5 steps to achieving supply chain excellence · 5 steps to achieving supply chain excellence 1....
TRANSCRIPT
1
5 Steps to Achieving
Supply Chain Excellence
by Sharyn Grant
Managing Director
LSC Solutions Pty Ltd
2
Presentation Overview
• About LSC Solutions & Sharyn Grant
• What keeps you awake at night?
• Supply Chain Excellence Methodology
• Case Study Company: Surat Basin Homes
• 5 Steps to Achieving Supply Chain Excellence
• Conclusion
• Question Time ^
3
About LSC Solutions Pty Ltd
• Established in 2004
• Operate in QLD, NSW & VIC
• Team of 8 Professional Consultants plus Support Staff
• Best-practice sustainable solutions for:
o Supply Chain & Logistics Management
o Health Safety Environmental & Quality
Assist clients to achieve
superior customer service performance
through supply chain excellence ^
4
About Sharyn Grant
• Founder & Managing Director, LSC Solutions Pty Ltd
• 17 years’ experience in Logistics, Supply Chain and Human
Resources Management
Doctorate(starting soon)
Supply Chain Performance Management
Masters Logistics Management, RMIT
Degree – Double MajorLogistics & Operations Management; and
Human Resources Management, USQ
Lecturer Maintenance Materials Management, CQU
5
• Global non-profit organisation - close to 1,000 members
• Product: Supply Chain Operations Reference (SCOR®) Model
• World standard for supply chain management
• SCOR® Framework, Training, Certification & Benchmarking
• Sharyn Grant:
• Events Chair, Supply Chain Council Aust/NZ Leadership
Team
• LSC Solutions is trained and experienced in applying SCOR®
& Supply Chain Excellence Methodology ^
Supply Chain Council
Source: Supply Chain Council
SCOR® is a registered trademark of Supply Chain Council.
6
What Keeps You Up at Night?
Source: Supply Chain Council
Stock Market Volatility, Oil Prices,
Labour, Political Instability, Security
Reducing Total
Supply Chain Costs
Supply Chain
Resiliency &
Sustainability: Risk
Management & Green
Inventory/
Working Capital/
Asset Management ^
Competing in a
Global Market
Providing Superior & Consistent
Customer Service While Increasing
Revenue & Margin
7
Supply Chain Excellence Methodology
• World-leading supply chain management best practice
SCC & SCOR® Brochures are available
at LSC Solutions’ trade booth ^
SCOR® Model The Framework Supply Chain Council
Supply Chain
Excellence
Methodology
Application of
SCOR® within a
project
framework
Peter Bolstorff and
Robert G. Rosenbaum
8
SCOR® organises around 5 key management processes:
Source: Supply Chain Council
http://supply-chain.org/online-access
Plan Alignment of resources to demand
SourceBuying or acquiring materials or
services
MakeConversion or value-add within
supply chain operations
Deliver
Customer interaction, from
receiving order to final delivery
and installation
Return
Reverse material or service flows
away from customer backwards
through supply chain
SCOR® Model
SCOR® Model contains:
• 200 process elements
• 550 metrics
• 500 best practices
9
Source: http://supply-chain.org/f/SCOR-Overview-Web.pdf
This brochure is available at LSC Solutions’ trade booth
SCOR® Model End-To-End Supply Chain Management
10
Source: Supply Chain Council
Strategic Attribute Strategic Metric Strategy
Supply Chain
ReliabilityPerfect Order Fulfillment
Getting orders
right
Supply Chain
ResponsivenessOrder Fulfillment Cycle Time Speed
Supply Chain
Agility
Supply Chain Flexibility Respond to
changesSupply Chain Adaptability
Supply Chain
Cost
Total Supply Chain Management Cost Costs within
supply chainCost of Goods Sold
Supply Chain
Assets
Cash-to-Cash Cycle TimeManaging assets
Return on Supply Chain Fixed Assets
SCOR® Model Level 1 MetricsC
ust
om
er
Inte
rna
l
11
5 Steps to achieving Supply Chain Excellence1. Build support for supply chain improvement, profile your strategic position,
segment market channels and prioritise supply chains.
2. Research and identify the #1 strategic performance attribute (supply chain
reliability, responsiveness, agility, cost or asset management) that your key
target markets expect world’s best practice.
3. Measure and critically analyse priority supply chain networks, operations,
processes, material flow, technology and responsibilities, to identify risks,
constraints, competitive performance gaps and improvement opportunities.
4. Design and configure scalable, sustainable, efficient and safe supply chains
and operations that will enable the achievement of world’s best practice in
your #1 strategic performance attribute.
5. Plan, execute and monitor your Supply Chain Strategy to transform supply
chains and operations, and deliver best practice in customer service, cost
control, and management of risk, relationships and knowledge. ^
Source: Adaptation by LSC Solutions of Supply Chain Excellence
Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
12
Case Study Company:
About Surat Basin Homes
• Established in 2006
• Family business located in Chinchilla and Brisbane
• Leading provider of quality built homes in the Surat Basin
region: Chinchilla, Miles, Wandoan, Roma
• Winner of CCCI Business Excellence Awards:
• Business of the Year Award
• Gold Award
• Part of the Caspian Property Group
• 25 employees (58 in the Group)
• Over the last 2 years, staffing and turnover doubled ^
Phone: 1800 041 411
www.suratbasinhomes.com.au
13
Surat Basin Homes: Supply Chain Excellence Program
The Challenge
• $200B CSG projects in Surat Basin
• Rapid demand growth from 19 to 150
housing projects
• Focus: Capture growth. Manage
supply chain Risk.
• Required: Increase supply chain
capability & capacity to meet
demand, whilst improving:
o Perfect Order Fulfilment
o Order Fulfilment Cycle Time
o Total Supply Chain Management
Cost
o Costs of Goods Sold
The Solution:
• LSC Solutions’ Supply Chain Excellence
Program
• Commenced late 2010
• Using SCOR® & Supply Chain Excellence
methods:
o identified performance gaps in key
metrics to reach target performance
levels
o identified inbound / internal process
issues
o created 12 projects to drive
improvement
• Prioritised projects by impact, effort, risk
and benefit. ^
14
Step 1: Build support for supply chain improvement, profile
your strategic position, segment market channels and
prioritise supply chains.
Objective: Build Organisational Support & Define Project
Scope^
Source: Adaptation by LSC Solutions of Supply Chain Excellence
Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
15
Step 1: Build support (cont’d)
Surat Basin Homes:
• Market Channel Profile:
o 38% of clients represented 82% of revenue
o 4 Market Channels: Investors, Owner Occupied, Spec, Corporate
o Strongest Market Channel: Investors
• Demand growth forecast:
o 19 to 150 builds per year (87% increase) from 2010 to 2014 ^
FYE10 FYE12 FYE14
No. of houses
built / building19 50 150
16
Step 1: Build support (cont’d)
Surat Basin Homes:
Supplier Profile:
• 110 suppliers were used in
2010
• 23% of suppliers represented
80% of spend
• Supply & Install and Materials:
> 72% of spend
• Identification of major
purchasing categories &
commodity groups ^
Purchasing Categories Commodity Groups
Supply & Install
Roofing
Plaster
Air conditioning
Plumbing
Materials
Concrete & Reinforcement
Hardware
Frames & Trusses
Taps & Appliances
Windows & Screens
Contractors
Carpenter
Concreter
Bricklayer
Tiler
ServicesPermit Fees
Excavation
17
Step 1: Build support (cont’d)
Surat Basin Homes: Supply Chain Definition Matrix
Se
Products:
Market Channel
Corporate Investors Spec Owner Occupied
4bdrm/2bath x x x x
Duplexes x x x
2bdrm/2bath x
4bdrm/4bath x
3bdrm/2bath x
1bdrm/1bath x
Supply Chain = Product to Market Channel
• Eg. “4bdrm/2bath – Investors” is a supply chain
• 11 supply chains identified ^
Source: Supply Chain Excellence Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
18
Step 1: Build support (cont’d)
Surat Basin Homes: Supply Chain Priority Matrix
Evaluate & prioritise supply chains:
Supply ChainsOverall
Rating
Priority
Criteria
Supply Chain
Revenue
Gross Margin
%
Number of
House
Designs
Volume Sold
(Qty)
Strategic
Importance
(Rank) (Rank) (Rank) (Rank) (Rank)
Weight
x x x x x
RankingWeighted
ResultRanking
Weighted
ResultRanking
Weighted
ResultRanking
Weighted
ResultRanking
Weighted
Result
4bdrm/
2bathInvestors xx
Ra
nk
ing
x
We
igh
tin
g
=
We
igh
ted
Re
sult
xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
4bdrm/
2bath
Owner
Occupiedxx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
4bdrm/
2bathSpec xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
• 8 priority supply chains identified (80% of forecast revenue)
• Highest Priority Supply Chain: Investors - 4bdrm/2bath (incl. all designs) ^
Source: Supply Chain Excellence Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
End of Step 1
19
Step 2: Research and identify the #1 strategic performance
attribute (supply chain reliability, responsiveness, agility,
cost or asset management) that your key target markets
expect world’s best practice.
Objective: Identify competitive performance requirements ^
Source: Adaptation by LSC Solutions of Supply Chain Excellence
Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
20
Step 2: Research & identify #1 strategic performance
attribute
Surat Basin Homes• Method: Select 1 x Superior, 2 x Advantage, 2 x Parity (per channel)
• Scope narrowed to 3 market channels
• Result of Surat Basin Homes’ perception of market expectations:
Strategic Performance AttributesMarket Channels
Investor Spec Corporate
Cu
sto
me
r
Faci
ng
1. Supply Chain Reliability Superior Superior Advantage
2. Supply Chain Responsiveness Advantage Parity Superior
3. Supply Chain Agility Parity Parity Advantage
Inte
rna
l 4. Supply Chain Cost Advantage Advantage Parity
5. Supply Chain Asset Management Efficiency Parity Advantage Parity^
Source: Supply Chain Excellence Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
21
Step 2: Research & identify #1 strategic performance
attribute
Surat Basin Homes: Voice of Customer• Strong 75% response rate from surveying Investor Market
• A statistically sound response not achieved from other 2 market channels
• Survey revealed that Surat Basin Homes know their Investor Market very well
• #1 strategic performance attribute identified: Supply Chain Reliability
Voice of CustomerSurat Basin Homes
Perception of Customer Needs
1. Reliability (Superior)
2. Cost Management (Advantage)
3. Responsiveness (Advantage)
4. Asset Management Efficiency (Parity)
5. Flexibility (Parity)
1. Reliability (Superior)
2. Cost Management (Advantage)
3. Responsiveness (Advantage)
4. Asset Management Efficiency (Parity)
5. Flexibility (Parity)
End of Step 2
22
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse priority supply chain
networks, operations, processes, material flow, technology
and responsibilities, to identify risks, constraints,
competitive performance gaps and improvement
opportunities.
Objective: Analyse Performance & Identify Improvement
Opportunities ^
Source: Adaptation by LSC Solutions of Supply Chain Excellence
Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
23
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Surat Basin Homes• Measured performance areas requiring Superior & Advantage level
• Narrowed scope again to focus efforts on areas of greatest importance
Strategic Performance AttributesPerformance
Level
Level 1
Strategic Metrics
Ext
ern
al
Cu
sto
me
r Fa
cin
g
Supply Chain Reliability Superior • Perfect Order Fulfilment
Supply Chain Responsiveness Advantage • Order Fulfilment Cycle Time
Inte
rna
l
Supply Chain Cost Advantage• Total Supply Chain Management Cost
• Cost of Goods Sold ^
24
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Measure Supply Chain Reliability
Measure applicable activities
Source: SCOR Model Version 10.0, Supply Chain Council
Level 1
Strategic Metrics
Level 2
Process Metrics
Level 3
Activity Metrics
Perfect Order
Fulfillment
% of Orders Delivered in Full 2 Activity Metrics
Delivery Performance to
Customer Commit Date
2 Activity Metrics
1 Activity Metrics
Documentation Accuracy 4 Activity Metrics
Perfect Condition 5 Activity Metrics ^
25
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Measure Supply Chain Responsiveness
Measure applicable activities
Source: SCOR Model Version 10.0, Supply Chain Council
Level 1
Strategic Metrics
Level 2
Process Metrics
Level 3
Activity Metrics
Order Fulfilment Cycle
Time
Source Cycle Time 7 Activity Metrics
Make Cycle Time 7 Activity Metrics
Deliver Cycle Time 14 Activity Metrics ^
26
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Measure Supply Chain Cost (Part A)
Measure applicable activities
Source: SCOR Model Version 10.0, Supply Chain Council
Level 1
Strategic Metrics
Level 2
Process Metrics
Level 3
Activity Metrics
Total Supply Chain
Management Cost
Cost to Plan 5 Activity Metrics
Cost to Source 5 Activity Metrics
Cost to Make 3 Activity Metrics
Cost to Deliver 2 Activity Metrics
Cost to Return 2 Activity Metrics
Supply Chain Risk Mitigation Cost 5 Activity Metrics ^
27
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Measure Supply Chain Cost (Part B)
Source: SCOR Model Version 10.0, Supply Chain Council
Level 1
Strategic Metrics
Level 2
Process Metrics
Cost of Goods Sold
Direct Labour Cost
Direct Material Cost
Indirect Cost Related to Production ^
28
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Surat Basin Homes: Performance Results as at December 2010
Strategic Performance AttributesLevel 1
Strategic Metrics
Performance Result
December 2010
Ext
ern
al
Cu
sto
me
r Fa
cin
g
Supply Chain Reliability Perfect Order Fulfilment70%
(% of customer orders)
Supply Chain Responsiveness Order Fulfilment Cycle Time125 days
(Average actual cycle time)
Inte
rna
l
Supply Chain Cost
Total Supply Chain
Management Cost
7.84% (% of revenue) or
$78.38 per $1K in revenue
Cost of Goods Sold76.44%
(% of revenue)
• Data capturing not configured to measure performance
per market channel
• Therefore measured total performance
29
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Surat Basin Homes: Balanced Supply Chain Performance Scorecard [Dec 2010]
Strategic Performance
Attributes
Level 1
Strategic Metrics
Actual
Performance
Dec 2010
Parity
(50th)Advantage
Superior
(90th)
Parity
Gap
Competitive
Requirement
Gap
Ext
ern
al
Cu
sto
me
r Fa
cin
g Supply Chain
Reliability
(Target: Superior)
Perfect Order
Fulfilment70% 80% 90% >93% -10% -23%
Supply Chain
Responsiveness
(Target: Advantage)
Order Fulfilment
Cycle Time125 days 172 days
120
days
110
days
+47
days-5 days
Inte
rna
l
Supply Chain Cost
(Target: Advantage)
Total Supply Chain
Management Cost
7.84% or
$78.38 per
$1K in
revenue
$108.84
per $1K in
revenue
$76.16 per $1K in
revenue
$43.48 per $1K
in
revenue
-$30.46 -$2.22
Cost of Goods Sold 76.44% 80.74% 72.5% 59.57% -4.30% -3.94%
• Used benchmarks from Supply Chain Council data
• Identified Competitive Requirement Gap
30
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Surat Basin Homes: Performance Results Against Parity
• Competitive in world marketplace - Supply Chain Cost exceeding Parity
Strategic Performance
AttributesStrategic Metrics
Comparison against Parity
Level Performance
[Dec 2010]
Supply Chain Reliability
(Target: Superior)Perfect Order Fulfilment Below Parity by 10%
Supply Chain Responsiveness
(Target: Advantage)Order Fulfilment Cycle Time
Parity exceeded by 47
days
Supply Chain Cost
(Target: Advantage)
Total Supply Chain
Management Cost
Parity exceeded by
$30.46/$1k in revenue
Cost of Goods Sold Parity exceeded by 4.30%
Comparative benchmarking data not available for Order Fulfilment Cycle Time:
• Set Parity based on contract promise ^
31
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Best-in-class companies outperform their median competitors with a 50%
Cost Advantage
Source: Supply Chain Council - PRTM/The Performance Measurement Group
Total Supply Chain Management Costs (% of Revenue)
9.2%
12.3%
10.7%10.0%
10.7%
9.1%
6.6%7.4%
4.8%5.5%5.3%
4.2%3.5% 3.6%
5.4%
3.4%
0.0%
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
8.0%
10.0%
12.0%
14.0%
Automotive Industrial Chemical &
Advanced Materials
Computer Consumer Goods Pharmaceutical Semiconductor Telecommunications
Equipment
Best-in-Class
Median
% o
f R
ev
en
ue
Surat Basin
Homes as at
Dec 2010
7.84% ^
32
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Surat Basin Homes:• Analysis of Materials Management (sample only)
Findings Opportunities
• Materials purchased
project by project
• Sourcing not based on
aggregated demand
• No supplier agreements
• Doubling handling of
materials
• Supplier and delivery
issues
• Aggregate materials demand to maximise
buying power
• Significant spend savings opportunities
identified
• Establish supplier agreements
• Develop closer relationships strategic
suppliers and agree performance standards
• Source some materials from manufacturers
to eliminate double handling ^
33
Step 3: Measure and critically analyse performance and all
supply chain processes
Surat Basin Homes:• Analysis of Work & Information Flow, Operations & Systems (sample only)
Sample of Findings Sample of Opportunities
• Non-integrated information systems
causing process delays and duplicate
information
• Traces of strategic procurement
responsibilities across several roles
• Absence of procurement risk management
• Limited end-to-end supply chain mgmt
• Limited supply chain performance reporting
• Issues identified in processes pertaining to
purchasing and order management
• Integrated ERP to improve process efficiency
and information visibility
• Source integrated ERP for entire Group
• Identified need for Supply Chain Manager or
Procurement Manager
• Establish formal Procurement Function
including a list of processes required eg.
tendering
• Use a Balance Supply Chain Performance
Scorecard ^
End of Step 3
34
Step 4: Design and configure scalable, sustainable, efficient
and safe supply chains and operations that will enable the
achievement of world’s best practice in your #1 strategic
performance attribute.
Objective: Design Future State Supply Chains & Operations ^
Source: Adaptation by LSC Solutions of Supply Chain Excellence
Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
35
Step 4: Design and configure supply chains and operations
Surat Basin Homes: Improvement Strategies (sample only)• Designed material flows to eliminate doubling handling and improve
efficiency
• Identified opportunity procurement categories and commodities for the
establishment of strategic supplier agreements
• Developed a Procurement Strategy including a list of strategic
requirements to manage procurement risk
• Developed roles and responsibilities to manage Supply Chain end-to-end,
specifically Procurement Management
• Produced a Big Picture Process Map to capture processes across entire
Group of companies to identify ERP technology requirements
• Developed a series of Level 3 Activity Process maps to detail technology
requirements (including design of future state process requirements)
• Developed ERP specification ^
End of Step 4
36
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor your Supply Chain Strategy
to transform supply chains and operations, and deliver best
practice in customer service, cost control, and management
of risk, relationships and knowledge.
Objective: Develop Project Portfolio, Implement & Monitor
Performance ^
Source: Adaptation by LSC Solutions of Supply Chain Excellence
Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
37
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes:• Produced Supply Chain Strategy Report
• Assembled Project Portfolio for 12 projects – a sample included:
o ERP Implementation
o Establish Supply Chain & Procurement Roles
o Establish Procurement Function
o Establish Strategic Supply Agreements
o Improve Purchasing Process
• Conducted:
• Project Benefit Analysis
• Impact & Effort Analysis
• Opportunity Analysis
• Developed Supply Chain Strategy Implementation Plan & Schedule ^
38
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Project Benefit Assessment (sample of projects illustrated)
• Identify how each project contributes towards achieving strategic metrics ^
No. Project Description
Reliability Responsiveness Costs
Perfect Order
Fulfilment
(% of total orders)
Order Fulfilment
Cycle Time (days)
Total Supply Chain
Management Cost
($ per $1K in
revenue)
Cost of Goods
Sold
(% of revenue)
Baseline 70% 125 days $78.38 76.44%1 ERP Implementation This project will xxxx xx% -xx -$xx -xx%
2 Establish Supply Chain &
Procurement Roles
This project will xxxxxx% -xx -$xx -xx%
3 Establish Procurement Function This project will xxxx xx% -xx -$xx -xx%
4 Establish Strategic Supply
Agreements
This project will xxxxxx% -xx -$xx -xx%
5 Improve Purchasing Process This project will xxxx xx% -xx -$xx -xx%
Benefit (Competitive Gap) 23% -5 -$2.22 -3.94%
Target Performance Level 93% 120 $76.16 72.50%
Data withheld to maintain confidentiality.
Source: Supply Chain Excellence Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
39
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Impact & Effort Assessment (sample of projects illustrated)
Impact Assessment:1 1 1 1 1 1 1
x <= 9% x <= 9% x <= 9% x <= 9% x > 6 Negative None
2 2 2 2 2 2 2
10% <= x <= 19% 10% <= x <= 19% 10% <= x <= 19% 10% <= x <= 19% 3 < x < 6 Neutral Some to Many
3 3 3 3 3 3 3
x => 20% x => 20% x => 20% x => 20% x < 3 Positive Most to All
No. Project
%
IMPROVEMENT
for Perfect
Order Fulfilment
%
IMPROVEMENT
for Order
Fulfilment Cycle
Time
%
IMPROVEMENT
for Total Supply
Chain
Management
Cost
%
IMPROVEMENT
for Cost of
Goods Sold
Time Benefit
starts being
realised
(Months)
Customer
Satisfaction
Impact
Leveragable
across Target
Markets
Total
Impact
1 ERP Implementation 2 2 2 1 2 3 3 15
2 Establish Supply Chain
& Procurement Roles2 2 2 2 3 3 3 17
3 Establish
Procurement Function2 2 2 2 3 3 3 17
4 Establish Strategic
Supply Agreements1 1 2 3 3 3 3 16
5 Improve Purchasing
Process2 2 2 2 3 3 3 17
% IMPROVEMENT identified on Project Benefit Assessment ^Source: Supply Chain Excellence Methodology by Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
40
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Impact & Effort Assessment (sample of projects illustrated)
Effort Assessment: 1 1 1 1
x > 6 Project Team High x > $100K
2 2 2 2
3 < x < 6 FT Resource/s Medium $25K < x < $100K
3 3 3 3
x < 3 PT part of roles Low x < $25K
No. Project
Time to Develop &
Implement
(Months)
Resources
Required to
Implement
Complexity
(Technically /
Organisationally)
Project Cost
internal & external
resources, capital
Total
Effort
1 ERP Implementation 2 1 1 1 5
2 Establish Supply Chain &
Procurement Roles3 2 2 1 8
3 Establish Procurement Function 3 2 2 3 10
4 Establish Strategic Supply
Agreements3 2 2 3 10
5 Improve Purchasing Process 3 3 3 3 12
Source: Supply Chain Excellence Methodology by
Peter Bolstorff and Robert G. Rosenbaum
41
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Result of Impact & Effort Assessment (sample of projects)
Total Score* Project No. Project
29 5 Improve Purchasing Process
27 3 Establish Procurement Function
26 4 Establish Strategic Supply Agreements
25 2 Establish Supply Chain & Procurement Roles
20 1 ERP Implementation
* Impact Score + Effort Score = Total Score ^
42
No. ProjectTotal
Impact
Total
Effort
1 ERP 15 5
2Supply Chain &
Procurement Roles17 8
3Procurement
Function17 10
4Supply
Agreements16 10
5 Purchasing Process 17 12
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Individual Impact & Effort Scores (sample of projects)
•All recommendations were High
Impact projects
•Identify Quick Wins ^
43
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Priority of Implementation based on
Impact/Effort Assessment (sample of projects only)
Project No. Project
1 ERP Implementation
5 Improve Purchasing Process Quick Win
3 Establish Procurement Function
4 Establish Strategic Supply Agreements
2 Establish Supply Chain & Procurement Roles
44
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Opportunity Analysis – Expected Gross Opportunity• Approx $2.6M (absolute value) for 12 projects
• Gross Profit increase by 3.9%
• Plus significant spend savings through negotiated supplier agreements
Quantified Benefits for Achieving Supply Chain Performance Targets
Need to consider cost to implement projects to identify net opportunity.
Values withheld to maintain confidentiality.
(sample of projects only)
No. ProjectPerfect Order
Fulfilment
Order Fulfilment
Cycle Time
Total Supply
Chain
Management Cost
Cost of Goods
Sold
1 ERP Implementation $ value $ value - $ value - $ value
2 Establish Supply Chain & Procurement Roles $ value $ value - $ value - $ value
3 Establish Procurement Function $ value $ value - $ value - $ value
4 Establish Strategic Supply Agreements $ value $ value - $ value - $ value
5 Improve Purchasing Process Quick Win $ value $ value - $ value - $ value
Totals $ value $ value $ value $ value
45
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Priority of Implementation based on Opportunity Analysis
• ERP implementation remained a pre-requisite to addressing process issues
• Establish Supply Chain & Procurement Roles expected to generate 2nd highest
benefit (out of the 12 projects identified)
• Procurement/purchasing projects were combined into one project ^
Values withheld to maintain confidentiality.
(sample of projects only)
Project No. ProjectGross Opportunity
(absolute value)
1 ERP Implementation $ value
2 Establish Supply Chain & Procurement Roles $ value
3
4
5
Establish Procurement Function
Establish Strategic Supply Agreements
Improve Purchasing Process Quick Win
$ value
$ value
$ value
46
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Approval; Supply Chain Strategy Implementation Plan &
Schedule
• First project commenced: ERP Implementation
• Sourced and evaluated ERP’s
• ERP selected: JD Edwards EnterpriseOne (leading edge)
• First residential construction company in Australia to use
• Implementation by end of 2012
• End-to-end SCM roles assigned to GM and Construction Manager
• Procurement Manager recruited, who has:
• Commenced improving the Purchasing Process
• Established Procurement Function & Strategic Supply Agreements
• A long list of other improvements have been achieved
• Completed SCOR® training with Supply Chain Council - saying course
was “Fantastic!” ^
47
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Benefits Achieved as at 2012
• Superior Target Achieved:
• Perfect Order Fulfillment: � 23.9% to 93.9%*
• 93% Target Exceeded
• Order Fulfillment Cycle Time: Reduced by 3 days* to 120 days
• Cost of Goods Sold: Reduced by 0.64% to 75.80%
• expected to reduce further once spend savings realised
• Revenue has doubled
• Spend savings forecast: $1.6M over next 8 mths
• 8% savings over past 2yrs
• includes 6% by Procurement Manager within first 3mths
of starting ^ * As at 17 August 2012
~ As at 30 June 2012
48
Step 5: Plan, execute and monitor Supply Chain Strategy
Surat Basin Homes: Monitoring Supply Chain Performance
Balanced Supply Chain Performance Scorecard - 2012
* As at 17 August 2012
~ As at 30 June 2012
End of Step 5 ^
• � TSCMC: staff increase to manage demand & ERP costs
• SC Cost targets expected to be achieved by FYE13
Strategic Performance
Attributes
Level 1
Strategic Metrics
Actual
Performance
2012
Parity
(50th)Advantage
Superior
(90th)
Parity
Gap
Competitive
Requirement
Gap
Ext
ern
al
Cu
sto
me
r Fa
cin
g Supply Chain
Reliability
(Target: Superior)
Perfect Order
Fulfilment93.9%* 80% 90% >93% 13.9%
Exceeded
TargetSupply Chain
Responsiveness
(Target: Advantage)
Order Fulfilment
Cycle Time122 days 172 days
120
days
110
days
50
days-2 days
Inte
rna
l
Supply Chain Cost
(Target: Advantage)
Total Supply Chain
Management Cost
9.29%~
$92.88
per $1K in
revenue
$108.84
per $1K in
revenue
$76.16 per $1K in
revenue
$43.48 per $1K
in
revenue
$15.96 -$16.72
Cost of Goods Sold 75.80%~ 80.74% 72.5% 59.57% 4.94% -3.3%
49
SCORindex – Supply Chain Council
• SCORindex chart
tracks the value of an
aggregate 70
company SCC
members from 2003
on.
• Correlates SCC
Membership/SCOR
investments with
Shareholder value.
Source: http://supply-chain.org/scor/scorindex
50
Industry Membership Scope
Source: Supply Chain Council
51
Conclusion: 5 Steps to Achieving Supply Chain Excellence1. Build support and prioritise your supply chains
2. Identify #1 strategic performance attribute target markets expect best practice
3. Measure and critically analyse performance and supply chain processes
4. Design and configure supply chains and operations that will achieve and sustain
your #1 strategic performance attribute
5. Plan, execute and monitor your Supply Chain Strategy to become globally
competitive.
Visit Sharyn at LSC Solutions’ trade booth regarding:
• LSC Solutions’ Supply Chain Excellence Program
• Supply Chain Council Membership
• Training: SCOR® Framework & SCOR® Project
• SCOR® Certification
• Brochures available
LSC Solutions
1300 LSC LSC
www.lscs.com.auThank You!
Any Questions?