noise levels, soil quality and floristic
descriptions are largely drawn from the data generated by M/s Vardan Enviro Lab,
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 178
Gurgaon (NABL Accredited Lab). Land use pattern shows that most of the land is
agriculture land. The study area represents almost flat alluvial plain without any
conspicuous topographical features. The area falls in the Upper Jamuna and Ghaggar
Basins and the principal ground water reservoir in the area is unconsolidated alluvial
deposits of Quaternary age. Ambient Air Quality Monitoring reveals that the minimum
and maximum concentrations of PM10 for all the 06 AAQM stations were found to be
41.4 g/m3 and 69.2 g/m
3 respectively, while for PM2.5 it vary between 25.0 g/m
3 to
40.1 g/m3. The maximum and minimum concentrations of SO2 were found to be 14.7
g/m3 to 25.0 g/m
3 respectively. The maximum and minimum concentrations of NO2
were found to be 15.0 g/m3 to 28.0 g/m3 respectively. Maximum and minimum noise
levels recorded during the day time were from 54.10 Leq dB and 49.67 Leq dB
respectively and maximum and minimum level of noise during night time were 44.70 Leq
dB and 42.00 Leq dB respectively. Thus noise levels at all locations were observed to be
within the prescribed limits. The analysis results show that soil was basic in nature as pH
value ranges from 7.23 to 8.10 with water holding capacity of 36.78 to 42.80%. Analysis
results of ground water reveal the results: pH varies from 7.60 to 8.30, total hardness
varies from 156.0 to 416.0 mg/L, total dissolved solids varies from 302.00 to 532.50
mg/L. All the basic facilities like road and rail network, medical facilities, post and
telegraph, market, drinking water facilities and education facilities are available. The
project will also provide impetus to industrialization of the area and would be boon for
the district as it will not only result in employment opportunity but also infrastructure
development and overall growth of the area.
11.4 Anticipated Environmental Impact and Mitigation Measures
The construction and operational phase of the proposed project comprises various
activities each of which will have an impact on some or other environmental
parameters.
Construction Phase
This phase involves the activities like erection of civil structures, movement/ removal
of old construction, erection of new equipment and machinery, green belt development
etc. Air, Noise and Land are likely to be effected by these activities, although
Aesthetics and Socio-economic factors are also identified. But the impacts will be
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 179
marginal and for short term only. The green belt development will have positive
impacts. The impact on land use will be long term and permanent but will be on a
smaller scale. Construction of plant will lead to permanent change in land use pattern at
the site as a direct impact. The excavation material should be dumped in low lying
areas so as to reduce visual impact. Impacts of construction activities on air quality are
cause for concern mainly in the dry months due to dust particles generated from
leveling, grading, earthworks, and other construction related activities. The dust
generated is in the range of 2500-3000 µg/m3. By adopting mitigation measures the
emission level will be brought down and PM10 will be minimized below 100 µg/m3.
Effluents from the construction area mainly contain suspended solids while the sanitary
waste from the labour colonies contains suspended matter. Adequate arrangements for
proper drainage and disposal of wastewater and routing of the effluents from
construction area through sedimentation basins and provision of proper sanitary
facilities with treatment will eliminate these problems of water pollution. Moreover,
these impacts will be temporary in nature. The major sources of noise during the
construction phase are vehicular traffic, construction equipment like dozers, scrapers,
concrete mixers, cranes, generators, pumps, compressors, rock drills, pneumatic tools,
vibrators etc. The operation of these equipments will generate noise ranging between
70-90 dB (A). Mandatory use of personal protective equipment like ear plugs will be
ensured to mitigate any significant impact of such equipment on personnel operating
the machinery. During construction phase of the proposed project, labors will be
required and this requirement will meet from surrounding area. Hence, positive impact
will be on Socio economic environment.
Operation Phase
This phase of the project is important because it generates long-term impacts as the
production starts. The primary impacts causing likely deterioration will be in Air,
Water, Noise and Land / Soil due to the gaseous emissions, vehicular movement, and
discharge of liquid effluent. During transportation of raw material finished product
there will be generation of dust emission from the road. In order to control the emission
level of 1500-2000 mg/m3 the ESP of (99.8%) will be installed which will be bring
down the emission level within permissible limit of 50 mg/m3. Total except for the
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 180
major and most harmful effluent (spent wash) from the analyzer column and fermenter
sludge, other effluents are quite small and do not need any specific treatment. Spent
wash will be concentrated in MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator), then the semisolid
waste from MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator) will be sent in specially designed boiler
for incineration. Annually about 13111.16 m3 water will be conserved by rain water
harvesting system and will be discharge in ground water through recharge pit. The
predicted resultant noise levels found near plant boundary vary between 50.18 to 50.20
dB (A), which is dependent on the baseline noise level and the predicted incremental
noise level. Noise level can be reduced by stopping leakages from various steam lines,
compressed air lines and other high pressure equipment. There is no discharge of waste
water onto land. The solid wastes will be segregated according to their properties,
packed, transported and stored in a separate impervious storage area demarcated for
them. The proposed project will generate the employment to local people. Solid waste
and Hazardous waste will be store separately. Hazardous waste will be send to TSDF
site.
It has been concluded that the proposed project has no major adverse impact on
surrounding environment.
11.5 Analysis of Alternative Site
No alternate site has been proposed for our 60 KLD capacity molasses based ethanol plant
having 3.0 MW Captive Power Plant in conformity with Steam plant capacity at Village-
Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad, Dist.-Kurukshetra, Haryana.
11.6 Environmental Monitoring Programme
For the proposed project post monitoring program has been prepared. Sampling stations
will be selected on the basis of CPCB guidelines. Monitoring of environmental samples
shall be done as per the guidelines provided by MoEF&CC, CPCB and HSPCB. The
method followed shall be recommended / standard method approved / recommended by
MoEF&CC and CPCB.
An environment management cell will be formed. Adequate fund will be allocated for
Environmental Protection Measures and CSR Activities.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 181
11.7 Additional Studies
The public consultation was conducted by Haryana State Pollution Control Board,
Panchkula on 19th
May 2015, 11 A.M. at Village Jandheri, Tehsil Shahabad, District
Kurukshetra (Haryana). The Public consultation advertisement has been published in
Dainik Jagran Newspaper on dated 17th
April, 2015. The public hearing held smoothly and
ended with a vote of thanks to the chairperson as well as to all villagers.
Ethanol Plant is associated with potential hazards that effect to the employee and
environment. It would normally require the assistance of emergency services to handle it
effectively. The operation shall be taken out under the well management and control by the
qualified safety manager. Activities requiring assessment of risk due to occurrence of most
probable instances of hazard and accident are both onsite and off-site. Emergency planning
is just one aspect of safety and cannot be considered in isolation from the proposed 60
KLD capacity molasses based ethanol unit and hence before starting to prepare the plan,
works management will ensure that the necessary standards, appropriate to safety
legislation, are in place. Personal protective equipment is used mainly for three reasons; to
protect personnel from a hazard while performing rescue/accident control operations, to do
maintenance and repair work under hazardous conditions, and for escape purposes. Safety
awareness among workers by conserving various training programmes and Seminars,
competition, slogans etc. will be done.
11.8 Project Benefits
The management will recruit the semi-skilled, unskilled workers from the nearby
villagers. The project activity and the management will definitely support the local
Panchayat and provide other form of assistance for the development of public amenities
in this region. The company management will contribute to the local schools,
dispensaries for the welfare of the villagers. Green belt development/plantation will be
taken around the plant premises. Rain water harvesting/recharge will also be done to
improve ground water level.
11.9 Environmental Cost Benefit Analysis
Total Project cost is 6170.00 Lakhs. The financial feasibility and profitability projections
shows that cash back period for proposed project is 10 year. From the above financial
analysis it is clear that the ethanol plant is financial and technically viable.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 182
11.10 Environment Management Plan
The environmental management plan consists of the set of mitigation, management,
monitoring and institutional measures to be taken during implementation and
operation to eliminate adverse environmental impacts or reduce them to acceptable
levels. Effective environmental management plan will be formed. Stack height would
be approx. 45 m for the boiler for gaseous emission confirming to the CPCB norms.
For D. G. Sets, stack height of 8 m above the roof level will be maintained. In order
to avoid fugitive emissions from different sources, dust collectors will be provided at
material transfer points. Spent wash will be concentrated in MEE (Multiple Effect
Evaporator), than the semisolid waste from MEE (Multiple Effect Evaporator) will be
sent in specially designed boiler for incineration. A duly lined lagoon of 30 days
capacity will be provided. Boiler ash collected and will be sold to brick manufacturers.
Green belt development (plantation of dense trees across the boundary) will help in
reducing noise levels in the plant as a result of attenuation of noise generated due
to plant operations, and transportation. Fire safety measures will be incorporated
within the factory premises. All the fire extinguishing media such as water, dry
chemicals, CO2, sand, dolomite, etc. will be kept in vital locations. LED will be used
in whole plant premises, and hence energy will be conserved. Waster after treatment
in ETP will be reused.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 183
Chapter -12
Disclosure of Consultants Engaged
12.1 Disclosure of Consultants Engaged
Vardan EnviroNet is a “NABET approved EIA Consultant” certificate no.
NABET/EIA/1316/IA001, having its registered office at D-142, Sushant Lok III, Golf
Course Extension Road, Sector 57, Gurgaon 122001.
M/s Shahabad Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. EIA/EMP Report
(60 KLPD Ethanol Plant and 3 MW Co-Generation Power Plant)
Village -Jandheri, Tehsil-Shahabad,
Dist. Kurukshetra, Haryana
Document no. 2014 VI_10043_FEIA 184
EIA Coordinator: Mr. SK Sharma
Team Member: Mr. R.S Yadav & Mr. Mukesh Kapila
Functional Area Experts:
S. No Functional
Area Name of Expert/s
Signature
1. AP Mr.S.K.Sharma
2. WP Mr.S.K.Sharma
3. SHW Mr.S.K.Sharma
4. SE Mr. Madhusudan
Hanumant
5. EB Mr. H.S. Matharu
6. HG Mr.R.S Yadav
7. GEO Mr.R.S Yadav
8. AQ Mr.Asif Hussain
9. NV Mr. Asif Hussain
10. LU Mr.Joshua Anand
11. RH Mr. Kuldeepak Ahuja
12. SC Mr.S.K.Sharma